תעתיק 🔗
00:00:00:22 - 00:00:15:08
Calum Fraser
I’m Calum Fraser, physiotherapist and director at Wilson Physiotherapy & Massage in Grange, Brisbane. Today I'm going to look at a paper The Walk Back Trial, published in The Lancet in 2024 by the
00:00:15:11 - 00:00:25:18
Calum Fraser
Spinal Pain Research Group in Macquarie University. It asked whether a structured walking and education program could stop low back pain coming back in people
00:00:25:18 - 00:00:27:24
Calum Fraser
who had just recovered from an episode.
00:00:28:01 - 00:00:57:11
Calum Fraser
So it's a randomised controlled trial of 701 adults, run through 25 private physiotherapy clinics around Australia between 2019 and 2022. They screened 3206 people and excluded 78%, with chronic back pain being the most common reason. They also deliberately excluded anyone already walking for exercise three times a week, doing more than 150 minutes of moderate to
00:00:57:14 - 00:00:59:21
Calum Fraser
vigorous activity a week.
00:00:59:23 - 00:01:28:14
Calum Fraser
And anyone already doing a prevention program like Pilates, the people who were included were mostly women, average age 54 and average BMI around 30, sitting about eight hours on a workday and walking about an hour a week. They had a median of 30 odd previous episodes, usually lasting 4 or 5 days, and have the last one finished about three weeks before they were enrolled.
00:01:28:16 - 00:01:35:22
Calum Fraser
The walking group had six sessions with physio over six months. The first was 45 minutes with a history and physical examination.
00:01:35:24 - 00:01:52:07
Calum Fraser
the starting dose came from a prescription guide based on current walking age and BMI. Then adjust for the person's goals, confidence and practical barriers. Follow up through at two, four and six weeks and three months, with a booster at six months.
00:01:52:09 - 00:02:15:08
Calum Fraser
Participants got paedometer and a walking diary for the first 12 weeks, with a target of 5 x 30 minute walks a week by six weeks. The education covered basic science, reducing fear of back pain, lowering recurrence risk and self-managing a minor flare. The comparison group had no intervention, and they could seek whatever care they wanted.
00:02:15:10 - 00:02:19:13
Calum Fraser
Based on the 12 week walking diary completed by the intervention group.
00:02:19:19 - 00:02:24:15
Calum Fraser
The median accumulated duration of walking
00:02:24:17 - 00:02:46:13
Calum Fraser
week one was 80 minutes, and by week 12 was 130 minutes. The Walking Diary also indicated that the median times walked per week by the intervention group was three times a week and a week for 12. So they increased the amount of activity they had done. Results. The median time
00:02:46:16 - 00:02:55:14
Calum Fraser
to an activity limiting recurrence was 112 days in the comparison group, and 208 days in the walking group.
00:02:55:16 - 00:03:11:16
Calum Fraser
The hazard ratio was 72. So the rate of those flares was about 28% lower, an absolute terms. About 72% of the comparison group had won in the first year, against 57% of the walkers.
00:03:11:18 - 00:03:23:17
Calum Fraser
Care seeking recurrences showed the biggest effect, with 42% of the comparison group saw someone for their back in the first year, against 28% of the walkers by 12 months,
00:03:23:21 - 00:03:30:05
Calum Fraser
85% of the comparison group and 75% of the walkers had some back pain return. Walking.
00:03:30:07 - 00:03:35:01
Calum Fraser
Cut the flares that mattered, but back pain still came back for most people.
00:03:35:03 - 00:03:37:23
Calum Fraser
so where does this apply to physiotherapy?
00:03:38:00 - 00:04:00:08
Calum Fraser
Having a carefully controlled increase in exercises increases your exercise tolerance and helps prevent further injury. The participants still had injuries and flare ups. They were just limited. So if you have back pain and do no exercise, then increasing the amount of exercise you do will have a positive effect. The main principle is that you increase the exercise gradually.
00:04:00:09 - 00:04:22:16
Calum Fraser
If you go from 0 to 100, then you may make your back pain worse as your body struggles to adapt to the increased demand of the exercise. And this is where people often hurt themselves. Consistency is the key. Start easy and build up. A good saying is that most people overestimate what they can achieve in three months, but underestimate what they can achieve in a year.
00:04:22:21 - 00:04:40:07
Calum Fraser
And this runs very true here. Same thing happens at the start of the year. I notice when people start a New Year's resolution to get back into the gym, and they may not have exercised for, say, two years, and then they go to the gym and they go every day or even twice a day to try and make the most of the gains.
00:04:40:09 - 00:05:09:12
Calum Fraser
And often I would see them at about, say, the six week mark where they've hurt themselves. And it's you can. And when you suggest reducing the load or even having a week off, they really don't want to because they don't want to lose any of the gains they've made over the last six weeks. But the reality is they have pushed themselves really hard for the last six weeks, and they had done nothing for a whole year beforehand, so the body was actually in need of some recovery.
00:05:09:14 - 00:05:18:15
Calum Fraser
Yeah. But it's obviously a hard psychological point to break through when this has happened to someone.
00:05:18:17 - 00:05:30:12
Calum Fraser
does the study crossover to more active people? Not really. This study doesn't show that by increasing the amount of walking a fairly active person does will prevent further injury.
00:05:30:14 - 00:05:53:02
Calum Fraser
However, often in physiotherapy we go by the philosophy where by increasing your strength and endurance, you build up your resilience, therefore creating protection from injury. So an example would be if all you lift is five kilograms, then by lifting five kilos you could be lifting towards your body's limits and over time this could be lead to injury.
00:05:53:02 - 00:06:15:10
Calum Fraser
Or maybe you have to lift ten kilos, which is a lot more than what you normally lift and that's when you injure yourself. However, let's say if you train up and progressively build up what you can lift and you can lift 20kg safely, then, your body adapts to that load. So when you go back to lifting five kilos or ten kilos, your body can manage it a lot safely.
00:06:15:10 - 00:06:26:20
Calum Fraser
It's used to it and it's less likely cause irritation or injury. So yes, it's a good, good study and it shows people if you do nothing and you've hurt your back.
00:06:26:22 - 00:06:39:10
Calum Fraser
doing some exercise in a controlled manner that doesn't irritate you doesn't make things worse, then that will quite possibly build up some resilience and lead to less injuries in the future.
00:06:39:12 - 00:06:40:02
Calum Fraser
Thank you.