अनुलिपि 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:01.017 --> 00:00:06.487
Good morning, this is John Richardson speaking with you from Toronto, Canada.
00:00:07.404 --> 00:00:09.819
It is Friday, November the 20th,
00:00:09.970 --> 00:00:17.088
2026, and I am very happy today to have somebody who is a return guest.
00:00:17.088 --> 00:00:21.598
I haven't spoken to him for at least a year or so, so I'd like to introduce
00:00:21.598 --> 00:00:25.198
you to Jimmy Sexton, who runs the Esquire Group.
00:00:25.198 --> 00:00:31.468
Esquiregroup.com would be the coordinates. He is a U.S. tax advisor based in
00:00:31.468 --> 00:00:36.908
Dubai, and I would say at this point that we go back a lot of years,
00:00:36.908 --> 00:00:38.098
Jimmy. Would that be right?
00:00:39.498 --> 00:00:43.738
I would say probably not close to 10 years. Yeah, probably it is.
00:00:44.698 --> 00:00:50.738
Time flies. Well, as you know, I have an interest in expatriation.
00:00:50.738 --> 00:00:54.598
That is renunciation of citizenship and getting rid of green cards.
00:00:54.598 --> 00:01:00.388
And Jimmy is a fellow advisor on that journey. So this is going to be a wonderful
00:01:00.388 --> 00:01:05.274
opportunity to get his perspective on these issues sitting in Dubai.
00:01:05.869 --> 00:01:10.368
And an actual expatriate on top of that And an actual expatriate actually had
00:01:10.368 --> 00:01:13.848
the experience of going out and announcing citizenship himself My God,
00:01:13.848 --> 00:01:19.348
we're going to get this upside down, sideways, and diagonally today,
00:01:19.985 --> 00:01:22.298
So, where would we begin, I guess?
00:01:22.298 --> 00:01:27.361
First of all, before we get into that, let's just talk a little bit about what you do professionally,
00:01:28.220 --> 00:01:33.368
So, I mean, obviously it includes all this international tax stuff But in what
00:01:33.368 --> 00:01:38.538
context, what exactly do you do that allows you to sit in that expensive chair in Dubai?
00:01:38.538 --> 00:01:41.937
I'm very impressed with this chair you've got. Thank you. Thank you.
00:01:42.472 --> 00:01:49.641
So I mostly work on multinational estate planning for families that have U.S. connected persons.
00:01:50.048 --> 00:01:53.634
I also do it for families that don't have U.S. connected persons.
00:01:54.377 --> 00:01:58.258
But I would say that for by and large, there's U.S. connected persons involved.
00:01:58.258 --> 00:02:02.633
So, you know, you have a non-resident alien dad, you know, American mom.
00:02:02.865 --> 00:02:04.990
American kids, how do you plan for that?
00:02:05.956 --> 00:02:09.978
And then, you know, also work a lot of, you know, foreign investment into the U.S.
00:02:09.978 --> 00:02:14.338
And structure that because obviously we have the estate tax issues and things of that nature.
00:02:14.338 --> 00:02:19.358
And then like you, I work with a lot of people helping them expatriate and abandon
00:02:19.358 --> 00:02:23.038
their green cards, which is something, as I think
Load full transcript
we were talking about a few
00:02:23.038 --> 00:02:26.318
minutes ago before the checkout, that we're seeing more and more of.
00:02:26.661 --> 00:02:28.838
I mean, that seems to be a little bit of a snowball.
00:02:29.830 --> 00:02:34.938
Yeah, I think that's right. Right. So anyway, without too much elaboration,
00:02:34.938 --> 00:02:40.688
if I were to say anytime U.S. gets involved, citizenship, green cardness,
00:02:40.688 --> 00:02:44.707
whatever, it gets more expensive and complicated, would that be accurate?
00:02:45.276 --> 00:02:47.352
That would be 100% accurate.
00:02:47.967 --> 00:02:51.818
Yeah. So it's expensive to be an American. Okay. Yeah, absolutely.
00:02:52.258 --> 00:02:55.778
Absolutely. And, you know, and the work you're doing is, you know,
00:02:56.118 --> 00:03:00.518
I think difficult. It requires a certain intricate kind of thinking.
00:03:01.638 --> 00:03:05.398
And it's interesting because so many of the ways that people would think about
00:03:05.398 --> 00:03:09.818
this are initially are totally counterintuitive. I mean, do you find your clients
00:03:09.818 --> 00:03:11.477
look at you and say, what?
00:03:12.133 --> 00:03:16.178
That couldn't possibly be right? yeah no i mean look,
00:03:16.758 --> 00:03:21.248
i i feel like i'm usually the you know if they let me plan it from the beginning
00:03:21.248 --> 00:03:24.178
they might not be happy about it but they've already done planning and then
00:03:24.178 --> 00:03:28.070
they want my advice put it this way i'm rarely the bearer of goodness you know.
00:03:30.044 --> 00:03:34.608
Well i i think i think that's right i think that's right and not only you're
00:03:34.608 --> 00:03:39.968
not only the bearer of good news but this is not a situation where no news is
00:03:39.968 --> 00:03:41.300
good news would you agree,
00:03:42.011 --> 00:03:46.091
first for sure you know i had i had a case.
00:03:47.213 --> 00:03:54.464
It was somebody that had set up a foreign trust and for the benefit of their kids and all that stuff.
00:03:55.137 --> 00:04:00.397
And they didn't realize that it was going to be, you know, a foreign grantor
00:04:00.397 --> 00:04:04.430
trust. And there was going to be 3520s and 3528s and all that kind of stuff.
00:04:05.073 --> 00:04:09.915
Luckily, they set the trust up, but they never put in the 10 bucks to fund it
00:04:10.286 --> 00:04:11.807
or transferred anything to it.
00:04:11.807 --> 00:04:15.679
So I think you're pretty safe that it's a nothing without being funded.
00:04:16.170 --> 00:04:23.427
But otherwise, you know, they had years of unfiled 3520As and 3520s that,
00:04:23.427 --> 00:04:25.322
you know, could be some expensive penalties.
00:04:25.914 --> 00:04:31.933
Yeah. AKA, in other words, the synonym for U.S. tax warrants would really be penalties.
00:04:32.785 --> 00:04:39.058
For sure. I mean, look, I think with the 3520, I think it's like 5% of the gift,
00:04:39.581 --> 00:04:44.422
or $100,000 a month or something ridiculous like that, up to 25%.
00:04:45.337 --> 00:04:51.560
That is correct. The problem with it is the way the statute reads,
00:04:51.687 --> 00:04:56.227
the statute in that area, I think, reads in mandatory language,
00:04:56.227 --> 00:04:58.186
shall pay or something like this, right?
00:04:58.992 --> 00:05:02.156
Yeah. And this adds another dimension to it.
00:05:02.522 --> 00:05:05.842
Well, you know, and that's something interesting, right? I mean,
00:05:06.225 --> 00:05:11.047
you know, you have, I'm sure, I don't know if you're familiar with this form 5472. Yeah.
00:05:12.287 --> 00:05:16.291
You know, you got the 5472 that if you have a U S foreign owned LLC,
00:05:16.680 --> 00:05:18.433
you gotta file this 5472.
00:05:18.991 --> 00:05:24.140
It used to be an automatic $10,000 penalty. Now it's an automatic $25,000 penalty.
00:05:24.819 --> 00:05:29.437
And I've seen those assessed like plot. Like I've never seen one filed like
00:05:29.437 --> 00:05:34.167
it where they have an assessment, but the 3520s, I mean, up until a few years
00:05:34.167 --> 00:05:39.487
ago, they never assessed the penalties. Like if you file that voluntarily.
00:05:40.315 --> 00:05:45.160
I never saw a penalty assessed, but the last few years, what I've heard from,
00:05:45.160 --> 00:05:50.250
from, you know, people that file those forms is that they've been automatically
00:05:50.250 --> 00:05:51.466
assessing the penalties,
00:05:51.972 --> 00:05:56.140
on, on late filed 3520s, which, which can get expensive, you know,
00:05:56.140 --> 00:06:00.060
and especially not even when it comes to foreign trusts, but the gifts from
00:06:00.060 --> 00:06:02.414
non-resident aliens, you know, if they're over the a hundred grand,
00:06:02.925 --> 00:06:07.110
and, and there's, you know, there are a lot, I'd be surprised.
00:06:07.110 --> 00:06:12.581
I feel like in recent years, this is something that I've seen more and more of, you know,
00:06:13.210 --> 00:06:18.250
foreign parents giving their American kids something and then just finding out
00:06:18.250 --> 00:06:22.834
later that this 3520 should have been filed and what the potential repercussions are.
00:06:23.485 --> 00:06:27.880
And to be relaxed, I think for listeners, okay, well, here, I'll summarize the
00:06:27.880 --> 00:06:32.310
rule, and you can agree or disagree, but where I'm going with this is that,
00:06:32.310 --> 00:06:35.900
you know, the way you're describing it, the imaging I'm getting is sort of, you know.
00:06:37.049 --> 00:06:41.300
Somebody living in the United States receiving a gift from a foreign person,
00:06:41.300 --> 00:06:43.481
but this would apply to Americans abroad, right?
00:06:44.224 --> 00:06:48.595
You know, this is a problem. But the rule that he's talking about,
00:06:49.191 --> 00:06:55.080
I think it's 6039F, I think, of the Internal Revenue Code, but it's in that area.
00:06:55.080 --> 00:06:58.440
Anyway, basically what it says is that if a U.S.
00:06:58.440
--> 00:07:03.990
Person receives a gift of, the way it's interpreted now, of over $100,000 in
00:07:03.990 --> 00:07:08.350
a year from a foreign individual, meaning a non-resident alien,
00:07:08.350 --> 00:07:12.612
there's a reporting requirement, and the penalties are just enormous.
