TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
Josh Arnold: Great leadership on the shop floor isn't about just giving peptocks. It's about creating an environment where a technician feels safe enough to take on bigger challenges and level up without fearing that they'll get thrown in the bus when learning does happen.
Marshall: Scope Creep will destroy a technician's flag hours faster than almost anything else, and today on WithinSpec, we're talking about building trust that develops technicians and setting boundaries that protect your time.
Josh Arnold: All right, so diving straight in the first question that we need to answer is first off, as a leader or as somebody that's in the shop, what's are what is some of the things that you do to help develop that trust with your technicians enough to where they'll actually be willing to take on a bigger challenge?
Marshall: Well I think we gotta there's a small elephant that we've got to work through and that's
Josh Arnold: boy, small elephant.
Marshall: the small elephant is making sure that our technicians are getting compensated. as long as they feel like they're gonna be safe there, then I feel like we're or and even like especially in flat rate, you know what mean? We if we were like, Hey, the next level is like, hey, we want this guy to learn this, up skill him, let's make sure that we we put that technician in an environment where they're gonna get paid, but they're they're gonna learn something too. and And that they can feel comfortable taking that step and putting some time into something that they're not necessarily wrenching on. and then Vice versa, in an hourly situation, the technicians are held accountable for their productivity and efficiency and and that we make sure that those technicians know that like hey, those numbers are gonna go down. We know they're gonna go down because you're gonna be doing these additional tasks and you know, have a way to build those to obviously repair orders. So, you know, we're gonna make sure you're good to go. we're not gonna hold that against you when it, you know, comes time for raises, things like that. So I think like obvious
Josh Arnold: I think on on flat rate. Well I was gonna say to so to your question, on the on the flat rate is different hourly, you probably it's it's a lot more safer flat rate. I'd say the biggest thing is that if you're gonna push a guy to the next level as far as diagnostic repairs, doing more warranty work, whatever it might be, bumping his pay rate, his or her pay rate before they're experiencing that work will go a long way with them. So obviously we know as we do more complex repairs that things are gonna be harder, we're probably gonna be slower, especially if it's new. to us so when you have an apprentice where you could potentially bump them up a couple of dollars an hour before they're taking on that kind of work, that can help supplement that income that might experience lower flag hours than normal.
Marshall: Even mid mid level or even a senior guy, like
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: say you want a senior guy to start doing some dispatching or something like that, and like that's something that's outside of his normal
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: day to day, his scope, if you will, his scope of work. you know, we wanna ensure that like this technician is compensated in some
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: way, shape or form. Like you're Hey, I'm gonna give you two bucks more an hour, but I I want you to start learning this whatever task and you give him the direction of some s whatever and you you point in the in there in the right direction, you coach through some things and you upskill this particular person because you might see something special on They might be an assistant service manager someday or a shop foreman that you're trying to develop.
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: and y you've got to put them in a situation where they're they feel sick enough to do it.
Josh Arnold: I I think for me too, it's also so the pay is obviously duh, like right, first step. The second thing
Marshall: Right.
Josh Arnold: is a manager I can trust to have my back. So like when you're coming up, you're gonna make mistakes. When you're doing something new, you're gonna make mistakes, you're gonna fuck shit up. You gotta have s a manager that you know will have your back in those situations. if I break something, how are you gonna respond? So or when I put you know, when I cause a situation that's gonna lead to some negative outcomes, you know, accidentally, of course, how are you gonna have my back in those situations? I think that before you're going into that situation where you're having to the only way you can build that trust is by experiencing that. Right. So I would say for me, one of the things my managers have always done or haven't done is that they make me feel like I can make a mistake and not necessarily feel like they're gonna grill me on it or you know, hit me harder than I need to. I'm already absorbing it so much of myself that I don't need anything more put on top. so I it's important to me to be in that environment and that's really what's gonna allow me to push myself to that next level.
Marshall: Yeah, and it's like, we we talk about a lot of the stuff that
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: in the industry that's just like adds on, right, like to what the technicians do. Like you know, like you've worked at places that do the c you know, like a cultural fit deal and it's like the people come in and they're gonna work with you for the day and that's obviously going to make you slower. you're not gonna build as many hours that day. you know, and that's it, but it's an expectation. that you do this. or like I mentioned earlier, like maybe there's a person they they want to bring up to for a particular reason, you know, they have the conversation with them, like, hey, I could see you here. Is this something you're interested in? They say, Yeah. You guys making arrangements. You know, like there's just
Load full transcript
a lot of tasks administratively that we are already putting on the technicians. And I it just weighs heavily on my mind that we we ensure that like we're doing things in a way that like we can upskill our texts but also make sure we're, you know, taking care of them and having their back, like you said, and like when people learn stuff they they they screw up. Like that's part the learning part of it, you know.
Josh Arnold: Yeah. Yeah.
