תעתיק 🔗
Shepherd Press: You can have that gratitude because God gave you the ability to have it. He allows you to see his beauty. He allows you to taste a part of this world. He allows you to hear things in this world. That's from the Lord. God is the one that has created us to be relational. So you can be grateful for your friends and family in exploration. That's a gift of God. Welcome to the Shepherd Press Podcast, where we talk with authors who write from the heart and point us to the grace of the gospel for transformed living. I'm your host, Shannon K. McCoy, and today we are talking about gratitude. Our guest is Dr. Carl Hargrove, author of A Thankful Journey Meditations on the Psalms. That's very easy to say, look at me, I'm grateful for, look at my home, look at my career. I'm achieving my goals. Look at my family. Okay. So do you still have a list when you come home and your wife is packed up and taking the kids for no reason? Do you still have a list when they say, even if it's an excellent job, the economy is hard. We're cutting back 40%. And I'm sorry, you're part of that 40. What's your list now? I mean, what's your list when you come back from the doctor? And he says, Mm. Come here, let me let me talk with you a little bit. Here are your options. And none of ⁓ are promising. Th then where's your list? Yeah, the the list has to go beyond that. No, I'm not saying that as a Christian. I'm thankful for my health. I'm thankful that I can go on these walks. I'm thankful that I can still go hiking and do things like that. I'm thankful for that. I'm thankful for my family. Last weekend my one of my sons is married with the family was here and the grandkids and Ito it was raining all day on yeah, it was all day on s Monday. So he literally was in his pajamas the whole time. Cause we normally would go out and f look for lizards in in the backyard, but there was no looking for lizards this time. And I enjoyed it. I could say, wow, I'm thankful for my family, but what if they weren't there? Yeah, what's my list then? And this is why the psalmist is often his list is ⁓ when I think about your works. ⁓ when I think about your ways. ⁓ and I think about who you are. Now that with the other things, sure, I can write down thankful family. I was telling someone this Christmas because my kids, I had two that were in the military and they were in different places in the world at times, and one's on the East Coast and one's here. And I said, Wow, it's gonna be the first time in eight years that we've all been together. Was I did I have gratitude for that? Sure I did. Absolutely I did. So we we can enjoy life and in the things of life and the people of life. God has made us as relational creatures. And He's given us even smell and touch and taste. So I'm thankful I was talking with some students on the patio at the Master Seminary. Three of them are from India and they're studying here. And I was telling them how much I love Indian food. And initially they didn't
Load full transcript
they think, ⁓ you're just saying it to be kind. And I showed them pictures, of course, from Indian restaurants. And they're like, wow, you really do like it. So now we have a ⁓ in a couple of weeks we're gonna go out and we found ⁓ a buffet where we're all going to go. I'll be thankful for that. I'll be thankful for these taste buds ⁓ when I eat that chicken masala. So enjoy all the things that God has given you. So don't even don't allow, say, for instance, the Oprah's of the world to say, well, that's gratitude. No. That's gr you can have that gratitude because God gave you the ability to have it. He allows you to see his beauty. He allows you to taste a part of this world. He allows you to hear things in this world. That's from the Lord. God is the one that has created us to be relational. So you can. Be grateful for your friends and family in exploration. That's a gift of God. That's interesting you say that, that it is a gift of God and God has given us the ability to be thankful. Scripture repeatedly commands us to give thanks and sometimes gratitude doesn't seem to come naturally, which makes sense in what you just said. So if gratitude is commanded in scripture, does that mean it's a discipline before it becomes a feeling? Yeah, and I think all things are we discipline ourselves for action. And Peter, like in chapter four, talks about being of sober mind and sound judgment for the purpose of prayer in view of the latter times. That's interesting. I f what is that? First Peter four and seven. So discipline is involved. Paul talks about beating his body, making it subject. Right? He he uses the analogy of what? The athlete and the farmer. And the boxer. That those are all disciplines. Some people are waiting for this moment to happen for them. And you discipline yourselves. Like I teach a course at the seminary on prayer, and they're required to pray a certain amount of time per day. And it's so you