TRANSKRIP 🔗
1
00:00:00,270 --> 00:00:10,920
Thank you all for coming. It's a great pleasure to deliver this lecture, especially because it bears the name of best German.
2
00:00:10,920 --> 00:00:16,080
I think Voltaire drank 18 cups of strong coffee.
3
00:00:16,080 --> 00:00:19,350
Perhaps this would if I were to adopt this strategy,
4
00:00:19,350 --> 00:00:26,400
I might finish this everlasting book on the history of rules about which you are to hear a fragment.
5
00:00:26,400 --> 00:00:38,040
So we're going to be interested in arguing this evening is to present on the basis of an episode in the history of of rules, a certain kind of mania.
6
00:00:38,040 --> 00:00:41,280
In fact, I'm going to contrast two episodes of Romania.
7
00:00:41,280 --> 00:00:51,120
I'm interested, of course, in the content of these rules, but I'm even more interested in the kind of rule the form of rule.
8
00:00:51,120 --> 00:01:00,570
And I'm going to argue that at least in certain realms in the late 17th and in the 18th century,
9
00:01:00,570 --> 00:01:05,880
what a rule could be underwent a significant mutation.
10
00:01:05,880 --> 00:01:14,070
But let me start off with some examples. Paris Police Ordinance February 20th,
11
00:01:14,070 --> 00:01:29,220
1737 Women caught wearing dresses made of cotton and gin in defiance of previous bans of this material will be fined 300 leaflet.
12
00:01:29,220 --> 00:01:39,990
Paris Police Ordinance November 28th, 1750 In defiance of the edicts of 16, 63, 16,
13
00:01:39,990 --> 00:01:47,400
66 and 17 44, Parisians are still not getting up at seven a.m. to sweep their stoops.
14
00:01:47,400 --> 00:01:55,890
They are still emptying the contents of their chamber pots from the window and they are still blocking the streets with manure
15
00:01:55,890 --> 00:02:05,730
and bricks and generally not at all conforming to the edicts ordinance and prohibitions repeatedly issued by the authorities.
16
00:02:05,730 --> 00:02:27,750
Paris Police Ordinance September 3rd, 1754 In defiance of the edicts of 16 67 16, 72, 7500, 17, three, 17, five, 17, 22, 1724, 17, 32, 1746 and 1748.
17
00:02:27,750 --> 00:02:37,020
Parisians are still playing ball games in the street and endangering passers by and breaking street lanterns.
18
00:02:37,020 --> 00:02:46,260
The culprits who are shop boys, artisans and liveried servants are hereby enjoined to cease and desist or pay a fine of 200 leave.
19
00:02:46,260 --> 00:02:57,450
But these rules are typical of the thousands of police regulations issued between 16 67 when the
20
00:02:57,450 --> 00:03:05,370
Office of the Lieutenant de Police was created and its abolition during the French Revolution.
21
00:03:05,370 --> 00:03:10,080
The office was created in the words of the royal decree of sixteen sixty seven.
22
00:03:10,080 --> 00:03:21,030
I'm quoting now to assure the peace of mind of the public and individuals to purge the city of all that could cause disorder,
23
00:03:21,030 --> 00:03:29,760
to procure abundance and to make each live, according to his condition and his station.
24
00:03:29,760 --> 00:03:38,220
Catching and punishing criminals actually rank rather low on this list instead.
25
00:03:38,220 --> 00:03:49,110
Far more important was to regulate almost every detail of what we might now call urban life,
26
00:03:49,110 --> 00:03:53,880
from firefighting to street cleaning to traffic and clothing.
27
00:03:53,880 --> 00:04:01,890
No unruliness was in principle too small to escape the notice of the Parisian police.
28
00:04:01,890 --> 00:04:09,720
Fishmongers who blocked the husar poor rowdies, who hissed during performances of the comedy,
29
00:04:09,720 --> 00:04:17,910
says fashionistas who were wearing band gold and silver buttons and embroidery of any kind.
30
00:04:17,910 --> 00:04:28,470
Carriage drivers who were swearing at pedestrians unprecedented in their number, their scope of their mind numbing detail.
31
00:04:28,470 --> 00:04:35,130
These rules aimed to micromanage every aspect of Parisian life.
32
00:04:35,130 --> 00:04:40,530
Everyone and everything, at least within city limits,
33
00:04:40,530 --> 00:04:50,790
to turn famously unruly Paris into a place in which Parisians obeyed all the rules all of the time.
34
00:04:50,790 --> 00:05:00,300
Never before had the vision of what rules could accomplish been so, all encompassing and so all.
35
00:05:00,300 --> 00:05:10,740
So unbending, excuse me. This was in ludicrous contrast to the lived reality of life in the city.
36
00:05:10,740 --> 00:05:22,800
If there was one thing that Parisians and visitors agreed upon during most of the 18th century, it was that Enlightenment Paris was a squalid,
37
00:05:22,800 --> 00:05:36,210
stinking, teeming chaos where then, as no one took one's life in one's hands to cross the street.
38
00:05:36,210 --> 00:05:43,500
A German visitor complaint is just one of many such reports of quote the incessant din of carriages,
39
00:05:43,500 --> 00:05:52,560
HIAC and street vendors, the dirty streets, the horrid, multifarious steam and the unhealthy stench.
40
00:05:52,560 --> 00:05:57,630
Describing Paris a decade or so later in his tabloid apathy.
41
00:05:57,630 --> 00:06:09,690
The Paris native Louis Sebastian, M.C., described harrowing scenes of panicked pedestrians fleeing carriages driven at breakneck speeds.
42
00:06:09,690 --> 00:06:14,370
As you can see here, the royal carriage making its way through a throng.
43
00:06:14,370 --> 00:06:25,350
M.C. wrote a utopian novel as well as Paris in the year 24 40, and he imagines the Paris of the future as a place where,
44
00:06:25,350 --> 00:06:30,000
to the astonishment of the time traveller, Parisians are polite.
45
00:06:30,000 --> 00:06:39,570
They're hard working. They have abandoned high fashion for plain, sturdy clothing and where the streets are broad,
46
00:06:39,570 --> 00:06:47,430
well lit and safe for pedestrians, including the king who
Load full transcript
has abandoned his royal carriage.
47
00:06:47,430 --> 00:06:55,290
It's worthy of note that he thought it would take Paris at least 750 years to achieve this.
48
00:06:55,290 --> 00:07:07,620
The prolific, prolix and relentlessly issued rules of Lieutenant of Police seemed wildly inadequate to the task of taming Enlightenment Paris.
49
00:07:07,620 --> 00:07:10,440
Yet the rules kept coming.
50
00:07:10,440 --> 00:07:20,640
Thousands of them each more unyielding than the last in its expectation of being obeyed to the letter backed up by fines or worse.
51
00:07:20,640 --> 00:07:27,780
Here we see prostitutes being carted off to the side that will only the door
52
00:07:27,780 --> 00:07:34,500
recite all of the long list of previously and obviously in efficacious ADX,
53
00:07:34,500 --> 00:07:44,100
and the exasperated tone of the preambles betray any sign that all had not gone exactly to plan.
54
00:07:44,100 --> 00:07:52,110
It is this obduracy and rigidity of rule making in the face of abject rule failure.
55
00:07:52,110 --> 00:07:55,140
That is the topic of my lecture this evening.
56
00:07:55,140 --> 00:08:04,470
As I said at the outset, I'm more interested in the kind of rule that Parisian ordinances exemplified than in the content of the particular rules,
57
00:08:04,470 --> 00:08:15,180
although I'll be giving lots of examples. I'm going to argue that the Roumania of Enlightenment Paris represents the advent of a new kind of
58
00:08:15,180 --> 00:08:24,840
rule that contrasted starkly with the equally profuse and detailed rules of the early modern period.
59
00:08:24,840 --> 00:08:34,230
The latter were almost always framed with an eye toward the adjustments that would be necessary in practise.
60
00:08:34,230 --> 00:08:39,660
It's very rare to encounter a freestanding or naked rule.
61
00:08:39,660 --> 00:08:48,870
The formulation of the rule itself almost always includes examples and often exceptions,
62
00:08:48,870 --> 00:09:00,780
and an exhortation that some amount of judgement and discretion will be necessary to apply this rule to particular circumstances.
63
00:09:00,780 --> 00:09:09,570
These earlier rules were as simple as those of the later Parisian ordinances were rigid.
64
00:09:09,570 --> 00:09:21,840
My question is what made the Parisian authorities so confident that their rules could be formulated as if particulars always conformed to universals?
