תעתיק 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.239 --> 00:00:01.840
Tax systems are trade-offs.
00:00:02.479 --> 00:00:09.919
And so the reason that we tax people with more money at a higher rate is because they won't miss it at some point.
00:00:10.000 --> 00:00:10.160
Right?
00:00:10.320 --> 00:00:16.480
Billionaires are accumulating money now that their great-great-great-grandchildren will have trouble spending.
00:00:16.879 --> 00:00:18.800
That's how big the pile of money is, right?
00:00:18.879 --> 00:00:24.000
They're accumulating money far faster than they they and their heirs can possibly spend it.
00:00:24.160 --> 00:00:29.600
And so the marginal value of a dollar to them is almost zero.
00:00:29.760 --> 00:00:31.519
That's what I mean when I say we won't miss it.
00:00:31.600 --> 00:00:46.240
So when tax systems are trying to figure out where do we get the money to pay for government, we should take it from the people who literally won't change their lifestyle in any way because they pay the tax versus people who have to give up food, shelter, and prescription drugs in order to pay the tax.
00:00:49.920 --> 00:00:54.560
You're listening to Bite-Size Business Law, where we discuss big issues in small doses.
00:00:54.719 --> 00:01:04.000
This podcast is sponsored by the Fordham University School of Law Corporate Law Center, which is run by Fordham Law Professor Richard Squire and me, your host, Amy Martella.
00:01:04.239 --> 00:01:06.560
Okay, let's get down to business.
00:01:10.319 --> 00:01:21.120
Welcome back to Bite-Sized Business Law, a first of its kind and one of the most contentious measures on any ballot anywhere this November is California's Proposition 40, the so-called billionaire tax.
00:01:21.439 --> 00:01:26.799
Today's guest helped write it, and we're looking forward to learning more about Prop 40, its benefits, and its criticisms.
00:01:27.040 --> 00:01:31.519
Brian Galley is a professor at Berkeley Law School where he specializes in tax and nonprofit law.
00:01:31.680 --> 00:01:38.079
His scholarship, which has been featured in top law journals across the country, focuses on tax policy, charity, and wealth taxes.
00:01:38.239 --> 00:01:42.239
And he is considered one of the 10 most cited legal scholars in tax law.
00:01:42.400 --> 00:01:43.280
Brian, welcome.
00:01:43.760 --> 00:01:46.000
Thanks very much, Amy, happy to be here.
00:01:46.319 --> 00:01:50.560
So I have to admit, I have a little secret, which is that my husband is a tax lawyer.
00:01:50.640 --> 00:01:59.519
And I'm always very interested in how people and attorneys become attracted to that very, what seemed to me like a niche area of law.
00:01:59.599 --> 00:02:00.480
Like I know his story.
00:02:00.560 --> 00:02:02.640
It was just one professor who he loved.
00:02:02.799 --> 00:02:03.680
What's your story?
00:02:03.840 --> 00:02:07.359
How did you become a tax law specialist?
00:02:07.680 --> 00:02:10.960
Yeah, well, I wanted to be a white-collar prosecutor.
00:02:11.199 --> 00:02:19.039
And I spent one summer at the Justice Department's antitrust division in New York City, where they do criminal antitrust work.
00:02:19.120 --> 00:02:20.319
And it was boring.
00:02:20.879 --> 00:02:25.840
And so let this be a lesson to anyone who wants to be an antitrust professional.
00:02:26.000 --> 00:02:27.840
It's even more boring than tax law.
00:02:29.199 --> 00:02:35.599
So at the end of my summer, my advisor said, you know, the problem you had is we never get to trial.
00:02:35.840 --> 00:02:38.719
We do grand jury work and then everyone pleads out.
00:02:38.879 --> 00:02:42.080
And if you actually want to litigate, you should try the tax division.
00:02:42.400 --> 00:02:47.360
It's an ironic story because you were told if you want something more exciting, look into tax.
00:02:48.000 --> 00:02:48.400
Exactly.
00:02:48.719 --> 00:02:57.919
We want to hear a little bit of background before we get into the, you know, all the big hard questions, but we want to know what is Proposition 40, and particularly how did you become involved in Prop 40?
00:02:58.000 --> 00:03:00.639
So why don't you start us out by telling us what it aims to do?
00:03:01.039 --> 00:03:01.680
Sure thanks.
00:03:01.759 --> 00:03:17.439
So in California, a lot of important fiscal lawmaking is done by ballot initiative because of a complex web of different restrictions on the California legislature, including most basically that it can't raise any new revenue except with a two-thirds vote.
00:03:17.680 --> 00:03:20.400
So Prop 40 is a ballot initiative.
00:03:20.639 --> 00:03:25.360
It is a measure the California voters are going to decide November 3rd this year.
00:03:25.680 --> 00:03:29.120
And in some cases, earlier, voting's already underway in California.
00:03:29.280 --> 00:03:37.280
If it passes, it would be a one-time tax on California billionaires, of 5% of their net worth payable over five years.
00:03:37.439 --> 00:03:43.599
So essentially a 1% annual tax, although they pay a little interest charge for spreading the payment out over five years.
00:03:43.919 --> 00:03:44.240
Got it.
00:03:44.319 --> 00:03:46.879
And so will this result in a constitutional amendment?
00:03:47.280 --> 00:03:47.599
Yes.
00:03:47.759 --> 00:04:04.080
So the measure amends California's constitution to remove the obstacles, the various like marine training course obstacles that the California legislature would have to go through in order to raise revenue that are in California's constitution.
00:04:04.240 --> 00:04:12.400
So it does that and then adds legislative measures that are mostly the heart of the mechanism of the tax.
00:04:12.879 --> 00:04:13.599
Okay, got it.
00:04:13.840 --> 00:04:16.639
So what sequence of events inspired this?
00:04:16.720 --> 00:04:20.319
Because I think some people read this and they think, oh, they just decided they're going to tax billionaires.
00:04:20.480 --> 00:04:22.720
But there's something that motivated this.
00:04:23.279 -->
Load full transcript
00:04:23.759
Yes.
00:04:24.000 --> 00:04:26.399
So this measure was not my idea.
00:04:26.639 --> 00:04:44.879
We were approached by the California Health Workers West, which is a subdivision of SEIU, because in July of 2025, last year, on July 4th, the Trump administration proposed and Congress passed a large tax cut for very wealthy Americans.
00:04:45.120 --> 00:04:54.560
Top 1% of Americans got about a trillion dollars worth of tax cuts, along with a bunch of other expensive stuff that they did, mostly corporate and business tax measures.
