TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Andrea: Good morning, Rebecca.
Rebecca: Good morning, Andrea.
Andrea: How is your heart?
Rebecca: My heart is a mix of really tender and really delighted. So let me explain. so my sister, her family, recently moved to Sweden and I feel like it's been... just all the things of a transition that are really challenging and can hold a lot of hidden and unexpected grief. And her son, they have a requirement in Sweden that you, in fact, not homeschool. You can go to jail for homeschooling in Sweden. And there's only a month left of school, but They had to put, she son in school for this final month and she was really nervous because they know the language. I mean, they studied hard on Duolingo and that gets you about nowhere. And so they're immersed and she's like, people are saying things and I know the word in my brain is just I don't know what you're saying. There's something different, you so she's been feeling that her son is really like sensory sensitive. And so yesterday was his first day of school and she just left me this video message this morning. just in tears about the day and like it mostly went well, but then lunch and recess, she's sitting, they let her be there for the day sitting back and she's like, my gosh, he's playing, he's running, he looks so happy. And they leave after lunch and he just starts crying and he never cries. mean, he angers his default. And so she's like, these are some big emotions. And now she's crying and she hasn't been able to stop crying since yesterday. And basically there was this kid who was really excited about him from New Zealand who spoke English more fluently than some of the other kids. So he was like, I'll take you around. And he's like, he wouldn't stop touching me. And was like pulling me around. And so he was trying to be a good sport. And then just seeing her tender heart and recognizing that wave, the way that grief in the current moment brings back all the grief. I'm like, you just need to cry. Like you just need to let yourself cry. Anyway, the delight is that she said, and if you have any ideas for how to regulate my nervous system, and I was I thought you'd never ask. So I felt useful in that moment, but also just have to let yourself cry. are the things that are here. And I was just crying with her because I know all the grief that they've gone through in their life and that when grief is up, it's just let the feeling be up and don't get caught in the story and it keep moving through you. But and also if you want me
Andrea: No.
Rebecca: to do a daily nervous system hack, I will do that. So she's on board. So it it's like I feel tender. And I'm delighted.
Andrea: You've shared a bit with me about their journey. And I hope that, he has a little friend and can figure out how to tell him his boundary. And that can make it more useful.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm I was like, it's so weird because it is such a, I mean, it is a boundary violation in this way. that's not his comfort zone. But it's such a loving boundary violation that it makes it hard. it's just I want you to be part of everything. And he's like, stop touching me.
Andrea: totally. It's like excitement and like, Well, thank you.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm. How is your heart this morning?
Andrea: My heart, this is such a strange time for me. May, it's my birthday month, which used to be yay, it's my birthday month. and Mother's Day is just really hard. it's always been a really complicated day ever since I became a mom. I think the transition of becoming a mom, but
Rebecca: Hmm. Used
Andrea: It's still Mother's Day is about your mother and my family. know, Mother's Day was still about my mother. And so was just this weird day where I felt people wanted me to make it about me, but I really felt like it's not my turn. even though I'm not a mom, it's not my turn. And of course now I, you know, I have a really difficult relationship with my mom now. And so that makes it really hard. And it's right around when my dad, it's the month my dad died. We're coming up on that six years and I can't even.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Hmm, yeah.
Andrea: It's just hard to believe, you know? So it just, I just, think every season I wish I could just blink and then it's June 1st. And I never want time to go fast, but this is just a really hard month for me. I don't like it. And I used to love it and now I just want it to be over. So that's where I am. I feel in it. Cause Mother's Day is this weekend and that's the beginning of this is hard.
Rebecca: you Hmm. Yeah. Yeah, Mm-hmm. Mm. Okay, I'm wrapping your heart up in my heart. I love you.
Andrea: so yeah, that's where I am. Thank you. you. Well, today I'm so excited. Sometimes we get to talk to people all over the world, but this is the first time we get to talk to somebody in Nairobi, Kenya. And I'm so excited. Today we are talking with Carl Mandlin. Carl is Chief Partnerships and Business Development at AGRA. He has also held senior positions at Visa and for Central and Eastern European Middle East and Africa region at EcoBank Foundation. among many other influential roles. His expertise has been featured in Forbes, Scientific American, Le Monde, El País, and World Economic Forum. He is also a co-host of his own podcast that he has with his daughter, Inside the Blueprint. But behind this 30,000 foot view of global systems lies a very personal journey. of profound loss, a reflection on how grief reshapes us, softens us, and unexpectedly leads us back to meaning. His writing explores the emotional scaffolding of renewal, the quiet work of healing, and the inner forms of prosperity that no economic system can measure. I'm so excited to welcome you, Carl, to all the grief.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: Thank you, Andrea and Rebecca. I'm very happy to be here.
Andrea: Yeah, we're
Rebecca: Yeah.
Andrea: as are we. So Carl, how is your heart this morning?