65
00:09:21,840 --> 00:09:29,700
As if Parisians always did what they were told in the teeth of abundant evidence to the contrary,
66
00:09:29,700 --> 00:09:34,170
in order to highlight the novelty of these rigid rules.
67
00:09:34,170 --> 00:09:49,080
I'm going to begin with the suppl rules of the early modern period will then return to Enlightenment Paris and take a closer look at Rumania.
68
00:09:49,080 --> 00:09:52,380
In both theory and in practise,
69
00:09:52,380 --> 00:10:04,710
and I'll conclude with some speculative thoughts about why this new kind then new kind of rigid rule emerged as an ideal, if not a reality.
70
00:10:04,710 --> 00:10:14,670
When and where it did, and why it has endured and is still very much with us in this age of algorithms for everything.
71
00:10:14,670 --> 00:10:20,280
So let me begin in the 16th century. We are in Nuremberg.
72
00:10:20,280 --> 00:10:34,810
The year is 15 25. The artist Albirex Drew, who has dedicated a manual on geometry for the use of painters, goldsmiths, sculptors, carpenters.
73
00:10:34,810 --> 00:10:43,060
Stonemasons and all those who use measurement in their trade to his humanist friend Willy Bode here Como,
74
00:10:43,060 --> 00:10:52,540
as befits its intended readership of artisans dirty little treatise unto advising their missing,
75
00:10:52,540 --> 00:10:58,510
sometimes published under the title as devising their kunst, is written in the German vernacular.
76
00:10:58,510 --> 00:11:09,610
It's not written in Latin, but the dedication to a renowned classical scholar like Pierre Coma hints at dirs ambitions to
77
00:11:09,610 --> 00:11:18,580
elevate the status of these lowly crafts and also to associate them with what he calls the lost,
78
00:11:18,580 --> 00:11:27,770
excuse me, the lost art of the Greeks and the Romans.
79
00:11:27,770 --> 00:11:39,260
He writes that painters and other artisans who learnt their craft entirely from daily practise were like wild,
80
00:11:39,260 --> 00:11:45,290
unproved trees and were rightly laughed at by connoisseurs and herders,
81
00:11:45,290 --> 00:11:56,330
almost certainly alluding to his own unpleasant experiences when he first arrived in Italy and was ridiculed by his Italian colleagues,
82
00:11:56,330 --> 00:12:04,790
Dumber promises that by mastering the geometry of the straight edge and compass of constructions like this one,
83
00:12:04,790 --> 00:12:12,740
such art hungry youth, as he calls them would improve their minds as well as their handiwork.
84
00:12:12,740 --> 00:12:19,670
Dedicate dedicated a pistol rings the changes on themes that were endlessly repeated in hundreds,
85
00:12:19,670 --> 00:12:30,290
if not thousands, of books on how to do everything that began to roll from the presses in the 15th century.
86
00:12:30,290 --> 00:12:37,610
These are books which intend to turn the banaszak handicrafts into genuine arts.
87
00:12:37,610 --> 00:12:46,880
So remember briefly, that there is a kind of hierarchy set up between ski into a form of knowledge,
88
00:12:46,880 --> 00:12:55,310
which is associated with the university, which delivers universal necessary knowledge of causes.
89
00:12:55,310 --> 00:13:00,800
Then there are the arts, first and foremost the liberal arts, which,
90
00:13:00,800 --> 00:13:07,850
if they cannot deliver necessary universal knowledge, at least deliver a rule, govern knowledge.
91
00:13:07,850 --> 00:13:18,620
And then below that, there are the banality trades, which are at least in the hierarchy devised by the learnt a
matter of blind routine repetition.
92
00:13:18,620 --> 00:13:23,180
What Drucker and many of the other authors of these handbooks,
93
00:13:23,180 --> 00:13:28,490
these How-To manuals of the early modern period want to do is to elevate the status of the
94
00:13:28,490 --> 00:13:35,180
so-called mechanical arts to a position which could vie with thought of the liberal arts.
95
00:13:35,180 --> 00:13:43,460
And they are doing so by following the cicerone and dictum that an art can be reduced to rules.
96
00:13:43,460 --> 00:13:48,200
This is not only a formula for improving the status of artisans.
97
00:13:48,200 --> 00:13:53,030
It's a formula for improving their mobility in every sense of the word.
98
00:13:53,030 --> 00:14:02,330
Early modern courts are in competition with one another for doctors, cooks, artists,
99
00:14:02,330 --> 00:14:08,960
military engineers, whoever could and rich defend and embellish the court.
100
00:14:08,960 --> 00:14:20,180
This meant that artisans like Doura could pretty much write their own ticket and have a career that was first and foremost
101
00:14:20,180 --> 00:14:27,350
far more lucrative than one might have had had he remained in his native Nuremberg as a goldsmith as his father had been,
102
00:14:27,350 --> 00:14:38,300
but also one which promised worldly fame. This combination is captured in a fifteen eighty three engraving by the Dutch artist.
103
00:14:38,300 --> 00:14:51,770
Hendrik Galtier's called ours at Uzis Art and Practise, and what we see here is the winged figure of hours of art and notice that she is struggling.
104
00:14:51,770 --> 00:14:58,430
He or she seised upon a globe to suggest the worldly fame that comes from listening
105
00:14:58,430 --> 00:15:02,840
to her instruction and at her feet are books and geometrical instruments.
106
00:15:02,840 --> 00:15:07,400
She is instructing the male figure of practise who is drawing.
107
00:15:07,400 --> 00:15:15,500
Drawing is another technique of planting one's work ahead of time recommended by these handbooks.
108
00:15:15,500 --> 00:15:26,780
And here you see in the corner the hourglass, suggesting time because only experience can sediment practise.
109
00:15:26,780 --> 00:15:30,920
And between these two, the partnership of hours at Uzis.
110
00:15:30,920 --> 00:15:38,630
According to Goltz Yess legend, for this engraving, which is in both Dutch and Latin,
111
00:15:38,630 --> 00:15:44,510
it will bring riches and worldly fame to the artisan and guiltiest who himself came from
112
00:15:44,510 --> 00:15:52,700
very modest origins and also was severely crippled through an accident in his right hand.
113
00:15:52,700 --> 00:15:59,150
His own meteoric career bore witness to the success of this formula.
114
00:15:59,150 --> 00:16:05,090
The 15th and 16th centuries were the first age of rule mania.
115
00:16:05,090 --> 00:16:13,970
In addition to books like Duras that provided artisans with rules to guide their proctors, practise philosophers, courtiers,
116
00:16:13,970 --> 00:16:24,990
doctors and teachers, published rules on how to sense how to dance, how to swim, how to travel, how to spell and besiege of.
117
00:16:24,990 --> 00:16:32,010
Fortified city even treatises on how to discover new truths of which latter Descartes,
118
00:16:32,010 --> 00:16:38,490
just Google, the method of 16:37 is only the most famous example.
119
00:16:38,490 --> 00:16:48,000
So what exactly were these rules? I can only give you a kind of scattering of examples, but I think they're fairly representative of the genre.
120
00:16:48,000 --> 00:16:56,250
So let's start with a treatise first published in 1956 and republished multiple times.
121
00:16:56,250 --> 00:17:03,390
This is the sixteen thirty four edition by the English mathematical practitioner Leonard Diggs,
122
00:17:03,390 --> 00:17:14,880
who is instructing land surveyors on how to use what he calls diverse and most certain and sufficient rules.
123
00:17:14,880 --> 00:17:19,770
Touching the measure of all manner of surfaces of timber, stone,
124
00:17:19,770 --> 00:17:33,000
glass and land and digs like dirt reproaches the heady and self-willed craftsmen who adhere to their own practise unguided by rules,
125
00:17:33,000 --> 00:17:39,660
and he wraps himself in the mantle of the infallible grounds as he calls them of geometry.
126
00:17:39,660 --> 00:17:48,840
And you see here that in on the title page of the surveyors are using various mathematical siting instruments.
127
00:17:48,840 --> 00:17:55,800
Yet his alternative rules are not only expressed almost entirely by means of examples.
128
00:17:55,800 --> 00:18:01,620
He also cautions that discretion must be exercised in order to simplify calculations.
129
00:18:01,620 --> 00:18:06,480
Quoting from Diggs, it were intolerable tediousness. Yay.
130
00:18:06,480 --> 00:18:14,910
Impossible to set forth the true quantities of timber measure to all odd quantity of squares.
131
00:18:14,910 --> 00:18:23,280
The discreet handling of these the witty shall bring to a sufficient exactness, so the message is clear rules.
