TRANSKRIP 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:04] Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:10] Adam Urbanczyk is the principal attorney at AU LLC,
[0:14] a Chicago law firm focused on intellectual property litigation,
[0:18] e-commerce disputes, and helping businesses protect their brands
[0:22] and are rapidly evolving marketplace.
[0:25] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today Adam and I are discussing
[0:28] how companies enforce their intellectual property rights
[0:31] against counterfeit products.
[0:33] Hi, Adam.
[0:34] Hi, Sean. How are you doing?
[0:35] I'm doing great.
[0:37] You and I have spoken quite a bit on here about IP violations
[0:43] and what to look out for and all of that,
[0:46] so I know this will be a slightly deeper dive in.
[0:50] When you're practice with clients,
[0:53] once a business discovers counterfeit versions of its products,
[0:58] what legal options are available to stop them?
[1:02] I think the options can be disambiguated a bit.
[1:08] There are legal options. There are practical options.
[1:11] There are administrative options.
[1:13] There are more formal, less formal versions of those,
[1:18] so it's a bit of a matrix determination.
[1:21] If, for example, you are a brand owner
[1:25] and you are selling your own products in e-commerce on Amazon
[1:29] or per day, or your own website, or your own storefront,
[1:34] and say you notice there is a single product listing on Amazon
[1:40] for some product that is using your brand in the product title.
[1:46] It's one storefront.
[1:48] The accused product is something different,
[1:54] the seller is using your term in the product list thing,
[1:58] but you did provide that authorization for them to use your brand,
[2:02] your trademark.
[2:03] Do you race to court and sue that part?
[2:08] Probably not.
[2:10] I mean, litigation is going to be the last resort,
[2:18] although that can be last in some context
[2:22] because you don't have another choice.
[2:24] But there could be an informal resolution to something.
[2:29] Often infringements are,
[2:32] maybe most of the time,
[2:34] intellectual property infringement is the result of a misunderstanding
[2:38] or maybe just a lack of appreciation for the propriety
[2:44] or the exclusivity of a certain term or a certain technology
[2:49] or a design or artwork, I guess,
[2:53] in a more negligent sense.
[2:54] Lots of time, you know, it's 2020-60,
[2:56] people are still downloading images off the internet
[2:59] and using those for their own purposes,
[3:01] and then wondering, you know, what did they do?
[3:03] Right, it's like we can't do that.
[3:05] We shouldn't do that.
[3:06] So if you're the prototypical claimant,
[3:10] did you see a single instance of a sort of innocuous infringement
[3:17] of your trademark or your design patent,
[3:21] or your copyrighted work or something?
[3:23] Do you race to court probably not?
[3:25] The easiest thing to do would be to perhaps
[3:28] send the infringer a note on the platform.
[3:32] Say, hey, this is me.
[3:35] I own the rights to such and such trademark
[3:37] or such and such work or such and such patent.
[3:40] And I've noticed your selling this product.
[3:43] Here's the hyperlake to it.
[3:45] And I'd reviewed this,
[3:47] and this is infringing on my rights.
[3:50] So please take it down.
[3:52] And that might solve the problem that easily.
[3:56] That's the low hanging fruit easy scenario.
[4:01] The infringer responds.
[4:04] There's been a big misunderstanding.
[4:06] They had no idea there.
[4:08] I they just thought your trademark was some basic word
[4:12] for what they thought the product was
[4:14] or they heard it from somewhere.
[4:16] They didn't know anything better.
[4:18] They were very sorry.
[4:19] They won't do it again.
[4:20] And then they make the adjustment in their own
[4:22] seller platform.
[4:23] You can see the bark removed.
[4:25] And that's fantastic.
[4:26] That's great.
[4:27] On the other side of the coin,
[4:30] you have a situation where
[4:32] you wake up one day and there are
[4:35] a dozen or two dozen
[4:38] ambiguously named storefronts
[4:41] or there's an entire website that
[4:43] appears to have been there for some time
[4:46] but you've never heard of it.
[4:48] And they're clearly selling lots and lots of products
[4:51] under your trademark.
