TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:06.140
Most people in this country, including the conservatives that we met, see themselves as fundamentally pro-democracy.
2
00:00:06.320 --> 00:00:18.480
You would hear in some of these conversations a deep belief that the left is imposing their own values on American society in ways that are fundamentally illiberal.
3
00:00:18.580 --> 00:00:24.900
And you see people looking at that and saying, "Why would I stand up for this institution? This institution is not actually serving me," in a very kind of direct way.
4
00:00:25.060 --> 00:00:35.420
And I think oftentimes people are thinking about, "How do I ensure that I get the outcomes that I want?" It's a little bit of, do you wanna be right or do you wanna be effective, to say it a little bit more concisely.
5
00:00:36.860 --> 00:00:43.830
Welcome to the liberalism.org show. I'm Aaron Ross Powell, senior director of liberal projects at the Institute for Humane Studies.
6
00:00:44.240 --> 00:00:53.700
And I'm joined today by Scott Warren, a fellow at the SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University, and Morgan Ramsay Elliott, a partner at Red Associates.
7
00:00:55.140 --> 00:00:59.480
When we worry about democracy on this show, we usually mean institutions and norms.
8
00:01:00.060 --> 00:01:13.170
Scott and Morgan spent weeks embedded with conservative Americans in Wyoming, Michigan, and South Carolina, and found that many of them judge those institutions against something prior, what they call faith, family, freedom, and place.
9
00:01:13.960 --> 00:01:26.740
Scott and Morgan's liberalism.org essay, Can Democracy Survive If We Stand On Different Foundations, drawing on their major new ethnographic study, argues that's why save democracy tends to fall flat.
10
00:01:27.620 --> 00:01:39.300
We get into what conservative moral foundations actually are, whether they leave room for a pluralistic society, and what it would take to build institutions people with very different perspectives can still trust.
11
00:01:42.640 --> 00:01:54.040
What prompted this survey? What was the question that you guys were trying to answer by doing this work? Yeah, I can, I can start in on that and, and, and great to be here.
12
00:01:54.440 --> 00:02:14.989
Uh, we at the Agora Institute have spent a lot of time over the last few years working with conservatives interested in building trust in institutions, a lot specifically on, on trust in elections and figuring out how can we make elections more trustworthy and, and ensure that people trust elections,
13
00:02:15.920 --> 00:02:20.079
and have done a lot of quantitative work to, to try to understand that.
14
00:02:20.300 --> 00:02:33.660
Uh, and a lot of, of folks in the pro-democracy field have done, done similar work where we'll do polling and studies to figure out what are the messages and, and messengers that, that resonate most with, with the conservative electorate.
15
00:02:34.130 --> 00:02:40.220
I think there's some value
Load full transcript
utility there. We'll ke- we'll continue to do the, the quantitative work. There's also limited value.
16
00:02:40.269 --> 00:02:51.240
One, one of the things I, I often say is, in survey after survey after survey, you find that the most trusted messenger that can talk about elections is firefighters.
17
00:02:51.720 --> 00:02:57.440
But if you talk to election administrators, they never have firefighters actually talk about elections. It's not something that happens, right?
18
00:02:57.460 --> 00:03:01.480
So there's a lack of utility in, in terms of what some of that research is showing.
19
00:03:01.500 --> 00:03:10.820
And so we had met the, the Red folks, uh, actually at an IHS, at an IHS conference, and so, so you are, are all to, to, to, to take credit for, uh, the matchmaking.
20
00:03:11.300 --> 00:03:30.870
And really intrigued by the ethnographic approach, which Morgan can talk through more, and just thought that this would be a really interesting way to go deeper into how conservatives think about institutions in a way that, uh, that, that, uh, that, that just takes us a level deeper than some of the quantitative polling.
21
00:03:30.980 --> 00:03:40.700
Uh, and hopefully, which I think happened, it's not that, um, we, we knew this would happen, but, but pushes and tests some of the assumption that the quote unquote pro-democracy space has.
22
00:03:40.720 --> 00:03:51.100
And so that, that's what I think motivated some of this is, um, is, is wanting to go, uh, deeper than, um, than, than, uh, than, than some of the quantitative work has, had allowed us to go.
23
00:03:52.340 --> 00:03:57.740
Morgan, do you wanna talk about what that ethnographic research looks like? Yeah, happy to.
24
00:03:57.820 --> 00:04:21.500
So, um, very core to the ethnographic approach is the idea that, um, you as a researcher need to take a lot of your assumptions that you have about your participants, about the communities that you're going into, and kind of put them on the shelf and park them for a moment, and really try to understand people on their own terms in the context that they actually inhabit on a day-to-day basis.
25
00:04:21.560 --> 00:04:33.580
So, um, for-- So a lot of our work, uh, just for, for kind of broader context involves that kind of research, right? So we go out and we study people, um, in, in their nat- kind of natural environments.
26
00:04:33.600 --> 00:04:39.080
So that means going to church services with them. That means going to cattle sales. It means going to gun shows.
27
00:04:39.120 --> 00:04:58.360
It means, in the, in the context of this conservatives work, really kind of spending time with people in their homes, in their communities, um, you know, going to work with them in some cases, really observing all these different contexts that they, that they go through and that kind of matter to them to try and understand how do institutions show up for them, right?
28
00:04:58.480 --> 00:05:06.160
When we talk about institutions
in the pro-democracy space, we have a certain set of ideas about what that includes and what those mean.
29
00:05:06.220 --> 00:05:17.920
We want to understand for actual people kind of living their lives, how do these institutions show up? Um, what are the spaces that kind of feel political to them? How do they talk about politics?
