अनुलिपि 🔗
Frank Beckmann: I think we need to be honest to see what remains. what AI cannot do better. And are we okay with that one? Because still we are the decision makers. in 10 years maybe not. So you have to act now. the whole thing is just so strange because we were used to have, if we have new technologies, they need to be certified, they need to be safe before they are allowed to hit the road. Now it's the other way around. So they unleash the technology immediately and now we have to prove why it is unsafe. in the past, if you are a business leader and you want to take a decision, it was a process which helps the leader to understand is behind this? What is the source? What are dimensions and things like that? Now if they get from AI push a button so the judgment and and Decision-making we have based on AI is not the same as we had in the past
Jason Griffing: Welcome to the Thinking Straight Podcast. I'm your host, Jason Griffin, and today I am joined by Frank Beckman. Frank is a business leader and advisor with more than 25 years of experience as a CEO and CFO across multinational companies and venture ecosystems. He is currently the CEO of GVI Investment Advisory, where he assists with complex growth transitions, including international expansion, organizational transformation, and raising capital. Frank is also the author of Kaleidoscope Leadership, How Great Leaders Rotate Perspective in the AI Age. He serves as the senior senator and chair for Germany at the World Business Angel Investment Forum and as president of the German chapter of the Asia CEO community. He is joining me from Berlin. Frank, thank you so much for taking some time to be here.
Frank Beckmann: Thank you so much for the great introduction and for having me here. I'm very much looking forward.
Jason Griffing: Yeah, I'm really excited. Yeah, me as well. I'd love to start all of my conversations with the same question. So I'll ask you what is one thing about AI that you feel like most people get wrong?
Frank Beckmann: Basically, AI means artificial intelligence and people think or tend to think that now intelligence is kind of outsourced. So we have a second intelligence which might be as intelligent as we are or it is said that it will become more intelligent. So we stop, let's say we reduce our own ability to use intelligence in the right way. And that will give AI really a head start and we will lose maybe a lot of abilities we have and we become kind of dependent on that one. And dependency is something which never had been good in the history or nowadays. So it's pretty important to stay ahead of that one, to stay beyond.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. I heard a saying recently that really stuck with me, which is that you can outsource your thinking, but you cannot outsource your understanding. And I I think about that a
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, absolutely.
Jason Griffing: lot in the AI age. I I read your book, I really enjoyed it. One of the metaphors
Frank Beckmann: Thank you.
Load full transcript
Jason Griffing: that you draw in the book is essentially AI as a chef that's giving us these increasingly delicious precooked meals, and a lot of us are losing the ability to cook. I'd love to have you expand on that metaphor and paint a picture of what that means in in a business context for for leaders who are listening to the show.
Frank Beckmann: Yes, I like to give some pictures because that's easier to understand. if you use Google, for instance, you put in some words, put on search, and then you get a lot of hits. And then you have to decide which sources you want to look at. You dive into the sources, you decide which you take. You take some information from that, from that, you compose your own decision making document, and then you decide. There was the pause. Now all this is just pushing a button with AI. And that changes a lot. I compare that in my book with a supermarket. You go into a supermarket, you want to cook and you get inspired. What is there? What is fresh? What talks to you? So you buy fresh fish, some vegetables, spices, whatever, and create maybe your own individual recipe. You buy that, you go home, you do the cooking. This is also fun and inspiration and creativity. yeah, it trains also your way of thinking. Now, this is Google, AI is you go into a supermarket and you only have ready-made dishes. Which is also fine because they are cheaper, they are faster, more comfortable and they may be good, but you lose all the other things around. And that is pretty dangerous, yeah, if we delegate to AI and we stop that critical thinking. I think this is very important. There's a term neuroplasticity. Neuroplasticity means that we can build our neural pathways and even unused connections again. If we don't use them, if we don't trade them, they degenerate. They get unused. It's like the other people. forget things, are not having a fast grasp, they take time, they do not understand certain things. And that will happen earlier. So it's the reverse longevity mentally relying on AI.
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I like that I like that metaphor because when you go into the grocery store, if it's all these precooked meals, you can take those home and they might be delicious, but you don't actually know there could have been a meal that was even more delicious or something that was healthier for you. And there's this idea that we are in the process of increasingly relying on AI, we're losing that discernment or that judgment, that ability to way through the options and really bring our own unique perspective to which ingredients we are picking. And I'd love to hear you expand on that more again in in a business context, where do you see the value of human judgment in this AI age? How do you see that value growing or evolving as as leaders who are trying to be really thoughtful about how we approach AI?
Frank Beckmann: Yes, I think that comes with a certain awareness about that and I think we should elaborate on that one a bit later. becoming kind of dependent from AI, using it too much. provides a problem even if you have judgment and critical thinking. Because in the past, if you are a business leader and you want to take a decision, had been discussions in teams. There had been a lot of documents and questions to be answered and then they put the document together. So it was a process like cooking coming to a decision, which helps the leader also to understand during the process what is behind that. What is behind this? What is the source? What are dimensions and things like that? Now if they get from AI push a button Decision-preparing document they don't have this they just read that over and Then they should judge then they should decide that's not the same so the judgment and and Decision-making we have based on AI is not the same as we had in the past it will be I more wrong or not good decisions, I would say, yeah, because we not really pierce the foundations of question or a challenge of that one.
