TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: This is Coast to Coast. I'm Carol Masser. We are here every day bring you the latest news from the world of business and finance and the most interesting stories in global technology from Silicon Valley and beyond, powered by our more than twenty seven journalists and analysts in more than one twenty countries. You can download Coast to Coast on iTunes, SoundCloud, or Bloomberg dot com. You can also listen to our radio show weekdays at two pm Eastern only on Bloomberg Radio. All right, our producer Paul Brenna needs to get out of my head. This is exactly the song that I was hoping for to bring us into this discussion about the FED minutes hitting the tape just a few minutes ago. We heard a little bit from Joe Wisenthal and Dave Wilson. But we want to dig a little deeper, and for that we have Alex Harris, she's our bond reporter here at Bloomberg News, joining us in our Bloomberg eleven three oh studio in Manhattan. And we're also joined by Francis Donald, she is head of macroeconomic strategy for Many Life Asset Management, joining us on the phone from Toronto. Thanks so much for being here. So Alex, give us a first quick look as you guys digested all this on the desk, what jumped out at you, um in my head, what people were looking for, at least in the interest rate space was one discussion of the balance sheet, discussion of the yield curve, and maybe a discussion about the toolkit. We got a discussion about the FEDS toolkit, and in quite in depth. Actually, the first two pages of the FMC minutes are all about the FEDS toolkit, especially when they're at the lower bound, when they're near zero, and there's a lot of questions about it. And and ultimately where the discussion went was, you know, while the committee they said, while our current toolkits okay, we need to start discussing policy options further and and talk about evaluating the toolkit as we go and whether or not, you know, this is going to be an effective policy going forward. Because they did discuss the concerns fiscal policy, countercyclical fiscal policy as a concern which is getting to the end of a rate hike cycle and weren't in a massive fiscal stimulus as we have been lately. So these are things that came up the balance sheet. They're talking about how they need to resume this, and they'll probably start resuming the conversation and the fall, which is at least a good indication for market participants who have been saying the FED needs to get to the balance sheet discussion. They need to get to this discussion because the regulations have changed how reserves are used, so everyone in the market saying, well, wait a minute, reserves might not be as scarce as everyone once thought they were. The FED might not be able to excuse me, and it's balance sheet run off in one or if they do end in, they're they're significant risk for the funding markets. So now that's forcing them to sort of start talking about it, and I think that's a sigh of relief for some people. Um, and then the yield curve, you know, and their minds want to bring in Frances Donald on that as well. France is great to have you joining us. We have a commentary here that is the FEDS discussion about the yield curve is much more attained than when we talk about it. I'm taking a look here. Market reaction relatively muted. Both two tens thirty year yields not moving very much, but you're seeing a pretty flat yield curve that twos tends now a twenty two handle and the two thirties a thirty eight. Was there anything in this report that really surprised you, Well, what surprised me is that there isn't really any consensus internally on how to incorporate the information about yield curve flattens in the policy decisions. We know that the FED has been engaged in research that looks much more at the front end and trying to find whether there is a relationship between the two tens shape or whether it is really looking at something else. I did see a note that other participants emphasize that inferring economic causality from statistic correlations was not appropriate. So it doesn't appear that the set has a really strong view on whether they should be thinking about yield curve flatness and certainly whether they to pause that the Yoeld curve gets any flatter from here on out. So, for instance, I also want to ask you, you know, one of the things that we're starting to get a feel for is what is the shape of the Powell Fed? And we'll obviously get more sense of that later in the week when he speaks at Jackson Hole. But as I'm reading our top live blog about this, which is is a must read, especially if you're a fed GEEKU and you have a Bloomberg terminal. But one of our editors, Brendan Murray, who have known for twenty five years, points out that rarely do the minutes talk about the chairman by name, and they talk about the chairman by name here. Maybe don't read too much into that in particular, but what are we starting to learn about this Powell fed in your estimation, Well, it is said minute, So we are going to read into every single statement, well said, the power said generally, I would take on the street is perceived as one that has very strong communication skills, and something that's come as a welcome development. I think for a lot the market participants is the emphasis on the idea that perhaps talking obsessively about our star, what's the neutral rate, what's the real rate? He's kind of moved away from that. He's begun to say, well, let's see how that story evolves over time. Maybe there's you know, there's a whole wide list of research that says our star is a different number. There's no consensus in that area as well, So she's saying, maybe we need to be a little bit less technical, a little less theoretical, and play this as the data develops, and and really focused much more on the narrative and the risks of the narrative instead of focusing too obsessively on what the academic numbers might tell us. So, in the long standing
