KOPYA NG SALIN 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:02.640 --> 00:00:11.519
Consciousness, it's both a gift and a burden for Homo sapiens because the gods have stopped talking to us, but now we're godlike.
00:00:11.839 --> 00:00:16.000
For thousands of years, human consciousness looked very different.
00:00:16.160 --> 00:00:24.879
And the way we experience the world today, chatting to ourselves in our heads all day, feeling like an individual, that's new.
00:00:25.199 --> 00:00:26.239
Really new.
00:00:26.480 --> 00:00:34.000
Before about a thousand BCE, it's very difficult to find an in-depth self-reflection in the text.
00:00:34.159 --> 00:00:39.840
There was no sense that there's a mental space floating inside their head somewhere.
00:00:41.280 --> 00:00:49.439
That's Brian McVeigh, who's here to help us explore one of the most provocative ideas ever proposed about the human mind.
00:00:49.600 --> 00:00:56.479
That for much of human history, humans didn't have consciousness as we understand it today.
00:00:56.719 --> 00:00:58.320
And it wasn't that long ago.
00:00:58.640 --> 00:00:59.119
That's right.
00:00:59.280 --> 00:01:02.960
No inner narrator, no self-reflective I.
00:01:03.439 --> 00:01:14.400
Instead, guidance came from outside the self, through gods, rituals, and hallucinations that issued commands and organized everyday life.
00:01:14.480 --> 00:01:19.680
Not as a mental illness, but as a normal functional part of how societies worked.
00:01:24.879 --> 00:01:30.400
So the default mode of human psychic architecture, it's to hear voices.
00:01:30.640 --> 00:01:35.760
For McVeigh, consciousness wasn't something evolution simply switched on.
00:01:36.000 --> 00:01:43.120
It emerged over time through shared culture, language, ritual, and even technology.
00:01:43.599 --> 00:01:55.680
At one point, he says, the human mind was organized as if it had two chambers, what he calls the bicameral mind, with one side commanding the other with the voice of a god.
00:01:56.079 --> 00:01:57.920
Until something shifted.
00:02:00.239 --> 00:02:01.040
I'm Ollie.
00:02:01.280 --> 00:02:08.000
And I'm Matt, and this is what we did before, the podcast where we chart the history of modern inventions.
00:02:08.240 --> 00:02:17.439
McVeigh's work builds on ideas first proposed by Julian Jaynes, who came up with the idea of a bicameral mind.
00:02:17.840 --> 00:02:23.680
So you'll hear Brian mention Janes and what's sometimes called Jaynesian consciousness.
00:02:24.000 --> 00:02:35.439
But at its core, it's the argument that the consciousness we experience today isn't the same as what ancient humans or even surprisingly recent ancestors experienced.
00:02:35.680 --> 00:02:39.280
So we started by asking Brian to explain his theory.
00:03:04.879 --> 00:03:20.400
Hallucinations were pretty efficient as a means of governing societies, but eventually they started to break down because population scale increased, social complexity increased, and so a new mentality was needed.
00:03:20.639 --> 00:03:24.879
And that is that new mentality is what James called consciousness.
00:03:25.120 --> 00:03:32.960
There's a problem with the word, unfortunately, because there's in English languages maybe five to six different definitions of consciousness.
00:03:33.120 --> 00:03:38.479
So when people hear consciousness, they assume, oh, James was talking about perception.
00:03:38.639 --> 00:03:42.719
He was talking about feelings, he was talking about cognition or reasoning.
00:03:42.960 --> 00:03:44.719
And that's not what James meant.
00:03:44.800 --> 00:03:50.960
He had a very well-delineated definition of what he meant by consciousness.
00:03:51.199 --> 00:04:00.879
And that's admittedly a little bit difficult for people to uh get uh to get past because they all have their own understanding of what consciousness means.
00:04:01.039 --> 00:04:03.680
But in any case, uh to go back to the hallucinations.
00:04:03.840 --> 00:04:14.479
So hallucinations originally were adaptive, they broke down, and by around a thousand BCE, culture invented consciousness.
00:04:14.639 --> 00:04:24.959
And this also is a very important point because people, when they hear the word consciousness, they assume, oh, you're talking about neurology, something to do with neuroscience or genetics evolution.
00:04:25.279 --> 00:04:27.680
James was very clear about this.
00:04:27.839 --> 00:04:38.959
And if there's one point in today's talk that I think needs to be highlighted, it's that for Jaynes, consciousness was not a consequence of biological evolution.
00:04:39.120 --> 00:04:41.439
Rather, consciousness was something cultural.
00:04:41.600 --> 00:04:47.360
It's something that was learned in the same way we learn political beliefs or we learn religious beliefs.
00:04:47.600 --> 00:05:02.240
In any case, once consciousness started to take root, it radically changed uh people's experience of the world, needless to say, because it became a more efficient way of dealing with social complexity.
00:05:02.800 --> 00:05:03.040
Okay.
00:05:03.439 --> 00:05:18.879
So um with this kind of deceptively difficult definition of consciousness, because I think to a lot of people that maybe haven't thought this uh thought about this that much, they think, oh yeah, consciousness is just the state of being awake or thinking or perception.
00:05:19.120 --> 00:05:29.920
Are we sort of saying that ancient humans um did have some aspects of consciousness or they just didn't have the self-awareness that we have in the sort of modern sense?
00:05:30.319 --> 00:05:30.639
Right.
00:05:30.959 --> 00:05:43.839
So if you look at their ancient writings, um before about 1200 BCE, it's clear that they were not experiencing what we would call consciousness.
00:05:44.079 --> 00:05:54.720
It doesn't mean that they had no cognition, obviously, or that they could not perceive the world and they uh designed very uh sophisticated, advanced civilizations.
00:05:54.879 --> 00:05:58.240
So something was going on
Load full transcript
upstairs, needless to say.
00:05:58.480 --> 00:06:04.959
However, compared to conscious people of today, there were some limitations.
00:06:05.120 --> 00:06:10.319
And of course, the other big difference is that they would hear hallucinations, not all the time.
00:06:10.560 --> 00:06:14.079
They would only hear hallucinations if they were under stress.
00:06:14.399 --> 00:06:18.319
And probably not everyone heard hallucinations.
00:06:18.480 --> 00:06:24.480
Uh, people were they followed scripts, routines, they were told what to do by their leaders.
00:06:24.720 --> 00:06:29.199
So I think that's important to emphasize because actually that's true with conscious people.
00:06:29.360 --> 00:06:33.759
Many of our actions throughout the day are based on habit.
00:06:33.920 --> 00:06:37.199
We're not conscious of most of what we do.
00:06:37.439 --> 00:06:42.800
And it's similar to consciousness and hallucinations, is why do they why are they triggered?
00:06:42.959 --> 00:06:47.680
It's when we're under stress that we're usually going to be very conscious about something.
00:06:47.839 --> 00:06:49.920
It's the same thing, same thing with hallucinations.
00:06:50.079 --> 00:06:54.399
People would hallucinate when they were facing an important decision or choice.
00:06:54.959 --> 00:06:57.360
What what do you mean by hallucination then?
00:06:57.439 --> 00:07:07.920
Is it something that we would know today as an experience that we have, but it's just that we appreciate it differently, perhaps to uh an ancestor?
00:07:08.160 --> 00:07:11.920
Or is it something completely different that they had going on in their brains?
00:07:12.399 --> 00:07:17.360
Well, I think that the way to answer that is to look at present-day hallucinations.
00:07:17.600 --> 00:07:27.759
So usually when we hear the word hallucinations, we assume that there's some neurological wiring that needs to be fixed, that there's something wrong with a person's brain.
00:07:27.920 --> 00:07:31.439
We associate it with schizophrenia and other mental health conditions.
00:07:31.680 --> 00:07:40.879
But um, actually, many people who are not diagnosed, there are many people in what we can call a non-clinical population who experience hallucinations.
00:07:41.120 --> 00:07:45.199
Most people, at least once or twice, maybe heard a voice and nobody was there.
00:07:45.519 --> 00:07:53.279
So what I'm saying is that hallucinations present day are a vestige of an earlier mentality.
00:07:53.519 --> 00:07:58.720
Hallucinations, the ability to hallucinate, was something that evolved.
00:07:59.120 --> 00:08:09.360
When it when it appeared among Homo sapiens, it's very difficult to say, but certainly uh if you look at ancient civilizations, that's all they talked about.
00:08:09.600 --> 00:08:12.079
Were gods visiting them?
00:08:12.399 --> 00:08:15.680
And no one is surprised when they hear that.
00:08:15.759 --> 00:08:17.519
They say, well, that's what religion is all about.
00:08:17.600 --> 00:08:29.600
But what Jaynes argued is that there are definite historical patterns that these descriptions of visiting gods, ancestors, what have you, actually were hallucinations.
00:08:29.759 --> 00:08:30.639
Not all the time.
00:08:30.800 --> 00:08:32.399
I mean, it gets a little bit murky.
00:08:32.639 --> 00:08:43.440
So by the time you get maybe 1500, 1000 BCE, you can make the argument that just because someone was recording being visited by a god does not necessarily mean they had a hallucination.
00:08:43.759 --> 00:08:57.840
But the evidence seems to point to the fact that before about a thousand BCE, most of the time when people talked about being visited by a deity, um, having an ancestor or a ghost, they loved ghosts, Mesopotamia.
00:08:58.159 --> 00:09:00.639
You know, it's not like today where ghosts are unusual.
00:09:00.720 --> 00:09:01.679
Ghosts are quite common.
00:09:01.759 --> 00:09:11.120
And I think that is just another piece of evidence to show that interacting with uh divine powers was actually quite common.
00:09:11.519 --> 00:09:16.879
Yeah, because you don't hear that so much anymore, do you, of people saying that God spoke directly to them.
00:09:17.039 --> 00:09:20.159
Faith seems to have taken on a different form in the modern age.
00:09:20.320 --> 00:09:27.679
It would be quite unusual for somebody now to say God spoke directly to me and I heard his words, or uh whatever the case might be.
