TRANSKRIP 🔗
1
00:00:07,246.5767045455 --> 00:00:13,846.576704545
Hello and welcome to the Change by Design podcast where we take a look, uh, at all things engineering transformation.
2
00:00:13,846.576704545 --> 00:00:16,396.576704545
Got some really great topics to dive into this week.
3
00:00:16,456.576704545 --> 00:00:19,606.576704545
I'm Josh Corman, head of content at Lifecycle Insights.
4
00:00:19,606.576704545 --> 00:00:24,676.576704545
Joined once again by Chad Jackson, our CEO and Chief Analyst, Chad.
5
00:00:24,676.576704545 --> 00:00:32,716.576704545
Last week we started off talking about allergy season in springtime, and today we're both prepping for, I think, kind of a winter apocalypse.
6
00:00:32,716.576704545 --> 00:00:35,626.576704545
And so, you know, we've swung the other direction.
7
00:00:36,631.576704545 --> 00:00:37,831.576704545
Yeah, exactly.
8
00:00:37,831.576704545 --> 00:00:40,231.576704545
Yeah, I think, um, you know, it's interesting.
9
00:00:40,231.576704545 --> 00:00:44,251.576704545
I, I wouldn't mind getting a bunch of snowball at once.
10
00:00:44,251.576704545 --> 00:00:47,581.576704545
I think that could kind of be fun for a little while.
11
00:00:47,971.576704545 --> 00:00:51,301.576704545
But I think here, here in Austin, Texas, we're gonna go above and below the.
12
00:00:52,381.576704545 --> 00:00:53,731.576704545
You know, the freezing point.
13
00:00:53,731.576704545 --> 00:00:56,791.576704545
So, uh, hopefully we don't get a whole lot of ice on the road.
14
00:00:56,791.576704545 --> 00:01:02,671.576704545
That's the big concern that we have in Texas and on the trees and power lines and that kind of thing.
15
00:01:02,671.576704545 --> 00:01:05,371.576704545
So I think you're gonna get more of it.
16
00:01:05,461.576704545 --> 00:01:07,801.576704545
The, you're getting more of it, I should say.
17
00:01:08,521.576704545 --> 00:01:09,841.576704545
A little bit further north.
18
00:01:09,871.576704545 --> 00:01:12,151.576704545
Uh, again, like you, I think, hoping to avoid the ice.
19
00:01:12,151.576704545 --> 00:01:15,151.576704545
That's where the real, uh, snarls can come into play.
20
00:01:15,151.576704545 --> 00:01:22,591.576704545
But, uh, yeah, we went from springtime allergy discussions to, uh, it's hard to imagine anything blooming in the weather that's going on outside.
21
00:01:22,971.576704545 --> 00:01:34,731.576704545
So might not have to, uh, to worry about that for a while, but, uh, but like I said at the top, we've got some, you know, non snow related, uh, topics, uh, on the engineering side of things to, uh, to discuss.
22
00:01:34,731.576704545 --> 00:01:38,421.576704545
And, you know, I think the thing that's, that's at the top of our list.
23
00:01:38,421.576704545 --> 00:01:44,271.57670455
We've talked about AI a lot, right? I made the joke, I think last week that we might not get through an entire podcast recording this year.
24
00:01:45,301.57670455 --> 00:01:48,781.57670455
Who knows for how long without mentioning AI because it's, it's ever present.
25
00:01:48,781.57670455 --> 00:01:51,631.57670455
But I know that, you know, you participated in a conversation.
26
00:01:51,631.57670455 --> 00:01:55,21.57670455
Were kind of keeping your eye on, uh, a discussion around this.
27
00:01:55,21.57670455 --> 00:01:56,251.57670455
Right? And we've talked a lot about.
28
00:01:56,821.57670455 --> 00:02:17,161.57670455
How can you integrate AI into engineering and design workflows and, you know, is there really the capacity for that right now? Where does that stuff stand? Uh, and I know that you were involved in kind of taking a look at, uh, at the discussion with somebody who had sort of put out here's how that might look right, and here's how AI native engineering workflows could, uh, could kind of come around.
29
00:02:17,161.57670455 --> 00:02:21,916.57670455
So talk a little bit about what that conversation was, was around and, and kind of what you took away from it.
30
00:02:23,266.57670455 --> 00:02:23,746.57670455
Yeah.
31
00:02:23,806.57670455 --> 00:02:27,376.57670455
Yeah, it was, it was fascinating and pretty, pretty brilliant.
32
00:02:27,436.57670455 --> 00:02:44,446.57670455
Uh, so the author of The Post is Benedict Smith, um, has experience in the PLM industry and with PLM solutions, he's been exploring, okay, how do you make AI functional? Like, how do you really make it.
33
00:02:44,866.57670455 --> 00:02:55,846.57670455
How do you circumvent a lot of the problems that we're running into right now? And one of those problems is, I would just describe it best as like buffering.
34
00:02:56,806.57670455 --> 00:02:57,136.57670455
So Hmm.
35
00:02:57,436.57670455 --> 00:03:05,536.57670455
you have a progressive thread with ai, where you go back and forth, it only remembers so much.
36
00:03:06,16.57670455 --> 00:03:09,406.57670455
So if the thread is very, very long, there's stuff at the beginning.
37
00:03:10,741.57670455 --> 00:03:17,611.57670455
it no longer remembers and it will come back and say the same thing to you again and again and again.
38
00:03:17,881.57670455 --> 00:03:20,761.57670455
So in that way it's a little bit like, you know, I.
39
00:03:23,281.57670455 --> 00:03:29,881.57670455
Talking with someone with a DD or maybe a memory issue where they can't remember what you said, you know, five prompts ago.
40
00:03:30,541.57670455 --> 00:03:41,581.57670455
So to address that, he's been exploring this concept of AI scaffolding, and the idea there is that you use ai.
41
00:03:43,591.57670455 --> 00:04:01,231.57670455
And you collectively, you build up a document that acts as an input for the AI prompt and because of the buffer problem, you start a session with an ai, you only go two or three prompts and then you end it.
42
00:04:01,701.57670455 --> 00:04:02,121.57670455
Mm-hmm.
43
00:04:02,611.57670455 --> 00:04:07,741.57670455
session has ended, but
Load full transcript
everything that was there was documented in this document.
44
00:04:08,161.57670455 --> 00:04:10,141.57670455
That is the input to the next.
45
00:04:10,486.57670455 --> 00:04:20,941.57670455
Interaction or session with the ai and you do this progressively and you have, you end the session with AI at some frequently frequency, Mm-hmm.
46
00:04:21,376.57670455 --> 00:04:25,986.57670455
but everything's documented in that, in, in that document or spreadsheet or whatever you're gonna use.
47
00:04:26,701.57670455 --> 00:04:39,331.57670455
And that way it always has the full context because when you start a new session, it reads the whole document and says, okay, these are the constraints, this is the background information and it can hold that.
48
00:04:39,781.57670455 --> 00:04:41,461.57670455
So I thought it was fascinating.
49
00:04:41,821.57670455 --> 00:04:51,91.57670455
Um, it's a fascinating approach to address an issue that we're experiencing with AI today and a way to make it more productive.
50
00:04:51,391.57670455 --> 00:04:53,71.57670455
So that's, that's the top level view.
51
00:04:54,111.57670455 --> 00:05:04,791.57670455
Yeah, that's really interesting 'cause something you and I have talked about on here before is the challenge when it comes to, you know, design and development or integrating AI into, you know, engineering processes.
52
00:05:05,431.57670455 --> 00:05:07,981.57670455
You know, you don't have what people talk a lot about.
53
00:05:07,981.57670455 --> 00:05:21,481.57670455
Where does the model get all of its foundational information and what are those inputs, you know, if it is answering questions about a given topic at some point it had to ingest those answers and, and at least be able to piece together enough to provide a response.
54
00:05:21,841.57670455 --> 00:05:23,41.57670455
And this sounds like it.
55
00:05:23,41.57670455 --> 00:05:27,541.57670455
It's an attempt to provide that foundation by giving it.
56
00:05:28,61.57670455 --> 00:05:32,351.57670455
Engineering decision data and, and kind of building your own foundation.
57
00:05:32,351.57670455 --> 00:05:39,101.57670455
Maybe just, you know, internally, right? 'cause we've talked about leaving data out, you know, exposed so to speak.
58
00:05:39,101.57670455 --> 00:05:46,271.57670455
Or information that companies might not be super thrilled about handing over to, you know, an an LLM or something similar.
59
00:05:46,481.57670455 --> 00:05:48,701.57670455
So this sounds like a way of, of kind of addressing that.
60
00:05:49,206.57670455 --> 00:06:12,966.57670455
Core issue that we've run into on the engineering side of things and giving it some of that good input, that good kind of foundational information that you can use to build on top of it and, and kind of cutting those conversations off at a, you know, like you said, predetermined frequencies as a way of protecting against some of, like you said, the, the kind of, you know, just functional limitations that we're finding with some of these models.
61
00:06:13,696.57670455 --> 00:06:14,26.57670455
Yeah.
62
00:06:14,26.57670455 --> 00:06:14,626.57670455
exactly.
