TRANSKRIP 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:20.940 --> 00:00:23.760
Welcome to Why We Do What We Do. I am
2
00:00:23.820 --> 00:00:28.710
your possessed host, Abraham.
3
00:00:29.289 --> 00:00:31.510
And I'm your possessive host, Shane.
4
00:00:32.149 --> 00:00:35.390
Oh, no. We are a psychology podcast. We talk about
5
00:00:35.409 --> 00:00:38.429
the things that humans and non-human animals do. I'll probably
6
00:00:38.490 --> 00:00:42.189
have that be the end of my possessed voice for this. So,
7
00:00:42.250 --> 00:00:45.890
sorry if that was surprising and grating on your ears.
8
00:00:45.969 --> 00:00:46.789
So scary.
9
00:00:47.070 --> 00:00:50.219
I know. But either way, thank you for joining us.
10
00:00:50.340 --> 00:00:53.799
Welcome to our podcast. Did I say we talk about
11
00:00:53.820 --> 00:00:56.020
things that humans and non-human animals do because we're a
12
00:00:56.020 --> 00:00:57.619
psychology podcast? Yes.
13
00:00:57.880 --> 00:00:59.689
That's really important for this episode, actually.
14
00:00:59.700 --> 00:01:04.489
Yeah. Yeah. It turns out. Well, and worth stating maybe
15
00:01:04.590 --> 00:01:08.670
even multiple times because in the month of October, we
16
00:01:08.709 --> 00:01:12.090
take on these spooky topics that are sometimes harder to
17
00:01:12.129 --> 00:01:16.489
tie back to psychology and human behavior. Not impossible. Yeah.
18
00:01:16.700 --> 00:01:19.340
but maybe slightly more challenging to make that connection and
19
00:01:19.379 --> 00:01:22.659
make it feel cohesive. And maybe even sometimes we don't
20
00:01:22.719 --> 00:01:24.540
try that hard and we just kind of let it
21
00:01:24.599 --> 00:01:27.079
ride as a weird thing that we talked about. But
22
00:01:27.120 --> 00:01:30.909
we're tying this one more closely together in the psychology realm.
23
00:01:31.540 --> 00:01:34.239
Yes, and so today, because we have not announced it
24
00:01:34.560 --> 00:01:37.469
officially yet, we are talking about possessions in terms of
25
00:01:37.859 --> 00:01:40.709
spiritual and demonic possessions and what that means.
26
00:01:40.750 --> 00:01:44.010
But we are going to take, I think, a more.
27
00:01:44.230 --> 00:01:48.310
Stripped-down approach to this topic because, as I was kind
28
00:01:48.329 --> 00:01:50.159
of looking into it, we had kind of already done
29
00:01:50.189 --> 00:01:52.859
an episode on exorcisms and what that looked like. I
30
00:01:52.900 --> 00:01:54.680
figured that maybe a fun way to go about this
31
00:01:54.700 --> 00:01:56.780
would be to kind of expose the way that we
32
00:01:56.879 --> 00:02:01.689
think about topics in general from the basic assumptions of science.
33
00:02:01.829 --> 00:02:03.250
So that's the way that we're going to go with
34
00:02:03.280 --> 00:02:03.450
this one.
35
00:02:04.129 --> 00:02:06.650
If you are joining us for the first time, then welcome.
36
00:02:06.689 --> 00:02:09.139
I hope that you enjoy what you hear in this discussion.
37
00:02:09.240 --> 00:02:11.939
And if you are a returning listener, then welcome back.
38
00:02:12.419 --> 00:02:15.280
Thank you for seeking us out once again. And either way,
39
00:02:15.300 --> 00:02:17.060
if you'd like to support us, you can join us
40
00:02:17.139 --> 00:02:20.259
on Patreon, leave us a rating and a review, like, subscribe,
41
00:02:20.340 --> 00:02:22.889
tell a friend. I'll talk more about those things at
42
00:02:22.930 --> 00:02:26.349
the end of this discussion. And although that almost sounded
43
00:02:26.409 --> 00:02:29.370
like an ad for us, it was not. We'll save
44
00:02:29.409 --> 00:02:30.009
those for later. Nope.
45
00:02:30.430 --> 00:02:30.770
Yeah.
46
00:02:31.069 --> 00:02:33.770
Also, if you happen to catch this the day that
47
00:02:33.789 --> 00:02:37.569
we publish it, then you probably already know, but I'm
48
00:02:37.610 --> 00:02:40.849
going to wish it to you anyway. The actual holiday
49
00:02:41.030 --> 00:02:45.460
on this October 28th is Champagne Day. So happy Champagne Day.
50
00:02:45.680 --> 00:02:46.659
Happy Champagne Day.
51
00:02:46.939 --> 00:02:49.639
It's also International Animation Day, which I love.
52
00:02:50.460 --> 00:02:55.000
Yeah, for sure. It is Lung Health Day. So do that.
53
00:02:56.000 --> 00:02:59.020
And three days before Halloween, it is National Chocolate Day.
54
00:02:59.939 --> 00:03:04.319
Mmm, perfect. Love some nice dark chocolate. Yes. It is
55
00:03:04.379 --> 00:03:06.219
Plush Animal Lovers Day.
56
00:03:06.250 --> 00:03:07.810
It certainly is.
57
00:03:07.830 --> 00:03:09.590
And lovers of the animals are plush.
58
00:03:10.830 --> 00:03:13.969
Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Exactly. So I love that.
59
00:03:14.310 --> 00:03:17.819
It is Separation of Church and State Day. Big fan
60
00:03:17.840 --> 00:03:18.139
of that.
61
00:03:19.159 --> 00:03:23.509
Yay. Applause all around. Yep. It is Statue of Liberty
62
00:03:23.629 --> 00:03:25.870
Dedication Day. That's fun. Yeah.
63
00:03:26.129 --> 00:03:27.610
It's also Wild Foods Day.
64
00:03:28.270 --> 00:03:30.289
It is ACE Week, A-C-E.
65
00:03:30.789 --> 00:03:33.560
Yes, it is. It is also American Massage Therapy Week.
66
00:03:33.620 --> 00:03:34.319
Big fans of that.
67
00:03:35.460 --> 00:03:38.259
We did an episode, more or less, on that, not
68
00:03:38.379 --> 00:03:41.599
the week itself, but the topic of massage slash therapy,
69
00:03:41.979 --> 00:03:43.460
massage space therapy.
70
00:03:43.979 --> 00:03:44.840
Yeah, we did.
71
00:03:45.659 --> 00:03:49.110
It is Brain Tumor Awareness Week. Go get that checked.
72
00:03:49.650 --> 00:03:53.430
Yes, which also may be related to today's episode. It
73
00:03:53.449 --> 00:03:54.509
is Disarmament Week.
74
00:03:54.810 --> 00:03:59.409
Oh, also applause for that. Yay. Yes. And to accomplish disarmament,
75
00:03:59.449 --> 00:04:01.789
you might need a bit of magic. So it is
76
00:04:01.830 --> 00:04:02.930
International Magic Week.
77
00:04:04.689 --> 00:04:05.990
Load full transcript
Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.
78
00:04:06.090 --> 00:04:09.629
It's also Pro Bono Week. I'm a fan of donating
79
00:04:09.650 --> 00:04:13.889
services where you can. So if you can, when you can, volunteer, donate,
80
00:04:14.289 --> 00:04:15.289
donate your time where you can.
81
00:04:15.689 --> 00:04:16.250
It's good stuff.
82
00:04:17.269 --> 00:04:20.689
Indeed. Well, that's what we have to say about those holidays,
83
00:04:20.769 --> 00:04:23.699
but that's maybe not why you're here. Unclear. I don't
84
00:04:23.720 --> 00:04:26.300
know what drew you here. Maybe it was the holidays.
85
00:04:26.459 --> 00:04:29.220
Seems unlikely since that was not part of the episode
86
00:04:29.259 --> 00:04:33.100
title or billboard, but you're here and you heard that part.
87
00:04:33.139 --> 00:04:35.990
Let's get into the topic du jour. Is there anything
88
00:04:36.009 --> 00:04:37.949
that I'm missing or you'd like to add before we transition?
89
00:04:38.329 --> 00:04:39.350
No, I think we're ready to go.
90
00:04:39.670 --> 00:04:41.870
Okay, we're going to do this episode a little bit
91
00:04:41.910 --> 00:04:45.519
differently than maybe some of our other episodes have been done.
92
00:04:45.540 --> 00:04:49.100
And although I think there's a pretty varied range of
93
00:04:49.180 --> 00:04:53.139
experiences and the delivery of those types of episodes, this
94
00:04:53.240 --> 00:04:55.019
one we're going to try and explain possessions as a
95
00:04:55.160 --> 00:04:59.290
phenomenon and then dissect it, break it apart. We want
96
00:04:59.310 --> 00:05:04.209
to start this with a simple idea, which is, assumptions
97
00:05:04.670 --> 00:05:08.529
and the assumptions that I think we have going into this,
98
00:05:08.550 --> 00:05:12.500
the assumptions that science makes to be a field of
99
00:05:12.680 --> 00:05:16.579
or an approach to understanding the world. I actually love
100
00:05:16.639 --> 00:05:19.420
doing this. I like it. This I can only think
101
00:05:19.459 --> 00:05:21.279
of one article that's actually ever done this. But I
102
00:05:21.319 --> 00:05:23.490
think a lot of times when we talk about things,
103
00:05:23.519 --> 00:05:26.689
we start from a place of assumptions without explicitly stating
104
00:05:26.750 --> 00:05:30.550
what those are. And sometimes just understanding the assumptions that
105
00:05:30.589 --> 00:05:35.029
we make going into a conversation is fundamentally important to
106
00:05:35.050 --> 00:05:38.240
then how that conversation plays out. And sometimes I think
107
00:05:38.480 --> 00:05:41.360
were we to have disagreements and debates, we might not
108
00:05:41.399 --> 00:05:44.399
have those disagreements and debates if we started by understanding
109
00:05:44.439 --> 00:05:45.819
what our assumptions were to begin with.
110
00:05:46.519 --> 00:05:46.819
Yes.
111
00:05:47.199 --> 00:05:49.129
So as we kind of go forward, I looked at
112
00:05:49.149 --> 00:05:50.850
this episode as I was kind of writing it as
113
00:05:51.209 --> 00:05:52.310
like a naked cake scenario.
114
00:05:52.600 --> 00:05:53.839
Situation, right?
115
00:05:53.920 --> 00:05:56.720
Like you see exactly what's in there. You see the ingredients.
116
00:05:56.819 --> 00:05:59.139
It's not overly decorated. It's not, we're not gilding the
117
00:05:59.180 --> 00:06:01.819
lily or anything like that. So, you know, when we
118
00:06:01.899 --> 00:06:04.170
talk about this, what we are saying here is that
119
00:06:04.230 --> 00:06:06.949
science relies on basic assumptions to help us create a
120
00:06:06.970 --> 00:06:10.470
framework for which a phenomenon can be studied and possessions
121
00:06:10.569 --> 00:06:14.220
in terms of spiritual and demonic possessions is a phenomenon
122
00:06:14.540 --> 00:06:17.240
that I'm not going to say is worth studying, but
123
00:06:17.439 --> 00:06:19.740
from a basic assumption standpoint, We want to try to
124
00:06:19.860 --> 00:06:22.540
understand how it fits into a science framework, if it
125
00:06:22.579 --> 00:06:24.379
even fits into a science framework.
126
00:06:24.399 --> 00:06:25.470
So that's kind of the way that we're going to
127
00:06:25.490 --> 00:06:25.899
approach it.
128
00:06:26.230 --> 00:06:28.970
So simply put, these assumptions allow us to rule out
129
00:06:29.009 --> 00:06:31.750
some nonsense and really kind of look at a phenomenon
130
00:06:31.790 --> 00:06:34.329
and go, does this fit into the world as we
131
00:06:34.470 --> 00:06:36.459
understand it through these basic assumptions?
132
00:06:36.879 --> 00:06:40.079
So we are going to start this discussion with a
133
00:06:40.220 --> 00:06:45.379
simple premise. We will likely end with the same thing. Possessions, right? Uh-huh.
134
00:06:46.790 --> 00:06:50.779
if they are a scientific phenomenon, that should allow us
135
00:06:50.839 --> 00:06:55.379
to explore the basic assumptions within science and verify the
136
00:06:55.439 --> 00:06:59.189
feasibility of this thing. And so that's, I think, the
137
00:06:59.250 --> 00:07:01.750
way that we want to approach this is just that, like,
138
00:07:01.970 --> 00:07:04.870
let's look at this through a natural science lens.
139
00:07:05.610 --> 00:07:06.009
Exactly.
140
00:07:06.089 --> 00:07:11.540
So, in today's final episode our halloween episode for why
141
00:07:11.579 --> 00:07:12.720
we do what we do and the why we do
142
00:07:12.759 --> 00:07:15.699
we do timeline we are going to explore the interesting
143
00:07:15.860 --> 00:07:18.959
and very explainable world of possessions.
144
00:07:18.860 --> 00:07:22.500
Nice yeah okay let's do this uh let's begin with
145
00:07:22.560 --> 00:07:27.709
describing the phenomenon at hand possessions at least in the
146
00:07:27.750 --> 00:07:35.300
way i feel like i said that possessions possessions Possessions,
147
00:07:35.360 --> 00:07:38.220
at least in the way that we're referring to them today,
148
00:07:38.240 --> 00:07:44.730
is the spiritual
or supernatural experiences in which a person
149
00:07:45.050 --> 00:07:51.250
is taken over or controlled by some type of other entity.
150
00:07:51.529 --> 00:07:51.790
Yes.
151
00:07:51.949 --> 00:07:55.139
So that's like the sort of starting definition, if you will.
152
00:07:55.980 --> 00:07:59.680
Even in that sentence, there's a ton of assumptions that
153
00:07:59.699 --> 00:08:02.600
we're making for any of those words to possibly make
154
00:08:02.639 --> 00:08:05.720
any sense to us. That's sort of the definition. Yes.
155
00:08:05.959 --> 00:08:08.699
So we are going to unpack specifically the term supernatural
156
00:08:08.740 --> 00:08:10.560
shows up and I go, we're going to talk about
157
00:08:10.579 --> 00:08:10.879
that later.
158
00:08:11.259 --> 00:08:12.379
Okay. Super important.