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: And that makes really a difference. And I fear even if we say we need judgment and we need critical thinking, that's not enough.
Jason Griffing: Yeah, I I agree with you. I I'm curious if you share this experience. You know, in my own work, I do a lot of like strategy work, for example. And in the pre-AI age, there was a lot of friction and effort that would have to go into pulling people in, gathering all of the various options, trying to synthesize all of those options into some sort of useful framework that other people could digest. And then weighing out the different pros and cons of each and finally, coming to a decision. And I I think one of the things that it's a very there's a very human tendency to associate friction with inefficiency, and we all think inefficiency is bad. But in reality, one of the things that AI has really highlighted for me personally, and again, I'd love to know if you share this experience, is that that friction was actually very useful because through that process of really having to hammer out all of these different options. And grind through the the mechanics of gathering all of that information, you would often spot you you would see blind spots, or you would come up on ideas that you may have never considered or questions that you wouldn't have thought to ask. And now when you're just pushing the button, like you said, with AI, all of that gets lost. And I feel like something really important can get lost in that. And so I'm trying to be more deliberate about. bringing useful friction into my workflows and I'd love to hear you expand on that from your personal perspective.
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, absolutely on the spot because what you say is that we had an intensive process and we are learning, are developing, we are understanding with the process. If we don't have the process itself because AI is doing the process, what should we learn? really lack of understanding, of working with that and
being playful, even looking at things from different lenses. So friction, what you say, I think is utmost important. It's because we all tend to be in harmony, to have a culture of it, everybody agrees. And we are in the world. complexity grows and complexity you cannot handle it your own. need to different people with different perspectives to cope with complexity. I think different perspectives having friction, allowing friction, only allowing, even challenging different perspectives, different answers, allowing oppositions, not for the sake of an ego, but for the sake of the matter to make a better decision. I think that's essential. to get a competitive edge over other companies.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yeah, I'd love to hear your thoughts on a another facet of this conversation, which is, using AI as sort of a sparring partner to so to say, right? So the idea being that like AI is really optimized to
Frank Beckmann: Mm-hmm.
Jason Griffing: for human preference and one of our preference all of our preferences humans is to be told that we're smart and that our ideas are great. And so if we're not careful, you know, we can easily fall into the trap of AI just
Frank Beckmann: Mm-hmm.
Jason Griffing: Confirming everything that we think already and telling us why our idea is good. Do you recommend that people really lean into using AI in a way that's very deliberate? For example, maybe having the AI explicitly instructing the AI to say, here's my idea, tell me why it's good and tell me why it's bad. Are there techniques like that that you might recommend with using AI to make it a little bit more adversarial and challenge your own thinking?
Frank Beckmann: Yeah, yeah, love that question. What you say is typically if you ask AI or an LLM, always you say that's a great question. Yeah, so that's the way how they are built. It starts with an appreciation because everybody wants to have recognition. needs to be built to be trust to build a relation with the customer. And then you start to believe because once you have appreciation and trust, you start to believe. And that's the way AI and the LLMs are designed to work. And that's a trap that's very difficult. We all crave for recognition. And if we get it there and nobody else, then we get hooked to that one. And this is actually what happens. Now it is so important, and I like your approach. statement, we can use AI in a reverse way to get more creativity and more perspectives. That depends on it. What you said is how to prompt. It can also be as I'm using always two different LLMs, mostly an American and a Chinese one. Or you can use the French one, Mistral or whatever, because the Americans are all biased. The Chinese are all biased but in a different way. So that helps me already to get different views. Another thing is for instance what I have seen when I was in Abu Dhabi last year the head of G42 which is one of the major investment companies especially in AI he said we are using in our supervisory
board meetings an AI agent in that way that the AI agent is trained with the data and the agenda and all the information all others have and they should challenge us they should ask us
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: questions they should tell us if something is not in the right way or if there's a different opinion on that one. And since we did that, the quality of our board meetings went up significantly. And now it's compulsory for all of the portfolio companies to use an AI agent in that way. So we can use or we should use AI really to change perspectives, to create frictions because AI as such is designed to confirm, to support us. So it's up to us to change that. But we need the awareness and we need the ideas to doing that.
Jason Griffing: Yeah, you have to steer it in that direction deliberately. And w one of the ideas that I like about using an AI agent in that way in your meetings is that as humans, there's there's all these power dynamics and human tendencies that sort of push us to sometimes not want to challenge what's being said or not want to challenge the status quo. And you can see
Frank Beckmann: Right.
Jason Griffing: these dynamics play out in meetings in various ways all the time. The nice thing about an AI agent is it really doesn't care about any of that. And if you tell it, Hey, your job in this meeting is to be the kind of dedicated dissenter in the room and to challenge what we're saying and tell us why we might be going down a bad path. I think the AI can be, you know, really effective at that. I do want to also have you elaborate on the human side of this because, you know, it's not all about just using AI to challenge our own thinking. You talk about in your book creating a culture. where this kind of dissent and this challenging of the status quo is not only accepted but encouraged. So I'd love to have you talk about what are some of the ways that leaders can in this AI age not only use their AI to make sure that they're thinking clearly, but encourage their teams and and and create a culture where everyone is again not only allowed, but actually encouraged or even required to think in this way.
