TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Lindsay: Hi everyone and welcome to another episode of Broadband Breakdown. I'm your host, Lindsay Randazzo. Today we have a wonderful marketing panel discussion, so I'd like our panelists to introduce themselves and each tell us what marketing means to them and to their organization. We'll start with you, Jill.
Jill Marx: Hi, I'm Jill Marks and I work for Fort Collins Connection, which is a municipal broadband service in Fort Collins, Colorado. what marketing means to me is I mean, we we're community-owned fiber internet, and so we really maintain, want to maintain that local feel, I think, for you know, for our brand. And I think for me, it's like,
Amber: Yeah.
Jill Marx: Marketing means you know, what is gonna make a resident decide to go with us. And so really getting in the mind of the resident and the consumer and like what sets us apart from the competition, what's gonna make them choose us, and and then sort of, you know, developing the marketing strategy and tactics around that mindset and around the different audiences in our in our community.
Lindsay: That's great. How about you, Curtis?
Curtis Dean: I'm Curtis Dean. I'm executive director of Community Broadband Action Network. We're a nationwide nonprofit membership organization. marketing to me is strategic storytelling. And in fact, my first job in in broadband, so to speak, was right after being a journalist. And I took that same storytelling capacity into the job. And and that's you know the approach I've always taken, not only for my own. events that I've been involved with, but also in giving advice to our members is tell your story, tell it well, and tell it consistently and and tell it across as many channels as you have access to.
Amber: Right.
Lindsay: I love that and I love storytelling in in marketing and and really focusing on that. I think it makes a difference. Amber, how about you? Welcome.
Amber: Thank you. my name is Amber Rodriguez. I am the senior director of growth marketing at Surf Internet. We are an ISP and the Great Lakes area. and for me, marketing is it's beyond just storytelling. It's the representation of the brand. but the way I always look at it is marketing is like the hostess of a restaurant, right? You that's your first impression when you walk in the door, and that's what marketing should be doing. but it's even beyond that. I feel like marketing isn't just one department. It's every person within an organization. They all represent the brand and are all your salespeople. And then it goes beyond just, you know, the people within your organization. It goes to your customers. It becomes part of you, you know, your municipalities, your city leaders, anybody that's gonna be touching your product at the end of the day. become marketers for you. And so it's how do you represent your brand? How do you tell that story? How do you set yourself apart from any other provider that might be like you? and, you know, allow yourself to be represented in a way that tells what your brand and history of a company is and why a consumer should pick you.
Lindsay: Yeah, I love what you said there. And I actually I I kind of want to talk to our panel about this. How important is executive buy-in for marketing and for your executive team to be on the same page and for marketing to have a seat at the table in determining what happens operationally and kind of soup to nuts, start to finish to really execute a marketing strategy well? Maybe Amber will start with you if you'd like.
Amber: sure. I for me, I feel like when you look at your executive leadership and you have representation across the board, operations, IT, technical support, finance, accounting, you know, the the list goes on and on. You all make up a piece of a recipe, right? To get your end result. So you all play a part in what you're doing. but I think with marketing, you know. It it's a it's a connection of really understanding the whole organization and what's happening because marketing doesn't happen just, you know, after the fact of when you get the build done. It starts way before that. It starts when your business development team is going out and looking at where to build next and how to connect with that community. And it starts early on. So marketing has a seat at the table the whole time. and has to have their ears open and listening how to connect the dots in order to understand how to best serve that next community that you're going to. And I think it allows for an easier operation to take place from start to finish. So to me it's, you know, it's crucial to have a seat at the table, but then it's, you know, it's telling, it's doing exactly what we just said, right? It's storytelling, enabling yourself to understand who is your market, who are you going after, what makes them different from the next. You know, we recently when we all were on a panel, you know, we all have that stigma of you build it and they will come. And that is not true. That's not how it's happening in today's world. And and it's very important to set yourself apart. but that takes executive buy-in and believing in what you're telling, and everyone working together as a whole.
Curtis Dean: I think that part of the challenge that marketers face in getting that executive buy-in is that that's you have to be able to speak their language, right? you know, especially you know, if you're looking at like a CEO of a company or a high level manager, they've got a million different things on their plate. They've got to be A little bit of a technician, a little bit of an HR person, a little bit of all these different job pieces. And so when you're communicating with them about marketing, you have to be able to put it in terms that they can understand. I'm not saying dumb it down, although you might have to do that, but make sure it is they understand it in terms of the bigger picture of the entire company. And and so that they understand that marketing layer is just as important
Load full transcript
as the operations layer or the installation layer or whatever. different layers of your company. So I think that that is a challenge. But if you do that successfully, then your executive team is going to be one of your best allies.
