TRANSKRIP 🔗
Welcome to episode 11 of Travelling Science
[Music]
G'day Legends, welcome back to Traveling Science
The podcast that's sharing science with the world!
My name is Jesse Crowe and I'm The Travelling Scientist
Coming to you today from Vancouver in Canada
I'm a health science communicator and on this podcast we interview
researchers, doctors and experts, hearing their stories and sharing their ideas
That can help you to live a smarter, happier and healthier life!
This week's guest is a professor of mathematics and a cyber security expert Professor Asha Rao and she's here today to teach us how to be smarter and safer online Asher is also passionate about getting more people involved in stem which stands for science technology engineering and Mathematics and she especially encourages more females to get involved in those fields Professor Rouse not only a role model in the world of stem but she's also lovely to talk to she has so many little bits of Life advice and cute little stories and by the end of our discussion I just kind of wish that she was my mum you know sorry Mom during our conversation she answers questions like why you need to change your passwords what's the difference between spam and a scam why you shouldn't post photos of Children online what to do if the prince of Nigeria emails you and are our smart devices spying on us and we also discuss topics like malware phishing scams cookies iot people watching sharing and the remarkability of our brains but before that I'd just like to quickly share a review of the podcast with you and this week's review comes from Wild espororio 1749 who said bro I love the triple effect that you're having positive health education positive Charity donations and creating a positive Community well bro thank you for the review I always appreciate getting positive feedback like that it makes my day and if you're listening now and you like what I do or you want to make me smile you can leave a review as well on Apple podcast that would be incredible I truly appreciate it and I could be reading it out on next week's episode but for now let's get into this week's interview and learn all about cyber security with the one the only Professor Asha Rao Professor Asha Rao welcome to traveling science thank you Jesse lovely to be here it's an absolute pleasure having you thanks for taking the time I just like to start by asking you what exactly did you study at University and why did you study that okay so my bachelor's degree in India was physics chemistry and Mathematics so because that was the options you either did physics chemistry mathematics or you did chemistries zoology botany now I did love biology I still love gardening and I loved dissecting stuff other than cockroaches I think that was the only one I didn't like oh you had to dissect cockroaches yes how did I said cockroaches I said that was in year 11 and 12. and yeah so of course when I did my physics chemistry maths I the reason I did it was maths came
Load full transcript
easier to me and then I remember people saying oh my I just find it easy and I thought no that's not correct actually from about I think from for as far back as I can remember I would do maths again the problems again and again so even in you know when I did my masters years later I would do every every problem or every theorem because mine was a pure maths master's degree every theorem Thrice once when the when this teacher was doing it second time to practice and third time before the exam so you know I found Matt's easy because I put a huge amount of effort doing it it never felt like work because I kept doing it you know and there were lots of Hard bits but I kept doing it fantastic so what you're saying is that you if even if you're not necessarily born with the mathematics skills you can learn it through working hard at it perseverance yes if you think of pianos or you know the matildas they didn't get there by starting yesterday no they didn't you don't get anywhere by starting yesterday no it takes lots of work and effort cool and then after university did you you moved to Australia is that correct no no so what happened is I got married I had a kid and then I did my masters four years later in mathematics and while I was doing my PhD that's when we moved to Australia so I'd I'd finished my PhD I submitted my thesis in two years as I also say it's amazing what the brain is capable of when you have a deadline so the Australian immigration had given me a deadline and to meet that deadline I submitted my thesis in two years wow that sounds like a real fast track PhD I wish I could do that yeah and what it has given me is insight and how to help my students you know when people say it's it's difficult and I always say it's and it is amazing what the brain is capable of so just trust yourself two years she did her PhD in two years most people take three years minimum many people take four or more years she did it in just two with a child I am now Asher is a professor of mathematics at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology where she's doing some pretty important stuff so what I'm doing now is a lot of research in a number of areas mathematics and also basically the mathematics behind cyber security and anything else the risk management of cyber security how to make it safer for small and medium businesses how to deal with the post-quantum world that we are going into you know how to secure all those Internet of Things devices how to improve gender in cyber security what sort of impacts does this have for us as a society in the future like is it sort of uh working on stuff like AI or security or what sort of things we're working towards let's get it to a great extent is what I work on little bits of AI come in because you know when we're trying to secure things we are getting so much of data how do you tell that a signal that is coming is actually malware so malware stands for malicious software and it's basically a file or a code that can