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, which is more the exception. I think it is very difficult, as you said before, we need frictions, we need somebody who can be a dissenter. We need not... confirming what the leader says. But companies are structured that way. If you just look at onboarding interviews for instance, do you know or we teach you how we work here. We tell you how we think here. And these are our expectations. So even in the onboarding process already people get fitted into that culture, into that framework. And it's very clear you better should not question that. You should not behave differently because then you are out again or you won't get promoted. companies normally and there are lot of processes and mechanisms. automatically which avoids different opinions, diverse views, perspectives. But as we discussed
before, it's absolutely essential. Where does innovation come from? Where does creativity come from? It comes from different opinions. If everybody confirms and aligns, it doesn't work. The problem is that we get increasingly into a confauzone. We get complacent and in that comfort zone, the things which helps us in the comfort zone are stereotypes, are misconceptions, are beliefs, wrong beliefs, cliches and all these things. And we don't dare to risk our comfort. It comes with wealth. You see it in societies, in our industrial societies. We get more risk averse. You see it in companies. the longer and the more successful they are. Every company starts with risk, with innovation being open-minded. Founded teams are coming from different sides. But as they continue growing and creating worlds and success, they start to contain that and they build their own comfort zone. And it's very difficult to get out of that one. Their views get more narrow. They don't see anything anymore. grows, comes at a certain point, gets lower, success gets lower, they are only looking for risk. And this is the
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: bad thing, because normally the companies when they grow fast and they are open and they take risks, they are more profitable.
Jason Griffing: Right.
Frank Beckmann: There is a better atmosphere in the company where every employee is motivated. As soon as the comfort zone kicks in, as soon as a certain status arrives and we de-risk instead just looking for opportunities or can cope with uncertainty, then demotivation at workplace also comes in and profitability reduces. So there's a strong relation to that one.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yeah. You you talk about another another metaphor in your book is this kind of corporate im immune system, which I loved. It's this idea that
Frank Beckmann: Hahaha.
Jason Griffing: these new new ideas come in and the corporate immune system kicks in and does its job, which is to keep the company safe and de-risk things so new ideas get attacked and die before they have a chance to you know, to to even be properly considered. So I think th this is a probably a good place to set up the the title of the book is Kaleidoscope Leadership and you use that metaphor throughout. Talk about what what does that metaphor mean and how do we make that idea practical for somebody who's who's listening to the show.
Frank Beckmann: I mean I like pictures and the kind of the scope most people of us know is from our childhood, right? We turn it around, it shows a beautiful pattern, but if we change it around or turn it around the pattern changes. The old pattern breaks and we get a new one. But this is okay because we know if we break one there will be automatically a new one. And this is something what we have to do also. We are all in pattern recognition which is also important. But pattern recognition means also linear thinking. So what works in the past will work in the future. But linear thinking does not work anymore. It worked until 20 years ago. Now if we have exponential growth, if we have disruptive growth, it doesn't work. We have to think more what I learned from the future than from the past. And I think this is crucial to the whole setup here.
Jason Griffing: Yeah, yeah, I agree. The what one of the questions that I'd I'd love to hear your perspectives on is there's there's this kind of like it you could picture it as a spectrum. And on one side of the spectrum there is we're gonna jump on the very first idea that we come up with and we're just gonna go. And then on the other side of the spectrum, there's we're gonna get so lost in evaluating different options and weighing the pros and cons of each that we're gonna get analysis paralysis. And we're never going to move forward with anything, right? So again, on one side of the spectrum, it's just reckless moving forward. And on the other side, you're completely paralyzed because you're stuck evaluating a million different options and you can't make a decision. And obviously, like with anything, there's danger at the extremes, and generally we don't ever want to operate there. How do you think personally about finding the right balance in terms of making sure that you're being diligent? Rotating the kaleidoscope, thinking about different options, bringing in different perspectives, but still finding the right balance of making a decision and moving forward.
Frank Beckmann: Yes, if you think of the Kaleidoscope, it has two parts. One is to turn the Kaleidoscope, so the rotation, but the other thing is to hold the center. We don't hold the center, you don't break the patterns in the right way. So I think both comes together and both is also important for a leader. You have to hold your center while rotating the lens. Agility and stability at the same time. That works. It's not a contradiction. I think that goes together. So how do you hold the center? You hold the center by your principles, by your non-negotiables you have, by your values. And these values normally enable you to make decisions once you have rotated the lens. If you don't have that center, if you don't have that non-negotiable values for that, one. You might get lost in that one. So you rotate and rotate, you have more more input, you ask for more information, but it really doesn't help you. You can't decide. So it's also a fear of commitment. But the foundation, basic of that one is if you're not holding the center, if you are not aware of your principles, of your negotiables, you might get lost in that one. And that's very dangerous because decision
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: making, see it in lot of companies where no decision is taken, people are very demotivated and it's not really moving. Sometimes it's better to take even the wrong decision, but to take a fast decision because then the whole organization can continue. As long as you don't make a decision, they are on hold and nothing happens. Yeah.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I agree. I I think on the other side of that, I in my career have seen the tendency from some people to be really uncomfortable, particularly leaders being really uncomfortable in ambiguity or paradox, and they really just want to get to a decision very quickly. And that because that's more comfortable to them, right? Is like, let's make a decision and let's move because I'm really
Frank Beckmann: Exactly, exactly.
