अनुलिपि 🔗
WEBVTT
00:01.072 --> 00:04.228
Best-smelling offices I've ever been in, by the way. There's like incredible—
00:04.260 --> 00:07.577
they like pump some fabulous— How about the bathrooms? Beautiful.
00:09.002 --> 00:12.793
This is Open Work, a look inside the watch industry, a podcast
00:12.825 --> 00:17.073
from Collective Horology, and I'm Gabe Riley, co-founder of
00:17.105 --> 00:20.776
Collective. And I'm Asher Rapkin, co-founder of Collective. Collective Horology
00:20.824 --> 00:24.398
is an independent watch retailer based in Ventura, California. We carry a
00:24.430 --> 00:26.952
wide range of independent brands including Czapek.
00:27.240 --> 00:30.638
Pierce, Carl Suki, Nippon, and more.
00:30.942 --> 00:33.972
To learn more about us and check out our available inventory,
00:34.309 --> 00:37.739
visit collectiverhorology.com. You see what I did
00:37.771 --> 00:41.266
there? You changed it slightly. It's now watches we carry,
00:41.442 --> 00:44.728
not our available inventory. Oh yeah, so I stumbled because
00:44.744 --> 00:48.832
not everything is, you know, available inventory. Some things you got to preorder. To learn
00:49.332 --> 00:53.978
more about us and find out what's unavailable, visit collectiverhorology.com.
00:54.026 --> 00:57.697
Visit your local AP boutique. No, the brand's in
00:57.729 --> 01:00.842
there. Chapek, Fierce,
01:00.923 --> 01:03.879
Karlsuki, Nitan. These are all rebooted brands.
01:04.554 --> 01:08.217
And that's what we're talking about today. The great, the great brand
01:08.409 --> 01:12.153
reboot. So, you know, it occurs to me with Zenith rebooting,
01:12.185 --> 01:15.237
and of course, we've had so many other reboots this year.
01:15.639 --> 01:19.928
It's the year of brand reboots. Ebel has been purchased by Chanel
01:20.282 --> 01:24.106
and Mr. Journe. You've got Galley and Universal
01:24.154 --> 01:27.750
Genève. The reboots are just They're everywhere,
01:28.250 --> 01:31.300
everywhere. So we're gonna do a draft. I love draft episodes. They're, they're fun.
01:31.510 --> 01:34.890
Everyone loves a good draft, a snake style draft. I love the idea
01:35.390 --> 01:38.690
of snake style. It's really quiet. It's just, we could just go back and forth.
01:39.190 --> 01:43.640
It sounds like, you know, something out of Karate Kid. Snake style.
01:43.670 --> 01:46.990
I, my daughter attempted to snatch a fly outta the air
01:47.490 --> 01:50.150
and I made a Mr. Miyagi joke. And of course she had no idea what
01:50.650 --> 01:53.250
that, uh, was. And I realized I'm failing at parenting if she doesn't know what
01:53.750 --> 01:56.170
Karate Kid is. Interesting. My child was in a, like a Young Ninjas.
01:58.286 --> 02:00.915
Class and they're, they, every,
02:01.668 --> 02:05.355
every, I guess, season or what, however, when they do
02:05.855 --> 02:08.962
a new class or whatever, there's a different animal. And so they,
02:09.379 --> 02:12.809
so, you know, there's like, you know, tiger ninja class or whatever.
02:12.890 --> 02:16.801
And one, one year there was snake ninja class and
02:17.301 --> 02:21.386
one of the kids in the class kept on referring to ninja class as snake
02:21.402 --> 02:24.800
ninja class, which we found very amusing.
02:24.976 --> 02:27.990
There's gotta be like a DreamWorks movie hidden in here somewhere.
02:28.904 --> 02:32.640
Yeah. Snake Ninja school. Exactly. Kung Fu Panda and Snake Ninja.
02:33.233 --> 02:36.713
All right. Well, I have to interject here because of all of this talk about
02:37.213 --> 02:40.867
a snake style or a serpentine draft. I am a total idiot
02:41.367 --> 02:45.358
because this was just a regular draft back and forth. There was no hot corner
02:45.422 --> 02:48.902
where the final person in a round goes twice to
02:49.402 --> 02:52.270
lead off the next round or anything like that. It was just us going back
02:52.770 --> 02:56.343
and forth. I had initially planned a snake style draft because we were
02:56.359 --> 02:59.663
going to do different categories, but we just ended up having one.
03:00.192 --> 03:03.799
Category here. So no serpentine draft,
03:04.119 --> 03:07.534
just a regular old draft. We record early in the morning,
03:07.646 --> 03:11.060
so let's just blame that on maybe lack of coffee or something like that.
03:11.349 --> 03:15.004
All right, back to the show. Yeah, exactly. Okay. All right. Well, in any event,
03:15.020 --> 03:18.306
we're going to do this brand reboot draft. The rules here are
03:18.806 --> 03:22.009
pretty simple. So the most important rule is we're each going to pick
03:22.057 --> 03:25.728
3 brands we'd reboot. We're going to make the case. And the
03:25.824 --> 03:29.543
rule here, the primary one, is the brand needs to be currently active.
03:29.607 --> 03:33.102
No dormant brand. So this wouldn't be like, you know, plucking Gallais,
03:33.775 --> 03:37.028
you know, or Fierce or Carl Suki, you know, out of,
03:37.285 --> 03:40.522
out of hibernation and rebooting them. These are brands that
03:41.022 --> 03:44.577
are currently active that we think for one reason or another could need
03:45.077 --> 03:48.360
a reboot. And that could be because, you know, they're not doing so hot
03:48.860 --> 03:52.575
commercially. That could be because we just view them as underappreciated.
03:52.687 --> 03:54.979
Yeah, that's kind of the way I was thinking about it. It's less that and
03:54.995 --> 03:58.121
more of like, I think there's so much more here than is currently being seen,
03:58.441 --> 04:01.775
mined, or, or worked on. And, or,
04:01.887 --> 04:05.510
or, or there's so much there that isn't getting attention for whatever
04:06.010 --> 04:09.934
reason. Yeah. That there's opportunity. So I, I, I'd rather, like,
04:09.999 --> 04:12.579
for me at least, for my picks, I, I was looking at it from the,
04:13.349 --> 04:16.507
from the sort of, you know, look at what we're leaving on the table perspective.
04:16.795 --> 04:20.418
Yeah. I cast a
Load full transcript
pretty wide net, but I'd say generally my picks
04:20.918 --> 04:23.288
fit in that and I'm picking them because, and I would presume you are too,
04:23.304 --> 04:26.654
because you like them and believe in them and would like to see them do
04:26.734 --> 04:30.453
well. Oh, also all 3 of my brands, I, I either like or
04:30.501 --> 04:34.429
love certain eras of what they do. Got it. All right, cool. So that's
04:34.929 --> 04:38.372
the Eras Tour. It's the Eras Tour. It's the Eras Tour. So that's the first
04:38.872 --> 04:42.171
rule. Currently active brand, no dormant brands here. 3 picks
04:42.283 --> 04:45.746
each, snake-style draft. And I have a quarter. You know, I keep quarters in
04:46.246 --> 04:49.224
my car because at Aldi you have to have a quarter to get the shopping
04:49.272 --> 04:52.735
cart. You've ever been to this place? Yeah. And I never have. Never have.
04:52.879 --> 04:56.646
The whole reason I have a quarter, because I also use this office
04:57.146 --> 05:00.429
to store my cars. And so there's a quarter in my car.
05:00.734 --> 05:04.277
Here we go. And I picked a quarter. Ironically, it has 2 heads.
05:04.742 --> 05:08.159
So Alanis Morissette would be proud.
05:08.288 --> 05:12.251
It's 2 heads when all you need is a tail. And so we got George
05:12.267 --> 05:15.878
Washington. I referenced this for Alanis Morissette recently. On one side and
05:15.958 --> 05:19.761
Harriet Tubman on the other side. But we'll say Harriet Tubman is tails.
05:19.825 --> 05:22.890
George Washington traditionally tail, uh, heads on, on these things.
05:22.938 --> 05:26.436
So you get to pick heads or tails. All right. Pick Tubman.
05:26.965 --> 05:30.656
You, you're picking Tubman. I'm going for Tubman. All right. George or, or Harriet
05:30.720 --> 05:34.460
landed on Harriet. So do you want first? First choice? Yeah, I'll lead off.
05:34.960 --> 05:36.930
Okay. Because I don't, I don't know your picks. We should also disclaim, I don't
05:37.430 --> 05:40.150
know what you picked. You don't know mine. I have a couple of reserves in
05:40.650 --> 05:44.050
case because I suspect, I suspect you're going to use one of the
05:44.550 --> 05:46.990
ones I wanted, but go ahead, let it rip. I don't think this is one
05:47.490 --> 05:51.930
of yours, but let's see. Well, then pick strategically. All right. Glaciute Original.
05:52.430 --> 05:55.490
Okay. Not my, not my, not my pick. I've got my first pick is preserved.
