תעתיק 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:04] Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:10] Adam Urbanczyk is the principal attorney at AU LLC,
[0:14] a Chicago law firm focused on intellectual property litigation,
[0:18] e-commerce disputes, and helping businesses protect their brands
[0:22] and are rapidly evolving marketplace.
[0:24] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today, Adam and I are talking about legal risks.
[0:31] e-commerce businesses should watch for before launching new products.
[0:35] Adam, good to see you.
[0:36] Hi, Sean. Good to see you.
[0:37] How did they do it?
[0:38] I mean, you can't completely inoculate yourself against these kind of risks,
[0:44] but where are the main legal risks businesses overlook when they're launching a new product?
[0:51] There are probably two main issues.
[0:55] And this is if you're launching, I guess, are you launching a new product
[0:58] as though you've developed the product or it's you've just decided to start selling the product.
[1:05] The latter, which is may run a few more risks.
[1:10] So if you're developing a product, one consideration is going to be
[1:16] is this product stepping on an existing US or wherever you're going to be selling the thing?
[1:22] Presumably, we're talking about selling it here in the US.
[1:25] The concern A concern might be, is this is my use sale offer for sale or imported to this country?
[1:32] If you're having it made elsewhere, is that going to be infringing an enforceable US patent?
[1:39] There might be some threshold with respect to the sophistication of the product,
[1:45] whether that's more or less a risk that you want to take some steps to to mitigate.
[1:52] If we're talking about something that's internet of things or it's a network device,
[1:57] some smart version of something, there's going to be lots of prior art that cover those things.
[2:04] And, you know, maybe it's worthwhile in your product development process conducting a, you know,
[2:10] not a prior search exactly, but sort of like an infringement analysis to see whether there are any patents out there
[2:17] that might turn into a problem if, you know, even if you weren't,
[2:22] even if you weren't interested in filing a patent application yourself to cover the thing that you've developed,
[2:27] maybe you just want to sell the thing, you know, most things that people buy and sell,
[2:31] they're, you know, when we come to like mobile devices and things,
[2:34] there's going to be lots of patents and those things, but, you know,
[2:36] by and large, the stuff we buy on a day-to-day basis isn't going to be covered by an enforceable patent.
[2:42] It's just, it maybe it would have been 50 years ago, but most of the stuff isn't.
[2:47] So it doesn't mean you, you know, you can go ahead and sell things because there is a denny enforceable patent to be worried about,
[2:53] but if we're developing new stuff and it's going to be, you know,
[2:57] I was probably, you
Load full transcript
know, most prod, most, in the context of consumer products, you know,
[3:01] most things, most patents are going to be issued in a potential concern or going to be covering smart items.
[3:10] Smartwatches, networked devices that are receiving data, communicating data to a network,
[3:16] via Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, whatever. So if we're talking about products like that,
[3:20] it's going to be incumbent upon you to conduct an infringement analysis, maybe a prior search,
[3:24] just to see if there's anything out there in the U.S.
[3:26] Or in whatever other jurisdiction you might want to sell the thing into.
[3:30] From a branding standpoint, you know, whatever you're selling,
[3:34] if it's to the consumer, there's going to be a brand of,
[3:37] very much is going to be a brand of some kind.
[3:40] So what you want to call the thing, there's a two million plus,
[3:47] I think live trademark registration with the U.S.
[3:51] I think it's two million, don't call me, but it's a lot.
[3:55] And of course, that covers all goods and all services,
[3:58] and if you're just selling widgets, particular type of widget,
[4:03] you would have to worry about all, but many of them potentially.
[4:08] So coming up with a brand that not only or a trademark for example for the item,
[4:14] that not only is going to be distinctive of your business and your products,
[4:19] but isn't going to be stepping out anyone else's toes.
[4:23] There's an analogous due diligence process with that activity to the patent activity.
[4:30] So you're going to bring this product to market,
[4:32] see if there's any potentially intervening rights.
[4:35] You want to bring the product with a particular name to market,
[4:38] well then see if there's any intervening trademark rights.
[4:41] And how do you do that?
[4:42] You're going to be doing a search within USPTO's trademark electronic search system
[4:49] or the tests, which is USPTO's own trademark database search tool.
[4:55] But it doesn't stop there because there's lots of examples
[4:59] of uses of trademarks for products that aren't registered with the USPTO,
[5:03] so that's sort of like a common law search that's, you're doing a Google search.
[5:07] I wanted to sell this particular type of product with this particular name.
[5:11] Let me just type that into Google and see what, for example, does that have to be Google,
[5:15] but let's see what comes back.
[5:17] Is there anything else out there that's sort of like a common law search?
[5:20] So there's that type of due diligence too.
[5:23] And then when you're in the process of selling it,
[5:27] you're going to be using pictures on a web screen, a web page to sell the thing
[5:33] where the picture's coming from.