00:04:54.720 --> 00:05:07.600
And to reduce the costs of that, the bill also cut federal supports for state health spending mostly in Medicaid, as well as for other programs like SNAP, you know, nutrition assistance for kids.
00:05:07.759 --> 00:05:17.120
And California's share of those federal cuts was projected by Kaiser to be about$100 billion over the next five years or so.
00:05:17.360 --> 00:05:21.759
Those cuts very quickly translate out through the health system.
00:05:21.920 --> 00:05:26.079
So imagine you're a provider and now you have patients who can't pay.
00:05:26.319 --> 00:05:33.519
So you have to either turn them away, which in some cases you're not legally allowed to do, or you absorb the costs yourself.
00:05:33.600 --> 00:05:39.439
And so you raise costs on everybody else, which means health insurance premiums go up and so on.
00:05:39.600 --> 00:05:47.519
Or, you know, in some cases, the provider can't pass along the costs, they lay off workers, or in extreme cases, they might close their doors.
00:05:47.839 --> 00:06:05.360
And so that's the reason that the union was motivated by the O Triple B, the measure that passed last year on July 4th, to find$100 billion in new California revenues to replace this revenue hole that they expect to be temporary.
00:06:05.600 --> 00:06:26.240
And they were aware that I and some collaborators, David Gamage, Darien Shansky, Emanuel Sayez, we had written two previous wealth tax proposal measures for California in 2020 and 2021 for the legislature that hadn't gone anywhere because of the opposition of the governor.
00:06:26.480 --> 00:06:33.439
When they were looking for money, they came to us and they said, We're thinking of some kind of wealth tax measure.
00:06:33.680 --> 00:06:36.319
What might we do and can you help us write it?
00:06:36.480 --> 00:06:45.040
And Emmanuel, who is a world-renowned economist, observed that the net worth of California billionaires at that time was around$2 trillion.
00:06:45.759 --> 00:06:50.480
And 5% of$2 trillion is just about$100 billion.
00:06:50.879 --> 00:07:00.079
And so that was kind of, I think, how the basic architecture came together, that there's this hopefully short-run but large budget hole.
00:07:00.319 --> 00:07:07.279
And there's a vast amount of wealth in the hands of California trillionaires that they probably won't miss.
00:07:07.680 --> 00:07:12.399
Now, you said you've done it twice before, but tell us a little bit about what that process is like.
00:07:12.639 --> 00:07:15.120
You're not a legislator, but you're drafting a bill.
00:07:15.360 --> 00:07:16.319
What's that like?
00:07:16.639 --> 00:07:17.279
It's hard.
00:07:17.519 --> 00:07:25.199
And the people who write actual legislative language are very skilled people who spend all their time doing it.
00:07:25.439 --> 00:07:28.240
And so we took it very seriously.
00:07:28.480 --> 00:07:43.519
Some people have said that this bill kind of seemed to come out of our back pockets, but in fact, it's been in the works for about six years, in the sense that we, you know, we have these earlier measures that we wrote not just for California, but we wrote a bill for New York and we wrote a bill for Vermont.
00:07:43.759 --> 00:07:50.800
And each of those times we've taken in lessons and criticisms and advice.
00:07:51.040 --> 00:07:58.160
We also had a hand in writing the legislative text for a federal measure, President Biden's billionaire minimum income tax.
00:07:58.480 --> 00:08:08.560
And there we had the advantage of suggestions from the US Treasury and the Joint Committee on Taxation, a group that Congress employs to help them write tax legislation.
00:08:08.800 --> 00:08:12.560
So, yeah, it's not a thing that you would want to do as a hobby, right?
00:08:12.720 --> 00:08:21.120
Trying to write language to tax billionaires, because they have a zillion places to hide their money and they have people who are smarter than us to help them do it.
00:08:21.360 --> 00:08:33.039
But what we did was we just spent six years listening and reading and trying to figure out what are those places and what's the language that's most likely to block them from using those exploits.
00:08:33.360 --> 00:08:40.480
What I really appreciate about this, Bill, is that you also published something, a report of sorts that kind of explains it in English.
00:08:40.720 --> 00:08:42.080
And that was really helpful to me.
00:08:42.159 --> 00:08:45.759
I'll link it here to the show notes because it was helpful for me to understand all the provisions.
00:08:46.159 --> 00:08:46.720
Yeah, great.
00:08:46.879 --> 00:08:47.039
Yeah.
00:08:47.120 --> 00:08:52.639
We have a plain language section by section explainer, which is still pretty challenging to read, I think.
00:08:52.720 --> 00:08:57.360
But it's it's which is still not, you know, it's not pleasure reading, but it's it's much, much more helpful.
00:08:57.519 --> 00:09:04.320
And one thing that I found interesting that you mentioned in there, now you already told us that California has about 200 billionaires who are worth about$2 trillion.
00:09:04.960 --> 00:09:06.320
2.4 trillion now.
00:09:06.799 --> 00:09:07.600
Oh, even more now.
00:09:07.679 --> 00:09:09.279
Okay, so$2.4 trillion now.
00:09:09.600 --> 00:09:18.000
So you contend that, you know, even if you impose this 5% tax on them next year, they'll actually still be richer at the end of the year than they
were before they paid the tax.
00:09:18.159 --> 00:09:22.399
And that's why, Ryan, is that because the rate at which their investments grow like outpaces this tax?
00:09:22.480 --> 00:09:23.120
Like, why is that?
00:09:23.200 --> 00:09:24.399
I want people to appreciate that.
00:09:24.720 --> 00:09:26.799
Yeah, they're getting richer really fast.
00:09:27.039 --> 00:09:35.759
So if you just look at the Forbes 400, for instance, the Forbes 400, Forbes says, is worth about 8 trillion today, roughly.
00:09:36.080 --> 00:09:39.759
And last year at around the same time, it was worth 6.6 trillion.
00:09:39.919 --> 00:09:44.080
So they are 21% richer today than they were a year ago.
00:09:44.240 --> 00:09:45.200
That's pretty impressive.
00:09:45.279 --> 00:09:50.320
I mean, the reason that you get to be a billionaire is your stuff goes up in value faster than everybody else's.
00:09:50.480 --> 00:10:01.600
And so Emmanuel and his work with economist colleagues finds that billionaire wealth has grown over the last decade or so at an average of something like six to seven percent.
00:10:01.919 --> 00:10:08.399
And this year actually has already gone up by something like eight to nine percent already this year.
