TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.580 --> 00:00:12.970
[upbeat music] Welcome to Charter School Insider, lessons from the nation's top charter school operators, the only podcast dedicated to the behind the scenes business of running a successful charter school.
2
00:00:13.460 --> 00:00:24.400
Join us as we sit down with charter school leaders who share how they are overcoming the biggest operational hurdles facing their schools today. All right, Michael, welcome to the show. It's great to have you here.
3
00:00:25.040 --> 00:00:34.800
All right. Thank you. I'm glad to be here. Glad to talk to you more. I, uh, am looking forward to the conversation, and I thought we could start just with a quick introduction on yourself.
4
00:00:34.860 --> 00:00:43.559
For those who don't know you or maybe our friends on the East Coast who don't know Aspire- Yeah... can you give us like the, the quick intro? Absolutely. So my name is Michael Wimbish.
5
00:00:43.640 --> 00:00:50.540
I'm the chief financial officer for Aspire Public Schools. Uh, we are a charter management organization in, uh, California.
6
00:00:51.000 --> 00:01:05.340
We operate, uh, 36 charter schools across three regions in California, so the Bay Area, Oakland, Richmond, East Palo Alto, the Central Valley, which spans Sacramento, Modesto, Stockton, Lodi area, and then the Los Angeles area.
7
00:01:05.500 --> 00:01:17.240
I have been in this role for a little bit over five years, moved into the role in February 2021. I've been with Aspire coming up on eight years. Um, I originally joined as the director of finance.
8
00:01:17.340 --> 00:01:23.980
Um, and then prior to that, I had the opportunity to serve for about 11 years. I started my career in the corporate finance space.
9
00:01:24.420 --> 00:01:31.380
I worked for Intel, I worked for Clorox in corporate finance capacities before making the transition to the education sector. I love it.
10
00:01:31.420 --> 00:01:38.170
And I, I think the-- one of the reasons I was super excited to talk to you was you do, you do bring the unique background. You know- Yeah...
11
00:01:38.170 --> 00:01:42.580
a lot of times we talk to folks and they're, like, born out of the, the school environment. Yeah.
12
00:01:42.780 --> 00:01:56.240
Um, and not everybody's had that sort of big corporate experience and then transitioned into the education space, and so I, I think you bring a, a unique perspective. You also mentioned starting this role in 2021.
13
00:01:56.380 --> 00:02:04.630
Super interesting time to step into the seat. Yeah. COVID, crazy funding changes, enrollment- Yeah... going all over the place.
14
00:02:04.840 --> 00:02:09.840
You know, fast-forward five years, we're now sitting-- we're recording this in March of, of 2026.
15
00:02:10.360 --> 00:02:21.260
I wanted to start just by asking about how would you describe the current environment we're in right now, and how does it maybe feel different than, than a number of years ago?
16
00:02:21.520 --> 00:02:29.820
So in
Load full transcript
my seat, I, I would obviously use the analogy of, like, a juggler. It feels like there are, like, uh, multiple different balls in the air. You're trying not to drop one.
17
00:02:29.880 --> 00:02:37.900
You got, like, declining enrollment over here. You got oversight, authorizer stuff over here. You got, like, all these t- types of things, and you're trying to balance it all.
18
00:02:38.140 --> 00:02:46.520
And I would say, like, as it relates to where we are now versus five years ago, like, what's changed so much even from oversight requirements.
19
00:02:46.560 --> 00:02:56.060
You know, I think one of the things, the blessing and the curse coming out of the pandemic in California was that also California introduced a number of new categorical funding programs. Mm.
20
00:02:56.160 --> 00:03:02.440
So like expanded learning, TK, community schools, which are great, great programs.
21
00:03:02.520 --> 00:03:12.070
Obviously, additional funding allows to do some great things, and each of them come with their separate oversight li- like all the things. And so, like, that's one way.
22
00:03:12.100 --> 00:03:22.120
And then kind of on the operational side, it probably seems crazy to think about this, but there was once a time where it felt like enrollment was just automatic, [laughs]
23
00:03:22.160 --> 00:03:28.920
where you automatically had 500 students, or you are automatically at full enrollment. Yeah. Waiting list for days. Yeah.
24
00:03:28.940 --> 00:03:34.260
Yeah, waiting list with kind of minimal effort, uh, which seems crazy now 'cause it's kind of like, how does that happen?
25
00:03:34.520 --> 00:03:40.300
And fast-forward now, obviously, we know the environment we're in in terms of enrollment and recruitment and things of that nature.
26
00:03:40.340 --> 00:03:45.400
So I would say, like, those are some of the, the big changes from where we were five years ago.
