TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
1
00:00:56,248.333 --> 00:01:01,33.333
This week's one pasuk comes from Parshas Noach, Perek Zion, Pasuk Zion.
2
00:01:01,52.333 --> 00:01:05,592.333
We're already in the thick of the story of Noach and the flood and the building of the Teva.
3
00:01:05,592.333 --> 00:01:14,813.333
Noach has spent many, many years building the Teva and having already been told that the Mabul was coming and the Torah describes how the waters have already come.
4
00:01:15,270.333 --> 00:01:22,9.333
And, After Noach fulfilled the command to build the teva, the Torah says, "Vayavo Noach uvano ve'ishto u'neshei vanav eto el hateva."
5
00:01:22,299.333 --> 00:01:33,442.333
Noach, together with his sons, his wife, his sons' wives, all of them came into the ark, mipnei mei hamabul, because of the waters of the flood.
6
00:01:34,7.333 --> 00:01:55,186.333
And those last three words have captured the rabbinic imagination, and Rashi famously suggests or posits that Noach was a man of little faith because he needed to wait for the waters of the flood to actually arrive before going into the teva rather than going as a result of God's command.
7
00:01:55,560.333 --> 00:02:05,565.333
It really is one of the richest and most fruitful Rashis because it really elicits important conversations and reflections about what it means to be a person of faith.
8
00:02:05,912.333 --> 00:02:10,780.333
And I was hoping maybe we can reflect a little bit on that together, or not, depending on what we're thinking about in this passuk.
9
00:02:11,232.333 --> 00:02:13,598.333
But let's turn it over to the rabbis and see what they have.
10
00:02:14,866.333 --> 00:02:32,346.46888608
So the first thing that struck me about, this passuk and this famous Rashi is that, there's obviously, there's that constant running debate, do we look at Noach favorably or unfavorably in different ways? But I think it's a little bit unfair, to say that Noach was of weak faith okay, I understand.
11
00:02:32,903.46888608 --> 00:02:37,471.46888608
But maamin ve'lo maamin sheyavo hamabul, right? He believed, didn't believe.
12
00:02:37,471.46888608 --> 00:02:39,21.46888608
Maybe Hashem would've changed his mind.
13
00:02:39,437.46888608 --> 00:02:50,175.46888608
To say that the reason why he is of weak faith is because he didn't fully believe that the, the mabul would come, I don't know, maybe I'm reading Rashi too closely, but that's okay.
14
00:02:50,176.46888608 --> 00:02:54,217.46888608
You can still believe in Hashem and still not believe that he's actually gonna bring the mabul.
15
00:02:54,286.46888608 --> 00:03:04,456.46888608
but I guess what Rashi's saying is that his belief that the mabul, the flood might not come wasn't just, will Hashem actually bring it, but rather doubting Hashem's actual promise.
16
00:03:04,456.46888608 --> 00:03:06,250.46888608
That's actually just a question I want to throw out there.
17
00:03:06,301.46888608 --> 00:03:17,667.6729415
But the the observation I wanted to
Load full transcript
share from Rabbi Moshe Taragin is just a straightforward observation What Noah represents is what it means to struggle with faith.
18
00:03:17,667.6729415 --> 00:03:22,554.6729415
And struggling with faith is something that is not necessarily a, a failing.
19
00:03:22,554.6729415 --> 00:03:29,370.6729415
The way I would put it is that faith isn't just something you accomplish, achieve, you decide, Okay, I believe fully."
20
00:03:29,885.6729415 --> 00:03:31,192.6729415
Faith is a practice.
21
00:03:31,192.6729415 --> 00:03:32,512.6729415
Faith is an exercise.
22
00:03:32,516.6729415 --> 00:03:35,426.6729415
It's a muscle that we strengthen over the course of our lives.
23
00:03:35,426.6729415 --> 00:03:52,800.77281809
And seen from that perspective to have periods of doubt or skepticism is somebody with a very active, engaged mind or soul is somebody who is engaged with the Rabbono Shel Olam and trying to really understand Hashem, his world, how he runs the world.