63
00:06:14,626.57670455 --> 00:06:17,146.57670455
You hit the nail on the head that That's exactly right.
64
00:06:17,146.57670455 --> 00:06:30,226.57670455
And I think that, you know, it's gonna be really interesting, I think, and number one, I think this method could work, it could make things more productive right now, but gonna have to be a.
65
00:06:31,336.57670455 --> 00:06:33,56.57670455
Culture shift Mm-hmm.
66
00:06:33,376.57670455 --> 00:06:34,126.57670455
domains.
67
00:06:34,186.57670455 --> 00:06:44,206.57670455
Uh, like for example, engineers can be fairly disciplined around, get this stuff in the model.
68
00:06:44,236.57670455 --> 00:06:51,46.57670455
'cause if it's not in the model, then you can't do traceability, you can't do a flow down from RFLP.
69
00:06:51,556.57670455 --> 00:06:56,746.57670455
Um, so I think that could work well with systems engineers.
70
00:07:00,76.57670455 --> 00:07:16,216.57670455
With mechanical engineers, it might, there might be challenges, and we've talked about this before, where a mechanical engineer sees the space that their design needs to go into, right.
71
00:07:16,216.57670455 --> 00:07:19,336.57670455
A bracket, a motor, or whatever it's gonna be.
72
00:07:20,866.57670455 --> 00:07:26,746.57670455
They do a lot of that processing around constraints and context in their head.
73
00:07:27,136.57670455 --> 00:07:44,446.57670455
It never gets documented anywhere, and then they go into CAD and start creating 3D geometry, so they jump from no documentation very, very little documentation to, I'm developing the physical implementation the solution.
74
00:07:45,496.57670455 --> 00:07:56,516.57670455
So I think for a system engineer that might be very disciplined, this method could work really well for a mechanical engineer that's used to, you know, skipping steps Mm-hmm.
75
00:07:56,816.57670455 --> 00:08:01,996.57670455
as I like to say, you know, show your work, uh, for calculus, Yeah.
76
00:08:02,806.57670455 --> 00:08:11,206.57670455
it, it's a big change and I think that could be an impediment or a barrier, to adopting this approach.
77
00:08:12,406.57670455 --> 00:08:12,736.57670455
Yeah.
78
00:08:12,736.57670455 --> 00:08:14,56.57670455
And, and it gets to something else.
79
00:08:14,56.57670455 --> 00:08:24,526.57670455
We, we talk about a lot, you know, value and risk, right? And, and those two different situations are maybe a good illustration of you make an evaluation and one group might be a little bit more well suited to.
80
00:08:25,636.57670455 --> 00:08:42,16.57670455
Implement a tactic like this because existing, uh, you know, processes and their sort of existing way of working, it doesn't feel like you said, you know, if you're used to putting everything in a model and needing
that representation, changing the workflow a little bit, but still following that same principle might be easier, whereas, yeah, I'm not sure.
81
00:08:42,16.57670455 --> 00:08:45,346.57670455
You know, and I don't know if as a, you know, somebody who's mechanical engineer.
82
00:08:45,746.57670455 --> 00:08:55,376.57670455
By trade is, is there a way to get those internal, you know, processes and calculations out and represented? It feels almost like a, a generational shift.
83
00:08:55,376.57670455 --> 00:09:04,811.57670455
You know, I think about people who are streamers and they just sort of get used to like narrating their entire lives out loud and putting that, you know, out into the, the world almost feels like you would need.
84
00:09:05,181.57670455 --> 00:09:11,391.57670455
Someone sort of talking their way through their thought process, you know, as that input to maybe build some of that AI foundation.
85
00:09:11,391.57670455 --> 00:09:32,781.57670455
I'm not sure how practical, uh, that is, but, but that does, you know, it's, it's clear when you describe that, why that represents a challenge and why the, the value for mechanical engineers maybe requires a little bit more thinking to get to that point where it could be something that would be easily integratable or at least, you know, integratable without a massive amount of, of disruption to existing, you know, protocols.
86
00:09:33,721.57670455 --> 00:09:40,366.57670455
So Josh, you just triggered an image in my head of something I had talked about a little a long time ago, but.
87
00:09:41,956.57670455 --> 00:09:45,916.57670455
And this is gonna be a callback or think back to the first Iron Man movie.
88
00:09:47,176.57670455 --> 00:09:54,736.57670455
Um, and the design process that Tony Stark used with Jarvis, he was talking Oh yeah.
89
00:09:55,36.57670455 --> 00:09:56,26.57670455
loud.
90
00:09:56,866.57670455 --> 00:10:02,296.57670455
Um, stream of consciousness almost right, but interacting through a voice prompt.
91
00:10:02,296.57670455 --> 00:10:08,836.57670455
And, you know, eventually, maybe that's what the solution looks like for mechanical engineers, which is very different from.
92
00:10:09,691.57670455 --> 00:10:15,186.57670455
You know, fundamentally systems engineering is built on a, a, a code language, Mm-hmm.
93
00:10:15,486.57670455 --> 00:10:23,671.57670455
ml, uh, and that's a lot more like vibe coding, you know, where you're going back and forth building code up with an AI assistant.
94
00:10:23,671.57670455 --> 00:10:25,441.57670455
So there might be different modes here.
95
00:10:26,821.57670455 --> 00:10:35,341.57670455
I mean, I mean, the Ironman maybe came out, what was that? Was that early two thousands or was it I think 2008 was the first.
96
00:10:35,371.57670455 --> 00:10:40,171.57670455
Yeah, I think the start of the, the MCU, the year, the, the, the smartphone, the iPhone launched right.
97
00:10:40,171.57670455 --> 00:10:43,291.57670455
In uh, kind of, kind of wide widespread way.
98
00:10:43,501.57670455 --> 00:10:45,961.57670455
But, you know, it's funny you use that as, as, uh.
99
00:10:46,576.57670455 --> 00:11:07,36.57670455
You know, the, the example of, of how that might work because, you know, as someone if, if you're outside the world of engineering, I think that idea that like so much of this work happens inside people's heads, it both makes sense and feels kind of scary, you know, because you're like, wow, there is so much there that is not potentially represented.
100
00:11:07,366.57670455 --> 00:11:13,306.57670455
Uh, and the how right of getting what is internal into some sort of form that can be ingested.
101
00:11:14,171.57670455 --> 00:11:21,221.57670455
Or used as a way to guide, you know, future processes and kind of try to stabilize those things and make them, you know, more predictable.
102
00:11:21,551.57670455 --> 00:11:22,571.57670455
Uh, it makes sense.
103
00:11:22,571.57670455 --> 00:11:32,321.57670455
But I, I think your, your point about it requiring a shift to be implemented, maybe in kind of the mechanical engineering world that shift needing to be a little bit greater, that way of thinking.
104
00:11:32,801.57670455 --> 00:11:34,571.57670455
Uh, and it, you know, it sounds like that will be.
105
00:11:35,116.57670455 --> 00:11:36,166.57670455
A competitive advantage.
106
00:11:36,166.57670455 --> 00:11:41,296.57670455
Perhaps you get to the point where AI integrated and AI native workflows are more the norm.
107
00:11:41,296.57670455 --> 00:11:57,676.57670455
We, we discussed that last week when that exactly is coming and how, we don't know, but it sounds like there's a huge advantage out there for the company that can kind of get to that point and maybe solve that problem of, of taking the purely internal and, and making it something that can be read and responded to.
108
00:11:58,501.57670455 --> 00:11:58,981.57670455
Yeah.
109
00:11:59,41.57670455 --> 00:11:59,731.57670455
exactly.
110
00:11:59,731.57670455 --> 00:12:00,91.57670455
Yeah.
111
00:12:00,91.57670455 --> 00:12:03,181.57670455
I, I think, I think there's some real potential for it.
112
00:12:03,181.57670455 --> 00:12:09,286.57670455
I think this you know, we, we got deep into a tactic and it talks Sure.
113
00:12:09,586.57670455 --> 00:12:12,391.57670455
addresses the, a flaw of ai.
114
00:12:12,391.57670455 --> 00:12:15,661.57670455
But I think if we kind of elevate the conversation.
115
00:12:17,551.57670455 --> 00:12:21,61.57670455
This does get into the interaction mode and it Mm-hmm.
116
00:12:21,361.57670455 --> 00:12:32,401.57670455
does need to look different for different people, um, and different generations, you know, like you said, kinda like that stream of con consciousness for the, the youngest generations, they're more used to it.
117
00:12:32,881.57670455 --> 00:12:41,221.57670455
Um, you wanna, you know, stick a chip in
someone's head and have it process thoughts without talking.
118
00:12:41,311.57670455 --> 00:12:41,731.57670455
Um.
119
00:12:42,646.57670455 --> 00:12:44,686.57670455
But yeah, maybe that's a little too crazy.
120
00:12:44,686.57670455 --> 00:12:56,176.57670455
But anyway, the overall point here is that you're gonna need different modes of interaction and user experience as these things get more mature.
121
00:12:56,491.57670455 --> 00:12:56,781.57670455
Okay.