27
00:03:45.440 --> 00:03:54.700
So how does that inform priorities for you right now when you think about what are the big pillars of navigating the current environment? H- How do you think about that?
28
00:03:55.220 --> 00:04:03.380
I mean, I think there's a couple different layers to that. I think there's obviously, like, the fiscal sustainability pieces of it, making sure you're navigating that.
29
00:04:03.480 --> 00:04:07.440
I think there's a big, big, big compliance aspect of it. Right.
30
00:04:07.560 --> 00:04:16.120
And I think the environment has changed to where you have to get, like, a A+ on oversight and compliance and, like, all the things, and that's become super important.
31
00:04:16.200 --> 00:04:26.219
I think as I navigate that, or as we navigate that, particularly on the financial sustainability, like, one framework that's been helpful, and I wanna just caveat, like, I was not the originator of this framework.
32
00:04:26.780 --> 00:04:36.500
[laughs] CSGF, uh, Charter School Growth Fund, actually introduced this framework and kind of saw it from them at, at one of their conferences and, and gatherings, so I just wanna put that out there.
33
00:04:36.520 --> 00:04:45.680
But it's been really helpful for me just to think about the financial sustainability challenges and just all the things, and it started out as the four E's framework. Okay.
34
00:04:46.080 --> 00:04:55.620
And those four E's were, uh, ESSER, which is the one-time funding from the federal government and how that w- is coming to an end or was coming to an end.
35
00:04:55.660 --> 00:05:05.030
The economy, we know that there's all kind of different levels of, of uncertainty in our economic environment. Enrollment, which we talked about, like the declining enrollment.
36
00:05:05.220 --> 00:05:14.600
And then educators, the need or the continuing need to, like, hire and retain- Mm... strong people and the cost that comes along with that in this environment.
37
00:05:14.860 --> 00:05:39.080
And all of that is against, if you think about all the backdrop of increasing, increasing student needs, how do you balance that, meet your mission in a way that's also, like, balancing all those things and fiscally, uh, sustainable, I think is the biggest thing that keeps me up at night, I guess, uh, from that perspective is, like, how are you juggling or balancing all of those, all those different things?
38
00:05:39.360 --> 00:05:49.960
Yeah, totally. So you mentioned it, it was originally the four E's. How has it changed? I assume- Yeah... I assume ESSER dropped off. What-- How do you think- Yeah, yeah... what's the, the fourth letter these days?
39
00:05:50.260 --> 00:05:57.600
We said three E's and one O. I know that's probably not super catchy, but it worked for us. [laughs] And then O being one-time funding.
40
00:05:57.840 --> 00:06:07.500
In the state of California, again, we were fortunate actually, as ESSER came to an end, the state has actually introduced some new, new state one-time funding pots.
41
00:06:07.510 --> 00:06:13.760
Fortunate in that, and we also know that those are decreasing and, you know, at some point will be coming to an end as well.
42
00:06:13.780 --> 00:06:21.332
So I think it's just the overall concept of like- We were fortunate to have buckets of one-time funding that we could use to put to good use.
43
00:06:21.782 --> 00:06:29.982
As those come to an end, obviously we have to, you know, right size and do the things we have to do as an org to be fiscally sustainable once that one-time money runs out.
44
00:06:30.352 --> 00:06:38.012
Yeah, I think the framework is super helpful, and especially for others who maybe haven't thought about fiscal sustainability through that lens.
45
00:06:38.452 --> 00:06:47.712
For you and the, the finance team, how do you feel like the three E's, one O framework influences your decision-making?
46
00:06:47.772 --> 00:07:00.472
Like, how do, how do you use the framework practically when you're thinking about we're looking long term around financial sustainability? How are you
kind of running things through that framework in terms of- Yeah...
47
00:07:00.501 --> 00:07:07.132
priorities or, or otherwise? First, before we even get there, I think it's been most helpful as a, as a communication tool.
48
00:07:07.172 --> 00:07:13.112
We at Aspire have tried to be really intentional about being, like, open and transparent across our org- Mm...
49
00:07:13.152 --> 00:07:23.872
with the financial challenges, financial realities, and this is a framework I've actually used across the org. And my experience has been that, like, it's a framework that resonates. Folks get it.
50
00:07:23.992 --> 00:07:34.952
It may mean that we don't land in the place that folks may desire, but at least, at the very least, they can understand the thought process. It res- everyone gets that the economy is very volatile, right?
51
00:07:34.992 --> 00:07:45.212
Like, people can resonate with that. So I would say first and foremost, it's been immensely helpful in just the, our ability to communicate transparently across our organization.