24
00:03:53,198.77281809 --> 00:03:57,557.77281809
And somebody who is maamin ve'ein maamin isn't, necessarily a bad person.
25
00:03:57,890.77281809 --> 00:04:00,787.77281809
It's a person who's really committed and really engaged.
26
00:04:01,25.77281809 --> 00:04:03,965.77281809
Somebody who gives up and who abandons and who just says, "Forget it.
27
00:04:03,965.77281809 --> 00:04:06,443.77281809
I don't, I don't care about anything," that's a problem.
28
00:04:06,750.77281809 --> 00:04:16,499.77281809
But Noach really represents what it means to be a person who wants to understand this world and wants to be closer to Hashem and is actually putting forth the efforts.
29
00:04:16,873.77281809 --> 00:04:25,859.77281809
Yes, it would be wonderful if we could all just live our entire lives with emunah peshutah and just always have that, that constant faith, and that's a good thing, and maybe that's achievable for some people.
30
00:04:26,407.77281809 --> 00:04:30,120.77281809
But I think for a majority of people, Noach represents the real person.
31
00:04:30,179.77281809 --> 00:04:38,502.77281809
And which is why I think it's a little cute and ironic that we have this song, «Noach was a big tzadik,» which then it turns into, «Every Yid's a big tzadik.»
32
00:04:38,512.77281809 --> 00:04:40,912.77281809
So I like the fact that every Yid is like Noach.
33
00:04:41,38.77281809 --> 00:04:42,128.77281809
I totally agree with that.
34
00:04:42,681.77281809 --> 00:04:46,327.77281809
Is a big tzadik maybe he isn't, but I don't think that's Noach's greatness.
35
00:04:46,348.77281809 --> 00:04:53,791.77281809
Noach's greatness is the fact that he is the exemplar for what it means to keep struggling with one's faith because one wants to.
36
00:04:54,26.77281809 --> 00:04:54,411.77281809
Yeah.
37
00:04:54,830.77281809 --> 00:04:55,823.77281809
That's very well said.
38
00:04:56,68.77281809 --> 00:05:00,359.77281809
I am reflecting on one of my dear rebbeim, our shared rebbe in
some sense, Rabbi J.J.
39
00:05:00,362.77281809 --> 00:05:00,888.77281809
Schachter.
40
00:05:01,84.77281809 --> 00:05:01,350.77281809
Yeah.
41
00:05:01,403.77281809 --> 00:05:07,314.77281809
So he once told over the following, I guess it's a factoid rather than a mesechta, which is that Rabbi Dr.
42
00:05:07,314.77281809 --> 00:05:10,185.77281809
Norman Lamm wrote a book called Faith and Doubt.
43
00:05:11,3.77281809 --> 00:05:18,63.77281809
And in response to that title, Rabbi Bleich wrote his sefer With Perfect Faith.
44
00:05:18,397.77281809 --> 00:05:18,704.77281809
Yeah.
45
00:05:19,179.77281809 --> 00:05:20,683.77281809
That there is no faith and doubt.
46
00:05:20,697.77281809 --> 00:05:21,722.77281809
There's perfect faith.
47
00:05:22,227.77281809 --> 00:05:25,842.77281809
That it was somehow meant to almost be like a corrective.
48
00:05:25,939.77281809 --> 00:05:35,554.77281809
And to me this calls it up because Rashi's words, they're he's so terse, but it's so beautiful 'cause, we typically think about a belief as something that's real or not.
49
00:05:35,888.77281809 --> 00:05:40,640.77281809
Do you really believe, Is this real faith, he said he believed, but he didn't really.
50
00:05:40,699.77281809 --> 00:05:42,113.77281809
Faith is either real or not real.
51
00:05:42,505.77281809 --> 00:05:47,365.77281809
But Rashi allows us an alternative, which is, no, there is real faith.
52
00:05:47,754.77281809 --> 00:05:53,294.77281809
He was maamin, but real faith is not undermined by, it's accompanied by doubt, v'lo maamin.
53
00:05:53,727.22736355 --> 00:05:55,407.22736355
It's not that he had bad faith.
