תעתיק 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.470 --> 00:00:01.409
This week on Inside Olympiad.
2
00:00:31.250 --> 00:00:35.500
Should Washington opt into President Trump's school choice tax credit?
3
00:00:35.920 --> 00:00:38.520
The deadline to decide is coming up, and a chorus
4
00:00:38.560 --> 00:00:41.920
of voices on the left and right say yes. But
5
00:00:41.960 --> 00:00:45.649
opponents insist it's a bad deal for Washington. We debate
6
00:00:45.689 --> 00:00:48.869
this issue on the program Laura Ruderman, CEO of the
7
00:00:48.929 --> 00:00:52.950
Technology Alliance, and Mike Priner, founder of the Math Agency,
8
00:00:53.369 --> 00:00:56.310
plus State Superintendent of Schools Chris Reykdal.
9
00:01:01.700 --> 00:01:08.540
From the TVW studio, it's Inside Olympia with host Austin Jenkins.
10
00:01:10.500 --> 00:01:14.019
Welcome to Inside Olympia. Washington Governor Bob Ferguson has until
11
00:01:14.040 --> 00:01:16.340
the end of the year to decide whether to opt
12
00:01:16.459 --> 00:01:21.200
Washington into President Trump's Education Freedom Tax Credit, a school
13
00:01:21.219 --> 00:01:24.920
choice program baked into the president's One Big Beautiful Bill Act,
14
00:01:25.319 --> 00:01:28.180
which was signed into law last year. It's billed as
15
00:01:28.239 --> 00:01:31.870
a school choice options program. A range of individuals and
16
00:01:31.909 --> 00:01:34.530
groups on both sides of the aisle is urging Governor
17
00:01:34.549 --> 00:01:38.590
Bob Ferguson to opt Washington into the program. Others say
18
00:01:38.670 --> 00:01:42.280
Washington should not participate, arguing it will benefit families who
19
00:01:42.310 --> 00:01:45.180
send their kids to private or religious schools more than
20
00:01:45.239 --> 00:01:48.879
public school students, while adding to the national debt. Here's
21
00:01:48.900 --> 00:01:52.659
how the program works. Taxpayers can earn a dollar-for-dollar tax
22
00:01:52.719 --> 00:01:54.609
credit of up to $ 1, 700 for an individual and $ 3, 400
23
00:01:54.480 --> 00:01:59.329
for a married couple if they make a cash contribution
24
00:01:59.390 --> 00:02:04.790
to a qualified scholarship-granting organization, or SGO. The SGOs, in turn,
25
00:02:04.829 --> 00:02:07.549
can use the funds to offset tuition to private or
26
00:02:07.609 --> 00:02:13.060
sectarian schools, or provide funds for tutoring, after-school programs, school supplies,
27
00:02:13.340 --> 00:02:17.400
or other educational services. Families making up to 300% of
28
00:02:17.439 --> 00:02:20.259
an area's median gross income, which in some places is
29
00:02:20.300 --> 00:02:22.939
well into the six figures, can qualify for the grants.
30
00:02:23.780 --> 00:02:27.419
Democrats for Education Reform, a national group, has estimated that
31
00:02:27.560 --> 00:02:31.699
if 15% of eligible taxpayers participated, it would net about
32
00:02:31.699 --> 00:02:36.949
$ 750 million annually for students in Washington, twice that if
33
00:02:36.949 --> 00:02:41.409
30% participated. 31 states have opted in so far, according
34
00:02:41.430 --> 00:02:44.789
to tracking by Education Week. Washington is one of 16
35
00:02:44.789 --> 00:02:47.560
states that have not decided whether to participate in the program.
36
00:02:48.060 --> 00:02:51.240
Three states, Minnesota, Oregon, and Wisconsin, have said they will
37
00:02:51.259 --> 00:02:55.840
not participate. Governor Bob Ferguson has until January 1st to decide.
38
00:02:56.300 --> 00:02:58.919
His office told TVW that he is reviewing the rules
39
00:02:58.960 --> 00:03:01.039
of the program, but did not say when he will
40
00:03:01.060 --> 00:03:03.550
make a final decision. In our second half, we will
41
00:03:03.590 --> 00:03:06.430
talk with state school superintendent Chris Reykdal, who sent the
42
00:03:06.469 --> 00:03:09.389
governor a letter last month urging him not to opt
43
00:03:09.430 --> 00:03:12.789
Washington in. But joining me first are two supporters of
44
00:03:12.830 --> 00:03:16.509
this program. Laura Ruderman is a former Democratic state representative
45
00:03:16.789 --> 00:03:20.129
who is now CEO of Technology Alliance, which bills itself
46
00:03:20.189 --> 00:03:23.280
as a voice for the state's innovation economy. And Mike
47
00:03:23.340 --> 00:03:26.860
Priner is founder of the math agency, which partners with
48
00:03:26.900 --> 00:03:30.139
schools to provide math coaching to low income students. Welcome
49
00:03:30.259 --> 00:03:31.060
both of you inside Olympia.
50
00:03:31.080 --> 00:03:31.449
Good to see you.
51
00:03:31.659 --> 00:03:32.219
Thanks for being here.
52
00:03:32.479 --> 00:03:33.159
Thanks for having us.
53
00:03:33.800 --> 00:03:38.659
So big picture. This is a tax policy that is
54
00:03:38.699 --> 00:03:41.740
associated with president Donald Trump, who is not super popular
55
00:03:41.800 --> 00:03:44.680
in this state. Uh, it is associated with a Republican
56
00:03:44.699 --> 00:03:49.500
led Congress. It is opposed by our state school superintendent,
57
00:03:49.560 --> 00:03:53.439
Chris Reykdal, fairly vociferously. Let me start with you, Laura Ruderman,
58
00:03:53.500 --> 00:03:56.620
as someone who's been in political office as a Democrat
59
00:03:56.740 --> 00:04:00.150
and is sitting here advocating for Washington to opt in.
60
00:04:00.219 --> 00:04:02.659
Why do you think this would be good for Washington,
61
00:04:02.689 --> 00:04:03.840
good for Washington students?
62
00:04:06.009 --> 00:04:09.050
Wow. Thank you, first of all, for having us. It's
63
00:04:09.270 --> 00:04:11.729
a great opportunity to be able to talk about this.
64
00:04:12.110 --> 00:04:19.610
You know, Washington State has some phenomenal students. It is
65
00:04:20.250 --> 00:04:26.009
phenomenally iconic companies in our state. We lead the nation
66
00:04:26.310 --> 00:04:30.410
when it comes to AI, cloud computing. We are the
67
00:04:30.470 --> 00:04:33.970
center of the universe when
Load full transcript
it comes to life sciences
68
00:04:34.290 --> 00:04:38.329
and AI. David Baker won the Nobel Prize for using
69
00:04:38.420 --> 00:04:42.160
AI and proteins at the Institute for Protein Design. And yet,
70
00:04:42.519 --> 00:04:47.079
when it comes to the educational attainment of our own kids,
71
00:04:47.839 --> 00:04:52.329
we are not where you might imagine that we would be.
72
00:04:53.629 --> 00:04:57.319
There is really good data from the state's Educational Research
73
00:04:57.540 --> 00:05:01.920
Data Center that eight years after graduation, less than 50%
74
00:05:01.920 --> 00:05:05.339
of our kids have any sort of post-secondary credential, a
75
00:05:05.439 --> 00:05:09.959
number that has held steady for 20 years. And yet
76
00:05:09.959 --> 00:05:13.660
70% of the jobs in our state need some sort
77
00:05:13.680 --> 00:05:19.399
of post-secondary credential. We are leaving thousands and thousands of
78
00:05:19.500 --> 00:05:22.579
kids behind. For a long time, we thought that that
79
00:05:22.639 --> 00:05:25.819
was entirely because of the cost of college. So we
80
00:05:25.860 --> 00:05:31.350
now have the most generous state-sponsored financial aid program in
81
00:05:31.379 --> 00:05:34.110
the country, and yet we are still in the bottom
82
00:05:34.149 --> 00:05:36.790
five states in the nation when it comes to our
83
00:05:37.610 --> 00:05:43.230
own kids getting a post-secondary credential. And I would argue
84
00:05:43.329 --> 00:05:48.399
that another reason major reason for that. And Mike can
85
00:05:48.439 --> 00:05:51.240
certainly talk about what he's seen. Another major reason for
86
00:05:51.279 --> 00:05:54.459
that is kids not only don't feel ready for going
87
00:05:54.540 --> 00:05:59.480
on to post-secondary, but they're not ready. And there is
88
00:05:59.800 --> 00:06:04.819
not the support in most high schools to advise them
89
00:06:05.019 --> 00:06:08.579
about what their next, the next step on their journey
90
00:06:08.689 --> 00:06:09.189
could be.
91
00:06:09.560 --> 00:06:12.069
So let me just interrupt you by saying this could
92
00:06:12.089 --> 00:06:17.370
be an argument for reinvesting in public education, for adding
93
00:06:17.410 --> 00:06:21.009
supports beyond what's happening in the classroom. But in this case,
94
00:06:21.089 --> 00:06:23.149
for purposes of this conversation, you're going to make the
95
00:06:23.170 --> 00:06:28.730
case that Washington opting into this tax credit program could
96
00:06:28.769 --> 00:06:30.949
help address some of these. And why is that?
97
00:06:31.269 --> 00:06:35.029
Absolutely. Because 90% of kids in Washington state go to
98
00:06:35.069 --> 00:06:39.439
public school. And so if I would imagine if you're
99
00:06:39.459 --> 00:06:42.779
thinking about making this contribution, if I'm thinking about making
100
00:06:42.819 --> 00:06:46.029
this contribution, we are going to make it to a
101
00:06:46.060 --> 00:06:52.509
scholarship-granting organization that is going to support our community. And
102
00:06:52.649 --> 00:06:54.689
so we're going to give it to the Boys and
103
00:06:54.709 --> 00:06:57.910
Girls Club. We're going to give it to, we can
104
00:06:57.949 --> 00:07:03.629
talk later about other entities that could be formed, for
105
00:07:03.750 --> 00:07:08.470
exactly the tutoring that kids will need to feel ready
106
00:07:08.509 --> 00:07:10.449
and be ready. And I'm going to leave it to Mike,
107
00:07:10.490 --> 00:07:14.720
who's got great data can talk about the importance of
108
00:07:14.800 --> 00:07:20.899
tutoring in terms of educational attainment, but also could be
109
00:07:21.180 --> 00:07:25.939
used for the kinds of college advising services like College
110
00:07:25.959 --> 00:07:31.480
Success Foundation that wealthy kids get, right? I had someone
111
00:07:31.519 --> 00:07:34.519
say to me when I talked about how kids at
112
00:07:34.790 --> 00:07:39.689
fancy private schools get college advising or say, well, you know,
113
00:07:40.089 --> 00:07:42.290
Seattle Public Schools is never going to be able to
114
00:07:42.370 --> 00:07:47.339
advise kids like that. And my question is, why not?
115
00:07:48.100 --> 00:07:53.779
Doesn't a kid at a college in South Seattle or
116
00:07:54.079 --> 00:07:58.699
Ferry County or Adams County deserve the opportunity to have
117
00:07:58.759 --> 00:08:04.649
that same kind of advising? Well, let's inject maybe a
118
00:08:05.149 --> 00:08:12.490
billion dollars into... the system to help with the tutoring
119
00:08:12.529 --> 00:08:15.470
that will help them get ready and the advising that
120
00:08:15.509 --> 00:08:20.279
will help them with the next steps among other things
121
00:08:20.459 --> 00:08:28.160
and really make public education the great equalizer that we
122
00:08:28.439 --> 00:08:32.230
all talk about it being and hope that it will be.
123
00:08:32.990 --> 00:08:34.730
Let me bring you into this conversation, Mike. First off,
124
00:08:34.769 --> 00:08:36.970
why don't you explain to us what the math agency
125
00:08:37.210 --> 00:08:41.269
is and then And you are an interested party. You
126
00:08:41.289 --> 00:08:44.990
can explain that, how so, but why you see value
127
00:08:45.070 --> 00:08:46.990
in the state opting into this program.