30
00:05:18.290 --> 00:05:28.040
And even more importantly, kind of what are the underlying drivers for that, right? From a community perspective, from a cultural perspective, from a kind of societal perspective, what is, is kind of,
31
00:05:28.960 --> 00:05:42.320
um, underneath a lot of those kind of surface level perceptions of politics and democratic institutions? So this is a much deeper, more laborious version of, say, The New York Times, we talk to people in diners
32
00:05:43.680 --> 00:05:45.820
kind of thing. Yes, I would say so.
33
00:05:45.860 --> 00:06:06.130
So in, in this case, we spent, you know, weeks, um, in these communities, both in, in Wyoming and South Carolina and, and Michigan, um, really spending a lot of time not just with an individual, but also their whole-- their family and the other pe- their friends, their colleagues, uh, the kind of in, in broader social ecosystems that, that end up having a big impact on how they think about politics.
34
00:06:07.424 --> 00:06:18.764
I want to get to the findings because it's really interesting stuff. But I'm just curious first, how did you pick those communities? We wanted a cross-section of places that would offer
35
00:06:19.824 --> 00:06:29.444
some diversity of thought and also ideally places where we had some existing relationships. Uh, I think one of the, the,
36
00:06:30.444 --> 00:06:41.944
the, the keys to this work is you wanna, you wanna find people that know people that know people to actually get you some of the, the participants. Um, and so we chose rural Wyoming.
37
00:06:43.084 --> 00:06:52.404
We've done a lot of work in, in, in Wyoming through SNF Agora, through our partnership with, with R Street. We've done a number of convenings there and, and so know of a, a number of folks on the ground.
38
00:06:52.984 --> 00:07:06.004
Um, Ottawa County, Michigan, um, which is, which is close to, to Grand Rapids. And, um, and, and we've also done, we've done work with the, the Ottawa County Clerk and, and have relationships there.
39
00:07:06.064 --> 00:07:12.044
And to be in the, the, the Midwest, the Rust Belt, a different type of, of, of conversation there.
40
00:07:12.074 --> 00:07:23.584
And then in Greenville, South Carolina, we had some partners on the ground there and, and doing, uh, some work in, in the South in a little bit more of a suburban population offered, um, some different insights too.
41
00:07:23.724 --> 00:07:41.244
So you look at, you know, Wyoming, Michigan, and South Carolina, I think one of the, the, the lessons that, that we wanna make sure comes out of this research, this is not meant to be a fully representative sample of we understand conservatives in the United States and their, and their perceptions of institutions right now.
42
00:07:41.284 --> 00:07:46.434
But thought that this was, uh, enough of a, of a sampling that, that, that would be useful.
43
00:07:46.484 --> 00:07:56.264
The other thing I will say is that we've done existing quantitative work at Agora where we've tried to understand what are different demarcators, ways to break down the conservative electorate.
44
00:07:56.564 --> 00:08:04.684
Um, prior to twenty twenty-four, we looked at, uh, Republicans that believed that Trump had won the twenty twenty election versus those that believed that Biden had won.
45
00:08:04.704 --> 00:08:09.804
It was about two-thirds that thought that Trump had won and one-third that believed that Biden had won. They, they acted in different ways.
46
00:08:09.864 --> 00:08:20.764
Most supported, uh, and, and voted for Donald Trump, but, but they had different media diets, they had different perceptions toward, towards out party, they had different perceptions toward, um, towards other leaders.
47
00:08:21.084 --> 00:08:29.264
We had done some quantitative work with a group called Public Agenda earlier this year trying to figure out are there different questions that break up the Republican electorate.
48
00:08:29.444 --> 00:08:34.884
We found that one that did was asking, "Do you think the president should be able to ignore court rulings to advance his own agenda?"
49
00:08:35.714 --> 00:08:40.704
A third of Republicans said yes, a third of Republicans said no, a third of Republicans said unsure.
50
00:08:41.424 --> 00:08:48.524
Again, most supported Donald Trump, but you had different media diets, different ways of, of conceiving of the moment from those folks.
51
00:08:48.964 --> 00:09:00.644
Um, and so when Morgan can talk through the recruitment process, uh, but there was an, uh, there was an over-indexing on those that said unsure, um, just as a way to, to, to get at what, what actually animates some of, some of those folks.
52
00:09:00.684 --> 00:09:07.614
But so that's, that's both how we chose the communities and, and how we, um, how we got at the individuals. There's more that, that you want to say on that, Morgan? Yeah.
53
00:09:07.664 --> 00:09:18.974
I would just say that, um, uh, as Scott mentioned, overall, we were trying to kind of look for the most important kind of angles and cuts on the broader kind of conservative population of the U.S., right?
54
00:09:19.144 --> 00:09:30.374
So, um, you know, s- all of our participants identified as conservative or Republican or both, and of course, that, you know, how they self-identified become a, became a big part of discussions with us when we were in the field.
55
00:09:31.104 --> 00:09:38.284
Um, because as we all know, there's a lot of hot takes on what it means to be Republican, what it means to be conservative, what it means to be MAGA, et cetera, et cetera.
56
00:09:38.644 --> 00:09:48.094
Um,
and so we were looking for, you know, different angles on that. Um, and then we were also looking for, you know, for example, a mix of, uh, representative, um,
57
00:09:49.324 --> 00:09:58.904
SKUs when it comes to, like, things like age and gender and income, education level, and things like that. So what'd you find?
58
00:09:59.764 --> 00:10:03.964
Like, I guess two, two ways of answering this, I think, um, or two ways to frame the question.
59
00:10:04.084 --> 00:10:12.564
One is, like, the overall takeaways, um, and the other, I suppose, is among those, was there anything that really surprised you?
