תעתיק 🔗
00:00:03
Speaker 1: This is Outsiders.
00:00:08
Speaker 2: Good morning and welcome to Outsiders, the show that believes we should welcome our American cousins to these shores to play football with us with a proud display of classic Aussie larrikin land down under, Vegemite sheilas, you little ripper shulby apples, sporting culture like this.
00:00:28
Speaker 3: And to you, we pay our respects to your culture and heritage and those watching at home.
00:00:37
Speaker 4: Yes, that was from the first ever NFL game in Melbourne.
00:00:42
Speaker 5: Or was it Melbourne?
00:00:46
Speaker 3: We also thank the National Football League for bringing the San Francisco 49ers and the Los Angeles Jams to NAMM.
00:00:59
Speaker 6: Yes, my fellow Americans may have thought that they were playing in Melbourne, but no, no, no, no, no. Turns out the game was moved to a place none of them had ever heard of called Nam, which, if you say it to most Americans, well, I don't know, maybe it means Vietnam. But anyway....
00:01:17
Speaker 3: We are known as the Manigal people and I'll take this leaf on our behalf, on behalf of our community the Wurundjeri Wurrung and our neighbouring islands. Accepting this gift means that you are welcome to everything from the tops of the trees to the roots of the earth.
00:01:41
Speaker 6: No, no, stop it, stop it.
00:01:43
Speaker 7: Cut, cut, cut.
00:01:44
Speaker 2: That'll do, thanks, technicians. That'll do. We can't have any more of that. And while we wait for the NFL to brush up on the landslide victory for the no side of the voice referendum, even in Victoria, let's grab the latest outside news. So, Risa, the NFL... Yes. That well-known sporting code from America.
00:02:10
Speaker 5: It's enormously well-known, in fact.
00:02:12
Speaker 2: Not to be confused.
00:02:14
Speaker 4: So much so that people don't call it the American NFL, they just call it the NFL.
00:02:18
Speaker 2: Huge.
00:02:19
Speaker 4: I was there Friday. Such a resounding success. They did such a good job of putting it on. The NFL took over. I've never seen the MCG operate in that manner. They had these barricades set up around the ground to enter all sorts of new rules.
00:02:36
Speaker 5: They brought everybody.
00:02:37
Speaker 4: They brought everyone from their cheerleaders.
00:02:40
Speaker 5: To their musicians.
00:02:42
Speaker 4: So the whole production was an enormous success. But so much of the commentary and focus in America was what happened at the start with that welcome to country. And they are shook. They cannot believe this is happening. what the NFL has brought. But that's not the NFL. That's the Victorian government. That's the Victorian government portion of proceedings. And I've seen commentary from everyone from Fox News commentators to sportscasters, regular sports fans watching in America going, what is going on in Australia?
00:03:18
Speaker 5: Just how crazy.
00:03:20
Speaker 4: Have they become that they consider this normal?
00:03:24
Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah, exactly. The American commentary, James, you would have seen a lot of it, but they were going, what is this?
00:03:29
Speaker 6: But the one.
00:03:30
Speaker 2: I just want to play you this one. This was Clay Travis, and after having a go at, you know, what is going on in Australia, he talked about COVID with the authoritarianism, he talked about the NAM nonsense down at the NFL game, and he was saying, what is going on in Australia? And then he played... He said this comment. Now, have a listen to this, particularly in light of when we had Mike Newman on recently, saying that he would take the Aboriginal flag... off the Sydney Harbour Bridge. Listen to Clay Travis talking about having climbed to the top of the Sydney Harbour Bridge.
00:04:00
Speaker 8: You can climb the Sydney Bridge.
00:04:02
Speaker 2: Awesome.
00:04:02
Speaker 8: Get up at the very apex of the Sydney Bridge. This view out is majestic. The first thing that they say when you're touring the Sydney Bridge is that you should understand that you are standing on stolen land and that all of the land you see was stolen. On this majestic, incredible edifice that has been built to connect the two different parts of Sydney, the first thing you want to say is that it's stolen land?
00:04:34
Speaker 2: Now, James, I mean, I was appalled to hear that. I mean, the flag's bad enough, but they are telling every visitor, every school kid, every tourist that goes up and down that bridge all day long, whoever's running that show, they should be absolutely ashamed of themselves, and whoever's running those tours, they should be thrown, you know... Not thrown off a bridge, but thrown out of their job. Because, seriously, how can you have this on our most iconic structure, built out of the colonial enterprise that is Australia... this amazing structure, one of the structures of the world, seven wonders of the world, and we're standing there. We've got a guide at the top of the bridge telling them that all the beauty of Sydney is stolen land. This is a disgrace. And whoever's running that Harbour Bridge show, you should be utterly ashamed of yourselves.
00:05:19
Speaker 6: Who built the bridge, Rowan?
00:05:19
Speaker 7: It's a disgrace.
00:05:20
Speaker 6: Who built the bridge? Bradfield.
00:05:21
Speaker 2: Was the bridge there previously? Well, exactly.
00:05:23
Speaker 5: Because if you're standing on a stolen bridge.
00:05:27
Speaker 6: This is basically dark emu taken to its absolutely logical conclusion here. Oh, you know, there was this whole sort of civilization here, there were bridges, all sorts of things, but apparently the white man stole them. Well, you know, I'm sorry, you can have perfectly good respect for Aboriginal culture, but say, you know, what has been achieved here in Sydney, you know, the most marvellous, beautiful city, there's not another city with a harbour as gorgeous as what we have here today. in Sydney. And you see that this beautiful
Load full transcript
Sydney with its beautiful architecture, which our irresponsible state government is being allowed to be knocked over for horrible high rises and things like that. That's another story. But, you know, this is a real achievement. This is an achievement of our civilization. We are proud of it. There's nothing wrong with it. But I can tell you something else. This stuff here, this this is stolen land thing. You know, it's not just on the bridge tours where allegedly they're getting it. It's like everywhere. Every single friend of mine who has preschool-aged children tells me that their two-, three-year-old kids come back from childcare and say the white man stole the land from the Aboriginal and that they are pumped with this. So this is this sort of self-loathing that runs through this entire culture. And I don't think, you know, we pay enough attention to that. We pay a lot of attention to it, but I think the country..... but the country has allowed itself to drift. I agree. And because we've been allowed to drift and let these other guys take over the narrative, that's why the culture wars are important. We've spoken about this show for years.
00:07:01
Speaker 5: The left know that culture wars are important.
00:07:04
Speaker 4: All the left do is relentlessly push their culture wars And then they cry culture war as soon as there's any resistance and say, well, that's a culture war issue, as if that's not what they're doing all along. And this is why the Liberals are in so much grief, because they allowed this. They were too scared to fight the culture wars. Scott Morrison said there's no jobs in the culture wars. They've decided it's much safer to talk about economic issues and completely leave that field to the so-called progressives who have now desensitised much of the population to what we just saw there.
00:07:46
Speaker 5: And when the rest of the world gets a.
00:07:47
Speaker 4: Glimpse of it and they're shocked, I think that becomes a bit of a wake-up call.
00:07:51
Speaker 5: But Australians had their say.
00:07:53
Speaker 4: We had a referendum and the results were absolutely clear. All across the country, with the exception of the ACT, every single state and the Northern Territory clearly said no. We don't want racial division. We don't want an enshrined in the Constitution. And I'm telling you, if there was a referendum on these sorts of ceremonies, the results would be even stronger.
00:08:17
Speaker 2: Absolutely.
00:08:17
Speaker 6: Can I just make a point here?
00:08:19
Speaker 2: Sorry.
00:08:20
Speaker 6: What you make the point there, Rita, is they're relentless. They do not take no for an answer. I know we're going to talk a bit about it later in the show, but there's such a great example of this in this digital duty of care censorship legislation that they're putting. Because remember, the Gillard government tried to censor the press. They made a specific attack on the Murdoch press. Then, you know, they tried the misinformation and disinformation bill. And then that finally fell over, thank God, because it was so totalitarian. They've upped the powers of the e-safety commissioner undemocratically and now having failed both at those other big legislative attempts to destroy the freedom of speech, they're doing it again through digital duty of care, which sounds all lovely, but it's really about... They don't like the fact that populist voices are getting more of a run and that, you know, establishment parties like themselves are getting hurt by that.
00:09:11
Speaker 5: I'm telling you, this is worse than the previous version.
00:09:14
Speaker 2: You're both jumping ahead of yourselves here. I'm going to... I'm going to put control on the show. We're going to be talking about digital... Is the e-roll on?
00:09:22
Speaker 4: In the interest of social cohesion, is this rolling?
00:09:26
Speaker 5: I'm sorry, but.
00:09:26
Speaker 2: We're jumping ahead of ourselves. We're going to be talking at length about the digital duty of care. It's a great and a very important topic. We've got Sarah Henderson. We will be talking about that. But I want to stick on something I thought you were going to say, which was the great example... Well, you didn't let me finish. No, the great example of why talking about stolen land and endlessly doing this is so bad, we're also going to talk about it later in the show in the celebrity section, is Ray Martin, who this week came out and is very upset because there's a Sydney tennis club which now has been taken by, you know, is now owned by an Aboriginal corporation, and they're sticking up a massive high-rise there. So Ray Martin's come out and said, hang on, hang on, this was our tennis club, and now the Aboriginal corporation said, sorry, it's not a tennis club, or something like that. The story is something like that. But we'll talk about it later. But it's a fascinating example of what you were saying about the kind of... dark emufication of Australia, whereby we do have all this, it's Aboriginal land, it's stolen land, we repeat it endlessly and endlessly. That must, I'm not a lawyer, but at some point that becomes sovereign risk, in my opinion, because at some point, if you keep repeating year after year after year that you don't own that land, that somebody else owns that land, there will be a court case, and we're seeing already so many native title examples where land that they promised us would never be under native title... Places like, you know, surf clubs and Bondi Icebergs, I read, was another one, you know, that was going to be subject to this.
00:10:51
Speaker 6: I mean, it's what we've talked about a million times on this program, the blue banded bee. You can own the land, you can know there's gold under it, you're going to get the gold out, pay royalties to the crown for it, but know the blue banded bee, because there's still... And that's the sovereign risk. That's the sovereign risk.
00:11:04
Speaker 2: I
agree, it's sovereign risk, yeah. Now, let's talk about Andrew Hastie. Let's talk about Pauline Hanson. Andrew Hastie was on with Andrew Clennell earlier on. A very good interview, very interesting interview.
00:11:14
Speaker 4: Yes, that was a very interesting interview. Quite a few revelations there. If I was Angus Taylor, I'd be a little bit worried about what he said about his own ambitions and how close to the surface they may or may not be. The analogies used there were pretty fascinating.
00:11:31
Speaker 1: But.
00:11:33
Speaker 5: The Liberals need.
00:11:34
Speaker 4: To be very careful with this fight because I can just see them creating more One Nation voters.
00:11:43
Speaker 5: They are on the wrong path and they need.
00:11:46
Speaker 4: To correct course very quickly because they're already in peril.
00:11:51
Speaker 5: They're already about.
00:11:52
Speaker 4: 10 points behind Liberals. One Nation and Labor in the latest news poll. This is going to set them back further. If they think this is going to bring back those voters they've lost to One Nation, no, that's not going to happen with this.
