TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
Josh Arnold: Marshall, there's no worse feeling in this trade than watching a tow truck pull up on the service drive with a car you shipped yesterday. Your stomach drops, your ego takes a hit, and right there you have a choice. You can make excuse like a child or you can step up and handle it like a professional.
Marshall: Weak techs immediately start pointing fingers at parts, blaming the advisor, dodging the service manager. The good techs walk straight to the counter, grab the keys, and own every single inch of the problem. And today on Within Spec we're talking about comebacks and how a real tech handles a bad day. And I want to introduce our our co founder of the Within Spec community, Brent Osman, joining us as he does so often. and he's gonna jump in here with us. Talk a little smack about given
Josh Arnold: On the fifty first state, the fifty first.
Brent Osmond: Yeah, thanks for watching the last.
Marshall: from the great state of Canadia. The
Brent Osmond: Thanks, fellas.
Josh Arnold: Well well welcome in, welcome back for another round.
Marshall: Welcome back as always to another round.
Josh Arnold: So you you you screwed up, okay? You did something wrong, maybe you didn't, but
Marshall: We don't know.
Josh Arnold: we don't know.
Marshall: We don't know. But it came back.
Josh Arnold: The car's back. You just worked on it. Customer states picked up the car, had coolant light come on.
Marshall: It's doing the same thing. That's what they always say. It's doing the same thing I brought it for.
Josh Arnold: Ever since you rotated the tires, I've
Marshall: Doing the same thing now.
Josh Arnold: I've got a brake squeal. But it doesn't matter at the end of the day, right? and that's what kind of what we're talking about today is that when you have a comeback, the the worst thing you can do is say, Was me. Not my fault, without even looking at the car. I mean, step one, you actually have to go into it. You're gonna have to look at it, you're gonna have to assume that you are not perfect. I know, I know it's a Hard thing, but you have to accept that there is a potential that you made a mistake and until innocent until proven guilty, of course, but you need to act in the way that the it is possible that you made a mistake, because if you did make a mistake, then you just look like a complete asshat if you didn't own up to it the right way. So what do you think about that, Brent? Have you ever had that happen in your career?
Brent Osmond: yeah, for sure. and it it in been in this trade for how long now and it still kinda happens. thankfully I haven't had anything like actually come back recently, but there have been a few things that have happened in the shop where, you go to fix something or you fix something and then somebody else, because of the way our shift work right happens, right? somebody else might notice something that you did wrong, right? So then you come back on shift and you know, I think it was A couple months ago, I forgot the second O-ring on a fuel filter change. Right? On the new fuel filter housings, right? And so when they
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Brent Osmond: went to go start the truck, it wouldn't start because it was just bypassing fuel the fuel filter, right?
Josh Arnold: Oof.
Brent Osmond: So I need that one, right? So I owned up and
Josh Arnold: Ha ha.
Brent Osmond: I was like, yeah, totally forgot, right? So yeah, and then you know, I've had it I've had it before where a truck comes back and you're so tied up on like a bigger project that maybe you don't actually get put back on your own comeback and then somebody else is working on it and you're going, Holy fuck, hopefully they don't find, something I screwed up, right? That's how you're thinking
Josh Arnold: Yep.
Brent Osmond: the whole time. You screwed up, right? Because it's the same truck coming
Josh Arnold: Yep.
Brent Osmond: back from possibly the same issue, right? But that's that's a terrible feeling. And then yeah, you're right. owning up to it. that's, accountability is is the big part of the, you know, integrity in this trade, right? So, you know, own up to it. And I always I always say to the young young apprentices coming in, if you fuck up, just don't up to it, man. It happens, right? And it's the best way to learn really.
Josh Arnold: Yep.
Brent Osmond: If you're not fucking up, you're not learning. So
Marshall: I was I would say dude if you put your hands on enough gear you're bound to fuck something up. And if you ain't
Brent Osmond: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: fucking nothing up, then you ain't putting your hands on enough gear.
Josh Arnold: A and by gear he means heavy duty, just so you know. Calm down, guys.
Marshall: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. We're not yeah. D depends on the
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: gear we're talking, yeah. Could be other illicit types of gear.
Josh Arnold: No, but but I do like that quote that you say, and I've used it a couple some times since I've known you, it's stolen it from you for, you know, other purposes, of course. But yeah, it's true. If like if you are never making a mistake, are you really pushing yourself? Especially on flat rate. Are you really finding that that next level? Or are you
Brent Osmond: Mm.
Josh Arnold: comfortable and are you being casual about it, right? It's great that you don't make ever mistakes, but also you're not growing that way. If you're not hustling a little bit, if you're not pushing and making mistakes, then you're not growing as much as you could be.