122
00:12:57,721.57670455 --> 00:12:58,21.57670455
Yeah.
123
00:12:58,21.57670455 --> 00:13:01,261.57670455
And, and that interactive description you have of, of kind of working with.
124
00:13:01,261.57670455 --> 00:13:04,51.57670455
I think there maybe I, you know, I don't know.
125
00:13:04,51.57670455 --> 00:13:09,301.57670455
My, my lay person's vision would be like, well, hopefully you get to a point where you press button design created.
126
00:13:09,301.57670455 --> 00:13:10,531.57670455
Right? You get this sort of.
127
00:13:11,26.57670455 --> 00:13:16,666.57670455
But I don't know that that is actually, you know, the way you're talking, it's like, I think there's maybe more security, more peace of mind in.
128
00:13:17,911.57670455 --> 00:13:23,41.57670455
The idea of scaffolding, and I come from an education background is, is, you know, really rooted in there as well.
129
00:13:23,41.57670455 --> 00:13:31,711.57670455
Trying to build supports for tools and the people using them in place because students learn at different paces, they learn most effectively in different ways.
130
00:13:31,711.57670455 --> 00:13:34,411.57670455
So there is some of that, you know, those, those principles.
131
00:13:34,411.57670455 --> 00:13:45,781.57670455
I think that that can be, you know, kind of applied in the same way and, and that idea of it not as a solution that takes the place of engineering actions, but that works in concert with.
132
00:13:46,501.57670455 --> 00:13:48,601.57670455
You know, the human side of that and goes back and forth.
133
00:13:49,171.57670455 --> 00:14:03,421.57670455
Um, Yeah, it feels both closer to reality, right? Like where we are now, um, but also maybe something that actually would be better from an outcome perspective of having that check and balance in place from the engineers who have been doing something a certain way for a very long time.
134
00:14:03,421.57670455 --> 00:14:05,131.57670455
And, and, you know, usually pretty effectively.
135
00:14:06,316.57670455 --> 00:14:11,386.57670455
and, and, and also I think it's a good half measure.
136
00:14:12,391.57670455 --> 00:14:24,91.57670455
Step towards agentic ai, right? The idea that AI is going to operate independently and autonomously of you making choices and decisions.
137
00:14:24,961.57670455 --> 00:14:34,471.57670455
I think this is that interaction mode and using scaffolding is still human, A human layer involved in driving decisions.
138
00:14:34,861.57670455 --> 00:14:36,271.57670455
So, um.
139
00:14:36,961.57670455 --> 00:14:41,966.57670455
I think that is a good half step or half measure, uh, to Yes.
140
00:14:42,286.57670455 --> 00:14:43,456.57670455
Yeah, that's great.
141
00:14:43,456.57670455 --> 00:14:48,646.57670455
Well, and we can include the link to the original post, um, that you, you mentioned was Benedict Smith.
142
00:14:48,646.57670455 --> 00:14:49,776.57670455
Is that right? Mm-hmm.
143
00:14:50,76.57670455 --> 00:14:58,926.57670455
Um, the author of that, so, you know, people can check that out and, and check out the conversation that was going on around, um, you know, AI native workflows and the scaffolding we just discussed.
144
00:14:58,926.57670455 --> 00:15:02,526.57670455
So, yeah, we'll, we'll put that link in the show notes and people can, can check that out.
145
00:15:02,826.57670455 --> 00:15:06,666.57670455
Um, and we'll, we'll transition kind of right to, to research.
146
00:15:06,666.57670455 --> 00:15:10,686.57670455
I know that we've got, you know, as always a little bit of research on our agenda, but I'll, I'll slip.
147
00:15:10,756.57670455 --> 00:15:12,106.57670455
A, that's not a word.
148
00:15:12,106.57670455 --> 00:15:30,376.57670455
I'll swap the order of the, uh, of the topics just a little bit, because we've just been talking about AI and I know that's something that we've discussed on recent episodes is really wanting to be community driven and community led in, you know, not just the content that we, we put out, but also hearing from people about what is interesting and valuable on the research side of things.
149
00:15:30,376.57670455 --> 00:15:35,956.57670455
And we asked that question, you know, what, what out there is sort of most pressing as, as you know.
150
00:15:35,956.57670455 --> 00:15:43,961.57670455
To our, our tribe, I think as you described, Yeah, and a little about where people's focus is pointed.
151
00:15:47,971.57670455 --> 00:15:49,561.57670455
yeah, yeah, absolutely.
152
00:15:49,561.57670455 --> 00:16:11,296.57670455
So, um, are you talking about the resistance thing or the systems engineering thing? Well talking about AI in engineering in general, right? 'cause we, we kind of wanted to know what is it that you want us to go out there and, and dig into, right? And we've learned that, uh, there is a pretty, pretty sizable amount of in interest in that topic, much to our relief.
153
00:16:11,296.57670455 --> 00:16:13,6.57670455
'cause like I said, we're gonna mention it all the time.
154
00:16:14,11.57670455 --> 00:16:15,91.57670455
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
155
00:16:15,91.57670455 --> 00:16:15,481.57670455
Absolutely.
156
00:16:15,481.57670455 --> 00:16:21,511.57670455
So yes, we, we ran a LinkedIn survey and I think we got 25 responses.
157
00:16:22,411.57670455 --> 00:16:23,791.57670455
it is very small.
158
00:16:23,881.57670455 --> 00:16:28,51.57670455
Um, however, it was really interesting what the answer was.
159
00:16:29,41.57670455 --> 00:16:30,511.57670455
I think we had four answers in there.
160
00:16:30,511.57670455 --> 00:16:30,911.57670455
I think we had.
161
00:16:31,711.57670455 --> 00:16:37,711.57670455
Agile for hardware, ai, for engineering, resistance to change, and other, please specify in the comments.
162
00:16:38,101.57670455 --> 00:16:42,451.5767045
Um, and AI and engineering came out at 48%.
163
00:16:42,691.5767045 --> 00:16:43,501.5767045
So, you Yeah.
164
00:16:43,801.5767045 --> 00:16:50,131.5767045
this is a topic of extreme interest, um, and we're seeing that in other research as well.
165
00:16:51,451.5767045 --> 00:16:53,371.5767045
But actually in, in.
166
00:16:54,316.5767045 --> 00:16:54,646.5767045
Yeah.
167
00:16:54,646.5767045 --> 00:16:57,76.5767045
So I think this is gonna be a theme throughout the year.
168
00:16:57,436.5767045 --> 00:17:00,526.5767045
It's gonna manifest in all sorts of different ways.
169
00:17:00,586.5767045 --> 00:17:13,306.5767045
Um, and yes, I, I think we will be talking about this pretty much every week, but the thing that also caught my eye is resistant resistance to change, uh, was number two at 36%.
170
00:17:14,641.5767045 --> 00:17:16,216.5767045
And I think that shows.
171
00:17:18,556.5767045 --> 00:17:25,186.5767045
And we actually saw this in our bigger, broader study where we collected 300 respondents, Yeah.
172
00:17:25,486.5767045 --> 00:17:35,146.5767045
and people side of change, was the biggest barrier or challenge in terms of change initiatives.
173
00:17:35,386.5767045 --> 00:17:38,986.5767045
And this kinda reinforced that and I thought that was very interesting.
174
00:17:39,196.5767045 --> 00:17:39,931.5767045
It, you know, it's.
175
00:17:41,176.5767045 --> 00:17:44,986.5767045
It's good to hear types of topics from different angles.
176
00:17:44,986.5767045 --> 00:17:52,396.5767045
It helps us triangulate verify and validate that, okay, yeah, this, this is a thing, this is an important thing.
177
00:17:52,786.5767045 --> 00:17:58,756.5767045
Right? Um, so resistance came out pretty high, and if you're competing, like if.
178
00:17:59,191.5767045 --> 00:18:04,201.5767045
You're talking about 12 point difference between AI and engineering and resistance to change.
179
00:18:04,501.5767045 --> 00:18:06,961.5767045
I think one is a very high profile topic.
180
00:18:07,441.5767045 --> 00:18:10,51.5767045
AI and engineering, it's got everybody's mind share.
181
00:18:10,416.5767045 --> 00:18:10,836.5767045
Mm-hmm.
182
00:18:11,311.5767045 --> 00:18:22,951.5767045
that the fact that like this simple, issue we've been talking about resistance to change.
183
00:18:23,776.5767045 --> 00:18:41,836.5767045
For decades, and the fact that that's competing with this hot, fresh, like in your face all the time type of topic, AI to engineering in this case, but that just shows you how, I guess, how long.
184
00:18:44,356.5767045 --> 00:18:50,986.5767045
The staying
power of that issue and, and how unsolved it is, frankly.
185
00:18:51,196.5767045 --> 00:18:56,661.5767045
Um, yeah, a lot of people are still definitely still struggling with that.
186
00:18:57,751.5767045 --> 00:19:11,641.5767045
Yeah, it, it's, it's interesting, you know, those two things feel connected because my guess is when, you know, we see this in other, in other areas in Hollywood, for example, right? Hundreds of people signing petitions keep AI out of movie production.