have to develop the discipline. And we were talking even Wednesday in class, you know, and Calvin just succinctly said. That one has to plan for prayer or it mil it will not happen. Because I think everybody wants to think they can have a prayer life that just flows. I think that's an element of it, but you also plan for prayer as well. I'm I need to pr plan, discipline myself to be thankful. And that's where you have to talk to your soul. And so when the s Psalmist says, Why are you downcast? Perhaps we could substitute, why are you ungrateful, O my soul? Yeah, put your gratitude in God. ⁓ that's right. So it could mean things like, Okay, if I I want to develop thankfulness, I'm gonna read these psalms every day. I'm gonna list and I in one of my devotions I talk about if we could be like the psalmist and list all of his deeds and I make a point, the ones that we know, but they're also the actions of God in his providence we didn't even know he was intervening. And he provided for us and helped us and protected us. If we included all of those,
wow. So I think it is good to write down, I am thankful for. I am thankful for. And put it on a post it. Listen to music that reminds you of God's thankfulness. Worshipful songs that remind you of his thankfulness. Memorize scriptures that are thankful scriptures, if you will. One Thing that I like, I found it a while ago on YouTube called Bible Scapes. The gentleman that puts together ⁓ just verses and he goes over these wonderful scenes everywhere, and he's just reciting the scriptures, and ⁓ it's it's beautiful. And he has one that's literally he has one on the peace of God, even forgiveness, some about perseverance, rest, love. And he has one, it's just thankfulness. So I think people to develop it, let me do something like that. I'm just gonna listen to these verses on thankfulness over and over again. And the because the scripture tells us what to be renewed in the spirit of our mind. So that means if I'm not thankful, my mind has to be renewed. And what's the way that I can renew it is place in it right thoughts. So I can push the the other thoughts back and bring the others to the forefront. Okay, that's that's making me think of ⁓ a little bit earlier we talked about disciplining yourself and that think makes me think of like training. So like in our humanness, you know, we're tempted not to be grateful, right? It's like in our humanness, the temptation is to be discontented because we feel crappy, right? It's like the how how do you feel? So can the Psalms train us? To feel rightly by teaching us what to think rightly? ⁓ sure, they do, because they journey with us. ⁓ we enter the journey of the psalmist. Where was he? That's I've been there before. How did he get out of that? Let me travel with him and follow it. So those these are roadmaps, and that's why even the title is a thankful journey. It is a journey. And you'll notice that first the the cover picture which turned out very well. That's another picture I took when I was in ⁓ on Kiowa Island in South Carolina. And I love going to the beach there. And there's this just this walkway that was there. And I I just took that picture thinking that says so much right there. Because at the end of it there is this vast ocean. But yet the path to it was only like this. But then once I got to the end of the path, it opened up this vast beach and this vast ocean and it's a journey for us. And the Lord is saying, every resource that you need, it's readily available to you. I love it. I love it. but after walking through all the one hundred and fifty Psalms, what insights have you gleaned from the connection between suffering and gratitude? Hmm. I look at it a couple of different ways. I think. I would say the connection of suffering and gratitude is that ultimately the s the psalmist will resolve himself to be grateful in his suffering. And again, I say eventually. So I I realize that suffering takes on different looks, it takes on a different amount of time, you know, of that we experience suffering itself. So he will eventually resolve That he can be grateful in the midst of his suffering and even at times for his suffering. Think about this. The psalmist in 119, notice what he says. He says, I have wandered off like a lost sheep. Search for your servant, for I have not forgotten your commandments. That's 76. But also the psalmist says, What? He talks about his affliction. But his affliction was good because then he learns God's word. So there's a connection between affliction humbling us. And then when we're humbled, we realize that we're not sufficient in ourselves and we need something more than ourselves. And then it brings us back. And for that we can be grateful. Thank you, Lord, that I see my shortcomings. I'm so thankful for that. I thought too much of myself. But you as an all wise God, what did you do? You revealed it. So that's another connection with gratitude and suffering. The