00:10:08.559 --> 00:10:16.639
And so uh the 5% tax will actually probably by the end of the year only take half of the growth of their wealth in 2026.
00:10:17.279 --> 00:10:21.279
So, Brian, you said that Prop 40 is taxing their net worth.
00:10:21.600 --> 00:10:24.799
Tell us what exactly does the wealth tax tax?
00:10:24.960 --> 00:10:37.679
Aaron Powell With a few exceptions for administrative ease and things that the US Supreme Court in way back in the 1920s and 30s prevented states from being able to tax.
00:10:38.080 --> 00:10:41.919
We're trying to tax everything that a billionaire owns anywhere in the world.
00:10:42.320 --> 00:10:47.279
And in the 20s and 30s, the Supreme Court made these weird carve-outs.
00:10:47.519 --> 00:10:51.919
There were state wealth taxes in that era, a thing that most people don't know.
00:10:52.320 --> 00:11:01.519
And so the Supreme Court said, for instance, that a state couldn't impose its wealth tax on personal property that was permanently located outside the state.
00:11:01.600 --> 00:11:10.639
So, like if you have a car collection somewhere else and it's been there for a long time, Prop 40 doesn't reach it because of the Supreme Court in the 1920s said you couldn't.
00:11:10.799 --> 00:11:17.679
And although they would probably reach a different decision today, there's no reason to do something that's facially unconstitutional.
00:11:17.840 --> 00:11:23.200
There's also small carve outs for things like other personal property of up to$5 million.
00:11:23.600 --> 00:11:26.639
You don't have to even catalog or value.
00:11:26.879 --> 00:11:28.480
You just get an exemption for that.
00:11:28.559 --> 00:11:35.120
So people are not going to have to go through their baseball card collection and figure out what
those, what those Derek Cheater rookies are worth or whatever.
00:11:35.440 --> 00:11:36.480
So what about stocks?
00:11:36.639 --> 00:11:42.879
Because my understanding is that there's a little bit of a controversy over stocks, particularly the dual class shares that confer voting rights.
00:11:43.120 --> 00:11:44.080
How will those be valued?
00:11:44.399 --> 00:11:48.000
So interest in publicly traded entities obviously is pretty straightforward.
00:11:48.240 --> 00:11:59.679
And that turns out to be something like 70%, between 65 and 75 estimates have bounced bounced around this year of all of the wealth of the California billionaires.
00:11:59.840 --> 00:12:03.200
So everything else is kind of at the margins.
00:12:04.159 --> 00:12:12.399
We know exactly what the worth is of that three-quarters of the tax base, essentially, because it's stock of companies like Alphabet and Meta.
00:12:13.200 --> 00:12:15.440
So for publicly traded companies, it's straightforward.
00:12:15.919 --> 00:12:21.120
For non-public companies, there's a couple of approaches.
00:12:21.360 --> 00:12:30.480
So the default approach that the Prop 40 uses is based on a similar measure that they use in Spain and Switzerland.
00:12:30.720 --> 00:12:41.279
And what they do there is they do essentially the same thing that most appraisers do, which is they look at the balance sheet and financial statement revenues.
00:12:41.519 --> 00:12:55.200
And so there's a taking a discounted flow of future financial statement income, you know, discounting it to the present value, plus the balance sheet items that the company owns, and that's the value of the company.
00:12:55.360 --> 00:13:00.480
And that's essentially at a high level what most appraisals of businesses are doing.
00:13:00.720 --> 00:13:04.799
And so that's what the statute says that a taxpayer can do, right?
00:13:04.960 --> 00:13:10.879
If you're happy with that number, then you just kind of submit that to the tax authority.
00:13:11.039 --> 00:13:14.480
If you're not happy with that number, you have to go out and hire your own appraiser.
00:13:14.639 --> 00:13:22.159
And then that appraiser has to, you know, disclose the information that they relied on and you submit that to the tax authority instead.
00:13:22.399 --> 00:13:24.320
So, yeah, let's talk about dual class stock.
00:13:24.399 --> 00:13:27.360
I'm sure all of your viewers know what dual class stock is.
00:13:27.600 --> 00:13:31.759
Many of them may not know that it's a very common tax planning technique.
00:13:32.080 --> 00:13:43.600
If you are expecting to someday be worth more than$30 million, dual-class stock is a way to transfer your wealth to your heirs without paying any estate tax.
00:13:44.720 --> 00:13:53.360
And usually the way that you do that is you put the value of your company inside a trust that's controlled by a trustee, not by you.
00:13:53.759 --> 00:13:58.080
And since it's not controlled by you, it's not part of your estate, won't be subject to estate tax.
00:13:58.639 --> 00:14:02.639
The problem is you don't want a trustee running your company.
00:14:03.200 --> 00:14:07.200
So what you do is you split the stock of the company into two classes.
00:14:07.360 --> 00:14:12.399
One that is entitled to all the dividends, and which you'll argue therefore has all the value.
00:14:12.639 --> 00:14:16.480
And then another, you know, tiny group of shares that have all the votes.
00:14:16.639 --> 00:14:25.039
So you keep the votes, the trust gets the value, and now you argue no estate tax or estate tax only on this tiny slice of shares that has all the votes.
00:14:25.360 --> 00:14:30.320
We can have a conversation if anyone wanted about whether that is a rational way to structure the estate tax.
00:14:30.480 --> 00:14:31.600
It isn't, obviously.
00:14:31.759 --> 00:14:33.840
And I have a paper that talks about how to fix it.
00:14:34.000 --> 00:14:42.480
But that is why dual-class structures are exceedingly common, especially for family-owned businesses that expect to be worth more than$30 million today.
00:14:42.559 --> 00:14:47.200
You know, one of President Trump's advisors famously said, like, only morons pay the estate tax.
00:14:47.519 --> 00:14:52.720
And this is one of the fundamental ways that you use to escape from the estate tax.
00:14:53.360 --> 00:14:56.639
Okay, so we knew that from our research.
00:14:56.879 --> 00:15:08.399
And so we were worried, you know, a lot of the value of California privately held businesses is going to appear to not be owned by the California billionaire, but instead to be owned by a trust somewhere else.
00:15:08.720 --> 00:15:23.039
And so when we were trying to value that family business, we said if you're going to use that default method of just taking the balance sheet and financial statements, you're going to multiply that implied value of the company by your share of ownership.
00:15:23.200 --> 00:15:29.600
And what the dual class provision says is your share of ownership has to be at least your share of the vote.
00:15:29.919 --> 00:15:32.080
So some people read this online.
