TRANSKRIPTIO 🔗
Jackie Slaght: Welcome to Beyond Tech, where innovation meets insight. I'm your host, Jackie Slatt. Today we're discussing a challenge that nearly every industrial facility faces. What happens when critical equipment is still doing its job, but the technology supporting it is becoming outdated? Many organizations are operating equipment that has been reliable for decades. However, aging controls, obsolete components, cybersecurity concerns and increasing maintenance costs can create risks that are difficult to ignore. The good news is that replacement isn't always the only option. Modernization strategies can often extend asset life, improve performance, and reduce risk while avoiding the cost and disruption of a complete system overhaul. Joining us today are two experts who help organizations navigate these decisions every day. Ed Formeika is an eTech group business development manager who works closely with manufacturers and industrial organizations to identify opportunities for modernization, evaluate, Investment priorities and align technology strategies with business objectives. And joining him is Bill Bartlett, a senior engineer at eTech Group with extensive experience evaluating legacy systems, implementing modernization projects, and helping facilities improve reliability, performance, and maintainability while minimizing downtime. Today we'll discuss how organizations can balance operational needs, budget constraints, and long-term growth when deciding whether to modernize or replace critical assets. So with that introduction, let's dive into the discussion. so I'll ask both of you guys first, what are you hearing from customers regarding aging equipment and infrastructure today? How do those conversations go?
Ed: Yeah, so along with the aging infrastructure that these customers are faced with in companies and manufacturing, a lot of these components are becoming obsolete and very difficult to find. And it's critical to their business because they have to keep running. 24-7, a lot of these plants run. And when they can't find those parts and something goes down, they're usually buying them from eBay or a third-party provider that, you know, we that aren't fully tested and for us for a system. So that's real critical. What we're seeing a lot of is obsolescence. These systems have been out there for thirty plus years. Software's a little dated and technologies continue to advance well beyond what those controllers have been designed for.
Bill Bartlett: on top of that, a lot of it is just because of the re increased maintenance cost that's concerning with all those because of those parts, having to try to repair at the same time. I know that they try to try to flip from one to another on on the equipment itself, or send it off for repair. It increases the cost there. And like you said, you know, trying to buy on eBay and everything, you know, that ha it it's it's basically doubling and tripling the cost of what they need.
Jackie Slaght: So
Load full transcript
when you say flip I does that mean you're they're changing the lines that the equipment's running on?
Bill Bartlett: Well, no, what they'll do is they'll may make a small change to one piece of equipment and they'll take that old obsolete hardware and and they'll try to update it, try to repair it themselves or whatever, just try to keep their lines continuously running because of the cost of the parts. because they are high trying to find those old parts.
Ed: And build build on top of those things, what we see too is when we upgrade a particular line and we bring them up to current standards, they take those old parts that they have, because they're similar in a lot of places in their manufacturing plants, and they'll put them back into inventory a short-term fix, right? So they take
Bill Bartlett: Correct.
Ed: them out, they repackage them, they put them in inventory, and but it's it doesn't really stop the obsolescence problem, but it does allow them to continue to run a little longer. as we update these lines.
Jackie Slaght: So what is preventing facilities from changing the equipment? And you know, they're just sticking with what has worked. Is it like all cost driven or is it not being able to have the downtime?
Bill Bartlett: Well, some of it has to do with, you know, their margins are low, with the product. So They're trying to keep the machines that they have that's been in production for so many years keep going because trying to replace that is cutting into their overhead and everything. So, you know, they got low, low margins on their output and trying to keep this equipment going so they get to a point like we were talking about before, is they'll try to save those existing parts, upgrade one particular line, bring it up to the legacy. and then hold on to those. So i i it just has to do with their cost. You know.
Jackie Slaght: Mm.
Bill Bartlett: They got low margins, you know, it's difficult for them to to get that. So they have to find out what's priority, what's really needs to be, you know, upgraded.
Jackie Slaght: reminds me of keeping an old car 'cause you don't wanna have the cost of a new car and getting a monthly payment. I'm assuming if they've had the equipment in there for quite some time, there's not like the investment cost of putting something brand new in there and having that go against their margin if it's a brand new machine.