[4:53] You can't identify who they are.
[4:55] I mean, very typically,
[4:57] these pop up retail websites
[4:59] for clothing.
[5:00] It's a very common thing.
[5:02] They will have terms of service privacy policies
[5:05] or some perfunctory documents on their website
[5:08] that don't identify who the seller actually is.
[5:11] They're kind of drafted and big duosly.
[5:13] They just refer.
[5:14] They don't refer to any particular party
[5:16] or legal entity or anything.
[5:18] So you're left wondering who it is.
[5:20] In that situation, what do you do?
[5:23] Maybe there's a contact email or maybe
[5:26] the website has an IP enforcement process.
[5:31] Is that going to be robust
[5:33] and actually legitimate and effective?
[5:35] You don't know, but maybe it's worth reaching out.
[5:38] So you're sending them a
[5:41] less formal, more formal,
[5:43] but let me know.
[5:44] No, didn't email.
[5:45] You could send a bit of the
[5:47] attachment as opposed to identifying what the problem is
[5:50] and then seeing what they do.
[5:52] Does it go anywhere?
[5:54] If it's just, you know, info at website.com.
[5:57] Who know, you know, it's just,
[5:58] you may be sending it off into the ether.
[6:00] But maybe it's worth an attempt.
[6:02] Even if it's not successful,
[6:04] you don't get a response back.
[6:05] You know, the fact that you're reaching out
[6:07] in a deputy contact this infringing party
[6:10] and they're not complying with what you're doing,
[6:13] that could be used, you know, in the event of some litigation
[6:15] as some form of evidence that what they're doing is willful
Load full transcript
[6:18] or there's some reckless disregard for the rights
[6:20] you're trying to enforce.
[6:21] You're praising them of,
[6:22] you're giving them notice if the assets
[6:25] that we didn't have noticed before,
[6:26] that hey, these are my rights.
[6:28] This is my trademark.
[6:29] I own this patent.
[6:31] Your products are infringing it.
[6:33] Please stop.
[6:34] You could say please or you could use
[6:36] more threatening language if you want or you could hire an attorney
[6:39] to pay for that a bit more with some legal authority
[6:42] and a nice recitation of the remedies available to you
[6:45] if you decide to go through the litigation.
[6:48] And, you know, if that's not successful,
[6:51] you're back to the last resort, which is litigation.
[6:54] And then in other situations where you have a suite of
[7:00] online retailers who just aren't identifiable
[7:03] and they're like pop-up shops,
[7:06] they're churning through products
[7:08] and you notice your sales are just, you know,
[7:11] cratering or falling off a cliff in some very short period of time.
[7:14] There's very much a strategy that sellers use.
[7:18] Not necessarily or categorically,
[7:21] but they're just trying to infringe your trademark rights.
[7:23] But lots of products are just popular for short
[7:26] amounts of time.
[7:28] So something gets hot,
[7:29] there's a wave,
[7:30] everybody glams on to the trend
[7:32] and they want to sell as much as possible until
[7:35] the site gets moves on to the next
[7:38] stuffed animal or whatever it's going to be.
[7:41] So this sellers are just trying to capitalize
[7:44] literally on this short window.
[7:47] And they think that can cause a lot of damage
[7:49] in a short amount of time.
[7:50] So in that situation,
[7:52] do you want to go through a more informal,
[7:55] casual process?
[7:56] Maybe not.
[7:57] Maybe there,
[7:58] if you're suffering enough,
[8:00] you know, if there's a threshold of injury,
[8:03] or suffering financially,
[8:05] if it's a certain amount,
[8:07] then I guess maybe you are ready to court.
[8:09] Maybe you're getting some evidence
[8:11] preparing a complaint and seeking a temporary restraining
[8:16] or to sort of stop the bleeding before it gets too bad.
[8:19] You know, when you send that first letter like,
[8:21] hey, man,
[8:22] don't know if you know this,
[8:24] but this is my problem.
[8:25] You know, you're infringing how long do you wait
[8:28] for a response before you escalate?