Carl Manlan: It's afternoon in Nairobi now, but the heart is still processing what the long day has been. And today my
Load full transcript
heart is full on two things. Full on the fact that I have done some work which is starting to come to fruition. So you have that moment just before it just happens. And then I'm also thinking about the fact that
Andrea: How is your... right...
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: I, for many years, I lived in a city which is going through trauma. I lived in Dubai for almost five years. So there's that grief as well about the city that gave me so much and is going through a difficult period. So you have this constant tension. And as I was listening to both of you between a young person that's transitioning to a new city, which I've done many times, and he's trying to figure out, okay, what the things he has lost and what is. maybe coming his way, but you can't really see. And then there's this boy from New Zealand that suddenly sort of shows that path and that light for him. And I'm listening to you about May being a difficult month. I have two special days in month. My wedding anniversary is in May and then my daughter's birthday is also in May. So you also, see that in the duality of life. One month that may not necessarily be something that brings joy. is the opposite father. And I mean, to me, this is what grief is about. So my heart is actually right in that middle where one side is love, the other side is grieving, you and they really that balance that we often don't recognize, you listening to both your stories and thinking about that young boy is grieving in a way, but is probably not using those terms, because we are taught about grief very late, at least sort of the expression of it doesn't come early. So
Rebecca: Hmm. you Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: Yes, this is who I am and also very happy to be sharing this moment with both of you.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Andrea: my goodness, Well, I hadn't expected to ask you so quickly, but it feels so apropos to what you just said. You have a poem, called Become Sad. Would you mind reading that for us right now? Thank you.
Rebecca: Mmm.
Carl Manlan: I will do that.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: I encountered sadness on my way to Pepe. Mama carried the cross on her own. The nurse we knew, the nurse who believed, the nurse who breathed lives, the nurse who tried, the daughter who could not, the sister who could not, the niece who could not, the mother who could not. Death is love. Jesus died on the cross. The cross we let go. Mama, I did not know. Pepe was no longer. Mama, I experienced something. What I could feel did not match anything I knew, as words did not match numb. Maybe sadness is a word for that moment. Simply, my first experience of grief.
Rebecca: I'm already crying. Thank you.
Andrea: thank you, Carl. That was such a beautiful poem to come across before we hopped live on the air. Rebecca was lovingly joking that, there's no wrong poem in this book to be read on air. They're all so beautiful. But I had dog-eared that one among many because it was that first moment where a
Carl Manlan: Yes.
Andrea: child doesn't even have words for the big experience that they're having. And so often, like you just were saying in your check-in, we don't identify grief. We don't identify that as a process that we're moving through. Probably, I imagine we talk about feelings with little kids, like sad, mad, frustrated, but grief is such an all-encompassing process. It's like it's rageful. It's devastating. these moments of remembrance and joy and laughter. It's love. So I just thought it was such a beautiful poem. could feel little Carl and then in Rebecca's check-in and your reflection on it just felt so perfect. So thank you.
Carl Manlan: Right. Welcome.
Rebecca: Yeah.
Andrea: So Carl, and it may or may not be related to that poem, I don't know, but when you think about your grief origin story, so the moment when grief came into your life and kind of created a before and after moment, what is that grief origin story for you?
Carl Manlan: So it's actually connected to this poem that you selected. And I didn't add a word for it because the word for grief in French is chagrin, you know, but, you know, it's often associated with like a love relationship that sort of fails. So you don't really have that expression. And to me, it's shortly after my grandfather passed away. He was the first...
Andrea: Mm.
Rebecca: Mm. Mm.
Carl Manlan: And in that case, that was what God was to me. Now, you every Sunday to the heart of his home, always being there, having that little shiny note that you slip into my hand. Then he died. I knew something was off because my mother was not being a nurse. She was, could see there was something and then it happened. And his burial was on my first communion. so you have this moment where
Andrea: Mmm.
Rebecca: Of course.
Andrea: Yeah.
Carl Manlan: am walking into the church, this procession of all these children dressed in white. And then you have this beautiful hymn on this holy day that God has given us. And here I am not understanding what it means because I was brought up believing that God is love. But then you have this tension between the fact that how does this loving God takes away something from you on that day? But you know, it didn't take it on that day, but it happened that the burial had to be on that day.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: So I now have the intersection of faith, love, death, all in one. And I didn't understand fully, but there's one thing that I remember. I did not my confirmation for following year. And my parents never forced me. I just said the association of that moment and being in church for
Andrea: Mmm.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: a joyous occasion, which is also a grief moment because I ended up with my father, my two sisters and my brother. None of the aunt's friends were around because they all went to the funeral. So, but at the same time, I saw a duality. talking about grief being the other side of love where I was celebrating the first communion and for everyone that is raised in the Catholic faith, which is a very
important moment.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: At the same time, my God on earth was leaving. No, so I found myself I couldn't put words to it as I did it now. I couldn't explain exactly what it was, but there was certainly something in me that changed. You know, because then the next Sunday when I went to my grandparents' house, it was just my grandmother.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: you
Andrea: Mm.