05:55.990 --> 05:59.290
All right. So let's separate out the fact that, and we've talked about the Swatch
05:59.790 --> 06:04.482
Group ad nauseam and where we see opportunity for serious improvement in the
06:04.982 --> 06:08.794
way that they operate their business. I think Glashütte
06:08.970 --> 06:11.583
Original is a really interesting brand on a lot of levels.
06:12.497 --> 06:15.446
My first introduction to the brand 15,
06:15.542 --> 06:18.668
16 years ago was what I think a lot of
06:19.168 --> 06:22.163
people kind
of dismiss the brand as, which is like, you know, A. Lange& Söhne.
06:22.740 --> 06:26.395
Yeah. And they do that, I think, because especially within like the Panorama line
06:26.587 --> 06:29.986
with the Offset Grand Date, there are some
06:30.486 --> 06:35.404
similarities that one could argue are more specific to the
06:35.484 --> 06:38.436
region for that they occupy, you know, Glashütte,
06:38.693 --> 06:42.257
than the, the brands that, that are necessarily
06:42.757 --> 06:46.158
famous for making those, you know, things like grand dates and offset
06:46.658 --> 06:49.369
dials and, and the rest. We'll get to the movements in a minute, you know,
06:49.385 --> 06:52.564
so, so recognizable. But the thing is,
06:52.997 --> 06:56.176
and I've owned a lot of Geo watches over the years,
06:56.272 --> 06:59.900
I've owned a Panorama, Panorama Date,
07:00.045 --> 07:04.363
I've owned several variants of the CQ, I currently
07:04.460 --> 07:08.136
own one of the really just astoundingly beautiful new
07:08.409 --> 07:12.520
executions of the '70s line, the Tweed Amp dial, which just—
07:13.020 --> 07:16.422
it's a very Asher watch. Yeah. And it's with that dial. But that watch,
07:16.502 --> 07:19.681
I think, exemplifies in many ways the opportunity of that
07:19.729 --> 07:24.081
brand. That watch is very thin. The bracelet is excellent.
07:24.611 --> 07:28.384
The movement is beautiful with a gorgeous hand-engraved balance cock.
07:29.363 --> 07:32.698
It is a complete thought and is executed phenomenally.
07:33.227 --> 07:36.322
So it's kind of like a sports watch. It's there very well.
07:36.738 --> 07:40.154
Arguably the sports watch. Yeah, arguably the CQ is
07:40.186 --> 07:43.345
like the sports watch. But this has an engraved balance cock as well, because I
07:43.845 --> 07:47.097
think that's just a cool little feature on the grand— or rather on the large
07:47.161 --> 07:51.073
side. There's 2 sizes of the CQ. The one, the larger
07:51.573 --> 07:55.114
size, the 42mm, does have engraving. That's kind of neat. It's more than neat.
07:55.242 --> 07:58.531
It's incredible. Look, I think the thing about Geo that
07:59.031 --> 08:02.368
I find fascinating and, you know, within,
08:02.561 --> 08:07.136
within the Swatch Group, Geo kind of occupies the same strategic
08:07.636 --> 08:10.282
place as Lange does within Richemont.
08:10.908 --> 08:14.600
However, how— but to be clear, I'm not comparing— I'm
08:15.100 --> 08:17.923
not comparing the 2 brands. What I mean by that is it is of all
08:18.051 --> 08:21.711
the brands in the, in the portfolio for Swatch,
08:21.920 --> 08:25.819
it's the most independent-like. In the sense that—
08:25.835 --> 08:29.441
do you think it's also the most independently run? I can't speak to that.
08:29.602 --> 08:32.118
I don't know. But I, but I just feel like it's the most independent,
08:32.166 --> 08:35.966
like in its product lineup, the volume
08:35.998 --> 08:39.621
that they make. They also make their own dials. They own their own dial workshop
08:39.781 --> 08:43.019
that comes through in the Sixties line. Are they the only non-Swiss
08:43.788 --> 08:47.123
brand, like non-Swiss-made brand in the Swatch Group stable?
08:47.219 --> 08:50.713
I can't think of another, which is kind of interesting. They're like, off the top
08:50.777 --> 08:53.086
of my head, let's take a look at sort of like a world apart over
08:53.586 --> 08:56.035
there in Germany. You know, let's see if we look at the Swatch Group.
08:56.517 --> 08:59.903
Union Glashütte is also— oh yeah, there we go. So anyway,
09:00.144 --> 09:03.643
but yeah, they're definitely in the minority. Anyway, I think the opportunity
09:03.675 --> 09:07.687
there is a brand opportunity. And this is not true of my other picks who
09:08.187 --> 09:12.165
have incredibly strong brands. Glashütte, the product is so much better
09:12.665 --> 09:16.402
than the brand. The brand is not bad. The brand is just kind of nothing.
09:17.237 --> 09:20.270
And I think to me, you know, when we talk of— and we've talked about
09:20.770 --> 09:23.642
this, or I've talked about this, you know, in Maybe never on this podcast,
09:23.658 --> 09:27.497
but certainly from, you know, in previous lives, I think about
09:27.997 --> 09:30.774
brands as, as, as like celestial objects with gravity,
09:31.593 --> 09:34.629
you know, and the brands that are the best are the ones that, that have
09:34.821 --> 09:38.387
a lot of gravity. They pull in collector interest, they pull
09:38.516 --> 09:42.018
in industry interest, they pull in creative
09:42.435 --> 09:46.130
collaborators because people want to be in orbit
09:46.387 --> 09:49.983
of a brand with gravity. Glashütte Original has no
09:50.079 --> 09:53.497
gravity, which is a damn shame because
09:53.529 --> 09:57.220
the products that they make are absolutely phenomenal.
09:57.942 --> 10:01.152
And you could quibble around the edges that like, yes, maybe some of their case
10:01.652 --> 10:05.148
architecture is a little stark. Sure. Some of their watches are a little thick.
10:05.630 --> 10:09.914
Totally. But they know that and they work on that. The new '70s,
10:10.059 --> 10:14.119
for example, is really thin because they have calibers
10:14.553 --> 10:18.086
which can do that and then execute on phenomenal
10:18.586 --> 10:21.780
ideas and come to life in ways that just aren't available
10:22.280 --> 10:25.844
elsewhere. The '70s is a better Cubitus than the Cubitus.
10:26.759 --> 10:30.582
Yeah. You know? So what are you doing differently? You're rebooting.
10:30.630 --> 10:33.023
So I think if I'm going to reboot it, the first thing that I'm going
10:33.523 --> 10:37.601
to do is I'm going to think about, honestly, the workshop
10:37.665 --> 10:41.086
keeps doing the workshop stuff. They shouldn't change a darn thing.
10:42.177 --> 10:46.077
But someone needs to come in there who understands
10:46.109 --> 10:49.447
how to build gravity and work on what
that brand
10:50.025 --> 10:53.250
feels like. And I think there's 2 sides to that. There's the verbal and
10:53.750 --> 10:57.038
the visual articulation of the brand. What does it stand for right now? It basically
10:57.538 --> 11:00.103
stands for fine German watchmaking. Okay.
11:00.793 --> 11:03.971
I mean, how is that different than Dornbluth? How is that different than Nomos?
11:04.388 --> 11:07.549
How is that different? You could make an argument whether it's factual
11:08.049 --> 11:11.417
or not. There's tons of great German watchmakers. So the first thing
11:11.529 --> 11:14.835
is like, what is this brand? What does it stand for and how does it
11:15.335 --> 11:18.767
differentiate it? And then I think there is a serious opportunity around the
11:19.267 --> 11:22.313
visual articulation of that brand. You know, who did a great job of this is
11:22.442 --> 11:25.924
Armstrong. Armstrong over the last 3 to 5 years has
11:26.389 --> 11:30.080
fundamentally evolved their brand, the way the
11:30.144 --> 11:33.883
brand comes to life in everything from like their marketing material
11:34.477 --> 11:38.728
to their spaces at events to their logo. Every element
11:39.228 --> 11:42.368
of the verbal and visual articulation of that brand has changed. And I'm not saying
11:42.868 --> 11:46.440
that's, that, that's solely responsible for their continued growth and
11:46.940 --> 11:51.282
popularity. The watches are. Yeah. And the brand, you're right, in Armin Strom's case reflects
11:51.490 --> 11:54.825
the watchmaking. Exactly. Modern. It's precise. Yes.
11:55.434 --> 11:58.496
It feels contemporary and premium,
11:58.688 --> 12:01.895
but different from, you know, more conventional independent
12:02.395 --> 12:04.701
watch brands or classical independent watch brands. And yeah,
12:04.781 --> 12:08.292
Glashütte, you're right. The The brand identity
12:08.404 --> 12:12.299
itself feels kind of also ran. It's like luxury watch brand.
12:13.037 --> 12:16.900
Yes. And as a result, I think they are not doing themselves
12:17.400 --> 12:19.785
any favors because the product deserves better.