132
00:18:23,280 --> 00:18:30,750
Even mathematical rules had to be tweaked by judgement when applied to specific cases.
133
00:18:30,750 --> 00:18:42,630
Another example In a very similar vein, the early 17th century Welsh composer Elway Bevan explained on how to write musical canons,
134
00:18:42,630 --> 00:18:51,900
which are the most mathematical form of what was still then a branch of mathematics, namely harmonics.
135
00:18:51,900 --> 00:19:01,320
Bevan also instructs the would be composer not so much by rules as by heaps and heaps of examples.
136
00:19:01,320 --> 00:19:09,690
We now consider canons to be the most mechanically rule bound of all musical genres.
137
00:19:09,690 --> 00:19:20,670
And it's not an accident that the very first computer compositions were of musical canons, but Bevan proceeds from simple example.
138
00:19:20,670 --> 00:19:32,100
So by taking plainsong and using alternating rest in the different lines to get at least some form of of polyphony
139
00:19:32,100 --> 00:19:41,790
to ones which are so complex that he compares them to the frame of the whole world made up of the elements of air,
140
00:19:41,790 --> 00:19:49,470
earth, fire and water. This is a this is his picture of this canon in four voices.
141
00:19:49,470 --> 00:19:55,230
All of this takes place without so much as a faint at formalisation.
142
00:19:55,230 --> 00:20:00,300
I take these examples because I want to show that even the mathematical sciences like arithmetic,
143
00:20:00,300 --> 00:20:10,350
measurement and harmonics were codified as much by examples as by rules in these handbooks, or to put it more accurately.
144
00:20:10,350 --> 00:20:14,310
The examples were part and parcel of the rule.
145
00:20:14,310 --> 00:20:24,780
So let me give you yet another example. This, perhaps from a context which is more prototypical of rules, namely rules of games.
146
00:20:24,780 --> 00:20:34,200
A London man about town, Charles Cotton, published in 1887, a treatise called the complete game Stir,
147
00:20:34,200 --> 00:20:40,560
in which he sets forth the rules in a lot more than the rules on horse racing,
148
00:20:40,560 --> 00:20:44,190
billiards, chess, all manner of card games,
149
00:20:44,190 --> 00:20:51,090
cockfighting just about any form of what he calls the enchanting witchery of gaming that was going on at that time.
150
00:20:51,090 --> 00:20:58,230
In the more lush sections of London, cotton is profligate into tales of all kinds.
151
00:20:58,230 --> 00:21:06,420
This is a real brick of a volume, the complete treatise. He is not only tells you how to play card games like this one,
152
00:21:06,420 --> 00:21:16,470
he tells you to watch out when you're bending over looking at your cards that someone doesn't strip off the gold buttons on your waistcoat.
153
00:21:16,470 --> 00:21:20,670
Why you? You're in a state of concentration, he tells you.
154
00:21:20,670 --> 00:21:24,880
Never bet on a fighting cock unless you've been to visit the.
155
00:21:24,880 --> 00:21:30,700
Courtyard and heard how frequently it grows in comparison to the others.
156
00:21:30,700 --> 00:21:38,200
He tells you if you have a horse that you want to race, make sure that it empties its bowels before it starts the race.
157
00:21:38,200 --> 00:21:44,080
This is a man who leaves no detail unsaid.
158
00:21:44,080 --> 00:21:53,500
Various orders and laws and rules are set forth for the various games, many of which we would readily recognise as rules of the game.
159
00:21:53,500 --> 00:21:59,170
So one of the rules is if you touch a chess piece, then you have to play it.
160
00:21:59,170 --> 00:22:09,980
But Cotton continually warns his readers that many of these games can only be played through long observation and experience.
161
00:22:09,980 --> 00:22:13,780
So there's some game. Perhaps some of you know it, it must be fiendishly difficult.
162
00:22:13,780 --> 00:22:17,530
It's called Irish, and he says there's no way of giving the rules to this.
163
00:22:17,530 --> 00:22:26,020
You just have to watch other people play Irish and even in chess, which is the subject of one of the book's longest chapters.
164
00:22:26,020 --> 00:22:34,510
Cotton toys with the idea of first that chess as well as draughts quote, may be played by a certain rule.
165
00:22:34,510 --> 00:22:38,740
But after about 20 pages of detailed instructions,
166
00:22:38,740 --> 00:22:45,250
he concludes quote many more observations might be here inserted for the understanding of this noble game,
167
00:22:45,250 --> 00:22:48,790
which I am forced to waive to avoid prolix city.
168
00:22:48,790 --> 00:22:53,950
So Cotton is interested not only in telling you what we would consider to be the rules that proper of the game.
169
00:22:53,950 --> 00:23:02,410
He's interested in telling you how to win. So, for example, he gives values for the pieces in chess, which are very much like the values we have now.
170
00:23:02,410 --> 00:23:11,170
That is a bishop is worth more than a knight. But he says, look, if you notice that your adversary likes to use his night,
171
00:23:11,170 --> 00:23:17,200
you should be willing to sacrifice your bishop to put that night out of commission.
172
00:23:17,200 --> 00:23:22,660
That's as much of a rule as how the night can can move in.
173
00:23:22,660 --> 00:23:26,320
Cotton's treatise these examples of rules,
174
00:23:26,320 --> 00:23:31,210
which I've called more or less at random from early modern handbooks on how to
175
00:23:31,210 --> 00:23:37,600
measure would compose a canon or win it games could easily be supplemented by many,
176
00:23:37,600 --> 00:23:39,400
many more from the same period.
177
00:23:39,400 --> 00:23:49,300
There are treatises on how to make jams, how to start a pig farm, how to dredge a ditch, how to draw in perspective, how to pass a bill in parliament.
178
00:23:49,300 --> 00:23:55,540
Generally, anything you need to get on with daily life in an orderly manner.
179
00:23:55,540 --> 00:24:05,840
In today's parlance, to call an activity an art is to draw attention to its implicit intuitive aspect.
180
00:24:05,840 --> 00:24:13,330
So, for example, when we say that medicine is an art as well as a science, we are contrasting.
181
00:24:13,330 --> 00:24:20,920
It's more formalised, rule governed. Part two is more savoir faire aspects.
182
00:24:20,920 --> 00:24:24,460
The meaning of art in the early modern period is quite different.
183
00:24:24,460 --> 00:24:32,560
It's to render explicit by rules what white might have been seen as implicit practise.
184
00:24:32,560 --> 00:24:42,490
And this becomes an obsession not only for the authors of these rules and method books, but also for governments.
185
00:24:42,490 --> 00:24:46,540
Cobell is only perhaps the
most successful.
186
00:24:46,540 --> 00:24:51,670
I assume that this is a case where the night has just been taken.
187
00:24:51,670 --> 00:25:00,700
Cobell is only one of the most successful of reforming mercantilist ministers of the 17th
188
00:25:00,700 --> 00:25:11,440
century who publish treatises of rules to improve the quality of artisanal products for export.
189
00:25:11,440 --> 00:25:19,750
In order to fill the royal coffers in this case, he was particularly interested in the silk market in France,
190
00:25:19,750 --> 00:25:27,040
and this is one of the many patterns that was published for the guidance of William Silk Weavers.
191
00:25:27,040 --> 00:25:38,440
The rules of art brought to haphazard practise a certain order, and they elevated the prestige of the artisans.
192
00:25:38,440 --> 00:25:44,380
But rules did not eliminate the need for discretion and experience.
193
00:25:44,380 --> 00:25:50,770
They were always formulated with an eye toward inevitable exceptions.
194
00:25:50,770 --> 00:25:59,620
The rules, as I said, are not freestanding models. Examples, tips and observations prop them up and filled them out.
195
00:25:59,620 --> 00:26:10,120
This isn't because the rules were unnecessarily vague or unspecific or undertale, some of them fulminate with detail.
196
00:26:10,120 --> 00:26:20,680
Rather, it was because no universal formulation was expected to be able to do justice to particular circumstances,
197
00:26:20,680 --> 00:26:24,870
even if the authors of these books had never read Aristotle.
198
00:26:24,870 --> 00:26:32,760
Nicole McKee in Ethics. They were well aware of the problem that Aristotle formulates in the NICKLEBY and ethics concerning legislation,
199
00:26:32,760 --> 00:26:42,510
which is no lawmaker can foresee all of the particular cases which such a law may eventually confront.
200
00:26:42,510 --> 00:26:47,790
And therefore, the judge will have to, in our Suttles words,
201
00:26:47,790 --> 00:26:59,250
imagine himself in the position of the original legislator in order to avoid injustice in certain particular cases.