00:09:27.759 --> 00:09:32.799
Uh and yet in ancient writings, that seems to be hugely common.
00:09:33.200 --> 00:09:33.600
That's right.
00:09:33.840 --> 00:09:43.200
In fact, the founders of most of the um the major religious traditions claimed that they were visited by a god or gods.
00:09:43.279 --> 00:09:45.360
It's not unusual at all.
00:09:45.600 --> 00:09:53.120
Um, and the if you look at the Bible, uh the Old Testament, especially, it's there's something very nostalgic.
00:09:53.519 --> 00:09:59.279
The New Testament is composed of books that indicate that something's been lost.
00:09:59.360 --> 00:10:01.440
They want Yahweh to come visit them.
00:10:01.519 --> 00:10:02.879
They're looking for Yahweh.
00:10:03.039 --> 00:10:12.720
And I think that points to an earlier time before the uh books of the Old Testament were written, where meeting with Yahweh actually was not that uncommon.
00:10:13.279 --> 00:10:22.399
And just for uh reference, Yahweh, I don't think everybody will know Yahweh um is what God is referred to as in the Old Testament, correct?
00:10:22.720 --> 00:10:23.039
That's right.
00:10:23.200 --> 00:10:23.360
Yeah.
00:10:23.840 --> 00:10:44.080
If we sort of go right back to very early Homo sapiens, um sort of long before any civilization that we recognize today, um we we've we've touched on hallucinations, but can we speculate what the internal kind of conscious experience would be like for those ancient humans?
00:10:44.320 --> 00:10:53.759
Day to day, you know, we we're many of us have an inner
monologue or um we know what it feels like to be us and have a concept of self.
00:10:53.919 --> 00:10:56.960
Um could is there something that we can expand upon on that?
00:10:57.279 --> 00:11:06.159
Yeah, because I I know that Jane's work specifically is talking more about um societies from that that had civilization already, right?
00:11:06.240 --> 00:11:15.919
So if we're looking back maybe 300,000 years, I'm not sure how far back your research goes, but is there is there something you could speculate as to what humans were thinking then?
00:11:16.399 --> 00:11:16.639
Right.
00:11:16.720 --> 00:11:18.879
So I think the key word there is speculate.
00:11:18.960 --> 00:11:21.039
Um it's it's very difficult to know.
00:11:21.200 --> 00:11:30.480
Um now, as you know, we do have a lot of cultural artifacts, especially beginning around 60,000, 50,000, 30,000 BCE.
00:11:30.960 --> 00:11:37.679
Um the first evidence of monumental architectures 10,000 BCE in Turkey.
00:11:37.759 --> 00:11:44.399
They found some fascinating things that uh relatively new in terms of archaeological finds.
00:11:44.639 --> 00:11:49.440
And um this is quite exciting because we have to rewrite the textbooks actually.
00:11:49.600 --> 00:12:16.639
But in any case, other than that, there are no, I think the problem is why we have to speculate, is there are no written records, because there's a world of difference between finding some old monuments, uh finding, as I say, bones and stones, um other cultural artifacts, versus finding written text that tell us or maybe don't record what people were experiencing.
00:12:16.720 --> 00:12:18.240
So it's actually very difficult.
00:12:18.399 --> 00:12:24.399
I mean, I you know, there's an assumption that some people make that prehistoric people practice a type of shamanism.
00:12:24.879 --> 00:12:26.799
And um, I don't know if that's true.
00:12:26.879 --> 00:12:30.320
And I really I to me that's sort of reading things back into the past.
00:12:30.720 --> 00:12:31.759
There's no evidence.
00:12:31.919 --> 00:12:34.320
We we just simply don't have the evidence yet.
00:12:34.480 --> 00:12:37.519
Now, you know, we can extrapolate, I suppose.
00:12:37.600 --> 00:12:39.360
And James, you're right.
00:12:39.440 --> 00:12:41.600
I mean, James doesn't really get into that too much.
00:12:41.679 --> 00:12:45.600
He does talk about the origins of language and how that relates to hallucinations.
00:12:45.759 --> 00:12:50.799
Um, but um I think he he uh would be very careful, and I'm gonna be very careful.
00:12:50.879 --> 00:12:52.960
I I really don't know how to answer that question.
00:12:53.360 --> 00:13:13.840
And it's actually um a thought of mine, I guess, that in a way this is a catch-22, because um from what I've read anyway, uh, and correct me if I'm wrong, but language and uh writing and metaphor, as you've written a book about, are sort of tools of creating consciousness.
00:13:13.919 --> 00:13:16.000
Is that sort of correct to say?
00:13:16.480 --> 00:13:17.039
Yes.
00:13:17.200 --> 00:13:26.000
Uh yeah, so language to understand Jaynesian consciousness, and of course, what I mean by by Janezian consciousness is how Jaynes defined it.
00:13:26.159 --> 00:13:29.200
Um language is crucial.
00:13:29.519 --> 00:13:34.720
Things really don't make sense um unless we understand how language worked.
00:13:35.039 --> 00:13:38.240
So, of course, pre-conscious people had language.
00:13:38.480 --> 00:13:49.679
We know that because they they had written text, but they probably those languages up until about a thousand BCE, those languages, and I have looked at them.
00:13:49.759 --> 00:13:57.600
I'm I'm not conversant in ancient languages, but I I have gotten out the old dictionaries and done some statistical analysis.
00:13:57.759 --> 00:14:08.879
And what's amazing is that it's very difficult to find in these ancient languages clear-cut words that describe what we would call conscious experience.
00:14:09.120 --> 00:14:16.879
The what we can call mind words or uh a vocabulary that describes mental events is very, very limited.
00:14:17.120 --> 00:14:22.639
And we're not talking about one place, we're talking about anywhere that we have written languages.
00:14:22.720 --> 00:14:24.159
So there's a definite pattern there.
00:14:24.240 --> 00:14:27.279
And we're talking about maybe 15 to 20 centuries.
00:14:27.519 --> 00:14:30.159
So this is not a fluke in historical record.
00:14:30.399 --> 00:14:46.720
And to me, that is probably the one of the most important pieces of evidence that supports what Jane said about a shift in human mentality from a hallucinatory type of mentality to uh uh a conscious mentality.
00:14:47.120 --> 00:14:55.600
So are you saying that written language back then would have been more instructional, perhaps, than it would have been self-reflective?
00:14:56.080 --> 00:14:56.480
Yes.
00:14:56.720 --> 00:14:58.399
Yeah, I think that's a fair statement.
00:14:58.559 --> 00:15:18.559
And something uh else I would add to that, if you look at uh written language, up until again, just to use this uh as a uh as a point on a timescale, up until about a thousand BCE, almost all written texts have to do with what we would call religion.
00:15:18.799 --> 00:15:21.759
By modern standards, it's like they were obsessed with religion.
00:15:21.919 --> 00:15:24.480
It's almost as if there's something pathological about it.
00:15:24.799 --> 00:15:40.879
Written texts, if they were not specifically prayers or hymns, they were administrative records about how to keep the gods happy in their temples to make sure that they were collecting whatever needed to be collected to offer to the gods.
00:15:41.039 --> 00:15:47.679
So every so the what written texts tell me is that those civilizations were intensively religious.
00:15:47.759 --> 00:15:50.000
Everything revolved around religion.
00:15:50.240 --> 00:16:00.000
And um uh since we we bring up the written text, it gets a little
complicated, but um well, for one thing we have to remember that very few people could read.
00:16:00.159 --> 00:16:04.080
Um only a priestly class typically could read the text.
00:16:04.720 --> 00:16:24.639
But uh Janes argued that uh eventually the written text started to erode the hallucinations because there's this idea that when people when priests would write something down, the text would read back to them somehow, or they would hear the words.
00:16:25.200 --> 00:16:27.440
This is kind of a bizarre way of looking at things.
00:16:27.679 --> 00:16:33.519
But what happened is once you write something down on a tablet, you can move that around.
00:16:33.840 --> 00:16:37.200
And that sort of took the power away from the gods.
00:16:37.360 --> 00:16:52.399
And so James has this argument, it's it's a little bit convoluted, I think, but he tries to show how ironically that technology of the written text started to erode um bicameral or hallucinatory mentality.
00:16:52.799 --> 00:17:05.119
So so we have this sort of 10,000 BC, we have the shift to farming, we have people settling in places like the Fertile Crescent, and soon after that's the beginning of civilization.
00:17:05.359 --> 00:17:18.960
So that that period must have impacted consciousness a lot, but it seems that the really big shift and uh the work that you're talking about here about the bicameral mind didn't happen until much later.
00:17:19.200 --> 00:17:23.519
So, what started shifting when civilization began?
00:17:23.759 --> 00:17:26.480
And why was there this breakaway point?
00:17:26.880 --> 00:17:31.279
Well, of course, you know, most people would say it had to do with the agricultural revolution.
00:17:31.440 --> 00:17:35.839
That's sort of a textbook response, and I think there's something to it, of course.
00:17:35.920 --> 00:17:51.279
I think it's a little more complicated than that because of, as I said, recent archaeological finds in Turkey, where they had monumental architecture, um, they had engravings and everything else 10,000, 12,000 years ago.
00:17:51.440 --> 00:18:19.680
And so the reason why I'm mentioning that is rather than viewing the agricultural revolution leading up to social complexity, leading up to a type of religion based on the voices of the gods, it could be that religion came first, that people were communicating with gods somehow, assuming that the archaeological finds in Turkey are some kind of um religious architecture, temples, what have you.
00:18:20.000 --> 00:18:22.000
That that's more of a footnote, I suppose.
00:18:22.160 --> 00:18:43.599
But in any case, by the time you get from around, again, there's a lot of geographical variation, but from around 10,000, 12,000 BCE up to around 4,000, 3500, 3,000 BCE, that's when you start to see a a big change, urbanization about 3,000 BCE.
00:18:43.680 --> 00:18:49.440
And so it seems that the agriculture revolution, once it got going, people started to settle.
