תעתיק 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Murder Homes is a production of iHeart Podcasts.
00:00:17
Speaker 2: See what You're reporting A girl Hunger? It's an old across from.
00:00:26
Speaker 3: The hotel play that you the today.
00:00:30
Speaker 1: Okay, so what is the end there? On July thirteenth, twenty eleven, it seemed like any summer morning in Coronado, California. Waiters swept crumbs off the white tablecloths at the Grand Victorian Hotel del Coronado and refreshed tourist coffee cups. Surfers paddled into the first pale blue swells of the day, and the first batches of sun Bayth's wandered down to the beach, umbrellas and coolers in hand. But that early morning tranquility was soon broken by the clattering sound of a police helicopter hovering over a sprawling mansion that overlooked the ocean. Soon three other news helicopters joined in the cloudless blue sky, their cameras trained on the nude body of a young woman lying in the courtyard below, her wrists still bound with bright red polypropylene rope. The young woman who was found in the courtyard was named Rebecca Zow, a Burmese American immigrant who was thirty two years old. She had been found hanging from a wrought iron balcony at the mansion, where she'd been staying by herself the previous night, except for one other person who was sleeping in the guest home. His name was Adam Shacknai and he was the brother of Rebecca's boyfriend, Jonah. Adam had flown in the day before because of a family emergency. Jonah's son Max had fallen from the second floor staircase of the mansion and critically injured himself. Rebecca had picked Adam up at the airport because Jonah had been keeping vigil by his son's bedside in the hospital. The Grand Home, known as Spreckel's Mansion for the sugar company tycoon who had commissioned it, is a ten bedroom mansion that boasts one of the best locations in San Diego County. Directly across the street from the beach, the historic home offers glorious views of the Pacific Ocean. Boasting high wood beam ceilings, wrought iron balconies, and red tail roofing, the ten thy, five hundred square foot mansion is considered one of the architectural jewels of Karnada. Now it is known as the location of Rebecca Zoo's mysterious death. This is Murder Holmes. I'm Matt Murdovitch. According to Rebecca's autopsy report, her ankles had been bound and her arms tied behind her back. A black T shirt used to gag her mouth. The death had been ruled a suicide. The moment the medical examiner made is the term nation. He set off a controversy that has continued to divide the Coronado community to this day. Authorities believe they had a credible motive for self harm. Rebecca was distraught after Max, who she was caring for, had critically injured himself. Though she had told police she had tried to perform CPR and the critically injured boy, his condition was worsening. At the time of her death. Her boyfriend and the boy's father, Jonah Shackni, was in a state of shock. He had not returned to the
Load full transcript
mansion the night before Rebecca was found hanging. Only two people occupied the sprawling home that final night, Adam Shackney and Rebecca. Just before she is said to have killed herself, Zao had illigedly written the following words in black paint on the bedroom door that she had been using as her art studio inside the home. This is what it said. She saved him, Can he save her? The medical examiner said she had gagged herself, tied a rope around the bed, wrapped the other end of it around her neck, bound her feet and hands, and threw herself off the second floor balcony. Adam Shakni had found her early in the morning of the thirteenth, hanging from the balcony in the rear courtyard. He was going to fetch an early morning cup of coffee when he saw her suspended, lifeless, and then he told the police he cut her down. At the time of her death, Zio's boyfriend, Jonah Shakni, was CEO of Medicis Pharmaceuticals, a medical cosmetic company that was worth two point six billion dollars. Jonah had purchased Spreckl's mansion in two thousand and seven. Rebecca and Jonah had met in two thousand and eight, when she was still married and working as an ophthalmic technician. She got along well with his son Max, to the point where the boy's mother became a little jealous. In terms of her past there was one notable event that occurred a year after she had met Jonah. She had shoplifted one thousand dollars worth of jewelry from Macy's in Phoenix, Arizona. It was strange because she was a year into a earlytionship with a man who was the ninth wealthiest CEO in the state. I spoke to Caitlin Crowther, author of Death on Ocean Boulevard, the New York Times best selling book about the Rebecca's out case. A native of San Diego, Caitlyn's interest was immediately piqued by the mysterious death. Here's what Caitlyn told me.