Jill Marx: Yeah, I'll I'll build on what both Amber and Curtis said. And I totally agree. It's like executive buy-in is everything. I sit on the executive leadership team for our organization, which is really helpful. So I give weekly updates to our team and then we have quarterly two hour, you know, marketing updates. And so we talk about the previous quarter, we talk about the plan going forward, you know, where we are. relative to the goals that we set, you know, for the year. and so we do that quarterly. And then we also, because we're a municipality, we also meet with our city manager and our deputy city managers quarterly as well and sort of talk to them about our marketing budget, our strategies, you know, what we're doing out in the community. And and there is a little bit of internal education that has to happen. You know, our executive director is a civil engineer by trade. But you know, so he so he and I are learning from each other all the time. and you know, even just me saying something like, you know, our our our paid digital versus our organic digital, you know, that that is sort of meaningless to to a lot of people unless you work in marketing. And so I think just like yeah, just doing a little bit of internal education and and gaining buy-in from that and then also showing them the results. Like I think that's what we really
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: we work on in those quarterly marketing meetings is like look at the at the results, look at the the ROI, the impressions, the engagement, look at, you know, anecdotal information that you're getting at events and sponsorships in the community. And so I think just like everyone on the leadership team having a little bit of ownership over the marketing program helps and and I think yeah just U understanding I think for leaders who maybe are not as familiar with marketing, understanding that there's it's an art and a science as well. And so, yeah, just learning as we all go.
Curtis Dean: Right.
Lindsay: So how do you determine, you know, what effective marketing looks like in within our industry or what actually is a success and then how are you kind of talking to leadership about that? And anyone can take this one.
Amber: I think for me it's you know, it goes back to budget, it goes back to what are your leads and sales looking like. It it all goes to numbers, right? A lot. It's hard to tell a story. And we as marketers, we love the pretty things, right? We love the creative, the campaign development, the storytelling side. But when you're a leader and you're making, you know, cost effective decisions, you're really analyzing what's happening in the marketplace, it comes down to the numbers. So it's really evaluating, you know, the leads and sales. The tough part about marketing is that you are talking about brand awareness. You know, there's not a great way to measure it unless you're getting leads and sales. But even then, it's still a struggle, right? We all know that a marketing, a strong marketing mix is what's gonna drive leads and sales. You can't just have one type of marketing, one channel of marketing. It's a whole, you know, melting pot of all the different things that eventually drive a consumer to not just be a lead, but then turn into an ultimate, you know, a conversion and a sale. And so I think it's really reflecting on those numbers, looking at what's, you know, happening. And you know, what works in one area may not work in another. So it's always going back and trying to re-evaluate what's happening. You know, we have for us, we have areas that really rely on that local community feel. So they're hearing about us at events and they're really engaging and they're saying, my friend Bob over here told me that you guys are the best. I want to go with you. But then you have communities that are very quiet and they they don't do that and they hear and their best channel to get their attention is maybe direct mail.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Amber: and some digital placement. You have commuters and commuter cities where maybe, you know, listening to a radio ad is what's going to connect to them. So it's just really understanding your audience and then reporting back on that and saying, okay, well, what's working? What's actually driving? And like I said, it's not going to be the same for every area. And it's really understanding that and being able to step back and look at your data and make data driven decisions by seeing what that story is telling you to do.
Curtis Dean: One thing I would say too is it's important as a person involved in marketing is to never assume you know your audience as well as you think you do. you're always rediscovering who your your customers are, who your who your marketing audience is. Because it shifts, it changes. And well the the the you know, it not only because people, you know, move in and out of a community, but their preferences change, how they consume media changes. So you always have to constantly be reintroducing yourself to what their needs are, what their preferences are, so that you can be effectively reaching them.
Jill Marx: Yeah, and I think I I think every, you know, every channel has sort of its own way to measure it. And so I think like obviously that's why we like to do a ton of digital because it's super measurable. and and also, you know, I I think I mentioned when we did the panel is that we just did 10 bus wraps in the community and they're beautiful and they're big and they're driving around town and you know, people on the team were like, okay, let's do 10 more. And it's like, we can totally do that. Those are really hard to measure. but also they're great for brand awareness. And so I think, I think understanding the different
channels and and how to measure the effectiveness of each of those channels. And then I think also understanding which channels are really hard to measure, but then looking at maybe some some natural marketing signals like traffic, website traffic going up.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: we've doubled down on our market research this year. So we we're doing quarterly focus groups with different audiences in the community. and so really like deep diving in those of like, you know, what what are you listening to? Where are you in the community? and and I mean, yeah, we just did one with our college students in town. We learned a lot from that, you know. and and so I think. just knowing which ones, you know, how to track each channel and then knowing what effectiveness looks like and a good ROI. And then also there is like a little bit of like you kind of have to take a leap of faith with some of these channels and just understand that it's gonna be that's gonna be that top of funnel like high brand awareness that's gonna kind of lift everything.