Marshall: and and yeah, you're right. I think like what does that really look like? I think as a manager I've you definitely have to say, listen, I know you're gonna mess up. You know what I mean? But you know, you do it together. Do some of that stuff together. Like if you're like I I give you an example of the dispatching, like be out there on the floor dispatching with them. I it's like, hey, well if you give the the wrong guy the wrong repair, you know what I'm
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: saying, and then they take way too long on it and they lose their ass, that's on you just as much as it is it's really not on the tech. They weren't capable of doing the job. That was really on you because you dispatched the work. so it's like, you know, making sure that that how would how would he react to that? Well it's on him 'cause he wasn't paying attention to what you were what what the technician was doing while they were learning, you know what I mean? So it's like you gotta take some ownership as a as a manager too, I think.
Josh Arnold: yeah, for sure. that's any time anyone's learning like it's a You don't look at an apprentice and you go, Why did you make a mistake? you you look at him
Marshall: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: and you say, This is what we learned from it, right? Same thing
Marshall: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: when we're and that that's a hard thing, right? Because sometimes these these technicians are masters, right? They're forty years old at this point. And so keeping in mind that they are now an apprentice again in a no whole new way can be difficult. And it can be difficult for the technician too, right? When you're feeling that sense of like, I don't know what I'm doing anymore.
Marshall: Well dude, when you go like from like a real season technician and then you get that first service manager role, like dude, you went from like being a a big fish in a little pond to a little fish in a small pond all over again. Like you said that's
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: a good analogy, is like being a junior service manager is just coming in as a as a junior technician. you you don't have all the skill sets to do your job yet. And hopefully you have a good GM or or you know, someone to mentor you through that position.
Josh Arnold: if not at least some people that you can pull from that are in similar stories or similar stores.
Marshall: Yeah, yeah.
Josh Arnold: so let's talk about the next side of this, which is like, okay, so say we're upskilling and say we don't have the best manager we're working with. or at least
one that maybe isn't the most attentive. And we have the thing called what you said earlier, which is the scope of your job is this, but then it becomes this and this and this and getting bigger, right? Slowly. It's basically you're good at something, you start to do well, you start to have, you know, you offer to help one time, and then next thing you know you're getting more tasks. I think it's really crucial here that we say that that's not always bad because it can give you an opportunity to learn those things new skills, but where's that line, right? How do I protect myself from doing the services man service manager's job and doing my job when that when we're trying to expand our scope?
Marshall: Yeah, and and dude, when you're good at it, right? it's like it's hard to see it when it's when it's happening too, 'cause it's like
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: and they got this whole industry, not just our industry, but just job jobs in general, they call it a scope creep. And it's like basically where, like you said, you take on an extra duty, an extra task, and then it snowballs, you get good at it, so they give you something else and then something else and something else. And keeping in mind that some of us are flat rate, like we've Got to make sure that we draw a hard line in the sand on some of these items because it's like, hey, listen, yeah, I get it. I'll do the dispatching for a little while and learn how to do it, and then okay, well, let's try a different task. don't keep letting them add it on to you.
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: It's like learn how to do the dispatching. Once you feel like you're doing really well at it, teach somebody else it, and then you move on to the next task and learn on it, learn what the next task is,
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: and and just keep acquiring skills. that the ideally you're doing it in a way that you're acquiring more skills but not adding on more of what responsibilities, yeah. Until
Josh Arnold: Responsibilities. Yeah.
Marshall: you get until you get the title, you know what I'm saying, and and the pay for it. So
Josh Arnold: It's just c you just gotta be careful with it because it it happens slowly and and if you're a really nice person or you're a little bit more passive, like it can come off in a way that you know, you're just being a team player, right? But there's only so far you can go. Now I am curious, you're being hourly How does it work in that situation, right? So flat rate, it's a lot easier, right? I'm not getting paid for this. That cuts it off. It's it's my want to do it that in does it. But when you're getting paid every day, no matter what
Marshall: Well yeah, I feel like you've got more standing when you only get paid to turn wrenches. Like you have
Josh Arnold: Right.
Marshall: more like you can say, Well, hey, you know, like I said, it's not part
Josh Arnold: That's not my job.
Marshall: of my job, but like in how in an hourly solution, you know, in an hour hourly situation, they'll say like at the end of your job description it's like and then any other task to you, you know what I'm saying?