infect your technological devices and do a whole bunch of bad things things like viruses spyware Trojan horses these are all types of malware that can do a lot of damage if we're not careful so that's where the AI the machine learning comes in how do we use machine learning uh to to address security because one of the major problems we have and as you would know the spam we get so much of spam and one of the things that I have realized over the last few weeks itself is that we we classify things as either phishing which is where there is a link you click which will then disturb your security or a Spam is but much of the spam is actually a scam and there is no software no way that the spam is divided into scam and spam so spam is essentially unsolicited communication usually emails for erectile dysfunction but they can also come through as text messages and phone calls and they're usually just trying to get you to spend money a scam is when someone is trying to steal your money or perhaps valuable information which they then use against you to steal your money but a Spam scam is when they do both they offer you something you want you try to get it and then they just screw you over big time spam scams be careful out there and that's when I realized this is the major problem you know Australians lost three billion dollars last year to scams three billion just in Australia just last year I'm not really what you would call a religious person but Jesus one of the major things is the over 2022 there have been more money lost and more scams through the phone now why is that it's because there is a human at the other end as opposed to when you get an SMS text you can easily either block it delete it whatever so I do remember getting a call you know this was just after we had gone into lockdown so I think June 2020 the person rang me and said you know on my home phone and said that there was a why there was a problem there was malware in my compute laptop and I needed to give them access and I said no I didn't engage I didn't say why I just said no I'm not giving access the person got really angry with me saying that I was not trying to protect my computer I was not trying to protect the company data and I feel like they definitely called the wrong person like if all the people they could have spoken to you were like the expert in preventing this from happening but what it told me also was I realized why people fall for it what would you do if you're not an expert you don't understand how for example your company deals with these things or you you know you have not done it before or you're just you know somebody on your own laptop and the person starts scolding you started scolding me and I said no and I I did I disconnected because I knew the procedures for MIT so rmit is the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology and they have their own online security system which is why Asha knew that she was being scammed unfortunately we all don't have our own online security team so if somebody calls you up and asks for access to your computer just hang up on them but how do you stop these people threatening are grandparents our older uncles and aunts that is an excellent question and that's what you're working on now you're working on Research in ways that we can prevent these scams from happening ABS absolutely that is what I'm trying to think of and what I say and the other thing is that these people do is they they tell you not to tell anyone because you know they they put it on some sort of this is very secret at the increased paranoia and I suppose that's a method of getting the scam to work for a bit longer as well if people don't know about it it's more likely to spread and work on more people in the long run I I have a theoretical scenario for you they say there's a young couple in their late 20s or early 30s and they've just had their first child and they're posting photos and videos on Instagram Facebook online everywhere I'm not really thinking too much about any security access or anything like that what are the potential ramifications or long-term issues that could arise from that sort of behavior how do I put in my mind boggles when I see this I see it on Twitter I see it on Instagram I see people taking a picture of the child's birth certificate and I say you have now set your child up for identity theft for the rest of your life you know we have deep fakes has you have has the child given you permission to do this probably not that's right so your truck people are trusting you and you shouldn't as far as possible keep your personal information personal there is no need to share it with the rest of the world the the birth certificate is an interesting one I'm not sure why you would post that but I understand the desire to want to share photos of loved ones with the world I think the term is called sharonting have you heard of this yeah no I haven't I haven't that's a new one thank you sharonting the practice of parents publicizing sensitive content about their children on internet platforms don't be a Sharon don't be ashamed the concern that we're facing now and in the future is the ability of AI to generate copies of people with you know with a photo or two and with a small snippet of their voice and we should all be careful of what we are sharing what we are doing absolutely to bring it back to the this theoretical scenario though it can happen with anybody like my mum for example bless her posts photos of me online and obviously I post photos of myself online anyway and YouTube and everything but I I guess the idea is that with all that stuff out there photos and videos that can be used in bad ways if it's not kept secure is that correct yes absolutely absolutely they can use because you know that's how scams happen because it starts with one and then they're trying to build the profile so then there is you know and I look at it and I think there's way too many pictures of myself
