رونوشت 🔗
Josh Arnold: Whoever decided an oil change pays. three clearly never had to track down a set of keys in a busy shop. By the time you check the three different desks, find a car double parked on the back lot, and jumpstart a car with a dead battery, your eighteen minutes were gone before it even hit the bay.
Marshall Sheldon: The actual wrench time might be 0.3, but the real world process is 0.8. The technician is footing the bill for the difference. Today we're talking about the gap between the book time and the true time. And we got a special guest today, our our co-founder also with our within spec community, Richard Mueller, an accomplished technician in his own right, and the great Fifty second state of fucking Alberta.
Josh Arnold: Yeah. The o the only downside is he is Canadian. That's it.
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah, he is Canadian. So we'll have to give him his graces on that. We love Canadians still.
Josh Arnold: All right, so let's let's dive into it. And and to to preference like what we're going over, we're not talking about just oil changes here today. We're talking about how something pays a a book time, but you you go and find the car, you move the car, you get it in your bay, the parts aren't in your bay, like all the things around it that really add up to a technician walking around with a big fat negative at the end of the day. So since Richard is joining us here, let's have him kick it off.
Richard Mueller: It it all it all
Josh Arnold: Ha ha.
Richard Mueller: starts there though, right? Like if if you get like for instance, say you got a vehicle that comes in on the hook and it's no crank, no start. You're you're starting there like most manufacturers pay what do they pay? By the time you Get the keys, find the boost back if you don't have your own, walk out onto the lot, hook the boost back up, try and fire the truck up or car up or whatever it is, and get it in your bait. You know, your it pays point six, so that's thirty six minutes. and that's even before you like you could already have half hour into it. You got point five into a point six bang job. And you still have to hook up the OEM's approved battery tester to to allow it to run for Up to an hour and a half in a bay or longer than that to potentially recharge a battery or do whatever the hell it needs to do and then generate a code so then you can go to parts, push parts requests through, walk into the parts apartment and for them to say we don't have a battery for this vehicle. And then you
Marshall Sheldon: And hey, and and don't forget it's negative forty two degrees outside. And it's been sitting outside in a snowstorm all night long. And then on top of that, the manufacturer's battery testers are always a piece of crap. They never freaking work, bro.
Josh Arnold: They gotta run an hour just to test a bad battery that you can see it's on fire.
Marshall Sheldon: Dude, they gotta they
Richard Mueller: Well yeah. And if the battery's not up to temp
Marshall Sheldon: gotta connect to Wi Fi.
Richard Mueller: that's the thing, if it if it's minus forty two out and your battery's frozen, your tester won't test the battery until the battery's
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah.
Richard Mueller: at a decent temperature. So
Josh Arnold: I've literally seen a battery smoking from the tester and it still said it was good. Retest again.
Richard Mueller: yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So that that's just one example and then there's tons of other examples from OEMs. We had one at one man one manufacturer I worked for. I don't know if you guys want me to name names or not, but one OEM I was at. yeah. So
Josh Arnold: Let's play it safe. We don't want to get sued already. We're too small.
Richard Mueller: one one OEM I was at, this was back in seventeen. No. Before that. It was a door handle recall and there's still an open recall on for the door handles not working properly. That when that recall came out, I think it was like four hours and some change to do four four door latches that's peel the skins off, put the door latches in, adjust them or the door handles in, adjust them correctly, put it all back together, test operation, kick it out, right? And then one guy posted on a forum. He's like, you know, I can do this job in like just over an hour. Tex let them up, right? Because the manufacturer was only using hand tools. And then the manufacturer turned around and updated the bulletin, slashed the time almost in or greater than in half, and produced a list of power tools to use at the top. So right now the current manufacturer or the current OEM that my f my dealership is under, they have switched everything like all flat rate time going forward from twenty twenty six forward, I think. It started with some late models in twenty six. Everything changes from hand tools to power tools. So technicians are gonna see a great reduction in that. And the the argument from that is well when when is the OEM gonna supply tools to the dealerships? The technicians have made the investment in the tooling to make themselves more efficient at the jobs that they do in their bay and to reduce the amount of wear and tear on their body. They've spent, you know, tens of thousands, some technicians with toolboxes and everything and scan tools have spent, you know, upwards of we're looking at the h close to that hundred thousand dollar mark where, you know, they've they've made this investment only to get slapped backwards, right?