00:07:12.873 --> 00:07:15.520
And they have been assessing them. That's what's incredible.
00:07:15.520 --> 00:07:20.090
I mean, it's the most counterintuitive rule because, you know,
00:07:20.090 --> 00:07:22.457
there's no tax associated with it, right?
00:07:23.088 --> 00:07:26.340
Yep. No, no, there's no tax. I'm going to give you a perfect example because
00:07:26.340 --> 00:07:30.294
you were talking about Americans abroad. You know, I have a client...
00:07:31.131 --> 00:07:37.046
The entire family, I mean, the entire extended family is not American and never has them.
00:07:37.707 --> 00:07:41.765
It's just this particular guy, because their other passport,
00:07:42.369 --> 00:07:48.315
because, you know, their citizenship isn't a great one, ensured that his three
00:07:48.315 --> 00:07:49.668
kids were born in the U.S.
00:07:50.317 --> 00:07:54.990
So out of this entire extended, very large family, it's only these three kids
00:07:55.350 --> 00:08:00.383
that are American. So they have no idea of tax laws in America or nothing. They understand.
00:08:01.045 --> 00:08:06.845
If the kids, you know, and so the reason they contacted me is because your father goes, listen,
00:08:07.598 --> 00:08:12.955
like, like kids are going to turn 18 and I think they need to start filing taxes
00:08:12.955 --> 00:08:14.413
in the U S because, because he,
00:08:14.930 --> 00:08:18.485
because he doesn't know what he's talking about, but he knew there was something
00:08:18.485 --> 00:08:24.206
with the U S and it turns out it's kids don't need to file because they don't earn any income.
00:08:24.786 --> 00:08:35.161
But the issue is that these kids has received millions of dollars in, in gifts over the years.
00:08:35.306 --> 00:08:40.102
And, you know, they just have no idea. I mean, these kids aren't even 18, you know what I mean?
00:08:40.625 --> 00:08:45.385
Or, or just turned 18 or something. I mean, they had no idea and their parents
00:08:45.745 --> 00:08:48.885
certainly didn't have any idea, but you know.
00:08:50.561 --> 00:08:55.371
Yeah, well, I mean, it's such a serious problem that maybe a rule of life in
00:08:55.371 --> 00:09:00.061
the 21st century is be careful and look very carefully to see if there's any
00:09:00.061 --> 00:09:03.169
U.S. citizens in your family. Yeah. I mean.
00:09:05.341 --> 00:09:11.412
This is 100% correct. I mean, you know, it's from a tax perspective,
00:09:11.952 --> 00:09:12.817
you know, it's a nightmare.
00:09:14.961 --> 00:09:18.141
Both the tax and the reporting. I mean, it's a total nightmare,
00:09:18.141 --> 00:09:21.146
period. I mean, there's nothing quite like it, that's for sure.
00:09:21.442 --> 00:09:26.121
Well, the reporting going to the 3520, right? I mean, that's the killout because
00:09:26.121 --> 00:09:27.950
that form doesn't even trigger tax.
00:09:28.304 --> 00:09:30.870
You know, you're just doing the reporting.
00:09:31.288 --> 00:09:34.771
And, you know, there's $100,000. It's not like that's indexed for inflation,
00:09:34.771 --> 00:09:38.521
right? I mean, it's been $100,000 since I've been in this business,
00:09:38.521 --> 00:09:42.184
and that's over 20 years at this point. Yeah, yeah.
00:09:42.886 --> 00:09:46.521
No question about it. Well, I mean, this would be worth a separate podcast.
00:09:47.221 --> 00:09:52.271
Is how inflation increases the tax and penalty exposure in many areas.
00:09:52.271 --> 00:09:56.371
I mean, it's extraordinary, right? I mean, you can actually raise,
00:09:56.371 --> 00:10:00.951
you can actually let, these governments can actually let inflation raise their
00:10:00.951 --> 00:10:05.251
revenues, right, without doing anything, which is another huge problem.
00:10:05.251 --> 00:10:09.191
But, I mean, you know, the immediate example that comes to mind is the obvious
00:10:09.191 --> 00:10:12.222
$2 million threshold to be a covered expatriate, right?
00:10:13.096 --> 00:10:17.133
I mean, you know, so that starts in 2008 and, you know, I don't know how much
00:10:17.133 --> 00:10:21.343
less, but there's absolutely no question that more and more people haven't covered
00:10:21.343 --> 00:10:23.191
expatriates just through inflation, right?
00:10:23.826 --> 00:10:28.859
No, of course. I mean, look, 2 million bucks, you know, 17 years ago.
00:10:29.283 --> 00:10:33.759
It's a lot more than 2 million bucks today. Mm-hmm.
00:10:34.493 --> 00:10:36.269
Yeah, no question about that. Yeah.
00:10:37.042 --> 00:10:43.123
Well, so what about shifting over into the whole issue of expatriation,
00:10:43.123 --> 00:10:47.768
meaning renunciation of U.S. citizenship and abandoning the green cards?
00:10:48.477 --> 00:10:49.852
You're seeing increases in both.
00:10:50.603 --> 00:10:55.137
Yeah, I'm seeing increases in both, especially the green cards.
00:10:56.384 --> 00:10:59.322
But yeah, I'm seeing a lot more of both.
00:10:59.757 --> 00:11:05.503
And I mean, most of them are, you know, most of them, most of my clients are,
00:11:05.503 --> 00:11:09.100
are, you know, when the citizens are, are dual citizens.
00:11:10.286 --> 00:11:13.573
Tax compliant, and they've been aware of the filing, you know,
00:11:13.573 --> 00:11:16.103
requirements and taxes and everything.
00:11:16.103 --> 00:11:21.863
You've been doing it for, for years, but, you know, one of the big,
00:11:21.863 --> 00:11:24.203
but now they're just one out, you know, and the same with the,
00:11:24.203 --> 00:11:25.268
with the green card holders.
00:11:26.023 --> 00:11:30.392
And a lot of them, I mean, look, part of it, and I mean, a big part of it is,
00:11:30.752 --> 00:11:33.516
and I mean, I'm sure you can attest to this being a Canadian,
00:11:34.544 --> 00:11:38.617
you know, America is not loved right now. Getting.
00:11:39.249 --> 00:11:44.383
Yeah, in a lot of the world. And, you know, it's been getting more unpopular,
00:11:44.803 --> 00:11:50.481
you know, as the years go by, even before you know, the current president.
00:11:51.073 --> 00:11:55.953
And so I think a lot of people, you know, So it's not just the difficulty of
00:11:55.953 --> 00:11:59.355
doing business and the reporting and the tax and all this stuff,
00:11:59.860 --> 00:12:05.793
but then it's also kind of, you know, being aided just for being American.
00:12:05.793 --> 00:12:09.630
I think a lot of people are sort of doing it in protest a little bit.
00:12:10.787 --> 00:12:19.023
It seems to me that I am seeing for the first time people expressing up front,
00:12:19.691 --> 00:12:24.680
as a reason for renunciation of the political situation in the United States.
00:12:24.680 --> 00:12:28.760
I'm definitely seeing more of that. I don't think it's usually the only reason,
00:12:28.760 --> 00:12:32.430
but I do think it's something that's pushing people over the top.
00:12:33.055 --> 00:12:36.590
That's what I wanted to say. I think it's kind of the straw that broke the camel's back.
00:12:39.605 --> 00:12:45.080
You know, on the green card thing, I agree with you that at least the interaction
00:12:45.080 --> 00:12:49.880
I have, and apparently same thing with you, you're having more interaction with
00:12:49.880 --> 00:12:52.958
people who want professional help getting rid of green cards, right?
00:12:54.070 --> 00:12:58.460
I wonder if that isn't just more heightened awareness of the problems,
00:12:58.460 --> 00:13:00.420
you know, and more education out there.
00:13:00.420 --> 00:13:03.960
Because what I do find is I get a lot of people who, you know,
00:13:03.960 --> 00:13:07.750
well, I moved from the United 20 years ago, my green card expired.
00:13:07.750 --> 00:13:10.581
What's this? You know, sort of thing, right?
00:13:11.208 --> 00:13:18.990
Is that your experience? No. So most of my people have been people with active
00:13:18.990 --> 00:13:23.637
green cards that just weren't sure if they were going to go back to the U.S.
00:13:24.291 --> 00:13:27.826
And then just now kind of deciding, no, not doing it.
00:13:28.812 --> 00:13:34.120
And, but not, I haven't had a case with somebody that, you know,
00:13:34.120 --> 00:13:39.102
this sort of expired green card, right? Where they just never, never left properly.
00:13:39.479 --> 00:13:41.227
I haven't had one of those in several years.
00:13:41.610 --> 00:13:44.490
That's right. That's very interesting. Very interesting. So,
00:13:44.490 --> 00:13:47.605
you know, my experience is more of the opposite on it, but okay.
00:13:48.277 --> 00:13:52.160
But, but I will, but I will tell you, I will tell you what's interesting with,
00:13:52.160 --> 00:13:54.506
with the, with the green card thing, right?
00:13:55.430 --> 00:14:01.880
Virginia and I, you know, we both know went down a rabbit hole on this a few years back.
00:14:02.657 --> 00:14:07.667
You know, what is the controlling date, you know, for the abandonment, right?
00:14:07.899 --> 00:14:11.940
Because, you know, with citizenship, it's easy. It's the day you appeared before
00:14:11.940 --> 00:14:13.130
a consular officer, right?
00:14:13.130 --> 00:14:16.479
I mean, that's that, that it's dons black and white,
00:14:17.111 --> 00:14:20.246
but you know, the green card, you either have to go and, you know,
00:14:20.790 --> 00:14:25.450
you have to basically abandon it by mail unless you, you do it you know when
00:14:25.450 --> 00:14:29.270
you're leaving the u.s and i forget what it's called a you know but there's
00:14:29.270 --> 00:14:34.478
certain ports of exit where you can abandon on the way out but,
00:14:35.397 --> 00:14:41.705
you know so so nobody it's not clear on the regulations or the guidance or anything,
00:14:42.227 --> 00:14:46.151
what the controlling date is right when you abandon is it the date you mail it in.