00:05:19
Speaker 3: I think one thing is that pretty much everyone that comes up to me says she was definitely murdered. Nobody wants to believe that a woman would do this to herself. That's what I hear primarily over and over again. A woman would never do this to herself.
00:05:36
Speaker 1: Caitlyn spoke to Jonah shack Night, Rebecca's boyfriend, a number of times as research for her book. She said that her interviews with him left her with more questions than answers.
00:05:46
Speaker 3: Jonah I interviewed eight times on Skype for an hour and a half two hours each time, and that was right before I was about to turn the book in, so I had to go back in and rewrite a bunch of stuff, change a bunch of stuff. But it was great because he was her boyfriend and he knew her really well, and what he told me basically showed that she was not the person that her family really thought she was. That's what she showed them, But she had other parts to her that she showed other people. She told different stories to different people about the same thing that happened, but everybody got a different version. He says now that he thinks that she killed herself, but
initially he was more concerned that somebody might be after him because he didn't think she would have done this to him the way that she did it, because it would have brought such embarrassment to him, and it was causing his stock to fall because he looked like he was a suspect, and he actually asked the Sheriff's department, can't you publicly declare that I'm not a suspect, which is what caused people to believe that he was asking for special treatment and that the Sheriff's department gave him special treatment, and that's where us case really took off.
00:07:03
Speaker 1: We'll be back after a short break. We're back with murder Hums. After the medical examiner ruled Zao's death suicide, authorities considered the case closed. But if they hoped this would make it go away, they were mistaken. From the moment TV helicopters had hovered over Spreckel's mansion, filming her nude body on the grass. The case became a favorite of true crime buffs and internet sluice. The Zoo family, who always felt their daughter was murdered, were also infuriated, and they finally got their day in court. Although it was a civil trial, they were still finally able to face the man who they believed in murdered Rebecca and cold blood Adam Shacknei Jonah Shacknai's beloved brother. Even the sheriff, Bill Gore, admitted that he understood the public's skepticism about what had happened at Spreckel's mansion. It's an unusual case, he said. It lends itself to conspiracy theories. There were many areas of concern, but these were quickly distilled into the six biggest mysteries about Rebecca's death. Just like the knots found on Rebecca's body, they tended to tighten as more and more experts pulled on them in an effort to untangle fact from fiction. The first mystery is how had Rebecca managed to tie her arms behind her own back before leaping to her death. I asked Caitlin what she knew.
00:08:24
Speaker 3: About this, So there's a lot to do with the knots during the trial, and also what Adam told me in an interview on the witness stand. He said, you know, yes, I'm a talk about captain, but I don't know how to tie these knots. And he told me afterwards he was upset with his attorneys because he felt like they were complicated knots when the attorneys tried to make it sound very simple, like a bird or a monkey could tie these knots. And so Adam basically said, you know, I have to take these tests, but I don't know how to tie these knots. And in fact, I did some research and I think that there this Japanese erotic bondage art form. And so my question is who in this case knows about bondage because it's a weird way to be tied up. I mean, if she did it to herself, where would she get that idea. There's nothing on her computer that showed she ever did any research into this. I asked Jonah Shacknai straight out, did you guys have this in your relationship? He says, not with me, So that's one of the mysteries. But when we were in trial, this is a house expert did this super complicated series of knots and said, this is how I think they were done. I have examined the knots because they saved them. They pulled them off her body and put them on cardboard tubes, and the Sheriff's department also did a video to show that this is how it could have been done. He said, whatever the sheriff did was a much more simplified version of what was actually on her body.
