תעתיק 🔗
EditBay Ep108 Audio Edit: Mm-hmm. In Edit Bay, The Alchemy of Postproduction, we are pulling back the curtain on post-production in TV and film. What it is, how it operates, who are the people behind it, why it matters, and how it is used synergistically with production to create storytelling alchemy. I'm Mallory Yund, a 20-year post-production professional in Los Angeles and a producer on the Netflix hits Obliterated and Cobra Kai. Joining me is Patrick Hogan. Who, aside from being an award-winning independent filmmaker, has been immersed in post-sound for 30 years as the supervising sound editor on dozens of shows, including Roswell, New Mexico, Fire Country, and Cobra Kai. On today's episode of Edit Bay, we are diving a little deeper into the cuts process. To illuminate the nuances of this seemingly simple process, we are joined by assistant editor Nicole Acevedo, editor Anthony Rosk. And Cobra Kai executive producer John Hurwitz. Through stops and starts, discussion and discord, all shadowed by a ticking clock, this could be the most dramatic element of any episode. Join the journey now. Hello, hello. Today we are taking a little bit of a deeper dive into the workflow of the cuts process. While this process exists in features as well, we're going to be speaking specifically towards the television process because that's where we all work and because it happens so much in TV. Joining us today are executive producer and sharerunner John Hurwitz, editor Anthony Rosk, and assistant editor Nicole Acevedo. All our colleagues and collaborators from the Netflix Hit Shows, Obliterated and Cobra Kai. Welcome guys. So happy to have you here. Glad to be here. Thanks for having us. Agreed. Thank you. Yeah. So first I just want to take a little bit of a dive into what the cuts process entails. Just some technical things before we get into some of the more creative process. So if you for you know anybody watching this, if you watch the episode on workflows. You saw this. So this is an outline, a pictorial outline of what the cuts looks like. From Dailies Media to the assistant editor to the editor, and then we have the editors cut, the director's cut, producers or studio cut, and then finally, you know, a network cut as well. All these go back and forth. Yeah, if you're listening to this on the audio only, it looks like spaghetti. Lines going back and forth. It's like you're just throwing spaghetti at a ball. It's an it looks like the editor is octopus attached to a lot of people. Yeah. Yeah. So this is just to give us a reminder of what exactly we're talking about. And I'm gonna go to a different screen really fast to again just give a quick rundown technically of what this workflow looks like. What do you guys? Okay, good. That's the right thing. So in any cuts process, we're gonna have our quick time specs, our watermarks, but the formatting is what's gonna get established in this part of the process too. What does the head formatting look like? Where does the slate come in? What are the logos that are gonna be included? Where does the program start? Does it start at hour one or does it start at hour zero? Different studios and networks require different things. And then as we go Down through our cuts, then we get to, you know, more of a locked cut look, where we list all of the logos, we list all of the crew cards, we list all the head formatting, the program. And we want to make sure that this part happens during the cuts phase, before lock, so that studio and network understand what the total time of the episode is going to be. That's just a really quick, really quick rundown of what we're talking about. However, what I brought our friends here to talk about is a little bit more of the nuts and bolts in the room. What is it like to be in there to get these notes that you have to then kind of figure out which ones you really want to do? Do you think I feel like some of the people in here are having PTSD right now looking at that, Mallory. I hope we're bringing back some happy memories, not just Dealing with this group, it's happy memories. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Exactly. Wait, you know what? We were all in this this quagmire together. We made it out safely on the other side. Although I see a grin from Nicole, yeah, she knows. She knows how this all goes. In the background. so literally had that on my notes, like, Nicole's probably gonna be nodding and shuddering at this point. Yes, and that is exactly what happened. It's tough when you're in it. Say that again, Nicole. It's tough when you're in it, but you know, it's it's always like when you're on the other side and it's done, you're like, it was all worth it. It just a little tough when you're doing it. Like, yeah. Yeah. No, exactly. And and this is the part where we get so many voices in the room. There are people who want to bring their their opinion to the table, their ideas, how they want the episode to go. And and it is kind of one of the more political processes of the entire Entire workflow of getting a TV show to air. So, Anthony, I want to start with you to take us into the cuts process from a creative standpoint. How long do you typically get or would it be ideal to get for an editor's cut? And what are your considerations while you're putting it all together? the ideal length for an editor's cut, I think I can speak for all editors, would be indefinite. But unfortunately, you know, if you have worked on TV before, you just know that there's always this ticking clock called the schedule. And these shows and production, it's a it's a freight train. Once you start that thing's going down the tracks, it's going and it's it's not gonna stop. so once the dailies start coming in, you gotta play catch up, you gotta stay up to schedule. You gotta make decisions very quickly. And usually you get, you know, if it's a seven day shoot, six day shoot, you get those six days, and then you get three to four days to put your editor's cut together.