other is this, but let me it's true in the Old Testament, but I'll go briefly to the New Testament in Second Corinthians one, the God of all comfort, and he comforts us in affliction so that we will be able to comfort others. And we see that in the psalmist as well, as he experienced heartache and pain and difficulty, especially with David. What happened with David as he went through the episode with especially with Saul, this galvanized his faith. So as he saw God's faithfulness with Saul, he was a better leader to other people. And I think whenever we go through suffering, there's a sense of in Christ God becomes sweeter to us. Because especially if we find ourselves alone, what other person is there? know, in the Psalms, but also in Isaiah, he talks about, you know, if mother and father forsake you, but I I would never do that. Not the most intimate of relationships, they may forsake you, but I never will. And that's the thought that we have of Jesus Christ in Hebrews, right? I would never leave you or forsake you. Lo, I'm with you to the end of the ages. So the psalmist do that for us. This sense of hope that they have. And that they're better people because they were afflicted, because they were hurt. So if I'm a better person, I can be I can show gratitude. If I'm gonna help others, I can show gratitude. ⁓ my college, you know, like football days, I remember running the stadium steps at University of Cincinnati. I remember sprints even to this day, painful. And all the coach did was blow the whistle. We had to run. Yeah, you're huffing and puffing and blowing and you lifted weights and you did all of these things, but you knew it was for your teammate, so you could be ready. And God takes us through moments in life that are hard, then it's for your teammate. He'll use you in those moments. Because there are moments in life things that I've been through I can actually say to a person, I understand. So I can have empathy. Let's for a moment distinguish empathy and sympathy. So empathy, you know, I've I've been there, I can I can identify.
In sympathy, I haven't been there, but my heart goes out to you. And we experience both with people. And so in the psalmist, you look at it and say, Well, I identify with that. These truths that help the psalmist can help me. And he was on a journey. And I'm on a journey. And the word of God will get us through that journey. That's that's a roadmap. We go back to the psalmist. What did they say? Your word is a lamp. It's a light to my feet. It guides me on my journey. And so that those are my thoughts on that. Well, ⁓ speaking of that, can you share a personal example where the psalms help you root your gratitude and who God is, even when your circumstances were difficult? Yeah, and really, and that's why Psalm twenty seven is so important to me, because in verses one to three you see the compelling difficulties that the psalmist faces. And what's interesting that in verse four, because he's talked about if enemies and detractors and if war even comes against me, I'm gonna trust the Lord. But then he says in verse four, one thing I've asked. And initially y you may think, okay, one thing I want, wipe out my enemies. No, that's not the one thing he wanted. He just said, I want to be in the house of the Lord again. Now some of that may have required his enemies being addressed, but the his main thought, I want to be in the house of the Lord, I want to have unencumbered worship, and I want to behold your beauty. So me years ago coming across that psalm and then teaching it and diving in and asking what is beauty? What is behold? Just that word behold is very rich in the Hebrew language. I have some notes in the book on it. So that helped me realize that when everything around me may seem like it's coming against me, I have to have one objective. Let me behold the beauty of of the Lord. And I have to gaze upon it. It's it's not a glance. We live life like this, right? It's boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. And we get glances of things. And he's saying, No, you need to gaze. In one older lexic Hebrew lexicon, it talks about having a chained gaze. And think about that, we don't say that often. A chain why did it say in it chained gaze? I mean really you are chained down and you're gazing. That's what it says. You're fixed on it's what he's saying. So let me fix on the Lord. You say, wait a minute, but what about everything around you? Yeah, that's true. But if I'm fixed on the Lord, if he's for me, who can be against me? Yeah, you gotta you got a quote in in the in the at the beginning of the book that says the resting place for the child of God is the reality that God is incapable of failure and unable to break any promise uttered through his revelation. This must be a reason to live a life of thanksgiving before a world desperately searching for satisfaction and hope amid a landfill of incomplete solutions. When you