Marshall: Brent, what's your what's your safety saying again? How's it go?
Brent Osmond: we do dangerous stuff very carefully all the time.
Marshall: Yeah, yeah. So there's a we could make up a new version of that, but essentially as you grow in skill, right, you're I always d like joke around with some of my senior guys. It's like, dude, when you fuck up, it's like we do things in a way that when we do fuck up it's just it's really not that big of a deal. You know what I'm saying? when you're when
Load full transcript
you're coming up, you don't know things how to do certain things and so a lot of times some of the things you fuck up are are bigger. You know what I'm saying? Whereas like I feel like as you become more skilled when you do actually mess something up, it's usually like you forgot that second O ring or whatever. It's like usually it's like really not that big of a deal. It's like, shit, we'll just get the other O ring and put it on there. You know what I mean? It's like a a s a small thing and it's like not that
Josh Arnold: Well, you you g you get better at fixing your shit. I mean that's Well not covering them up, but like you strip a bolt. You've you've stripped enough bolts in your career, you know how to fucking fix it, right? Like or or in maybe not even you, but like an apprentice. I mean, the apprentices
Marshall: Well Yeah, you almost get better at covering up your buck ups, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, and you covered it up, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
Josh Arnold: are the best practice at fixing s broken stuff. Like they'll come over, head all down, you know, they're just like put this bolt in and it got really tight and then they're just like my gosh here we go and know it's the one that's in the yeah
Brent Osmond: There's still four inches of bolt to go.
Josh Arnold: and you know it's the one in the worst spot because of course which one are you gonna cross thread right and so
Brent Osmond: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Marshall: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: yeah apprentices will always get you plenty of practice and then by the time you've done a few of them you're a freaking master so when you strip something accidentally or you said it goes wrong you're just like I got this no problem at all But to circle back, for the young techs in the room, when you do have a comeback, just just say it. Say, hey, I may have messed this up. Let me look into it really quick. Let me take care of it. And then the best part is if you didn't, then you're a guy that also took care of that customer, right? that's unfortunate that happened, but here's here's what we found.
Marshall: Yeah, and I I think like
Brent Osmond: Yeah. And and I mean and for the young guys too, if if you do fuck up and your and your journeyman comes by and he fixes it in five minutes, don't be impressed that he fixed it in five minutes, but
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Brent Osmond: it's probably because he had the same he had the same comeback or the same fuck up too, right? And he's already fixed it once before, right? So yeah. So that's where that comes from, is just experience and and doing it wrong and then experience to do it right, right?
Josh Arnold: I think I think so for sure. Go ahead, Marshall.
Marshall: I always have one s one story about comebacks that I always tell apprentices when they have a comeback, so it's like just kinda ease the tension a little bit. Because they always and here my theory on apprentices is that if they don't beat themselves up about fucking something up, then I I don't really like that's
a bad sign to me. I I don't know, like if I fuck something up like legit, like No there's nothing anybody could say to me that would make me feel worse about it than what I'm telling myself about it. You know what I'm saying? And so it's a good sign when to me if an apprentice comes over and hey, I fucked this up and and they're feeling shitty about it. But if they're really nonchalant about it, that's like, dude, that's somebody else's shit that you fucked up. You know what I'm saying? you should feel bad about that. you know what I mean? So, for me, that's
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: something that like That that makes me a little nervous if I got an apprentice that is really nonchalant about messing up somebody else's stuff. You know what I mean? And so I don't really that that's a bad omen to me. But like I've got a s like I've got a a comeback that I had that I always tell the apprentices about and it's like, you know, the reason why I tell it to is because The point being is that we're not all infallible. You know what I'm saying? even though I have years and years and years of experience and I tell them a story about an engine that I built and it's an engine that I specialize in and that I messed it up. And it was a catastrophic failure. And it was a fifty-five thousand dollar bill. So it's like I built an engine essentially. I made early on in the in the ISX fifteen days, they had a ceramic the t IS X twenty two fifties had ceramic plungers in the fuel pump heads. And what would happen is is they would explode and then they would put ceramic pieces all over inside the engine, little little tiny little ceramic pieces. And the filter would get plugged up, the oil filter would get plugged up and it would go into bypass. And then it would bypass the f the oil filter and all those pieces would go into the actual engine and it would fuck the engine up bad. So, but they had a process for repairing engines that had that failure, and most of the time I always felt like they couldn't be repaired. This one happened out of warranty, and I made recommendations due to prior experience with those failures, and I said, Hey, this we need to put a short block in this. So I made a recommendation
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: for a short block on this particular engine, and then the client declined it, and they said no. they had their own Cummins rep because it was a large fleet, and they said no. Is what we want you to do. And they delegated to us, hey, you're gonna polish the crank, you're gonna re-bearing it, you're gonna clean as much of the stuff as you can, put new new oil cooler in it, all the other things that I recommended, but they didn't want to do the short block portion or the long block portion. So now all of that was in my notes, which is what we do as technicians to protect ourselves.