[8:31] Do you think what's reasonable?
[8:33] Maybe a week.
[8:34] And that's,
[8:35] that that's contemplating the complete spectrum of,
[8:41] you know, allegedly,
[8:42] allegedly infringing parties.
[8:44] The parties who just didn't know any better
[8:46] or the ones who know exactly what they're doing.
[8:49] Everyone, you know,
[8:50] we're in a 24-7 cycle.
[8:52] Everyone's staring at the computer all day.
[8:55] Infriguing parties very often,
[8:57] if they are,
[8:58] if bridging parties
very often are going to be located
[9:00] on the other side of the world in 12 hours ahead.
[9:02] So,
[9:03] it's not like,
[9:04] and you would expect to read a,
[9:06] be receiving responses when you're sleeping,
[9:08] at least if you're in the United States.
[9:11] So, maybe a week is enough time for emails
[9:15] to kind of circle through.
[9:16] And then,
[9:17] if they don't respond to you,
[9:19] then that,
[9:20] that might be,
[9:21] you know,
[9:22] it's less likely that an email is just going to be hung up
[9:24] or it's going to be misinterpreted,
[9:26] or the party you're sending it to,
[9:28] is it going to have enough time to go through it
[9:31] or it's going to be caught in a span filter,
[9:33] or something like that.
[9:34] So, maybe a week is a reasonable amount of time
[9:38] before you take some next steps.
[9:40] No, that seems relatively quick to me.
[9:43] Like, okay.
[9:44] You know,
[9:45] we gave you a week,
[9:46] and now,
[9:47] heads up,
[9:49] taking it to the next level.
[9:50] So,
[9:51] and that's even,
[9:53] and when you're sending an initial,
[9:55] no,
[9:56] and you could be very direct,
[9:58] as in you're just,
[9:59] identifying the,
[10:01] the, the,
[10:03] the offenders email address,
[10:05] maybe it's posted in their online storefront or something,
[10:08] and you're just directly sending them an email.
[10:11] Depending on the platform you're,
[10:12] you're,
[10:13] you're using,
[10:14] or you're,
[10:15] or that's at issue.
[10:16] The platform can have its own administrative tool.
[10:18] So, there's like the,
[10:19] the direct,
[10:20] extremely basic reach out
[10:22] and let them know that you have a problem with what they're doing.
[10:26] The next step,
[10:27] I guess, you know, formalizing the dispute further,
[10:29] from there,
[10:30] and before litigation,
[10:31] would be using some platform tool.
[10:34] So, Amazon, eBay,
[10:36] they will have,
[10:37] you know,
[10:38] platform tools by which you identify their infringing content
[10:41] to the platform,
[10:42] and then the platform,
[10:43] reviews it,
[10:44] and then take some action.
[10:45] They'll,
[10:46] they'll inform the other party that,
[10:48] hey, they received this infringement notice,
[10:50] they say you're infringing some trademark,
[10:52] or under the DMCA,
[10:53] you're infringing their,
[10:54] or copyrighted,
[10:55] you have this amount of time
[10:56] to either stop,
[10:57] you can,
[10:58] they can respond with a counter,
[10:59] and then often,
[11:01] it puts it back into your position
[11:03] to have to escalate the situation further.
[11:05] That could be the next thing to do too,
[11:07] or you could do both at the same time.
[11:09] You could send them a note directly.
[11:12] You know,
[11:13] the receiving party,
[11:15] whenever you're submitting a platform dispute,
[11:17] the platform is going to keep a log of the disputes
[11:21] against the particular sellers.
[11:23] That can be a bit of a pain point.
[11:26] So often what you'll see is,
[11:28] you send the DMCA notice,
[11:30] you send the trademark notice,
[11:32] the seller comes back,
[11:34] apologizes, says they'll stop,
[11:35] and then we'll ask the complaining party
[11:37] to retract at the complaint,
[11:39] because if that,
[11:40] that can, you know,
[11:41] corrodes the seller account,
[11:43] and at some threshold,
[11:47] if a seller has too many of these strikes,
[11:50] the platform could just shut them down
[11:51] and take all their money.