52
00:07:45.452 --> 00:07:53.591
As far as, like, tactical things and frameworks, uh, it's actually very helpful. Uh, we kind of took this approach of, of a tiered school approach.
53
00:07:53.652 --> 00:08:05.232
So a lot of times you may see tiered school approaches, like, when it comes to, like, academic or programmatic items where, you know, I, I know a lot of times school leaders and just at our schools, we may tier supports, right?
54
00:08:05.352 --> 00:08:13.132
Tiered supports to schools based on their needs. We took a kind of similar approach of, like, tiering our schools from a financial perspective.
55
00:08:13.832 --> 00:08:25.491
So looking at the different financial metrics, days of cash, operating profit, reserve levels, all the things, and being able to tier our schools in a way that I think gave us a couple things.
56
00:08:26.092 --> 00:08:33.952
One, it allowed us-- It-- The-- You talked about priorities, and it allowed us to, like, develop those priorities, and really we're operating across 36 schools.
57
00:08:34.092 --> 00:08:44.432
We're trying to determine where we may need to lean in a little bit more. Yeah, that's a lot of schools to keep track of. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, ex-exactly. And so, like, everyone can't be everywhere, but at least- Right...
58
00:08:44.492 --> 00:08:51.732
some little framework of where we may need to lean in. And again, it's always a little bit art and science, right? It's never, like, 100% black and white.
59
00:08:51.832 --> 00:09:03.612
But we did go through of developing, like, um, a decision tree framework- Okay... that it could at least help us guide our process of, of, like, if this is true, what does this dictate from a budget decision?
60
00:09:03.672 --> 00:09:10.352
If it's not true, what's the next variable you look at? Okay, if that's not true, what's the next variable you look at? And again, it's never perfect.
61
00:09:10.652 --> 00:09:15.592
There's always
what I call corner cases still that don't fit inside those boxes.
62
00:09:15.672 --> 00:09:27.312
But I will say that it was as helpful as a starting point, uh, certainly, and something that you could use to kind of frame decision-making and at least talk more, discuss more throughout the process.
63
00:09:27.432 --> 00:09:35.332
What are some of those metrics? 'Cause, uh, I'm, I'm sure others who are listening may be on the finance team at their organization or leading the finance function.
64
00:09:35.832 --> 00:09:47.152
What are some of the metrics that you incorporated as a team into that decision tree framework? 'Cause to your point, you've got a ton of schools. You gotta figure out what's going on at a high level.
65
00:09:47.452 --> 00:09:59.212
How are we, y-you know, using metrics as a canary in the coal mine for potential problems down the road? You alluded to a couple, like days cash on hand or, or reserves.
66
00:09:59.241 --> 00:10:07.252
What are just a few of the metrics that you all keep a close pulse on across the whole 36 campus network? Yeah. I would say those two you mentioned.
67
00:10:07.272 --> 00:10:11.172
In addition to those, I would say, you know, the, the kinda standard around, like, operating profit.
68
00:10:11.292 --> 00:10:22.872
You know, we wanna make sure that at least over time, right, each individual site is able to operate, you know, in the black, right? It has a solid operating profit. We also, uh, have what are called coverage ratio.
69
00:10:22.952 --> 00:10:34.892
So we have a group of our schools that have been financed over the years, and so there are specific coverage ratios that we have as part of our covenants that measure how much coverage you have relative to your debt requirements.
70
00:10:35.072 --> 00:10:46.062
Got it. And so that's something that we, we have to keep a pulse on. Then I would say in the same vein as, like, cash and reserves, things like your current ratio, which, like, measures your near-term liquidity.
71
00:10:46.152 --> 00:10:52.652
You may recall back in that to wh- actually, when I came into this seat, one of the thing, the big things we were planning for was deferrals.
72
00:10:52.912 --> 00:10:56.872
You know, we're not in that state right now in California, but you know, you never know, right?
73
00:10:57.172 --> 00:11:07.792
Also, like, those ratios around liquidity to make sure that if there is those cases, deferrals or whatever it may be, that we're in a position as an org to be able to ride it out. Yeah, totally.
74
00:11:08.072 --> 00:11:14.192
You talked a little bit about the challenge of finance is part art, part science.
75
00:11:14.292 --> 00:11:22.272
I think that's a really good way of, of thinking about it 'cause a lot of times it's easy to say, "Oh, well, finance is just, it's all metrics."
76
00:11:22.412 --> 00:11:33.712
You know, like, it, it's all in the numbers, and I think you're hitting on the reality that we're balancing decisions around mission and student need and- Mm...