Carl Manlan: rules, she's equally important, you and it's not the same relationship that sort of existed. So that was a before and after moment. But, then in 89, I wouldn't have been able to express it in those words. You and having, know, then, you life goes on and then you sort of say, OK, what does it mean to lose someone that you care, that deeply cares about you?
Andrea: Yeah, of
Rebecca: you
Carl Manlan: that is not your father or your mother, but has expressed so much love and appreciation for who you are without really any questions. He just loves you because you come from his daughter. And so you have that very deep connection to something that he loves by association with what you represent. Some is a piece of his daughter that is living through you.
Andrea: Yeah.
Carl Manlan: So yeah, it was that moment. you know, back in 89 when it happened, I wouldn't have been able to have the words of the emotions to sort of process that.
Andrea: can totally understand, especially for a child, also the way that we associate just timelines and things. And so the idea of even a milestone moment in the church being tied to this really devastating milestone moment in your life. And I imagine some fear of if I have another one of those milestone moments in the church,
Rebecca: you
Andrea: Might I have a devastating milestone moment in my life? I think we've heard a lot from people experienced grief really young that that becomes this sort of like background worry of like, are these two things inextricably linked forever?
Carl Manlan: does.
Andrea: Sam.
Rebecca: And I feel curious, so in the absence of a word in language, which I feel, you language is so important and there's so many ways, like when people study linguistics and talk about the way language even structures our thinking, our relationship to the world. I'm wondering within your family, was there a way that that grief was held or tended to, or did you feel kind of dropped like what did you witness in your family system that taught you something.
Carl Manlan: Yeah. We don't speak about grief. Emotions are not necessarily names. You know that your parents love you and they express it in different way. But I didn't grow up with really being able to call that feeling. I knew it existed. I knew my parents loved me. I can maybe count a number of times when I heard them say it. Not because they didn't love me, but it wasn't something that is necessarily part of the way the lingua sort of evolves. And it's not a criticism. It is the way that this was being expressed. And when I did a book reading a couple of weeks ago, and when we finished, there was a guest in the room that happens to be a psychologist. And she asked me the question.
Andrea: you
Carl Manlan: Why didn't you read it, write it in French? And because she says a lot of emotions that you are carrying in your book happen when you were much younger, when you live through those emotions in French. And I said to her, going back to question about language, and I said to her, I took the lazy route because by writing in English, there are things that I was not ready to deal with in the language where these happen. So I parked it. You so, and, and no, and then we had a full of conversation where we spent two and a half hours together to just talking about through this thing. And she happens to be a psychologist and we had this very beautiful human conversation around grief because she's also going through her own experience of grief. And the language that we often choose is also to protect ourselves because, you know, grief takes time. We have to be in a place where we feel comfortable and you know,
Andrea: Mm.
Carl Manlan: When you write poetry, you don't write it necessarily for the rest of the world. You write it for yourself to heal through the process and to sort get a sense of how do you then express in language those emotions that you have? How do you write them? How do you feel? And then so going through that exercise was the year 25, which if you look at the book, the forward
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: date of 8th of September 2025. My friend Susana, who lives in Argentina, sent it to me around 8 p.m. or 9 p.m. that evening. That was the day I was fired. So you have these moments where grief in a way presents itself differently. Then you have this message from Argentina that arrives. And then again, the duality of life. You this one is close while finish your book. And that's the beauty of a language because language also can be transmitted without words necessarily. So Susana sitting in Argentina.
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: Mm. Hmm Mm.
Andrea: you
Carl Manlan: had no idea what was happening to me in Dubai. But somehow she felt that that was the time for her to send that forward that is in the book. And I kept the date, know, because it's a reminder for me of a power of a language, of a power of words, of a power of this moment where being expected, like death, sometimes you don't expect it and it just happens, you know.
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: I feel like you've spoken to the duality a few times this morning and it reminds me of tango, the one where you're talking about grief and joy and moving in that way. And as you're saying all of these things, I feel this huge question is up for me. so you go from there's not a lot in the language. There's not a way.
Carl Manlan: Yes.
Rebecca: to even name it grief. And now you're just writing about grief, grief, grief, grief. So how did you start to come into relationship with your own grief and know,
that's what 10 year old me was experiencing. When did it really become nameable as grief and identifiable as grief for you in your life?
Carl Manlan: I think it was the second time. I was a student in South Africa when my father passed away. And I think I was mature enough to start to understand what it meant at that point. Also, I did my confirmation in Cape Town. So there was a gap between that 89 moment and then sort landing in about 2000 doing the confirmation.