00:14:47.184 --> 00:14:50.394
Is it the date they receive it? Is it the date they stamp it?
00:14:50.904 --> 00:14:56.924
And I forget what code section it was, but Virginia and I found an old code
00:14:56.924 --> 00:15:04.524
section that said something about when you mail in your letter that you want.
00:15:06.027 --> 00:15:06.817
To abandon.
00:15:07.293 --> 00:15:12.684
And I think this is even before they got a form I-407, but it's still on the books, right?
00:15:12.684 --> 00:15:17.104
So we kind of thought, well, look, you send the I-407, which is the current
00:15:17.104 --> 00:15:22.414
requirement, with a letter, say, you know, you're sending your stuff and you
00:15:22.414 --> 00:15:24.027
want to abandon and the stuff.
00:15:25.264 --> 00:15:29.144
That we believe that there's a reasonable argument that it would be the date
00:15:29.144 --> 00:15:30.482
you mail it that controls.
00:15:30.935 --> 00:15:36.294
But what are your thoughts on that? My thought is that it is the date that it
00:15:36.294 --> 00:15:41.804
gets sent in, as long as it goes by registered, you know, some kind of service
00:15:41.804 --> 00:15:43.544
that would acknowledge receipt.
00:15:44.024 --> 00:15:52.044
You will find Treasury Reg 7701 in there somewhere. I can actually send it to you.
00:15:52.704 --> 00:15:56.539
That's what I've been working with anyway, because that's the only thing that makes sense to me.
00:15:57.347 --> 00:16:02.024
I mean, it's also consistent with, you know, of course, we understand that the
00:16:02.024 --> 00:16:04.850
tax rules are different from the immigration rules. So, yeah.
00:16:05.552 --> 00:16:10.709
You know, I think you could be in a situation where you could cease to be a
00:16:10.709 --> 00:16:15.339
resident for tax purposes, still have the green card, you know,
00:16:15.339 --> 00:16:17.319
for immigration purposes, et cetera.
00:16:17.319 --> 00:16:23.579
My general
advice to people is to try to do it in a way that you're logged out
00:16:23.579 --> 00:16:27.857
for tax purposes and immigration purposes in the same year.
00:16:28.490 --> 00:16:33.629
100%. You know, and that your, you know, and that your net worth and stuff could
00:16:33.629 --> 00:16:35.990
survive a challenge either way.
00:16:36.175 --> 00:16:41.619
Because, you know, you put your finger on, like, this is so odd that it is so
00:16:41.619 --> 00:16:46.653
difficult to find anything particularly authoritative on this, right?
00:16:47.832 --> 00:16:52.489
Other than that one reg. But that's what I do anyway. That's what I do. That's how I view it.
00:16:53.355 --> 00:16:58.209
Well, I mean, look, the other big argument that you always hear people talk
00:16:58.209 --> 00:17:01.349
about, too, is the certification, right, on the 8854.
00:17:02.029 --> 00:17:04.391
Is it at the time that you're filing the 8854?
00:17:07.269 --> 00:17:12.049
Or what are you certifying? What's the time frame that's covered for that,
00:17:12.049 --> 00:17:16.199
right? Are you certifying that you're tasked and applied at the time of expatriation
00:17:16.199 --> 00:17:17.677
or at the time of filing the form?
00:17:18.198 --> 00:17:22.389
I think it's, I think it's gotta be time of filing because, you know,
00:17:22.749 --> 00:17:26.460
how could you then have somebody say renounce January 15th?
00:17:27.120 --> 00:17:31.189
Yeah. Right. I mean, they wouldn't. Well, you'd still, you'd still technically
00:17:31.189 --> 00:17:36.054
be in compliance though, because the return wouldn't be due until the next year. Right.
00:17:37.198 --> 00:17:40.091
Yeah, but you wouldn't be in compliance for the five years, right?
00:17:40.091 --> 00:17:42.150
The test is the five years. Yeah.
00:17:42.307 --> 00:17:47.041
Yeah. So I don't know. I mean, obviously, I agree with you a thousand percent,
00:17:47.041 --> 00:17:51.201
okay, that there's plenty of room, you know, for ambiguity here.
00:17:51.201 --> 00:17:54.311
So I think, you know, when you're dealing with people, you have to do your best
00:17:54.311 --> 00:17:58.340
to protect them on, you know, given any interpretation stuff, right?
00:17:59.301 --> 00:18:02.915
You know, and be very, very careful. I mean, there's no doubt about it.
00:18:03.316 --> 00:18:06.451
Yeah. You know, there's a lot of moving parts to this problem,
00:18:06.451 --> 00:18:09.181
and it's very much compounded.
00:18:09.181 --> 00:18:13.131
I mean, the tax stuff is bad enough, right? But it's very much compounded when
00:18:13.131 --> 00:18:14.672
it starts to interact with the,
00:18:15.171 --> 00:18:19.681
you know, either the nationality laws or the, you know, the green law.
00:18:20.381 --> 00:18:27.113
So it's tough. I mean, you know, I have these conversations with people often,
00:18:27.569 --> 00:18:31.881
you know, and say, look, you know, we want to protect you no matter what,
00:18:31.881 --> 00:18:34.002
no matter what the interpretation is.
00:18:34.269 --> 00:18:36.510
Yeah, for sure. You know, and that's that.
00:18:37.361 --> 00:18:39.764
I mean, you know, one of these days we should write a book, Jimmy.
00:18:39.764 --> 00:18:41.947
We'll call it The Expatriation Games.
00:18:42.394 --> 00:18:48.048
We should. We should. But hopefully we can only strive to be as good as for good and evil.
00:18:49.169 --> 00:18:53.764
Oh, yeah. Well, of course. Now, yeah. So Jimmy's referencing this great book
00:18:53.764 --> 00:18:58.044
by Charles Adams for good and evil, the impact of tax and civilization.
00:18:58.044 --> 00:19:01.234
We did a series of podcasts on that a couple of years ago. It's important.
00:19:02.281 --> 00:19:06.901
But, Jimmy, I got a question for you. Would you agree with me that taxation is destiny?
00:19:08.094 --> 00:19:14.954
Yeah and the taxation is the destiny and the death it's destiny to fail states right oh yeah,
00:19:15.854 --> 00:19:20.324
yeah it always winds you know it's when you read when you read that book you're
00:19:20.324 --> 00:19:28.654
just like man since the beginning of time this has just been destroying civilizations and then and you know,
00:19:29.142 --> 00:19:33.534
governments of every kind and then it's just don't learn oh absolutely well
00:19:33.534 --> 00:19:35.114
to read this end of the podcast.
00:19:35.114 --> 00:19:38.101
It's still on my desk, Jimmy. Here you go. Yeah. I love it.
00:19:39.836 --> 00:19:43.754
So this is, well, certainly Jimmy and I, and anybody else who's actually read
00:19:43.754 --> 00:19:48.112
this book, I think would agree that it's probably up there as one of the greatest books ever written.
00:19:51.233 --> 00:19:56.354
It's called For Good and Evil, The Impact of Taxes on the Course of Civilization
00:19:56.354 --> 00:19:59.430
by Charles Adams, the late Charles Adams.
00:20:00.072 --> 00:20:02.964
And I was amazed. I didn't discover the book, of course, until,
00:20:02.964 --> 00:20:06.294
I don't know, probably about the time I met you, whenever that would have been, right?
00:20:07.467 --> 00:20:10.479
So Charles Adams, believe it or not, I'm a University of Toronto graduate.
00:20:10.676 --> 00:20:13.341
He actually taught at the University of Toronto at one period.
00:20:13.666 --> 00:20:16.935
No, I was there, but I thought that was a bit of interesting trivia.
00:20:17.612 --> 00:20:21.494
So, you know, your people, back to the expatriations, your people that have
00:20:21.494 --> 00:20:26.157
been expatriated, so are they mostly people based in Canada or all over, or
00:20:26.530 --> 00:20:30.794
are they people that have been living outside the U S like, like Americans abroad
00:20:30.794 --> 00:20:34.302
and accidental Americans getting around to it now, or who's sort of your,
00:20:34.958 --> 00:20:36.534
typical client.
00:20:36.534 --> 00:20:39.359
If, if you have a particular client profile.
00:20:40.744 --> 00:20:46.810
Okay, first of all, my client base generally is
not super, super wealthy people,
00:20:47.077 --> 00:20:49.184
but many of them are covered expatriates.
00:20:49.463 --> 00:20:52.700
Okay. You know, just because of owning real estate or something like that.
00:20:52.700 --> 00:20:58.630
So I think, first of all, the whole notion that it's only wealthy who are,
00:20:58.630 --> 00:21:02.510
you know, expatriating is absolutely ridiculous. In fact, I think...
00:21:03.864 --> 00:21:08.002
I mean, look, I would say the vast majority are not wealthy, right? I mean...
00:21:08.615 --> 00:21:11.910
Yeah, they just can't afford the compliance. I mean, it's real simple.
00:21:11.910 --> 00:21:15.001
They want to be in compliance. It makes them nervous. They can't.
00:21:15.634 --> 00:21:19.976
You know, they can't understand the rules. The advisors are super expensive.
00:21:20.638 --> 00:21:23.610
Yeah. And, you know, they just throw up their hands and, you know,
00:21:23.610 --> 00:21:27.308
I'm out. Not because I don't want to pay taxes.
00:21:27.948 --> 00:21:29.270
They don't owe taxes.
00:21:29.922 --> 00:21:33.138
Most of them don't owe any taxes anyway. Yeah, that's right.
00:21:34.299 --> 00:21:37.750
You know, but because I can't manage the compliance. I mean, it's crazy.
