رونوشت 🔗
Mark Shaw
00:00:08
Welcome to Underworlds from the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime.
Mark Shaw
00:00:12
My name is Mark Shaw, and in today's episode, I'm talking to Mark Gagliotti, who's written a fascinating life history of Yevgeny Prigozhin called Downfall.
Mark Shaw
00:00:22
It tells the story of his relationship with Putin, the rise of Wagner, his involvement in the invasion of Ukraine, and it is, in many ways an unbelievable story and a very, very good read.
Mark Shaw
00:00:35
Over to the episode.
Mark Shaw
00:01:16
It's such a huge pleasure to.
Mark Shaw
00:01:19
To have you discussing the book.
Mark Shaw
00:01:21
And I have to say that I'm not a Russia expert, obviously, but the book kind of shattered a couple of stereotypes that I had.
Mark Shaw
00:01:30
One, that Putin is this incredibly decisive figure who makes a whole lot of decisions.
Mark Shaw
00:01:36
The second that Prigozhin himself had a lot of agency.
Mark Shaw
00:01:40
He sort of.
Mark Shaw
00:01:43
He operated, he was independent, he moved around.
Mark Shaw
00:01:48
He was not a key player, but he was on the out.
Mark Shaw
00:01:51
But still, he.
Mark Shaw
00:01:52
He determined his own fate.
Mark Shaw
00:01:53
At least that's what I took from reading this book.
Mark Shaw
00:01:57
And I have to say, the book is fantastic.
Mark Shaw
00:01:59
It's an absolutely great read, filled with action, humor.
Mark Shaw
00:02:04
I mean, you just couldn't ask for anything more.
Mark Shaw
00:02:10
Is Prigozhin a decisive figure in Russian history?
Mark Shaw
00:02:14
Your conclusion says some interesting things, but you portray him in part, at least in one part as a kind of big figure, and in another part as a sort of.
Mark Shaw
00:02:26
Is it too strong to say, a sort of streetwise dimwit, not the brightest guy, but in another part, as somebody who's got courage, he steps forward, he speaks truth to power.
Mark Shaw
00:02:37
So what, is he or is he all of these things?
Mark Gagliotti
00:02:40
I mean, to a degree, he is all of those things.
Mark Gagliotti
00:02:42
Again, none of us, frankly, are the simple stereotypes.
Mark Gagliotti
00:02:46
You know, I think that in some ways, if I can just sort of pull back slightly, I mean, when Anna and I were thinking about writing this book, because we had several people saying, oh, you should write a book about Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:02:57
And we were thinking, do we really want to devote a chunk of our lives to chronicling this deeply unpleasant entrepreneur thug?
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:06
And then, well, we thought, well, actually, not so much for Prigozhin's sake, but because it's a way of illustrating actually how this whole system emerged and evolved and the degree to which it relies on people like Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:19
So to go back to your point about which of these things Prigozhin is, he is a man who clearly had a certain.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:26
Let's say, a certain skill set.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:27
I mean, he clearly knew how to flatter people in power and also how to control, in often very brutal ways, people beneath him.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:34
He never learned how to deal with peers, which is one of part of his downfall.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:38
But also, this is a man who in some ways was custom built for the 1990s.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:44
He came out of his time in the prison camp system clearly highly entrepreneurial.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:49
He didn't manage to set up a business while behind bars, but at the same time had no real kind of constraints.
Mark Gagliotti
00:03:57
He wasn't held back by family connections or anything else.
Mark Gagliotti
00:04:02
He could reinvent himself for the 1990s as exactly the kind of gangster businessman that the times demanded.
Mark Gagliotti
00:04:10
And I think this was the thing, it's that someone like Prigozhin was in many ways a man of his times.
Mark Gagliotti
00:04:17
And the key point is in some ways the degree to which, despite the much more orderly veneer of Putinism, in many ways the key drivers, this sort of lack of any kind of meaningful law based state at the high levels of society, the fact that business was simply seen as a way of making money regardless of how you did it, you know, all of these actually were very much the 1990s phenomena, but now put in a smart suit and now with their own media advisors and everything else.
Mark Gagliotti
00:04:48
And so this is why Prigozhin was interesting.
Mark Gagliotti
00:04:50
He ultimately failed because precisely of the limitations of his skill set, but he was someone who managed to both help shape the Putin era, but above all was a product of it.
Mark Shaw
00:05:04
Monk, this you say some interesting things about.
Mark Shaw
00:05:09
Well, at least somebody who tried to write on Prigozhin before the threats came thick and fast.
Mark Shaw
00:05:17
Did it?
Mark Shaw
00:05:18
This seems a strange question, perhaps, but did it?
Mark Shaw
00:05:20
The fact that he's dead, did that make it easier to write a more sort of complete, rounded story from your perspective, or did you suddenly hear when he was dead, oh, my goodness, this key figure is gone.
Mark Shaw
00:05:35
This makes it even less relevant, or whatever the case.
Mark Gagliotti
00:05:38
I mean, to be honest, that was part of the sort of solipsistic initial response to when he died.
Mark Gagliotti
00:05:43
That sense of what does this mean for us?
Mark Gagliotti
00:05:46
That's inevitable.
Mark Gagliotti
00:05:47
No, I mean, the interesting thing is we actually signed the contract to this book two weeks before his mutiny.
Mark Gagliotti
00:05:53
So when we originally pitched the idea and signed it, he was still very much a key figure within this system, even if increasingly, I mean, this was after all sort of summer of last year, increasingly kind of on the ropes.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:07
Then there was this mutiny.
Mark Gagliotti
Load full transcript
00:06:09
And unsurprisingly and perfectly legitimately, that's the point where the publisher said we really would quite light this book out and fast.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:18
But again, there was that point where we think, well, actually, this is what really makes him interesting, because precisely this is someone who has been such a beneficiary of the system, in some ways, almost a poster child for the Putin era.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:28
Not the oligarchs, but the minigarchs who are the real foot soldiers keeping this system running.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:34
And then of course, there was, two months later, there was his mysterious, but not so mysterious plane crash.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:41
And so, yes, again, there was that sense of, okay, what does this mean for us?