Ed: Yeah, capital capital is certainly one of the elements to when you do a monetization project, right? But the other aspect of it too is how much downtime can they afford, right? It's it's a double edged story because if you don't migrate forward and something breaks and you can't find that component, you're gonna be down a whole lot longer than If you did an upgrade and we turn it around in a week or two, whatever it will be, but there's also production constraints, right? They have obligations to their customers for X amount of product. And can they can they shut down for a week or two? Some of the people that we we deal with were on 24-7, 365, right? They they do have little maintenance outages, but can they really afford to take that line down with their commitments from production? So production definitely has a say on. when they could have the line to do an upgrade based on what their what their bookings and backlog look like for their customers.
Jackie Slaght: So I guess Ed, maybe you can answer this. What business pressure pressures are driving organizations to consider modernization now?
Ed: Well that's a really good question because the the first thing that plants are thinking about is the safety of their employees, right? Safety of their employees, making sure it's a safe product, safe piece of equipment to work around. So some of the projects that Bill and I have been working on, certain corporations have been implementing more and more safety standards into an upgrade. And the other thing about it, Jackie, I like to say being a main automation partner when we come into a plant that we're not familiar with, it's our obligation to say, have you guys considered these things around these pieces of equipment. And Bill can jump in on that what we're talking about. There's there's mats and cages that need to stop if someone moves to open that so no one gets hurt. So that's number one I think on all manufacturers' line is the in stake the safety of their employees and making sure they have they're up to the latest safety standards for either a corporate standpoint, state standpoint, or a federal standpoint.
Bill Bartlett: true too is 'cause a lot of things do we do on a corporate side, you're saying on the upgrades, it it's it's a common with this is what we implement when we do those upgrades because we're dealing with the corporate. And then we get into the plant level employees and stuff that they ask for upgrades and they're not as aware of all these safety concerns and everything that the corporate does and we kinda have to bring that to their attention and point these things out and make those suggestions to them. why they're asking us to, look at the equipment, find out what needs to be upgraded along the ways and and some of kinda, no, let's just say what we have and we tr we try to we really get to understand, why it needs to be brought up to the the current codes and everything of bringing that safety points up, you know, to protect the employees themselves.
Jackie Slaght: what are the kind of warning signs that you've seen from equipment that's kind of reaching this the critical point of like, yeah, you we really gotta do something about this now. What what would they be experiencing?
Bill Bartlett: some of it is because their employees are operators they're touching the the c the product, with their own hands and stuff. And they're reaching into areas that, you know, is kinda unsafe, you know, when we look at it and trying to point that out. And and a lot of it has to go to, you know, try to get them to to
automate specific areas of downstream equipment, to kinda keep it out of the operators You know, 'cause there is some pitch points or or cut points or whatever, 'cause it it They try to make it safe as possible, but sometimes, you know, people don't do the right thing, you know, if you know what I'm saying. so we we try to bring that to their attention, and just
Ed: Yeah.
Bill Bartlett: try to make it safer.
Ed: And and Bill, sometimes we we're sometimes we're connected to corporate more, sometimes we're connected to the plants more, but when we when we have those conversations with corporate and the plant, we're able to help communicate that message, right? And bridge that gap that they may not have even known about, right? These new corporate standards coming down because we've had corporate meetings, that those messages don't always translate down to the plant. And I can t I can think of two cases where you and I were just recently, not too long ago, where we said, have you considered what corporate wants here? And I don't think they knew and we put that in. Now they're in alignment with the corporate standards and it's gonna be a safer manufacturing line.
Jackie Slaght: And what kind of I guess sticking with safety, what what kind of measures can we implement when when when we're kind of like upgrading a piece of equipment or a line? What sort of safety precautions can can we add?
Bill Bartlett: Well, some of the safety precautions is is what they call is a dual channel setup on guard door switches, e stop buttons, 'cause a lot of these places are what they call just a single channel and it's just one set of contacts on the system. if that contact fails, then that particular E stop or that particular guard door i is not going to shut the line down. So we get into category three dual channel systems with feedback on so when they open up, if one fails you still have the other one that will actually save the machine, open it up, shut it down like it's supposed to, in the critical areas.
