TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Bloomberg Audio Studios.
00:00:04
Speaker 2: Podcasts. Radio.
00:00:06
Speaker 3: News.
00:00:08
Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg Businessweek Daily. Reporting from the magazine that helps global leaders stay ahead. With insight on the people, companies, and trends shaping today's complex economy. Plus, global business, finance, and tech news as it happens. The Bloomberg Businessweek Daily Podcast. With Carol Masser and Tim Stenevek on Bloomberg Radio. Hi, everyone.
00:00:32
Speaker 1: Welcome to the Bloomberg Business Week weekend podcast. Artificial intelligence remained top of mind this week, with all eyes on chip giant NVIDIA Tuesday and its first quarterly earnings since the ouster of founder and longtime CEO Jensen Huang. Now, for the company, revenue more than doubled from a year ago to nearly $ 116 billion, and NVIDIA also delivered an upbeat outlook. It wasn't, though, enough for investors. A share slipped on Wednesday, the first day of trading after earnings another 2.9%. And then on Thursday, Anthropic took center stage with its record-breaking initial public offering. We unpack it all with the host of Bloomberg Tech, Ed Ludlow, in just a bit.
00:01:14
Speaker 4: Meanwhile, from Jensen to Shenzhen, geopolitics took center stage as President Trump headed to China for historic high-stakes talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. It was a major diplomatic gathering with implications for everything from global trade to technology and national security. All the latest can be found on the Bloomberg Terminal and at Bloomberg.com.
00:01:34
Speaker 1: This hour, we stay on China and take a closer look at the extraordinary economic transformation 25 years after joining the World Trade Organization. From highly automated factories and a dense battery supply chain to producing increasingly sophisticated cars at competitive prices. China's economic influence is difficult to overstate. We dig into the cover story of the December issue of Bloomberg Businessweek magazine, It Is the China Issue.
00:02:02
Speaker 4: And with Thanksgiving just around the corner, we're turning our attention to what's on the table and what's being left behind. We do that with the CEO of Share My Meals. It's a nonprofit that works to tackle two major problems all at once, food waste and food insecurity, by putting surplus meals into the hands of people who need them most.
00:02:20
Speaker 3: And then.
00:02:21
Speaker 1: We're going to get into what's everyone drinking this holiday season, from changing consumer tastes to the latest trends in wines and alcohol. Jessica Kogan, founder and CEO of HSP Brands, discusses how the beverage industry continues to evolve and what younger Americans are reaching for when it's time to raise a glass.
00:02:39
Speaker 5: All that to come.
00:02:40
Speaker 4: First, though, we stay on AI and move to our Anthropic coverage with Ed, who joined us on the company's first day of trading with
Load full transcript
Anthropic investor Sebastian Dusteroff, partner of Lightspeed Venture Partners.
00:02:50
Speaker 6: Take us back to the.
00:02:51
Speaker 4: Fall of 2023 and ahead of the Series D and the conversations that you and the team at Lightspeed were having with Dario, with Daniela, with the team at Anthropic that made you commit early, relatively early.
00:03:05
Speaker 6: Yeah. It was really the combination of us looking at this technology, this space for a year. ChartGPT was November 2022. It changed everything for all of us. We made a number of changes in our firm. And we spent the bulk of 2023 starting to learn about this technology. And then we found this company. We met at first at the tail end of 22. One of my very first meetings in 23, I had just joined at the beginning of 23, was with Anthropic. And then we were able to make this commitment at the end of 2023. And it was not obvious back then. I'm sure we can talk more about that, but that's where it started.
00:03:41
Speaker 7: Well, go deep into the story, right? It was you and two of your close colleagues, and you present this opportunity to the rest of the firm. Maybe we don't have time to go into the structure of how Monday morning meetings work and voting on a sponsor idea, but like, that was a very different Anthropic. It was scary, you know, compared to where it sits now.
00:04:02
Speaker 6: I mean, it's interesting. I wouldn't call it scary perhaps, but look, it wasn't consensus at the time, right? It wasn't obvious. I think most people talked about OpenAI at the time, and maybe most people experienced the consumer experience, ChatGPT. This was a company, less than 300 people, It was two years old, you know, less than 100 million, less than 100 million revenue. It was early. But really what we saw was, one, a focus on enterprise. We are enterprise investors, first and foremost. That resonated with us. We saw a team that was incredibly strong on the research side, but also one that we felt we had a lot of alignment with when it comes to the mission and the values of the company. Trust safety, I'm sure we'll talk more about it. But that's really what we saw. You know, and the best investments in our industry tend to be a little bit more non-controversial. Our team, the deal team, was very convinced. We got questions and that's the way it should be.
00:04:51
Speaker 4: So how long do you hold on to the investment now?
00:04:55
Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean, first and foremost, we're locked up for a while as every other investor. And then we'll see and we'll learn over the coming months. But we're still so early in the journey of this company. We're still so early in the journey of AI. So we're excited to be shareholders for a very long time.
00:05:08
Speaker 4: Do you feel like you have to lock in some of the gains to be a responsible fiduciary?
00:05:14
Speaker 6: We are responsible to ILPs. We were fortunate enough that we were able to bring many endowments and pension funds with us, and they
are shareholders and investors in this company now too. And we do have a fiduciary duty to them as well. So we'll make decisions along the way as appropriate.
00:05:30
Speaker 7: You talked about how the bravest or riskiest bets are the best ones. Is Anthropic the biggest and the best for this firm in its history, or.