12:21.052 --> 12:24.306
So Gio, what do I think they should do? They need the, like, the guy
12:24.514 --> 12:27.800
in the black shirt, you know, and the bald head to come in and do
12:28.300 --> 12:32.545
the full brand refresh. Call in Landor Associates or Strawberry Frog
12:33.045 --> 12:37.018
or Strawberry Frog. There's a throwback, but something like that to really consider what that
12:37.518 --> 12:41.153
brand means and why it matters. Okay, cool. Brand refresh on the table for those
12:41.250 --> 12:44.199
guys. My first pick, I was worried this is gonna be on your list,
12:44.311 --> 12:47.389
so I'm going first, is Minerva. Now,
12:47.662 --> 12:51.381
yeah, yeah, now it's interesting. I think Minerva is kind
12:51.881 --> 12:55.565
of going through, it seems like, a brand refresh. So we've talked about the
12:55.613 --> 12:58.819
palace intrigue at Montblanc with their watchmaking division. Basically,
12:58.883 --> 13:02.457
Montblanc has kind of their core watch line,
13:02.586 --> 13:05.519
the Montblanc watches, which are made in Le Locle, and,
13:05.776 --> 13:09.142
you know, and more of an industrial scale. From what we understand, there have
13:09.642 --> 13:12.892
been layoffs there. We know that they're they pulled out of Watches and Wonders.
13:12.941 --> 13:16.498
So it seems like there's some sort of reassessment happening of the mainline
13:16.594 --> 13:21.081
stuff. But then Minerva has sat within Montblanc since 2006,
13:21.097 --> 13:24.526
and for a while Minerva effectively came off the
13:24.542 --> 13:28.228
dials, and these were Montblanc watches sort of made at Minerva or
13:28.728 --> 13:33.099
a Villaret collection or whatever it is. But this year we saw Minerva
13:33.516 --> 13:37.346
back on at the top of the, the Minerva
13:37.442 --> 13:41.003
dials. And what we're hearing is that Minerva will be once
13:41.067 --> 13:44.820
again its own brand. However, comma, but it will continue
13:45.320 --> 13:48.814
to live under Montblanc. I believe it will continue to be distributed and sold through
13:48.830 --> 13:52.888
Montblanc points of sale and all that sort of stuff. So I'm
13:53.000 --> 13:56.737
good. I'm coming. They're going to hire me and I'm going to do
13:56.753 --> 14:00.218
a couple of things differently at Minerva. I'm going to
14:00.718 --> 14:04.307
say it seems great that you're taking this approach, that you're going to,
14:04.452 --> 14:08.062
you know, give, give Minerva, it's, it's time
14:08.562 --> 14:11.705
in the sun and it's spotlight again. That's great. You're focusing on it as its
14:11.753 --> 14:14.851
own sort of brand in the high horology space.
14:15.043 --> 14:18.558
Great. Everyone loves Minerva. Everyone is a Minerva fan.
14:18.670 --> 14:21.912
This is fantastic news. Let's take it a little farther. So there's a
14:22.025 --> 14:25.395
few things I'm, I'm gonna do. The first
14:25.895 --> 14:29.199
thing I'm going to do is address 2 things from a product standpoint.
14:29.263 --> 14:32.890
The first is ergonomics. I think one of the big objections to
14:33.002 --> 14:36.437
Minerva watches is that they're too big. This has come
14:36.550 --> 14:40.627
up a lot. Now, part of this has to do with the historic calibers
14:40.724 --> 14:44.930
they use in there. They use larger movements, you know, historical Minerva movements.
14:44.994 --> 14:48.317
In some cases, these were stopwatch movements, so some of them do
14:48.430 --> 14:51.127
require larger cases. Pocket watch movements. Sorry.
14:51.319 --> 14:55.253
Well, yeah, pocket watch, although they didn't make stopwatch movements. They did, you know,
14:55.269 --> 14:58.528
pocket watch movements. Good, fair correction. But I'm
14:58.544 --> 15:02.284
gonna, I'm gonna focus on ergonomics. So as much as possible within
15:02.332 --> 15:06.167
the current collection, really
looking at as much
15:06.667 --> 15:09.836
as we can with the, with the calibers we have, making the watches as small
15:10.028 --> 15:14.001
and as thin as possible. Can you think of an example of another brand
15:14.834 --> 15:17.974
that came back or was rebooted that was that
15:18.474 --> 15:21.931
niche but still like blossomed? Like, can you
15:21.963 --> 15:26.096
think of anything like that? Because Minerva— Minerva, I mean, when we say everybody,
15:26.449 --> 15:30.037
we're really talking about is like the 2% of like, you know,
15:30.053 --> 15:33.354
the top of the watch pyramid. Those who know it respect it. Yeah. It's not
15:33.854 --> 15:36.269
like those who know it are like, oh, garbage, or, you know, I hate it.
15:36.542 --> 15:39.910
I think there's a lot of— we discovered there's just a ton of goodwill for
15:40.410 --> 15:43.905
it. But yeah, I think you're right. It's definitely among the cognoscenti. And that's okay.
15:44.001 --> 15:48.059
I mean, I think their expectations, it seems like production
15:48.171 --> 15:51.331
is— or maybe not Lucien Ardan, maybe Universal Genève. I was going to say
15:51.524 --> 15:53.785
UG. Similar sort of thing. Yeah.
15:54.652 --> 15:58.437
But the jury is still out on UG. But what UG has done, I think,
15:58.453 --> 16:01.950
is a little bit of what Minerva needs to do, which is I think Minerva
16:02.450 --> 16:06.188
is a bit stuck in its cow tracks. Where they're so committed to
16:06.204 --> 16:10.012
continuing these historic calibers that are 100 years old
16:10.512 --> 16:14.124
or not that that sometimes gets in their way. So I think within
16:14.173 --> 16:17.675
the— within those calibers, try to refine the proportions as much as possible.
16:17.852 --> 16:20.727
Now, the other thing that's going to help proportion, and the other thing I'm going
16:20.760 --> 16:24.133
to do differently over at Minerva, is introduce
16:24.633 --> 16:28.118
watches in a more accessible price point. Still high horology watches,
16:28.166 --> 16:32.773
still watches that continue Minerva's Minerva-storied
16:32.950 --> 16:36.782
calibers and product lines. So there is
16:36.815 --> 16:40.711
a watch in Minerva's history— has a long history. It's a time-only watch
16:40.743 --> 16:45.169
with a small seconds called the Pythagore, or the Pythagore,
16:45.779 --> 16:49.307
like Pythagorean. Look these up. Yeah, I know what
16:49.807 --> 16:52.754
this is. Yeah, these are, these are beautiful. They're very classical watches. They kind of
16:53.254 --> 16:56.539
almost look like, you know, like an IWC Portugieser in terms of its
16:57.039 --> 17:00.247
dial layout with you know, sub-seconds. And but
17:00.311 --> 17:04.197
they did them in all these different beautiful combinations. Some are a bit more
17:04.711 --> 17:08.308
sporty, some are more dressy, some have beautiful applied
17:08.340 --> 17:12.098
dial furniture. And they did— they created this watch, I believe,
17:12.419 --> 17:16.595
in the
modern incarnation of the brand, but it's discontinued
17:17.095 --> 17:20.031
now. But what this would do is allow them to do 2 things.
17:20.706 --> 17:23.918
One is have a product, and it would still be an expensive product. This is
17:23.934 --> 17:27.145
a $20,000 plus product, I'm imagining. Sure.
17:27.451 --> 17:30.711
But it's not— I think, you know, a lot of Montblanc chronographs now probably,
17:30.727 --> 17:34.934
I'm guessing, start around $40,000 and go, go up from— for
17:35.434 --> 17:39.238
sure— from there. So this is a time-only watch, small seconds, almost a dress
17:39.738 --> 17:42.145
watch. You could do different versions of it that are sportier or more dressy,
17:42.209 --> 17:45.341
almost like Fieders does with the Brunswick 38. You know,
17:45.373 --> 17:48.296
like that watch can be sportier or more dressy.
17:48.809 --> 17:51.877
They explore different dial furniture and finishing and things like that.
17:52.326 --> 17:55.370
I would reintroduce this time-only collection that would
17:55.870 --> 17:59.023
allow you to have a more ergonomic case, a smaller case, a more straightforward,
17:59.071 --> 18:02.916
more accessible thing. You can still bring back a historic caliber.
18:03.061 --> 18:06.489
You can still finish it to the T's, but it just creates an entry
18:06.922 --> 18:10.911
into the brand that allows people who are really excited about the brand to
18:11.411 --> 18:14.965
get in without having to spend $40,000, $50,000. I think you also got
18:15.465 --> 18:19.227
to get it out of Montblanc boutiques. Well, that was my— that's my third strategy
18:19.243 --> 18:22.868
here. The other thing I'm doing is I'm saying, look, Bless Montblanc's
18:23.368 --> 18:27.656
hearts. And we talked on previous podcasts about how Montblanc and Richemont rescued
18:27.688 --> 18:31.271
Minerva from likely, you know, certain death.