60
00:10:13.584 --> 00:10:19.984
I mean, I can start at a high level, and then, and then Morgan take, can take specifics and, and maybe starting with the, the latter question.
61
00:10:20.024 --> 00:10:27.263
I think one of the, the most important findings, and I don't know if this is surprising or not, um, is just that, uh,
62
00:10:28.884 --> 00:10:40.064
most people in this country, including the, the conservatives that we met, see themselves as fundamentally pro-democracy. Now, they might use different language. They might articulate that in different ways.
63
00:10:40.544 --> 00:10:52.844
Um, but, but folks are not, um, uh, are not actively in favor of some different form of government, um, some, some more authoritarian form of government. And I think this is one...
64
00:10:53.024 --> 00:10:56.604
Th- there's, there's sort of a quote unquote pro-democracy ecosystem.
65
00:10:56.624 --> 00:11:12.284
And even some of the work that Agora's done in the past where we talk about pro-democracy conservatives, just not a good lens to use because, um, you know, most, most, uh, Americans, uh, in addition to, to the conservatives that, that, that we work with fundamentally see themselves as pro-democracy.
66
00:11:12.324 --> 00:11:21.444
They don't love the word democracy, and we can, we can get into that. I think some of that is nomenclature and some of that's substantive when you, when you hear, um, sort of republic versus, versus democracy.
67
00:11:21.524 --> 00:11:33.564
So I think that, um, uh, that, that, that that's, um, uh, that that's important. I mean, these people are, are highly invested in, in, in civic life. They have high reverence for, for the Constitution.
68
00:11:34.044 --> 00:11:45.903
Um, and, and so the, the other thing that, that I think came up loud and clear that we talk about in the report is this notion of, um, a, a, a moral foundation.
69
00:11:46.004 --> 00:11:57.344
Um, and what, what we mean by a moral foundation, and this came up in interview after interview, is, um, uh, there's, there's sort of a three-tiered mental model of democracy, um, that, that a lot of these conservatives have.
70
00:11:57.404 --> 00:12:01.824
And at the base, so at the, the most important part of this, is this moral foundation.
71
00:12:01.864 --> 00:12:13.344
And some of this might be, um, aspects that are, um, you know, that, that, that are, that are, um, uh, that are, that are clear to conservative life generally, but talk about faith, family, freedom, place.
72
00:12:14.204 --> 00:12:20.860
Everything else is judged on whether- Democracy is delivering on those four pillars.
73
00:12:20.980 --> 00:12:32.860
Um, is democracy actually delivering, um, the, the, the, the, the type of society that can le- live up to what these folks would call, um, you know, a Christian, Christian society, Christian values?
74
00:12:33.420 --> 00:12:38.460
Um, you know, is, is the natural social order that, that comes from family upheld?
75
00:12:39.340 --> 00:12:57.240
Um, is, um, uh, is, is freedom and, and the individual's right to be left alone something that, that, that government gets out of the way to allow for, um, and is place in, in sort of that bedrock principle of connecting to a specific community something that, um, you know, is, is part of that too?
76
00:12:57.280 --> 00:13:05.140
Everything else flows from that. And so the second model, we, we sort of had more formal, um, constitutional apparatuses and, and the third was democratic norms and conventions.
77
00:13:05.960 --> 00:13:12.070
Um, they have to, according to conservatives, deliver for that moral foundation.
78
00:13:12.440 --> 00:13:40.010
If they are not in service of that moral foundation, they are not actually delivering what they should be, which is a, which is one way of, of thinking that a lot of the, the language of we need to save democracy or democracy is at risk does not land, um, because a lot of these folks feel that America has become untethered through that moral foundation, and it's become-- if it's become untethered, um, that there might have to be more drastic means to take to actually get to, to that moral foundation.
79
00:13:40.120 --> 00:13:47.040
So I think that that, that's something we can, we can go through specific examples, but again, being in this pro-democracy space, a lot of times people
80
00:13:47.980 --> 00:13:58.120
will, um, will, will try to focus on those norms, will try to say, "Oh, it's important that, um, you know, that we have rule of law. It's important that we have free and fair elections.
81
00:13:58.180 --> 00:14:09.000
It's important that our leaders act in a certain way." And I think for a lot of these folks would be like, "It's important that we live in a society that upholds this moral foundation.
82
00:14:09.050 --> 00:14:16.840
If it doesn't, then what's the point of these norms?" Um, they're, you know, not baked into anything, and so we might need to, to think in different ways.
83
00:14:17.080 --> 00:14:25.040
Um, so, so I think that that's, that's, you know, the, the, the principle, uh, I, I think some of the most important findings of the research and some implications of
84
00:14:26.080 --> 00:14:33.980
let's think through different ways to potentially reach folks that aren't anchoring on those democratic norms. Yeah, maybe just to build on that.
85
00:14:34.200 -->
00:14:48.660
Um, I think that there are also a bunch of really interesting, um, observations about how institutions, especially kind of on the, on the ground for people, really are failing them, right?
86
00:14:48.800 --> 00:14:54.760
I think a lot of folks in the, in the kind of pro-democracy space, again, talk about the value of institutions in this very kind of abstract way.
87
00:14:55.560 --> 00:15:02.180
Um, and again, talk about, well, we need to be preserving these democratic institutions for their own sake, which is probably true.
88
00:15:02.720 --> 00:15:12.630
But when you actually look at the experience of those institutions by people, right, how they actually show up for them in their day-to-day life, in a lot of cases, they're actually not doing a very good job, right?