say, Be thankful because God is worthy and accept the reality and responsibility that those around you need your example. Let the world know that our great God and Savior floods our lives with reasons to live thankfully. That's very powerful. ⁓ Part about they need you to be that light. And Christ said we're light on the hill with the salt of the earth. So we know the world needs answers. Paul says we we are lights in the world in the midst of a perverse and crooked generation. So they're looking in all the other places. So if they see believers that are handling life the same way they are, what's the difference? So we have a responsibility to our neighbors to be thankful people. How many times have you heard a testimony of someone that unbelievers look at them and say, How did wait a minute, your spouse died and you you're dealing with it this way? I I know that you've been you're sad, but you you don't you're not mad at God, you're not mad at the other person, you're not mad here, you don't have bitterness. What's different about you? A dear member of our church. ⁓ and it's public information and there's a memorial service it's actually this Saturday for little Claire. ⁓ had a very unique disease and initially the secular world says, Well, you should just abort. ⁓ she she just if she even makes it through childbirth, then she definitely It'll be mo if she makes it through the birthing process within hours, minutes, she'll die. So the husband and wife, they made a decision to go full term. And they knew you could see how she was not developing. But she gave birth to that child. And they were thinking they had a had named her. ⁓ and then she had they had thirty nine minutes with her. Thirty nine minutes of thankfulness. You say, wait a minute, how can that be? Yeah, thirty nine minutes. We're so thankful. We had thirty-nine minutes with her. And so a number of us prayed that she would make it through the birthing process, and she did. And they had thirty-nine minutes together to be thankful. And so that example, trust me, and people that know about it in our church, how did you do that? Because of God and who He is. Yeah. Often say that's the difference Christ makes. Like again, in the counseling room, I, you know, it's like w we go through different things like what you just described, or divorce, or something tragic, and you have an unbeliever going through, you have a believer going through. And the question is, you know, we we often respond like unbelievers until we realize like what what difference does Christ make in our lives? There should be a difference. And what you just described is the difference that Christ makes, that we can be. Thankful for the thirty-nine minutes instead of being angry for you know for a lifetime. Correct. And and people do that. Then they're anger for a lifetime, and now their life is devoid of gratitude. And you cannot live life devoid of gratitude. That is a sorrowful life. It's not really even life at all. And sometimes this is what happens. There's a personal offense against someone, and so they believe that somehow they're gonna hurt
that other person by Holding on. And that person has moved on in life often. And there you are with a thankless life. And now it becomes a miserable life because of that. Yeah, it makes me think of forgiveness and unforgiveness. Okay, so let's let's dig in for a little bit in terms of of the daily pages of the devotional. And I want to reach another quote because this is relevant. You will quickly notice that every thought begins. With a call to be thankful. I took this approach to counter the grumbling one that is so often seen in social media forums. This was particularly true during the COVID restrictions. I wanted to help those who saw my post that start their day with a heart of gratitude to counter the atmosphere of that period. I also wanted to help them cultivate such an attitude throughout their spiritual journey. Mind you, it is not as if social media has turned a corner. and become a place to nurture thankfulness and contentment. It is so often the opposite if one allows it. Many inspiring posts and insights tend to be lost in the day's more tantalizing clickbait stories. Okay, so six years later, I mean this is so okay, what are your thoughts on how relevant your purpose for this devotional is today? Yeah, it's not COVID, but we're we're still we're always facing something. Yeah, we're always facing something. And now you go to social media and people are forever talking about what's wrong with society. What's wrong with that party? What's wrong with that party? There's a lack of thankfulness and a lack of contentment. And when you don't have thankfulness, it it means ultimately you're not content. Then if you're not content, that's an indictment against God. So we It's still relevant. No, we're past COVID. At least ⁓ the vast majority of people are past COVID. I still see some that seem like