out there yes but you know let's protect the younger generation I don't know if if you if I had the choice I'd probably not put anything on what certainly not birth certificates or any forms like that yes birth certificates um there was a passport photographs which I think a lot of people wouldn't but more importantly boarding passes Tony Abbott got caught with a boarding pass wow yeah and he's a pretty important guy to especially for identity theft that's right and he just said here's my budding pass I was like okay now I know your date of birth I know when you're traveling yes I know a whole bunch of stuff if you don't know Tony Abbott was an Australian prime minister who was famous for eating an onion like an apple look it up it's hilarious but it turns out that he also got hacked because he posted a photo of a boarding pass on his Instagram this guy was our prime minister so marvelous story is don't be like Tony Abbott don't eat raw onions and don't post pics of your plain ticks that rhymes sweet I've got another theoretical scenario say you've got roughly 100 different accounts across various applications Netflix bank accounts investing whatever else and you've got one password genius or insane insane insane I know people use password generators and stuff like that in you know we what we what you need to remember are the passwords you use on a regular basis the ones you don't often you can just reset it you know that feeling when you go to log into something and it's been like six months since the last time and you just have no idea what the password was or even the criteria for the password like is there capitals is there numbers is there special characters and then what special characters do you use do you go for the classic exclamation mark maybe with the dollar symbol or do you mix it up something like the percentage sign or a good old Ampersand well probably don't waste your time just reset the password doing this I was recently able to log back into my MySpace account from the mid-2000s would not recommend going back to Myspace It's haunting just reset it if you're going to use it once a year I know everything and and one of the reasons I don't like to do online shopping is one easier to create an account and do then they spam you and keep spamming you you buy one vacuum cleaner they spam you with every vacuum cleaner how many vacuum cleaners does a person need it's like I've already got one vacuum cleaner that's the one I wanted I've got it so leave me alone absolutely um is password hacking is that common is having a super basic simple password dangerous oh that's very dangerous it's very dangerous because it's you know it's very easy to crack you don't have to be very ingenious to have a more difficult password so at all better still two-factor authentication and not with sms use an authenticator app so authenticated apps are becoming more popular now because they only work from your own device so assuming that you haven't had your
phone or laptop stolen in the last 10 minutes you and only you will be able to use the authenticator app to prove that it is you trying to log into your bank account your dating app or whatever the hell you're trying to log into this is always with you ever transmitted remember when you get an SMS it's being transmitted across maybe an open Channel but if it's an authenticator app then you already have it and your phone has not left your hands Professor asherao saving us from all of the spam and the scams out there
yes trying to you mentioned a couple of books that you've read I wonder if you have any book recommendations for our listeners anything to do with say cyber security or the or the modern state of where we're at any particular books jump out so that is Bruce schneier's secrets and lies it's a very old book so maybe back uh sometime in 2000 four or five something like that quite old that's not that old I'm talking remember the the younger you know those born in the 2000s it's like oh that was before I was born so I I clarify these days yeah but yeah Bruce Nair's secrets and lies is a really good book so secrets and lies by Bruce schneier spelled s-c-h-n-e-i-r was originally written in the year 2000 and it teaches you about security Technologies their capabilities and their limitations so if you're interested in cyber security get this wherever you get books just be aware that the television series also name secrets and lies which follows detective Andrea Cornell as she investigates a series of homicidal cases great series but totally unrelated to the book just FYI if you if you can stay awake the first one of the first books I read was David cons the chord Breakers k-a-h-n that is from the 1960s I think or maybe even earlier it talks about encrypt of basically cryptography from the beginning so it goes back to to before Caesar it talks about everything and the the best thing I liked about it he talks about how the Enigma was broken and the second world war all right so this book is old it's from 1967 and if you're from 1967 don't worry you're beautiful but this book talks about the history of cryptography from ancient Egypt up until 1967 which includes the story of cracking the Enigma code during World War II but that was also depicted really well in the movie Imitation game definitely check that out if you haven't seen it and if you have watch it again but anyway we're talking about David Khan's book The co-breakers yes I tell my students get that book it's usually in the libraries and read it at bedtime because it'll do two things it'll increase your knowledge about cyber security and it will send you to sleep right that is great advantages of reading books which send you to sleep two birds with one stone okay so I just had to cut a huge section of our conversation here because we just started talking about our favorite books fiction versus non-fiction paperback versus Kindle can you blame me she's just such a pleasant human being and