00:15:32.399 --> 00:15:44.559
As you said, it's hard to read a dense tax statute, especially if you're not a tax lawyer, and they misunderstood what was happening, or they kind of decided to misunderstand for propaganda purposes.
00:15:44.799 --> 00:15:54.559
And so they started saying things like, well, Sergei Brynn is going to pay a tax bill of$130 billion because he has 20% of the vote of Alphabet, which is just not true.
00:15:54.639 --> 00:15:58.799
This is a set of rules that is for privately held businesses, not public companies.
00:15:59.039 --> 00:16:04.240
And also, as I said, like this is kind of one of the two options that the taxpayer has.
00:16:04.399 --> 00:16:06.399
This is like the default rule.
00:16:06.559 --> 00:16:10.399
And if they don't want to use it, they just hire an appraiser instead.
00:16:11.600 --> 00:16:16.960
It's so crazy to me
because the tax code is basically a piece of Swiss cheese for high wealth people.
00:16:17.200 --> 00:16:21.360
And so you all must have had to run down tons of scenarios like this.
00:16:21.519 --> 00:16:26.799
Like, how do we capture tax from this loophole or this loophole loophole?
00:16:26.879 --> 00:16:28.960
I mean, this must have happened again and again.
00:16:29.440 --> 00:16:30.320
Well, that's right.
00:16:30.639 --> 00:16:32.000
It was a lot of research.
00:16:32.159 --> 00:16:39.360
And luckily, we've written, I think at this point, 105,000 words worth of law review articles on this set of questions.
00:16:39.440 --> 00:16:42.480
And so we've spent a lot of time doing the research.
00:16:42.720 --> 00:16:47.279
But also, a thing that's nice for us is tax lawyers have to advertise.
00:16:48.480 --> 00:17:00.000
And so if you want to know how to evade the estate tax, it's very simple to find out the techniques on the internet because tax lawyers tell you on the internet what they'll do for you.
00:17:00.240 --> 00:17:08.720
You know, they don't write the language on their website, you still have to hire them for that, but they spell out their techniques very clearly and you know, sort of shamelessly.
00:17:09.119 --> 00:17:10.240
Interesting, interesting.
00:17:10.559 --> 00:17:16.319
Um I'm interested in your paper about the estate tax, and I will link that into the show notes here for sure.
00:17:16.559 --> 00:17:20.160
So, Brian, tell us why is this only a one-time tax?
00:17:20.799 --> 00:17:23.759
So, this is a design decision that comes from the union.
00:17:24.079 --> 00:17:26.799
And you know, there's a couple of reasons.
00:17:27.039 --> 00:17:33.039
The main one is because it is a one-time problem that the union is trying to solve.
00:17:33.519 --> 00:17:42.160
It's a gap in federal support for state health spending, mostly through the Medi-Cal program, which California calls Medicaid.
00:17:42.720 --> 00:17:45.519
And they expect that to be temporary.
00:17:45.839 --> 00:17:50.400
Now that expectation may not turn out to be true, but that is the expectation.
00:17:51.039 --> 00:17:59.680
And so they didn't need a permanent bill and thought it would be easier to pass the temporary measure than a permanent one.
00:17:59.839 --> 00:18:04.880
So why do the harder thing when that's not the problem you're trying to solve?
00:18:05.119 --> 00:18:17.039
The other thing is if you think about the difficulty of trying to pass a measure to tax billionaires on a ballot, you have to give voters a thing that is comprehensible.
00:18:17.200 --> 00:18:18.880
It can't be a hundred pages long.
00:18:19.440 --> 00:18:23.839
As it is, it's probably longer than would be ideal, you know.
00:18:23.920 --> 00:18:29.759
But we made it as as short as we possibly could and still be confident that it would work, essentially.
00:18:30.400 --> 00:18:42.160
Having said that, if you make it permanent, you probably are gonna have many more opportunities for
billionaires to plan how to avoid the tax in the future.
00:18:42.799 --> 00:18:56.559
And because of the, you know, the Byzantine set of, you know, Marine Corps training obstacles that the California legislature has to go through to change anything, you can't count on them fixing the law if it's broken.
00:18:56.960 --> 00:19:07.279
And so a one-time tax can be a lot simpler because you don't have to try to anticipate what's going to happen in 10 years and write mechanisms to try to kind of keep those bad things from happening.
00:19:07.680 --> 00:19:08.319
That makes sense.
00:19:08.480 --> 00:19:10.640
It also seems a lot more palatable for voters.
00:19:10.720 --> 00:19:20.960
I mean, when I have had conversations in the last few weeks about Prop 40, and if I remind the person, you know, this is a one-time tax, the response is kind of like, oh, you know, it feels a little bit easier to swallow.
00:19:21.039 --> 00:19:30.240
But what do you say, Brian, to people who are nervous that like maybe this isn't, maybe this bill isn't permanent, but this might become like the go-to remedy whenever money's tight in California.
00:19:30.640 --> 00:19:31.599
That's certainly a possibility.
00:19:31.759 --> 00:19:40.240
And again, the only way generally to get new money in California is through some kind of ballot measure, not necessarily a tax on billionaires, obviously.
00:19:40.480 --> 00:19:48.079
I do think like one of the reasons I'm involved in this proposal is because I think billionaires have too much money in power currently.
00:19:48.240 --> 00:19:50.400
I don't think that's a controversial view.
00:19:50.640 --> 00:19:55.039
And I also don't think they pay nearly their fair share of California tax.
00:19:55.359 --> 00:20:04.640
So, you know, one statistic we discovered that I found kind of shocking is they pay an average income tax rate on their economic income of about 1.3%.
00:20:05.359 --> 00:20:09.279
Your average California dentist pays a tax rate of 13.3%.
00:20:09.680 --> 00:20:11.200
That's the top rate in California.
00:20:11.359 --> 00:20:13.920
So billionaires are paying one-tenth the rate of dentists.
00:20:14.000 --> 00:20:17.759
That doesn't make a great deal of sense to me, or of obstetricians for that matter.
00:20:17.920 --> 00:20:25.359
And so, look, I'm pretty sympathetic to the idea that maybe some permanent fixes are needed to make the system more rational.
00:20:25.680 --> 00:20:37.519
I think where this back and forth about is this going to happen again matters most is one of the things we sometimes do say about it being a one-time tax is some people say, well, all the billionaires would leave California.
00:20:37.599 --> 00:20:43.279
And we can talk more later about the evidence of how likely that would be, even if it were a permanent measure.
00:20:43.440 --> 00:20:45.039
But it's a one-time tax.