00:18:49.599 --> 00:18:53.359
And it
took centuries for these changes to really sink in.
00:18:53.599 --> 00:19:06.960
But once you had urbanization, you had a concentration of wealth, you had the formation, of course, of city-states, you had the um uh what we would call a sort of politics, but of course, back then there was no notion of politics the way we think of it.
00:19:07.119 --> 00:19:10.640
Um and that was all fine and dandy.
00:19:10.799 --> 00:19:24.799
Uh, that sort of explosion of civilizations, especially Mesopotamia around 1,000 BCE, really was the um the the uh the high point, you might say, the consequence of bicameral mentality.
00:19:25.119 --> 00:19:30.559
But what happened is human civilization became a victim of its own success.
00:19:30.880 --> 00:19:34.480
Because as the agriculture revolution led to an expansion of populations.
00:19:34.640 --> 00:19:41.519
I mean, it would contract here and there, famine, wars, things like that, but in general, populations were steadily increasing.
00:19:41.839 --> 00:19:56.880
And once population scale increases, it can lead to a lot of problems with governance, with uh people not wanting to take orders, breakaway, uh a lot, a lot more warfare.
00:19:57.039 --> 00:20:02.640
And so what was needed was a new mentality, and that's when consciousness started to develop.
00:20:02.799 --> 00:20:08.880
So it's important to keep in mind there's no clean break between hallucinatory mentality and consciousness.
00:20:09.039 --> 00:20:26.319
We're talking about, you know, probably you can find incipient evidence of a type of consciousness beginning to emerge uh d during the even during the heyday of um hallucinations, you know, if if you look carefully.
00:20:26.640 --> 00:20:44.720
And then by the time you get up to the late uh Bronze Age collapse, which is one of the most important events in human history, then civilizations started to really cultivate a culture that encouraged a metaphoric language, and of course that led to uh consciousness.
00:20:45.279 --> 00:20:56.319
So ultimately we still um physically have the same kind of minds or largely the same minds as our ancestors.
00:20:56.400 --> 00:21:00.160
And you've touched on um and spoken about the bicameral mind.
00:21:00.319 --> 00:21:08.240
I was just wondering um before we move on, if we could sort of define bicameral mind um just briefly for the listeners.
00:22:01.010 --> 00:22:01.410
Sure.
00:22:01.570 --> 00:22:09.970
So bicameral uh comes from the word um, as you know, two chambers, two houses, and that that's why modern governments meant in some modern governments.
00:22:10.050 --> 00:22:17.570
We do, we have a bicameral system um in the United States, and that's you know, Jaynes used that as a metaphor, a governance.
00:22:17.730 --> 00:22:21.890
So you have a higher legislative house and then a lower legislative house.
00:22:22.050 --> 00:22:28.450
So in Jaynes accounting, the higher legislative house was the right hemisphere.
00:22:29.250 --> 00:22:33.170
And so
that's one chamber of this two chamber system.
00:22:33.330 --> 00:22:58.210
And so when someone would be confronted with a problem or some sort of novel experience, the gods we we could say uh would organize information on in the right hemisphere and then send commandments or uh messages, instructions to The left hemisphere, where people would follow the gods' instructions.
00:22:58.370 --> 00:23:03.810
Um, people rarely argued with the gods, they would just do what the gods or ancestors told them what to do.
00:23:03.890 --> 00:23:05.330
So that's what bicameral means.
00:23:05.410 --> 00:23:08.690
The right hemisphere communicating with the left hemisphere.
00:23:08.770 --> 00:23:24.450
And we in James pointed out, and I'm not a neurologist, so I have to be careful what I say, but James pointed out that it is a little bit odd that in modern humans, most of us, there's some variation, but most of us, the linguistic areas of the right hemisphere are dormant.
00:23:24.690 --> 00:23:27.890
So there's this idea that they used to do something differently.
00:23:27.970 --> 00:23:34.050
And it was culture, or it is culture that determines how these two hemispheres relate.
00:23:34.210 --> 00:23:42.530
So I think an important point to make about uh bicameral mind is uh that means two things.
00:23:43.090 --> 00:23:46.610
One is bicameral neurology.
00:23:46.770 --> 00:23:53.170
And when James in his book talked about bicameral neurology, he wasn't talking about the roots of consciousness.
00:23:53.250 --> 00:23:55.490
He was talking about hallucinations.
00:23:56.130 --> 00:23:58.450
What is their neurology behind hallucinations?
00:23:58.530 --> 00:24:00.530
And there's there's some evidence for that.
00:24:00.770 --> 00:24:16.930
Um but neurology is such a complicated field that I think there's still a lot more work to do to ground Jane's claims about um bicameral neurology.
00:24:17.730 --> 00:24:34.690
I feel like I've got a bicameral mind even now though, in some ways, um in that I've got this one, you know, this one part of my brain, which is the sort of thinking, logic, like the the brain that sort of speaks to me inside my head, my inner voice.
00:24:34.770 --> 00:24:47.330
And then I've got this, you know, what people often call the monkey brain, which just acts and does as it pleases based on instinct and and other features of human evolutionary biology, I suppose.
00:24:47.650 --> 00:24:49.410
So I d I don't know.
00:24:49.490 --> 00:24:52.690
It feels like there are still two chambers to my to my mind.
00:24:53.010 --> 00:24:54.930
Oh, there yeah, oh, there definitely are.
00:24:55.090 --> 00:25:03.730
And and an important point I wanted to make is that um the voices have not gone away, they've just been suppressed by this layering of culture.
00:25:03.890 --> 00:25:11.090
So the default mode of human psychic architecture is by caring, it's to hear voices.
00:25:11.650 --> 00:25:18.930
And that's why some people still do hear voices, especially when the mind is under a lot of stress, those vestiges are going to emerge.
00:25:19.250 --> 00:25:22.370
So um yeah, they it's it's still there.
00:25:22.450 --> 00:25:30.690
I mean, in terms of evolution, five, ten thousand years is just the blink of an eye, it doesn't really mean anything.
00:25:30.850 --> 00:25:40.370
And so that's why it's important to, as I said, make a distinction between when we talk about the bicaramel mind, their neurology versus bicaramel psychology.
00:25:40.610 --> 00:25:49.810
Now, with bicaramel psychology, I mean religion, experiencing divisions in the voices, belief in gods.
00:25:50.050 --> 00:25:53.970
Bicaramel psychology is very easy to demonstrate.
00:25:54.130 --> 00:25:56.610
There's needless to say, there's a tremendous amount.
00:25:56.770 --> 00:26:09.410
And you know, the other important point related to this to make is that it's a fascinating scientific fact that we have yet to find a civilization that was not religious.
00:26:09.570 --> 00:26:27.730
Um, I mean, now many civilizations or societies, of course, you could say uh officially communist or atheists, what have you, but when you go back in time before about a thousand BCE, you cannot find a civilization um that lacked religion, that lacked belief in gods.
00:26:27.810 --> 00:26:35.090
And to me, that's a very important piece of evidence that uh supports um Jane's theories.
00:26:35.570 --> 00:26:37.570
So um I was sort of wondering.
00:26:37.730 --> 00:26:49.410
Um we talk about the bicameral mind and the sort of hallucinatory hearing voices and how this can happen to people under stress or people with say schizophrenia.
00:26:49.650 --> 00:27:09.490
Um I was wondering if the things that we learn or theorize um about our ancestors and how the brain sort sort of naturally worked before consciousness tells us much about some of the more modern mental health things that we experience now that we have kind of modern consciousness.
00:27:09.970 --> 00:27:10.210
Sure.
00:27:10.290 --> 00:27:26.770
Well, I mean, for one thing, um for people who have hallucinations, and I don't necessarily mean people who have a full-blown diagnosis of schizophrenia, but there's actually a lot of people, as I said before, who hear voices.
00:27:26.850 --> 00:27:30.290
Their voices are not necessarily very distressing, but they don't like them.
00:27:30.530 --> 00:27:41.650
And there's actually organizations that uh these people belong to, and that they they try to teach these people that actually this is just a vestige of an early mentality of hallucinations.
00:27:41.810 --> 00:27:50.850
So that that that can be very reassuring to somebody who hears voices now and then, um, that it it's part of being a um uh a person in a way.
00:27:50.930 --> 00:27:54.130
And so rather than resisting to voices, try to integrate those voices.
00:27:54.210 --> 00:27:57.170
So so there's actually therapeutic techniques that are used.
00:27:57.330 --> 00:28:01.490
So that's
one important practical application, I think, of James in psychology.
00:28:01.730 --> 00:28:14.050
And besides that, um consciousness itself, though it um was a cultural adaptation, too much consciousness can cause problems for people.
00:28:14.290 --> 00:28:27.490
And what I mean by that, um I'm a psychotherapist and I I see this with people, where because consciousness gives us this, if you will, extra mental space in our head, there's more things to worry about.
00:28:28.210 --> 00:28:35.090
So a minor worry becomes becomes anxiety.
00:28:35.490 --> 00:28:41.570
Um a little apprehension becomes fear, and it's because consciousness is working over time.
00:28:41.650 --> 00:28:58.770
I mean, that's kind of a simplistic way to put it, but the I guess the point I'm trying to make is there's actually a lot of practical uh research, um, there's a lot of practical applications that can be um grounded in Jaynesian uh psychology.
00:28:59.330 --> 00:29:02.610
I just want to roll back a little bit on this idea of the inner voice.
00:29:02.850 --> 00:29:11.730
So um I've got a bit of an interesting anecdote, I think, which may illustrate your point or or may be completely contrary to it, so you can correct me if I'm wrong.
00:29:11.890 --> 00:29:34.770
But I'm just wondering if the sort of ancient ancestors were hearing the inner voice that we typically hear when we're monologuing to ourselves or having a debate in our own heads or whatever, or reading a book perhaps, um, but mistaking it for a god, or whether it was different entirely, and you know, the hallucination that they were were hearing was nothing to do with an inner voice at all.
00:29:35.010 --> 00:29:44.130
Because my anecdote is I recently asked my daughter if she speaks to herself in her head, and she was like, No, I don't.