00:21:37.750 --> 00:21:40.250
So, you know, you ask this question, you know, so you're talking about,
00:21:40.250 --> 00:21:44.140
you're talking about, maybe you can comment on this before we started recording
00:21:44.140 --> 00:21:46.580
about your client and Zagreb or whatever, right?
00:21:46.580 --> 00:21:52.510
But, you know, when they ask her, you know, are you renouncing to avoid the
00:21:52.510 --> 00:21:56.600
payment of U.S. taxes? I mean, the answer is overwhelming. I'm not doing that.
00:21:56.600 --> 00:21:59.068
I don't owe any U.S. taxes. How in the world, you know?
00:21:59.720 --> 00:22:04.248
Yeah. You know, but you impose a bunch of expensive compliance costs on people,
00:22:04.846 --> 00:22:09.020
you know, where they can't manage it, you know, that's, that's why people are getting out.
00:22:09.020 --> 00:22:12.540
Well, and I mean, look, I think, you know, a lot of people don't realize that,
00:22:12.540 --> 00:22:17.610
you know, I mean, a lot of Americans, you know, are ordinary folks like teachers,
00:22:17.610 --> 00:22:22.542
which make like 50 grand a year, but you know, if they live in a foreign country, right.
00:22:22.902 --> 00:22:28.230
Then, you know, maybe they actually invested their money in some foreign funds
00:22:28.230 --> 00:22:32.710
and now They got PFICs, they got four retirement plans and all this stuff.
00:22:32.710 --> 00:22:38.030
And now all of a sudden their relatively simple tax situation means a $3,000 tax return.
00:22:39.002 --> 00:22:47.296
And that's a significant portion of annual income that's going to compliance.
00:22:47.477 --> 00:22:50.467
Especially in a country like Canada where it's after tax.
00:22:50.739 --> 00:22:53.984
You know, I mean, you've got to
make $5,000 to pay $3,000.
00:22:54.430 --> 00:22:58.802
Yeah, exactly. And think of it, $5,000 a year. You know, I mean,
00:22:58.802 --> 00:23:01.175
to manage this, it's just crazy talk.
00:23:02.052 --> 00:23:05.472
And then, you know, I mean, here's a characteristic of a lot of people I work
00:23:05.472 --> 00:23:07.409
with in Canada that you might find interesting.
00:23:07.619 --> 00:23:11.370
And this would not be true you know in your part of the world because where i live,
00:23:11.950 --> 00:23:15.184
you know pensions are still a thing right you know there's a lot of people with
00:23:15.544 --> 00:23:19.542
we don't have those right yeah yeah a lot a lot of people with pensions particularly
00:23:19.542 --> 00:23:24.102
teachers pensions okay so you get these people who are you know 35 years of
00:23:24.102 --> 00:23:27.262
teaching high school or being a university professor you know these people got
00:23:27.262 --> 00:23:30.115
pensions worth over a million dollars no problem right Right.
00:23:30.742 --> 00:23:35.615
And then, you know, if they happen to live in a house in downtown Toronto,
00:23:36.211 --> 00:23:39.552
you know, that there, we can now double that. I mean, these people,
00:23:39.552 --> 00:23:42.662
you know, they have no cash, they have no money, but somehow they're wealthy
00:23:42.662 --> 00:23:44.662
enough to be covered expatriates. Right. Yeah.
00:23:45.534 --> 00:23:49.002
And I mean, you know what the rules are and how the U S goes after these foreign
00:23:49.002 --> 00:23:52.922
pensions. It's incredible. So they've got it out. I mean, they're forced out of this.
00:23:54.302 --> 00:23:55.755
I think in general, it's just ordinary.
00:23:56.416 --> 00:24:01.072
Absolutely extraordinary. I mean, it's no wonder that more and more people are doing it, right?
00:24:01.072 --> 00:24:06.962
And I mean, like we were saying, I think the political, I think there's a lot
00:24:06.962 --> 00:24:13.772
of people where the difficulty of being American gets ratcheted up, right?
00:24:14.899 --> 00:24:20.502
At first, it was, okay, the whole world, every American abroad basically is
00:24:20.502 --> 00:24:23.723
not tax compliant. In fact, it came out in 2010, right?
00:24:24.042 --> 00:24:28.252
There's nobody really knew about it. It was probably 100% of Americans abroad
00:24:28.252 --> 00:24:30.228
that were tax compliant in 2010.
00:24:30.564 --> 00:24:33.473
I mean, that might be an exaggeration, but it was a very small amount, right?
00:24:34.077 --> 00:24:38.494
And then the people started going, oh, shit, we got to get into compliance.
00:24:38.924 --> 00:24:41.672
And then it's okay. Then there's the compliance. And then, you know,
00:24:41.672 --> 00:24:44.922
then it's difficult getting bank accounts. Then you can get bank accounts,
00:24:44.922 --> 00:24:46.645
but you can't get private pensions.
00:24:46.993 --> 00:24:49.662
Oh, you can't get the private pensions. Oh, you get a bank account,
00:24:49.662 --> 00:24:52.860
but you can't get a brokerage account because we're not allowed to,
00:24:53.336 --> 00:24:56.837
you know have you invest in there because it's too complicated with the p face,
00:24:57.313 --> 00:25:02.012
oh now we're going to start enforcing the 35 20 penalties because you got for
00:25:02.012 --> 00:25:03.844
a gift you know it just keeps,
00:25:04.517 --> 00:25:08.712
you know at some point the people get boiled to death and and i think that that
00:25:08.712 --> 00:25:12.602
like we were saying before you know now i think with the political situation
00:25:12.602 --> 00:25:17.114
and for a lot of people it's just kind of like you know i tolerated everything up to here but,
00:25:17.636 --> 00:25:20.097
that's too much well i don't you know what,
00:25:21.032 --> 00:25:24.822
you know so we talk about we've tolerated everything up to here and we're pushed
00:25:24.822 --> 00:25:27.702
over the top i think there's another dimension going on here,
00:25:28.344 --> 00:25:32.522
you know you can frame it as you know the political situation but what i think
00:25:32.522 --> 00:25:36.431
is it's just a clear distrust of the united states and where this could go.
00:25:38.155 --> 00:25:41.852
Yeah yeah it's a good way to say that i mean i think it's i think it's largely
00:25:41.852 --> 00:25:47.722
that but what i find amazing is the i mean you know so many people i work with
00:25:47.722 --> 00:25:50.171
like honestly their situations are very simple.
00:25:50.974 --> 00:25:53.993
But, I mean, they're just completely panicked to death, right?
00:25:53.993 --> 00:25:57.073
I mean, you know, and it's interesting. I mean, you know, they have an easy
00:25:57.073 --> 00:26:02.083
exit now. But, I mean, the emotional sort of strain and scars this leaves on
00:26:02.083 --> 00:26:04.564
people, you know, is, I think, enormous.
00:26:05.373 --> 00:26:09.503
You know, I have an interesting question for you, John, because this is actually
00:26:09.503 --> 00:26:14.243
something that I was talking about with Virginia about today and it's something
00:26:14.243 --> 00:26:18.394
that I've had this discussion several times throughout my lifetime.
00:26:18.933 --> 00:26:23.740
But, you know, I don't think I've ever come across citizenship,
00:26:24.368 --> 00:26:29.083
that is so emotional, that people are so emotionally attached to,
00:26:29.083 --> 00:26:32.643
like, the American citizenship, without any logic behind it,
00:26:32.643 --> 00:26:34.260
right? It's like religious nuts.
00:26:34.591 --> 00:26:40.419
You know, they're just whatever proof you show them, right? Like, it doesn't matter.
00:26:42.281 --> 00:26:45.423
But what I—I don't know if your religious figures might be a bad thing.
00:26:45.423 --> 00:26:50.128
What I wanted to say was, you know, I have clients sort of changed from,
00:26:50.813 --> 00:26:55.027
you know, I don't know, German to being Spanish or whatever it is. Right.
00:26:55.515 --> 00:27:01.023
And like to them, it was okay. You know, I, I don't live in Germany anymore.
00:27:01.023 --> 00:27:04.490
I'm in Spain. I'm going to stay here. Why not be Spanish?
00:27:05.448 --> 00:27:12.699
Whatever just no emotional anything tied to the citizenship i've never seen
00:27:13.041 --> 00:27:15.723
i've never seen this other than with american,
00:27:16.269 --> 00:27:20.762
citizens where there's this illogical emotional attachment,
00:27:21.575 --> 00:27:26.729
to this passport i think it has to do from the indoctrination of you know pledging
00:27:26.729 --> 00:27:29.337
allegiance from a kid all the way through that there's just,
00:27:30.120 --> 00:27:34.099
completely attached to it even though it's answer that's exactly i think that's
00:27:34.099 --> 00:27:38.989
a huge huge part of it is this you know i was talking to somebody i don't know
00:27:38.989 --> 00:27:41.420
some somebody or other in the last few months,
00:27:42.023 --> 00:27:47.449
you know about this and i made the point that every i assume this is still true
00:27:47.849 --> 00:27:51.793
that every every american kid growing up in the school starts the day with,
00:27:52.292 --> 00:27:57.189
i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic
00:27:57.189 --> 00:27:58.619
for you know blah blah blah,
00:27:59.473 --> 00:28:02.590
and i was explaining this to her and she looked at me like i was out of my mind,
00:28:03.152 --> 00:28:08.560
yeah like are you kidding me you know etc i mean and you think about it it really,
00:28:09.222 --> 00:28:12.319
you know i mean i think that that's where you know i think a lot of the the
00:28:12.319 --> 00:28:17.309
indoctrination comes from but i think there's a subtle part two to it that works
00:28:17.309 --> 00:28:20.051
at the same time sort of correlatively and that's,
00:28:20.614 --> 00:28:25.139
a sense that if you're growing up and part of the great american experiment
00:28:25.139 --> 00:28:29.749
you are at permanent war with the rest of the world would you agree with that.