they're still lingering in it. Yeah. And and the powers that be trying to bring it something back. They want to bring it back. But no but social media's still the same. People respond to bad news more than good news. That's just the reality. And that's why people purposely their first line or two is to get you into something. And I was trying to get people into be thankful. If you don't want to be thankful, move on to, you know, did you hear such and such again? Or whatever it was. Right. Yeah, all all you know, the world is gonna end in about twenty four hours, whatever it may be. But you have to make a choice again to be thankful. So it's true in society today. ⁓ it hasn't really gotten better. ⁓ it's going to get worse. Because the Bible tells us that we're on that path. That's our journey. That's the journey of this world. That's the journey of this world. So we have to then ⁓ adjust our expectation. Yeah. So adjust your expectations about the world and what you can receive from it and how it will respond to you. That is so powerful. That's another book, Dr. Hargrove. Adjusting your expectations is very true. It is true and I I do mention that a lot ⁓ about adjusting your expectations. I think we can have them, but the question is what are they and what's the basis of them? And especially the basis is once your expectations aren't met, the prime thing is how will you respond? So i I think it's still a need today. ⁓ we're faced with issues today. And it's not like wow, ⁓ this book is so irrelevant because social media is filled with such joy and happiness and positive thinking. ⁓ who who needs this? No, I don't think so. That's like rapidly, like things are speeding up rapidly, right? So and it feels like in our fast paced digital age, we've lost the discipline of slowing down long enough to notice God's world. ⁓ do you think gratitude grows when we slow down? And what tips can you give us to cultivate a slower pace? And I think the language of even Psalm 27, 4 forces you to think about that because it says, Behold, behold. You have to make a a decision in your day. I pray through my, like in the morning, through my calendar. Like, okay, what am I doing today? And I pray about. you know, meetings that I have and other things like that. So all of us have a calendar somewhere. And you need to put in that calendar a moment to be still. Stillness is good. I mean I'm in Southern California. The only thing that's really still here is the traffic, right? Like a snail. Like a snail. You can like eat lunch, you can do all kinda things. ⁓ But we run it at such a fast pace. So you have to put it in your calendar to slow down. And here's another thing. You need to find a place of solace, some quiet place. Wherever it is. Me, obviously I like getting out if I can and exploring and I'm away from things. I I like that. So in your calendar, find you a place where you can slow down. And then here it is. You need to find some other friends. Who have the same desire, and you make a pack with one another. Let's keep each other accountable to slow down in life enough to behold. So Oprah Header, Gratitude Club, and Book Club. Create your own spiritual club of stillness and beholding is what you need to do. Friends, you can get together and say, Hey, what did you discover this week? Even if it's even if it's in text message, a text message group, do it. People that you may know in the other part of the world, put it in WhatsApp so you you can do it and don't incur fees and that sort of thing. Do it. Be innovative when it comes to this. I take pictures, personally, I take pictures so I can reflect and go back and look. ⁓ yes, I remember that. Why is it important to remember? If you look at the Bible in the old testament, The number of times where God says, Remember, remember, remember, remember, remember. And this is why it begins in Deuteronomy, and he says, Remember this and remember this and remember this. And then throughout scripture, he talks about remembering. And the basic reason for that is that we tend to forget. That's right, you're distracted. So you need pointers that will bring you back and
remember God's fateful moment. Remember a place where you were and you beheld the beauty of God. So a way to keep your create your own archives, if you will, is what people need to do to slow down in life. And here is the other thing. You you have to look at your life and ask what's most important. Like I just made a decision, a practical decision. I didn't teach as much in the seminary this semester because I felt like I needed to invest more time with our church. That's me slowing down a little bit. And sometimes you have you have to make real life decisions to slow down. I just met a friend who's very capable, but he's getting married soon. And I asked him, I said, So what are you going to do to change your life? And he he's made decisions. He has to prioritize because he's now entering into marriage. He