00:29:44.290 --> 00:29:47.010
And she thought it was such a weird question for me to ask.
00:29:47.250 --> 00:29:55.650
And she also used to say, uh, she doesn't say it so much anymore, but that her she she used to say, My books talk to me at night.
00:29:55.970 --> 00:29:58.690
And the same goes for her toy, which she calls Rag.
00:29:59.010 --> 00:30:04.210
Um, it's this comforter uh that Matt bought her actually when she was born, funnily enough.
00:30:04.290 --> 00:30:07.410
And um, she'd said, Oh, Rag always tells me to do things.
00:30:07.570 --> 00:30:14.370
Um, and and I thought this is so strange, but you know, she's a child and maybe that's just normal.
00:30:14.610 --> 00:30:25.810
But the fact that her books may talk to her at night uh or her toy might tell her to do things, is this an example of what consciousness could have been like for our ancestors?
00:30:25.970 --> 00:30:35.090
With the key difference here being that her consciousness is now being actively shaped and socialized, so she'll probably lose those abilities, as it were.
00:30:35.890 --> 00:30:36.210
Right.
00:30:36.450 --> 00:30:56.050
So, of course, um I never met your daughter, so I don't
know, but there is this idea of imaginary playmates, and you know uh just because a child claims that a toy is talking to them or uh or a book is talking to them doesn't necessarily mean that that's the case.
00:30:56.210 --> 00:30:58.210
However, I think sometimes it is.
00:30:58.370 --> 00:31:02.530
I think I think this phenomenon called imaginary playmates is real.
00:31:02.690 --> 00:31:05.010
There's actually been a lot of research on it.
00:31:05.170 --> 00:31:09.250
It's something that a lot of psychologists shy away from because it sounds so bizarre.
00:31:09.410 --> 00:31:15.410
But I think that imaginary playmates is something that most people grow out of.
00:31:15.650 --> 00:31:20.050
It is a vestige of an earlier uh psychic architecture, I think.
00:31:20.290 --> 00:31:38.850
As I said before, hearing voices is the default mode of the human mind, but culture, specifically consciousness and the language associated with consciousness, suppresses those voices and we're discouraged from hearing those voices.
00:31:39.010 --> 00:31:49.410
Um, in fact, uh in the Bible, in the Old Testament, um, there's an instance where parents were told to kill their children who were hearing voices and communicating with Yahweh.
00:31:49.570 --> 00:31:50.850
That's an extreme example.
00:31:51.090 --> 00:31:54.370
Uh the fortunate we don't do that today, hopefully.
00:31:54.530 --> 00:32:03.330
But um in any case, yeah, it sounds to me that that that could be evidence of uh uh of an earlier mentality.
00:32:03.410 --> 00:32:05.810
But like I said, it's something that we grow out of.
00:32:05.890 --> 00:32:07.970
And many people don't remember these things.
00:32:08.130 --> 00:32:19.330
You know, I'm sure there are parents who would claim, oh, don't you remember you had an imaginary playmate and the person, you know, they're in their early 20s say, I don't know what you're talking about, because we just don't, we're not encouraged to have those types of memories.
00:32:19.890 --> 00:32:26.930
But it but it's not that she's mistaking her inner monologue or her her inner voice for the voice of something else.
00:32:27.170 --> 00:32:31.650
In the case of our ancestors, there really was something separate happening.
00:32:32.210 --> 00:32:44.210
Well, I think there was because at that time, during the pre-conscious period, society encouraged people to accept and listen to those voices.
00:32:44.290 --> 00:32:47.730
And that goes a long way into how people interpret something.
00:32:47.970 --> 00:32:55.010
I think it's uh pretty clear that uh hallucinations played a very important role in organizing societies.
00:32:55.090 --> 00:33:00.450
And you know, when you think about it, um it's really not that unusual.
00:33:00.610 --> 00:33:03.010
Um you think of Joan of Arc.
00:33:03.730 --> 00:33:13.730
So she heard voices, and until they um executed her, um they people believe that they went along with that.
00:33:14.130 --> 00:33:15.730
That was not that long ago.
00:33:15.890 --> 00:33:18.610
That was only six, seven centuries ago.
00:33:18.850 --> 00:33:26.450
Uh it's the same thing uh in with um many other people, uh Joseph Smith, Mormon and Mormonism.
00:33:26.530 --> 00:33:28.850
And I I don't want to question people's beliefs, you know.
00:33:29.090 --> 00:33:35.170
I'm I'm not anti-religious, but clearly you could make the argument that uh Joseph Smith was hearing voices.
00:33:35.330 --> 00:33:39.810
And in fact, that occurred not very far from where I live, um upstate New York.
00:33:40.050 --> 00:33:41.730
Um, and that was not that long ago.
00:33:41.810 --> 00:33:44.130
We're talking, I think, the 1830s, 1840s.
00:33:44.450 --> 00:33:47.490
So these things are still with us, they're not that unusual at all.
00:33:47.810 --> 00:33:51.730
Yeah, and Moses, uh you know, talking to the burning bush.
00:33:51.810 --> 00:33:59.090
Um, and it is it's always been a fascination for me that God seems to be very active.
00:33:59.330 --> 00:34:03.810
And in the old testament, he seems to be doing a lot, commanding a lot.
00:34:03.970 --> 00:34:06.930
In the New Testament, he seems to have taken a back seat.
00:34:07.090 --> 00:34:13.570
And by now, but you know, by the by the time we reach the 20th and 21st centuries, he's sort of like given up.
00:34:13.730 --> 00:34:15.730
He's like, I'm taking a back seat.
00:34:15.809 --> 00:34:22.690
He used to be um cruel and he used to you know demand attention and worship, and now he doesn't seem to bother so much.
00:34:22.769 --> 00:34:25.250
So there is that's a really interesting tie-in.
00:34:25.730 --> 00:34:26.369
Yeah, you're right.
00:34:26.449 --> 00:34:39.489
There's that's why I think we have uh uh Old Testament and a New Testament, because the New Testament represents writings that uh could accommodate this new conscious mentality.
00:34:39.650 --> 00:34:49.090
Um, of course, people did not write it that way, they didn't think it alone think of this change in those psychological terms, but definitely that's what was going on.
00:34:49.329 --> 00:34:55.570
So in the New Testament, you have angels, you have um more intermediaries.
00:34:55.650 --> 00:35:15.170
Well, Jesus himself, uh, you could make the argument, was sort of a desperate attempt to bring Yahweh into this world, uh incarnate, um because before then uh people were not uh uh they weren't as desperate uh to talk to God.
00:35:15.329 --> 00:35:20.050
The idea is that, well, if you're uh if you're patient enough, Yahweh will talk to you.
00:35:20.130 --> 00:35:47.410
And you know, I I think it is since we're talking about um the Judeo-Christian tradition, you know, besides Moses, um, of course, there are other people in the Bib in the Old Testament who um talk to God, but there are also prophets where you know, I some people would call it a type of spirit possession, possessed by God, where Yahweh spoke to these people, and that's more evidence for a vestige of of an earlier uh mentality.
00:35:47.809 --> 00:35:57.890
I'm wondering sort of if we come closer to present day, um, you know, with we've spoken about language and community and ritual and thing and metaphor.
00:35:58.289 --> 00:36:08.210
The technological sort of growth that we have in present day, uh, the way that we communicate, the way that we live in kind of silos, more isolated a lot of the time.
00:36:08.369 --> 00:36:22.210
Do you think that uh, and not to mention obviously the technology that we have, do you think that the information and everything else that has changed quite rapidly maybe having effects on our consciousness or may have effects going forward?
00:36:22.690 --> 00:36:23.650
Most definitely.
00:36:23.809 --> 00:36:30.930
Um, I mean, I think it's clear that well, technology always impacts and shapes somehow human psychology, and we see that now.
00:36:31.490 --> 00:36:33.970
Um, it's just more sped up, you might say.
00:36:34.210 --> 00:36:52.930
Um, so we talk about human psychology and technology, but we also want to be more specific and talk about Jain Zian consciousness and technology and how, as a type of cognition, Janesian consciousness, how is Janesian consciousness being shaped by social media, shaped by AI?
00:36:53.170 --> 00:36:56.369
And I'll be honest with you, I'm not really I've thought about it.
00:36:56.450 --> 00:37:00.769
I I don't really have any definite answers, uh just some speculation.
00:37:00.930 --> 00:37:16.530
Um don't ask me why I think this, but I suspect because we use screens a lot, there's a certain type of visuality that has taken over the world, you might say, um, beginning with TV in the 1940s and 50s.
00:37:16.690 --> 00:37:18.130
Now screens are everywhere.
00:37:18.289 --> 00:37:40.930
I don't I I I can't make a clear argument, but I just have an intuition that that all those screens, all this visuality is somehow eventually it's going to teach us to be to engage more with mental imagery, that our images are going to become more clear.
00:37:41.010 --> 00:37:46.610
Our mental eye will um will see things, will see more things.
00:37:46.769 --> 00:37:49.090
Um and of course, everyone's a little bit different.
00:37:49.250 --> 00:37:52.849
Some people have very strong mental imagery, some it's weaker.
00:37:54.050 --> 00:37:56.930
There's a small population that does not have any mental imagery.
00:37:57.010 --> 00:38:02.130
But in any case, just for the sake of argument, um, most of us do have mental images.
00:38:02.289 --> 00:38:07.090
And I think somehow technology is going to make those images clearer.
00:38:07.250 --> 00:38:11.170
And that may enhance some of our abilities.
00:38:11.410 --> 00:38:18.610
We may be able to, we won't, we won't need virtual uh a device to um augment uh the environment.
00:38:18.849 --> 00:38:20.289
We won't need virtual reality.
00:38:20.369 --> 00:38:26.610
We'll we'll have a built-in virtual reality in our head where we can see things more clearly and store things.
00:38:26.849 --> 00:38:30.450
Specifically, what what will that ability do for us?
