TRANSKRIP 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:06] Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:10] Adam UrbancZyk is the principal attorney at AU LLC,
[0:13] a Chicago-based law firm focused on intellectual property
[0:17] litigation, e-commerce disputes, and helping businesses
[0:21] protect their brands in a rapidly evolving marketplace.
[0:25] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today Adam and I
[0:27] are discussing temporary restraining orders,
[0:30] TROs, in Amazon seller losses.
[0:35] Hi, Adam.
[0:36] Hi, Sean.
[0:36] How are you doing?
[0:37] I'm doing well.
[0:38] I'm doing well.
[0:39] I mean, I think everybody within earshot of us
[0:42] has done some business with Amazon I'm guessing.
[0:46] I'm interested in the fact that there's specific,
[0:49] I don't know if it's rules and regs around Amazon specifically,
[0:52] but let's get into, like, why is it?
[0:54] Or what is a temporary restraining order?
[0:57] And why is it such an important part of so many Amazon seller lawsuits?
[1:03] In general, of course, we need federal law, TROs come under rule 65.
[1:10] So temporary restraining orders and preliminary junctions
[1:12] are both under the different components of rule 65.
[1:15] In the context of schedule A lawsuits,
[1:17] most of them include a request by the rights
[1:21] older for temporary restraining order at the outset of the case,
[1:24] at least simultaneous with the opening of the case,
[1:28] along with filing the complaint, or it might take a couple of days
[1:32] for the case to be assigned to a particular judge
[1:34] and then the rights older might bring that motion
[1:38] pursuant to the particular judges' standing order
[1:41] and requirements about what to do with motions.
[1:44] But the point of it is that it could be considered exparte
[1:49] that is without the defendants being aware of it
[1:52] or knowing about it without notice.
[1:56] In the schedule A context, the utility of that
[2:00] is, well, the defendants are going to be located overseas, primarily.
[2:06] Primarily, occasionally you'll have a US seller
[2:09] that is roped in as one of the defendants.
[2:13] But by and large, the defendants are overseas, mostly from China.
[2:18] But they're not going to have any commercial presence
[2:22] physically in the United States or have any assets
[2:25] that are reachable by any order or judgment in the United States,
[2:30] except for the funds that are being
[2:33] withheld by the platform's merchant account.
[2:36] OK.
[2:37] So in order for the rights holder to be
[2:41] able to conduct an accounting of the defendants' profits,
[2:45] that's going to have to be frozen.
[2:47] That's going to have to be restrained.
[2:48] And it's extroordinary relief under the rule, which
[2:52] is, which is true, most cases don't include requests
[2:56] by the plaintiff for a TRO or preliminary injunction.
[3:00] In the IP context, I think it's much more common.
[3:04] I think much of the criticism about schedule A suites
[3:08] is based on the fact that relief under this rule 65
[3:14] is invoked so often.
[3:17] But it's like, well, the nature of the rights
[3:19] are such that when they are infringed,
[3:22] the harm is going to be more presumably
[3:25] irreparable because once the genies out of the bottle,
[3:28] how do you put it back in?
[3:29] Yeah, right.
[3:30] Very, very generally.
[3:31] So and the defendants are going to be located overseas,
[3:35] and they're going to be in the position
[3:37] to to visionate or sign the rights holder's ability
[3:41] to seek the relief that's otherwise
[3:43] going to be entitled to seek under rule 65
[3:46] and that judgment.
[3:47] OK, so it's kind of part and parcel.
[3:50] I mean, it would be something you, as a rights holder,
[3:52] you just would do, unless there is some other issue
[3:57] with the evidence collection.
[3:59] For example, we've brought cases where
[4:00] we're not seeking a temporary restraining order.
[4:03] Like the evidence is a little bit older.
[4:05] It wouldn't really support an argument
[4:07] that the plaintiff is going to suffer a irreparable injury
[4:11] because the evidence that we're relying on is too old.
[4:15] So we're just whether that's seeking a TRO.
[4:17] If we ask the court for a lead to conduct some expedited discovery,
[4:21] the courts are usually amenable to doing that.
[4:24] That we send just an order to the platform
[4:27] that allows us to get some information about the defendants
[4:29] and then we kind of proceed that way.