54
00:05:55,407.22736355 --> 00:05:57,857.22736355
He had real faith, maamin, ve'elo maamin.
55
00:05:57,933.22736355 --> 00:05:58,580.22736355
It's both.
56
00:05:59,148.22736355 --> 00:05:59,168.22736355
Mm.
57
00:05:59,168.22736355 --> 00:06:02,336.22736355
That I think captures the complexity of the lived experience.
58
00:06:02,679.22736355 --> 00:06:05,26.22736355
It's not all or nothing, and it's not zero sum.
59
00:06:05,526.22736355 --> 00:06:11,549.89403021
Real faith can live alongside doubt, and I think that's also the machloket between these Gedolei HaAcharonim, Acharonim.
60
00:06:12,231.89403021 --> 00:06:12,553.89403021
Yeah.
61
00:06:12,612.89403021 --> 00:06:12,759.89403021
Yeah.
62
00:06:12,840.89403021 --> 00:06:13,825.89403021
I love that 'cause you're right.
63
00:06:13,884.89403021 --> 00:06:19,922.22736355
When you read it, maamin, ve'ein maamin, if you just read it quickly, it's like, he was doubtful faith, whatever.
64
00:06:19,943.22736355 --> 00:06:20,263.22736355
Yeah.
65
00:06:20,346.22736355 --> 00:06:20,878.22736355
But you're right.
66
00:06:20,892.22736355 --> 00:06:21,749.22736355
He's a maamin.
67
00:06:22,140.22736355 --> 00:06:22,710.22736355
He believes.
68
00:06:22,761.22736355 --> 00:06:34,252.22736355
Ve'ein maamin, and he doesn't believe and I would make another observation based on what you're saying, and that is People have to recognize that people are complex and we're sophisticated, and we can feel two ways at the same time, right? A person can feel love and frustration.
69
00:06:34,369.22736355 --> 00:06:36,595.22736355
A person can feel, right? Two things are true.
70
00:06:36,689.22736355 --> 00:06:37,222.22736355
Two things are true.
71
00:06:37,222.22736355 --> 00:06:38,792.22736355
That's the lang- language we use in my home a lot.
72
00:06:38,936.22736355 --> 00:06:39,55.22736355
Yeah.
73
00:06:39,112.22736355 --> 00:06:39,972.22736355
Two things can be true.
74
00:06:40,105.22736355 --> 00:06:40,348.22736355
Exactly.
75
00:06:40,348.22736355 --> 00:06:41,581.22736355
You know? Exactly.
76
00:06:41,618.22736355 --> 00:06:42,466.22736355
Two things are true.
77
00:06:42,466.22736355 --> 00:06:42,798.22736355
That's it.
78
00:06:42,826.22736355 --> 00:06:46,155.22736355
You feel very grateful, and you were a little disappointed.
79
00:06:46,177.22736355 --> 00:06:47,82.22736355
You know, two things are true.
80
00:06:47,82.22736355 --> 00:06:47,259.22736355
Exactly.
81
00:06:47,270.22736355 --> 00:06:48,271.22736355
You know, we do that a lot in my home.
82
00:06:48,274.22736355 --> 00:06:52,103.22736355
Just to add on to the point Rashi here is citing a passage from Bereishis Rabba.
83
00:06:52,103.22736355 --> 00:06:52,735.22736355
From the Midrash, yeah.
84
00:06:52,752.22736355 --> 00:06:56,667.22736355
If you look at Bereishis Rabba, the language is different from- Mm this is then what I was gonna say.
85
00:06:56,667.22736355 --> 00:06:59,315.22736355
I was just reflecting on what the both of you just commented on.
86
00:06:59,315.22736355 --> 00:07:04,146.22736355
The language of the Bereishis Rabba is, "Amar Rabbi Yochanan Noach mechosar amana haya."
87
00:07:04,228.22736355 --> 00:07:04,581.22736355
Yeah.
88
00:07:04,680.22736355 --> 00:07:06,802.22736355
Right? And Rashi changes it.
89
00:07:07,65.22736355 --> 00:07:08,332.22736355
Rashi makes three changes.