Ed: Yeah, on that bill, some e-stops would only start, stop a certain piece of equipment, right? When it should stop the entire line. You're talking, I think, about something that was daisy chained prior, right? a single
Bill Bartlett: Correct.
Ed: a single single contact that's daisy chained for all the inch stops the entire line. And that's very useful on the majority of lines, but sometimes they only need to stop, say, the bagging area while it's accumulating to stop that section, but the soul line can still run. Do I have that correct?
Bill Bartlett: Correct. you got two pieces of equipment and a lot of times they want to keep one up and going because of either has to do with heat controls or whatever, 'cause they don't want to shut it down. Well you got the downstream equipment that's, you know, taking care of the other pieces of equipment for bagging, or whatever the case may be, they'll keep that kind of separated out. and then you've got a global system that, you know, goes from one end of the piece of equipment to the other end. which will shut the whole system down. So i it just depends on the circumstances of the equipment and how it needs to be arranged. That makes sense?
Jackie Slaght: Yes, I think I have not had a lot of conversations around safety. So this is all new. so when you say dual channel, does that mean
Bill Bartlett: It's dual is two. Okay. So
Jackie Slaght: To like lines?
Bill Bartlett: no, so a push button. So
Jackie Slaght: Okay.
Bill Bartlett: so emergency push button. instead of having one set of contacts, which would be normally closed on it, you'd have two. So and they come in, so and then we get into the what they call safety IO. you take into a s a safety input card. So if one of the contacts fails you have a backup that would take care and shut down the system if they hit that opponent.
Jackie Slaght: To okay. So it's like getting I guess just more insurance that you
Ed: It's okay.
Jackie Slaght: could
Bill Bartlett: It's a rectal redundant.
Ed: It's re it's it's redundant, it's a fail safe. If one contact didn't shut the line off, the other contact should, right? Because they're independently wired. Do I have that correct?
Bill Bartlett: That's correct. They are independently wired.
Ed: Wired. They do the same thing, but if didn't the first contact didn't make it, second contact
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ed: should.
Jackie Slaght: Okay. well that's yeah, that seems important. That's a good thing. Let's let's do more of that.
Ed: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: I know Bill, you and I, and Ed, we've had some conversations around safety and some of the other projects that we're working on together. So this is, like I said, not certainly a very important aspect, I think, of modernization that we haven't necessarily in our other episodes really focused on. So I I kind of appreciate the the insight and knowledge. So thank you.
Ed: Mm-hmm.
Bill Bartlett: Yeah, and that's just a small piece of it because there's so many more safety devices out there,
Jackie Slaght: Well, I assume a lot of the safety devices I think would somewhat depend on the the actual line and what it's producing and what machines are there.
Bill Bartlett: Correct equipment, so yes.
Jackie Slaght: So I I I said I'm guessing it's depending on what the machines are and what you would need to have, as far as I I know for my very limited knowledge that on some like robotic machines they have like the cages around them and things. That's
Ed: Right.
Jackie Slaght: really the the extent of what I have.
Bill Bartlett: Yeah, urge cages
Ed: the light curtains because they wrap the boxes you break that light that that arm spinning spinning wrapping up boxes and if and if somebody breaks that beam that arm's got to stop on a dime right because they can swing around hit somebody really cause some serious injury to a an employee an operator maintenance guy so that is why I think I think in the past some of these lines have been
grandfathered in but as these companies migrate forward These safety standards are becoming more and more apparent that that Bill and I are been seeing, which is a good step for any corporation out there.
Jackie Slaght: because I feel like every conversation we're having right now ends with AI. Have they has AI become a part of any like safety analysis of like looking back through records to kind of make recommendations on what sort of safety measures. a facility should implement or could
Ed: From from our standpoint at at at at this time, no. It's we're we're basing we're basing our knowledge on best practices that we know. We have, safety engineers, we have control engineers, and and we're we're a team. And again, being a main automation partner is to bring these things to the attention of the customer. But at the end of the day, ultimately it's up to them if they want to proceed down that direction. and we typically haven't gotten a no yet on anything that we brought forward to them. along those lines, right? But AI, from my knowledge with the customers that we deal with, I don't think they brought that say, hey, we sold us in AI, can you guys design this or engineer this for us? But we'd be open to it for sure. If somebody has something that wanted us to bring and see if we can come up with some configuration or an engineering drawing or a design, be more than happy to do it.