187
00:19:11,646.5767045 --> 00:19:12,811.5767045
Don't use it to do effect.
188
00:19:12,961.5767045 --> 00:19:13,801.5767045
There is this real.
189
00:19:14,366.5767045 --> 00:19:30,116.5767045
Fear right around is this gonna take my job? Is it going to make me redundant? And we've talked about some of how change in general right, can inspire those and spark those kinds of fears and that uncertainty in, in the people, the practitioners on the end of it, right, who are being asked to, to change the way that they, they work.
190
00:19:30,536.5767045 --> 00:19:42,776.5767045
And so it feels like no matter what the change is, right, whether it is AI coming down the pipe and we're gonna have to figure out how this applies and how best to, to use lit or how to get value out of it while minimizing our our risk.
191
00:19:43,711.5767045 --> 00:19:53,161.5767045
And no matter what that is though, there is this anticipation and this prevalence of, we know it's going to meet some kind of resistance.
192
00:19:53,161.5767045 --> 00:19:56,581.5767045
Like you said in our, our bigger study that we just did, we learned that.
193
00:19:56,581.5767045 --> 00:19:56,731.5767045
Right.
194
00:19:56,731.5767045 --> 00:20:00,811.5767045
And we've talked previously about organizations being good at achieving.
195
00:20:01,246.5767045 --> 00:20:10,306.5767045
Their goals re related to change initiatives, but still experiencing a lot of resistance along the way, right? And having to navigate that and how much less efficient it might make that process.
196
00:20:10,756.5767045 --> 00:20:17,386.5767045
And so it feels like people are never, you're right, it's not the sexier of the two topics, right? AI versus just resistance to change.
197
00:20:17,686.5767045 --> 00:20:20,386.5767045
But I think it does speak to this sort of ever presence.
198
00:20:20,816.5767045 --> 00:20:32,636.5767045
Of that resistance and that understanding that no matter what shift we make, we are going to have to deal with some amount of pushback right From, from the people who are, are taking that on.
199
00:20:33,86.5767045 --> 00:20:35,511.5767045
And, you know, we've learned a lot about, I think I.
200
00:20:35,981.5767045 --> 00:20:38,261.5767045
How to manage that, how that can actually be valuable.
201
00:20:38,261.5767045 --> 00:20:54,461.5767045
And we've talked about resistance as feedback, but you're right, those two topics, I think no matter what the shift is, people understand that if they cannot execute efficiently on the changes and they, they get bogged down by the resistance and it leads to workarounds or delays, then.
202
00:20:54,861.5767045 --> 00:21:04,371.5767045
You know, it, the technology, the goals that you're trying, all of that stuff sort of has to take a back seat to managing the people side of that, which we've also discussed.
203
00:21:04,371.5767045 --> 00:21:12,886.5767045
Right? And, and so resistance being there is not, it's not shocking, but I do think it speaks to, no matter what the topic of the moment is that Yeah.
204
00:21:13,191.5767045 --> 00:21:15,351.5767045
perspective, there really is a, a heightened awareness.
205
00:21:16,741.5767045 --> 00:21:28,171.5767045
Somebody somewhere is going to have an issue with this, and how do you deal with that? Becomes kind of the linchpin in maximizing your success levels and minimizing the inefficiency that you get from resistance along the.
206
00:21:29,386.5767045 --> 00:21:29,956.5767045
Yeah.
207
00:21:30,46.5767045 --> 00:21:30,976.5767045
Yeah, absolutely.
208
00:21:31,366.5767045 --> 00:21:42,676.5767045
And I think there, know, you and I have talked a little bit about this and I wanna share it with the, the listeners and viewers, it's about attitudes and assumptions towards change.
209
00:21:44,461.5767045 --> 00:21:55,321.5767045
So in this, you know, mini poll that we did on LinkedIn and then the broader study that we just conducted here recently, and we're gonna publish, you know, reports on this soon.
210
00:21:55,951.5767045 --> 00:22:05,161.5767045
Um, my attitude, I think your attitude too, going into this is that you wanna achieve benefits from your change initiative.
211
00:22:05,191.5767045 --> 00:22:06,781.5767045
And resistance is bad.
212
00:22:07,756.5767045 --> 00:22:08,106.5767045
Right.
213
00:22:08,881.5767045 --> 00:22:11,521.5767045
you want to minimize it, right? You wanna.
214
00:22:12,991.5767045 --> 00:22:19,711.5767045
You wanna deal with it, get it outta the way, and then get onto the good stuff the change initiative.
215
00:22:20,371.5767045 --> 00:22:28,141.5767045
think, you know, I, I certainly have learned a lot that that's, that's not the healthy way to approach it.
216
00:22:28,891.5767045 --> 00:22:31,111.5767045
And what I mean by that, you know, there are certain.
217
00:22:31,996.5767045 --> 00:22:40,846.5767045
There are certainly activities that you can do, and this is actually part of what we're analyzing right now, and we're gonna publish in the report can help reduce resistance.
218
00:22:42,76.5767045 --> 00:22:51,46.5767045
However, I think it's important to fundamentally change your attitude about resistance.
219
00:22:53,266.5767045 --> 00:22:55,726.5767045
And there's two kind of pivot points there.
220
00:22:55,726.5767045 --> 00:23:00,796.5767045
One is it's gonna happen fundamentally.
221
00:23:01,411.5767045 --> 00:23:06,451.5767045
A change initiative is about change and no one
really likes change.
222
00:23:06,601.5767045 --> 00:23:10,801.5767045
No one really wants to change the way that they've been doing things.
223
00:23:10,831.5767045 --> 00:23:11,971.5767045
'cause that's really hard.
224
00:23:11,971.5767045 --> 00:23:13,501.5767045
It means you're gonna be slower.
225
00:23:13,741.5767045 --> 00:23:16,801.5767045
It means that you, maybe you need new skills, it can be threatening.
226
00:23:16,801.5767045 --> 00:23:17,581.5767045
All these things.
227
00:23:18,391.5767045 --> 00:23:20,431.5767045
There's gonna be resistance period.
228
00:23:20,671.5767045 --> 00:23:24,391.5767045
So coming to that realization that if I do anything at all.
229
00:23:25,351.5767045 --> 00:23:33,451.5767045
gonna be resistance, but number two, flipping your attitude from this is a terrible thing.
230
00:23:34,171.5767045 --> 00:23:37,231.5767045
Resistance to good grief.
231
00:23:37,231.5767045 --> 00:23:50,161.5767045
This is an amazing opportunity, right? This is an opportunity meet people where they are, to actually try to listen to them, get feedback, um, and help them.
232
00:23:51,136.5767045 --> 00:23:59,56.5767045
you, help me, help you, uh, kinda reduce disruption, like, oh, this little piece of your change initiative.
233
00:24:00,136.5767045 --> 00:24:02,386.5767045
It would completely trash.
234
00:24:03,511.5767045 --> 00:24:07,171.5767045
You know, my week, every week I'm gonna be working twice as much.
235
00:24:07,621.5767045 --> 00:24:10,591.5767045
I'm gonna be getting half much stuff done.
236
00:24:11,551.5767045 --> 00:24:16,381.5767045
So it, it's an opportunity to listen and improve your change initiative.
237
00:24:16,651.5767045 --> 00:24:22,441.5767045
But number three, it's an incredible opportunity to increase investment.
238
00:24:23,251.5767045 --> 00:24:35,731.5767045
So if you can get them and, and engage those people to say, not just, Hey, how do we tweak this thing? But hey, why don't you come help us figure out the best way to do this.
239
00:24:35,971.5767045 --> 00:24:36,691.5767045
You're smart.
240
00:24:36,751.5767045 --> 00:24:42,781.5767045
You're doing this every day, a piece of this process or practice or methodology.
241
00:24:43,981.5767045 --> 00:24:53,671.5767045
What do you think is gonna work? What? What would improve it? Right? So if you can get them to contribute, they become invested in the success of the change initiative.
242
00:24:54,1.5767045 --> 00:24:57,841.5767045
So I think attitudes about resistance.
243
00:24:58,921.5767045 --> 00:25:00,151.5767045
It's not just feedback.
244
00:25:00,151.5767045 --> 00:25:11,761.5767045
You know, we have that famous quote that we use a lot here, um, from Sarah Juno, uh, a great, you know, insightful person looking at organizational change management and resistance.
245
00:25:12,391.5767045 --> 00:25:19,916.5767045
But not, is it only just feedback? It's an opportunity to engage and increase investment and, and.
246
00:25:21,886.5767045 --> 00:25:27,796.5767045
I've gotten some religion around this, you know, some passion 'cause it's so important, Right.
247
00:25:27,886.5767045 --> 00:25:28,486.5767045
this is it.
248
00:25:28,516.5767045 --> 00:25:34,156.5767045
We've seen from the findings, the people side of change is the biggest problem.
249
00:25:34,846.5767045 --> 00:25:38,986.5767045
talked with a CTO of a business unit in the aerospace defense company.
250
00:25:39,256.5767045 --> 00:25:43,551.5767045
They have on the order of 10,000 engineers.