Load full transcript
debate between is the said run by academics or B schoolers, it seems a little bit more like the B schoolers might be winning out. Just to touch more right now, I want to chat quickly just about the Phillips curve, which is of course the relationship between unemployment and inflation. We did hear from the f O m C that recent tariffs are putting upward pressure on input prices, that over the medium term inflation remains near two percent, in some are expecting nominal wages to rise. Are you starting to see a little bit more of a significance about that Phillips curve come back as we're starting to see inflation start to go back up to that two percent level. Isn't it funny? You know a while ago, the first question that I would have received from all of you would have been what's going on with the FED view of inflation. It's part of their dual mandate. And yet now all of the focus on the FED comes back to what's going on with fiscal and trade and balance treat management. But at the end of the day, the settlers does have a dual mandate of stable, low employment and predictable inflation. In our view, we are not witnessing any sizeable upward pressures on inflation right now. We're expecting co inflation to accelerate through to the end of the year, and that headline inflation probably peeks out around July or August. But this is almost kind of a perfect environment for the SET to operate, and it implies that they can move forward with great heights because they have inflation around two percent on target. But they also have the capacity to say, wait, we want some optionality. We can slow down for the timer rate type, we can press pause because we don't see signs of overheating just yet. So I was looking today in the seven minutes for evidence as they were going to become concerned about overheating. I only see a couple of comments here about the pool being a potential upside risk, But on balance, no, I don't see evidence of the Philip's curve is suddenly back in play in a sizeable way that changes Mornjarry policy. Francis Donald, head of macro economic strategy at Manual Life. Alex Harris, Bond reporter at Bloomberg News, thank you so much for joining us and helping us break it down. This is Bloomberg Radio, This is Bloomberg Markets with Carol Measure on Bloomberg Radio. It has been a remarkable twenty four hours, to say the least. And over that period of time we have tapped any number of experts, especially across the Bloomberg empire, and we've got two of them joining us now to help us understand where we go from here. Joining us in the studio here in New York is Greg Ferrell, our go to guy for all things legal, and on the phone joining us from our Washington yours Andrew Harris. We spoke with him yesterday as he was covering the minute by minute of the Paul Manafort trout. Greg, I want to start with you, where do we go from here? Well, there's obviously two tracks from yesterday. There's the Manafort track and there's the coin track. Let's start with Manafort um guilty plea big victory for the Special Council. The question we've been wondering about, we did a story on it today involves a pardon um Trump. The President Trump signaled today in a tweet that he was at some even proud that Manafort didn't break and confess or make up stuff in order to police prosecutors. But it was very sad what has happened to him, and that could be interpreted as a sign that he wants, you know, Manafort to hang in there. So the question would be President Trump has you know, shown you know that he's perfectly willing to use the power of the pardon uh several times in this past year. And if you were to pardon Manafort, that could make a dent that would um yeah, it could make a dent in Mueller's probe, but it could also spark a political backlash against Republicans in the upcoming elections. That's the you know, the theme we hit is that a pardon might backfire on November seven, and as a result, there might be a third option and as a commutation, if the President waited until such a point that Manafort was going to be sentenced and then just commuted the sentence, that that might be a way for him to get more Manafort out of jail without the political backlash of something, you know, interfering with the election. Yeah, and Greg, before we switch on over to the Cohen case, I want to bring in Andrew Harris here. You're joining us from our d C bureau. Thank you, Andrew for being for being so willing to jump on the phone with the given short notice. Talk to us a little bit as well about that reaction to the pardon. Some of the commentary I've heard today is that a pardon what it makes sense because the state has a case that they could bring against Manifort as well. What is your take on this as our legal expert, well as as as you noted, a pardon is only good for federal crimes. The president cannot exercise that power if Paul Manafort got charged by say, uh state of Arts in New York or Virginia for crimes committed there, perhaps related to tax filings there that echo the federal filings for which he was convicted yesterday. So Paul Manafort remains in considerable jeopardy. He's got another trial schedule to start here in Washington in September on money launitoring and foreign lbying undisclosed foreign looming charges plus obstruction of justice. So, um, there's a lot still hanging over his head that is undetermined. So Greg, let me jump back to you and let's talk a little bit about Michael Cohen, because, notably, the commentary from the President via tweets today was shall we say less portive of Michael Cohen, his former personal attorney and self described fixer. Uh. He made a tweet, a rather caustic and presumably sarcastic tweet about you know, not hiring and not advising that anyone hire hire Michael Cohen as their personal attorney. I saw a tweet earlier today. It said it's the world's worst Yelp review for legal advice. What happens next in the Cohen case? Good question. Cohen is essentially
