KOPYA NG SALIN 🔗
Josh Arnold: Thanks for calling the service department. I see your vehicle has an open recall. Can I get you scheduled?
Brent Osmond: Yeah, Tuesday works.
Josh Arnold: Great. While you're here, have you thought about what your trade in is worth?
Brent Osmond: I'm just here for the recall ban.
Josh Arnold: Totally understand. What if we looked at it Thursday instead?
Brent Osmond: It's 9pm, who am I talking to?
Josh Arnold: That's the thing. You might not be talking to anybody. Today on within spec, we break down whether an AI advisor boosts sales or pushes customers out the door. Now we've all heard about it, talking about the kiosk replacement incoming.
Marshall: Right.
Josh Arnold: For service advisors, every technician's dream, I'd I'd say to some degree, right? But the honest truth is like in this exact situation, if you know, they're known to increase sales or at least pitch more sales, but are they actually doing anything? Are they generating more or are they just pushing their customers out the door? What do you got, Marshall? Kick it off.
Marshall: Well, I don't know if either of you have actually talked to one of these, but one of one of my friends our one of our mutual friends, runs a couple of stores and and they use one and while they were training it he asked me to call it a few times and see what I thought. And I called
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha.
Marshall: that thing and it's pretty legit.
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: Yeah, it was pretty dang legit. It I called made probably fifteen appointments that he had to cancel, obviously. But w what
Josh Arnold: Yeah you should
Brent Osmond: Hey, what's the phone number?
Marshall: I'm he knew he knew it was me because they were all heavy duty trucks. And it's
Josh Arnold: Okay. Okay.
Marshall: and it's an automotive dealer, but I told him it'd be easy for him to figure out which ones they were because
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha
Marshall: because of that. But in the particular instance it wasn't really it was more scheduling. so it did do a good job of communicating that and it sounded very person like. and it did a really good job of a after hour scheduling, but it couldn't answer a lot of like really detailed questions if you started kinda beating it up. Now the if you g It did have some problems if you give it an off brand VIN number. So it was kinda wigging out. It's like, well,
Josh Arnold: Yeah, yeah.
Marshall: what's the last date of your VIN? Or something like that. And since
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha.
Marshall: that is a, you know, particular brand dealer, it was like kinda wigging it out a little bit. I think that that stuff's improved by now.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Marshall: but that's my only like direct conversation with one before. But I'll be
Josh Arnold: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Marshall: honest, I was fairly impressed because like I don't know if you've guys called the schedule appointment or anything like that at the dealership, but sometimes, the people aren't polite or you know what I
Load full transcript
mean? Like they're rushing to try to just you know, f you know, honestly, the AI was pr was pretty welcoming. So
Josh Arnold: So I was gonna say my experience, I haven't dealt with it at a dealer really. Have you ever been to a McDonald's or a Panda Express recently though? Y you haven't? Ma maybe not.
Marshall: I'm a door DoorDash guy.
Josh Arnold: Okay I know that. The Mr. DoorDash King over here. Either way, so I I I sometimes will stop and get like a breakfast sandwich. or my wife loves Panda Express, so we'll sometimes get that. But I roll up to the the board on this thing and y It's honestly hard to tell at first unless you're like, I really didn't notice it. But what caught me was the ending of it. Because you you finish your order and you know what they say? Would you like an egg roll with that? Would you like a coffee with that? they're trying to they they they try to
Marshall: no shot.
Josh Arnold: upsell you before they let you finish the order. So I guess I haven't experienced it in automotive yet, but a hundred percent I did experience it in both of those. They do try to upsell you before you finish out your order. So to me, was it better than ordering through a person there? Not really. It was about the same. Like they were nice, they they seemed efficient. I did think it was funny too. They added little typing effects when you place your order like someone was sitting there on a keyboard writing everything down. But I mean it really didn't change my experience that much. It didn't make it better or worse. The only thing I noticed was they were trying to upsell me. So I don't know. I can kind of see it. What about you, Brent?
Brent Osmond: I, to be honest with I haven't had any, I don't think any interactions with an AI calling in or ordering anything. I did, I do think, however, my, my wife took her Jeep in for an oil change the other day. And I've had, I want to say 13 text messages from two different phone numbers, asking about trade in, asking about something else, asking about a few other things, right? So, eventually I just texted back and I said, please remove me from there. Yeah,
Josh Arnold: Opt out. Yeah yeah.