251
00:25:45,556.5767045 --> 00:25:58,126.5767045
And he, we talked about this balance of how much of it is a technology problem, how much is a people problem? And he said it's 80 20, 80% people, 20% technology.
252
00:26:00,586.5767045 --> 00:26:04,486.5767045
again, it's gonna happen.
253
00:26:04,966.5767045 --> 00:26:12,376.5767045
Uh, it's a way to engage and improve what you're doing, but also increase investment in participation and contribution.
254
00:26:13,771.5767045 --> 00:26:22,996.5767045
Yeah, I, I think when we talked offline about it recently, you, you used a phrase that immediately made sense to me and that I'm, I'm going to expose now the judo throw.
255
00:26:23,536.5767045 --> 00:26:24,376.5767045
Of resistance.
256
00:26:24,376.5767045 --> 00:26:35,536.5767045
Right? If you don't know anything about judo, there's, so you, you see the idea of the little, you know, fighter and the big fighter and the little guy using the weight of the opponent against them.
257
00:26:35,536.5767045 --> 00:26:40,126.5767045
And that is the principle, right, of judo, of knowing your balance and your position.
258
00:26:40,696.5767045 --> 00:26:43,36.5767045
And when you describe this to me, it sounds like.
259
00:26:43,981.5767045 --> 00:26:46,861.5767045
Look, there's a threat right across the ring from you.
260
00:26:46,861.5767045 --> 00:26:49,471.5767045
It's, it's this large threat called resistance.
261
00:26:49,531.5767045 --> 00:27:09,151.5767045
And if you just brace yourself and grit your teeth, you might get run over by it, right? But if you're prepared and you can anticipate that shift and, and you can then use the weight of the resistance, right, which can cause disruption if everybody has just heels dug in against this and thinks it's a bad idea, but there's no opportunity to communicate that.
262
00:27:09,426.5767045 --> 00:27:11,136.5767045
To be heard, to build trust.
263
00:27:11,136.5767045 --> 00:27:12,6.5767045
I think that's another thing.
264
00:27:12,6.5767045 --> 00:27:18,486.5767045
You know, in the research we, we discovered, we asked people qualitatively, right, what is your experience with some of this stuff? And we heard a lot of.
265
00:27:19,246.5767045 --> 00:27:31,41.5767045
This is an opportunity, like you said, not just to hear, not just to get the feedback, but to build the trust and to build this idea of transparent communications by actually
engaging in those moments with the concerns that you're hearing.
266
00:27:31,341.5767045 --> 00:27:31,631.5767045
Yeah.
267
00:27:31,726.5767045 --> 00:27:37,6.5767045
then, like you said, using them in the stream of the process to make improvements.
268
00:27:37,121.5767045 --> 00:27:40,1.5767045
To what you're doing well before you get to the end of the road.
269
00:27:40,1.5767045 --> 00:27:56,171.5767045
You know, it, it's so funny to me as a layperson how this overlaps with what we discussed, like agile for hardware, build frequent prototypes, learn fast, understand early what your problems might be so that you're not running into them at the end of, you know, validation process where they can cause even bigger, you know, bigger headaches.
270
00:27:56,351.5767045 --> 00:27:59,501.5767045
And there's a very similar kind of logic at play here.
271
00:27:59,651.5767045 --> 00:28:02,21.5767045
And you're right, we, we've seen, and, and I've been working on.
272
00:28:02,881.5767045 --> 00:28:14,281.5767045
That report and, and it's exactly right, right? There's a high correlation for not just success, but outstanding levels of success, right? You achieved your goals and, and you actually found value that maybe you didn't even expect beyond those goals.
273
00:28:14,941.5767045 --> 00:28:28,921.5767045
And, and the, the correspond, the correlation there to having these open feedback and listening sessions and making the sort of, you know, making that preparation and making that engagement really explicit and getting it out in the open.
274
00:28:29,281.5767045 --> 00:28:31,351.5767045
Uh, and like you said, elevating.
275
00:28:31,816.5767045 --> 00:28:41,866.5767045
And discovering potential flaws that you might not have seen, because the practitioners are in a position to speak to what will wreck their whole weeks, for example, you know, or, or get into that kind of disruption.
276
00:28:42,286.5767045 --> 00:28:44,836.5767045
Uh, and so all of that is, is really fascinating.
277
00:28:44,836.5767045 --> 00:28:55,276.5767045
But I, I do think you're right, your, your first point about the, the flip of your attitude, right? Don't assume that well, people have got their heels dug and this is gonna mean failure.
278
00:28:55,276.5767045 --> 00:28:57,106.5767045
It's gonna mean, you know, pain.
279
00:28:57,106.5767045 --> 00:28:59,206.5767045
For us, embracing that.
280
00:29:00,646.5767045 --> 00:29:06,226.5767045
Executing the judo throw of resistance, uh, can really make, can really make a huge difference.
281
00:29:06,226.5767045 --> 00:29:23,176.5767045
So I'm, I'm eager to, for that to, you know, for those findings to kind of be put out in that format because, you know, it is an opportunity for us, I think, to find a, a piece of nuance in a conversation that, you know, I'm sure most executives are like, well, if, if I can avoid resistance, please, let's go that path.
282
00:29:23,446.5767045 --> 00:29:24,281.5767045
And we
kind of learned it like.
283
00:29:25,741.5767045 --> 00:29:29,971.5767045
You can't really, you know, like you can't avoid all resistance, you're gonna run into some of it.
284
00:29:30,361.5767045 --> 00:29:32,911.5767045
So have your eyes open, know what you're getting into, and.
285
00:29:35,86.5767045 --> 00:29:35,686.5767045
Yeah.
286
00:29:35,746.5767045 --> 00:29:40,756.5767045
And you know what's really interesting about this, excuse me.
287
00:29:42,436.5767045 --> 00:29:51,766.5767045
The, the place that this line of thinking, the, these conclusions leads you to is really interesting.
288
00:29:52,546.5767045 --> 00:29:58,306.5767045
So if you need to flip from, okay, resistance is something to just be overcome.
289
00:29:59,26.5767045 --> 00:30:04,876.5767045
Flipping to resistance is an opportunity, right? On many, many different fronts.
290
00:30:06,466.5767045 --> 00:30:15,916.5767045
It leads you to a place of, well, what's the skillset of the people leading this initiative look like now? Okay.
291
00:30:16,186.5767045 --> 00:30:26,866.5767045
If you need to engage people, if you need to understand their concerns, if you need to get them to participate, if you need to draw them in.
292
00:30:28,36.5767045 --> 00:30:33,736.5767045
There's a whole set of emotional intelligence and soft skills that you need to be successful.
293
00:30:34,156.5767045 --> 00:30:44,596.5767045
So the profile of that change agent needs to be different, right? It, it needs to not just be, here's the technological solution, here's the IT stuff.
294
00:30:45,286.5767045 --> 00:30:51,916.5767045
Um, here is a whole bunch of broadcast communications to let people.
295
00:30:52,711.5767045 --> 00:31:09,361.5767045
Know what we're talking about, and to drive alignment with vision, you need another set of skills to engage and listen and also be comfortable in some cases with confrontation.
296
00:31:10,126.5767045 --> 00:31:10,546.5767045
Mm-hmm.
297
00:31:11,551.5767045 --> 00:31:21,61.5767045
That's very different when you look at the profile, the modern and successful change agent, and you don't see a lot of that training out there today.
298
00:31:21,361.5767045 --> 00:31:21,901.5767045
So.
299
00:31:23,896.5767045 --> 00:31:31,906.5767045
Yeah, those, those feedback and listening sessions and that, um, intentional cultivation of, of resistance and feedback on that front.
300
00:31:31,996.5767045 --> 00:31:39,76.5767045
It does, you're right, inform you of what the path of your particular change initiative and the struggles you might face as an organization.
301
00:31:39,586.5767045 --> 00:31:43,336.5767045
That's where you're gonna get the kind of detailed information that can give you what you.
302
00:31:43,886.5767045 --> 00:32:07,286.5767045
To, like you said, plan for what those roles need to have in their toolbox and maybe the processes that you then go through with different groups to address, you know, that feedback and it, and it
stands to reason that in different industries, different kinds of, of organizations, complexity of product, all these things could shift that a little bit and make it make the specific kinds of challenges and feedback that you're gonna get.
303
00:32:07,826.5767045 --> 00:32:19,526.5767045
A little bit different, but knowing that that's coming and, and like you said, kind of being aware of, of how you can then flow that down to the people who are in charge of managing the change itself.
304
00:32:20,26.5767045 --> 00:32:34,846.5767045
You put yourself in a position to be more successful and really like it's, again, not eliminating the resistance, but it's just using it as efficiently as possible so that you don't have big, long-term delays in your change initiatives, or they don't bleed into and pull resources from.
305
00:32:35,296.5767045 --> 00:32:39,646.5767045
Other programs and projects that you're, you know, that you're currently leading that you can't just put aside.
306
00:32:39,646.5767045 --> 00:32:42,916.5767045
So, um, like I said, eager to, eager to get the report out.