202
00:26:59,250 --> 00:27:01,680
This is the law of of of equity.
203
00:27:01,680 --> 00:27:14,970
Even if the authors of these books had never heard of the law of Equity, they were very much adhering to Aristotle's warnings about the necessary,
204
00:27:14,970 --> 00:27:23,310
in our subtle view, necessary constraints upon on all universals applied to variable subject matter.
205
00:27:23,310 --> 00:27:31,080
So the differing degree of pungency of an exotic spice that might change your recipe or
206
00:27:31,080 --> 00:27:37,140
the knot in the wood that might force the carpenter to swerve from an initial plan.
207
00:27:37,140 --> 00:27:47,950
Those were the sorts of particulars which were assumed to be absolutely ubiquitous and inevitable, and therefore the rules had to do them justice.
208
00:27:47,950 --> 00:27:55,410
And now take us back to 18th century Paris and a rather different kind of rule.
209
00:27:55,410 --> 00:28:03,870
If the rules of the first wave of rule mania in the early modern period were thick rules cocooned in their
210
00:28:03,870 --> 00:28:14,820
examples and exceptions and appeals to experience the rules of the 18th century Parisian bureaucrats within rules.
211
00:28:14,820 --> 00:28:20,340
So we are now in Paris. The year is 1749.
212
00:28:20,340 --> 00:28:32,670
This is a manuscript submitted by an officer of the Paris police to Louis, the 15th exquisitely illustrated by Gabriel S. Obama.
213
00:28:32,670 --> 00:28:36,570
And it shows the invention of licence plates.
214
00:28:36,570 --> 00:28:44,190
So what one sees here is that there are going to be a if the recommendations in this manuscript are followed,
215
00:28:44,190 --> 00:28:47,580
their every fiasco is going to have a number up here.
216
00:28:47,580 --> 00:28:57,660
So the police will know who the miscreants are and every cart horse on its with milk here is going to have its number over here.
217
00:28:57,660 --> 00:29:03,930
The author of this treatise is Francois Jacques Griot, who is an officer of the constabulary.
218
00:29:03,930 --> 00:29:11,640
He is resident in Paris, friend of. He lives in the same building, we think in the WHO moved out as Dero,
219
00:29:11,640 --> 00:29:19,260
and he also proposes in this same treatise the numbering of Powers Houses the numbering of the staircases in Paris,
220
00:29:19,260 --> 00:29:23,520
houses the numbering of the apartments, the doors in Paris houses.
221
00:29:23,520 --> 00:29:34,740
He imagines a kind of identity card that will allow the police to trace the movements of passers by, then circa 500000 residents.
222
00:29:34,740 --> 00:29:46,860
He imagines a gigantic paper shuffling machine that will allow the officials at the camera, at the police to at the.
223
00:29:46,860 --> 00:29:50,070
So what you see here is see these giant wheels here.
224
00:29:50,070 --> 00:30:01,170
They got there. They're sort of like the book wheels that you sometimes see in a depictions in early modern libraries and but underneath their desks,
225
00:30:01,170 --> 00:30:13,260
these functionaries have a pedal which moves on the wheels and can summon up one of millions of dossiers to the touch of a foot.
226
00:30:13,260 --> 00:30:21,150
He wants to weave a finely meshed net of policing that will, in his own words,
227
00:30:21,150 --> 00:30:28,950
leave everyone the freedom to do good but make doing evil extremely difficult.
228
00:30:28,950 --> 00:30:39,840
He's obsessed with the regulation of every aspect of the booming, expanding and notoriously unruly city of Paris circa 1750,
229
00:30:39,840 --> 00:30:46,200
and it's no wonder Michele Fuko was fascinated, morbidly fascinated with this treatise.
230
00:30:46,200 --> 00:30:54,900
It is a phantasmagoria of surveillance and control, but it is a complete fantasy.
231
00:30:54,900 --> 00:31:01,440
As
one look at the actual efforts of the police to keep even a semblance of order in 18th century,
232
00:31:01,440 --> 00:31:11,310
Paris confirms, I've already read you a quotation describing the kind of chaos of mules,
233
00:31:11,310 --> 00:31:22,800
pedestrians, carts, carriages, market stands competing for space in the absolutely filthy streets of 18th century Paris.
234
00:31:22,800 --> 00:31:27,350
You've got to imagine not only. Are the streets, for the most part, very narrow.
235
00:31:27,350 --> 00:31:31,460
They are heaped with garbage and also building materials because there's a
236
00:31:31,460 --> 00:31:36,710
building boom going on and you have to put the bricks and the masonry someplace.
237
00:31:36,710 --> 00:31:46,010
And moreover, to most streets starting in sort of the early 19th century are what are called in French Bombay, which means they're convex.
238
00:31:46,010 --> 00:31:54,260
So there's a slight hump in the middle so that water and refuse can flow into gutters on the sides of the street.
239
00:31:54,260 --> 00:31:57,530
This implies that you have a well working gutter system.
240
00:31:57,530 --> 00:32:13,490
The streets of Paris are still concave, so they have in the middle a filthy stream of revenues that is meant eventually to flow into the sand.
241
00:32:13,490 --> 00:32:18,230
There is this a I think the hood initialled in the 5th,
242
00:32:18,230 --> 00:32:29,210
the 6th arrondissement still has a structure that you can see the Latin with a few remnants of of this form of a street design.
243
00:32:29,210 --> 00:32:36,560
So the streets, they're congested, they're filthy, and they're also really dangerous.
244
00:32:36,560 --> 00:32:45,770
When in the 1770s, the first sidewalks for pedestrians were created on the pontiff.
245
00:32:45,770 --> 00:32:57,530
It was a seven days wonder as the words 2.2L and 01:12 suggest these raised walkways were originally meant not for pedestrians,
246
00:32:57,530 --> 00:33:07,580
but for horsemen to mount their steed to get a leg up to mount this as a Montréal 212, et cetera.
247
00:33:07,580 --> 00:33:13,340
No one had seen anything like it that the pedestrians actually had a place of their own to walk.
248
00:33:13,340 --> 00:33:16,850
From the late 16th century to the mid-19th century.
249
00:33:16,850 --> 00:33:25,670
The Parisian police and municipal administration saw their chief task as the conquest of public space,
250
00:33:25,670 --> 00:33:31,760
which often boiled down to keeping the streets clean and traffic flowing.
251
00:33:31,760 --> 00:33:43,640
This was no easy task. Paris, like many early modern European cities, was freed from its constraining mediaeval walls and 17th century.
252
00:33:43,640 --> 00:33:59,990
So what happens is that with siege warfare and fortifications, you move the site of warfare to a series of fortified garrisons on the border.
253
00:33:59,990 --> 00:34:11,300
This is what happens after the martial volleyball
Louis, the 14th legendary field commander, wins several key battles.
254
00:34:11,300 --> 00:34:17,420
That means that these mediaeval cities can tear down their walls and start to expand.
255
00:34:17,420 --> 00:34:22,640
And that's exactly what happened. You can see you can see here that will go back of the seventeen thirties.
256
00:34:22,640 --> 00:34:31,190
You can see the tracing of the old walls, and what you start to get is a lot of building and what are being called the Faubourg.
257
00:34:31,190 --> 00:34:49,100
The football company here. And you also get a use of the repurposed ramparts, which all return in a few minutes in which they are turned into.
258
00:34:49,100 --> 00:34:54,920
So here this is from the port. Somebody needs to sample one.
259
00:34:54,920 --> 00:34:58,940
What you get here is so this would have been the top of the ramparts.
260
00:34:58,940 --> 00:35:03,620
It's now being turned into Paris's first broad boulevards and nuked.
261
00:35:03,620 --> 00:35:11,780
And it's a little hard to make out here. These little dots are actually rows of trees planted at strictly regulated intervals.
262
00:35:11,780 --> 00:35:23,660
I'll say more about that in in a moment. This is a city where the population and commercial activity are skyrocketing.
263
00:35:23,660 --> 00:35:29,930
The rising revenues from the North Atlantic trade triggers a building building boom.
264
00:35:29,930 --> 00:35:38,990
And by 1779, Paris is estimated to have about 50000 houses, 17 public squares,
265
00:35:38,990 --> 00:35:49,850
a 975 streets of wits ranging from two to 20 metres, and a population of about 650000 people.
266
00:35:49,850 --> 00:36:07,800
A city that had had eight carriages in 1994 had about six, had about 300 in sixteen sixty and somewhere between 14000 and 20000 in 1722.