00:20:45.200 --> 00:20:52.960
It defines residency based on where you live on January 1st of 2026, which obviously is a date
that's already happened.
00:20:53.200 --> 00:20:57.119
And so there's no reason for billionaires to leave if it's a it's a one-time tax.
00:20:57.279 --> 00:21:05.200
But critics say, if the billionaire thinks you're going to do this again, then maybe this is an impetus for them to leave.
00:21:05.279 --> 00:21:09.519
And there I say, well, this was already a possibility.
00:21:09.680 --> 00:21:14.400
You know, it's not like the idea of wealth taxes on the super rich in California is new.
00:21:14.480 --> 00:21:26.000
And I know that, as I said, because I wrote two previous measures that the California legislature introduced, one supported by, you know, not exactly an obscure figure, Rob Bonto, who's now the attorney general of California.
00:21:26.319 --> 00:21:37.359
So I just don't think if you're a billionaire and you're trying to think what is my likely future tax rate in California, I don't feel like Prop 40 changes, economists like to say, your priors.
00:21:37.759 --> 00:21:43.119
It doesn't change their expectations that much of what your future tax rate is going to be.
00:21:43.359 --> 00:21:53.440
It was already the case that in 2030, California is probably going to need money and is probably going to look at these people who are paying way too little to supply a portion of it.
00:21:53.599 --> 00:22:04.240
So, yeah, I mean, I think Profit maybe helps to lay some groundwork in the sense that we've done the Work of figuring out what the language should say in that future tax measure.
00:22:04.400 --> 00:22:10.400
So yeah, maybe we make that future tax measure a little easier, but I don't think we make it a lot more likely.
00:22:10.720 --> 00:22:10.960
Yeah.
00:22:11.119 --> 00:22:11.279
Okay.
00:22:11.359 --> 00:22:14.480
So none of these sophisticated actors are blindsided right now.
00:22:14.960 --> 00:22:15.519
I don't think so.
00:22:15.680 --> 00:22:27.039
No, there's reporting that they they were, you know, in December angry to discover that we had actually introduced this ballot measure, but certainly I don't think their tax lawyers were surprised.
00:22:27.279 --> 00:22:27.839
Yes, yes.
00:22:28.079 --> 00:22:29.920
Okay, so let's talk about the pushback.
00:22:30.079 --> 00:22:32.240
I wanted to go through a few of the main criticisms.
00:22:32.400 --> 00:22:39.279
And of course, as you mentioned, the biggest one that people love to cite with any wealth tax is capital flight.
00:22:39.519 --> 00:22:41.839
So tell us why you think that won't be a problem.
00:22:42.240 --> 00:22:47.359
Well, we review this evidence pretty carefully in our LARVI article from last year.
00:22:47.519 --> 00:22:49.279
It's about 30,000 words long.
00:22:49.359 --> 00:22:52.880
So people can read all the evidence that we lay out there.
00:22:53.039 --> 00:22:55.359
But you know, this is not the first wealth tax in the world.
00:22:55.440 --> 00:22:56.799
There have been a bunch of others.
00:22:57.039 --> 00:23:06.400
And Spain and Switzerland in particular, they're structured very similarly in the sense that the rate varies in different states, essentially.
00:23:06.480 --> 00:23:09.440
They're called cantons in Switzerland, but same idea.
00:23:09.839 --> 00:23:16.640
And studies of both Spain and Switzerland find that people don't really move very much in response to differences in wealth tax rates.
00:23:16.799 --> 00:23:21.359
So take Madrid, and I can't roll my R, so maybe I should just say Madrid.
00:23:21.680 --> 00:23:28.319
So Madrid, I'm told, is lovely, the Prado, world famous museum, a lot of things to attract you to Madrid.
00:23:28.400 --> 00:23:37.119
And one of them is that it has a 0% wealth tax rate, whereas other states in Spain have rates as high as 3% per year.
00:23:37.440 --> 00:23:47.680
And yet, when Spain reintroduced its wealth tax system, the evidence is that people did not suddenly start living in Madrid despite its many charms.
00:23:47.839 --> 00:24:00.559
Now, there were some people who already owned an apartment in Madrid who started claiming that that piedater was their, I don't know what the Spanish equivalent is, but of piedater, but started claiming that that residence was their permanent residence and so on.
00:24:00.640 --> 00:24:05.920
So there, you know, people are going to do the tricks that taxpayers always do.
00:24:06.000 --> 00:24:09.279
But in terms of real relocations, it's very modest.
00:24:09.440 --> 00:24:10.559
Some people move.
00:24:10.960 --> 00:24:14.000
But the actual moves are very, very small.
00:24:14.640 --> 00:24:29.359
And that's consistent with the American experience, although we haven't had wealth taxes again since the early 20th century on a you know wealth taxes that covered most of what people own, as opposed to just taxes on their real estate.
00:24:30.240 --> 00:24:38.079
And in the US, in changes in income tax rates have not led to meaningful relocations.
00:24:38.400 --> 00:24:48.720
As you know, as you alluded to, a lot of these measures were preceded by dire threats that the economy would collapse and the wealthy would flee.
00:24:48.880 --> 00:24:54.079
And we heard that in New York, even before the Piedatera tax in New York City.
00:24:54.160 --> 00:25:00.480
And the design of that tax is such that it's not even logically rational to flee from it.
00:25:00.640 --> 00:25:03.519
But nonetheless, that was the claim.
00:25:03.599 --> 00:25:11.039
In 2012 in California, there was an increase on the in the tax rate, income tax rate imposed by million-dollar earners.
00:25:11.200 --> 00:25:14.319
And there was a projection then that they would all flee.
00:25:14.480 --> 00:25:20.400
And instead, California now has a larger share of the nation's million-dollar earners than it had in 2012.
00:25:20.720 --> 00:25:27.680
So some of them probably did leave, but also more arrived, and California was good at creating million-dollar earners.
00:25:28.079 --> 00:25:30.160
Also, has anyone ever been to California?
00:25:30.319
--> 00:25:31.680
Like, there's no reason to leave.
00:25:31.759 --> 00:25:34.079
It is so ridiculously beautiful.
00:25:34.240 --> 00:25:36.240
That in and of itself will keep people there.
00:25:36.559 --> 00:25:40.640
Yeah, I won't point the camera out my window here, but yeah, it's very pleasant.
00:25:40.960 --> 00:25:41.200
Yeah.
00:25:41.440 --> 00:25:49.039
So one thing you wrote that made me laugh, even though it's actually quite sad, is something you pointed out earlier, which is well, California billionaires don't really pay a lot of tax.