307
00:32:42,916.5767045 --> 00:32:56,476.5767045
But I do think you're right that it can help people maybe reframe their thinking and their processes around some of this stuff in a way that becomes hopefully foundational, you know, and every change initiative, okay? We know that if we do these things that we can really.
308
00:32:57,106.5767045 --> 00:33:03,166.5767045
Make good use of people like me who were the pesky people when a change initiative got introduced somewhere.
309
00:33:03,166.5767045 --> 00:33:06,346.5767045
And it's like, here are the nine reasons why that will not work.
310
00:33:06,346.5767045 --> 00:33:21,466.5767045
You know? And I'm sure that people, you know, sure that the leadership in, uh, in, you know, the school where I was teaching for example, or whatever organization I was working with, probably thought, well, one, I knew this was coming and two, now I'm rolling my eyes because I have to deal with Josh's resistance.
311
00:33:21,526.5767045 --> 00:33:21,826.5767045
Right.
312
00:33:22,246.5767045 --> 00:33:25,366.5767045
Uh, but I do think that, that, you know, that really was.
313
00:33:25,971.5767045 --> 00:33:34,911.5767045
Maybe my, I'm just gonna cast that as my attempt to be a very helpful soldier in the organization and point out all of the things that we needed to address.
314
00:33:34,971.5767045 --> 00:33:36,381.5767045
You know, I was just trying to be helpful.
315
00:33:36,381.5767045 --> 00:33:37,101.5767045
It wasn't, uh.
316
00:33:38,416.5767045 --> 00:33:39,646.5767045
It's human nature.
317
00:33:40,261.5767045 --> 00:33:40,621.5767045
Sure.
318
00:33:40,621.5767045 --> 00:33:48,661.5767045
But I, you know, I, I do think it makes sense and I think our findings are gonna be interesting to people and, and hopefully give them, like I said, a path to doing things a little bit differently.
319
00:33:48,661.5767045 --> 00:34:02,641.5767045
If they find that man, you know, we do get bogged down and we do find that we're having to coach people through, you know, using some of these processes and not running end, end arounds to try to do it their own way because they don't feel supported in, in what they're doing.
320
00:34:03,541.5767045 --> 00:34:03,841.5767045
Mm-hmm.
321
00:34:04,291.5767045 --> 00:34:05,161.5767045
Yeah, exactly.
322
00:34:05,341.5767045 --> 00:34:05,791.5767045
Yep.
323
00:34:05,941.5767045 --> 00:34:06,301.5767045
Yep.
324
00:34:06,331.5767045 --> 00:34:06,901.5767045
Dead on.
325
00:34:07,826.5767045 --> 00:34:11,311.5767045
All right, so we've talked about recent research and, and stuff that we've got coming out.
326
00:34:11,311.5767045 --> 00:34:19,501.5767045
We also, did you mention the, the resource library being a part of, of Insight ex the platform that we're building to try to help out a lot of the, the folks that we're talking about Right.
327
00:34:19,501.5767045 --> 00:34:22,381.5767045
Make better decisions around, um, you know, some of these big.
328
00:34:22,706.5767045 --> 00:34:25,766.5767045
These big questions around change and, and the initiatives that they're leading.
329
00:34:26,186.5767045 --> 00:34:34,376.5767045
Uh, but we also have in this resource library a whole host of stuff that, you know, as you've mentioned before, this is not, uh, a game that you're new to.
330
00:34:34,376.5767045 --> 00:34:45,296.5767045
We've been in the engineering world, been conducting research and, and creating publications around that for a long time, and we've set aside a lot of those that, you know, have some value hopefully, that people can dig into in our resource library.
331
00:34:45,296.5767045 --> 00:34:50,336.5767045
So talk a little bit about what we've got there and, and what people can expect to find if they kind of go digging through.
332
00:34:50,571.5767045 --> 00:34:52,941.5767045
Past publications from Lifecycle Insights.
333
00:34:53,536.5767045 --> 00:34:53,806.5767045
Yeah.
334
00:34:53,806.5767045 --> 00:34:54,286.5767045
absolutely.
335
00:34:54,556.5767045 --> 00:34:59,806.5767045
So, um, you know, going forward we're gonna be contributing a lot of content.
336
00:35:00,496.5767045 --> 00:35:06,706.5767045
Uh, you know, it's so funny, Josh and I had these conversations, viewer, uh, listener around like.
337
00:35:07,936.5767045 --> 00:35:09,946.5767045
We don't have enough places to put this stuff.
338
00:35:10,66.5767045 --> 00:35:12,336.5767045
Like all the findings, all Yeah.
339
00:35:12,706.5767045 --> 00:35:15,346.5767045
all the posts that we can generate now.
340
00:35:15,766.5767045 --> 00:35:21,316.5767045
Um, so, and we're gonna curate that, right? We're gonna try to distill that down.
341
00:35:21,346.5767045 --> 00:35:23,746.5767045
'cause we know change agents don't have a lot of time.
342
00:35:23,836.5767045 --> 00:35:24,166.5767045
Right.
343
00:35:24,166.5767045 --> 00:35:28,756.5767045
So going forward, we're gonna be contributing frequently, you know.
344
00:35:29,521.5767045 --> 00:35:33,241.5767045
podcasts a week, you know, is, is an example of that.
345
00:35:33,241.5767045 --> 00:35:50,101.5767045
It's gonna be fresh, it's gonna be timely, especially in the midst of fast changing parts of the industry like ai, right? In three months it's gonna look very, very different, right? So we're doing that going forward.
346
00:35:50,581.5767045 --> 00:35:51,151.5767045
However.
347
00:35:52,186.5767045 --> 00:36:01,486.5767045
We have been doing this since 2010, and over the course of that time we have published over 200 things, eBooks reports.
348
00:36:02,236.5767045 --> 00:36:04,366.5767045
done a lot of studies in the past.
349
00:36:04,366.5767045 --> 00:36:12,196.5767045
We've surveyed over 20,000, uh, engineers and their organizations, there's a lot of value in those past.
350
00:36:12,901.5767045 --> 00:36:19,201.5767045
eBooks and reports and, and sometimes it's even the look back and say, boy, look how wrong that was.
351
00:36:19,261.5767045 --> 00:36:20,551.5767045
Don't do that.
352
00:36:21,181.5767045 --> 00:36:26,161.5767045
So what we're doing is we're, we're adding those to the library over time.
353
00:36:26,281.5767045 --> 00:36:34,831.5767045
You know, initially we're doing about 30 from 2024 and 2025, uh, those are going in the library now.
354
00:36:34,831.5767045 --> 00:36:35,761.5767045
We're kind of setting it up.
355
00:36:35,761.5767045 --> 00:36:42,181.5767045
So you can easily navigate through those, take a look at those, but we will be going backwards in time.
356
00:36:42,901.5767045 --> 00:36:48,931.5767045
Uh, as we progress, right? So going to 20 23, 20 22, and on and on and on.
357
00:36:49,261.5767045 --> 00:37:03,511.5767045
And, you know, as we get back to the mid, you know, 20 teens, 14, 20 15, 20 16, we were doing a lot of research, a lot of publishing around MBD model-based definitions and model-based enterprise.
358
00:37:03,991.5767045 --> 00:37:08,366.5767045
So some of that still stands, you know, as good.
359
00:37:09,91.5767045 --> 00:37:09,811.5767045
Practice.
360
00:37:10,171.5767045 --> 00:37:11,371.5767045
Some of it does not.
361
00:37:11,716.5767045 --> 00:37:20,161.5767045
And, and that's why we're doing your research and I think something we're gonna be doing in the community, know, we have the discussion forum that, that you get access to.
362
00:37:20,941.5767045 --> 00:37:31,351.5767045
you don't work for a software provider, you don't work for a consulting firm, but you're a practitioner, you're working for a manufacturer, looking at implementing these change initiatives.
363
00:37:32,131.5767045 --> 00:37:36,721.5767045
what we're gonna be doing is discussions of, okay, back in 2018.
364
00:37:37,861.5767045 --> 00:38:01,411.5767045
We said these things about, you know, shift left electronics design, how
much of that still holds true? W what's proven out to be valuable? What's proven out not to be valuable? Let's get a refresh of this thing based on what collectively we as a community, as a tribe, are experiencing.
365
00:38:02,611.5767045 --> 00:38:04,321.5767045
and I think that is gonna be.
366
00:38:05,626.5767045 --> 00:38:08,896.5767045
That's part of the thing I'm so excited about the platform with.
367
00:38:08,896.5767045 --> 00:38:12,316.5767045
It's not just us our stuff.
368
00:38:12,316.5767045 --> 00:38:14,476.5767045
I think we have good perspectives.
369
00:38:14,476.5767045 --> 00:38:15,826.5767045
We get exposed to a lot.
370
00:38:16,36.5767045 --> 00:38:43,36.5767045
We're conducting research, but to have these discussions around, okay, does this thing really hold true anymore? All of you out there practice actually trying to implement these changes, do you think? Here's your opportunity to weigh in, to prove it or disprove it, or maybe there's nuance, um, maybe there's circumstances it works and other circumstances it doesn't.
371
00:38:43,36.5767045 --> 00:38:48,886.5767045
So there's gonna be a lot of value add on top of what we contribute through this platform.