Jason Griffing: uncomfortable with this. uncertainty and this paradox. And I'd love to hear your perspectives on like in in your personal experience or with clients that you've worked with, what what's the benefit of a leader being a little bit more comfortable saying, you know what, we're gonna leave this as an open question for, you know, at least the duration of this meeting. We're not gonna just snap to a decision and we're gonna stay in this space of not knowing and explore it together. what what do you see as the benefits of of a leader, you know, building that skill?
Frank Beckmann: I think that creates innovation, that creates quality also with your teams, we tend to answer things very fast. Just imagine you go into a meeting and somebody has a presentation. And some other people in that room already have an answer before that person has finished. Yeah. So they are not really listening. They are not understanding. And these people are mostly listening to themselves. We are very often listening to ourselves, not to the others. Now creating some silence in between, creating some pause to understand. then if you're not really 100 % understand to ask. Ask more than to give statements. We all give statements now. The art of questioning is kind of lost. I experienced that and this something I can do pretty well. I can ask a lot of questions. I go deeper and deeper and deeper. I want to find the source of a problem, of a Once I get there, very often the answer unfolds itself. without answering before. As soon as you answer something, you close the topic. You close the question. There is no further discussion. And that's what happened with a lot of companies. But if you leave that open, you have room for better understanding for better decisions, for more ideas, for innovation, motivation of the people. That's a totally different culture, totally different atmosphere. And I think that's the winner atmosphere. If you look,
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: for instance, at Elon Musk, he has this algorithm of four steps. These four steps are built on being uncomfortable. He tells the marketing director, we want to increase sales by 50 percent. And the marketing director typically asks, OK, I need a budget of this and that. And Elon would say, I don't give you more budget, you get the same. You have to do it with the existing budget. What happens? The marketing guy then has to think, well, I can't do it with a budget. Then I knew what I'd do. But without that, I have to think totally different to achieve that. So it breaks their patterns. It breaks their mold. And I think that only comes from being uncomfortable.
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: And also learning. We learn most where we are uncomfortable with. If we think, there's a situation or something or a topic, don't, I don't want to learn more or do anything because it doesn't feel good. You don't learn. If you jump exactly
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: in that one, you evolve, you grow. And the same happens for a business leader and the same happens for a company.
Jason Griffing: Yep. Yeah. And I think w w one of the things I think about a lot as a as a leader is that this the second I take a position, or the second any leader takes a position, there's this kind of gravitational force that develops around that decision and the room will tend to move in that direction and align on it, whether my decision is a good one or a bad one. So I like to deliberately sort of leaders speak last. I will offer my idea last in the conversation. And I I really like your point about almost creating a culture that rewards good questions as much as it does answers. One of the things I like doing at the very beginning of an er of a larger complex project is saying, hey, at this point, you know, it's all about teasing out, you know, what what are the right questions that we need to be asking and And circle circling around back to AI, because we've been dabbling around leadership topics and things like that. are there ways that you would recommend using AI to kind of create this culture of more open exploration and being uncomfortable in this this space of of ambiguity and paradox?
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, absolutely. I think we need to use AI in a different way. So we need to be able to stay uncomfortable. And I have lot of techniques and methods in my books, which you can use immediately, even though it takes some time. But you can really change things. I think this is so important because it's on the one hand the business leader first who needs to understand what to how to employ AI, how to see it differently, and then to break it down to the team and the whole organization. I just read an article some two days ago about PwC, and they have now a certificate for each employee for critical thinking and judgment. For that, they build a course. So you have to make the course in order to get a certificate in that one. Now, I think that's the right path, really. to bring your people staying ahead of AI and have this critical thinking and judgment start. What they hopefully will do, and I haven't read that, they need to recertify the people after one or two years, because our ability of judgment and critical thinking will not automatically stay if we are not training it, if we are not working with that one.
Jason Griffing: Mm.
Frank Beckmann: And the same happens if you're a leader with your teams. You have to train them in a certain way, be it with kind of these courses or a certificate,
be it with an AI curriculum you can build to help them to change perspectives, to find out where their original ideas is, that they don't have this confirmation bias, and to be open to listen and to tell their story.
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: not just really following others. Because as you
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: see, we are now influencers or followers, right? And apparently we have 99 % followers in the world and 1 % influencers. But we don't want to become the followers. I think as a business
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: leader, we always need to be the influence. And the more influencers we have, not followers, we will be more successful.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Well one of the things that we've seen as we've rolled out AI to more more people in our company is that everyone gets really excited about it, which is great. And we love seeing that. one of the dynamics though that I'm really paying attention to lately is this idea that like people will share out these clawed artifacts or documents written by an AI and sort of say, Look at this and look at this analysis. And I I find myself increasingly going, Well, what do you think? I if I if I want to know what the AI thinks, I can I can go ask the AI. And in in some sense, this artifact that you've shared is is useful. And yes, it does provide, some insights and a good framework for for thinking about this. But ultimately, I want to know what you think. And I'm curious if you encourage leaders that you work with who are adopting AI in their company to like like are there ways that they're training their team specific ideas that you can share about establishing the right cultural norms. around the use of AI and how do we interact with each other to ensure that we're not losing that unique perspective that each of us as humans bring to the business.