Load full transcript
you know, barring any sort of extensions or if there's pickups, maybe you get an extra day or so. but creatively, initially You hope to be part of the tone meeting before the the shooting happens. that's always invaluable. You get an idea of what the showrunners, the producers, directors are going to be going for with the shoot. And then once the footage starts coming in, you start to see whether they were successful or whether there were things that maybe you need to help along. And then and then yeah, and then you just start making decisions. You start, you know, putting it Putting the performances together, you start to get an idea of the pace of the show, transitions, and then you just try to get it to a point where you can then start, you can deliver it to the director, and then he can start to see, okay, what were the decisions that I made that I need to maybe correct, or what were the ways that we need to go to get it to a point where we can start thinking about it, you know, on a global story scale. Brilliant. So how involved do you get your assistant editor at this point? In the editor's cup process, usually it's right away. I mean, they're they're prepping the dailies. once I get something on a scene on its feet, usually I like to have have them chase me with sound work. That's a big important part. you want to, you know, you don't want anything in the background to distract people from the story, whether that's working or not. And little technical things, temporary visual effects. Again, things that just tell the story. they'll be chasing me the whole time. So we're we're involved from the first day. Get them involved right away. Yeah, I mean it it it can only really serve to to help help you, that is their role, to support you to help the story along, to keep keep that freight train moving. Can't have it derail that early in the process. Absolutely. What are some Typical or maybe atypical notes that you get back in general, or maybe some specific examples from your editor's cut. Like I feel like sometimes it can be like deciphering hieroglyphs with some of these notes. And it it can be difficult to interpret unless you have a larger understanding of the director's or EP's language as a whole. Yeah. Yeah, you get some notes back, and sometimes you're you're you're looking at what what you're seeing, and you're like, wait, I just don't quite understand what you're going for. But I feel like as the editor, your your job is to at least give it a try. Like the last thing you want to tell someone is, no, I, you know, we don't either have it or no, I can't do that. even if you know that that note necessarily isn't going to be successful, I feel like it's it's your job to at least get a version of the note or try to figure out what the note actually means what you know the note behind the note. and then yeah, you know, sometimes you'll go down stylistic rabbit holes and you just know that once the showrunners are gonna get it, they're gonna be like, let's reverse course. And so if you do get a note that's way out in left field, you try to at least show that version to say a director. But then have a version in your back pocket that more is gonna fit you know, fit the intention of of the EPs. Could you c for our audience, could you explain a little bit more about the note behind the note? Because one thing I've discovered is beginning filmmakers, maybe even sometimes beginning showrunners, and especially beginning editors, at haven't figured out yet what that means and and sometimes stay on the surface and don't dig deeper. What do you mean when you say the note behind the note or the note within the note? Yeah, some sometimes people will react to say like characters or performance or or lines. and and the scene, like they'll react to a scene and they just won't feel like it's working and they won't exactly know why. And sometimes executives or Directors will maybe they'll say, okay, it's not working. Can we either lose the scene or or what can we do with this scene? can we cut these lines or reduce characters? when really the scene is working fine. It's just that we haven't necessarily found the emotional anchor of the scene or the the POV isn't quite dialed in. And once you get You get those things aligned, all of a sudden, wow, emotionally the scene is paying off, or this character now is totally paying off. And then that by figuring out exactly why people aren't reacting or connecting to it, then you can satisfy those notes. Not necessarily by doing them as they're written on the page, but all of a sudden you've you've you've basically given them, told them. why it wasn't working and you fixed it for them without them even asking for it. $5,000 film school class right there for free given to everybody from Anthony. They don't necessarily all have Anthony's talent to do that. But it's a good point. But there's still something to work towards. Yeah. Yeah, no, it's it's a lot just you know jumping in real quick, you know, the note behind the note is something that is throughout the entire process of filmmaking And you know, it's it's recognizing that, okay, something isn't working for whoever the the viewer is or a group of viewers are. And then even if they're throwing out suggestions, their suggestions may also not work, but you're you're understanding why they didn't connect. And then it's the the the challenge and the fun when you succeed is to have the solution that makes everyone realize exactly what needed to happen. Yeah, there's something special when you just see something and you go, yeah, there it is. Yep. there it is. And just it wasn't on your your notes pad in the first place. No, and that going back to one of your previous questions, it's the the solutions, finding the solutions. Even if even if you know, like say you get a note or you know, you're sitting there and one of the notes you get back, you're like, Okay, this I know they're not gonna like this, or this
isn't necessarily gonna work. It's in the trying something, trying to figure something out, trying to make something work that you may find these happy accidents, these alternate versions, that all of a sudden you're like, man, this is cool. I didn't think of it like this before. This is worth worth showing, you know, like I'll show John, like, hey, you know, you gave me this note, we worked on this, this is great, but I found this look or I found this this line, maybe if we moved it here. What do you think? And they don't always go for it, but I think sometimes it even later on you can, those things can pay off. you keep just digging and digging and digging, and you never know what you're gonna find. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So through through this whole process, you and it it it seems so obvious to me, but you know, I've been working in this industry for 20 years, but you you take a very large and hands on creative role in in the outcome. and the expectations of of it the episode that you're working on. It's not just, okay, slap some cuts together. Yeah, I think this'll work. And they'll tell me what to do later. Right. No. initially the first the first editor's cut, you're you're basically you are just kind of you're making your first initial instincts, you know, performance, pace, you know, you're making those quick decisions to get something up on its feet because you only have a few days to get it. to get it going. So you you watch the dailies, you pick the performances, and then with the director, they'll usually have their very specific moments and ideas that they had, like sequences that they really wanted, you know, they had something very stylistic they wanted to do. so as long as they can watch that first cut and the performances are at least at a baseline level where they're like, okay, I'm I'm happy with that. They'll they'll more focus in on specific sequences or moments that they really want to nail before they pass it off to the showrunners. So you're working a little bit more general and specifically on certain beats to really make those hit. And then the further on down the line you kind of really start to dial in and drill down on major story character moments and shaping those. to the original vision of of the writers and creators of the show. And then once you get to the studio side, then you're getting very nitpicky. You're getting very, very nitpicky. So a lot of their follow up. Do we lose this joke? Do we keep this joke? Is this funny or not? You know, things like that. So creatively, yeah, your your brain has to work in in a lot of different capacities and in different modes throughout the whole process. Mm-hmm. And that's that's what I love about editing. You're you're constantly thinking story, creative, broad, very micro. It's yeah, it's a little bit of everything. Yeah, zooming in and out constantly. Just is this working? Is this working for the whole house? Is working for this beat? Nicole, I wanna switch over to you
for a second. And we and I know Anthony has has touched on this a little bit, but just so you can expand, what is your typical workflow or way of working to support your editor and the CUDS process as a whole? And where do you put your creative acumen to work in this process? So I guess I kind of do two kind of complementary roles. So right, my main job is to kind of support the editor at any time, kind of do whatever they need. and I do that in my mind by kind of keeping things as on the rails as possible and as organized as possible. So that you know, if Anthony's like, do we have like, you know, John might send a note and he's like, do we and Anthony might be like, do we have this? And I'll be like, you know what? I don't know, but I know where I can look. and that's kind of like my job is to kind of keep things moving along this like pipeline on a freight train that's like not gonna stop if I don't unless I get it unless I do something wrong. So I'm always kind of of the mindset to like keep ahead of things, anticipate what we might need. You know, we're we're gonna need music here. And I know we probably don't have a cue for this. So can we contact the music team to see if they can get us something or if they have a suggestion of a song that we have previously that might work. and then like on the creative side, I do a lot of sound work for Anthony, particularly Cobra Kai was a pretty sound intensive show. we had a lot of fight scenes, and those need a lot of work. so that they kind of work in the editorial phase and then they go over to the sound team and they just make them twenty times better than anything I could do. So but yeah it's a good chance to kind of like try things out, teach myself something new, right? because I'm not necessarily always knowledgeable how to do something. So yeah, it's a chance to kind of like compliment what Anthony's doing if at all possible. And then sometimes, you know, if he has questions or wants some feedback, I'm happy to think through the same problem because we're we're trying to move the project in the same direction always. So the fun part about it is how can we solve this problem? Like you didn't think of this, but maybe maybe we could try that. And like might be a bad suggestion, but it's worth giving it a shot. So yeah, yeah. I do I do want to add too, yeah, that that's a big important part that Nicole will usually be the first person To to see a version of a cut of a scene and give feedback, because it's as the editor, you can get so so microfocused on something that, you know, to see a larger view of, well, is the scene working or or what am I, you know, what do you see in this scene that it's invaluable sometimes to have Nicole come in and I'll say, Hey, can you watch this and let me know? Is you know, is it working? and I think that's an important part for For the assistant editor too to to be well versed in in story and edit you know, editorial, you know, in terms of decisions and and characters and things, or if if those things are working, she'll be able to tell me and I'll be like, Okay, great, and I'll move on. Is that why I mean, I think that would explain I I see I noticed that, you know, obviously there's a teamwork there and you see a lot of editors and AE's who always work together. And I think is that the that trust and that ability to to talk and and work together and get honest feedback to each other. Is that part of why you kind of find those teams that end up kind of working together frequently? Absolutely. Yeah. And I think I John would know this as well as as anyone too, that that's the biggest part is to find the people and the team and surround yourself with the people that you just develop a shorthand with. Yeah, it's every part of the process. And, you know, it's funny, as you were asking that, Patrick, I was just thinking it's the same way that I feel about like, you know, working with all you guys. You know, it's because, you know, we've you you we've done we've done a lot together, but even like, you know, early on you felt that it was working. when it's not working, you make a change. and when it's really working and it keeps working over and over again, you want that like, you know, you wanna, keep bringing the band back together. Yeah, T T V doesn't have enough time and money to to to not have that develop that shortcut, I've discovered at least. I think that's the s successful shows discover how to make it work through teamwork. Definitely not through the networks just lavishing money upon us. Yes. Yeah. Because we're so used to that. Yes. I feel like we're like the Eagles, just we keep coming back for the farewell tour. If we can Keep that up. That'd be great. So, John, I'm gonna get you involved in this conversation now. I'm not forgetting you. just going through the process, you're a showrunner, you're an executive producer, so you have to wait. Like you're on set, you're shooting, and then you wait. So I can imagine your your level of excitement to see this cut for the first time is building. When you see a director's cut, what are some of your common initial reactions and instincts from from what you've seen? I'm also a director, so sometimes I'm the director, so I'm seeing the editor's cuts. I've seen both versions of it. And it's it's interesting because it depends on, you know, sometimes it's a director you've worked with a lot. Sometimes it's an editor you've worked with a lot. so, you know, I'll say I'll just speaking for, you know, Anthony, anytime I was getting a cut from Anthony, I was excited. there are other times when there's editors that you haven't worked with as much or who you've worked with a bit. And you're in the midst of a season and you're there it's going well enough not to make a change, but also there, you know, there's gonna be lot of hand holding. There's different levels of excitement depending on, you know, where it's coming from. I will say that like early on in most