89
00:15:12.660 --> 00:15:22.640
And you see people, um, uh, in, in a lot of cases, I think for very reasonable reasons, looking at that and saying, "Why would I, why would I do-- why would I stand up for this institution?
90
00:15:22.680 --> 00:15:31.980
This institution is not actually serving me in a very kind of direct way." So I think that's also one of the, um, again, probably for folks who really study this stuff in, in depth all the time, maybe less surprising.
91
00:15:32.360 --> 00:15:48.300
Um, but I think for the, for the broader discourse around pro-democracy and, and the kind of pro-democracy space, um, it is a really important thing to remember, which is like, you know, w-we do actually need to address whether or not these institutions are actually working for people or not.
92
00:15:48.440 --> 00:15:53.300
So I'm, I'm struck by kind of the, call it like the ideological valence of this.
93
00:15:53.350 --> 00:16:03.720
So this is, you know, a show on a website called liberalism.org, and we care about it's not just democracy, but liberal democracy specifically is... And
94
00:16:04.820 --> 00:16:18.200
Scott, as you were describing this, would it be fair to characterize the worldview as something like an pro-democracy, but in an illiberal sense?
95
00:16:18.520 --> 00:16:31.920
Because what you're describing is they want, they want a world that conforms to a certain set of Christian values, has a certain perspective on the family, and is g- like have natural structures that flow out of that.
96
00:16:31.980 --> 00:16:48.300
And those seem like you could take those as fairly, they can anti-pluralistic views, that democracy is good when it produces a certain kind of life, and when it doesn't produce or enable or support that kind of life, then it's
97
00:16:49.300 --> 00:17:03.050
failing. But that seems like a fairly illiberal view about just living in kind of a pluralistic, large, dynamic, and open society. Is that a fair reading, or is that a misreading of, of the views that you guys found?
98
00:17:03.920 --> 00:17:06.780
It's a good question, and I think the distinction between
99
00:17:08.000 --> 00:17:22.240
liberal democracy and illiberal democracy is, is, is one in, in which, um, I mean, you, you might take an example of Orbán's Hungary as, as more of an illiberal democracy where he's, he was pushing some of these, these, these
100
00:17:23.880 --> 00:17:33.940
Judeo-Christian values, um, potentially at, at risk of, of having that more pluralistic society. Uh, I can't speak, and, and, and Morgan can, can weigh on this too. I mean, I can't speak for, for all of our participants.
101
00:17:34.420 --> 00:17:41.300
I don't know if they would charac-- I mean, I don't think they would characterize themselves as being illiberal or anti-pluralist. I, I think they'd use different language.
102
00:17:41.400 --> 00:17:57.740
I think that they fundamentally believe in the importance of, uh, a society that engages with each other. I think that they think that that needs to be based on a moral foundation that has become untethered.
103
00:17:58.140 --> 00:17:59.480
And so I, I don't...
104
00:17:59.540 --> 00:18:17.440
I think it's, it's a little bit more, I mean, if you wanna go deeper down this sort of liberal democracy versus illiberal democracy, I would venture to say that a lot of these folks would say, "In order to have a liberal democracy, we have to ensure that there are certain values that we all abide by.
105
00:18:18.080 --> 00:18:28.850
And if, b- if we're not abiding by those values, it's difficult to be on that moral foundation." I think on the left, you might hear different- Different, uh,
106
00:18:29.750 --> 00:18:41.670
different semblances of this as well, which is we need to be on the same moral foundation of abiding by these democratic norms, and if we can't abide by these democratic norms, then we can't live in, in a, in a liberal democracy.
107
00:18:41.710 --> 00:18:58.590
So I think that the, the, the, the belief that we should live in a pluralistic society is there. I think that there just would be a, um, a, a disagreement on do we have what is necessary and in place, um, in order to
108
00:18:59.490 --> 00:19:11.030
actually live there. I mean, the other thing that, that, that you would hear in some of these conversations is a deep belief that the left does not believe in liberalism.
109
00:19:11.090 --> 00:19:20.550
Again, not using those words, but is imposing their own values on American society in ways that are fundamentally illiberal.
110
00:19:21.030 --> 00:19:44.570
Um, I think that that's one of the challenges, a piece coming out with you, uh, with, with, with all, with all of you soon that sort of makes the case of, I think, a lot of times in, in these bridging dialogue initiatives, we're, we're talking about policy and how do we engage across policy differences, but there's something deeper in terms of are we actually thinking about different moral foundations and how do you engage across those deeper moral foundations?
111
00:19:44.630 --> 00:19:54.690
So maybe this is the deeper, more difficult work of pluralism, is not just engaging across difference,
but engaging across difference when there is a belief that,
112
00:19:55.750 --> 00:20:06.300
that, that the other, um, the other partisan political party in this case has those different moral foundations. So it's a long-winded way of saying I don't think that they would say that they
113
00:20:07.570 --> 00:20:13.030
believe in an illiberal democracy, but I think the ramifications of this are a little bit, um, a little bit more complex.
114
00:20:13.530 --> 00:20:39.590
Yeah, I think that that's right, and I would just add to it that I think a lot of that, um, where a lot of the conservatives we met are coming from is a, um, a real almost, like, existential fear that, um, that, that their kind of lifestyle and their perspective and, and that their values, honestly, are not being taken seriously by the institutions and processes that are kind of like the formal infrastructure of democracy.
115
00:20:39.710 --> 00:20:59.790
Um, so I think what, what they're trying to fight for from, from their perspective is, is probably, um, you know, more representation and more kind of, uh, ability to kind of advocate and to, and to be-- and have agency, um, in order to kind of advocate for themselves, um, in, within this kind of structures of democracy that we have today.