00:10:07
Speaker 1: Caitlin's mention of the possibility that the knots found on Rebecca's wrists and ankles might have been tied to a Japanese bondage form got me thinking what if it were, and who might I ask? I decided I had to talk to someone who knew a lot about knots and a rope play in Japanese bondage, or more specifically, a type of rope play in the BDSM community called shabari. Shabari is the act of restricting the mobility of the human body with the help of thin ropes. These thin ropes are known as asanawa. I connected with one of the most renowned practitioners of shabari, a Russian named Maxim Kalahari, whose invite only bondage workshops in far flung exotic locales that goa have become infamous. He spoke to me from Indonesia with his girlfriend translating so with Rebecca Zau. Did you get a chance to look at the photographs?
00:11:01
Speaker 2: Yes, yes, yes, I see.
00:11:03
Speaker 1: Is it possible that that kind of knot would be used in road play or b d s m as.
00:11:12
Speaker 2: He said that for sure this not is done not by professional.
00:11:17
Speaker 1: That's very interesting. Is it something that's ever used in road play or bondage the corregion Mochi.
00:11:31
Speaker 2: Yo us He says that this not looks like the not that could be done by a person who do it first time or done not often, so it's not professional one.
00:11:48
Speaker 1: But to go back to the question in the community, I'm going to say road play is part of maybe B D S M. Right. Have you ever seen it use like a clove hitch, not as far as with shabari or role play.
00:12:01
Speaker 2: No, no, it's not sabari. In Sabari we always tart time double ropes. We don't time single ropes. The person who has done this do it very quickly.
00:12:14
Speaker 1: That's really interesting.
00:12:15
Speaker 2: He was in hurry or the model if resistance it was like a role play, she played like she wanted to escape or not without He can think about three reasons on he never do this before, or he was in hurry, very in hurry, or she did some resistance without any knowledge about how to do and practice his things that it's impossible to do herself. Behind that, the.
00:13:00
Speaker 1: Highly staged nature of the alleged suicide, the intricate binding of wrist ankles, the gag in the mouth, the nudity, it did seem beyond the capability of a highly distraught, suicidal person. Seven years later, at a civil trial, Rebecca Zo's family finally had the feeling that there might be some closure. The jury listened as Rebecca's family lawyer walked them through the final hour, again sketching out
what he had believed happened. Handwriting expert was brought to the stand to testify that the message painted on the door fit Shacknai's handwriting pattern. A knot tying expert was brought into the courtroom to demonstrate that the knots were most likely tied by someone other than Zau. He leaned over a mannekin draped with a white sheet, and jurors watched him retie the same knots that had bound Rebecca. He tightened the rope and figure eights and explained the clove hitch and overhand knots. Adam Shakni, the lawyer, pointed out, was well versed in the use of knots, of which the clove hitch was one. He was a tugboat captain on the Mississippi River. Adam Shackni's lawyer countered that his client's DNA had never been found on the rope, not one strand of it. Is it conceivable that it might have been wiped down, or, as Caitlin Rother suggested when we spoke, that someone could have used gloves. Sure, that was a theoretical possibility, but nothing else connected him to the bedroom where Rebecca had spent her last moments. A sheriff's investigator would later demonstrate how Rebecca could slip one hand out, hold both hands behind her back, slip her loose hand back into the knot, and tighten it, which brings us to the second mystery of the Zou case. The seven words Rebecca had allegedly painted on the bedroom door she saved him? Can you save her? The plaintiff's lawyer contended that they had been left by Adam Shacknin after the handwriting analyst left the stand. Adam Shackni's lawyer countered that a murderer wouldn't want to draw attention to himself by leaving a message on the wall. He told the jury that the cryptic message would have been left by Rebecca, who was not in a rational state of mind. The message itself, to me is tantalizing. It both makes sense and doesn't. She saved him contradicts what actually happen. Considering that Rebecca had told Jonah she was in the bathroom at the moment Max had fallen from the second floor staircase, can you say of her? Is even more mysterious. Is she talking about Max or Jonah or someone else? Or is this really Adam's handwriting trying to throw police off his track. Adam Shacknay, the younger, devoted brother, would have felt enraged too after seeing his nephew, six year old Max, in critical condition at the hospital. Would he have felt so overwhelmed with anger that he waited until Rebecca fell asleep that night? Could he have bludgeoned her unconscious, bound her, gagged her, and thrown her over the balcony, watching her swing just a few feef in the lush manicured grass, her toenails painted a glossy red. What did the seven words painted in black on the door? She saved him? Can he save her?