[11:54] Pursuant to their own terms of service,
[11:56] that generally will let them do whatever they want,
[11:59] under almost any circumstance,
[12:01] including deciding that they're going to shut you down,
[12:03] to take all of your money,
[12:04] and exchange for some nebulous liquidated damages,
[12:09] for the reputation being injured or whatever.
[12:14] You know, if a business successfully proves its IP rights
[12:20] have been infringed,
[12:22] what remedies are typically available?
[12:24] Well, if we,
[12:25] if a dog you litigation,
[12:27] and the dispute out of necessity has got to the point,
[12:32] sooner or later,
[12:33] to where the complaining party is filing a lawsuit,
[12:35] a complaint,
[12:38] you know, trademark infringement
[12:39] or copyright infringement or patent infringement.
[12:41] But those acts are going to prescribe
[12:43] what remedies are available,
[12:45] under the copyright act,
[12:46] to resume simply for copyright infringement,
[12:49] you'll be able to get your damages,
[12:51] get injumped to relieve,
[12:53] you can request to receive the defendant,
[12:55] you know, the profits that the defendant has received
[12:57] from the infringing conduct,
[12:59] conduct,
[13:00] under certain circumstances,
[13:02] you'll be able to get attorneys fees,
[13:04] if you're the prevailing party,
[13:05] if you win,
[13:06] you can petition the court for attorneys fees,
[13:09] and then there's a statutory remedy
[13:11] under 17 U.S.C. 504C,
[13:14] that is usually the long teeth in the demand
[13:16] because in the statute,
[13:18] the wording of the act,
[13:20] that section, it says,
[13:21] you know, up to $150,000 per work in French,
[13:25] is the remedy.
[13:26] Now,
[13:27] it would be interesting to dig
[13:29] through pastured A to D to C,
[13:31] of all copyright infringement,
[13:33] you know, statutory damage awards
[13:35] at any conduct,
[13:36] at any context,
[13:37] whether it's a trial,
[13:38] some rejudgment,
[13:39] whatever,
[13:40] how many of those are actually
[13:41] the full $150,000 per work,
[13:43] is probably not too many.
[13:46] I think after the,
[13:48] the large amount of copyright infringement litigation,
[13:51] overfile sharing,
[13:52] seven years ago,
[13:54] I think most courts,
[13:57] in most contexts where there's,
[13:59] eight,
[14:00] there's like one work being in French,
[14:02] it's an image,
[14:03] or it's a song,
[14:05]
or there's a character,
[14:07] like what,
[14:08] you know, without some,
[14:10] probably significant proof from the plaintiff's side
[14:14] that it would have to introduce,
[14:16] as the value that's being taken,
[14:19] or appropriated by the infringer,
[14:22] you know,
[14:23] the court is going to be awarding some,
[14:24] you know,
[14:25] mid-for-figure amount,
[14:26] low to mid-for-figures,
[14:28] something like that,
[14:29] if it's just, hey,
[14:30] there was some one work,
[14:31] this is the internet,
[14:32] yep, it's infringement.
[14:34] Yes.
[14:35] You know, the work was registered
[14:37] before the defendant was infringing.
[14:38] Like, okay.
[14:39] Here's your statutory remedy.
[14:41] And then in some courts
[14:43] are going to be,
[14:44] are going to be defaulting to lower amounts,
[14:46] and they're going to be starting at, you know,
[14:48] at a minimum,
[14:49] and then enforcing the plaintiff
[14:51] to ratchet up in sort of a quasi-proof up,
[14:54] why it's statutory remedy should be higher.
[14:58] Despite the fact that, you know,
[15:00] part of the point of the statutory remedy
[15:02] is supposed to be a deterrent.
[15:04] So in the future,
[15:06] the defendant,
[15:07] the same defendant
[15:08] and then other parties,
[15:10] stay away from infringing the work.
[15:12] I mean, theoretically, right here,
[15:13] it's like if you were getting hit
[15:14] with 150K fine,
[15:16] you might not mess with that IP again.