159
00:08:12.420 --> 00:08:15.350
So now by definition, possession is, and this is the
160
00:08:15.370 --> 00:08:19.769
standard definition for possession. Possession is defined as, quote, the act, fact,
161
00:08:20.129 --> 00:08:23.850
or condition of having, holding, or controlling something. This generally
162
00:08:23.870 --> 00:08:27.470
refers to things like property, territory, emotional states, like self-possession,
163
00:08:27.569 --> 00:08:30.209
possessing a state of calm or anything like that, and
164
00:08:30.310 --> 00:08:32.509
or a ball or a puck, like in sporting events.
165
00:08:32.830 --> 00:08:35.029
When somebody has the ball, it is in their possession.
166
00:08:35.450 --> 00:08:37.929
Fair point. Yeah. I started saying, like the very first
167
00:08:37.980 --> 00:08:41.070
part I said was like, When a person is controlled
168
00:08:41.090 --> 00:08:43.720
by something, but just very broadly, the term possession is
169
00:08:43.769 --> 00:08:46.600
like stuff that you own. Yeah, stuff that.
170
00:08:46.480 --> 00:08:49.879
You own, stuff that you control, things that you have
171
00:08:49.980 --> 00:08:52.580
in your control or in your kind of like range
172
00:08:52.639 --> 00:08:53.860
of things that you control.
173
00:08:54.059 --> 00:08:58.000
Yeah. Yeah, which could even include other living things such as,
174
00:08:58.100 --> 00:09:01.720
for example, pets. People might think of them as possessions.
175
00:09:02.100 --> 00:09:03.899
Not that we're weighing in on that in one way
176
00:09:03.940 --> 00:09:08.100
or another, but just thinking about what that means from
177
00:09:08.139 --> 00:09:10.559
different perspectives. But of course, we're not really here to
178
00:09:10.600 --> 00:09:13.000
debate the part of the law that has to do
179
00:09:13.039 --> 00:09:16.759
with private property. We're going to focus on spiritual possession,
180
00:09:16.899 --> 00:09:19.360
which is more in line with that original definition of
181
00:09:19.419 --> 00:09:24.269
being controlled by an entity. Yes. More specifically... demonic possession
182
00:09:24.470 --> 00:09:27.490
for this discussion. Now, why are we going to do this? Well,
183
00:09:27.769 --> 00:09:34.049
these aren't generally separated out given the intrusive nature of possessions.
184
00:09:35.049 --> 00:09:37.720
Yeah, so basically what we mean is that demonic and
185
00:09:37.769 --> 00:09:41.240
spiritual possessions are often kind of used synonymously because it
186
00:09:41.279 --> 00:09:43.460
is some entity controlling the person. But there are some
187
00:09:43.480 --> 00:09:47.220
examples of beneficent or beneficent, however you want to say that,
188
00:09:47.559 --> 00:09:52.470
possessions in shamanic, animist, or African diasporic traditions, such as
189
00:09:52.830 --> 00:09:55.529
sacred practices related to spirit animal possession and whatnot. And
190
00:09:55.549 --> 00:09:57.750
we're going to share some of those characteristics in some ways.
191
00:09:57.769 --> 00:09:59.149
We're going to kind of talk about that and how
192
00:09:59.169 --> 00:10:02.649
that's important for cultivating practices. But what we are really
193
00:10:02.669 --> 00:10:05.340
going to focus on is just understanding what it means
194
00:10:05.399 --> 00:10:09.080
for an entity to possess somebody and how we explain
195
00:10:09.100 --> 00:10:09.899
that through a scientific lens.
196
00:10:10.610 --> 00:10:12.899
I know this is not at all the intention or
197
00:10:12.960 --> 00:10:15.559
direction that we're even going with this conversation, but thinking
198
00:10:15.639 --> 00:10:18.769
of like what would be a beneficial possession by an
199
00:10:18.990 --> 00:10:24.320
animal spirit, I'm thinking of like Spider-Man. Maybe Kraven the Hunter. Yeah.
200
00:10:24.759 --> 00:10:28.139
Black Panther. I could see that being in that space.
201
00:10:28.179 --> 00:10:31.639
But I think also, too, thinking about when you talk
202
00:10:31.659 --> 00:10:35.700
about guidance or when you talk about the ability to
203
00:10:35.980 --> 00:10:39.659
impart wisdom on somebody through that possession and what that
204
00:10:39.679 --> 00:10:42.860
looks like or some type of enlightenment, that's usually kind
205
00:10:42.879 --> 00:10:44.379
of what shows up in those spaces.
206
00:10:44.399 --> 00:10:44.539
Yeah.
207
00:10:44.820 --> 00:10:47.899
Rather than it being like this animal spirit is controlling
208
00:10:47.919 --> 00:10:50.889
your body and making you do some wacky.
209
00:10:50.590 --> 00:10:51.149
Things, right?
210
00:10:51.190 --> 00:10:53.250
So, like, I think that's probably the benefit is, like,
211
00:10:53.389 --> 00:10:56.980
almost like a wisdom piece rather than it being, you know, like,
212
00:10:57.149 --> 00:10:59.220
you know, malfeasant type of process.
213
00:10:59.720 --> 00:11:01.200
I could see it. I'm trying to think if there
214
00:11:01.340 --> 00:11:04.919
are like pop culture stories of this, but like where
215
00:11:04.960 --> 00:11:08.320
the like the animal shows up and leads you to
216
00:11:08.360 --> 00:11:10.000
a place you need to be. And it's kind of
217
00:11:10.019 --> 00:11:13.259
like a spirit animal. It's not maybe really there, but
218
00:11:13.299 --> 00:11:15.740
like that's sort of the idea is that like summoning
219
00:11:15.840 --> 00:11:18.240
the that sort of thing. That makes sense.
220
00:11:18.799 --> 00:11:21.759
There's some overlap with, like, spirit quests or, like, vision
221
00:11:21.799 --> 00:11:24.159
quests and stuff like that. You'll see some of those
222
00:11:24.220 --> 00:11:27.360
things inside of that. Or, like, you know, like, hunting traditions.
223
00:11:27.379 --> 00:11:29.879
You'll see that where, like, somebody is said to be,
224
00:11:30.120 --> 00:11:32.929
you know, imbued with the spirit of a predator. Like,
225
00:11:32.990 --> 00:11:34.690
you know, a powerful predator that is going to be
226
00:11:34.730 --> 00:11:36.529
successful in the hunt and whatnot. Like, you'll see some
227
00:11:36.570 --> 00:11:39.370
of those things show up. But, like, to your point, like,
228
00:11:39.429 --> 00:11:40.429
I don't think that we see a lot of this
229
00:11:40.470 --> 00:11:43.250
in pop culture because I think... A lot of our
230
00:11:43.269 --> 00:11:45.809
pop culture is kind of like white sanitized or whitewashed.
231
00:11:45.870 --> 00:11:47.490
So like we kind of miss a lot of those
232
00:11:47.549 --> 00:11:48.490
opportunities to see that.
233
00:11:48.970 --> 00:11:53.840
All right. So getting into demonic possessions, ads or demonic
234
00:11:53.879 --> 00:12:05.029
possession of a podcast. Yes. Okay, we're back. We've been
235
00:12:05.090 --> 00:12:09.490
just getting into sort of what possessions are. And what
236
00:12:09.529 --> 00:12:12.600
we started segwaying into was the fact that the idea
237
00:12:12.639 --> 00:12:15.259
of possessions and how these show up have existed in
238
00:12:15.299 --> 00:12:17.899
different ways across different cultures throughout human history.
239
00:12:18.340 --> 00:12:18.960
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
240
00:12:19.000 --> 00:12:22.100
So, tales of spiritual possessions, good, bad, or otherwise, can
241
00:12:22.120 --> 00:12:28.860
be found across cultures. And there's lots of examples in Buddhism, Christianity, voodoo, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism, Wicca,
242
00:12:28.980 --> 00:12:31.519
as well as indigenous cultures around the world. So you
243
00:12:31.539 --> 00:12:33.159
kind of see this show up a lot. And I
244
00:12:33.210 --> 00:12:37.149
think that given the complex nature of spirituality and creation stories,
245
00:12:37.210 --> 00:12:40.750
or like, I learned this term cosmogonic, cosmogonic myths.
246
00:12:41.269 --> 00:12:43.389
It looks like cosmogonic to me, but I'm not sure.
247
00:12:43.490 --> 00:12:44.769
I think it's cosmogonic. Yeah, yeah.
248
00:12:44.789 --> 00:12:46.529
Are you sure it's maybe not cosmogenic?
249
00:12:46.549 --> 00:12:49.000
I don't know. The word I saw was cosmogonic. It
250
00:12:49.019 --> 00:12:50.220
could be cosmogenic either way.
251
00:12:50.779 --> 00:12:53.039
It
stands to reason that humans would arrive at belief
252
00:12:53.080 --> 00:12:56.399
systems that involve connections with higher powers, spirits of the earth,
253
00:12:56.799 --> 00:13:00.120
different things like that. You know, polytheistic practices. Like, it
254
00:13:00.220 --> 00:13:03.519
makes sense that you're going to find that the kind of, like,
255
00:13:03.950 --> 00:13:09.309
reach to spirituality would include possession by those different entities.
256
00:13:09.750 --> 00:13:11.789
It's sort of like, I think about the fact that
257
00:13:11.970 --> 00:13:17.340
because language is this very malleable tool... it is capable
258
00:13:17.409 --> 00:13:22.740
of impressive things like coordinating cooperation, the development of science,
259
00:13:23.220 --> 00:13:25.200
like all of these. But at the same time, because
260
00:13:25.240 --> 00:13:27.679
it's just a tool, it can kind of also be anything.
261
00:13:27.779 --> 00:13:31.580
And from that, we also get like, if language enables
262
00:13:31.750 --> 00:13:36.169
us to imagine things that are not, while that's extremely
263
00:13:36.210 --> 00:13:42.440
helpful for things like creativity and developing experiments to test hypotheses, Right. Right. Right. Right.
264
00:14:02.500 --> 00:14:06.779
angels and demons and monsters and gods and whatnot. So anyway,
265
00:14:07.360 --> 00:14:10.490
language does that. And the reason that I think these
266
00:14:10.539 --> 00:14:13.139
things show up in a somewhat ubiquitous way across different
267
00:14:13.159 --> 00:14:16.529
cultures is not because there is a likelihood that there's
268
00:14:16.610 --> 00:14:21.590
any reality to these ideas, but instead because language is
269
00:14:21.649 --> 00:14:24.210
the tool by which we come to those things. And
270
00:14:24.610 --> 00:14:27.429
human culture tends to not stray super far from our
271
00:14:27.450 --> 00:14:31.850
technologies and body shapes. Right. In our quote unquote creative endeavors.
272
00:14:31.970 --> 00:14:35.080
And so things end up looking somewhat similar across cultures,
273
00:14:35.240 --> 00:14:39.220
even though they might have originated from very different geographical
274
00:14:39.279 --> 00:14:42.759
places and very different cultures, they'll end up having some
275
00:14:42.820 --> 00:14:46.330
amount of overlap anyway. Right. Let's get into this. Our
276
00:14:46.370 --> 00:14:50.370
first barrier in studying possessions is in its description and features,
277
00:14:50.509 --> 00:14:52.909
which probably should come as a shock to no one.
278
00:14:53.309 --> 00:14:56.820
They're not necessarily agreed upon characteristics of a possession, but
279
00:14:56.879 --> 00:14:59.639
there are some things to look out for in, if
280
00:14:59.679 --> 00:15:04.169
you're interested in studying this in your studies, in our discussion,
281
00:15:04.210 --> 00:15:05.710
at least here's the things to look out for.
282
00:15:06.299 --> 00:15:09.720
The first one
is preternatural or supernatural abilities. And this
283
00:15:09.759 --> 00:15:12.159
could refer to superhuman strength, the ability to speak in
284
00:15:12.200 --> 00:15:15.799
languages unknown to the person, or quote-unquote hidden knowledge, somebody
285
00:15:16.080 --> 00:15:20.440
having some level of clairvoyance, supposedly, about something they shouldn't
286
00:15:20.480 --> 00:15:22.960
really have information on. So if you start to observe
287
00:15:22.980 --> 00:15:25.840
this in somebody, this is often cited as one of
288
00:15:25.860 --> 00:15:28.139
the first indicators that possession has happened.
289
00:15:29.240 --> 00:15:32.889
Yeah, so possessions could include, but are not limited to, Yes.
290
00:15:33.169 --> 00:15:37.350
The supernatural abilities, also behavioral and psychological shifts, which is
291
00:15:37.450 --> 00:15:40.960
like loss of self-control, changes in vocal patterns, which I
292
00:15:41.000 --> 00:15:44.980
was doing at the beginning of this, extreme emotional volatility,
293
00:15:45.480 --> 00:15:46.279
that sort of thing.
294
00:15:46.799 --> 00:15:49.220
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then you also see spiritual or
295
00:15:49.299 --> 00:15:50.179
sacred aversions.
296
00:15:50.519 --> 00:15:53.659
So the possessed person may find a direct aversion to
297
00:15:53.759 --> 00:15:57.360
holy objects, relics, or rites. or further display aggressive behavior
298
00:15:57.419 --> 00:16:02.059
towards said relics or people that represent or have those
299
00:16:02.179 --> 00:16:03.720
relics in their own possession.
300
00:16:04.070 --> 00:16:05.649
So you'll see that kind of show up too.
301
00:16:06.529 --> 00:16:11.490
Super common in the exorcist movies and exorcism scenes. There's
302
00:16:11.549 --> 00:16:17.740
also somatic or sensory symptoms. This includes unexplained illnesses, increased
303
00:16:17.889 --> 00:16:21.059
sensitivity to stimuli and smells and that sort of thing.
304
00:16:21.590 --> 00:16:23.509
They've definitely played with this in some of the storytelling
305
00:16:23.529 --> 00:16:24.990
I've seen around possessions as well.
306
00:16:25.669 --> 00:16:26.610
Yeah, most definitely.