77
00:11:33.752 --> 00:11:47.132
enrollment impacts, and there's, there's humans on the other side of these numbers. We're trying to retain our, our strong staff. How do you feel like that kind of push/pull comes into play- Yeah...
78
00:11:47.232 --> 00:11:57.668
as you think about my job is to ensure the long-term... financial stability of the organization, but I'm also sup- here to, like our team is here to support the mission. Yeah. How do you think about that- Yeah...
79
00:11:57.698 --> 00:11:59.187
that sort of constant push/pull?
80
00:11:59.428 --> 00:12:11.088
Push/pull is a great way to put it 'cause that's exactly the way it is between, like, at the end of the day, we know our mission is to provide, like here at Inspire, a high quality education to our students, many from underserved communities.
81
00:12:11.118 --> 00:12:17.968
And so that's our mission, and we feel, you know, passionate about that. And we also know we have to do that in a financially sustainable way. Right.
82
00:12:18.268 --> 00:12:27.308
And we also know that, put it bluntly, the reality is, like, we are not funded in a way that allows us to do, like, all the things we would want and need to do.
83
00:12:27.608 --> 00:12:38.568
We talk a lot around, like, trade-offs, acknowledging that, like, we wish it wasn't like this, but, like, the reality is, as we think about those and that push/pull, you know, we're often faced with trade-offs, right?
84
00:12:38.868 --> 00:12:47.528
You know, on a variety of different fronts of can we offer these supports? Well, if we offer these supports here and invest here, we, you know, may not be able to invest as much over here.
85
00:12:47.868 --> 00:12:54.368
And so there's always that push/pull. There's always that tension, and balancing that is tricky, right? And we talked a little bit about frameworks.
86
00:12:54.728 --> 00:13:11.548
And I would say, like, an example, like, when you talk about the art of it is, you know, I can remember a situation where at one of our schools we got into a discussion specifically, like, around instructional supports of the school, right, relative to budgets, and there was a very intentional decision.
87
00:13:11.648 --> 00:13:23.208
Uh, there was a, a rising third grade class where, for a variety of reasons, you know, we were saying we, we wanted to be able to invest really intentionally around, like, additional instructional supports- Mm-hmm...
88
00:13:23.218 --> 00:13:24.028
um, and things of that nature.
89
00:13:24.058 --> 00:13:46.128
And so, like, from that discussion and looking at data and things like that, we actually made a very intentional decision, um, at least in the short term, as much as we could to, like, have, like, really small, like, cohort sizes for that grade span, um, and that 15-ish type, 15, 17, which we know, like, unfortunately, that's not long-term sustainable to have that for, like, every grade level.
90
00:13:46.228 --> 00:13:57.548
But
given where we were at that time and just the nature of the investment that we felt needed there, that was a very intentional kind of like art is to some degree decision that we made- Right...
91
00:13:57.588 --> 00:14:09.008
to try to balance at least in, again, short term, the balance of achieving the mission and also, like, the, the financial sustainability component. I want to build on that idea of short-term investments.
92
00:14:09.428 --> 00:14:28.428
One of your letters in the framework was O, shifting the Esther to, to one-time funding, and one-time funding obviously creates a temptation to expand programs and commitments and the balance of what gets a one-time investment versus what needs to be funded in, in perpetuity.
93
00:14:29.028 --> 00:14:39.548
How have you all thought about those decisions? And, like, the example you just gave is a great example of, "Hey, we know we can't do this long term, but this makes a ton of sense right now." Yeah.
94
00:14:39.868 --> 00:14:49.768
How do you communicate that with staff or, or what does that conversation look like as you think about the one-time funds? So we have been really intentional around tying our investments.
95
00:14:49.928 --> 00:14:58.988
I think compensation is an example, right? Tying our compensation investments to the ongoing funding profile. Mm-hmm. And it worked. It does work both ways, right?
96
00:14:59.088 --> 00:15:10.328
So I think it was '22, '23 and '23, '24, I mean, plus or minus, but the LSFF, which LSFF is our per pupil funding formula in California, was higher than normal.
97
00:15:10.408 --> 00:15:19.288
I think one year it was like it grew at 13%, another year it grew at 8%. And so in those years, we actually invested close to that amount.
98
00:15:19.308 --> 00:15:25.308
If you look at the rate of, like, salary increases, it was, it was very closely aligned to those amounts.
99
00:15:25.948 --> 00:15:38.828
And then conversely, even in, in our current environments where the per pupil funding increase is closer to 2 to 3%, we've been very clear that, like, that will need to match our ongoing commitments.
100
00:15:39.508 --> 00:15:48.748
And so we tried to be very intentional both ways on that and then acknowledge that given that, you know, the one-time funding we're using it in places that are not ongoing commitments.