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:43
But I think it was very, in some ways, very useful for two reasons.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:46
One, on a purely, shall we say, book writing technical level, it did allow us to write a final chapter, which was a final chapter, and it wasn't full of who can tells and such like.
Mark Gagliotti
00:06:57
But also, I think it really does mark the point at which actually Prigozhin matters, because in some ways, up to that point, he was a representative of a particular element within the Putin elite.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:10
But the very fact that he turned against it, I mean, for his own reasons, and in some ways that it, that the system itself chose to devour him, even though he was an insider in due course, is where his real historic importance lies.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:25
It's that first of all, by his mutiny, he reveals certain weaknesses within the Putin system that hadn't been obvious before.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:32
And secondly, by his murder.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:34
And I think that is, frankly what it was.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:36
It's the very first time that the Putin system has repudiated a deal made with an insider.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:42
And again, that will have long term implications.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:45
So actually, in that respect, that nice Mr.
Mark Gagliotti
00:07:47
Putin did us both a favor by actually, by his own actions, making Prigozhin more important than he could otherwise have been.
Mark Shaw
00:07:56
Very interesting.
Mark Shaw
00:07:57
Mark, when you and Anna heard about the mutiny, did you have a sense?
Mark Shaw
00:08:03
Wow.
Mark Shaw
00:08:04
Well, you had just signed the book, right?
Mark Shaw
00:08:06
So you had a sense, you have a peak in the story.
Mark Shaw
00:08:10
Did you have a sense that this was also his death warrant?
Mark Shaw
00:08:13
I mean, that.
Mark Shaw
00:08:15
I'm not linking the book to say you were relieved and this helped you.
Mark Shaw
00:08:18
I mean, it's a genuinely analytical question.
Mark Gagliotti
00:08:22
Were you?
Mark Shaw
00:08:24
Well, this is both, obviously an explosive case situation step, but this may be the end of our main character.
Mark Shaw
00:08:34
Was it your sense then, at that time, how did you read the mutiny?
Mark Gagliotti
00:08:39
I mean, it was an extraordinary sort of period and to see that happen, and particularly just how easily they were able to take this key city of Rostov on Don and then move towards Moscow.
Mark Gagliotti
00:08:50
But yes, at that point, I think it was fairly clear that no one really ought to be offering Prigozhin life insurance now to be Honest, Once.
Mark Gagliotti
00:08:59
I mean, because it was a very quick process from start of the mutiny to the deal that ended it once that deal had been struck.
Mark Gagliotti
00:09:06
To be honest, I anticipated the Prigozhin would have maybe a year or so, either to demonstrate his loyalty and to buy his way back into the fold, or for the regime to have decided, okay, he's now no longer in so much public view, we can dispose of him more safely and quietly.
Mark Gagliotti
00:09:26
So I hadn't anticipated there'll be quite such a quick turnaround from traitor to invited to tea in the Kremlin to falling out of the sky north of Moscow.
Mark Gagliotti
00:09:37
But nonetheless, I think it was fairly clear that it was unlikely that this was going to end well in the long term.
Mark Shaw
00:09:42
For people who haven't read the book, this is great.
Mark Shaw
00:09:44
It's a couple of paragraphs which sort of analyze his decision to take the step to mount the mutiny.
Mark Shaw
00:09:53
Can you talk about that?
Mark Shaw
00:09:54
Because that's a little bit what I was saying, that that's Agency, right?
Mark Shaw
00:10:00
He steps outside of the system and he does this decisive thing.
Mark Shaw
00:10:04
And he knows the system.
Mark Shaw
00:10:05
He himself must have known that, well, this was profoundly dangerous thing to attempt.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:12
Yeah, I mean, this is a point that, you know, obviously it's very hard to actually crawl inside someone's head, especially once they're dead, and try and work out exactly how it operates.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:22
But I think it is clear that, look, as we say, it could well be.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:26
The evidence is contradictory, but it could well be that, frankly, Prigozhin hadn't wanted to be the face of Wagner in the first place.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:33
Way back in 2013, when the Kremlin had wanted to create a mercenary organization, they decided, okay, Prigozhin's, I think, the guy that's best for us.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:41
And he couldn't say no.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:43
So this is an interesting thing.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:45
He was kind of, in many ways pitchforked into this role of mercenary condottiere.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:49
But over time, it increasingly became something that he was engaged in, fascinated with.
Mark Gagliotti
00:10:56
I think, again, it played to his sort of macho Persona that he liked being the idea of this sort of tough guy and the terror of the West.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:05
And then when he went out and recruited prisoners from the labour
camp system, it's interesting how the prisoners themselves would say about it that, you know, they felt that.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:17
Exactly.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:17
Prigozhin spoke to them as one of them.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:20
They were able to be recruited because this is a guy who'd been through the Zone, the prison system, you know, and, you know, they basically felt that there was a.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:31
A guy who had certain kind of their interests at heart.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:34
And I think he did.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:35
At the same time, he was willing to use them, Sedgwick's human ammunition in these horrific, what were called meat wave attacks.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:43
But nonetheless, he felt that he and they were being taken for granted.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:49
And so much of this became personalized in terms of his relationship with the Defense Minister, Sergei Shoigu.
Mark Gagliotti
00:11:55
And again, this is where that point I made earlier about the fact that Prigozhin knew how to relate with superiors and inferiors but never with peers comes in.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:04
You know, Shoigu was essentially.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:05
I mean, actually stronger, but essentially a peer.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:09
And Prigozhin couldn't really handle that.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:11
He kept trying to basically bring Defense Minister Shoigu down, which was not going to happen because Shoigu was a personal friend of Putin's and also had a much greater institutional power base.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:22
So eventually Shoigu, who's a much better behind the scenes political operator, manages to create the situation in which all the Wagner mercenaries are going to have to sign contracts with the Defense Ministry, which would be the kind of a final emasculation of Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:36
And this is where I think sort of, again, you know, this is all just warmed over pop psychology, but I think both his own character and also the culture that he clearly did absorb from the prison system, there's this very brutal, very macho type of culture there where one of the things is you never back down.
Mark Shaw
00:12:55
Because.