116
00:21:01.550 --> 00:21:13.410
Well, so that gets then to, Morgan, the, the point you raised earlier about the institutions and, and the perception that the people you all talk to have that the institutions are not working, are failing them.
117
00:21:13.750 --> 00:21:25.510
And I was curious as you were saying that what you or I guess they mean by not working. So does it mean two possibilities, and it might be both, it might be somewhere in between.
118
00:21:25.530 --> 00:21:41.490
But, um, just for clarification purposes, one is they're failing because the institutions are not sufficiently supporting or might be actively undermining the kinds of moral foundations that they've identified.
119
00:21:41.550 --> 00:21:52.850
So the institutions are undermining places they've defined it in family and faith and, and so on. Um, so it's tied into that, like, broader kind of ideological and lifestyle preference worldview.
120
00:21:53.410 --> 00:21:54.840
The other one, though, might be like,
121
00:21:55.850 --> 00:22:04.970
"Man, my local Social Security office really sucks, and I have to sit in line forever, and the service is terrible," and like, "When I call for people to come and, like, fix the streets, it's not..."
122
00:22:05.070 --> 00:22:20.510
Like, much more kind of practical-minded. They're not delivering the goods. Is it more one than the other? Yeah, it's a good question. I, I think we see so many examples kind of covering that whole spectrum.
123
00:22:20.850 --> 00:22:36.910
Um, so for example, uh, one of our participants who features prominently in the report, um, she was a, a public school teacher for a while, and, um, so she had a lot of kind of reflections on the education
system.
124
00:22:37.050 --> 00:22:53.730
Um, and she-- I think a lot of her stories, um, were interesting in the sense that they showed us that, uh, there's a lot of very prosaic ways in which these institutions are, like, not, um, are basically not kind of demonstrating care for people as individuals.
125
00:22:53.810 --> 00:23:00.880
So for example, she talked a lot about, this part- particular participant, she talked a lot about how, um, you know, she grew up, uh,
126
00:23:01.900 --> 00:23:15.210
the, uh, the child of a single mother and h- you know, her family kind of had a lot of hard times growing up, and the church really kind of took her and her family in and, like, really kind of, like, did the good Christian work of, like, making sure that she was clothed and fed and all that stuff.
127
00:23:15.230 --> 00:23:30.930
And that had a very profound, um, effect on her, understandably, and she kinda started comparing other institutions in her life, democratic institutions, government institutions, up against that and basically recognizing, "Hey," like, "I'm not getting the kind of care that I was shown by the church," right?
128
00:23:30.960 --> 00:23:37.160
"I was not give-- I was not seen in the same way that the church kind of saw me. I was not heard in the way that the church kind of heard me," right?
129
00:23:37.590 --> 00:23:59.630
And so I think that, uh, underlying a lot of these, um, experiences that people have with institutions is that they are not feeling heard, they are not feeling recognized, they're not being kind of seen, um, in the way that they would want in order to, to feel like they actually should participate in them or should be kind of, um, you know, using them to their advantage to self-advocate and all these different things.
130
00:24:00.290 --> 00:24:07.930
Um, Scott, I'm curious what your take on that is. Yeah, I think-- I mean, I think that that's, I think that that's right.
131
00:24:08.010 --> 00:24:14.590
The, the other thing that I, I, I would say, because this came up in, in a, in a few different places, is, um,
132
00:24:15.490 --> 00:24:27.758
there's a sense of Well, if these institutions at the local level are failing me, even your example of like a local, a local DMV, there's no way they can work on the national level, right?
133
00:24:27.898 --> 00:24:44.938
And so I think that there's a sense of people wanting to know and have a sense of their, um, you know, of, of, of who these institutions are, and they feel like the more removed that they are, um, the less likely that, that they can, you know, that they can be, they can be trusted.
134
00:24:44.958 --> 00:24:51.778
Which I, which I think also goes into how some of these people are taking in information and their information ecosystems.
135
00:24:51.818 --> 00:25:00.798
They're, they're very skeptical of, uh, of everything, anything that reeks of having, um, uh, affiliation with some sort of institution because they think it's captured, right?
136
00:25:01.338 --> 00:25:07.318
Um, and so I think that that, um, you know, that's something that, that, that comes up frequently.
137
00:25:07.878 --> 00:25:19.128
Um, and so I think that some of these folks have, like Morgan's story, like very real stories of, of institutions at the local level that have failed them, um, and they'll, um,
138
00:25:20.058 --> 00:25:23.548
extrapolate that to, to, to broader, more national institutions.
139
00:25:23.618 --> 00:25:32.488
If this institution that's close to me is not working, um, then, then that's something that, um, that, that, you know, is, is, is not gonna have trust at the, the national level.
140
00:25:32.538 --> 00:25:47.038
Again, I think there's some interesting repercussions here because a lot of times, um, the, the protodemocracy community will-- I mean, it, it, it's difficult to think about how do you build trust in very local institutions, but that's where people are, are forming these levels of trust.
141
00:25:47.078 --> 00:26:00.098
And there's also sometimes, uh, a, a necessity to be, you know, in the election space, for example, to say, "Here, go and meet your local election administrator, your local clerk. You know them. You'll trust elections."
142
00:26:00.218 --> 00:26:10.038
But what might happen is that people will think, "Okay, I know, you know, I, I, I know this person, uh, and I, I trust my local elections in this place, but they're an exception to the rule.
143
00:26:10.078 --> 00:26:20.978
They're an exception to how captured and corrupted institutions are, so I'm not gonna trust everything just because I trust one person." So, um, I think that the, the, the, the frustration and the skepticism runs deep.