00:38:30.530 --> 00:38:38.849
I'm I'm not sure, but I think it would be uh quite interesting to come back 100, 200 years from now if we could do that and see how things have changed.
00:38:39.010 --> 00:38:40.530
So that's just that's just one example.
00:38:40.690 --> 00:38:58.849
I think another example is with um social media, I think the way to look at it is throughout our existence as a species, Homo sapiens, technology externalizes uh our nature.
00:38:59.809 --> 00:39:04.690
We're allowed to store information outside our bodies, outside our minds.
00:39:04.849 --> 00:39:09.410
Um devices increase the power of our senses.
00:39:09.570 --> 00:39:12.610
So there's this, as I said, externalization.
00:39:12.769 --> 00:39:22.450
But anytime the you have externalization, there has to be a reaction inside the actual psyche, inside our mental architecture.
00:39:22.690 --> 00:39:25.010
And there's more and more internalization.
00:39:25.170 --> 00:39:36.130
And in fact, I think that's what consciousness is that the more we externalized, the more we had to connect with people, the more we extended our bodies, our minds had a shift.
00:39:36.690 --> 00:39:46.450
And again, I know this is kind of an abstract argument, and I don't have a lot of uh clear-cut concrete examples, but I think that's what's happening now with social media.
00:39:46.610 --> 00:39:52.289
I mean, you you I'm sure you've met people on Facebook, they have 3,000 friends or something like that.
00:39:52.450 --> 00:40:01.650
So, you know, there there's this increased externalization, and I think that somehow is going to cause changes within us.
00:40:01.809 --> 00:40:02.930
I think we see it already.
00:40:03.010 --> 00:40:04.769
I think people are more private.
00:40:05.090 --> 00:40:13.809
Since I was young, um, I there there's been a uh an increase in um the in privatism where people just want to cocoon themselves.
00:40:13.890 --> 00:40:21.650
And I think that's a reaction to what technology has done to us, how technology has kind of stretched us out with all these connections.
00:40:21.809 --> 00:40:33.010
Um so in any case, uh it's a little it's a little bit speculative at this point, but I definitely think that technology does uh shape not just psychology but our actual uh consciousness.
00:40:33.570 --> 00:40:45.490
So is that to say that ancient people weren't self-reflective, often referring to themselves as I or me or in an individual sense then?
00:40:45.650 --> 00:40:49.250
And and that's one of the major shifts that we've seen with consciousness.
00:40:49.730 --> 00:40:50.450
I think so.
00:40:50.610 --> 00:41:00.050
I I I think before about a thousand BCE, it's very difficult to find an in-depth self-reflection in the text.
00:41:00.289 --> 00:41:08.769
Um, people in their languages, of course, they had words, pronouns for I, me, but the I would just be a person's body.
00:41:09.090 --> 00:41:16.130
There was no sense that there's uh a mental space floating inside their head somewhere.
00:41:16.369 --> 00:41:26.930
Um and uh people were just not as concerned with what we would call deep philosophical questions uh during the uh preconscious period.
00:41:27.090 --> 00:41:42.369
That's something that would come later, and that's why from about maybe the seventh, eighth century BCE, there's an explosion of philosophy in Greece, um in China, in India.
00:41:42.690 --> 00:41:58.450
Um in the Judaic tradition, you have all these prophets, and then a little bit later you have almost a more philosophical type of Judaism developing, and that is because people were be had become much more what we would call self-reflective.
00:41:58.849 --> 00:42:04.450
That's so interesting because I want to do a whole episode what we did before uh before philosophy.
00:42:04.610 --> 00:42:21.809
Uh but it kind of sounds like bliss to me to not be musing philosophically on life all the time, and sometimes I wear myself out wondering about what the meaning of life is or what what the meaning of life is for me, or on a wider and a grander scale.
00:42:22.050 --> 00:42:29.010
It does feel like um not necessarily the best thing that we've latched on to consciousness.
00:42:29.329 --> 00:42:30.930
Maybe it was easier before.
00:42:32.530 --> 00:42:36.289
Maybe it's a bit provocative to say consciousness isn't good.
00:42:37.170 --> 00:42:38.369
Yeah, I I think you're right.
00:42:38.610 --> 00:42:49.410
I mean, I think just more of a as a footnote to what you just said, uh, to me, what a a very important point is that there was no philosophy or philosophers before 1000 BCE.
00:42:49.730 --> 00:42:51.250
There was certainly religion.
00:42:51.570 --> 00:42:57.490
People did question the gods sometimes and argue with them, but there's no in-depth philosophical mindset.
00:42:57.730 --> 00:42:59.730
That would not happen until much later.
00:42:59.970 --> 00:43:01.170
There's just no need to.
00:43:01.250 --> 00:43:14.930
And yes, consciousness, um, it's both a gift and a burden for Homo sapiens because uh the gods have stopped talking to us, but now we're godlike, especially with our technology.
00:43:15.170 --> 00:43:28.289
We have tremendous responsibility, but it leads to consciousness can easily lead to um a lot of self-rumination, uh, too much re self-re-reflexivity, you might say.
00:43:28.450 --> 00:43:31.010
Uh but the universe does not answer back.
00:43:31.170 --> 00:43:32.849
The universe is very quiet.
00:43:33.010 --> 00:43:39.010
It's very disturbing to be a deep thinker, because the gods are not giving us any direction.
00:43:39.410 --> 00:43:48.849
So it consciousness introduced this real existentialist ache um uh into the human condition that I think we're still grappling with.
00:43:49.650 --> 00:44:03.090
Yeah, uh I think um there's kind of a few schools of thought that there's a almost a meaning crisis going on in the world, or at least
that humans have this deep innate desire for meaning in life.
00:44:03.250 --> 00:44:17.730
Um and I wondered if this is kind of a side effect of consciousness, or whether meaning was just easier with a by bicameral mind where it was just the meaning was that you were following the commands of the gods.
00:44:18.050 --> 00:44:18.210
Right.
00:44:18.289 --> 00:44:19.730
Yeah, I think that's a good way to put it.
00:44:19.809 --> 00:44:24.849
I think meaning w w was, uh as you said, just doing what you were told.
00:44:25.090 --> 00:44:31.090
Not just by the gods necessarily, or the ancestors, but by your parents, by your elders.
00:44:31.329 --> 00:44:38.369
But uh, you know, pe people were more likely to follow traditions, but consciousness really upends everything.
00:44:39.010 --> 00:45:13.890
In the Middle Ages, there was this this idea that your you could your soul could be alienated from God, and then by the nineteenth century, you had um Um, people like Kierkegaard, uh Nietzsche, who sort of introduced this very disturbing notion that um, well, in case in the case of Nietzsche, God is dead with Kierkegaard, uh, the idea that um you, there may god, there may be a god, there may not be a god, but you are an individual and you have to live in your own head and you have to be responsible for your own actions.
00:45:13.970 --> 00:45:14.769
You have agency.
00:45:14.849 --> 00:45:32.849
You cannot, like in the Middle Ages, you know, they would still maybe rely on the gods and the saints for things, but by the time you get into the 19th century, after the Enlightenment, when science started to really have a big impact, um, it was more difficult to argue that supernatural entities existed.
00:45:33.010 --> 00:45:36.849
And so there's this tremendous focus on the individual.
00:45:37.090 --> 00:45:44.769
And I think I, you know, with some of my clients, uh I sometimes I notice they want to talk about these things.
00:45:45.010 --> 00:45:47.170
They they want to talk about the meaning of life.
00:45:47.329 --> 00:45:49.809
They're maybe they're they're facing the end of their lives.
00:45:49.890 --> 00:45:52.050
Um, they want to know if it had meaning.
00:45:52.210 --> 00:45:54.369
And uh that's it's a very scary thing.
00:45:54.450 --> 00:46:02.450
And I think in our society, because in many senses we are so self-aware, we're actually afraid of that awareness.
00:46:02.610 --> 00:46:04.210
It's very, very disturbing.
00:46:04.610 --> 00:46:32.930
Well, I want to touch on um language and writing because um first of all, I want to know if if you feel that we created words in our heads and then and then needed a sort of an outlet to externalize them, uh, either through voices or through writing, or whether like we developed written language and vocal language before then we were able to internalize it as inner thought.
00:46:33.170 --> 00:46:48.210
And also, if all of this is part of the puzzle, like writing is part of the puzzle of consciousness shifting, why did the bicameral mind take so long to come about after writing had been invented?
00:46:48.369 --> 00:46:52.530
Because there were thousands and thousands of years of writing being in existence.
00:46:52.849 --> 00:47:06.849
So to try and answer your first question, um, the way I look at it, language is the consequence of changes in the environment, changes in social relations.
00:47:07.250 --> 00:47:08.930
Languages change and evolve.
00:47:09.010 --> 00:47:12.530
In fact, they can change quite rapidly if need be.
00:47:12.769 --> 00:47:19.250
And so I I view languages um more as a representation of something.
00:47:19.570 --> 00:47:27.090
Uh now, with that said, that does not mean that language um that words lack any impact.
00:47:27.410 --> 00:47:45.090
And this is where it gets a little bit uh a little bit challenging because some people accuse Janes of being a linguistic determinist, that you had these words develop, these metaphors, uh, these mental words, and that changed how people that that changed their experience.
00:47:45.170 --> 00:47:46.450
But it's a little more complicated than that.
00:47:46.530 --> 00:47:50.530
It's really a chicken or egg problem, you know, which came first.
00:47:50.930 --> 00:47:56.849
Um, but in any case, I I don't think James was a linguistic determinist.
00:47:57.250 --> 00:48:05.809
And what why I'm mentioning that is because I don't think just because a person hears a word, it's gonna change their cognition.
00:48:06.050 --> 00:48:15.010
So, for example, if someone came to me and tried to convince me that when I go to bed tonight, there are gonna be, I don't know, night demons in my room.
00:48:15.090 --> 00:48:19.010
And I never heard the word demon before, but they say tonight demons are coming in your room.
00:48:19.170 --> 00:48:21.490
That doesn't mean I'm gonna believe it necessarily.