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Richard Mueller: To get punished for it. Like that it's the you know, I understand
Josh Arnold: And and I think that
Richard Mueller: the labor time. No, go ahead.
Josh Arnold: I I I was gonna say I think that I think that the tooling definitely I mean obviously anytime a tech is losing out on hours on warranty that's already low is never good, but I think the real bleed is the processes around the car, right? Like just what we were talking about, the battery tester. Who who mandates that? Right? Who enforces it?
Load full transcript
Richard Mueller: Yeah. yeah.
Josh Arnold: Who manages the tool that's gonna be there when it's broken? That's gonna be the dealership. So all this is out of the technician's control.
Marshall Sheldon: Is there an optime for scraping the snow off the car or what's the deal?
Josh Arnold: Point three in Canada.
Richard Mueller: No, there isn't for that for for there's no opcode for there's no like straight time for for pulling hooking up and towing a vi jet vehicle in because it won't boost, right? Like it's the you know, the manufacturer, the one OEM I was with, there was an actual time, so their their labor times are a lot different and they're broken down to go and get the vehicle and pull it into your bay and hook the scan tool up is point three. That was when I was there. They
Josh Arnold: It's always point three.
Richard Mueller: would they they would pay you point three to do that. And then it was point one to retrieve codes. And then if you if you were doing training work it was awesome because you got paid to do like a line pressure test, a stall point test, to retrieve your DTCs, check fluid level and condition, all that other stuff. So but like, you know, now the current OEM with like a lot of the a lot of them are just one hour blanket up to one hour of diagnostic time. And then from there, if you need additional time, you gotta hope and pray that you're gonna get approved for straight time, right? So but it could be worse. There's other manufacturers out there that have a cap. And I worked for one manufacturer that if you were in the interior of the vehicle, you got nothing for diagonal. Like and if you didn't
Josh Arnold: Ha ha
Richard Mueller: if you didn't have a strong service manager, which I didn't have at the time, yeah, you were just bombing bombing parts of the vehicle until it was fixed. You didn't give you not
Josh Arnold: man.
Richard Mueller: care. Did not care if it was a comeback or if it left and then came back. No, okay, I'll put another part in it. Let's leave that's use the slave rop code to claim it now 'cause there's no diagon.
Josh Arnold: And I think for me, like it's not even usually the diagnostic under the warranties, it's the recalls they get me. Because especially the small recalls. Like the things that are like min
Richard Mueller: The a programming one?
Josh Arnold: yeah, or like I remember Toyota had one that was like slap a place card on the car, right? Okay. That's point one. I get it from the manufacturer standpoint. Why that is point one? The problem is dealerships require the multi point, the racking of the car, the go getting of the car, the parking of the car. Potentially even washing the car.
Richard Mueller: Any any dealership that forces an MPI, like a free MPI on a recall. That's that's We don't do like at my dealership we don't do that. If a vehicle comes in for if they're coming in strictly for recall work, we do the recall, that's it. I'm not gonna try and like we're gonna look at history of
the vehicle. We can briefly look at history of the vehicle, but I'm not gonna turn around and and force my technicians to waste their time if a customer just is coming in for a recall. Because the most of the time those customers that are coming in for a recall, you're gonna look at their warranty history. And it's only gonna be warranty concerns they're in for. They're like, No, I'm here for my recall. I want my programming done. You're like, Okay, cool, but you go in and do your programming, it pays point three and the module ships to bed and now you're looking at four hours of time just to try and recover a stupid module while you're you're stuck in the middle of programming rate. So Yeah.
Josh Arnold: All right, but I mean, Marshall, you're being quiet down there. I get it that you're hourly, you're getting paid for this conversation while we're flagging we're we're not. But like, come on, try them in here.