of my career, you know, from the features I made to, you know, early seasons of Cobra Kai, the first cut would come in. And I'm usually in the midst of also production and writing and doing a a zillion things at the same time. And the cut will come in and I'll be like, no. Like I'm I'm worried. Because more often than not, the first instinct is to kill yourself. Like that's the first instinct. And I don't mean to be like, you know, I don't speak about throwing that around throwing that around, you know, jokingly, unfortunately. But like the it's just the first thought is my career's over. You know? And that's that's a result of usually Time and it go going back to Anthony's first comment on well, how much time should you have as an editor and you want indefinite? The schedule is so tight that editors, even the best editors, don't have enough time to really refine what they would view is the best version of a cut. And sort of a push pull that you and I have sometimes, Mallory, is I'm I I like people giving me what they think is good as opposed to what they think is on schedule. So, because I know the b I know the bigger schedule and I know the challenges that we're all going through. But it for me, it's not worth my time because I'm so busy to see something that Anthony knows is not what he believes is worth my eyes. but the TV, the nature of a TV schedule often forces me to see things before they're ready. And that's where the, you know, the harsh fears come in. Luckily, I'm also experienced enough at this point to know that usually what I'm seeing in the first cut that makes me scared is going to turn out. I'll say I've made 73 episodes of television, and all 73, when I've released into the world, I've been very excited about them and thrilled about the episodes. There are zero episodes where I haven't been happy at the end of the process. So now I have the perspective of knowing that we will get there. More often than not, very few times, it's it's rare that I've had the opportunity to do reshoots. either either either in features or in TV. I I've been usually working with the editor and the and the post team to make it work and figure out a solution with whatever we have. And the the creative process of that can be a wide array of crazy things. sometimes it's simple and everything is in the bins that we're intended and other times you're searching for stuff from other episodes or other you're you're looking for a look of a character and you're you know we don't have we didn't get it. So you're trying to find did I ever get that look from that character and is there a way to put that into this episode? that kind of thing and and you know being close enough up on the person where you don't realize that no, they're actually at in the dojo and it's you're in a completely different location. th those are the kinds of crazy, outside the box things you have to think about there. But it I it's my long way of answering your first question, which was just I I'm it depends on who the cut's coming from. usually there is a level of nervousness at times, when it's again, when it's Anthony or somebody else that I I usually get a really great cut from, it's excitement. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, no, I I I love when you get going, John. You're a storyteller, so I'm just gonna let you go just keep going as much as you want to. I think you've probably already touched on this a little bit, but but just in case you want to expand on it at all, how would you describe your working relationship with the editor of the episode that you're working on? Of course it's different if you know that person versus coming into them on the first time or you know, maybe you've heard good things, good recommendations from your colleagues and counterparts and And how do you how do you approach that relationship as a show runner and executive producer? You know, first and foremost, it's, you know, before the episode, I mean, Anthony mentioned the tone meeting. And more often than not, we would try to have we would have a tone meeting. There are times where we're buried and it's and the tone meeting happens and I'm not in the tone meeting. And other people are, you know, a proxy for me and may not be explaining what I would. want there. So, the best version of the process is I'm having a conversation in the tone meeting, or there have been times where I'm not in the tone meeting and I'll call Anthony beforehand and I'll say, here's, here are the things that are really important to me in this episode. I'll talk about certain scenes here and there. And I always make it clear that it's a two way street. I'm available anytime. If anyone needs to reach out to me, I won't I'm not always able to pick up the phone in that moment, but I will get back to you quickly with any sort of information that's gonna be helpful to the process. Cause I I believe that the more information that whoever you're working with has of what's inside your head is going to be helpful for them. you know, I I think in terms of like throughout the process, you know, a cut will come in and the the process has evolved over the years. At this point, the process is just writing down notes. And writing down notes with time with sometimes it's some general thoughts, sometimes it's stuff within scenes, and sometimes it's you know some time code thoughts. Depends where we are in the process and how far along the cut is. And try to be as clear as possible with the notes of what you're saying there. sometimes I only have the time to send the the written notes. More often than not, what I would try to do in a scenario with Anthony and Nicole would be. Let's get on a Zoom and let's talk through some things and try so that there's a give and take conversation. So they're not just reading the pages and wondering what's what's going on here. But it depends on how busy I am at the time. when I first started filmmaking and I was making features, I didn't I never went to
film school. I didn't know any sort of experience other than back then I would just sit in the room. Once I got the editors cut, from that moment on, I'm just in the room all day long with the editor working and pi and going through every single take and all that and, you know, you know, frame effing. I don't know if this is a family friendly We can always bleep it. It's fine. Yeah. But the the bottom line is that I, I was involved so much in every single nitty gritty element of it. And I'd say in early seasons of Cobra Kai, especially when an editor wasn't delivering, we spent like hours and hours and hours where we're just in the room with them. As things went on on the show and we found a a team of editors who were excellent. it allowed for you and who also had seen many episodes of the show and or have edited a number of episodes of the show themselves and have worked with us. They start to know the rhythms, they start to know what you want. And the process became really lovely by the final few seasons where it's really just see a cut. Either the night either send notes or speak, talk through notes, let them take a stab at it and then you know send it back and then rinse and repeat until we until we get to the end of the process and maybe there's some things that we all need to dig in a little bit deeper on. One thing that I do say, and I think Anthony can attest to this, is I care most about people giving me work that they believe is good and that they believe works rather than what was intended at times. So you know, not everyone feels that way. Not every showrunner or writer feels that way. I like to see what an editor believes is the best is a good version of something. And then I can always say, You know what, we intended it like this, or I'd like to see this version of of of something. but I like the I like, you know, when you hire talented people, you want them to be able to, you know, stretch their creative muscles and bring something to the table. And you develop a certain trust level with certain collaborators that as long as