00:48:21.730 --> 00:48:33.090
So words themselves do not have power, rather, a whole collection of words and socializing experiences give power and meaning to words.
00:48:33.329 --> 00:48:43.809
So, in any case, that I just want to point that out because this the the relationship between language and social relations, language and reality um is uh quite quite contested.
00:48:44.050 --> 00:48:52.769
Um but um the other to answer your question about um the relationship between writing and consciousness.
00:48:52.930 --> 00:48:58.050
So hallucinatory mentality broke down for a variety of reasons.
00:48:58.369 --> 00:49:00.610
Writing, I think, was one of them.
00:49:00.769 --> 00:49:03.809
I personally don't think it was uh a key reason.
00:49:04.130 --> 00:49:09.410
I think that hallucinations broke down because they just were not efficient anymore.
00:49:09.570 --> 00:49:15.650
They just the lines of communication got stretched between the rulers and the masses.
00:49:15.890 --> 00:49:19.010
Territories that had to be governed just got too big.
00:49:19.329 --> 00:49:25.010
People were performing more
specialized roles as the economies changed.
00:49:25.090 --> 00:49:28.210
Um, people had to deal with strangers.
00:49:28.450 --> 00:49:33.329
As societies grew, population, they uh would bump up against each other.
00:49:33.490 --> 00:49:46.210
And though everybody believed in gods, they perhaps maybe they they weren't uh so uh enthusiastic about the customs of other people, and so they had to explain why are people different?
00:49:46.530 --> 00:49:50.690
And perhaps they would say, well, it must be something inside them.
00:49:51.010 --> 00:50:06.610
So all these different reasons um I think led to two things the collapse of hallucinatory mentality and the emergence of a new, more adaptive mentality, which was Jamesian consciousness.
00:50:07.170 --> 00:50:19.570
Okay, so consciousness isn't really just a side effect or that it popped up, it's actually almost like a social uh evil evolution of the way our minds worked.
00:50:19.650 --> 00:50:25.730
It it was just a requirement for us to continue developing in the kind of environments that we had.
00:50:25.890 --> 00:50:27.650
Is that sort of fair to say?
00:50:28.130 --> 00:50:29.329
Yes, yes, it is.
00:50:29.410 --> 00:50:37.010
It it it's an adaptive I I would call consciousness an adaptive technology, or I would call consciousness an adaptive set of ideas.
00:50:37.170 --> 00:50:46.849
And the reason why I'm putting it that way is to highlight how consciousness is something cultural, it's something learned, it's something that people had to develop over centuries.
00:50:47.010 --> 00:50:56.530
Um, it's not uh innate ability, it's not something that evolution uh gave us, it's something that people had to uh develop.
00:50:57.090 --> 00:51:26.610
Sort of on this note, could this kind of explain why um or or be part of the reason why, for much of human history, it feels like Homo sapiens made quite small gains technologically over a long period of time, and then kind of in the last 300 years or so the technological kind of advancement has gone up, and so has our sort of self-reflection and our way of kind of being able to communicate by text and things like that.
00:51:26.690 --> 00:51:30.050
Uh, is consciousness kind of linked in with this, do you think?
00:51:30.530 --> 00:51:31.650
I think it is.
00:51:31.970 --> 00:51:37.010
Um, how it is linked in, to be honest with you, I'm not entirely sure.
00:51:37.170 --> 00:51:41.490
I think it's very difficult to find direct connections, but I I I think it is.
00:51:41.650 --> 00:51:46.690
I mean, certainly uh human psychology is related to all these changes.
00:51:46.849 --> 00:52:03.170
And you know, I think also it's important to keep in mind that the idea that Homo sapiens should, or Homo sapiens has been evolving in terms of technology is kind of a modern assumption because we assume that technology is good.
00:52:03.410 --> 00:52:09.809
But the idea of technological progress or social progress, social improvement, really is a it's a new idea.
00:52:09.890 --> 00:52:11.890
It's only maybe a couple hundred years old.
00:52:12.050 --> 00:52:19.730
You know, before then the idea is that time goes in cycles, or there's no need to um radically change society.
00:52:19.970 --> 00:52:22.450
In fact, that that was considered very dangerous.
00:52:22.769 --> 00:52:35.730
But in any case, I think the challenge with understanding why there have been spurts of technological innovation is because those spurts, those changes occur because there's so many variables.
00:52:35.970 --> 00:52:44.450
I think there have to be new sources of energy, whether it's coal or electricity, for example, or domesticating animals could be anything.
00:52:44.690 --> 00:52:48.289
Um there has to be an acceptance among the population that they want change.
00:52:48.450 --> 00:52:53.010
Again, we assume people want change, but that's not always the case.
00:52:53.170 --> 00:53:02.769
Uh of course, uh, there has to be a knowledge base, a type of science that allows for changes in technology to figure out how to improve technology.
00:53:03.010 --> 00:53:09.809
So there has to be a politics uh behind it where the leadership says that technological change is good.
00:53:09.970 --> 00:53:27.809
Um, so for example, if you look at in the ancient Roman world, they're very sophisticated people, but from what I heard, the leaders did not want certain technological innovations because they were afraid it was going to put people out of work and they didn't want the masses wandering around looking for trouble.
00:53:27.970 --> 00:53:29.730
So that's just one example.
00:53:29.970 --> 00:53:35.090
But in any case, uh I think the point is there are so many reasons why technology changes.
00:53:35.170 --> 00:53:40.930
I think in the modern world, sometime around 1500, there was a major shift.
00:53:41.090 --> 00:53:42.130
It certainly looks that way.
00:53:42.369 --> 00:53:45.970
If you look at the Atlantic powers, certain things came together.
00:53:46.210 --> 00:53:52.849
Um from the Renaissance, there was an awakening of agent, self-agency, you might say.
00:53:53.010 --> 00:53:55.329
Uh, then the Enlightenment.
00:53:55.570 --> 00:54:01.890
Um and then, of course, uh really an explosion of science and technology in the 1800s.
00:54:02.050 --> 00:54:07.250
So, you know, actually, that's not a long time, three, four, five centuries ago.
00:54:07.490 --> 00:54:16.050
But in any case, uh, yeah, that that's that's kind of a big question, the relationship between uh technology and uh psychology.
00:54:16.130 --> 00:54:39.490
I do think to zero in on the relationship between techno technological innovation and jainzian consciousness, again, the the connection is difficult to prove, but I do think that Janezian consciousness, one of the things it does, it allows us to think in hypotheticals, to come up with hypotheses easier.
00:54:39.650 --> 00:54:43.970
It allows a certain imagination because it gives us a kind of mental space.
00:54:44.210 --> 00:54:53.570
We're able to ask more questions that perhaps pre-conscious people, maybe they could have asked the same questions, but it would have taken them a lot longer.
00:54:53.809 --> 00:54:56.289
And I think that's what technological change is all about.
00:54:56.450 --> 00:54:57.890
It's things just speed up.
00:54:57.970 --> 00:55:02.530
And I think Jaynesian consciousness does allow things to speed up.
00:55:02.930 --> 00:55:07.170
It's interesting that you mentioned the Renaissance and the Enlightenment.
00:55:07.490 --> 00:55:13.170
Could those two things be associated with consciousness then?
00:55:13.570 --> 00:55:14.369
I think so.
00:55:14.530 --> 00:55:15.490
Uh I do think so.
00:55:15.730 --> 00:55:24.610
Again, it's um there's the same problem of how do you show that uh in terms of um of uh of an argument.
00:55:24.769 --> 00:55:26.210
You know, what's the evidence for that?
00:55:26.289 --> 00:55:27.730
I think it's the same thing with technology.
00:55:27.890 --> 00:55:34.130
How do you make that linkage between technological improvement and changing consciousness?
00:55:34.289 --> 00:55:36.530
But I do think it's the same rules.
00:55:36.930 --> 00:55:48.530
What I mean is with the Renaissance and the Enlightenment, the Enlightenment rather, there was sort of a liberation, you might say, the human spirit, that the individual was given power.
00:55:48.769 --> 00:55:58.369
And I think I don't think that um individualism or individuality is uh is an inherently Western invention.
00:55:58.610 --> 00:56:01.090
I think it just looks that way, things worked out that way.
00:56:01.250 --> 00:56:16.289
But I think one of the features of changing consciousness is what I call self-individuation, where the individual is asked to look within themselves and find strengths to find out what's different.
00:56:16.369 --> 00:56:18.849
How am I different from the collectivity, from the group?
00:56:19.010 --> 00:56:22.530
How can I do things that no one else has done before?
00:56:22.769 --> 00:56:25.890
And so that's a key feature of Jaynesian consciousness.
00:56:25.970 --> 00:56:42.930
And that's what you find in the Renaissance, that's what you find in the Enlightenment, where individual thinkers were celebrated, where people were more um, I don't want to mischaracterize two or three centuries of history, but people were just more open-minded, at least certain elites were more open-minded.
00:56:43.090 --> 00:56:48.050
And I think this has to do with uh there's a powerful sense of uh self-agency.
00:56:48.530 --> 00:56:52.690
We can forgive you for paraphrasing hundreds of years of history, don't worry.
00:56:53.730 --> 00:56:57.730
What does this tell us about animal consciousness then?
00:56:57.809 --> 00:57:11.090
Because we're often talking about animals being conscious, we're show you we're demonstrating that they can pass things like the mirror test, so they're they're understanding that in the mirror is is them, and
it's a reflection of themselves.
00:57:11.250 --> 00:57:19.490
So we're starting to figure out at least um from a certain version of how we describe consciousness that animals do have consciousness.
00:57:19.650 --> 00:57:25.329
Are we saying that they don't have consciousness in the same sense as we do?
00:57:25.490 --> 00:57:27.170
Or yeah, how does that work?
00:57:27.490 --> 00:57:28.690
Yeah, I I would say that.
00:57:28.849 --> 00:57:34.210
I mean, to be precise, I would say that they don't have Janesian consciousness.
00:57:34.369 --> 00:57:40.690
Um, animals certainly have um very powerful cognitive abilities.