Bill Bartlett: Yeah, we just have to do a you know, risk analysis on it. we get with one of the the safety engineers run it by them, and then see, you know, what their thoughts are on it. 'cause, you know, sometimes AI get is not always right.
Jackie Slaght: What? I've heard that.
Bill Bartlett: So you still gotta do your homework,
Jackie Slaght: Yes, no, absolutely. so speaking of things not always being right, what are some misconceptions that people have about aging equipment?
Ed: Yeah, so look they a lot a lot of the lines we're updating are 30 years and they they really have gotten their their capital return out of it for for a long time. I I think what they're not realizing or a misconception is with tod today's technology with going from one communication standard twenty years ago to A standard today is that data can be pushed up higher up into the organization for them to see what these lines are doing. It can also have increased performance on a manufacturing line, depending on the specs of the equipment, right? So we we can't run a winder any faster than it's been designed to do. but speaking of winders, Bill and I get in a lot of winder projects. that the newer winders and the newer motors on those winders can run faster, right? And they can make more product. So they're so so backing up just a little bit. Some of these projects that we do are are capital improvement projects, right? So they don't really do they don't ha always have to get a return on the investment. It's an age piece of equipment. They can be somewhat dangerous because they can fail. It can,
you like we talked about safety, but it can also hurt them from a production standpoint by migrating to something faster. We can help these companies gather all this information. and and push it up to higher levels so they can see the performance or the OE OEE of that line, of how much that line actually improved from an efficiency standpoint too. Because the controllers are a lot faster than they were built 30 years ago. Right? We can
Bill Bartlett: Yeah.
Ed: take way more data in, way more analog digital inputs in to these cards as well, and we can do a lot more with today's technology. And it will last probably another 30 years for them.
Bill Bartlett: True. Well, here's thing I just ran into just recently. and some of the misconceptions also is they think that the control side of it is just what they we just upgraded a system that, you know, we were able to optimize it, improve it, and we can actually run a lot faster than what they allow us to at the moment. And the reason why we can't run it faster is because of the mechanical side. is hindering us from allowing that equipment to run any faster than what it will go now. so it's something that they have to address not just on the control side of it, mechanical side also if they have to address those things. And sometimes they don't even look at the mechanical end of it. They just think it's all fine and good. just put new controls on it and let it go. But they just found out that they have to correct a problem basically on some for example this is the LU bowl temperatures. it's overheating. If we go and increase on the on the system any higher, we run it any faster, it's going to over temp. So they've got a correct what they call a heat exchanger system on it so it'll cool it down and then we can you know increase the output of the line that we we've helped them develop and and basically increase that output that they didn't have before. So I think that's kind of a misconception there that they don't see a lot of time.
Jackie Slaght: So when an organizer organization is starting these conversations, How do they decide whether they should completely replace a piece of equipment or kind of work through some upgrades and modernizing, but keep the keep the physical part of the equipment there?
Ed: Yeah, that's
Bill Bartlett: quite it.
Ed: Yeah, there's there's a couple things. you know, depending on how they keep their their books, right? The age of the equipment, they might have depreciated it. You know, there's no le no no depreciation left on the equipment. It's aging. So it's being very costly to run that 30-year-old piece of equipment. The other thing that we saw was these companies are coming out with new product lines, right? And the existing line that they have is not long enough. to manufacture a new product coming out. So we've seen a company or two take out an existing working line because they developed a new product to come to market. So instead of trying to upgrade that, which they
couldn't because it wasn't long enough long enough for the production line for this new product coming to market. So there's there's a number of factors, right? Age, what's it cost to to Bill's point, upgrade all these other things besides the controls versus a new line for a new product that could be be depreciated over the next, say, three decades. There are financial decisions for corporations that they have to face with, right?
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm. Are there any factors that you that like aside from cost that you think have or have seen get overlooked that maybe should have been more considered when looking and deciding what to do?
Bill Bartlett: Yes, I've run into that quite a bit because it's amazing that they only look at part of the equipment, you know, instead of the whole line. And and sometimes that has to do with budget constraints.