307
00:16:26.649 --> 00:16:29.139
So now this leads us to want to describe the
308
00:16:29.179 --> 00:16:32.379
casual elements of a possession. So according to most accounts
309
00:16:32.840 --> 00:16:35.990
that are often anecdotal, the initial cause of a possession
310
00:16:36.110 --> 00:16:38.590
is some type of supernatural. Again, you're going to see
311
00:16:38.610 --> 00:16:40.690
that word supernatural. That's going to be really important when
312
00:16:40.730 --> 00:16:44.009
we get into this later. supernatural entity or spirit. This
313
00:16:44.029 --> 00:16:46.539
can include any number of entities spanning a variety of
314
00:16:46.620 --> 00:16:49.600
cultural views. So for example, the Loa or the Eva
315
00:16:50.100 --> 00:16:53.519
in Haitian voodoo is a possessing spirit, where in
Catholicism,
316
00:16:53.620 --> 00:16:56.799
it's usually some demon. So you'll see different kinds of
317
00:16:57.059 --> 00:17:00.750
variations of this. I've seen angels, demons, spirit animals, like
318
00:17:00.850 --> 00:17:03.590
lots of different descriptions of different types of entities that
319
00:17:03.610 --> 00:17:04.869
might show up and possess the person.
320
00:17:05.579 --> 00:17:08.720
All right, perfect. So we've set the stage. With this information,
321
00:17:08.779 --> 00:17:11.200
we now have a cause, which is to say an entity,
322
00:17:11.839 --> 00:17:14.799
and some characteristics of the possession, those that we just list.
323
00:17:14.839 --> 00:17:19.420
There's the spiritual sacred aversions, behavioral and psychological shifts, supernatural abilities,
324
00:17:19.480 --> 00:17:23.140
somatic sensory symptoms, et cetera. So with this understanding, we
325
00:17:23.160 --> 00:17:25.640
can go ahead and unpack what this means through our
326
00:17:25.720 --> 00:17:32.250
basic assumptions of science and how we would start to
327
00:17:32.390 --> 00:17:36.660
bring this under that natural science lens. Because obviously it's
328
00:17:36.700 --> 00:17:39.259
a people, it's a thing that people report on observing
329
00:17:39.440 --> 00:17:43.359
and experiencing and having it happen. So that means that
330
00:17:43.400 --> 00:17:48.960
like with science, an element of this existing in observable reality,
331
00:17:49.039 --> 00:17:52.759
we can take a level of scientific scrutiny to that event. Yeah.
332
00:17:53.000 --> 00:17:54.559
And I want to be clear about this too, because
333
00:17:54.579 --> 00:17:56.640
I don't want this to sound as if we are
334
00:17:56.680 --> 00:18:00.049
trying to disrespect belief systems that people have. I think
335
00:18:00.089 --> 00:18:02.349
what we're trying to do is just understand it the
336
00:18:02.390 --> 00:18:04.289
way that we see the world and kind of understand
337
00:18:04.329 --> 00:18:07.359
it through these observable phenomenon in this framework. So I
338
00:18:07.500 --> 00:18:09.440
want to be clear about that. The goal of this
339
00:18:09.500 --> 00:18:13.859
is not to be disrespectful or to be cynical about this.
340
00:18:14.079 --> 00:18:16.480
This is where we kind of enter that skepticism place, right?
341
00:18:16.819 --> 00:18:18.660
So as we move forward and we kind of move
342
00:18:18.700 --> 00:18:21.569
through these basic assumptions, these basic scientific assumptions, which we're
343
00:18:21.589 --> 00:18:23.529
going to describe briefly as we go, we're going to
344
00:18:23.549 --> 00:18:25.490
be as objective as possible. We really want to look
345
00:18:25.509 --> 00:18:27.470
at this through a science lens because I think it
346
00:18:27.529 --> 00:18:30.529
is worth accounting for these features and the flaws of
347
00:18:30.690 --> 00:18:33.960
any phenomenon, no matter what that phenomenon is. It's worth
348
00:18:34.039 --> 00:18:37.720
doing that With some level of scrutiny. So I think
349
00:18:37.759 --> 00:18:39.299
the first one that we have to start with is
350
00:18:39.339 --> 00:18:41.880
because we are talking about this term supernatural and we're
351
00:18:41.900 --> 00:18:44.579
talking about kind of like patterns and stuff like that.
352
00:18:45.099 --> 00:18:46.500
I think that we start with determinism.
353
00:18:47.019 --> 00:18:50.619
Perfect. So getting into this, we're starting with the fact
354
00:18:50.660 --> 00:18:53.880
that like there are certain assumptions that we have to
355
00:18:53.940 --> 00:18:57.640
make to engage with the world through a scientific process.
356
00:18:58.440 --> 00:19:04.789
Because without these assumptions, a scientific approach would be incoherent. Honestly,
357
00:19:04.849 --> 00:19:09.089
without these assumptions, any approach in my mind feels incoherent.
358
00:19:09.130 --> 00:19:21.930
But again, that's why it's an assumption. Because without it,
359
00:19:21.970 --> 00:19:24.809
we simply can't proceed. And so the first one is determinism.
360
00:19:25.309 --> 00:19:27.130
And I think a lot of people hear determinism and
361
00:19:27.190 --> 00:19:29.279
confuse this for like fatalism.
362
00:19:29.480 --> 00:19:29.680
Right.
363
00:19:29.799 --> 00:19:33.319
Everything is predetermined, prescripted fate, which is not what it means.
364
00:19:34.279 --> 00:19:38.519
In a deterministic lens, all phenomenon that exist in the
365
00:19:38.599 --> 00:19:43.250
universe follow natural observable patterns. And again, we'd like to
366
00:19:43.289 --> 00:19:46.289
emphasize the word natural here. Natural.
367
00:19:46.529 --> 00:19:46.750
Yes.
368
00:19:47.069 --> 00:19:52.450
Oftentimes, spiritual positions use the term spiritual. meaning elevating it
369
00:19:52.609 --> 00:19:57.880
beyond natural phenomenon. The basic assumption that possessions occur as
370
00:19:57.930 --> 00:20:02.960
a result of beyond natural circumstances would specifically put it
371
00:20:03.099 --> 00:20:10.099
outside of our ability to evaluate it through a natural lens. However,
372
00:20:10.279 --> 00:20:13.319
if we're to hypothesize that the spirit or entity possessing
373
00:20:13.359 --> 00:20:17.529
the person were a natural phenomenon, it would require evidence
374
00:20:17.710 --> 00:20:20.430
of an additional type of life form, if you will,
375
00:20:20.490 --> 00:20:25.150
because again, we're talking about some thing, some entity that
376
00:20:25.329 --> 00:20:30.039
does not adhere to any of the understandings or laws
377
00:20:30.079 --> 00:20:35.529
that we have of biology, physics, chemistry, It simply does not.
378
00:20:36.049 --> 00:20:39.779
So coming out through the assumption of determinism, that all
379
00:20:39.880 --> 00:20:46.869
things exist in a deterministic universe... We therefore can accept
380
00:20:47.190 --> 00:20:50.180
only the parts of this that exist along the natural
381
00:20:50.460 -->
00:20:54.519
framework because if you start trying to put any of
382
00:20:54.559 --> 00:20:58.900
these things outside of that, they become incoherent. They do
383
00:20:58.940 --> 00:21:02.900
not work. Right. There is no example at all ever
384
00:21:03.180 --> 00:21:07.210
of things existing outside of the natural world. They just
385
00:21:07.349 --> 00:21:10.289
don't happen. Right. Here's the other problem with this. If
386
00:21:10.369 --> 00:21:14.250
they did happen outside of natural phenomenon, the fact that
387
00:21:14.269 --> 00:21:18.599
they exist at all would automatically make them natural phenomenon.
388
00:21:18.700 --> 00:21:22.960
And so as soon as it exists in the natural
389
00:21:23.019 --> 00:21:27.160
world at all, then it becomes natural phenomenon. So if
390
00:21:27.220 --> 00:21:29.259
we try and put it and say that it exists
391
00:21:29.319 --> 00:21:32.789
outside of the natural world, then you're saying it doesn't
392
00:21:32.990 --> 00:21:37.269
exist at which is why it has to exist through
393
00:21:37.289 --> 00:21:40.700
a deterministic lens because that is the only way that
394
00:21:40.720 --> 00:21:42.769
it exists at all. Yeah.
395
00:21:42.990 --> 00:21:45.789
I mean, I think you absolutely nailed it there. I mean,
396
00:21:46.470 --> 00:21:48.549
when you brought up ghosts the other day as part
397
00:21:48.589 --> 00:21:50.880
of why it doesn't make sense for them to exist,
398
00:21:50.930 --> 00:21:53.339
because they would have to have mass for them to
399
00:21:53.380 --> 00:21:56.500
be able to reflect light. And if they don't have mass, then.
400
00:21:56.480 --> 00:21:59.099
You can't see them. Or interact with matter.
401
00:22:07.329 --> 00:22:13.259
That we as scientists have observed or can explain everything
402
00:22:13.559 --> 00:22:17.079
through a naturalistic lens. And yes, we can if we're
403
00:22:17.140 --> 00:22:20.680
able to identify those patterns. So it is very possible,
404
00:22:21.000 --> 00:22:22.880
and I think this is where the skepticism piece comes in,
405
00:22:23.339 --> 00:22:26.230
it is possible that at some point in time, one
406
00:22:26.269 --> 00:22:29.549
of these phenomenon that is unexplained can could eventually be
407
00:22:29.609 --> 00:22:33.109
explained through pattern recognition that occurs inside of this deterministic space,
408
00:22:33.630 --> 00:22:35.799
but we may not know what the pattern is yet.
409
00:22:36.359 --> 00:22:39.660
So an example that I might use here is the
410
00:22:39.720 --> 00:22:42.759
quantum physics and physics in general involved with light-speed travel.
411
00:22:42.859 --> 00:22:45.000
We can explain that to some degree, but we have
412
00:22:45.039 --> 00:22:49.049
not observed this thing happening yet from a machine that
413
00:22:49.089 --> 00:22:52.750
we have made to create light-speed travel. What I'm saying
414
00:22:52.809 --> 00:22:56.349
is the theory is there, some descriptions are there, but
415
00:22:56.390 --> 00:22:58.380
we have not observed this thing. We haven't observed the
416
00:22:58.410 --> 00:23:02.119
patterns that make this thing happen or reasonable to occur
417
00:23:02.299 --> 00:23:07.039
in our observable world right now. The point is that everything,
418
00:23:07.420 --> 00:23:12.809
everything underneath a deterministic view has a pattern. Scientists, as
419
00:23:12.950 --> 00:23:15.829
part of their observation and discovery of the world, are
420
00:23:15.930 --> 00:23:18.990
trying to identify what those patterns might be in the
421
00:23:19.049 --> 00:23:20.529
event that we have not identified them yet.
422
00:23:21.190 --> 00:23:25.289
Yeah, it's what are all of the variables in play
423
00:23:25.569 --> 00:23:28.809
that allow this thing to happen the way that it does?
424
00:23:29.250 --> 00:23:29.509
Yes.
425
00:23:29.910 --> 00:23:31.509
And just as you said, and that's very, very important,
426
00:23:32.210 --> 00:23:35.339
sometimes we know what those are, but a lot of
427
00:23:35.380 --> 00:23:39.049
times we don't yet know. know what they are. It
428
00:23:39.069 --> 00:23:42.109
doesn't mean we never will. And I think before we
429
00:23:42.150 --> 00:23:45.509
had any idea of what caused disease, there were a
430
00:23:45.549 --> 00:23:49.029
lot of very silly ideas about why people got sick.
431
00:23:49.670 --> 00:23:52.799
And there was no way of understanding things like bacteria
432
00:23:52.819 --> 00:23:55.819
and viruses when you couldn't even conceive of that being
433
00:23:55.880 --> 00:23:58.599
a thing that exists in reality. But that doesn't mean
434
00:23:58.640 --> 00:24:03.119
that the actual explanation was demonic possession or bad air
435
00:24:03.339 --> 00:24:06.220
or the arrangement of the stars in the sky. It
436
00:24:06.259 --> 00:24:09.500
just meant that we didn't understand it yet. And we're
437
00:24:09.539 --> 00:24:11.279
just still in the place where there are things that
438
00:24:11.319 --> 00:24:15.039
happen that we currently don't understand why they happen. Why
439
00:24:15.119 --> 00:24:25.440
do we keep having ads? All right, we're back. I
440
00:24:25.619 --> 00:24:27.450
think we've done a great job with determinism. I'm ready
441
00:24:27.490 --> 00:24:29.950
to move on to our next major important assumption here,
442
00:24:30.009 --> 00:24:31.089
which is empiricism.
443
00:24:31.859 --> 00:24:33.079
Yeah, let's talk about empiricism.
444
00:24:33.119 --> 00:24:37.079
So, for possession to meet the requirement of empiricism, there
445
00:24:37.119 --> 00:24:40.380
would need to be verifiable and replicable demonstrations of the phenomenon.
446
00:24:40.420 --> 00:24:41.380
There needs to be evidence.
447
00:24:41.420 --> 00:24:43.970
So, empiricism is the idea of evidence. But when we
448
00:24:43.990 --> 00:24:46.529
talk about evidence, we are not talking about a singular
449
00:24:47.009 --> 00:24:50.230
observable event. We are talking about multiple
instances where we
450
00:24:50.269 --> 00:24:54.089
have consistent evidence to demonstrate a phenomenon exists. So, we
451
00:24:54.109 --> 00:24:57.279
talked about this with the cryptids episode, where, like, one
452
00:24:57.339 --> 00:25:00.559
person will see some creature that is, like, Kind of strange,
453
00:25:00.619 --> 00:25:02.579
kind of odd, but it might be the result of
454
00:25:02.599 --> 00:25:03.279
a mutation.
455
00:25:03.359 --> 00:25:04.779
It might be the result of a deformity.
456
00:25:04.799 --> 00:25:07.119
It might be the result of whatever thing is going on.
457
00:25:07.440 --> 00:25:10.109
And it might have been the only member of the
458
00:25:10.140 --> 00:25:14.430
species that has this particular type of characteristic. So that
459
00:25:14.470 --> 00:25:17.529
does not mean, like when you see something like a
460
00:25:17.589 --> 00:25:20.430
swamp ape or something like that, that that is evidence, right?
461
00:25:20.470 --> 00:25:23.839
That just means that we have some level of inquiry
462
00:25:23.859 --> 00:25:26.200
that we need to engage in. Now, as we write this,
463
00:25:26.559 --> 00:25:28.460
there are a lot of reports, right?
464
00:25:28.720 --> 00:25:29.319
Of possessions.