Andrea: Wow.
Carl Manlan: And that was a way for me to sort of say, I have to continue to live. And part of living is completing what we start. You don't leave things sort of hanging. have to finish the process. And doing this, and then, November 2001, When that hit, I had a blueprint. I had experienced these feelings before. It's not the same intensity because the circumstances were completely different. But I had now words to express it. I had matured from having to live in different places, leaving family in Cote d'Ivoire, moving to Zimbabwe and moving to South Africa.
Andrea: you
Carl Manlan: And when I was listening to your nephew story or your sister story of moving to a new country and having to understand what it means to be you in that new space. Okay. And in that process of trying to understand who you are in that space, you have to deal with a full spectrum of emotions. You can't just park this one and say, what, that one, it will continue to be there and I don't know what it is. I don't want to name it.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: And me going through the confirmation, was now saying to myself, you must have faith. And having faith is also accepting that death is part of it. You can't just say, I believe, believe. And then, know, there's this part about that eventually die, which is the only certainty that we have. We don't know when, but that's the only certainty that it will end. And that experience of being in South Africa, in a country that was also in transition. When I came to South Africa in 1999, it was the second democratically elected president, President Aboumeik, he came to power. And I was a student who barely understood the English language was, yes, it was okay to me, but was still new. So when you were telling me about your nephew, I like, yeah, I mean, I was much older, but then you have to go beyond who I was. I was then to ask myself how do I complete my degree in a foreign language. And we tend to associate grieving with only dying, but no, we grieve every day, that sort of who you were is no longer that person that is required for you to move to the next level. Therefore, okay, I need to park this person. And in parking that person, you realize that there are things that you need to figure out, and I became very comfortable with the idea of seeing a psychologist after my father passed away.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: which when I first was home for the funeral and there's a psychologist that came to me and she sort said, I'm here to help you. I didn't really understand what she meant by I'm here to help you, but she planted the seed. So I think the ability to be able to name is also accepting the fact that we as individuals need to seek help and accept help when it's given in whichever form it is because we go through grief in different ways. And my experience of grief is very different to mine. But one thing which is common to all of us is that we don't know that feeling until it happens.
Andrea: Yeah. You have this beautiful reflection on that time as you close the second section of your poetry book. It's the poem Tears. 91. Would you mind reading that to us? I think it speaks to the complexity, so many of the complexities of becoming.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: Tears. Uphold masculinity in silence. Uphold strength in silence. Uphold tradition in adversity. Tears weaken the fabric of society in public masculine identity. Heroic gesture of weak internal strength. pillars of strength in families, communities around and beyond. Emotions cried out, cloud judgment, like the soul calls for relief. Tears pressure breaker of excess, yet a sign of inability. In quiet, silent soul, regenerative. In the midst of a funeral, I found an escape, rinsed my soul. I was caught behaving against principles of masculinity. Remaining time held my tears in my soul's bladder.
Rebecca: Hmm. Thank you.
Andrea: that part, holding my tears in my soul's bladder, was ugh. I mean,
Rebecca: Mmm.
Andrea: And listening, having even more context, listening to where you were and this transition of life, of being in university, which is such a transformational time. And I'm so glad that you spoke to. these ways that we're grieving all the time, even though we mostly think about grief and death. And I think Rebecca and I, we were starting this podcast, that was really our intention was we wanted to talk about and shed light on all of the grief that we're experiencing all the time, the heartache of where you lived, the heartache of Dubai, the heartache of, I think about I lived in Honduras for a couple of years and
Rebecca: Hmm.
Andrea: It's not even a country I can go back to because of how dangerous it is. And I feel such grief for the beauty, the love, the people, the experiences, all the food I ate. so I didn't lose anyone in death, but there's such a grief and a mourning about that. so in having the context of your transition into university, which is also a transition into adulthood for many of us, and part of that as a man is this transition into this full step into masculinity and this moment of I'm also losing my dad. I'm also in this moment, a child losing my father. It was really touching and I think a really important poem that reflects the pressure of masculinity and holding those emotions. Yeah.
Carl Manlan: Thank you.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: Does.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: It does.
Andrea: Yeah, it was really beautiful. journey, I also want to say, was not a direct line from grief experiences to a poetry
book. not at all. So talk to us a little bit and I'd love to spend some time talking about this other world that you Inhabit.
Rebecca: Inhabit?
Carl Manlan: I think it started very early because I studied economics and finance as a student. And the first 10 years of my career, I was working in health. And my father was a medical doctor. My mother was a nurse. And my mother's always wanted me to become a which before she passed, told her, you were never talking about numbers. you're always talking about saving lives. And I grew up in 80s where the HIV pandemic was quite high. So when they were coming home or when they were late from home, the stories that I was hearing were related to trying to save a life, trying to understand this new virus and how it was affecting. So I said them that there was nothing in what I was learning at home and listening at home that made me want to just to be a banker. But I understood because that's a epitome of success. You you have to have a real profession. banker, engineer, lawyer, these are the real profession, And if I look at my professional life, the first 10 years were in health, the following 10 years were in financial services. And this is the first time in my life that I'm in a field that I'm not related to either what my mother wanted me to do.
