TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: I know our next guest will have some thoughts on cooking beggies, but let's get these thoughts on the state budget first. David Penberthy, Hello.
00:00:08
Speaker 2: Oh, I'll tell you what save. It's MINNESTRONI weather. Just left the convention center and it is as cold as charity in the city. It was blowing a gale up Monte Fury Road. I've just managed to jump in an uber and come home though, which is good. I think I've got all the stuff file for the newspapers. But yes, five billion dollars. That is the increase in state debt. This time twelve months ago. I was in the lock up with Matt Abraham and Smith oh and Paul Starrick and all the usual crew from around the traps, and we're being told that within four years state debt would reach forty eight point nine billion dollars. The new figure is that within four years it'll reach fifty three point six billion. So that's a jump of about five billion bucks. Now the government says it's manageable. I had a long chat in there, both at the press conference and then one on one with Tom kinsontonus. He's saying a couple of things that are different from our approach. In essay, he's sort of positioning himself as doctor. Know. When it comes to new infrastructure spending, he's saying, look, we're doing this for two reasons. We definitely need a new women's and children's hospital, and we've got to fix South Road, and there's an economic argument for fixing South Road. So between them, that's twenty billion dollars almost, which is a huge chunk of that debt. The other thing is he's put a cap on twelve month cap on public service hirings, which we already know that because they let that one out, So any public servant who leaves, they'll only replace every second public servant and they won't hire any new ones apart from for emergency roles. So there's a few things that they're doing that make them look different from say Victoria, where the debt there is basically debt that has been entered into to just keep the government running. Here, the debt, he says, is around two things that we need new road, new hospital. But I still worry that there's this, you know, it's like the old term exponential growth from the pandemic, where you know, this time last year, the increase was going to be four billion dollars a year every year for four years in debt. Now it's a little bit more than four billion dollars a year. And the most confronting thing was he completely admitted, completely admitted that they have no idea how much the new women's and children's hospital was going to cost. Oh what, Yeah? And I said, I said, look, the last estimate was three point two billion, and he goes, that's correct, and I said, and that was what four years ago? Yep. I said, so is this the only building in the world that hasn't gone up in price in the last four years? And he smirked, and he said, well, he said, I'm holding their feet to the fire. So what he's done, he said to Essay Health, I still want you to work within that parameter, as absurd as it might's down on the face of it. I still want you to aim for a three point two billion dollar build cost. But you have to come back. If you come back, if you make the case that it needs to now cost X, let's cross that bridge when we come to it. But I think that the answer was that it was the most dramatic softening up from from Tom Kaks and saying, is yet that three grided teeth? He might have to soon say okay, here's the new number.
00:03:40
Speaker 1: Oh yeah, well, at some point they'll have to have an updated figure. There's there is no way we'll be able to work to that old number.
00:03:48
Speaker 2: One.
00:03:48
Speaker 1: Was it three point one billion?
00:03:51
Speaker 2: Yeah, three point two three point two and that was revised where Marshall's premiere. But like, you know, the cost of building anything. I mean, get a quote to put up a new length of shared of fence in your backyard. You know, if you get a quote like three months ago for four grand or something, they've probably rung you already by nan, so it's actually gone up to five exactly. Imagine going to build a hospital that's got six beds in it.
00:04:17
Speaker 1: That's the thing. You almost don't want them to be working to that old budget because you'reant a functioning hospital.
00:04:22
Speaker 2: But is exactly yeah, yeah, the woman and child hospital.
00:04:29
Speaker 1: Exactly one at a time. Please don't get sick at the same time people, Yeah, exactly.
00:04:35
Speaker 2: So Dave, I was did you had you had I know, you made a special request. Ye think you either I'm completely inept, which is the most likely explanation, or maybe the government's being sneaky, I couldn't find the exact amount that's set aside for events. I saw the tourism line, which is about one hundred and fifty fifty six million dollars all up, but I think that for commercial and confidence. Since they don't actually put a line item in the budget that says this year we have set aside eighty million to attract events, it might be there, but I couldn't find it.
00:05:09
Speaker 1: Okay, interesting, I am Look, it's been a couple of years since I was in a budget lock up because unfortunately I'm on air these days well while the lockups are taking place. But I am almost certain that just a few years ago there was a line in there that was major Events funds, and it would just have a total figure, and it obviously wouldn't break it down. They're not going to say we're doing this much money for live golf, We're spending this much money on gather around it. They wouldn't break that down. But I'm almost certain they used to have that.
00:05:37
Speaker 2: Well, maybe it's in there, but I okay, well that's interesting. No, Well, it's the sort of thing we'll we'll find because he reads all the he reads all the pages with the numbers on them. I only read the pages with the words, So I've read the speech. Yeah, I always read the speech, but I'm not sitting there reading volume
Load full transcript
four brackets one, you know, horizontal. Yeah, so maybe I'm missed all the good bit.
00:06:07
Speaker 1: That's all right, thank you for anyway. Yeah, fair enough. Now I also did what you did, read the words. I read read this speech. Well, I'm you know, very briefly, and I skimmed it because I've been a bit busy. I don't know, is this The first thing that came to my mind was boring?