Brent Osmond: we need to opt out of this, right? You know, we're not trading it in. It's in 2019. It's done us really great. But yeah, still. So I think
Josh Arnold: So did that give you a negative experience?
Brent Osmond: Yeah, I'm like, it was an we were there for an oil change. Like literally, that's not it's like that's it. I don't need 13 text messages after knowledge range. Right.
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha.
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: Man and
Brent Osmond: But I do think I do think on for the technician to advisor role. I think that'll make things easier. Right, because there's some technicians like we we cannot let them talk to customers. Right.
Josh Arnold: We've heard about them.
Brent Osmond: But if we take what a technician is going to advise the customer about and we prompt that into AI and then the AI
just makes the phone call, right?
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Brent Osmond: And then done. mean, ideally then.
Josh Arnold: I don't know I don't know how much I would trust it though. Not that I would trust a service advisor either. At least that's my perception.
Marshall: I'll tell you what, I was like as you guys were chatting, I was just kinda reading through consumerreports dot org and they're talking about
Josh Arnold: Legitimate.
Marshall: on here that consumer reports observed was that the prospective c customers who answered the phone didn't seem to mind talking to a bot. Even though this this one's name was Pam sounded a little stilted. interrupted callers to rattle off a seventeen digit VIN and even mispronounced Nissan, customers sounded like they were comfortable with the interaction. While some voice agents are obviously AI powered, others sounded especially human, and they could be customized with different names, tones, and even regional accents, and with ongoing advancements in AI they're likely r to rapidly improve.
Josh Arnold: What's the birda accent sound like?
Marshall: The Berta accent would be wild, bro. my gosh.
Josh Arnold: I need some bird AI in my life.
Brent Osmond: Yeah, you just answered. Yeah, they pick up the phone. yeah, but she's just locked in here right now. What do want us to do with that?
Josh Arnold: I'm buying I'm buying whatever that advisor is recommended for sure. No, I think I think there's I think people are gonna get more used to it. I don't know if it's what I wanna deal with all the time. 247, 365.
Brent Osmond: No. Yeah.
Josh Arnold: I guess if I was trying to get my car out, I was in a waiter situation, I needed to be somewhere at four o'clock, I don't want to talk to a bot at that point, right? I want to get somebody that's actually gonna make something happen for me. And I think that's where a lot of the frustration lies. Bots are good when you're not in those situations, but the second that you need something done, you probably want somebody on that line that's actually gonna take care of it. Marshall, what do you think about that?
Marshall: Yeah, I was looking at some just some overall numbers on it. eighty two percent of dealership surveyed said that they use AI in some form. let's see here some customers prefer AI for booking. In a C DK survey, thirty-one percent said they'd rather book service with an AI assistant than a person on the phone. And that rose to fifty percent when th those people were Gen Z.
Josh Arnold: How how bad are are people at communicating?
Brent Osmond: I was just gonna say, it's because these Gen Z's can't talk to people, so they'd rather talk to a robot.
Marshall: Yeah, it says just in general though, thirty-one percent would rather book with an AI assistant, and that rose to fifty one percent of Gen Z respondents and forty four percent of millennials.
Josh Arnold: No.
Marshall: So, it it sounds to me that they should at least have the option, and if you could just say, I wanna talk to a person, then I'll just give you a person. You know what mean?
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: so if you're if you're dead set. See go ahead.
Josh Arnold: So do we think that we do do we think that advisors won't exist in the future because other people don't wanna communicate because they don't have that communication skill?
Marshall: I don't even think it's that. I think it's just, you know, I know for sure that it it's hard to find good parts people and it's equally hard to find a good advisor and it's even harder to find a good mechanic. So I think if you can bring something in, and this this is a Pied Piper study that two tho from two thousand one hundred and five dealerships found AI handled service calls without human help ninety one percent of the time.
Josh Arnold: Wow.
Marshall: So if you can bring something in that ninety one percent of the time is gonna handle what needs to be handled when a client calls in, get them
Josh Arnold: No brainer.
