תעתיק 🔗
Hugo Fonseca: Welcome to Herdless, the property podcast that doesn't follow the crowd. I'm Hugo Fonseca, head of tpb invest, and every hump day we cut through the property market noise, challenge the headlines, and look at what the numbers are actually telling us. No fluff, no herd mentality, and definitely no crystal balls. Let's get into it. We've all heard the argument, you think you've got it tough. We were paying double-digit interest rates back in the 90s, etc. And those repayments were tough. I'm not dismissing that. But the one thing that people aren't looking at is the size of the loan, right? The interest rate only tells us part of the story.
Maria: you
Hugo Fonseca: What were you actually borrowing back then, and how did it actually compare with what you earned versus what's happening now? That's what makes the affordability figures interesting. the real Real estates.com.au report recently found that a typical income household could afford just 12% of homes in FY26. That was 43% just five years ago. So that typical household was actually earning around $125,000. So we're talking about people that are earning a reasonable income and still having relatively few options. If you think about the maths, let me just run some numbers past you. A $300,000 loan at 17% means $51,000 a year in interest. Fast forward to now, a nine hundred thousand dollar loan at six percent is actually fifty-four thousand dollars in interest. So interest is like a third of what it was, but Because the loans are bigger, the prices are higher, you're actually paying a lot more. So it is more unaffordable now, and it is harder now than it was back in the day, as as they say. It's obviously a simplified example, and it does include principal repayments, etc., but it really shows why the smaller percentage on its own doesn't necessarily mean that the burden is smaller. So when you're at the next family barbecue and you hear someone say something like that, just remember that everyone remembers. rate that they were on or are on now, but you very rarely talk about the balance of your loan and how much you actually owe. and that's once you've actually bought, right? Before that, you're still trying to save a deposit while paying rent, which by the way is also at record highs. You also having to incur all of your living expenses, which are also higher now than they used to be and continue to increase. So there's a lot more factors to keep in mind when you're looking at buying. And then once you actually buy, there's everything else. Insurance, maintenance, all the other property expenses that once again are higher now and continue to increase. So that actually leads me to an interesting question. And a lot of people talk about smaller deposit schemes. So all the different government schemes where you don't need as high a deposit in order to get into the market. They they can actually Yeah, obviously be useful for someone with a strong income who hasn't accumulated enough savings to have that deposit. But helping someone get into that loan doesn't necessarily mean that the repayments are going to be comfortable or that they're going to be able to sustain that. So if you have more buyers that can enter without more homes becoming available, what happens then? Exactly what happened last year when we had the expansion of the first homeowner scheme and we injected more demand into the market than we had supply that could cater for it. For me, the the useful conversation here isn't so much about which generation had it harder or you know the who who Had it tougher in order to get into the market or to be able to afford it. It's about whether people can actually realistically sustain today's affordability challenges. What compromises make sense? What breathing room do they need? What buffers do they need to allow for? Because just getting approved for a loan and being comfortable with it long term are two very different things. Even in this difficult affordability environment though, you can still find some really good quality individual properties that offer some really good value. And that brings me to something else that I wanted to talk about today as well, which is around buying below replacement cost. It gets talked about a lot. we also talk a lot about needing more housing. But there's a fairly basic question underneath all the targets and the announcements. And that's whether someone can actually afford to deliver those homes. At the price that buyers can pay or are paying or are willing to pay at the moment. The cost of actually producing a property and what the market's going to pay for it are two very different things. You've got to consider land, labor, materials, infrastructure, all the fees, and obviously the red tape and the bureaucracy that we all know exists as well. And that's all gonna feed into the cost to deliver the project. But when you've got a softer property market at the moment. Then how are you gonna actually be able to make that project feasible and actually walk away from it without being in the red and running at a loss? That's a really key point at the moment that isn't getting talked about enough and is going to impact supply in the long term once we get past this downturn. So all of a sudden, you're gonna have the taps turning back on, more demand coming back into the market. But guess what? We've actually built less than we were building before, and that shows. In a lot of the figures, and therefore we will have less supply to cater for that newly found demand that will come. So that's the squeeze that I wanted to explore. Because in in parts of the market, the selling price doesn't actually justify the cost and the risk of delivering that project. So a project doesn't have to be automatically loss making for it to stall or not go ahead. If there's not enough margin anyway, you won't be able to potentially satisfy your lending conditions from the bank either and therefore it might