00:05:40
Speaker 1: Is it close?
00:05:41
Speaker 6: It's certainly up there. There's no question about it, right? There were many really important decisions. The first one was obviously a difficult decision. We made it one of our largest investments ever at the beginning of 2025. We had to make that investment right around the time when the deep-seek moment happened. That was a very big moment. And so, yes, oftentimes these really big outcomes have these critical moments in time where, you know, you can't make one decision or another and you kind of have to take the right path. And Fortunately, we did, and that made a difference.
00:06:12
Speaker 7: It's an interesting reflection because you also talked about safety and the commitment to safety, right? And that's the balance that I think lots of people who have not had the privilege of being with the company over the last two or three years in the private markets are trying to understand. When Dario or Daniela or Krishna make a decision... that prioritizes and maximizes safety, but it might be to the commercial detriment of the company. And they seem so committed to that. But you also seem very, very relaxed about their commitment to that.
00:06:45
Speaker 6: I think it's really important. This is an incredibly important and powerful technology. By the way, it's not the first time that a technology has a dual use to it. It's almost always been this way with important technologies, whether that's fertilizers or dynamite, whatever. Take the examples, right? It's incredibly important. And I also think in the long term, both commercial and sort of safety and risk goals are actually very aligned. These enterprises that are users of the technology needed to be trustworthy.
00:07:11
Speaker 1: I want to understand, forgive me if I don't get it right, but you have some, Lightspeed has exposure to open AI as well, correct?
00:07:17
Speaker 6: We have very, very small shareholders.
00:07:19
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:07:19
Speaker 6: I mean, it pales in comparison to Anthropic.
00:07:22
Speaker 1: So in terms of how we think about these major models, Do you, though, whether it's OpenAI, maybe it's not OpenAI, maybe it's another.
00:07:31
Speaker 6: Do you see.
00:07:31
Speaker 1: A world where there's several of these large language models that exist, that thrive, that flourish?
00:07:40
Speaker 6: Yes, I believe so. I think we've seen it in the past with hyperscalers where there are multiple. I think we'll see it here again. And I think, frankly, that's healthy. I think it's healthy to have competition. It brings the best out of each of these companies. I think it's good for the world as well. And
we think there are going to be open source models on closed source models. This is not an or, it's more of an and.
00:07:59
Speaker 4: How do you draw a distinction? Mistral is also one of your investments. How do you draw a distinction between what Anthropic offers and what Mistral offers? I mean, it's not talked about as much now, but this was supposed to be the LLM for Europe.
00:08:11
Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah.
00:08:12
Speaker 6: I think there still is really an important role for open source to play, right? There's going to be sovereign angles, I think, for Europe, and I'm European, I grew up in Germany, it's still very important that there is a local model that can be used by some of the critical infrastructure that exists in Europe. I think when customers want to bring very specific data to these models in a way that they maybe cannot with the closed-source model, there is a role for that. So I do think we're going to see a world where both of them coexist.
00:08:36
Speaker 7: Sebastian, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I think that many of your peers and your colleagues that are already on the cap table would say, One of Anthropic's strengths or its probably biggest advantage was its compute strategy and that they've really executed on that. How do you think about that? And even go back a couple of years, how you felt that they were going about that differently to others?
00:09:01
Speaker 6: Yeah, I really think it is one of the core strengths and maybe one that maybe even as recently as the S1 wasn't really understood. The S1 brought a lot of that to light. I think, how did that start? Look, I think it was constraints, right? This was a company that for long periods of time had less capital than others in this industry, right? And it helped them be a little bit more creative and it's really helped them today.
00:09:22
Speaker 1: How difficult, though, do you think it's going to be? I mean, they have to spend a lot of money. Now they have more capital to play with. They can tap debt markets. Potentially the equity markets go back there as well. So they've got a lot to play with. But they've got to spend a lot To make it all happen. Yeah. How tricky is going to be getting that mix right?
00:09:41
Speaker 6: Yeah, I think Dario has talked about very openly.
00:09:42
Speaker 1: Basically, revenue staying ahead of the cost.
00:09:44
Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah.
00:09:44
Speaker 6: I think Dario has talked about this very openly in the past, that it is a very critical and difficult balance to get right. I think they've done a fantastic job so far, right? But it is an industry that requires large investments.
00:09:55
Speaker 1: Does that mean, Sebastian, as a public company, that there's going to be quarters? that it's not going to be so great because of the mix?
00:10:02
Speaker 6: I think that's possible. I think that's possible. And that's okay, right? Especially for us, we are long-term investors. For us, we're not going to think about
quarter over quarter. I know for others, it's going to matter more. And in the long term, I think it will play out.
00:10:13
Speaker 4: On the question of compute, it's actually something that our tech columnist, Dave Lee, wrote about yesterday, earlier this week. He said, and he quotes Dario Amadei in a recent interview, quote, if you buy too much, of course, you can financially overextend yourself. If you buy too little, then you can't support inference with customers. And even more importantly, you can't do the R & D to build new frontiers.
00:10:33
Speaker 7: But this is also away from the safety debate altogether. This is what the cone of uncertainty is, right? You know, the future is uncertain. So you have to also match the army of amazing engineers. You know them better than I do.
00:10:45
Speaker 2: Right.
00:10:45
Speaker 7: But they are going to be knocking down the door on the training side saying, Hey, Krishna, I need that compute. And Krishna is going to be getting visits from the go to market saying, what? You know, it's so hard.