128
00:08:47.169 --> 00:08:48.110
Yeah. Thanks, Austin.
129
00:08:48.509 --> 00:08:51.620
So I run the math agency. We're a nonprofit that
130
00:08:51.679 --> 00:08:56.659
provides academic coaching or tutoring, if you will, to students
131
00:08:57.000 --> 00:09:01.730
in high poverty public schools. So we're an interested party
132
00:09:01.870 --> 00:09:05.759
in the sense that if this program it gets approved
133
00:09:05.799 --> 00:09:09.379
in Washington, the math agencies services, the tutoring services could
134
00:09:09.440 --> 00:09:13.039
partially be paid for by scholarships from these SGOs. So
135
00:09:13.080 --> 00:09:16.929
we could potentially
be a service provider to organizations providing funding.
136
00:09:17.169 --> 00:09:19.409
And potentially this would allow you to expand your offerings
137
00:09:19.450 --> 00:09:20.009
to more schools.
138
00:09:20.289 --> 00:09:20.830
Absolutely.
139
00:09:21.190 --> 00:09:22.649
And I can talk about that in a second, but
140
00:09:23.250 --> 00:09:25.289
in terms of like how to think about this from
141
00:09:25.330 --> 00:09:28.610
like a simple taxpayer perspective, which, which I am, um,
142
00:09:29.230 --> 00:09:33.149
as of today, Every taxpayer in Washington is going to
143
00:09:33.190 --> 00:09:36.389
have two options in January. You're going to be able
144
00:09:36.450 --> 00:09:41.500
to pay $ 1, 700 in taxes that goes to the federal
145
00:09:41.539 --> 00:09:45.980
government in Washington, DC, or you'll be able to give
146
00:09:46.059 --> 00:09:50.360
that $ 1, 700 to SGOs in other states to serve students
147
00:09:50.440 --> 00:09:51.019
in other states.
148
00:09:51.299 --> 00:09:52.620
Right now, those are our two options.
149
00:09:53.789 --> 00:09:58.370
Now, if the governor opts in to this program, there
150
00:09:58.389 --> 00:10:01.960
will be a third option. for every single taxpayer in Washington,
151
00:10:02.519 --> 00:10:06.000
and that is to give the $ 1, 700 to SGOs that
152
00:10:06.080 --> 00:10:08.740
serve students here in Washington.
153
00:10:09.919 --> 00:10:10.230
That's it.
154
00:10:10.570 --> 00:10:11.429
Those are our options.
155
00:10:11.850 --> 00:10:15.450
And so as a Washington taxpayer, and a parent who
156
00:10:15.529 --> 00:10:18.009
really cares about our local students here in Washington, I
157
00:10:18.309 --> 00:10:21.690
would really like to have that third option available in January.
158
00:10:22.009 --> 00:10:25.309
I know that the criticism that I anticipate hearing from
159
00:10:25.370 --> 00:10:28.470
State School Superintendent Chris Reykdal and others who are opposed
160
00:10:28.490 --> 00:10:32.509
to opting in is that the benefits are going to
161
00:10:33.529 --> 00:10:38.149
accrue primarily to kids who are going to private school,
162
00:10:38.230 --> 00:10:40.889
kids who are going to religiously affiliated schools, not to
163
00:10:40.929 --> 00:10:45.409
public school students, and that that is sort of upside
164
00:10:45.450 --> 00:10:48.029
down because, to your point, 90-plus percent of students are
165
00:10:48.149 --> 00:10:51.490
in the public schools. Laura Ruderman, what gives you confidence
166
00:10:52.710 --> 00:10:55.570
that the inverse is true, that the majority of the
167
00:10:55.629 --> 00:10:57.789
benefit would accrue to the public school students, to the
168
00:10:57.830 --> 00:11:00.009
million or so public school students of this state?
169
00:11:00.529 --> 00:11:05.799
Well, I would say the data. My kids went to
170
00:11:05.840 --> 00:11:12.139
public school. Why would I, again, as a taxpayer, and
171
00:11:12.179 --> 00:11:16.690
let's remember... If my tax bill, if I'm going to
172
00:11:16.809 --> 00:11:24.289
owe to the federal government, right, $ 1, 700, or I'm married, $ 3, 400,
173
00:11:23.009 --> 00:11:27.360
I can, as Mike said, I can pay that $ 3, 400,
174
00:11:26.759 --> 00:11:29.720
or I can contribute it to my local Boys and
175
00:11:29.740 --> 00:11:33.820
Girls Club. And I will tell you, my local Boys
176
00:11:33.860 --> 00:11:38.360
and Girls Club is not making scholarship, is not granting
177
00:11:38.379 --> 00:11:44.149
scholarships to go to private or religious schools. You're not,
178
00:11:45.830 --> 00:11:49.389
and so what is my, my confidence is, I guess
179
00:11:49.470 --> 00:11:54.429
on some level, it's people's own self-interest, right? People wanna give,
180
00:11:54.870 --> 00:11:59.009
people generally give to benefit their own communities and their
181
00:11:59.049 --> 00:12:03.490
own values. And so if my value is I want
182
00:12:03.610 --> 00:12:07.289
low-income kids to be able to get tutoring, then I'm
183
00:12:07.330 --> 00:12:12.970
gonna give my $ 3, 400 to an organization that gives grant
184
00:12:13.049 --> 00:12:17.950
scholarships for kids to get that tutoring or get that
185
00:12:18.009 --> 00:12:23.169
college advising. There may be some people for whom their
186
00:12:23.210 --> 00:12:25.570
values are they want more kids to be able to
187
00:12:25.629 --> 00:12:31.529
go to private school or Catholic school. That's fine, but
188
00:12:31.570 --> 00:12:33.919
the numbers really bear out. 90% of students go to
189
00:12:33.929 --> 00:12:43.370
public schools. When people are choosing where to make this contribution,
190
00:12:43.789 --> 00:12:47.990
if they get that choice, I can't imagine that most
191
00:12:48.070 --> 00:12:52.220
of them are going to give that money to scholarship
192
00:12:52.250 --> 00:12:56.019
granting organizations that are going to benefit some other kid
193
00:12:56.039 --> 00:13:00.679
to go to be in a situation that doesn't follow
194
00:13:00.759 --> 00:13:05.759
their values. And clearly we know that public education is
195
00:13:05.799 --> 00:13:08.370
a huge value for the people of the state of Washington.
196
00:13:08.570 --> 00:13:10.919
I think that the Further argument might be that this
197
00:13:10.960 --> 00:13:14.350
would be a self-selecting number of taxpayers who can, A, afford,
198
00:13:14.830 --> 00:13:16.620
have the tax bill that would allow them to do this,
199
00:13:16.730 --> 00:13:20.830
and secondly, that the people who might be particularly motivated
200
00:13:20.870 --> 00:13:23.169
to participate would be people whose kids are already in
201
00:13:23.570 --> 00:13:26.629
private or parochial schools. What are your thoughts, Mike, on
202
00:13:26.649 --> 00:13:30.850
sort of designing a program in this state that would
203
00:13:30.909 --> 00:13:34.250
primarily benefit, because it has been essentially billed as a
204
00:13:34.269 --> 00:13:37.149
school choice
program, and yet.
205
00:13:39.070 --> 00:13:40.950
And that's, I think, where some of the heartburn from
206
00:13:41.149 --> 00:13:42.590
those who oppose it is coming from.
207
00:13:42.950 --> 00:13:43.129
Yeah.
208
00:13:43.309 --> 00:13:46.769
So it is true that taxpayers can choose which organizations,
209
00:13:46.830 --> 00:13:50.929
which SGOs they give their money to. Personally, I'm very
210
00:13:50.990 --> 00:13:54.309
focused on public schools. Like my own three kids, my
211
00:13:54.710 --> 00:13:57.029
foster kids my family has supported have all gone to
212
00:13:57.269 --> 00:13:59.980
public schools. And the math and the work I do
213
00:14:00.019 --> 00:14:03.610
at the math agency is all in public schools. The
214
00:14:03.669 --> 00:14:07.169
fact that a small amount of the money could help
215
00:14:07.210 --> 00:14:10.889
kids in private schools doesn't bother me personally. It's a
216
00:14:10.929 --> 00:14:14.909
little bit like refusing to build roads for Washington citizens
217
00:14:14.970 --> 00:14:17.980
because we're worried that folks in Oregon, like, will come
218
00:14:18.009 --> 00:14:21.379
and also benefit from our roads, right? Like, why would
219
00:14:21.460 --> 00:14:24.600
I want to deny support to kids in public schools, again,
220
00:14:24.759 --> 00:14:28.399
a billion dollars worth of support, just to hurt kids
221
00:14:28.440 --> 00:14:30.740
in private schools who are also Washington citizens?
222
00:14:30.779 --> 00:14:34.100
But what if the concern... was validated and we did
223
00:14:34.139 --> 00:14:36.700
see 75% of the benefit accrue to kids out of
224
00:14:36.740 --> 00:14:38.279
public school. Would you still think it was worth it
225
00:14:38.299 --> 00:14:41.059
if one in four kids in public schools were benefit?
226
00:14:41.840 --> 00:14:44.000
Or 25% of the funds were going to?
227
00:14:44.019 --> 00:14:46.899
Yeah, I don't think that's realistic given that, I mean,
228
00:14:47.759 --> 00:14:50.330
if it happens, I would be very surprised given that
229
00:14:50.330 --> 00:14:52.889
90% of families go to public schools.
230
00:14:53.309 --> 00:14:54.110
So you'd have to have.
231
00:14:54.029 --> 00:14:56.389
A scenario where all of these families whose kids are
232
00:14:56.429 --> 00:14:59.029
in public schools are somehow sending their money to private schools,
233
00:14:59.070 --> 00:15:02.029
which to me seems hard to imagine here in Washington.
234
00:15:03.870 --> 00:15:06.350
I want to pick up on two things. One is
235
00:15:06.370 --> 00:15:11.200
I don't have the exact number, but I think what
236
00:15:11.240 --> 00:15:16.919
I heard is if you make well under $ 50, 000 a year,
237
00:15:17.360 --> 00:15:22.940
your tax bill is approximately.
238
00:15:20.759 --> 00:15:23.039
$ 1, 700.
239
00:15:21.519 --> 00:15:26.480
So this isn't about very wealthy people who are who
240
00:15:26.559 --> 00:15:30.419
are able to make a philanthropic contribution, this would allow
241
00:15:30.500 --> 00:15:37.389
that taxpayer whose tax bill was $ 1, 700 to take that $ 1, 700
242
00:15:35.870 --> 00:15:41.330
and give it to their local, a local Boys and
243
00:15:41.350 --> 00:15:42.710
Girls Club. I'm just going to keep picking on the
244
00:15:42.730 --> 00:15:45.620
Boys and Girls Club. But the local Boys and Girls Club,
245
00:15:45.629 --> 00:15:49.240
which may also be under-resourced if it's in an area, right,
246
00:15:49.379 --> 00:15:51.919
instead of sending that to the federal government. So one,
247
00:15:51.940 --> 00:15:54.500
I think that this is going to be available and
248
00:15:54.519 --> 00:15:57.809
will open up that possibility to a lot more people.
249
00:15:58.200 --> 00:16:03.480
Here's the second thing I'm going to say. If so
250
00:16:03.620 --> 00:16:08.669
many people are giving their dollars I may get in
251
00:16:08.690 --> 00:16:10.909
trouble for saying this, but if so many, if we
252
00:16:10.990 --> 00:16:14.700
find that so many people are giving their dollars to
253
00:16:14.759 --> 00:16:20.659
scholarship granting organizations whose primary purpose is to provide scholarships
254
00:16:20.980 --> 00:16:24.740
to private and religious schools that we see a great
255
00:16:25.220 --> 00:16:29.279
sucking sound, then maybe we really, it will be an
256
00:16:29.379 --> 00:16:35.809
opportunity to really undertake a rigorous evaluation of our public
257
00:16:35.850 --> 00:16:36.470
school system.