00:16:02
Speaker 3: Mean?
00:16:03
Speaker 1: And is it conceivable that someone besides Rebecca had left them there? Here's what Caitlyn told me.
00:16:09
Speaker 3: Nobody is willing to say what that message really means because nobody really knows. But she came from a religious family, she had a religious upbringing. You can you save her? Could be God? I heard one theory that she was angry with Jonah, which is reflected in the note as I mentioned, and that maybe this was a message to him what she did to herself. If it was a suicide, that she was angry at him, and wanted to embarrass him. So, I mean you, I don't know if you use Jonah, is you God? Is you the killer? I mean, who is it? We don't know who it is. But the fact of the matter is is a very strange message. The strokes with the paint look pretty angry. There have been other people who are staging scene experts who say the whole scene was angry. She was placed in this demeaning position with her hands tied behind her, her ankles bound. The house attorney also suggested that she may have been hogtied previously. Yes, the lividity of her body and the way the blood is positioned only on one side of the body and not in her feet where it should have been when she was hanging. There's so many things with this. The fact that she wasn't decapitated. If she really fell with that force nine feet jumping off, why wasn't she decapitated from the force of it. Why did she only have these minor injuries with the cartilage's very similar injuries by the way with Jeffrey Epstein.
00:17:41
Speaker 1: And then there's the third mystery, the latex glove and menstrul blood found on a knife in the bedroom a latex glove was found in a crawl space under the guest house where Adam was staying. Was this evidence that Adam had used the glove to hide his fingerprints. The defense stressed that there were no visible signs that the latex glove may cometac with any surface. At one of fourth Reocean Boulevard, including the bedroom where Zoo spent her final moments, the zal family attorney said that a knife had been found in Rebecca's bedroom with menstrual blood on the handle. He said that this was evidence that it was inserted into her body in a sexual assault. The medical Examiner's office found no evidence of a sexual assault. The fourth mystery is Rebecca's blunt force injuries. Four blunt force injuries were found on Rebecca's head in the autopsy. The prosecution maintained these wounds were caused after Rebecca jumped off the balcony and subsequently hid her head on the balcony floor as she swung back and forth. The lawyer representing Zao's family had this theory. Adam had hit her over the head with a blunt object, rendering her semi or fully unconscious, molested her, and then Hogg tied her with the bright red rope, carrying her over to the balcony, cutting the part of the rope that connected hands and feet, then threw her off the balcony, the rope instantly snapping taut around the foot of the bed. In this version, Adam knows full well what he'll find when he emerges from the guest house in the morning. He takes his sweet time cutting her down, and she lands with a stiff thud. He stands over her and starts getting into character for the call he has to place to nine one one. The fifth Mystery the call to nine one
one. The call Adam Shackney makes to nine one one is unnerving, and not just because he is audibly distraught. He tells the dispatcher that he's got a girl who hung herself, but when asked for the address, draws a blank twice, giving the dispatcher the wrong address before telling her he'll have to call her back. When he finally manages to give the dispatcher the right address of his own brother's home and the place he's been staying, he seems unable to come up with the most basic details of who the dead woman is. Telling the dispatcher quote, she came yesterday to pick up a little boy. Caitlin Crother finds other things Adam did that morning also a little unerving.