465
00:25:29.400 --> 00:25:31.559
And I want to be really clear, these are anecdotal
466
00:25:31.619 --> 00:25:36.400
reports of possessions, right? Where some famous possessions include Annalise Mickle,
467
00:25:36.700 --> 00:25:40.069
which we did talk about in our exorcism episode, who
468
00:25:40.150 --> 00:25:44.089
underwent 67 separate exorcisms, Roland Doe, who's the basis of
469
00:25:44.130 --> 00:25:47.910
the novel and movie The Exorcism, and Arne Cheyenne Johnson,
470
00:25:47.930 --> 00:25:49.309
who's the basis of The Devil Made Me Do It
471
00:25:49.450 --> 00:25:51.710
and The Conjuring 2, which we referenced in the last episode.
472
00:25:52.430 --> 00:25:55.480
Yeah, perfect. So I will add a little bit that, like,
473
00:25:55.619 --> 00:25:59.319
there are things that only happen once that are very
474
00:25:59.400 --> 00:26:00.920
clearly observable phenomenon.
475
00:26:01.160 --> 00:26:01.339
Right.
476
00:26:01.420 --> 00:26:04.579
And you take, like, for example, like, we're pretty confident
477
00:26:04.599 --> 00:26:08.480
that the moon that orbits the Earth... came from a
478
00:26:08.579 --> 00:26:11.460
large impact where the Earth was struck by a very
479
00:26:11.529 --> 00:26:13.349
large thing and a chunk of it broke off and
480
00:26:13.410 --> 00:26:16.809
essentially formed into the moon. And as far as we know,
481
00:26:16.829 --> 00:26:19.529
that has only ever happened once, very early in the
482
00:26:19.589 --> 00:26:23.309
Earth's history. But we have a lot of evidence that
483
00:26:23.710 --> 00:26:28.259
we can collect that supports that as a theory, understanding
484
00:26:28.720 --> 00:26:30.579
all of the evidence that we've gathered. Yeah.
485
00:26:30.759 --> 00:26:30.900
So.
486
00:26:31.720 --> 00:26:33.859
But just, yeah, so it was like the repeated thing
487
00:26:34.000 --> 00:26:36.539
is definitely important when it comes to most natural phenomenon
488
00:26:36.579 --> 00:26:38.839
that we're looking at. But like also if there is
489
00:26:39.299 --> 00:26:41.920
like something that happened only a single time, if there's
490
00:26:42.009 --> 00:26:44.569
evidence for it, then again, it exists in an empirical way.
491
00:26:44.589 --> 00:26:47.829
It can be validated through observation. Right. And it can
492
00:26:47.849 --> 00:26:50.609
be validated by an observation from anybody at any point
493
00:26:50.650 --> 00:26:55.000
who's able to have potentially observed that thing. And therein
494
00:26:55.059 --> 00:26:59.269
lies the lacking that comes from some of these possession stories.
495
00:26:59.950 --> 00:27:01.670
And also, I want to be mindful of the fact
496
00:27:01.690 --> 00:27:05.170
that while anecdotal reports and data can be useful, I
497
00:27:05.210 --> 00:27:09.869
think especially in qualitative studies, I actually find qualitative data
498
00:27:09.910 --> 00:27:14.549
to be extraordinarily useful and maybe even something That would
499
00:27:14.569 --> 00:27:16.170
be worth doing a little bit of a mini-on or
500
00:27:16.210 --> 00:27:20.490
something because I think it is an underappreciated approach to
501
00:27:20.829 --> 00:27:24.519
thinking about behavioral phenomenon and science more broadly. Right. There
502
00:27:24.619 --> 00:27:27.799
is just simply insufficient evidence to demonstrate that any element
503
00:27:28.000 --> 00:27:31.059
of a possession is replicable and verifiable.
504
00:27:31.079 --> 00:27:33.099
Yeah, at least from the ghost standpoint.
505
00:27:33.559 --> 00:27:36.039
Yes. Yeah. From the premise that there's an entity responsible
506
00:27:36.059 --> 00:27:39.690
for the characteristics of things. Because what we can observe
507
00:27:40.130 --> 00:27:45.390
is unique situations with people doing strange things. But the
508
00:27:45.650 --> 00:27:50.519
evidence that there is anything outside of the natural world
509
00:27:50.559 --> 00:27:54.609
that's involved in these virtually does not exist. Right.
510
00:27:55.049 --> 00:27:57.660
Which I think brings us to the third assumption of science,
511
00:27:57.720 --> 00:28:00.519
which is parsimony. So when we talk about parsimony, we
512
00:28:00.559 --> 00:28:03.960
are talking about Occam's razor, the simplest explanation. And to date,
513
00:28:04.259 --> 00:28:09.089
we actually have verifiable or observable phenomenon that are simpler
514
00:28:09.569 --> 00:28:12.849
and more likely to be verified causes for how key
515
00:28:12.910 --> 00:28:16.910
characteristics of possessions could occur. So we could argue that
516
00:28:16.930 --> 00:28:19.859
there is an unknown demonic entity controlling someone's behavior or
517
00:28:19.880 --> 00:28:22.240
that It could be any number of biological, neurological, or
518
00:28:22.259 --> 00:28:27.200
medical factors. Brain tumors, neurodegenerative disorders like dementia, Alzheimer's, you
519
00:28:27.240 --> 00:28:31.160
have schizophrenia, severe mania, Tourette's syndrome. These are all more
520
00:28:31.299 --> 00:28:36.089
viable explanations for why we might see sudden behavior changes. Now,
521
00:28:36.460 --> 00:28:39.210
With that being said, you might hear that and go, well,
522
00:28:39.269 --> 00:28:41.670
why we do what we do? What about those religious
523
00:28:41.710 --> 00:28:44.210
aversion pieces that you talked about earlier? People who all
524
00:28:44.230 --> 00:28:46.650
of a sudden start hating crosses and they start not
525
00:28:46.730 --> 00:28:50.599
liking holy water. Language is powerful, first and foremost. And
526
00:28:50.619 --> 00:28:53.380
we do have studies on the experience of traumatic religious
527
00:28:53.440 --> 00:28:55.960
events and how those have shaped some of our behavior
528
00:28:56.000 --> 00:28:56.980
in lots of different ways.
529
00:28:57.019 --> 00:28:59.119
They shaped our expectations, thoughts, We've.
530
00:28:58.940 --> 00:29:02.670
Been conditioned to respond under certain circumstances. When we see
531
00:29:02.769 --> 00:29:06.730
things like priests or crosses, or somebody tells us that
532
00:29:06.750 --> 00:29:08.690
something is holy water or something like that, we might
533
00:29:08.730 --> 00:29:12.150
have those experiences and religious expectations, language around possession and
534
00:29:12.190 --> 00:29:15.680
internal damnation, social pressures from congregations. All of these things
535
00:29:16.200 --> 00:29:19.619
are all factors that are observable within the natural world
536
00:29:19.980 --> 00:29:22.500
that we could consider as part of the specific experience
537
00:29:22.539 --> 00:29:24.839
of somebody having a said possession.
538
00:29:25.440 --> 00:29:28.990
It all comes down to like, Have we ruled out
539
00:29:29.009 --> 00:29:32.539
the most likely explanation first? Right. So like, for example,
540
00:29:32.559 --> 00:29:34.839
we have a bunch of Halloween decorations. One of them
541
00:29:35.240 --> 00:29:37.829
is mounted on the wall using this sort of thick
542
00:29:38.009 --> 00:29:41.359
jelly-like adhesive kind of tape. if you will, and it
543
00:29:41.400 --> 00:29:44.529
keeps falling down. And this is the second year we've
544
00:29:44.549 --> 00:29:46.410
tried to use this. So I think the adhesiveness is
545
00:29:46.430 --> 00:29:48.569
wearing off. But again, like you could see this thing
546
00:29:48.609 --> 00:29:51.289
fall down and start looking for a wizard or or
547
00:29:51.309 --> 00:29:54.710
a Cthulhu who is responsible for knocking that down. But like,
548
00:29:55.019 --> 00:29:57.480
shouldn't you first rule out that the tape is just
549
00:29:57.579 --> 00:30:01.400
not that sticky anymore? Like, that is the better explanation.
550
00:30:01.480 --> 00:30:04.420
That's
what parsimony is about. It's like, let's make sure
551
00:30:04.460 --> 00:30:07.200
we've accounted for the things that are the most likely
552
00:30:07.279 --> 00:30:08.980
to be responsible for this first. What are the most
553
00:30:09.079 --> 00:30:12.089
likely variables? And people do like to say simpler. And
554
00:30:12.109 --> 00:30:13.630
then I think that they get caught up in what
555
00:30:13.690 --> 00:30:16.750
that means to them, like what means simple. And I
556
00:30:16.789 --> 00:30:19.250
think the better way to maybe phrase it is like,
557
00:30:20.109 --> 00:30:25.170
How far away from reasonable, rational explanations and assumptions do
558
00:30:25.190 --> 00:30:28.519
you have to get to make your idea make sense? Right.
559
00:30:28.559 --> 00:30:31.339
So again, if like the thing is falling down and
560
00:30:31.380 --> 00:30:35.640
I'm like, probably it's aliens. I'm like, well, we have
561
00:30:35.660 --> 00:30:37.799
to go, we have to move really far away from
562
00:30:37.880 --> 00:30:40.190
things we are very certain about to get to the
563
00:30:40.230 --> 00:30:43.190
point at which aliens is a reasonable thing to have
564
00:30:43.230 --> 00:30:46.119
jumped to as the next reasonable explanation for this. Now,
565
00:30:46.180 --> 00:30:48.420
and there are things where I think they appear so
566
00:30:48.539 --> 00:30:51.319
strange to us that we want to make that leap
567
00:30:51.400 --> 00:30:55.220
right away because it's like this doesn't seem obvious that
568
00:30:55.240 --> 00:30:59.450
there is a simpler explanation for this. But I guarantee
569
00:30:59.490 --> 00:31:00.230
you there is.
570
00:31:00.950 --> 00:31:02.190
Right, right.
571
00:31:02.329 --> 00:31:05.650
I guarantee it that there is. So anyway, this all
572
00:31:05.690 --> 00:31:08.819
comes down to like, I think if, let's look, for example,
573
00:31:08.839 --> 00:31:11.299
in that religious aversion piece, like imagine you're in this
574
00:31:11.380 --> 00:31:16.200
exorcist scenario, someone who is probably from some religious affiliation
575
00:31:16.359 --> 00:31:20.980
shows up with a lot of religious language and symbolism
576
00:31:21.519 --> 00:31:24.740
on their body. They're holding a cross, they're wearing a cross,
577
00:31:24.779 --> 00:31:28.759
they're using religious words and And the person who they're confronting,
578
00:31:29.519 --> 00:31:32.700
like that person is now just imbued with these symbols.
579
00:31:32.980 --> 00:31:35.740
So their rejection of those symbols come with the fact
580
00:31:35.809 --> 00:31:38.690
that they're being confronted by a person who's wearing those symbols.
581
00:31:38.990 --> 00:31:42.809
So their reaction to something like a cross might just
582
00:31:42.869 --> 00:31:45.490
be because it's the person who's there with that symbol.
583
00:31:45.750 --> 00:31:47.990
Had they shown up with a Star of David? Had
584
00:31:48.029 --> 00:31:51.359
they shown up with a... any other religious symbolism that
585
00:31:51.400 --> 00:31:53.539
you might think of, that might've been the thing that
586
00:31:53.559 --> 00:31:55.759
they reacted to instead. But when we talk about these
587
00:31:55.839 --> 00:32:00.460
religious exorcisms, particularly because exorcisms are almost exclusively performed by
588
00:32:00.579 --> 00:32:04.039
Christian clergy when they're calling them exorcisms. Yeah.
589
00:32:04.119 --> 00:32:05.960
It's part of the Catholic church for sure.
590
00:32:06.200 --> 00:32:09.099
Yes, exactly. Then like, that's the kind of symbolism that
591
00:32:09.119 --> 00:32:11.569
they bring to them. But like, it would be, I
592
00:32:11.609 --> 00:32:14.410
think the simplest explanation of these moments is like, yeah,
593
00:32:14.450 --> 00:32:16.450
that's what they showed up with. Like, that's the symbol
594
00:32:16.470 --> 00:32:18.269
that they use. Like, Sure. Had they shown up with
595
00:32:18.289 --> 00:32:20.269
anything else, that could have been the symbol that then
596
00:32:20.329 --> 00:32:23.210
was rebelled against, if you will. But anyway, that's the
597
00:32:23.250 --> 00:32:25.130
parsimony piece, I think. Yeah, yeah.
598
00:32:25.190 --> 00:32:25.930
I think you nailed it there.
599
00:32:26.269 --> 00:32:29.190
So then going on to the fourth basic assumption, we
600
00:32:29.210 --> 00:32:33.519
have pragmatism, right? The idea that science is going to–
601
00:32:33.670 --> 00:32:35.750
like whatever phenomenon it is, however we're studying it, it's
602
00:32:35.769 --> 00:32:37.009
going to have some ultimate benefit.
603
00:32:37.410 --> 00:32:39.750
To humanity, to the world at large, to natural science, right?
604
00:32:39.769 --> 00:32:41.579
So like, so the question that kind of comes up
605
00:32:41.599 --> 00:32:44.640
here is like, what is it worth to humanity to
606
00:32:44.839 --> 00:32:47.680
study this and spend time like intervening on this? Well,
607
00:32:48.140 --> 00:32:51.000
if we consider advancements in medicine, psychological and behavioral practices,
608
00:32:51.259 --> 00:32:53.160
and all of those things that go along with kind
609
00:32:53.200 --> 00:32:56.809
of modern medicine, just in general, then treating possessions as
610
00:32:56.849 --> 00:32:59.710
a spiritual phenomenon doesn't really have as much utility or
611
00:32:59.730 --> 00:33:01.470
any sort of success rate.
612
00:33:01.849 --> 00:33:03.130
So, like, that's the other side.
613
00:33:03.009 --> 00:33:05.660
Of this is, like, even if this were demonic possession
614
00:33:05.680 --> 00:33:08.839
and we were treating it through those more traditional means
615
00:33:09.119 --> 00:33:12.940
of exorcisms, we find that that's not really the solution,
616
00:33:13.440 --> 00:33:16.750
especially when there's a more medical reason going on, like
617
00:33:16.910 --> 00:33:20.170
a brain tumor or a psychotic break. So when these
618
00:33:20.250 --> 00:33:23.109
types of conditions emerge, we find
greater benefits from a
619
00:33:23.130 --> 00:33:25.529
medical or behavioral or social model. And I think I
620
00:33:25.650 --> 00:33:26.990
want to be clear about that, too, because it might
621
00:33:27.029 --> 00:33:30.599
not necessarily be something medical. It could be some social
622
00:33:30.779 --> 00:33:33.500
engagement where the person is not connected with their community.