they understand what the overall tone that we're going for is and the overall story that we're telling is. There's leeway within that to try different things. so I'm always trying to make sure that whatever's get whatever gets sent to me is something that people believe in, so that I'm not telling people what they already know. Yeah. So what's on the page in the script may not always work once you get the footage in what you have and disseminate out to the screen. So I I remember this happening a couple of times on Cobra Kai and Obliterated, where sometimes and I and I think Anthony, you can correct me if I'm wrong, but in this situation, would you, you know, your instinct is, God, I really don't think this is working, but this is what they want to see. I'm gonna present what I think works best, but I'm gonna have this version over here for when they wanna say, Hey, what did you what about this? Yeah, absolutely. And I think John and I mean when when I started working with John and I quickly realized that like he said, the best version of this is that where you can find people and you build that trust. And for an editor, the way John works is the b you know, for me it's it's the only way. And you spend sometimes your whole career trying to find a collaboration or a collaborative environment like the one that John fosters with the people that he works with because there's so much going on and there's so many decisions you're making that you don't want to worry about the people that you're working with closely on this. You want to say, okay, you know what we're going for. This is what we're trying to build. Doesn't mean that every single piece of it is going to be exactly how We imagined or how it was planned. So as John said, the best version that you feel like I want to see it. It may not be the way that will ultimately go, but I trust you and that there's a valid there's a a point of view behind it. It's not just trying things to try things. Because you understand the show. Yeah, you understand the characters and what we're going for. I I remember a a great example and this might have been Was episode three of Obliterated your first episode you did for us on anything? Yes. So, the first episode, first cut that came in of that, I remember, was not a good cut of it. It went through our our director, who's great, but for whatever reason, it was the whatever that process was led to a cut that was one of those scary cuts for me. And I remember Mallory saying, like, you know, should probably watch the editor's cut. Also, because the editor's cut was really good. And I think that there were some things that were tried and maybe there wasn't enough time because like like as I said, the editor doesn't have enough time. The directors do not have enough time, also. So, like whenever when I when I'm saying any of these things about the scary cut coming in either through an editor or director, it's not often the fault of either of those people. It's just a function of time and process and that kind of thing. But when I remember that the first cut came in. Was very worried. Mallory says, look at the editor's cut. I watched the editor's cut. I was like, that's actually a really good cut. And that was just Anthony and Nicole working and putting what they put together. And so I at that moment knew if I when I'm working with with this team, we should be able to get there. And a big challenge in that particular episode was, you know, you know, in the streaming world, obviously, you have leeway with how long episodes can be. But you want to find the right length for any episode that there is. And then there is from a studio, perhaps, well, it needs to be under a certain amount because then it costs more money if you have longer episodes. So there's different things that you're that you're figuring out there. But in this particular episode of the show, we needed
to get things moving quicker. And there was a section that was on Fremont Street where there was a lot of cat and mouse where, bad guys were going in one direction. Our team was going and look and trying to find these find these people. We had a bunch of different team members all in different places. So there were so many different moving parts happening at all times. And you're also dealing with the, you know, page length when you write scripts, you you a script needs to be within a certain page length for a variety of reasons of budgetarily and all these things, even though there may be some connective tissue that would probably be helpful in the final product, but putting all that on the page, it just makes your it just makes your your script too long. And I remember when we I worked with Anthony talking through sort of like the challenges of the episode and, you know, gave them the leeway to just put in if there's anything that's gonna help us get from A to s A to Z or A to C, like put throw in some ADR. F find anything that you're that you think is gonna work to help along the process and continue to tell the story. And I remember the the the each cut just got better and better and better and better. And that was sort of the start of our collaboration. but it's one of my favorite parts about working with Anthony in general is and and I think Nicole, I think your voice is in there sometimes too. am I right? Yeah, it's the the the ADR is always great because there's performance behind it. Sometimes an editor will put in just ADR just to okay, well, I'm gonna write up a a little line or they get a line from one of the writers or whatever and just do it and then they're it's just a flat performance. But the performances when I get when I get it from the from this team are, you know, you're getting the performance of the character and often good lines as well. Anthony's temp ADR is my favorite temp ADR of all time. There's no question about it. my god, you guys too much. Yeah. it's definitely up there. Yeah. Spe as speaking from somebody who's very experienced at Temp ADR. Yes, Mallory does Mallory does a lot of temp ADR and she gets pulled into it often as well. There we go. There was someday on a D V D bonus the the the temp mix with all of the editorial ADR. there there should be alternate cuts where you can watch an episode as it was in the offline with all the temp ADR and everything. I mean Yeah. I love all that. Yeah. Just taking it back in case anybody was wondering, there are guild rules about how long an editor minimum time an editor can receive for their cuts for various lengths of episodes, various types of shows. And the same with directors too. So, you know, for I think the guild rule is for, you know, a one hour drama, four days, like dailies production plus four days. and then for a director it it it c it's often only two. Maybe three if there's time in the schedule. if, John, you're in production. Yeah. You're not gonna look at
