رونوشت 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Life Audio.
00:00:04
Speaker 2: On today's episode of Timeless Wisdom.
00:00:07
Speaker 1: God has created the world where the evidence for atheism is tremendous and the evidence for theism is tremendous. Therefore, leaving it up to your free will whether or not to believe in God. Now let me answer this further because it's actually a topic I wanted to talk about tonight anyway. Early human beings needed Super bold manifestations of God. That's what they needed. Wow, he could send locusts. Wow, he could play with the gods of Egypt. That's impressive. At this point in history, the human being should not need magic tricks to believe in God. We should be sophisticated enough to see many other things.
00:00:53
Speaker 2: That's coming up on Timeless Wisdom with Dennis Prager. Welcome to Timeless Wisdom with Dennis Prager. Hear thousands of hours of Dennis' lectures, courses, and classic radio programs. And to purchase Dennis Prager's Rational Bibles, go to DennisPrager.com.
00:01:11
Speaker 1: All right, now, last week was about as intense as it will get, and it gets pretty intense, on the importance of God. Does anybody have any questions or any comments? Sir? Yes, I have two questions. Mm-hmm. My question to that point is, if we destroy the candidates, would they possibly work at church?
00:01:43
Speaker 2: My second question has to do with another point you.
00:01:48
Speaker 1: Made, that without God we are not.
00:01:49
Speaker 2: Really technically considered brothers and sisters, because only we try to share the same character.
00:01:58
Speaker 1: If someone makes the point that we all can contain a mother and a half-brother, and therefore that makes me a brother or sister to anyone else on earth. Yep. The first question with regard to the Greeks, after all, were pantheists or polytheists, and they had abstract thought. I don't have an answer to. I have thought about that. The only thing I can answer is that we are, we who, we who have inherited, we in the West, are really resting on the foundations of Jerusalem and Athens. And so the fairest statement in that regard would be that the odds are that Greek thought would have ended, probably, and lapsed into a more pagan mode of thinking without the infusion of Jerusalem. And Jerusalem needed the philosophical influence The Torah is not a philosophical book. It's a moral book. It's a spiritual book. It's a holy book. And so that it's an anecdote. It's an asterisk that I should have inserted. So I'm happy you raised it. The the second question was with regard to. Oh, yeah. After all, do we not have all the same mother in Africa? Are we therefore not all brothers and sisters? Yes. But that that's blood brother. This is spiritual, brother and sister, and as we all know, blood brothers and sisters don't treat each other necessarily well. There is no moral implication from our all descending from the same biological parent in Africa, right? I don't think that that fact makes any of
Load full transcript
you think, therefore, of somebody living right now in Burma as your brother or sister. Right? It has no implication. One God, and we're all his children, has an enormous implication. Is that fair? Okay. Yes. Do you believe that God reveals himself in a human, specific kind of way that mankind evolves and is ready to hear? And the corollary to that is that he does not have a thing about human beings. Okay, the corollary is really a second question. I'm not sure, although it might be a corollary. The first question was, does God reveal himself in increasingly sophisticated ways, which is a gentle way of saying in less obvious ways, correct? I was just reading a review of a book written by an atheist who said, come on, let's be honest. If God simply came in the last quarter of the Super Bowl, everybody would know there's a God You know, why doesn't God do that? All right. You know, he's a big talker. Why doesn't he show up at the Super Bowl? You know, half the world is watching. And that's in effect. Right. That's an unsophisticated revelation. Of course, my theory and I'm going to wait for this till we get to the splitting of the sea and the Jews reactions to that, which is, of course, coming up, though not tonight, is that I suspect that if God did show up in the fourth quarter of the Super Bowl, it would have no impact whatsoever. on most viewers. Those who believe would be convinced. Those who don't believe would be convinced it was a trick, an extraterrestrial. I'll give you a classic example. To me, your existence is a bigger miracle than anything else. It is a bigger miracle than any splitting of seas. That To me, suffices. There was a Nobel Prize winning astronomer who said, human life really is incredible. I have deduced scientifically it doesn't make sense that people are here. But he nixed the possibility of it being God and said, in total seriousness, extraterrestrials spread spores on Earth, which eventually developed into people. He was more prepared to believe in extraterrestrials sprinkling spores that made us than a God. And that is how I truly believe it would happen if God came during