258
00:16:38.769 --> 00:16:40.389
Because you would say people are voting with their dollars
259
00:16:40.450 --> 00:16:40.870
at that point?
260
00:16:40.950 --> 00:16:44.370
Because people are voting with their dollars. But I will
261
00:16:44.389 --> 00:16:47.909
tell you, the way that charter schools are set up
262
00:16:48.009 --> 00:16:51.049
in our state, which is very different from some other states,
263
00:16:51.409 --> 00:16:53.460
we have very few of them. The way that they
264
00:16:53.519 --> 00:16:56.240
are set up and the current private and parochial schools,
265
00:16:56.659 --> 00:17:02.360
they just simply cannot scale fast enough to take 75%
266
00:17:02.360 --> 00:17:03.440
of the funds.
267
00:17:03.679 --> 00:17:05.880
But I think that one of the, again, kind of
268
00:17:05.920 --> 00:17:10.089
concerns from the other side is that the is what
269
00:17:10.130 --> 00:17:12.950
will the SGO infrastructure in the state be? The idea
270
00:17:12.990 --> 00:17:14.690
that there may be SGOs that are actually from out
271
00:17:14.730 --> 00:17:18.970
of state prepared to sort of come in and get
272
00:17:19.029 --> 00:17:21.859
the early dollars. They would be serving kids in the state, certainly,
273
00:17:22.019 --> 00:17:25.099
but that we don't even have the infrastructure in place,
274
00:17:25.579 --> 00:17:27.279
and you won't be donating directly to the Boys and
275
00:17:27.299 --> 00:17:31.599
Girls Club. You'll be writing your check to a SGO
276
00:17:31.640 --> 00:17:35.069
that then is going to send money to one of
277
00:17:35.089 --> 00:17:35.869
these beneficiaries.
278
00:17:36.269 --> 00:17:38.039
Yeah, well, there's a couple things to keep in mind there.
279
00:17:38.059 --> 00:17:40.380
And here's some data in terms of the numbers. This
280
00:17:40.440 --> 00:17:43.809
was one recently that came out from Edgenomics, which specializes
281
00:17:43.869 --> 00:17:48.160
in financial analysis of public school districts. By their estimate,
282
00:17:49.400 --> 00:17:53.630
if we only raised monies from employees of our current
283
00:17:53.730 --> 00:17:57.130
public school districts, that alone in and of itself would
284
00:17:57.150 --> 00:18:00.869
be about $ 200 per student in our public school system.
285
00:18:01.289 --> 00:18:04.589
So again, I think realistically, it's safe to say large
286
00:18:04.650 --> 00:18:07.869
amounts of resources are available to kids already in our
287
00:18:07.910 --> 00:18:11.190
school system, even if the only people that participated were
288
00:18:11.490 --> 00:18:15.690
school district employees. So just for level setting, that's already
289
00:18:15.710 --> 00:18:20.240
a large sum of money. In terms of the risk
290
00:18:20.480 --> 00:18:24.150
of SGOs being created from out of state, I think
291
00:18:24.210 --> 00:18:28.029
this is actually a really great opportunity for Washington state
292
00:18:28.150 --> 00:18:30.509
to lead and learn from what some of the other
293
00:18:30.569 --> 00:18:32.990
states are doing. In Colorado, for example.
294
00:18:33.609 --> 00:18:35.829
One of the states that's opted in. One of the states.
295
00:18:35.849 --> 00:18:38.069
One of the Democratic-led states that's opted in, along with
296
00:18:38.109 --> 00:18:38.490
New York.
297
00:18:38.609 --> 00:18:38.970
That's right.
298
00:18:39.730 --> 00:18:45.500
They have worked specifically setting up SGOs, One specifically for
299
00:18:45.539 --> 00:18:49.220
the Denver school district and another specifically to support all
300
00:18:49.240 --> 00:18:51.660
of the rest of the public school districts in the state.
301
00:18:52.089 --> 00:18:53.789
So one of the great things about sort of the
302
00:18:53.829 --> 00:18:55.710
way this is set up is if the state of
303
00:18:55.829 --> 00:19:00.029
Washington does really want to lead on this, the state
304
00:19:00.049 --> 00:19:02.130
can set up, can work with districts to set up
305
00:19:02.269 --> 00:19:07.549
SGOs to target specific. populations, low-income students, for example, in
306
00:19:07.589 --> 00:19:10.230
our public schools. And I think by leading on this,
307
00:19:10.250 --> 00:19:13.529
you could really get ahead of any concerns of out-of-states
308
00:19:13.670 --> 00:19:19.019
SGOs getting the vast majority of donations from Washington taxpayers.
309
00:19:20.200 --> 00:19:24.140
And this is a phenomenal opportunity, as Mike said, for
310
00:19:24.220 --> 00:19:26.259
not only our state to lead, but
for the governor
311
00:19:26.279 --> 00:19:30.460
to lead. Governor Polis in Colorado is marketing the heck,
312
00:19:30.480 --> 00:19:32.279
has said he is going to market the heck out
313
00:19:32.319 --> 00:19:37.599
of these SGOs and urge all Coloradans to donate their
314
00:19:37.920 --> 00:19:44.769
tax credits to these two SGOs. I don't know if
315
00:19:45.910 --> 00:19:49.890
you've watched television lately, but I see a lot of
316
00:19:49.960 --> 00:19:54.980
ads urging me to play the lottery to support Washington
317
00:19:55.019 --> 00:19:59.509
State education. That is not something I am interested in doing,
318
00:19:59.730 --> 00:20:04.230
but I would love to see that same Governor Ferguson
319
00:20:04.730 --> 00:20:10.450
and Superintendent Reichdahl urging me to contribute my federal tax
320
00:20:10.549 --> 00:20:20.839
credit dollars to a scholarship-granting organization that serves my public school.
321
00:20:21.019 --> 00:20:23.200
I don't live in Seattle, so I would be in
322
00:20:23.240 --> 00:20:27.119
the other SGO. But I really want to make clear,
323
00:20:27.220 --> 00:20:35.109
we are talking about individual taxpayers making a determination about
324
00:20:35.130 --> 00:20:39.420
where they are going, what organization they are going to
325
00:20:39.480 --> 00:20:44.690
give their money to. And again, I don't know about
326
00:20:44.730 --> 00:20:46.910
you or anybody watching this, but I think we all
327
00:20:46.990 --> 00:20:50.269
tend to give our money to the organizations that we know.
328
00:20:51.259 --> 00:20:56.930
I give my contribution to Meow, my local cat rescue agency,
329
00:20:57.349 --> 00:21:00.250
because one of my good friends works there and they
330
00:21:00.670 --> 00:21:03.230
lent me a Havahart trap when my cat disappeared. And
331
00:21:03.269 --> 00:21:05.890
after three days, he was there. I don't give to
332
00:21:05.910 --> 00:21:10.119
the ASPCA. I give to Meow because I know what
333
00:21:10.240 --> 00:21:13.839
they're going to do with my dollars. I can go
334
00:21:13.920 --> 00:21:17.069
down there. And I think that when we start talking
335
00:21:17.160 --> 00:21:21.859
about when we start throwing around pronouns and the money, no,
336
00:21:21.900 --> 00:21:24.779
we are talking about, Austin, where are you going to
337
00:21:24.839 --> 00:21:28.960
give your money to reduce your tax bill? Where is
338
00:21:29.039 --> 00:21:32.690
Mike going to give his money to reduce his tax bill?
339
00:21:33.089 --> 00:21:38.089
Where is Sally and Joe going to give their individual dollars?
340
00:21:38.329 --> 00:21:41.950
And what we know from philanthropic giving is it stays
341
00:21:42.309 --> 00:21:46.099
close to home and it follows people's values. And here
342
00:21:46.140 --> 00:21:50.680
that means going to organizations that serve kids in public school.
343
00:21:50.819 --> 00:21:57.900
And it's a tremendous opportunity for Governor Ferguson to really
344
00:21:57.960 --> 00:22:00.789
be a national leader on this issue, along with Governor Polis.
345
00:22:01.130 --> 00:22:04.730
There are Democrats who are supporting opting in. There are
346
00:22:05.089 --> 00:22:08.769
those who also oppose it and do so in part
347
00:22:08.829 --> 00:22:11.470
on the grounds that they believe the big, beautiful bill
348
00:22:11.710 --> 00:22:17.109
is anything but beautiful. and feel that if the Congress
349
00:22:17.250 --> 00:22:21.690
wanted to do something to better support public school students,
350
00:22:22.029 --> 00:22:24.250
they could have sent a billion dollars to the state
351
00:22:24.269 --> 00:22:27.559
of Washington for special education, for instance, and didn't do that.
352
00:22:27.650 --> 00:22:31.319
So their argument is this is baked into a flawed
353
00:22:31.839 --> 00:22:35.140
bill and that this mechanism for trying to help kids
354
00:22:35.339 --> 00:22:39.259
is flawed and that a blue state like Washington doesn't
355
00:22:39.299 --> 00:22:41.660
want to have any part of this. What would you
356
00:22:41.700 --> 00:22:44.359
say to somebody who's making that argument? And I believe
357
00:22:44.420 --> 00:22:45.220
Chris Rakedahl will be.
358
00:22:45.700 --> 00:22:48.539
Yeah, what sort of gets us as a non-politician, what
359
00:22:48.740 --> 00:22:51.589
really bothers me about the politics of the discussion right
360
00:22:51.609 --> 00:22:58.349
now is that today, Washington State's education system is failing
361
00:22:58.369 --> 00:23:01.990
the kids that need it the most. Right now, only
362
00:23:01.990 --> 00:23:06.890
36% of kids from low-income families here in Washington are
363
00:23:06.930 --> 00:23:10.890
meeting basic state standards in math. One third of the
364
00:23:10.930 --> 00:23:13.890
students from low-income families are meeting basic state standards in math.
365
00:23:14.549 --> 00:23:19.390
That's unconscionable to me. And what's particularly frustrating about it
366
00:23:19.430 --> 00:23:21.759
is that we know it doesn't have to be this way.
367
00:23:22.019 --> 00:23:24.420
Two weeks ago, the New York Times had a report,
368
00:23:24.660 --> 00:23:28.640
How to Fix US Schools. They interviewed 37 education experts.
369
00:23:29.220 --> 00:23:32.799
The number one recommendation by far was small group tutoring.
370
00:23:33.380 --> 00:23:36.140
Everybody knows it works. That's why rich people send their
371
00:23:36.259 --> 00:23:39.089
kids to tutors when they're struggling. At the math agency,
372
00:23:39.140 --> 00:23:42.529
we've shown that multiple years of tutoring done in high
373
00:23:42.609 --> 00:23:45.670
poverty schools right here in Washington can double the number
374
00:23:45.690 --> 00:23:48.289
of kids meeting state standards in math. You can see
375
00:23:48.329 --> 00:23:51.569
it in the OSPI publicly available data. The part that
376
00:23:51.609 --> 00:23:54.349
blows my mind is that the money from this tax credit,
377
00:23:54.609 -->
00:23:57.630
regardless of how we got to this point legislatively, the
378
00:23:57.670 --> 00:24:00.930
money from the tax credit could provide year-long tutoring to
379
00:24:01.210 --> 00:24:06.190
every single second grader, third grader, fourth grader, fifth grader,
380
00:24:06.650 --> 00:24:10.130
sixth grader, and seventh grader in the state of Washington.
381
00:24:11.289 --> 00:24:13.450
Every single one of those students. What could be more
382
00:24:13.509 --> 00:24:16.349
important than letting that happen? What would be so important
383
00:24:16.369 --> 00:24:19.049
that you'd prevent that from happening for a political reason?