00:12:07
Speaker 2: Sort of rhetoric. They do think that, and I'll be speaking about this later on in the show, they do think that, James... and the Financial Review have already... Philip Khoury's already written, oh, this is great, there's a proper fight now, the Liberals have got the fight back on. And most, quote from Philip Khoury... Idiotic. Most Liberal MPs are supportive of this.
00:12:26
Speaker 6: Well... James, of course.
00:12:27
Speaker 2: Yeah, because they're desperate.
00:12:28
Speaker 7: Hang on, hang on, hang on.
00:12:29
Speaker 4: They're desperate and they're without a clue and they are floundering. They don't know how to recover from this position, James.
00:12:37
Speaker 6: Well, no, they don't, and here's the problem. Great for the Liberals that they're starting a fight, but they're starting the fight with the wrong side. The only chance the Liberals have right now is to fight the government. Ignore One Nation. Andrew Hastie, I think, everybody sees that this is a very cynical play. Everybody sees that canning his seat in WA is under threat. If he was to roll Angus Taylor and then fight the next election from the seat of Canning, we could have the ignominious record of yet another Liberal leader losing his seat at the coming election, this time not necessarily to Labour, but to One Nation to his right. I think that a lot of people I've spoken to have a few big questions about Andrew Hastie's upset over Pauline Hanson's cartoon, and the number one being, this was published... A month ago, several weeks ago.
00:13:34
Speaker 2: Six weeks ago.
00:13:35
Speaker 6: Six weeks ago. And Andrew Hastie didn't arc up then and say, this is outrageous that I've been called a traitor then. Now, when suddenly it starts to look like a more politically opportune thing to do, I'm sorry, I'm cynical about it, and I just don't think that a confected... I mean, a glass jaw is bad enough, but a confected glass jaw to try and get attention over this, I don't think it's a political winner for him.
00:14:03
Speaker 4: And having the likes of Jackie Lambie in your corner is the biggest own goal you could possibly score.
00:14:10
Speaker 5: I'll be talking about that in Reality.
00:14:13
Speaker 4: Rita's Bradley check after the break. But they are desperate, though, Rowan, and they are scrambling for ideas of how to reassert themselves. So we've had all sorts of policy announcements like jail for those who burn the Australian flag and trying to be more one nation than one nation.
00:14:34
Speaker 5: If that doesn't work, so what do we do?
00:14:37
Speaker 4: Do we try to go over for that centre that Malcolm Turnbull famously thought existed in the Australian election?
00:14:43
Speaker 2: And I'm sorry, you mentioned Malcolm Turnbull. I might be mentioning him as well later on in the show. But, you know, it's so.
00:14:50
Speaker 6: And it's, again, because the Liberals have this allergy to doing any sort of thing with One Nation. You know, a great sort of coalition sort of vague setup would be you let One Nation run the culture stuff, you know, you run the economy stuff, all the economic policies. Everybody is talking about what an absolute disaster the Australian economy is. We are now possibly, if you look at... the bond interest rates at the moment, which are getting very scarily high. We are possibly looking at not one, but two more interest rate hikes. You are looking at Bill Kelty, the former union leader, big man of the left, big man of labor, has come out and said this whole thing where Albanese goes out and crows about falling property prices is a nonsense because, sure, they're going down, but affordability is going down even faster, investor loans down even 26%. First home buyer loans down 30%. We were told, oh, you know, this is how... We just want everybody out there to get a fair quack. We want the young, fresh homebuyers to get a fair quack at the housing market. And, you know, and he does this, and then he looks, and says, there's no buyers at all. The entire housing market has frozen up. And the wealth effect that this is having on the rest of the economy, because so many people, you know, their wealth is tied up in their house, and if they've just had 20% knocked off it, they're not going to be, you know, going out and spending big off of their day-to-day cash flow.
00:16:17
Speaker 2: Well, maybe nobody wants to buy a home on stolen land.
00:16:20
Speaker 6: Oh! That's it. That's it.
00:16:23
Speaker 4: They've gone from, Rowan, claiming that their changes in the budget, the May budget.
00:16:29
Speaker 5: Wouldn't impact prices.
00:16:31
Speaker 6: Yeah. 2%, they said.
00:16:33
Speaker 5: Well, no, yes.
00:16:33
Speaker 4: No, it was going to just slow it down by 2%. There will still be modest growth. They've gone from that to then denying that the market's
crashing and it's now dropped... It's a 40-year... deterioration. We haven't seen drops like this in about 40 years. They've gone from that to now saying, oh, no, no, it is falling, but that's a good thing.
00:16:55
Speaker 5: We acknowledge it's falling. That's what we wanted all along.
00:17:01
Speaker 4: You cannot crash the Australian housing market and pretend it's for the greater good.
00:17:07
Speaker 1: This is.
00:17:09
Speaker 4: Making every Australian who has invested in property, including their own home, poorer. Every single Australian who has a mortgage, that mortgage hasn't gone back in value, their house has.
00:17:20
Speaker 5: It is absolutely the most.
00:17:23
Speaker 4: shameful, economically destructive thing I've seen an Australian government do, to deliberately crash the housing market.
00:17:30
Speaker 6: Well, but not only that, they're also crashing entrepreneurialism. Because, remember, they said, oh, well, you know, we're going to... If they had just said, we're going to change the rules around know cgt for property but uh investment in other things businesses entrepreneurial ventures startups you know that all stays the same you could almost say well they're trying to redirect capital into sort of productive enterprises you know you might not agree with it but you could sort of see this was there's a logic to it what they're doing here though they're attacking achievement enterprise. They're simply saying, and I know a lot of young people who say, well, you know, I've been putting money every fortnight, every month into ETFs, just trying to, you know, invest and so on. And what's the point? Because I'm going to get smashed there as well. It's really crueling the chances of a generation of young people. You see how little planning they did for this, too, by the number of backflips that Jim Chalmers has had to do on trusts, on widows' taxes, because they wrote this legislation, they didn't think about it, they didn't analyse what was in there, they didn't, you know, think about all the consequences, because none of these people have any experience in the private sector.
00:18:44
Speaker 2: That's it.
00:18:45
Speaker 5: That's it.
00:18:45
Speaker 4: And those young people you talked about... Most of them are renters. Rents, we are told now, are going to jump between 20% and 30% in the next couple of years. So those people who are supposedly being helped to get into the property market are going to find it even more difficult to enter the property market when the savings they're trying to put aside for a deposit diminish because their rents are jumping up and the rental pool continues to diminish because investors have exited the market. The ramifications across the board... for this idiocy are profound. And you could say, well, some of it is unintended consequences. Well, not really, because it was entirely predictable.
00:19:27
Speaker 2: We've talked about it.
00:19:28
Speaker 6: On the program.
00:19:29
Speaker 2:
Something's tried and failed in the past, and it was tried and failed under Paul Keating. The idea that you could replicate it, go in harder, and it would work. No, it's failed twice as hard as it did last time. So great work, Labor, there. Terrific. So, if there is a leadership contest between Andrew Hastie and Angus Taylor down the track, the target should be Labor, as James was saying and as Rita was just saying. But have a listen to a little bit of that Clennell interview with Andrew Hastie earlier on.
00:19:56
Speaker 11: She's still a lying coward? She's still a lying coward. I'm not backing down. I put the challenge to her. She could have accepted that she'd got it wrong and pulled it down, but she refused to do so and she's doubled down.
00:20:07
Speaker 2: Her people say it's satire.
00:20:09
Speaker 12: Well.
00:20:10
Speaker 2: people with double standards.
00:20:11
Speaker 11: They got their knickers in a knot over the Gina Reinhart ABC satirical video, but this is OK to be called a traitor. Pauline Hanson has to explain why the other 20-odd combat veterans who gave evidence at the court are also traitors to their country.
00:20:29
Speaker 2: I'm just... Sorry, I've just got my knickers in a twist here. I'm sorry about that.
00:20:34
Speaker 1: Rowan, did I.
00:20:37
Speaker 4: I saw him make that analogy previously and I thought, He'll think better of it because he is not a dumb person, Andrew Hastie.
00:20:44
Speaker 5: He is very astute.
00:20:47
Speaker 4: But that is possibly the most idiotic and, frankly, offensive analogy I've heard in some time. The ABC supposed skit, one, wasn't funny. The Please Explain cartoons are actually enormously funny and I think that's objectively true.
00:21:05
Speaker 5: But even if, say, OK, the.
00:21:08
Speaker 5: The Gina Reinhart.
00:21:10
Speaker 4: ABC skit was a comedic genius.
00:21:14
Speaker 5: It was calling for a person to be raped to death. That's what it was.
00:21:21
Speaker 4: Is he comparing what happened in a cartoon? Was there a call in that cartoon for Andrew Hastie to be physically harmed, to be killed?
00:21:31
Speaker 1: No, furthermore.
00:21:32
Speaker 4: I mean, it is just the most wild analogy and it does his cause no good. Whoever is advising him with these talking points needs to cease and desist, because that was just dumb.
00:21:44
Speaker 6: Furthermore, I mean, talk about playing into one nation's hand right here. You know, everybody reads the headline, oh, Hastie was called a traitor. But then if you watch the cartoon, they're talking about him being a traitor to his party and to the principles of the party for things like, you know, voting for hate speech legislation and things like that. That was what it was about. That was what it was about. It was not about impugning his service... to his country or his loyalty to the Australian flag. And it's just so disingenuous. Maybe a little hint of that.
00:22:14
Speaker 5: There was a bit of a double entendre. Well, it
was a double entendre.
00:22:18
Speaker 6: But the point is, though, is that, you know, they're acting like Pauline Hanson got up on TV or a cartoon of her got up and said, Andrew Hastie is a traitor to his country. And that's not... I'm sorry, it's just not what was going on here.
00:22:32
Speaker 2: It's not what was in the cartoon, and that's the point. Something else. So lots happening for One Nation. We talked about Warren Pickering last week. Pauline Hanson is in hot water, as it were, again, for talking about Anthony Albanese's mother, who's spent most of her life, or all her life, I gather, in public housing. I think it might have even been the same house. I'm not sure. But anyway, have a listen to The Grab.
00:22:57
Speaker 9: Oh, this is the Prime Minister.
00:22:59
Speaker 2: Oh!
00:23:00
Speaker 9: I've actually grew up in a house commission house. You have no idea how hard it is to grow up in a house commission house. Oh, my God. House commission houses should not be there for people to live in them for 30, 40. And he said his mother lived in the same one she was born in for 65 years. Sorry, that's not on to me. It should be a limited time. You've been given a hand up. Moving on to the next one that's coming through.
00:23:23
Speaker 2: So for my money, there's two very, very distinct and specific arguments at play here. One is the argument about social welfare, cradle to grave, et cetera, et cetera, which was the classic kind of British welfare. NHS, everything was cradle to grave. The state would look after you. That's one argument. The other argument is, do you bring parents into politics? I think on that one, most would agree. But accept that it's Anthony Albanese who keeps bringing his mother into politics, saying, I grew up in a housing community, I grew up in this, I grew up... That's why I am who I am, et cetera.
00:23:56
Speaker 6: Et cetera.
00:23:57
Speaker 2: So I think it is legitimate to attack him when he's brought his own mother into the political arena so often. But I think the more important question question there is, what should public housing be? What is its role? Who should get it? Et cetera, et cetera.
00:24:12
Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean, look, there is that question. I think Pauline got some of the details on the biography wrong there, but the broad point is she spent most of her life in public housing. Anthony Albanese grew up in public housing. He makes no secret of the fact, in fact, he casts this as his origin story.