[15:19] That's right.
[15:20] And then on the other hand,
[15:22] you know, the court is in the business
[15:24] of awarding windfalls.
[15:26] And there's lots of argument over the,
[15:29] you know, the scope of what those types of awards would be.
[15:32] And similarly with,
[15:33] with trademark claims under the Lanham Act,
[15:34] you can ask for whatever game
[15:36] as you've suffered,
[15:38] what the,
[15:39] what the defendant's profits were
[15:41] as a result of the infringement conduct.
[15:43] There's a statutory remedy there too,
[15:45] that goes up to $2 million,
[15:48] which are huge teeth in a demand.
[15:50] But again,
[15:51] of all statutory damage awards,
[15:53] whether it's at default,
[15:55] summary judgment, trial,
[15:57] what is the, you know,
[15:58] what is the all-time average number
[16:00] of that award?
[16:01] That would be a good data dive
[16:03] to figure that out.
[16:04] But in the context of e-commerce,
[16:07] we're just, we're selling widgets on Amazon,
[16:10] whatever, you know,
[16:12] some product that is going to show up at your house on a box.
[16:16] What is that award going to be?
[16:20] Maybe it's, you know,
[16:21] 50 to 100,000,
[16:23] you know, larger brands are going to be able to command more money.
[16:27] So if it's a pair of our Jordans,
[16:28] it's going to be more,
[16:29] it's going to be a bigger number than if it's a taco source,
[16:34] maybe, which is a throwback example for some years ago,
[16:37] maybe my favorite one.
[16:38] Yeah, but like,
[16:39] the Disney's going to want to have somebody,
[16:42] even though they can,
[16:43] they can absorb the pain,
[16:44] they want to want it inflicted on others,
[16:47] and that might be, you know,
[16:50] playing fast and loose with Mickey Mouse.
[16:52] Absolutely.
[16:53] And the very large brands,
[16:55] you know, they're large companies,
[16:58] they're sort of going to have, you know,
[17:00] infinite money to enforce their rights.
[17:04] Is that enforcement a profit center?
[17:07] Probably not as much,
[17:09] but they just, they just want to,
[17:12] you know, swing their way to route
[17:14] and make examples out of everybody.
[17:16] So if you,
[17:17] if you get in trouble because you're selling,
[17:19] you know, fake envy,
[17:20] you know,
[17:21] fake Chicago Bulls jerseys,
[17:23] and NBA properties is coming after you.
[17:26] They're going to be,
[17:27] you know,
[17:28] outfits like that,
[17:29] no, NBA,
[17:30] like the professional sports teams,
[17:32] NCAA teams,
[17:33] like they,
[17:34] they, they don't negotiate very,
[17:36] very much,
[17:37] I at least said our,
[17:38] in our, in our experience.
[17:40] Smaller brands will,
[17:43] but the larger ones,
[17:44] I guess they don't have to.
[17:45] And, you know,
[17:46] they have these,
[17:47] these very powerful marks
[17:49] and rights that they can just draw
[17:51] very hard lines.
[17:52] So there's not going to be a lot of wiggle room with them.
[17:54] So yeah, there's,
[17:55] there's, there's,
[17:56] there's a spectrum of what awards
[17:58] are going to be rendered.
[18:00] And it's going to be based on, you know,
[18:02] this, this,
[18:03] this ultimate is going to be based on the scope
[18:04] of the defendant's activity.
[18:05] Did they sell just one thing?
[18:07] Did they sell zero?
[18:08] It's zero products,
[18:09] but they used a few images in the listing.
[18:12] Okay.
[18:13] Or,
[18:14] is there a,
[18:15] like a small factory in New Jersey
[18:17] and they're hammering these things out?
[18:19] And they,
[18:20] then there's going to be a,
[18:21] at some threshold,
[18:23] it's, it goes beyond compensation
[18:25] and it becomes more of a deterrent.
[18:27] And in the plaintiff,
[18:28] the rights holder is going to lean on that particular justification
[18:32] for large statutory remedies to,
[18:36] you know, to ask the court to hit the defendants
[18:38] with something a lot higher.