Andrea: Mmm. Mm. Mm.
Carl Manlan: or what my parents were doing. So the book, in a way, comes at a time where I am becoming me as a person. And I'm stepping into my own path. So the 8th of September, yes, yes, I was pushed out, but it's okay. Because that had to happen for me to get into the next phase of my life and to say to my parents, I did everything that you would have wanted me to do.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: I worked in health, I worked in financial services, and now I'm in a new field that I did not think that I will be in, but that's where I am today. So that journey, yes, was not linear at all because when you are 22 and you lose your father, you don't live in the same space anymore.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: the connection that he had also disappear. So suddenly you have to figure out once I get my degree, who's gonna be opening that door.
Andrea: Mm.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: because you need that sort of reference of somebody who calls and says, my son is, I don't, and. There was a gentleman from Peru who at that time I had never met that used to work with my father that opened the door for me.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: So it wasn't linear. I didn't expect it. It happened. That door was open. I entered. And from there, I took the opportunities that were coming my way. We weren't necessarily knowing which would be the next. But I was convinced that that was the right thing to do. And I moved from the internship to employment into one of the largest fund that was created to fight HIV, TB and malaria. So circling back to this childhood and listening about the stories about people that were suffering from the disease with virus that was, and then I spent about 10 years in that space of understanding what it means to be moving billions of dollars to solve for HIV, TB and malaria. And then, from there, I really wanted to move out of Geneva. not because I didn't like the place, but I felt that I had done whatever I could do. And then I had an opportunity to move to Addis Ababa. And at that time, it was another difficult moment because we had a toddler and we were expecting the second one. And then you have to make a decision where for the first pregnancy I was a student. So I wasn't there for the entire pregnancy. The second one, three months in,
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: I have this opportunity to move to Addis Ababa and I had to trust my instinct and sort of disagree with my wife. And then it created the kind of tension that you can imagine. And sometimes I joke with her now and say, yeah, if I hadn't done it then, we would not be where we are today. And I think that's part of also getting those moments where you cannot explain the why in the moment.
Rebecca: Hmm. Hmm.
Carl Manlan: You can only explain your blessing forward.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: Never, because when it happens, you sort of look at it and say, oh my God, what am I going to do? You know, 8th of September, 2025, you know, what am I going to do? But that's the reality that you face. And then you know. And then now you say, oh, OK, they had to do this for me to be where I am. So on the moment, you may look like, oh, my God, it's terrible. But it's the same as when you die.
Rebecca: Yeah. Mm.
Carl Manlan: But when you experience death, at that particular moment, you think about only the fact that this is not just. But in reality, you don't know if it's just or not. You're just going through a period of time where the way you have to explain to yourself, those are the words that come to mind. A question of justice, equality, inequality, and why. then, to me, at some point in that process of grief,
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: I was asking myself when it happened, why my father? And then at some point, as I bit, that question implies that you would prefer that somebody else father dies.
Andrea: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: And it's almost a very selfish way of looking at the world. Why should you be the one whose father is paid? But that, how do you know when you're born that your parents are not gonna live long?
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: which suddenly creates an opportunity for me as a father now to make sure that we speak about emotions, that we name them, that we engage in this, because whatever happens, you need to have the tools, the emotional tools to figure out by naming what it is. And I think a lot of us go through life with...
Andrea: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: starting to name these things very late in the process because we just never had the tools, the language to do so. So from a professional perspective, how do I land in that space that when I became a father in 2012. So I asked myself, what is it that
Andrea:
Mm.
Carl Manlan: I would have loved for my parents to tell me who my grandparents were. And not just me living with them and figuring out as a young age, who they are. my paternal grandmother passed away before I was born, so I never met her.
Andrea: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: So the idea of writing then came from there, back in 2012, of documenting who my parents were and who these individuals were in my life so that my children can understand who these people are. So the first idea was a memoir. And then in February, 2025, I was in San Miguel de Allende in Mexico for the book festival. The first workshop that I selected was on grief. And we sat around the table as strangers. And then suddenly, it dawned on me that this is probably the one thing that we share the most, but we never speak about it, regardless of race, religion, gender, whatever it is that you name yourself, we all share grief.
Rebecca: Mm.
Andrea: you
Rebecca: Hmm. Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: And the story of this man will always stay with me. He said, every time I introduce myself, I'm in a dilemma. When I say I have two daughters, I feel guilty for my third daughter. When I say I have three daughters, people are asking me, where's the third one? So he's in this constant dilemma. And I just pray to God that I don't have to learn what it feels like to lose a child.