done with prosecutors in New York. Um. However, despite the fact that he doesn't have a plea deal where he's required to continue cooperating, I think we can expect that if he has more information about the Trump organization, he will share it with prosecutors in New York. More importantly has to do with Mueller. This case was handled out of New York. But if Cohen does have any information that he can offer on potential or in Russian interference and the involvement of members of the Trump campaign, and he's in a position that he might then um he could offer that to be called before grand jury and given some level of immunity and speak about that. So that's the you know, million dollar question, if you will, now, is what does Cohen have that might go to Maler's investigation? And really all of this brings up the broader question of we're approaching mid terms of course so soon. It was interesting that when we were hearing from Sarah Sanders, she reiterated that the White House is still very much focused on their economic policies, their borders. That has been their priority since January. Greg, I want to ask you what does all of this mean for the midterms. Do the Republicans still sort of stand their ground, keep their focus on the economy and border control and how does this sort of mobilize them in a new way. Well, this this is where yesterday was such a bad day, not just for the President but for the Republicans because they have a great economic story to tell. It's been you know, the last year and after two years in the market and overall the tax cuts pro business, there's all sorts of positive economic factors that are reaching highs that we haven't seen in fifteen or twenty years. Um. So there's this great story, but in fact, every day the newspaper is filled with other stories about Paul Manaford, about money laundering, about Michael Cohen, about Stormy Daniel's payoffs to porn stars. It's just that's that's not something that most Republicans really want to run on at all. And Andrew, I want to bring you back in here to just make sure we understand that the context for Manafort and the role that he played in the campaign, because the it's important to to understand, uh that a lot of these charges and a lot of this investigation was not about the campaign per se. And and one of the things that the President pointed out was that while this was triggered by the Mueller investigation, it was related to a lot of issues and a lot of business, uh and activity that Manafort conducted long before he was associated with President Trump. How significant is that going forward and from a public perception perspective. That's that's correct. Manafort was indicted predominantly, and not exclusively, but predominantly for money that he made while working for the Ukrainian Party of Regions and UH the Ukrainian President Victor Janakovich, who held office there from two thousand ten to two thousand fourteen. Manafort allegedly made about sixty million dollars working for those Ukrainian entities, money paid him by ukraining oligarchs that flowed into offshore accounts, mostly in Cyprus, UH, much of which went to furnish our lavish lifestyle here in the US and went unreported to US authorities. That's what gott Muller Manifort rather in trouble. But at the tail end of that, when the money ran out in Jannakovich was no longer in power, he went seeking bank loans from American banks, and some of that conduct overlapped with his time initially being hired on to run the Republican UH convention and then when Corey Lewandowski got into trouble to take over as Trump's campaign chairman in May two thousand and sixteen. So it's not of the election, but some of it is contemporaneous with the campaign. And so, Greg, you've done a great job sort of breaking down sort of what happens legally next, and we have sentencing presumably coming up for Cohen in December. I believe Andrew has done a great job laying out for us what happens next in the Manafort case. I do want to make sure everyone understands this issue of cooperation though, as it relates to Cohen, because that was not part of the original agreement as far as we understand it, and yet that is hanging out there, and that does seem to be one of the big questions that that looms. Correct. Yes, and I think Cohen and his lawyers wanted some kind of a p we deal, some kind of a cooperation agreement which would imply vastly reduced sentence with New York, and he didn't get it. Um. I think it's part of the posture of the New York prosecutors, as it has been with Muller in some cases, and they see a crime just to go after it as hard as they can. Um. Now, having said that, it does not preclude Cohen from cooperating. He still has the ability to serve as a witness. In fact, in some ways, once you've pleaded, you've walked involuntarily plead guilty to a crime. If you then testify um in another matter, UM without a plead, real plea agreement, then that undercuts most defense arguments, saying, well, the only reason this guy is saying such and such about my client is that he's trying to reduce a sentence. It's like, no, he has no deal. He's agreed to plead guilty, and in some ways he's cleaner as a prosecution witness. Great stuff our thanks to two of the hardest working men in Hollywood, Greg Ferrell are legal reporter joining us here in our Bluebirg leven three at the studio, and Andrew Harris joining us from Washington. He has been on the case, as it were with Paul Manafort, will continue to be as both of these stories continue to play out. Oh love anything dirty or ninchy or it is always a good day, Taylor when you can have Oscar the Grouch in your life. And this is a really cool story in the latest issue of Bloomberg Business Week, it's about Chinese companies and I'm just gonna read the headline Chinese firms quote, starving for trash, are buying up US factories. And the guy who dug into this literally and figuratively for us as Michael Sasso. He's an