Josh Arnold: C Y A.
Marshall: And all of that stuff was in there. I built the engine, I polished the crank, everything, you know, to the best of my ability,
everything looked on the up and up. I finished the engine, I filled it all with fluids, I ran a regen in it just to kind of make sure everything was working and get it up to good operating temperature. Night shift technician was to take over that repair and then do a test drive and make sure everything was on the up and up, and then the following day the client was coming to pick the unit up. So this unit went through a regen. F the I did a regen on it and everything was good. I checked all the fluids and I was happy with my work. I looked everything over. It was tight. The night shift technician Does the same thing, he runs a region, and then he test drives it like 50 miles, brings it back, and he's like, Yeah, it's good to go. Everything's Gucci. The client comes and picks the unit up the following day. They drive it about 75 miles, 80 miles, and the engine locks up and it's catastrophic. It's a catastrophic engine failure. It shows up to one of our sister dealers. They disassemble it to do a failure analysis and they said that I put the engine oil cooler in backwards, upside down.
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: And our master tech was like in there with the service manager and they were talking to the other facility and there my master tech was like, No, you can't do that. Like they don't even fit in there. Like that. That's it, it's impossible, can't do it. So essentially they send it back. Well, my service manager said, Hey, you what? We're sending a tow truck to get that joker and my Master Tech's gonna look it over and we're gonna dis we're gonna work this out with the client, we're gonna get it fixed. So they had it towed back, the Master Tech takes the failure analysis over, goes back over everything, he even gets a brand new oil cooler and brand new gaskets, flips it upside down and then pressurizes the cooler housing to see if it's even possible, and it would have leaked instantly. There's no way I could have done it. The the the cause of failure wasn't correct. It was more likely that some of that debris didn't get cleaned out and that was the cause of failure. And plus there was no o there was no coolant in the oil or nothing like that. So long story short, it couldn't be I couldn't be exonerated from the failure. and it was a big enough client that they just said, you know what, we're just gonna take the hit on this one. So we did. Now that money has got to go to somebody. somebody's gotta be responsible for that failure. And and so I was I was the guy. I was the fall guy on that deal. So I got a ride up for fifty-five thousand some change. I signed it. I went on about my fucking life and I moved on. even though like I didn't really ever feel that like that was my deal. But every oil cooler that I installed after that point I marked all the bolts and I wrote on the outside of that cooler housing on the outside of that cooler so nobody could ever say that I put that joker upside down because I put my paint marker on the outside. I usually put a smiley face
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall: and I put guess again or something like that on it. I put that a couple of times.
Josh Arnold: So s so I think, Brent, start thinking about this. you brought up a good point there, Marshall. One comeback that taught you something that changed your process. You already said yours is the oil cooler, right? You're never fucking letting that shit happen again. There's gonna be a smiley face waiting for you.
Marshall: Yep. And I I literally put I put guess again a hole on a bunch of There's a there's a there's a bunch of out there riding around like that. But I put
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha I bet a tech has seen it and been like, what the f I
Marshall: What the heck dude? But I I do also there's a lot of engines that I've built out there that have the torque spec written on them too. So like I I make my marks on there, I tighten the bolts up and I mark my bolts like I do I mark every internal bolt and then I also on some specific things like that, I'll put something on there like you know, the torque specs of the bolts or something like that. So so I can prove that like, hey, that was the way it was out. You know what I'm saying?
Josh Arnold: Yeah, so for me, I would say mine was early on I had a wheel and it was when I was working in used cars initially, started my career and I was working with a mentor. So we would both work on the cars together when I was first starting out. And we had a Jeep, a wheel came off, luckily on one of our internal people, right? Not great, but better than a customer. And me and the mentor both, you know, didn't what the gap was in the process, right? One of us obviously forgot something. you could assume the younger guy, that's what most would do. but I don't remember and he doesn't remember either, and thankfully he was pretty nice about it to own up to it as well. So I would say the one thing I changed in my process is I hit the wheels with a torque stick and then I leave the torque wrench on the wheels every single time now so that if I back out of the stall it's gonna hit my torque wrench before you know make a noise before I keep driving down the road. Brent, what's yours?