Load full transcript
never get funded and it never takes off. In fact, I I'm gonna use a bit of an example here and just again run some numbers past you. If you've got a small development that might be expected to generate, say, ten million dollars in in sales, that's a total cost, right? Including land, construction, fees, finance, and and a bit of a contingency as well. You will need to fund it fully and ultimately the cost to deliver it is ten and a half but you've only generated ten million in sales. It's a straightforward loss. Even if the costs were just nine point eight million, that tiny remaining margin isn't going to be sufficient to cover the risk either. So the developer might defer the project, they might redesign it, they might renegotiate costs, or they might also do what we see happening quite often nowadays and try and cut corners. They'll cut corners in terms of the materials that they use, they'll cut corners in terms of the construction methods that they use, and ultimately you're still going to be paying a premium for that property, even though you're no longer getting a premium product. So replacement costs don't necessarily guarantee that prices will rise because you still need the market to be willing to pay those amounts, and therefore there's always going to be that that challenge in that gap. That gap has actually widened recently, and that is what's putting even more strain on the supply. There's something else as well, because there's also an interesting buyer angle here that I wanted to talk about. If you can imagine just a single property that might cost, let's say, 1.8 million to to replace or to recreate, including land and all the associated costs. If a completed home or an established home is available for 1.55 million, then that could be a much more attractive alternative to building, especially in the current market. It doesn't necessarily mean that just because you're buying something for one point five five, you've instantly made two hundred and fifty thousand dollars in in profit, for example, if it if the replacement cost is one point eight million, because you've got to consider other factors as well that you're not looking at in terms of what the finishes are like in those properties, what the layout is, what materials have been used, etcetera You buying an existing property for one point five five and something being built for one point eight doesn't mean that yours automatically is worth one point. Eight. So it's not always a bargain, but it is something that you need to consider. And we need to discuss what needs to change for projects to start becoming viable and long-term supply to come back into the market. There's a third factor that I wanted to talk about today as well, and that's interest rates because they're going to affect both sides. What buyers can pay, but also what developers pay to finance that construction. I'm going to make a big call here. My view is that we won't get another rate hike in November. That's
just my forecast. And the next inflation result could actually challenge it and mean that we do get a rate rise. But the emerging weakness in employment, the pressure on households out at the moment as well, make me think that there's a stronger case for waiting than to actually raise rates. And I'll talk you through some of the factors as to why. One is unemployment. So it's actually fallen by 39 about 39,000 in the September reporting, and unemployment has ticked up to 4.7%. That's important, and it's not the only thing that you need to look at, but it's a sign of weakness in the economy and potentially a sign of things to come. What interests me more though is how the pressure spreads. So if you imagine a household, one person in these tighter economic times might have lost their overtime that they were always relying upon. The other person in the family might be worrying about job security because there's talks about job cuts, et cetera. Just yesterday, NAB announced 2,500 jobs being cut as an example, right? So that impacts their confidence. They're gonna postpone large-scale purchases, including potentially upgrading their home. They'll cut back on spending and they're just gonna become more cautious. We're already seeing that happening out in the market across Australia. Local businesses are gonna feel it as well. And because there's weaker spending and less consumption from those households, they're gonna be cautious themselves. So it's it's a snowball essentially, because they're bringing in less, they're gonna be more cautious in investing less and therefore hiring less and potentially even doing the opposite and having to cut jobs, which then triggers higher unemployment. That's how weakness can build. It doesn't mean that we're in a recession already now. and if you look at the numbers, of course, the figures say that we're not in terms of GDP figures. But it does raise the question as to how much more pressure the economy can actually absorb. You know, it's not like the economy gets a rate increase on a Tuesday and then it's reorganized itself and it's all functioning by by Friday. Like things take time to actually land and trickle down through the economy. But there's something else and another part of this discussion. Even if I'm right about the interest rate hold in November, it doesn't give us a simple answer about property prices. And this is actually really interesting. We've spent a lot of