623
00:33:33.720 --> 00:33:36.579
They're having distress related to distances from their community, which
624
00:33:36.599 --> 00:33:39.359
we've seen a lot in the indigenous populations where the
625
00:33:39.460 --> 00:33:43.380
further away somebody gets from their identity, the more likely
626
00:33:43.420 --> 00:33:46.450
they're going to have some unique distressors around that. So
627
00:33:46.690 --> 00:33:49.289
the social models of support too are really important and
628
00:33:49.490 --> 00:33:52.069
accurate medical treatment, social support, and all those things. tend
629
00:33:52.089 --> 00:33:54.529
to have more of an impact on improving symptoms of
630
00:33:54.569 --> 00:33:58.700
possessions than involvement from the church. Unless the church is
631
00:33:58.759 --> 00:34:04.640
that support model, and it's more about providing community than
632
00:34:04.660 --> 00:34:06.599
it is about doing exorcisms.
633
00:34:07.160 --> 00:34:10.909
Which again, then that becomes what you do instead.
634
00:34:11.110 --> 00:34:11.329
Right.
635
00:34:11.570 --> 00:34:13.550
Like, why do the thing that doesn't work when we
636
00:34:13.590 --> 00:34:16.099
can do the thing that does? If there's a piece
637
00:34:16.119 --> 00:34:18.739
of this that does work, albeit inefficiently and through this
638
00:34:18.900 --> 00:34:22.000
very weird elaborate ritual, instead let's take the part of
639
00:34:22.039 --> 00:34:25.320
that that actually matters and make that the main ingredient
640
00:34:25.360 --> 00:34:27.530
of how we're going to approach this. Right. I kind
641
00:34:27.550 --> 00:34:29.210
of love this whole point anyway of just sort of
642
00:34:29.250 --> 00:34:32.170
like what is this– what utility does this have for
643
00:34:32.230 --> 00:34:36.929
us as a species? None. Right. None utility. None.
644
00:34:36.989 --> 00:34:37.289
Yeah.
645
00:34:37.309 --> 00:34:39.170
To approach it from that lens of the like the
646
00:34:39.210 --> 00:34:40.250
supernatural lens, if you will.
647
00:34:40.909 --> 00:34:43.269
I think what we're saying is like in those situations
648
00:34:43.309 --> 00:34:48.570
or circumstances when somebody is having some concerning presenting problem, right?
649
00:34:48.699 --> 00:34:52.300
This is not like in those, like more, those nicer,
650
00:34:52.699 --> 00:34:54.920
you know, beneficial types of possessions that people talk about,
651
00:34:54.960 --> 00:34:56.500
like that are part of the spirit guides and those
652
00:34:56.519 --> 00:34:58.880
journeys and all that. That's a different context, right? We're
653
00:34:58.920 --> 00:35:00.719
talking about like the people who are possessed and are
654
00:35:00.760 --> 00:35:03.579
having possessed by demons who are engaging in a barren
655
00:35:03.619 --> 00:35:06.619
or problem or concerning behavior, like self injurious behavior and whatnot,
656
00:35:06.940 --> 00:35:09.039
like an exorcism isn't going to work, right? It just
657
00:35:09.059 --> 00:35:12.289
doesn't benefit that person, right? It doesn't benefit the people.
658
00:35:12.309 --> 00:35:15.010
It doesn't benefit anybody in that situation.
659
00:35:15.030 --> 00:35:18.840
Yeah, yeah. I think you actually get to what I
660
00:35:18.940 --> 00:35:23.369
said was it has none benefit. Which I obviously say
661
00:35:23.409 --> 00:35:25.409
that grammatically and correctly for the humor of the way
662
00:35:25.449 --> 00:35:28.590
that it lands. But I would actually– I think you
663
00:35:28.650 --> 00:35:32.130
actually point out that it goes beyond not having benefits
664
00:35:32.150 --> 00:35:34.150
to the fact that it's actually counterproductive.
665
00:35:34.170 --> 00:35:35.679
It's harmful. Like, yeah.
666
00:35:35.969 --> 00:35:38.030
It's not just that it doesn't work. It's that it
667
00:35:38.159 --> 00:35:41.579
actually puts us in the wrong direction and makes things worse,
668
00:35:41.639 --> 00:35:51.840
like putting ads in a podcast. Right. Okay, we're back.
669
00:35:52.300 --> 00:35:55.619
We are unpacking these various assumptions of science. Now, one
670
00:35:55.659 --> 00:35:59.960
that we hadn't originally discussed, including in this episode, I'm
671
00:35:59.980 --> 00:36:01.480
going to bring up really quickly before we move on
672
00:36:01.500 --> 00:36:03.480
to sort of our last one, is there is, I think,
673
00:36:03.519 --> 00:36:06.110
an assumption that it's a little bit ties a lot
674
00:36:06.119 --> 00:36:09.070
of these together. And it's assumption of something called monism.
675
00:36:09.710 --> 00:36:13.030
And that is the assumption that we only live in
676
00:36:13.070 --> 00:36:16.530
this one plane of reality. And that, again, is a
677
00:36:16.590 --> 00:36:19.519
scientific assumption that we depend on that like there are
678
00:36:19.579 --> 00:36:22.699
not different versions of reality that could spontaneously exist at
679
00:36:22.739 --> 00:36:25.420
different points. There is one universe that we live in.
680
00:36:25.920 --> 00:36:27.119
And a lot of people like to think about this
681
00:36:27.199 --> 00:36:29.980
idea that there's this multiverse of things. And I honestly,
682
00:36:30.000 --> 00:36:32.769
I don't know how to feel about there being the
683
00:36:32.809 --> 00:36:35.329
idea of multiple dimensions. Certainly a lot of very smart
684
00:36:35.369 --> 00:36:36.849
people seem to think that that could be a thing
685
00:36:36.889 --> 00:36:39.630
that exists. I am very skeptical of the arguments that
686
00:36:39.670 --> 00:36:43.010
they have made, but I'm perfectly willing to accept that
687
00:36:43.110 --> 00:36:44.869
they maybe have put thought into this in a way
688
00:36:44.909 --> 00:36:48.250
that I haven't. But the idea is that we don't
689
00:36:48.269 --> 00:36:51.920
get to have both a universe where something like gods
690
00:36:52.019 --> 00:36:54.679
exist and a universe that we live in that we
691
00:36:54.739 --> 00:36:58.500
have all these observable phenomenon and have those two coexist simultaneously,
692
00:36:58.539 --> 00:37:01.099
that doesn't make any sense. Again, it just comes back
693
00:37:01.119 --> 00:37:03.480
to this incoherent piece. And related to that, that's where
694
00:37:03.519 --> 00:37:07.210
we get things like empiricism. That's like where, like determinism
695
00:37:07.309 --> 00:37:10.449
and parsimony, because all of that is sort of exists
696
00:37:10.489 --> 00:37:13.030
in the sort of monistic framework of there being just
697
00:37:13.070 --> 00:37:16.409
the one sort of world that Moan coming from like
698
00:37:16.590 --> 00:37:20.059
mono or singular, just one. Anyway, I just wanted to
699
00:37:20.079 --> 00:37:22.099
throw that one in there as we're sort of getting
700
00:37:22.119 --> 00:37:24.139
to the end here of our assumptions. Yeah.
701
00:37:24.300 --> 00:37:25.980
No, I think it's beautiful. I think it's so perfect.
702
00:37:26.039 --> 00:37:28.440
So, I think another one that kind of ties everything together,
703
00:37:28.500 --> 00:37:29.840
and this is, I think, one of the most important
704
00:37:29.900 --> 00:37:34.170
parts of the scientific practice is this idea of philosophic doubt.
705
00:37:34.329 --> 00:37:36.510
And I think this is the thing. I mean, you've
706
00:37:36.530 --> 00:37:38.409
said it more than once on the show where science
707
00:37:38.449 --> 00:37:41.309
is self-correcting. And with new information comes new ways to
708
00:37:41.349 --> 00:37:44.210
study things. And so, I think this is so important
709
00:37:44.230 --> 00:37:46.530
for kind of like the theme and the practice and
710
00:37:46.570 --> 00:37:48.650
the understanding of what we're talking about in this episode
711
00:37:48.989 --> 00:37:52.699
is we land on this idea of philosophic doubt because
712
00:37:53.199 --> 00:37:56.860
information shows up. So, what happens when we're presented with
713
00:37:56.960 --> 00:38:00.400
new evidence? Well, up until this point, there is really
714
00:38:00.460 --> 00:38:03.659
no evidence of spiritual possession being a thing. It's important
715
00:38:03.679 --> 00:38:05.099
to know that. And I think one of the things
716
00:38:05.119 --> 00:38:07.219
that we talk about on the show is that we
717
00:38:07.300 --> 00:38:08.250
have a value of.
718
00:38:08.320 --> 00:38:09.530
Skepticism over cynicism.
719
00:38:09.849 --> 00:38:10.150
Yes.
720
00:38:10.369 --> 00:38:12.829
The idea is that when we approach these topics, we're
721
00:38:12.849 --> 00:38:15.329
not approaching them being like, oh, this isn't true.
We
722
00:38:15.369 --> 00:38:17.630
approach these topics of going, I want to understand this
723
00:38:17.690 --> 00:38:20.960
better because I'm skeptical that this is a phenomenon that exists.
724
00:38:21.380 --> 00:38:21.699
And so.
725
00:38:22.420 --> 00:38:25.920
Of course, if there's ever a circumstance where new evidence
726
00:38:25.960 --> 00:38:29.219
is presented, we may consider other options. However, at this
727
00:38:29.280 --> 00:38:32.389
point in time, on this topic, with the available information
728
00:38:32.409 --> 00:38:34.150
that we have and the way that we study the
729
00:38:34.190 --> 00:38:37.449
world and our understanding of natural sciences, the evidence that
730
00:38:37.510 --> 00:38:39.750
would need to happen for us to believe or to
731
00:38:39.949 --> 00:38:44.630
understand or to accept that demonic or spiritual possession is
732
00:38:44.690 --> 00:38:47.900
a natural phenomenon that actually exists is It would require
733
00:38:48.320 --> 00:38:51.900
so much evidence that it would have to be substantial, replicable, verifiable.
734
00:38:51.960 --> 00:38:54.280
It would require that there is enough evidence to move
735
00:38:54.320 --> 00:38:58.920
the phenomenon out of the quote-unquote supernatural territory or category
736
00:38:59.179 --> 00:39:02.119
that's often described in into a natural science to allow
737
00:39:02.260 --> 00:39:04.780
us and basically to adhere to those basic assumptions that
738
00:39:04.800 --> 00:39:07.219
we just talked about. So far at this point in time,
739
00:39:07.559 --> 00:39:11.610
we are very, very, very, very long way from that happening.
740
00:39:12.050 --> 00:39:15.650
Based on current available information, like we simply do not
741
00:39:15.710 --> 00:39:21.530
have information on varying planes of existence, on corporeal entities,
742
00:39:21.889 --> 00:39:26.849
sentient corporeal entities or demons or angels or ghosts or
743
00:39:26.949 --> 00:39:29.389
any of those things that are often the primary kind
744
00:39:29.409 --> 00:39:32.659
of information. of entity, the causal factor of these types
745
00:39:32.699 --> 00:39:35.199
of possessions that we're talking about. Now, we have studies
746
00:39:35.340 --> 00:39:40.019
on how hallucinogens work and how things like that and
747
00:39:40.039 --> 00:39:43.739
how people have those experiences, those lived experiences underneath those
748
00:39:43.780 --> 00:39:47.300
varying states of different types of like psychogenic drugs.
749
00:39:47.639 --> 00:39:49.139
And I'm not saying that that's the case for everybody.
750
00:39:49.179 --> 00:39:49.719
I want to be clear.
751
00:39:49.739 --> 00:39:52.460
I'm not saying like, well, you were possessed because you
752
00:39:52.739 --> 00:39:53.820
took some really great mushrooms.
753
00:39:54.159 --> 00:39:55.039
That's not what I'm saying.
754
00:39:56.199 --> 00:39:58.760
But I think it's important to note that is also
755
00:39:59.489 --> 00:40:03.230
more likely to be the parsimonious explanation for somebody having
756
00:40:03.630 --> 00:40:07.489
experienced possession than a ghost. And that's kind of where
757
00:40:07.510 --> 00:40:09.789
we're at here. And in the event that more evidence
758
00:40:09.829 --> 00:40:12.630
comes up that ghosts exist, we may have a different conversation.
759
00:40:12.650 --> 00:40:14.809
But right now, as it currently stands, we simply do
760
00:40:14.829 --> 00:40:15.409
not have enough.
761
00:40:16.550 --> 00:40:19.730
Just as you said, the evidence would have to be incontrovertible.