267
00:36:07,800 --> 00:36:14,450
A sign, as I say, from these newly created broad boulevards on the city's repurposed ramparts.
268
00:36:14,450 --> 00:36:24,700
Most of the streets are sinuous higgledy piggledy with the facades of the houses they see.
269
00:36:24,700 --> 00:36:33,460
Every which way. Here is the room move, dad where Gilbert lived, which is then as now a market street.
270
00:36:33,460 --> 00:36:39,970
So one of the streets where traffic was particularly congested,
271
00:36:39,970 --> 00:36:52,840
it's no wonder that got played with the fantasy of just raising the whole city to the ground and starting over again.
272
00:36:52,840 --> 00:37:00,820
As I say it, the Parisian police who have to deal with all of this, not just keeping the peace and catching criminals.
273
00:37:00,820 --> 00:37:09,520
They are from 16 sixty seven on responsible for almost all aspects of urban administration and
274
00:37:09,520 --> 00:37:18,340
assuring not only the safety but also the comfort and convenience and prosperity of Paris's citizens.
275
00:37:18,340 --> 00:37:22,240
This is a period starting in the late 17th century at about the time the Office
276
00:37:22,240 --> 00:37:28,090
of the Lieutenant of Police is created when early modern European cities,
277
00:37:28,090 --> 00:37:35,020
at least a few of them, like Amsterdam, Paris and London, start to compete with one another.
278
00:37:35,020 --> 00:37:44,140
Amsterdam is the poster child for what a orderly will govern city should look like.
279
00:37:44,140 --> 00:37:55,300
Here you see the map that is going to extend the canal system of Amsterdam and a completely symmetric fashion.
280
00:37:55,300 --> 00:38:01,750
Visitors to Paris or to Amsterdam marvel at the cleanliness,
281
00:38:01,750 --> 00:38:10,270
the handsome and uniform street facades, the efficient sewage system, the spacious public squares,
282
00:38:10,270 --> 00:38:21,700
the night-time illumination by oil lamps of the strictly regulated traffic and the workhouses to keep beggars out of the public eye.
283
00:38:21,700 --> 00:38:34,420
Paris and London in the late 17th century fall painfully short of the standards set by Amsterdam and by the late 17th century.
284
00:38:34,420 --> 00:38:44,200
Not only are travellers, but official delegations visiting each other's cities to take note of their innovations and
285
00:38:44,200 --> 00:38:53,140
try to import it home after the creation of the Office of the Paris Lieutenant of Police,
286
00:38:53,140 --> 00:39:01,810
who has approximately 50 commie cells stationed in the city's neighbourhoods, reporting to him on a daily basis,
287
00:39:01,810 --> 00:39:07,310
thousands of dossiers start to be collected and filed chronologically and alphabetically.
288
00:39:07,310 --> 00:39:17,620
Remember that paper shuffling machine that quiet fantasises about the police become in part because of this competition amongst cities,
289
00:39:17,620 --> 00:39:26,590
the avant garde of Europe's bureaucracy? When, for instance, the empress of the Austro-Hungarian Empire,
290
00:39:26,590 --> 00:39:34,810
Multi-taskers wants to set up her own when she wants to basically upgrade Vienna as her capital.
291
00:39:34,810 --> 00:39:40,900
She writes to the Parisian lieutenant of police to give her recommendations.
292
00:39:40,900 --> 00:39:50,980
It's no accident that it's fantasies not only about surveillance, but also paperwork centred on the Parisian police and who you see once again,
293
00:39:50,980 --> 00:39:58,150
these officials consulting the many, many dossiers kept on every aspect of powers.
294
00:39:58,150 --> 00:40:07,600
Releasing a good deal of that mass of paperwork was generated by the regulations I've already mentioned,
295
00:40:07,600 --> 00:40:17,230
and many of these regulations are issued multiple times and they're about everything who can have a chemical laboratory.
296
00:40:17,230 --> 00:40:25,000
Only doctors and apothecaries. What is the minimum age for driving a hired carriage?
297
00:40:25,000 --> 00:40:29,560
18. How should you celebrate a royal birth?
298
00:40:29,560 -->
00:40:34,750
Candles in the window? Yes. Firing guns into the air? No.
299
00:40:34,750 --> 00:40:47,590
The proper placement of chimneys. How gold and silver should be used only for coinage, except for the occasional cross for an archbishop.
300
00:40:47,590 --> 00:40:57,640
What can and cannot be worn in public? So imported Swiss cotton, Italian lace and any kind of embroidery are prohibited.
301
00:40:57,640 --> 00:41:05,620
The spacing of trees planted along main thoroughfares at least 18 feet apart and innumerable
302
00:41:05,620 --> 00:41:09,980
prohibitions of the sort that I began with against blocking the streets with trash,
303
00:41:09,980 --> 00:41:16,240
snow carts, animals, stalls or ball games.
304
00:41:16,240 --> 00:41:24,500
These regulations were rather limited efficacy. Here is a slightly exotic.
305
00:41:24,500 --> 00:41:29,750
Rated view of the pontiff on a bad day,
306
00:41:29,750 --> 00:41:36,650
and you can see that all the regulations that you're not supposed to have markets so these these are these are the famous 212 the sidewalks here.
307
00:41:36,650 --> 00:41:42,410
This was to have market stands cluttering them. You're certainly not supposed to have the pedestrians in the middle of the street.
308
00:41:42,410 --> 00:41:49,280
They're supposed to be on the sidewalks. And you see also here what this can lead to.
309
00:41:49,280 --> 00:42:00,950
This poor water carrier is being kicked by a horse who has been spooked by someone driving their cattle through the turf.
310
00:42:00,950 --> 00:42:07,640
When you read through all of these ordinances decade by decade,
311
00:42:07,640 --> 00:42:17,690
you occasionally catch a glimpse of the episodes that Enlightenment historians habitually uses landmarks of the era.
312
00:42:17,690 --> 00:42:26,120
So, for example, an ordinance closing the San Medalled cemetery in the wake of the alleged miraculous
313
00:42:26,120 --> 00:42:34,010
cures of the convicts younow or the banning the suppressing of the all sick paddy.
314
00:42:34,010 --> 00:42:44,390
But these are really just drops in a huge ocean of regulations that occupied the Parisian police day in, day out.
315
00:42:44,390 --> 00:42:49,280
The scope and the detail of these regulations is staggering.
316
00:42:49,280 --> 00:43:00,110
A heroic effort to anticipate, counter and regulate every aspect of urban life, as Montesquieu said of the police in this plea deal,
317
00:43:00,110 --> 00:43:08,000
while they are perpetually concerned with details with regulations rather than laws.
318
00:43:08,000 --> 00:43:15,890
But apparently all of this bureaucratic foresight, surveillance and recordkeeping was largely in vain.
319
00:43:15,890 --> 00:43:24,530
All of these infringements carried fines and some even prison sentences and those daily reports from the neighbourhood.
320
00:43:24,530 --> 00:43:30,170
Those 50 neighbourhood copies sell on infractions, provide evidence of vigilance and enforcement.
321
00:43:30,170 --> 00:43:33,770
So every Tuesday and every Friday, the lieutenant of the police,
322
00:43:33,770 --> 00:43:41,750
who also has the powers of a magistrate, is hearing cases of infractions of these regulations.
323
00:43:41,750 --> 00:43:51,200
So he's handing down, for example, a truly hefty fine of 300 leaflets to one dim wasn't cook resident in the Bhutani,
324
00:43:51,200 --> 00:44:04,730
who was spotted wearing a dress of court contraband called DNA printed with red roses or a lighter fine of 100 sue to the widow Shihad,
325
00:44:04,730 --> 00:44:09,350
who had emptied the contents of her chamber pot onto the street below.
326
00:44:09,350 --> 00:44:15,320
At nine p.m. one January evening, it was not considered exculpatory.
327
00:44:15,320 --> 00:44:22,370
First together, Gallo. Watch out below as a warning to passers by beforehand.
328
00:44:22,370 --> 00:44:28,880
More serious offences such as riding faster than a trot and recidivists were fined more
329
00:44:28,880 --> 00:44:36,500
heavily armed because the chemical usually cashier a cut of whatever fine was levied.
330
00:44:36,500 --> 00:44:42,410
They had every motive to report the miscreants.
331
00:44:42,410 --> 00:44:49,940
Yet the sheer number of times that these ordinances were reissued absolutely verbatim,
332
00:44:49,940 --> 00:44:59,990
except for an increasingly hysterical preamble about the iniquity of the Parisians that made it necessary to reissue the regulations.