Mark Gagliotti
00:12:55
Because if you back down once, you're going to spend your entire term behind the razor wire, backing down.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:00
In Prigozhin's career, he'd never actually been defeated, shall we say, by a peer.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:05
I mean, actually, yes, he sometimes had to operate.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:09
He obviously knew that he wasn't as strong as the state.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:12
But basically speaking, this is a man who had gone from success to success and wasn't very good at metabolizing the idea of a defeat.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:19
And final point, and he says it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:22
I mean, I'm sure my point is much longer than the two paragraphs you mentioned.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:27
We think this is extraordinary that Putin, that Prigozhin, might feel that he could challenge the state in this way and get away with it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:34
But the point is a.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:35
It's.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:36
In historical terms, it's not at all surprising for how mercenary companies try to renegotiate their contracts with the Bosque.
Mark Gagliotti
00:13:42
But even within the Russian context, in Chechnya, you have Ramzan Kadyrov, this willful dictator, who every time there's even some hint that the huge amount of federal subsidies which go to Chechnya and which help him ensure the quality of life in which he's become accustomed and also pay off his elites and build vanity projects and so forth.
Mark Gagliotti
00:14:03
Anytime anyone makes a hint that maybe it's time to scale those down slightly, he throws his weight around, whether he just says, oh, well, maybe it's time for me to retire, or in one case, he actually invaded a neighboring Russian republic over a territorial dispute, and each time he gets away with it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:14:20
Each time, actually, it's the state that backs down.
Mark Gagliotti
00:14:23
So, I mean, Kadyrov and Prigozhin ended up being in very different situations.
Mark Gagliotti
00:14:27
But nonetheless, I could see why Prigozhin might be able to convince himself that if he moves fast and he was thinking that he was actually going to be able to capture Shoigu and his chief of the general staff, Gerasimov, and essentially presents Putin with the fait accompli, Putin will take the line of least resistance, because that is often how Putin operates and side with him over against Shoigu.
Mark Gagliotti
00:14:48
So I think all of these things together, a mix of desperate hope, macho unwillingness to give in, and a sense of a genuine commitment to his boys, as he'd come to think of them.
Mark Gagliotti
00:15:01
All of those came together for him to think, okay, well, I either submit or I give one last throw of the dice, and he faithfully went for the latter.
Mark Shaw
00:15:09
Marcus, is Polozhin a familiar figure in Russian history, or is he a kind of outlier?
Mark Shaw
00:15:14
You've.
Mark Shaw
00:15:15
You've mentioned another parallel, the renegotiation of mercenary contracts.
Mark Shaw
00:15:23
Is he a simple product of his time, or can you think of others assertive because you use this language, the serfs.
Mark Shaw
00:15:31
Some of the language in the book is a sort of historical, analytical language to place him.
Mark Shaw
00:15:38
Hence my question.
Mark Gagliotti
00:15:39
No, I think that there is a very definite.
Mark Gagliotti
00:15:41
Well, anyway, actually, I think two historical parallels worth drawing.
Mark Gagliotti
00:15:45
One of them is that there's a constant conflict in Russian history between what we could call the boyars, in other words, the upper aristocrats, the most powerful figures, and the gentry, the people who are actually running the country, whether they're, you know, colonel of a regiment here or a large
landowner there.
Mark Gagliotti
00:16:05
And often the role of the Tsar, the monarch, has been to play these two social strata off against each other.
Mark Gagliotti
00:16:12
He needs the boyars, he needs the gentry, but so long as he can basically keep them fighting against each other, then he can control the situation.
Mark Gagliotti
00:16:22
Prigozhin was ultimately at best, gentry.
Mark Gagliotti
00:16:25
Shoigu was definitely a boyar.
Mark Gagliotti
00:16:28
So I think there was an element of, for want of a better word, a kind of class relationship there.
Mark Gagliotti
00:16:33
But more to the point, if one looks at the great rebellions which have characterized Russian history, you know, particularly coming from or originating from Cossacks, people like Pugachov and the like, almost invariably these are people who were once servants of the state, they were loyal and then they felt the state had betrayed them, had taken their loyalty for granted, had not observed the social contract, and thus they had turned against the state.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:02
And again, I think that's the tradition into which Prigozhin falls, of the loyal servant of the state who ultimately feels that the state has screwed him over and that he's not going to take it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:14
And because often actually these rebellions were not about toppling the Tsar, they were about actually grievances that they wanted sorted.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:22
And that sense of if I create enough trouble, the Tsar will have to deal with me, it's very much Prigozhin's thinking.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:28
But if I can just throw in, there's also one third posthumous historical parallel which has emerged.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:34
I mean, we've now seen, we're just over a month, a year, sorry, since Prigozhin's death.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:39
And it's not just that Prigozhin's grave has become a shrine where people sort of leave flowers and things, but there's this constant claims, particularly in social media, amongst the sort of the so called turbo patriots, the ultra nationalist wings of sightings of Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:55
He's been seen in Chad, he's been seen in the Central African Republic.
Mark Gagliotti
00:17:58
He was seen for some reason at a school assembly in Tumen, whatever.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:03
And again, this speaks to a long tradition.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:06
I mean, if one thinks after the death of Ivan the Terrible, there were not one, not two, but three false Dimitris who claimed to be Ivan's younger son in no, I Wasn't Killed when everyone thinks.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:16
And people flocked to him not because they necessarily thought that they really were Prince Dimitri, but because they represented something different.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:25
Again, a chance to rebel legitimately, to think that you're rebelling, but you're doing so in the name of something that is kind of right.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:35
And again, I think this is what's interesting.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:37
Now Prigozhin is being reinvented in certain circles as the ultimate patriot, the man who was willing to, as you said, speak truth to power, but also roll up his sleeves and do what the motherland needed without enriching himself.
Mark Gagliotti
00:18:50
When, of course, actually he enriched himself on a massive scale.
Mark Shaw
00:18:54
Fascinating.
Mark Shaw
00:18:54
Mark, this is obviously a podcast on organized crime, illicit markets, and that's a kind of constant thread through the book.
Mark Shaw
00:19:03
Prigozhin himself has a criminal background.
Mark Shaw
00:19:06
There's the Saint Petersburg mafia, there's organized crime in Russia more generally.
Mark Shaw
00:19:11
There's the activities of Wagner in Africa compared to criminal activities, et cetera, et cetera.