00:24:30
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:24:30
Speaker 6: Go back to... Go back to 2022. There are glowing articles in The Nine Press about how his growing up in public housing informed his entire sense of government and social welfare and all of that.
00:24:46
Speaker 2: And, you know.
00:24:47
Speaker 6: Like, that and the fact that he got into a low-speed car crash in the Inner West once are, like, the two most interesting things about this guy. And so he always brings those sorts of things up. And it is very funny, by the way, I do have to say, it is very funny that a guy who grew up in public housing and spends his life talking about how he fights Tories, we learned this week, had an honorary membership at the Royal Sydney Golf Course. But that's another interesting sort of story arc for him. We have to talk about that. We do have to talk about that. But I don't think it's... He.
00:25:14
Speaker 5: Still has a property in that.
00:25:16
Speaker 2: Well, so.
00:25:16
Speaker 6: That's near Royal Barrackville that he's got the property, yes.
00:25:20
Speaker 2: Well, we've got that clip, which we're going to play to Sarah Henderson, but I think we should play it now because it does pick up on this hypocrisy thing. And that is where Anthony Albanese, he made a big song and dance in Parliament about, oh, lots of jokes, it's 2.50 to join the golf club, I never go there, et cetera, et cetera. et cetera, you know, what's it got to do with me? And that was the basis for him saying this is all a storm in a teacup. $ 6 million grant went to this golf club, but, hey, how would I know? I just happen to be an honorary member. And then someone, of course, because the internet never lies, the footage is there somewhere, someone pulled out this footage of him at the golf club, in the golf club.
00:26:02
Speaker 3: Have a look.
00:26:04
Speaker 6: I've been coming here for decades and using this club.
00:26:07
Speaker 13: I got honorary membership. Someone made a decision.
00:26:11
Speaker 2: I don't have a card. I don't go to the club. I've been coming to this club for decades. I've never been to a club. Wow.
00:26:22
Speaker 6: It's so ridiculous because, you know, I'm fairly familiar with this, being a constituent of the Prime Minister, Randler.
00:26:28
Speaker 2: Are you a member of the golf club?
00:26:30
Speaker 6: I'm not.
00:26:31
Speaker 2: We've got a scoop.
00:26:32
Speaker 6: I wouldn't be a member of any club that would have me as a member, as they say.
00:26:35
Speaker 2: Hang on, it's also a sporting club, isn't it? Yes. So that would rule James and our house altogether.
00:26:39
Speaker 5: I'm sure it has a pretty nice bar and.
00:26:42
Speaker 6: Well, it does after a $ 6 million renovation. It's crazy. That golf course, they were the only golf course to get a grant through this program. He has been going there forever. Darcy Byrne, the mayor, who's also one of Albo's best friends, has all this stuff up about how great Albo is for doing up the golf club. It's just, you know, again, he's made a much bigger deal out of this story by appearing shifty about it.
00:27:07
Speaker 3: There you go.
00:27:08
Speaker 2: We're going to take a short break. When we come back, oh, Rita's reality check. Don't want to miss that. We've got Sarah Henderson coming up. Lots more here on Outsiders. Don't go away. Back in a tick.
00:27:24
Speaker 5: Welcome back.
00:27:24
Speaker 4: You're watching Outsiders with your host, Rowan. Don't call me a traitor. I was an
advertising executive dean, James Dandy Doodle Yankee Morrow, and I'm Rita Panahy, and soon we'll be speaking to Senator Sir Anderson about the extraordinary antics of parliamentarians we have seen on this station and in parliament in recent days. And let's take a minute to take a closer look at one of these fine parliamentarians, an eloquent... Totally rational woman with a refined, calm under pressure exterior.
00:28:00
Speaker 10: I have to say you're a bloody maggot yourself and you're a coward.
00:28:03
Speaker 13: And Hasty's right.
00:28:05
Speaker 10: Call her out because she's a bloody coward.
00:28:07
Speaker 1: She's finished.
00:28:08
Speaker 13: I'm onto you now.
00:28:09
Speaker 10: I told you I warned you years ago to leave my bloody veterans alone.
00:28:14
Speaker 13: Well, now you've got Lambie and I'm fuming.
00:28:18
Speaker 10: Absolutely fuming. That woman is disgusting. She's an angry little woman with so much baggage on her.
00:28:27
Speaker 4: Yes, that is Senator Jackie Lambie from the little state of Tasmania, a state with less than 600,000 people that nevertheless has 12 senators.
00:28:38
Speaker 5: Think about that.
00:28:38
Speaker 4: 12 senators, the same number as New South Wales, which has more than 8.6 million residents. That's why Paul Keating called the Senate unrepresentative swill. And wowee, we've had some doozies elected to the Upper House over the years, but none so unhinged as to suggest the world's richest man, a protector of free speech, should be in jail.
00:29:02
Speaker 10: LL Musk has no social conscience or conscience whatsoever. I don't know, whatever Elon Musk is on that says that that's okay to continue to air that is absolutely disgusting behaviour. And quite frankly, the bloke should be jailed. And the sooner that we can bring rules in or do something about this sort of game playing with our social media, the better off we're going to be.
00:29:23
Speaker 4: Yeah, that was over efforts by the Australian government to suppress footage of an alleged Islamist terror attack in a significant church. Jackie Lambie, along with Australia's leftist activist, a safety commissioner, wanted the footage banned worldwide.
00:29:39
Speaker 14: Worldwide.
00:29:41
Speaker 5: Elon Musk said no and he won.
00:29:43
Speaker 4: He won in the Australian legal system while copying slanderous invective like this.
00:29:50
Speaker 2: What's your take on the tech billionaire story?
00:29:56
Speaker 10: So when it comes to the tech billionaire, like I've already said, I think he's a social media knob with no social conscience. He has absolutely no social conscience. Someone like that should be in jail and the key be thrown away. That bloke should not have a right to be out there on his own ideology platform and creating hatred.
00:30:16
Speaker 4: Yep, she is in the Australian Parliament because every state has the same number of senators because the upper house was supposed to be the state's house. But it has never really functioned in that way. The framers of our Constitution designed the Senate to provide equal representation to protect smaller states.
00:30:35
Speaker 5: But almost immediately after.
00:30:37
Speaker 4: Federation, national parties dominated and senators vote along party and ideological lines.
00:30:43
Speaker 5: They don't vote as state blocks.
00:30:46
Speaker 4: So now we have unrepresentative swill carrying on like this.
00:30:50
Speaker 5: This meltdown over.
00:30:51
Speaker 4: A satirical cartoon is something else.
00:30:57
Speaker 10: She has no idea of patriotism, that woman.
00:31:00
Speaker 1: She has no idea.
00:31:01
Speaker 10: You don't attack veterans and you don't stand like a coward behind your goddamn cartoons, which I can tell you that in itself.
00:31:09
Speaker 1: They are shocking.
00:31:10
Speaker 10: How they are allowed to go over social media is beyond me because.
00:31:13
Speaker 13: They incite hatred, they are vile, they.
00:31:16
Speaker 10: Are disgusting and they are absolutely repulsive.
00:31:20
Speaker 1: Should she be required to pull that down?
00:31:23
Speaker 10: She should pull it down and she should get out there today and show some bloody courage and apologise to that veteran, to Andrew Hastie, right now. I tell you what, he's come from special air services, mate, the SAS. Only the best of the best get in there and, by God, they've got to be the toughest. And the country asked him to do so much more than anybody else can imagine.
00:31:45
Speaker 13: So you bloody show your respect.
00:31:47
Speaker 10: To Hastie because I tell.
00:31:49
Speaker 13: You what, he's bloody earned it. Leave him alone.
00:31:52
Speaker 1: Do you think that this is going to backfire now politically on Pauline Hanson? She's finished. I'm onto you now.
00:32:00
Speaker 10: I told you, I warned you years ago to leave my bloody veterans alone.
00:32:04
Speaker 13: Well, now you've got Lambie and I'm fuming, absolutely fuming. That woman is disgusting.
00:32:13
Speaker 1: She's just disgusting.
00:32:15
Speaker 10: She has never achieved one bloody thing up here.
00:32:22
Speaker 5: I'm sorry. That is hilarious, you have to say.
00:32:27
Speaker 4: I'm sure Pauline Hanson is quaking in her boots. Forget about the brilliant Please Explain cartoons. No satirist could write something that funny. That should be the next One Nation ad and this ironically hilarious rant too.
00:32:43
Speaker 13: All she does, she's a 10-second grab of rubbish and that's all she is.
00:32:47
Speaker 2: You have had a... Yep, sorry.
00:32:50
Speaker 10: And the other thing is, because of what she does, she's dividing this country.
00:32:54
Speaker 1: She is dividing it.
00:32:55
Speaker 13: She's not uniting it.
00:32:56
Speaker 10: She's an angry little woman with so much baggage on her that everybody else and her supporters think that is acceptable behaviour and think it's everybody else's fault besides theirs.
00:33:07
Speaker 1: Well, you
know what?
00:33:09
Speaker 10: Enough of dividing this country. There's no patriotism in that woman. She doesn't know what it is and she never will.
00:33:17
Speaker 4: Oh, what was just as hilarious as that carry on was the reaction of some simpletons in the media and political landscape who thought that uncouth tantrum was somehow a massive win, a big blow against One Nation. Have a look at this from failed former Liberal leader John Hewson who posted on X, if Jackie Lambie calls you an arsehole, you probably need to have a good hard look at yourself. You might not like her truth, but her consistency is hard to ignore.
00:33:51
Speaker 5: Yes, she's consistently or she's consistent. Yes, she's consistently. What would the kids call it?
00:33:58
Speaker 2: Cooked. Yes.
00:34:00
Speaker 4: And here is commentary from journalist Latika Burke.
00:34:03
Speaker 5: From The Nightly, who wrote this about what you just saw.
00:34:08
Speaker 4: Ten second grab of rubbish. Who has never achieved anything in Parliament, she said, quoting Jackie. And from nowhere, Jackie Lambie demonstrates how to counter-attack Australian populist One Nation leader Pauline Hanson.
00:34:23
Speaker 5: Ah, the idiocy.
00:34:24
Speaker 4: The complete ignorance of Hanson and her supporters is profound. If you think they're worried about Jackie Lambie and her ridiculous, shrill attacks, then you've lost the plot. No, Lambie is just a reminder that we need electoral reform in this country, desperately.
00:34:48
Speaker 2: Great stuff, Rita. Now, let's unpick the week's political news. I'm pleased to say that we're joined by the Shadow Communications Minister, Sarah Henderson. Sarah, great to see you. Thanks so much for coming on the show this morning.
00:35:01
Speaker 6: Well, let's kick off.
00:35:02
Speaker 2: I don't know if you watched Rita's... Expose there of one of your colleagues in the parliament. What did you make of it?
00:35:13
Speaker 1: Well, how could I miss that, Rowan? Look, I just want to start by saying One Nation and ourselves, the Coalition, are aligned on one critical mission, and that is to get rid of Labor.
00:35:26
Speaker 2: Yep.
00:35:26
Speaker 1: That is our mission, because this government is driving our nation off a cliff. Australians are poorer. They are doing it tough. And, of course, that is also because of the Prime Minister's shocking lies in relation to the budget. No negative gearing. No capital gains tax changes. And now look what Australians are enduring. A crashing housing market. So many people walk into the... supermarket Rowan, they can't even buy the week's groceries. It is just appalling what Australians are enduring under this government. That's why we are on a mission to get rid of Labor. Now, let me just say in relation to Andrew Hastie and the One Nation cartoon, I do believe they should take it down. I'm exercising my free speech. That is my view. I don't think what this cartoon has said is right. Andrew Hastie is totally correct to raise objections, as he has. Barnaby has apologised. I also think Pauline should apologise and take down the cartoon.