333
00:44:59,990 --> 00:45:03,410
This is, I think, damning evidence of their futility.
334
00:45:03,410 --> 00:45:15,260
So recall the examples that I began with the police ordinance of November 28th 1750 on street cleaning repeats the edicts of sixty three and 16,
335
00:45:15,260 --> 00:45:18,710
66 and 1740 for verbatim the edicts.
336
00:45:18,710 --> 00:45:24,440
Banning games from power streets were issued 17 times between sixteen,
337
00:45:24,440 --> 00:45:34,850
sixty seven and 1750 for a 16 44 royal decree prohibiting yet again imported lace despaired.
338
00:45:34,850 --> 00:45:37,070
Now, quoting from the preamble,
339
00:45:37,070 --> 00:45:49,460
experience has shown that heretofore all regulations made by the kings or predecessors and by ourselves have been futile and not executed,
340
00:45:49,460 --> 00:45:53,810
having served only to just fly display defiance to their authority.
341
00:45:53,810 --> 00:46:01,550
The weakness of the magistrates and the corruption of the manners of this century in the
342
00:46:01,550 --> 00:46:09,860
face of such humiliating failure to get Parisians to shovel their snow forswear lace,
343
00:46:09,860 --> 00:46:16,970
stop playing ball in the streets or place their trash in the appointed containers at the appointed hours.
344
00:46:16,970 --> 00:46:24,570
The response of the police bureaucracy was to issue yet more regulations even more.
345
00:46:24,570 --> 00:46:34,290
Detailed and to redouble surveillance and reporting Wyatt's manuscript treatise of 1749 for Louie,
346
00:46:34,290 --> 00:46:44,320
the 15th recommended more police inspectors, more reports, more registration and observation of everyone and everything.
347
00:46:44,320 --> 00:46:51,210
Here's his his suggested form for registering all Parisians where they come from, where they're living.
348
00:46:51,210 --> 00:46:54,900
Have they paid their taxes, their comings and goings?
349
00:46:54,900 --> 00:47:06,570
What in retrospect looks like a glaring example of rule failure was interpreted at the time as a call for rule repair.
350
00:47:06,570 --> 00:47:11,910
If the existing rules had encountered resistance and exceptions,
351
00:47:11,910 --> 00:47:21,360
the solution was to weave an ever tighter mesh of rules, darning the loopholes catching the scofflaws.
352
00:47:21,360 --> 00:47:29,910
This bureaucratic reflex to rule failure is so familiar to us that we no longer query its authority.
353
00:47:29,910 --> 00:47:40,590
Why should the response to failed rules be yet more rules, and not just more of the very same repeal rules repeated verbatim?
354
00:47:40,590 --> 00:47:48,360
What dilution of order held the famously worldly lieutenant of police in its thrall?
355
00:47:48,360 --> 00:47:51,870
The lieutenant of police men like yourself, teen and Linn?
356
00:47:51,870 --> 00:47:56,490
Well, these were famously worldly men.
357
00:47:56,490 --> 00:48:05,670
They they knew everyone's secrets. They knew literally and figuratively where all the bodies were buried.
358
00:48:05,670 --> 00:48:14,790
And yet yet these really hard headed men of action seem to believe that if they
359
00:48:14,790 --> 00:48:19,590
just issued those rules against ball playing in the streets one more time,
360
00:48:19,590 --> 00:48:28,800
it might actually take hold. The lieutenants of the Paris police, who were arguably France's and perhaps Europe's foremost bureaucrats,
361
00:48:28,800 --> 00:48:35,010
clung to the fantasy of a perfect rule that would ensure perfect order.
362
00:48:35,010 --> 00:48:40,800
They refused to give in to the recalcitrance of the Parisians.
363
00:48:40,800 --> 00:48:50,730
Rules had stiffened. So what accounts for this obstinacy in the face of abject failure?
364
00:48:50,730 --> 00:49:02,250
Time and time again, why were so many ordinances neither scrapped nor amended but simply reissued verbatim,
365
00:49:02,250 --> 00:49:12,570
except for an increasingly ill tempered preamble? Despite the evident refusal of most Parisians to pay them any heed,
366
00:49:12,570 --> 00:49:18,030
the explanations of this lamentable state of affairs in the preambles ranged from
367
00:49:18,030 --> 00:49:26,520
the conciliatory so the preamble of one 17:35 reissue fire regulations suggest,
368
00:49:26,520 --> 00:49:34,500
well, maybe we'll just forgot the earlier regulations. They ranged from the indulgent in that to the indignant.
369
00:49:34,500 --> 00:49:46,710
It is
intolerable that people are still wearing banned lace once again and melting down gold and silver coins to make buttons to flatter their party.
370
00:49:46,710 --> 00:49:55,560
Historians of Paris document the resistance of the Parisians and the inadequacy of the regulations to bring chaos under control,
371
00:49:55,560 --> 00:50:06,180
but they rarely remark upon the puzzling obstinacy and inflexibility of the regulations themselves.
372
00:50:06,180 --> 00:50:15,720
The Roumania of the early modern period with which I began was just as prolific in rules,
373
00:50:15,720 --> 00:50:25,410
just as confident that the right rules would solve all problems from learning how to swim to arriving at self-evident truths.
374
00:50:25,410 --> 00:50:30,840
But the earlier examples of rules which I gave had been sick rules.
375
00:50:30,840 --> 00:50:39,480
They'd given you a great deal of latitude in how to apply them, and they had been supple in the face of exceptions.
376
00:50:39,480 --> 00:50:46,650
In contrast, those of the police bringing order to Enlightenment Paris were thin and rigid.
377
00:50:46,650 --> 00:50:58,440
It was as if in the imaginary of the rule makers, Aristotle's problem of universals and particulars had been solved, at least within city limits.
378
00:50:58,440 --> 00:51:07,950
And if it hadn't, the solution was to repeat the selfsame rules again until they were eventually obeyed.
379
00:51:07,950 --> 00:51:14,550
It was as if the Parisian police suffered from some kind of obsessive compulsive neurosis,
380
00:51:14,550 --> 00:51:24,280
doomed to repeat the same futile rules year after year, decade after decade unable or unwilling to adjust.
381
00:51:24,280 --> 00:51:30,280
To circumstances, why a clue lies,
382
00:51:30,280 --> 00:51:38,620
I think in the competition that I've already mentioned amongst European metropolises that began in the late
383
00:51:38,620 --> 00:51:46,180
17th century and gathered momentum throughout the 18th century and has never stopped ever since Amsterdam,
384
00:51:46,180 --> 00:51:51,490
Paris and London begin this competition. They're not only in competition with each other.
385
00:51:51,490 --> 00:52:00,430
They were emulating each other, implicitly establishing new standards who were the first rank city should look,
386
00:52:00,430 --> 00:52:13,030
sound and smell like when, for example, Amsterdam adopts a system of fire pumps and street lanterns.
387
00:52:13,030 --> 00:52:22,810
It is imported within a decade or so to Paris and London, Parisian displays of luxury goods in betweens on the loose,
388
00:52:22,810 --> 00:52:29,590
and they are duly imitated on London's fashionable shopping streets.
389
00:52:29,590 --> 00:52:42,520
Rival cities vied with each other for the most free flowing traffic, the most splendid parks and promenades, and the cleanest, best lit streets.
390
00:52:42,520 --> 00:52:46,810
Here we see the pontiff on a somewhat better day,
391
00:52:46,810 --> 00:52:55,330
although the stated goal of all of these improvements was the comfort, safety and convenience of the city dwellers.
392
00:52:55,330 --> 00:53:03,040
The authorities were acutely conscious of the judgements of foreigners when, for example,
393
00:53:03,040 --> 00:53:09,760
the Parisian police banned merchant stalls from the pontiff for the umpteenth time.
394
00:53:09,760 --> 00:53:16,120
They justified the regulations not just by pointing to traffic congestion,
395
00:53:16,120 --> 00:53:27,610
but also to the fact that the stalls blocked quote the most magnificent view and the one most worthy of admiration by foreigners.
396
00:53:27,610 --> 00:53:33,850
It is tempting to bundle all of the measures to control traffic and fight fires.
397
00:53:33,850 --> 00:53:37,840
Clean streets and beautiful views together as modernisation.
398
00:53:37,840 --> 00:53:46,840
And that's exactly how urban historians do refer to these efforts on the part of early modern western European metropolises.