384
00:24:19.190 --> 00:24:22.450
And you're convinced that this could be, it can't be
385
00:24:22.490 --> 00:24:26.109
designed or engineered or forced to ensure that that happens,
386
00:24:26.150 --> 00:24:28.089
but you think that the state could sort of put
387
00:24:28.130 --> 00:24:31.700
its shoulder into the wheel on that and encourage dollars
388
00:24:31.779 --> 00:24:35.690
to go to support that sort of service for students.
389
00:24:35.710 --> 00:24:39.390
That's right. So a strong leadership position from the state,
390
00:24:39.450 --> 00:24:42.230
if they work with SGOs to say, hey, we want
391
00:24:42.769 --> 00:24:46.250
Washington's taxpayers to know that these SGOs are supporting these
392
00:24:46.329 --> 00:24:50.509
causes that we care about. Again, I'm partial to tutoring
393
00:24:50.529 --> 00:24:53.869
in high-poverty schools, but the state could absolutely make sure
394
00:24:53.910 --> 00:24:56.569
that the resources are getting driven in that direction.
395
00:24:56.950 --> 00:24:57.490
What do you just.
396
00:24:57.650 --> 00:24:58.450
You know, when I was.
397
00:24:58.819 --> 00:25:02.220
Because, yeah, you were a state lawmaker. You've run for office.
398
00:25:02.480 --> 00:25:06.349
In 2000... George W. Bush was Republican. We had a
399
00:25:06.789 --> 00:25:09.670
Republican governor. We didn't turn down Medicaid money.
400
00:25:10.150 --> 00:25:11.230
We didn't have a Republican governor.
401
00:25:11.289 --> 00:25:12.890
I'm sorry. We had a Republican president.
402
00:25:12.930 --> 00:25:13.170
I'm sorry.
403
00:25:13.190 --> 00:25:13.549
I misspoke.
404
00:25:13.710 --> 00:25:17.420
There was a Republican administration. I didn't see anybody suggesting
405
00:25:17.460 --> 00:25:19.079
we should turn down Medicaid money.
406
00:25:19.859 --> 00:25:20.019
Right.
407
00:25:20.140 --> 00:25:23.359
Oh, let's not help poor people get health care because
408
00:25:23.400 --> 00:25:26.059
we don't like the president who's in office. Are we
409
00:25:26.200 --> 00:25:32.440
really going to say let's. Let's not allow half a
410
00:25:32.720 --> 00:25:38.509
million Washington state kids to get the tutoring and the
411
00:25:38.589 --> 00:25:43.799
college advising and other supports that they need in order
412
00:25:43.839 --> 00:25:47.339
to be successful because we don't like the president?
413
00:25:47.359 --> 00:25:47.480
Right?
414
00:25:48.339 --> 00:25:51.039
Are we really there?
415
00:25:51.299 --> 00:25:55.220
What about waiting a year and seeing if the leadership
416
00:25:55.259 --> 00:25:55.799
in Congress may change?
417
00:25:55.819 --> 00:25:57.140
Congress will do nothing in a year.
418
00:25:57.220 --> 00:25:59.980
Change the program, see how it goes in other states,
419
00:26:00.519 --> 00:26:01.420
opt in next year.
420
00:26:01.539 --> 00:26:07.400
This kind of program does not change in a year.
421
00:26:07.960 --> 00:26:10.839
And that, you know, I read Superintendent Raichdahl's letter. It
422
00:26:11.619 --> 00:26:15.359
is Something in our state doesn't change in a year.
423
00:26:15.960 --> 00:26:19.339
There were lots of opportunities to try and shape this.
424
00:26:20.119 --> 00:26:22.700
And I'm sure people tried. We are not there. We
425
00:26:22.740 --> 00:26:27.250
have two choices. We can opt in. We can not
426
00:26:27.410 --> 00:26:31.390
opt in. I, for one, and waiting a year, what
427
00:26:31.410 --> 00:26:33.950
are we going to tell the half a million kids
428
00:26:34.569 --> 00:26:39.299
as their peers in other states are getting ahead and
429
00:26:39.359 --> 00:26:42.549
we are letting them fall even further behind. We have
430
00:26:42.720 --> 00:26:46.990
two choices. The governor should lead. I have full confidence
431
00:26:47.009 --> 00:26:49.890
that he will. He is a very smart guy and
432
00:26:49.910 --> 00:26:50.670
we should opt in.
433
00:26:50.690 --> 00:26:52.750
We have less than a minute. Mike Printer, I'll give
434
00:26:52.769 --> 00:26:54.549
you the last word. What would you tell the governor?
435
00:26:55.769 --> 00:26:58.859
I would tell the governor that a billion dollars is
436
00:26:58.910 --> 00:27:01.819
a huge amount of money to leave on the table
437
00:27:02.019 --> 00:27:04.680
when you could be using it to support Washington students.
438
00:27:05.289 --> 00:27:07.970
And in particular, the state could be helping lead which
439
00:27:08.009 --> 00:27:10.450
students it goes to. Again, the students that are struggling
440
00:27:10.490 --> 00:27:12.849
the most, the students that are in our public schools.
441
00:27:13.369 --> 00:27:13.609
Okay.
442
00:27:14.130 --> 00:27:16.990
Mike Priner with the math agency. Thank you for coming down.
443
00:27:17.019 --> 00:27:20.660
Appreciate the interview. Laura Ruderman, CEO of Technology Alliance. Thank
444
00:27:20.700 --> 00:27:23.039
you as well. When we come back, we'll get a
445
00:27:23.079 --> 00:27:26.900
different perspective on this, an opponent's perspective. We'll talk with
446
00:27:27.099 --> 00:27:30.099
state school superintendent Chris Ragtall back right after this.
447
00:27:32.710 --> 00:27:33.950
It will dwarf Katrina.
448
00:27:34.109 --> 00:27:36.470
It'll be absolutely the largest thing that we will have
449
00:27:36.490 --> 00:27:38.369
had to have dealt with in our
country.
450
00:27:38.619 --> 00:27:39.839
We know the clock is ticking.
451
00:27:40.339 --> 00:27:42.960
With only 15 minutes or so, that's not a lot
452
00:27:43.000 --> 00:27:44.160
of time to evacuate.
453
00:27:44.180 --> 00:27:58.519
A vote in Olympia, a change in your community.
454
00:27:58.920 --> 00:28:03.180
On TVW's Field Report, Angela Nolesko tracks how state policies
455
00:28:03.259 --> 00:28:07.539
become real-world changes across Washington. Field Report, Saturday and Sunday
456
00:28:07.559 --> 00:28:10.900
mornings at 7.30 and online at tvw.org.
457
00:28:11.289 --> 00:28:13.829
Welcome back to Inside Olympia. Joining me now is State
458
00:28:13.890 --> 00:28:18.029
Schools Superintendent Chris Reykdal, who is encouraging Governor Bob Ferguson
459
00:28:18.269 --> 00:28:22.109
not to opt in to the federal education tax credit program.
460
00:28:22.170 --> 00:28:22.680
Thanks for coming in.
461
00:28:22.690 --> 00:28:23.490
Appreciate this. Thank you.
462
00:28:24.430 --> 00:28:26.210
Usually we talk about a bunch of issues. We're going
463
00:28:26.230 --> 00:28:29.839
to be very focused for this segment on this particular topic.
464
00:28:30.039 --> 00:28:32.539
You do not like this program, which the Trump administration
465
00:28:32.559 --> 00:28:37.460
has called America's first nationwide school choice program. What is
466
00:28:37.480 --> 00:28:41.000
your big picture opposition before we get to some of
467
00:28:41.019 --> 00:28:42.269
the specific criticisms?
468
00:28:43.269 --> 00:28:46.910
The big picture is that according to Republican members of Congress,
469
00:28:46.990 --> 00:28:51.309
they balanced the big, beautiful bill paying for this thing,
470
00:28:51.670 --> 00:28:55.950
which will primarily fund private religious institution choices of families.
471
00:28:56.069 --> 00:28:56.589
And that's fine.
472
00:28:57.049 --> 00:28:58.910
Those, those are great choices, but I don't think taxpayers
473
00:28:58.930 --> 00:29:02.789
should do that. They did it by significantly cutting benefits
474
00:29:02.849 --> 00:29:06.380
to seniors and Medicaid. They cut affordable care act subsidies
475
00:29:06.410 --> 00:29:10.180
and they cut snap food assistance. The most vulnerable Americans
476
00:29:10.539 --> 00:29:13.500
are about ready to take a multi-billion dollar hit. So
477
00:29:13.599 --> 00:29:15.539
the sum of this money can either give tax breaks
478
00:29:15.579 --> 00:29:20.359
to the billionaires or in part subsidize private choices. And
479
00:29:20.400 --> 00:29:24.119
I think that's a terrible thing. Uh, So as I've said,
480
00:29:24.240 --> 00:29:26.650
we're not a no forever. It's that the way it
481
00:29:26.710 --> 00:29:31.210
was written by one party following Project 2025 and all
482
00:29:31.230 --> 00:29:34.309
of its flaws, which we'll get into, make this a terrible,
483
00:29:34.630 --> 00:29:36.069
terrible piece of legislation.
484
00:29:36.589 --> 00:29:36.769
Okay.
485
00:29:36.890
--> 00:29:42.039
So you are philosophically opposed for myriad reasons to much,
486
00:29:42.079 --> 00:29:45.019
if not most of what's in the big, beautiful bill.
487
00:29:45.380 --> 00:29:45.559
Fine.
488
00:29:46.220 --> 00:29:50.599
But isn't what we're talking about right now the potential
489
00:29:50.740 --> 00:29:56.329
for the state of Washington to pump maybe $ 750 million,
490
00:29:56.619 --> 00:29:58.549
maybe twice that if a lot of people, 30% of
491
00:29:59.190 --> 00:30:04.170
Washingtonians opted into this, into education at a time when,
492
00:30:04.450 --> 00:30:08.630
as you have been saying and warning, we are facing scarcity.
493
00:30:08.819 --> 00:30:12.400
We need more money in education. Isn't this an opportunity
494
00:30:12.640 --> 00:30:14.519
for Washington students?
495
00:30:15.839 --> 00:30:18.599
I'm going to say candidly, it is. So that's why
496
00:30:18.640 --> 00:30:21.099
it's not a no forever. There's a possibility here we
497
00:30:21.140 --> 00:30:23.750
could do something What's got to be really clear is
498
00:30:23.789 --> 00:30:25.809
this is not money that's going to go fill the
499
00:30:25.930 --> 00:30:29.829
current hole. When the legislature doesn't fund insurance costs and
500
00:30:29.849 --> 00:30:33.289
school districts have to rob programs from kids, this money
501
00:30:33.349 --> 00:30:37.250
won't do anything to backfill that. This is a private option.
502
00:30:37.690 --> 00:30:41.619
This is pushing money through the U.S. tax code to
503
00:30:41.680 --> 00:30:44.599
nonprofit organizations who get to decide who they're going to serve.
504
00:30:44.660 --> 00:30:47.440
So it's not broad-based basic ed. It doesn't solve any
505
00:30:47.500 --> 00:30:50.309
school district's budgets. And we have to figure out, we've
506
00:30:50.329 --> 00:30:52.609
got to come up with things we can charge students
507
00:30:52.650 --> 00:30:54.869
for in order for any of this money to come
508
00:30:54.930 --> 00:30:58.390
back to schools. So this is the worst way you
509
00:30:58.430 --> 00:31:00.779
fund schools. And I've said there are three things Congress
510
00:31:00.819 --> 00:31:03.890
could have done to really help us. Fund special ed.
511
00:31:04.390 --> 00:31:07.099
They fund 12% of it. Their obligation is 40%. That's
512
00:31:07.119 --> 00:31:10.079
a billion dollars. They could have directly funded a child
513
00:31:10.119 --> 00:31:14.920
tax credit so that every American for every child got.
514
00:31:13.880 --> 00:31:14.299
$ 1, 700.