00:28:32.040 --> 00:28:39.129
Well, man, I don't know. I mean, look, I think I grew up between the U.S.
00:28:40.709 --> 00:28:45.457
And Austria and Germany, and I never had that feeling.
00:28:46.394 --> 00:28:54.597
Now, it very well could be that other people have that feeling, but I haven't. Yeah.
00:28:55.114 --> 00:28:59.360
Well, at the very least, you know, I mean, you say something enough times,
00:28:59.360 --> 00:29:01.813
and, you know, the brain sort of starts to believe it.
00:29:02.393 --> 00:29:07.290
But what I will say to your point is this, and maybe it's the same thing you're
00:29:07.290 --> 00:29:11.720
saying, or I'll phrase it a little differently, is not that you're at war with
00:29:11.720 --> 00:29:15.930
the rest of the world necessarily, but that the rest of the world is jealous
00:29:15.930 --> 00:29:17.270
and we need to protect ourselves.
00:29:18.300 --> 00:29:22.600
I think maybe we include that. I mean, well, but we see this, this is baked into laws.
00:29:22.600 --> 00:29:25.114
I mean, you know, you make a super interesting point because,
00:29:25.791 --> 00:29:28.940
you know, I mean, you may or may not know this by section number,
00:29:28.940 --> 00:29:33.230
the Immigration Nationality Act, but you know the presumption of immigrant intent, right?
00:29:33.230 --> 00:29:37.700
That every single person who shows up at the border of the United States is,
00:29:38.180 --> 00:29:40.261
doomed to want to stay forever, right?
00:29:40.813 --> 00:29:45.605
Yeah. You know, I mean, this is really, and therefore has the burden of proof,
00:29:46.500 --> 00:29:49.210
which generally a visa will, you know, rebut that, right?
00:29:49.210 --> 00:29:52.170
But, you know, the burden of proof of showing they're not intending to stay
00:29:52.170 --> 00:29:57.680
forever. And that's a very interesting assumption to base an immigration statute
00:29:57.680 --> 00:29:58.599
around, wouldn't you think?
00:29:59.387 --> 00:30:03.010
No, look, I think, I absolutely think it is.
00:30:03.945 --> 00:30:08.076
And I think, you know, I think what's sad was a little bit more philosophical
00:30:08.076 --> 00:30:10.847
than the expatriation point. But I think what the U.S.
00:30:11.376 --> 00:30:16.306
Used to do so well was, you know, look, the vast majority of people that go
00:30:16.306 --> 00:30:24.166
to America legally on a visa or an F-star or whatever for visit or work, they go home, right?
00:30:24.166 --> 00:30:29.076
You know, most of the people that I think stay illegally are people that got
00:30:29.076 --> 00:30:33.146
in illegally, right? It's not, it's not the people that came in legally that
00:30:33.146 --> 00:30:35.566
are, that are overstaying their visas and staying. I mean, not,
00:30:35.566 --> 00:30:38.984
not, I'm sure there's a few, but not, not the most.
00:30:39.646 --> 00:30:43.416
And, you know, the U S used to be a super welcoming country,
00:30:43.416 --> 00:30:47.816
right? Like, you know, you'll form students, which is great.
00:30:47.816 --> 00:30:51.780
They're instilling American values, sending people home. Everybody was welcome.
00:30:52.146 --> 00:30:55.586
And now it's kind of this, no, don't come visit us. Right. Like you're lucky,
00:30:55.586 --> 00:30:59.246
you're lucky if you get in, but then people are kind of seeing what's going
00:30:59.246 --> 00:31:02.866
on there and thinking what's not that great once I get in, right?
00:31:02.866 --> 00:31:06.576
Like the infrastructure's falling apart, there's mass shootings every other day.
00:31:07.607 --> 00:31:13.279
It's crazy. Well, there's definitely a lot of friction. Okay.
00:31:13.759 --> 00:31:18.799
Well, there's definitely heightened friction from, say, 10 years ago of trying to get in.
00:31:19.259 --> 00:31:22.879
But there's an even greater perception of the heightened friction.
00:31:23.379 --> 00:31:26.929
A lot of people are just very
reluctant to go there for whatever reason.
00:31:26.929 --> 00:31:30.492
But I was reading, I think it was Bloomberg or something yesterday that,
00:31:31.089 --> 00:31:35.279
again, who knows if this is true, You know, the number of foreign students studying
00:31:35.279 --> 00:31:37.719
in the United States declined by 15%.
00:31:37.719 --> 00:31:43.099
Now, I mean, that is a big drop. It's a huge loss to America generally.
00:31:43.099 --> 00:31:46.449
But think of how it impacts the local economies that, you know,
00:31:46.449 --> 00:31:49.560
rent apartments to these people, the restaurants.
00:31:50.215 --> 00:31:56.519
I mean, this is not helpful at all to the country, you know, no matter how I see it.
00:31:56.519 --> 00:31:59.579
But, you know, you know, there's there's ebb and flow.
00:31:59.579 --> 00:32:03.569
And, you know, I think that we, I think, you know, if we were to put it charitably,
00:32:03.569 --> 00:32:08.079
I think that this is a period in which people's basic assumptions about the
00:32:08.079 --> 00:32:11.626
United States and what it stands for are being challenged.
00:32:13.254 --> 00:32:17.013
No, I mean, look, I can just say, you know, I think.
00:32:18.828 --> 00:32:28.393
A lot of Americans in America don't understand America's importance to the rest of the world, right?
00:32:29.593 --> 00:32:36.353
How important this role of global policeman actually was, you know?
00:32:36.753 --> 00:32:41.633
And I think I didn't realize that growing up until, you know,
00:32:41.633 --> 00:32:46.283
I moved overseas and it took me several years to understand what the U.S.
00:32:46.283 --> 00:32:47.972
Actually gives the world.
00:32:48.506 --> 00:32:53.243
And I think people abroad feel very abandoned by the U.S.
00:32:54.127 --> 00:32:58.017
And are very angry that they feel abandoned by the U.S.
00:32:58.435 --> 00:33:04.121
And I think that a lot of the Americans abroad also feel that way because,
00:33:04.608 --> 00:33:07.603
you know, I mean, you look at the Americans here in, in, in,
00:33:07.603 --> 00:33:10.075
in, in, in, you know, most of the Middle East,
00:33:10.743 --> 00:33:14.678
and they're like, man, the baronkin made my homeland safe for no reason.
00:33:15.384 --> 00:33:20.643
Right. Like there's, there's missiles inbound, you know, and,
00:33:20.643 --> 00:33:22.461
and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and.
00:33:24.784 --> 00:33:28.383
And I think those people, if they have an option to expatriate, are doing it.
00:33:29.582 --> 00:33:35.294
Well, these are reasons why, there are some of the reasons why expatriations are continuing.
00:33:35.294 --> 00:33:38.414
But I mean, I think regardless of all the reasons, which we'll never know,
00:33:38.414 --> 00:33:41.184
I think would we agree that definitely,
00:33:41.884 --> 00:33:45.384
there's heightened interest in expatriation relative to, you know.
00:33:45.866 --> 00:33:47.898
Yeah, I think there absolutely is.
00:33:48.522 --> 00:33:54.513
I want to bring up another topic. Just briefly, we were talking about this before the program.
00:33:55.001 --> 00:34:02.878
What about this news that's been around that they're denying Estes to people that have expatriated?
00:34:03.692 --> 00:34:07.684
Well, I think I would start with, so far, I'd say it's news.
00:34:09.813 --> 00:34:14.104
I think it was October 27th, 28th. There are various blog posts on this.
00:34:14.104 --> 00:34:17.664
I wrote one that actually lives at the Isaac Brock Society. I just thought that
00:34:17.664 --> 00:34:19.536
would be the place where you get the most exposure.
00:34:20.168 --> 00:34:25.574
It's hard to say. I think what is clear is that there are people who renounce
00:34:25.574 --> 00:34:28.591
U.S. citizenship who have been denied Estes.
00:34:29.346 --> 00:34:33.684
Now, you know, it's hard to know what the reason for that is.
00:34:34.624 --> 00:34:40.264
As far as I'm aware, there's no published policy for that. I mean,
00:34:40.264 --> 00:34:44.084
certainly, I mean, the U.S. is certainly within its rights to do that.
00:34:44.084 --> 00:34:45.824
I mean, there's no problem with that.
00:34:46.744 --> 00:34:51.776
But it is interesting. I don't know. It may be sort of a temporary thing.
00:34:52.246 --> 00:34:56.614
I have heard suggestions that it can be appealed by, you know,
00:34:56.614 --> 00:35:00.684
sending a copy of your CLN or whatever, certificate of loss of nationality, etc.
00:35:01.024 --> 00:35:06.392
I really don't know. But I guess my reaction to it would be twofold. One.
00:35:07.608 --> 00:35:11.149
I don't think we're at a stage where we can say that there's a definite policy
00:35:11.149 --> 00:35:14.969
and everybody who expatriates should understand they can't use an ASTA.
00:35:14.969 --> 00:35:16.455
I don't think we're at that stage.
00:35:17.260 --> 00:35:21.904
But I think we are at the stage, because of this, that people need to be aware
00:35:22.276 --> 00:35:27.539
and should factor the possibility of not being able to get an ASTA into their
00:35:27.539 --> 00:35:30.489
travel plans. I don't know. I guess that's how I would view it.
00:35:30.489 --> 00:35:31.935
What are your thoughts on it?
00:35:32.446 --> 00:35:37.549
Well, I mean, look, I've told every single one of my clients since I started.
00:35:37.549 --> 00:35:43.089
Advising on expatriations that look, once you give up citizenship,
00:35:43.089 --> 00:35:46.760
you have no right to go to America. It's a privilege of that one, right?