00:36:31
Speaker 2: James.
00:36:32
Speaker 6: But on the question of freedom of speech, Senator, I want to talk a bit more about that. I'm very glad to have you here to exercise your freedom of speech while we still have it, because I'm very concerned about this digital duty of care legislation that they are trying to push through here. Specifically wording in the legislation about giving the minister the right to take down what is nebulously described as harmful content. Now, we have seen people like Andrew Lee bell the cat and say, oh, well, you know, people are becoming more right wing because of the Internet at the moment. This seems like the most blatant political stitch up. But am I wrong?
00:37:17
Speaker 1: Well, James, it is. This is a serious threat to free speech. But I just want to firstly address the issues or the concerns you raised about the Liberals at the beginning of the program, because I just want to remind you that apart from the very strong stand we have taken on reversing Labor's tax cuts, driving down immigration, fixing the housing market. Just in the last couple of weeks, apart from taking a very strong stand against Labor's digital duty of care bill, we've also passed an amendment to a bill which will lift the terrible cap on allied health for veterans. Michaelia Cash will bring back her sex discrimination amendment into the Senate next week. We've reversed the widow's tax. We've announced the criminalisation of the burning of the flag and the desecration of war memorials. We are doing so much to stand up for our values under the leadership of Angus Taylor.
00:38:10
Speaker 5: So I just want to remind your viewers.
00:38:12
Speaker 1: About our hard work. And of course, we've made it very clear we will oppose this draconian legislation, which is a serious threat to free speech. And of course, continues Labor's insidious agenda of controlling what we say and what we see online.
00:38:29
Speaker 6: And, Senator, I just want to play a little bit of Laura Jay's interviewing Annika Wells, the Communication Minister. Have a look at this.
00:38:37
Speaker 15: The duty of care legislation is so broad it could capture more than social media, though. It could capture news websites, no?
00:38:45
Speaker 5: Well, sorry, yes, it does.
00:38:46
Speaker 16: The digital duty of care, my apologies, does go to all online services. News websites are not a function and feature of an online platform.
00:38:56
Speaker 5: Yes, they are.
00:38:58
Speaker 2: They're on online platforms.
00:39:01
Speaker 5: How are they a functional feature?
00:39:01
Speaker 15: Because if you were turning off the algorithm, that would change how news websites would be seen, would it not?
00:39:10
Speaker 16: Well, you as a user would be making a choice about whether you wish to follow the algorithm or whether you wish to follow your
following feed.
00:39:18
Speaker 6: This is the person who is supposed to be deciding harmful content. It would only be worse if she pulled out the Ooshies to start explaining it.
00:39:28
Speaker 1: Well, James, can I just... make the point we want to see kids safe online. The government must do much more and I took forward some amendments in that respect. We think that parents deserve the safety tools on the platforms like, you know, Apple, Google and Microsoft offer so that they can do more to protect their children online. We want to see algorithmic transparency, which of course is what Elon Musk has done on the 4U feed on X. We haven't seen that on other platforms. So more needs to be done. But this legislation is a backdoor way of reintroducing the disinformation and misinformation bill. It's all about shutting down any online service. And it is frightening that it includes, as Laura said, did a great job nailing Annika Wells to the mast on this. It is frightening that it includes news websites, which of course means they have the power to shut down any commentary, any news report, any media organisation, any opinion. I mean, this is abhorrent legislation, one of the worst things I've ever seen in the parliament. And as Angus Taylor and Matt Canavan and myself made very clear when we held our press conference, we are going to fight this every step of the way. Fantastic.
00:40:44
Speaker 5: The Liberals flirt.
00:40:45
Speaker 4: With this a bit too much for my liking. The support for the ban on under-16s, for example, the support for algorithm changes, which quite often, I think, are also just... attempts to censor speech that the Uniparty, for want of a better expression, don't like. How do you manage that? How do you walk that fine line? And could you please also speak about this notion of the government funding activists who campaign on this issue and then changing or proposing legislation that will fix an issue that they've manufactured, essentially, and pretending like it's some grassroots campaign when it's been well-funded activists who've been pushing that barrow all along.
00:41:39
Speaker 1: Well, Rita, there are various issues you've raised and they're quite separate. So on the algorithm, of course, if you have a non-profiled algorithm, as is the law in the EU, then you can make some choices about what you want to see online. But we have reservations about this. We think there is a legitimate debate to be had about whether what sort of algorithm you had. And it's ridiculous to say you can turn the algorithm off because even if you are following your own followers on a feed, the algorithm will decide how that content is served because an algorithm is just a set of rules which decide how content is served. And that's why I moved an amendment in the Senate which was rejected by Labor and the Greens in relation to algorithmic transparency because this also includes what's being censored, what's been suppressed, what's been pushed down. And I congratulate Elon Musk... for being transparent in relation to his algorithm on the For You feed, but why aren't we seeing this on the other platforms? So much more work needs to be done on that. Yes, on the social media ban, we supported it and the intent, but this is not working. It's been very poorly designed and badly implemented. And as a result, children are less safe online than they were before the law changed. And so I think much more needs to be done to keep kids in particular safe online. And the government has not done that hard work. It is basically in this new digital duty of care bill, it has included a whole range of harms like terrorism material, child sexual abuse material, they are already prohibited. They are already banned, either under the criminal law or under the Online Safety Act. So this idea that the minister can decide, oh, we're going to ban this type of harm or this type of harm including they've even referenced in relation to children you know material that is hostile to women or gender equality what does that even mean I mean it's just ridiculous it is a it is an open door to the government doing anything they want and if you see what the e-safety commissioner has done some of the decisions that she has made including trying to shut down the likes of Selim Baungarten, when she raised concerns about a queer club at a primary school, we need to make sure that our laws strike the right balance. And that's why there's a fair bit going on in my space in recent weeks. That's why we opposed additional powers for the eSafety Commissioner, because what the government has done is give the eSafety Commissioner the power to impose fines of up to $ 21. 8 million without judicial oversight. So there are big fines, but previously the eSafety Commissioner had to go to court, commence court proceedings, and now she can impose these massive fines without any judicial oversight, and we think that's wrong.
00:44:43
Speaker 2: Sarah Henderson, please keep up the fight on behalf of all Australians. It was the eSafety Commissioner who told us that, you know, free speech, or told Davos that free speech in the new age of the internet, that'll have to be a secondary issue. It's terrifying what you mentioned. We know that what Rita was talking about earlier, the culture wars, this is how Labor intends to win the culture wars, by banning things, in my opinion. If they can go after the transgender thing, what's to stop them saying, oh, climate change is a dangerous area? What's to stop them saying, oh, discussion of immigration is dangerous? All of that stuff. So, please, Sarah Henderson, on behalf of all Australians, please, you have to win this fight. Thanks so much for coming on the show today. I'm going to take a short break after that. The mission's impossible. Yes, they are. Yes, the mission's impossible. It is our mission, and we do accept it every single week to look at the madness of the net zero renewables cult. And I do
call them a cult, the climate change cult. Many members, many members they are, but... Let's talk first of all about Maureen Faruqi. I called her Farine Maruqi last week, didn't I?
00:45:56
Speaker 4: She was kind of poetic, but that is not her name, Rowan.
00:46:00
Speaker 2: I know, that's not her name, but you quite like that. But Maureen Faruqi has an interesting take on the tragedy in Nepal. Have a listen.
00:46:09
Speaker 14: And where colonialism is involved, racism is lurking right there and it is writ large in impacts of climate change. While billionaire lists dominated by white men get richer and richer and protect themselves from the worst consequences of climate breakdown, black and brown communities across the global south are being flooded, burned, displaced, starved and buried.
00:46:32
Speaker 2: So, unfortunately, this sort of stuff is what is taught in schools and universities. So, racism... Is she saying.
00:46:37
Speaker 5: The ice shelves are racist?
00:46:39
Speaker 2: leads to capitalism, which leads to the breakdown of the climate, which leads to the tragedies in Nepal. Do we talk about... Now, they're set with a straight face. This is the problem.
00:46:49
Speaker 5: Do we talk about.
00:46:50
Speaker 4: Last week that if we had an alert system, which they could have.
00:46:55
Speaker 5: Had? Had, at minimal cost, which other.
00:47:01
Speaker 4: including Bangladesh, have put in place to ensure that when you do have these natural disasters, that people have enough time to get to higher ground and save themselves, and they abandoned those sorts of systems, perhaps because they're created.
00:47:17
Speaker 5: By the white man.
00:47:18
Speaker 2: I don't know.
00:47:18
Speaker 6: Maybe it's colonialism.
00:47:20
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:47:20
Speaker 5: I mean, the rationale here, James, is confounding.
00:47:24
Speaker 6: Well, it is confounding. I was just about to say that. I was about to say that, you know, perhaps this really is the issue. Maybe it is, you know, the climate issue guilt, which has been a development of white culture spread around the world like a bacillus that has infected cultures everywhere. And so, of course, they obsess about climate rather than, again, doing the sorts of things that people like the great Bjorn Lomborg talk about, about mitigating and preparing for weather events, climactic events. But there's another part of this, too, that the good senator ignores, and that's the role of what was happening upstream with the engineering projects done by China, which we know very little about, but which there is some talk about having potentially contributed to the severity of this disaster. And yet we don't have any focus, we don't have any eyes on what they're doing, what they're building dams that could have been constructed in ways that would have actually made downstream effects of these sorts of events, which happen regularly and throughout There are records. This is a civilisation there around Nepal that has had written records for a long, long, long, long time, and we know that these sorts of events do occur.
00:48:35
Speaker 2: Well, more... Sorry, Rita. More crucially, the drilling that was going on, they're building the world's largest hydro dam up there, the world's largest, most powerful hydro dam. You've got to... Unlike Malcolm Turnbull's Snowy 2.0... So, you're saying you're... You're saying..... which we still can't do one tunnel... Up in China, on the Tibetan border, which China controls, of Nepal, high up in the Alps, there's a massive amount of drilling, all secretive, massive underground drilling, and the Chinese do it well, unlike whatever we're doing in the snowy. But more importantly.
00:49:06
Speaker 5: No, no, no, I think you've missed a point there.
00:49:08
Speaker 4: You're saying Maroon Farooqui is right. You're saying this loss of life, unnecessary loss of life.
00:49:14
Speaker 6: I think Rowan's gone.
00:49:15
Speaker 2: is Chinese colonialism.
00:49:16
Speaker 4: No, no, not Chinese colonialism, but the white colonialism of climate change alarmism.
00:49:24
Speaker 5: Because that's what's been exported.
00:49:26
Speaker 4: That's what the rich white folk in rich white nations have obsessed about in recent decades is climate change and the world ending. And they have exported that to the third world. And the third world has suffered because of it. And their living standards have suffered, and you can arguably say there's been loss of life because of it as well.
00:49:46
Speaker 5: So, inadvertently, I think she's right.
00:49:49
Speaker 4: Just everything else she said was wrong about how it's happened.
00:49:53
Speaker 5: But this obsession.
00:49:55
Speaker 2: The climate change dogma... with global warming... That's true.
00:49:57
Speaker 4: that is a white obsession, a rich white obsession, has been exported.