Frank Beckmann: Yeah, it's wonderful what you just said and I think that's very important with my stuff. always say I don't want to have an AI report. As you say, I can do it myself. I don't need you. I want to have your opinion. I want to have your report. You can base it on an AI report, but I don't want that. You also see that all AI reports, look different. They look the same because they have the same wording. You immediately realize, that's written by AI. As you see on LinkedIn, for instance, most of the posts
Jason Griffing: Mm.
Frank Beckmann: nowadays are all written by AI. So they become so similar and there is no really content, no individuality. There's nothing in there. And people now tend to be against it. They don't like it anymore. And I see it also in the VC world. If a pitch deck is written by AI, the VC says, I'll put it away. I don't look at this one. Because as you say, we want to see what people are saying. So this is so important. So one, don't want to say never give me an AI document, give me your document. You can base it on that one. But I want to read your wordings, your style. Yeah, I want to see you inside and I want to have your opinion on that one. And I always want to have a critical opinion. So I want to have two opinions. Yeah, I want to have one opinion, which is good for that one, but also critical perspectives. So for instance, there are also in meetings, I call it the three chairs, for instance. If you have to make a decision, you start writing your own decision. The second is you put yourself into the person or the company which is mostly affected by that one. That's the second one. And then there's a third
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: one. It's a neutral one. Just imagine you are, I don't know, housekeeper or a taxi driver. Explain your problem and how that person would make that decision. And then you automatically
Jason Griffing: I like that.
Frank Beckmann: have three different perspectives on that, very diverse perspectives. start thinking about that one.
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think that's that that's a useful exercise. because it really forces you to take a different view of the problem and and get out of your own head and and you know, consider other other perspectives. What one of the other things I I'd love to add here is that like from my personal perspective, I I don't necessarily mind reading an AI generated document that somebody sends me, provided that they stand behind it 100%. So the big no no for me would be. I point out something in the document and they're like, I actually don't agree with that. AI wrote that. it's like, well, you have to own the
Frank Beckmann: Uh-huh, that's worst case. Uh-huh.
Jason Griffing: outcome. If you're going to send me an AI generated artifact or document, that's okay. But you need to make sure that you fully endorse it. And then separately, the other thing that I'm realizing is just that AI will it's it's so good at processing and generating large amounts of information that you get into this environment where even at a smaller company, if you get pe a bunch of people using it, all of a sudden there's just this spike in information that's flying around in Slack, and I can't possibly consume it all. So the thing that I really want to see more of is like if you're gonna send that out, I want it to be accompanied by a short exec summary that you wrote that tells me what's the big takeaway here, what's the number one thing, you know, that I that I need to be thinking about. And I I'm curious if you have ideas or thoughts you can share around this concept of AI just amplifying the amount of information that's flying around inside of a company and it makes it really hard for people to process that all and make sense of it.
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, that's why we will have AI agents who process that also for us. That will come, yeah,
Jason Griffing: Exactly. Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: which is even worse because
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: then we don't have any thinking and judgment anymore. But of course, on the one hand, as AI is really great in
collecting information, they know the markets, they know competition, market dynamics, geographics, prediction. This is awesome. So the quality of information we get and the quantity is really superb yeah but to transform them into a decision-preparing document that's the art I would say it's it's kind of art to do that yeah and of course it's need to be kind of reworked so where's the essence as you said where's we should emphasize on that one What is something the AI is not seeing? Because the AI is for instance just looking for logical things. What about if something would be better which is kind of illogical? AI can't do that, because it's built on logic. So really challenging that. And I think this challenging is the quality we have. The rest is the quantity and itself the stringent quality of the AI, but the real decision making quality. is still our judgment, is still our critical thinking, is to work with that one. So if you have an output, it's not the ending point. A lot of employees take it at the ending point. They make an AI, get a result, and as you said, they just pass it to the next one. But we should take it as a starting point to work with that one. And that makes a difference.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yep. Yeah. And your your your point about AI agents then processing all of the information that's being sent out. I agree with you. That's a a concern of mine because I I can totally I I sometimes joke that the AI companies really have it figured out because what what they do is you you get a bunch of people in your company using AI and then they're generating so much information that the only way to process it is to also use AI so
Frank Beckmann: Exactly.
Jason Griffing: they get you coming and they get you going and I think really being deliberate about counteracting that. And I I even see this in I've been paying more attention to I'll sit down with AI to work through a very specific question and I'll ask it something and then it'll come back with this long answer that points in all these different directions. And I have to be really deliberate about no, I I understand this and that and that, but I want to talk about this thing. And really keeping it in line because if you're not deliberate about that, like you said, bringing your perspective and forcing your own initiative into the conversation, it can easily pull you off, in in a lot of different directions. But that that requires a certain level of of awareness. You have to be able to step back from the situation and look at it and ask yourself what's happening. And that's something I've heard you talk about. You mentioned in your book, there's the this idea of of awareness, being able to take a step back, look at everything that's going on without judgment. And it it comes th there are lots of different ways this plays out, but in the age of AI, I think this this idea of awareness feels even more important and I'd love to hear you elaborate on that.
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely.