Mark Shaw
00:19:18
Can you piece that together for us, this refrain of organized criminality, what it means, how it shaped the actors on both sides?
Mark Gagliotti
00:19:29
Well, yes, this is the interesting thing, I mean, and it speaks to the whole definitional question that the field has grappled with time and time again.
Mark Gagliotti
00:19:38
And what is organized crime, particularly in the context of states in which the rule of law is weak?
Mark Gagliotti
00:19:45
I mean, Russia is a.
Mark Gagliotti
00:19:47
Russia is a very bizarre state in many ways, because essentially it is a modern, institutionalized, bureaucratic state that just happens to have a medieval court sitting on top of it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:19:58
So, you know, for most Russians, actually a fair degree of rule of law does exist.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:02
You know, if someone welches on a contract, if someone bangs into your car or whatever, you can go to the courts and essentially it'll be sorted the way it would be anywhere else.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:12
But as you go further up the system, the power of the rule of law becomes more and more attenuated.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:17
So, I mean, Prigozhin's strength was precisely his ability to navigate this strange hybrid realm of places where actually the personalistic relationships matter above all, rather than the niceties of the law and those areas, other areas which actually were still to a large extent dominated by contract and so forth.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:42
And I think this is the thing.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:43
It's actually, it's a very hybridity of the Putin system that creates the opportunities for people like Prigozhin, but also creates the problems for people like us who are trying to look for neat definitions.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:54
And Wagner is a classic case in point.
Mark Gagliotti
00:20:56
Wagner is a mercenary organization that is essentially created by the state, and much though not all of the time, its primary customer is the state, whether it's in Ukraine or Syria or elsewhere.
Mark Gagliotti
00:21:08
And yet Russian law expressly prescribes private military companies.
Mark
Gagliotti
00:21:14
So in some ways it is an illegal venture from the get go, but in many ways it operates in Russia as if it were a perfectly constituted legal venture.
Mark Gagliotti
00:21:27
It signs contracts with whether it's its soldiers or whether it's its suppliers, and in the main actually follows those contracts, it behaves as if it's legal.
Mark Gagliotti
00:21:38
But then when you look at its operations, particularly at Africa, there it's great strength.
Mark Gagliotti
00:21:42
And one of the reasons why I don't think actually it will in the long term survive in a post Prigozhin world and under its new Branding of the strangely tone deaf Africa Corps is what they decided to call it is precisely because you had a mercenary organization that operated like so many others.
Mark Gagliotti
00:22:02
But the point is, what really made it different was the whole back end, the fact that it was part of Prigozhin's wider business empire, the Concord Group, which meant that precisely you could hire it without having to pay cash on the nail, but instead by providing rights to a gold mine here or a diamond concession there, that much of the money was then transferred through what could be politely described as untransparent and non traditional channels.
Mark Gagliotti
00:22:33
That this was an organization that has no problem at all paying kickbacks.
Mark Gagliotti
00:22:37
Indeed, the norm, the expectation is that whoever signs a contract with Wagner can anticipate a certain amount flowing back into their private accounts.
Mark Gagliotti
00:22:46
And Prigozhin himself at the heart of this, precisely because of his capacity to, on the one hand, be legitimate enough within the Russian system that he could speak with a certain amount of authority and people would treat him as a representative of the Russian state in many ways, but on the other hand, sufficiently deniable and illegal that he can use all these questionable ways, whether it's smuggled gold heading via United Arab Emirates to reach Russia and such like.
Mark Gagliotti
00:23:15
So, I mean, again, hybrid state begat this hybrid structure that was a bit like an organized crime group, a bit like a regular private military company.
Mark Gagliotti
00:23:28
And it could be whichever one, it could anyway morph from being more one thing than the other, as circumstances required.
Mark Shaw
00:23:38
Marg, given all of this, what do you think Putin, the Russian elite, learned from the Prigozhin series of events?
Mark Shaw
00:23:51
This very interesting bits and pieces in the book, you know, after the mutiny, before, how he was dealt with, the thinking or the sort of orientation of different actors, what do you think the lessons that would have been drawn are?
Mark Gagliotti
00:24:10
I mean, I think the interesting thing is if one thinks about Putin and the actual state, I think the lessons they learned were essentially very narrow and very technical.
Mark Gagliotti
00:24:19
I mean, for example, they're now, they continue to be private military companies fighting in Ukraine, but it is clear that they're a very different sort, that they're really just simply using private military companies as structures through which to recruit more warm bodies for the war.
Mark Gagliotti
00:24:35
And although these private military companies may technically be owned by or sponsored by business people, business groups, local governors, a whole variety of different actors, none of them have anything like the kind of personal stake, let alone command authority that Prigozhin had.
Mark Gagliotti
00:24:51
So no more private armies.
Mark Gagliotti
00:24:53
That's a very, very kind of practical, technical lesson that's been learned.
Mark Gagliotti
00:24:57
The interesting thing is that on the other hand, I think the Putin regime has.
Mark Gagliotti
00:25:02
It's either not learned or more likely deliberately chosen to ignore the much bigger political questions about precisely what happens when you have an essentially personalistic system which relies on constant struggles and Putin's role as the sort of the grandmaster of this game of divide and rule.
Mark Gagliotti
00:25:25
The fact is he's going to throw up figures like Prigozhin who are going to become increasingly problematic in fighting their own struggles.
Mark Gagliotti
00:25:33
But I think, finally, if one looks at lessons that the elite has learned, I think it's quite interesting the degree to which the Putin regime came out of this very badly, and Putin himself personally did.
Mark Gagliotti
00:25:44
When the mutiny happens, as is usually the case for all the bare chested machismo of the sort of the formal portrayal of Putin actually in a crisis, he tends to hide.
Mark Gagliotti
00:25:54
And this is exactly what happened.
Mark Gagliotti
00:25:56
We first of all had a period in which no one really knew what the hell was going on.
Mark Gagliotti
00:26:00
He may well have actually been evacuated out of Moscow at the time, though officially he stayed there to rally the forces.
Mark Gagliotti
00:26:09
When he eventually does emerge, that's what he calls Prigozhin, a traitor.
Mark Gagliotti
00:26:13
And that's the point at where Prigozhin realizes that his gambit has failed and he needs to negotiate.