00:10:58
Speaker 6: It is, but Krishna has talked about this quite a bit. They talk about it as sort of a fungible pool of compute.
00:11:03
Speaker 7: And there are.
00:11:04
Speaker 6: Four types of users for it. There's the training of models. There's the inference. There is an internal use of these tokens. And then there's also, what do you associate to safety?
00:11:14
Speaker 4: Do we get to a point because of technology that it's no longer a significant cost within the next few years?
00:11:19
Speaker 6: I mean, I think what we've seen is that it's already come down quite a bit.
00:11:22
Speaker 4: It has, but as a share of overall, you know, as a share of what Anthropic has had to spend, it's bounced around a little bit.
00:11:31
Speaker 6: Yeah, I think ultimately compute will continue to be very important for this industry, right? That is the lifeblood of what makes these models hum ultimately, right? But we've also seen that they're now obviously distributed across a larger and larger customer base, right? So you train the model once, you bring it out in the world, lots of people use it, it generates revenue, and there is a real scale effect to this. But it is going to continue to be important to scale this compute.
00:11:52
Speaker 1: All right, so I'm going to pull back. We've had NVIDIA in the news over the last week and a half. There's lots of concerns over the last couple of months, it feels like, in terms of the AI spend, the build-out, the return on investment. There's nervousness in the market. We see it even today with the anthropic IPO. What's your educated take on this?
00:12:13
Speaker 6: Yeah, look, it's a really difficult question. Look, it's one we ask ourselves as well. What I always try to do is sort of step back a little bit and really ask myself, is this a technology that over the longer arc of time, is it going to change every industry, every functional role, every job that exists out there? And when I ask myself that question, my resounding answer to that is yes. Does it mean that from where we sit today to that point in the future, it's going to be straight line? No. It doesn't mean we're going to have pockets along the way that are overvalued ahead of the skis. Some companies that are getting it wrong on some of these really difficult balances at Unistrike, we're going to have those instances, right? I'm not going to predict them right. I'll be very honest. But over the long term, I think we'll be right.
00:12:50
Speaker 4: Our thanks to Ed Ludlow, host of Bloomberg Tech, and anthropic investor Sebastian Dusteroff, partner at Lightspeed Venture Partners. More of our Anthropic and NVIDIA coverage on the Bloomberg at Bloomberg.com and also on our podcast feed.
00:13:03
Speaker 1: Coming up, China went from playing catch up in the auto industry to becoming a major force in the global car market.
00:13:10
Speaker 4: Now its dominance in EVs has American and European automakers scrambling to compete. We dig into China's path to modernization next. This is Bloomberg.
00:13:26
Speaker 2: You're listening to the Bloomberg Businessweek Daily Podcast. Catch us live weekday afternoons from 2 to 5 p.m.
00:13:33
Speaker 1: Eastern.
00:13:33
Speaker 2: Listen on Apple CarPlay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg Business app. Or watch us live on YouTube.
00:13:40
Speaker 1: Business Week's December issue is all about China, its path to modernization, what life is like today, what obstacles lie ahead, and how it's competing with the rest of the world. That was in focus big time as President Trump met with Chinese President Xi for a bilateral meeting at the APEC summit in China this past week.
00:13:57
Speaker 4: As Brad Stone, the editor of Bloomberg Business Week magazine, put it after his own trip to China, quote, spending time there can feel like visiting another planet. Breaking down China's turbocharged past few years, dominant present and uncertain future is the editor of Bloomberg Businessweek, Brad Stone.
00:14:14
Speaker 8: The mission of this issue was to take a big step back and to look at the overarching story of China's remarkable growth over the past 25 years. So 25 years ago, December 11th, 2001, China entered the World Trade Organization. And there are a whole bunch of expectations at the time. We explore that in a story. The belief, though, was that the West would be changing China, that you bring in China, you let free trade flow, you have the cooling winds, the warm winds, let's call them, of capitalism, and you have liberalization that comes with it. But really what's happened, apart from this extraordinary growth, China becoming a superpower faster than any country in really modern history is is you have the West kind.
00:15:03
Speaker 5: Of becoming more like China.
00:15:04
Speaker 8: You have the China shock, which we've talked a lot about over the years, lots of political instability in the West as China
becomes the factory for the world. But I think that one of the things that we pinpoint here is that China became a learner more than anyone expected. And I think the NVIDIA story is partly part of that. Yes, maybe there was an espionage factor here, but it's really all these joint ventures, the way in which China learned how the West functions how innovation happens, and became like a careful student of the West. And that is the story that we're telling in this issue.
00:15:39
Speaker 1: Brad, you went right to, I love this quote in your story. The biggest surprise over the past 25 years is that China became a much better student than everybody thought, including we Chinese. And this is from a professor of finance at a university in Beijing. Says, we learned very fast. We've talked about this with Apple. Apple moving over in China and everything that it taught the Chinese. I mean, what does it mean then for China's role going forward? I mean, talk to us about kind of how you guys divided things in the issue, because you kind of look back, you also look forward. Tell us about, because it's such a massive story.
00:16:16
Speaker 5: Yeah, so it really is.
00:16:19
Speaker 8: For the first time, actually, since Businessweek became a monthly magazine, we're devoting really the entire issue to one topic. The first part looks at the last 25 years, some of the expectations around China entering the World Trade Organization, for example, they were really worried about their car business and whether the old state-owned automakers would be extinct when you started having Western brands come in unfettered. The opposite has happened. Chinese automobiles now are on the upswing. Countries like the U.S. don't even allow them to be sold in the U.S. because of what they might potentially do to U.S.