Marshall: scheduled or what have you or or give them an update. It it's really not difficult for them to for an AI to supply an update even with the tools that we have available to us if the technician is clicking it's in di you know, you pull it in and you have a drop down and change it to you know, at shop to diagnosing and then from diagnosing to at quoting and and all of that and if there's a process to change those things, which a lot of have that for text message updates, then the AI can use that data to to update the clients.
Josh Arnold: Does it have increased sales by any chance data?
Marshall: That's what I was actually looking for when I put this when I was starting to search this. It says callers got an appointment eighty f eighty six percent of the time with AI compared with ninety percent when a person answered.
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: the weak spot was the handoff when the AI couldn't handle a request. A transfer to a human failed fifty per six fifty six percent of the time. So if they were working the way I read that is if Somebody calls in, the AI's trying to get it scheduled, the person gets frustrated, and then they get to a person and then the person still couldn't get the appoint person
Josh Arnold: Yep. They're already pissed off. Yeah.
Marshall: in for an appointment after that fact.
Josh Arnold: Hmm so I mean do you
Marshall: th this is a s survey of three hundred three hundred and forty US automotive consumers found that sixty percent said they had definitely or possibly spoken to an AI voice agent during a recent car buying journey. so I mean th that's only three hundred and forty dealerships, but
Brent Osmond: So that's them purchasing
Josh Arnold: Well
Brent Osmond: a vehicle.
Marshall: That was with a yeah, with a purchase situation.
Josh Arnold: So I know of a Subaru dealer in Utah that does fully autonomous car dealers through AI. Basically,
Marshall: Right.
Josh Arnold: you don't have to talk to anybody if you don't want to. Now, I'm sure there's
things that happen to make that work, right? Like I don't think it's truly all one click away, but I still think it shows that customers are definitely looking sometimes to avoid people. The the thing I wonder though is when it comes down to the customer service, if someone still delivers an over the top customer service experience, is that gonna be better than AI? Is that still what people are gonna want? Or do you think that they're just gonna want the the consistency of AI? is it is it is this due because of our people being inconsistent or is this due to AI actually being better?
Marshall: dude, check this one out. this is right in your neck of the woods, brother. Mercedes
Josh Arnold: That data man.
Marshall: Benz of Plano reported one point six million dollars more in recommend recommendation sales year over year. seventeen percent more recommendations presented, ten percent more customer pay labor hours sold, and five point five percent more revenue per repair order after adopting adopting a service advisor AI.
Josh Arnold: Woo hoo. Man, man. Do they have advisors there still?
Marshall: psh I'm assuming they do, but they literally have a published case study.
Brent Osmond: Holy shit.
Josh Arnold: Well, it was nice to know all those advisors out there. That blows my mind.
Marshall: I know, that's pretty s pretty substantial. It says on this one, Ven Solutions reported that dealerships using AI tools sold twenty five percent more vehicles per month and acquired thirty seven percent more vehicles per month than participating dealerships not using the same tools. Those are vendor reported comparisons. So you take that however you want, but
Josh Arnold: So so what do you what do you think l just to get on the other side of this, what do you think that data shows us? Does that show us that in the automotive industry the advisor and BDC role people weren't really doing what they were s supposed to be doing?
Marshall: Well, I think it expos w for me what I think
Josh Arnold: 'Cause AI is not better, right? We're not saying AI is better, right? Y than a person.
Marshall: No, no. I
Brent Osmond: it
Marshall: what I what I think it comes down to is like you know, and I talk to this I talk to my mobile team about this all the time. You have to be available to your clients.
Josh Arnold: Right.
Marshall: so if a client calls, we need to be able to talk to the client. And AI always answers. Day or night, Saturday, Sunday, doesn't matter.
Josh Arnold: Christmas, Hanukkah, New Year's.
Marshall: yeah, AI always answers and that's that's where we miss I think a lot of the times and if you're available to your client you're gonna have an opportunity for a sale. And AI is always available to give an opportunity. So I think that for me that's where I see that happening is that a client can call at ten o'clock at night. I'm not expecting a a facility to stay open twenty four seven just so they can make sure they can answer their calls. But I think that that's where a lot of this is coming from. After hours calls, that thing is setting up an appointment and that counts. You know what I'm saying?