she did suggest that we should all go to the library more and if you've never been check it out because you can usually find just about any book you want to read and just borrow it and read it for free anyway somehow our conversation got into embroidery and uh well I'll let the professor finish that story that's that's right often I find I remember I do a lot of embroidery as well so I used to I used to live you know further away from the city and around the train I would sit and embroider stuff and you know I remember people would come up to me and say oh don't worry you will finish it and I'm like I'm not worried for me it's the journey so I always feel sad when a book is finished because it's the journey I prefer the Journey of reading not the ending I mean the ending is nice yeah sometimes I love what you were saying before about enjoying the journey as well I think that's a good metaphor for for life as well you know some people are always waiting to or or just can't wait for the next big thing but you've got to enjoy every moment I know most of the time when I'm walking I love walking I am more often having earphones on you know but most of the time I just like to look at people and especially when I travel I don't like to have my earphones in because I want to see people and you know one of the things I've realized no matter where you go in the world people are the same I people watch I you know people watched in the Greek Islands have people watched in Canada I love to go for a long walk and you know it's not like I sit there and stare at people but I'm just watching it's like oh this is very similar to the people in India and in in Australia in the US everybody's the same we're all doing the same stuff there may be different shapes and sizes but other than that in the past few years Professor Asha Rao has been named one of the superstars of stem in Australia and she was added to the Victorian on a roll of women for her work inspiring younger generations to get involved in the fields of science technology engineering and maths and she's trying to break down gender barriers and get more females involved in stem so I asked her to speak a bit about that oh absolutely women are half the population we it's amazing challenges facing facing so one of the
one of the girls are told that they are not good enough and the craziest research shows that girls are turned off from mathematics because they are primary school teacher is turned off mathematics it's it's really crazy you know the primary school teacher feels uncomfortable and anxious and so consequently that anxiety for some very strange reason is passed on to the female students not the male whether the teacher is male or female doesn't make a difference so what I'm trying to say is you know basically what I try to tell people is that and especially girls I go out and talk to year eights and nines a lot is that everything takes work never listen to anybody who says you're not good enough if
somebody says you're not good enough don't believe them how do they know how do they know you're not good enough you know do they have access to your brain cells that's that's the thing and I'm just looking at some something somebody put up yesterday and they said oh I thank this these people to giving me the chance and I was like you are good enough don't ever think that somebody is giving you a chance they are only giving you you did good girl yeah you go for it all right this is for the men as well it's not just you know a lot of people who are uncertain girls more than men so yeah so that that's what I try to do is you know all the things I have learned you know that you know it's amazing what the brain is capable of so let it let it take over and let it do its job absolutely and yeah if you're interested in anything like learning more about science technology engineering mathematics anything like that don't be deterred if you're if you're not incredible at it yeah you don't have to be persevere you know just keep working at it and you will improve inevitably we'll all improve our brains like you said our brains are incredible that's that's right and you know all of these you know Pavarotti and everybody they didn't get there without practice practice and more practice that's what we need absolutely uh Professor Asher I've got a few listener questions for you if you would like to answer those but before that every week here on traveling science we make a donation to a charity of the guest choosing and this week Asher has chosen to donate to the Australian mathematical Sciences Institute or amsi which focuses on advancing and strengthening all areas of mathematics education in Australia helping more young people to get involved in the world of maths so a donation has been made to amsi on behalf of Professor Asha Rao and if you'd like to make a donation to them as well you certainly can or if you'd like to support this show and the Charities that we contribute to every single week you can certainly do that as well and it will be truly appreciated either way both those links are in the show notes just down below and now let's get back to traveling science first one here is from Anala Cooper she wants to know are we being spied on like the you know the cameras in our laptops or the the microphones in our phones is it possible for people to tap into those and actually spy on us is that happening or is that just a big rumor no it probably is happening you need to be careful do you have uh you know anti yeah you know there could be spyware so spyware is the type of malware that installs itself on your computer and then tracks and monitors your online Behavior without you even realizing it is your is your computer protected laptop protected what I would be more worried about is your TV have you got a smart TV I do I actually don't I travel around a lot hence the name traveling science but I just decided to lie to her to keep the conversation rolling