00:16:55
Speaker 5: Automakers.
00:16:55
Speaker 8: And of course, there also is a kind of surveillance worry there. Then the middle of the magazine is really like a day in the life. We've taken a dozen everyday Chinese and looked at their hopes, their fears, their habits, how they're trying to make ends meet. In one case, how they're kind of dropping out of the economy. And then the final part of the magazine is the next 25 years. What is China's vision for the global economy? They're not the kind of country that wants to spend really blood or treasure trying to make other countries adapt their ideological framework.
00:17:29
Speaker 5: No, it's really more about economic power.
00:17:31
Speaker 8: We're seeing kind of the exporting of cultural power, Chinese chains and comedians, movie franchises being transported around the world. So we look ahead and we really ask, what does the next 25 years look like for China?
00:17:45
Speaker 4: Brad, these so-called smartphones on wheels that we've been hearing about for a couple of years. And in fact, you even had Ford CEO a couple of years ago not wanting to give up his Chinese EV that he was able to drive around for a few months. What did you see on the roads there that blew you away?
00:18:01
Speaker 5: A lot of innovation, Tim, a lot of choice.
00:18:05
Speaker 8: Chinese automakers are trying a lot of different things.
00:18:08
Speaker 5: Some of it's visible on the outside.
00:18:11
Speaker 8: LiDAR in your standard EV. Sensors where you can open the door without a key. Inside the car, massage chairs in the back seats, weird sort of robotic displays where the eyes follow you if you're talking to the car. But also things that you can't see, mileage, EVs that extend 400, 500 miles.
00:18:38
Speaker 5: And then price.
00:18:39
Speaker 8: I mean, this is the strength of the Chinese auto industry right now, where basically 60% of all cars are EVs, is their expertise in manufacturing and robotics and the density of the supply chain. Batteries make up about half the cost of an EV, and you've got BYD.
00:18:56
Speaker 5: And CATL, the two biggest manufacturers.
00:18:58
Speaker 8: Manufacturers of batteries for cars in the world that are there. And so China has a lot of advantages because they have cultivated this expertise. It started with a long-term plan from the government and private industry has followed suit.
00:19:12
Speaker 3: Right.
00:19:12
Speaker 1: You can also get, I love, is it BYD that's got a car that's got a roof-mounted drone on it. So you can get just about everything.
00:19:19
Speaker 5: You need a drone for your car.
00:19:20
Speaker 3: Talk about options.
00:19:21
Speaker 1: Talk about options. Brad, what's interesting is the Chinese model, right? They love, the government loves companies to be competitive. They encourage it. And as a result, you get a lot of companies doing some pretty cool stuff, right?
00:19:34
Speaker 5: Yeah, exactly.
00:19:35
Speaker 8: I think it was 2015 where China introduced its first long-range 10-year plan for where they talked about dominance in the EV market. And these things, you can argue about how much coordinated action there is, but the way I describe it in the piece is a kind of a bat signal to not only venture capitalists and automakers but also local governments and start provisioning land for factories and competing to bring companies like Geely Automotive that I wrote about in the piece you know to their province and set up state-of-the-art factories. I visited one Geely factory where there's a big sign in Mandarin calling it a dark factory, so it can operate.
00:20:17
Speaker 5: With the lights off.
00:20:18
Speaker 8: It is the symphony of automation and robotic arms, kind of bringing all the advantages of the Chinese supply system to bear. It's also that's one factory, but it's surrounded by all of their suppliers. So there's just total density in the supply chain, which is why like Jim Farley, when he went and took his Xiaomi EV, he said touring a Chinese automobile factory was the most humbling thing he's ever seen. because they are kind of far ahead on innovation, automation, and electric vehicle
technology.
00:20:51
Speaker 4: So do, well, let's separate Europe and the United States into two distinct geographies, which they are, but also they have different rules about these cars being imported into them. Does BMW... Does VW, does Ford, do they stand a chance competing with these companies?
00:21:11
Speaker 8: I mean, I think what we're going to see is, so let's go back 25 years. And that's the framing, as you guys know, of the issue. When China joined the World Trade Organization, there was panic inside China about what globalization would do to the Chinese auto industry. And they were talking about raising tariffs 50% to.
00:21:30
Speaker 5: Protect the state-owned automakers.
00:21:32
Speaker 8: And eventually, as a condition of joining the WTO, they had to start at 25% and gradually bring it way down. And what the Chinese automakers were doing and then increasingly did is create joint ventures. And, I mean, I remember the old Chinese taxi cab was called the Volkswagen Santana because these were– and it was a horrible-looking car, but these were joint ventures.
00:21:54
Speaker 5: And the Chinese automakers learned.
00:21:56
Speaker 8: Lei Jun of Xiaomi, the reason that he started an EV industry is he met Elon Musk in Silicon Valley. He bought his own Tesla, and he really admired it. So I think the script has to be flipped. And I think the Western automakers that right now are somewhat protected, particularly in the U.S. from Chinese competition, because we cannot buy these state-of-the-art Chinese automobiles in the United States. I think they've got to start taking that Chinese mentality and learning.
00:22:24
Speaker 5: And so these are joint ventures.
00:22:26
Speaker 8: Factories in different parts of the world where they can co-produce and start to, you know, learn and nurture the same kind of ecosystem in the West that exists in China. And that is going to take many, many years.