Brent Osmond: Hmm. Overhaul went great, dynall went great, but for whatever reason, you're in the industry long enough, you can when an when a hood is closed and an engine's running, you can tell what engine that is, right? So for whatever reason, this this cat engine I rebuilt was a MXS, so twin turbo cat. it sounded like a Cummins after the rebuild. It just had it just had this this distinct weird, it sounded like gear train noise. And I went through that thing, pulled the gear train back apart, put it back together, reset gear lash, everything like that, still couldn't get rid of it, went back through the top end, did another top end set, and couldn't figure it out, couldn't figure it out. So, you know, and I and I was doing this as a contractor, right? So this is all all work that just I just
couldn't figure it out. And I said to the guy, you know, I still do still do some work for time to time. but I said to him, I said, just send us to this shop. I said, I'll cover the bill. Right. And it turns out I had set the in the injectors too low. Right. So the injectors were making the noise is what was happening. And so they went through the engine. So they pulled mains down, they pulled connecting rod bearings down. They pulled the front gear train back apart. And then they went through the top end and they ended up finding out yeah I set the injectors too low that was causing the noise. So essentially the needle in the injector was bottoming out and hitting. So every second revolution you that's what you were hearing was the needle and the injector bottoming it out, right? So it was about a it was almost a $12,000 hit out of my bad count. Right. So yeah.
Josh Arnold: Ouch. What so what did you what did you change in your process from that one?
Brent Osmond: reading literature.
Josh Arnold: Fair point. Fair point.
Marshall: Well
Brent Osmond: I and I used you it's funny because you I spent a lot of time teaching at the college too and I used to say reading's hard. Right. Because
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha.
Brent Osmond: sometimes there's things you're gonna overlook, right? And I don't
Josh Arnold: Yeah, yeah.
Brent Osmond: know how many cat top end sets I've done over the years. And I even went through and did the same procedure the wrong way the second time for whatever reason. And it just like I don't know if it was maybe it was stubbornness.
Josh Arnold: Wasn't the day.
Brent Osmond: Right. Maybe it was I've done so many of these was in my head. I don't know. I don't know what it was. Right. So
Marshall: Well to be fair, Josh, like I know you guys don't set like you guys don't really have mechanical jet injectors like that, in in automotive really, but maybe on some of the diesel older diesels you guys might, but a lot of the old mechanical injectors across multiple engine platforms, it doesn't matter Cummins or or Cat had a very similar setting to like you run down and you back off two flats or whatever it was.
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: Or you run down flush and then you and then you do two more flats or whatever it was, but like they're I mean I'm kinda like you, Brent. Now I just I'll get out the procedure every single time. I don't even commit it to memory on purpose because like if
Brent Osmond: Yeah. Yeah.
Marshall: I do that then I'll do something similar and so but yeah, there was like there's kind of a generic way to do it and so a lot of gu like a lot of the older hands and and it Brent was probably taught that way back in the day when he was coming up because I was taught that same way, like, hey, this is how you do the injector, and it's like, you know, run it to his flesh and go two more flats or whatever it was, or I can't remember what it was now, but
Brent Osmond: So this one was the the tool that cups around the injector and it's got the rod that travels
Marshall: Right.
Brent Osmond: up and you're supposed to split the difference on the step, right? To make it that I guess it's I can't
Marshall: Right, right.
Brent Osmond: I can't exactly remember. It's like 72.6 millimeters or something like that. Anyways, my tool just has a slot down the middle, right? And I thought that the slot had to be flush with the tool when it mounts, right? So there's two different types of tools you can use, right, to to do it. So with that. slot down the middle being flush, it actually set the injector too low, right? So either way, you know what I mean? It's it's lesson learned. Expensive, right? So yeah.
Josh Arnold: I mean the the the yeah. The I mean both your guys' expenses are definitely a little bit more spendy, but that's because you're from the the heavy duty side, right? Bigger money, bigger bigger tools. But
Brent Osmond: Mm-hmm.
Josh Arnold: to sum it all up, I mean just if you make a mistake, own up to it. Whether it
Brent Osmond: Yeah. Yeah.
Josh Arnold: ends up being yours or just a random accident or anything like that, it's better to play it safe. Own up to the mistake
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: until you're proven innocent, and then once you're proven innocent, then you can be like, Yep, I knew it And and
Brent Osmond: And it's
Marshall: But regardless, when when loser draw, you should put
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: something in place to not let it happen again or not even Yeah.
Josh Arnold: A hundred percent. And that's and that's the biggest
Brent Osmond: Mm-hmm.
Josh Arnold: takeaway I think for today is that we've all learned from those mistakes and made sure they don't happen again 'cause and I heard this on SDL, it was a mistake's only a mistake if it happens two times in a row. Right? The first time's a learning opportunity. While it may have been a mess
Marshall: But hey.
Josh Arnold: up. Yeah. So what do we say?
Marshall: We hit our we hit our twenty minute mark and at the end of every podcast we always say the same thing. And that's I'll catch you on the next one.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, right.