144
00:26:22.198 --> 00:26:39.698
I'm reminded of, there's a very good book that came out a few years ago, um, Trump's Democrats by John Shields and Stephanie Moravcsik, where they went to communities that had voted Democrat for like two hundred years or a hundred years or whatever, and then had flipped to Trump.
145
00:26:39.798 --> 00:26:47.138
And, um, and what they found was often these were communities where, like, the local governance was particularly corrupt and personalist.
146
00:26:47.238 --> 00:26:55.478
And, um, and so Trump kind of, to them, looked like some sense what they were used to in their local governing.
147
00:26:55.638 --> 00:27:10.138
Um, but it does seem like, that seems like a real problem for liberals trying to preserve a liberal democracy or defend it or make the case for it, is often local government is terrible. Um, and especially in, like,
148
00:27:11.218 --> 00:27:23.728
lower income rural communities, it's often really, really bad and corrupt. Um, so what do you do with that? And what do you do with that in the context of this information environment?
149
00:27:23.798 --> 00:27:26.258
Because that was the other thing I wanted to ask about, is
150
00:27:27.598 --> 00:27:45.298
it seems like a real problem if there's this sense that,
like, the high, what we might call the high quality sources of information in a society, like the, the high quality journalism outlets, um, high quality reporting, because it's coming from elite institutions,
151
00:27:46.478 --> 00:27:55.138
often necessarily because it's so expensive to do well, um, is by its nature, because it's coming from those institutions, untrustworthy.
152
00:27:55.278 --> 00:28:04.018
Therefore, we get the information from these other sources that are in fact profoundly untrustworthy, if not outright dishonest.
153
00:28:04.598 --> 00:28:17.318
Uh, but then that colors kind of your view of how the system's working and what it's doing to people like you, and, like, this just seems like a real knot to untangle. Is there-- How do we address that?
154
00:28:17.378 --> 00:28:27.818
Because it seems like you have to in order to get people on the same page of at least we should have democratic institutions. Yeah. I mean, to try to tackle both of those, first, on the
155
00:28:28.938 --> 00:28:47.738
local government not working, there, there were a few folks that explicitly talked about, for example, you know, in Wyoming, the, the Freedom Caucus has taken over the, the, the state legislature, and would say things like, um, you know, "I don't agree with them on, on everything, but, um, they'll take my call," or, "They seem like more normal people.
156
00:28:48.338 --> 00:28:50.798
Um, uh, and they respect me."
157
00:28:51.398 --> 00:29:09.798
Um, and, uh, you know, someone said that they overheard their local legislator, you know, talking to one person about their perspective on an issue in one way and talking to another person in another way, and said, "Well, I don't, I don't like the Freedom Caucus member, but at least I know that he's telling me what he actually believes," right?
158
00:29:10.278 --> 00:29:20.348
And so I, I think that this isn't, this isn't the solution to everything, but I, I do think that you have, and this is, I mean, we can talk about it, this has come up even in some of the reactions to the report, [chuckles]
159
00:29:20.858 --> 00:29:32.458
sometimes there's a sense from, uh, from the folks that we talked to and from conservatives that, you know, everybody else looks, looks, looks down on us, and sometimes that is true.
160
00:29:32.498 --> 00:29:36.938
Like, the response is, is, is, is true, and so they're acting in somewhat rational ways.
161
00:29:36.968 --> 00:29:51.318
And so I do think that there's, there's just-- I mean, to the, the, the point on liberalism, there, there's a, there's a importance of respecting fellow citizens in a way that, um, I think is being perceived that that's not happening and is not all, all, all the time is false.
162
00:29:51.378 --> 00:29:59.278
On the informa- I mean, I, I agree that the information, the, the bifurcation in terms of where people are getting their information is, is, is quite challenging.
163
00:30:00.058 --> 00:30:11.258
I think the, maybe the optimistic point here is that a lot of the folks are seeing themselves as we're going to do the work to figure out what is true and what is not true.
164
00:30:11.678 --> 00:30:21.998
Now, they might, I, I, I-- Some, I mean, some of the interviews are a part of people might sometimes think that they're smarter than the algorithm, and there's no one that's really smarter than the algorithm.
165
00:30:22.038 --> 00:30:33.236
And so, like, they might be actually Trying to articulate, you know, I've done the work, I'm gonna articulate talking points in my own way, but they're actually parroting talking points that come from specific places.
166
00:30:33.296 --> 00:30:40.206
But I think that there is something to people wanting to fund-- to find, um, unbiased information.
167
00:30:40.786 --> 00:30:47.806
Um, I, I teach college students, and actually one of the things that comes up, and I don't, I don't, I don't think this is good, but maybe it's not the worst thing in the world.
168
00:30:47.846 --> 00:30:56.166
They just assume that everything's biased now, so they don't trust anything. Um, and so you do have some of that coming up. I don't, I don't-- I mean, I don't have all of the solutions here.
169
00:30:56.206 --> 00:31:04.266
It's just something that is gonna be worth figuring out. I think, I think some of what we're pushing on with all of this is just recognizing that there's a problem.
170
00:31:04.586 --> 00:31:10.206
So recognizing there's a problem with talking down to people, recognizing there's a problem that mainstream institutions have.
171
00:31:10.306 --> 00:31:20.086
COVID, for example, came up all of the time because people would say our public officials and the media, the institutional media, was telling us one thing one day and something else another day.
172
00:31:20.666 --> 00:31:32.126
Um, so I think that recognizing and, and being clear, um, that, that people understand sort of the, the, the rationale behind some of the grievances is, is important too. Yeah.
173
00:31:32.186 --> 00:31:41.666
I think just one other thing to add to that is, is, you know, there's one set of, of media sources, which is the kind of the, the non-elite, right, that you were talking about, Aaron.