[4:32] That's probably the minority of schedule A cases.
[4:36] It's at least 85% of schedule A cases
[4:38] include a temporary restraining order.
[4:40] So it's common.
[4:43] It's the prevailing way to conduct them,
[4:46] but they don't all utilize them.
[4:50] What's the distinction that they're asked for?
[4:53] The TRO comes in at the very beginning
[4:56] of one of these schedule A lawsuits.
[4:58] Is it just for that freezing of assets and such?
[5:04] Yes.
[5:05] The alternative would be.
[5:07] And Amazon has, I think, generally a 14-day turnaround
[5:12] to disperse funds and an account.
[5:19] If you don't get that at the outset,
[5:21] if you open up a schedule A case and it's public, nothing sealed.
[5:28] So that your complaints up there, the name of the plaintiff,
[5:31] identification of the rights ad issue, the PAMS,
[5:34] the copyright registration, the trademark that's ad issue,
[5:37] that's all public.
[5:39] Within about 36 or 48 hours, that's
[5:41] going to be information about that dispute
[5:44] and those rights being enforced is going to be proliferated,
[5:48] particularly overseas and some seller
[5:50] communities that are letting everyone know.
[5:53] You've said in previous episodes
[5:55] that they've got people watching and monitoring
[5:57] these kinds of filings, right?
[6:00] Yes.
[6:01] And so then I'm going to go, if I know something's happening,
[6:04] I'm going to go, I'm going to
Load full transcript
pull my money out.
[6:07] Yes.
[6:08] And you can see it in some instances
[6:12] where you weren't seeking a TRO for one or more reasons.
[6:15] You know, by the time the defendants are sort of a process,
[6:19] most of those accounts are going to be cleaned out,
[6:22] which the decisions are made about cases like that
[6:26] for one or more reasons.
[6:28] But you could see that there'll be some staggering number
[6:34] of sales and there's $30 in the account.
[6:40] It's like, well, it's gone.
[6:42] I mean, it was in there at some point.
[6:44] I suppose.
[6:44] Yes.
[6:45] I know whether the plaintiff would be entitled to it
[6:47] for one or more reasons might be something else,
[6:49] might be a different question.
[6:50] But you see the open the door.
[6:53] You're in Al Capone's safe or whatever.
[6:57] And there's just like crumbs and papers everywhere.
[6:59] Yeah, there's nothing in there.
[7:00] But something was in there at some point.
[7:02] Sure.
[7:03] The utility of the TRO, of seeking a TRO,
[7:07] the outside of the case is readily demonstrated
[7:10] by anyone who's been involved in this tail litigation
[7:13] for a free any amount of time.
[7:15] Well, what does it allow the court to TRO?
[7:17] Oh, yeah.
[7:18] What does the TRO actually allow the court to do?
[7:22] Are there, is it, and that can't be unlimited, right?
[7:26] It's not.
[7:27] It'll be, you know, the forms that the TRO take,
[7:31] that TROs take and schedule a cases are from judge
[7:37] to judge court to court type of case,
[7:40] the type of case patent to copyright.
[7:43] They're all very similar.
[7:44] There will be a general like a first section
[7:48] that is prohibiting the defendant's affiliates
[7:54] from infringing, you know, basically taking acting
[7:57] in some way that is infringing the rights that are at issue
[8:00] in the case, there will be some requirement
[8:04] that the third party service providers,
[8:07] like the platform or banks, credit card processors,
[8:10] things like that, restrain certain funds,
[8:13] disable advertising that involves the accused products.
[8:19] Now, the scope of the asset restraint
[8:21] is very often litigated.
[8:24] I mean, after personal jurisdiction issues,
[8:27] like the number one source of motion practice
[8:29] for scheduling cases is probably attacking this scope
[8:33] of asset restraints that are being applied.
[8:36] So at the outset, a rights holder might ask the platform
[8:42] to restrain all of the funds that are in a particular
[8:46] defendant's account irrespective of what those sales are.
[8:52] Now, you know, going into the case,
[8:54] you're not going to know what the defendant's sales are
[8:56] in particular item.