you know have you got a smart TV have you have you made sure that the default is not that it is on all the time I think it's I think it's off but I'm not sure how how off it is yes so that's the whole thing is I do remember a few years ago Samsung was caught where everything was just being recorded oh wow yeah people having conversations so you know my I I think it was about a few quite a few years ago that you started getting these automatic devices which you switch off your TV completely at the at the plug that's probably a good idea and especially if you have a fridge your smart fridge what is that doing a smart microwave to these kitchen the kitchen appliances that have microphones can they you can talk to them as well they have yeah yeah because you can talk to them you can you know iot everybody's uh going under the iot of things and Bluetooth look you probably already knew this but embarrassingly I didn't so iot stands for internet of things because so many things hooked up to the Internet nowadays we all know about our laptops our phones Smart TVs but here are some smart things that are connected to the internet that you might not have known about smart fridges smart microwaves smart toasters smart water bottles smart light bulbs smart cars not the really small ones actual internet Cars Smart irons smart vacuums smart clocks smart shoes smart teddy bears smart picture frames smart coffee machines smart baths smart toilets smart toothbrushes smart rubber duckies even smart pot plants these can all be connected to the internet and most of them you can speak to which means most of them could be listening right now they could be listening to this to you freaky yep The Internet of Things why do you need to talk to your fridge are we getting so I suppose it's it's it's looking at the progression where you reset you know we had to get up and we had to change the channel on the TV now we have a remote now we don't even want to use the remote we want to use voice commands we are being spied on we are we are forget being spied on we are we are handing out data by the by this paid full true you mean just based on everything we're doing online like the sort of things we're searching for and information we're inputting into certain websites that's right you know voice commanding your TV but I feel like we have to do that almost it's almost like an age we live in where if you don't do that you can't have access to to so much that so many people take for granted yeah so that's things of the have security to certain extent iot is less that was one of the hot research topics because the problem with technology is that it goes much faster than we can react to it so it used to be you know you buy a laptop don't ever buy the latest one if you're buying Electronics don't buy the latest one buy one off because it's cheaper and it has been tested right just to finish off on that question is the idea that if someone was listening like companies were recording down the information the conversations is it so they could advertise to you like you hear the story that someone was talking about flying to Italy and then they'll get offered flights to Italy on their phone 10 minutes later is that a coincidence no that's could be happening no it's not a coincidence yep it is definitely happening it's definitely happening freaky it is freaky it is very freaky and I remember uh you know most of the time what happens is if you have your you know if you have your email open so talking of a laptop you have your email open and then you do a search for flights to Italy the the browser you know the what do they call it the cookies cookies are bits of data from websites that get stored in your web browser so they can remember what you've been looking at and then they can Target specific content and advertisements to you in the future the cookies are saved and then the cookies basically will talk to each other they remember and then Google if you're doing your search on Google Google that tells you oh you know you wanted flights here are some flights there you go all right I hope that answers your question and now B Dixie is wondering is it important to change passwords regularly for important applications like say your bank is important to change passwords often or is it better to just have one very good password that you keep the same it's it's good to change passwords but at this point definitely wherever you can multi-factor second Factor authentication get the authenticator app almost every every Bank does Authenticator apps or restricts what you can do you can restrict what you can do yourself yeah and I I think that's great advice second Factor authentication I'm sure a lot of people think that that's very annoying to to put up with but when you think about what you could potentially be protecting yourself from losing a lot of valuable information potentially losing a lot of money I'm happy to take a few extra seconds to authenticate when I'm trying to log into something like that yeah and also trying to minimize exposure of things like records so you know using say for example maybe PayPal or something like that instead of putting your credit card into every single uh into every single you know online shopping use something else so there is there is what I prefer to call is a single point of failure because you can then attack it immediately you know that that is the place and yeah so the worry is not just that they're taking information the worry is are they protecting it because uh I have another question from Pigeon Shepherd and apple V wanted to know how safe are we and what's the best way to protect yourself from getting hacked say on social media um one advice I give to most people is pause before you click okay take a moment take a moment you know often what happens is we are in a rush it happens to me as well but that's that's the whole thing take take a moment and think should I be clicking on this at