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Bill Bartlett: they're told from the corporate level, this is your budget that you gotta work within these means. And so they try to, pick and choose, what's the worst case scenario and what can they do. but a lot of the guys understand that they would like to get the whole thing done, not just bits and pieces of it done. You know. For example, just say an extrusion line itself, which is the main heart of of creating the plastics. you've got that, they upgrade the controls on that part, but then you got all the downstream equipment, you know, for lamination, winders, everything else down there that's still aging and and needing controls upgrades and it just kinda it's almost like, you know, a stepbrother down there that you forget about and you know, it just kinda goes away. But yeah, it it's we we try to point out and and try to help them analyze it and and make good s suggestions. but we understand too that, you know, there are only a limited amount of budgets that you know they're provided. So i it it's
Ed: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Bill Bartlett: it's tough. It's really tough. what we want to do and what they can do is, you know, sometimes two different things.
Jackie Slaght: So I guess in your experience and what you're seeing out in the field, are there what type of modernization projects are you seeing the most of today? Like what what are people upgrading or is there is it spread across the board?
Bill Bartlett: Well it's most of it it just has to do with their PLC platforms that I see.
Ed: Sure.
Bill Bartlett: Some has a combination of PLCs, drives, servos. some systems we encounter is just d drives. lately it's been you know, we've been asked, you know, is like they want to upgrade their drive systems. they don't want to update their PLC systems, but they just want to update their drives, you know. and we try to talk to about it, but they feel that, you know, their system is fine for the PLC side of it. and some of we make recommendations. if you're gonna upgrade this, this look like upgrading this because the new software, new firmworks and everything else, sometimes it
doesn't like talking to old equipment. old drives, old servos, you have communication conflicts. it doesn't just it doesn't play nice. Just put it that way. And it could
Ed: Yeah. Well we'll
Bill Bartlett: be a nightmare for the engineers and then they they start getting mad at you because why'd you design it this way? You know?
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ed: Well, Bill, some of the things that we're seeing is and again, I think this is where eTech group is unique, is some of the manufacturers, not naming at them, but they're at end of life. They've the drives are end of life, which means there's no more support. They're done. Whoever made the drive or servo, they're end of life. they know it, and it's gotta be addressed sooner than later. And a a a few companies that we that we're working with, a few different companies are we're helping them redesign a way to put a different drive in there and and bring it more into a PLC or some other way of communicating with because guess what else besides the hardware that's obsolete. The software's no longer been in development. It's at end of life.
Bill Bartlett: Can't get it anymore. Yeah.
Ed: You can't get it. You can't you can't find it. And if you bought it if you bought somewhere else somewhere else other than the manufacturer or a a genuine distributor, authorized distributor, I wouldn't want to use that in my plant. And that's some of the things that Bill does with his electrical background. I'll go out there and look at, you know, a drawing that might have been done thirty years ago and Things may have changed, but the drawing's never been updated. And he's literally out there with voltmeters and amp meters and and lit literally tracking that wire down to see it is it really landed here still or is it just bare somewhere?
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Ed: these are the type of services that I think that makes us unique. because we really do a thorough job when we go and do a site walk down.
Jackie Slaght: So when you say end of life, what are the some risks to operating a a piece of equipment or a piece of software that is no longer supported?
Ed: That's what it means. End of life is there's no more development, there's no more repairs. You have end of life. If you go back one step up, it's mature, which means it's still supported and you can still per purchase it and then you have current, right? So it's usually green is current. Yellow is mature and end a red is end of life, is the the color codes that I've used in the past. And
Bill Bartlett: Yeah.
Ed: end of life just means they any manufacturer, OEN manufacturer won't repair it. Now you can find some people out there that are very good at repairing these old boards from a component standpoint. They have test beds. And I'm not saying they're they're real costly, but to try to get a board back turned around in twenty-four, forty-eight, seventy-two hours, it's very difficult to do. So end of life, that's what it means. Then we're developing on software, then
we're developing on hardware.
Jackie Slaght: So for the software portion, does that increase I guess cyber like being protected from it, is it more vulnerable to cyber attack or having malware or something a come through that software?
Ed: Yeah. I'm gonna let Bill I'm let me just start with it it can be, and that's y they're so end of life and software, they're not doing any more patches to it, right? But the the the plants and the IT corporate folks try to put as much in there as they can from a cybersecurity standpoint, make sure no one has access to those controller cards.