Curtis Dean: Yeah, sometimes you have to just try things and you may not be able to evaluate whether how successful it was until after you try it. I know back in my in in the when I was doing a daily marketing budget for a broadband company, I had, you know, the normal channels that I did, but I was had this little contingency fund over there for s to try something different, something that I hadn't done before to see if it generated results. and sometimes the all the results were
Jill Marx: Yeah.
Curtis Dean: with somebody catching you at the grocery store saying, Hey, I saw that banner you put up in the outfield at the at the baseball stadium. That was cool. But, you know, you need to, you know, explore because that's how you'll discover what new channels may be out there that are emerging that you weren't aware of.
Lindsay: Yeah, I love the the multi channel approach that you know you all really mentioned. And I think too you need all of these channels and it depends on your market segmentation and your demographics and even the time of year. I think all of this matters and factors in. One thing that I think you brought up, Jill, and maybe Amber as well, I I think that there's something to be said for mailers, yard signs. I love the world of digital. I think it's great. But can you talk to us about why printed material works and how you all are utilizing it? And then how are you capturing it on the back? And I know most people don't remember and say, I saw our yard sign. Maybe they do, or a door hanger. How are you measuring that until let's talk about print for a second?
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Jill Marx: yeah, so we I know I I don't I didn't come from the broadband industry. So then when I, you know, started four years ago with connection and and you know kind of learn more about the industry, it's like direct mail still really works in telecom. and so we we've tried a number of ways to do our direct mail.
We try to do a a big quarterly direct mail to all our perspective. prospective customers because since we're a municipality, we have like address information and and then we can we can determine, we can filter out who our current customers are versus our prospective customers. and yeah we've just we try to make it suit as measurable as possible. And so we we do so each of our residential sales reps we we create a piece of collateral that has a unique phone number on it.
Amber: Yeah.
Jill Marx: in a unique QR code so that we we can measure the sales and leads that way. and then we just again, like for us, we just really try to since we're so like hyper local, we have a our our community has a lot of trust in its local government, which is which is not the same everywhere. Like, like Amber was saying, communities are different. Like I've lived in some communities where I'm like, they would never, they would never go for the municipal fiber internet, you know? but in Fort Collins, we're lucky that people really trust the local leader leadership. And so I think too, like to talk about the yard signs, like you know, we do a yard sign promotion. So every time every new customer that signs up, you get ten dollars off your first bill if you put a sign in your yard for 30 days. Really simple, right? And and it's like I am always shocked at how many people
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Jill Marx: Say they got our service because everyone else on their street had a sign in their yard. But that's really kind of like that word of mouth, right? Because you trust your neighbors and your friends, honestly, you know, more than than a digital marketing campaign, maybe. and so so I think it's one of like like direct mail and yard signs, that those are two tactics that we'll never stop doing just because they work so well. and
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Jill Marx: And yeah, I mean it's like some of the some of the more stuff that you would think of as more old school, sometimes it's like back to basics. It's like that works that's more effective than you than you maybe think it would be.
Curtis Dean: One.
Amber: I would say so direct mail is is one of my favorites, but that's just when I started a long time ago in the industry I worked for a a T V provider. And so anyways, it it worked so well. And so I I love direct mail, but I think it's because you can tell a different story than what you would be able to tell like in radio, digital and otherwise.
Curtis Dean: Sure.
Amber: and it is trackable. People, you know, there there it isn't just like direct, you know, like dig digital world. You're able to track, you know, you can use phone numbers, QR codes, unique promo codes, et cetera. There's ways to track it, which is very effective. you also know exactly who you mail and who connects, right? So it's the easiest one for one measure that you could ever get. I just really like it because you're also able to target a core, you know, very specifically to your consumer. So with depending on your segmentation, you're able to bring in some of that persona marketing and really understand who you're talking to with your consumer. you're able to really analyze the data of the community you're looking at and make sure that you're getting in front of the right people. You know, if you're mailing, you know, small family in a small community that's, you know, the suburbs versus, you know, maybe a retirement area. Those are two different messages and you're able to do that within direct mail and it really clearly communicate. so I I really like it from a a direct mail. I mean, for us, that's one of our biggest budget drivers is you know, we really enjoy utilizing that channel. It is a phone driver for us, it's all of those things. I think the other thing is is with print media though, in general, is you have so many opportunities in these communities to really effectively, you know, communicate your brand and your storytelling, whether it be
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Amber: You know, within newspapers, your traditional, you know, advertisements, anything that you see within the chamber. I mean, there's all kinds of opportunity that's out there that's beyond just the digital realm, which is really nice. people really do interact with it. And I think you see that. and I will agree with you, Jill. I love yard signs. I think it's a great way for someone to know that you're connected, especially when you're not a big ISP. You know, you always hear the big names and you get kind of, I mean, overwhelmed by it because you just assume that's who you have to go with. But when you're driving down the road, you know, I I also live in Colorado and you there's a couple of new guys that are coming around and the only way I would know that they were here is because you see them, right? You see their signage and you see it in the yard and you're like, they just got installed. It must be available to me now. And that's the type of conversation starter you want within that community, because then it drives, you know, that action to really get them connected.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm. I have just have a question for Amber and Jill since they're doing this on a daily basis, and I'm more on you know off on the side in my current career. are you how important is it and how much effort do you go through to culture your address lists that you're sending your direct mail to? Because I know back in when I was actively doing marketing every day, that was a real challenge for me, is getting a good address list that that was actually going to be delivered to the right people. So It are you are you I mean I mean Joe you mentioned you've got an ad list of every address in town as a municipality have access to that, but how do you you know, are are people buying mail lists based on demographics? I'm just curious about that.