00:57:40.849 --> 00:57:42.130
I mean, if anyone has a pet.
00:57:42.210 --> 00:57:45.490
And I notice I've been asked this question before, and people get upset.
00:57:45.650 --> 00:57:47.010
What do you mean my dog is conscious?
00:57:47.090 --> 00:57:49.490
My cat, I know my cat communicates with me.
00:57:49.650 --> 00:57:53.090
Well, of course, there's cognition there.
00:57:53.490 --> 00:57:56.610
Dogs do relate to us emotionally, actually.
00:57:56.769 --> 00:58:08.610
And you know, I remember being um uh with James in his office talking about this, and he said that squirrels, if you look at if you study the neurology of a squirrel, it's very sophisticated.
00:58:08.769 --> 00:58:09.650
And he had done that.
00:58:09.809 --> 00:58:13.809
You know, remember Jane started out as a comparative psychologist.
00:58:14.050 --> 00:58:21.890
That is a specialty where they compare the neurology and the mentality, the behavior of animals and people.
00:58:22.050 --> 00:58:35.329
And what happened is he realized that his interest in consciousness would not go anywhere if he just stayed at that comparative neurological level, that he had to introduce culture into the uh equation.
00:58:35.570 --> 00:58:43.010
But yeah, so people, you know, they go back to some of the examples you used about um apes looking in mirrors and scratching themselves, you know.
00:58:43.090 --> 00:58:48.369
Yeah, there's something going on there, but it's certainly not um Janezian consciousness.
00:58:48.530 --> 00:58:54.610
And and animals, um we're beginning to find out now, actually, they're a lot smarter than we think.
00:58:54.769 --> 00:58:59.329
I mean, we you hear this all the time: the mind of animals as if we just discovered this.
00:58:59.490 --> 00:59:07.970
But uh actually, researchers for quite a while, going back to late 19th century, knew that animals um were quite sophisticated.
00:59:08.050 --> 00:59:16.050
It's just that their neurology, their mentality, whatever you want to call it, is completely different from ours.
00:59:16.690 --> 00:59:23.570
So we have language, we have maybe you know the ability to build things and create culture.
00:59:23.650 --> 00:59:32.610
And do you think then that this is the missing thing, or is it also something kind of physically with our brains as well that allows us to have this Jainzian consciousness?
00:59:33.170 --> 00:59:34.369
That's a good question.
00:59:34.530 --> 00:59:44.930
Um, I I I do think that the reason why animals cannot have Jainsian consciousness is because their neurology is different.
00:59:45.090 --> 00:59:50.130
Um, and humans do have a very well-developed, a very large neocortex.
00:59:50.289 --> 00:59:57.730
And that neocortex allows us to do things that no animal can do, even primates.
00:59:57.970 --> 00:59:59.329
And that is the difference.
00:59:59.490 --> 01:00:11.090
And I know some people, people who love animals, I love animals, I grew up with dogs, you know, some people get very upset and offended by this idea that oh, you're you're you're being uh anthropocentric or something.
01:00:11.170 --> 01:00:15.570
I'm looking down, disrespecting animals, but no, I'm just looking at the science.
01:00:15.809 --> 01:00:26.289
Um and um yeah, so just to reiterate that, because I think it is an important question, it's an important point, that animals, I mean, a million years from now, who knows?
01:00:26.450 --> 01:00:37.730
Dogs may evolve, they're they may evolve the neocortex and they can somehow learn consciousness, but as it stands now, um only humans have that neurological grounding.
01:00:37.890 --> 01:01:02.369
So if you remember at the beginning of our discussion, I talked about when we talk about the bicameral mind, we have to distinguish between the neurology and the psychology, and they're related, and the psychology rests upon the neurology, but you can't have a certain psychological, socio-psychological behaviors if you don't have certain neurological components in place.
01:01:02.690 --> 01:01:11.329
That doesn't mean we should reduce everything to neurology, and the a good metaphor, I think, is the difference between computer hardware and software.
01:01:11.570 --> 01:01:16.130
Things aren't really going to work on a computer unless you have the software.
01:01:16.369 --> 01:01:19.650
Um, it doesn't mean the neurology is not important.
01:01:20.050 --> 01:01:28.369
It just means the way James looked at things, the software is the culture and our neurology is the hardware.
01:01:29.010 --> 01:02:14.769
Okay, because this is actually um as a I'm a software developer, actually, by sort of trace, and um it's sort of something that I've been following in the background a little bit is watching um some news where people have sort of successfully uh simulated like a worm's brain, or you you know, um and I was kind of thinking uh along the same lines of what you were saying there, if at some point in the future if we were able to simulate every neuron firing in our brains, that's the hardware, but the software to uh have consciousness in that simulated brain is just not possible because you would have to have the culture and the human-lived experience that it that sort of simulated simulation wouldn't have.
01:02:14.930 --> 01:02:23.970
Is that kind of we're going into sci-fi territory a little bit here, but
yeah, it's it's pretty it's actually very deep, uh very deep stuff.
01:02:24.050 --> 01:02:27.890
I'm I think what you just described, I think is probably accurate.
01:02:27.970 --> 01:02:29.570
That's my feeling, because I'm asked that a lot.
01:02:29.730 --> 01:02:34.769
Like we're will you know, will AI develop consciousness?
01:02:34.849 --> 01:02:38.130
Well, um, and I'm I'm sort of doubtful.
01:02:38.210 --> 01:02:48.130
And I I I I think there's a difference between will a program become conscious versus can humans create an entity that becomes conscious?
01:02:48.289 --> 01:02:49.730
Those are two very different things.
01:02:49.970 --> 01:03:07.329
I do think probably at the rate we're going, we will be able to develop an entity that is not just pure electrical circuitry and uh programming, some sort of bio-engineered entity that can learn from the environment.
01:03:07.490 --> 01:03:09.490
You know, we're talking way in the future.
01:03:09.650 --> 01:03:17.570
Because I think consciousness arises because we're externalized, we are embodied creatures, we're connected to the environment.
01:03:17.809 --> 01:03:27.410
And so I don't know if that's clear the distinction I made between AI developing consciousness versus a man-created entity developing consciousness.
01:03:27.490 --> 01:03:30.210
I think the latter is a is a possibility.
01:03:30.369 --> 01:03:40.130
You know, maybe we we'll we'll build robots, but those robots have to be able to sense the world, they have to perceive the way people do.
01:03:40.369 --> 01:03:44.450
Consciousness is not this magical cloud floating around.
01:03:44.610 --> 01:03:50.369
Consciousness is something that's built up in in the mind of a child um over many years.
01:03:50.530 --> 01:03:58.050
And I think that um it's certainly a possibility um that we'll we'll be able eventually to do that.
01:03:58.369 --> 01:03:58.690
Okay.
01:03:59.170 --> 01:04:26.610
We could get really deep with this into the realms of uh people are talking a lot about panpsychism at the moment, about how consciousness is fundamental, it's like a fundamental sort of fabric of the universe, and that would suggest that perhaps consciousness doesn't arise purely in the brain, although by this definition it sounds like really it is the mechanics of the brain coupled with culture and human experience, and nothing external like in the theory of panpsychism.
01:04:26.769 --> 01:04:31.809
I feel like I could do a whole podcast episode on that, but it might not be an episode of what we did before.
01:04:32.050 --> 01:04:37.490
Um and I I sort of want to get a little bit onto the future of consciousness.
01:04:37.570 --> 01:04:44.610
We've touched on how it may be changing and reshaped by technologies and tools and AI that we've got now.
01:04:44.769 --> 01:04:46.289
But is it possible?
01:04:46.690 --> 01:04:56.849
Could you argue that consciousness is still being experienced differently between different cultures today and different peoples, depending on where exactly in the world they're living in?
01:04:57.010 --> 01:05:08.450
Because we do often talk about the difference between Western ideologies and eastern ideologies, and and uh perhaps how uh tribes like the Hadza think compared to um people like us.
01:05:08.610 --> 01:05:15.170
So, yeah, is is consciousness, given that it is culturally informed, being experienced differently globally?
01:05:15.650 --> 01:05:19.250
Um that's a very uh good and important question.
01:05:19.490 --> 01:05:31.250
I think that the way to look at it, it's not so much that different cultures experience consciousness differently that different individuals do, because we're also very unique.
01:05:31.809 --> 01:05:43.570
Um and I would also say that all present-day cultures and all individuals um have a basic set of capabilities that allow them to be conscious.
01:05:43.809 --> 01:05:56.610
However, on top of that, there's a more subtle, nuanced layer of linguistic differences, of personal experiences that do shape uh how we experience consciousness.
01:05:56.849 --> 01:05:59.730
So um, yes, I do think that there are differences.
01:05:59.809 --> 01:06:01.329
And those differences do matter.
01:06:01.410 --> 01:06:07.410
I because as I said before, I think there are about uh 12 different features of consciousness.
01:06:07.650 --> 01:06:12.930
Not everybody will engage or utilize those features in the same way.
01:06:13.090 --> 01:06:22.610
So, for example, um being able to look at your use your mind's eye and look at your mental space, some people are very good at that.
01:06:22.849 --> 01:06:25.329
That's a feature, a key feature of consciousness.
01:06:25.490 --> 01:06:28.369
Some people struggle with that, some people don't do it at all.
01:06:28.610 --> 01:06:32.210
So that's one very particular example of differences.
01:06:32.369 --> 01:06:44.130
And also cross-culturally in many societies, um the vestiges of uh of hallucinatory mentality are still around.
01:06:44.530 --> 01:06:53.890
My dissertation was on spirit possession in Japan, and I viewed spirit possession as a vestige, a neurological leftover of the bicameramal mind.
01:06:54.450 --> 01:07:09.170
And so those so that that you know when you step back and look at the whole range of different ways of being a person in the modern world, there's act there's actually tremendous socio psychological variety.
01:07:09.730 --> 01:07:16.289
I mean it's just fascinating exploring the history of how consciousness has developed and evolved.