101
00:15:48.808 --> 00:15:58.688
So you think about maybe equipment purchases, like tech purchases, things of that nature. There may be, may have opportunities to do, like, retention bonuses or, like, signing, like...
102
00:15:58.748 --> 00:16:11.008
So we, we have tried to be very clear in that delineation. The one thing I will name in that that is, that's always tricky to navigate is, of course, in our business, you know, 75 to 80% of our costs are personnel.
103
00:16:11.327 --> 00:16:22.588
Particularly when you have, like, big buckets, it can be tricky to, to be able to figure out a way to spend that in a way that's not an ongoing commitment but also, like, gets you bang for your buck. Right.
104
00:16:22.908 --> 00:16:30.428
I know one of the things we have done to, to try to balance that is there are times where we create interim positions and think or, you know, intentionally invest.
105
00:16:31.028 --> 00:16:48.508
Um, and I will say I think that makes sense on the ground and, and I think there have been benefits, and I will just say, like, I do think one, one thing that I kind of learned over time is, like, even if it's interim and it's titled interim, everybody agrees it's interim, the experience becomes that that's permanent.
106
00:16:48.728 --> 00:16:59.028
Like if I'm- Yeah, yeah. [laughs]... from a school leader perspective or from a school perspective, that's human nature, right? It's like I've had this, this role for last year. It was great. Yeah.
107
00:16:59.088 --> 00:17:01.768
I know it's titled interim, but it feels permanent. That was just...
108
00:17:01.908 --> 00:17:13.388
I just throw that out there as, like, one learning as we, we navigate this is like interim, it's all good, makes sense, and the practical reality of that sometimes can be different and how do you navigate that. Right.
109
00:17:13.588 --> 00:17:19.788
We can't lose Michael. He was amazing. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I think that's a really good call-out.
110
00:17:19.948 --> 00:17:32.748
It seems like a big part of this is, you know, intentionality, communication, setting expectations. A lot of that is maybe the soft skills or the EQ side of being a finance leader.
111
00:17:33.128 --> 00:17:45.738
How do you all as an organization think about prioritizing communication and also just practically speaking, 36 schools, you're spread across a huge geographic region.
112
00:17:46.268 --> 00:17:59.900
How do you all get people on the same page in terms of... where the organization is at financially, how you all are thinking through some of these push/pull trade-offs, you know, communications around staffing.
113
00:18:00.120 --> 00:18:04.060
What does that look like? What have you all learned on the transparency and communication front?
114
00:18:04.620 --> 00:18:12.520
Yeah, I, I mean, I will say, like I mentioned, like we have tried to be very intentional on the comms side and over-communicate where we can and then be transparent.
115
00:18:12.660 --> 00:18:27.600
I think some of the things you mentioned, we're a 36-school network, that we have done is we probably for the last four or five years we've actually done budget webinars around the January preliminary budget release and then the May revised release.
116
00:18:27.880 --> 00:18:45.360
We give a download on, you know, the budget, right, in terms of the mechanics and the funding is going here and, and that, but also give some insight and framework into like how we're thinking about it, what are the risks, what are the opportunities, what are the things we're monitoring, and also like allow for some, some Q&A
generally.
117
00:18:45.400 --> 00:18:50.150
So that's one way. Again, it doesn't capture everything, but I, I think it's one way we've done it.
118
00:18:50.180 --> 00:18:58.970
And also we've had cases where with our leaders we've had like leader convenings in the past where we've had like a fireside chat or what- whatever have you- Sure...
119
00:18:58.980 --> 00:19:03.420
where we kind of do a similar, similar download and also allow for question and answer and just cover.
120
00:19:03.500 --> 00:19:12.720
So those are some of the things, just kind of broader org communications that we, that we have made consistent staples. So those are consistent things. In fact, what would it be?
121
00:19:12.840 --> 00:19:24.090
Last month maybe, I think, but we did a budget webinar related to the January prelim, and so those are just consistent staples of, of our communication when it comes to like financial matters.
122
00:19:24.110 --> 00:19:33.060
And so I think that's been helpful to at least bring folks under the hood, allow for some questions and from a larger org perspective. Okay, so quick in the weeds question. Yeah.
123
00:19:33.240 --> 00:19:42.820
Who is actually invited to that budget webinar, and then how do you-- like is this everybody? Is it just the principals? Is it- Yeah... you know, do you have specific leader cutoffs?
124
00:19:42.860 --> 00:19:51.010
And then same question for that, that like leader gathering 'cause others who are listening to this are probably thinking, "Oh, maybe we could do that." But like- Yeah...