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Ed: They can make those winders or or or dryers go faster or these pumps run faster, because they can go they can what we call runaway bill, right? That that's that that can happen. So they try to put the layers in there, but being somewhat on a current platform. or mature platform at least, they're still doing patchwork, right? When they see these things, they update the controller cards, build the update the firmware and the software
Bill Bartlett: Firmware.
Ed: too. So I'm gonna just turn it over to you from that standpoint, if you wanted to add anything to that.
Bill Bartlett: Yeah, certain places, you know, we're we're still trying to work with some of some of the manufacturers and stuff because right now a lot of the machines are not tied into their network. they're in the progress of trying to tie into the network because their main reason to do it is because they want to do data collection.
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Bill Bartlett: You know, so they want to gather information out of the machine so they can get their data collection, get their reports. find out the aging stuff and all that, get better equipped and have better knowledge of what's going on with their equipment with the today's technology that they couldn't do before. And then as far as the cyber stuff on top of that, of course, you know, that falls into their IT groups and everything and building those layers so, you know, somebody can't get in and hack it. We try to do better we can to a certain point within the equipment itself. to keep everything private on the machine side and then it's public, going out to the plant networks and everything and then from that then, you know, the plants gonna have to do their due diligence,
Jackie Slaght: So for a facility that is building a case for modernization, how do they make that case in the most compelling way, whether it be like ROI value, safety increases, production increase, what kind of moves the needle to like, yes, let's let's do it. Let's get let's get the modernization effort started and what's what's your
Ed: Yeah. I I'll start from my standpoint of of of understanding a few of the customers that I've worked with. it it it comes down to production, right? is it a new project that we've like companies will commit to making so many tons per day or tons per week, whatever it may be, and then they look at it's a business decision. Can
this line being 20 or 30 years old Is there something that could be catastrophic, meaning the line fails, right? And then now we missed our commitment to our customer that's depending on this product to make another product, right? So that would move a move the needle. And sometimes we are brought in to help consult with them, with our customers, on how does this sound to you? This is the way we think we should go in this direction. but what are your thoughts, right? What are your thoughts on this? But we also want to understand of you know what does success look like for you as a as the customer as the end user, right? When you go down here, you're gonna spend all this capital. What how do you define success? We want to make sure we have a clear understanding of what their objectives are. And then, yeah, as an engineering team and a sales team, we we look at it, we come back and we share some ideas and what we think we could do. And again, uptime is very important for our customers, right? Because I I I can't think of I can only think of one customer I know that's not maybe two, that's not running 24-7. And they literally give the lines back to maintenance only four. three to four days
Bill Bartlett: Brown.
Ed: a year to do all the repairs until the next year. It's that critical for them. So that can move the needle, right? If if there's a gap in production and they got the money to spend, we get a call. Can you guys do this in the next two months or next three months? And how long will it take you? So that they're business decisions that we can help guide our customers through with the right information. Again, we signed non-disclosures we just need to understand what the process is, what their objectives is, and and what their time frame is on on how to do these.
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Bill Bartlett: Well true. Some of too, i it depends on d do they have another piece of equipment that can make the same product. Okay.
Ed: Right. A sister plant, sister line.
Bill Bartlett: Or or i in the same facility. You know, and then sometimes they've only got one piece of equipment that makes this particular product. So if they're having issues with this particular line, that line moves up the chain. Okay. If it starts having problems, it moves up the ladder. Okay, we've got to get this fixed first. some of the other ones, how long has it been having problems? You know, how many times you've been having to fix it, how many times has it been repaired, how many times maintenance been involved, you know, is it mechanical, is it electrical, you know, is it is it just what is it? So there there's
Ed: So
Bill Bartlett: a lot of variables that go into, you know, what a customer is going to consider of doing their modernization or or what upgrades they're gonna make in and We try to help them with that and and some of the lines are critical lines. some lines are kinda like in a loop system. They make the product, they got scrap on the product, they take the scrap,
goes back around, and they put it into what they call a reclaim system. so sometimes they can't shut that down because if they shut that down then they gotta shut other pieces of equipment down.