18:32.251 --> 18:35.576
But I think if they're going to do this, selling watches like this is a
18:36.076 --> 18:39.737
very different proposition. Look, their other products are fantastic. They make great leather
18:40.237 --> 18:43.448
products. They certainly make excellent pens. But selling watches like this
18:43.948 --> 18:48.941
is a very different proposition than retailing pens,
18:49.053 --> 18:52.340
leather goods, and dive watches like Montblanc dive watches and things like
18:52.840 --> 18:56.363
that in their, in their stores now. And I would, if it were up to
18:56.863 --> 19:00.820
me, I would reassess the retail network. I don't think they need to have Minerva
19:01.320 --> 19:05.148
boutiques, but I would be talking to high-end retailers who
19:05.648 --> 19:09.300
specialize either in independents or other horology brands who specialize
19:09.332 --> 19:12.667
in selling this and have the clients for this kind of thing. And I would
19:12.763 --> 19:16.114
retool the retail network around that kind of,
19:16.466 --> 19:20.073
that kind of retailer. So those are the things I would do. I would focus
19:20.573 --> 19:24.128
on ergonomics. I would focus on creating an entry to the brand
19:24.401 --> 19:27.975
that is both historical, but yet more ergonomic, more accessible,
19:28.023 --> 19:31.148
no, well, less finished or anything like that, but less complicated.
19:31.453 --> 19:35.011
And then I would retool retail and distribution. Fair.
19:35.524 --> 19:39.403
That's a good one. All right. I pick Hermès. Hermès or
19:39.451 --> 19:41.759
Hermes, as they said. What was the movie, that movie?
19:42.592 --> 19:45.926
Showgirls. Oh, you know that, that movie came up recently
19:45.958 --> 19:49.566
because I was talking to somebody about like, the best worst movies of all
19:50.066 --> 19:52.935
time. That's one of them. And that there's like a whole— that's a whole other
19:53.435 --> 19:56.609
podcast. Anyway, the director, he did like RoboCop and— yeah, yeah, yeah. But, uh,
19:56.770 --> 19:59.754
oh God, what the fuck was that guy? Starship Troopers. Yeah.
19:59.834 --> 20:02.642
And people like talk about the fact that the absurdity of that movie is what
20:03.142 --> 20:05.754
make it— is the point. Yeah. When of course when it came out everyone was
20:06.254 --> 20:09.541
like, this movie is ridiculous. Went right over their heads. Yeah.
20:09.781 --> 20:12.685
And I go back— is the point. All right, whatever.
20:12.814 --> 20:16.181
Anyway, back to Hermès. Hermès. Okay,
20:16.277 --> 20:20.044
so this one's the opposite of Gio to me, where the
20:20.544 --> 20:22.978
brand is about as strong a brand as you could ever hope to have.
20:23.571 --> 20:26.697
Oh yeah. And there's nothing to be done there. And it's
20:27.197 --> 20:30.785
not that the product is bad with Hermès. It's that the
20:30.865 --> 20:35.081
wind's gone out of the sails a little bit because I think it's gotten diluted.
20:35.177 --> 20:38.768
And I'll give you a few examples. Think about when Hermès came
20:38.800 --> 20:42.359
out the gate like about a decade ago with
20:42.391 --> 20:46.735
the Slim Dermes, which is, yeah, just gorgeous
20:46.799 --> 20:48.883
watch. And I, you know, and I think it got a lot of people in
20:49.383 --> 20:52.506
the watch world to sort of turn their head and be like, whoa, what am
20:53.006 --> 20:56.610
I looking at here? Like the typeface for that watch is what makes that watch.
20:57.011 --> 21:00.169
It's extremely wearable. It's beautiful. And the price point was very competitive.
21:01.002 --> 21:05.074
And then came some of the variants in the Slim Dermes line, that beautiful
21:05.090 --> 21:09.017
GMT that they did a collaboration with Hodinkee with
21:09.517 --> 21:13.008
that incredible World Timer, which I don't, which I believe is not in the slim
21:13.508 --> 21:16.694
line, but still. And then finally, of course, the H08,
21:17.030 --> 21:20.364
which is a very cool watch, but I also would argue is
21:20.540 --> 21:24.114
kind of the root of the problem. The H08, when it came
21:24.162 -->
21:27.639
out, was a $5,900 watch in steel
21:28.569 --> 21:32.110
with— and at the time, I think they had a carbon variant that also
21:32.174 --> 21:35.828
came out the high end, like around $8,000. And they have
21:35.844 --> 21:39.161
milked that cow dry. There are so many versions of
21:39.661 --> 21:43.615
the HO8 all over the place that it's so diluted that
21:44.115 --> 21:46.692
it's also taken away from part of what makes Hermès Hermès.
21:47.317 --> 21:50.922
Part of what makes that brand what it is is the takeaway that you can't
21:51.422 --> 21:55.136
have it. And the problem for them in terms of the brand,
21:55.328 --> 21:59.270
largely not the watches, not the watches. Yeah. So but what, what has
21:59.318 --> 22:02.891
happened is that the brand has sort of rejiggered things just like, well,
22:03.019 --> 22:06.516
what's our main vehicle? Well, it's leather goods and bags and things.
22:07.207 --> 22:10.627
So we're happy to like just sell you whatever watch you want, you know,
22:10.787 --> 22:14.400
on your quote unquote journey to becoming, you know, for you or
22:14.900 --> 22:18.639
your wife to be a Birkin owner. It is the equivalent of
22:18.671 --> 22:21.866
the Calatrava to the Nautilus is the
22:21.947 --> 22:25.848
H08 and the Slim d'Hermès to the Birkin. And I
22:25.897 --> 22:29.798
think they've actually done themselves a great disservice there because
22:29.895 --> 22:33.390
while that I believe that to be financially true for them.
22:34.319 --> 22:37.061
Their watches deserve better because they are better.
22:37.766 --> 22:41.196
And I'm not advising that they should treat their watch line the same way they
22:41.696 --> 22:44.563
treat their bag line and should be bundled and you have to buy a couple
22:45.063 --> 22:48.714
of saddles before you can get a watch or something. But I am saying that
22:48.891 --> 22:52.433
they are making too many variants of too many
22:52.933 --> 22:55.527
things. That the leather goods are a crutch for the watches? That they're keeping them
22:55.623 --> 22:58.701
from being less— because they can bundle watches, they're not as ambitious as they
22:58.765 --> 23:01.474
should be? Is that what you're saying? I think that they recognize that they can
23:01.974 --> 23:05.002
make money off of watches in order to sell their primary business.
23:05.484 --> 23:08.723
And even though the watches are something they clearly care about because the time and
23:08.771 --> 23:12.316
effort and money and design strength is there, if I
23:12.380 --> 23:14.930
think they look at it and they say, if we excised this part of our
23:14.962 --> 23:18.490
business, we would still be fine. And therefore
23:18.990 --> 23:21.745
we don't really need to do much with it. And my argument to them is
23:22.098 --> 23:25.450
that's probably true, but I think you're actually leaving so
23:25.950 --> 23:29.682
much more on the table. And the proof of that is Cartier and Bulgari.
23:30.115 --> 23:32.967
Now, I
could hear somebody saying, whoa, whoa,
23:33.223 --> 23:36.797
whoa, but Cartier has a long history of watchmaking that Hermès does not.
23:37.069 --> 23:40.850
Fair. Bulgari, you know, I think is maybe a better example
23:41.350 --> 23:45.625
in the sense that— or Bulgari is maybe a better example. Bulgari is
23:45.657 --> 23:49.279
maybe a better example of, you know, someone who went deep
23:49.487 --> 23:53.989
into the brand's creative vision and
23:54.489 --> 23:57.692
the watchmaking that's coming out. Feels very of them, but also
23:58.192 --> 24:01.379
very new and modern. And there are a lot of people like me
24:01.763 --> 24:04.825
who would never go into a Bulgari store before or
24:04.969 --> 24:08.608
prior to watchmaking. And I'm in there now. And the chances that I
24:08.672 --> 24:12.087
might end up buying something for a wife, you know, or like someone else might
24:12.587 --> 24:15.357
go in and buy something for their girlfriend or their daughter, like whatever, or themselves
24:15.774 --> 24:19.204
is higher because they are attracting a new group of people.
24:19.300 --> 24:22.811
So my argument to Hermès is you aren't investing enough in watchmaking.
24:22.907 --> 24:25.825
I would agree. I'm looking through the watches on their website. I mean, it's funny
24:26.325 --> 24:28.886
when you go to look at watches, they include all like the Hermès Apple Watch
24:29.386 --> 24:32.060
variants too, and they're all mixed in with the watches. Well, it tells you that
24:32.560 --> 24:35.025
they— it tells you that for them, it's just that's the business unit. Yeah.
24:35.265 --> 24:38.311
Watch, not haute horology. Yeah.
24:38.391 --> 24:41.532
And there's some— I mean, they definitely have a clear design language. They've got some
24:41.596 --> 24:44.610
interesting stuff, but it feels like to some extent they sort of
24:44.962 --> 24:48.456
made a bunch of watches and felt like, okay, we've checked the box on watches.