00:50:02
Speaker 2: Well, speaking of that... Yeah. And just on that, it was the bedrock, by the way, that fractured with the ice on top of it. So... It wasn't any... It appears very much that it was an earthquake.
00:50:13
Speaker 6: Yeah, well, in any case... Triggered by whatever. That will all come out. But, you know, just on this notion of people being really freaked out about climate change, there's this fascinating story here about how now they are saying the Climate Council is saying that the Australian summer may be dead because of climate change, and that people are now so worried about... Climate change that they can't even enjoy the summer. And I can testify to this because I know that I have heard people in the inner west when I'm out walking the dog. When we had some really beautiful spring days last week, I heard more than one person say, I said, you know, lovely weather we're having here is the dogs frisk around and everything. They say, oh, yes, but it's. it's very alarming, it's quite concerning. I'm like, it's spring, it's Sydney, can't we just enjoy the good weather?
00:51:00
Speaker 4: Well, you choose to live amongst those sorts of people. Rowan and I choose not to sort of live amongst that.
00:51:07
Speaker 5: We pick more sensible places to live.
00:51:10
Speaker 4: But can I read you the quote from Leslie Hughes from the Climate Council, the director there?
00:51:16
Speaker 5: This is The View of Australians.
00:51:19
Speaker 4: They dread heat waves, the bushfires, not being able to do the things that they used to, climate change is stealing the part.
00:51:28
Speaker 5: Of the year Australians look forward to the most.
00:51:31
Speaker 4: I'm sorry, in most normal households and normal parts of Australia.
00:51:38
Speaker 5: You do look forward to summer.
00:51:39
Speaker 2: Of course I do.
00:51:40
Speaker 6: You love summer.
00:51:41
Speaker 4: You love being able to go outdoors. You love the warmer temperature. The one thing you might not like is how much your air conditioning bill's going.
00:51:48
Speaker 5: To cost you.
00:51:49
Speaker 6: Yeah.
00:51:49
Speaker 4: But then again, that's because of the climate change cult, not because it's getting too hot.
00:51:54
Speaker 2: We've got to take a short break. When we come back, I'll have more to say on the hasty thing. Lots more happening here. We've got John Hinderecker coming up. James will be talking about 9-11. Don't go away. Lots happening here on Outsiders in a tick. Hello, you're watching Outsiders with Rita Hanoi, Jane Panahy, James, Kim Philby-Morrow and myself, Rowan, whistling Lickspittle Dean. In the wake of Tratergate, I thought we all deserved a good laugh this morning, and I'm pleased to say The Guardian did not disappoint in providing it. I literally burst out laughing yesterday when I came across the following quote from none other than our dear old friend, the miserable ghost.
00:52:34
Speaker 6: Quote.
00:52:35
Speaker 2: Former Liberal Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull tells Guardian Australia that Andrew Hastie should be entitled to absolute 100% solidarity from his team.
00:52:48
Speaker 7: Oh!
00:52:50
Speaker 2: Ah, yes, when Malcolm Turnbull is lecturing parliamentary members of the Liberal Party about 100% loyalty to the team, what else can you do but laugh? In the same article, Malcolm Turnbull goes on to insist that Andrew Hastie has been unfairly targeted for being a reluctant witness in the Ben Roberts Smith defamation case, where he was compelled to appear by subpoena, as well as maintaining that, quote, a senior member of the Coalition frontbench, a former SAS officer, has been accused of treason in cartoons published by One Nation, end of quote. As was clear from Shari Markson's interview with Andrew Hastie last week, the first claim is relevant at best and the second claim is simply false. Nowhere in the cartoon is Hastie accused of being a traitor to his country. He is accused of being a traitor for his role in the Ben Robert Smith affair and he is accused of being a traitor to his many previous fans and supporters
who were horrified when Mr Hastie went from insisting he would vote no to Labor's hate speech laws to only six days later voting yes to them. an act which Andrew Hastie justified by saying his party gutted Labor's original bill like a fish and that the subsequent bill that he voted for was, in his words, in the national interest. And that's fair enough. But for many, that U-turn was an act of betrayal, regardless of the reasons Mr Hastie gave for, to use that famous phrase, for changing his position. It was that perceived betrayal that led directly to many online comments accusing him of being a traitor. And it was those online comments that were entirely the basis of the now notorious One Nation cartoon. But like all politicians, it's not the first time Andrew Hastie seems to have changed his position. This week, Mr Hastie announced to the world how outraged and offended he is by the One Nation cartoon. But how did he feel about it when it actually first came out over six weeks ago? He told the ABC, Patricia Carvellis, and indeed he put up the transcript on his own website, that he was flattered to be the subject of the One Nation cartoon.
00:54:50
Speaker 11: It's not for me to tell One Nation how to spend their money, but I'm obviously living rent-free in James Ashby's head, and I wouldn't be surprised if he spent some of that money on the cartoon he made about me.
00:55:00
Speaker 6: I'm flattered.
00:55:02
Speaker 2: So I'm voting no to the bill. Six days later, I'm voting yes to the bill. I'm flattered to be in the cartoon. Six weeks later, I'm outraged by the cartoon. Those are fairly dramatic U-turns. But Andrew is a politician, so I guess that's what we, you know, expect from the Canberra crowd. But why is the word traitor suddenly such a big deal? Don't mention the T word. Again, I fully appreciate how being accused of treason or being a traitor to your country or anything like that after you've served in the army is really hurtful. Absolutely. I understand that. But Mr Hastie left the army and became a politician. Politicians are accused of being traitors and far worse and all sorts of things all the time. That's the nature of the political battlefield. Here's just a few examples. John Wacker Williams labelled Barnaby Joyce's resignation an act of treason. Tom Elliott brands Liberal Party defector Cory Bernardi a traitor. Joe Hildebrand labels Fatima Payman a Labour pariah, now traitor. Jacinta Nampajimpa Price branded a traitor for defecting to the Liberal Party. Mr Hamilton Smith branded a traitor by his Liberal colleagues for defecting to Labour. Adam Bant hits back at being labelled a traitor to his country. So there you go. That one was actually about being called a traitor to your country. Another one, Liberal senator confesses, they called me a traitor, and so on. It goes on. Look, it's politics. But apparently it is now absolutely beyond the pale to accuse a politician who happens to have served in the army in the past of being
a traitor now, in whatever political sphere. Interestingly, it is OK to attack someone who served the army in the past and is now a politician and call them a sexual deviant, a drug addict, and heaven knows what else Warren Pickering... was being accused of by Orland's inquiry only a week ago. There you go. Speaking of which, I'm sure I'm not the only person to question the timing of the two events, Hastie and Pickering. I would speculate that after all the sex, drugs and rock and roll kerfuffle over Warren Pickering last week and One Nation appearing to some to be on the back foot, those individuals who are keen to see Mr Hastie elevated to leader of the Liberal Party saw an opportunity not to be missed. Andrew Hastie has insisted in the past that Malcolm Turnbull is not his mentor, but the two have certainly been close in the past. Is it totally beyond the realm of possibility that Mr Turnbull, who seems to have taken an interest in young Mr Hastie's leadership ambitions, recognised an opportune moment to fan the flames, maybe set and train a leadership spill? After all, he is a bit of an expert in such matters. You can imagine the sales pitch. Andrew Hastie, the valiant warrior prepared to take down One Nation versus the more circumspect Angus Taylor. I think we can see how all this is going to play out. The Liberals haven't changed leaders for what? Oh, must be getting on for, that's a coincidence, seven months today. Must be about time for a Mr Trumbull style rumble in the jungle. Here we go. But guess what? Here's the thing. The only person benefiting As we were saying earlier, as Rita said, the only person benefiting from traitor gait is Anthony Albanese. We all know it. At the very moment Albo was beginning to look vulnerable, the harsh media spotlight shifted off Albo the liar and switched on to Andrew, the valiant and offended veteran, et cetera, et cetera. So what next? Well, clearly Liberal MPs are being sucked into either supporting Hastie in his war with Hanson or staying out of it altogether, probably the wiser course of action, the latter. But Andrew Hastie has promised to carry on with this war with Hansen right up until the next election. He recommitted to that just an hour or so ago on this network. with Andrew Clennell. If One Nation starts to slip in the polls and after the double whammy of Warren Pickering and Tradergate, that could happen. That could even happen at the next poll. Who knows? But if it does, that will be seen as proof that Hasty is a tough and successful fighter. And the argument will be, if Hasty can do this to Hanson, imagine what he could do to Albanese. Taylor will look weak in comparison. Hasty will look strong. And hey, presto, there will be a spill. In fact, the Financial Review are already pushing this line, arguing yesterday that Liberal MP Andrew Hastie has decided to take the fight up to One Nation and his colleagues are mostly enthusiastic. I don't know if that meant mostly as an adjective or an adverb, but anyway, whatever. And with Andrew Clennell, Hastie made a point of reiterating his fighting skills. When asked, he also reiterated his full support for Angus Taylor's leadership. Full support. But if Andrew Hastie were to take over the Liberal leadership, my fear is that that would sink any chance of any kind of crucial cooperation and preference swaps between the Coalition and One Nation before the next election, and we will see a futile and counterproductive continuation of an increasingly bitter war on the right, which will most likely lead, as we keep being told, to a return to power of the worst government in our history. Poor fellow, my country. Oh, one last thing. Since he launched his Tom and Jerry-style war on a cartoon, that cartoon has had around a million more views across all its platforms. That's a million people who probably hadn't seen the cartoon or hadn't heard Mr Hastie being called a traitor in it. So that's a million more people, give or take, who are now asking themselves whether or not Mr Hastie's actions in the Ben Robert Smith affair or in changing his vote on the hate speech laws can or cannot accurately be described as the actions of a traitor. So I'm not quite sure what Mr Hastie hoped to achieve with this belated umbrage, other than..... I guess we'll have to find out. Stay tuned. As I said, they'll be popping the bubbly over at Kirribilli House this weekend and possibly at other harbourfront mansions too. So, with some interesting stuff happening in Britain.
01:01:41
Speaker 6: Yes!
01:01:42
Speaker 2: we talk a lot about Britain, So there's been these anti-immigration protests going around Portsmouth, Dover, other sorts of places, and they were all in black headgear. Some character turned up in a burqa. Some bloke, big bloke, in a full burqa at the protest. Have a look. Here he is. There is... So he was there in his burqa. The police came up and questioned him. Have we got that, Graeme?
01:02:09
Speaker 10: I'm converting to Islam, and I'm... gender fluid, and I feel very comfortable in this.
01:02:18
Speaker 2: Gear, and I like mixing with people.
01:02:20
Speaker 13: He identifies as a lady.
01:02:31
Speaker 2: So he identified as a woman who had converted to Islam, hence he was wearing the thing. The police officer was going, oh, yeah, yeah, OK, that's fine. And then he cut to an hour or so later or whatever it was, and he'd been arrested.
01:02:44
Speaker 4: Don't laugh, Rowan, because that was extraordinarily transphobic and Islamophobic at once, which.
01:02:50
Speaker 6: And misogynistic.
01:02:51
Speaker 2: And misogynistic.
01:02:52
Speaker 6: It's a trifecta of offence that Rowan is going to be... It was Doverphobic as well.
01:02:57
Speaker 2: It was Doverphobic.