00:35:46.964 --> 00:35:51.778
And it can absolutely be denied. So, I mean, and what I've always said is.
00:35:52.586 --> 00:35:57.479
Look, I mean, for the most part, my clients have always gotten back in.
00:35:57.479 --> 00:36:01.523
I mean, I think every single one of my clients has gotten back in,
00:36:01.819 --> 00:36:03.578
whether on an a store or a visa.
00:36:04.361 --> 00:36:08.036
The only one that didn't was a pretty wealthy guy.
00:36:08.389 --> 00:36:11.479
He
expatriated, but he didn't have a residence anywhere. He was one of these
00:36:11.479 --> 00:36:14.398
guys that he thought are just going to travel a lot, be a resident in Norway.
00:36:14.868 --> 00:36:19.609
And the U.S. basically said, well, how do we know you're not going to stay here
00:36:19.609 --> 00:36:20.799
if you don't have a house or anything?
00:36:20.799 --> 00:36:23.609
Yeah, right. Let's pause on that for a minute for listeners.
00:36:23.609 --> 00:36:25.819
I think that's a really important point, right?
00:36:25.819 --> 00:36:30.679
So we link that back to the general bedrock presumption of U.S.
00:36:30.679 --> 00:36:34.189
Immigration law, which is that you bear the burden of proof of showing you're
00:36:34.189 --> 00:36:35.259
not going to stay, right?
00:36:35.259 --> 00:36:39.579
So if we link that to your client who didn't have a residency anywhere,
00:36:39.579 --> 00:36:44.429
I mean, you know, certainly it makes it a lot easier to deny it based on the
00:36:44.429 --> 00:36:47.526
inability to overcome the presumption of immigrant intent, right? Yeah.
00:36:48.077 --> 00:36:50.991
No, I mean, look, I think that's what I was saying. I think that,
00:36:51.695 --> 00:36:56.500
you know, I mean, I told the guy that perpetual alert travel and things is not a good plan,
00:36:57.424 --> 00:37:01.986
Anyway, long story short, I feel like that was a reasonable one to deny.
00:37:02.311 --> 00:37:07.141
I mean, all the rest of my people, even if they were on some citizenship by
00:37:07.141 --> 00:37:12.161
investment passport, have been able to obtain visas to go back if they wanted
00:37:12.161 --> 00:37:15.605
to. But what I always tell people is you don't have a right.
00:37:16.531 --> 00:37:22.551
Even though my experience has been this, we never know what's going to happen in the future.
00:37:23.151 --> 00:37:27.141
You've lost that right when you actually patriate. And I think that this is
00:37:27.141 --> 00:37:34.898
potentially the beginning of a change of a policy, potentially. We don't know that.
00:37:35.340 --> 00:37:38.731
But something could be happening here where that's going to become more prevalent.
00:37:38.731 --> 00:37:41.882
It's people not being able to get Estos or visas to get in.
00:37:42.488 --> 00:37:45.261
Well, that may very well be the case. And we don't know.
00:37:45.261 --> 00:37:50.971
And I agree with you totally that it's important that anybody renouncing citizenship
00:37:50.971 --> 00:37:54.258
or handing and a green card, okay, needs to understand,
00:37:54.863 --> 00:37:58.801
that that's not a nothing decision, okay, that, you know, strictly speaking,
00:37:58.801 --> 00:38:01.091
they have no right to enter the United States.
00:38:01.604 --> 00:38:06.562
You know, what's really interesting, though, is how, you know, consider this, right?
00:38:07.363 --> 00:38:11.271
Giving up citizenship, the effect of it depends largely on what country you're
00:38:11.271 --> 00:38:12.921
a citizen of when you're done, right?
00:38:12.921 --> 00:38:16.739
So think of this, like Canadians don't need any kind of visa,
00:38:17.046 --> 00:38:20.738
they just show a passport, right? So all the things that we're talking about,
00:38:21.398 --> 00:38:24.875
Would have far less effect on that group, right?
00:38:25.585 --> 00:38:28.853
Yeah. But you need an S to those, a Canadian, right? No, no.
00:38:29.534 --> 00:38:34.048
Oh, really? Just show a passport. That's it. Oh, well, you guys are special.
00:38:34.723 --> 00:38:38.451
Uh, well, there's a special rule under the immigration laws.
00:38:38.451 --> 00:38:42.040
Yeah. Yeah. No, that's what I meant. Yeah. Yeah.
00:38:43.804 --> 00:38:47.115
But, you know, it's the general theme that's interesting, right?
00:38:47.115 --> 00:38:52.075
So, I mean, one of the questions, you know, so somebody comes to you or me or Virginia.
00:38:52.655 --> 00:38:56.245
By the way, we're talking about Virginia Latour-Jeker, who's been on many of
00:38:56.245 --> 00:39:00.036
my podcasts and is a friend of both of us for many, many years.
00:39:00.715 --> 00:39:04.235
But, you know, it seems to me that one of the questions is, okay,
00:39:04.235 --> 00:39:08.118
well, what citizenship are you left with, right, after this?
00:39:08.989 --> 00:39:13.360
Yeah. and if you're left with a really really difficult citizenship,
00:39:14.146 --> 00:39:18.703
you know i would i would put more thought into the renunciation decision right,
00:39:19.432 --> 00:39:24.215
a hundred percent look if you have a canadian passport or or a passport that's
00:39:24.215 --> 00:39:26.889
on a you know that has a visa waiver available,
00:39:27.458 --> 00:39:30.915
or at least a place you know even if they're not on a visa waiver that's like
00:39:30.915 --> 00:39:35.135
a nice place that you people would want to live it's either you've got something
00:39:35.135 --> 00:39:38.455
to go back to i think about it less But I mean, yeah, I mean,
00:39:38.455 --> 00:39:39.618
look, if you have, if you have,
00:39:40.271 --> 00:39:45.025
you know, a bad second passport, I mean, that's something big time to consider,
00:39:45.025 --> 00:39:48.175
because I think one of the other things that people don't think about when they
00:39:48.175 --> 00:39:53.078
expatriate and when you talk about, you know, the value of an American citizenship, right?
00:39:53.537 --> 00:39:59.930
I mean, one is, yeah, you lose that ability to travel to the United States,
00:40:00.441 --> 00:40:05.055
but you also lose the ability to travel to a lot of other places where Americans
00:40:05.055 --> 00:40:09.195
are allowed to go, but you might not be able to because of your passport.
00:40:09.636 --> 00:40:14.045
And I think one of the risks that I think people don't see that I always like
00:40:14.045 --> 00:40:21.143
to point out is look, that potentially also limits your job and business opportunities, right?
00:40:21.567 --> 00:40:26.905
Because if they're
going to, if you, you know, any job that you get that requires
00:40:26.905 --> 00:40:31.745
travel, if you're an American, that's super easy. Like here's my passport.
00:40:31.745 --> 00:40:35.468
I can go anywhere you need me to go through meetings or travel or whatever.
00:40:35.799 --> 00:40:38.144
But if you're not, you got to get a visa to go everywhere. Yeah.
00:40:38.953 --> 00:40:43.290
You know, I think if, if, if, if you have an American next to each other and
00:40:43.290 --> 00:40:47.370
somebody with a, with a, with a bad passport with the same qualifications,
00:40:47.370 --> 00:40:50.830
they're going to take the American because they know we can get in places. Yeah.
00:40:51.632 --> 00:40:54.830
And the same thing, the same thing goes, goes with business,
00:40:54.830 --> 00:40:57.333
right? Where are your business meetings? Who do you need to go meet with?
00:40:57.844 --> 00:41:01.250
How, you know, where do you like the vacation? Because, you know,
00:41:01.250 --> 00:41:04.150
it's, it's, everybody's always worried about, oh, you know, like,
00:41:04.150 --> 00:41:05.550
well, I don't know if I can go to America.
00:41:05.550 --> 00:41:10.072
I'm like, yeah, that's a, it's a problem. But, you know, potentially a problem,
00:41:10.461 --> 00:41:13.530
but if it's all the other stuff you lose, which could have an economic impact
00:41:13.530 --> 00:41:14.815
on your future earning potential.
00:41:15.593 --> 00:41:20.280
Well, that's absolutely right. You know, I mean, the passport you have,
00:41:20.280 --> 00:41:25.450
whatever it is, okay, determines where you can go to an awful lot of places, excluding the rights.
00:41:25.450 --> 00:41:28.577
I mean, I think, you know, you make a really, really good point. I think that,
00:41:29.252 --> 00:41:35.254
once people reach the point where they're consulting a lawyer about expatriation,
00:41:35.469 --> 00:41:42.055
usually they're hyper-focused on the problems, the pain points of being an American citizen. For sure.
00:41:42.502 --> 00:41:47.430
And it's harder for them, I think, to see these other things objectively,
00:41:47.870 --> 00:41:54.036
sort of dismissing it. But I mean, even on a simple or on a very simple level, consider this.
00:41:54.704 --> 00:41:58.080
You know, you want to get on a cruise ship You know, that lands in Miami That
00:41:58.080 --> 00:42:02.156
goes to Miami You know, I mean, even that can be a problem, right?
00:42:02.975 --> 00:42:06.897
A hundred percent. I mean, look, that's nothing but just tourism.
00:42:06.897 --> 00:42:08.548
I guess maybe you just don't get off the ship.
00:42:09.169 --> 00:42:13.187
Well, I mean, look, but again, I think it's also important, like I said,
00:42:13.187 --> 00:42:16.965
you know, when people like expatriate, I mean, obviously, I'm 100% with you.
00:42:17.418 --> 00:42:21.917
They're hyper-focused on all the downsides. And I always try to point out all
00:42:21.917 --> 00:42:26.457
the upsides, you know, because you can't forget because there are upsides, right?