24:49.033 --> 24:52.415
Yeah. What's weird too is their pricing structure. Like, I'll give you an example.
24:52.496 --> 24:55.829
Take— and I know this because I was interested and was looking at these watches.
24:56.487 --> 25:00.081
The slim Hermès GMT, which is a watch I really like. Yeah, it's nice.
25:01.156 --> 25:04.958
They come in a multitude of interesting metals from palladium up to platinum
25:05.086 --> 25:08.423
with some like gold and titanium in the middle. And they're all basically the same
25:08.456 --> 25:12.322
price. They're all like between like $30,000 to $38,000
25:12.822 --> 25:16.221
depending on the material. There is a ton of opportunity here
25:16.721 --> 25:20.247
and it just feels like this isn't a priority unless it's the H08 where
25:20.747 --> 25:24.339
they're like, make it blue. How about green? There's a lot of H08s. And the
25:24.839 --> 25:28.481
secondary market reflects that. Yeah. So I think there's, I think Hermès,
25:29.460 --> 25:32.479
best brand, one of the best brands in the world, no dispute there,
25:33.395 --> 25:37.265
needs to put more attention here to raise their watchmaking up to the level it
25:37.765 --> 25:40.380
deserves. Your turn. That's a good one. No, I think when the H08 came out,
25:40.396 --> 25:43.319
people were like, oh, this is so exciting. What else is here? And it turned
25:43.431 --> 25:47.366
out, well, there wasn't much more in the pipeline other than
25:47.623 --> 25:50.835
a lot of other H08s. So I'd like to see them continue. Well, it's because
25:51.335 --> 25:54.014
they just had one banger after another, like an incredible moon phase, the really good
25:54.127 --> 25:57.768
world timer, the slims. The H08, and then— yeah,
25:58.217 --> 26:02.048
yeah, exactly. All right, that's it. That's a good pick. Hey, it's Gabe,
26:02.209 --> 26:05.238
and no, I'm not gonna ask you to buy a watch. Instead,
26:05.591 --> 26:09.054
if you're enjoying this podcast, please take a moment, if you would, to give it
26:09.554 --> 26:13.350
a rate and review on your podcast player of choice. I know we
26:13.366 --> 26:16.957
ask for this all the time, but there's a reason we do. You know,
26:16.973 --> 26:20.788
it's pretty incredible. Openwork has quickly risen to become one of
26:20.885 --> 26:23.982
the top watch podcasts in terms of downloads,
26:24.094 --> 26:28.332
but we still trail many other watch podcasts in terms of ratings
26:28.509 --> 26:31.559
and reviews on places like Apple Podcasts,
26:31.591 --> 26:35.026
Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. So if you take
26:35.526 --> 26:38.718
a moment to give us a rating and review, we would really appreciate it.
26:38.814 --> 26:42.330
It goes a long way to helping other people who would enjoy this content find
26:42.830 --> 26:46.262
it themselves. Back to the show. My next brand
26:46.439 --> 26:50.244
is, is similar in, in a sense It's Ralph Lauren.
26:50.902 --> 26:54.290
Oh cool. And they still make watches, usually under
26:54.435 --> 26:57.052
kind of like the Polo brand. So they've got all the watches with the bear
26:57.084 --> 27:01.195
on, people like that. But you know, for a long time Ralph
27:01.695 --> 27:05.177
Lauren, they had a partnership actually with, with Richemont. So Richemont was
27:05.209 --> 27:08.468
making the watches. It ended in 2018. So from
27:08.645 --> 27:11.808
2007 to 2018, they had a partnership with,
27:12.113 --> 27:15.132
with Richemont, and Richemont was basically white label producing.
27:15.469 --> 27:18.872
It was like JLC that was doing it, wasn't it? I'm not sure. I wouldn't—
27:19.161 --> 27:22.386
I'm pretty sure that some of the higher-end pieces had JLC calibers. Yeah, and they
27:22.886 --> 27:27.425
had some amazing watches. They had a line I think called like the Classique,
27:27.666 --> 27:31.276
I believe it was called, and they very much kind of actually looked like
27:31.292 --> 27:35.689
Breguet watches. They had Breguet hands, they had a Breguet-like
27:35.705 -->
27:39.926
dial layout and things like that, but they're elegant. I think Justin Hast actually has
27:40.519 --> 27:44.435
one of— one of those watches. They're beautiful and very elegant.
27:44.531 --> 27:47.628
They came in precious metal and all that sort of stuff. I mean,
27:47.660 --> 27:51.494
they're, they're really interesting watches. They had kind of tank-shaped
27:52.216 --> 27:56.788
watches, rectangular watches, watches that had these pebble-shaped
27:57.288 --> 28:00.734
cases with these very graphical Arabic numeral dial layouts
28:01.234 --> 28:04.969
and things like that. They still sell some of these watches on their website,
28:04.985 --> 28:08.017
but it seems like they're just running out old stock. Maybe they're
28:08.033 --> 28:10.456
still making some of them. Some of them are quartz now.
28:11.322 --> 28:15.525
Watchmaking just really isn't a focus for Ralph
28:15.653 --> 28:19.631
Lauren, forgetting Polo for a second. Really isn't a focus
28:19.808 --> 28:23.336
for them in the way it was maybe, maybe 10 years ago.
28:23.496 --> 28:25.484
And I think, one, that's a shame,
28:26.463 --> 28:29.991
but two, I think there's a real opportunity now around that for
28:30.491 --> 28:33.695
a few reasons. Number one, we talk about this all the time, the kinds of
28:33.759 --> 28:36.838
watches that they were making, and I would assume would continue to make,
28:36.902 --> 28:40.510
these jewelry pieces, these elegant
28:40.735 --> 28:43.445
shaped watches of all sorts. To me, it's like,
28:43.477 --> 28:47.553
it's like the Western engraved like tonneau-style case
28:48.053 --> 28:51.374
watches that really like felt distinct to me. Yeah. Because when
28:51.406 --> 28:54.602
you say Ralph Lauren, like to me the question is like, well, who do they
28:54.618 --> 28:58.006
want to be in this space? Right. One thing that's interesting about Ralph Lauren
28:58.506 --> 29:02.438
is that it's a house of brands and that those brands really vary
29:02.887 --> 29:06.339
in everything from price to quality to, to audience
29:06.839 --> 29:10.097
that they're addressing. But they're all strong brands in one way or another.
29:11.076 --> 29:14.223
When I think about like on the higher end of Ralph Lauren, so I think
29:14.723 --> 29:17.965
like Purple Label or Black Label, right? To me, I'm like,
29:17.981 --> 29:21.369
well, who's that competing with? And then on the watch front, who's playing in that
29:21.869 --> 29:24.355
space? And to me, it's like, well, that sort of competes not in style but
29:24.855 --> 29:28.739
in price with like Tom Ford, you know, which is another men's
29:29.239 --> 29:32.576
fashion or high-end men's fashion brand. Dior, another one
29:32.769 --> 29:35.964
to a much lesser degree for men. Chanel, that, you know,
29:35.980 --> 29:39.320
participate in watchmaking. Yeah. And what's interesting to me
29:39.336 --> 29:43.330
about those is that Chanel has done a
29:43.830 --> 29:47.190
ton of work to bust themselves
out of— was it the J-12?
29:47.690 --> 29:50.470
Yeah. Out of that, like, you know, which is an iconic watch. Yeah. They're,
29:50.970 --> 29:53.990
they're doing what you're suggesting Hermès should do, essentially.
29:54.490 --> 29:57.590
Right. And they've done an incredible job about that. And Chanel is like, we should,
29:58.090 --> 30:00.590
we should do a whole episode on Chanel because there's an interesting company. But putting
30:01.090 --> 30:04.090
that aside for a minute, best smelling offices I've ever been in, by the way.
30:04.590 --> 30:07.080
It's like incredible. They like pump some fabulous— How about the bathrooms?
30:07.350 --> 30:10.890
Beautiful. I was the ugliest
30:11.390 --> 30:14.446
person walking around the Chanel offices when I called on that place. In my
30:14.946 --> 30:17.251
old career. Anyway, moving on. Low bar, though.
30:19.190 --> 30:22.571
Tom Ford is not interested at all in haute
30:23.071 --> 30:26.369
horology, you know, and they're just pumping out some design
30:26.401 --> 30:29.943
pieces. Ralph Lauren could go either way. Well,
30:29.959 --> 30:33.260
that's what, that's what I'm saying. Like, just take the things that they were making
30:33.372 --> 30:37.026
before. Let's say they were on the high-end purple black label sort of
30:37.058 --> 30:41.032
tier of stuff. Like, they were making things then, those shaped watches,
30:41.144 --> 30:44.317
elegant watches, jewelry pieces, haute horology pieces,
30:44.413 --> 30:47.555
dress pieces that are what in vogue. That's where the market
30:48.055 --> 30:50.955
is today. You look at some of the watches Ralph Lauren was making 10,
30:51.067 --> 30:54.419
15 years ago, it was ahead of its time. They were making
30:54.515 --> 30:58.204
the watches then that are kind of in vogue
30:58.300 --> 31:01.796
now. It's not like they were wrong. They were just a decade too
31:01.844 --> 31:05.645
early to a trend at a time where everyone was interested in like sports watches.