762
00:40:20.510 --> 00:40:24.239
There is no way to doubt any aspect of the
763
00:40:24.260 --> 00:40:26.079
thing that you've seen. And I think another thing is
764
00:40:26.139 --> 00:40:31.710
that people have done... a very incomplete job of actually
765
00:40:31.769 --> 00:40:34.829
trying to work out the implications for if something like
766
00:40:34.889 --> 00:40:37.789
this were to exist. Like if we were to actually
767
00:40:37.849 --> 00:40:41.340
grant that something like a demon possession could exist, the
768
00:40:41.420 --> 00:40:45.079
implications for that are so far reaching and would be
769
00:40:45.239 --> 00:40:48.780
so pervasive and so embedded in so many other aspects
770
00:40:48.840 --> 00:40:51.860
of reality that like, I think that once you start
771
00:40:51.920 --> 00:40:54.179
working out, like, let's start from the assumption that something
772
00:40:54.199 --> 00:40:56.659
like that could exist and What would that mean for
773
00:40:56.679 --> 00:40:58.650
the rest of how we understand the world? You eventually
774
00:40:58.670 --> 00:41:01.250
get to a point where the answer is it can't
775
00:41:01.329 --> 00:41:06.829
exist again, because like if something were this within controvertible evidence,
776
00:41:06.869 --> 00:41:09.670
we'd have to completely rethink and reshape everything that we
777
00:41:09.690 --> 00:41:13.849
understand about all of reality from top to bottom. And again,
778
00:41:14.150 --> 00:41:17.519
like the amount that it would have to have altered
779
00:41:17.699 --> 00:41:21.519
everything that currently is would be so vast and it'd
780
00:41:21.539 --> 00:41:23.900
be like none of our other experiences we've ever had
781
00:41:23.940 --> 00:41:26.860
were even real. Like that's how substantial of a shift
782
00:41:27.000 --> 00:41:29.519
like the implication of that would be. But I would
783
00:41:29.559 --> 00:41:31.869
love it if someone wanted to take on thinking through
784
00:41:32.010 --> 00:41:35.449
every facet of like, if this were real, what implications
785
00:41:35.489 --> 00:41:36.929
would that have for the world? Because again, you're going
786
00:41:36.949 --> 00:41:39.590
to run to the point where like this implication has
787
00:41:39.690 --> 00:41:43.570
never been. And therefore, this thing cannot have ever been,
788
00:41:43.650 --> 00:41:45.880
even though we already knew that. Right. And I will
789
00:41:45.889 --> 00:41:48.260
say like philosophic doubt is not necessarily an assumption of
790
00:41:48.320 --> 00:41:50.780
science as much as it is like an attitude that
791
00:41:51.079 --> 00:41:53.980
scientists take. But I think, you know, that's kind of
792
00:41:54.000 --> 00:41:57.280
splitting hairs. But just when we're thinking about like the
793
00:41:57.360 --> 00:42:00.019
various approaches and things that we either take for granted,
794
00:42:00.059 --> 00:42:03.719
I think that we take, for example, empiricism for granted,
795
00:42:03.739 --> 00:42:06.059
determinism for granted. That one, like we can't prove that
796
00:42:06.119 --> 00:42:09.820
it's right. But it is like an assumption versus like
797
00:42:09.980 --> 00:42:11.989
a philosophic doubt of pragmatism or more like sort of
798
00:42:12.050 --> 00:42:16.090
attitudes that we bring to these investigative things that we're
799
00:42:16.110 --> 00:42:16.530
looking at.
800
00:42:16.829 --> 00:42:17.070
Yeah.
801
00:42:17.170 --> 00:42:19.750
To say that we're very far away from it is, again,
802
00:42:19.809 --> 00:42:23.269
even putting it nicely because like it's it just doesn't exist.
803
00:42:23.510 --> 00:42:27.889
Like it just can't exist, at least in that realm
804
00:42:28.010 --> 00:42:30.090
of it, as you said, like moving it into something
805
00:42:30.179 --> 00:42:33.719
like a natural phenomenon. And I do think going to
806
00:42:33.760 --> 00:42:36.300
your position, you mentioned all these things like hallucinations and
807
00:42:36.539 --> 00:42:38.860
tumors and things like that, that could be someone's subjective
808
00:42:39.019 --> 00:42:41.340
of experience. Because a lot of people say like, I
809
00:42:41.420 --> 00:42:43.599
experienced this thing, I saw it. And I think that
810
00:42:43.639 --> 00:42:46.820
we sometimes have an assumption as a species, not necessarily
811
00:42:46.840 --> 00:42:51.289
as scientists, That everything we experience is a direct and
812
00:42:51.289 --> 00:42:55.170
100% accurate representation of the world as it is. Sure.
813
00:42:55.349 --> 00:42:57.690
That is just not it. We are very limited in
814
00:42:57.789 --> 00:43:01.469
our biological capability of interacting with this world through what
815
00:43:01.489 --> 00:43:04.110
we can see, hear, touch, smell, feel, measure in any
816
00:43:04.159 --> 00:43:08.460
capacity whatsoever or design equipment to measure. Right. Those things
817
00:43:08.500 --> 00:43:11.619
are coming from our own culture and biases and sensory perceptions.
818
00:43:11.679 --> 00:43:14.539
And the thing is, like, our sensory system that we
819
00:43:14.599 --> 00:43:17.619
have in our body is somewhat fragile. It does not
820
00:43:17.699 --> 00:43:19.480
take very much to screw it up.
821
00:43:20.269 --> 00:43:20.530
Right.
822
00:43:20.769 --> 00:43:23.110
And so, like, the things that we think that we
823
00:43:23.289 --> 00:43:27.010
hear or see or smell,
like, first of all, that
824
00:43:27.070 --> 00:43:29.889
goes through a filter of a mechanical system through our body.
825
00:43:29.929 --> 00:43:32.820
But also there is a whole then software system in
826
00:43:32.860 --> 00:43:35.739
our brains that has to process that information. Right. And
827
00:43:35.880 --> 00:43:40.119
sometimes that processing happens without any actual sensory input. And again,
828
00:43:40.500 --> 00:43:43.409
that's the squishy, fuzzy software part of our body doing
829
00:43:43.489 --> 00:43:46.409
things without information from the outside world. But we can't
830
00:43:46.469 --> 00:43:49.630
tell the difference, right? Like, how would I know if
831
00:43:49.690 --> 00:43:52.610
my brain, if like an experience I had because of
832
00:43:52.670 --> 00:43:54.530
something that happened inside of my brain that made me
833
00:43:54.639 --> 00:43:57.659
smell something, and I can't actually tell the difference between
834
00:43:57.679 --> 00:44:01.599
that and me smelling something, you know, or should I
835
00:44:01.659 --> 00:44:03.940
have smelled something and then it not make its way
836
00:44:03.980 --> 00:44:07.599
to my brain? It would appear as an incomplete experience
837
00:44:07.679 --> 00:44:11.000
of a real phenomenon that I'm participating in. And therein lies,
838
00:44:11.059 --> 00:44:12.860
I think some of the experiences that people have where
839
00:44:12.880 --> 00:44:16.090
they're like, I had this very strange experience. I am
840
00:44:16.170 --> 00:44:18.570
not sure what to make of it. It must be
841
00:44:18.610 --> 00:44:19.050
a ghost.
842
00:44:19.670 --> 00:44:19.869
Right.
843
00:44:20.070 --> 00:44:23.869
You know, it mustn't be a ghost though, is the thing,
844
00:44:24.230 --> 00:44:27.210
or it mustn't, you know, Yeah, or it must be–
845
00:44:27.429 --> 00:44:29.449
that's going back to ghosts. Like it must be a possession.
846
00:44:29.469 --> 00:44:31.110
It must be a demon of something. I'm like it
847
00:44:31.170 --> 00:44:33.389
mustn't be that is the thing though. It could like
848
00:44:33.739 --> 00:44:36.500
let's first– going back to the parsimony thing, like let's
849
00:44:36.559 --> 00:44:39.440
first figure out what is the most likely answer here
850
00:44:39.820 --> 00:44:43.340
and understand that we are fallible in our ability to
851
00:44:43.679 --> 00:44:46.219
perceive the world and that that can get screwed up
852
00:44:46.280 --> 00:44:46.960
quite easily. Yeah.
853
00:44:47.409 --> 00:44:50.000
Yeah, I mean, we have to examine our wetware, you know?
854
00:44:50.239 --> 00:44:50.440
Yeah.
855
00:44:50.559 --> 00:44:51.500
Like, that's just what it is.
856
00:44:51.579 --> 00:44:53.519
Like, you know, when we talk about this and we
857
00:44:53.559 --> 00:44:56.460
talk about, like, brains in general are just these unique,
858
00:44:56.579 --> 00:45:00.730
complicated things that are just, it's electrified meat. And when
859
00:45:00.750 --> 00:45:03.190
you really think about what that does is, like, it
860
00:45:03.309 --> 00:45:06.630
really truly is, it is a miracle of nature, right?
861
00:45:07.099 --> 00:45:09.360
The way that brains work and the way that evolution
862
00:45:09.400 --> 00:45:11.099
has happened and all that stuff and how we have
863
00:45:11.139 --> 00:45:15.739
arrived today is really a confluence of infinite variables that
864
00:45:15.760 --> 00:45:17.920
have led us to the place where we can sit
865
00:45:17.960 --> 00:45:20.079
on microphones and we can talk about whether or not
866
00:45:20.119 --> 00:45:22.519
a demon has possessed us. I mean, that is truly
867
00:45:22.579 --> 00:45:27.219
a feat of the incredible, miraculous nature of biology and
868
00:45:27.340 --> 00:45:30.250
evolution and all of those things. And the fact that
869
00:45:30.269 --> 00:45:32.070
we wasted on ads is insane.
870
00:45:39.670 --> 00:45:42.090
All right, we're back. I think we've talked before about
871
00:45:42.230 --> 00:45:46.179
things like neurology and brains and the fact that our
872
00:45:46.239 --> 00:45:49.019
brains are where all of the other parts of our
873
00:45:49.039 --> 00:45:53.239
body connect in one central hub. Because if you imagine... Yeah. Yeah.
874
00:46:17.480 --> 00:46:20.329
All of those sensory pieces, all of those motor functions,
875
00:46:20.409 --> 00:46:22.650
all of those biological functions, like we also need to
876
00:46:22.769 --> 00:46:25.090
be able to consume energy and we need to be
877
00:46:25.130 --> 00:46:27.369
able to, for some reason we don't fully understand, we
878
00:46:27.409 --> 00:46:30.309
need to be able to sleep. we need to be
879
00:46:30.449 --> 00:46:34.869
able to reproduce. So to have those biological systems work together,
880
00:46:34.989 --> 00:46:37.309
you need a very complex network that's going to bind
881
00:46:37.530 --> 00:46:39.949
all of those. And having them in one central hub
882
00:46:40.610 --> 00:46:43.139
is a very efficient way to do that. Not the
883
00:46:43.239 --> 00:46:45.579
only way to do it, actually, though. There are actually
884
00:46:45.619 --> 00:46:49.539
many creatures that have instead broken off their brains into
885
00:46:49.559 --> 00:46:55.710
a Now, again, the brain that we have has allowed
886
00:46:55.750 --> 00:46:58.929
us to do remarkable things. And our level of efficiency
887
00:46:58.989 --> 00:47:01.989
and our ability to process sensory information and coordinate with
888
00:47:02.050 --> 00:47:04.659
all these other things allows us to do incredible things
889
00:47:04.739 --> 00:47:07.780
like have developed language, which has allowed us to mold
890
00:47:07.960 --> 00:47:12.119
the universe to our liking, apparently. Right. Anyway, so you
891
00:47:12.340 --> 00:47:16.289
can see how we eventually got there. Although I like
892
00:47:16.469 --> 00:47:19.090
calling it a miracle in the sense that it's amazing.
893
00:47:19.250 --> 00:47:22.329
It's amazing that nature could do something like produce the
894
00:47:22.349 --> 00:47:24.909
brains that we have. I mean, just unbelievable that we
895
00:47:24.949 --> 00:47:29.559
got there. I would say... For my own history with
896
00:47:29.579 --> 00:47:32.239
the word miracle, I don't like that word because I
897
00:47:32.260 --> 00:47:35.710
think it implies that something like this could not have
898
00:47:35.989 --> 00:47:38.610
arisen naturally. And it just, it did. Like it did
899
00:47:38.630 --> 00:47:42.210
arise naturally, which is really cool. But like, anyway, that's, that's,
900
00:47:42.630 --> 00:47:44.019
I wasn't even trying to push back on that just
901
00:47:44.039 --> 00:47:45.480
to add a little bit of elaboration there.
902
00:47:45.800 --> 00:47:47.519
It's fair though. I think this is a nice way
903
00:47:47.539 --> 00:47:48.219
to talk about it for sure.
904
00:47:49.190 --> 00:47:51.969
But we were really here to talk about spirits and
905
00:47:52.050 --> 00:47:55.880
ghosts and, well, not even those things, mostly hauntings or possessions.
906
00:47:56.300 --> 00:47:59.380
And the reason that we've spent so much time on
907
00:47:59.400 --> 00:48:02.500
the science part of this is because we then could
908
00:48:02.579 --> 00:48:06.360
take all of that science piece and say, what does
909
00:48:06.429 --> 00:48:09.269
this mean now for how we're thinking about possessions?
910
00:48:09.880 --> 00:48:12.019
Yeah, so the phenomenon.
911
00:48:11.579 --> 00:48:14.000
That we're talking about, if we were to assume that
912
00:48:14.159 --> 00:48:18.039
possessions are a phenomenon to explore, it just means that
913
00:48:18.059 --> 00:48:21.360
this phenomenon that we're trying to talk about doesn't actually
914
00:48:21.429 --> 00:48:23.869
meet the rigor of our basic assumptions of the science, right?
915
00:48:24.170 --> 00:48:24.369
Yeah.
916
00:48:24.590 --> 00:48:27.750
Not only is there no empirical evidence, explanations for possessions
917
00:48:28.170 --> 00:48:31.550
do not follow observable patterns outlined by the requirements of determinism.
918
00:48:31.630 --> 00:48:36.170
And further, we have available simpler explanations for observable changes
919
00:48:36.329 --> 00:48:40.659
in a person. Or I say simpler, more readily available
920
00:48:41.340 --> 00:48:45.780
explanations or more statistically reasonable explanations.
921
00:48:46.219 --> 00:48:48.739
Yeah, a lot of great people working in this space
922
00:48:48.760 --> 00:48:51.949
have gone through and figured out and they've debunked a
923
00:48:52.010 --> 00:48:55.269
lot of the shenanigans that have been involved. So ultimately,
924
00:48:55.329 --> 00:48:59.570
it's just more parsimonious and predictable to understand the kinds
925
00:48:59.630 --> 00:49:02.690
of extreme changes you would observe in someone who might
926
00:49:02.730 --> 00:49:05.539
be said to be possessed and By looking at it
927
00:49:05.559 --> 00:49:10.400
through a medical,
psychological, behavioral, and social model, like those
928
00:49:10.519 --> 00:49:14.869
things account for everything we see in what looks like
929
00:49:14.909 --> 00:49:18.849
a possession. And that does a better job than leaping
930
00:49:18.949 --> 00:49:23.260
to supernatural. events as the conclusion, as the variable of
931
00:49:23.300 --> 00:49:26.280
interest here. And we just have so much more evidence
932
00:49:26.559 --> 00:49:29.079
to support those claims because we have evidence to support
933
00:49:29.119 --> 00:49:32.179
those claims. Right. And we have zero evidence to support
934
00:49:32.199 --> 00:49:34.530
that is anything other than those things. Right.
935
00:49:34.889 --> 00:49:35.630
Right, right.