all if you are on social media people then use social media it's a very good use I know from Twitter I've learned a lot of recipes so what do you then do is you want to buy something go into a browser and type the thing in don't link to a website through Facebook or Twitter don't buy you can go you can have a look you can walk off but do it through something else or maybe you can just go buy it in a store elsewhere that would be yes that is what I prefer to do as I prefer to see and look and feel okay so if at any point online you're concerned just just take a moment if you're not sure about something just take a moment and maybe think of another way that you can access the information you're looking for or the product you're looking for fantastic thank you so much for answering those listener questions and just to finish off I've got the lightning round yes roughly six questions 60 seconds and time starting now you get an email from the prince of Nigeria offering you money do you open it no there's no such thing as free money good just testing you there all right a little more serious if you could do so if you could have done something completely different with your life like say you never got into mathematics for example what do you think you might have done I wanted to do medicine for years I wanted to do medicine awesome good good answer what do you love most about researching and teaching cyber security and Mathematics what do you love most about it the fit with students you know you will some some student will turn up maybe a year maybe and I remember some student turning up to me you know when we had masks in lockdown and she can say do you remember me you taught me and yours was the only class I made a point of attending because you expected me to be there that'll keep me going for another four years and research it's also you know my it ideas marinate in my brain it's it's this that entire world in here and and research allows me to tap into that world try and figure out some answers what's what's your least favorite part about uh cyber security and Mathematics what do you hate about it what I don't like about teaching I would say is students I just wish students would pay attention but then they wouldn't be students would they um hit about it I love every bit of it even the bits that make me crazy true it can be tricky if you had unlimited funding where would you like to see that money spent reducing homelessness well that's very honorable putting money towards homelessness fantastic and last question do you have a favorite mathematics principle yes it is it's been what I've realized is you know the quadratic equation ax squared plus BX plus C is equal to whatever D or zero that one I found that you know the more research I do in this big problems and they they come down to the quadratic equation always comes back to that equation
okay oh Professor asherah thank you so much for being here today you've done incredible things for the world of mathematics and cyber security and also influencing and inspiring many people to get involved in stem so we thank you again for coming on the show today and I'd just like to finish with one final question if you have one last piece of advice for our listeners perhaps something they could take home and act on to improve their lives in some way what would your final bit of advice be it would be let ideas marinate in your brain don't have to solve things immediately just think about it you know while you're on the toilet or cooking because the brain is amazing it will come up with answers and I know mine comes up with answers at 3am I wish I would stop doing that but that is the that's the you know you really understand what what is there what is possible what is possible just letting it marinate think of something and just idly think of things just let one idea just sit there and know it it's like a like a rodent but in your brain
so there you have it legends that was mathematician and cyber security sensation Professor Asha Rao and wasn't she just awesome like so humble yet so inspiring and she kept reminding us that our brains are truly extraordinary and if you think you might be interested in science or mathematics engineering something like that but you're worried that you might not be smart enough think again with a bit of determination and perseverance you can learn and improve at just about anything also plenty of great technological advice like get better passwords or better yet use a two-factor authentication system to prevent your password from getting hacked also don't click on suspicious stuff online just take a moment and take a breath before you click that thing and end up filling your computer with viruses don't post photos of small children online or if you do make sure they're secure and can't be seen by complete random strangers and definitely don't post photos of personal documents online that's just asking for identity theft come on finally if you have Smart devices in your home and most of us do make sure you whisper or make sure the security settings are appropriate or that they're just switched off completely before you go sharing your secrets with the world anyway it was a fun interview with a great guest and I really hope you enjoyed listening to Professor Asha Rao and if you did you can follow her on Twitter at Asha Rao rmit you can also find her on LinkedIn and make sure you subscribe for more traveling signs every single week and follow traveling science on Instagram to see who we're interviewing next and there you can also send in your own listener questions finally if you're more visually oriented feel free to check out the traveling scientists YouTube channel and if you stick around to the end of the episodes I always leave you with a little secret and this week's secret is that I was once naked in the Himalayas true story I was actually hiking up there in 2016 with a couple of really good friends and I lost a bet to my brother and the deal was if I lost this bet I would go and get naked out in the mountains and so there we were nearly 5 000 meters above sea level and I had to take off all my clothes in a space where no one could see me but then I had to get my friend Charlie to come out and take a photo of my bear butt in the Himalayas as evidence unfortunately about a week later I actually got that camera stolen so I never got to send that photo to my brother so he doesn't believe that it happened he doesn't believe that I was naked up in the mountains of langtang national park in Nepal but it happened it's in my memories Charlie was there he saw it and I suppose randomly there's a Nepalese guy out there who's got a naked photo of me up in the hills so good for him anyway thanks so much for listening Legends I'll catch you next time Sunday cheers