[8:59] Oh, I mean, you might, you can,
[9:02] you might be able to ballpark based on reviews.
[9:06] Yeah.
[9:07] If you're on Amazon and you have tools like helium,
[9:10] and there are some like jungle scout
[9:11] and some other tools that can give you an estimate
[9:15] based on their statistical analysis
[9:18] of how different asins move or are sold on the platform,
[9:23] they might be able to give you a ballpark
[9:24] of what the sales might be.
[9:27] But it's not going to be very accurate.
[9:28] So most of the time, we'll play to full ask
[9:31] that the platform to freeze everything.
[9:35] Now, if the defendant is selling 100 products,
[9:39] one of them is being restrained like one asin.
[9:42] It doesn't make sense that all of the funds
[9:45] are going to be in that account as a result
[9:47] of the sales of that one asin.
[9:49] Now, with a straight face, a raceholder can say,
[9:52] I don't know what's going to be frozen.
[9:55] If it's a particularly hot item,
[9:57] 95% of a defendant's sales might be the one accused,
[10:02] the one accused, everyone's selling,
[10:04] you could have a defendant that selling nicknacks
[10:07] and then air Jordans.
[10:09] Well, if the air Jordans are going to be what,
[10:11] the sales of the air Jordans that are fake
[10:13] are going to be comprising most of the money
[10:16] that the source earning, exactly what that dollar is.
[10:21] The right-holder, the plaintiff,
[10:22] is going to know at the outset.
[10:23] So they're generally going to ask to freeze everything.
[10:26] The defendant, when they have the funds frozen,
[10:29] can march to court or march to the plaintiff.
[10:32] I was going to have to see, listen.
[10:33] Can they go, can they, do they have some rights
[10:36] to go and petition the court, I guess, to say,
[10:39] hey, please free up some of that money.
[10:43] Or absolutely.
[10:45] As a plaintiff, it's your evidentiary burden
[10:49] to establish the basis for all of the relief
[10:53] you're seeking under Rule 65.
[10:56] You're going into the case with screenshot
[11:01] or test purchase evidence that the defendant
[11:03] is selling accused products, OK.
[11:05] Then, as far as the scope of the essay was shared specifically,
[11:10] once the platform gives the expedited discovery back
[11:14] as a component of its obligations
[11:16] under the temporary restraining order,
[11:18] it's going to show, OK, this particular ace
[11:20] and had this many units of sales,
[11:22] this many units for this GMV gross market value.
[11:28] Then, they're also identified the balance of the account.
[11:31] There'll be some delta there.
[11:32] Sometimes, the sales will be way more than what's in the account
[11:36] because the defendant cleaned the account out randomly
[11:39] before he heard about it.
[11:40] Yeah, it just happened, right, he's probably going on.
[11:45] But if you're sitting there and you have,
[11:48] sometimes we'll have clients on the defense side
[11:50] that have 50, 100, 200, up to a couple million dollars
[11:57] in different accounts that are restrained
[12:00] for selling a handful of things.
[12:03] Which obviously does, importantly, you can't maintain
[12:09] an asset restrained for these large
sums just
[12:12] because the plaintiff is trying to get
[12:14] a large statutory damage remedy.
[12:15] It has to be tied to the defendant's profits
[12:19] as a result of the accused item.
[12:23] So you can start with what the revenue is, basically.
[12:27] Here's the revenue we sold, $40,000 of fake air Jordans.
[12:32] And, well, we only made $2,000 in profit.
[12:37] Well, really, the $2,000 should be the extent
[12:41] of what is feasible on a free judgment basis.
[12:46] Now, that's going to be argued over in the plaintiff
[12:48] is going to say, well, the profit margin
[12:50] is artificially low because you're, that's
[12:53] the subject of the motion practice.
[12:55] But generally, the court, a court
[12:56] is going to be very receptive to the defendant's
[12:58] showing up to say, hey, they froze all this money.
[13:01] We sold three of these things.
[13:03] I can't access this capital.
[13:05] We need this to buy inventory.
[13:07] XYZ, and in the courts are usually very responsive
[13:11] to hearing those disputes.
[13:14] And, you know, very often, the defendant and their counsel
[13:19] will be able to negotiate some agreed asset restraints.