Jill Marx: Mm-hmm. I think for us, yeah, I think we are maybe a little unique in that and that we do have like the add like the physical address list to every
residence in town. We might not, you know, have the the right resident that lives there, but but we do have access to that information and I think and then from there, yeah, we just like filter and segment. So, you know, we like we We sent one to wired but inactive households. So, you know, because those are those are a quick turnaround as far as like install goes. So so we, you know, filtered out all the homes that had service before, but maybe don't anymore. And so and then said, Hey, did you know that we can, you know, offer them a unique promo code? Did did you know we can get you set up within, I don't know, 48 hours? and And and you know, filtered it that way. Something else we like we've just did Fort Collins is a is a deep college town, you know, they're the largest employer in our community. And I think Colorado State has over thirty thousand students. And so so we just did a a student mailer and and you know, worked with our GIS department to really like set some boundaries on
Curtis Dean: Mm.
Jill Marx: on like which neighborhoods are really student heavy and then filter out the current customers, filter out in inactive in MDUs, so non-serviceable MDUs, and then and then just created our list from there. But yeah, it is a little bit tedious and it does take a little bit of work. And then, you know, occasionally we'll get a a person that says, you know, please not do not send me direct mail to my home. But but
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Jill Marx: Like Am building off what Amber said, you can tailor the messages so sp make them so specific and so targeted. And then I mean, even or if it's a certain neighborhood where there's like a neighborhood community event in that neighborhood, you can even speak to that a little bit. Or you know, you can really we you can just do some deep segmentation off of like their location. so yeah, I don't I don't know, Amber, you can add to
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: I don't know if what I said mak is making sense at all.
Amber: It does. I I think it goes back to segmentation marketing and really understanding your list, right? You know who you're building to, you know the community. You're able to get demographic data very easily about those. and you can always, you know, you can model off of that and use different tools, CRM tools, et cetera, to really understand and mold those audiences. So then you know who you're mailing. but like I said, you know exactly who can who's serviceable and who you can mail to. And I think just taking that at its most basic form and then backing into all the rest of the data, demographics and analysis, you're able to really tailor the message. Is it always going to be 100%? No. But as you tailor that message and you really get to know the consumer, you start to understand their buying behavior. you know, I highly recommend utilizing CRM tools so that you're able to understand how many different pieces because yes, it's direct mail, but also what they're responding to elsewhere.
You know, the digital message, the Facebook message, the social media that's coming in. Are they able to hear the radio ads if you place those? You know, did they drive by a billboard that you have? Is that in their local community? When you kind of start pulling that all together into the mix, you can kind of understand, well, what's resonating? because I, you know, the the comment is, you know, you need to see something eight times before you're gonna act. And so is, you know, is all those things happening? Does it have to be just direct mail? No, absolutely not. But there's a you know, there's a good mix in there. And I think
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm. Right.
Amber: taking those learnings, you are able to refine what you're doing.
Curtis Dean: I got another question. I'm sorry. I yeah, when I got marketing brains around me, I just have lots of questions. Are you for direct mailings, are you finding certain formats of like postcard size work better than others? Or you'll be able to really analyze that? I I've I've been told by various, the big ones don't send them because they're too big and others say, Well, the small ones are too small. I don't know what what size or format and timing wise.
Lindsay: I love it.
Curtis Dean: I assume you don't want to do it postcard mailing during an election.
Jill Marx: We've tried a variety of of like sizes and formats. we did we like maybe three years ago now I did one that was like open and it was like it kind of opened up and it was multiple pages. That one that one worked pretty well. We also did like a recently we did a die cut one. So it had it was like had like a flower shape.
Curtis Dean: yeah.
Jill Marx: it it was a little bit expensive to print, but it was it was adorable. The the mailing like some of them got a little bit messed up in the mail. I mean, you know, we are work we're like working with snail mail here. So but honestly the the to me it's not I think I think our regular four by six or five by seven direct mail piece works just as well as long as there's a good promotion on it. So that's what we've found. It all
Curtis Dean: Right. It all goes back to the message, not necessarily the
Jill Marx: Yeah, it all goes back to
Curtis Dean: the shape of the paper.