Marshall Sheldon: Ha well so there is a you know w so in heavy duty is a little bit different. We do a lot of our own warranty claims. at least the different companies that I worked for So like you would go in and call the manufacturer of that axle or axle housing and they would tell you, hey, this is what it's gonna pay, this is the time. You had an opportunity to say, Hey, you know, I had to do this and this and you know, access stuff and you know, you had opportunity to kind of get some extra time because you were the one talking to the person. So for us it's a little bit different. We have a I feel like it's a little bit better in that aspect, is that we have have an opportunity to talk to the manufacturer ourselves as technicians. We're paid hourly so we're not like stressed about that like really hard line in the sand of that point three or whatever because like I'm calling the manufacturer and saying, Hey, this unit's in here for recall. the freaking I did the software update and it wiped out this computer. And like I have a opportunity to get some time back out of that. you know, one of the manufacturers, one of the engine manuf manufacturers I do that with all the time, they'll tell you, you know, they call it ninety nine time. So it's like above and beyond time And they'll say, hey, but sometimes on there the recall will say this recall does not pay any 99 times. So it's like that's it. So you may end up having to call the manufacturer and say, hey, listen, this is what happened. I did what you said in the recall to the T, but it wiped that ECM out. Now I've got to reprogram it. And then you also have the opportunity to get, you know, one of the manufacturer representatives representatives involved, you know. DSMs or something like that involved to to help you out with some of that time. so we don't
Josh Arnold: And then how
Marshall Sheldon: go ahead.
Josh Arnold: how do you feel about Richard's statement about the MPI thing though? Do you do an MPI in every single vehicle you touch, even if it's a a small recall?
Marshall Sheldon: I mean we don't do it as well as like you guys do, so like to begin with. So unless somebody comes in and they're wanting like a yearly DOT inspection or something like that. I don't think most of the heavy duty places do as good of a job as doing inspections on every vehicle. which I think they should. They also don't do the video inspections like you guys do, which I also think they should do those, because I've seen the power of them. I think they're really great tools and I think heavy duty should definitely do them because I see the potential for the dealership to make more money. And you know I have always looked at it to dealership ship is making more money then they're more likely to give me more money. So especially if I'm going out there doing these videos and just slaying you know, I feel like there's a good opportunity for me to make some coin out of that deal. So
Richard Mueller: So
Josh Arnold: I think go ahead, Richard.
Richard Mueller: my c my question for you Josh is is your dealership doing the MPIs just for a liability standpoint or are they doing it for a potential like upsell?
Josh Arnold: All the dealerships I've come across, they always do MPIs on every car for both purposes. Yes, they want the potential, right? A recall is the chance to bring a customer in. Now, most of the time recalls are low mileage, but not always the case. And then number two, yes, liability is the other thing. Like we don't want to make sure that we're sending a customer out that we had eyes on. we don't want to miss a tire, you know, potentially gonna blow up on them down the road. We don't want to miss the basics. So that's where
Richard Mueller: So
Josh Arnold: it gets hard.
Richard Mueller: here here's my question then. When you so say you bring a vehicle in, it comes in for recall, it's got an MPI on it, you you
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Richard Mueller: for whatever reason you rack it, you do a suspension test and then you find that the front lower ball joints are punched out. Can you legally hold that car then and be or can the customer come and get that car and take it and as long as they s sign a waiver, that means nothing in court.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, defin definitely the latter. As long as they sign a waiver saying that we have s s found that their vehicle was not safe, they are allowed to take that vehicle.
Richard Mueller: Yeah, 'cause like even up here we we've done that and we've had our lawyers say, No, that waiver doesn't mean anything.
Josh Arnold: And and that's the thing. Like if somebody wants to sue you, they're gonna they're gonna sue you,
Richard Mueller: Yeah, yeah.
Josh Arnold: right? Like I don't think anything can stop at the lawyer's love on both sides of things. But like the the point being here that you know it this also costs the dealership money when we have technicians that aren't efficient at what they're doing. So if a point three pay if point three oil change pays takes me actually point eight, that dealership is
also losing that point five. And that's the thing and here that really Sticks with me is this is that dealerships have the scale. They have 40 technicians, they have 20 technicians, right? So they don't feel that as much as the single technician that experiences that on a day-to-day. Now, if they were to look at it in a way that they saw that number, that bet that'd scare the crap out of them, right? But for the most part, they don't experience the key box being 10 minutes away from where your stall is, grabbing the car, bringing it back, and that's another five. They don't experience that on a day-to-day basis. So I think that there's a lot of room for improvement for number one technicians to speak up to those types of things, but also dealerships to realize how much money they're leaving on the table every single day.