00:22:37
Speaker 5: And frankly, we haven't really even gotten started. You know, it's.
00:22:40
Speaker 1: Interesting at a time when we talked so much about NVIDIA over the past week, and we know Jensen Wong, the former CEO, thought was very much in favor of sharing NVIDIA sophisticated chips with China. Like you do wonder, Brad, you know, is it time for the American auto industry to kind of see what the Chinese technology does, introduce it into the United States and, you know, let the best winner win, you know, make it a competitive market.
00:23:08
Speaker 5: It's incredibly sensitive, right?
00:23:09
Speaker 8: Because we're talking about American jobs and factories and tradition and pride. You know, we have enormous pride in our automobile factory. It's not just in the state of Michigan, but but really around the country, and there's an argument that is made by the unions, by the automobile companies, that China competes unfairly, and that's a debate to have, but to a certain extent that there's subsidies, and these factories that I visited, they
come in with a lot of local and state support, and so there are arguments that it's unfair competition, but you can't really complain when the rules of the game are what they are, and so I think the West and countries like the U.S. have to do it in a way that, you know, is politically feasible and so protects local jobs, protects the companies that America is proud of, but gradually opens up to this larger world.
00:24:01
Speaker 5: And, you know, I think one of the things, obviously, the Trump administration has done is discourage the development of EVs.
00:24:07
Speaker 8: We're at 7.4% of new cars sold being electric vehicles and plug-ins. And that's just not the future. The future is obviously long-term development. not going to be combustible engines, but electric. And so I think, you know, the first thing you have to do is start opening your eyes to the way the automobile.
00:24:25
Speaker 5: Industry is evolving.
00:24:26
Speaker 1: Yeah, I do wonder, there's an auto industry consultant that he's, and also author of an upcoming book, Car Wars, that you've included in your story. And he says, I can't find a country outside the U.S. where I don't see Chinese cars. And you do wonder what happens if we are the only market that doesn't embrace these cars.
00:24:45
Speaker 8: It's not just a business question, it's a political question. Because, yeah, there are countries and states in the U.S. where those voting interests are very powerful.
00:24:55
Speaker 4: So it's not just industrial policy. What I want to dive into a little bit is what, in your view, after the time and the reporting that you spent doing this, what are global companies competing with when they compete against Chinese automobiles?
00:25:10
Speaker 8: I think the most important thing is the long-term signaling from the central government that this is the bet, a long-term bet, a 10-year plan, and the direction that they want to bring the auto industry. And so in 2015, as I mentioned, the Chinese government identified a dangerous dependency on foreign oil, on fossil fuels. And they said that it was leading to pollution in the cities and congestion, but also the potential for military conflict, for inflation and political unrest. And so they said the future is electric. And so when you have a stake in the ground like that, companies and investors and workers, they can move in lockstep with a certain amount of security. So I think, Tim, all the things you mentioned are factors. But we don't have to argue about political systems here, but having every four years in America a different policy about EVs has been confounding for companies and for the stewards of capital.
00:26:13
Speaker 4: So is it fair to say that the U.S. with rare earths is taking a page out of China's book, what the Trump administration is doing?
00:26:21
Speaker 8: Yeah, and it's hard because that's one piece of the supply chain in batteries and electric vehicles, and it's going to be incredibly hard to duplicate in the U.S., if not impossible. But there are other places in the world and allied countries where we could start to duplicate that.
00:26:39
Speaker 5: And again, it's probably.
00:26:42
Speaker 8: creating joint ventures with companies like CATL and BYD and starting to learn, you know, learn as much as we can and duplicate it.
00:26:49
Speaker 7: Yeah.
00:26:49
Speaker 1: And you think about government policies, whether it's the EV, you know, tax credit that we used to have that we don't have anymore. That really, you know, certainly gets people to think twice or possibly buy an electric vehicle. But that's it's a different environment.
00:27:02
Speaker 9: It is political.
00:27:03
Speaker 3: It's not just business.
00:27:04
Speaker 4: That was Brad Stone, the editor of Bloomberg Businessweek. The December issue of Businessweek is all about China. The issue out on newsstands December 7th. But you can check it out now on the Bloomberg Terminal or online at Bloomberg.com slash Businessweek.
00:27:17
Speaker 1: Still ahead on Bloomberg Businessweek, with the holiday season upon us, we turn our attention to the dinner table.
00:27:23
Speaker 4: From tackling food waste to the latest trends in wine and cocktails, we take a closer look at what we throw away, what we're drinking, and the changing tastes shaping both.
00:27:33
Speaker 5: That's next.
00:27:34
Speaker 4: This is Bloomberg.
00:27:39
Speaker 2: You're listening to the Bloomberg Businessweek Daily Podcast. Catch us live weekday afternoons from 2 to 5 p.m.
00:27:46
Speaker 3: Eastern.
00:27:47
Speaker 2: Listen on Apple CarPlay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg Business app. Or watch us live on YouTube.
00:27:53
Speaker 1: As we look ahead to Thanksgiving this coming week and the holiday season overall, America's food waste problem really does come into sharp focus.
00:28:02
Speaker 4: It's a problem with real economic and environmental costs. Food insecurity is where Camille Williams comes in. She's CEO of Share My Meals. It's the Princeton, New Jersey-based nonprofit that works to tackle food insecurity through recovering food waste and delivering prepared meals.