can't live at the same pace. And ⁓ so we need to make those decisions. In life. Those are some things I think about. It helps me slow down. Can you see this? I don't know if you can. I can. This is ⁓ scripture writing that I've done. So this helps me slow down. This is okay. Whole book scripture writing where I mean I just take a book of the Bible and start writing. You know, like I if I'm I'm right now I'm looking at one of my favorite Psalms, it's Psalm seventy well, one nineteen. And it says, May your loving kindnesses also come to me. Write it down. May your loving kindness because that helps me to slow down. It stops my brain right now, you know, with social media and and stroll scrolling on and our s on our phones, that has trained our brains just to scan things and down and and comprehend. But scripture writing for me. It gets me in the word, it gets me reading, it gets me, you know, writing and thinking about what I'm writing. It becomes devotional. So that's one practice. ⁓ I love the practice of, you know, getting a group of people and texting and stuff like that. That that can happen, but I know people are so busy. ⁓ but what can you do by yourself between you and the Lord? Take a moment in the morning and just write a couple of scripture verses down like whole book. I mean, it's it's just very powerful. Wa one thing I asked my students to do three weeks ago in class, each one of them I said, Go and write your own psalm. ⁓ I think all of us should from time to time write our own psalm out. And maybe based on what we're facing in life that psalm will be different. Yeah, and there are a lot of good ⁓ biblical counseling books coming out on lament. It's like you can go and write your own lament and there's structure to it and lament ends in thankfulness to God, really, and trusting God. So Yeah, there's so many resources out there for us. But for someone listening who feels spiritually dry, overwhelmed, distracted, ⁓ you've given us some good pointers, but what else would you say? Is it really as simple and as profound as opening songs daily and responding honestly? That's surely ⁓ foundational because we ask ourselves, what are the what are the means of grace? Well, the the word of God, prayer, fellowship. Communion with God and communion with his people. So if these are means and I don't avail myself of it, then I why am I expecting significant change? But to just read, apart from vulnerability, I'm gonna throw up put some words here vulnerability, honesty, and consistency. Because if one has been, you know, ungrateful. A song may not be the breakout for them. It's gonna mean I I've been in this pattern for a while. I need to peel back some layers in my mind and I need to renew the mind. And that may take me a while to do that, but I'm so committed to it. Consistency is the key. And that's why even at times I tell people that aren't praying as much, start with something that's very manageable, but be consistent. Don't try to be a Martin Luther. right away. Don't try to be a George Mueller right away. Just be consistent in your time with the Lord. And ⁓ here's another thing one has to do. You have to avoid having competing affections. Now what I mean by that obviously that could be another thing. It could be a number of things people, ⁓ prestige, career. But I'm just going to talk about social media and entertainment. I just did a lecture about fasting and prayer and I said that when you're fasting and praying, you entertainment should have should be a part of that fast. You don't just pray, give up food, and watch two football games. That's ridiculous. That's another book, Doctor Hargrove. Fasting. No, I am I am writing one on prayer. And fasting. And and that'll be a chapter. That'll absolutely be a chapter 'cause it's a bit confusing to people on the issue of fasting and prayer. It means that I have to place myself in that fountain is what I must do. I have to be at that fountain. I have to drink from that fountain. And I have to drink consistently from it. Because the thirsty soul like here in California, Southern California is an irrigated desert. You get to Central Coast and above, ⁓ wow. Okay, that's natural. Here, like right now I'm looking out my window, I see these green hilltops and come June, it's all brown. That's what's going to happen. And so it takes a lot sometimes when we go through these dry spells here in California to say we're back to our proper levels. So a person's spiritually if in their journey they've had this dry period of time, then it may take it's gonna take a lot to get them back where they should be. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. So don't say, Okay, I've been at this for a while. I don't feel a breakthrough. Keep fighting for it. So we we read the word of God. We we write down our thoughts about what God is teaching us. We spend time with the living God. We surround ourselves with people who are wanting to to follow the same journey that you're on. And you can stimulate one another to love and good deeds. And I believe when one does that. Your promise that you will grow in the grace and knowledge of Christ. That's a promise. That is a promise. And