90
00:07:08,362.22736355 --> 00:07:08,634.22736355
Yeah.
91
00:07:08,650.22736355 --> 00:07:10,952.22736355
First of all, he says, "Af Noach."
92
00:07:11,327.22736355 --> 00:07:11,580.22736355
Yes.
93
00:07:11,592.22736355 --> 00:07:13,316.22736355
Which is not in the Midrash.
94
00:07:13,328.22736355 --> 00:07:13,456.22736355
Hold on.
95
00:07:13,456.22736355 --> 00:07:14,201.22736355
No, I'm gonna get to af.
96
00:07:14,240.22736355 --> 00:07:14,552.22736355
Okay.
97
00:07:14,563.22736355 --> 00:07:16,717.22736355
I'm not- 'Cause I'm gonna leave that, leave af on the table.
98
00:07:16,717.22736355 --> 00:07:16,727.22736355
Okay.
99
00:07:16,727.22736355 --> 00:07:18,452.22736355
I'm le- I'm leaving the af on the table, right? Stay af of my Torah.
100
00:07:18,452.22736355 --> 00:07:19,190.22736355
I'm staying off of your af.
101
00:07:19,190.22736355 --> 00:07:19,783.22736355
Stay af of my
Torah.
102
00:07:19,948.22736355 --> 00:07:20,273.22736355
All right.
103
00:07:20,273.22736355 --> 00:07:20,293.22736355
All right.
104
00:07:20,356.22736355 --> 00:07:21,856.22736355
Stay out of the outfield.
105
00:07:21,946.22736355 --> 00:07:27,53.22736355
But also, the Midrash calls him mechosar amana- Yeah lacking faith, and Rashi does not say.
106
00:07:27,57.22736355 --> 00:07:27,67.22736355
Yeah.
107
00:07:27,67.22736355 --> 00:07:29,470.22736355
He says, "Mektanei-" Yeah amana."
108
00:07:29,508.22736355 --> 00:07:29,744.22736355
Yeah.
109
00:07:29,999.22736355 --> 00:07:33,405.22736355
Which is also just a, such a thought-provoking word.
110
00:07:33,405.22736355 --> 00:07:33,415.22736355
Yes.
111
00:07:33,415.22736355 --> 00:07:38,170.22736355
What is mektanei? It c- a katan is no less of a person than a gadol.
112
00:07:38,200.22736355 --> 00:07:40,742.22736355
He's a smaller person, but no less of a person.
113
00:07:41,75.22736355 --> 00:07:43,24.22736355
There's nothing chaser about a katan.
114
00:07:43,110.22736355 --> 00:07:43,348.22736355
Yeah.
115
00:07:43,379.22736355 --> 00:07:48,42.22736355
Right? Nothing lacking or missing or deficient about smallness, per se.
116
00:07:48,331.22736355 --> 00:07:52,88.89403021
So I think it's Noach's faith which leads to the third difference, which is amanu v'ein omanu.
117
00:07:52,381.89403021 --> 00:07:58,433.89403021
Noach, just putting all these pieces together as I'm hearing you talk about it, Noach's faith wasn't lacking, it was just small.
118
00:07:58,689.89403021 --> 00:08:02,523.89403021
And, as people who yearn, who journey we're, faith is a journey.
119
00:08:02,587.89403021 --> 00:08:04,280.89403021
The Don't stop believing don't stop.
120
00:08:04,295.89403021 --> 00:08:06,996.89403021
The, the word- Faith is a journey the word- With me? Yeah.
121
00:08:06,996.89403021 --> 00:08:07,474.89403021
You got one more.
122
00:08:07,494.89403021 --> 00:08:07,580.89403021
I got you.
123
00:08:07,580.89403021 --> 00:08:07,909.89403021
I got you.
124
00:08:07,996.89403021 --> 00:08:08,300.89403021
Nice.
125
00:08:08,367.89403021 --> 00:08:11,929.89403021
The word usual- usually we segue into music at some point or another here in the podcast.
126
00:08:11,934.89403021 --> 00:08:12,883.89403021
I know, at you.
127
00:08:14,108.89403021 --> 00:08:14,118.89403021
Yeah.