515
00:31:14.019 --> 00:31:16.970
Public school, private school, anybody. That would have been the
516
00:31:17.009 --> 00:31:18.519
choice of the family then to say, what am I
517
00:31:18.559 --> 00:31:19.660
going to do with this money and how will it
518
00:31:19.670 --> 00:31:23.160
help me most? They could have directly funded tutoring programs
519
00:31:23.200 --> 00:31:24.980
all across the country and said the money can only
520
00:31:25.019 --> 00:31:27.539
be used for that to help kids that are struggling
521
00:31:27.579 --> 00:31:30.819
in math or reading. There is no framework to this.
522
00:31:31.440 --> 00:31:33.779
This can be targeted at wealthy families. It can be
523
00:31:33.839 --> 00:31:37.299
targeted at one student's faith group, one religious institution. It
524
00:31:37.319 --> 00:31:40.359
can be targeted at certain private schools. This has the
525
00:31:40.559 --> 00:31:44.160
least shape and it will do almost nothing to actually
526
00:31:44.220 --> 00:31:46.109
address the school needs in the state of Washington.
527
00:31:46.539 --> 00:31:49.819
It seems like the advocates are making the counterargument, though,
528
00:31:49.880 --> 00:31:52.740
that even if you accept that this is flawed as
529
00:31:52.779 --> 00:31:56.279
it was created, it is what it is, and that
530
00:31:56.359 --> 00:32:01.829
Washington could perhaps tailor this to make it work for Washington.
531
00:32:01.930 --> 00:32:04.450
And you've talked about sort of Washington values, not that
532
00:32:04.470 --> 00:32:07.009
there is one set of values. But, for instance, one
533
00:32:07.029 --> 00:32:10.230
of your concerns is that we have very strict anti-discrimination
534
00:32:10.269 --> 00:32:12.460
laws in this state, and these dollars are not subject
535
00:32:12.500 --> 00:32:14.579
to those. But there are advocates who are saying, who
536
00:32:14.619 --> 00:32:17.519
are already trying to set up a fund that would
537
00:32:17.559 --> 00:32:21.940
be one of these special purpose entities that would at
538
00:32:21.980 --> 00:32:26.720
least voluntarily make a commitment to adhere to anti-discrimination laws.
539
00:32:28.900 --> 00:32:32.539
Isn't there a way to sort of sub-design this to
540
00:32:32.579 --> 00:32:35.900
make it work for our state? If you got together
541
00:32:35.960 --> 00:32:39.180
and said, instead of no, let's make this work for us.
542
00:32:39.920 --> 00:32:42.150
I've actually said that. So let's take a year and
543
00:32:42.170 --> 00:32:44.490
get this right, either by going back to Congress, who
544
00:32:44.509 --> 00:32:46.410
it looks like will have at least split party rule
545
00:32:46.859 --> 00:32:50.240
use the budget appropriations process there to put shape around
546
00:32:50.259 --> 00:32:52.900
the U.S. Treasury. Let's get states back in a position
547
00:32:52.940 --> 00:32:55.029
of saying we want to focus it on low-income youth
548
00:32:55.049 --> 00:32:57.210
or we want to focus it public and private on
549
00:32:57.250 --> 00:33:00.049
kids struggling in reading or math. Any shape would be
550
00:33:00.069 --> 00:33:03.150
better than what it has today, but the explicit rules
551
00:33:03.190 --> 00:33:05.950
by U.S. Treasury right now says states shall not put
552
00:33:06.210 --> 00:33:10.089
any conditions, any additional conditions on. So it's true that
553
00:33:10.109 --> 00:33:12.599
a nonprofit may pop up that wants to focus
on
554
00:33:12.680 --> 00:33:15.309
public school students who are struggling in reading, But it's
555
00:33:15.369 --> 00:33:17.630
also true and more likely based on what we see
556
00:33:17.670 --> 00:33:19.950
around the country that they're going to prop up groups
557
00:33:20.349 --> 00:33:22.670
that say we're going to focus on these upper and
558
00:33:23.130 --> 00:33:25.750
wealthier families. We're going to give them credits to help
559
00:33:25.829 --> 00:33:28.849
pay for their private school tuition. That's the actual evidence
560
00:33:28.869 --> 00:33:30.859
we have from Arizona and Florida and around the country.
561
00:33:30.920 --> 00:33:34.279
So it is possible this could get better. All we
562
00:33:34.339 --> 00:33:37.359
need is Treasury by rule or Congress by action to
563
00:33:37.400 --> 00:33:39.420
say states, you really do have the right to put
564
00:33:39.460 --> 00:33:41.640
a little more shape around this thing. And I would
565
00:33:41.680 --> 00:33:43.700
be all in once we can figure out how to
566
00:33:44.000 --> 00:33:45.619
actually help students most in need.
567
00:33:46.359 --> 00:33:49.400
Playing devil's advocate, because again, the advocates for opting in
568
00:33:49.440 --> 00:33:51.549
are saying, look, we're going to leave money on the
569
00:33:51.589 --> 00:33:53.690
table if we don't do this. Why not try it
570
00:33:53.750 --> 00:33:56.589
for a year and see if your worst concerns come true?
571
00:33:56.650 --> 00:33:59.289
And then if that's the case, and I also want
572
00:33:59.309 --> 00:34:01.690
to make clear, this is the governor's decision, not your decision.
573
00:34:01.710 --> 00:34:04.730
But you could be advocating as the chief schools officer
574
00:34:04.769 --> 00:34:06.990
in the state for him to opt in. Why not say,
575
00:34:07.009 --> 00:34:09.510
let's give it a year. It's not working. You can
576
00:34:09.530 --> 00:34:10.500
always opt out in year two.
577
00:34:10.969 --> 00:34:11.510
Let's play it out.
578
00:34:11.789 --> 00:34:14.050
So let's say the governor opts us in January 1
579
00:34:14.050 --> 00:34:16.429
and everyone starts going for it. It means that a
580
00:34:16.449 --> 00:34:18.769
bunch of Washingtonians have to first have enough money to
581
00:34:18.909 --> 00:34:22.190
donate it, $ 1, 700 a person or $ 3, 400 for a couple.
582
00:34:22.550 --> 00:34:24.530
You have to donate money first and then wait a
583
00:34:24.550 --> 00:34:26.650
year to get that back on your taxes. So it's
584
00:34:26.789 --> 00:34:29.260
neutral to any donor. There's not a ton of incentive
585
00:34:29.280 --> 00:34:31.619
to do it. But who's ready at the door right.
586
00:34:31.500 --> 00:34:32.059
Now to pounce?
587
00:34:32.940 --> 00:34:37.400
Texas firms, Florida firms, Arizona private organizations, they're ready to
588
00:34:37.440 --> 00:34:39.300
go in all the states to pounce on day one.
589
00:34:39.650 --> 00:34:41.829
because they've been doing this in other
states and obviously
590
00:34:41.869 --> 00:34:44.530
doing it to the detriment of their budgets in those states.
591
00:34:45.369 --> 00:34:48.800
So once you open that door and that money, who
592
00:34:48.820 --> 00:34:50.760
can afford to donate this kind of money, usually up
593
00:34:50.780 --> 00:34:52.530
the income ladder, they're already going to push their money
594
00:34:52.570 --> 00:34:54.920
into their private choices for the most part. And then
595
00:34:54.980 --> 00:34:58.420
as maybe public school options come available, maybe a school
596
00:34:58.460 --> 00:35:01.320
district's foundation comes forward or a tutoring group comes forward,
597
00:35:01.980 --> 00:35:04.599
they're going to be begging people to make donations to them.
598
00:35:04.639 --> 00:35:06.860
They're new. No one's ever heard of them. And most
599
00:35:06.900 --> 00:35:08.599
of that money has already been kind of pushed out.
600
00:35:09.170 --> 00:35:12.039
And remember, there's not a pile of money just sitting
601
00:35:12.059 --> 00:35:14.559
there waiting. We don't lose anything until we convince a
602
00:35:14.599 --> 00:35:16.380
bunch of people to make a donation first.
603
00:35:16.440 --> 00:35:20.119
So who are you predicting would get these for those
604
00:35:20.139 --> 00:35:22.849
who opt in right away if Washington went down this
605
00:35:22.889 --> 00:35:27.449
path and people wanted the tax deduction? Who are you
606
00:35:27.550 --> 00:35:30.730
saying that you think would be the primary beneficiaries out
607
00:35:30.809 --> 00:35:31.190
of the gates?
608
00:35:31.829 --> 00:35:32.449
Well, here's the weird part.
609
00:35:32.469 --> 00:35:33.840
Because you just mentioned out-of-state entities.
610
00:35:33.860 --> 00:35:34.539
Yeah, yeah.
611
00:35:34.599 --> 00:35:37.420
So any scholarship-granting organization can come into any state and
612
00:35:37.460 --> 00:35:39.480
do this, and it's a very low bar. So there
613
00:35:39.519 --> 00:35:41.280
are firms already at the door waiting to come into
614
00:35:41.320 --> 00:35:43.179
Washington and say, we want to go. Now, once a
615
00:35:43.239 --> 00:35:46.469
Washingtonian donates to this, it'll stay in Washington, but you
616
00:35:46.489 --> 00:35:48.829
don't even get to direct your own donation. You don't
617
00:35:48.849 --> 00:35:50.750
get to say, I'm giving $ 1, 700, and I want it
618
00:35:50.769 --> 00:35:51.809
to go to my Catholic school.
619
00:35:51.829 --> 00:35:54.489
But what would these organizations or entities be? What would
620
00:35:54.510 --> 00:35:57.250
they do? They're not charter schools? Are they private schools?
621
00:35:57.309 --> 00:36:00.130
Well, they're nonprofit organizations that simply collect the money and
622
00:36:00.170 --> 00:36:02.909
then give the money out to those who qualify.
623
00:36:03.269 --> 00:36:04.289
For what purpose, though?
624
00:36:04.449 --> 00:36:05.369
Well, it depends.
625
00:36:05.809 --> 00:36:08.179
What are you
thinking? How would this play out for Washington?
626
00:36:08.619 --> 00:36:10.480
Well, the way it's played out everywhere else in the country,
627
00:36:10.500 --> 00:36:12.500
whether it's a state program, is the first people to
628
00:36:12.539 --> 00:36:14.380
donate are those already in private school because they want
629
00:36:14.420 --> 00:36:16.400
a break on their tuition. Then they apply to that
630
00:36:16.460 --> 00:36:20.349
scholarship organization. They say, I'm eligible because I make up
631
00:36:20.389 --> 00:36:26.010
to $ 400, 000.
632
00:36:22.289 --> 00:36:22.710
And then the.
633
00:36:22.670 --> 00:36:25.349
Scholarship group says, fine, we're going to discount your tuition.
634
00:36:25.369 --> 00:36:27.409
We're going to pay part of your tuition. Or worst
635
00:36:27.449 --> 00:36:30.530
case scenario, the private school just ups their tuition 1,700 bucks.
636
00:36:31.010 --> 00:36:33.739
And all this is is a laundering scheme of people
637
00:36:33.800 --> 00:36:36.500
already paying private choices to go to a nonprofit only
638
00:36:36.519 --> 00:36:38.840
to give back to that private institution. That's how it's
639
00:36:38.860 --> 00:36:39.739
played out in most states.
640
00:36:39.820 --> 00:36:44.659
Let me bring up sort of the but argument that
641
00:36:45.059 --> 00:36:48.659
we hear from the advocates. If we don't opt in,
642
00:36:49.039 --> 00:36:52.179
then people... in Washington will take advantage of this and
643
00:36:52.219 --> 00:36:55.900
the money will go not just to out-of-state organizations, as
644
00:36:55.920 --> 00:37:00.559
you're predicting, but to out-of-state kids because you can still
645
00:37:00.599 --> 00:37:03.530
get the tax benefit. It's just the money will go out-of-state.
646
00:37:04.320 --> 00:37:06.369
Yeah, there is zero evidence of that. I'm just going
647
00:37:06.389 --> 00:37:07.969
to be candid with you. Number one, there is no
648
00:37:08.070 --> 00:37:11.010
real tax benefit. You have to give up $ 1, 700 to
649
00:37:11.050 --> 00:37:13.010
get it back a year later so you break even.