00:06:27
Speaker 2: Nothing is there all? Well, actually I would describe it as boring in a good way. And this is this is where you can you can say that Jim Charmer's budget was a lot of things, but boring. It wasn't like it was really really eye catching for all the wrong reasons because it set a world record for breaking promises. And this is where one of the most interesting parts of the lockup was at the start and I got there late, but men Abraham was there furiously taking notes for this. So Mali spoke and I was still, you know, get himself organized after doing the Breaky Show today, but malely got up and he made some quite pointed comments, either by accident or design, and I charitably say I think that probably by accident. But he really talked about the need for people in politics to keep their promises, and even't the national debate over the last few weeks it was a Matt Abraham sort of ask him and asked Keot's questions about this actually sounded like he was reflecting on the manner in which the FEDS had gone about their budget, because Mali said, you know, go keep promises. It's not just important in a political sense, it's important in a policy sense because you don't want business to have any surprises, and that's long been his mantra. But because of the debate about Albo and Charmers having no mandate for their changes, having repeatedly ruled them out, it actually sound like a reflection on the PM and the Federal Treasurer. And that's why the piece that is up now that I've just written half an hour ago, finished it for The Australian and that's leading their website now, is that the state budget is framed around a fifty three billion dollar debt bomb and a small hand grenade lobbed in the direction of Anthony Albaneasy, reminding him that honestly matters in politics. So to your question, is it boring, Well, yeah, it is kind of boring because it does everything they said they were going to do in the election, which I think is like, you know, a good thing for people in politics. It's got all the housing money in it, it's got all the free education stuff in it, where you don't have to pay public school fees at primary or secondary level anymore. It's got all of the transport projects as outlined. There's nothing new in it. There's nothing different in it. The only new thing, and to people's eyes of guys either is this research and Development fund, which is actually a really I think good story about encouraging new high tech businesses, businesses and new needs to do more investigative stuff, take more risks. Well, that's a really good enterprising sort
of thing that's in there, which is an Anauskis sort of passion project. But the rest of it, no, it is. It is boring, but it's boring in a good way because they haven't suddenly said, oh, we've had an idea and we're going to do this, and it's going to cost this like it is just the bland delivery of everything that the election campaign that just gone was framed around.
00:09:29
Speaker 1: So and in this economy, we know, you know, further spending that could fuel inflation is not welcome by the community. We don't want, we don't want any more interest rate rises, please at the at the hands of government spending.
00:09:42
Speaker 2: So maybe South Australians is a good thing totally. And you know, the dead increases are worried. But and you know, all things are relative in life and in politics, and you know, it's a political sort of advantage for for Mali and Keats to have you know, Australia's equivalent of then as well over the border in Victoria. But when you look at all the completely demented things that the Allen government has done, like bringing in new unforeseen land taxes, tourism taxes, property taxes, like just killing business, killing investment, there's nothing at all like that here. The only concern is debt keeps going up and they need to do more to act on that beyond just a one year freeze, I mean off at Ashton's Ashton Hern's proposal the other day, why not make the fhreeze last longer? I think that there's merit in that, you know. I know Cory's Bernardi has been talking about a debt ceiling. I'm not sure that people to spend up to that level. So you always have debt, like when I try to actually get debt down and gone, you know. But anyway, it's it is. It is unspectacular and it's not going to alter anybody's life except for the big bill still on the horizon.
00:11:00
Speaker 1: Okay, well, Dave, we always appreciate your insights. But before you go, probably the more important topic to talk about is cooking vegetables. We've we've been discussing it today.
00:11:11
Speaker 2: Do you have any i a veggie for people who don't like veggies, I'd say the Spanish and the Italians give us good tricks, particularly for getting men to eat them. Or either do is get a bit of churisto or a bit of panchetta or a bit of bacon involved with some vegetables and they suddenly become a lot more alluring. So, you know, big hearty stews of diced vegetables with canelly beans. But if you even if you put in like half a churiso diced uff at the start and a big slug of paprika before you check the veggies and the tomato pure in. I think you're going to enjoy your vegetables a lot more with a bit of meaty goodness on the side.
00:11:52
Speaker 1: Oh stop it now, I'm hungry.
00:11:53
Speaker 2: That sounds delicious. It's the weather for it. I'm going to go inside and thaw out.
00:11:58
Speaker 1: Yeah good, all right, get inside, get warm. Thank you and we look forward to hearing more tomorrow on Bricky with Will see you day Bye bye, David Pempathy. There you can hear him from six o'clock tomorrow morning with Will for the Bricky Show, and I'm sure they will have much more information for you and they'll continue to break it down tomorrow all right. On the tourism, Maddie was able to find this grab from Tom Kots and Tonas from his speech. Is pretty much the only mention of tourism in his speech that he gave to Parliament a short time ago.
00:12:32
Speaker 3: South Australia's visit of economy is currently valued at eleven billion dollars. That translates into economic activity for business in our state, both in our cities and across our regions. Local cafes, restaurants and hotels and caravan parks and to tourism experiences far and wide. The value of the tourism dollars fall across every corner of our economy. Unless our business sector supports communities and adds vibrancy to our state, there we go.
00:13:00
Speaker 1: So that's what he had to say about the tourism and the visitor economy valued at eleven billion dollars. Nothing in the budget though, about how much money is in the Major Events Fund, which is that pot of money that they use to attract big events. That's where the money for gather around, for live golf, for the Moto GP, for the Adelaide five hundred, all of those events, the payment of them comes out of the Major Events Fund, and we know because of commercial and confidence, we never find out how much each individual event costs, but usually there's a figure put on the Major Events Fund, so you can see how much that fund has grown by over the years. I was very keen to see how much it's grown by this year because there's also the Moto GP announcement that was made recently, and the Australian Open, the golf Men's and Women's Australian Open.
00:13:50
Speaker 3: But.
00:13:53
Speaker 1: Not there apparently, I'm going to have to find the budget papers and have a little look and double check. I might have to go back. I've still got the USBs at home from the budgets that I covered. I didn't do last years. I was on maternity leave and the year before I was on air with you, so I didn't go into that one. But for the probably about ten before that, I've been in every budget lockup before that, I'm almost certain there was a major events fund line. Anyway, I'll see what I can find out for you, and i'll update you throughout the word