00:42:26.457 --> 00:42:29.867
I mean, you know, even, I mean, look, even if there's a world war,
00:42:29.867 --> 00:42:33.377
right, you're probably going to be safe in America, right? unless people are
00:42:33.377 --> 00:42:34.675
setting nukes over there, right?
00:42:35.046 --> 00:42:40.038
I mean, they have enough oil, they have enough food, they have enough everything there, right?
00:42:40.172 --> 00:42:45.087
I mean, plus, you know, I mean, if, you know, I mean, you see Americans notorious
00:42:45.087 --> 00:42:46.563
for getting their people out of,
00:42:47.914 --> 00:42:50.646
you know, doing prisoner swaps with other countries like, like,
00:42:50.646 --> 00:42:55.216
like Russia or getting people out of, you know, like that whole thing that,
00:42:55.216 --> 00:42:57.376
that happened in, in, in, in Iran,
00:42:57.887 --> 00:43:00.406
you know, when they got people out in the seventies, I mean,
00:43:00.406 --> 00:43:03.376
the U S is pretty notorious for, for, for rescuing the people.
00:43:03.376 --> 00:43:06.366
And the, I mean, look, those were all great parts about being,
00:43:06.366 --> 00:43:11.065
being an American and you have to, you have to understand that you're giving that up.
00:43:11.935 --> 00:43:17.326
Oh, I think, I think that is absolutely right. and yet large,
00:43:17.326 --> 00:43:19.520
large numbers of people are doing so. Yeah.
00:43:21.923 --> 00:43:25.706
I think it's a lot easier to give it up if you're a Canadian,
00:43:25.706 --> 00:43:27.576
for example, right? For sure.
00:43:28.216 --> 00:43:30.618
And I keep coming back to this.
00:43:31.979 --> 00:43:37.106
Generally, I don't know how you see this. You probably get a lot of clients
00:43:37.106 --> 00:43:40.836
in the Gulf region, certainly more than I would in any case,
00:43:40.836 --> 00:43:44.096
right? I mean, you know, my client base is people who are citizens of first
00:43:44.096 --> 00:43:45.418
world democracies, right?
00:43:46.142 --> 00:43:50.956
So, you know, they're done. They end up with a British passport or a German,
00:43:50.956 --> 00:43:55.546
you know, or this or that, right? And, you know, that is a far,
00:43:55.546 --> 00:43:58.849
far better position, you know, than these other things.
00:43:59.075 --> 00:44:01.876
But, you know, I have a question. You know, we're talking about what's going
00:44:01.876 --> 00:44:02.936
on in the news these days.
00:44:02.936 --> 00:44:06.136
I'd really love to get your take on this. So presumably you're aware,
00:44:06.136 --> 00:44:10.876
and if not, I'll fill you in, that Europe has put pressure on these Caribbean
00:44:10.876 --> 00:44:14.936
countries to get rid of their citizenship by investment program.
00:44:15.316 --> 00:44:18.084
Some of them are. What are your thoughts on this?
00:44:19.741 --> 00:44:20.068
Well,
00:44:23.319 --> 00:44:24.933
look, I think that Europe.
00:44:28.428 --> 00:44:32.528
Is dramatically
trying to protect their tax basis, right?
00:44:32.528 --> 00:44:39.678
I mean, Europe is, I think their big fear is people are going to get these citizenship
00:44:39.678 --> 00:44:45.796
by investment passports and then, you know, get a different residency somewhere,
00:44:46.452 --> 00:44:49.668
and open bank accounts and all that kind of stuff.
00:44:49.668 --> 00:44:54.886
Under this second passport that these European countries don't know anything about, right?
00:44:55.953 --> 00:45:00.868
I think that's the real reason behind it, right? But look, I mean.
00:45:02.328 --> 00:45:05.808
Europe, instead of Europe, I mean, one of the things that I kind of rant about
00:45:05.808 --> 00:45:12.078
on LinkedIn sometimes is Europe's gotten to this point where you always attract
00:45:12.078 --> 00:45:13.308
more flies with honey, right?
00:45:13.308 --> 00:45:17.965
Like, why are there so many people that love coming to Dubai, right?
00:45:18.371 --> 00:45:23.238
They've created a place where people want to be right like it's safe i mean
00:45:23.238 --> 00:45:27.805
at a bare minimum it's safe like i don't have to lock my car door i can walk down the street,
00:45:28.316 --> 00:45:32.288
and my girl you know my fiance can walk at night i don't have to worry about
00:45:32.288 --> 00:45:37.389
her you know anything happened to her it's safe and when i was a kid most of the world was safe,
00:45:38.091 --> 00:45:41.808
and that's just not the case anymore and especially not in europe and you're
00:45:41.808 --> 00:45:45.652
going around these these you know capital cities of europe,
00:45:46.344 --> 00:45:50.148
Europe, where people are paying 50% tax and they can't even protect their people
00:45:50.148 --> 00:45:55.080
from not getting stabbed on the street for their wash or their shoes or some nonsense.
00:45:55.649 --> 00:46:03.038
And so Europe, rather than trying to realize that it's not that great in Europe
00:46:03.038 --> 00:46:05.693
anymore, it's actually kind of becoming a cesspool.
00:46:07.273 --> 00:46:11.476
And trying to fix the problems they have there and attracting,
00:46:11.743 --> 00:46:13.745
you know, people to want to stay there.
00:46:14.626 --> 00:46:17.571
You know, they're doing everything they can to generate more taxes,
00:46:18.585 --> 00:46:21.563
stop people doing any kind of tax planning.
00:46:22.454 --> 00:46:27.021
And I think the citizenship by investment thing is, again, I think they're afraid
00:46:27.021 --> 00:46:32.590
that people are going to use that second citizenship to evade taxes. It's interesting.
00:46:33.319 --> 00:46:40.211
Very interesting. So to your first point, we are seeing, you would agree,
00:46:40.571 --> 00:46:44.817
a trend in exit departure taxes from Europe, right? Yeah.
00:46:45.363 --> 00:46:50.211
You know, the latest of which I, is Italy the latest within the last couple
00:46:50.211 --> 00:46:51.557
months or something like that?
00:46:52.312 --> 00:46:55.131
So, but we're seeing that worldwide, okay?
00:46:55.531 --> 00:47:01.455
But the point is we are seeing it in Europe. So there's that concern about the erosion of the tax base.
00:47:02.462 --> 00:47:07.661
You know you may very well be right that that they see uh second citizenships
00:47:07.661 --> 00:47:13.831
as opportunities for capital flight but i think they also just don't want okay
00:47:14.251 --> 00:47:20.111
you know easy access to the schengen region either you know i think i think this is operating yeah.
00:47:21.514 --> 00:47:25.701
But look that's super easy to solve for right and i don't i'm going to disagree
00:47:25.701 --> 00:47:29.229
on that because look if they don't want to give them access to Schengen,
00:47:29.595 --> 00:47:31.371
don't give it to them, right?
00:47:32.011 --> 00:47:35.733
The country doesn't have to cancel their CBI program, right?
00:47:36.284 --> 00:47:39.215
There's just going to be a CBI where you don't get EU access.
00:47:39.545 --> 00:47:42.123
I mean, that's easy for the EU to solve.
00:47:42.472 --> 00:47:47.471
Well, that's precisely why. Was it saying kids? That's precisely why the rationale.
00:47:47.471 --> 00:47:49.991
One of those countries already agreed, you know, to get rid of it.
00:47:49.991 --> 00:47:52.890
I think it was saying kids. That was the point, right? Yeah.
00:47:53.661 --> 00:47:57.131
But it's interesting, you know, we're seeing, I mean, Do you think that the
00:47:57.131 --> 00:48:01.696
golden age of citizenship by investment is starting to come to an end?
00:48:02.746 --> 00:48:09.701
Uh i would say i would say yes and i'll tell you why you know in my business,
00:48:10.583 --> 00:48:16.730
you know we set up a set up a lot of trusts and foundations clients setting up bank accounts.
00:48:17.897 --> 00:48:24.519
Um and more and more i'm seeing on the application forms for the for the kyc that know your customer,
00:48:25.240 --> 00:48:30.516
you know what are your citizenships or are any of your citizenships from by
00:48:30.516 --> 00:48:38.594
citizenship by investment so this is the question that i'm seeing more and more on government like,
00:48:39.316 --> 00:48:43.103
on on on kyc from governments from,
00:48:43.760 --> 00:48:47.716
now i don't know i don't know what happens if you if you you know have clients
00:48:47.716 --> 00:48:50.198
that do and have checked yes and nothing's happened,
00:48:50.703 --> 00:48:55.036
right and they have not had a negative consequence but they're gathering that
00:48:55.036 --> 00:48:59.288
information for reasons like and my feeling is that,
00:49:00.037 --> 00:49:02.109
you know It's going to be an issue at some point.
00:49:02.719 --> 00:49:04.431
Otherwise, they wouldn't be asking the question.
00:49:06.293 --> 00:49:10.883
Well, so what we're really, you know, I think we're going to generalize.
00:49:10.883 --> 00:49:14.913
It's like, you know, we're at the part of human history, probably,
00:49:15.273 --> 00:49:21.572
you know, where
there's maximum physical mobility, right? It's easy for people to get around the world.
00:49:22.412 --> 00:49:27.823
And that very ease is generating all these various responses from governments,
00:49:27.823 --> 00:49:30.743
right, from both the tax side and the immigration side.
00:49:30.743 --> 00:49:35.283
But it is amazing. It's just another example. We go back to Charles Adams, right?
00:49:35.283 --> 00:49:40.003
Taxes and civilization so we see how civilization evolves in a certain way and
00:49:40.003 --> 00:49:41.880
we can see the tax response to it,
00:49:42.568 --> 00:49:48.803
be really interesting to have him alive today and write a chapter about sort of global migration,
00:49:49.475 --> 00:49:53.053
yeah for sure that sort of things i think you know the book ends i think in
00:49:53.053 --> 00:49:59.692
1994 which incredibly i mean he actually foresaw the problems of fatka f-bar all his stuff,
00:50:01.313 --> 00:50:02.503
in the chapter on the U.S.