Jill Marx: the message. And I think Amber said this maybe on the panel or when we were leading up to the panel, but like we've really done we've had like consistent direct mail campaigns. So we'll have artwork that looks similar and it's kind of you know, and so maybe like seasonally we'll update it a little bit, update the message or the promotion a little bit, but it but like you can tell it's it's from the same direct mail campaign. And so one of our best promotions that we do because it's a it's a good deal is first two months for two dollars and so like i mean I know it maybe it sounds cynical but it's just like the a really good promotion that's what that's what gets the calls and the signups, you know? but yeah we've tried it we've tried a the die cut one was like so cute. We were so proud of it. Like I think you can like open it and then like it pull out the flower. It was adorable. But
Curtis Dean: Ha ha ha.
Jill Marx: You know, honestly, yeah, a four by six postcard works just fine too.
Curtis Dean: And I suppose you really have to mix it up, right? If you you can get creative like that and something that's eye catching, but then sometimes you just go back to the basics. Yeah.
Jill Marx: Exactly.
Amber: Yeah, I would I would
Lindsay: Come ahead Emma.
Amber: to just go off of that. I think it's a mix for sure. I think it's a mix of different formats so that you're always mixing it up a little bit. but also at the same time staying consistent with your message and the branding, right? You don't want to get lost where you're looking at someone and someone can't even find your name of who your company is. Like you almost want to be able to identify that you know it's you know, unfortunately, it's you we always get those credit card ones, right? Everyone always gets the credit card.
Jill Marx: Okay.
Curtis Dean: Mm.
Amber: But you know it's a credit card, right? You know that it's MasterCard or you know it's Visa or whoever it is at that moment because it's very distinct and you know what that offer is. but I think it's the offer, the promotion, the message that you have on there. and then something that you know a lot of people I don't know if they take advantage of is you know, the the postal service always is offering discounts. Pay attention to what those discounts are so you're getting the most for your dollar. You know, sometimes it's as simple as just, you know, mixing up the type of envelope you're using. you know, it's adding a little texture, whatever it might be, but then that also helps drive down some of that cost and make you a little bit more efficient while not having to make a giant change to your camp, you know, your campaign itself.
Lindsay: We've had some customers too. I I love direct mail. I think it works really well for a lot of our customers. And they have really been focused on doing things purposefully f throughout the year. So it's it can't just be one, one message, one postcard, and you kind of wait and and you see what happens. And they've actually had some success. Yes, as Jill, you mentioned those promotions I think get a lot of calls and and get a lot of activity and the sign ups online are great. But they've I I know two people that have had a lot of success doing, you know, like Santa visits or hosting an event and using a postcard to promote the local event. And I think, you know, you do the QR code, you get them into your funnel, into your CRM by saying RSVP here, it's free, you can bring the kids. a lot of people I know too have had success with summer picnics or summer events, same same sort of scenario. So I know we touched on segmentation a little bit.
Curtis Dean: Yeah. Yeah.
Lindsay: But for somebody maybe who's starting at ground
zero, how do you all define your segments and your kind of ideal buyer personas and what really works for channels for each segment? So what have you found?
Amber: I can I can start. I I think it's really, you know, I I think it's reading the data, right? It's the first thing is really understanding, but it's also communication within your organization itself. Understanding your business development team, what have they learned? You know, there's always market research that's going into when you're you're looking at a build, but understanding who that is, right? Understand the lay of the land, do your research on the area you're in, and then start to kind of play around and test. You know, you don't know and what you don't know. So you have to kind of test. I don't think it's like a you know, let's just spray and pray everyone's gonna get all the direct mail and they're gonna respond. That's not the best mix, right? You have to kind of try a few things. And if you're getting respondents, great. If not, turn it off and move to the next one. Or, you know, shift your dollars around so that you're doing a mix of different marketing. But I don't think there's a perfect recipe for any one market. I think it's almost like you gotta kind of throw it all at the wall, see what kind of sticks and then kind of refine over time. The other thing that I think is a struggle it's not as much as in the digital world, but in the offline channels, you can't just throw it out there and expect some magic to happen over, you know, 14 days, 30 days. You're waiting sixty to ninety days before you really get a feel for what's happening. And I think that's the hardest part is someone that might be just starting out, they want that instant, you know, gratification of knowing that calls are happening and actions taking place. That's not how it happens, right? We have to give it some time. So the other thing I do think it's, you know, important is that you do need to rely utilize your digital channels though.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Amber: in those areas because they are able to quickly learn, take those learnings and apply them elsewhere. You know, something that might be resonating in digital may just as well resonate on radio or, you know, direct mail or maybe a tagline in a billboard or that offer that's driving, but kind of utilize all of it. So don't just, you know, get narrow tunnel vision on one thing and expect the instant result. You have to kind of explore all options.
