TRANSKRIP 🔗
Matter: Hi, I'm Dr. Dusty. This podcast lives at the intersection of science, medicine, and the human experience, exploring mind, body, and spirit medicine in real life. This space is about understanding the human experience and this one beautiful life we're living. I was on an airplane flying home after spending time with someone new in my life, someone who had become very special to me very quickly. And I was in that strange space between leaving and returning. You know that feeling? When you've just spent time with someone who matters to you, and now you're going back to your everyday life, but something feels a little different. The world looks the same. Your responsibilities are waiting. Your calendar is still full. But something inside you has shifted. And somewhere on that flight, I ended up having a conversation with another passenger. I don't know why some of the most unexpected conversations seem to happen on airplanes. Maybe it's because we're sitting beside complete strangers for hours. Maybe it's because there's something about being suspended thousands of feet above the ground that makes ordinary boundaries feel a little less important. Or maybe people just feel comfortable telling strangers things they'll never tell the people they actually know. Whatever the reason, this person asked me a question. If you knew you were going to die in three years, would you tell the people you love? Well shit, that's quite a question to ask someone at 35,000 feet. And it's one of those questions that sounds relatively simple until you actually try and answer it. Would you tell them? Would you tell your partner, your children, your parents, your closest friends? Would you sit down with the people you love and tell them that your time was limited? Or would you keep it to yourself? Would you want to spare them the fear, the sadness, the anticipation of losing you? Would you want them to continue living normally without the weight of knowing that every holiday, every birthday, every ordinary Tuesday might be one of the last? Or would you want them to know? So they could be there, so they can make memories, so they could ask questions, so they could say the things that might otherwise be left unsaid. And as I thought about that, I realized something. My answer might depend on which side of the question I was standing. Because there's a difference between asking whether I would tell someone I was dying and asking whether I would want someone I loved to tell me. I'm Doc Dusty, and this is Doc Dusty Reflections, a series within the Doc Dusty podcast where we explore the moments, experiences, And unexpected conversations that invite us to look at ourselves and the human experience a little differently. Today we're talking about a question a stranger asked me on an airplane, but we're also talking about love, about mortality, about protection, about the things we choose to share and the things we keep to ourselves, and about something I think we all struggle with at times. When we try to protect someone from pain, are we always protecting them? Or are we sometimes making decisions? That belongs to them? Imagine for a moment that you knew, not suspected, not feared, but knew that you had approximately three years left to live. What would change? Would you quit your job? Travel? Spend more time with your family? Would you stop worrying about the things that currently consume so much of your energy? Would you finally have conversations you've been avoiding? Would you love people? Regardless of logistics. Would you tell them that you love them? Would you forgive someone? Would you stop trying so hard to be everything everyone expects you to be? Or would you continue living much as you do now? Because here's something I find interesting. We often imagine that knowing we had limited time would radically transform our priorities, but I'm not sure it's that simple. We still have responsibilities, people who depend on us. Bills to pay, bodies that need care, relationships that are complicated, and sometimes the things we imagine we'd do if we were dying are the things we genuinely want to do right now. We just keep postponing them until the right time, until life settles down, until we have more money, until we're less busy, until we're ready. And I wonder why the possibility of death makes us suddenly more willing to consider the life we've been postponing. But let's return to the original question. What I tell the people I love. I can imagine wanting them to know, but I can also understand the desire to keep it private. Because once you tell someone you're dying, something changes. Not necessarily their love for you, but perhaps the way they look at you, the way they speak to you, the way they react when you don't answer the phone, the way they interpret your fatigue, the way they hold you a little longer when they say goodbye. Suddenly every ordinary moment. Chances becoming something extraordinary. Every conversation carries the awareness that there may not be many more. And maybe you don't want that. Maybe you want to laugh without someone becoming emotional because they're thinking about how much they'll miss your laugh. Maybe you want to be frustrated with someone without feeling guilty because time is running out. Maybe you want to have a bad day without it becoming a tragedy. Maybe you want to remain a person. Not a diagnosis, not a countdown, not someone everyone is already beginning to lose. And I think that's important. Because when we talk about telling the truth, we sometimes overlook what it might cost the person who has to live with everyone else's reaction. Now imagine the situation is reversed. Someone you love knows they have three years to live, and they don't tell you. You continue living your lives together, you make plans. You argue about something ridiculous. You cancel dinner because you're tired. You say you'll call tomorrow. You assume there will be another birthday,