[13:23] We'll just come do a number like, OK, well,
[13:25] to save the time of, you know, briefing this out,
[13:29] let's just say $5,000.
[13:31] Yeah.
[13:32] And that might be more than what ultimately
[13:34] would be restraintable after motion practice in the time.
[13:37] But just for the sake of moving the defendant
[13:41] and resolving it through settlement,
[13:43] probably, that's what often happens.
[13:46] Yeah, that makes sense.
[13:48] What do you, you know, what have you come across,
[13:50] you know, with clients, like misconceptions, you know,
[13:54] like what are some of the biggest misconceptions businesses
[13:57] have about temporary restraining orders?
[14:02] One, there might be a misconception
[14:04] that you can't do anything about it.
[14:07] Ah, right.
[14:08] As we were just discussing, right?
[14:11] Yeah, they can be attacked.
[14:13] I mean, it's a temporary restraining order,
[14:16] emphasis on temporary.
[14:17] It's good for 14 days, right?
[14:20] Now, if you're the defendant, you'll hear about it,
[14:26] maybe 36 to 48 hours after it's actually entered by the court.
[14:32] So the plate of file is its motion.
[14:35] The court enters it, say, at lunch on Tuesday.
[14:40] The plaintiff's counsel gets it, probably that same day
[14:42] will send it to the platform's point of contact
[14:45] to handle temporary restraining orders
[14:48] and judgements, the fault judgements, the things like that.
[14:50] It's going to take the platform probably 24 hours
[14:55] or 36 hours to actually implement it.
[14:58] And then depending on how front facing
[15:02] you are with your storefront as a defendant,
[15:04] you may not realize that things are frozen.
[15:06] And you'll get an email from the platform saying,
[15:09] like, hey, we're restraining your account.
[15:11] We got this legal notice.
[15:13] And here's the plaintiff's attorney.
[15:15] And here's the case number.
[15:17] You'll get that.
[15:18] So you'll see that's three days after the fact.
[15:23] The TRO is good for 14 days total.
[15:25] The plaintiff can go in and get an extension of that.
[15:28] Usually, there's not too much of a problem
[15:29] because they're still waiting on discovery
[15:31] from the platform.
[15:34] You can't show up.
[15:35] And if there's a problem with the plaintiff's argument,
[15:38] if, for example, you were selling authentic product
[15:41] or there is a problem with the evidence is too old
[15:45] to really support.
[15:47] When we're dealing with scheduled cases,
[15:49] there's usually a threshold, a number of defendants.
[15:53] The evidence that the court is relying on
[15:56] is pretty voluminous.
[15:59] When the plaintiff files this motion
[16:01] for entry of the temporary restraining order
[16:02] and expedited discovery, it'll be supported
[16:05] by evidence in the form of a declaration
[16:07] from the plaintiff's representative that'll have exhibits.
[16:10] And those exhibits are going to be usually
[16:11] hundreds of pages of long because they're
[16:13] going to comprise screenshots of the product listing
[16:17] showing the infringing character, the trademarks
[16:22] and the product title or the product description.
[16:25] They'll show pictures of the product.
[16:26] And maybe if there are test purchases of the product
[16:31] they'll have pictures of the product
[16:33] showing that it was in fact shipped into the jurisdiction.
[16:36] Here are the product features.
[16:38] And then here's a claim chart if we're talking about a patent
[16:41] case.
[16:42] So the court's going to be looking at hundreds
[16:44] and hundreds of pages of things.
[16:46] And certain details can be missed.
[16:49] Like day stamps and a screenshot showing
[16:52] that actually this evidence is two years old.
[16:55] That's a problem.
[16:56] If you're the rates older to establish that,
[16:57] actually there's an issue with the rubber winjury
[17:01] if the plaintiff waited that long to bring the case
[17:02] and seek the relief.
[17:03] That's something that's the defendant you can bring up.
[17:05] Yeah, you're still in there as the asset
[17:08] and strain issue too that we just talked about that.
[17:10] Right.
[17:11] At the outset everything might be frozen
[17:13] but you can march back into court and say, listen,
[17:16] you know, we're the infrigi character of the product's aside.