00:28:18
Speaker 1: We find it ironic in a cruel way that you have Food insecurity, people who don't have enough food to eat, and then you have food waste that is just being thrown out a lot. And then it also has an impact on the environment. It just seems like a bad cycle and an obvious one to fix. Tell us about Share My Meals because you guys are going at this problem of food insecurity and also food waste.
00:28:41
Speaker 9: Right, at the same time. So that really is the heart of our mission is to rescue prepared meals. provide them to local nonprofits who are serving members of our community that are food insecure.
00:28:54
Speaker 1: How do you do it? Tell me how you get these people and how much is out there that people are like, oh yeah, we have all this leftover stuff.
00:29:00
Speaker 9: Right. So there's an
estimate that there's about 1.4 million tons of surplus meals. And or food, I should say. And about 25% of that are prepared meals. And only 3% of that is what is being rescued through organizations similar to ours. So right now, I mean, the organization's only just over six years old. And so we're starting with commercial kitchens. So we work with you know, large corporations, you know, Johnson & Johnson, Nova Nordisk, Sanofi, and we are those commercial kitchens, those dining services. are anything that is left over, not served, they are packing up and donating to share my meals.
00:29:46
Speaker 4: The challenge, though, for you, I imagine, is that it's very unpredictable about how much you would get at the end of a certain day. Because these companies want to optimize for the people that they're serving. So any additional food is extra expense that they don't necessarily want to have.
00:30:03
Speaker 9: It is, but because it is their food dining services, it's their business to make sure that they're serving their client, which is the big corporation. So while you're saying that, you're right. But they want to make sure every day that there's enough for their customers.
00:30:19
Speaker 4: So is there a guaranteed portion for your nonprofit every day?
00:30:23
Speaker 9: No, it really is whatever is left over.
00:30:26
Speaker 4: So that makes it challenging logistically for you to then go and make those, make that those meals available to other people if you don't know how much you're going to get.
00:30:34
Speaker 5: That is true.
00:30:34
Speaker 9: But whatever it is, it is some of the most highly nutritious foods that, you know, you can provide, right? Because if you think about it at these corporate cafeterias, you know, the quality of the food that they have available for their employees is is very high. And so, you know, and they are, you know, while they are trying to watch costs and obviously they don't want to have a huge surplus, the reality is that there is a surplus. So we're also talking about hospitals, school districts. Those are all the different types of organizations we partner with.
00:31:06
Speaker 1: Well, to Tim's point, like if I was in a company at some point, I'd be like, let's be smarter about what we're ordering. Like, so like how, like, how do you, do you just have so many different people out there that they're, is going to be excess because they have to make sure that there's no shortages. I mean, does the accessible amount of food, does it vary a lot from week to week or.
00:31:30
Speaker 7: Month to month?
00:31:31
Speaker 9: Yeah, I mean, it will vary. And what we have seen when we first start with an organization, yes, you know, the donation may go down a little bit, but it's not like it goes from this huge surplus to zero. And so part of what we've been doing over the six years that we've been in existence is is just making sure like, are we connecting with all of the different corporate cafeterias that are out there? And there's so many, you know, and like I said, hospitals, school districts, you know, private schools, they all, you know, universities, there's a lot of, you know, commercial kitchens and donated food.
00:32:05
Speaker 4: So then the other logistical challenge is getting these prepared meals to the people who need them in the New Jersey area, in New York, and in parts of Pennsylvania. How do you do that?
00:32:15
Speaker 9: Right. So our number one way of doing that is through a great volunteer force. And part of the reason why we use volunteers is very strategic because what we want to make sure is that we're keeping that food safe from the moment that it gets from the donor to until we can get it to the recipient organization. And so our volunteers are out there and in a moment they pick up the food within 20 minutes, they're at a local charity. And so rather than have a 18 wheeler go around and picking it up and you know what I mean? Our volunteer force, they're committed, they're nimble, they're responsive, yeah.
00:32:52
Speaker 1: You know, one of the reasons we like to talk to organizations like you, in a perfect world, we wouldn't need an organization like you because people wouldn't be dealing with food insecurity. But having said that, you also provide a window into, we talk about wealth creation and how wealthy people are, but it's a reminder that our economy is very diverse. Tell us about some of the families that you are providing food for and just give us an idea, a window into... the family economies that you are seeing?
00:33:24
Speaker 9: Yeah, so what we know is in New Jersey, one out of every six children are living in a food insecure environment. In New York City, it's one out of every four. So it's very, very real. And as you mentioned earlier, as food prices go up, it's only limiting the dollars that these families have at their disposal. And most of the families are working families.
00:33:49
Speaker 4: What I've been shocked to find as my kids are in public school here in New York is the way that food is available to them throughout the day. Breakfast, lunch, and I think even a third meal. Does that make a dent in New York?
00:34:01
Speaker 3: It does.
00:34:02
Speaker 4: It's remarkable. It's even during the summer, too.
00:34:04
Speaker 9: Right, it does. But then we have the weekend, right? We have the weekends that these families are spending. struggling trying to figure out how to keep food on the table.
00:34:16
Speaker 4: Is that when you're more active on the weekends as a result of those services not being available?
00:34:20
Speaker 9: No, it's not that we're more active then, but Friday is a big active day, right? At the end of the week, these corporate cafeterias, whatever they have left, they make sure that they reach out to us and then that's when our volunteers... You know, Friday is a very busy day for us.