31:05.741 --> 31:08.692
Yeah. But you know, it's interesting too. You know what another example of this is
31:08.804 --> 31:12.813
like the way Louis Vuitton has like evolved their watchmaking. Because like
31:13.053 --> 31:15.602
you roll back the clock 10 years ago, maybe a little longer than that,
31:15.618 --> 31:17.959
like, like pre-Fabrique du Temps, you know?
31:18.087 --> 31:21.165
Yeah, they really were fashion watches, largely,
31:21.309 --> 31:25.284
largely, not entirely, but largely. They've completely overhauled
31:25.300 --> 31:29.244
what that is. So Louis Vuitton as a watchmaker, as opposed
31:29.744 --> 31:32.578
to having unique watches that were special, you know,
31:32.674 --> 31:36.105
like the Monterey or whatever they were making, now they're making
31:36.313 --> 31:39.375
fine watches largely fine
31:39.487 --> 31:43.318
watches. Yeah, not all of them, but largely. And Louis Vuitton
31:43.350 --> 31:46.828
as a watchmaker stands on its own. So the question for
31:47.328 --> 31:51.493
me is like, you know, Ralph Lauren and Louis Vuitton are not necessarily
31:51.589 --> 31:55.372
on equal footing from a brand standpoint, but you could— you'd be hard-pressed to find
31:55.872 --> 31:59.989
stronger American brands than Ralph Lauren. Yeah. So the question there really
32:00.005 --> 32:03.964
is, do they have enough interest to really
32:04.464 --> 32:07.365
invest in it? Because I think if they did, to your point, Ralph Lauren watches
32:07.477 --> 32:11.219
could be meaningful. Yeah. And Ralph Lauren, the brand, is like tofu. It takes on
32:11.716 --> 32:14.880
the, you know, the meaning and the stature of whatever's around it. You can have—
32:14.944 --> 32:18.991
it's pretty remarkable. You go into a Ralph Lauren store. I was at the one
32:19.039 --> 32:22.653
in Caesars Palace a couple of months ago, and it's like you have
32:23.153 --> 32:26.780
everything from Polo to Double RL to Purple Label in the same place.
32:26.892 --> 32:30.184
And it does. It hangs together. And like the Purple Label stuff or
32:30.684 --> 32:34.440
the Double RL stuff doesn't feel cheap because there's a sweater with a teddy
32:34.940 --> 32:37.395
bear in the front, you know what I mean? Like, the brand is able to
32:37.411 --> 32:40.561
rise to the occasion of whatever segment it enters. So I
32:41.061 --> 32:43.373
think if they decide— it's also, it's also like always been a kind of high-low
32:43.873 --> 32:47.454
fashion brand. Yeah, but, but they have permission to go high or
32:47.470 --> 32:51.085
to, or, or not or whatever. Now they're, they're not with, with Polo
32:51.585 --> 32:54.556
watches. But so, so there's a lot of opportunity there.
32:54.861 --> 32:58.252
The other thing I think is happening is just with Ralph Lauren itself, the brand
32:58.752 --> 33:02.781
and the guy. Like, I think there's a cultural reckoning around Ralph Lauren the
33:02.813 --> 33:06.004
brands, the house of brands, and the guy in particular,
33:06.340 --> 33:09.899
where people are realizing like, oh my gosh, this is like an American
33:10.188 --> 33:13.843
design style fashion icon, like sort of hidden in plain
33:13.972 --> 33:17.851
sight that we're only now starting to recognize, like really deserves
33:18.124 --> 33:22.020
his, his flowers. Like, I think there's a broader cultural reckoning happening
33:22.052 --> 33:25.755
there. And so there's an opportunity to carry that momentum into
33:25.803 --> 33:29.315
watchmaking at a time when that is the segment of the watchmaking
33:29.331 --> 33:32.714
market that's doing well. The question will be Do
33:33.214 --> 33:36.739
they— does it take them so long to do this and to re-enter this
33:36.867 --> 33:40.330
market that maybe the, the pendulum and the
33:40.830 --> 33:44.147
trend has swung another way by the time they do? But if I were working
33:44.179 --> 33:47.178
there, I'd be like, we have got to get back into watchmaking.
33:47.627 --> 33:51.203
We don't need to
reinvent the wheel. The things we were making 10 years ago
33:51.235 --> 33:55.051
have never been more relevant than they are today. The Stirrup watch
33:55.148 --> 33:57.874
is another great one. You know, it's a shaped watch. Yeah, it kind of looks
33:58.374 --> 34:01.646
like a stirrup. Yeah. But without trying too hard, it's a beautiful— I mean,
34:01.662 --> 34:04.921
Hermès does the exact same thing. Yeah, beautiful ladies' watch.
34:05.050 --> 34:08.132
So I think that they have so many ingredients, they just need to
34:08.148 --> 34:11.986
turn it back on essentially and refocus there. There's not, not too
34:12.018 --> 34:16.080
much I would do other than to say there's an opportunity now culturally
34:16.915 --> 34:20.897
and from a business standpoint to really reactivate this. This brand
34:20.913 --> 34:24.096
has the potential, so I'd love to see them do it.
34:24.301 --> 34:27.762
I get that. Final pick, Asher. All right. Make it count.
34:28.547 --> 34:32.248
Blow us away. My last one is, I think,
34:32.296 --> 34:35.084
one that has been screaming for it, which is Roger Dubuis.
34:35.981 --> 34:39.570
And I think they know it in this instance, you know, because the brand,
34:40.147 --> 34:43.880
the, the brand in the way that it's lived versus the way
34:44.024 --> 34:47.742
that it was is so different. And I suspect that was
34:47.854 --> 34:51.379
by design, you know, that the, that the folks at Richemont
34:51.699 --> 34:55.243
wanted to take it into this sort of futuristic,
34:55.612 --> 34:58.855
you know, here's what, you know, we view the future of
34:58.903 --> 35:02.435
haute horology to look at look like. But instead of the
35:02.935 --> 35:05.806
sort of like— and Ming has this philosophy, but instead of the Ming path,
35:05.822 --> 35:09.450
they took kind of like the Terminator RoboCop path, you know,
35:09.996 --> 35:13.335
whereas like it's futuristic because it has all these edges and because we have
35:13.367 --> 35:16.851
3 lugs, not 2. And, you know, it's those creepy robot
35:16.979 --> 35:20.366
dogs. That was just bizarre. Yeah. One time at Watches and Wonders,
35:20.399 --> 35:24.251
they had these like robotic dogs wandering around their space. It was very
35:24.829 --> 35:28.580
strange. But I think, you know, the reason
35:28.612 --> 35:32.589
that's so strange, that just it felt so put on.
35:32.926 --> 35:36.870
They also had that like Blade Runner Knights of the Round Table kind
35:37.370 --> 35:40.974
of setup in there one year. That's a very good example. It seems
35:41.263 --> 35:44.374
they seem to have lost their way. But, but this is my point.
35:44.790 --> 35:48.462
Like, they, they have absolutely
35:48.494 --> 35:51.925
lost their way. What to you is compelling about this brand at its core?
35:52.904 --> 35:56.114
The history of it. I mean, the history of it is what makes
35:56.614 --> 35:59.982
it who they are. And, you know, like the watchmaker himself,
36:00.527 --> 36:04.218
the iconic designs, those cases, the, you know,
36:04.298 --> 36:07.556
the 1990s Roger Dubuis cases
36:07.749 --> 36:11.231
are recognizable from across the room. And I
36:11.279 --> 36:14.714
think they've left so much of their
36:14.730 --> 36:17.988
DNA on the table that all they need to
36:18.100 --> 36:21.535
do is come back to where they were, you know?
36:22.112 --> 36:26.045
And if they do that, I think they will be able to— Yeah,
36:26.061 --> 36:29.223
I'm looking at those watches now. You're right. And that's—
36:29.271 --> 36:33.107
and also, this is a moment for what— for those watches and that kind
36:33.607 --> 36:36.365
of case style. I mean, Daniel Roth is a good example of,
36:36.894 --> 36:40.249
of a brand with a distinctive '90s case shape like that
36:40.749 --> 36:43.062
that's come back to some acclaim. Why can't Roger Dubuis do it?
36:44.181 --> 36:47.455
In many ways, I think that for them, of all the 3 that we've discussed,
36:48.113 --> 36:52.266
They are the most obvious path
36:52.443 --> 36:56.019
back to success. Stop what you're doing now and do
36:56.051 --> 36:59.755
what you were doing before. And if there's any evidence to prove
37:00.255 --> 37:03.540
that, I direct you over to the file cabinet for
37:03.588 --> 37:07.533
D, where you will find Daniel Roth. Yeah. So Hodinkee,
37:08.239 --> 37:12.264
Tony Traina, good old Tony Traina wrote a great piece over at Hodinkee a couple
37:12.764 --> 37:16.240
of years ago. So this was back in 2023.