650
00:37:13.030 --> 00:37:16.130
There's nothing in this that's a credit of net benefit.
651
00:37:16.789 --> 00:37:18.989
So we don't see any evidence of that. We don't
652
00:37:19.050 --> 00:37:21.570
see anywhere where folks are like, I'm giving a bunch
653
00:37:21.610 --> 00:37:23.110
of money right now to the state of Florida because
654
00:37:23.150 --> 00:37:27.130
I can help kids in Florida. So that's a rhetorical
655
00:37:27.210 --> 00:37:31.190
argument that has no basis in fact. What is factual
656
00:37:31.210 --> 00:37:32.659
that they say is, gosh, if we were in it,
657
00:37:32.690 --> 00:37:34.909
we could start donating right now, and at least some
658
00:37:34.929 --> 00:37:37.650
people's donations would stay. And again, I say let's wait
659
00:37:37.690 --> 00:37:39.969
a year and get the program right. But also, how
660
00:37:39.989 --> 00:37:41.679
would you feel if you're a nonprofit in this space
661
00:37:41.719 --> 00:37:44.360
right now, and when people donate to you, the tax
662
00:37:44.400 --> 00:37:47.530
break that they get today– is their marginal tax rate.
663
00:37:47.849 --> 00:37:49.889
So if Austin Jenkins and family has a marginal tax
664
00:37:49.929 --> 00:37:52.949
rate at 20% and you donate $ 1, 700 to a scholarship
665
00:37:53.070 --> 00:37:55.960
nonprofit today, you only get 20% of that back. This
666
00:37:56.019 --> 00:37:59.300
program is going to give you 100% credit. So we're
667
00:37:59.340 --> 00:38:01.579
going to open up the door to out-of-state groups and
668
00:38:01.639 --> 00:38:06.019
some that will form in-state and essentially potentially wipe out
669
00:38:06.039 --> 00:38:08.360
a bunch of nonprofits in this state who are currently
670
00:38:08.400 --> 00:38:11.989
getting donations, not just in the education space, If you
671
00:38:12.010 --> 00:38:14.110
have $ 1, 700 and that's what you give, you can give
672
00:38:14.150 --> 00:38:15.590
to the food bank right now and get 20% of
673
00:38:15.829 --> 00:38:17.730
that back on your taxes, or you can give it
674
00:38:17.750 --> 00:38:20.730
to this other thing and get all of your money back.
675
00:38:21.570 --> 00:38:24.409
I think we have a crisis coming of nonprofit organizations
676
00:38:24.429 --> 00:38:26.940
who say, why do they get four or five times
677
00:38:26.980 --> 00:38:29.440
the benefit if they give to that thing, especially since
678
00:38:29.480 --> 00:38:31.599
we know a bunch of that's going to subsidize private
679
00:38:31.659 --> 00:38:33.460
choices instead of common public goods?
680
00:38:34.199 --> 00:38:36.639
Well, on that point, as I understand it, something like
681
00:38:36.639 --> 00:38:40.530
90% of kids in the state are going to public school.
682
00:38:41.260 --> 00:38:46.489
And while it wasn't originally, this program was originally intended
683
00:38:46.530 --> 00:38:48.889
to support private school choice, it was actually amended late
684
00:38:49.690 --> 00:38:52.530
in the game to allow for public schools to include
685
00:38:52.550 --> 00:38:56.989
public schools. But again, wouldn't it logically flow if 90%
686
00:38:56.989 --> 00:38:59.619
of parents or taxpayers who have kids are sending their
687
00:38:59.639 --> 00:39:02.699
kids to public schools, that they would then be looking
688
00:39:02.800 --> 00:39:08.860
for these SGOs, as they're known, that support public school kids? Again,
689
00:39:09.039 --> 00:39:11.579
just because The culture here in Washington is most of
690
00:39:11.619 --> 00:39:12.579
our kids are in public schools.
691
00:39:13.360 --> 00:39:16.360
Maybe if those schools conform, but the first flow of
692
00:39:16.409 --> 00:39:18.909
this money is going to be to the first market participants,
693
00:39:18.949 --> 00:39:21.150
and that's the big privates and the big out-of-state firms.
694
00:39:21.170 --> 00:39:23.769
But there
is an entity that's trying to put together
695
00:39:23.809 --> 00:39:26.230
a Washington fund that would be ready on day one.
696
00:39:26.610 --> 00:39:26.809
Great.
697
00:39:27.329 --> 00:39:29.170
But again, why would you do that? Why would you
698
00:39:29.210 --> 00:39:31.750
give to that? with no guarantee it's coming back to
699
00:39:31.789 --> 00:39:34.449
you or your school for one? You don't exactly know
700
00:39:34.469 --> 00:39:36.349
what they're going to do. They get to make the choice.
701
00:39:36.889 --> 00:39:40.429
It's not necessarily helping low-income kids. They could pick one
702
00:39:40.489 --> 00:39:44.119
religious group of incomes over $ 300, 000. I mean, that's a
703
00:39:44.119 --> 00:39:46.809
little silly. They probably won't, but they could. And so
704
00:39:47.130 --> 00:39:49.570
I just don't think there's any evidence that this thing
705
00:39:49.590 --> 00:39:51.130
is going to do any harm to wait a year.
706
00:39:51.409 --> 00:39:53.150
If we get the shape of it right, then we
707
00:39:53.369 --> 00:39:55.159
actually have a focus when it happens and we don't
708
00:39:55.179 --> 00:39:56.570
bleed off a bunch of money on the front end
709
00:39:56.610 --> 00:39:59.559
of this thing. If you go too soon and these
710
00:39:59.719 --> 00:40:02.059
ones that want to focus on public schools can't ramp
711
00:40:02.119 --> 00:40:06.099
up fast enough, you've got the biggest exodus of federal
712
00:40:06.139 --> 00:40:08.599
tax receipts that's currently paying for national defense, is paying
713
00:40:08.639 --> 00:40:10.599
for health care for the vulnerable, it's paying down a
714
00:40:10.639 --> 00:40:13.559
national debt that's $ 40 trillion. You're not diverting some of that.
715
00:40:14.110 --> 00:40:16.139
to some of the wealthiest families already in private school.
716
00:40:16.159 --> 00:40:19.789
That is not a risk anyone should take, especially when
717
00:40:19.829 --> 00:40:22.230
I hear some of these Democrats are just complaining every
718
00:40:22.269 --> 00:40:25.570
day around the big, beautiful bill. It gutted services here.
719
00:40:25.849 --> 00:40:28.010
If somebody robbed a bank and you thought that was wrong,
720
00:40:28.070 --> 00:40:29.750
but then you said, you know, I guess it already happened,
721
00:40:29.789 --> 00:40:31.090
so if they want to give you some of that money,
722
00:40:31.130 --> 00:40:34.789
that's insane. That is the worst neoliberal argument, and this
723
00:40:34.849 --> 00:40:37.230
is what D.C. does all the time. We did a
724
00:40:37.309 --> 00:40:39.409
terrible thing, but as long as it's terrible, we might
725
00:40:39.429 --> 00:40:41.679
as well get benefit from it. That's how we've straddled
726
00:40:41.780 --> 00:40:45.039
every child in this country with $ 112, 000 in national debt,
727
00:40:45.079 --> 00:40:47.300
and it's growing, and this program will add to that.
728
00:40:47.860 --> 00:40:50.679
If you thought that this would benefit in
a demonstrable
729
00:40:50.739 --> 00:40:57.230
way some percentage of the million plus school kids in
730
00:40:57.269 --> 00:41:02.190
this state, notwithstanding your sort of principled objection to how
731
00:41:02.210 --> 00:41:05.050
this was structured, your concern about the impact more broadly
732
00:41:05.090 --> 00:41:07.920
to nonprofits, so on and so forth, would you be
733
00:41:07.960 --> 00:41:11.630
supporting this? kind of the embrace of this program now?
734
00:41:12.590 --> 00:41:16.969
Or is this more of a blanket opposition?
735
00:41:17.469 --> 00:41:18.289
No, it's not.
736
00:41:19.070 --> 00:41:21.030
Because, I mean, I will point out, your number one
737
00:41:21.050 --> 00:41:23.159
job is to look out for the well-being of the
738
00:41:23.219 --> 00:41:25.219
school kids in this state, not to be worried about.
739
00:41:26.320 --> 00:41:28.579
I'm the superintendent of public instruction, so we have some
740
00:41:28.599 --> 00:41:31.239
great private school choices, but that's done in the private marketplace.
741
00:41:31.980 --> 00:41:33.780
So my job is the million kids in public school.
742
00:41:33.800 --> 00:41:36.780
This will hardly benefit them at all. So what I
743
00:41:36.840 --> 00:41:39.360
consistently say is there's a way Congress can fix this
744
00:41:39.420 --> 00:41:41.719
and focus it. There's a way that if they give
745
00:41:41.739 --> 00:41:43.800
the legislature in our state or our governor a little
746
00:41:43.840 --> 00:41:46.150
shape or my office, we can get this a little tailored.
747
00:41:46.230 --> 00:41:48.630
So no, it's not blanket for me. If they want
748
00:41:48.650 --> 00:41:50.530
to roll this out as a tax credit to families,
749
00:41:50.690 --> 00:41:52.570
I'm all in because let's face it, it takes somewhere
750
00:41:52.590 --> 00:41:55.389
between $ 400, 000 and $ 500, 000 now to raise a child from
751
00:41:55.449 --> 00:41:59.070
birth to age 22. Middle-class families are struggling. People are
752
00:41:59.090 --> 00:42:01.150
struggling all over the country. This would have been a
753
00:42:01.530 --> 00:42:06.139
perfect addition to family tax credit. They didn't do that
754
00:42:06.550 --> 00:42:09.360
because then those dollars don't necessarily in the volume that
755
00:42:09.420 --> 00:42:13.139
this conservative Congress wanted, those volumes of dollars are not
756
00:42:13.159 --> 00:42:14.639
going to flow to private schools that way. They're only
757
00:42:14.659 --> 00:42:15.980
going to get 10% of the money and they want
758
00:42:16.000 --> 00:42:17.719
them to get 80 or 90% of the money. And
759
00:42:17.739 --> 00:42:19.380
that's how it was originally structured. And then late in
760
00:42:19.400 --> 00:42:21.510
the game, they're like, we better throw some things in
761
00:42:21.530 --> 00:42:23.750
there that might make it possible for public school students
762
00:42:23.789 --> 00:42:27.610
to benefit. This is terrible. Everyone knows it's terrible
and
763
00:42:27.630 --> 00:42:30.139
you shouldn't go grab money from a bank robber because
764
00:42:30.179 --> 00:42:31.539
the robbery's already been committed.
765
00:42:31.599 --> 00:42:34.760
But it's so interesting because while this is a bill
766
00:42:34.840 --> 00:42:38.230
that President Trump backed and that the Republicans passed, you
767
00:42:38.309 --> 00:42:40.710
do have Democrats here in this state and across the
768
00:42:40.750 --> 00:42:43.929
country saying, we should not take a flyer on this.
769
00:42:44.590 --> 00:42:49.460
You've got former, say, Senator Joe Wynn. You've got former
770
00:42:49.500 --> 00:42:52.579
state representative Laura Ruderman, who's on the program talking about this.
771
00:42:53.059 --> 00:42:55.239
You've got Arne Duncan, who was the Secretary of Education
772
00:42:55.440 --> 00:43:01.239
under President Obama. The two Democratic governors, Jared Polis of
773
00:43:01.320 --> 00:43:04.079
Colorado and now Kathy Hochul of New York, have said
774
00:43:04.219 --> 00:43:07.400
their states will opt in. Kathy Hochul, who is running
775
00:43:07.420 --> 00:43:10.639
for reelection, she's bucking one of the strongest teachers unions
776
00:43:10.679 --> 00:43:12.840
in the country on this, said, I'm not going to
777
00:43:12.880 --> 00:43:15.239
leave money on the table to get help our kids.