174
00:31:41.706 --> 00:31:48.226
So all, all of the kind of grassroots, um, kind of alternative media sources that, that do end up spreading misinformation for people.
175
00:31:48.906 --> 00:32:09.806
But then there's also another interesting thing that, that we saw, and I'm sure other researchers have seen this in their work as well, which is the role of the church in, um, kind of communicating different messages about democracy and how trustworthy democracy is and specific democratic institutions, everything from elections to, um, to democracy as a, as a kind of whole, uh, construct, right?
176
00:32:10.366 --> 00:32:25.126
And so what we saw is that there's a lo- and, you know, in, in some cases, um, pastors directly ministering to their congregations
about how they should be-- they should cultivate a sense of, of kind of skepticism toward the government and, and, uh, electoral processes and all sorts of different things.
177
00:32:25.186 --> 00:32:38.906
So I think, at least for us, that also was quite striking to see that it's not just the kind of formal media sources that are, um, channels for this kind of information, but also, um, churches, which are in a lot of cases like very trusted for all sorts of obvious reasons, right?
178
00:32:39.106 --> 00:32:49.706
Um, these are people who, um, th-these are people's congregations where they spend a lot of time with, with each other, uh, on a kind of weekly basis, and then they're, they're leaders in the community, um, the people who are ministering to them.
179
00:32:49.766 --> 00:33:01.146
So at least to us, that also seemed like an, a very interesting kind of, um, channel, but also potential lever for people who are kind of interested in bridge-building there. I'm curious what the response is to
180
00:33:02.886 --> 00:33:13.236
Americans who are, say, like more progressive and on the left who would read through this. And so, you know, the, the, the value of a study
181
00:33:14.206 --> 00:33:27.706
like what you guys have done is if we're going to have fru- if we're gonna participate in politics together, which is what democracy is, uh, we need to have a baseline level of actual understanding of each other.
182
00:33:28.136 --> 00:33:56.186
Um, and, and kind of to the extent that we can get into each other's heads and have that subjectivity, um, and view each other as subjects and not simply as objects we're competing against, is important, not just from the perspective of we're fellow humans sharing this world together and trying to do the best we can in it, but also we have to work together, and we have to persuade each other, and all of that depends upon a grounded understanding.
183
00:33:56.286 --> 00:34:11.786
Um, and they look at this and say, "Okay, like, that sounds great, but what I see in my life is racism and misogyny and nationalism and demands for control and, um..."
184
00:34:13.286 --> 00:34:17.866
And so how do I, how do I engage with that?
185
00:34:17.926 --> 00:34:32.186
Or how do I have sympathy or understanding or want to give more of a voice to people who are, say, like trying to round up my friends and deport them or cheer it, like that, that view, which is what I see a lot from people on the left.
186
00:34:32.226 --> 00:34:44.666
Like, how do you respond to that, or how does this kind of information that you all have assembled in this study help with addressing that? Because those aren't baseless concerns.
187
00:34:44.725 --> 00:34:54.566
They're, they're a perspective on the state of the world right now. So how do we, how do we respond to that in like a way that pushes towards, again, like liberal democracy and shared liberal citizenship?
188
00:34:55.726 --> 00:35:09.526
I, I think a few, a few points. One, hopefully some of the value of the way that, that we've done this research is that we're presenting how these people think about
189
00:35:11.006 --> 00:35:19.806
their communities and the country and the world as is, right? And so sometimes we're, we're not providing with a value judgment. We're not providing our own judgment.
190
00:35:20.586 --> 00:35:24.646
And sometimes people will respond with their own values and their own judgment.
191
00:35:25.266 --> 00:35:36.766
And, uh, I guess we would say that there is value to trying to see the world through the way that others see it rather than just the way that, that you see it. It's a difficult thing to do.
192
00:35:36.826 --> 00:35:41.566
There takes a, a level of humility, political self-awareness that can be difficult.
193
00:35:41.586 --> 00:35:49.806
Then it's also, I mean, if, if people have, uh, their own challenging conditions that have been caused by the political climate, it's, it's even difficult to do s- to do that.
194
00:35:49.846 --> 00:36:01.016
So, so I recognize, um, the difficulty in, in doing that. I, I also think that there is something-- It, it goes to, to the original premise of your, of your question, which is
195
00:36:02.886 --> 00:36:07.226
th-there, there is some utility to how do we effectively live together.
196
00:36:07.646 --> 00:36:23.086
And I think oftentimes people are thinking about how do I ensure that my preferences or that I get the outcomes that I want rather than-- So it's, it's a little bit of do you wanna be right or do you wanna be effective, to say it a little bit more, you know, concisely.
197
00:36:23.166 --> 00:36:31.506
Um, then I think sometimes people, you know, they, they'll see the report, and they'll say, "Well, these people are wrong, so I don't really care the motivation behind why they're wrong.
198
00:36:31.886 --> 00:36:48.796
They're wrong, and, and I'm right." Um- And they might ascribe to how this moral foundation is associated, and we've heard this as excuse-making for racism and misogyny. And my response to that is, is sort of, you know,
199
00:36:49.716 --> 00:36:55.756
okay, so what do you wanna do with that? I mean, you might, you might feel better on the other side, but it's not gonna be particularly effective.
200
00:36:56.396 --> 00:37:16.236
And so I, I guess that that's maybe it's, uh, it's a little bit, uh, trite or Pollyannish, but there, there's some utility to, to figuring out per the how do we live in a liberal democracy to engage with people who, um, you know, who, who, who fundamentally it's not disagree with you, who fundamentally have a different way of seeing the world.