00:25:49.119 --> 00:25:52.640
So like even if they did leave, is that a huge hit we're taking?
00:25:53.119 --> 00:26:00.880
Yeah, actually, so California has a nonpartisan office that analyzes ballot measures and called the LAO.
00:26:01.279 --> 00:26:11.599
And the LAO says property is likely to raise at least tens of billions of dollars in new revenue and might result in some loss of revenue if billionaires leave.
00:26:11.759 --> 00:26:18.960
But that revenue they project would be very small, less than a billion dollars a year, for a combination of reasons.
00:26:19.440 --> 00:26:24.960
One is it doesn't seem likely that billionaires, the meaningful amount of billionaires will leave.
00:26:25.119 --> 00:26:27.680
And the other is, as you say, they don't pay any income tax.
00:26:27.839 --> 00:26:32.400
Like I said, the income tax rate that they average on their economic income, 1.3%.
00:26:32.720 --> 00:26:42.160
What I mean by economic income is of the increase in their wealth each year, they pay an income tax that's 1.3% of that.
00:26:42.400 --> 00:26:46.319
Now that's not how the income tax system works legally.
00:26:46.799 --> 00:26:49.200
This is why billionaires don't pay any income tax, right?
00:26:49.359 --> 00:27:02.079
Our income tax system, income tax systems around the world, measure income when it's realized, which is to say a wealthy investor only pays tax on their investments when they choose to sell their investments.
00:27:02.880 --> 00:27:17.200
And then in the US, there's an even crazier rule that says that when you die, your heirs pay zero tax on all of the accumulated value of the decedent's investments, even though the decedent didn't pay any taxes on them either.
00:27:17.279 --> 00:27:19.359
This is called the basis step up at death.
00:27:19.680 --> 00:27:30.079
So that's to say again, billionaires are not paying tax because they have the luxury of not having to sell a meaningful amount of their investments to fund their lifestyle.
00:27:30.319 --> 00:27:35.039
They have just a trickle of realized income as a share of their wealth.
00:27:35.200 --> 00:27:39.920
But it turns out that that trickle when you're a billionaire is enough to kind of pay for yachts.
00:27:40.480 --> 00:27:46.480
Oh, so that trickle is enough because you always hear this of like, oh, billionaires, all their wealth is in stock and they never sell it because they don't want to pay tax.
00:27:46.559
--> 00:27:48.400
And I'm like, but how are they buying a yacht?
00:27:48.559 --> 00:27:51.039
Like, how are they physically liquid enough to buy a yacht?
00:27:51.359 --> 00:27:58.960
Yeah, I think it's typically that there's a stream of income that's small as a share of their economic income, but is still really big to everybody else.
00:27:59.119 --> 00:28:01.839
There are some billionaires for whom that's not enough.
00:28:02.079 --> 00:28:10.079
So kind of famously, Larry Allison bought the Hawaiian island of Lanae by pledging his Oracle stock.
00:28:10.319 --> 00:28:14.960
So he borrowed several billion dollars against his Oracle stock.
00:28:15.039 --> 00:28:18.400
And you can you can search the UCC filings and find that.
00:28:18.720 --> 00:28:27.119
Elon Musk borrowed, I think, about half of the purchase price of Twitter by pledging his existing interests in other companies and so on.
00:28:27.200 --> 00:28:28.559
So that does happen too.
00:28:28.799 --> 00:28:37.200
But I think the evidence that I've seen from recent studies is it's more that, yeah, billionaires do have some realized income.
00:28:37.279 --> 00:28:40.000
It's just small as a share of their wealth.
00:28:40.480 --> 00:28:40.640
Okay.
00:28:40.720 --> 00:28:43.920
So what about the other side of the coin to billionaires will leave?
00:28:44.079 --> 00:28:50.480
What about the argument that this will deter people from coming in the first place to found their startup in California?
00:28:51.039 --> 00:29:10.240
Those long-run effects are harder to convincingly identify in econometric studies, because the longer after a change has happened, the harder it is to convince referee number two that the changes you observe are really caused by the the thing that you're studying.
00:29:10.559 --> 00:29:15.599
And so that's a possibility, and I think it it's a it's a fair one to be concerned about.
00:29:15.759 --> 00:29:26.559
What you can say on this front, again, is that California is the source of, I think it's 90% of all AI startups, for instance.
00:29:27.599 --> 00:29:32.559
And your company is a lot more likely to be a unicorn.
00:29:32.799 --> 00:29:40.240
The number that I recall is 10% more likely to be worth a billion dollars if it's in Silicon Valley than if it's anywhere else.
00:29:41.440 --> 00:29:48.640
And so it's just a state that has been an engine of innovation, and there are network effects.
00:29:49.279 --> 00:30:04.720
One of the reasons it's so promising to be here in Silicon Valley is because it's easier to recruit talent, easier to find funders, easier to find buyers of your product when you're looking for exit, all those things.
00:30:05.039 --> 00:30:21.920
And so it's just exceedingly improbable that someone is going to give up kind of a golden ticket to become a unicorn company owner because there's some danger that after they become a billionaire, they might be subject to a slightly higher tax rate.
00:30:22.079 --> 00:30:26.240
It just doesn't seem likely to me that that's gonna affect people's planning in a meaningful way.
00:30:26.319 --> 00:30:28.799
But I don't know, maybe other people have different intuitions about that.
00:30:29.920 --> 00:30:42.240
Brian, what do you say to the overarching argument that some people put forth, which is just basically that in a capitalist society, it's it's just wrong to tax people who worked really hard and made a lot of money as a result.
00:30:42.319 --> 00:30:44.160
Like, what if this were 20% tax?
00:30:44.240 --> 00:30:45.599
What if it were 30% tax?
00:30:45.680 --> 00:30:48.079
This just is wrong to do it.
00:30:48.240 --> 00:30:50.319
Tax systems are trade-offs.
00:30:50.640 --> 00:30:58.400
And so the reason that we tax people with more money at a higher rate is because they won't miss it at some point, right?
00:30:58.480 --> 00:31:04.720
Billionaires are accumulating money now that their great-great-great-grandchildren will have trouble spending.
00:31:05.039 --> 00:31:07.039
That's how big the pile of money is, right?
00:31:07.119 --> 00:31:12.240
They're accumulating money far faster than they they and their heirs can possibly spend it.
00:31:12.400 --> 00:31:17.759
And so the marginal value of a dollar to them is almost zero.
00:31:17.920 --> 00:31:19.680
That's what I mean when I say we won't miss it.