778
00:43:17.090 --> 00:43:17.269
Sure.
779
00:43:17.769 --> 00:43:19.449
And she's going to send 90% of that money to
780
00:43:19.489 --> 00:43:21.789
private school students in her state. And so good luck,
781
00:43:21.829 --> 00:43:25.030
Kathy Hochul. She's making a political choice in election season,
782
00:43:25.050 --> 00:43:26.909
and I respect all those other people for their choices.
783
00:43:27.869 --> 00:43:30.590
If we constantly settled on the status quo is what
784
00:43:30.610 --> 00:43:32.449
we just have to live with, we'd never make progress.
785
00:43:32.829 --> 00:43:35.050
There are groups all over this country in our history
786
00:43:35.610 --> 00:43:37.510
who we could have said, you know, let them make
787
00:43:37.530 --> 00:43:39.340
the choice in civil rights. Let them make the choice
788
00:43:39.360 --> 00:43:42.920
on equity. They'll probably do the right thing. Many cases
789
00:43:42.980 --> 00:43:45.860
they don't, and that's why we have these democratic institutions.
790
00:43:46.159 --> 00:43:48.719
Legislatures matter. Local school boards matter. And we can be
791
00:43:48.780 --> 00:43:51.579
frustrated with them, but I think elected officials should get
792
00:43:51.619 --> 00:43:56.260
those choices, not a private organization with zero accountability. We're
793
00:43:56.320 --> 00:43:58.320
not even allowed to figure out at this point under
794
00:43:58.360 --> 00:44:01.199
the rules who they gave the money to. Did they
795
00:44:01.219 --> 00:44:03.530
give it for tutoring? Did they give it for computers,
796
00:44:03.570 --> 00:44:07.070
which is apparently allowed? Did they let families buy uniforms
797
00:44:07.150 --> 00:44:11.250
for their private school? The Secretary of Education came to
798
00:44:11.309 --> 00:44:14.349
our state to promote this program, saying it's available to everyone,
799
00:44:14.389 --> 00:44:18.170
and she visited two private religious institutions in her tour.
800
00:44:18.190 --> 00:44:18.389
Wow.
801
00:44:19.210 --> 00:44:20.750
So no, I don't buy into the argument that because
802
00:44:20.769 --> 00:44:22.909
there's five Democrats who think it's a good idea, somehow
803
00:44:22.949 --> 00:44:24.250
it's this big bipartisan thing.
804
00:44:24.289 --> 00:44:26.849
But if you're helping, let's just sort of interrogate the
805
00:44:26.949 --> 00:44:31.170
idea that helping kids and middle-class families who send their
806
00:44:31.190 --> 00:44:33.969
kids to private school is a reason to not opt
807
00:44:34.050 --> 00:44:37.070
into this. I mean, is it going to fundamentally hurt
808
00:44:37.289 --> 00:44:39.570
the million-plus kids in public schools if we do this?
809
00:44:39.929 --> 00:44:42.219
And what's the downside of helping some kids who are
810
00:44:42.280 --> 00:44:45.559
in private or parochial schools?
811
00:44:45.920 --> 00:44:47.260
And well, I said, I'd love to help them do
812
00:44:47.280 --> 00:44:50.159
it as a tax credit or fund tutoring programs explicitly.
813
00:44:50.460 --> 00:44:52.679
Don't run this through the tax code, right? That's going
814
00:44:52.699 --> 00:44:55.969
to be the problem. And so there's nothing wrong with that.
815
00:44:56.250 --> 00:44:58.309
That's an equitable way to do it public and private.
816
00:45:00.250 --> 00:45:03.449
So we're back to this sort of argument of if
817
00:45:03.469 --> 00:45:06.289
you did incredible damage over here, is it okay to
818
00:45:06.309 --> 00:45:08.420
look the other way? You know what every member of
819
00:45:08.480 --> 00:45:10.460
Congress is going to do when they go back in January?
820
00:45:10.800 --> 00:45:12.360
They're going to try to undo the big, beautiful bill
821
00:45:12.380 --> 00:45:14.219
and they're going to try to replace food assistance for
822
00:45:14.239 --> 00:45:17.539
the vulnerable. medical care for our vulnerable seniors and they're
823
00:45:17.559 --> 00:45:20.340
going to try to put back affordable care subsidies and
824
00:45:20.360 --> 00:45:21.860
they're all going to run around say where'd all that
825
00:45:21.940 --> 00:45:24.679
money go and what they're going to tear down a
826
00:45:24.719 --> 00:45:27.699
program that's barely underway are they going to make cuts
827
00:45:27.760 --> 00:45:29.760
somewhere else or they're going to add more money to
828
00:45:29.780 --> 00:45:32.420
the U.S. deficit as if it's just free all the
829
00:45:32.460 --> 00:45:36.780
time we just keep pulling our future opportunity forward for
830
00:45:36.889 --> 00:45:38.800
everyone to benefit today and our kids are going to
831
00:45:38.840 -->
00:45:42.469
pay a dear price $ 112, 000 per human being in the
832
00:45:42.530 --> 00:45:45.639
United States right now and counting on the deficit It's
833
00:45:45.780 --> 00:45:47.840
just bad. It's just bad, and there's no way to
834
00:45:47.920 --> 00:45:50.340
argue it. You would get some benefit if we just
835
00:45:50.380 --> 00:45:53.159
jumped in today, no question about it. But the relative
836
00:45:53.219 --> 00:45:55.019
impact of that, when you could wait a year and
837
00:45:55.059 --> 00:45:58.949
go back and get it right, man, we are charged
838
00:45:58.989 --> 00:46:01.849
with taking the variables we have, making calculated risk and
839
00:46:01.889 --> 00:46:04.250
understanding when we can make something better. This thing has
840
00:46:04.269 --> 00:46:05.090
to get better.
841
00:46:06.869 --> 00:46:10.409
The Washington Student Success Coalition has formed. It includes Microsoft,
842
00:46:10.429 --> 00:46:14.230
Big Brothers, Big Sisters, Seattle Metro, Chamber, National Association of
843
00:46:14.269 --> 00:46:18.800
Education Foundations. They support opting in. Have you had conversations
844
00:46:18.840 --> 00:46:21.679
with that coalition or those individual groups?
845
00:46:21.780 --> 00:46:23.599
A little bit on the individual groups, and they make
846
00:46:23.639 --> 00:46:26.179
similar arguments like, hey, you know, yeah, sure, most of
847
00:46:26.199 --> 00:46:28.280
it might go over here, but we could get some benefit.
848
00:46:28.300 --> 00:46:30.380
And I say, absolutely, let's go make it right in
849
00:46:30.400 --> 00:46:33.019
a year and get you lots of benefit. They all,
850
00:46:33.219 --> 00:46:36.179
in some cases, have a direct reason why they benefit more.
851
00:46:36.239 --> 00:46:38.760
Some of these folks would get direct resources out of this.
852
00:46:39.199 --> 00:46:41.039
They get to keep 10% of the money as a
853
00:46:41.119 --> 00:46:42.659
scholarship-granting organization.
854
00:46:43.280 --> 00:46:45.480
But just to be clear, none of the– do you
855
00:46:45.760 --> 00:46:48.599
see– see any of the members of the Student Success
856
00:46:48.619 --> 00:46:52.000
Coalition actually becoming scholarship-granting organizations potentially?
857
00:46:52.820 --> 00:46:55.940
Some of them will be recipients. So an SGO will form,
858
00:46:56.300 --> 00:46:57.550
and then who are they going to give it out to?
859
00:46:57.550 --> 00:47:00.070
Because remember, you have to have a reimbursable expenditure. We
860
00:47:00.110 --> 00:47:02.789
are public schools. We don't charge. But there's an after-school
861
00:47:02.829 --> 00:47:06.750
program out there where we're charging families $ 200. So the
862
00:47:06.769 --> 00:47:09.190
Boys and Girls Clubs say, let us do this thing
863
00:47:09.230 --> 00:47:12.070
because then we can get that money and maybe subsidize
864
00:47:12.110 --> 00:47:15.090
those costs for kids in after-school programs. Again, we'll benefit
865
00:47:15.110 --> 00:47:18.550
a little. not worth the trade-off here. But I respect
866
00:47:18.570 --> 00:47:21.280
where they're at. These are folks, like so many, who
867
00:47:21.320 --> 00:47:23.659
say once the bad deed's already been done, we might
868
00:47:23.679 --> 00:47:25.619
as well get our share of it. I cannot live
869
00:47:25.679 --> 00:47:28.159
that way. I didn't get into public service to say
870
00:47:28.199 --> 00:47:29.800
every bad thing we've done in the past, we just
871
00:47:29.820 --> 00:47:31.480
have to live with. You go change them when they're
872
00:47:31.500 --> 00:47:31.800
not good.
873
00:47:33.110 --> 00:47:36.489
A couple of other examples of entities that are maybe
874
00:47:36.550 --> 00:47:40.510
reluctantly supporting this, the Southern Education Fund, which NPR says
875
00:47:40.550 --> 00:47:43.190
was created after the Civil War to ensure the schooling
876
00:47:43.210 --> 00:47:46.289
of of the children of formerly enslaved people. It's pivoted
877
00:47:46.369 --> 00:47:50.610
on this. It is creating an alliance of scholarship-granting organizations
878
00:47:50.710 --> 00:47:54.090
to specifically support public school students. Their focus is on
879
00:47:54.349 --> 00:47:58.699
specifically supporting public school kids. The foundation opposes private school vouchers,
880
00:47:58.739 --> 00:48:01.099
but the president and CEO says, quote, public school students
881
00:48:01.119 --> 00:48:04.380
should have every opportunity to benefit, and organizations committed to
882
00:48:04.420 --> 00:48:07.079
public education need to be at the table making sure
883
00:48:07.099 --> 00:48:11.610
they do. Again, that's this argument that there's a way
884
00:48:11.699 --> 00:48:14.849
to make this work. net positive for public school students.
885
00:48:15.570 --> 00:48:17.239
There is a way to put a lipstick on a
886
00:48:17.320 --> 00:48:20.000
pig to make it slightly more kissable. I understand that.
887
00:48:20.460 --> 00:48:22.860
In the meantime, there's a billion dollars a year owed
888
00:48:22.900 --> 00:48:24.860
to our state from the federal government to support students
889
00:48:24.880 --> 00:48:28.340
with disabilities. That's now years and years even further behind
890
00:48:28.389 --> 00:48:31.489
the possibilities because this money was diverted. So you can
891
00:48:31.510 --> 00:48:33.409
give me 10,000 groups. I can tell you that the
892
00:48:33.449 --> 00:48:36.250
last secretary of education who was actually qualified is violently
893
00:48:36.289 --> 00:48:38.150
opposed to this thing. I can share with you lots
894
00:48:38.190 --> 00:48:41.579
of groups who have said not right now. This is
895
00:48:41.659 --> 00:48:45.039
not going to be about that. It's going to be about,
896
00:48:45.539 --> 00:48:47.360
do we want a little bit of benefit for public
897
00:48:47.440 --> 00:48:52.039
ed students right now at the trade-off of this privatization shift?
898
00:48:52.539 -->
00:48:54.510
Do we want to then take this money off the
899
00:48:54.550 --> 00:48:56.650
table now so that a new Congress can't pull it
900
00:48:56.690 --> 00:48:59.829
back into health care and support for vulnerable seniors? These
901
00:48:59.869 --> 00:49:01.949
are just big policy choices. And some people live in
902
00:49:01.969 --> 00:49:03.670
the world of, let's get what we can while we can.
903
00:49:04.210 --> 00:49:06.630
And some of us say, no, let's actually not do
904
00:49:06.670 --> 00:49:08.630
that and give ourselves a better opportunity later.