Load full transcript
another holiday, another trip, another chance. And then eventually you find out. Maybe you discovered the truth near the end. Or maybe you don't learn about it until they're already gone. How would you feel? Would you understand why they kept it from you? Would you appreciate that they wanted to protect you? Or would some part of you feel hurt? Not because you believe you're entitled to every private detail of another person's life, but because you would have wanted the opportunity to be there, to love them through it, to ask what they needed, to have conversations that might never happen otherwise, to make choices about how you wanted to spend your time together. And maybe you'd be angry, not necessarily because they were dying, but because they made the decision about what you could handle. without allowing you to participate. And here's where their question becomes complicated, because both people may be acting from love. One person may withhold the truth because they don't want to cause suffering. The other may desperately want the truth because they don't want to lose the opportunity to share that suffering. Neither response is necessarily selfish. Neither is automatically right. In the very same direction can feel compassionate From one side and devastating from the other. That's what makes relationships so beautifully, frustratingly complicated. We don't simply love people, we also have ideas about what love is supposed to look like. And sometimes those ideas are very different. There's a distinction I think we need to explore: the difference between privacy and secrecy. We all have a right to privacy, even in our closest relationships. We don't lose ownership of our bodies, our experiences, or our thoughts simply because someone loves us. A person facing a life-limiting illness has the right to decide when, how, and with whom they share their diagnosis. They may need time to understand what's happening, to process their emotions, to consider treatment options, to make sense of a future that suddenly looks different. And sometimes they may choose not to disclose certain information at all. That's their decision. But secrecy can become more complicated when the information also affects the lives and choices of other people. Not because love gives us ownership of another person's truth, but because relationships involve shared experiences, shared plans, shared responsibilities, and decisions that may affect both people. So where does privacy end and the responsibility to communicate begin? I don't think there's one universal answer, but I do think it's worth examining our motivations. When we say I don't want to tell them because I don't want to hurt them, what exactly are we protecting them from? The grief, the fear, the sadness? Or are we protecting ourselves from having to witness those emotions? Because sometimes watching someone we love suffer is almost unbearable. We want to fix it, we want to make it better, we want to remove the source of their pain. And when we can't, we try to control what they know. But there is a difference between wanting to spare someone pain. And having the ability to prevent it. And sometimes, by withholding the truth, we aren't eliminating the pain. We're simply changing when and how it arrives. Of course, that doesn't mean disclosure is always the right decision. There are circumstances in which privacy is necessary, boundaries are important, and safety must come first. But in relationships where there's trust and mutual care, I think the questions become worth asking. Am I protecting this person? Or am I trying to protect them from having a human response to something painful? Because grief is not evidence that we've harmed someone by being honest, and sadness is not necessarily something love needs to prevent. Sometimes love means allowing another person to feel what they feel, even when we wish we could make it easier. There's a concept in psychology called anticipatory grief. It's the grief that can emerge when we know or expect that a significant loss is coming, and it's complicated because the person is still here. You can still talk to them, hold their hand, have dinner with them, laugh, make memories, and yet you're already grieving the possibility of losing them. Sometimes you find yourself imagining the future without them. Sometimes you feel sadness in moments that would otherwise be ordinary. Sometimes you're angry. Sometimes you're feeling guilty for being angry. Sometimes you become intensely aware of every passing day. And sometimes you feel completely normal. Because grief isn't a single emotion and it doesn't follow a predictable schedule. Now imagine living with that awareness for three years. Three years of knowing. Three years of loving someone while also anticipating their absence. Would that knowledge deepen your connection? Or would it make it harder to be present? Would you become more intentional? Or would you begin treating every moment as though it needed to be meaningful? Would you allow yourself to laugh, to argue, to be annoyed, to have ordinary days? Because here's something we don't always acknowledge. When we know someone is dying, we can begin placing enormous pressure on the time we have left. We want to make every moment count, every conversation meaningful, every experience memorable. But human relationships don't work that way. Sometimes love is sitting in the same room doing absolutely nothing. Sometimes it's laughing about something completely inappropriate. Sometimes it's being irritated because someone left their dishes in the sink. Sometimes it's a conversation about groceries or the weather or whether you remembered to feed the dog. And these moments matter too, maybe especially those moments, because intimacy isn't only about extraordinary experiences. It's also found in the freedom to be ordinary together. And I wonder whether part of loving someone through a terminal illness is learning how to hold