37:16.740 --> 37:20.940
Check this out, Vintage Watches: Why Early Roger Dubuis Is Worth Knowing About.
37:21.440 --> 37:24.700
And he gets into the— those designs from the 19— the designs and the
37:25.200 --> 37:27.640
watchmaking from the 1990s. You look and you're like, yeah, why aren't they just making
37:28.140 --> 37:31.610
that? Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's funny, it's like when you look at Geo,
37:31.680 --> 37:34.800
it's like— would Dana Roth be under D or R, by the way? Depends how
37:35.300 --> 37:38.340
you file. Daniel Roth. But I mean, like, you know, it really, really depends,
37:38.840 --> 37:41.936
right? Like, you know, Hermès There's, there's, there's product work to be done.
37:42.050 --> 37:45.412
Glashütte Original, there's brand work to be done. You know,
37:46.963 --> 37:50.765
Roger Dubuis, just stop. Keep it simple, stupid. You know,
37:50.846 --> 37:53.871
just, just stop. And if you just do that,
37:54.404 --> 37:57.904
I think there's a lot to rediscover there. I'm going to make
37:58.404 --> 38:01.472
a prediction. Please. I think at Watches and Wonders this
38:01.568 --> 38:05.296
year— oh, you know, there are rumors that Richemont has been exploring a
38:05.796 --> 38:08.986
sale. Oh, for sure, of the brand. I don't know the particulars, but I know
38:09.050 --> 38:12.928
that's out there. But I'm gonna say, let's assume it stays within Richemont,
38:12.992 --> 38:16.100
or maybe even if it doesn't, but let's assume it stays within Richemont and they're
38:16.180 --> 38:19.657
at good old Watches and Wonders with their creepy robotic dogs.
38:20.362 --> 38:24.256
I'm gonna make a call that they're going to reissue one of their early watches
38:24.272 --> 38:27.652
from the '90s this coming year at Watches and Wonders. I think, I think
38:27.877 --> 38:31.722
it's— you've heard it here first. Yeah, I think that's an inevitable choice because it
38:32.222 --> 38:36.112
is the obvious and only choice, you know. And, but again,
38:36.369 --> 38:40.358
and this is the key, who is selling those watches is
38:40.470 --> 38:43.739
going to be critical because in the same way that
38:44.239 --> 38:46.863
when you walk into a Montblanc boutique, and this is no shade on these people
38:47.363 --> 38:50.853
because these people sell pens, they don't know how to sell a watch.
38:51.109 --> 38:54.250
Hey, look, so the question— selling a watch is a thing. So is selling like
38:54.750 --> 38:57.070
a $1,000 pen. Like, that's just an— I don't know anything about that. This is
38:57.086 --> 39:01.011
my point. It's same thing with like Hermès. Is it reasonable if somebody who is
39:01.140 --> 39:04.650
focused on custom leather goods to know everything about how watch movements
39:05.150 --> 39:08.323
work? I'm sure there are some people, but like, that's a really different skill set.
39:09.013 --> 39:11.899
So you can't like hold people accountable to that. That's not fair,
39:12.348 --> 39:15.315
right? Like, how many times did I work in a job where I was the
39:15.815 --> 39:18.555
marketing guy and I didn't understand anything about like how operations worked?
39:18.795 --> 39:20.992
It's not reasonable. So my point is,
39:21.891 --> 39:24.537
I get it, but they still need to think about who's selling it.
39:25.355 --> 39:28.932
And a good example of this is Universal Genève. Again,
39:29.670 --> 39:32.896
they have one boutique that they're opening in Geneva, and then they are
39:33.396 --> 39:36.588
picking very carefully 1, 2, or 3 points of sale who will be
39:37.088 --> 39:41.066
trained meticulously on those watches. And that will set them up
39:41.563 --> 39:44.870
as best they can for success, I think. I think Roger Dubuis requires the same.
39:45.255 --> 39:48.866
And by the way, once again, I direct you to R in the
39:49.366 --> 39:52.590
cabinet for Roth, Daniel. Oh, this is, this is R,
39:53.039 --> 39:55.800
D. Exactly. For how that— or D, R.
39:56.089 --> 39:59.665
Yeah, exactly. Because that's how they're doing it. When you first said this brand,
39:59.697 --> 40:02.951
I was just like, what? Because I'm so lost in where the brand has been
40:02.999 --> 40:07.135
in the last few years that I just sort of like blacked
40:07.635 --> 40:11.319
out and forgot about all these early pieces, which are quite remarkable. It's all there.
40:11.399 --> 40:14.765
It's hid— talk about hidden in plain sight. That is a great— that
40:15.265 --> 40:18.853
is a great pick and one that sort of writes itself. So
you've been focused
40:18.917 --> 40:22.235
on the world of high horology here. You know,
40:22.459 --> 40:25.954
you're where the market is, I guess. But I'm,
40:26.307 --> 40:29.288
I'm, I'm gradually going down the ladder here and And the,
40:29.416 --> 40:32.381
the thing that I'm going to reboot is Iron Man.
40:33.102 --> 40:36.323
Yeah. So it's a good one. It's a product. I guess you could say it's
40:36.823 --> 40:39.928
a, I mean, Iron Man is a brand. It's licensed by Timex.
40:40.473 --> 40:44.046
So like literally like from, I don't know who owns the brand of Iron
40:44.094 --> 40:48.068
Man, but like the races. Yeah, exactly. That was the whole idea behind the watch
40:48.180 --> 40:51.337
is, you know, it was meant for people who are competing in Iron Man races.
40:51.401 --> 40:54.189
It can handle whatever you throw at it. So it was like one of the,
40:54.253 --> 40:57.171
one of the first collabs I guess so, yeah.
40:58.118 --> 41:01.263
But, you know, I think at least when watch people think of Iron Man,
41:01.488 --> 41:04.777
they're thinking of Timex watches. And I think at a certain point in culture,
41:04.793 --> 41:08.114
certainly in the 1990s, you know, everyone had an Iron Man. Bill Clinton
41:08.147 --> 41:11.500
famously wore an Iron Man. When people heard Iron Man, they were thinking about the
41:12.000 --> 41:15.479
watches. And Iron Man watches have stayed within the Timex
41:15.528 --> 41:18.865
portfolio, and they do like cool limited editions. They do
41:19.058 --> 41:22.620
these like Japan market exclusives, which are really cool.
41:22.684 --> 41:26.441
You can still get some like like cool newer Ironmans
41:26.941 --> 41:30.810
and some of these like vintage throwback Ironmans. So in 1984,
41:30.938 --> 41:34.360
Timex worked together, to your point, with the triathlon.
41:34.552 --> 41:38.616
Yep. At the time that they hoped that this would improve
41:38.648 --> 41:42.503
their sales and Timex's product manager for digital launches, a guy
41:42.519 --> 41:46.438
named Mario Sabatini flew directly to Kona to
41:46.938 --> 41:49.232
get a feel for the market. He took 1,500 of these watches with him and
41:49.732 --> 41:53.033
he sold all of And that's what set it off. Yeah,
41:53.498 --> 41:57.104
interesting. And oh, it also, it also was the
41:57.604 --> 42:00.598
first watch to introduce Indiglo. Yeah, exactly. I mean,
42:00.630 --> 42:03.996
this was the flagship product for Timex in the 1990s,
42:04.237 --> 42:08.372
so of course they introduced Indiglo with, with the Ironman. I had an Indiglo
42:08.404 --> 42:11.161
watch too, an Indiglo Ironman. It was cool.
42:12.171 --> 42:15.921
So in any event, they, they've kept the, this mark
42:16.178 --> 42:19.335
alive and this partnership alive, but it's more or less
42:19.447 --> 42:23.469
kind of in the drugstore territory. You know, it's like most
42:23.485 --> 42:26.930
of the Ironman watches today probably don't. I mean, let's take a look
42:27.430 --> 42:29.733
at the Ironman product portfolio here.
42:30.615 --> 42:34.092
So yeah, if you want like a basic Ironman, it's like $119,
42:34.604 --> 42:37.216
you know, so it's not drugstore level,
42:37.408 --> 42:40.645
but it— oh, you can get a $72 Ironman.
42:40.773 --> 42:44.730
You can get, oh, a $54 Ironman at
42:44.843 --> 42:48.400
Walmart. So it's kind of like, you know, kind of a
42:48.464 --> 42:51.991
drugstore— oh yeah, $42 Ironman at Walmart. Hey, hey.
42:53.049 --> 42:56.768
So it's, it's alive. It's still a going concern.
42:56.880 --> 43:00.567
But I think there's so much more potential here. I think Ironman for Timex
43:01.067 --> 43:05.504
can be what G-Shock is for Casio and cannot just be these rugged
43:05.681 --> 43:08.181
watches that are made for these kinds of, you know,
43:08.823 --> 43:12.109
triathlon-type competitions and all that stuff, but can be a
43:12.609 --> 43:15.844
platform for innovation the same way, you know, it made sense that they
43:15.860 --> 43:19.451
would unveil Indiglo in the '90s in an Ironman,
43:20.284 --> 43:23.602
I think, you know, for digital watches for Timex, this should be the platform.