201
00:37:16.586 --> 00:37:20.416
And that, that's where it's sort of a level deeper than, um, you know, than pluralism.
202
00:37:20.445 --> 00:37:28.516
And they might be-- You might think that they're wrong in terms of how they see the world, but there's still utility in engaging with them on that, especially if you wanna be effective.
203
00:37:28.756 --> 00:37:38.236
The last just, just specific thing on this 'cause I, I think it speaks to some of it. So when we talk about the, um, the value of, of freedom, um,
204
00:37:39.436 --> 00:37:47.616
on, on the right or in this report, people have said, "Well, it's, it's freedom to make my own decisions with, with my own body."
205
00:37:47.636 --> 00:37:57.576
And, and that's an interesting one because people on the left would hear that and they'd say, "Well, how are they saying that and they don't think that I have the right to have an abortion?"
206
00:37:57.676 --> 00:38:16.516
Um, and what people on the right are saying is, "Well, there are all these vaccine mandates that came out during COVID that people were imposing, and then I didn't have the chance to make my own decision because employers and the government was telling me what to do," which is just an interesting way of people saying the same things but having different value systems.
207
00:38:16.556 --> 00:38:29.936
And you could make a credible case for, you know, whatever policy outcome, but there's some utility to actually sitting in that foundation rather than gravitating to the outcome you want, whether it's pro-choice or whether it's anti-vaccine.
208
00:38:30.036 --> 00:38:44.866
Um, and, and so again, it's difficult to do, but I think if you wanna be effective, it's, it's important work. So this research is fascinating, raises really interesting, uh, things to think about.
209
00:38:44.976 --> 00:38:52.196
And so I'm just curious where both of you are going next with this. What comes after?
210
00:38:52.236 --> 00:38:59.916
Where are the-- What are the avenues to run with now that you have the, this baseline understanding that came out of this deep ethnographical research?
211
00:39:01.516 --> 00:39:11.276
I, I mean, some of it is, is hoping to have conversations like the one that we're having, and, and we've had a number of folks, you know, I think to their credit, that are curious and, and, and wanna engage with the findings.
212
00:39:11.296 --> 00:39:24.896
And so I think that there's something to that. Um, and, you know, hopefully playing a small role in ensuring that, that folks, um, recognize the importance of, of, of engaging deeply with,
213
00:39:25.956 --> 00:39:35.996
with people that might think differently about values, the political moment, et cetera. I think that there's some, you know, potential ramifications for, quote-unquote, the
214
00:39:36.896 --> 00:39:52.676
pro-democracy sector, whether it's using different language so not referring to people as pro-democracy or anti-democracy, engaging more on, um, on some of this, this, this moral foundation, so meeting folks where they are in terms of thinking about faith, tackling that information question that, that, that you talked about.
215
00:39:52.736 --> 00:39:55.356
I think that there's some ramifications here.
216
00:39:55.436 --> 00:40:05.136
Um, also hopeful that, that people see value to this research and ethnographic approach, and so are there different ways to think about, um, you know, to think about institutional trust?
217
00:40:05.176 --> 00:40:14.356
We've been talking about, um, doing some of this work with, with young people too. So hopefully it, it spurs a conversation, and I, I think that, that
218
00:40:16.056 --> 00:40:21.116
one of the hard things about the moment that we're in is that everybody's looking for silver bullet solutions.
219
00:40:21.566 --> 00:40:32.956
And so I, I think that this is the type of research that I hope leads to further conversations, not a, "If only we don't use the word democracy when we talk to other people, everything will be all right."
220
00:40:32.996 --> 00:40:38.706
Like, this is hard stuff. People are engaging in fundamentally different ways in society right now.
221
00:40:38.756 --> 00:40:55.475
And so one of the takeaways is that the work to rebuild, to get us to a place where we can all engage in, in, in, in, in the same set of, of, uh, you know, the same set of civic values is gonna be really difficult.
222
00:40:55.575 --> 00:41:04.076
Um, and so I, I, I-- There, there's a part of this that, that hopefully is a little bit of a, a, a sobering up, not in a bad way, but just in a, in a necessary way too.
223
00:41:05.176 --> 00:41:19.276
Yeah, I think the only other thing I would add to that is that, you know, there are so many-- Scott, to your point, there are so many topics in our political environment right now that are so thorny and that feel so, um, yeah, difficult to kind of untangle.
224
00:41:19.316 --> 00:41:39.076
And so, um, I think, you know, for example, we were talking about, like, health and people's relationship to formal healthcare systems and, like, doctors and, like, you know, science, quote-unquote, um, and how there-- within our country, there are people with, like, very different, um, perspectives on what is it, you know, how trustworthy are these institutions and these systems?
225
00:41:39.456 --> 00:41:45.916
How should we engage with them? Should we get vaccinated on things? It has real ramifications for everything from public health to, to all sorts of other things.
226
00:41:45.956 --> 00:42:09.636
So, um, I think that the one thing that, that Scott and, and, uh, you know, we are excited about is how can you take this approach to really diving deep into the kind of underlying drivers behind those perspec- perspectives and, and positions to really understand what are the different levers that we actually have as a society to try and pull to, to get people to, to kind of come together around some of these really complicated topics.
227
00:42:09.756 --> 00:42:18.196
[gentle music] I wanna thank all of you for listening to our conversation. If you enjoy the liberalism.org show, be sure to tell your friends about your favorite episodes.
228
00:42:18.586 --> 00:42:26.276
And to find Scott and Morgan's essay, as well as essays by many other liberal thinkers, visit us on the web at www.liberalism.org.
229
00:42:28.136 --> 00:42:39.136
[gentle music]