00:31:19.839 --> 00:31:34.480
So when tax systems are trying to figure out where do we get the money to pay for government, we should take it from the people who literally won't change their lifestyle in any way because they pay the tax versus people who have to give up food, shelter, and prescription drugs in order to pay the tax.
00:31:35.119 --> 00:31:40.640
The flip side of that is when you tax people, they do change their behavior.
00:31:40.880 --> 00:31:53.200
And so you're trying to balance the fact that they shouldn't miss it against the fact that nonetheless some people will act in a way that tries to reduce the tax burden that they have.
00:31:53.519 --> 00:31:57.200
So I would not recommend a 20% annual wealth tax.
00:31:57.359 --> 00:32:03.119
That to me would be crazy and would be seriously economically damaging, if not disastrous.
00:32:03.440 --> 00:32:13.680
1%, the evidence is a 1% annual tax, which is what Prop 40 is, just only lasts for five years, the evidence is has almost no real economic effect.
00:32:13.920 --> 00:32:19.200
And so it's a matter of figuring out how to get that balance right.
00:32:19.440 --> 00:32:31.119
The US economy grew massively and thrived after between World War II and 1986, and economic inequality declined over that stretch even as the economy was booming.
00:32:31.279 --> 00:32:34.799
And that's partly because we had very high marginal tax rates.
00:32:34.960 --> 00:32:36.880
So it's possible to get both.
00:32:37.039 --> 00:32:40.480
And since 1986, we've had more unequal growth.
00:32:40.720 --> 00:32:51.519
We've had a lot of growth at the top to the point where my colleague Gabriel
Zuckmann finds that the richest handful of people in America own a larger share of the economy than they ever have.
00:32:52.000 --> 00:32:54.960
So that's probably not the right way to design your tax system, right?
00:32:55.039 --> 00:32:56.559
You got the balance wrong there.
00:32:57.119 --> 00:33:04.960
There's this notion that, you know, billionaires worked harder than everyone else, but you know, they don't make money off their labor.
00:33:05.119 --> 00:33:06.319
They make money off their money.
00:33:06.400 --> 00:33:10.720
And it's really these like middle income earners who are really driving the tax base.
00:33:11.119 --> 00:33:12.480
There's a mix of stories.
00:33:12.720 --> 00:33:15.680
About half of US wealth is inherited.
00:33:15.839 --> 00:33:19.519
So those people, I would argue, didn't work especially hard for it.
00:33:19.680 --> 00:33:23.119
They managed to not blow it before they turned 18, I guess.
00:33:23.200 --> 00:33:27.359
But that was often the decision of the trustee who held the family business in trust.
00:33:27.599 --> 00:33:31.359
But yeah, you want to incentivize innovation and hard work.
00:33:31.519 --> 00:33:33.759
And that's why tax systems are a trade-off.
00:33:34.000 --> 00:33:43.359
Success should be repaid back to the society that helped enable it, but not too much of the success people should be able to benefit from their success, I believe then.
00:33:44.079 --> 00:33:44.400
Yeah.
00:33:44.640 --> 00:33:44.880
Okay.
00:33:44.960 --> 00:33:49.119
This last criticism is a little bit nerdy, but just humor us for a second.
00:33:49.279 --> 00:33:54.160
What about the idea that this proposition is unconstitutionally retroactive?
00:33:54.559 --> 00:33:57.359
Is that something you might hear a challenge about?
00:33:57.839 --> 00:34:01.359
Yeah, this is kind of wheezy, but it is a thing that I'm sure we'll hear about.
00:34:01.519 --> 00:34:14.000
So as I mentioned, the election is November 3rd, but if Prop 40 passes, it's going to tax every billionaire who was a California resident as of January 1st of 2026.
00:34:14.239 --> 00:34:15.280
This is pretty common.
00:34:15.519 --> 00:34:31.280
Most tax legislation of the 20th century raised tax rates, let's say, on events that had already happened starting at the beginning of the year that that legislation passed, going back to like the when the federal income tax modern federal income tax was enacted in 1913.
00:34:31.440 --> 00:34:45.360
It was enacted in October of 1913 and imposed income tax on all the income that had been earned in 1913, going back to the date when the 16th Amendment was ratified at the beginning of that year.
00:34:45.679 --> 00:34:57.039
Nonetheless, we expect that billionaires will argue that it's unconstitutional, violates the due process clause to tax them based on something that happened before the measure gets passed.
00:34:57.199 --> 00:35:09.679
The Supreme Court most recently has said that those kinds of decisions by legislatures are subject to rational basis review, which is to say that there just has to be some plausible reason why you would do something like that.
00:35:09.840 --> 00:35:24.480
Besides just the fact that Congress always did it for at least a century, the good reasons are to prevent billionaires from using the time that you give them, if you only have a prospective tax, to like move their money to places that you're not going to be able to find it.
00:35:24.639 --> 00:35:28.079
So that's part of their reason why it's retroactive.
00:35:28.159 --> 00:35:32.000
You don't want them claiming to live in Madrid when they don't live in Madrid, those kinds of things.
00:35:32.320 --> 00:35:50.800
So we expect, given that the Supreme Court says it's subject to rational basis review and that there's a gajillion precedents for similar things, we don't expect this to be likely to be a successful argument, but we I also understand that this current US Supreme Court has done a lot of crazy things that I didn't think were justifiable.
00:35:51.440 --> 00:35:55.360
Well, looking ahead, Brian, we're coming up on this vote, obviously, imminently.
00:35:55.519 --> 00:35:57.519
The polling shows it's pretty close.
00:35:57.760 --> 00:36:01.599
What's the story with props 41 and 42?
00:36:01.840 --> 00:36:04.639
What would their effect be on prop 40?
00:36:05.039 --> 00:36:10.000
Yeah, this is kind of, I don't know, sadly hilarious or I don't know, deeply ironic.
00:36:10.079 --> 00:36:12.079
Alonis Morosev should write a song about it.
00:36:12.239 --> 00:36:16.480
So Prop 41 and Prop 42 are fake ballot measures.
00:36:16.639 --> 00:36:21.280
They're actually on the ballot, but they don't do anything except they nullify Prop 40.
00:36:21.519 --> 00:36:28.400
So Prop 41 says that we'll audit California spending to make sure it's not spent waste.
00:36:28.559 --> 00:36:31.280
But we already have a California auditor who does that.
00:36:31.440 --> 00:36:49.840
But then buried within Prop 41, there's language that says if there happens to be another ballot measure on the ballot this year that waives California constitutional restrictions on spending, that ballot measure is nullified, which of course is a thing that Prop 40 does.