43:23.666 --> 43:26.344
And they've shown that they can make it work. So they do have a high-end
43:26.456 --> 43:30.287
product called the Ironman Adrenaline. It's like a $200,
43:31.104 --> 43:34.807
$229 watch, and it's sort of the high end of the range. But to
43:35.307 --> 43:39.120
me, it's like, that should be like really the core of
43:39.620 --> 43:43.063
the range. And it's not to help them raise prices or gouge people or make
43:43.127 --> 43:46.782
people pay more for stuff, but instead it's to give Timex some
43:46.878 --> 43:50.405
permission to take creative risk, to take commercial risk,
43:50.421 --> 43:53.757
to build Cool-looking watch. Adrenaline. To build watches that are
43:53.933 --> 43:57.174
really robust and interesting. Yeah. You know what's interesting about this? I've never
43:57.302 --> 43:59.884
even seen this before until you pointed it out to me. This, this to me
44:00.384 --> 44:03.590
feels like, like a Suunto competitor. Yeah, exactly. You know, which of
44:03.638 --> 44:06.108
course is a watch that sells for 3 times this price.
44:06.686 --> 44:09.830
That's really interesting. And so it's a good-looking watch.
44:09.926 --> 44:12.941
It's a cool watch, right? And it has some of the, you know, the famous
44:13.441 --> 44:16.823
Ironman signatures in terms of like color and things like that.
44:16.871 --> 44:20.240
Rubber strap, robustness, basic functionality. It's a
44:20.740 --> 44:24.506
cool any-digi watch. Like you look at that thing, this, this Adrenaline Ani-Digi.
44:24.570 --> 44:28.098
Yeah, okay, there's— it shows you— oh, it's big though.
44:28.258 --> 44:31.802
This thing's 46.5 millimeters. Sure, but build out the product line and
44:32.302 --> 44:35.795
do some smaller ones, do some shaped ones, do some different
44:36.295 --> 44:39.419
layouts, do a
purely digital one, do, you know, do an analog one. Like,
44:39.884 --> 44:42.995
take some risk here and experiment. I think if anything,
44:44.214 --> 44:47.966
not just Casio, but the, the resurgence and interest for Ani-Digi
44:48.062 --> 44:51.943
watches, I think, gives and the, and the built-in love. I mean, talk about
44:52.874 --> 44:56.499
who doesn't look back on Ironman watches with some nostalgia
44:56.723 --> 45:00.188
and some tenderness in their heart. Like, people, I think, want to see
45:00.813 --> 45:04.647
Ironman succeed as a product line. And to
45:04.743 --> 45:08.304
me, it's one where it's like they are barely scratching the
45:08.804 --> 45:11.689
surface of what is possible with this product line.
45:11.897 --> 45:15.233
And again, it's not about just making more money
45:15.266 --> 45:19.500
and charging more for fancier watches. It's about
45:20.000 --> 45:23.319
taking some risks, doing some creative things, and innovating and putting it in this,
45:23.688 --> 45:26.944
in this platform. To me, it's a no-brainer,
45:27.201 --> 45:30.297
and I, and I almost wonder why they haven't. And I'm sure the folks at
45:30.346 --> 45:34.068
Timex know more about, you know, Ironman watches and why they are
45:34.340 --> 45:37.806
where they are than, than I do, but man, would I love to see
45:38.306 --> 45:41.720
them blow this thing out. It's a great call. All right, well, take that,
45:41.800 --> 45:46.165
Asher. You know, I'm a man of the people. You know,
45:47.337 --> 45:51.253
I'm here with a vision for stirrup-shaped watches and,
45:51.686 --> 45:55.699
and Timex Ironmans, and you're off, you know, the $50,000
45:56.199 --> 45:58.973
and up price segment polishing your silverware.
45:59.695 --> 46:02.921
Sounds about right. Shall we leave it there? So I wanted
46:03.421 --> 46:06.708
to do a couple of honorable mentions. Do you?
46:07.094 --> 46:10.288
Not to get into it, but one of the other brands I thought about and
46:10.320 --> 46:14.045
it's— I guess it's the, the uber brand is
46:14.414 --> 46:18.075
still out there, but they haven't been in watchmaking for some time, so maybe
46:18.575 --> 46:21.238
it deserves another, you know, another draft— is Oakley.
46:21.383 --> 46:24.802
Remember the crazy gonzo Oakley watches?
46:25.397 --> 46:28.576
I do. Yes. Okay, is that honorable?
46:29.073 --> 46:32.028
Yeah, but you know, like, they had a very distinctive voice in,
46:32.365 --> 46:35.896
in watch design and watchmaking. I mean, those things were were
46:36.396 --> 46:39.805
absolutely gonzo. And you know, with the resurgence of Y2K fashion
46:39.918 --> 46:43.202
and things like that, you kind of wonder, like, is there, is there
46:43.702 --> 46:46.871
a moment now to bring back those crazy Oakley watches? I mean, they were taking
46:46.951 --> 46:50.636
risks. Sure, they had a point of view. You had me
46:50.652 --> 46:52.927
at Iron Man. I don't know if you got me on— All right, yeah,
46:53.119 --> 46:56.548
I was between Oakley and, and Iron Man. But you don't want to see the
46:56.564 --> 46:59.752
Oakley watches make a comeback? I think that's a much higher hill to
46:59.768 --> 47:02.972
climb. That's not your, not your vibe.
47:03.149 --> 47:06.674
That's my honor. You don't have any honorable mentions? No, I mean, those are the
47:07.174 --> 47:10.667
ones that like, I really, like, I really thought had potential.
47:10.939 --> 47:12.991
There are plenty that you can be like, that one's dead in the water and
47:13.491 --> 47:15.765
we need to like figure it out. But these have potential,
47:16.535 --> 47:19.581
like they really do. All right. So I
47:20.081 --> 47:24.198
did have a couple of others, but I think the only other one worth discussing,
47:25.272 --> 47:28.687
and we won't get into it, but worth a mention are like Mickey Mouse watches.
47:29.441 --> 47:32.968
You know, like Mickey Mouse watches have been licensed here, there, and everywhere.
47:33.353 --> 47:37.168
Why wouldn't Disney bring it, you know, bring it in-house and make— and they
47:37.668 --> 47:40.598
don't have to make them. They could have a production partnership with someone like Ralph
47:41.098 --> 47:44.429
Lauren did with Richemont. But like, why wouldn't there be a Mickey Mouse watch brand?
47:44.525 --> 47:47.458
I guess there's just not enough runway for it. I don't think so. I mean,
47:47.538 --> 47:50.519
and it's funny because like when I was at Disney a few months ago,
47:50.776 --> 47:53.452
it was just me and my wife. You go to that little store of the
47:53.484 --> 47:56.946
watches in it. We went to the one in California Adventure,
47:57.075 --> 47:59.543
you know, like the big store right by the entrance, which does have a watch
47:59.591 --> 48:02.620
display. And like there was a pocket watch and some other stuff. But the reality
48:03.120 --> 48:06.308
there is like While there are plenty of people who go there with lots of
48:06.324 --> 48:09.964
money, I don't think that's where— what they're buying.
48:10.076 --> 48:13.908
Now, that said, I don't, you know, and I'll
48:14.408 --> 48:17.275
put it this way. I think the reason why I think they don't care is
48:17.775 --> 48:21.043
that they already have a higher-end Disney watch and they're not even bothering to sell
48:21.139 --> 48:23.272
it, which are the Oris Muppets watches.
48:24.250 --> 48:27.441
Oh yeah. You know, I forgot. Yeah. The Jim Henson stuff is
48:27.473 --> 48:29.734
part of Disney. It's part of Disney now. So I'm, you know, so I look
48:30.234 --> 48:31.433
at that and I'm like, well, if you're not even going to sell that,
48:32.043 --> 48:36.054
then you clearly aren't interested. Yeah. Oh, they don't know. They don't— I guess that's
48:36.554 --> 48:39.471
a whole nother kind of thing. Can you imagine some— someone at like the Disney
48:39.503 --> 48:42.920
Store sizing your Oris? Yeah, like it's not gonna happen.
48:43.337 --> 48:46.450
Yeah, I don't know. I mean, AP built an empire out of the Royal
48:46.626 --> 48:49.273
Oak. Can't Disney build an empire out of the Mickey watch?
48:50.236 --> 48:53.781
Shall we leave it there? Well, we'll leave it
48:54.281 --> 48:57.776
there. Well, thanks for listening. This of course is Open Work. It's a production of
48:57.792 --> 49:01.209
Collective Horology. You can find us, but no Mickey watches,
49:01.723 --> 49:05.949
at collectivehorology.com. And please get in touch with your suggestions,
49:06.383 --> 49:09.660
your feedback, your own ideas for brand reboots. What are
49:10.160 --> 49:12.824
you rebooting? And to do that, you can email podcast@collectivehorology.com.
49:30.156 --> 49:31.122
It's the Eras Tour.