125
00:19:51.060 --> 00:20:01.899
who, who needs to get that comms and, and how, how should we think about what's appropriate for different audiences? So the budget webinar, it's available to everyone. Everybody has access. Yeah, everyone has it.
126
00:20:01.920 --> 00:20:07.200
There's a calendar invite we send out with the link. I believe we broadcast it via YouTube. Cool.
127
00:20:07.380 --> 00:20:15.940
And so there is a live webinar that they can log into and listen to, and also like a recording that they can access afterwards. Um, so that is the entire org.
128
00:20:16.020 --> 00:20:22.540
We also this past year actually solicited, allowed teammates to submit questions ahead of that.
129
00:20:22.600 --> 00:20:32.860
At the end of it, I actually answered the questions that were submitted ahead of time and/or provided kind of resources for, for those questions. Um, so that's the webinars, everybody.
130
00:20:33.520 --> 00:20:40.300
The space with our leaders that we've had in past years has been our principals and our regional leaders.
131
00:20:40.700 --> 00:20:47.950
That has been a space where we've kind of-- That space wasn't just for budget, but it was already a space that we were bringing leaders together.
132
00:20:47.980 --> 00:20:58.120
And so then we decided as one of the agenda items or, you know, it was like a two-day maybe convening- Yeah... to cover just the kind of we call it the financial state
of Aspire, right?
133
00:20:58.200 --> 00:21:05.180
And, and go into both the state budget dynamics and then the Aspire-specific dynamics, metrics, all of those things.
134
00:21:05.420 --> 00:21:11.300
I think gotten generally positive feedback just along the, the helpfulness of those, those sessions and those opportunities.
135
00:21:11.620 --> 00:21:40.960
One of the things that has been a countless refrain that I've heard from school leaders, particularly finance leaders, is one of the challenges being making sure that the finance speak, for lack of a better term, is like understandable and relatable and tr- translatable by principals, and I'm guessing-- I'm, I was curious to ask you this 'cause you have 36 schools.
136
00:21:41.140 --> 00:21:43.969
Mm-hmm. Presumably you've got some super savvy- Yeah...
137
00:21:43.980 --> 00:21:58.900
principals who are like have been reading P&Ls for years and years and years, and then you've got other principals who really strong on the academic side, got promoted, they're, you know, worked their way up to principal, but they're like, "Hey, I never had to manage the budget in the same way."
138
00:21:59.400 --> 00:22:11.920
How does your team enable those types of follow-up discussions where it's like, okay, we do the state of the organization, but then there's presumably all sorts of one-on-one conversations that have to happen after that.
139
00:22:12.200 --> 00:22:25.400
How do you all think about or, or enable staff to understand sort of the implications for them on the, the finance side? We're really blessed, uh, to have a really like capable and strong finance team.
140
00:22:25.560 --> 00:22:34.900
The way we're structured is we have a finance director in each of the regions that is tactically managing the budgeting and forecasting for each of the sites in their region.
141
00:22:35.320 --> 00:22:39.980
Like you said, you start with the broader communication, to your point, that doesn't cover it all or get at everything.
142
00:22:40.440 --> 00:22:50.740
But really, I think our finance team is also really good around being able to kind of carry on that message in a way that's understandable, but also in a way that allows for...
143
00:22:50.800 --> 00:23:04.720
I, you know, I can't count countless times where I know they've had one-on-ones with principals or different forms, and they're always making themselves available as needed to have those kind of offline discussions or just Q&A or what have you.
144
00:23:04.780 --> 00:23:10.280
To your point, like I'm not gonna get the opportunity to have a one-on-one with all 36 principals. Right.
145
00:23:10.299 --> 00:23:25.360
[chuckles] But I think, you know, having a strong team that kind of mission aligned, you know, thinks in a similar vein and kind of also is, is good at translating the finance speak as you, as you, as you mentioned, is, yeah, invaluable.
146
00:23:25.420 --> 00:23:37.900
And so I think through that structure, I think we've tried
to do to accomplish that. As we come towards the end of our conversation here, I wanna ask about forward planning. Looking ahead, a lot's changed. A lot.
147
00:23:38.220 --> 00:23:48.820
Uh, a lot will change in the next five years, some of it known, a lot of it very unknown. How are you all starting to plan, you know, one year, three years, five years out?
148
00:23:49.180 --> 00:23:59.000
I know enrollment has gotten more challenging, especially in California. What are some of the data points you all are looking at? Give us like the quick view on forward-looking.
149
00:23:59.180 --> 00:24:10.192
We are definitely, definitely, definitely there are much more in the way, as you can imagine, of like just deeper Data dives, deeper data en- engagement as we think about, um, enrollment.