01:02:58
Speaker 6: It's Doverphobic, Portsmouthphobic. But, you know, Whitecliffsphobic, you know? Yes, exactly. But it is... Look, this is actually a really serious situation here that's happening down in the south of England,
because right now we have had this situation where protesters have been showing up en masse, peacefully, but quite forcefully, trying to interrupt the flow of migrants into the country and their interception and then being taken to, you know, the hotels and so on that they're getting dropped off all around the country, much to the great horror of the people who have to live next door to them. The authorities, of course, are now revealed to be in complete cahoots with the migrants. Now, according to the protesters, they say that this is facilitating an invasion. And when you look at the population of these people, young military age males for the most part, I mean, where are the women? Where are the children? Normally you'd think refugees, women and children, but not so much in this case. But now this is really interesting. It's a great little bit of jujitsu from that fellow there. to put on the burqa. I actually think, technically... I paid attention to your editorial last week. I think that may have been a kneecap, but I'm not sure. But, anyway... It was. It was. Yeah.
01:04:12
Speaker 7: Sorry, Ron, I think I've got to correct you. But this puts now... This puts the British police into a really... interesting double bind, because by arresting him, but there were protesters wearing, you know, actual burqas nearby.
01:04:26
Speaker 6: Racial profiling. They are essentially... They're either saying it's a two-tier system, so they're, you know, ratifying the whole charge that it's two-tier policing in Britain, which we know is correct, but also, if they allow... women to go about with these face coverings, well, then suddenly they've just created a blasphemy law.
01:04:44
Speaker 4: Oh, no, they've been quite on board with blasphemy laws in the UK for some time.
01:04:49
Speaker 5: They're not even.
01:04:50
Speaker 6: Shying away from that. Only when Islam is concerned.
01:04:51
Speaker 5: Well, that's it.
01:04:52
Speaker 4: And how can they say that if you say you're a woman, you're a woman, and then suddenly... think critically about that statement when it's coming from someone involved in a march they don't like, then, oh, well, no, no, you're obviously mocking womanhood. You're not actually serious. You're not actually really identifying as a woman. But when you've got some bloke with a full beard and a miniskirt saying I'm a woman, well, everyone has to respect that and, God forbid, you use the wrong pronouns or you'll have a knock at the door. So British policing is... I think an absolute disgrace to their country. There's entire areas where they haven't solved regular crimes like robberies and house break-ins.
01:05:37
Speaker 5: They've lost all interest in that.
01:05:39
Speaker 4: They're far more interested in knocking on people's doors to question them about things they may have retweeted or, you know, parodies that they may have shared. It really is quite disgraceful. I know we joke about it, but when you look at the numbers... This
isn't some little fringe once or twice a year. There are thousands of cases.
01:06:00
Speaker 6: And this is why, you know, like, for me, the great terror for Australia is that we are just five years or ten years or two years away from becoming... like Britain. And that's why the whole thing about these digital duty of care censorship laws that they keep trying to push through are so vital. Because once those go through, then suddenly you have this situation where, you know, you start to say, not only are we going to dial back what you can and can't see, what news stories you can and can't see, because we don't like them because they're bad for social cohesion, but also, you know, you start to get the knocks on the door and you start to get police forces that are indeed less concerned about, say, you know, somebody getting hacked up with a machete in your shopping centre than they are about, hey, I think, you know, you were a bit mean to share that meme online.
01:06:49
Speaker 4: And I know the Liberals, we had Senator Henderson before saying they don't want the Safety Commissioner to have the extraordinary powers that she's been granted, extension of powers, including being able to impose these massive fines on social media companies that don't do her bidding.
01:07:09
Speaker 5: Let's look at the history here, Rowan.
01:07:11
Speaker 4: This is a woman who decided a post by Jasmine Sussex, who was a breastfeeding expert, someone who helped women breastfeed for years, who posted words to the effect of men can't breastfeed because there are men who are trying to breastfeed and.
01:07:28
Speaker 5: Saying, you know, they can lactate.
01:07:30
Speaker 4: So a statement like men can't breastfeed was deemed so harmful that it was struck down.
01:07:37
Speaker 5: Australian.
01:07:38
Speaker 4: Twitter users couldn't see it. That is the sort of ideological decisions being made out of the office of the eSafety Commissioner.
01:07:47
Speaker 5: So do you want to.
01:07:48
Speaker 4: Have a radical leftist like that determine what's harmful to society, what's harmful for children.
01:07:56
Speaker 5: To see, what sort of algorithms... we.
01:07:58
Speaker 4: Should have in place and what sort of material should be banned from that algorithm. I mean, this is just frightening stuff. This is China's Communist Party.
01:08:07
Speaker 2: It is. If you look at the legislation, the legislation sounds all great, you know, protecting from... Oh, it sounds great. But you drill down, there is a clause in there that says basically the minister, i.e. Annika Wells, the ushi girl who seems to.
01:08:22
Speaker 6: Ushi girl. Minister for ushis.
01:08:24
Speaker 2: who also likes to travel a lot... she decides what is serious harm into the future. So that can be... There's no... There's no indication, no parameters, nothing that says what serious harm... Now, they think, you know... Well, they've already said Pauline Hanson's cartoon is harmful, so that would come straight off. That would be... The East Safety Commissioner and thing would have that banned.. in a jot. They would have many TV shows banned. They would have many.
01:08:54
Speaker 6: Well, Rowan.
01:08:54
Speaker 2: Because they're online. And they can just say, well, that's harmful, it's climate change or it's immigration or.
01:08:59
Speaker 11: Or that.
01:09:00
Speaker 6: On that, you know, just this week, and, you know, we saw before Laura Jay's nailing the minister for Ooshies to the wall over this question of news and the algorithms, just this week in The Daily Telegraph, I reported this story that in Sydney and in Melbourne, in big cities, in the parts of those cities where they are taking the most migrants... more and more Australian-born Australians are leaving. So the net internal migration out of areas that are being you know, made to take in these huge numbers of migrants. It's a huge demographic change. No-one ever voted for it. And it is reshaping the character of our cities. And we reported this, I reported this in The Telegraph, and it's exactly the sort of news story that when they have control of the algorithm, they'll say, we don't think that's a great idea, we're going to dial that one back because it might start to cause people to think thoughts that are, you know, maybe against social cohesion.
01:09:56
Speaker 5: Well, we need more information, not less.
01:09:59
Speaker 6: Correct.
01:09:59
Speaker 5: I remember there was a time where you could.
01:10:01
Speaker 4: Very easily get credible statistics on different immigrant groups and their criminality, and you could see whether they were underrepresented in the crime stats or overrepresented, sometimes dramatically overrepresented, and they were clear, credible statistics that you knew were correct information. You weren't getting anecdotal information from, say, talking to police officers or people in the legal profession, it is now so difficult to get that information. They have deliberately made it almost impossible without jumping through a lot of hoops and a lot of sorts of guesswork that makes the information possibly less credible.
01:10:47
Speaker 5: And that's what we should.
01:10:49
Speaker 4: Have our politicians concerned about, the fact that Australians have less access to information that is important to them, to have a fact based debate about important issues, whether it's around migration or anything else. But no, all they want to do is hide more information from you that they'd rather you did not have.
01:11:09
Speaker 5: And with the.
01:11:10
Speaker 4: Explosion of independent media where you've got anyone who's got access to a microphone could do a podcast or to write something and put it online. that's also the sort of information they want to absolutely flatten because they're scared of it.
01:11:29
Speaker 2: Yeah, and we saw during COVID how determined they will be if they decide, you know, that this drug or they want to do the mandate of this
or that, anyone who disagrees... And that was under a Liberal government. That was under a Liberal government, absolutely, Scott Morrison's government. And they will quite happily just... The public doesn't need to know this. And if you give power to these sort of bureaucrats... as I repeatedly say, particularly the Labor Party, not necessarily the brightest tools in the parliamentary shed. You can look forward to your liberties being absolutely stripped away. It's a terrifying thought and it has to be defeated, this bill.
01:12:05
Speaker 4: And the sad thing is there are so many in the media who are cheering on for greater censorship.
01:12:11
Speaker 5: I think that's a huge part of the problem in itself.
01:12:13
Speaker 2: Absolutely. We're going to take a short break, come back with James's truth bomb. John Heinrich, lots more here on Outside. It's back in a tick.
01:12:27
Speaker 6: Hello, you're watching Outsiders with your hosts, Rowan Dean, Rita Panahy, and myself, James Morrow.
01:12:33
Speaker 2: Well.
01:12:34
Speaker 6: Over the past 48 hours, the world has been marking the horrific terror attacks of 25 years ago, when Islamic extremists from the al-Qaeda terror group hijacked four planes, struck the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, and killed nearly 3,000 innocents, including 10 Australians. And somehow, maybe I was just being naive for a moment, kind of thought the anniversary would be marked with more universal solemnity. Boy, was I wrong. Let's start with the 9-11 memorial commemorations in Lower Manhattan, shall we? Here, the names of every single victim were being read out somberly, a moving process that you would imagine would call for quiet reflection. Unless, of course, you happen to be the left-wing firebrand Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, or worse, New York City Mayor Zoran Mamdani. Have a look here as the pair were caught on camera yucking it up during the proceedings.
01:13:39
Speaker 1: Catherine L.
01:13:41
Speaker 2: Labore.
01:13:42
Speaker 4: Amarnath Lachman.
01:13:44
Speaker 2: Ganesh K.
01:13:46
Speaker 6: Ladkut. Sure, there was a pretty funny joke there. Would you care to share it with the rest of the class, guys? By the way, AOC is, I must say, capable of being sad. Recall how, back in 2019, she turned all the waterworks over kids being held in immigration detention. Clearly, she feels differently about bad things happening to actual Americans. Even more bizarre were the scenes outside the memorial where this man ranted about Israel while screaming Allahu Akbar. It is nothing sacred, but I was very impressed with the free character assessment this firefighter gave to a man dressed for whatever reason in an Elmo costume while wearing a Palestinian flag. Palestine.
01:14:49
Speaker 2: Go back to Palestine. We don't want you here.
01:14:52
Speaker 6: And take Obama.
01:14:54
Speaker 2: Take Madami with you. And AOC. And Hochul.
01:14:58
Speaker 13: Take them all.
01:15:00
Speaker 2: They're all no good.
01:15:03
Speaker 6: I've never been prouder to be a New Yorker than seeing that. But further afield, it is also downright shocking the way America's classrooms, and probably Australia's as well, it must be said, in those places, the entire history of 9-11 is being rewritten, and the memories of the fallen spat upon. In California, at UCLA's once prestigious law school, they held a symposium on September 11th entitled 25 Years After 9-11, Reimagining Freedom, Justice, and Security. Well, you can imagine where this is going to go because among the speakers, they had a defense attorney for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind behind the attacks, and as well they had speakers who have called counterterrorism a, quote, racist gravy train. and others who even celebrated the murder of health care CEO Brian Thompson. Meanwhile, on another college campus, PragerU correspondent Franklin Camargo asked some of the kids what they knew about 9-11.
01:16:04
Speaker 2: Do you know who attacked us? As far as I know, not really.
01:16:07
Speaker 5: I wasn't really educated much on it.
01:16:09
Speaker 2: I try to do research, but you already know the internet and people, they always spread misinformation. It was, oh my God, my boyfriend's a lot of our history.
01:16:17
Speaker 5: We literally talked about this.
01:16:19
Speaker 2: Do you know the name of the group? I forgot the specific group who did that, but yeah. So it was Al-Qaeda. Al-Qaeda, yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:16:25
Speaker 6: You're right.