00:50:02.503 --> 00:50:07.169
In the same way that James Dale Davidson and the Sovereign Individual in 1996,
00:50:08.213 --> 00:50:09.758
echoes this stuff as well.
00:50:10.106 --> 00:50:14.146
They were very percyate people way ahead of their times.
00:50:14.855 --> 00:50:20.733
But it sure would be interesting to have him back today make a nuclear cameo
00:50:20.733 --> 00:50:21.813
appearance or something.
00:50:24.113 --> 00:50:26.581
Maybe what we should do is ghostwrite that chapter.
00:50:27.828 --> 00:50:32.456
I like that idea i'm on board for that yeah i mean yeah because it's completely
00:50:32.456 --> 00:50:36.406
consistent right you know with everything that he's been talking about,
00:50:37.130 --> 00:50:40.276
you know wow it's been a great discussion one more thing i'd like to get your
00:50:40.276 --> 00:50:45.529
thoughts on uh i know we should probably save this for another podcast but so,
00:50:46.185 --> 00:50:50.836
prior to our recording we were talking about some of your clients experiences
00:50:50.836 --> 00:50:55.084
at the actual renunciation of point you want to comment on that a bit or,
00:50:55.531 --> 00:50:59.746
Yeah, I would say, and I'm not going to mention which, which embassy I'm going
00:50:59.746 --> 00:51:02.526
to call people out, but, you know, I mean, look, I, you know,
00:51:02.526 --> 00:51:05.678
when I expatriated, it was a very pleasant experience,
00:51:06.312 --> 00:51:11.043
you know, and I, I, you know, when I went in, I remember the lady asked me,
00:51:11.957 --> 00:51:14.006
you know, why are you expatriating?
00:51:14.386 --> 00:51:16.186
And don't say tax, right?
00:51:16.850 --> 00:51:19.590
I mean, she was really cool.
00:51:21.486 --> 00:51:27.466
And up until this year, I've never had a client that's had a bad experience.
00:51:27.466 --> 00:51:33.983
I've never even heard about a client from another professional that's had a bad experience.
00:51:34.482 --> 00:51:38.616
But this particular individual went into an embassy where I've had many clients
00:51:38.616 --> 00:51:42.036
expatriate and all have had a great experience. And then they've actually thanked
00:51:42.036 --> 00:51:43.007
me for sending them there.
00:51:43.454 --> 00:51:48.396
Some of them and you know he was caught and got there and he was brought into
00:51:48.396 --> 00:51:53.146
a room and then he was just kind of left to sit there by himself for like a
00:51:53.146 --> 00:51:57.761
half an hour and then they came back and then they looked at you know his forms,
00:51:58.614 --> 00:52:03.038
you know they kind of kind of pressing him on this this voluntariness issue,
00:52:03.520 --> 00:52:05.830
and he was like yeah yeah there's voluntary,
00:52:06.438 --> 00:52:10.636
and then you know i forget what the reason he had on there but it was it was
00:52:10.636 --> 00:52:13.753
you know it's a very simple reason right Like, because, you know,
00:52:14.345 --> 00:52:17.816
I don't know, because I don't plan on moving back to the U S or something at any point.
00:52:17.816 --> 00:52:21.306
And I don't need, you know, something simple and you know, they started trailing
00:52:21.306 --> 00:52:24.286
him on that. They actually made him elaborate on it on the form.
00:52:24.286 --> 00:52:28.332
Like we had it all printed in nights. We had to, you know, fill in more by hand.
00:52:29.410 --> 00:52:32.550
And then, um, you know, because I always tell all my clients,
00:52:32.550 --> 00:52:36.480
you know, in my experience, the consular officer always set signs,
00:52:36.480 --> 00:52:39.308
the forms, color signs, the forms in front of you.
00:52:40.431 --> 00:52:43.830
And, and they always, if you ask them, they'll be kind enough to make you a copy.
00:52:43.830 --> 00:52:49.487
So you have a copy of the fully executed documents, which I think is super important
00:52:49.830 --> 00:52:54.480
when you're in this purgatory between, you know, the date of your expatriation
00:52:54.480 --> 00:52:58.702
at the embassy and the CLN, right? I mean, you need to have some proof of what happened.
00:52:59.425 --> 00:53:03.326
And, you know, not only did they not countersign in front of them,
00:53:03.605 --> 00:53:05.149
they refused to make a copy.
00:53:05.858 --> 00:53:14.353
And one of the things that I was very surprised about is that they told him two falsehoods.
00:53:15.240 --> 00:53:22.097
One was that he's still American until he gets to CLN, which is just not true.
00:53:23.400 --> 00:53:27.540
And the other was that his children were going to be used to lose their U.S.
00:53:27.540 --> 00:53:29.351
Citizen check. Oh, my God.
00:53:30.062 --> 00:53:33.850
Both of which are absolutely incorrect. Yeah, you know what?
00:53:33.850 --> 00:53:36.650
I think I was going to say this. We were going to sign off now,
00:53:36.650 --> 00:53:40.595
but now I think we better talk for a few more minutes. Okay, seriously.
00:53:41.205 --> 00:53:50.630
Now, on your first point, I agree with you 100% that
under the Immigration Nationality
00:53:50.630 --> 00:53:55.260
Act, that you lose citizenship for nationality purposes on the day of renunciation.
00:53:55.260 --> 00:53:57.080
That's what you're saying, right? Yeah.
00:53:57.399 --> 00:54:01.800
Yeah, okay. Now, a lot of people don't think that's the case,
00:54:01.800 --> 00:54:07.525
right? I mean, their view is that you don't actually lose the citizenship until the CLN is issued.
00:54:08.132 --> 00:54:11.360
But it's right down in the statute. Oh, yes, I love it. I love it.
00:54:11.360 --> 00:54:14.652
God, you know, Jimmy, you're as simple-minded a guy as I am.
00:54:16.396 --> 00:54:20.000
I mean, imagine reading the statute. Yeah.
00:54:20.564 --> 00:54:26.480
Imagine you know so many people don't do that but it's in a statue yeah no I
00:54:26.480 --> 00:54:28.117
agree with you I agree with you,
00:54:28.857 --> 00:54:33.182
But then, you know, we do have the problem. I mean, there are certain embassies
00:54:33.182 --> 00:54:36.352
that seem to take a contrary view, which is interesting.
00:54:36.352 --> 00:54:41.962
Now, what I think that means is just that the people need to understand there
00:54:41.962 --> 00:54:46.002
are certain embassies that take a contrary view, right, and factor that into
00:54:46.002 --> 00:54:48.432
their thinking. But I think you're 100% right.
00:54:49.051 --> 00:54:55.122
Now, let's move on to the second point, which is another incredibly important point, right?
00:54:55.122 --> 00:54:57.872
So what you're saying, at least what I understood you to say,
00:54:57.872 --> 00:55:03.842
was the counselor officer told the individual that by renouncing his children
00:55:03.842 --> 00:55:08.592
would no longer, his children, existing children could not be U.S.
00:55:08.592 --> 00:55:10.062
Citizens. That's what you're saying, right?
00:55:10.762 --> 00:55:13.882
That were already U.S. citizens. That passport. Yeah.
00:55:13.922 --> 00:55:17.602
That they were going to lose them. Yeah. In other words, from that point going
00:55:17.602 --> 00:55:22.102
forward, right after you renounce, if you were born, then clearly,
00:55:22.102 --> 00:55:23.712
well, you're no longer born. Yeah.
00:55:24.302 --> 00:55:29.032
It's not retrospectively affect any of those family relationships.
00:55:29.032 --> 00:55:30.217
And that's important. Yeah.
00:55:31.783 --> 00:55:36.632
Oh, my God. So, but it was the first time that I've ever had anybody have an
00:55:36.632 --> 00:55:38.099
experience like this, you know.
00:55:38.366 --> 00:55:41.692
So I had to go look up the statute and say, look, I don't care what opinion
00:55:41.692 --> 00:55:43.706
the embassy says. This is what the law says.
00:55:44.461 --> 00:55:48.455
Oh, that's exactly right. I mean, I find that that whole thing.
00:55:49.526 --> 00:55:56.020
Astounding and i find and i find it troubling right and it makes me wonder if,
00:55:56.895 --> 00:56:01.689
i don't think there's anything i don't read the statute as giving any regulatory
00:56:01.689 --> 00:56:07.419
whatsoever regulatory authority whatsoever to you know to the state department
00:56:07.419 --> 00:56:08.959
to change that you would agree.
00:56:10.700 --> 00:56:14.739
Yeah and by the way you know from a tax side you know when you're calculating
00:56:14.739 --> 00:56:17.119
net worth on the data We're Nazi, you know, et cetera.
00:56:17.119 --> 00:56:20.769
Okay. You know, I mean, you know, that's important. Anyway. Wow.
00:56:20.769 --> 00:56:23.455
This has been a great conversation. As always.
00:56:23.989 --> 00:56:27.349
Yeah. Well, we should definitely pick this up again soon, but listen,
00:56:27.649 --> 00:56:30.709
I know after listening to this and people have made it to the finish line,
00:56:30.709 --> 00:56:33.229
they're going to want to know what your contact information is.
00:56:33.229 --> 00:56:38.167
So that's why group.com that I love that simplicity.
00:56:38.515 --> 00:56:45.568
Yeah. I group.com. Awesome. So I've been speaking with Jimmy Sexton, long time friend.
00:56:48.909 --> 00:56:54.409
Collaborator, conversationalist, et cetera. So great to speak with you again
00:56:54.409 --> 00:56:56.869
today, Jimmy. Thanks so much. Thank you, John. It was a pleasure.
00:56:56.869 --> 00:56:58.460
Thanks, John. It was a pleasure to reconnect.