Richard Mueller: Well, I think because you ha have you ever been part of a build, like when a dealership has built a like built a new build. Have you ever been part of that
Josh Arnold: I've seen I've
Richard Mueller: though?
Josh Arnold: I've seen it happen and I've seen I've never seen a dealership that I'm like, yep, they did it right.
Richard Mueller: So I worked for one dealer group where they were building a new dealer dealership right across the road from the old dealership and they had like the overall building outline and they came to me with the plans. I was a shop foreman at the time and they're like, We want you to review the plans here and let us know what changes you want to make before we finalize the drawings. So I went through the plans and was like, We need to change this wall, we need change this door, you know, because they had it they used to be like there was a quick loop And in order to go from quick lube to detail, you had to walk out the building and all the way around and then through another door in the back and then walk through and like door here, door here, door here, move this wall, change this door. 'Cause they used to have you with the original plans where you had to walk out into the showroom and then walk to the parts counter and then through another door to get your parts and then back out. I'm like, that doesn't fly like they actually did went ahead and did all the changes but then there was like stupid crap, like the the floor slope was like and a half was 'cause floor slope is usually supposed to be a quarter inch per what is it, a quarter per inch per every every foot or something like that. So over a four foot run, it should slope and it I can't remember what the run is or whatever, but they the run for them was doubled. So they couldn't put the
Josh Arnold: Not within spec.
Richard Mueller: they couldn't put the alignment rack in because when it rack when the they built up the back end, the ramps they had to get extension ramps and the extension ramps stuck out the door. because the ramps were at such a bad angle you couldn't drive a car onto it. But like that's I think if the dealer
Josh
Arnold: And that and
Richard Mueller: is gonna build a dealership though, like if they're gonna build a new location, they need to l have a meeting with the technicians and and like it's kinda like when Homer built his car, right? He wants a horn here, here, here, here and here 'cause whenever he's mad he can never find one. So I think
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha.
Richard Mueller: I think that But any good dealership is gonna any d good group is gonna be listening to their technicians, right? What works, what doesn't work, you know, what what pipes have been leaking for the past twenty five years and you know, they the they need dealerships need to listen to their technicians.
Josh Arnold: Marshall, you got anything to add?
Richard Mueller: And you can
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah, I was just thinking yeah, I was just thinking about it, you know, there's a nice tie in for like tech utilization in here. you know, we get sadly not enough technicians are trained in the utilization of all of their time properly and and things like that. And so we're kind of getting on the precipice of the conversation about tech utilization where we're talking about, you know, a tech, you're there from you know eight o'clock in the morning to five o'clock at night, and you have X amount of hours that you're there. And you wanna be that all that time, as much of it as possible, to be on work orders fixing cars. And so you know, our our good friend Joshua, he likes to talk not this Josh, our other friend Joshua. he likes to
Josh Arnold: Too many of us.
Marshall Sheldon: talk about making taking notes about all of those little things, you know, journaling out all of those time points that you're missing throughout the day. And if you do that then you'll be able to have some ammunition when you're having that conversation with your foreman, your service manager, and you're like, Hey, every day I I spend you know twenty-five minutes through my shift going to get keys. And and if you add that up and you work five, six
Josh Arnold: And then yep.
Marshall Sheldon: days a week and then you you multiply that times fifty-two weeks a year, then you're gonna have a pretty good understanding of how much time you're actually wasting and you're not hourly like I am and you're a flat rate, that's you know, hours and hours that you've just
Josh Arnold: Better yet, I mean, better yet,
Marshall Sheldon: Throw it away, you know.
Josh Arnold: have that number and times it by the effective labor rate. And then you're gonna tell the manager, this is how much money you're leaving on the door by having that keybox that far away from your text.
Richard Mueller: Mm-hmm.
Josh Arnold: Just by saying that, you've already got his attention immediately, his or hers. That being said,
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah. And
Josh Arnold: we're about that 20 minute mark. So what do we say?
Marshall Sheldon: Well, at the end of the episode we always say the same thing and that's I'll catch you on the next one.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, right. Well