00:34:34
Speaker 1: Yeah, no, and I think you made the point, you know, you said
these are for working families. So it is a reminder that it is super, super tough out there for lots of folks.
00:34:43
Speaker 4: That was Camille Williams, CEO of Share My Meals.
00:34:46
Speaker 1: All right, no easy segue here, but it is the holiday season. And with a lot of entertaining being thrust upon all of us, in a good way, Americans' drinking habits, we're noticing, are increasingly continuing to change. And so, too, is the wine industry to adapt. From Gen Z's evolving relationship with alcohol to the growing popularity of canned cocktails and non-alcoholic alternatives, the wine and spirits industry is adapting to a new generation of consumers.
00:35:15
Speaker 4: Here to help uncork it all was Jessica Kogan, CEO of HSP Brands. She joined Carol in Bloomberg's Jess Menton.
00:35:22
Speaker 3: We're going to throw this back for a minute to an incredible book, a great business book called Who Moved My Cheese? So if you think about the wine industry, that is exactly what is happening. They have believed for decades that there is this one consumer that is going to eventually come into my business and eventually buy in at a regular premium level, then go higher and higher and higher. And that's how it's always been for the last, I would say, 50 years. But things have changed. Things have been changing very rapidly over the last 20 years, especially the last 10 years with all the RTDs. the RTSs, all of the cans that you get to open. Ready to drink, ready to drink, ready to this, ready to that. And that really speaks to kind of, so the industry has expected certain things. The world has changed. It hasn't adapted. Who moved my cheese? They were waiting, they were watching, and the world has changed. Consumers want different things. They want lighter, they want brighter, they want easier. They want something that is less of a commitment, something that is available, easy to open, affordable. And they have choices. And so it isn't just turning to wine. They can turn to anything. So wine has to work harder. They have to work harder to get into the mind space of a consumer. Are they doing it?
00:36:46
Speaker 1: Because this is what you're all about. You've got lots of proprietary technology and data and trying to figure out, How do you take a brand and really connect with consumers?
00:36:55
Speaker 3: So they are. And so we have some examples. I've brought some examples of who is doing it. But those who don't, you're going to continue to see vineyards closing, wineries shutting down.
00:37:07
Speaker 1: Breaks kind of my heart.
00:37:08
Speaker 3: It breaks my heart too. But it is the truth is that you have to win the heart of a consumer now. The wine industry has approached it very differently. They've thought, hey, this is, We just expect people to turn to wine. It's just going to be something intergenerational.
00:37:24
Speaker 1: It's been around for centuries.
00:37:26
Speaker 3: It's been around. And the dynamics are very similar to any
business, which is things are going well. Why would we change anything?
00:37:35
Speaker 9: And then.
00:37:35
Speaker 3: In parallel, something else is changing and disrupting. And that's essentially what has happened. Is it just wine, but it's also beer? So we've talked about this. So they're drinking different, right? And so, yes, they are drinking in single formats. They are saying, you know what? I'd love a camp. That's more than enough for me for tonight. Tomorrow night, I want something else. And that may be leaning into something bigger. So the whole point really is... leaning into experiences and getting the consumer to want to choose your brand instead of saying, oh, whatever, just pour me something. So it's really a mind shift. And I will say like for the wine industry, there's a lot of good things going on. A lot of like, as we say, cheese moving, that's okay. There are brands that are taking that opportunity and that's really format changes. So we have Matua, a great brand, white wine, Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand. What I love about this brand, two big trends right now. One, light, lighter, better. Speaking to wellness, there are a lot of people. I personally am not. I want a full, big, rich, heavy glass of wine. I want a full red.
00:38:46
Speaker 7: I do.
00:38:47
Speaker 1: But a lot of people don't.
00:38:48
Speaker 3: A lot of people don't. I kind of like the lighter ones, the lighter white ones. So this is a lighter Matua. So this is a lighter Matua. But this also, this is fascinating. Okay, so this is called a Bagamon. So boxed wine, we've all done it in college, right? And we pull the bladder out, and there's no branding on it. Right. But guess what? Branding.
00:39:08
Speaker 1: Right.
00:39:08
Speaker 3: Look at that. And it is based off a beloved Sauvignon Blanc that starts at $ 7. 50, and it's selling like hotcakes. It sells faster than a $ 7. 50.
00:39:18
Speaker 4: $ 7?
00:39:18
Speaker 1: Really?
00:39:19
Speaker 9: Wait.
00:39:20
Speaker 3: This is $ 20. This is a $ 7.
00:39:21
Speaker 1: 50 ML.
00:39:21
Speaker 3: This is a 1.5 liter. And it tastes the same, the quality, everything. In fact, it's easier and better.
00:39:32
Speaker 2: Really?
00:39:32
Speaker 3: It stays fresher.
00:39:34
Speaker 1: Longer?
00:39:34
Speaker 3: You can keep it in your fridge for 30 days.
00:39:37
Speaker 2: Okay.
00:39:40
Speaker 3: And you can pour however much you want.
00:39:42
Speaker 1: Exactly.
00:39:43
Speaker 3: Small glass, big glasses. So that's one way that the business is adapting.
00:39:48
Speaker 1: So is it geared towards the younger demographic?
00:39:50
Speaker 3: Yes, it totally is. It totally is. It is really understanding the consumer and where the consumer is at. Because you can have a conversation with your family. Dad is drinking Caymus. You're like, I can't drink that. That's way too expensive. That's the entry point. It's the same thing with cake bread sellers, super well-known. And then we have our cans.
which to me is the future and how we're going to see things change.