Mark Gagliotti
00:26:18
But Putin is clearly so desperate for this whole crisis to go away that he actually gives Prigozhin what is, I think it's fair to say is too good a deal.
Mark Gagliotti
00:26:27
If you just describe someone as a traitor to more or less give them a deal that says, look, you can hold on to most of your businesses, just go to Belarus, keep on operating in Africa, and, you know, and everything will be fine, that actually lacked credibility, frankly, that made Putin look, look weaker.
Mark Gagliotti
00:26:43
And one of the reasons for that is precisely because the security apparatus that we and Russians and I think Putin himself had always thought was the final
backstop of his regime proved notably unwilling to actually support the Kremlin against Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:00
Nor were they willing to support Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:02
I mean, he himself had thought that half the army would back him.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:04
Well, I think he had 90 guys defect to his side, that's all.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:08
But the main thing is most of the security apparatus was just willing to basically sit it out and just see what happened.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:13
And I think that was a particularly chilling shock to the regime and not one they really know how to respond to.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:20
And finally, the very fact that Putin welched on a deal, he clearly had reached an agreement with Prigozhin that allowed Prigozhin to survive.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:31
Now, Putin may be a man who breaks international law every day before breakfast, but nonetheless, like any mob boss, he'd understood the importance of loyalty within the gang.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:44
And this is the first time, really, that Putin had actually broken a deal with an insider.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:50
Not some dissident, not some foreign businessman or whatever, but an insider.
Mark Gagliotti
00:27:54
And that broke the ponyatia, the understandings that I think are central to how this personalistic regime relies.
Mark Gagliotti
00:28:02
So that really was a shocking thing for the elite to actually have Putin now break a deal, which means that next time there's a deal, will people think, well, okay, but will Putin hold to it or not?
Mark Shaw
00:28:13
Well, because, interesting.
Mark Shaw
00:28:14
When I had followed events obviously not closely like you have, and then reading the book, when Prigozhin died, there was a sense that Putin planned this the whole time.
Mark Shaw
00:28:27
Right.
Mark Shaw
00:28:27
This was very, you know, strategic.
Mark Shaw
00:28:30
A lot of the attributes that are given to him and which I think a narrative is built around those.
Mark Shaw
00:28:37
But actually, when you read the book, it's not clear that his death was inevitable.
Mark Shaw
00:28:43
Am I wrong in that.
Mark Shaw
00:28:45
In the sense that he did a deal, it was a good deal, as you say.
Mark Shaw
00:28:51
Do you think when negotiating that deal, Putin had already decided he would die, or was this just sort of like an incremental set of decisions later, and then it was done?
Mark Shaw
00:29:03
Because at the time, people sort of sat back and said, I told you so.
Mark Shaw
00:29:07
You know, Putin's strategic.
Mark Shaw
00:29:08
This guy was sort of asking for it.
Mark Shaw
00:29:13
The point you make, which is, I think, a very apt point on the Mafia boss equivalency, which is, he broken the unstated agreement, which shakes everybody up and undermines trust, which is core to sort of holding the center together.
Mark Shaw
00:29:28
But I guess the question is, in your reading, was his death an inevitable issue when the very negotiations were taking place, if you follow what I'm asking.
Mark Gagliotti
00:29:42
Yeah, I mean, I suspect that kind of probably inevitable in the long term.
Mark Gagliotti
00:29:47
But I don't think for a moment that Putin was thinking, right, we'll sign the deal, lull him into a full sense of security, and then I'm going to kill him.
Mark Gagliotti
00:29:54
Because if nothing else.
Mark Gagliotti
00:29:55
Well, firstly, Putin is not strategic.
Mark Gagliotti
00:29:58
We see that in so many other ways.
Mark Gagliotti
00:29:59
He is a tactician rather than a strategist.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:01
He responds to the moment, and sometimes that works well and sometimes that works badly.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:06
Secondly, he had many other opportunities to dispose of Prigozhin before that point, and he didn't have to even do it in such a pyrotechnic way.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:14
He could have had Prigozhin Arrested, put on trial.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:17
Or indeed, Prigozhin could have fallen out of the metaphorical window when the next week, he was invited to the Kremlin for a meeting with Putin, accompanied by about 50 of his field commanders.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:29
There were so many times in which, actually, Prigozhin was entirely within the grip of the Kremlin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:33
They didn't need to do it at this time in this way.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:37
So it's very hard to obviously crawl into the deep, dark recesses of Putin's brain.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:41
But nonetheless, my sense is that, no, I mean, there wasn't any kind of specific plan or timeline, and instead, what's come out is, first of all, Prigozhin himself clearly thought he got away with it, at least for the moment, and he was going to throw himself into his Africa ventures.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:56
I suspect precisely that was his way of.
Mark Gagliotti
00:30:58
He thought, this is how he can buy his way back into the Kremlin's favor, because it's clear that the Kremlin did appreciate the whole Concord and Wagner operations in Africa.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:10
They had economic but above all, political value.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:15
He's moving back and forth between Belarus and Russia without hindrance.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:21
And we also know that there was actually debate within the Kremlin or within the government circles about what to do.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:28
And by all accounts, one of Putin's kind of closest henchmen, Secretary of the Security Council Nikolai Patrushev, was a guy who actually had drawn together a plan for how Prigozhin can be killed, but that he had drawn it up on his own authority.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:46
So, in other words, he had a plan ready to push on Putin rather than because Putin has said from the beginning, make sure that we're ready to kill him.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:55
So I think that this is classic Putin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:31:57
This is classic Putin that, you know, he makes decisions and then he changes his
mind.
Mark Gagliotti
00:32:01
We have a sense that somehow, again, everything always works out the way Putin wants, because in some ways, Putin is this gray blur.
Mark Gagliotti
00:32:07
He is in so many ways.
Mark Gagliotti
00:32:08
And again, I say this as someone who's also written a biography of Putin, but, you know, a gray, dull man, and in his very grayness, makes him a Rorschach inkblot over which observers can overlay.
Mark Gagliotti
00:32:20
You know, if they want to see him as the sort of the grand grandmaster of geopolitical 3D dimensional chess, they can see that in him.