Jill Marx: Yeah, and I can build off of that too. I think so I think it's just a deep knowing of your community. and I think, you know, being a municipal provider, we might have, you know, just a deeper knowledge of that. just because our audience is like, you know, so specific. it's it's within the city limits. And And and you know, there are our constituents. So we so we really try to like we understand the makeup of the community and the demographics. but what I will say, so and yes, I think Amber, it's like a lot of it is just trial and error and what resonates with people. I can give an example of late last year. like I said, Fort Collins is home to Colorado State University. And and so they're the C CSU students and then faculty and staff are a huge part of our community. And and so at the end of last year we sort of pulled, we have almost 27,000 customers. We pulled demographic data and learned that really we only had like maybe 500 customers that are in that 18 to 24-year-old range. Well, so we're missing like a huge part of our community. And so basically we just dove in and did a lot of research. We did a a CSU focus group, CSU student focus group.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: This past spring, learned a lot about why or why not? you know, they're choosing us. And so and just like many of them don't have a choice because they live in multi-dwelling units that have bulk deals with our competitors. Okay, so that's you know, that's some of the problem. So how do we, how do we, you know, try to get bulk deal deals in some of those apart student apartment complexes? And then also just again, like just doing our research, like what resonates with students? Where are you? We learned that they are, you know, this might seem obvious, but they're very, they very much respond to digital. And so so doubling down on that for that audience, that channel for that audience. And then also we're doing like some fun on campus events this summer with student orientations. We're gonna do a some collaborations with Rocky Mountain student media. So
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: doing like some on campus interviews with you know some some content creators on campus and so just like trying to get creative and how do we capture that audience because that's a huge just like we would have never if we hadn't sort of dug into our demographics and researched a little bit about you know our audience segmentations like we would never know that we had so few of that audience and sort of like you know learning what exactly resonates with them and how to how to get their attention because it's hard.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Lindsay: question about that, Jill. So I know that you mentioned I love the focus group's ideas and actually not just assuming what segments want or what 18 to 24 year olds are are looking at, but actually asking them. And I'm curious what you found, and I know that you're you know working with their media on site in terms of you know going to social and social channels, what were your what did they say? And then how is influencer media or how do they look online to determine their buying decisions.
Jill Marx: So we advertised so we advertised the focus group on Instagram and then I think like posters on campus and then maybe like email newsletter or something. Every single participant, I think we had 10 participants, learned about the focus group through Instagram. They said they did not even see the posters on campus. We were like, okay. so you
know, I mean, they told us funny stuff. They said that, you know, we were too stiff. Like we were inviting them to this focus group. We incentivized with a gift card and then a free lunch. And we you know, they were like, I we you know, it was very stiff. Like when you were like, Hello students, do you want to participate in a focus group? They were like, you know, you d they didn't know if it was a AI robot or whatever, you know, if they didn't know if the ad was real. and so, you know, so so but even hearing that feedback is like is I mean some of it was hard to hear, but but
Curtis Dean: Yeah. Ha ha.
Jill Marx: just like learning, you know, they also like humor resonates with them, which again sounds sounds obvious. Many of them had the the national competitor in town as as their service provider and really are were like unhappy. You know, they were like, I'm unhappy with my current service, you know, at my apartment complex. So you know please feel free to tell me like explicitly how you're different. and so and you know, even doing that in a humorous way. yeah, and we we're partnering with some Rocky Mountain student media content creators. I you know, they're sort of like influencers. there's there's a little bit of risk in that because you know, they're creating their own content that that resonates with CSU students. But but I think I think, you know, CSU and the city of Fort Collins are so Or have such a good partnership in the community that I think that the it's worth the risk. and it's j it I think for that demographic, it's like they really want to hear from their peers. You know, they really wanna hear, they don't want to be like sold to from some company. They want, they wanna know that, you know, this is what their peers are choosing and here's why.
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Lindsay: Yeah. No, I love
Jill Marx: That answers your question.
Lindsay: that. Curtis, what are your thoughts too? I know that and I and I'm interested in checking back in with you, Jill, in a couple of months and seeing how kind of the influencer campaign works because I think there's some risk because like you mentioned, you can't control the messaging or the narrative as well when it's, you know, other people being able to do this online. K interesting interested to hear from Curtis and Amber.
Curtis Dean: Okay.
Lindsay: What do you all think you know, about kind of utilizing different channels, especially when targeting that younger demographic or what else have you been doing that's working for kind of your eighteen to twenty four year old?