Ed: Yeah, and Bill, along that line, some of these some of the older lines, e if it's in CPG or chemicals and other areas that we're dealing with that are that are AIDS, they're using a number of different OEMs for these lines, right? And if one of those components go out and fail, a lot of these at least two two cases that I know of. They're not on the shelf ready to go. They're built to order. Meaning they need three months to build it. Could you imagine a line being down for three months, a main line being down for three months that feeds other lines? They don't have they have inventory, but most people don't have three months of inventory sitting on a shelf that feeds the other lines, right? So it's called line starvation, is what we call it, right? They're gonna starve that line, the other lines. Am I correct, Bill? And I'm
Bill Bartlett: Yes.
Ed: I'm thinking of one CPG customer I'm dealing with in particular, that if it goes down and that part's made to order because it's a custom part, it's just not sitting on the shelf. It's not something we can just call our local distributors, get this drive or this pump or this motor out the next day Bill and I walked a number of lines in a lot of different industries. and when we're looking at it, we're like, you might want to address this, you know.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ed: Y it is because by and and quite honestly, i if we if we don't have a a good a good report back to the OEM for a a pump, say, they're not gonna sell us the pump. They can do that, you know. so that's why we do our due diligence when we're walking through these plants and addressing these things, that I think is I think it's very valuable of what we do here at ETEC Group and how we go about doing business.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, no, is very true. Have either of you experienced a kind of a part going down that's made to order and like what what happened that that were they just they couldn't do anything for three months until the part was made or they
Ed: so I'll I'll just say it this way without giving too much weight. They the the end user, the customer that's making something, they'll there's there's you can expedite things as as quick as you can. OEMs will charge a premium to you know for that. We don't we don't do that, right? Because we're not making motors and pumps and drives and you know things along those lines or instruments on the on the side of the vessels. So there's ways to do it, but it's very costly, right? And
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Ed: again, it's our job to say, We've seen this before. If you don't have a spare, you should order one or think about migrating to something more current. Because
Bill Bartlett: That's true because we run into this one scenario too, is like, yeah, you might want to bid on s on spares, but you can't even get that spare now because they don't have the certain application that would go into a drive. they don't have anybody to certify it because this is an old technology and the person, you know, they're retired. You know,
Ed: Yeah, true.
Bill Bartlett: so you run into those situations. So what do you do? You know, You have to kinda re engineer it into a different way and and try to get something standardized and get it something that's off the shelf that you can get the next day. that you're not sitting there and being down for two weeks, because you're waiting on a part.
Jackie Slaght: So I just want to thank you guys for spending some time with me today and kind of having this conversation. I always learn a lot, so I really just appreciate you guys taking the time. my last non-fun question is Given all the experience and some of the stories that you have shared, what advice would you give to a leader who's evaluating their kind of modernization or asset upgrade strategy today?
Bill Bartlett: Go for it, Ed. You're the man.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ed: Yeah. Yeah. So so I the the advice I would give a leader to say of Of a dairy plant is to look across his organization, look at those legacy systems, look at the how old they are and how important they are to the business, right? And you know, can you really afford to lose, say, a spray dryer or an evaporator that's 20 years old with those controls? And and it comes down to let's help us. build out a a capital plan for you for the next three to five years. Let's not short think short term. Let's build out a strategy as your automation, main automation partner of how we can do this over a three, five, five, maybe even seven year plan. And I am working on with one customer on a 10-year plan, right? For a hundred and
Jackie Slaght: No.
Ed: a hundred and fifty some plants, right? Of this is gonna be high this is going to be 150 plants over 10 years, that we want to do this and And have standardizations, that's the other key. So as much as we can, let's standardize plant A and Plan Z as much as we can, right? With the same HMI, same controllers, because what that does for them, it lowers their cost of ownership. Also, it lowers the training effort that they have to give to their operators and their maintenance people by doing so. They can pick whomever they like, we can give them suggestions, but as we said earlier. We're hardware, software, agnostic. We can give you our advice, but at the end of the day, it's their decision of who they want to move forward with. before I was a salesperson, I was a field engineer, so I was out there doing the repairs and the upgrades like you were, but on a much lower scale. You know.