both realities, the awareness that time may be limited, and the permission to continue living within that time. Not every moment has to become a farewell. Sometimes dinner can just be dinner. I think there's another question hidden inside this conversation. What do we owe the people we love? Honesty, protection, the opportunity to make informed choices, the freedom to experience their own emotions, and what do we owe ourselves? Privacy, autonomy, the right to decide how we want to live, the right not to become responsible for everyone's grief. These questions don't always have answers that fit neatly together. And I think that's where some of our deepest relationship struggles come from. We want to love people well. But sometimes we confuse loving someone with deciding what's best for them. We withhold information because we don't want them to worry. We avoid difficult conversations because we don't want to upset them. We pretend we're fine because we don't want to become a burden. We make decisions on someone else's behalf because we believe we're protecting them. And sometimes we're acting with genuine care. But sometimes we're also removing their opportunity to choose to participate. To respond, to show us who they are when things become difficult. And I wonder how often we underestimate the people we love, not intentionally, but because we assume their pain is something we need to prevent, when maybe what they want most is the chance to be beside us, not to fix it, not to make it disappear, but simply to be there. There's a kind of intimacy that comes from allowing someone to witness us when we aren't strong. When we don't have the answers, when we can't make things better. And for many of us, that kind of vulnerability is far more difficult than offering support to someone else. It's one thing to say, I'll be there for you. It's another to say, I need you to be here for me. And maybe part of the difficulty in answering the airplane question is that it's asking us to imagine allowing ourselves to be loved when we can no longer protect the people we love from our own suffering. But there's something else about the question that I find fascinating. Why three years? What if it was three months? Would your answer change? What if it were 10 years? Would you tell them then? What if you knew you had only three weeks? And here's the uncomfortable part. None of us actually know how much time we have. We make plans as though tomorrow is guaranteed. We schedule vacations, we postpone conversations, we assume we'll see someone again. We tell ourselves we'll make more time when things settle. And most of the time that assumption is allowing us to function. We couldn't live every day in constant awareness of our mortality. That would be exhausting. But sometimes I wonder whether we become so comfortable assuming we have time that we forget to recognize what we're doing with it. We wait to tell people how much they matter. We wait to express gratitude. We wait to apologize. We wait to have the difficult conversation. We wait to take the trip. And we wait to say I love you. And I don't mean that we should live in constant state of urgency. I don't think every moment needs to be maximized. And I certainly don't think we should turn mortality into another reason to pressure ourselves into doing more. But I do wonder whether we sometimes need a reminder that the people we love are not permanent fixtures in our lives, and neither are we. Not to frighten us, but to bring us back to what matters, because sometimes that awareness that something is temporary doesn't make it less beautiful, it makes us more willing to notice it. And this is where I keep returning to the circumstance in which I heard the question. I was flying home from spending time with someone who had become very special to me, someone new, someone whose presence in my life mattered. And I was already in that strange emotional space that comes with leaving someone you care about, not knowing exactly what the future holds, not knowing how things will unfold, not knowing how much time you'll have together. And then, of all the questions a stranger could ask me, this was the one. If you knew you were going to die in three years, would you tell the people you love? I find that timing fascinating because when someone new enters our lives, We are confronted with uncertainty in a different way. We don't know what the relationship will become. We don't know how long it'll last. We don't know whether it will deepen, change, or eventually end. And yet, we have to decide how much of ourselves we're willing to bring into it, how honest we're willing to be, how vulnerable, how present, how willing we are to care about someone without knowing what the outcome will be. And maybe that's part of what makes love so extraordinary. It's asking