the cut right away. I'm like, I'm happy to give extra time to people in that situation if we're not up against deadlines. so so just so that, you know, we are clear, there are guild rules and regulations that do state how much minimum time, but it is often up to show and schedule discretion, you know, kind of what your limit is for maximum amount of time that they get. Yes, a hundred percent. so I Okay, so since Josh and Hayden are not here, we we might dump on them just a little bit. I'm kidding, I'm totally kidding. but there were three, there are there are three showrunners on Obliterated and Cobra Kai. And so that could make potentially a slightly chaotic cuts process because three different sets of notes are coming in at three different times or more. at at different stages of the process, based on on all of your schedules. And and I know that you come together and you talk this over if there's ever a conflict or, we've tried something before and it gets brought up again. And and you know, those discussions do happen. I'm not throwing the team under the bus whatsoever. Of course. But it's just, you know, when again, when you have different voices in the room, how do you decide kind of who wins the the notes challenge? Like, I mean I I don't want to say blows have been made in the NFA. You know, it it's you what you strive for is something that everybody likes, is what you're striving for at all times. And you keep trying things until either everybody likes it or somebody gives up, you know, and and I never give up. I know that. so I'm always happy in the end. But I'll say it's also just the nature of when you have three showrunners, a job the job of a showrunner is especially different shows are different levels of challenge. both Cobra Kai and Obliterated are both extremely challenging shows because you don't have the budget that you necessarily should for how ambitious the show is. You're also doing you're also doing action scenes in addition to it's not just a straight comedy, every things are complicated. So the three of us are juggling a lot of different things outside of post all at the same time. when it comes to the editing process, I found that I I did I sort of spearheaded the editing process more often than not throughout. and it was just by nature of I'm the kind of person who after a long day of work and the cut comes in And I have a hard time not watching the cut and not starting to give notes because I'm constantly thinking of, okay, well, we need to get this thing delivered on time and all that. So usually the first round of notes is coming from me unless say Josh directed an episode. and i in in that scenario, you're just you know, keep you keep I think that we we have enough of a hive mind in what we've planned that by the time others are watching the cut, usually it's far farther along and they're feeling good about it. And usually when notes are coming in from the other guys, they're not things that are like drastically different than what I would want. And sometimes they're a great solution to something that we've been trying to work through. you know, every once in a while there will be something where someone has a, you know, Different vision for what to do. you know, this is not throwing Hayden under the bus, but just saying Hayden's the first person to see a scene and be like, can we get rid of that scene? And, you know, and and after the studio cut. Yeah, yeah. Well, at any time, at any time. And I mean, even back when we made like the Harold and Kumar movies, like I there there are times where because he's always focused, the thing that Hayden likes least is moments in an episode where people would want to just fast forward. is the Hayden's big thing. And Hayden has no attention span. So he doesn't have a barometer how of when other people would fast forward. But for himself, it episodes should be like three to four minutes long, as opposed to like a half hour. So like for him, he's just fast forwarding the whole time. but no, but it's it's you know, so he but he he'll d sometimes default to like we should cut a scene. And what I'm usually trying to do is figure out what's the economical way to make sure that the scene stays If the scene has value in the pushing the story forward. Sometimes in that process, we'll find Hayden was completely right to want to get rid of that scene because you didn't really need it in the grand scheme of things. In the grand scheme of the season, hey, you know, we have we're in episode four. In episode three, we kind of already learned this information, and now we're just sort of r reminding you of it in this next episode. And then it's the balancing act of, well, not everyone just watched episode three. So what do they need to know within this episode for this episode to be fulfilling rather than just what did they need through the the full season. So it's a give and take throughout, with all of us. But you know, it's those guys when whenever they're in the editing mix, it only makes things better. It's never there's never a moment where it's going backwards. It may briefly go backwards, but it never ends up backwards. Right. Right. Yeah. No, I I much like Nicole and and handing the cut over for just for a fresh perspective. Hay Hayden Hayden doesn't always watch those early cuts. He wants it to be more finished, but then when he does watch it, he can offer a little bit of a fresh perspective that sometimes, you know, we all have been so just in the micro of every scene. Just takes a minute to step back and go, right. Hayden can't handle the early cuts. Emotionally I talk about the idea of thinking your career's over. I'm an optimist in life. Hayden is less of an optimist in life. So when if he sees the early cuts, I worry about what's gonna happen. So he needs to like see it a little further along before he he'll be mentally ready to watch what's about to happen. Now I get it 'cause I on my side in sound, Hayden's notes
always came in last. So now I know why. Well he's also, he's he's he'll he's always he's busy working on something else also at the same time. he's always writing something. Yeah. Yeah. he he's never just idle. Yeah. And and and nor is Josh, none of you are. So with with as big as these shows are, yeah, it it definitely took a team to get through them. Okay, now for our favorite bit, because we're getting into the studio and network notes. yes. we'd love these. and we do. You know, they they're is an important part of the process. They want to make sure that their, you know, what they paid for is gonna be getting on the screen, their IP is being well represented, and and what they're expecting from the script is is indeed what's going to be delivered. And if not, you know, why not? We're gonna have those conversations. So what are what are some typical notes from Studio Network that you that you receive? Anthony, John, shout them out. I'll let Anthony go first. I'm gonna bring Martina to join us. Okay. Usually they're they're usually they want it shorter. I I feel like the the the general network note is can we make yeah, this is good, but can we make it shorter? That's that's definitely a huge part of it. And often that has to do with money and often that has to do with just sort of like wanting it to to move faster. And I think that a part of our job is to determine is it their desire to save money that's giving you that note, or is it the the episode does need to be shorter? And that's a thing that I think we all work through together through the process. Because you know, you know, there are times I'll say like it it's a great note when it's helping the creative. It's a bad note when it feels like they're ac answering to their, you know, their bottom line or their boss. and You want to find the advocate w the best studio executives are the ones who love the show and like know it intimately and are and are part of a collaborative process amongst all of us. And they don't feel like they're they feel like they're one of us as opposed to like someone who is working against the creative process. So when or saying a note just to get one of their notes heard or something. Yeah, just to get something heard or to feel like, well, I have my job to do, even though I like this thing. if I don't give any notes, then what then what am I doing? So I gotta give some notes here. you wanna find people who have good that have good taste, who know the show, who have good opinions, who when