Jackie Slaght: Ha ha ha. Well, thank you guys again. I have just some kind of rapid fire fun closing questions. what's the oldest piece of equipment that you've seen that's still operating successfully?
Bill Bartlett: to me, you talking about without being modernized?
Jackie Slaght: I
don't have a
Bill Bartlett: I've seen some that still go on that are forty fifty so
Ed: Nineteen seventyish? Around nineteen seventies. Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: my gosh. Thank
Bill Bartlett: Sixty five.
Jackie Slaght: you. You're saying it was installed in 1965, Bill.
Bill Bartlett: Yes.
Jackie Slaght: my gosh. Wow. Well, good job. You're my parents have
Ed: Fifty six years.
Jackie Slaght: fridge in their basement that is from like the 1960s that is still going strong and it is super cool looking. and it keeps things. Yeah.
Bill Bartlett: Well, they built them really good back then.
Ed: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: I'm like, it's gonna end up in a museum somewhere. but yeah, that's it. If it's if it's still working, you know. Go for it.
Bill Bartlett: Right?
Jackie Slaght: if you could instantly upgrade one piece of technology across the industry, what would it be?
Ed: Yeah, I'm s so it's not so much it's not so much technology, but one of the things that I like companies to do, one piece of advice is that we're seeing a couple of little problems on is is grounding, right? it's it's not a piece of equipment, but it's something that really needs to be looked at and maintained because if you have a bad ground, all kinds of things happen throughout that line. And I know Bill knows what I'm talking about. and it can be quite, quite dangerous. So it's one of the things that I think that we look at when we're doing our our walkthroughs and when we do our projects is is it is effectively granting. So that's not a piece of equipment, but that goes on every piece of equipment, right? Again, it's one of the things I think that whoever's doing the integration should be should be looking at. But the other piece of equipment, the other thing that's critical on on the power side is is power supplies and transformers and UPSs, make sure the power is clean going into any other piece of equipment, especially the controllers, Bill. dirty power is not good, no PLC likes it, but that's been my experience. But I'm but I'm going back and to the nineteen nineties and two thousand when I was in the field. Has it changed much from today?
Bill Bartlett: No, it has not changed much and that
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Bill Bartlett: is one technology that probably would night would be nice to get is, you know, on the utility side.
Ed: Yeah, clean power. UPS's
Bill Bartlett: Swing power. Yep.
Ed: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Well, that I you guys came up with a good answer. It sounds like you both in agreement and I let's see what we can do to make it happen.
Ed: Yeah, and it's unrehearsed. Yeah. It it it's something that it's it's a safety issue for sure. It's it's a controls issue and we've seen both, right? We've seen it. We've seen things not properly grounded or loose grounds and it's very dangerous. Again, I went I started out with safety, I don't mean to end with it, but it it's very important that that the entire staff, either the customer staff or our staff is In a safe working environment and there's nothing worse than not having a proper ground and dirty power, which is easily cleaned up with the right UPSs and the right transformers and things along those lines.
Bill Bartlett: Well actually I don't want it to be
Jackie Slaght: well I've got one one last question.
Bill Bartlett: no okay, go ahead.
Jackie Slaght: what is a few one future topic you'd like to see us cover on an episode of Beyond Tech?
Bill Bartlett: future topic.
Ed: I I have one that that and my apologies because you know being relatively new the last eight months. there are some things that I saw implants with robotics, right? Where these automatic packing machines, be Bill mentioned it. there's there's operators sometimes putting their hands in where there's automation now where that thing can be pushed out, the box can be filled, it can be taped. the robotic arm can pick it up and put it on a pallet and that helps save, injuries to the hand, it helps save injuries to people's backs. And
Jackie Slaght: Mm-hmm.
Ed: I think I because we do I think we do well on robotics. you know, we do a lot of warehousing and and and wrapping and picking things up and putting them on pallets and putting them in inventory. I would like to see a little bit more conversation around that 'cause it's it's it's money well spent for these for these customers, it it it's efficiencies and it's less injuries as well.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah? Yeah, I'm sold. I'll do it.
Ed: All right. You gonna invite me back on?
Jackie Slaght: Maybe, yeah. All right. well thank you guys for for spending some time and just joining me on this episode. I'm sure we'll talk again soon.