00:20:00
Speaker 3: He had woken up six point fifteen, said he felt some nervous energy, so he pleasured himself while looking at porn on his cell phone, and then took a shower, so no DNA in his hands, supposedly right, and then took her down, left the knife on the grass. They found none of his DNA on the knife that he said he used to cut her down. Okay, none of his DNA anywhere. He also admits that he took ambient and I don't know if you've ever taken ambient, but I have, and it does make you kind of confused. In fact, there's this whole defense that some people have used if they've done things when they've taken ambient that they don't remember. It leaves you in this weird dream like state.
00:20:47
Speaker 1: Let's examine the sixth mystery, the missing voicemail. The day prior to her death, Rebecca picked up Adam at the airport. She then ate dinner with the two brothers before returning to the mansion with Adam. Jonah returned to his vigil at Max's bedside. Someone had called Rebecca just hours before her death and left a message, a voicemail that was never recovered, but that many felt had been left by Jonah Shacknay at his dying son's bedside in the hospital, and that he was calling to inform Rebecca about his son's grim prognosis. I asked Caitlin about the missing voicemail.
00:21:24
Speaker 3: When I asked Jonah about it, Jonah said that, and he told the Sheriff's department the same thing, that he called to leave her a message saying that they had talked to the doctor and the best prognosis for Max was that he would never walk or talk again. And what he told me was he wished he had not left that message because she didn't call back, and she always called him back, and so he was worried about her. Her family say, well, there's no proof what he said, because the message was deleted and was never recovered. Either the Sheriff's department waited too long to try to recover it from the provider, or they were very angry about that, and there's no way to prove what that message said.
00:22:16
Speaker 1: Could this have finally broken her mentally. After all, Jonah, who she was in love with, had entrusted Max to her. The worst possible thing had happened, and she would have felt that he would always hold her responsible. Any reasonable adult would have felt despondent at that moment, knowing that a child under their care would never walk or talk again. Or was Adam shack Ny, the younger devoted brother, so enraged after seeing six year old Max in critical condition that he was gripped by need for revenge? Did he wait until Rebecca fell asleep that night? Then bludging her unconscious, bind her gagger and throw her over the balcony. We'll be back after a short break, were back with murder arms. In twenty eighteen, a stunning verdict was announced. The civil jury had decided nine to three that Adam Shaknai had battered Rebecca with the intent to harm, but then, in another twist, the judgment was thrown out a year later as a settlement was reached with Adam Shackni's insurance company. It seems the insurance company had grown tired of paying the mounting cost of his legal bills, and it hoped that a figure of ten million might satisfy the family. Despite the settlement, closure for Rebecca Zoo has remained elusive. To add further insult, the Sheriff's department ruled in twenty eighteen for a second time that Zao had committed suicide. Sheriff Gore said there is no evidence that Rebecca Zaoo died at the hands of another leaning toward a cluster of microphones in a podium. He then told reporters that all of the evidence pointed to the one logical conclusion, and that was suicide. Rebecca's family attorney, Keith Greer had something to say about that finding. He called the Sheriff's review incompetent and said that his team quote gave the same stupid answers that a civil jury rejected. Adam Shackni had his own tourist statement. He said there is no evidence to support an outcome that had anything to do with Rebecca Zoo's death. Twelve years after Rebecca Zoo was found hanging from the balcony at Spreckel's mansion, her cause of death is as hotly debated as ever. The Zoo family continues to try to clear her name, as does Adam Shackni, who says his reputation has been ruined. Crother says that her book continues to be a best seller at the Caronada bookstore, and she passes by one oh four to three Ocean Boulevard whenever she is in the area. But she says it bears no resemblance to the place it once was.
00:24:50
Speaker 3: So they basically planted a bunch of palm trees out in front, you know, try to make it less vulnerable looking. Maybe they did all kinds of landscaping. I thought it looked pretty nice. The next owner came in, ripped all that out again, did a bunch of interior remodeling, and then another person bought it during the lockdown and now looks completely different. It looks like a house out of Miami. It doesn't look anything like it used to. So talking about a stigmatized house, this definitely was one.