936
00:49:35.769 --> 00:49:38.989
So, simply put, possessions, while they appear to be unpredictable
937
00:49:39.030 --> 00:49:42.190
and scary to some people, like these are presenting concerns
938
00:49:42.210 --> 00:49:43.929
for a lot of people, there's some challenging behavior that
939
00:49:43.969 --> 00:49:45.929
might come up with this, they are better explained through
940
00:49:45.949 --> 00:49:48.289
science than faith. It doesn't mean that we need to
941
00:49:48.349 --> 00:49:51.409
take steps to undermine a person's experience, though, like we mentioned.
942
00:49:51.429 --> 00:49:54.110
People have very, or they feel like they have very
943
00:49:54.250 --> 00:49:57.360
real experiences with this, and what ends up happening is
944
00:49:57.659 --> 00:50:00.360
the best language they have to describe their experience is
945
00:50:00.440 --> 00:50:02.360
something like, I've been possessed.
946
00:50:02.699 --> 00:50:03.760
That might be the best.
947
00:50:03.619 --> 00:50:05.719
Language they have or the best understanding they have of
948
00:50:05.780 --> 00:50:08.420
that particular phenomenon. It doesn't mean that we take steps
949
00:50:08.460 --> 00:50:10.239
to undermine it. And some people who believe they are
950
00:50:10.260 --> 00:50:14.670
experiencing possessions are experiencing real crises with real consequences. Other
951
00:50:14.710 --> 00:50:19.230
people are having enlightening experiences that don't require us pathologizing it.
952
00:50:19.510 --> 00:50:22.050
So like we have this understanding of like what's going
953
00:50:22.090 --> 00:50:24.070
on in the world. And I think that like, I
954
00:50:24.110 --> 00:50:26.090
think that we can kind of take steps back and go,
955
00:50:26.409 --> 00:50:29.880
we can be scientists and be compassionate, understanding scientists and,
956
00:50:30.079 --> 00:50:33.590
without having to undermine people's belief systems entirely.
957
00:50:33.650 --> 00:50:35.139
I think we can have those conversations.
958
00:50:35.840 --> 00:50:38.539
Absolutely. I think that we approach it from the position
959
00:50:38.699 --> 00:50:41.159
of compassion, of humanism, of like, this is a human
960
00:50:41.199 --> 00:50:43.659
being who's reporting some type of
experience that they're having.
961
00:50:44.059 --> 00:50:47.119
And honestly, I think the more compassionate experience then is
962
00:50:47.199 --> 00:50:51.210
to try and understand that using a scientific lens. Because
963
00:50:51.289 --> 00:50:55.409
if you try to feed into that and lean into
964
00:50:55.449 --> 00:50:59.349
this idea of whatever they're calling a possession or something,
965
00:50:59.809 --> 00:51:02.550
you're going to exacerbate the experience and make it worse
966
00:51:02.570 --> 00:51:05.480
for You're going to exploit that fear. You're going to
967
00:51:05.619 --> 00:51:10.280
build their paranoia. You're going to create helplessness. So I
968
00:51:10.340 --> 00:51:13.739
think trying to bring a level of compassion and understanding
969
00:51:13.760 --> 00:51:15.929
that like you're a person who is having some experience.
970
00:51:15.949 --> 00:51:17.309
Let's see if we can figure out what's going on
971
00:51:17.349 --> 00:51:20.309
here and help you. is ultimately, I think, a lot
972
00:51:20.349 --> 00:51:23.210
more of a compassionate place to be than to feed
973
00:51:23.389 --> 00:51:27.320
into that and to exacerbate it and prolong it and
974
00:51:27.380 --> 00:51:29.820
make it worse. So I actually think that, yeah, that
975
00:51:29.920 --> 00:51:32.059
is the more appropriate approach to take anyway. And I
976
00:51:32.099 --> 00:51:35.199
do think that you could hear... I think that people
977
00:51:35.320 --> 00:51:38.539
could approach this and say like, you're stupid. And like,
978
00:51:38.599 --> 00:51:41.039
that's their, like what they're bringing to the table is like,
979
00:51:41.079 --> 00:51:43.019
I don't believe you, you're dumb. And I don't think
980
00:51:43.059 --> 00:51:45.769
that's helpful either. But I think if we want to
981
00:51:46.230 --> 00:51:48.630
think about like what we're doing as this, doing with
982
00:51:48.650 --> 00:51:50.670
this as scientists in any capacity, then the approach that
983
00:51:50.690 --> 00:51:55.090
we take is let's be compassionate and figure out what's
984
00:51:55.130 --> 00:52:00.090
going on and not feed into whatever that person's traumatized
985
00:52:00.139 --> 00:52:01.880
by in their own sort of language about that event.
986
00:52:02.440 --> 00:52:04.329
Right, right. So.
987
00:52:05.119 --> 00:52:07.409
As scientists, I don't think that we can scoff at
988
00:52:07.429 --> 00:52:10.550
the idea that possessions appear ridiculous. I think rather we
989
00:52:10.590 --> 00:52:13.710
embrace anecdotal data as part of our analysis, meet stakeholders
990
00:52:13.730 --> 00:52:17.010
where they're at, and attempt to provide pragmatic support for
991
00:52:17.030 --> 00:52:20.409
their concerns rather than leaning on ineffective and frankly dangerous
992
00:52:20.449 --> 00:52:23.750
practices that are unlikely to be helpful, like exorcisms.
993
00:52:24.070 --> 00:52:26.190
I think if we lean into what's.
994
00:52:26.110 --> 00:52:28.809
Useful for that person to achieve whatever goals they're trying
995
00:52:28.829 --> 00:52:31.329
to achieve, to make it so that they are suffering less,
996
00:52:31.409 --> 00:52:34.110
that is, I think, the best way to approach these things.
997
00:52:34.570 --> 00:52:35.349
While we try to.
998
00:52:35.530 --> 00:52:38.360
Approach this from a scientific lens and understand what might
999
00:52:38.380 --> 00:52:39.599
have led them to this space.
1000
00:52:40.119 --> 00:52:43.059
And thinking about this from that compassionate lens, spiritual practices
1001
00:52:43.139 --> 00:52:46.500
do play that important role in many cultures. So we need,
1002
00:52:46.619 --> 00:52:50.059
we must be careful not to write off spiritual possessions
1003
00:52:50.079 --> 00:52:55.159
as nonsense or In that way, I mean, creation stories,
1004
00:52:55.260 --> 00:52:58.960
shamanic practices, etc., they include important possession elements and they
1005
00:52:58.980 --> 00:53:02.500
play a vital role in the life of the transitions, guidance, counsel,
1006
00:53:02.579 --> 00:53:07.239
and more. And I think appreciating that these kinds of stories,
1007
00:53:07.260 --> 00:53:10.019
these kinds of beliefs, these kinds of religious practices in
1008
00:53:10.039 --> 00:53:16.039
many of these spaces... Like while they include some statements
1009
00:53:16.280 --> 00:53:20.630
about the world that are outside, they lean on the
1010
00:53:20.730 --> 00:53:24.969
idea of sort of supernatural things, gods, et cetera. That's
1011
00:53:25.010 --> 00:53:27.650
actually not the point of those things. They play a
1012
00:53:27.730 --> 00:53:32.190
different social role and psychological role that is important for
1013
00:53:32.250 --> 00:53:37.860
those communities that the fact that they use fantastical imagery
1014
00:53:37.900 --> 00:53:41.980
and stories as a foil is is unimportant in the
1015
00:53:42.059 --> 00:53:45.719
role that they play. And we'd be naive to believe
1016
00:53:45.760 --> 00:53:48.739
that a lack of explanation regarding causal features of spiritual
1017
00:53:48.760 --> 00:53:52.800
possessions mean that they are unimportant from that social standpoint.
1018
00:53:53.409 --> 00:53:55.949
Because it's easy, I think, to sometimes look at them
1019
00:53:55.989 --> 00:53:58.809
and say, like, you believe this, that's wrong. And whether
1020
00:53:58.829 --> 00:54:01.309
or not it's factually accurate is kind of irrelevant to
1021
00:54:01.349 --> 00:54:04.030
the point. The point is that it facilitates a social
1022
00:54:04.090 --> 00:54:08.940
connection or facilitates a social... I guess, practice or cultural
1023
00:54:08.980 --> 00:54:12.820
practice that's important to that community in another way. And
1024
00:54:12.980 --> 00:54:16.019
the thing on top of it, if you will, the veneer,
1025
00:54:16.099 --> 00:54:19.340
the image that's created is done through that sort of
1026
00:54:19.380 --> 00:54:23.119
storytelling narrative lens.
And that's okay. And so, yeah, I
1027
00:54:23.179 --> 00:54:24.340
think it's Yeah. Yeah.
1028
00:54:44.159 --> 00:54:46.719
Pete Holmes is a stand-up comedian. He said one of
1029
00:54:46.739 --> 00:54:49.119
the best things I've ever heard about all of this.
1030
00:54:49.179 --> 00:54:51.550
He said, God is the sheet that we put over
1031
00:54:51.590 --> 00:54:54.789
the unknown. And it's such a great way to explain
1032
00:54:54.849 --> 00:54:58.269
how people arrive to some of those conclusions and those explanations, right? Like,
1033
00:54:58.570 --> 00:55:01.329
I'm not a spiritual person myself, but I understand that reference.
1034
00:55:01.369 --> 00:55:03.349
And I'm like, that is fair. Like, God is the
1035
00:55:03.389 --> 00:55:05.889
metaphor that is the sheet that we put over the unknown.
1036
00:55:05.909 --> 00:55:07.730
And I was like, okay, sure. Like, I think that
1037
00:55:07.769 --> 00:55:09.070
that's a fair way to look at that.
1038
00:55:09.130 --> 00:55:09.250
So.
1039
00:55:09.909 --> 00:55:12.659
I thought that was an interesting way, a very philosophical
1040
00:55:12.699 --> 00:55:13.349
way to approach it.
1041
00:55:13.389 --> 00:55:16.420
But I think at.
1042
00:55:15.739 --> 00:55:17.519
The end of all this, I think the most important
1043
00:55:17.539 --> 00:55:19.860
thing is where we draw the line is not in
1044
00:55:19.900 --> 00:55:24.099
the reported experiences that people have, but in the treatment space.
1045
00:55:24.480 --> 00:55:27.460
We draw the line at treating possessions as possessions where
1046
00:55:27.599 --> 00:55:31.449
medical cause or some other important cause that is treatable
1047
00:55:31.670 --> 00:55:34.590
is present. And the person needs effective medical care or
1048
00:55:34.630 --> 00:55:36.909
they need some type of intervention that's going to improve
1049
00:55:36.949 --> 00:55:37.829
their well-being.
1050
00:55:38.369 --> 00:55:40.369
Exorcisms are not it. And we know that. And we
1051
00:55:40.409 --> 00:55:41.530
know that from the episode that we did.
1052
00:55:41.849 --> 00:55:44.809
But otherwise, I think that that's– I think that allowing
1053
00:55:44.849 --> 00:55:48.150
somebody to believe that– to me, the intervention piece is
1054
00:55:48.230 --> 00:55:50.230
really where you have to draw that line. I think
1055
00:55:50.250 --> 00:55:53.369
that having conversations and– And all of those things and
1056
00:55:53.409 --> 00:55:55.110
kind of like the belief systems that exist, I think
1057
00:55:55.150 --> 00:55:57.139
is one thing. But like when people start intervening and
1058
00:55:57.159 --> 00:56:00.619
they hurt people, they waste time on interventions that don't
1059
00:56:00.659 --> 00:56:02.739
work when there are interventions that could help that person.
1060
00:56:03.059 --> 00:56:04.900
I think that's where it's really important to draw that
1061
00:56:04.920 --> 00:56:07.219
line and say like, hey, we can't really do this
1062
00:56:07.480 --> 00:56:07.860
this way.
1063
00:56:08.420 --> 00:56:12.070
Beautiful. I don't even want to try and follow that
1064
00:56:12.090 --> 00:56:13.449
with anything. I think that was a great way to
1065
00:56:13.510 --> 00:56:13.809
end that.
1066
00:56:14.489 --> 00:56:16.619
Man. I thought that this was going to be a
1067
00:56:16.760 --> 00:56:19.829
funnier talk and it turned into a very insightful and
1068
00:56:19.889 --> 00:56:22.449
philosophical talk. So I'm glad that it turned out the
1069
00:56:22.489 --> 00:56:22.760
way it did.
1070
00:56:22.769 --> 00:56:23.210
It was fun.
1071
00:56:24.010 --> 00:56:26.570
I love the philosophical ones. I mean, I do appreciate
1072
00:56:26.610 --> 00:56:28.690
when we can bring a level of humor, but I
1073
00:56:28.809 --> 00:56:31.449
like the getting into the philosophy thing personally. Yeah.
1074
00:56:31.659 --> 00:56:32.639
It's good stuff for sure.
1075
00:56:33.300 --> 00:56:35.099
Probably at least one other person who listens to this
1076
00:56:35.159 --> 00:56:38.280
also likes that. Yeah.
1077
00:56:38.340 --> 00:56:42.139
Well, if not, then you've got a whole episode of it. Sorry, folks. Indeed.
1078
00:56:42.219 --> 00:56:44.530
Well, and so I guess for the rest of you,
1079
00:56:44.570 --> 00:56:54.260
here's an ad. All right, we're actually not done. I
1080
00:56:54.460 --> 00:56:57.780
hope that that didn't set us up for us being
1081
00:56:57.800 --> 00:56:59.280
done and people are like, oh, we're out now, and
1082
00:56:59.300 --> 00:57:00.880
then they just finished. We do have a little bit
1083
00:57:00.920 --> 00:57:02.989
more at the end of all of our full-length discussions.
1084
00:57:03.050 --> 00:57:05.610
We like to recommend some things just for fun, for funsies.
1085
00:57:06.320 --> 00:57:08.420
And we're going to do that today. They're usually unrelated
1086
00:57:08.460 --> 00:57:12.440
to our topic at hand. But first, there is credits
1087
00:57:12.460 --> 00:57:14.500
to get through, as I mentioned at the top of
1088
00:57:14.539 --> 00:57:16.539
this discussion. If you'd like to support us, there's lots
1089
00:57:16.579 --> 00:57:17.980
of ways that you can do that. You can leave
1090
00:57:18.000 --> 00:57:20.840
us a rating and a review, like, subscribe, or tell
1091
00:57:20.880 --> 00:57:22.519
a friend. And all of those things are very helpful.