Curtis Dean: Sure. I I I'm a big believer in meeting people where they are. I don't try you know, instead of trying to coerce people to get your message away they aren't using you know, consuming media, meet them where they are. Big fan of events or visibility. like I think that's perfect for a a college campus, being visible, being, you know, seen and in part you know in their natural environment. but you know I'm also thinking that in addition to we're talking about kind of almost like mass marketing, but I think direct sales is really important. That, you know, door to door, whatever you want to call it, is is vital. And I and I think that that's something that a lot of ISPs are not utilizing well. And I think it's because they don't have the internal skill set to train and coach those people. or or they they or they want to farm it out to somebody and find a direct sales
Lindsay: Mm.
Curtis Dean: you know, company to do that for them and and and or have done so when they had a bad experience. So they give up on it. But I think that's that's a very important channel that some ISPs, especially I think Jill, like ones in your position, municipalities are shy away from that and and maybe th they shouldn't for sure shouldn't do it. Cause that's r I mean it's a relationship a one on one is is in the end, that's how you make a sale is two people talking about something. A piece of paper gets their attention, but in the end it's a it's a discussion between two people.
Jill Marx: Yep, hundred percent agree.
Amber: yeah, I I agree with all that. I also agree with event marketing. I think you see a lot of people, you know, younger folks that are going out festivals, county fairs, all the things that, you know, local communities are doing. I think digital is obviously a really big one, but it's also offer. I think it's really the offer and promotion to grab that audience's attention, right? And and making sure that you are promoting it in a way where they can connect, you know, the dots of
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Amber: Why is this beneficial to me? Why pick your brand? Your, you know, why are you the most reliable? and I also think just playing around, you know, with with other top forms of digital type of advertising, whether it be CTV, radio, ads, etc., those are all things that they're engaging with and connecting to. But then also just word of mouth, I think that really, you know, goes a long way of understanding what's, you know, who's the best provider out there. They want to make sure it's someone reliable.
Lindsay: Mm. Do do all of you or any of you know do you do review campaigns or have you had success with the review campaigns or getting kind of doing a push to get more Google reviews or getting that feedback and then keeping that captured so that people can when they look you up, they can kind of see and get that, you know, nod from their their peers or people in the community?
Jill Marx: Yeah, so we rely heavily on Google reviews. Like I said, I mean, we are we're so local and so people really do like word of mouth and and just community perception is so important to us. and so we've done some like internal contests for our installers, like Whoever gets, you know, like there's a prize for whoever gets the, you know, the most Google mentions, review mentions. We were finding that it was, you know, like we would our installers would be deliver or even our CSRs
would be delivering this like amazing experience, getting so much feedback. And I would always be like, ask for the Google review. And they thought that was very awkward. so our our marketing agency actually suggested this, but and it was a great idea, but
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: so we just made them little business cards for Google reviews with the QR code. And so if they're having like a great interaction with a customer, you know, and even like at our CSR, even at the CSR window, same thing. and then you can just hand them a a business card that's like, hey, you know, if if you feel up to it, you know, here's the here's a way to do a Google review. And so that it then the card explains. everything how to do it QR code that leaves them right there and so that helped a lot and then the internal contests the like internal incentives work so great too yeah they get like super competitive with it and but I do I think like I think that really matters we also monitor our Reddit thread and you know we don't respond as as an organization we you know because
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Jill Marx: We just feel like that's a place where people should be able to honestly share their feelings and shouldn't be, you know, you shouldn't be have to in interact, you know, with a an employee, but but like we just monitor and we we take that feedback and we're like, okay, it seems like this is a challenging customer, you know, touch or whatever. Or there's, you know, there's a lot of tech support calls around this one issue. And we so we sort of like monitor those channels or like next door channels and kind of see what people are saying and just like modify our customer experience based on on that feedback.
Curtis Dean: Yeah, reviews are reviews are amazing as long as they're positive. And
Jill Marx: Yeah.
Amber: I think what's interesting is is you say reviews, but I also think it plays into t customer testimonials, right? Like really allow your customer to tell your story for you. Someone's gonna believe your, you know, your next door neighbor before they're gonna just r view a random, you know, advertisement. so I think we're relying heavily on those as well and it plays a big part.
Curtis Dean: Yes.
Lindsay: Yes.
Curtis Dean: Yeah, I think that's another channel that honestly a lot of ISPs don't use as as much as they could and should is the testimonial route. and gathering testimonials from the demographics that you want more customers from would be really helpful if you can identify who those people are and you know, burden them with the opportun. Because you know, we're all naturally we don't want to ask people things like that, but you know, you have to kind of get to point where it's just part of your flow of business.
Lindsay: Agreed. And if you can use a CRM and be on a cadence where you say, let's, you know, check in with it it it makes it easier. okay, last burning question. I I know we've talked about segmentation and we've talked about channels that work and you know, what works and what doesn't and kind of, you know, iterating as you go and and and seeing using the data to really see and define your story and and focus on what channels. Okay, but let's get back to maybe the whole point of all of this or how we how we do all of this. How do you define a marketing budget at all? Like where do you start and how do you define that and what does that look like? And we'll start maybe with Amber.