128
00:08:14,118.89403021 --> 00:08:14,138.89403021
Don't stop.
129
00:08:14,188.89403021 --> 00:08:21,735.89403021
The, the word in Hebrew for practice is lehithamen, right? And when we say like v'chol maminim, It's like not really true.
130
00:08:22,15.89403021 --> 00:08:35,462.89403021
v'chol maminim shehu el emunah, right? Really? I mean, it's like a very difficult proposition to say, but we all strive to believe, and Noach strived to believe, and that's, you know, that's Yeah, but you're right I- Mektanei, meaning, it was immature.
131
00:08:35,603.89403021 --> 00:08:35,766.89403021
Yeah.
132
00:08:35,766.89403021 --> 00:08:36,784.89403021
It wasn't fully developed.
133
00:08:36,826.89403021 --> 00:08:37,110.89403021
Right.
134
00:08:37,356.89403021 --> 00:08:37,854.89403021
I love it.
135
00:08:37,971.89403021 --> 00:08:39,786.89403021
A methodological side point here.
136
00:08:40,120.89403021 --> 00:08:41,883.89403021
Going back to why you keep bringing us back to why you.
137
00:08:41,886.89403021 --> 00:08:51,492.89403021
So when I was in Professor Schneer Lyman's class, so he made the very simple but incredibly insightful point, which is that to study Rashi in any serious way, you always have to be looking at Rashi's source material.
138
00:08:51,551.89403021 --> 00:08:56,125.89403021
The majority of Rashi, like 60-plus percent of Rashi is directly from Midrash.
139
00:08:56,125.89403021 --> 00:09:08,839.73848192
So the question is, I would even push back to you, where else does this Midrash appear? and what was Rashi working with? Was he working with our version of Brit Shlomo, et cetera? But to really study Rashi, you have to look at his source material and say, "Okay, he had these six Midrashim that he could have put on this passage.
140
00:09:08,840.73848192 --> 00:09:15,341.73848192
He chose this one, and then he took it, and he took a Midrash that was five lines and had this verbiage, and he changed it to this."
141
00:09:15,404.73848192 --> 00:09:19,188.73848192
And then you can really see the brilliance of Rashi and the choices that Rashi makes.
142
00:09:19,190.73848192 --> 00:09:19,203.73848192
Right.
143
00:09:19,421.73848192 --> 00:09:27,596.73848192
So this is a great example to show that to understand this Rashi and understand what Rashi really wants, you have to look at the Midrash and see how Rashi is adapting it.
144
00:09:27,600.73848192 --> 00:09:28,766.73848192
So that's just this point.
145
00:09:28,878.73848192 --> 00:09:29,216.73848192
It's beautiful.
146
00:09:29,216.73848192 --> 00:09:32,735.73848192
And I'm also thinking about just, again, hearing the two of you develop the idea.
147
00:09:33,16.40514859 --> 00:09:51,52.40514859
I'm thinking about, the members of our communities who, as we all do, who struggle with faith, and I mean, I remember on my prabha Shabbos at Kesher, now 16 years ago- Mm just started my 17th year I remember being asked "What would you tell somebody Who comes to you with a sh- like faith struggles.
148
00:09:51,463.40514859 --> 00:09:56,561.40514859
And there's no perfect answer to that question, but- Yeah I said something along the lines of, "I'm right there with you."
149
00:09:56,592.40514859 --> 00:10:03,216.40514859
We're all on the journey together, and just because your faith isn't perfect doesn't mean that it's not there.
150
00:10:03,246.40514859 --> 00:10:21,113.40514859
It is mikhtaneh emunah, not necessarily mechusar emunah, and that's just an important kind of word of encouragement that we need to offer people who- Yeah You're striving,
you're searching, and just because your faith is muddled by other things doesn't mean that it's not there- Mm I think.
151
00:10:21,115.40514859 --> 00:10:27,46.40514859
Yeah And I think that actually tees up my one ha'ara, my additional ha'ara here, which is exactly that first word, af.