⁓ I'm thinking about I think it's Philippians four, be anxious for nothing but in everything with thanksgiving. ⁓ and I with that verse, it just puts me in the mind of when you said you said keep fighting for it. Is ⁓ to me sometimes thankfulness, gratitude can be like a spiritual weapon, you know, like in the spiritual warfare that we're in. Because when you fight for that, ⁓ it's It's a spiritual fight. When you're in the midst of an unhappy situation, it you know, it it's it's ⁓ it's a power actually that takes you out of discontentment into contentment. ⁓ sure it is. And you know, and Paul when he wrote to the church at Colossae, he talks about the word of God richly dwelling within you in chapter three. And what's interesting about when he talks about that, he is looking at it corporately, I believe. He's saying, in the midst of the whole body. When you sing these songs, the word of God dwells within you and it helps the body of Christ. And that sense of thankfulness that you see so often in scripture that is a sort of a it's a it's an exclamation point. Because it's with Thanksgiving, in Thanksgiving. And that's an attitude we must have because what was I before? I was in utter darkness. How can I not be thankful? This is why Paul in 2 Corinthians talks about the love of Christ controls him. Christ's great love controls him. Why is Paul willing to live the way he's willing to live? Why why is he willing to risk his life? Why is he really why is he ready to go into danger? Look at this great love that he has for me. How can I not be thankful? And I'll say this at some point. Well, I just say even immediately. To not have gratitude is sinful. Whoa, you use the S word. Because the question is if we're if we're commanded to be thankful and we're not thankful, it doesn't take rocket science to figure that one out. You're in disobedience. And sometimes a person may be in prolonged disobedience. But here is the thing about it, here is the great joy of it all. He is so patient with us. He's so patient. And then when we come out of this period of a person comes out of not being thankful, they should surely be thankful. ⁓ my, he was so patient. He did not give up on me. I'm preaching through right now Isaiah, and I'm in 49 right now. And especially starting in chapter 40, you see God says to to Judah, proclaim to Judah, comfort or comfort my people. Like comfort them? Why? They committed covenant treachery. They didn't learn from their northern brothers who were taken away by the Assyrians. They had over a hundred years to r to learn a lesson and they didn't. So the Babylonians take them away. But God says, What? No, these are my people. And I still love them. And I have a covenant with them. And I'm going to be faithful to them. And we are in covenant with the living God. And he will see us through. He will. ⁓ we've covered so much down to the sinfulness of being ungrateful, which requires repentance. So in in closing, if you could leave our listeners with one pastoral encouragement about gratitude, what would that be? I would say this. Let me use an illustration as a father. And I do something for one of my kids and now my grandkids. And when they said dad, I'm so thankful. My s grandson now he's five, almost five here. And you thank you, thank you, granddad. My little granddaughter, she's not there yet, she's only one. There's just something about hearing your loved ones say, I'm grateful for what you've done. Or I'm grateful what you've done for us. I'm grateful that you helped us. I'm grateful that you've counseled with us. I'm grateful that you provided for us. So that brings a smile to my face. And so I would say to our listeners, when you're thankful, your Heavenly Father, this praises and that's an act of worship to your Heavenly Father. You're saying, Father, I have gratitude for what you've done and who you are. So thankfulness is worship. Wow. Thankfulness is worship. Dr. Hargrove, thank you for shepherding our hearts today and for reminding us that. Gratitude is not just a response to good days, it is a way of walking with God through every day. Friends, thank you for joining us. And if a thankful journey meditation on the songs touched your heart in this conversation, we invite you to visit us at shepherdpress.com. Thank you for listening. If this episode has been helpful to you, please share it with a friend, leave a rating and a review. And for more resources, visit us at shepherdpress.com. I close with this reminder from Romans 15, 13. May the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, so that by the power of the Holy Spirit you may abound in hope. Until next time, keep walking in truth and keep your eyes on Jesus.