[5:35] Did you take them?
[5:36] If you took them, did the person who took them, did the person who took them,
[5:40] provided you the rights to actually use them for the,
[5:43] in the way that you want to use them.
[5:46] So it's, it's a lot of t-crossing and
eye-dotting.
[5:50] Yeah, but there are lots of tools available,
[5:54] so it's a must to everybody to take a good, like a good faith pass
[5:58] to mitigate some low hanging fruit problems that might shell out.
[6:01] Oh, that's great.
[6:02] Well, you know, beyond trademarks,
[6:04] what other intellectual property issues should businesses evaluate,
[6:09] you know, before they bring a product to market?
[6:12] The trademark risk is going to be a main one.
[6:15] Like the copyright risk.
[6:17] Okay.
[6:18] If, if it's your product,
[6:21] you're not trying to make a version of some existing IP that's out there.
[6:26] Like I'm going to bring a new product to market.
[6:28] It's going to be a,
[6:29] it's going to be a Thanos-themed water bottle.
[6:35] And you screw his head off and you like,
[6:38] don't do that.
[6:39] Marvel's going to come back to you, right?
[6:41] So like there's obvious things like that,
[6:43] but if it's like, if you're developing a new product and it doesn't have a theme,
[6:47] it's not trying to leverage existing IP rights that are out there
[6:51] that you probably should know about.
[6:53] The copyright interest really might just pertain to imagery,
[6:58] media that you have produced to market the thing,
[7:03] promotional material,
[7:05] that whoever is doing that,
[7:07] if you're not doing it yourself,
[7:09] the marketing company,
[7:11] or if you just have a photographer taking products still photos
[7:14] in the little box, the light box thing,
[7:16] or whatever,
[7:17] that they're doing a pursuit to a certain agreement.
[7:19] You have all the rights to the works.
[7:21] That issue as long as you want.
[7:23] There's some reversion or like reflexive rights to the photographer
[7:27] or the marketing company that they can only use it for a certain
[7:31] limited promotion of purposes, things like that.
[7:33] That's going to be almost a transactional issue on the copyright side.
[7:38] And then of course,
[7:40] if you're introducing a product into a field
[7:43] that say it's crowded and there's lots of copy,
[7:46] you have competitors that have their own product listings
[7:49] for things that are similar,
[7:51] that are doing the same type of thing.
[7:53] Don't copy and paste text from a web page.
[7:57] That should be obvious to you with 2026.
[8:00] Don't do that.
[8:01] But I think the copyright side is probably the most easily mitigated.
[8:04] And then on the patent side,
[8:06] it goes to if it's at all technological,
[8:11] just kind of vague thing to say.
[8:13] If it's not something that's very basic,
[8:16] maybe there's a prospect that there's an existing enforceable US patent
[8:25] that might cover it.
[8:28] If you think back to the development process,
[8:31] like where did you,
[8:33] were you inspired to create the thing that you created?
[8:37] Where did that inspiration come from?
[8:39] A particular company that had its own product.
[8:41] Okay.
[8:42] Well, you know,
[8:43] lots of products are developed
[8:45] because there's a need.
[8:48] If you're a consumer of something,
[8:50] you have a problem with the thing,
[8:52] and then you decide,
[8:53] you know what,
[8:54] this would be great if somebody just did this.
[8:56] Well, I could just do this.
[8:58] It's 2026,
[8:59] and there's lots of resources for all different types of people,
[9:02] moderately entrepreneurial and inclined.
[9:05] I will take it upon myself to redesign this
[9:08] and maybe bring it to market.
[9:09] What's the initial investment for something to get to a prototype?
[9:14] Is it, you know, $152,000?
[9:16] Okay.
[9:17] Let's do it.
[9:18] I'm sick of my desk job anyway.
[9:19] Let's just roll it down.
[9:20] Maybe that's how it happens.
[9:22] But wherever you're getting the inspiration from,
[9:24] that might be a pretty good place to look to see that,
[9:27] to see whether there are any rights that are flowing that way.
[9:30] And even making slight changes to things,
[9:33] sometimes might, you know,
[9:34] might not get you out of the difference.
[9:36] You know, often we'll have clients that they develop something
[9:40] in response to some deficiency with an existing product.
[9:44] And they change it slightly.
[9:46] And they're like,
[9:47] well, this is different, you know,
[9:49] there's no, you know,
[9:50] in their minds, often there is a patent infringement problem
[9:54] because it's different in some what they perceive to be material way.
[9:59] Like, well, that product does this this way.
[10:01] Our product does this that way.
[10:03] It's like, okay, well, that's good.
[10:05] That might not be enough, though.
[10:07] And novelty is just one of the requirements
[10:09] for patentability, patentability standpoint.
