رونوشت 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Views and news with Clarence Ford. We all have a voice.
00:00:05
Speaker 2: Use yours.
00:00:08
Speaker 1: Call 021-446-0567. Join the conversation on Cape Talk.
00:00:15
Speaker 2: And we're also going to talk about multilateral, yeah, well, coalition talks, essentially, after local government elections. And Nkhlumelo Traba joins us, South African governance and political analyst, journalist, and so much more. It's good to have you with us. Welcome, Chlomelo.
00:00:34
Speaker 1: A very good morning to you too, Clarence, and to your listeners. Thank you very much for having me.
00:00:38
Speaker 2: You know, we appreciate your time, and we know you're a busy man, and we know we have limited time. So let's get right to it. But I also want to ask our listeners to join the conversation via WhatsApp at 0725671567, and you can call 021-446-0567. You can interact directly with Chlomelo Kaba. Ten minutes past 11. It looks as if Johannesburg and maybe in all of Gauteng, it's fair complete. It's a done deal or is it not time to call it just yet?
00:01:11
Speaker 1: Well, I think that there seems to be a direction insofar as where things are tilting, insofar as the coalition arrangements in the Gauteng metro is concerned. And this is something that I predicted coming into the election that the coalition arrangement that you see at the Gauteng provincial legislature might actually cascade down to the metro post the election. I'm saying this because the leadership in the Gauteng province, ANC leadership, actually isolated the DA from all levers of power post the 2024 election. You would remember that the Gauteng legislature did not have an outright winner even KZN. But in KZN, we saw a GNU-like arrangement, whereas in Gauteng, we didn't. And that actually stems from the fact that the cohort of the ANC in Gauteng took that decision and actually isolated the DA, even in the metros, where the DA had been co-governing with other parties. Action SA then also collapsed the coalition there and formed a partnership with the ANC, which is what actually made me to predict that we are likely to see a similar arrangement that will not involve the DA even in the Metro's post-election. And I think that's exactly how things are unfolding now.
00:02:34
Speaker 2: Yeah, 44% in Joburg voted for the DA or voted against the ANC. It's important, and my colleague this morning said that 46% of Joburg residents voted against the DA, which is also one way of looking at it. Now, the arguments from the DA is, that this is an expedient coalition and it is going to suffer the wrath of voters come 2029, that it is short-sighted. And then, yeah, I think what would Herman Mashaba perceive as the benefits of the coalition direction that he's taking?
00:03:15
Speaker 1: Well, I think there's a certain level of double standards in political circles, particularly in those who claim that the Democratic Alliance is the largest party in Gaudeng, sorry, in Johannesburg, and should therefore govern Johannesburg with other parties. Because if you would recall, two years back, in the advent of the 2014 elections, the MKP in KZN received about 45%, which was way more than what the Democratic Alliance received. You're saying Eta Queenie, not Gauteng, right? Sorry? You're saying Eta Queenie. No, I'm saying in KVN. The MKP had received 45% yet is not governing in that province. And the ANC, TN, IFP took that decision to actually push it out of power. So I think now that the tides have changed and also tilting towards another party, people cry foul. So I think there's a certain level of double standards among politicians.
00:04:22
Speaker 2: Understood. It doesn't necessarily talk to.
00:04:29
Speaker 1: Yes, but I think that what you also need to take note of is when it comes to coalition arrangements is the fact that We need to look at the interrelationship between the different political parties that are likely to form these coalitions, as well as the numerical strength of the different political parties. And if you can look at the three Gauteng metros, you'll realize that the top five political parties, the picture, insofar as the top five parties are concerned, is constant across all the three metros except Botswana, where the Freedom Front plus, where the MK party is not part of the top five. And if you can look at the relationship between these different parties, you'll realize that the DA... at this point in time, is the only outlier insofar as not really having good relations with other political parties. So I think that factor is something that is actually at play right now and is also going to lead to the DA being isolated in these three metros. So the interrelations between the different parties is something that needs to be taken cognizant of going into a partnership, even if you can go back to the 2021 local government elections, as far as 2016 for that matter. you will realize that the relationship between the parties was central in terms of how the different coalitions were established. In Nelson Mandela Bay, for instance, you would remember that the EFF took a decision not to support the ANC at that time because of how strained the relations were between the EFF and the ANC, even in all the other networks. where the EFF did not support, yet other parties were able to cobble a coalition. So I think that element is also what we are currently seeing now in the metros that are hanging out there.
00:06:11
Speaker 2: Do you think that this will benefit the Action SA? Do you think they will benefit from this coalition agreement? Do you think they would get more votes, or will they be punished for this action in 2029? It would be.
00:06:31
Speaker 1: They are going to benefit is neither here nor there at this current stage, primarily because of the fact that when there's a correlation, I'm saying it's because of the correlation that is there between government performance as well as the voter turnout for electoral
Load full transcript
outcomes. you realize that in the early 2000s, for instance, the ANC was at its peak in terms of the support that it used to get at the polls. That was mainly because of how it was delivering services across the board during the Mbeki administration. But fast forward to now, you'd realize that the ANC's support has been waning over the past 15 or so years. And that is because of how the poor service delivery that has been confronting a lot of communities and people ultimately looking for political alternatives. So I think in terms of Action SA. particularly even the other parties that are going to be co-governing with them in a scenario where they end up governing the metros of Gauteng through a coalition. What will determine their support is their level of performance as a leading party in these coalitions.
00:07:35
Speaker 2: I got you. Okay, the other important thing that we want to discuss is suggestions that the South African Communist Party may be ceding local government election gains back to the ANC. And Jumelo Kaba is our guest. We're talking, well, South African governance and political analysts. We're wondering just how that's going to go down with the principle left. And maybe I perceive that principle left as ideological purists. I know there's rank and file caters there. There's segments of the Young Communist League as well. How will the leftists perceive that? Will they perceive it as a strategic and ideological portrayal or not?
00:08:19
Speaker 1: As I'd mentioned initially, that when it comes to coalition agreements, it's usually a game of numbers as well. You look at the different parties' numerical strength on the different councils. And if you can look also at how much support the SACP in the metro, you realize that it may not actually be a very significant player insofar as forming these partnerships is concerned. However, if you can look at the premise of why the SACP chose to split from the ANC in this election and contest as a sole entity, it was primarily because of the ANC's arrangement with the Democratic Alliance post the 2014 election. So I think that now that the ANC is It seems to be taking a different direction than the one that it took in 2024. It's something that is yet to be seen as to whether or not they will actually warm up to the ANC again and also maybe regain their or maybe support the ANC insofar as these coalition partnerships are concerned. So I think the SACP, if you can look at the current engagements that have been occurring, you will realize that it's parties involved. that the SACP has actually advised the ANC to go with, such as the MKP, as well as the EFF. So I don't necessarily think there might be a problem considering this arrangement, because even if you can look at Action SA, which appears now to be the main player in terms of, or rather the main political party, around which these coalitions are going to be centered. And if you can look at some of their policy positions as well as they have done, I don't necessarily think that the SACP may really have a problem. with the ANC forming these partnerships because it is parties that they actually advise the ANC to form partnerships with in the post-2024 era.
00:10:09
Speaker 2: Rumelo Kaba, we know you're going to catch a flight, so thank you very much for your time. It's appreciated. South African governance, political analyst, writer, author, researcher, That's Savik, a root advocacy.