00:25:19
Speaker 1: You're going to understand a new owner's desire to renovate a murder home until every room looks brand new. But the fact remains that Rebecca Zoo keeps calling us back inside to the bedroom where someone painted the message on the door. She invites us back into that bedroom to see the bright
red rope to imagine the knots that were meticulously tightened around her wrist before she ran towards the railing of the balcony or was pushed early that morning. Her suicide or murder was so elaborately staged that it ensured one thing, it will most likely never be forgotten. Toward the end of my interview with Caitlin, she offered another anecdote about Zoo that has nagged at me. It's vital to what happened at one O four to three Ocean Boulevard because one of the most sensitive questions about this case is whether Rebecca was mentally ill. It turned out when she was married she had another boyfriend before Jonah. When she suddenly decided to end things, she did so in a very disturbing way.
00:26:17
Speaker 3: She was never diagnosed with any mental illness, but the Sheriff's department. Part of the reason they said that they ruled it a suicide were these notes on her phone, which were written sort of as a journal entry. They looked more like letters that you would write to yourself. This is actually a psychological therapeutic technique to kind of work through your own issues. Anyway. One of them was apparently to Jonah, and she was angry at him, and there was another one, maybe the same one. But she was depressed. She was crying, she couldn't sleep. So that's what they cited when they said that they thought she killed herself. But there's another story which also contributed to her state of mind. She was with this man who I interviewed also for the book, and he thought they were boyfriend and girlfriend. She was living with him for a time. She said she was going through a divorce from her husband, when in fact, nobody had filed any paperwork, so she basically disappeared, didn't come home from work one day, and he reported her missing to the Glendale Police Department, and she kept calling him and saying, they've got me. They've got me blindfolded. They're driving me around in the back of a car. I don't know where I am. It sounded like she was in a bathroom. He's like, where are you and she said, well, I'm using the bathroom. They let me go to the bathroom. So basically she said she had to go back to her husband. And when she came back to see Michael briefly a couple days later, he says, we need to go to the police, and she says, I don't want to go to the police, but they go to the police. They go to the police station, she talks to the detectives by herself. They come back and she's smiling. Everything's fine. He goes, Okay, is it my turn?
00:28:08
Speaker 2: Now?
00:28:08
Speaker 3: I have some things I want to say, and they said, no, it's fine, you can go. Well, it turns out she told them that she was breaking up with him, but she hadn't told him yet, and so this is her way of breaking up with him by saying she was kidnapped.
00:28:25
Speaker 1: It's easy to see Rebecca in those moments as someone with a screw loose, a vulnerable soul who could seem highly imbalanced when she felt stressed about something. But just as I begin shifting my opinions slightly, begin to see her slipping one arm out of the knot she is tied in front of her, then holding her wrists behind her back and slipping the arm in again. I think of Adam Shacknay and his short fuse the garbled nine one one call the precise attention one would need to pay to the elaborate knots that bound her the absence of a previous suicide attempt, the deeply flawed police investigation, and I wave can you save her? It's a question that's still relevant because whoever wrote those words is certain of one thing. That Rebecca's death has changed nothing. She's still waiting for an answer. In June twenty thirteen, Jonah Shacknai put the mansion where Rebecca died on the market, finally selling it for nine million, far less than the asking price. This is Murder Holmes. I'm Matt mrin Ivitch. Murder Holmes is created by an executive producer by Matt Mrinovich. Executive producers are Jennifer Bassett and Taylor Chakogne. Story editor is Jennifer Bassett. Supervising producer is Carl Katl. Producer is Evan Tyr. Sound design by taylos Chicoine, Evan Tyre and Carl Catl. Special thanks to Ali Perry and Nicietour. Murder Holmes is a production of iHeart Podcasts. For more shows from iHeart Podcasts, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.