Josh Arnold: Ha ha
Marshall: Yeah, so it's like it's a little different, but it's at the same time it's try to ride the the advice that I would give people is try to stay true to your job description. because at the end of the day that's what you're getting paid to do is that job description. Understand
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: that pretty thoroughly and and what you're supposed to be doing. And I wouldn't suggest not upskilling yourself. Like the more valuable the more you know the more valuable you are, no matter
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: if it's learning more stuff to that more things that you can fix or more skills within the business or whatever that is, I always suggest that people upskill themselves and become more valuable. But like, you know, have that it's just have a real conversation. I think relationships are really about communication and just be forward with hey, I wanna learn how to do this and I appreciate the opportunity to do it. I'm gonna go out there and do it and I'm gonna figure it out and I'm gonna do it. But like once I get good at it, how about I train the next guy how to do it and then, you know, like I said and then Maybe we'll try something else. So that way you can just the goal being that like, hey, I I wanna be able to do any of the job in the dealership. Like that's that's how my mindset has always been, like, I wanna be able to do every role in a dealership. If somebody called out, I could just do their job. Maybe not like at a super high level, but like I could do it in a way that like I could get the job done and be decent. You know what I mean? Like if a service writer called out and I'm a senior guy,
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: and like I the I already have the the the technicians respect me and so like if I was to be the service rider that day for three or four ticks, I could go out there do it. I could talk to the clients, I could do all the things I need to do
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: and and I could keep the shop running, you know what mean?
Josh Arnold: Do you do you think so let's let's say we have some of our you know five viewers
Marshall: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: that that need advice here, right? And they say, Okay, they realize that they have been getting scope creep. How do you establish that boundary? how do you do it in a way that doesn't damage anything, but also make sure that you're protecting yourself? Like what would be your advice to them?
Marshall: Yeah, I think if I was just hearing this right now and I was just like, god I'm doing all Yeah, I'm
Josh Arnold: crap.
Marshall: doing all I am doing all this other crap and I didn't even know that was a thing. which I'd been there before, I'm not gonna lie to ya. so I would just back up, I literally would just okay, Monday morning I'd go in and have a conversation with my management team and just be like, Hey,
listen, I've been doing a lot of these extra tasks I don't mind doing them, but it's got to be to where it's like I'm almost not doing my fucking job now. You know what I'm saying? I'm doing all
Josh Arnold: Ha ha.
Marshall: this other crap. So list out whatever they are. It might be two or three extra things that you're doing right now. and figure out tell the management team like hey I've been doing this, this and this and this above and beyond my my job description. I'm happy to I've been happy to do I've learned a ton and appreciate it. But let's let's back it down to one. What is the most important task that I'm doing now that helps the business? And then and then stay on that one. Now if you're doing all three really well and those are actually supposed to be other positions are supposed to be doing them and they're not doing them and it's because you've been doing them all this time. Ask for some bread or give it back.
Josh Arnold: Money. Yeah.
Marshall: Let those people do it again. Let them have that task back and then after you've been able to sh shove all that back to where it's it belongs, then maybe you ask for something else to learn.
Josh Arnold: I so and I wanted to before we wrap in with that, so like First off, it is important to understand when you are learning a new skill, sometimes it's better to do it when it's free. The reason why is the expectation is not you know, when somebody does something for free, the expectation is is what it is. It i it's for free, right? You're not expecting the best. So I've used it in my career, but like when you do do something extra and it's not compensated, the expectation is lower, but it still allows you to learn and level So it is important, I think, for everybody listening. You're not always going to get paid for everything. Now there's some good shops out there and some dealerships that will bring you up and pay you to do that, but I wouldn't say that's the norm. And I wouldn't say that that's almost the expectation. If you want to get better at something, it does require an investment from you.
Marshall: Yeah, I think that's a a pretty key component is is like literally when you like you said, when you're you're doing something for free basically because it's like that's actually somebody else's job or it's a task that you're just learning, there is no expectation really of you to do it at a high level. So it's like, you know, I get paid to be a mechanic, not to be a service writer. So if I'm covering up for the service rider 'cause for whatever reason I called out and I'm an hourly technician and I get paid the same whether I was working on trucks today or if I was covering up for the rider. So the expectation that I'm gonna go in there and just crush it out as a service rider that day is not there.
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: But while I'm there, I can learn what they do. I can learn all of their system maybe they use a different part of our DMS or something that I don't usually use. and I can learn a lot of things being in having that opportunity. And you know if the next level for me is service manager or something like that, the service manager's gotta know the service man the service writer side of the DMS and they've gotta know the technician side of the DMS. So it's
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: like it would be who of anyone to try to learn as much about the systems and the processes that they work through, I think.
Josh Arnold: No, I think that's good. So just a quick summary of of the advice here today is gonna be number one, build the trust. Take care of the compensation. Always do that number number one. Number two, build the trust with that person. If they make a mistake, how do you respond to it? Make sure that you show when they do make a mistake that you're not gonna grill them harder than it needs to be. And then the the the part where you are taking those up skills, you are starting to develop it, watch out for that scope creep. But keep in mind that if you do something for free the expectation is a lot less. I miss anything there?
Marshall: you nailed it.
Josh Arnold: Fucking killed it. So that being said, it's about that time.
Marshall: And yeah. And at the end of the podcast we always say the same thing. Catch you on the next one.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, right.