150
00:24:10.332 --> 00:24:20.032
I mentioned earlier, like five, six years ago, pre-pandemic, it felt like it was kinda autopilot enrollment. As we think about that, we are obviously like indexing a lot on historical trends.
151
00:24:20.252 --> 00:24:29.102
Like even this concept of like, hey, if I wanna get... I'm making up numbers, but if I wanna get my enrollment to 450, my first-day enrollment has to be 500. Right. Right.
152
00:24:29.132 --> 00:24:35.992
Because we know historically that, you know, you're gonna have some attrition, you're gonna have some mid-year drops, you're gonna have some different things that happen.
153
00:24:36.232 --> 00:24:43.392
Trying to incorporate that into our enrollment, uh, process and projections to understand like what that looks like.
154
00:24:43.832 --> 00:24:55.532
The other area that I think, I think there's a more opportunity for us to dig deeper in from a data perspective is also just understanding like, uh, neighborhood demographic trends.
155
00:24:55.562 --> 00:25:06.272
A lot of the bulk of our students, or a lot of our students come from the neighborhoods, you know, that are close by. Sure. And even within our regions, you know, there's a lot of different demographic trends going on.
156
00:25:06.352 --> 00:25:14.952
So really like, uh, I think peeling back the onion, there is an opportunity or more, I should say, um, to really be able to inform, uh, kind of our forecast.
157
00:25:14.992 --> 00:25:24.312
And I would just say from a budget or finance perspective, we try and we don't get this perfect. I think in this world you kinda have to err on the side of conservatism. Yeah.
158
00:25:24.382 --> 00:25:27.232
Um, so I think there's always this push/pull there too as well.
159
00:25:27.632 --> 00:25:43.162
You know, understanding the data, understanding the historical trends, and understanding that, you know, there's areas you may have to be a little bit more cautious and hope to like be cautious but over-deliver, you know, just given our current environment, or I should say, hope to over-deliver given our, our current environment.
160
00:25:43.492 --> 00:25:56.152
Where do you go for advice, Michael? That might
seem like a silly question, but there's only so many charter networks in the country that are operating as many schools as you all are.
161
00:25:56.472 --> 00:26:11.232
Um, a- and that list dwindles, you know, when you get into the, the 40-plus campus range. Um, the problem set your team is dealing with is, is significantly more complex than maybe a two-school operator. Yeah.
162
00:26:11.332 --> 00:26:22.811
Where have you found, you know, beneficial resources or opportunities for advice in the broader ecosystem- Yeah... uh, that have benefited you as a CFO? So I'm fortunate.
163
00:26:22.892 --> 00:26:28.302
I feel like I have a ton of resources in a couple different layers. I think it starts with my direct boss.
164
00:26:28.432 --> 00:26:38.952
Previously it was Malu Batra is the, the CEO, and now, uh, Bess Kennedy is our executive director of kind of our central support. So they have always been great thought partners.
165
00:26:39.012 --> 00:26:51.112
I can always come to them and like bounce things off of them and, and things of that nature. Um, so that I would say starts there. Um, I've also been fortunate enough in the finance-specific, uh, aspect to...
166
00:26:51.422 --> 00:26:57.272
I, I had an opportunity a couple years ago to go through, uh, the Fox Fellowship program, which is a program- Yeah...
167
00:26:57.312 --> 00:27:03.392
sponsored, uh, by CSGF and o- others that specifically I was in the finance and operations piece of it.
168
00:27:03.492 --> 00:27:16.512
And through that and also just other connections, you know, I was f- I have a, uh, a coach, Carrie Stewart, who's been in the, the industry for a ton of time, a ton of experience, who I've been able to maintain a relationship.
169
00:27:16.612 --> 00:27:28.032
I also was fortunate, before I took on the CFO role, we had an interim CFO, Matt Shaw, who's also worked in capacity for like Rocketship and other charters, and I main- main- maintain a relationship with him.
170
00:27:28.092 --> 00:27:36.732
So like I have access to really experienced leaders who I can just like call and like say, "Hey, I'm kinda dealing with this. Like, what do you think or what have you seen?"
171
00:27:37.112 --> 00:27:48.232
And then finally, I would say the other piece of invaluable is CSGF. They sponsor and kinda host a CFO cohort where there are finance leaders from across, uh, California Charters.
172
00:27:48.312 --> 00:28:04.652
Um, and just even beyond just like the, obviously the insight, 'cause most of the time what you find is like, like 95% of the time what I'm dealing with, others are dealing with simultaneously or have dealt with, and so being able to, to understand how they approach and how they think.