Andrea: you
Carl Manlan: And I started writing this book the next day.
Andrea: Hmm
Rebecca: Well.
Carl Manlan: And I say to Judith that was doing the workshop that when I land in Dubai next week, the following week on Wednesday, I'll send you what I have.
Rebecca: I love that. Wow.
Carl Manlan: That's how his book was born. I called Susana who lives in Argentina and I was telling her about the experience and from the end I said, I would love for you to write the foreword. I I know Susana for many years, being in that spot, that's the first person that came to mind. So this book was really literally written between that workshop and the flight that I took. It's a long flight from Mexico to Dubai. And that's how the book was born.
Rebecca: That's so great. there's something for me that that stirs up in me that this idea of, and you saying, and now I am who I, and I'm becoming myself. There's this feeling of these moments in life where We have a notion to do a thing that starts to put us in a certain direction. And then it wasn't quite a memoir. that's parked for now, but it was something about writing. was something about capturing story emotion. And then you just sort of, I guess I'll choose the grief workshop. And then it just opens into this book that I mean, reading it, I would not have thought you just started writing this. in February of 2025, I would have thought, this has been 10 years in the work. But then just that listening that you did that was, guess I'm writing this book because I just got fired So here we are. And you just listened and knew this was the next right step.
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: it was in the journey and I was like, I can't stop lingering on these words. I just marked them as so important to me, to my heart to hear right now. Grief reminds us of our humanity. Humanity reminds us we are not alone. God made grief a journey. God distributed grief equally so unbeknown to us, we could find equality in grief. And just this sense of when you were talking about you're at the workshop and you're like, this is the thing that we're all equal in and we will all know grief. it's a powerful reminder at a time that feels so unsettling. I mean, that is for us. well, we're going to keep showing up and making space for grief because
Carl Manlan: Yep.
Rebecca: We're all in it. We're just collectively in right now.
Carl Manlan: And I think living in the UAE, the news about what was happening in Lebanon and in Gaza was present. You you read it in newspaper. And then when on the 20th of February, those missiles started coming on Dubai, we're very fortunate with a defense missile system. Having only then it became very clear that our neighbours don't have the same protection.
Andrea: you
Carl Manlan: So even that experience in such proximity is very different. So you go through these experiences in life of what you're grieving, but it's not at the same intensity, at the same level. One is not better than the other. One is not worse than the other. It's just that there's that experience And once we start to recognize that our humanity a little bit more, and we acknowledge that...
Andrea: Yeah.
Carl Manlan: Grief is probably the common factor, denominator in our lives. Maybe we'll appreciate this situation differently. No. I remember a couple of months ago, I saw the pictures of a couple of buildings that were burning in Hong Kong. So I saw it and I moved on to the next thing. And this has been on my mind because I asked myself, how did I get to a place where this grief is almost if I became numb to it, going back to that 11 year old that was just didn't know how to name it. And I think one of the challenges that we face as humanity today is that empathy is no longer something that
Andrea: Mm.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: we accept as a common thread to unite us. So I can no longer feel for the others because I am bombarded with information that is just too much. And I have to start thinking, OK, how do I protect myself from all this information, which is often not necessarily good news? And that is a challenge of our generation. How do we make sure that the next generation has empathy? because we are losing empathy as adults and we become numb to many of the things that are happening around us. And we have to find a way to recover. because our humanity is at risk. If you can no longer feel for the other, then what is that humanity that we share? So grief then becomes that thing that we can all hold on to as a way to connect. The three of us are connected because you chose grief as a way to hold space for things that are often about just crying. But then you
realize that
Rebecca: Yeah.
Carl Manlan: I am still alive, you know. And as the title of a book says, I can breathe. And I chose that title so that everyone that reads it is talking to himself or herself.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm. You
Andrea: Yeah, in the opening, there's such beautiful openings, there's so much context, which I really love, you talk about the cover and the intention of the cover. then, of course,
Rebecca: Yeah. Bye-bye. Bye. I just want to say as
Andrea: Susanna writes,
Rebecca: graphic design was my previous life. And I really appreciated reading the process of the cover. It was beautiful. this is the level of meaning that usually goes into a good cover, a good piece of abstract art.
Carl Manlan: Thank you.
Andrea: You would be able to appreciate it so much at an even deeper level. then, so then we have our letter from Susanna and then you have a preface and as I was reading it, I admit I was taken aback, you cared about what was happening here. you write about George Floyd in this and being in the States, I don't know that we could have known if it was news everywhere. And so to see that, I read it twice because I just was wow.
Carl Manlan: Yep. Yep.