the Super Bowl. Very few people would change their mind. Believers would stay believers. Nonbelievers would stay nonbelievers and say it was a trick. the Christian coalition had rented the Super Bowl and made something silly happen, or whatever. Look, and I don't want to give my punchlines away from when we get to the chapter, but how did the Jews make a golden calf right after seeing the sea split in ten plagues? That's more dramatic than an appearance at the Super Bowl. And then they still went to a calf. So I argue to you that our belief, you know, God's revelation, that is the genius of God, and there are many genius aspects. This to me is a genius aspect. God has created the world where the evidence for atheism is tremendous and the evidence for theism is tremendous. Therefore, leaving it up to your free will, whether or not to believe in God. Now let me answer this further, because it's actually a topic I wanted to talk about tonight anyway. Early human beings needed super bold manifestations of God. That's what they needed. Wow, he could send locusts. Wow, he could play with the gods of Egypt. That's impressive. As we get sophisticated, the corollary question you asked, we should not need that sort of magician stuff. That's why it goes on, even the magicians did it. This is the stuff that impressed the Israelites. Wowee, magic. God, at this point in history, the human being should not need magic tricks to believe in God. We should be sophisticated enough to see many other things. As for the Jew, for example, Jewish history. Jewish history is a pretty amazing thing, even from an atheistic standpoint. The non-Jew has awesome evidence as well. I just gave one specific Jewish example. So that is how I would answer you, and that is why, ladies and gentlemen, if God did come in the Super Bowl and forced you, not by twisting your arm, but by twisting your mind, to believe in him, you would lose your freedom of choice. It would no longer be belief. I was just asked by an Australian Jewish magazine some basic questions about my beliefs, and they said, you know, is something with regard to that, and I said, If there were proof, it wouldn't be a belief. Belief is by believing God. If I could prove God, God would be not God. God is accessible through belief alone, not through proof. I never agree with believers who try, oh, there's a proof. There was an ongoing source of some levity to a dear friend of mine who was a clergyman at the time He used to be on Religion on the Line. And he's a former priest. And we're still quite close. And we often, when we get together, go through some of the clergy who would come on and say, what do you mean? Of course I believe in God. Or in one case, of course I know Jesus Christ was the Messiah. How? Because the same way I know George Washington was president. But that's not true. A Christian believes in Jesus not the way one believes that George Washington was the first president. I know George Washington was the first president. And God wants us to believe and not know in an empirical manner. Does that answer you? More or less. Okay. Yes. Or certainly tackles that subject. That's right. Disappearance of God by Friedman. Thank you. A couple of more, yeah. The question was, she believes whatever the arguments that I made for the importance of God, but why then is the Jewish God more important than any other God? The Jewish God is not more important than any other God. There is no Jewish God. There is no Jewish God. There is God. Do you mean the Jewish perception of God? Well, the answer... The best answer I can give you is that the Jewish perception of God is the God that all monotheistic faiths accept. There is no other God offered. There is now. I mean, the only alternative, Buddhism does not offer a counter God. Confucianism does not offer a counter God. The
only alternatives are polytheistic gods with a small g, and there is a leap of faith. Perhaps Vishnu is. Well, I don't want to take the Hindu, because Hinduism could argue when its higher levels is monotheistic. We'll leave that aside. Zeus, maybe Zeus is God. I can't disprove that fact, but I don't believe it. We're talking about the God, though, that this Bible revealed to the world. That is the God accepted by all monotheistic faiths, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. So do you have something in mind that... Oh, why the Jewish path to God? Well, I frankly think that there are many paths to God. I've never argued that there's only a Jewish path. I accept the Jewish path out of faith and out of rational conviction. But I want people to follow. I want people to be good ethical Christians and good ethical Muslims and follow their paths to God. I do not believe that there is only a Jewish path to God, nor does Judaism. It does not hold that at all. If it did, then it would obviously insist that everybody convert to Judaism. And while I believe Judaism is very encouraging and open of conversion, certainly I don't believe insist that you become a Jew in order to come to God. There was no hint of that notion in Judaism. Okay?
00:13:13
Speaker 2: No, what I said, the Torah's perception of God is unique.