372
00:38:49,636.5767045 --> 00:38:53,836.5767045
And I am, I am super excited about that.
373
00:38:54,951.5767045 --> 00:38:55,311.5767045
Yeah.
374
00:38:55,551.5767045 --> 00:39:26,691.5767045
Well, I mean, you know, even what we talked about earlier, right? On a very small scale, having a LinkedIn poll where you get to ask folks, follow you, following you on LinkedIn about, you know, Hey, what's the most interesting research direction? Or what feels like it's the most pressing concern? Even that little amount of feedback is, uh, such a helpful input for us to think about, you know, what are our positions and what are we learning in research, but also how does that stack up to, you know, the specific experiences of people across a range of industries, right? We know that there's gonna be variation with that, and so I think you're, you're exactly right.
375
00:39:26,691.5767045 --> 00:39:27,351.5767045
We, you know.
376
00:39:27,881.5767045 --> 00:39:34,756.5767045
Kind of envision this as taking that, the effect of something like a LinkedIn poll and blowing it up, right? Because it becomes Yeah.
377
00:39:35,111.5767045 --> 00:39:48,881.5767045
bigger in number, right? It's not just asking more than the handful of people, but it's getting that qualitative response and feedback from people about their experience and about, you know, how some of what we're putting out there shows up in the real world and in their, you know, work experience.
378
00:39:48,881.5767045 --> 00:39:52,541.5767045
I think that that is, you know, is going to be, it's almost like.
379
00:39:53,81.5767045 --> 00:39:54,611.5767045
The perpetual motion machine.
380
00:39:54,611.5767045 --> 00:40:01,301.5767045
You know, if we can, if we can get that started and get people involved, I think we do envision that as having a huge amount of value.
381
00:40:01,331.5767045 --> 00:40:04,751.5767045
'cause there's nothing like hearing from somebody who's in the thick of it.
382
00:40:04,781.5767045 --> 00:40:05,171.5767045
Right.
383
00:40:05,171.5767045 --> 00:40:07,181.5767045
Who's, who's in the weeds on a, on a given thing.
384
00:40:07,301.5767045 --> 00:40:09,221.5767045
And that's true, not just for our other.
385
00:40:09,781.5767045 --> 00:40:12,871.5767045
You know, subscribers, audience members, but for us as well to Right.
386
00:40:12,871.5767045 --> 00:40:14,641.5767045
Really get that, that specific sense.
387
00:40:14,641.5767045 --> 00:40:20,641.5767045
So I think that gives us so much kind of fuel and it sparks, you know, good ideas and it sparks questions, right.
388
00:40:20,641.5767045 --> 00:40:21,601.5767045
That we get to ask.
389
00:40:21,601.5767045 --> 00:40:32,311.5767045
And then, you know, a big part of that, uh, you know, our excitement around it gets, oh, we've got something to answer, right? And we know there's gonna be value for the people listening to us because they're the ones raising the concerns.
390
00:40:32,311.5767045 --> 00:40:34,531.5767045
We're conducting our own feedback and listening sessions.
391
00:40:35,491.5767045 --> 00:40:38,741.5767045
We're not really judo throwing resistance, but we are taking that feedback and really true.
392
00:40:39,336.5767045 --> 00:40:39,696.5767045
Excuse me.
393
00:40:39,696.5767045 --> 00:40:44,316.5767045
Trying to turn it into something that works for, you know, the, the audience that we're really trying.
394
00:40:44,646.5767045 --> 00:40:46,746.5767045
So I agree that's exciting all around.
395
00:40:47,626.5767045 --> 00:40:49,726.5767045
I I think to me it feels like a flywheel.
396
00:40:50,461.5767045 --> 00:40:50,971.5767045
Right.
397
00:40:51,61.5767045 --> 00:41:11,581.5767045
And like on two sides of the flywheel, we're on one side with our research and discussions on LinkedIn and the other research in the podcast, we're we interviewing practitioners and we're pushing up on one side and the community's gonna be pushing down on the other side and it's just gonna build momentum.
398
00:41:11,671.5767045 --> 00:41:15,91.5767045
Uh, and it's, I'm, I'm really, really excited about it.
399
00:41:16,146.5767045 --> 00:41:16,356.5767045
Yeah.
400
00:41:16,356.5767045 --> 00:41:17,796.5767045
Ready to, ready to learn a lot.
401
00:41:17,796.5767045 --> 00:41:23,446.5767045
I, I talk all the time on here about how, you know, I feel like my job is mostly learning about these new things and, uh, Yeah.
402
00:41:23,556.5767045 --> 00:41:27,396.5767045
and you know, this is, is, is definitely, you know, a pathway to, to doing that.
403
00:41:27,396.5767045 --> 00:41:35,646.5767045
And we're, we can kind of close out on, on, I think, you know, a related topic we've, we've learned, uh, a little bit about, you mentioned
systems engineering.
404
00:41:36,26.5767045 --> 00:41:47,471.5767045
Uh, earlier and, and systems thinking is its own kind of way of operating systems engineering is, is its own way of doing things for people who are, you know, in that world of systems engineering.
405
00:41:48,301.5767045 --> 00:42:06,361.5767045
We've, we've asked about struggles and, and tried to learn about what are kind of the challenges that people run into, uh, and the, the lack of, well, or maybe the, the level of training, um, around systems engineering, the learning curve associated with it, um, is, is near the top of that list.
406
00:42:06,361.5767045 --> 00:42:15,836.5767045
So talk a little bit about why that matters, right? What is, what, what strikes you as important about, um, you know, kind of learning that when it comes to systems engineering, it's the getting up to speed.
407
00:42:17,801.5767045 --> 00:42:17,921.5767045
A.
408
00:42:18,541.5767045 --> 00:42:19,21.5767045
Yeah.
409
00:42:20,341.5767045 --> 00:42:31,921.5767045
Well, what's fascinating about this, I had a convergence three things this week on this exact So number one, someone on LinkedIn.
410
00:42:33,601.5767045 --> 00:42:40,321.5767045
I can't remember their name right now, but they, they put out a post about CS ML 2.0
411
00:42:42,931.5767045 --> 00:43:02,11.5767045
or no, maybe it was an in csi, like body of knowledge around systems engineering and MBSE and they shared that that documentation was, it was either 12 or 1300 pages long.
412
00:43:03,631.5767045 --> 00:43:04,261.5767045
Yes.
413
00:43:05,341.5767045 --> 00:43:14,731.5767045
And the takeaway there was that this is ridiculously complex and this represents a challenge, uh, for adopting MBSC.
414
00:43:14,941.5767045 --> 00:43:22,956.5767045
And then yesterday I interviewed Bradley Ramsey, um, and.
415
00:43:23,971.5767045 --> 00:43:25,531.5767045
Braden La Ramsey, sorry.
416
00:43:25,831.5767045 --> 00:43:50,101.5767045
And, um, we had a really good discussion all around systems engineering and MBSE, and he cited this issue that there's clearly value with systems engineering and MBSE, yet the learning curve, like the pitch on that is so steep that it's, it's a real, it's a real challenge.
417
00:43:51,166.5767045 --> 00:43:55,726.5767045
That is not as present with other types of initiatives.
418
00:43:56,476.5767045 --> 00:44:00,256.5767045
just not as complex as MBSC.
419
00:44:00,556.5767045 --> 00:44:09,196.5767045
And then the third point convergence of three, uh, from the study that we conducted, I think we finished it back in December.
420
00:44:09,196.5767045 --> 00:44:13,96.5767045
Um, and there were three parts, you know, about change.
421
00:44:13,96.5767045 --> 00:44:19,876.5767045
Agents, MBSC and MBD, and we're kind of our analysis and triage of findings.
422
00:44:20,281.5767045 --> 00:44:21,601.5767045
Of those progressively.
423
00:44:23,401.5767045 --> 00:44:36,151.5767045
So last week you saw this, Josh, we had an internal review of the MBSE findings and what we found was is that, you know, we asked what the challenges are and we do this as an open field.
424
00:44:36,151.5767045 --> 00:44:40,866.5767045
You could type whatever you want, because we don't want to introduce bias.
425
00:44:41,791.5767045 --> 00:44:44,956.5767045
If you present three options and people Yeah.
426
00:44:45,1.5767045 --> 00:44:50,701.5767045
about a fifth, Well, there's nowhere to put it, right? You're artificially constraining the respondent.
427
00:44:51,241.5767045 --> 00:44:55,21.5767045
So open field, you can type in whatever you want.
428
00:44:55,21.5767045 --> 00:45:02,551.5767045
And then we use AI to analyze it and, and categorize, uh, the response.
429
00:45:03,601.5767045 --> 00:45:11,881.5767045
So what's interesting about that is both with generic change initiatives and with systems engineering people, were the biggest issue.
430
00:45:12,151.5767045 --> 00:45:16,201.5767045
You know, we've, we've, you know, pounded this drum for a while now.
431
00:45:16,651.5767045 --> 00:45:29,101.5767045
Um, it was around 40% to 45%, very well aligned between generic change initiatives and MBSE, the second most frequently cited challenge around systems engineering.
