TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
CATHERINE BARBER: I think this system allows you to ask questions with specificity and to rely not on ideology, but on letting the lessons of the dead inform what you're doing to save the living.
SOPHIA MEADOR: From the American Public Health Association, I'm Sophia Meador and this is The Nation’s Health Podcast.
Violent deaths are more common than many people in the U.S. may realize. In fact, homicide is the leading cause of death for pregnant women, firearm injuries are among the top causes of death for young people, and suicide ranks the second leading cause of death for Americans ages 10 to 34.
For years, these tragedies existed only as statistics. But through the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's National Violent Death Reporting System, researchers are uncovering the stories the systemic neglect, and the missed opportunities that connect the dots behind these numbers — and may help prevent future loss.
BARBER: Oh, my God, it's put us just head and shoulders above where we were.
MEADOR: That's Catherine Barber. She helped design and test the pilot for the National Violent Death Reporting System.
BARBER: We're getting such rich information on the circumstances and what was on board for the victim.
MEADOR: Catherine. Thank you so much for joining us today. It's really an honor to have you here.
Violent deaths are all too common in the U.S., but what exactly does that look like? And how does National Violent Death Reporting System give public health researchers a clear picture of victims' deaths?
It's all homicides and suicides by any method, and then, in addition, injury deaths of unknown intent and accidental or unintentional firearm deaths. It combines data from the death certificate on the victim's demographics, education, occupation, things like that; the police report, including information about the weapon, the circumstances, the perpetrator if it's a homicide or other inflicted accident; and also the coroner or medical examiner's report, including any post mortem test results and the death investigator's report on the circumstances of the death.
So how do public health workers use National Violent Death Reporting System to prevent deaths?
BARBER: One way that you can use it is by looking at very narrow types of cases.
Like, say, you're looking at suicides that occur at shooting ranges. Now that's a very rare type of death, but nobody cares about it more than the people who run shooting ranges. They're the people who can put that information to use in trying to avoid the death.
Another example might be helium suicides, where we saw a big increase in those. And the thing that's so wonderful about NVDRS is that you're getting not just coded data, but you're getting narratives. The abstractor who's collecting the data and reading the reports writes up an incident narrative explaining the circumstances, and so as a researcher, when you go in and read those, you get a lot of insight on the cases that you can then pass along to
Load full transcript
custodians of the places where you might implement prevention policies.
MEADORL Together with the Joyce Foundation, APHA honored two researchers with the Catherine Barber Research Award. The award, named after Barber’s lasting contributions to violence prevention, honors leaders who are advancing the science of violence and suicide prevention.
Research on violent deaths is essential to creating prevention policies that actually save lives. Men of color are far more likely to be victims of crime and violence. Sean Stielow, an MD, MPH student at Emory University's Rollins School of Public Health and a Research Award recipient, knows this reality all too well.
SEAN STIELOW: I first became interested in this topic when I was working as a public health intern in the DeKalb County Medical Examiner's Office.
So as an intern, I not only was able to look at the mortality data, but I was also able to assist with autopsies, and I honestly saw within the two or three months that I was there that there were a lot of young Black men that were coming through the office that had died either by suicide or gun deaths.
I was a teacher in Camden, New Jersey. I taught a lot of young Black boys. This could have been my students. This could have been my family, my friends, and in other circumstances, this could have been me.
MEADOR: And based on your research, Sean, what systems are factors focused on when addressing violent deaths in this population?
STIELOW: First, I hope that everyone gets access to health care. I think health care is a basic human right. And then thinking about, okay, now that people have access to health care and are able to get healthy, how can we ensure that their health and well being extends beyond health care access?
So thinking in terms of the social determinants of health — education, housing, employment — because, again, health is more than just being healthy and going to the doctor's office.
MEADOR: How do you think studying violent deaths can inform real world interventions?
So while I was working as a public health intern in the DeKalb County Medical Examiner's Office, I had the opportunity to sit in on the Child Fatality Review teams, and this was a meeting, maybe monthly, of professionals from all different backgrounds — Children's Hospital, the DeKalb County Medical Examiner's Office, the district attorney, public safety. And essentially what they would do is examine child deaths that had happened within a certain amount of time, and then they would decide if the death was preventable or not preventable, and oftentimes it was preventable.
And then they would think about, okay, what can we do to ensure that this death does not happen to anyone else? So they would think about changing policies and practices within the various systems to ensure that children are not dying by the same causes as the child that died when they were presenting the case.
MEADOR: Finally, what lasting impact do you hope this research has?
First and foremost, I'm hoping my research can kind of reduce the preventable deaths of young Black men down the line by increasing health care access and increasing economic opportunity for this population.
MEADOR: Like Sean, Millan AbiNader became interested in studying violent deaths after working directly with communities deeply affected by them.
She's an assistant professor at the University of Pennsylvania School of Social Policy and Practice, and a recipient of the Catherine Barber Research Award.
Intimate partner violence alone claims nearly 1,300 lives a year and results in more than 2 million injuries. Millan’s work underscores just how urgent and far reaching this public health issue remains.
ABINADER: So when I'm studying gender based violence, which is so often thought of as an individual problem or, at best, a family problem, it often ignores the environment and how the environment impacts the violence itself from happening in the first place.
MEADOR: How can National Violent Death Reporting System inform real world interventions?
ABINADER: When looking at suicides that occur in the context of intimate partner violence. One of the things that we're seeing is a lack of record that traditional IPV interventions are being used in large proportions. So those would be protection orders and contact with law enforcement. It doesn't mean they're not happening, but they're not captured in the formal data.
And what we are seeing are contacts with mental health providers and with hospitals when someone’s experiencing escalating suicidality. And so one of the interventions that I'm working on, based from this data, is trying to think about when someone comes into the emergency department with suicidal ideation, are we asking questions about intimate partner violence, whether they are presenting as a victim or presenting as a perpetrator? Do we have interventions to address the violence as well as the suicidal ideation?
Because in the context of intimate partner violence, the violence is just as risky as the suicidal ideation, and typically, when someone comes into the hospital with suicidal ideation, that becomes the primary focus because it's dangerous and there's imminent harm.
I think we need to create more robust interventions in the hospital so that we're asking about intimate partner violence and connecting people to appropriate resources, whether they are experiencing violence as a victim or are perpetrating that violence, so that the precipitating factor, the contributing factor of violence to the suicidal ideation, is being addressed, and hopefully then both pieces will decrease.
MEADOR: How does your work with National Violent Death Reporting System advance social justice, particularly around intimate partner violence?
ABINADER: The number one thing the NVDRS does is it allows us to have an adequate sample to ask questions related to social justice, related to equity, and to try to decrease violence in our communities.
One of the hardest things about studying intimate partner violence is getting an adequate sample size to say anything, to have enough power to drive your statistical methods so that you can tell differences between groups. And it's particularly hard with certain sub populations that might be harder to contact or harder to find, or may exist at smaller proportions. And so then the proportion of that proportion that experiences IPV is a very small group.
So that means we miss lots of different details related to equity and to justice, because we just can't get the sample at the size where we can actually ask the questions we want to ask.
MEADOR: Because of National Violent Death Reporting System and the researchers behind it, better policies, systems and interventions can save countless lives.
BARBER: I think this system allows you to ask questions with specificity and to rely not on ideology, but on letting the lessons of the dead inform what you're doing to save the living.
With NVDRS, you're getting such a multifaceted look at the problem. You can take the tools of the scientists to ask questions, but you can also work with prevention people on the ground to say, okay, what will work for your community to help prevent these cases?
MEADOR: Thanks to the Joyce Foundation for sponsoring this episode.