us to participate in something we can't guarantee. We don't know how long someone will remain in our lives. We don't know how the story ends. And we don't get to eliminate the possibility of loss before deciding whether to love. But we do get to decide whether we're willing to be present for the experience. And I wonder whether the airplane question was really asking something much bigger. Than whether we could disclose a terminal diagnosis. Maybe it was asking: if you knew your time with someone was limited, would you love them differently? Would you be more honest, more present, more willing to say what matters? Would you stop holding back? Or would you become so afraid of losing them that you struggled to enjoy the time you had? Because knowing that something will end doesn't necessarily make us better at experiencing it. Sometimes it makes us cling more tightly, sometimes it makes us withdraw, sometimes it makes us try to control the outcome. And sometimes, if we're fortunate, it reminds us to be here, not in the imagined future, not in the anticipated goodbye, but here with the person in front of us. I think we
often talk about vulnerability as though it's simply the willingness to share our feelings, but there's another kind of vulnerability. The willingness to allow someone else to have their own response to our truth, to tell someone something difficult without knowing how they'll react, to allow them to be frightened or sad or angry, to resist the temptation to manage their emotions for them, and to trust that they have the capacity to decide what they want to do with what we've shared. That's difficult, especially when we love someone, because we don't want to cause them pain. But maybe part of mature love involves recognizing that we cannot protect one another from every painful experience. And that isn't a failure of love. Sometimes it's simply the reality of being human. We can be compassionate without controlling, honest without being careless, protective without becoming paternalistic, and vulnerable without surrendering our right to privacy. There's no single answer to how much someone should share about a serious illness. No universal rule that can account for every relationship, every family, every culture, or every circumstance. But I think there is value in asking ourselves whether our choices are coming from intention or fear, whether we're making space for connection, or quietly closing the door because we don't know how to let someone see us struggle. I thought about the stranger on the airplane and the question: if you knew you were going to die in three years, Would you tell the people you love? I still don't think there's one right answer. I can understand wanting to protect the people we love. I can understand wanting to preserve normalcy. I can understand wanting to keep something so personal to ourselves. And I can also understand wanting to know, wanting the chance to be there, wanting the opportunity to love someone through something difficult, wanting to say the things we might otherwise assume we have time to say. And I think what makes the question so powerful is that it reveals how differently love can look depending on where we're standing. Sometimes love says, I don't want you to suffer because of me. And sometimes love says, please don't decide for me what I'm capable of carrying. Both can be sincere, both can be deeply human, and sometimes they exist in the same relationship. But there's one thing I keep coming back to. We spend so much time trying to protect the people we love from pain. And sometimes we forget that being allowed to love someone through pain can be meaningful too. Not because suffering is beautiful, not because grief is something we should see, but because love isn't only about sharing the easy parts of life. It's about having the opportunity to show up when things are difficult. And maybe the most important part of the question isn't whether we would tell someone we had three years left. Maybe it's what the question reveals about how we're living and loving right now, because we don't actually know how much time we have with ourselves, with our families, with our friends, with the people who are just beginning to become important to us. We don't know how many conversations remain, how many ordinary morning, how many times we'll say goodbye and assume there will be another hello. And I don't think we need to live in fear of that uncertainty. But maybe we can stop pretending it doesn't exist. Maybe we can be a little more honest, a little more present, a little more willing to let people know what they mean to us, and a little more willing to let ourselves be known. Because there's something else I realized about this question. If someone told me they were dying, I wouldn't suddenly begin loving them. I would already love them. I would simply know something about our time together that I hadn't known before. And I wonder why we sometimes need the knowledge to give ourselves permission to express what was already there. I was on a plane heading home from someone who had become very special to me, and a stranger asked me a question about dying. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized that what stayed with me wasn't really death, it was love and the extraordinary vulnerability of allowing someone to matter to us when we have absolutely no guarantee how much time we'll have together. I'm Doc Dusty, and this has been a Doc Dusty Reflection. Until next time, remember, we don't have to know how much time we have left to let someone know how much they matter.