432
00:45:30,226.5767045 --> 00:45:50,56.5767045
Was the learning curve in training, and it was, I think it was high twenties, it was close to 30%, and I think that just speaks to the unique complexity of MBSC and that it is very powerful.
433
00:45:50,86.5767045 --> 00:45:53,146.5767045
It can provide you a lot of value yet.
434
00:45:54,256.5767045 --> 00:46:05,506.5767045
It also introduces significant challenges in terms of actually adopting it and implementing it and deploying it and then making it part of your processes.
435
00:46:06,316.5767045 --> 00:46:08,986.5767045
So there was a convergence of those three things.
436
00:46:09,76.5767045 --> 00:46:15,976.5767045
Um, oh, and a fourth thing, um, someone.
437
00:46:17,41.5767045 --> 00:46:26,401.5767045
Underneath CS ML models, it uses, um, CS ML, is uh, a code language basically.
438
00:46:26,401.5767045 --> 00:46:32,491.5767045
So you get a pretty diagram that you can interact with, but underneath that is software code.
439
00:46:33,271.5767045 --> 00:46:36,511.5767045
you're building software code as you build an MBSE model.
440
00:46:36,871.5767045 --> 00:46:42,691.5767045
Now, as we talked about before, AI's really good at working with software code.
441
00:46:43,396.5767045 --> 00:46:46,516.5767045
You can vibe code with it and you can be incredibly productive.
442
00:46:46,876.5767045 --> 00:46:49,876.5767045
Gotta check your work, right? 'cause it will hallucinate.
443
00:46:51,166.5767045 --> 00:46:52,906.5767045
it's a great way to be more productive.
444
00:46:53,176.5767045 --> 00:47:05,146.5767045
And because CS ML is a code language, I saw someone this week starting to experiment using AI with CS ML
and using it to automate the creation.
445
00:47:05,866.5767045 --> 00:47:06,466.5767045
a model.
446
00:47:06,736.5767045 --> 00:47:12,736.5767045
So that was really fascinating and that could be a potential solution to address this complexity issue.
447
00:47:13,516.5767045 --> 00:47:18,496.5767045
again, the interface layer AI might be a boon, uh, for this.
448
00:47:18,916.5767045 --> 00:47:21,736.5767045
So end rant.
449
00:47:22,96.5767045 --> 00:47:30,466.5767045
Um, there was, there was of topics, uh, to that, that really got me going this week.
450
00:47:31,291.5767045 --> 00:47:34,981.5767045
I was gonna say I was waiting for a fifth to, to converge there in the, in the middle.
451
00:47:35,41.5767045 --> 00:47:44,671.5767045
Um, but no, I, I think, you know, and, and you're right, looking ahead in, in February, I think we'll, we'll start to roll out some of our NBSE specific, you know, content around some of those findings.
452
00:47:44,911.5767045 --> 00:47:53,101.5767045
But I think that that's what, what's interesting to me about that is, you know, we've talked a lot in the past several weeks about change initiatives, you know, under kind of a big umbrella, right? This can be.
453
00:47:53,361.5767045 --> 00:47:58,551.5767045
Model based definition, MBSE, it can be a whole range of, of initiatives that you might need to be executing.
454
00:47:58,881.5767045 --> 00:48:10,881.5767045
And so asking questions around resistance, you know, obviously depending on what initiatives a given organization is pursuing, those respondents are going to probably be speaking from that experience.
455
00:48:10,881.5767045 --> 00:48:19,911.5767045
And so, you know, being able to divide up a little bit and say, okay, well MBSE has its own specific hurdles, right? And, and the learning curve could be one of those things.
456
00:48:20,546.5767045 --> 00:48:24,986.5767045
Doesn't really, you know, impact other types of initiatives as much.
457
00:48:25,346.5767045 --> 00:48:39,656.5767045
Um, you know, because in that case, I don't really know how to use the technology that we're, you know, bringing on board to implement this is a different thing than, am I gonna get fired because we're doing things differently now, or is my job gonna become redundant? Right.
458
00:48:39,656.5767045 --> 00:48:41,696.5767045
Those concerns are different, but.
459
00:48:42,166.5767045 --> 00:48:53,566.5767045
If you right to get back to what we talked about earlier, if you are able to catalog and, and understand that as part of your own struggles, then you can be prepared for it.
460
00:48:53,716.5767045 --> 00:48:55,336.5767045
And so it'll be interesting, whatever the tools are.
461
00:48:55,336.5767045 --> 00:49:05,626.5767045
And you know, ai, you just, you just talked about that enable organizations to do some of that and address the specific concerns or, or types of resistance that might spring out when you are targeting.
462
00:49:05,966.5767045 --> 00:49:13,406.5767045
MBSE is a specific initiative because it has a level of complexity that, I mean, when you said 12 or 1300 pages, you know, I feel a little bit of relief.
463
00:49:13,406.5767045 --> 00:49:17,606.5767045
'cause sometimes I feel like if we put out something that's 25 pages, I'm like, that's a little bit long.
464
00:49:17,606.5767045 --> 00:49:20,756.5767045
Is everybody gonna, people gonna really read that thing end to end.
465
00:49:20,756.5767045 --> 00:49:27,176.5767045
And then I, well 1200 pages, I'm pretty sure no one is reading that end to end or at least not doing so enthusiastically.
466
00:49:27,176.5767045 --> 00:49:29,816.5767045
So, you know, I think that that makes perfect sense.
467
00:49:29,816.5767045 --> 00:49:35,696.5767045
And hopefully, you know, going forward as we dig further into these results, we're able to provide some specificity around, you know.
468
00:49:36,166.5767045 --> 00:49:45,376.5767045
The impact, not just of, of some of these activities that organizations can pursue on change initiatives in general, but really target those things down to what kind of initiative they're pursuing.
469
00:49:45,616.5767045 --> 00:49:51,376.5767045
And if there are specific pieces of guidance we can offer to make that a little bit easier, then, you know, great.
470
00:49:51,496.5767045 --> 00:49:57,466.5767045
Uh, I mean, I'll, I'll feel great about making, making that 1200 page, uh, problem feel a little bit smaller.
471
00:49:58,621.5767045 --> 00:49:59,251.5767045
Yes.
472
00:49:59,311.5767045 --> 00:50:00,811.5767045
Yeah, yeah, exactly.
473
00:50:01,291.5767045 --> 00:50:05,641.5767045
Um, so yeah, yeah, lots of good topics.
474
00:50:05,646.5767045 --> 00:50:11,71.5767045
This, this week, um, it's, it felt like AI was part of every single one of them almost.
475
00:50:12,231.5767045 --> 00:50:20,31.5767045
I, I think that's, we're just looking into a crystal ball, you know? I think that's just our, I think, uh, I, I don't think that we're too, too far off the mark if.
476
00:50:20,881.5767045 --> 00:50:25,46.5767045
Our LinkedIn poll, uh, small sample size though it was, is anything to go by.
477
00:50:25,526.5767045 --> 00:50:27,956.5767045
There's certainly an amount of interest and I think what's.
478
00:50:28,816.5767045 --> 00:50:32,626.5767045
You know, maybe kind of most prominent about that is there is interest.
479
00:50:32,626.5767045 --> 00:50:35,986.5767045
There's maybe not a whole lot of certainty, and so maybe that's driving some of that.
480
00:50:35,986.5767045 --> 00:50:47,881.5767045
Like, I would just like to know, does anybody have a good idea about how to put this stuff into practice? And it sounds like from some of your LinkedIn conversations, there's movement in that direction, right? People are trying to, to get to a point where they can.
481
00:50:48,521.5767045 --> 00:50:49,691.5767045
Leveraged some of that stuff.
482
00:50:49,691.5767045 --> 00:50:51,491.5767045
So, uh, yeah, I, I agree.
483
00:50:51,491.5767045 --> 00:50:54,521.5767045
February, like I said, a lot more MBSE stuff coming forward.
484
00:50:54,821.5767045 --> 00:51:11,126.5767045
Um, and, and I look forward to being able to kind of deconstruct that more specifically and, and break down for those folks, especially knowing now the hurdle they face in, in the learning curve of, of putting something like that in practice to be able to provide some of that guidance and, and so, uh, yeah, forward stuff, talking about it with.
485
00:51:14,746.5767045 --> 00:51:14,986.5767045
Absolutely.
486
00:51:15,126.5767045 --> 00:51:16,171.5767045
I'm looking forward to it.
487
00:51:17,251.5767045 --> 00:51:17,641.5767045
Awesome.
488
00:51:17,641.5767045 --> 00:51:26,701.5767045
Well, Chad, thanks, uh, as always for the conversation and, uh, I appreciate all of the, all of the learning you sent my way, uh, as we prepare for, for snowpocalypse.
489
00:51:26,881.5767045 --> 00:51:27,601.5767045
Stay safe.
490
00:51:27,961.5767045 --> 00:51:30,691.5767045
Uh, hopefully the ice avoids both of us.
491
00:51:31,81.5767045 --> 00:51:34,321.5767045
Uh, and yeah, good talking to you and we will catch you all next time.