Mark Shaw
00:32:27
I don't this point, you've covered it a bit, but just to explore it a bit more, of elite competition in the Russian system, which the book covers really well.
Mark Shaw
00:32:40
It's a bit like a soap opera, and There's a bit of humor in there.
Mark Shaw
00:32:42
Not that you deploy to great effect.
Mark Shaw
00:32:47
Just explain that Prigozhin, the military, the fsb, this personal competition you've talked about, the contracts, but this was.
Mark Shaw
00:32:57
This was something pending for a much longer period of time from Syria, where clearly, as you described, the Americans were allowed to essentially destroy a part of a force.
Mark Shaw
00:33:14
I mean, just talk us through that.
Mark Shaw
00:33:17
Because this competition, this more than a triangle, was underway for some time.
Mark Shaw
00:33:24
And as you portray it, Putin is above all of this intervening.
Mark Shaw
00:33:29
He doesn't want to disappoint.
Mark Shaw
00:33:32
In effect, he comes across as a weaker figure under which this competition occurs.
Mark Shaw
00:33:36
And he doesn't intervene to solve it.
Mark Shaw
00:33:39
He uses it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:33:40
As I read the book, yeah, I mean, this is absolutely central to how Putin manages the elite.
Mark Gagliotti
00:33:46
And in fairness, although I regard Putin as distinctly limited in many ways, one has to say this is where he's really shown his skill, is precisely creating this constant ferment within the elite, individual factions and institutions competing against each other, usually because of deliberately overlapping responsibilities and interests, because that, first of all, means that no one can really unite against him.
Mark Gagliotti
00:34:13
He remains the sort of the final decider at the top.
Mark Gagliotti
00:34:17
And secondly, precisely because he can go in and he can decide who wins this particular competition, if he gets to pick the winners and the losers, then that gives everyone a good reason to basically want to please and flatter and speak to the boss.
Mark Gagliotti
00:34:31
And let's be clear, the real currency, the true currency of Russia, is not the ruble.
Mark Gagliotti
00:34:36
It is Putin's favorite.
Mark Gagliotti
00:34:39
So that is often politically very functional, even if administratively dysfunctional, because precisely you have all kinds of different sort of competitions over
particular areas of state activity.
Mark Gagliotti
00:34:55
The thing is, in this case, when you've got someone like Prigozhin who is not, as I say, in Putin's closest innermost circle, despite some of the talk, he was never a friend of Putin's.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:06
He was a one of many suitors to Putin's attention.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:11
He was clearly sort of trusted to a considerable degree or regarded as having certain competencies.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:16
But even then, I mean, you know, Putin, we talk in the book at one point about a point when Putin just goody gratuitously decides to put him down.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:24
You know, walking past him in St.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:27
Petersburg and sort of says, oh, nice hairstyle, and points to his, you know, points to his head.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:33
That's classic Putin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:35
He likes putting people down just to make sure that they appreciate where they are in the pecking order.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:40
So in that respect, Prigozhin is like so many of These kind of, what I call them, ad hocrats, whose responsibilities are just simply whatever the boss wants them to be.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:50
Hence, a catering magnate can become a troll master and then, in due course, a mercenary commander.
Mark Gagliotti
00:35:57
You're constantly trying to see how you can compete for the boss's favor.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:00
And sometimes that means guessing what the boss is going to want tomorrow and providing it today.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:05
And sometimes it's going to mean precisely doing down your rivals.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:09
And this is.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:10
This is exactly where Prigozhin found himself.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:12
But the point is, as he rose, he was getting into more and more dangerous environments.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:18
It's one thing when he was largely a kind of a catering and real estate magnate facing similar comparable figures.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:25
But by the time he was running a mercenary army, and particularly at the point where, you know, he really was making his.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:32
His name both for the trolls and the mercenaries at around 2015, which is when they were going into Syria, now he's up against much more formidable figures, figures like Shoigu, who, as I said, have actually, they are Putin's friends.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:49
Shoigu famously would take Putin on holiday to hiking through Siberia with added photo opportunities.
Mark Gagliotti
00:36:58
And this is the environment in which he finds himself, and it's one in which he again, can demonstrate certain sort of primal skills.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:06
But ultimately, Prigozhin's key blunder is that he's never able to make alliances.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:13
When you're operating at that level, you need to have allies, not just patrons and clients, but allies, and he was never able to do that.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:21
And again, that tells us something about the deinstitutionalization of the top of the Putin system, the degree to which it is.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:29
It's about personalistic relationships, it's about your capacity to pitch your ideas or just simply your value to the boss.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:38
And today he will support you.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:42
He might not tomorrow.
Mark Gagliotti
00:37:43
So, like a shark, you have to keep swimming in order to keep breathing.
Mark Shaw
00:37:48
Mark, can you talk about the sourcing for the book, if that's the right word, because you're struck.
Mark Shaw
00:37:56
This is an authoritarian regime.
Mark Shaw
00:37:59
It creates its own narratives.
Mark Shaw
00:38:02
Except what you have here in the book, what Ana and you have done is, well, there's a lot of information available, or maybe not all of it is as valuable as some core parts.
Mark Shaw
00:38:14
But how do you work on Russia as a man like Prigozhin?
Mark Shaw
00:38:22
Where do you get the material from?
Mark Shaw
00:38:24
How do you weigh it and balance it as a researcher, scholar, academic?
Mark Shaw
00:38:32
Is there things you think that you have hints of that will still emerge that you skirted over in the book and you didn't have Enough evidence, For example, is it a struggle to piece something like this together?
Mark Gagliotti
00:38:45
Well, the honest answer is, yes, it is.
Mark Gagliotti
00:38:47
And certainly there are some anecdotes and things which kind of broke our hearts in that.
Mark Gagliotti
00:38:53
You know, we heard it and think, oh, that's a great story, but we've got one source that claims it and not necessarily an authoritative source.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:01
We can't use it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:03
Yeah, I mean, look, first of all, I think there's often a misunderstanding about Russia.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:07
On the one hand, yes, this is an information controlled society, but I think it's also actually one in which there is still a lot of pluralism within sourcing, even within the media.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:17
I'm not just talking about social media type stuff.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:19
I am continually astonished that there are investigative journalists, for example, who are still doing their job or trying to do their job at least.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:29
Even though frankly being an investigative journalist in Russia has been demonstrated to be as dangerous as being a war correspondent.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:36
But nonetheless they do it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:38
So there is quite a bit of information that is still out there.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:40
Secondly, although we're seeing an increasing rollback, there have actually been quite a few moves within Russia, sort of, until recently, to push forward transparency.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:51
So whether it's in terms of corporate ownership structures and the like, you know, there was actually a lot of, lot of information available.