Amber: I think for me it's really understanding the organizational goals, right? As an as an overall organization, not just marketing, but what are we trying to achieve as an organization and working your way backwards from that? You know, you know how many homes passed you're trying to hit for a year, you know how what your sales goals are, you know what your connect goals are. Work backwards and figure out where does that play in and really figure out what what's your, you know, the average cost per acquisition that you're willing to spend.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm.
Amber: to go after and start backing into your numbers and your channels. You know, you know how which channels are the most effective. and you really gotta rely on the ones that tell the best story from a numbers perspective. So which ones can you get the best reporting from, whether it be digital, direct mail, you know, the the phone call interactions, promo codes that you're utilizing so that you know which ones are actually driving that, you know, sales and leads. and then work backwards from there and understand what that mix looks like. And it you know, it's not easy, it's not like a you know, snap of the fingers that it's done, but it really comes down to just playing the math and understanding what that end goal is. And I think starting from that end goal and working your way backwards is the best way to start.
Lindsay: Yeah, I love the working backwards.
Jill Marx: Yeah, I was gonna say,
Curtis Dean: Hundred percent agree.
Jill Marx: yeah, just beg. No. I think I think I think what Amber 100% agree with what Amber said is just like determine your marketing cost per customer acquisition and then just just driving that home. Like even in the cause sometimes it feels like you know, we're spending so much money on marketing, and it and it's like
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Jill Marx: Well, the industry standard for telecom, you know, cop marketing cost per customer acquisition is this, and we're way below that. And so I think just like, yeah, showing the data and industry data. And then that's where also our agency helps so much because they work with so many different industries. And so they'll always, you know, they'll always back me up of like, you're actually per spending only this small percentage of your revenue on marketing, whereas most industries or you know, most companies that we work with spend a much larger percentage on marketing. And so that always like, you know, I'm always like so thankful that they can do that and just like
have that more broad perspective. but yeah, I think I think just always coming back to that c cost per acquisition.
Lindsay: Thank you.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm. And and making sure the dis the the the leadership level, the decision makers understand that it's not an expense, it's an investment. just like if they are going to replace a piece of customer premise equipment, it's an it's an investment in a in in in in your entire operation. So it it is important to look at it that way as a part as opposed to just lighting dollar bills on fire.
Lindsay: Yeah. I love what you said there, Curtis, because I do think too, we always think of marketing and acquiring new customers, new subscribers, right? But it's also making sure that we're educating our current customers so that they feel the value in their current plan and don't leave. So it's also what is the cost of not continuing to educate and what is the cost if we don't do this promotion promotion with churn on the back end. So any thoughts around that?
Curtis Dean: Yes. Yep. Exactly. Acquisition and retention. They have to have both focus focuses. And I would say another thing is not just acquisition and r retention, but reputation. You know, you're constantly reinforcing your brand and it may not lead to a sale, but it will lead to a the stickiness of your product to to hopefully build that re not only reinforce that that retention, but also help with acquisition. So
Amber: I would also say it's just really looking at your full customer journey. It's not just a a start and stop. It's a full life cycle and you have to maintain it from start to finish. and realizing, you know, you have to engage with them well after they become a customer. You know, having a well thought out, you know, retention program, but not even just retention. It's just helping your, you know, your customer understand that you're not just collecting money from them every month. You are educating them, new products, new services, things are changing. This is a technology world, things are gonna change. The product that maybe they had three years ago may not still fit their needs. So how do you explain that to them so that they can engage with you in a manner and and really learn about what that's available to them? but really it's a full life cycle and I think it's continuously, you know, feeding that and allowing it to continue to grow with you.
Jill Marx: Yeah, I think I totally agree. And I think you just you just don't want to the only time you talk to your customers is when they're paying a bill. You know, you want to engage with them in other ways. Yeah, through education and and that's again where like community sponsorships really come into play. I think that we sponsor two big mus music festivals in town. I think it's like it's like interacting with them at those community events and and also understanding like
Curtis Dean: Yeah.
Jill Marx: Our values are aligned, you know, like we're local and we support these local causes and events too. And so that and that's like meaningful to people. So so we've done a lot. We've like we're trying to do a lot more with our like nurture campaigns, and just, you know, staying in touch with them and not, yeah, not just constantly asking them to pay their bill.
Lindsay: Mm.
Curtis Dean: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Lindsay: Yeah, I love that. Continual and I love what Amber said of just communicating across that subscriber journey. and making sure that it's a a partnership, right? That it's communication and their needs from five years ago, they change over time. Well, thank you all so much. This has been a a wonderful conversation and thanks for joining Broadband Breakdown and we'll all talk soon.
Amber: Thank you.
Jill Marx: Bye, thank you.
Lindsay: Thank you, bye.
Curtis Dean: Thank you.