00:13:34
Speaker 1: In that it shows a God that is separate from nature. The pagan gods were part of nature. Thunder was a god, the Nile was a god, the sun was a god. So you prayed in nature, you worshipped. This God created nature and can do whatever he wants with it. Okay? That's, again, the great point of the plagues. Any more? Okay. Chapter 10. These will really, chapters, I hope to get through 10 and 11 today, and 10 and 11 are more narrative than awesome moments, which is, give us a little break after last week's intensity, but we are doing it verse by verse and we will proceed. Then God said to Moses, go to Pharaoh, for I have hardened his heart and the hearts of his courtiers or his servants. In order that I may display these my signs among them. Remember I showed you the ten times it says that people will know that I am God. Remember we've gone through that intensely so I certainly won't repeat. And that you, this is you to God saying to Moses. The you in the Hebrew here is singular. You may recount in the hearing of your sons and of your sons' sons. How I made a mockery of the Egyptians. That is not exactly what it has in Hebrew. It's really of, I have, what other translations do you have? Toyed with what? Toyed with what? Egypt. That is the literal, not with Egyptians, but with Egypt. Okay, I just want you to know that. I think mockery of the Egyptians is a little too severe for what the Hebrew really says. and how I displayed my signs among them, in order that you, plural, that is you, all of you, will know that I am God. So Moses and Aaron went to Pharaoh and said to him, Thus says God, or Jehovah, the God of the Hebrews, How long will you
refuse to humble yourself before me? What other word do you have aside from humble yourself? Or does everybody have humble yourself? Submit, refuse. Okay. It really comes from the word humble, so I was just curious. Let my people go that they may worship me. For if you refuse to let my people go, tomorrow I will bring locusts on your territory. They hadn't had enough yet. Now it was locusts. They will cover the surface of the land so that no one will be able to see the land. They will devour the surviving remnant that was left to you after the hail. So what was not destroyed by the hail will now be eaten by the locusts, and they shall eat away all your trees that grow in the field. Moreover, hold on. Here is a description of what it is like when swarms of locusts come. Quoted in Hertz, citing Lord Bryce. It is a strange sight, beautiful if you can forget the destruction it brings with it. The whole air to 12 or 18 feet above the ground is filled with the insects. reddish brown in body with bright, gauzy wings. When the sun's rays catch them, it is like the seas sparkling with light. When you see them against a cloud, they are like the dense flakes of a driving snowstorm. You feel as if you had never before realized immensity in number. They blot out the sun above and cover the ground beneath. and fill the air whichever way one looks. The breeze carries them swiftly past, but they come on in fresh clouds, a host of which there is no end, each of them a harmless creature which you can catch and crush in your hand, but appalling in their power of collective devastation. Okay? Not charming. Something you'd rather see on a video. Moreover, they shall fill your palaces and the houses of all your courtiers and of all the Egyptians, something that neither your fathers nor fathers' fathers have seen from the day they appeared on earth to this day. With that, he turned and left Pharaoh's presence. He didn't even wait for a reaction. Moses, as you see, is getting bolder with each plague for good reason. He doesn't care to hear anything Pharaoh says. He simply announces, and leaves but our guys are back pharaoh's you know advisors don't you feel for these guys because they knew since plague number two this is the real thing remember it's the finger of god and they're dying you know pharaoh is the final word this is where the divine right of kings is a problem I have this image of these guys going back, go, how do we convince him? We're doomed. This is not magic. Does Pharaoh not realize what's going on here? And it's amazing they could even speak up to him as they did. Look at this. How long will this one be an obstacle, a snare to us? Let the men go to worship this Jehovah their God. You can just in that big deal let them go. We've already had, what did we have? Is this eight? Are you not yet aware that Egypt is lost? These are gutsy guys. To say to Pharaoh Egypt is lost? That's a big deal. And it is fascinating that Why do you think the Torah would go out
of its way to show you that his advisors didn't agree with him? To isolate Pharaoh's obstinance. That's why. I'm convinced of it. Because it's not necessary to the plot. They have no effect. And isn't it true, though, how often has it not happened that dictators have had advisors who have said, wait, all is lost, what are you doing, don't go on? And yet the megalomaniac mind doesn't believe the advisors and then tend to surround themselves with only yes-men. You know, the Stalin, whom I studied of all the dictators more than any other, was notorious for that. There was no one, anybody who would have said, you know, the Soviet Union is lost, would have been dead in the gulag the next day. I mean, it was not even possible. I don't think I ever told the story in the years that I'm teaching this, so I'll tell you the story to give you an idea of how you get sycophants around you if you're a dictator. This is a true story. Communist affairs was my field of study. Thank God I didn't enter it. I'd be unemployed today, happily. But this is an actual case of Stalin giving a talk before the Communist Party heads, the Politburo, same thing, essentially. And after his talk, they start applauding. But they are so afraid of him that each person was afraid to be the first to stop applauding. And so they kept applauding. And, you know, louder and louder until tears were running down some of their eyes from the pain in their hands. And this was related by, I don't remember, but it was a very bona fide professor. This is not an apocryphal joke. Finally, one guy did stop, and he was, in fact, purged. It was a legitimate fear that they had. To Farrow's credit, at least his advisors could say what they thought. It had no impact, but at least they were able to say what they thought. But again, it does isolate, as I said earlier, the obstinance of Farrow.