00:40:15
Speaker 1: It's like you read my mind. Let's talk about the can. So I'm going to actually open up one and.
00:40:21
Speaker 3: Tell me what we've got here. So this is Nomadica, and it's an LA startup. They make the most incredible ultra-premium wines. Now, what I love about this, this is a spritz. It's a yuzu-inspired spritz. Thank you so much.
00:40:38
Speaker 8: And.
00:40:39
Speaker 3: It's bubbly, delicious, vivacious, easy to drink. It's a single pour. You could actually pour the entire can in this glass, and you have one single serve.
00:40:51
Speaker 4: Right.
00:40:52
Speaker 3: And you don't have to buy a 750 ml. And it's easy to open, and you can take it anywhere.
00:40:59
Speaker 1: For those listening on radio, yes, we just took a sample. Oh, that's kind of fun.
00:41:02
Speaker 3: I like this. Yeah. Lovely, right?
00:41:05
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:41:06
Speaker 3: So it's not super sweet. It's refreshing. It's gentle. It's yummy. The alcohol level is about 8%. I think it's seven to 8%. So it's not super high and it's, just bright vivacious easy to drink easy to connect with and you and it's in a can.
00:41:26
Speaker 1: Right exactly listen i you know i've also been out even my husband and i who he loves he's yeah a bit of a snob about his red wines but we've done some cocktails and cans yes uh we're out and about and we just we want we don't want to make a major commitment we don't you know and it's a lot of fun um I want.
00:41:44
Speaker 3: You to try the red.
00:41:45
Speaker 5: Okay.
00:41:45
Speaker 3: So now I.
00:41:46
Speaker 8: Okay.
00:41:47
Speaker 3: Start talking about it because I have to chug this. Okay. So the red wine is a blend. Or you can pour it like a... We can pretend like we're in a tasting room here.
00:41:54
Speaker 2: Okay.
00:41:54
Speaker 3: I'm doing the sampling.
00:41:56
Speaker 1: I'm going to pour it into my.
00:41:57
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:41:58
Speaker 1: Oh, wait. I can pour... Yeah.
00:41:58
Speaker 3: I'm going to pour. Sorry. So let me tell you about this red wine. It is a blend. Okay. Tell me that. It is stunningly gorgeous, made by this incredible winemaker. And here's the thing, the message that's been out there. It's called Nomadica.
00:42:09
Speaker 9: Nomadica.
00:42:10
Speaker 3: The message out there is that you cannot have great wine in a can. The message is wrong. And I'm literally telling you the brilliance and beauty of wine that is so undersold is that it doesn't matter what everyone else says about wine. It's what you like.
00:42:31
Speaker 1: Some legs on it.
00:42:32
Speaker 3: This red is lovely. It drinks so easily. Super smooth.
00:42:39
Speaker 9: I'm going to start.
00:42:40
Speaker 3: In the palate, it has a fullness at the end, and you just open that from a can.
00:42:45
Speaker 1: That's really pretty cool.
00:42:46
Speaker 3: And that is a full, you can just pour that whole can in there. And tonight, you have your hamburger, or I don't know if you're vegetarian, you're vegetarian lasagna.
00:42:57
Speaker 1: It's normally pizza night, but I'm going to the theater, so I will probably have. But how much is this market growing in terms of the ready-to-drink, the cans?
00:43:07
Speaker 7: How much?
00:43:08
Speaker 3: Give me some numbers. All right. So here's the thing. For wine, it's very small.
00:43:13
Speaker 5: Okay.
00:43:13
Speaker 3: But here's the light. I was just with an Absco buyer in the Southwest, and they are re-merchandising their entire area around this type of wine packaging, this innovation wine packaging, because it speaks to a different consumer. to really the majority of consumers who don't want to waste, who want to experiment, who want to try and want to lean in. So I believe in the next five years, the way we see wine merchandised is going to totally change.
00:43:47
Speaker 1: Well, I am always amazed too when I go into the wine store and increasingly you're seeing cans and different things kind of starting to be up on the shelf.
00:43:54
Speaker 7: It changes the experience.
00:43:55
Speaker 4: That was Jessica Kogan, CEO of HSP Brands. Our thanks as well to Jess Menton for filling in while I was out.
00:44:01
Speaker 1: And that wraps up the weekend edition of Bloomberg Businessweek from Bloomberg Radio. Thank you so much for joining us.
00:44:05
Speaker 4: Be sure to tune into Bloomberg Businessweek daily, Monday through Friday, starting at 2 p.m. Wall Street time on Bloomberg Radio, Bloomberg TV, and on Sirius XM channel 121.
00:44:14
Speaker 1: You can also watch our daily broadcast on YouTube. Just search Bloomberg Podcasts. We're simulcast on Bloomberg Originals, available on Bloomberg.com slash originals. and streaming platforms, including Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Samsung TV Plus, and more.
00:44:28
Speaker 4: I'm Tim Stenevek.
00:44:29
Speaker 2: And I'm Carol Masser. Have a good and safe weekend, everyone. This is the Bloomberg Businessweek Daily Podcast. Available on Apple, Spotify, and anywhere else you get your podcasts. Listen live weekday afternoons from 2 to 5 p.m. Eastern on Bloomberg.com, the iHeartRadio app, TuneIn, and the Bloomberg Business app. You can also watch us live every weekday on YouTube and always on the Bloomberg Terminal.