you come to them and say, Hey, you know, this particular scene I really like. the rhythms of it for X, Y, or Z reason. And they say, just to be honest, this episode really needs to be a little shorter for to to, meet a budgetary situation. Then we you say, okay, well let's work together. I I prefer that honesty for that. Then we can all work together and be like, okay, we need to get it to a certain number and where it allows for us to choose. And they may say make some suggestions of hey, look at this scene or look at this scene, but That's for us to choose where that time comes from, as opposed to, you know, you know, an arbitrary thing. Now, there I'll say there are different examples though. Like sometimes it's helpful. Like I remember in was it season four, episode one, which was Terry Silver's return. And there was a scene on the balcony between Terry Silver and Sensei Creese, and Hayden, Josh, myself. We all love those characters. So for us as the super nerd fans, that scene could have been like five hours long and we're just gripped every single moment of the scene. And that was a scene where we kept getting like the note of like make it shorter, make it shorter, make it shorter. And they were right, you know, they were right to suggest to make it shorter because you wanted to, you know, keep the episode moving and keep the momentum going. And we ended up probably cutting a minute and twenty seconds or a minute and forty seconds from the scene. I forget how long it was a long amount that we ended up cutting, and the scene is still a lengthy scene and a meaty scene. and then you're just like, Okay, you know, it with the flow of the episode, it's actually working really well. And then you just save the long version for the, you know, the the super fans who get to watch it on the on the D V Ds or, you know, on on YouTube. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So so you know, it there is a purpose to this madness, right? Yeah. It's everybody's contributing to the whole at the end of the day. You just hope that you have, again, like an editor, a good collaborator on that side as well. The big challenge on a show like Cobra Kai that goes as long as it did, is continuity is was an issue. Like our show started on YouTube. We had certain executives at YouTube and certain executives at Sony. Most of those executives by season like after season one, one of our executives from Sony was gone and we had a new current executive. So now you're getting notes from someone, or actually, no, they they were there through three seasons, but we had a same current executive for three seasons of season one. And that was a continuity thing that was that was a relationship that built over those three years. season one, he was like, These guys don't know how to make TV, they're not handing in cuts. And then he saw the cuts by the end of season one. We earned his trust. And from that moment forward, it was a a good collaborative process. But at YouTube, we had an executive for the first two seasons. That executive was then gone. Then we moved to Netflix, where with a completely different set of executives. We had a new Sony current executive for that period of time who wasn't as familiar with the show and not somebody who would typically watch the show for that season. we had a new executive at at Netflix that like was not someone who was intimately involved in the thing. And now the notes that you're getting are the good news was the show was was
successful enough where they were not like i imposing their will on us, but the notes were not always, you know, you felt like coming from somebody who intimately knew the show or understood the show. but then as we as the seasons went on, like we had a new current executive at Sony who was wonderful and just probably just like super fan and understood it in a great way. And bought and at at Netflix we ended up having new executives come on who were the right executives. So there was just like this constant flow of like having different people come on. And it's a little bit of a crapshoot at times as to like, do you have the right person for your particular project? Yeah. Every every stage of of collaboration can really affect the tenor and the tone of the final product. throughout the and and maybe how how difficult or painless it is to go through the process. just a couple of quick questions at the end. I mean, d is do you feel it's your responsibility to manage expectations upstream? And I mean to upstream studio network executives, or do you just say, hey, you know what, here's here's what it is. Let's see what your notes are and then kind of get into it from there. Only if the episode has challenges. Do I feel the need to to manage it? More often than not, my expectation is that what we're handing in to them they should like. and there's the occasional moment where it's mostly working, but there's some things or there's like, you know, major visual effects that are missing in an episode. So every once in a while we'll have to say, Well, try to keep in mind that this is you know, Going to be different. The one thing that we do, and this was again something that was evolved over the years working on the show was working with the editors to make blank spaces not hurt disrupt the flow of an episode. So whereas in the past, it would just be like, okay, there'd be like, okay, just a card would be there that says missing scene, and it says the scene number. And there's no sound and there's no anything with it. And it's a little thing, and then you continue on. What we've what we try to do as we in the later scenes, and this is part of the managing upward, is put di put words on the screen that are explaining, taking them through the story of what's happening that they can that is on the screen long enough for them to be able to read it and for them to internalize, okay, you know. Hawk and you know, Hawk and Dimitri are, you know, have a fight here and you take them literally through the beats of the scene while having perhaps some score or or music in the background that's accompanying it that would give them the feel of what would be there, along with perhaps some images, if we have images that would be helpful for it. It's creating it's as much hand holding for the people above us so that they're not gonna be jarred and start giving bad notes as a result of a flow being off because something was missing. So that that's the way that I manage upwards is to try to make as complete an episode as possible. And the same thing goes for like people when submitting to us. It's you know one thing I can say is music and sound is huge. And back in the day, it wasn't really in the editor flow before a director sees something for there to be as much sound and music in in in cuts of things or or or the right music editing and all that stuff to make things there. And I remember like, you know, in my early career seeing cuts where there was it didn't feel finished. And you and it was just hard, even me as a viewer, as someone who wrote it and knows what it is. It's more jarring, especially maybe for someone like me who knows what the end is supposed to feel like in some way when it's not right. So like I think the more that in every part of the process people are able to present something to the people, you know, above them, who need to give some approvals that feels as as close to what it should feel like as possible. I think that's that's the way to manage upwards more so than just sort of the conversation. You have the conversation. But I found that even if you have a conversation, people don't they're gonna feel what they're gonna feel while they're watching something. So you try to give them the greatest feel while watching s while while watching it that you possibly can in the time that you have allotted. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. I remember those sequences. They were kind of fun. It was like it reminded me of like silent film days. Yeah, you just you see these cards in the screen and you're telling a story, but there's music and there's maybe some effects in there too. So it was it was fun. Yeah. It was a good way to do it. Are there any final thoughts from, you know, John? I have a qu I have a question I want to give them. Yeah. I have not to put it on a spot, but talking about the cut process from from Cobra Kai or obliterated, any example you can give of a moment where you thought the cut process took something that you were worried about or wasn't working or w what you know, sometimes you shoot something and as soon as it's on filmed, you're like, Okay, you know, it's there. But can you think of each of you a your favorite moment where the cut process kinda took something and elevated it to that next level and and really made it shine? I I know a lot of actors owe their careers to good editors, so we won't name them. But but you can you can work miracles. We don't have to get too detailed. I mean th I mean just for me, I already mentioned episode three of Obliterated was a great thing. I think fight scenes in particular are something that you know, you have in your head what you need it to be and you work with the stunt team. and your DP and everybody there to try to get everything that you want. On our show, we you often didn't have as much time as you wanted. So more often than not, it would be things like you hustled and you thought you were going have a day to shoot an entire fight. And
then because of things, you only had like half a day to shoot that fight. And you're hustling and getting every single thing that you can and pulling like, you know, quick Get one take of someone saying this one line real quickly, get this, all that stuff. So those are just like a lot of the big, more complicated fight sequences. I'll say like the Sikai Taekai, you know, when the big brawl happened, I felt like we got what we needed there. But really, like the editing process where you is where you really start to get the comfort level of, okay, I have everything here. And then how do we put the pieces? What ADR are we putting in to help tell the story within? All that kind of stuff. But that's just one example of many. I I did mention that, you know, episode three of Obliterated was like a clear one for me. Anthony, do you have any in your heads that you're thinking of? Yeah, I was gonna mention in episode three of Obliterated, like you did. I remember the first few rounds of of notes or even the first round w after you'd watched it, you just basically you said, Okay. Any decision you make, this episode needs to have momentum. Like this is you know, it needs to have this like pulsing, relentless drive to the end. And then once I got that note and I was able to look at it and see it the whole, I you know, it just made so much sense. And then every step, every round of notes, we just kept dialing in and pushing that momentum. And I feel yeah, the the end product I think got as close to what you were hoping for as possible. And it totally elevated, you know, that episode. and, you know, I got to reach into pretty much every toolbox an editor has. Like you said, the ADR lines of people, you know, like, let's go, let's go, or you know, it's a stakeout, like, where's he going? Where's he moving? 'Cause they're all on radio comms. So you could fit voices in there to help. Build tension, build energy. We're still shooting ADR for that episode now, I feel. Yep, yep. Yeah. I'll say that episode it I I love Obliterated, you know, that's my I mean the Gremlins back there over there hanging out. but you know, I I I love that show so much and that episode is one of my favorites. And, again, from the first cut of it coming in and and us having concerns to where it landed, I mean, it's I just I love that episode and it is the momentum. And then, you know, it's you know, the whole process we talked about like, you know, Zach and Leo and their score, like they they just did a really great job of keeping that momentum going and you feel the pulse going on through that episode, in a really strong way. Yeah, absolutely. It has like cat and mouse chase. It's great. Yeah. I'll throw in one from the last episode of Obl Obliterated, because I got to have a a pretty big hand in it. There was a there's a motif with these three screens. We have a character who's directing traffic for all intents and purposes. And I remember getting the dailies for those, and it's just like these blank screens and it's like a lot of stuff had to happen on them at once. And I feel like I spent I felt I I must have spent at least like three or four days just like figuring out what goes where and That and it's all in service of right, it changed over time and we had better graphics come in later and things like that, but it's all in service of explaining pretty significant plot points in that episode. we needed it to work. and I I really enjoyed the opportunity to take the reins on that, even though I knew I was like, someone's gonna come in and blow this away and they're gonna come up with something better. but I'm gonna maybe help give them a template to like This is what they're going for. And somebody else is going to come in and make it better, which is always what I love about this process is that I'm going to put my hand in there and I'm going to do what I can. And then somebody is 100% going to make it better afterwards. So But always based on your template, right? I mean, you you set that tone first and foremost in the cut. Without doing without doing that, then it never ends up in the final place. That's the thing. Like if you didn't spend those three or four days, like, you know, we'd still be trying to I get it to finish that episode. Many dozens of screens are in that shot. mean there was a lot. There was a lot there. There were so many. It was so fun. I say that now, like two years, three years later. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. We made it on that freight train. It did not ultimately crash. We did not lose cars along the way. Everybody came into the station nice and safe, if a little harried at the the speed of that train. those are that's I think that that finishes off pretty well. I mean, I have no other questions or curiosities about this process. Patrick, is there anything else you want to highlight? No, again, I'm what I'm telling people, you're getting you're getting a huge expensive film school experience listening to these people talk 'cause they know what they're talking about and you're you're you're learning things that most people learn the hard way. So hopefully people are finding value in this. and and now you know that John Herwoods keeps a gremlin over his shoulder as he works there. At all times. At all times. They're good for you everybody. Just don't always listen to him. Be very cautious when he speaks. All right. Great seeing you guys. Thank you everybody. Appreciate it. Talk to you next time. Thanks everybody. Thank you everyone. Bye. Thank you for joining us in the Edit Bay. Please follow us, like and subscribe wherever you are listening, on YouTube and on Instagram at EditBay Podcast. We would love to hear from you too. Please leave us your comments, requests, and suggestions as we continue to shed light on that most elusive part of storytelling arts, post-production.