01:16:25
Speaker 2: Yep, yep, yep.
01:16:26
Speaker 17: Well, from what I'm told, it's a terrorist organization, but there's a lot of contention on that.
01:16:30
Speaker 2: Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden. Correct. Who's responsible for that? Do you know why they attacked America? I forgot. No, not really.
01:16:38
Speaker 17: Probably just for some extremist goals of some kind.
01:16:44
Speaker 6: What can you even say? But what's even more remarkable is the attempt to rewrite the history of 9-11, to take the focus off the attacks and turn 9-11 into a story about the evil West and all the poor Muslims who were the victims of Islamophobia. The New York Times led its web coverage on the day with a story entitled After 9-11, Islamophobia Shaped a Generation of Muslim New Yorkers. Again, yes, I say let's remember the real victims here, right? Honestly. Even though, worse though, is what seems to me to be an attempt to create the narrative that 9-11 was actually about fighting back against American imperialism and oppression and interference in the Middle East, rather than look at more ancient grievances nursed by Islam against the West. which brings us back to our friend New York City Mayor Zoran Mamdani, seen here giving a commemorative pen to his chief counsel, Ramzi Qasem, after citing a proclamation about 9-11. Who is Qasem, you ask? Well, it turns out he once represented a convicted al-Qaeda member who was also brother-in-law of one of the 9-11 hijackers and again is now Mamdani's chief counsel.
01:18:05
Speaker 2: Thank you.
01:18:06
Speaker 6: This same guy, back in 2001, six days after the September 11th attacks, also wrote this for the Columbia Spectator. He wrote, quote, the resentment these terrorists felt towards the United States was rooted in political realities shaped by our country's policies. Our government has supported dictatorial and repressive regimes across the Middle East and elsewhere for years in total disregard of the aspirations and better interests of the indigenous population. populations of those regions. This is, again, Chief Counselor to the Mayor of New York. And I got to say, sorry, Counselor, I think you need a reality check. Let's not forget, Al-Qaeda and its founder, Osama bin Laden, were in fact inspired by this man, Saeed Khatoub, one of the intellectual fathers of the Muslim Brotherhood and perhaps the Islamic theorist most responsible for modern Salafist jihadism. Now, what turned Khatoum, an Egyptian radical, to radical Islam? Well, it wasn't American involvement in the Middle East. No. Instead, when he was a student in the United States in 1949, he was scandalized by a college mixer. Quote, and they danced to the tunes of the gramophone. Ketub would write in one of his books, quote, unquote. Now, what he was describing was not some Berlin nightclub, but a sock hop in Greeley, Colorado in 1949 that so offended him and turned him towards fundamentalist radical Islam. This is what turned Kutub into a leading apologist and inspiration for terrorism, including 9-11, not American foreign policy. Remember, not just on 9-11, but every day. Think back about what Khatib was saying there. They don't hate us for what we do. They hate us for who we are.
01:20:28
Speaker 2: Great stuff. Thanks, James. Well, let's stay on this topic and cross now to the US for more reaction to it. Centre of American Experiment President John Heinrich. John, always great to see you. Thanks for coming on. And obviously, 9-11 just passed in the States. A big... I remember it well. I'm sure you remember it well. I just wanted to play you one clip, which I remember at the time was just so bizarre, I couldn't really get my head around it. I thought it can't be real. But this was people actually celebrating 9-11. We don't have that clip. OK, I've got another one I want to play you, which kind of kicks off from that, which was when the current mayor, Zoran Mamdani, talked about the victims of 9-11, and he specifically referred to this aunt of his and the fact that she'd been supposedly harassed for wearing a hijab on the train or on the metro or whatever. I'll just play you that clip quickly.
01:21:26
Speaker 6: I want to use this moment to speak to the Muslims of New York City. I want to speak to the memory of my aunt, who stopped taking the subway after September 11th because she did not feel safe in her hijab.
01:21:39
Speaker 2: So, John, the question is, to what extent has the kind of fact that that kind of
Mamdani, I guess, reinterpretation of who the real victims are, how much has that played out in America and how important was this 25th anniversary?
01:21:55
Speaker 18: Well, I think the attitude that Mamdani showed there is very common in the Democratic Party. You know, we've got El-Sayed, the Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate in Michigan, who campaigned with a guy who openly said America deserved 9-11. And the idea that the real victims of the terrorist attack were American Muslims, it's insane. But I think it's pretty widespread.
01:22:18
Speaker 2: Yeah.
01:22:19
Speaker 18: Among Democrats. So what was the impact of the 25th anniversary observance? Well, I'll tell you what the impact on me was. In the days leading up to 9-11, my Instagram feed was full of videos of the attacks of that day that I hadn't seen for a long time. And to me, the most horrifying thing that happened that day was when more than 200 people jumped or fell or leap from the top stories of the World Trade Center, crashing through glass to do that because the alternative was to be burned alive. More than 200 people, they were dropping from the top stories of that building within days. After the terrorist attacks, the TV networks got together and they said, we're not going to show those videos anymore because they're making Americans angry. Well, when I saw them again, Rowan, they made me angry. I think Americans should be angry. And I hope that more of us are angry following this observance.
01:23:24
Speaker 2: Rita.
01:23:26
Speaker 4: Well, this week also marked the one-year anniversary of Charlie Kirk's murder and we saw the celebrations that followed that and we've seen that again this week with the left using the day to.
01:23:42
Speaker 4: To again celebrate, rationalise a man being murdered for sharing his political opinions and encouraging debate. Talk to me about this normalisation of violence, of political violence amongst the modern left.
01:23:59
Speaker 18: Rita, it's very concerning. I mean, there have been at least three attempts that we know of to assassinate President Trump, and I haven't seen any high-ranking Democrats really express concern about that. You know, I think they're hoping that one of these days they're going to get him. And healthcare executive Brian Thompson was murdered by Luigi Mangione. Luigi is now a hero. to many, many members of the Democratic Party. That is not a tiny splinter minority. That's a, it's a lot of people. And so this, this normalization of violence is something that I think is a, is a terrible, terrible problem.
01:24:36
Speaker 6: And John, you know, one of the things that struck me too, is the way that now with the 9-11 commemorations, we have seen the conflation of 9-11 with Palestine. And we have seen all sorts of people. I've played some idiots going around with Palestinian flags at the commemoration. We've seen other things. We saw somebody run onto the field at Yankee Stadium. with a Palestinian flag timed
for 9.11pm on 9.11, and he was pelted rightly with beer cans, which is fantastic, but the fact that the Palestine cause, you know, has gone from being, oh, the poor, oppressed people of Palestine to, you know, we support the Palestinians, we support 9.11.
01:25:23
Speaker 18: Well, yeah, that's exactly right. I mean, you know, I think it's important to remember that the terrorists don't hate America because of Israel. They hate Israel because it's Western. You know, we're the great Satan. Israel is the little Satan. We're the ones they really hate. And so, you know, the fact that these terrorists also, you know, it's about Gaza, it's about genocide, it's about hating Israel, sure. But as I say, we're the ones that they really hate. And we've seen this anti-Semitism take really a leading role in the ideology, again, of the Democratic Party. And it is very, very concerning.
01:26:00
Speaker 2: John, we've had... Donald Trump's had a midterm kind of rally. He's got them all back out again. When he throws a party, everybody turns up, unlike our climate change minister here, who throws a multimillion-dollar party and nobody shows up. But Donald Trump threw a party and everybody was there. I want to get your thoughts on it. Here's just a little clip of it.
01:26:21
Speaker 19: I will issue a dividend to every adult citizen in the United States of America for $ 5, 000. The only caveat I have is that the dividend that we're making must be spent in the United States of America.
01:26:39
Speaker 2: So that's not a bad way to entice people. John, what did you make of it? What does America make of it? How will you spend your five grand? You can get a flight out here. You can come on the set with us.
01:26:50
Speaker 13: Rowan, I'm not going to get it.
01:26:51
Speaker 18: There's no way that gets to Congress. What's going on here, Rowan, is that the Republicans have a serious problem because there are millions of Donald Trump fans who don't turn out to vote when he's not on the ballot. His enemies, the Democrats who hate him, they do turn out. His fans, like in 2022, didn't turn out. And so the whole point of this midterm convention was it was not to reach out to people in the middle. It was to motivate Trump fans to to understand that it's important that they vote in this midterm election. Whether it worked or not, I have no idea. I guess we'll find out in November.
01:27:31
Speaker 2: Rita?
01:27:32
Speaker 4: Well, leading up to the midterms, what are the critical issues? Obviously, cost of living is top of mind, but this ongoing conflict with Iran isn't helping the Republicans.
01:27:46
Speaker 2: Well, no, it isn't, Rita.
01:27:47
Speaker 18: I mean, most American voters, for better or worse, don't care much about foreign policy. The fact that Iran wants to rain nuclear weapons on New York and Washington, D.C. is a very abstract concern. An increase in the price of gasoline. in the eyes of most voters, is more important. And I give President Trump a lot
of credit. He understands the importance of this mission, of degrading the ability of the Iranian regime to attack America and our allies. And he's not being deterred by the fact that in the short term, it is hurting his political prospects. So, again, we'll just have to see how much impact it has in November.
01:28:29
Speaker 2: John Heinrich, it was great to have you on. Thanks so much for coming on. And we'll speak again very soon. And now we're going to take a short break. But when we come back, we've got some wallies and some celebrities. Lots to talk about here on Outsiders. Don't go away, because we will be back in a tick. Well, of course, Trafalgar Square in London celebrates the success of Nelson over Trafalgar at the Battle of Trafalgar over Napoleon. It's a very iconic place. You'll have been there. Centre of London there. They've got various statues, a very famous tall one, which has got Nelson on the top. They've now brought us a new modern statue and a modern work of art. And here she is. She's called the Lady in Blue. And it's a black woman who looks like she's heading off shopping or something. I'm not sure what she's doing. She's an everywoman, according to the artist. And let's have a listen to the artist, who I might be giving a nomination for Wally of the Week for to the artist. Have a listen.
01:29:41
Speaker 5: I've been working on this sculpture for about three years. It was produced at Factum in Madrid. And I think of her, Lady in Blue, as being an every woman. She's a quotidian figure. She's a young metropolitan woman.
01:29:52
Speaker 4: And I feel like all individuals that see her, if they allow themselves to, can identify with her.
01:29:59
Speaker 2: So there we go. Full woke, full woke. I'm not sure how, you know, it fits in with the history of Trafalgar Square, but I guess that's decolonisation for you.
01:30:06
Speaker 5: The less media love it.
01:30:08
Speaker 4: The headlines were all about how this would blow against the white patriarchy.
01:30:12
Speaker 12: Of course.
01:30:13
Speaker 5: I dislike it because it's a hideous work of art. Art should be beautiful.
01:30:17
Speaker 4: Art should, especially when it's public sculpture in a place like that, a significant landmark, it should be a thing of beauty.
01:30:27
Speaker 5: And that is not beautiful. And the artistic merit of that, oh, jeez.
01:30:32
Speaker 6: Well, the worst bit about it.
01:30:33
Speaker 2: It's embarrassing.
01:30:34
Speaker 6: It's not just embarrassing.
01:30:35
Speaker 2: It's boring.
01:30:37
Speaker 6: It's so boring. It is so every trope. Oh, we're going to subvert whiteness. So it's going to be a black woman. We're going to make her figure subvert traditional notions of beauty. We're going to do this. We're going to do that. It is all so obvious. trite first year university student. It's not even the fact that it's not beautiful, it's the fact that it is so blatantly political and so blatantly boring.