399
00:53:46,840 --> 00:53:52,150
But I think it would be more accurate to say that this competition amongst cities, which, as I say,
400
00:53:52,150 --> 00:54:04,150
has never stopped, had very little to do with science and technology sort of the 19th century version of modernity,
401
00:54:04,150 --> 00:54:15,370
but rather with inventing a first version of modernity, which has everything to do with orderliness, predictability and with rules.
402
00:54:15,370 --> 00:54:28,150
So when M.C imagines Paris in 20 for 40, he does not imagine people in flying cars or other technological marvels.
403
00:54:28,150 --> 00:54:38,470
Instead, he imagines Parisians are still getting around on foot and on horses, but they are getting around in an orderly manner.
404
00:54:38,470 --> 00:54:54,340
This is the vision of the future in seven circa 1770, and it's a vision which has everything to do with a certain few pockets of urban life,
405
00:54:54,340 --> 00:55:09,250
which are attempting to not only remap the physical dimensions of the city, but to re-educate the city dwellers in a certain form of conduct.
406
00:55:09,250 --> 00:55:16,960
So rather than striving to realise a vision of modernity, the did not yet exist and certainly not under that name.
407
00:55:16,960 --> 00:55:26,980
Enlightenment Paris and its rivals were aiming at a vision already glimpsed in the uniform facades and the efficient sewage system.
408
00:55:26,980 --> 00:55:34,780
The free flowing traffic and night streets blazing with lanterns in a city like Amsterdam here was
409
00:55:34,780 --> 00:55:42,250
a city in which the radius of predictability and everyday life had been impressively extended,
410
00:55:42,250 --> 00:55:44,620
at least within city limits.
411
00:55:44,620 --> 00:55:53,650
It was no accident that the Dutch had also pioneered mathematically based annuities, lotteries and insurance schemes during the same period.
412
00:55:53,650 -->
00:56:05,380
All devices designed to rein in the role of chance in human affairs in his justly celebrated essay of 1977,
413
00:56:05,380 --> 00:56:10,780
The Passions and the Interests political arguments for capitalism before its triumph.
414
00:56:10,780 --> 00:56:19,300
Albert Hershman described how the vices of greed and pursuit of self-interest were morally
415
00:56:19,300 --> 00:56:24,840
rehabilitated by enlightenment thinkers such as Bernard Mandeville and Adam Smith.
416
00:56:24,840 --> 00:56:35,460
These thinkers argued that even if the interests could not be considered full fledged virtues, they did make people calculable,
417
00:56:35,460 --> 00:56:43,140
and that was their great advantage over the more tempestuous passions of ambition, anger and lust.
418
00:56:43,140 --> 00:56:52,260
The interests begin, as Hershman says, as calm passions well suited to reigning in the tempestuous ones and ended up
419
00:56:52,260 --> 00:56:59,460
as demie virtues because they lubricated commerce and stabilised social life.
420
00:56:59,460 --> 00:57:06,060
What Hirschman does not explain is why the doctrine of the benign interests,
421
00:57:06,060 --> 00:57:12,990
which as his subtitle indicates and to date, the triumph of capitalism rather than rationalising it.
422
00:57:12,990 --> 00:57:18,760
Why this doctrine emerges when and where it does.
423
00:57:18,760 --> 00:57:28,510
Did the passions, after all, had been excoriated by philosophers since antiquity as enemies of reason?
424
00:57:28,510 --> 00:57:38,790
Why should the argument that the calmer interest could subdue the notoriously wild passions have been persuasive?
425
00:57:38,790 --> 00:57:44,850
And finally, why was it better to be predictable than to be truly good?
426
00:57:44,850 --> 00:57:54,750
I'd like to suggest that the answer to these questions about the rising stock of the interests gives us a clue to the
427
00:57:54,750 --> 00:58:04,470
answer of the question about why the Parisian police so stubbornly reissued their thousands of rules without adjustments,
428
00:58:04,470 --> 00:58:13,770
much less concessions of defeat. In both cases, it was a vision of partial success.
429
00:58:13,770 --> 00:58:27,390
Rather than bow to experience as a thick rules, had the municipal authorities banked on experience bowing to the rules in some places,
430
00:58:27,390 --> 00:58:36,270
few and no but populous and much publicised in both word and image was by early modern European standards.
431
00:58:36,270 --> 00:58:43,200
An astonishing degree of orderliness and predictability had been in fact achieved.
432
00:58:43,200 --> 00:58:56,100
I've already sketched the role that Amsterdam played in giving a tantalising example of what the iron willed municipal authorities might accomplish.
433
00:58:56,100 --> 00:59:05,520
But even in helter skelter Paris, microcosm of regularity brought about by regulation were emerging.
434
00:59:05,520 --> 00:59:13,980
Whereas in
Boswell's London, the right of way was adjudicated amongst pedestrians by a cudgel.
435
00:59:13,980 --> 00:59:24,450
By 1786, London visitors were being advised that if they keep kept the walls of buildings to their right while walking, you will have no interruption.
436
00:59:24,450 --> 00:59:35,670
Everyone will give way. In Paris, it is the broad boulevards which I've already mentioned, which were created here on the city's former ramparts.
437
00:59:35,670 --> 00:59:45,390
And here this is. The The Boulevard bus to home fell about here, which gave something like the same kind of glimpse of the possible.
438
00:59:45,390 --> 00:59:49,380
I'd mentioned already that they're divided into lanes by the regularly planted trees.
439
00:59:49,380 --> 00:59:56,910
This means that for the first time, pedestrian horse and carriage traffic can be segregated,
440
00:59:56,910 --> 01:00:05,070
which isn't considered by the Parisians to be nothing short of a miracle.
441
01:00:05,070 --> 01:00:17,820
They're emblematic of another aspect of why here you see, they become an extremely popular promenade their emblem,
442
01:00:17,820 --> 01:00:27,000
their emblematic of another aspect of why the municipal authorities were obsessed with order and predictability.
443
01:00:27,000 --> 01:00:35,490
Once the mediaeval city walls had been rendered obsolete by new siege warfare,
444
01:00:35,490 --> 01:00:43,830
you are dealing with a city that seems to no no check on its population growth.
445
01:00:43,830 --> 01:00:46,920
This is also the case for London and Amsterdam.
446
01:00:46,920 --> 01:00:59,310
So Amsterdam had a population of circa 50000 and hundred and two hundred and thirty five thousand by 7500 in the same period.
447
01:00:59,310 --> 01:01:08,370
Paris swelled from ten thousand to about 500 and 15000 inhabitants on the eve of the French Revolution.
448
01:01:08,370 --> 01:01:15,180
As many as 630000 people were living in the city. London's growth curve was even steeper.
449
01:01:15,180 --> 01:01:18,840
These were cities that were bursting at the seams,
450
01:01:18,840 --> 01:01:28,050
and neither the physical infrastructure nor social customs could absorb so many newcomers without buckling under the strain.
451
01:01:28,050 --> 01:01:34,470
Eighteenth century almanacs of professions show that as population and prosperity waxed,
452
01:01:34,470 --> 01:01:46,440
trees became ever more specialised and interdependent between twice and four times as many people were jostling each other in the streets,
453
01:01:46,440 --> 01:01:51,990
throwing their waste out the windows, crowding both official and unofficial markets,
454
01:01:51,990 --> 01:02:03,030
and blocking thoroughfares with bricks and other building materials. They were generally interacting with more people in more ways than ever before.
455
01:02:03,030 --> 01:02:07,530
It's under these circumstances of high density,
456
01:02:07,530 --> 01:02:21,540
urban mobility and sociability that a premium was placed on the predictability of human conduct once achieved, even within a narrow compass.
457
01:02:21,540 --> 01:02:29,520
Predictability could become addictive as our own epoch of self-avowed control freaks hardly needs to be told.
458
01:02:29,520 --> 01:02:34,050
Small successes feed vaulting ambitions.
459
01:02:34,050 --> 01:02:44,160
The promise held out by both the first and second waves of Rumania was to overthrow the empire of Trouts.
460
01:02:44,160 --> 01:02:53,490
Fortuna had reigned mighty in the imaginations of the authors of that first wave of rule books I mentioned.
461
01:02:53,490 --> 01:02:57,810
Here we see her with her emblem out of the wheel.
462
01:02:57,810 --> 01:03:01,950
Now you're up. Tomorrow you'll be down. And the fragile bubble.
463
01:03:01,950 --> 01:03:12,630
And, of course, a venturesome ship going off to sea with uncertain outcome the SEC rules aim to anticipate.
464
01:03:12,630 --> 01:03:25,200
The Russa's of Fortuna, by building variability into their very formulation, the thin rules aim to defeat Fortuna once and for all.