152
00:10:27,237.40514859 --> 00:10:32,644.40514859
Af Noach mikhtaneh emunah what does that mean? It means Noach's nose- Noach too it means Noach's nose was smaller than- Ah, there we go Everman.
153
00:10:32,684.40514859 --> 00:10:33,72.40514859
Okay.
154
00:10:33,314.40514859 --> 00:10:33,404.40514859
Yeah.
155
00:10:33,418.40514859 --> 00:10:37,590.40514859
So it, it lit- Sorry, had to throw that in It literally means that Noach too was mikhtaneh emunah.
156
00:10:37,825.40514859 --> 00:10:41,330.68586692
Or the way I want to read it, even Noach was mikhtaneh emunah.
157
00:10:41,584.68586692 --> 00:10:48,100.68586692
So who's the even? As, in addition to whom? So as I've always kind of glancingly, I mean, we've encountered this Rashi so many times.
158
00:10:48,103.68586692 --> 00:10:57,122.68586692
I guess even I just thought it wasn't just his generation, even Noach, but now I think of it almost even the great Noach even like Rashi's talking to us.
159
00:10:57,555.68586692 --> 00:10:58,542.68586692
Everyone struggles with faith.
160
00:10:58,548.68586692 --> 00:11:05,433.68586692
Guess what? Af Noach mikhtaneh emunah, mikhtaneh emunah, right? Even Noach had his faith accompanied by doubt.
161
00:11:05,794.68586692 --> 00:11:09,435.68586692
It's I think the word af especially, as you highlighted, it's not in the Midrash.
162
00:11:09,864.68586692 --> 00:11:15,578.68586692
So af is to is laravos whom, and I think that it's a message to us, to the reader.
163
00:11:15,871.68586692 --> 00:11:30,436.68586692
Rashi's telling us even the great Noach, who was, you know, et ha-Elokim hisalek Noach, walked with God, he too, when push came to shove, and for 120 years he's building the teva and he's, in conversation with Hashem, even he harbored doubt alongside his faith.
164
00:11:30,458.68586692 --> 00:11:31,622.68586692
I just think that's a very profound idea.
165
00:11:31,889.68586692 --> 00:11:35,158.68586692
Yeah and I would also say your beautiful observation in another way.
166
00:11:35,615.68586692 --> 00:11:54,838.68586692
Even Noach, who Hashem spoke to directly- Mm right? Even Noach, who is this primordial figure, right? How could Adam and Chava sin, right? Hashem created them, right? But so Noach how could Noach doubt? Hashem spoke to him, literally and, but, but- Faith is not that simple.
167
00:11:55,211.68586692 --> 00:11:55,487.68586692
Yeah.
168
00:11:55,593.68586692 --> 00:11:56,690.68586692
So yeah, exactly.
169
00:11:56,810.68586692 --> 00:11:57,257.68586692
Beautiful.
170
00:11:57,720.68586692 --> 00:11:58,0.68586692
Yeah.
171
00:11:58,18.68586692 --> 00:12:00,206.68586692
It's it's, it just reinforces the point.
172
00:12:01,333.68586692 --> 00:12:13,726.68586692
I think it's important for people to know that leaders can be vulnerable, especially in matters of faith, and especially leaders who undergo difficulty and pain and trial and tribulation in their life, and, they're human beings too.
173
00:12:13,774.68586692 --> 00:12:15,416.68586692
Af Noach miktani emunah haya.
174
00:12:15,423.68586692 --> 00:12:17,958.68586692
Even Noach, who heard the tziyon from Hashem himself.
175
00:12:18,446.68586692 --> 00:12:36,736.68586692
Which I guess in turn beautifully tees up what I wanted to say, which is I want to share an insight from the Ohavei Yisroel Rabbi Avraham Yeshua Heshil of Apt the Apter Rebbe, who's known as the Ohavei Yisroel as the name of his Sefer HaTorah, but he is known as the the paradigm of Ahavat Yisroel.
176
00:12:36,921.68586692 --> 00:12:40,600.68586692
He always spoke about Ahavat Yisroel loving one's fellow Jews.
177
00:12:41,373.68586692 --> 00:12:42,720.68586692
There's an anecdote that I heard.