[10:12] It also has to be not obvious, too,
[10:14] if you're looking to acquire patent protection from it.
[10:16] So that's, that's missed, too.
[10:19] So, you know, if you're looking to avoid infringement claims,
[10:22] though, it's a good place to start with be,
[10:24] who else is in, who else is in your market?
[10:27] What IP rates might they have?
[10:31] Google patents is a, is a great tool.
[10:34] Anybody can access it.
[10:38] You're making hand tools, go and look to see what kind of IP
[10:42] DeWalt has or black index or Stanley or whatever.
[10:47] Yeah, look at some of the big players because they've got,
[10:49] they got stuff in the pipeline and a pretty broad portfolio, I'm sure.
[10:54] Right.
[10:55] And in applications, you know,
[10:57] design patent applications are going to publish.
[10:59] And then a utility advocate,
[11:00] provisional applications won't publish.
[11:02] And then a utility application is going to publish
[11:06] like 18 months after the earliest filing date.
[11:09] So there could be stuff that's in,
[11:11] that's pending that you're not going to know about when you get started
[11:14] on your product development journey, too.
[11:16] So it's going to be an,
[11:17] it's going to be an ongoing process.
[11:19] But before you get too far along with it,
[11:22] you're going to be speaking within attorney.
[11:24] And the, you know, the attorney is going to have access to tools
[11:28] above and beyond Google patents to help mitigate the risk of you
[11:36] investing money into some product and then,
[11:39] you know, 18 or two years later,
[11:41] oh, by the way,
[11:42] this patent just showed up and we have to trash everything because
[11:46] this is clearly infringing.
[11:47] Or try to negotiate some like reflex of,
[11:50] you know, a reflex of license or something with the patent donor.
[11:54] And then you don't,
[11:55] if you,
[11:56] not going to have a lot of leverage in that situation,
[11:57] so you want to avoid it.
[11:58] What about,
[11:59] I know you're dealing with clients and others in online marketplaces,
[12:04] you know, like Amazon, right?
[12:06] Huge, huge business being done in these places.
[12:09] Are there legal risks unique to selling products through those marketplaces?
[12:15] The legal risk is probably going to be the same,
[12:19] whether you're selling on Amazon or you had your own website
[12:23] and you're just selling on your own website,
[12:25] or you don't have a website and you're just dropping the products off
[12:28] to the low goal store for whatever.
[12:32] The other risk though,
[12:34] can be,
[12:36] can be adverse action from the platform itself.
[12:41] So you can be selling products online and,
[12:45] you know, you're not getting sued,
[12:47] but some rights holder is initiating apex proceedings with you,
[12:50] or is sending you DMC notifications,
[12:52] or is sending you trademark infringement notices.
[12:56] And Amazon gets these,
[12:58] you can respond to them.
[13:02] Maybe there's a mistake,
[13:04] or the rights holder really doesn't have a claim.
[13:06] There's some argument.
[13:08] But, you know, Amazon is keeping, you know, Amazon,
[13:10] or every platform that has tools by which rights holders can enforce
[13:15] the rights through notifying the platform of infringement products,
[13:19] is going to be keeping track of this.
[13:22] And at some threshold,
[13:24] the number of strikes or claims that are made against your storefront
[13:28] will probably build up.
[13:30] And then the platform is just going to think,
[13:32] we're sick of dealing with this,
[13:34] and this guy's probably bad news.
[13:37] So before this guy winds up getting sued,
[13:40] and we're left having to,
[13:44] you know,
[13:46] commit resources to respond to temporary restraining orders,
[13:49] or plume injunctions,
[13:50] or devolved judgment turnovers,
[13:52] or whatever discovery requests for it.
[13:54] Before we have to worry about that,
[13:56] we're just going to shut this guy down.
[13:58] Maybe one notice, maybe two notices,
[14:01] but this particular storefront is getting hammered every week
[14:04] with something.
[14:05] They're clearly
just selling infringing stuff.
[14:07] They're bad actors.
[14:08] It makes the platform look bad,
[14:10] so we're just going to shut them down.
[14:12] Okay.
[14:13] It's not a legal issue if, you know,
[14:15] nobody's entitled to sell their products at a particular platform.
[14:19] Like you agree to the platforms terms of service.
[14:22] If you abide by them,
[14:24] ostensibly they will allow you to sell there.
[14:28] And then they're going to,
[14:30] they're going to reserve the,
[14:32] the right to decide if they don't want you to sell there anymore.
[14:35] And then they can kick you off.
[14:37] Now is that, you know,
[14:39] the end of your business?
[14:40] No.
[14:41] You can just sell some other way.
[14:43] The real, the practical risk, though,
[14:45] is if we're talking about Amazon,
[14:47] Amazon, for example, you know,
[14:49] they have payment accounts that are associated with the platform
[14:52] that they can decide to just freeze those.