[18:39] We're,
[18:40] we're up against telling Adam,
[18:42] I want to ask you one final question.
[18:44] To the extent you're going to answer it, you know,
[18:47] sort of succinctly here.
[18:48] Is there, you know,
[18:49] a single thing or, you know,
[18:51] that what a business should do,
[18:53] you know, strengthen their ability to enforce their,
[18:55] their IP rights before a counterfeit problem comes up?
[18:59] The law is going to reward a rights holder
[19:03] for securing their rights as soon as
possible.
[19:07] So copyright, for example,
[19:09] is going to attack you.
[19:11] You create a work.
[19:13] It's original.
[19:14] You're the author.
[19:15] It's going to be protectable automatically.
[19:18] Now, your ability to enforce it is going to,
[19:20] it's going to require you to register
[19:22] if you're here in the United States,
[19:23] it's going to require you to register
[19:25] that work with the US Copyright Office.
[19:27] The sooner you do that,
[19:28] the sooner you avoid a situation
[19:30] where you wrote a book,
[19:32] you never registered it.
[19:33] You're selling it online.
[19:35] It turns out somebody else has been selling it.
[19:38] You, you have an infringement problem.
[19:40] You have to race, file an application
[19:42] with a copyright office,
[19:44] spend an extra $800 to expedite,
[19:46] you know, especially,
[19:47] especially handle the application.
[19:49] You sued them,
[19:50] but the fact that the,
[19:51] yeah, yeah, yeah.
[19:52] The fact that the infringement occurred after,
[19:54] or before I'm sorry,
[19:55] before the registration,
[19:57] generally,
[19:58] it's going to prevent you from seeking statutory remedies
[20:00] or attorneys,
[20:01] under Section 412.
[20:02] That's a significant problem.
[20:04] That, that seems to bite people
[20:06] in the bottle a little bit.
[20:07] Okay.
[20:08] Oh, I was going to say that's,
[20:09] I mean, that's a great place to stop
[20:11] in terms of our timing
[20:13] and just that idea,
[20:14] like,
[20:15] don't drag your feet
[20:16] when it comes to registering this stuff
[20:18] because if you do run into an issue,
[20:20] it'll be more defensible,
[20:22] as opposed to being reactive.
[20:26] Right.
[20:28] Whether we're talking about a protected work,
[20:31] if it's an invention,
[20:32] getting a patent application on file soon as,
[20:35] you know,
[20:36] as soon as practicable
[20:37] and then,
[20:38] from a branding standpoint to trademark standpoint,
[20:41] filing an application,
[20:42] it can be an intent to use application.
[20:44] You can be,
[20:45] if you're in development,
[20:46] you can be trademark registration pending sort of
[20:49] for about three years.
[20:51] So you can,
[20:53] and if you change your mind,
[20:54] the application is 350 per class.
[20:56] So you wouldn't have to forfeit too much
[20:58] if you just had to go in a different direction.
[21:00] But the sooner you get things filed
[21:02] with the US federal government,
[21:03] the better.
[21:04] Well, thanks, Adam.
[21:05] That's a great,
[21:06] great summary of a lot of complex stuff,
[21:09] but interesting to hear about
[21:11] and thanks for sharing your expertise.
[21:13] And we'll connect on a future episode, for sure.
[21:15] You can.
[21:16] That's it for this episode
[21:17] of the e-commerce IP report.
[21:19] If you want to learn more about Adam or brand-check,
[21:22] visit the website AU-LLC.com.
[21:26] Thanks for listening.
[21:27] And you know,
[21:28] we appreciate if you found it interesting,
[21:30] leave us a thumbs up,
[21:31] leave a review,
[21:32] or share this episode
[21:33] with someone in the world
[21:34] that you know is dealing with IP issues.
[21:36] Always helpful.
[21:37] I'm Sean O'Connor.
[21:38] Have a great day.
[21:39] Thanks for watching.
[21:44] Be sure to hit that like
[21:46] and subscribe button
[21:47] and leave us a review in the comments.