[17:20] Even if they were infringing at the moment,
[17:22] plaintiff is in a tells of to restrain more than 50 bucks
[17:26] which is what we made on these two rams.
[17:28] So, and then the defendant will introduce
[17:32] their own evidence of the sales,
[17:35] a screenshot of the balance on the account
[17:38] supported by a declaration.
[17:40] And there's lots of case law now in most of the due to,
[17:45] most of the federal courts in which this stuff happens
[17:47] that a defendant can reliably go
[17:49] and get that restraint back down.
[17:52] Got it, got it.
[17:54] Well, let's see, we got like two minutes left out.
[17:56] I wanna ask one more question.
[17:59] What, you know, what can businesses do
[18:02] before dispute comes up to reduce the likelihood
[18:05] of facing a TRO?
[18:07] Like are there some two or three best practices
[18:10] that they should be adhering to?
[18:13] I don't know if there's anything,
[18:15] if there's anything a defendant or a seller rather,
[18:19] a prospective defendant can do specifically
[18:24] to avoid the impact of a temporary restraining order
[18:28] versus just being involved in the litigation at the outset.
[18:31] I mean, if you're selling products that are,
[18:39] that are infringing a rights holders
[18:41] intellectual property rights for one or more reasons,
[18:43] either you're in the listing title,
[18:45] you're using their protected trademarks,
[18:47] or you're using their photographs to sell some product
[18:50] or the widget you're selling is infringing the patents,
[18:54] or the plaintiffs' patents.
[18:57] You're at risk of being involved in the dispute.
[19:00] And then most of the time those rights holders
[19:03] are going to be seeking the relief for the reasons we discussed.
[19:07] They'll probably think that you're located overseas
[19:09] unless they're careful and they're doing the right thing
[19:13] if they look you up.
[19:14] If your seller account says,
[19:15] I'm located at 123 Main Street in Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
[19:19] and they go to the address and there's your bill.
[19:21] I mean, I like to think that you're not going
[19:25] to be involved as a defendant in that case.
[19:28] They might bring suit against you independently,
[19:31] which raises other challenges, obviously too,
[19:34] because I guess if you're here in the United States,
[19:38] you can't reveal yourself of a personal jurisdiction argument
[19:40] or a service of process argument, really,
[19:43] but you're here and your stuff is here
[19:46] and the plaintiff can enforce its judgment against you here.
[19:49] Presumably, you're not moving to Mexico
[19:51] or living on a beach to avoid or whatever.
[19:54] I mean, don't sell so much in Ohio.
[19:58] It doesn't much how do I avoid a TRO?
[20:00] How do you avoid being involved in the litigation
[20:02] and the disputes in the first place?
[20:05] And I think that we talked about in previous episodes,
[20:08] it's being very careful where you're
[20:09] sourcing your products, there are tools available to help
[20:14] make sure, don't use images if you find online.
[20:18] Right.
[20:19] I'm trying to say products, take the photos yourself,
[20:22] write the comments, make sure this stuff is authorized
[20:25] so that you can be very wary of pulling anything off
[20:29] of 1688.com or Alibaba or Aliexpress,
[20:32] they're getting you overseas, if at all possible.
[20:36] Yeah, I think that, I think that's most of it.
[20:38] That's 85% of the solution right there.
[20:40] Yeah, yeah, yeah, I get it.
[20:43] Well, listen, we're out of time
[20:44] and always a lot to cover and none enough time to cover it,
[20:47] but as always, great chat.
[20:49] Thanks for sharing your expertise
[20:51] and I look forward to seeing you on a future episode.
[20:54] Yeah, my question.
[20:55] That's it for this episode of e-commerce IP report.
[20:59] If you want to learn more about Adam's practice
[21:02] and his firm, visit their website AU-LLC.com.
[21:07] As always, we appreciate your listening.
[21:09] If you found this information helpful, leave us a thumbs up.
[21:13] Maybe write a review, subscribe,
[21:15] so you don't miss a future program.
[21:17] That's always helpful.
[21:19] I'm Sean O'Connor, have a great day.
[21:24] Thanks for watching.
[21:26] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button
[21:28] and leave us a review in the comments.