Awareness for me is key. It's key for coping with the future in a successful way. How to start? Maybe in my book I talk about the RAS, the reticulatory activating system. That's a filter system. Filters out what we don't need or want. Very typically you sit in a cafe and you read your book, even though it's noisy, filters out the noise. On the other hand, it's necessary because if you don't have a filter and you get all these signals and inputs from the environment, which are 100,000 per day, you would die. So it's a necessary function, but it is misused because it filters out everything which is not up to what you like. And what you like is very often based on emotions and on repetition. is how advertising, this is how social media is working. So they are narrowing us down. And look at social media, we instantly reply. You see something, so many also hate a post and whatever. instant emotional triggers to respond. So we don't stop, we don't listen and we lose our awareness. We become more dependent on that one. And the awareness is the distance to what we are doing. My brother told me when he started a company he said, Frank I'm not working in the company, I'm working with the company. And that you only can do if you have a certain distance, helping him to have a different perspective on that one. Leaders who can't delegate too much into details or in operations, they always lose the overall perspective and the awareness. So awareness is very important to see what happens to us. Awareness is looking into the mirror. understanding us, looking at us. And I think this is the essential prerequisite to stay ahead, to change perspectives and not to let AI control you, but always stay in control of yourself.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yeah. I'd love to hear what what what are some of the ways that you feel like AI specifically makes this concept of awareness even more critical? Because for example, I you know, I I can see somebody who's who's not practicing this idea of being able to step back, like jumping into their AI and essentially using it as a giant confirmation bias machine. Again, it goes
Frank Beckmann: Mm-hmm.
Jason Griffing: back to that idea we talked about earlier of like, tell me why my idea is good essentially. You're not saying those exact words, but if you're not careful, AI can do that. So how tactically speaking might you recommend somebody bring aware awareness into specifically into their use of AI? Are there prompting techniques? You talked about using multiple models earlier, which I thought was really interesting. Are there other ideas that you can share around you know being more thoughtful or aware of how you're using AI?
Frank Beckmann: Okay, I think you only can create awareness or raise awareness with discipline and with training. So it's not natural that we have it and all these social media or the AI takes it away. It makes it even more difficult to stay aware. So one point I already mentioned is one technique is the pause. If you have a meeting for instance, or if you hear a question pause for three, five seconds even until uncomfortable but that pause prevents that you have an auto reply that you work on auto mode and we all are on autopilot in a certain way and to break that to have a pause is very important yeah it's also another technique i show is a mirror meeting you go into a meeting but you're not actively take part in that one you just observe you just try to understand and try to understand what is behind You are not listening only to the questions, you try to understand the framework of the question. And that all creates a different awareness. This is also reason why we see spirituality growing in the past 20 years. Because spirituality is normally aimed to increase your awareness. So there are also a lot of techniques like meditation and others to create your awareness. And people are increasingly using that because they feel that this is more more needed to stay in control of everything.
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think the big idea there of stepping back is really important. And in fact, Kevin Lotto, who was my previous guest on the show, talked about when he is using AI and he'll, fire off an agent to take care of some big task. What a lot of us power AI users do is then say to ourselves, Okay, this agent is probably going to take a few minutes. So let me immediately jump over to another agent. and give it another task. And pretty soon you've got, three, four, five agents all doing different things. And you're just consumed with orchestrating all
Frank Beckmann: Mm-hmm.
Jason Griffing: of that and making sure that anytime an agent's ready for input, you're jumping in. And that mode of working I find to be really actually stressful and anxiety inducing. And something that I've been doing and that Kevin recommended is like maybe when you fire off an agent to do a task, use the time and the space that that agent is now creating for you. To just take a step back and go take the dog for a walk or you know, whatever it is, go get a glass of water, like just step away and create some space for yourself, like you were talking
Frank Beckmann: you
Jason Griffing: about. And I I think that that sounds like a really simplistic idea, but I've been doing more of that of like, let me just avoid the temptation to fire off three agents or four agents at a time and instead like. do one and then use that space that it's creating for me to actually just kind lean back in my chair and just think about what's going on and where am I at and is this going in the direction that I like. So I think there are simple ideas like that that you can do. And I'm a big believer in the idea of awareness and meditation and things like that to just give yourself some breathing room.
Frank Beckmann: Wonderful, but if you take that space to go for a walk or what others you not necessarily create your awareness. You are just let's say Just doing something else, but it does not create
normally awareness. Yeah, it gives you a bit distance But it doesn't have you to realize what happens. Who are you because awareness is that we see ourself if I ask you how Do you your body feels at the moment you can tell me if I? I can ask you how your mind at the moment feels like. You can tell me. But if somebody can tell or you can tell yourself what your mind thinks, there's an awareness about that. And
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: you can train that with that. That's a difference than just stepping a bit back, but not using that
Jason Griffing: I agree. Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: time to create that awareness. So you really need techniques here and training and some discipline to create that awareness. But that's uncomfortable,
Jason Griffing: I I agree. I
Frank Beckmann: right? That's uncomfortable because
Jason Griffing: it is. Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: it's not comfortable. You don't do the same things you always do. You face something new. You face something unknown. You need discipline. And you have discipline when brushing your teeth every morning. But to have it in a new mode, in new process, it feels so difficult. So
Jason Griffing: It it is.