178
00:12:42,720.68586692 --> 00:12:50,574.68586692
I think I read it in one of Rabbi Lamb's sermons where the Apter Rebbe said to his Hasidim, "There's Ahavat Yisroel in every parasha in the Torah."
179
00:12:50,737.68586692 --> 00:12:55,464.68586692
And the Hasidim said to him, "What about Parshas Balak? The Klal Yisrael isn't even in Parshas Balak.
180
00:12:55,876.68586692 --> 00:12:58,44.68586692
It's the only parsha in the Torah with no Jews in it."
181
00:12:58,490.68586692 --> 00:13:03,664.68586692
So, the Ohev Yisrael looked at them and said, "The word Balak is Roshei Teivos Ve'ahavta Lereiacha Kamocha."
182
00:13:04,235.68586692 --> 00:13:07,306.68586692
And they said, it's a vet, not a vav.
183
00:13:07,307.68586692 --> 00:13:08,368.68586692
It's a kuf, not a kaf.
184
00:13:08,374.68586692 --> 00:13:09,987.68586692
You can't say it's Roshei Teivos Ve'ahavta Lereiacha Kamocha."
185
00:13:10,315.68586692 --> 00:13:12,286.68586692
And he said, "When it comes to Ahavas Yisrael, don't be so makpid.
186
00:13:12,302.68586692 --> 00:13:15,731.68586692
When it comes to loving your fellow Jew, you shouldn't be so exacting on the words of the Torah."
187
00:13:15,736.68586692 --> 00:13:21,473.68586692
The Ohev Yisrael was someone who very much believed and spoke about and championed Ahavas Yisrael, loving our fellow Jew.
188
00:13:21,475.68586692 --> 00:13:23,652.68586692
We could use a little bit of that nowadays.
189
00:13:24,50.68586692 --> 00:13:25,684.68586692
Anyway, back to the pasuk.
190
00:13:25,696.68586692 --> 00:13:32,495.68586692
So the Ohev Yisrael also offers a comment on this Rashi and says something really so insightful and astute and beautiful.
191
00:13:32,819.68586692 --> 00:13:40,417.68586692
"We know," he says, "one basic truism of the world is," I suppose in the words of Herzl, "Im tirtzu ein zu agada.
192
00:13:40,450.68586692 --> 00:13:47,349.68586692
If you will it, it's not a dream, that when you
believe something will happen, you can will it into existence."
193
00:13:47,354.68586692 --> 00:13:57,294.68586692
When you actually really put your mind to something, you really truly believe, not like in a mystical metaphysical way, but when you really, really believe true down to your core that something's gonna happen, it'll happen.
194
00:13:57,526.68586692 --> 00:14:00,623.68586692
How is that not mystical and metaphysical? Maybe he means it mystical metaphysical.
195
00:14:00,623.68586692 --> 00:14:15,122.68586692
How do you mean it not in a mystical and metaphysical way to manifest something in the world? The way I think of that is that you will you will place your efforts and your determination and your time and your talents and your resources towards making something happen, you're more likely to make it happen.
196
00:14:15,153.68586692 --> 00:14:19,939.68586692
I suppose the Opta Rebbe probably meant in a more mystical way so thank you for that correction.
197
00:14:19,943.68586692 --> 00:14:35,542.68586692
But he said it is for that reason that Noach chose not to believe in the coming of the Mabul, because he thought, If maybe my faith waffles a little bit, if maybe I don't fully believe that it will come, maybe it won't come."
198
00:14:36,12.68586692 --> 00:14:40,245.68586692
And because of that, he was mikhtanei emunah, maamin ve'aino maamin.
199
00:14:40,255.68586692 --> 00:14:45,79.68586692
He thought maybe he can ward off the waters of the flood by being mikhtanei emunah.
200
00:14:45,453.68586692 --> 00:14:57,167.68586692
Certainly not the pshat of the Rashi, but I think what it also does is it invites us to read the Torah and the mefarshei ha-Torah charitably towards the heroes of the Torah.