Josh Arnold: I guess I could I guess I could see that. I just also wonder too does it does it do their jobs better in some way, right? I j
Marshall: Yeah.
Brent Osmond: Well, let's see if he's-
Josh Arnold: I've known some amazing advisors. Go ahead, Brett.
Brent Osmond: I think you can think about it too, is, you know, an advisor could have a lot going on just outside of the job that's affecting their day to day, right? So they could have a bad day. And if they're having a bad day at work, they're probably not going to be performing well, right? Whereas if you call AI, AI is not going have a bad day,
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Brent Osmond: right? So, I mean, there's a little bit of that. I think there's a lot of it too, like, you know, you're saying does it You said, the advisors in the BDC, they not doing their jobs properly? Well, that kind of goes back to our last topic, training, right? We can train an AI pretty easy, right?
Josh Arnold: Yeah. Yeah.
Brent Osmond: Where training people is a lot harder, right? So.
Josh Arnold: That's true. I and I think the pay at those positions is harder to motivate that that training too, right?
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: the AI doesn't forget its training over time. You know what I mean? You well, yeah, for the most part. it might need a little
Josh Arnold: Well some, but Yeah, but for the most part.
Marshall: prompting from time to time, but it's like an instant deal, and then it's right back to the races. So
Brent Osmond: No. No.
Josh Arnold: Right. So and that's and that's where I was saying AI is just what our departments could have been. It's not better. They're just the baseline. So that's where I'm like, okay, say we train a team. Obviously you have AI to cover those times. But say we train our advisors and train our BDC. We should potentially do better, right? Than AI? 'Cause I think everybody would say that a human can do better than AI when they try.
Brent Osmond: for sure. Right. Because you got to think an AI can't,
Josh Arnold: I would hope so, right?
Marshall: Yeah.
Brent Osmond: you know, an AI really can't express emotions or empathize. Right. So.
Josh Arnold: Empathy, yeah, yeah. Or if they do it's fake.
Brent Osmond: Yeah, right. Whereas, you know, human-to-human interaction, we can people can pick up on that. Right. So.
Marshall: It's kinda reminded me, Josh, of a conversation we had a while back about about service riders in general and just you know, about the role. Like the role over the last few years, it seems to me has become more administrative and less customer facing.
Josh Arnold: Easier. Yeah. Yeah. Yep.
Marshall: And I feel like I've and I've been feeling like this for a while, is that you almost you almost have t you have to do something because I don't feel like majority of the service riders are even customer facing anymore.
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: And and I think that's a problem. Even like my last dealer car deal automotive dealership experience, the last two, I've noticed that it's just like they're in just like a panic. All the that's like their hair's on fire the whole time and I'm like, Bro, I just wanna
Josh Arnold: Right.
Marshall: talk to you about my car and and they're not available. They're not available for their clients. you know, and
Josh Arnold: Right.
Marshall: so I I that's been a thing constantly on my mind. There should be somebody available. And so when you when you walk up to where all the service riders are sitting and everybody's running around with their hair on fire, it's like
Josh Arnold: Somebody ready to take care of you.
Marshall: Yeah, it's like it's not a very welcoming environment. It's like, bro, I just want to talk to you about my car. and so I think that that is part of the deal, whereas if I wanna update on my car after I've dropped it off and I can just talk to the AI and it just tells me real quick and it's not like I don't feel like I'm inconveniencing somebody because they're, you know, running around with their hair on fire, you know what mean?
Josh Arnold: I think I think that's what I mean this conversation kinda turned into. Obviously like the data says it works and it and it might be because like what you said, Brent AI covers those bad days. It might be what Marshall was pointing out, which is AI's always ready, right? But at the end of the day, I think what it mostly showed is that when our teams if our teams operated in a customer service mindset and did their training, that we would see big results. And I still think that there's still room to grow. That being said, will we reach that in time before AI's good enough to wear it just doesn't make sense on the financial statement. I that that's kind of where I'm at. So any closing remarks from you guys?
Marshall: I'm good.
Brent Osmond: Good. Yeah. Happy to see where this goes.
Josh Arnold: Brent, well, Marshall, it's about it's about that time. What do we say?
Marshall: Catch you on the next one.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, right.