Frank Beckmann: once you have realized that this is the way to get more appreciation, to get more success, to get more benefits, then you start doing that. But you have to jump into that.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. It's uncomfortable and it also feels like a really abstract idea that if you haven't experienced it, you're it's easy to brush it off. I agree with you. I think that was a good challenge. What what I would say is that yes, g going for a walk in and of itself does not create awareness. The idea though is that what definitely doesn't create awareness is just being glued to your screen and having five agents running at a time and g So it's more of a prerequisite, right? The idea of stepping back and creating space. Yes, there's an additional step to your point of like leaning back in your chair and taking a few deep breaths in and of itself is not going to create more awareness, but it's cre creating an opportunity for you to just ask yourself, okay, what's going on right now? How am I feeling about it? Do I actually think this is going in a in the right direction? All of these sorts of questions that can help steer like focus that lens back inward on. Yourself. So I think that's a really important idea.
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, but each step, even when you say that you use the time not going for another AI agent, I think it's important because it breaks addiction. And we all have this addiction to social media. We get it to AI and to have to break that in whatever way we have, even if it's in small steps. Yeah, absolutely.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yeah, that the the fact that you use the word addiction there is striking because I was just saying to myself the other day as I've, you know, watched my own behaviors, like I include myself in this, I'm not judging, but it's been interesting because I've like so I've been an AI power user since like ChatGPT came out. I kinda jumped right in and so it's been several years for me at this point. But I'm I'm seeing and coaching and helping other people get into it for the first time and you see their eyes light up and you see them As soon as they get that first light bulb moment, I call it, it's my gosh. And
Frank Beckmann: Yes.
Jason Griffing: then boom, boom, boom, they're just doing all these things. And I said to myself the other day, it's like, man, this feels a bit like a drug almost. people get hooked on it and you try to imagine take get having it taken away. And I think that that's a a disconcerting thought to me that we get so hooked on this technology so quickly.
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely, maybe we should call AI addiction intelligence because it has the power
Jason Griffing: Yep.
Frank Beckmann: to do so. Look, the whole thing is just so strange because we were used to have, if we have new technologies, critical technologies like health, like pharma, or even like cars, they need to be certified, they need to be safe before they are allowed to hit the road. Now it's the other way around. So they unleash the technology immediately and now we have to prove why it is unsafe. around and that is I think very critical what happens here and that is why it makes can make people addictive because there is no control in between
Jason Griffing: Yeah. Yeah. I I agree with that. I want to I was shift gears a little bit as we're coming down the home stretch of our time and talk about the idea of differentiating as a business in the age of AI. So it's always been important as a business to have a unique selling point, you clear differentiation from your competitors. There's this interesting dynamic with AI where we all feel more creative. We all feel like we're putting out more innovative ideas into the world. But if you step back and look at it from the aggregate We're all converging. You talked about it earlier, every LinkedIn post looking the same, every strategy deck looking the same. So it's this
Frank Beckmann: Mm-hmm.
Jason Griffing: kind of paradox where we feel more creative, but we're actually converging and becoming more similar in our outputs. Talk about from your perspective, you know, you've worked with a lot of businesses, you've got a unique lens on the business landscape. Talk about the idea of differentiating in the age of AI. How is it more difficult? Why is it even more important than ever?
Frank Beckmann: That's a very important question. And last week I had an event and I met a guy, CEO of a company, international company I knew him for years. And he came to me and said, Frank, Frank, Frank, we have built a new strategy and this is amazing. And now we will outpace our competitors. So I said, wow, that's great. Now, how did you build this strategy? He said, yeah, we use our AI agents. We employ AI agents since nine months. They know our company and it's just great what
they can do. they know the markets, the dynamics, they know competition, they give us predictions. So we worked on that one and of course we put our own ideas into that but 80 % was really based on the AI. I said wow that sounds amazing. Who are your biggest competitors? He said well we have two competitors who are on the same level and one who is a bit behind. I said okay now imagine your next competitor Maybe they also build a new strategy. How will they do it? And his eyes opened and he said, well, I think maybe they use AI. I said, yeah, how different will be their strategy than your strategy? And he said, very similar. said, yeah, maybe the same. And the next competitor also. So what would happen
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: is due to AI, companies will converge. They will lose their uniqueness and lose their competitive edge. This is one of the biggest threats hardly anybody sees at the moment and I'm advocating for that one. It is so important really to see that uniqueness is not coming from AI. It's all the same. If you ask Claude or if you ask Shadjib Iti for your strategy and you are a competitor, you will get the same answers. Yeah, definitely. So what you
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: said at the beginning, I don't want to hear what AI says, I want to hear what you say. And the difference, the uniqueness of the companies is really the humans inside and it's not the AI. And that's the danger I see in the future. So if companies converge, we will lose a lot of companies because if they are
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: similar, they won't be profitable anymore. Yeah.
Jason Griffing: Yep. Yeah, you've you've said that the the future belongs not to the companies who learn how to use AI the best, but to those who figure out what AI can't do and how to lean into
Frank Beckmann: Mm-hmm.
Jason Griffing: that gap. And I'd love to hear you elaborate on that as we again come down the home stretch here.