time researching this and looking at the data. Normally we assume that higher rates mean lower prices and lower rates mean higher prices. It makes sense, doesn't it? If repayments are higher, borrowing capacity is lower, it's harder to buy something. If rates are lower and you have more access to credit, then it's easier to borrow and to buy things than you assume prices would go up. But they don't always work that way. If we look at the previous cycle, Prop Track actually recorded 11 consecutive months of national price growth all the way to November 2023. So by then prices were 5.5% higher than the low in December 2022. But here's the clincher: the cash rate reached its peak, so the highest point prior to then rate cuts coming in that same November. And then stayed there until February 2025 when they did the first cut. So if you think about that, as rates were increasing all the way to November 2023, so were property prices for 11 consecutive months. So there wasn't a correlation there as an example. So you can't always assume that high rates mean lower prices and vice versa. Now why did that happen? There's a few factors and let's look at them and then have a look at whether they're still present now as well. We had strong population growth, right? Do we still have strong population growth now? Yes, we do. We had tight rental markets. Do we still have tight rental markets now? We sure do. And rents are even higher now than they were before because of that as well. We had low unemployment, we still have low unemployment, although I've noticed and I've mentioned that it is ticking up. But one thing that existed was that existing owners had a lot of equity that they were sitting in because of the growth that had already occurred in the past as well. And with the lower rates at that time, there was a lot more people borrowing to buy, even though rates were on the way up. There was one other factor which was limited stock. We didn't have enough supply, and we had all that demand coming in, and it was still sustained even through the rate rises without enough supply. Guess what? I just talked about before. There's not going to be enough supply once we come out the other end of this downturn. So you're going to have an increase in demand, you're going to have population continuing to grow. You still have rental markets that are tight. They're probably going to be tighter even because a lot of investors have pulled out, and those probably Properties have exited the rental pool and won't come back anytime soon. So the conditions are set for prices to go up fairly strongly at some stage in the near future, and that is another reason why I think rates will need to be on hold in November for a wait-and-see approach. Talking about rates and the relationship with prices though, I always like to give both sides of the argument. And so it can also work the other way. In late 2020, housing finance was obviously at a historical affordability level in terms of being the cheapest it it had ever been. We had really low rates, obviously, and the RBA reported Sydney and Melbourne prices declining over that period since its August statement, whilst other markets rose. So, you know, when you're worried about your job or what happens next, just having lower rates or having a cheaper loan doesn't automatically make you want to buy. So just have a think about that because that really paints a different picture to what everyone talks about all the time in terms of what rates do to prices. So waiting for a cut isn't a financial decision. There's people talking about it, saying, and I'll go back into the market when the rates start coming down, as an example. It could be that you're impacted from a borrowing capacity point of view, but I wouldn't be making a decision as to whether to buy or not solely based on whether rates are going up or they're going down. It doesn't guarantee you the right market timing or the timing of the bottom as a lot of people think that they're able to do either. Rates coming down will improve your borrowing capacity, we know that. And it might bring some more competing buyers back as well. So that's the thing that you've got to consider as well is if rates are coming down and more people are more confident and they're all coming back in, all of a sudden you're back at square one competing and fighting over each other to purchase a property. And that in itself raises prices, so you're chasing your tail again. The strongest challenge to my November forecast, and this is the caveat that I'll call, is inflation. The IBA is obviously concerned about it. We've all seen the the prices of petrol and diesel in particular, which I own one at the the petrol Bowser. So there is a risk that if inflation stays that high, we may need to have an interest rate rise. 28th of October is when they released inflation data. So keep an eye on that particular day and that data that comes out that day, because that will have a really strong impact on the 3rd November decision for the rate. Where I'd leave buyers is this: you gotta have a view on rates, obviously, but Don't let one forecast, whether it's a hold or a raise, etc., affect your whole purchasing decision. You gotta understand the property that you're looking at, understand your local competition. Make sure, as I mentioned before, that you can comfortably hold it if the economy does something different to what it's doing now as well. Super important. And that's a wrap for this week's Herdless. If you enjoyed the episode, give us a follow, share it with someone who could use a little less property hype. I'm Hugo Fonseca and remember, don't follow the herd, own the paddock See you next hump day.