Mark Gagliotti
00:39:57
Thirdly, I mean, yes, one also
has to rely quite a bit on social media, which, you know, is always a very sort of questionable source because the risk is otherwise it's all about, you know, you find the quote or the post that suits the narrative that you already assume is there.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:14
So one has to treat that with caution.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:15
But nonetheless, there's a lot of stuff there.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:17
But also there's personal contacts.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:19
I mean, the thing is that, look, I've been working on Russia since God helped me.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:24
It was still the Soviet Union.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:26
And my co author, Anna Rotunyan, she had been political editor of the Moscow News, she was the senior Russia analyst for International Crisis Group.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:36
She had her own network.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:37
But the key thing is actually these are actually quite different networks.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:40
I mean, mine had always focused largely on the sort of the security apparatus, the police and so forth.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:44
Hers was much more politics and business.
Mark Gagliotti
00:40:47
And going back to your earlier point about what changed when Prigozhin died, it's worth noting that there were several sources who either wouldn't talk to us at all while Prigozhin was alive because he was notoriously not just litigious, but if you happened to be in Russia, you know, he would indeed threaten to have people killed and so forth.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:07
And Others who were, after Prigozhin had died, suddenly, a lot more open in how.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:15
How they spoke to us.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:16
So there was a funny moment in which, although we were right close to the end of when we actually needed to submit the manuscript, suddenly one had people say, you know, when I, when I answered that question, I wasn't perhaps completely open about that.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:29
And you're suddenly factoring in a whole new amount of information.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:33
So, look, I mean, it's, obviously, it's inevitably difficult.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:36
And there were points where either we had to indicate.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:39
Well, it's like, for example, this whole question as to whether Prigozhin wanted or didn't want to actually run Wagner.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:45
We've got the two perspectives.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:48
My own personal hunch is actually that he didn't want to run Wagner.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:52
But the point is we haven't got the data to actually prove that.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:55
So we lay out both possibilities.
Mark Gagliotti
00:41:57
And there are other times when we did actually just have to make a leap of faith.
Mark Gagliotti
00:42:00
Just simply say, well, this feels like the right answer.
Mark Gagliotti
00:42:04
That's what you do.
Mark Gagliotti
00:42:06
But, no, I think that when it comes to Russia, the interesting thing is that although there are always certain specific bits that you're never going to know, what happens in Putin's discussions with his security chiefs, for example, that is the blackest of black boxes.
Mark Gagliotti
00:42:20
That's not going to come out for 50 years, unfortunately.
Mark Gagliotti
00:42:23
But beyond that, there's actually a surprisingly wide range of information sources still available on Russia Today.
Mark Shaw
00:42:33
Mark, you know, I've of course read your other stuff, and as to.
Mark Shaw
00:42:37
I mean, it's.
Mark Shaw
00:42:38
It's my assumption actually, that this is a different project for you, very personalized around one individual.
Mark Shaw
00:42:47
You slightly dismissively said warmed over pop psychology earlier.
Mark Shaw
00:42:53
I.
Mark Shaw
00:42:54
And I'm not sure that's true, but there's some very interesting analysis about, well, the man being a human, etc.
Mark Shaw
00:43:02
Competition, how people respond.
Mark Shaw
00:43:05
How did the book evolve?
Mark Shaw
00:43:07
You know, you've got these, the chapters which are very interesting because the chapter structure, Thug, entrepreneur, chef, mini garc, troll, master, conditier, scavenger, warlord, rebel, ghost, this sort of the multiple personalities of the man.
Mark Shaw
00:43:25
How did that evolve?
Mark Shaw
00:43:26
How were you.
Mark Shaw
00:43:27
Were there alternative ways that you debated about using the material?
Mark Shaw
00:43:32
Or did this just.
Mark Shaw
00:43:33
Was it just clear this was a man with multiple personalities, if you like, or ways that he could be pitched.
Mark Gagliotti
00:43:44
Yes.
Mark Gagliotti
00:43:44
I mean, first of all, to go back to your initial point about a different type of project, I mean, it is.
Mark Gagliotti
00:43:48
And in some ways it's precisely because it is not just my product, it's a hybrid of two people.
Mark Gagliotti
00:43:54
And it was a very equal writing process.
Mark Gagliotti
00:43:58
Most of the chapters, what would happen is we would discuss in advance, sort of, roughly speaking, what we thought it would cover.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:04
Though there's always discovery when you're writing.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:08
Usually Anna would write the first draft, but make sure it was well under word count.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:13
Then I would add in all the bits that I wanted to add in and so forth.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:16
And sometimes we discuss.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:17
And I'm thinking, well, no, it's not this.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:19
And Anna would say, yes, yes, it is that, or whatever.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:22
Whereas with the more military oriented chapters, generally I would do the first draft and then Anna would do all the tinkering.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:30
So this is definitely a sort of a geshed out project in that respect, but also.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:36
Exactly.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:37
I think it was a different way of trying to approach it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:41
There's so many books to try
and talk about what Putinism is about and the Putin regime and such like, and they tend to start from structure and then illustrate it with people.
Mark Gagliotti
00:44:52
And this is why we thought, well, this actually is an interesting alternative way of trying to talk about a system is through the story of one person who coincidentally, or more to the point, conveniently, actually his career does track through so many of the developments of the pre Putin era and then the Putin era itself, and deciding to structure it around his different roles.
Mark Gagliotti
00:45:19
It was a way of, you might say, keeping to a relatively chronological span, which gives the reader an easy thing to hold onto and allows it more easily to kind of demonstrate the evolving patterns of what's happening in Russia at this time.
Mark Gagliotti
00:45:38
But actually, fortuitously, one could periodize his life quite so clearly it's not as if he stopped being an entrepreneur with his catering and real estate and marketing and everything else ventures when he was running the Trolls or running Wagner, they were constantly operating in the background.