1092
00:57:22.559 --> 00:57:25.760
They actually help more people find the podcast. We do
1093
00:57:25.800 --> 00:57:28.309
get that ad revenue from the more people who listen
1094
00:57:28.329 --> 00:57:30.530
to it, the more that it makes for the podcast,
1095
00:57:30.550 --> 00:57:33.190
but also then people who tell their friends and find
1096
00:57:33.210 --> 00:57:34.889
some value and then write it and say nice things
1097
00:57:34.909 --> 00:57:37.099
and that... That fills the bucket of joy that we
1098
00:57:37.360 --> 00:57:39.730
try and have with us. in the things that we do.
1099
00:57:40.030 --> 00:57:41.909
And all those things are free. Now, if you would
1100
00:57:41.929 --> 00:57:43.739
like to support us financially, you can do that too.
1101
00:57:43.780 --> 00:57:46.239
You can head over to Patreon. And if you do that,
1102
00:57:46.260 --> 00:57:49.500
then you get some ad-free episodes, early episodes, bonus content.
1103
00:57:49.739 --> 00:57:51.699
And most importantly of all, I will read your name
1104
00:57:51.739 --> 00:57:54.159
in the list of people who have taken on supporting
1105
00:57:54.239 --> 00:57:59.570
us because we appreciate so much the generous, amazing, and
1106
00:57:59.889 --> 00:58:02.449
incredible commitment that these people have taken on to just
1107
00:58:02.469 --> 00:58:03.969
help us be a podcast for all the time that
1108
00:58:03.989 --> 00:58:05.630
they've been doing it. So a giant shout out and
1109
00:58:05.650 --> 00:58:12.050
thank you to Mike M., Megan, Mike T., Justin, Kim, Brad, Stephanie, Brian, Kiara,
1110
00:58:12.210 --> 00:58:14.510
and Charlie. Thank you all for your continued support.
1111
00:58:14.530 --> 00:58:17.170
Y'all are just truly lovely.
1112
00:58:17.530 --> 00:58:20.409
Truly the best. And of course, I do not make
1113
00:58:20.469 --> 00:58:23.809
this podcast alone. Writing and fact-checking from Shane and myself.
1114
00:58:23.829 --> 00:58:25.150
Thank you so much for your notes today, Shane. I
1115
00:58:25.170 --> 00:58:26.699
think this turned out great. Really good job.
1116
00:58:26.730 --> 00:58:28.989
Yeah, I think it turned out really, really nice given
1117
00:58:29.110 --> 00:58:30.739
how sleep-deprived I was. So I think it turned out
1118
00:58:30.760 --> 00:58:31.179
pretty good. Indeed.
1119
00:58:32.360 --> 00:58:32.679
Indeed.
1120
00:58:33.230 --> 00:58:37.489
Our social media coordinator is Emma Wilson. And the audio engineer,
1121
00:58:37.630 --> 00:58:41.539
King Titan Majesty, who is so good at podcast editing,
1122
00:58:41.639 --> 00:58:43.079
is Justin. So thank you, Justin.
1123
00:58:43.119 --> 00:58:44.820
The one above all, the end of all that is.
1124
00:58:46.250 --> 00:58:47.409
The one ring, if you will.
1125
00:58:47.429 --> 00:58:49.309
All right.
1126
00:58:49.369 --> 00:58:50.590
I think that is what we have to say about
1127
00:58:50.639 --> 00:58:52.480
that part of it. Is there anything that, oh, I
1128
00:58:52.500 --> 00:58:54.179
would actually like to, no, there's one more part. There's
1129
00:58:54.260 --> 00:58:55.659
one more thing I want to say, which is that
1130
00:58:55.760 --> 00:58:57.039
if you would like to tell us your thoughts on
1131
00:58:57.079 --> 00:58:59.679
anything that we said in this discussion on possessions or
1132
00:58:59.760 --> 00:59:02.510
anything else, you can email us directly info at WWD,
1133
00:59:02.719 --> 00:59:06.730
WWD podcast.com or reach us on the social media platforms.
1134
00:59:06.789 --> 00:59:08.889
And we do look forward to hearing from you. So
1135
00:59:08.909 --> 00:59:11.420
thank you in advance. for doing those things. And if,
1136
00:59:11.460 --> 00:59:12.079
and when you do them.
1137
00:59:12.539 --> 00:59:13.380
Yes, we love it.
1138
00:59:13.599 --> 00:59:15.460
All right. Now, is there anything that I'm missing or
1139
00:59:15.500 --> 00:59:17.659
you'd like to add before we transition to recommendations?
1140
00:59:18.099 --> 00:59:18.719
No, not yet.
1141
00:59:19.050 --> 00:59:30.719
All right. Recommendations. I'm recommending a book. It is a
1142
00:59:31.119 --> 00:59:34.960
book called A Walk in the Park by author Kevin Fedarko.
1143
00:59:34.980 --> 00:59:37.590
This is a nonfiction book, but it is written in
1144
00:59:37.630 --> 00:59:39.150
a way that is one of the most.
1145
00:59:40.530 --> 00:59:43.530
It's so well written. His writing style, his voice, it
1146
00:59:43.590 --> 00:59:47.070
is fantastic. It is so engaging. It is like... just
1147
00:59:47.289 --> 00:59:52.139
such a well-put-together story. It is a story about the
1148
00:59:52.360 --> 00:59:56.199
author and a friend of his going on what's called
1149
00:59:56.239 --> 00:59:59.119
a through-hike of the Grand Canyon, which is where they
1150
00:59:59.159 --> 01:00:03.730
essentially hike the entire thing. And it took... You do
1151
01:00:03.769 --> 01:00:05.860
it in chunks and then you like, you have to
1152
01:00:05.889 --> 01:00:08.559
stop because you just can't commit that much time to
1153
01:00:08.599 --> 01:00:11.019
a thing like this. But I think if I remember correctly,
1154
01:00:11.039 --> 01:00:11.940
it took them about a year.
1155
01:00:12.260 --> 01:00:12.559
Oh, wow.
1156
01:00:12.579 --> 01:00:14.760
Cumulatively to do it. So they do it for several
1157
01:00:14.780 --> 01:00:16.000
weeks at a time and then take a break and
1158
01:00:16.039 --> 01:00:17.400
go back and do the next chunk of it over
1159
01:00:17.440 --> 01:00:19.949
several weeks and then take a break. And that's just
1160
01:00:19.989 --> 01:00:22.170
really the only way that you can do it, I think.
1161
01:00:22.690 --> 01:00:24.429
It's a harrowing story. There's a lot of parts of
1162
01:00:24.449 --> 01:00:26.469
it that are like, you read like, oh my God,
1163
01:00:26.530 --> 01:00:28.730
like these people went through some stuff. Yeah. But it's
1164
01:00:28.809 --> 01:00:31.849
also just a very, very well done story. And I really,
1165
01:00:31.869 --> 01:00:33.369
really like it. I think a lot of people will
1166
01:00:33.389 --> 01:00:36.630
enjoy it. As I said, it's one of the best nonfiction.
1167
01:00:36.949 --> 01:00:39.139
The writing style is just so good. So you hear nonfiction,
1168
01:00:39.179 --> 01:00:41.559
and I think you maybe think boring. This is definitely
1169
01:00:41.639 --> 01:00:42.219
not that.
1170
01:00:42.679 --> 01:00:42.980
Right.
1171
01:00:43.019 --> 01:00:45.239
Because it's just telling their story. It's telling the story
1172
01:00:45.280 --> 01:00:48.300
of what
happens to them. I'm given to understand that.
1173
01:00:48.380 --> 01:00:49.780
So one of the two people who was on the
1174
01:00:49.820 --> 01:00:52.340
hike was on the hike to be a photographer. That
1175
01:00:52.380 --> 01:00:54.449
was his thing. And so you can actually go online
1176
01:00:54.550 --> 01:00:56.369
and find a lot of the photographs he took, and
1177
01:00:56.429 --> 01:00:59.269
they are breathtaking. Yeah. Many of them made it into
1178
01:00:59.289 --> 01:01:01.769
the book as well. I think there are maybe copies
1179
01:01:01.789 --> 01:01:03.829
of the book that don't have the pictures, but at
1180
01:01:03.869 --> 01:01:07.090
least the copies I'm aware of do. But they are
1181
01:01:07.510 --> 01:01:10.369
pretty stunning. So it's a really good read. I recommend
1182
01:01:10.389 --> 01:01:13.510
A Walk in the Park, which the title A Walk
1183
01:01:13.530 --> 01:01:16.849
in the Park is quite the understatement about this. Sort
1184
01:01:16.869 --> 01:01:18.829
of like when we recommended A Short Stay in Hell.
1185
01:01:19.289 --> 01:01:20.150
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1186
01:01:20.289 --> 01:01:25.619
That book did not adequately describe the length. The story
1187
01:01:25.639 --> 01:01:28.920
itself was short. The stay in hell was not. And
1188
01:01:28.940 --> 01:01:31.139
the walk in the park makes this sound like something
1189
01:01:31.260 --> 01:01:34.230
other than what it really was. But anyway, it's a
1190
01:01:34.250 --> 01:01:36.960
good book. I strongly recommend it. I love it.
1191
01:01:37.070 --> 01:01:39.210
I love it. So I'm going to recommend a show.
1192
01:01:39.710 --> 01:01:41.289
I say a show. It is a special.
1193
01:01:41.409 --> 01:01:42.090
Yeah, it's like a miniseries.
1194
01:01:42.110 --> 01:01:44.630
And this came out a couple years ago. Yeah, it's
1195
01:01:44.670 --> 01:01:47.349
a cool little thing. And it's called Werewolf by Night.
1196
01:01:47.929 --> 01:01:52.309
And it is Marvel, which is really fun. It's MCU specifically.
1197
01:01:52.449 --> 01:01:55.090
And it is a monster movie. So if you're not familiar,
1198
01:01:55.110 --> 01:01:56.760
it came out a few years ago. I'm sure I
1199
01:01:56.800 --> 01:01:58.980
recommended it then, too. But it was done as kind
1200
01:01:59.019 --> 01:02:04.000
of like a quick one-shot where it is about monster
1201
01:02:04.039 --> 01:02:08.039
hunters who are looking for this kind of relic. And
1202
01:02:08.059 --> 01:02:10.079
they also kind of all come together in this like
1203
01:02:10.539 --> 01:02:14.110
strange little space and all fight each other. But what's
1204
01:02:14.170 --> 01:02:17.190
really fun about this is it's like the Marvel Dark Universe.
1205
01:02:17.210 --> 01:02:21.170
It's like mysticism and like weird, spooky creatures and whatnot.
1206
01:02:21.409 --> 01:02:24.389
And the main character is Werewolf by Night, who is
1207
01:02:24.429 --> 01:02:29.019
played by Gail Garcia Bernal, who is fantastic. Love him
1208
01:02:29.039 --> 01:02:31.340
in everything that he's in. And also to, I'm sorry,
1209
01:02:31.400 --> 01:02:34.460
and Laura Donnelly, who plays a character named Elsa Bloodstone.
1210
01:02:35.699 --> 01:02:36.719
That's a very good name.
1211
01:02:36.980 --> 01:02:38.159
Yeah, it's such a great name.
1212
01:02:38.239 --> 01:02:41.159
And she's important in the Marvel Universe, like for like
1213
01:02:41.320 --> 01:02:44.079
Ghost Rider and Blade and all that. Like she's in
1214
01:02:44.119 --> 01:02:46.619
that world where it's like vampires and monsters and demons
1215
01:02:46.699 --> 01:02:50.750
on it. Gail Garcia Bernal plays the title character Werewolf
1216
01:02:50.789 --> 01:02:55.170
by Night. or just Werewolf, whose alias is Jack Russell,
1217
01:02:55.570 --> 01:02:56.110
which I love.
1218
01:02:56.250 --> 01:02:58.429
I love that. It's like, okay, so Werewolf is named
1219
01:02:58.489 --> 01:03:02.869
after a tiny dog. That's fantastic. Anyway, it's really well done.
1220
01:03:03.349 --> 01:03:07.670
It's kind of modeled after some old classic horror movies
1221
01:03:07.710 --> 01:03:10.130
like Dracula and Frankenstein and all that. It's got kind
1222
01:03:10.150 --> 01:03:12.889
of that feel and that vibe to it, but brought
1223
01:03:13.070 --> 01:03:14.800
up to date, a little bit more modern, a little
1224
01:03:14.840 --> 01:03:17.480
bit scarier. It's a really fun watch, and it's only
1225
01:03:17.519 --> 01:03:19.340
like an hour, so it doesn't take very long to
1226
01:03:19.380 --> 01:03:19.780
watch at all.
1227
01:03:20.179 --> 01:03:22.840
I second that. I did really enjoy that series. I
1228
01:03:22.860 --> 01:03:25.079
would love to go back and revisit it because it
1229
01:03:25.139 --> 01:03:29.800
was such a unique and fun little twist on Marvel
1230
01:03:29.860 --> 01:03:32.280
and Disney. It should be available on Disney Plus for
1231
01:03:32.360 --> 01:03:36.070
people who have that. But yeah, just a special miniseries
1232
01:03:36.090 --> 01:03:36.489
type thing.
1233
01:03:36.889 --> 01:03:37.510
Yeah, it's good stuff.
1234
01:03:37.789 --> 01:03:39.150
So it's A Walk in the Park, a book by
1235
01:03:39.190 --> 01:03:43.510
Kevin Fedarko, and then Werewolf by Night, the TV show
1236
01:03:43.610 --> 01:03:46.829
miniseries special from Marvel. All right, I think that's all
1237
01:03:46.849 --> 01:03:49.610
we have to say about our topic today. Thank you
1238
01:03:49.630 --> 01:03:50.849
all for listening. This is Abraham.
1239
01:03:51.170 --> 01:03:51.690
And this is Shane.
1240
01:03:51.969 --> 01:03:52.469
We're out.
1241
01:03:52.489 --> 01:03:55.449
See ya. You've been listening to Why We Do What
1242
01:03:55.489 --> 01:03:55.789
We Do.
1243
01:03:56.389 --> 01:03:59.010
You can learn more about this and other episodes by
1244
01:03:59.070 --> 01:04:02.760
going to www.wwdpodcast.com.
1245
01:04:03.199 --> 01:04:21.050
Thanks for listening, and we hope you have an awesome day. Bye.