00:36:50.079 --> 00:36:58.480
Prop 42 similarly says we're preventing taxes on retirement savings, which is California doesn't tax retirement savings.
00:36:58.719 --> 00:37:01.280
ERISA would prevent a lot of those taxes anyway.
00:37:01.440 --> 00:37:13.679
So again, totally redundant, but picks another random provision of Prop 40 without mentioning Prop 40 by name and says to be another measure with this rule in it, that measure is nullified.
00:37:13.920 --> 00:37:20.000
So 41 and 42, both you know, funded by the billionaires who are opposing Prop 40.
00:37:20.159 --> 00:37:41.360
And they both are essentially kind of deceptive measures aimed at getting voters to accidentally vote against Prop 40 without realizing it, which I think is
I mean, props to them, pun intended, for coming up with this kind of evil genius thing that only billionaires could do, right?
00:37:41.519 --> 00:37:47.280
Spend$100 billion in support of a measure that does nothing except block block another measure.
00:37:47.519 --> 00:37:52.000
So the bottom line is if you like Prop 40, you have to vote against 41 and 42.
00:37:52.400 --> 00:37:53.360
So let me get this straight.
00:37:53.519 --> 00:38:02.719
A bunch of billionaires who didn't want to pay a one-time tax sunk billions of dollars into defeating the tax, like just pay the tax at that point.
00:38:03.119 --> 00:38:03.280
Right.
00:38:03.360 --> 00:38:04.880
No, if I said billions, that was wrong.
00:38:04.960 --> 00:38:07.679
It's the estimate is uh over$100 million.
00:38:08.159 --> 00:38:10.719
So$100 million is not nothing.
00:38:11.119 --> 00:38:15.519
No, it's but it's only 0.1% of their expected tax bill.
00:38:16.159 --> 00:38:16.880
I see.
00:38:17.119 --> 00:38:24.000
Okay, so you you guys out in California understand this much, much better than I do, but why does Newsom oppose this?
00:38:24.639 --> 00:38:46.079
I mean, I tend to say things like you would have to ask him, but the public reporting is that he is close to Sergei Brynn, and that Bryn expressed his extreme displeasure to Newsom about Prop 40 repeatedly, and Newsom promised Brynn that Newsom would do everything he could to prevent it from passing.
00:38:46.480 --> 00:38:56.400
Long after that, the governor offered some policy rationales that I find unpersuasive and that we've talked about for why he wasn't supporting the measure.
00:38:56.559 --> 00:39:07.199
He has worked tirelessly behind the scenes to intimidate or buy off anyone who might have been inclined to support Prop 40.
00:39:07.440 --> 00:39:13.039
And so, you know, you would have to ask him about why he's he's working so hard to defeat it.
00:39:13.440 --> 00:39:23.519
We mentioned before the unconstitutional retroactivity argument, which you think is you're confident won't be um an issue, but have there been other legal challenges to the proposition yet?
00:39:24.159 --> 00:39:32.639
No, so in California and also in federal law, generally taxpayers have to pay their tax before they can challenge the tax.
00:39:33.280 --> 00:39:38.639
There is kind of a narrow exception to that that we built into Prop 40 for so-called facial challenges.
00:39:38.800 --> 00:39:57.360
If there's any objection that's going to apply to every one of the taxpayers, they can bring it immediately and it has to be resolved quickly so that we know whether the California Supreme Court is going to agree with or reject those arguments before the first time that the billionaires would have to file their billionaire tax return.
00:39:57.760 --> 00:39:59.119
Leave us with your prediction.
00:39:59.199 --> 00:40:05.840
I mean, not your prediction for whether it will pass, but your just your general prediction about other states adopting a wealth
tax.
00:40:05.920 --> 00:40:08.960
You know, we're out here in New York and we have our own versions of it.
00:40:09.280 --> 00:40:11.440
Do you see other states adopting a wealth tax?
00:40:11.519 --> 00:40:17.280
And why, in your opinion, would that never happen at the federal government level, even under a democratically controlled government?
00:40:17.519 --> 00:40:25.119
So I think if you look around, it's not hard to see that currently billionaires have too much money, too much power, and are paying very little in tax.
00:40:25.360 --> 00:40:31.840
I think that combination of things is likely to inspire more legislative efforts, including at the federal level.
00:40:31.920 --> 00:40:34.239
So I happen to have a book that came out in January.
00:40:34.320 --> 00:40:36.079
It's called How to Tax the Ultra Rich.
00:40:36.480 --> 00:40:37.039
It's free.
00:40:37.119 --> 00:40:55.280
You can download it from the Roosevelt Institute website, and it explains how you could implement a wealth tax at the federal level, notwithstanding the fact that there are some potential federal constitutional limits on what Congress can do to tax wealth, although those rules don't apply to states.
00:40:55.679 --> 00:41:12.320
So for I think people who observe the three facts that I mentioned, but also aren't convinced by my book, the place that they're going to work, I think, is probably at the state level, because at the state level, these federal constitutional limitations don't apply.
00:41:12.559 --> 00:41:22.320
And so places like Washington State, Vermont, Illinois, New York, these are all places that have previously had versions of a wealth tax introduced before.
00:41:22.480 --> 00:41:25.440
And I wouldn't be surprised to see them there again.
00:41:25.760 --> 00:41:34.079
Okay, well, I've taken a lot of your time, but Brian Galley, we are on the edge of our seats waiting to see what happens on November 3rd.
00:41:34.159 --> 00:41:38.800
I'm sure you will be a very busy man that week, and I'm sure you have been in the past couple of months.
00:41:38.960 --> 00:41:40.719
And so I thank you so much for your time today.
00:41:40.800 --> 00:41:42.239
This is just such a fascinating discussion.
00:41:42.639 --> 00:41:43.119
Sure thing.
00:41:43.199 --> 00:41:44.079
Thanks for having me on.
00:41:48.079 --> 00:41:53.360
Thanks to everyone at Fordham Law School, especially the Dean's Office and our corporate law center donors for supporting this podcast.
00:41:53.599 --> 00:41:56.480
Bite Size Business Law is produced by WeEdit Podcasts.
00:41:56.639 --> 00:42:01.199
Listen and subscribe to Bite Size Business Law on Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:42:01.440 --> 00:42:11.280
The information in this podcast is for educational, informational, and entertainment purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, nor is it intended to promote the organizations with which our guests are affiliated.
00:42:11.519 --> 00:42:14.800
For more information, check out our show notes, and thanks for listening.