01:31:08
Speaker 2: Well, it
does look like she's sort of rushing to catch the Charing Cross train or the Tube or something or other and she's running late. Well, hooray for her. It's Sadiq Khan's London, so she's probably running away from a pickpocketer or something.
01:31:20
Speaker 6: Yeah, fine. Give me back my phone, she's saying. Give me back my phone.
01:31:24
Speaker 2: Anyway, actually, Sadiq Khan gets the Wally of the Week for that one. The artist, I'm no doubt, was just... just given a grant and went, yeah, you beat me.
01:31:33
Speaker 6: Well, she applied for it.
01:31:34
Speaker 2: Well, there you go.
01:31:35
Speaker 6: So, you know, come on, it wasn't like, oh, I just landed all this money here and I'm going to make a big statue of a black woman. Like, come on.
01:31:42
Speaker 2: Rita, who have you got for us?
01:31:44
Speaker 4: Well, the Lindsay Clancy case has really exposed just the depths of the sickness in the hearts of, well, many people in the West. And Oprah Winfrey thought, oh, yes, let's, Just lean into this. Let's celebrate this insanity and listen to this woman that hopes that a black woman who murders her children in a similar fashion gets as much sympathy as Lindsay Clancy has.
01:32:10
Speaker 20: I want us to have the same passion for people who don't look like Lindsay, who don't have her same access.
01:32:19
Speaker 12: Yeah.
01:32:23
Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah.
01:32:25
Speaker 20: Who don't have her same access. and education, her melanin, her privilege.
01:32:33
Speaker 5: Yes, let's all.
01:32:34
Speaker 4: Clap politely for the concept of a woman who researched, meticulously planned, and then brutally murdered three little babies, three children.
01:32:47
Speaker 5: Youngest eight months old.
01:32:49
Speaker 4: And, I mean, it is hard to fathom the sickness at the heart of the US economy. justice system in the blue states where your jury pool is suspect, to say the least. And we know there was one lone juror, one lone juror who withstood the bullying, the attacks, every other juror trying to get him to acquit this woman, find her not guilty. And we knew he was one of the men. There was only three men in this jury and we knew he was one of the men. We only found out this week, and we found out with Gayle King, who's holding this interview, that it was a black man.
01:33:28
Speaker 5: Have a look.
01:33:30
Speaker 1: One person of color was a person of color, a woman or a man?
01:33:33
Speaker 7: A man.
01:33:34
Speaker 2: A man.
01:33:36
Speaker 1: Is a holdout juror a black man?
01:33:40
Speaker 2: Yes.
01:33:41
Speaker 1: A black man is a holdout juror?
01:33:42
Speaker 2: Yes.
01:33:45
Speaker 1: Well, I have to sit with that for just a second.
01:33:49
Speaker 4: Yes, Gail, let's have to sit with that because this man has been maligned, attacked, not just by the defence attorney but by people on the internet, mainstream media commentators. They've tried to dox him. They've tried to destroy his life. All, James, because he said she murdered three babies. At the end of the day, that's what matters beyond whatever.
01:34:13
Speaker 4: Defense strategy that they dreamt up with her hearing voices just once in her life, just once.
01:34:20
Speaker 5: The voices came.
01:34:21
Speaker 4: The voices stopped when she took a phone call mid-murder. She stopped then. She sounded normal. But then she went back, the voices came back, and she went back to murdering.
01:34:29
Speaker 6: So, extraordinary times. It's nothing sort of demonic. And we have to really remember... you know, the nature of this crime. It was so horrific, I don't want to talk about how bad it was. It was, you know, really awful. And yet we've heard jurors, these female jurors, come out and say things like, you know, this holdout juror, this holdout juror, he couldn't get over the fact that she brutally killed her three kids, brutally murdered her three kids. One of the jurors said that. Another one said, oh, but she had to be a loving mother because, you know, there was a big... sign in the House that said, it's a wonderful life. There was all of this really trite stuff. They loved the defense attorney and were just, you know, he played them like a fiddle. But I don't know how the American jury system survives if, you know, you get put on a difficult case and you're saying, I know that this is a result, but if I don't go with the result that I was supposed to, you know, in a totalitarian country, the government survives. puts you in jail and tortures you. In our system, we just simply outsource the role of destroying your life to the media. And have a look at this here. These supporters, look at this one here who is, again, talking about the fact that one of the jurors was black.
01:35:45
Speaker 5: This one's a non-practicing white.
01:35:47
Speaker 6: Have a look.
01:35:50
Speaker 5: The holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial was a black man. And I'm not going to share any opinions because I'm not a person of color.
01:35:57
Speaker 1: I am a non-practicing white.
01:36:00
Speaker 6: A non-practising white. I love that. And I looked it up. Apparently there is such a thing that in sort of woke world they call a non-practising white. I don't even know what that is.
01:36:08
Speaker 2: But the key line there was, I'm not going to say anything. So this whole woke thing is about silencing you. No free speech. I dare not voice an opinion because there's a black person involved. When you went back to the earlier person, you know, she was saying... Something about melanin. This was the big thing. Melanin is some mystical character. Rowan? This is what they're teaching kids.
01:36:28
Speaker 6: Let a strong woman of colour speak here. She has the floor.
01:36:31
Speaker 5: Thank you.
01:36:32
Speaker 4: Well, I think if you can identify as a man, if you can identify as a plural, why can't you identify as a non-practising white? Why can't you be a trans race person and say... I don't identify as my race, which is
essentially what that young lady was doing. So, you know, if we're going to go all in, let them.
01:36:51
Speaker 5: Go all in.
01:36:52
Speaker 2: James, what have you got for us?
01:36:53
Speaker 6: Oh, let's see. We've also got Andrew Lee.
01:36:56
Speaker 2: Oh, yes.
01:36:57
Speaker 6: Andrew Lee. He is the... I think he's the Assistant Competitions Minister. But I think I referenced this earlier, but let's have a look at what he is talking about when it comes to censoring the internet. Oh, sorry, I didn't mean censoring the internet. I meant digital duty of care.
01:37:13
Speaker 17: But this isn't going to affect adults' freedom of speech. It's simply the ability to opt out of an algorithm which we know has been polarising people. And not just polarising politics, Patricia. We've seen a significant divergence in attitudes of young men and young women on gender issues, for example, with young men now having more conservative gender attitudes than my generation of Gen X.
01:37:36
Speaker 6: So there you have it there. You see, the internet is making people have conservative opinions and therefore we've got to smack it down.
01:37:44
Speaker 2: He actually said it.
01:37:45
Speaker 6: He said the quiet part loud.
01:37:46
Speaker 2: He said that this is about stopping young people having conservative views, more or less, to paraphrase what he was saying. But that's clearly what is in the mindset of Labor.
01:37:56
Speaker 4: Well, they're shook because through the education system, through the culture, they've seen young women via further and further left.
01:38:06
Speaker 5: to a.
01:38:06
Speaker 4: Point that we've got a disturbing number of young women who've got mental health issues, like a disturbing percentage who have been diagnosed with a mental health illness and are up on.
01:38:17
Speaker 2: Drugs for it.
01:38:19
Speaker 4: So that is a societal issue that we need to grapple with. But at the same time, young men have gone the other way, and mainly through the internet, from Jordan Peterson to much smaller voices.
01:38:32
Speaker 2: Because they're watching to the rubbish they're learning in school. Absolutely.
01:38:34
Speaker 1: And they're, like.
01:38:35
Speaker 4: We're sick of being blamed for every... We're sick of being told we're toxic males and the patriarchy is the root of all evil, and they're resisting that indoctrination... And the left.
01:38:47
Speaker 6: Don't like that. And, you know, it's just like, you're talking about the manosphere, but, like, the Lindsay Clancy thing, that shows that there's this whole woman's sphere of really toxic stuff out there, and if a man killed his kids and was treated like that by men, you would never hear the end of it. And rightfully so, by the way.
01:39:04
Speaker 2: We've got to vote for our Wally of the Week, and I say Andrew Lee's got to be Wally of the Week, because it's our free speech he's threatening. It's the young people of Australia that he's threatening. to censor their ability to make up their own minds about politics, and I think that is an absolute disgrace. Yeah. Wally of the Week, Andrew Lee. So many members of the Labor Party have that trophy up on their wall, the Wally of the Week award.
01:39:26
Speaker 6: Well, we've got a whole box of them.
01:39:28
Speaker 2: Going to take a short break. Coming back with some celebrity news. We'll be right back. Yes, you're watching Outsiders, and thank you so much for watching us every Sunday morning. We certainly do appreciate your company, and we're glad we can be with you in this crazy world that we're living in at the moment, including some of the crazy celebrities. Rita, who have you got for us?
01:39:54
Speaker 4: Oh, well, let's start with Sandra Bullock, A-list Hollywood star, who seems to think it's not safe for black folk outside.
01:40:03
Speaker 1: I'm uber paranoid, and they will tell you.
01:40:05
Speaker 13: They're like, Mum's going to be fine.
01:40:07
Speaker 2: I'm like, it's not fine.
01:40:08
Speaker 1: It's not fine outside.
01:40:11
Speaker 4: No, because her children, you see, are black. And because of that, she thinks they're in danger once they step foot outside her mansion.
01:40:20
Speaker 5: So thank you, Sandra.
01:40:22
Speaker 6: Well, could that be because they live in some Democrat hellhole with really high crime? Possibly.
01:40:27
Speaker 2: Possibly.
01:40:28
Speaker 4: But I would imagine it would also be a very safe gated community that is.
01:40:31
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:40:32
Speaker 4: You know, got all that security that they deny everybody else, private police and the like.
01:40:38
Speaker 2: This obsession with race, it's so sad. If you go back to, you know, Morgan Freeman back in the 80s or 90s when he was saying, just never talk about race again and racism.
01:40:48
Speaker 6: I do have to say that, like... That's how it used to be. It wasn't there. When I was a child growing up in the United States, it was such an effort to solve the racial issue and the racial divide and it was awful. really pretty much settled mostly. And then Barack Obama came along and he absolutely picked every single scab of racial grievance on the American body politic. And, you know, we're still paying the price for that.
01:41:10
Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly.
01:41:12
Speaker 6: Annie Lennox.
01:41:13
Speaker 2: So Annie Lennox, the singer, she has some interesting thoughts on Gaza. Of course she does. Of course.
01:41:20
Speaker 12: I find it so hard to believe that grown men and women could support the slaughtering in the thousands of children. As if it's just normal, as if it's just the right thing to do. As if Palestinians were, yeah, we should kill them. They need to be all killed. We need to, we just need to destroy them.
01:41:51
Speaker 2: No one said that.
01:41:54
Speaker 4: Exactly which people are saying this? Who is saying this? It's OK to slaughter Palestinians.
01:42:00
Speaker 6: Nobody. It's nonsense.
01:42:01
Speaker 2: It's all been debunked.
01:42:02
Speaker 6: It's a blood libel.
01:42:03
Speaker 2: This is how these celebrities get off. They love this kind of Gaza porn or whatever you want to call it. It's sick. Anyway, that's it for us for Outsiders. We'll be back next Sunday. Don't forget, Friday nights, World According to Rowan Dean, US Report with James Morrow, Rita Panney, Lefty's Losing It, and, of course, all week, Rita Panney, every night at 11. See you next Sunday. Bye.