173
00:28:04.712 --> 00:28:13.942
And I think there's also like this, maybe silly as it may sound, I think there's power in knowing that you're not alone. Totally. You're not crazy. Like, you're not crazy- Yeah. [laughs]...
174
00:28:13.942 --> 00:28:24.052
that, that, that it's not like some failing of yours that this is happening and that others, really smart people and really like brilliant people are facing the same thing.
175
00:28:24.192 --> 00:28:37.432
And so having access to, to those kinda three layers, I've been super fortunate and, and honestly can say like, yeah, it's been invaluable to have those different folks and different layers of mentorship that I can depend on.
176
00:28:37.612 --> 00:28:41.592
All right, we always end with two questions or two similar questions.
177
00:28:41.652 --> 00:28:56.492
The first is, if you had to just pick one piece of advice to give a fellow charter finance leader facing the, the, all the uncertainty we've talked about over the next 12 to 24 months, what would you pick?
178
00:28:56.672 --> 00:29:05.692
I feel like the answer should be like maybe some sort of like very technical or, or, or- [laughs]... like finance thing. But honestly, mine is like transparency.
179
00:29:05.772 --> 00:29:16.312
Honest, I'm really, really big on like transparent and open communication, even with across the org, like not even, not just within finance, but like across the org and really like- Yeah.
180
00:29:16.832 --> 00:29:45.572
You know, one thing I've found is like I'm a firm believer that, of course everyone will not always agree with you, but I've found that 99.9% or 99% of people, if they know that you've been thoughtful about an issue, if they know that you have, it's well thought out, it's, you know, you're open to feedback, you're open to input, that even if you land in a place that they don't agree with, they appreciate the process that you got to, and they appreciate.
181
00:29:45.592 --> 00:29:59.252
They're like, "Hey, this is, this is well thought out, and this is something that you're taking seriously," and therefore can, again, at least they're not gonna like 100% of your decisions, but at least can, you know, to a certain degree get behind or like understand, right?
182
00:29:59.292 --> 00:30:13.042
And so I think open and honest dialogue is important, and really telling the story, right? Narrating You know, one of, uh, things Mala, one of my, my former, uh, bosses t- told me was, like, tell the story, right?
183
00:30:13.172 --> 00:30:23.612
Nar- narrate the story down to your thought process. "Hey, we were considering this, and then we, we almost went there, but we didn't go there because," making this up, "because this is not compliant," right?
184
00:30:23.702 --> 00:30:29.412
"And so therefore we pivoted here, and then we ultimately landed..." And really, like, narrating the thought process.
185
00:30:29.552 --> 00:30:39.922
It may seem like overkill, but even that can be helpful to folks, and to understand kind of where you ultimately land. Love it. Sage advice. All right, final question.
186
00:30:39.972 --> 00:30:51.392
Any tools, resources, templates, or, or otherwise that we haven't already talked about that we should, we should link in the show notes for guests? The three E's or three E's and a O framework from, from CSGF.
187
00:30:51.452 --> 00:30:54.712
I think there's a, a, the visual. I'm happy to share that. Perfect.
188
00:30:54.752 --> 00:31:03.762
I'm also happy to share, if folks are interested, w- I, I have an example of kind of the decision tree framework we used and the metrics that we talked about.
189
00:31:03.792 --> 00:31:12.292
We kind of tried to develop a, a red, yellow, green on each of the metrics, and then tie that back to the decision tree. So I'm happy to, to share that.
190
00:31:12.372 --> 00:31:20.232
Again, uh, it's not perfect, but you know, it may spawn some thought or folks find it useful. Happy to, happy to share that. Awesome.
191
00:31:20.272 --> 00:31:29.332
Well, Michael, thank you so much for being generous with your time, sharing more about your experience at Aspire. It was great having you on. Thank you so much. I enjoyed it. Appreciate it.
192
00:31:29.492 --> 00:31:40.452
Thanks for listening to Charter School Insider. This show is brought to you by BuyQ, the group purchasing organization specifically for charter schools. Want to learn how to maximize your school's purchasing power?
193
00:31:40.972 --> 00:31:50.912
Join together with thousands of other charter schools by visiting buyq.org/signup. BuyQ's purchasing program is free and has no obligations or commitments required.
194
00:31:51.452 --> 00:32:03.692
If you enjoyed today's episode, do us a favor and subscribe on your podcast listening platform of choice. If you have a question or feedback for us, we'd love to hear from you. Send us an email at podcast@buyq.org.
195
00:32:04.092 --> 00:32:08.932
Thanks, and we hope you'll tune in for the next one. [outro music]