01:07:16.530 --> 01:07:25.650
This is obviously a theory so it may not have happened like this but this I mean it seems hugely plausible and makes a lot of sense to me at least.
01:07:26.769 --> 01:07:29.809
But it's not just fascinating, is it?
01:07:30.050 --> 01:07:44.610
Because you've written books about this, it's you've dedicated your your life to talking about this subject and you can talk to us a bit a bit about your books as well and why
people might want to research this a bit more and pick up some of your work.
01:07:44.769 --> 01:07:49.410
But why does it matter beyond just a mere sort of curiosity or fascination?
01:07:49.570 --> 01:07:58.210
Why is it important that people understand that perhaps consciousness has changed and we did have these bicameral minds in the past and we don't anymore?
01:07:58.610 --> 01:08:01.410
Well um that's that's a that's a big question.
01:08:01.570 --> 01:08:17.809
I think um just I I think the way science works is when we develop a hypothesis and test it, we're not always sure what the result is going to be but often the the result of science scientific research is very unpredictable.
01:08:18.050 --> 01:08:19.090
So we don't know.
01:08:19.250 --> 01:08:42.369
So you know there's this debate in uh among um researchers is it uh which is more valuable pure research or something very practical how to make a better mousetrap um and I think we need both obviously but I I want to highlight and stress the importance of what we might call pure research or research that doesn't seem related now but eventually it might be.
01:08:42.449 --> 01:09:47.010
So for example in the case of Jane's um his work you know his his that book of his it's about consciousness yes but it's also about hallucinations and I think if someone wants to understand Jane's they should start with hallucinations and not worry about consciousness is because consciousness it's a lot more difficult to talk about when you're introduced to Janes but hallucinations we we know something about hallucinations and many people suffer um from hallucinations uh there's something going on there and I think jaynes sheds a lot of light on that um so that's just one example and um in one of my books I uh about psychotherapy I actually take the notion of Jane Zian consciousness and I break it down and I show how when it comes to a clinician developing techniques in order to help someone who's suffering from anxiety or depression or what have you what does our understanding of Jane Zing how does it help us develop those techniques and you know there's no need to go into the details right now but that I think is something practical.
01:09:47.569 --> 01:10:01.970
So in any case just to summarize what what I was trying to say um I think first of all we never know where pure research will lead or something that seems very academic and unrelated to the real world it probably will lead to something useful.
01:10:02.130 --> 01:10:32.050
And then the other thing as I already uh discussed is I see already how uh in my own practice I can use some of some of uh uh uh Jane's uh ideas to uh to help people clinically just as a I I mean maybe a final actionable tip for people could you argue that you know meditation is used as a way of quietening the mind so we can feel less stressed so we don't have to listen to our inner inner monologue so much.
01:10:32.289 --> 01:10:57.250
So is meditation maybe an attempt to
return to like a pre-narrative mind and can it help us get back in touch with the way in which our ancestors may have experienced the world yeah so um I'm not sure how it would help us get back to the way our ancestors experienced the world um but I definitely think that there is value to meditation.
01:10:57.489 --> 01:11:13.409
A lot of people do use it uh whether they've been diagnosed with a mental health condition or not I mean in meditation originally as you know its roots were very religious and and in all religious traditions you can find something that looks like meditation.
01:11:13.569 --> 01:11:22.770
You know I think maybe some people when they hear the word they they think of Hinduism or India or something but actually all traditions have this meditative technique.
01:11:23.010 --> 01:11:29.970
And I think the way uh meditation works is you're basically you're it's related to hypnosis.
01:11:30.050 --> 01:11:49.329
It's not exactly the same thing but what it shares with hypnosis is an attempt to step back and not shut off your mind because that's impossible to do but not take the contents of your mind so seriously and don't judge the contents of your mind.
01:11:49.489 --> 01:12:02.130
So when I say contents of your mind another way to look at it is the voices to just let those voices yell and shout and do whatever they want but don't attach yourself to those voices.
01:12:02.289 --> 01:12:05.409
Just let them parade by in your head.
01:12:05.650 --> 01:12:11.810
So uh I I do think that there's a lot to be said um for the usefulness of meditation.
01:12:12.289 --> 01:12:36.690
You are not your thoughts yeah right that that exactly you are not your thoughts right yeah yeah there's always there's always a an eye uh that can step out and look that that that's what I don't want to get into the theory too much right now but the idea is that our mind is always jumping ahead and there's always an eye looking back on this narrative line.
01:12:36.930 --> 01:12:45.170
And sometimes we take that narrative too seriously and we have to be open to the possibility that there are different narratives and then I don't think they get stuck in that narrative.
01:12:45.569 --> 01:12:55.970
And I think that sort of um understanding these tendencies of consciousness can help us just to step back and look and see okay that isn't just me.
01:12:56.130 --> 01:13:28.930
I'm not attached to this thought this is just something that is arising in my brain and I would really recommend to uh all of our listeners and viewers um some of your books Brian uh The Self Healing Mind um a psychohistory of metaphors I was reading last night very interesting and um yeah so just wanted to get a little plug in there thank you appreciate that well Brian McVeigh it's been an absolute pleasure thank you very much for joining us on what we did before.
01:13:29.250 --> 01:14:35.730
Okay thank you uh for having me I enjoyed the talk a massive thank you to Brian McVeigh so Matt tell me what did you think about about all that well um it's fascinating because I don't really know where to start um firstly this idea of the bicameral mind uh we touched on this and hallucinations and I think your point about your daughter um and how she maybe experiences the world is probably one of the things that really clicked for me that this is a potential uh like real thing because I I remember sort of having some of these experiences as a child and I often think as an adult that maybe m my ability to sort of see the world is different to how it was when I was a a child and maybe that's because our default state the state that our ancestors just continued having it is to have this kind of more hallucinatory experience of the world.
01:14:36.050 --> 01:14:45.329
Yeah I think for me um it was also interesting to hear that they could sort of be vestiges of a prior version of consciousness that we experienced.
01:14:45.409 --> 01:15:09.329
That made a lot of sense as well but what I do want to talk about a little bit is how this kind of theory, this idea does seem to stray away from ideas of religion as though they were only a sort of a mental benefit for our ancestors that they that they were they kept a hold of because it was useful for societies back then and isn't so useful now.
01:15:09.569 --> 01:15:22.289
But in a way that does undermine religion and the existence of a god and I I wouldn't want to say that you know religion isn't true because all it was was voices inside the heads of our ancestors.
01:15:22.449 --> 01:15:25.489
It could be that both things are true.
01:15:25.730 --> 01:15:32.130
It could be that maybe ancient humans or our ancestors really were communing with God in a way that we can't today.
01:15:32.289 --> 01:15:34.050
There are so many explanations.
01:15:34.210 --> 01:15:45.409
So yeah I just wanted to sort of mention I don't know where you land on this argument but that it isn't writing off religion entirely but it's a very interesting explanation regardless.
01:15:45.890 --> 01:16:18.609
Yeah I think that we should probably take this um for what it is with uh as open-minded people whatever your beliefs I mean uh I don't think that even necessarily uh these thoughts on kind of evolution really discount religion entirely or even specific religions I think it's just that we're exploring a potential kind of uh explanation for how our minds worked and that can be separate from the the God argument I think.
01:16:18.930 --> 01:16:33.489
Yeah and you know at the end of the day and I did say this to Brian that this is still just a theory right we can't go back into the minds of our ancestors and actually figure out whether there were these two chambers that composed the bicameral mind.
01:16:33.650 --> 01:17:03.569
It is just something that we can sort of reflect on based on the writings of the time and based on how we saw civilization grow and change but um actually trying to tap into how they understood the world that's almost impossible and but it is really fascinating because no matter what it does seem that there was some sort of shift in the way that we thought so whether there was a time before consciousness that still remains a bit of a mystery but there certainly was a time before modern thinking I would argue.
01:17:04.050 --> 01:17:24.529
Yeah and um I think one of the things that clicked for me at least as a sort of tech person and maybe it did for you as well is this kind of idea that the brain being hardware and then sort of consciousness or just you know thinking in general being like the software that runs on the brain.
01:17:24.770 --> 01:17:50.289
If we look at it that way it kind of maybe explains a few things that maybe effectively we got a software update sometime in history and we're not that this kind of just happened out of chance but actually that it was a required update to allow us to work in the communities and um with the kind of worlds that we have i i in the last sort of 2000 years or so.
01:17:50.609 --> 01:17:57.569
Yeah and maybe maybe if there is a God or maybe if we live in the Matrix, maybe it was a legitimate update that was just run one day.
01:17:57.650 --> 01:18:01.650
That's where it seems to have happened in such a short um time period.
01:18:01.890 --> 01:18:08.850
But you know there are probably loads of arguments against it that we didn't get into and that we didn't flesh out as well that kind of pull apart the theory as well.
01:18:08.930 --> 01:18:21.890
So for anybody listening who thinks you know um we're suggesting that this is the the way that consciousness did develop I think there's a lot more nuance to be had and probably Matt um some future episodes to be had in this conversation as well.
01:18:22.289 --> 01:18:46.930
It's a huge topic um I have to say personally that I find his argument very compelling and um I plan to read more into this and listen to more podcasts about this but you know you only have to look at the um the fact that Brian has his life has been mostly dedicated specifically on this branch of theory around consciousness.
01:18:47.170 --> 01:19:03.890
So it's such an enormous topic there's so many things that we could delve into we've tried to uh and Brian's tried to distill it into an hour and that's just one kind of uh school of thought on it so yeah there's many more avenues we could go down on this one.
01:19:04.210 --> 01:19:15.650
And if you listening have any ideas of where you'd like us to go next with this topic or any other topic please do let us know in the comments and if we choose your idea we'll be sure to credit you in the outro of that episode.
01:19:15.810 --> 01:19:17.730
This is what we did before I'm Ollie.
01:19:17.970 --> 01:19:26.529
And I'm Matt and please do subscribe if you like the video or follow us if you like the audio it really does help us out.
01:19:26.690 --> 01:19:27.489
Thank you