465
01:03:25,200 --> 01:03:35,010
Giving her no quarter. So let me conclude these two episodes from the history of Rules of Romania, the thick,
466
01:03:35,010 --> 01:03:40,410
supple rules of the early modern arts and the third rigid rules of 18th century Paris
467
01:03:40,410 --> 01:03:50,300
police highlight a contrast between two very different visions of what a rule can be.
468
01:03:50,300 --> 01:04:01,190
For practitioners of the mechanical arts like Dura and many other early modern authors of books that reduced practise to an art rules were flexible,
469
01:04:01,190 --> 01:04:06,800
necessarily so whether the subject was carpentry, cookery or siege warfare.
470
01:04:06,800 --> 01:04:13,760
Unexpected particulars might at any moment ambush the universal rule.
471
01:04:13,760 --> 01:04:23,170
In contrast. The rules on regulations ordained for 18th century Paris.
472
01:04:23,170 --> 01:04:27,490
This is once again guilt imagining what it would be like to have regular facades,
473
01:04:27,490 --> 01:04:36,220
house facades in Paris all facing the same way for these for these rules.
474
01:04:36,220 --> 01:04:42,850
A rule has to be rigid, and it has to be freestanding for the lieutenant of the Paris police.
475
01:04:42,850 --> 01:04:49,420
A rigid rule expressed a bureaucratic ideal in which regulations foresaw all
476
01:04:49,420 --> 01:04:57,010
eventualities and were obeyed as automatically as a driver today stops at a red light.
477
01:04:57,010 --> 01:05:02,200
This vision of a perfect rule goes hand-in-hand with a vision of a perfect order in
478
01:05:02,200 --> 01:05:08,470
which Parisians never invent a new way of evading prohibitions against lace and games,
479
01:05:08,470 --> 01:05:14,200
or if they do, the tight web of police surveillance will catch them in the act.
480
01:05:14,200 --> 01:05:19,960
All of
the rule makers knew all too well this was not the world in which they lived.
481
01:05:19,960 --> 01:05:30,340
The sheer number of times that the Parisian ordinances were reissued and the increasingly hysterical tone of their Prologis speak volumes
482
01:05:30,340 --> 01:05:41,170
about what historian Annette FAJ has described as the stubborn resistance of the people of Paris to new regulations and unwavering attention,
483
01:05:41,170 --> 01:05:48,850
vigilance and judgement on the part of the police inspectors made up for the failure of the thin
484
01:05:48,850 --> 01:05:58,090
rules like the return of the repressed Aristotle's ancient problems of universals and particulars,
485
01:05:58,090 --> 01:06:05,260
and the seasoned judgement needed to cope with particulars crept in through the back door.
486
01:06:05,260 --> 01:06:14,770
If these examples put you in mind of the thousands of human invigilators hired by Facebook to patrol
487
01:06:14,770 --> 01:06:22,360
paste postings of unsavoury content that the algorithms were supposed to eliminate automatically,
488
01:06:22,360 --> 01:06:29,260
your associations would not be amiss. The dream of the perfect rule In this case,
489
01:06:29,260 --> 01:06:38,410
the algorithms developed by the Facebook programmers has not relinquished its grasp on the imagination of the rule makers.
490
01:06:38,410 --> 01:06:43,480
On the contrary, the dream has turned febrile and contagious.
491
01:06:43,480 --> 01:06:53,860
Those ubiquitous utopias and dystopias of algorithms for everything from stocking your fridge to finding your mate to writing your next book.
492
01:06:53,860 --> 01:07:04,060
My point is not that digitalisation should somehow be minimised as something less than a revolution.
493
01:07:04,060 --> 01:07:10,420
I do think it is a revolution comparable to the print revolution of the early modern period.
494
01:07:10,420 --> 01:07:21,250
My point is rather that there's nothing new about the dream of a perfect rule all encompassing in its scope and merely automatic in its execution.
495
01:07:21,250 --> 01:07:32,290
No historian can resist a delusion that refuses to die, no matter how often it is buried with a stake through its heart.
496
01:07:32,290 --> 01:07:36,580
Why just the dream of the perfect rule endure?
497
01:07:36,580 --> 01:07:45,040
It's worth noting that although this dream is long lived, it is not eternal, nor is it necessary outside of logic,
498
01:07:45,040 --> 01:07:55,000
it's very difficult to find examples before the 17th century, even in the mathematical disciplines of these kinds of rules.
499
01:07:55,000 --> 01:08:03,790
But already in the early 18th century, especially in the context of modernising cities, aspirations rise.
500
01:08:03,790 --> 01:08:07,900
A girl policed city is not simply a safe city.
501
01:08:07,900 --> 01:08:13,210
It is an orderly city in which the streets are broad and straight.
502
01:08:13,210 --> 01:08:17,740
The houses are numbered and all face the same way.
503
01:08:17,740 --> 01:08:21,220
The night blazes with a thousand lanterns.
504
01:08:21,220 --> 01:08:30,670
There's a fire department that arrives on time, carriages are licenced and the carriage drivers no longer menace pedestrians.
505
01:08:30,670 --> 01:08:36,610
Residents dispose of their trash at the appointed time and place.
506
01:08:36,610 --> 01:08:47,800
It took almost 200 years for Parisians to internalise these norms, and these norms were always fragile as repeated street uprisings testify.
507
01:08:47,800 --> 01:08:57,880
What's important for my purposes is that partial success nourished hopes of complete success.
508
01:08:57,880 --> 01:09:06,640
It was the relative orderliness of early 18th century Paris with its first broad boulevards,
509
01:09:06,640 --> 01:09:16,530
as opposed to the spaghetti tangle of mediaeval streets that encouraged Quiet and his fellow police officers to press for more regulations.
510
01:09:16,530 --> 01:09:20,190
Of more aspects of urban life, in short.
511
01:09:20,190 --> 01:09:31,320
Promises made on behalf of the perfect rule were backward rather than forward looking like the algorithms that emerged from machine learning.
512
01:09:31,320 --> 01:09:36,510
They extrapolate from the known past to the unknown future.
513
01:09:36,510 --> 01:09:44,580
And just like past dreams of perfect rules, they do so from highly selective examples of the known past.
514
01:09:44,580 --> 01:09:54,660
Those parts, which are the most regular, the most stable, the parts that offer most encouragement to the vision of the perfectly orderly,
515
01:09:54,660 --> 01:10:02,130
perfectly stable, perfectly transparent world required for perfect rules to work.
516
01:10:02,130 --> 01:10:11,400
Under these circumstances, it's not surprising. Projects for perfect rules should fail with such dismal regularity.
517
01:10:11,400 --> 01:10:18,810
What cries out for explanation is their emergence and, above all, their astonishing persistence.
518
01:10:18,810 --> 01:10:29,310
The historical conditions under which such dreams first emerged offers us a clue in certain pockets of the world.
519
01:10:29,310 --> 01:10:38,370
Few, but prominent life really was slowly and fitfully becoming more predictable.
520
01:10:38,370 --> 01:10:48,870
The Parisian police visionary quiet effectively believed that he had solved Aristotle's problem of fitting universal rules to particulars.
521
01:10:48,870 --> 01:10:58,560
He didn't succeed, not by a long shot, but partial success in this context and others was enough to keep the dream alive until today,
522
01:10:58,560 --> 01:11:07,500
where it has been rekindled by machine learning. The visionaries of machine learning effectively believed that they can solve another
523
01:11:07,500 --> 01:11:13,530
philosophical problem Hume's problem of induction for the algorithms to work.
524
01:11:13,530 --> 01:11:23,940
The future must, in a strong sense, be like the past. It is the temporal version of Aristotle's problem of universals.
525
01:11:23,940 --> 01:11:33,690
David Hume spent most of his own life in some of these pockets of partial regularity Edinburgh and Paris.
526
01:11:33,690 --> 01:11:43,590
And since David Hume, it's been axiomatic that induction assumes that tomorrow will be like today and yesterday.
527
01:11:43,590 --> 01:11:49,350
Hume's problem makes the contingency of induction explicit.
528
01:11:49,350 --> 01:11:57,840
My aim has been to show that historical contingencies can alter even what a rule is.
529
01:11:57,840 --> 01:12:06,990
The history of the dream of the thin rule the perfect rule suggests that, like Aristotle's universals,
530
01:12:06,990 --> 01:12:14,460
even the axioms of induction might hold only under certain historical conditions.
531
01:12:14,460 --> 01:12:19,740
Thank you for your attention.