Frank Beckmann: Yes, just said, like awareness for instance, creativity, innovation does not really come from AI. It can't come from AI. You have to find out what it cannot do because this is your value, your asset, and you have to build on that one. Even though it gets smaller as AI gets more more intelligent, people think about or discuss what about emotions. AI does not have emotions. They can improvise, they can pretend emotions, they can read your emotions better. I just had a startup from Israel and they told me, I can ask you in a video call five questions and I can tell you if it's right or wrong, like a polygraph. So AI
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: can detect things, can detect emotions with us, also from the voice, which we even cannot do. So saying we are better in emotions, no. They can do it better, even though the existence of emotions is within us, but that doesn't help us. I recently came across a video from Krishnamurti that was from 1985. He was talking about the computer, because there was
no AI in robots. He already said that the computer can do everything better than we humans can do.
Jason Griffing: Mm.
Frank Beckmann: The only thing which we humans are left with are our emotions and our loneliness. That's very sad,
Jason Griffing: Interesting.
Frank Beckmann: but it's absolutely interesting, it's fascinating, and that was in 1985. And I think we need to be honest towards us to see what remains. What remains, what AI cannot do better. And are we okay with that one? Because still we are the decision makers. Still, in 10 years maybe not. Maybe then it's the AI who takes the decisions. But now... working, changing perspectives, not being narrow-minded, creating awareness. Take your teams along, bring diversity, bring different perspectives in the team, in the whole organization. And this is what helps to stay on top of your competition and to
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm.
Frank Beckmann: be sustainable success. All others, I think that's the most part, will get problems which they don't see at the moment. So you have to act now. In two years, in three years or four years. And there are techniques, approaches in my book which you can use immediately and that will change. However you have to do it for neuroscience has two to three months to really have a change. It needs
Jason Griffing: Yeah.
Frank Beckmann: discipline and it needs courage to be uncomfortable, to see sit between the chairs.
Jason Griffing: Yeah. That's a great place to segue into I love to ask the same closing question of my guests as well, which is how optimistic or pessimistic are you when it comes to our ability as humans to navigate this AI transformation in a way that ensures human flourish human flourishing and that we maintain agency through it all?
Frank Beckmann: Yes, that's a difficult question, a very difficult one because it's so difficult to foresee or to forecast what happens in the future. I think it will be very difficult for us to keep agency and to stay ahead. It's not only AI. And what we see is there are very big tech players who are now networking, investing each other. They become a community. And their goal is also to control everything. And AI helps them to be able to control most of the world. And I think that will be very difficult to stay independent and to stay ahead of that one. I think that will be very very difficult. That's really challenging and AI is just one milestone on our journey. Next thing which we expect, which we don't see at the moment, is quantum. Let's imagine in five years or ten years quantum is coming. And quantum allows us now to calculate the universe, to calculate the human body, the earth and nature, complex scenarios. But we can't understand that because it's too complex, as you said. AI is the only
Jason Griffing: Hm.
Frank Beckmann: one to translate that to us. But AI will then only translate to us what they think we should know. And the rest they will have. So we get more more dependent on AI and only AI then we'll understand what's really going on. So I see it bit more pessimistic, which does not mean we should be pessimistic, we should be optimistic, we should learn, we should evolve. We need discipline to stay ahead. If we stay in the comfort zone, I think for these people staying in the comfort zone, I'm pessimistic. They will lose in a certain way and it's also quality of life which is on the stake. So go out of the comfort for us on change your perspectives create awareness you know I think and you can use AI for creating awareness as well you should do that yeah but you should also have some other techniques to not only be involved in AI all the time
Jason Griffing: Mm-hmm. Yeah. I I appreciate that honest perspective. And I think one of the things I think about is being pessimistic is not the same as being a defeatist, right? And and so I think, you
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely.
Jason Griffing: know, like none of these outcomes are are preordained. And even if you are pessimistic about it, that's not a reason to throw your hands up and sort of be fatalistic about it. In fact, it's even more
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely.
Jason Griffing: of a call to action, I would say, to get in, to get into the game and try to take a thoughtful approach. And I think everything that we've talked about here on today's podcast is a these are great practices that if all of us can bring these to our to our AI use and the AI use inside of our companies we'll we'll be in a better place. And again, we can help try to steer this towards a positive outcome, which is a big part of what I am trying to do with this show. And I appreciate you taking some time to join me and share your ideas as as part of that. if there's anyone listening to the show
Frank Beckmann: Absolutely.
Jason Griffing: who wants to connect with you. maybe learn more about the work you're doing or ask a follow up question, what would be the best way for them to do that?
Frank Beckmann: Go on LinkedIn, look for Frank Anaya Beckman or look for kaleidoscope-leadership.com It's also in my book on the first page, you have your homepage, you have my email there as well. So buy a book, read it, become part of the mission. Change, learn, develop and you can always contact me via the email then or via LinkedIn. I always answer. So I'm not the
Jason Griffing: Excellent.
Frank Beckmann: guy who just has thousands of mails or requests on LinkedIn. I'm not answering, I'm answering everybody.
Jason Griffing: Awesome. Love that. Well, I will also include links to that in the show notes. And Frank, thank you again for taking some time to join me. This has been a lot of fun.
Frank Beckmann: Jason, thanks very much. Great question. I love it. Great conversation. And thank you very much for doing that because it's important at these times that these podcasts are here to help people with a better understanding of the whole topic. Yeah. Wonderful. Thank you very much, Jason. Thank you. Bye
Jason Griffing: Yeah, it was my pleasure. Thank you and have a great rest of your day. All right. Take care.
Frank Beckmann: bye.