201
00:14:57,351.68586692 --> 00:15:11,531.68586692
And of course, the heroes of the Torah are human, and they make mistakes, and we shouldn't gloss over those mistakes, and we shouldn't ignore the fact that maybe Noach lacked faith or was small of faith, or if that is indeed a deficiency as we've spoken about.
202
00:15:11,538.68586692 --> 00:15:26,177.68586692
But the Oy Yisroel goes out of his way to actually look at this not as a bug, but as a feature, and I think that is something that we can always be reminded of, not just in terms of our reading of the Torah and its characters, but our approach and attitude towards others in the world.
203
00:15:26,505.68586692 --> 00:15:35,361.68586692
We should see the very best in people, and even things that sometimes look like deficiencies, if we look hard enough, actually might reveal something beautiful, and that's what it means to have Abba Yisroel.
204
00:15:36,467.68586692 --> 00:15:44,44.15746821
Going back to your ha'arah here it also brings into stark relief the fact that there's faith in Hashem that he will actually bring the Mabul.
205
00:15:44,334.15746821 --> 00:15:51,549.15746821
There's also faith in humanity that they could turn the tide and, no pun intended actually, and avoid the Mabul.
206
00:15:51,810.15746821 --> 00:16:01,27.15746821
So there is a zero-sum game in some sense between whether Hashem is going to bring the Mabul and I have faith in the Mabul versus whether I have faith that humanity could redeem itself.
207
00:16:01,213.15746821 --> 00:16:22,261.15746821
So one of the critiques that we have, we contrast the Tevah of Noach and the Tevah of Moshe, and that Noach was a, what we call a tzadik in pelts, and he wasn't concerned about other peo- But the notion that, Ad yom oso techakelo, that he was somehow holding out hope, that humanity- Yeah Could be redeemed, could redeem itself, and that the gezirah could be ripped up is, it's just another side of the coin.
208
00:16:22,271.15746821 --> 00:16:23,541.15746821
There's faith in man, there's faith in God.
209
00:16:23,581.15746821 --> 00:16:29,98.15746821
They're not usually pitted against each other in the same way, but here it really is like a question of one versus the other.
210
00:16:29,110.15746821 --> 00:16:31,92.15746821
So I thought your point- Yeah makes that clear.
211
00:16:31,537.15746821 --> 00:16:31,825.15746821
Yeah.
212
00:16:32,392.15746821 --> 00:16:36,385.15746821
Yeah I don't think Rashi or the Midrash is speaking psychologically.
213
00:16:36,388.15746821 --> 00:16:45,10.1574682
They're talking about Emunah, but I think there is a parallel where, some things are just either so difficult or so fantastic to imagine that you just, you can't wrap your head around it.
214
00:16:45,70.1574682 --> 00:16:53,411.1574682
Like sometimes when people, unfortunately, people suffer a bereavement or something where, people will say "It's just, it's not real," right? "I just, this is surreal."
215
00:16:53,967.1574682 --> 00:17:02,805.1574682
And what that means sometimes is that a person may know something intellectually, cognitively, but emotionally they just still can't accept it.
216
00:17:02,854.1574682 --> 00:17:13,340.1574682
And it could also just make space for this notion that sometimes there are events, there are things that are just so unbelievable, it really just takes time to fully accept that this thing has happened.
217
00:17:13,340.1574682 --> 00:17:13,356.1574682
Mm-hmm.
218
00:17:13,732.1574682 --> 00:17:15,599.1574682
Again, this is a psychological observation.
219
00:17:15,677.1574682 --> 00:17:18,288.1574682
I don't think that's what the Midrash is saying, but I think it's a parallel.
220
00:17:18,409.1574682 --> 00:17:18,809.1574682
Beautiful.
221
00:17:18,952.1574682 --> 00:17:19,266.1574682
Shkoyach.
222
00:17:19,498.1574682 --> 00:17:19,814.1574682
Shkoyach.
223
00:17:19,814.1574682 --> 00:17:20,228.1574682
Shkoyach everyone.
224
00:17:21,295.1574682 --> 00:17:24,10.1574682
We got a lot of, we s- This was a good one we squeezed a lot of juice out of this Rashi.