economy reporter down in our Atlanta bureau, my old hometown. Uh, Michael, great to be with you, so take us inside this very uh provocative phenomenon of Chinese firms looking to the US. Uh, not for production necessarily, but for refuse. Yeah, yeah, thanks for happy to be with you. Yeah, this was kind of news to me. But China has been taking a lot of Americans trash for quite a number of years. A lot of the lot of the recycling material that you stick on the corner outside your house actually winds its way to China and uh and without without China taking that, you know, those recyclables, you know, you know, it wouldn't be as much of a market for recyclables in the United States. And that's kind of what happened. Um at the beginning of this year, China started getting must call it stingy. They wanted a cleaner stream of recycles, recyclables, and the South they start in the past, they have been taking all kinds of stuff, you know, pizza, boxes with nasty cheese stuck to it, and you know, glass broken glass would be shards would be included in lots of the plastics and whatnot. And what they had to do is they had to, you know, throw out a lot of that stuff that didn't kind of make the grade. And so, you know, essentially China was taking a lot of the you know, was having to discard in their own landfills, a lot of the recycled trash they're taking from America. The trash of the trash, I guess it was the substandard trash. Michael talked to me about some of the effect that this is having on the companies. On one hand, it seems like companies are being able to benefit from this or being able to export this to China, but I know that China has some new, uh pretty strict criteria coming up that might actually hurt some of these companies as well. Right, So, so what when China at the beginning of this year started getting more in injer wanted only the top of quality trash, I did a couple of things wanted kind of crater the market in the United States because much of the stuff that was being exported couldn't be exported anymore, and so that caused recyclable prices in the United States the same by six or so. UH and in China, a lot of China companies in China had company depend on this stuff. I didn't realize this, but as big as China is, it really has very little virgin would available to turn into pulp and to turn into paper. The same goes for the raw materials of plastic, and so it has come to rely on Americans recyclable stream to fuel the factories. UH almost all of its paper comes from recycled material, much of it from overseas, including the United States. And so when you know, one of the side effects of this, you know, China's decision to get strict at the beginning of the year was some of their own companies started starting for raw materials to make paper and cardboard and a whatnot. And and it's gotten bad enough that some paper mills, for example, are sitting empty in sitting idle old rather and they're actually having to source starting to
look at factories in the United States to purchase you know, there's been there's been a couple of paper mills uh US paper mills purchased by Chinese firms recently partly just to take recycled paper from the US, cleaned it up, you know, make sure it meets the new standards, turned it into pulp, and send it back to China to plug into their their paper mills. The same goes for plastics, where they're taking America buying factories in the US, cleaning up the plastic, politicizing it, and shipping it back to China to make all sorts of stuff including construction, piping and such. And while this has been a boon, it it sounds like there is some worry that this could all go away relatively quickly. There's potentially a ban on all forms of solid waste as imports from the Chinese. Is that right? That is there? There was a uh AN environmental agency in China that has put out a proposed rule has not past yet, but that would ban basically all imports of solid waste, and so that could really exacerbate things even worse. Um, the factories in China would be starving even more so than they are, and it would cause even more of a collapse of recyclable prices in the United States. Unbelievable, really great story. Michael Sasso, Economy reporter for US at our in our Atlanta bureau for Bloomberg News. The story is in this week's edition of Bloomberg Business Week. It is available already now on the Bloomberg terminal and at Bloomberg dot Com. They'll have to ask him next time how he found this story? Right, how did you start digging into this? And I mean it's really interesting and it is intually we didn't get into sort of the regional economics of this. But what I'm taking from this story is a lot of these types of factories are in the southeastern US. You think about sort of historically where these industries have and you know, one of the things I know just from living down there is the biggest private landholder in all of Florida for a long time was essentially the DuPont family only for the timber Um and it became one of the largest real estate companies down there at the St. Joe Company, big developers. See, there's your Southern trivia for the day. All right, you're listening to Bloomberg Radio Jason Kelly and Taylor Riggs Bloomberg Markets on a Wednesday afternoon, Come broom a journal. Yeah, but you let me drive. Oh no, no, no no, no, drive honey, please, I'll do the ride revels. I want to drive, just drive, baby questions driving the drive to the globe? Give thanks well, bring us Ja don radio. That is our drive to the clothes. We are about ten minutes now from the closing bell. UH and Jason. This is a treat because often UH in the mornings on surveillance, when I double head as a producer, I get to book Bill Smead. He's a chief executive officer and chief investment officer Smead Capital Management, and now he gets to be in my hot seat. UM so, Bill, it's great to have you. I wanted to start off with