Andrea: was just a beautiful connection of recognition and sorrow. of course that, his death was sorrows on top of sorrows. It wasn't only a man's murder, it was systems and it was just a country of neglect and abuse and sort of we're wrestling with that in the most shocking of ways on a daily basis. And so I think It feels so normal to us, sadly. I mean, it's devastating and it's sad, but it feels so normal that I think we have to, even as Americans, to remind ourselves our citizens shouldn't be being killed on the streets. Our children shouldn't be shot in schools. Not all of us. But sometimes it's yeah, yeah, I heard there was another one. Or they don't make it to the news. They don't even make it to the news. And so to see that George Floyd, whose murder was really such an impetus for a reckoning in our country, that I still hope we can continue on. Again, we can pick that back up and keep going. But it felt so personal. And then to see it reflected in your book was just, I don't know, it just created another thread between you and us, Carl. And you end with this beautiful reflection, a poem on breath of this reminder.
Carl Manlan: Okay.
Andrea: to all of us and I think When we have these moments of grief, whether it's a big D death, the loss of someone that reminds us that we are alive and reminds us of our own mortality, we all know it's coming. We just don't know when. But also these little D deaths, these little deaths of Andrea as the museum researcher, Carl as the finance guy in Dubai, these little deaths that we have grief for, but that also give us a shimmer of there's all this life. What do you want to do with it?
Carl Manlan: Absolutely. going through this exercise of writing was me going through the full spectrum of emotions that you you can have. And being a father, you want to share the full spectrum of emotions with your children so that they explore all of them as they're growing up and that they don't get surprised by what is this. and I remember speaking to the children about the loss.
Andrea: Yeah.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: in terms of a job. And as parents, we made the decision to keep them so that they finish the school year. It's not the most financially sound decision, but we have to give children the opportunity to understand that you can deal with the crisis as a family. and you give them the tools to understand that this happened to my father. but he managed to go through it. because it's the same experience as dying. It's not physical, but it's emotional death, where suddenly things that you thought were normal are no longer there. But if, as young children, you are then uprooted because this happens, then as your emotions will always be connected to the fact that when something happened which is sudden,
Rebecca: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: then everything else collapse.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: And that's our responsibility as parents, as community members, to hold something steady and make choices between maybe more money in the bank account and emotionally stable children.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: that can see the sacrifices to keep that balance and it's not their responsibility to figure out. And I remember a friend of mine when I was telling her the story of what we decided to do as parents, she said to me, my father lost his job when I was exactly the same age as your children. And I still have a trauma from that experience because my mother insisted that I pray for my father. but I didn't know what it meant. So suddenly as a young adult, I had this responsibility on me for something that I just don't understand.
Andrea: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: So as I listen to her, she's an adult now, but she's still grieving that opportunity that was stolen from her as a child to just be a child.
Andrea: Mm.
Rebecca: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: So there are things that we do as parents that have an impact on the emotional stability of our children, on the mental health of our children, and being able to hold steady and ask very simple question, how do I preserve my children in this period of transition? Of course, it was hard on me. It was hard on us as a family, but There was no way I would have sacrificed the mental stability and the opportunity to see how one can deal with a crisis because I wanted to have a little bit more money in my bank account little bit more something else. That is priceless.
Rebecca: in so many ways, primarily our world is set up to distract us from feeling our feelings. And I think of what you were saying feels. like this whenever we start our grief retreats or our grief groups, we talk about not getting into comparative grief, because, people are experiencing in a room of people, someone's grief is unimaginable in some ways, like they lost a child and you don't want to even know
what that is to experience and, and then, maybe what people are bringing is what might be perceived as a more manageable grief, like divorce grief or something. And I always love the idea. And I heard Francis Weller say it where when people think, who am I to grieve this thing when someone else is grieving something so much bigger? And he says, who are you if you don't tend to your grief? And it's this piece you're talking about that is our doorway in to being able to feel empathy, be able to have humanity. Yes, I don't know a grief at a level of... horror that some people are experiencing right now, but because I tend to my grief, I'm crying. I'm feeling grief that they are experiencing that even though I know it's so different to experience it. And then it changes how we make choices and show up as humans. And when you don't feel that, I don't like what people become who don't feel that, who can be so righteous that it's okay for children to die in a school, for genocide to happen, for anything.
Carl Manlan: Yeah.
Andrea: you
Rebecca: that we're bombarded with. thank you for bringing all of that in. It's so important. And I think we're at a turning point in are we choosing our humanity or are we shutting down? And we have to just start to turn towards every single little emotion that's here and make space for it.
Carl Manlan: Yeah. Yeah. a sense of gratitude to have been able to share with both of you that moment of unity, that humanity, you and you speaking to someone who grew up in Abidjan, in Cote d'Ivoire and now living in Nairobi that has carried different pieces of grief along the way.
Andrea: Hmm.
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: And that's what brought us together. And then there are billions of people out there that either don't know the words to put to it, but it's there. Because grieving is really, you only grieve what you love in a way. Having that to me has been revelation. If you don't have that emotional connection,
Andrea: Hmm.