[14:56] They will, you know,
[14:58] so if you're,
[14:59] you could be selling a hundred different products.
[15:01] If there's, you know,
[15:02] maybe one product is getting the seller in trouble.
[15:05] If that leads to a store deactivation,
[15:09] and you can appeal it,
[15:11] you know, there's an appeal process with Amazon,
[15:13] but say it just goes into a black hole.
[15:15] Like, a lot of things do.
[15:17] And they just decide to shut the store down
[15:20] and then, you know,
[15:21] the terms of service are ostensibly allowing them
[15:25] to just take the money that's there
[15:28] for perceived reputational injury, basically,
[15:33] and, you know, damages,
[15:35] sort of a liquid,
[15:36] but they, they will qualify it as a liquidated damages provision,
[15:39] which is something that's arbitrated
[15:44] in binding fashion every single day.
[15:48] And that's,
[15:50] that's the practical reality.
[15:50] It's not, you know,
[15:52] if you're not getting sued,
[15:52] it's just the store foot
[15:54] that had all of your money decided to just make it.
[15:56] And then,
[15:58] if the platform like Amazon has a binding arbitration provision,
[16:00] it isn't something you're going to be able
[16:02] to run the court for.
[16:04] So you're stuck in a,
[16:06] you know, alternative dispute resolution situation,
[16:08] which is still expensive,
[16:12] you know, generally,
[16:12] you're still spending thousands of dollars to open the,
[16:14] you know,
[16:16] if any,
[16:16] like the 80 or filing fees will depend on the size of the claim
[16:20] and things,
[16:20] but you're still spending money,
[16:22] you're still engaging with counsel to do it.
[16:24] And, you know,
[16:26] your fate is going to be left in the hands of an arbitrator,
[16:30] which isn't a judge.
[16:33] You know,
[16:34] the Federal Reserve procedure
[16:36] aren't going to apply exactly,
[16:38] and it's going to be a more casual,
[16:41] but often when you have very fact-intensive,
[16:45] a particular argument to raise,
[16:47] sometimes it's difficult
[16:49] for those to get traction.
[16:52] So, yeah, it's not illegal outcome.
[16:56] It's just a practical advantage potentially.
[16:58] You might just like lose everything,
[17:00] because the platform decides it doesn't match you on there anymore.
[17:03] Yeah, those are things to consider
[17:05] if you're going to be doing that.
[17:07] You know, with the,
[17:08] with the minute or so we have left,
[17:09] you know,
[17:10] Adam,
[17:11] if you could give every e-commerce business one piece
[17:14] of legal advice before launching a product,
[17:16] what would it be?
[17:17] Spend some time with due diligence.
[17:19] If it's a product that you've developed, you know,
[17:22] definitely spent some time on Google patents, for example,
[17:26] even just a step,
[17:27] to see what else is out there,
[17:29] what is live that might pose a problem.
[17:32] From a branding standpoint,
[17:34] you can always just do a Google search for similar names
[17:38] for similar products.
[17:40] It doesn't have to be,
[17:41] and I, you know,
[17:42] problems don't usually don't arise
[17:44] because there's the identical name for the identical type of product.
[17:47] But that's not the test for infringement.
[17:50] If it's creating a likelihood of confusion,
[17:52] that's the,
[17:53] that's the,
[17:54] going to be the general test for a trademark infringement claim.
[17:57] And it doesn't have to be identical.
[17:59] It can be just similar,
[18:00] but similar marks,
[18:01] similar products,
[18:02] that, that's often enough.
[18:04] Yeah.
[18:05] And then obviously don't just take things you find on the internet.
[18:09] That's,
[18:11] you know, step zero.
[18:12] Don't just take things you find online,
[18:14] and repurpose them for your own commercial purposes.
[18:16] That's awesome.
[18:17] Well, thanks, Adam.
[18:18] We're out of time for this episode.
[18:20] But as always,
[18:21] thanks for sharing your expertise.
[18:23] And I look forward to connecting on a future episode
[18:27] of the e-commerce IP report.
[18:29] By the way,
[18:30] that's it for this episode of the e-commerce IP report.
[18:33] Thanks for tuning in.
[18:34] If you want to learn more about Adam
[18:36] and his practice,
[18:37] visit the website AU-LLC.com.
[18:41] As always,
[18:42] we appreciate you listening.
[18:43] And if you like what you heard,
[18:44] leave us a review,
[18:45] subscribe.
[18:46] So you don't miss an episode,
[18:47] or share a link,
[18:49] and or share a link to the episode
[18:51] with someone out there in your world
[18:53] who's doing business
[18:55] and deals with trademarks
[18:57] and potential infringement thereof.
[18:59] I'm Sean O'Connor.
[19:00] Have a great day.