sort of a broad question. You're a value guy. Can you walk me through why this is the time that you think to be a value over a growth investor? Well, thank you for having us, and and there's never a bad time, UH to be a value buyer value investor. A way to think about it is, we're looking for companies through the lens of eight specific criteria for stock selection that have very favorable UH future prospects over the next five to ten years, that have something about their business that defends them from competition has a has a wide mode and then is available at a bargain in comparison to where that particular stock is trated, say the last five years. So I have to ask you, reading some of your notes here at some commentary you made earlier this month, and and in talking about Elon Musk and Tesla you say many and you go back to Valiant, which is such an interesting analog here, say many well respected value investors got excited about their roll up wizardry. And when the value guys catch the fever, history shows you need to be skeptical. Where are you skeptical right now? Well? Uh, Goldman put out their v I P list this week, that the list of companies that are both most heavily owned by the most respect but respected hedge fund manager. Yeah, and on that list it was almost exclusively technology stock. Interesting, so the Comcast was on that list. We owned Comcast. But you know they're the pipes that everybody gets their technology through if you live in there, if you live in there of the neighborhoods in America. Right. So, so, whether it be the index having in tech if you count Amazon and Netflix, whether it be the smartest value oriented hedge fund managers that have had the most success in the path, whether it be mutual fund managers that are used to be in the value category but now we're in the land category because they're they've drifted towards these popular items. Uh, the pressure to conform is absolutely been maximal in the last ninety days. Yeah, So Bill, talk to me a little bit about this, because we've been talking a lot, of course about how this is now the longest market in history. And I tracked back both Netflix and Amazon since March two thousand nine, and there are some of the best performers. You're returning six thousand and three thousand percent over that time. So what's the case that now might be the time to get out? Well, Uh, first of all, you have to kind of separate two things. That there's speculative success and there's you know, investment investing success. Right. In other words, the the the get rich slow crew is extremely conscious of the risk reward relationships. So let me take you back to oh nine, and I can remember conversations I was having with people at the time. So people would call me unsolicited and they'd be looking at the astoundingly low prices of things at the bottom and oh nine, and they'd say, say, Bill, that shouldn't shouldn't I buy some Ford motor stock at two dollars a share? And and my answer, my answer to them is there is a distinct possibility that unless things turn in the next year, that Ford could go out of business. So let's say you're trying to make ten times your money over the following ten years. There were lots of companies Starbucks, for one, that that was available at that time at at eight dollars to share, like one or two splits ago, where you had a chance of making ten times your money. But there there there was virtually zero chance of them going out of business. Right they didn't know anybody any money, strong balance sheet, massive freecash flow, addicted customers. It was the only luxury in two thousand nine that people were really willing to spend money on. Now, it happened that Ford rebounded to sixteen dollars, So you could have made eight times your money on Ford over the following four or five years. But if you'd have been wrong, you'd have lost all your money. And and the Amazons and Netflix, if you go back to oh nine, were companies that you could have lost all of your money, so so so that's available to a specific kind of investor who can be in all or none. The thing the problem is the S and P five hundred now has an amazingly large amount of money in very high risk oriented securities. And that's because for the last five years, the risk got taken out of the risk reward relationship right there. There's there's been no risk in writing expensive momentum revenue growth stories. So I gotta ask you. You know, you mentioned Amazon, and one of the ways that you've been playing this, it seems, is on the other side of of getting Amazon. You're looking at Target North from Target is up almost three percent today on its results, only about thirty seconds left. Where's the value in sort of the other side of retail right now, the nine Amazon side. We've made our best money in the last twelve months on the things we bought a little over a year ago that we're supposed to get annihilated by Amazon. That'd be Target, that'd be Kroger, that would be Discovery Communications North and and and those stocks gouts. You know, they returned to prices similar to the O nine bottom in terms of PE price to sales. You know, price to free cash flow. UH target at fifty four a year ago was at about the same prices were on an absolute basis that it was trading at the bottom and O nine. Well, I gotta tell you, Bill, Taylor was talking you up before we came on the air and UH, and you really delivered. It was great talking to you that. Of course. Bill's me chief executive officer and chief investment officer Smead Capital Management over seeing about two point three billion dollars based in Seattle, joining us on the phone. Great stuff. We know you'll come back soon with us. I'm Jason Kelly with Taylor Riggs here on Bloomberg Radio. Thanks for listening to Coast to Coast. You could subscribe to the podcast on iTunes, SoundCloud, or Bloomberg dot com. You can also listen to the radio show weekdays at two pm Eastern only on Bloomberg Radio