Carl Manlan: it will happen and then you move on, but you grieve and then, you you lose a toy when you're a child. And I remember being a seven year old, having a younger brother that was born. And then very quickly, when he turned one, he started destroying everything I had. And my parents were very comfortable with that idea. And I was OK, what is it? So you grieve this moment. So I think to me, it's really a sense of gratitude because the work you are doing.
Rebecca: You
Carl Manlan: is important to millions of people that you probably will never meet in person. And sometimes I get a message from somebody from somewhere that I don't know that has read the book and tell me it has helped me to go through my own grief experience. And finally is that, we wear different hats, different mask, but the one that we have to be able to remove is how comfortable we have to become with grief. We should not be shy about grief and we should not be hiding from it because it is part of daily lives. you lose your wallet. Yes, you grieve that piece of whatever it is, it's just plastic or whatever you had as a, you grieve it for some reason, but we don't see it as well. It's all I need to go and cancel my credit cards and all this. But it's something that you lost, and there's a reason why this has happened that you always don't explain. So yeah, I really, really deep sense of gratitude for you having made the time to read the book and to invite me and here to have this conversation.
Andrea: Thank you, Kar.
Rebecca: Thank you, Carl. So yeah, we'll end our podcast with a question about grief, a reflection on grief. And today, What's something about grief you only understood after living through it? a minute to think of our answer.
Carl Manlan: understood the meaning of patience.
Andrea: Hmm.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: You can't rush for grief. Even 25 years later, there are moments where it just hits. And I've learned to sort of accept those moments. And that patience is definitely something that has helped me to go through the new episodes of grief that came along the way and then recognizing that
Rebecca: Mm-hmm.
Carl Manlan: to hit, it to be in a lull moment, and then when you least expect it, it will come. And those often comes at moments of joy, where you wish you had those people around you, either to hug them, to share those moments with them, and to have just them looking at you with that pride.
Rebecca: Mm.
Carl Manlan: but you have to imagine it.
Rebecca: How about you, Andrea?
Andrea: Mine, I think, I would say how physical grief is. It really caught me by surprise. was the day of my dad's funeral and I had not yet seen him. And my siblings and my mom had seen him the night before. And they called me and said, Andrea, you need to get there before the funeral. You need to see him before there's other people. And I think they knew more than I did that it was going to be.
Rebecca: Ahem.
Carl Manlan: Thank
Andrea: a physical experience. And even as we were driving, my husband was driving and I could feel this. I couldn't get comfortable. couldn't breathe well. And it was like I had this stabbing pain in my back and I just, I thought I was losing my mind. was like, what is happening? And it was, it was the trauma of grief in my body. I couldn't take a deep breath. I was having what would probably amount to not a full blown, but a panic attack and
Rebecca: Hmm.
Andrea: then seeing him and I couldn't make my body walk toward his coffin I was out of my body couldn't look at my legs and say walk forward So that was that just how just grief just overtook my body. That was that was shocking to me. Yeah how about you Rebecca?
Rebecca: I feel like the thing that really stands out to me in that that moment of acute grief and needing people and Realizing for the first time. Oh No one needs to do anything. There's not a way to get it right and if people can just show up
Carl Manlan: Thank you. Thank you.
Rebecca: and not know what to do, but just not leave you. it's that leaning in and it taught me something. I was having this dual experience of, you my dad died. I have to tell people, people are being weird. People are moving away. But then there are people who are just I don't know what to say, but I'm here. Or they just show up with food or whatever. my gosh, now I know a thing. that actually makes a difference that I didn't know made a difference before I had felt a grief like that. So it's showing up when you don't know what to do is pretty important to show up.
Andrea: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. that's such a beautiful thing to leave with people. even if you've experienced grief sometimes, you can feel I'm not sure what to do, but you just show up. Carl, what a beautiful conversation. What a beautiful heart connection. What a beautiful book. We will link to it, of course, in our show notes. And...
Carl Manlan: Thank you.
Andrea: I wish you so much success in whatever this becoming chapter of your life is. And this is a beautiful first start. So thank you. Thank you, Carl.
Carl Manlan: Thank you. You're welcome, Andrea. You're welcome, Rebecca.
Rebecca: Yes, thank you. And I'm hoping you can close us out with a poem you can breathe.
Carl Manlan: You can breathe. When you reach the end, you can breathe. Breathe. You just began. Breathe. When you begin, you create. Breathe. Breath begins at the trauma of life. Breathe. Life continues with trauma. Breathe. Today begins with trauma in mind. Breathe. Tomorrow ends farther than today. Breathe. Trauma in the past, life in the now, all more to come. Breathe. You are breathing. You are becoming.
Andrea: Beautiful. Thank you. Thank you to our listeners. Goodbye, everyone.
Rebecca: you.