Mark Gagliotti
00:45:58
But nonetheless there was this sense that he was meeting a variety of needs of the state.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:04
And that's the crucial point.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:06
Prigozhin's.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:08
And it's strange because when you really dig into a person and you're watching all of their social media videos and any interviews they give and so forth, there is a sort of a weird cognitive dissonance that creeps in and you start to sort of become a bit of a partisan and he's still a horrible man.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:22
But then there are times when you think there he has a point, you know.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:26
But Prigozhin's brilliance was precisely his capacity to spot these evolving opportunities which were in themselves invariably products of the evolving state.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:38
This is not just simply about how a market Evolves.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:40
It's how a market is shaped by a political structure.
Mark Gagliotti
00:46:43
So in some ways, Prigozhin gave us that structure through his activities, and that gave us something that helps make the book kind of comprehensible.
Mark Shaw
00:46:54
As you've described, that you end with ghosts.
Mark Shaw
00:46:58
But you also have this fascinating concluding chapter about the.
Mark Shaw
00:47:04
Well, about the future of the Russian Federation and whether this will be viewed historically, the mutiny, or Prigozhin himself and his role as a sort of breaking point, I suppose, or whether this was more continuity.
Mark Shaw
00:47:20
What do you think it means for the future of Russia?
Mark Shaw
00:47:24
How will this be?
Mark Shaw
00:47:25
Ready?
Mark Gagliotti
00:47:26
Yes.
Mark Gagliotti
00:47:27
I mean, look, whenever you write something, you always want to be able to claim that this is absolutely pivotal and the whole
world changed when this happened, which may prove to be the case, but is likely to be something of an exaggeration.
Mark Gagliotti
00:47:40
But on the other hand, I mean, I do think that Prigozhin, by his rise, but above all by his fall, did demonstrate some fundamental weaknesses of the Putin system.
Mark Gagliotti
00:47:51
And not just to us, we're not the important ones, but actually, I think, also demonstrated them to the Russian elite and the Russian population as a whole.
Mark Gagliotti
00:47:58
You know, the degree to which Putin, who for so long had precisely been the man who could manage the elite and the rivalries within them, failed to manage this, even though so many people have been telling him that the Prigozhin Shoigu rivalry was becoming crucially dangerous.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:14
The fact that he was unable to rely on his security apparatus in this particular crisis, and the fact that he ultimately broke a deal with an insider, all of those are things that have become very much noticed, and they leave Putin in a weaker position for the next crisis, because this is a regime which, in my opinion, is, shall we say, strong but brittle.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:37
It can handle the day to day, even with this ghastly war taking place in Ukraine.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:42
But on the other hand, it's demonstrated itself the best of times not to be very good at dealing with the unexpected crisis.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:48
And one thing one can say about politics is there will always be an unexpected crisis coming along.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:52
We don't know when and what.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:53
That's the whole point.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:54
That's why it's unexpected.
Mark Gagliotti
00:48:56
But in the past, the regime was able to cope with crises thanks to three strengths.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:01
Putin's personal legitimacy, his capacity to throw huge amounts of money at problems, and ultimately his control of the security apparatus.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:10
Well, the money issue is already under pressure.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:13
His regime, sorry, his authority, his legitimacy has been demonstrated to be much weaker than might have been thought and indeed has been weakened by the mutiny and more to the point, this was the first real test of the security apparatus's willingness to put itself in the line of fire for him.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:30
And it showed that it was actually not that keen.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:32
Thank you very much.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:34
So going into the next crisis, the regime will be that much weaker.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:38
Now, it doesn't necessarily mean that the next crisis will bring it down or the one after that, but the point is it is a progressive degradation.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:44
So in this respect, I think one can say that Prigozhin sort of hammered some cracks into the edifice.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:51
The main due course, under other pressures, break open.
Mark Gagliotti
00:49:55
But a final point is, and this is something that Anna, I mean, speaking as someone who she's Russian, American, but basically Russian and had been living in Moscow and obviously got out quickly when the invasion happened, you know, was much more sort of insistent that we should include, and I think she was absolutely right about this, is the sense that one of the things that Prigozhin also highlighted was the moral intellectual vacuum at the heart of this regime, that there is very little sense now for all the attempts to build the current conflict to some kind of grand civilizational struggle and so forth.
Mark Gagliotti
00:50:30
No one really believes that there is that sense that this is just a self interested bunch of often deeply incompetent figures running it.
Mark Gagliotti
00:50:39
And Prigozhin, by doing one of the most dangerous things for an information control authoritarianism, which is actually telling the truth or some of the truth about what was going on in the war, that helped explain why he was popular, but it also helped explain why he was dangerous.
Mark Gagliotti
00:50:56
And although Prigozhin didn't really offer anything else, I mean, he was not a revolutionary, he was just a self interested thug who ultimately ended up on the wrong side of the state.
Mark Gagliotti
00:51:08
But nonetheless, what happens now is that people have mythologized Prigozhin.
Mark Gagliotti
00:51:13
The people precisely now see him as a certain figure who fulfills some of the needs of the Russian people.
Mark Gagliotti
00:51:21
They want to have something in which to believe Putin is no longer that thing.
Mark Shaw
00:51:25
Thanks, Mark, that's excellent.
Mark Shaw
00:51:27
I really appreciate the discussion.
Mark Shaw
00:51:28
And the title is Downfall.
Mark Shaw
00:51:30
And from what you're saying there, of course, that's downfall of Prigozhin himself, but potentially downfall of much more.
Mark Shaw
00:51:37
It's a fascinating read.
Mark Shaw
00:51:40
Prigozhin, Putin and the New Fight for the Future of Russia.
Mark Shaw
00:51:44
Anna Arutynyan and Mark Gagliotti, and we've been speaking to Mark.
Mark Shaw
00:51:51
A great read.
Mark Shaw
00:51:52
Mark, thank you very much for the candid back and forth about the book, how you structured it, how you worked on it.
Mark Shaw
00:51:58
It's really, really a great read.
Mark Gagliotti
00:52:00
My great pleasure.
Mark Gagliotti
00:52:00
Good to talk to.