905
00:49:08.750 --> 00:49:12.789
And part of why we're, I think, spending... the amount
906
00:49:12.829 --> 00:49:14.880
of time we are talking about this and debating it
907
00:49:14.960 --> 00:49:18.949
is that, again, it is striking the kind of coalitions
908
00:49:19.150 --> 00:49:22.380
and the voices that have emerged who are saying Washington
909
00:49:22.400 --> 00:49:25.539
should take a serious look at this and seem to
910
00:49:25.570 --> 00:49:27.389
be putting a lot of energy and effort into that
911
00:49:28.150 --> 00:49:31.150
and clearly feel maybe almost as passionately if not as
912
00:49:31.210 --> 00:49:33.610
passionately as you do but on the other side let
913
00:49:33.650 --> 00:49:35.329
me give you look let me loop back to this
914
00:49:35.389 --> 00:49:39.059
idea of um creating a Washington Public Schools Fund. So
915
00:49:39.079 --> 00:49:42.280
the group Excellent Schools Washington, which does support the public
916
00:49:42.340 --> 00:49:46.090
charter schools in Washington, is recommending the state opt-in. It
917
00:49:46.150 --> 00:49:48.949
says it's incubating a Washington Public Schools Fund that could
918
00:49:48.989 --> 00:49:52.030
serve as an SGO that would, as I mentioned earlier,
919
00:49:52.090 --> 00:49:56.250
voluntarily hold itself to higher standards, including around non-discrimination, and
920
00:49:56.289 --> 00:49:59.019
would ensure the dollars go to public school students. It
921
00:49:59.059 --> 00:50:01.460
says the fund is already working with national experts to
922
00:50:01.519 --> 00:50:04.440
identify eligible programming and would work with the districts to
923
00:50:04.480 --> 00:50:11.440
maximize the opportunity that this tax credit program offers. It
924
00:50:11.500 --> 00:50:14.500
seems like there are people with really good intentions who
925
00:50:14.599 --> 00:50:17.500
really don't want us to miss what they see as
926
00:50:17.539 --> 00:50:21.800
a potential opportunity here. And I'm just, again, isn't that
927
00:50:21.860 --> 00:50:26.179
somewhat compelling to you? Or what do you think they're missing?
928
00:50:27.559 --> 00:50:29.599
It's compelling because they care about kids, and that's awesome.
929
00:50:29.619 --> 00:50:31.039
So wait a year, and let's get them more money.
930
00:50:31.460 --> 00:50:32.460
Or Not.
931
00:50:32.559 --> 00:50:34.420
Maybe Congress doesn't do anything different in a
year from
932
00:50:34.460 --> 00:50:36.219
now because you have to opt in each year. It's
933
00:50:36.260 --> 00:50:38.360
not a once and done. So we'll come back when
934
00:50:38.400 --> 00:50:40.280
it's mature, when they've had time to build a program,
935
00:50:40.300 --> 00:50:42.079
when they've had time to market it to donors, when
936
00:50:42.099 --> 00:50:44.039
they've had time to tell us what they'll spend the
937
00:50:44.079 --> 00:50:46.239
money on. Like, great, let's do this in a year.
938
00:50:46.960 --> 00:50:48.639
This will be very small in the first year anyways
939
00:50:48.659 --> 00:50:50.179
because you've got a lot of work to get people
940
00:50:50.219 --> 00:50:52.420
to trust that they can give $ 1, 700 away and get
941
00:50:52.460 --> 00:50:54.739
it back. So no disrespect to that.
942
00:50:54.800 --> 00:50:55.320
It's great.
943
00:50:55.340 --> 00:50:57.239
If the governor opts us in, I think it'll be
944
00:50:57.280 --> 00:51:03.559
a tremendous blow. to everything we've argued around using those
945
00:51:03.619 --> 00:51:05.900
dollars for the most vulnerable families, but we're also going
946
00:51:05.920 --> 00:51:07.599
to follow the law, and groups like this are going
947
00:51:07.619 --> 00:51:10.159
to make it better by working hard, and we'll figure
948
00:51:10.219 --> 00:51:13.079
out a positive way forward as best we can. But
949
00:51:13.119 --> 00:51:14.820
that's not a tradeoff that we should take right now.
950
00:51:15.449 --> 00:51:19.710
Just let me go kind of one more level down
951
00:51:19.789 --> 00:51:23.730
on this, which is you, of all people, have been
952
00:51:23.750 --> 00:51:26.590
talking about the scarcity that public schools are experiencing. There's
953
00:51:26.670 --> 00:51:29.190
budget gaps. There's cuts to enrichment programs. There's not enough
954
00:51:29.230 --> 00:51:33.360
academic intervention. you are always arguing on behalf of funding
955
00:51:33.400 --> 00:51:37.940
for public schools. Again, now there is potentially upwards, I
956
00:51:37.940 --> 00:51:40.239
don't want to inflate the numbers, but some are saying
957
00:51:40.260 --> 00:51:41.940
it could be as much as a billion dollars on
958
00:51:41.960 --> 00:51:45.659
the table. What if this did go, not just for
959
00:51:45.719 --> 00:51:48.219
money for private school tuition, but for books or test
960
00:51:48.280 --> 00:51:52.199
prep or tutoring or supplemental special education services, which I
961
00:51:52.239 --> 00:51:56.070
know you're super passionate about, music and arts education, summer programs,
962
00:51:56.949 --> 00:51:59.690
technology after school programs. I mean, these are the kinds
963
00:51:59.750 --> 00:52:01.670
of things that the people who are saying yes to
964
00:52:01.690 --> 00:52:04.849
this say could be benefit. And these are all things
965
00:52:04.909 --> 00:52:08.679
that are not getting the resources I know you want
966
00:52:08.719 --> 00:52:09.179
them to get.
967
00:52:10.519 --> 00:52:13.000
First of all, our state won't allow you to do
968
00:52:13.059 --> 00:52:15.340
anything that's constitutional basic ed. So they all have to
969
00:52:15.380 --> 00:52:17.719
be outside of that. So after school works and, you know,
970
00:52:17.760 --> 00:52:21.570
summer art programs work, not supplemental support for students, individualized
971
00:52:21.610 --> 00:52:24.389
education plan, not supports for students with disabilities. So those
972
00:52:24.429 --> 00:52:27.409
are all good things. And like, let's, Make this thing
973
00:52:27.449 --> 00:52:30.500
right so it actually goes there. Would I take $ 200
974
00:52:30.019 --> 00:52:33.059
million of that if $ 800 million of it went over
975
00:52:33.099 --> 00:52:35.119
here at the cost of what they had to cut
976
00:52:35.159 --> 00:52:37.500
to do that? That's not a good policy tradeoff, even
977
00:52:37.539 --> 00:52:40.019
though our hearts compel us. Like, if there's even $ 1,
978
00:52:39.679 --> 00:52:42.869
we should do it. I don't believe that.
979
00:52:42.909 --> 00:52:44.090
And when you say at the cost of what they
980
00:52:44.130 --> 00:52:45.409
had to cut, you mean in terms of the big,
981
00:52:45.429 --> 00:52:46.190
beautiful bill?
982
00:52:46.469 --> 00:52:47.269
Oh, tremendously.
983
00:52:47.530 --> 00:52:49.710
So now our legislature is scrambling to fill up a
984
00:52:49.690 --> 00:52:52.090
$ 3 or $ 4 billion hole left by the federal government.
985
00:52:52.820 --> 00:52:55.579
And they're turning around trying to ask the voters now,
986
00:52:56.309 --> 00:52:58.769
for something that would at least try to extricate some
987
00:52:58.809 --> 00:53:00.809
money out of the wealthiest people in our state, which
988
00:53:00.869 --> 00:53:02.809
many people are fighting that because they believe it'll come
989
00:53:02.829 --> 00:53:07.289
down to them. So anytime you divert publicly intended dollars
990
00:53:07.349 --> 00:53:11.329
to private choices, the probability of ever backfilling the real
991
00:53:11.369 --> 00:53:13.840
need is very low. And all I can guarantee you
992
00:53:13.860 --> 00:53:15.719
with a program like this is Congress has already got
993
00:53:15.739 --> 00:53:17.699
a billion dollars less money that could come to Washington
994
00:53:17.739 --> 00:53:21.840
State to fund our basic education needs for private choices,
995
00:53:21.960 --> 00:53:25.849
which that is what a Republican White House, the Republican Senate,
996
00:53:25.869 --> 00:53:28.550
and Republican House believed was the right plan. They wrote it.
997
00:53:28.570 --> 00:53:32.159
They told us about it. I respect their political power
998
00:53:32.199 --> 00:53:35.360
right now. It's not the best thing for kids universally,
999
00:53:35.619 --> 00:53:36.380
and we can make it better.
1000
00:53:36.679 --> 00:53:38.440
So less than a minute left, you wrote in an
1001
00:53:38.519 --> 00:53:42.059
October 9th letter to Governor Ferguson that Washington cannot in
1002
00:53:42.079 --> 00:53:46.170
good faith participate in this program. What response or conversations
1003
00:53:46.449 --> 00:53:47.829
have you had with the governor? What do you think
1004
00:53:48.250 --> 00:53:48.650
he's going to do?
1005
00:53:49.500 --> 00:53:51.119
I don't know what he'll do. It's a hard choice.
1006
00:53:51.260 --> 00:53:52.860
He's going to frustrate a lot of people on either
1007
00:53:52.900 --> 00:53:55.539
side of this thing. He's been consistent. He's looking at
1008
00:53:55.559 --> 00:53:58.139
it legally. He's looking at it for all the reasons
1009
00:53:58.199 --> 00:54:00.699
he would. Is it good on balance?
1010
00:54:01.079 --> 00:54:01.780
All the rest of that.
1011
00:54:02.000 --> 00:54:04.559
And he'll make a choice and we'll follow along no
1012
00:54:04.599 --> 00:54:05.099
matter what.
1013
00:54:05.599 --> 00:54:07.449
Has he given you any tea leaves? Have you had
1014
00:54:07.469 --> 00:54:09.510
a conversation since the letter? Has he responded?
1015
00:54:09.530 --> 00:54:09.590
No.
1016
00:54:10.989 --> 00:54:13.630
And do you plan to lobby him anymore on this?
1017
00:54:14.309 --> 00:54:16.650
I've sent my letter. We gave the legal arguments. We
1018
00:54:16.690 --> 00:54:19.010
said how the thing could improve. We said that there's
1019
00:54:19.030 --> 00:54:21.110
a future for us in this thing if it can improve.
1020
00:54:21.630 --> 00:54:24.389
So we didn't shut any doors. He's got a difficult
1021
00:54:24.409 --> 00:54:25.090
decision to make.
1022
00:54:25.179 --> 00:54:28.320
And bottom line, you're speaking, your opposition is rooted in
1023
00:54:28.340 --> 00:54:31.340
your role as the state superintendent of public instruction, not
1024
00:54:31.380 --> 00:54:34.380
being a former lawmaker, not liking the president or what
1025
00:54:34.420 --> 00:54:37.699
Congress has done. This is really fundamentally about what you
1026
00:54:37.719 --> 00:54:39.480
think is best for the public school kids of the state.
1027
00:54:39.519 --> 00:54:39.960
That's right.
1028
00:54:40.059 --> 00:54:42.159
If it's a billion dollars that could have been directly
1029
00:54:42.199 --> 00:54:44.349
sent here to focus on the highest needs, it was
1030
00:54:44.409 --> 00:54:46.389
run through the tax code so that most of it
1031
00:54:46.449 --> 00:54:47.829
will not support public ed.
1032
00:54:48.179 --> 00:54:51.079
Okay, we'll stop there. State School Superintendent Chris Richtel, thanks
1033
00:54:51.099 --> 00:54:51.460
for coming in.
1034
00:54:51.460 --> 00:54:51.710
Thank you.
1035
00:54:51.719 --> 00:54:53.909
We'll have you on soon to talk about other issues.
1036
00:54:54.070 --> 00:54:54.300
All right.
1037
00:54:54.429 --> 00:54:56.469
Thank you for watching Inside Olympia. We'll see you again
1038
00:54:56.489 --> 00:54:56.829
next week.