00:22:30
Speaker 2: This episode of Timeless Wisdom will continue right after this. Now, back to more of Dennis Prager's Timeless Wisdom.
00:22:43
Speaker 1: Yes, I spoke about this in the very first session, but it says that God stiffened his heart, yes. I'll just say very briefly, and you've just got to pick up the tape, that it God gave Pharaoh back his strength after the plague in order to give him freedom of choice. God did not make Pharaoh obstinate. God gave him a strong heart in order to be obstinate. His choosing was to be obstinate. Okay? That's the quick answer. So Moses and Aaron were brought back to Pharaoh, and he said to them, Go worship Jehovah your God. Who are the ones to go? Immediately, immediately he's bargaining again. Excuse me, but exactly who is leaving? The moment he asks that, you realize he doesn't want to let the Israelites out. Right? Because whatever he keeps behind is a way of ensuring that they come back from their worship. You with me? So it's clear already that It's been to no avail. Moses replies, and it's a great reply, we will all go. And in Hebrew, it is one of the most famous lines in the Torah. With our young and our old, we will go with our sons and daughters, our flocks and herds. So everybody, the young and the old, number one. Men and women, number two. You can't just send along one sex and keep back the other. and even our animals. For we must observe the Lord's festival. But he said to them, now this is sarcasm. God will be with you the same as I mean to let your children go with you. You understand now how this sentence comes out? Yeah, God will be with you like I'll let the young go. Do you understand now? It's a sarcastic statement that he's making. Not, oh, God be with you.
00:25:00
Speaker 2: No.
00:25:00
Speaker 1: No. It's an angry, in other words, I'm not going to let everybody go any more than this God is with you. Now, the next line, clearly you are bent on evil or mischief, is a correct translation. In other words, and what is the mischief? Going forever. Right? If you want sons and daughters, young and old, and cattle, that means you want to get out of here. That's mischief. But there was another interesting translation to this. What is the major god of Egypt? What is his name? Ra. What does Ra mean in Hebrew? Bad or evil. So that the Hebrew can mean, look, Ra... or ra'ah here, is against your faces. That's the literal Hebrew. Either you're up to evil, or ra'ah is against you. And it makes more sense that ra'ah, our God, is against you, than even you're up to evil. Because ra'ah neged penechem is a strange construction of Hebrew. If you're up through evil, you'd say, you're doing bad, or some other variation of that. That evil is in front of your faces is strange, correct? It's possible. But it's either a play on words, or literally, the god Ra is in front of your faces. And that would make more sense. The beginning of the sentence is mocking Jehovah, and the end of the sentence is elevating Ra. So this guy is not convinced. He is, if anything, more obdurate than he was a few plagues ago. Right? Now he says, no way. Yeah, yeah, Jehovah, believe me, you'll see, Ra is now against you, or you're up to evil. Both are perfectly admissible. So no, you menfolk go and worship, you know, I use Jehovah because it's It's specific to the God of the Jews and as the name, and that's why I want you to know what he's using. Remember, because the first thing he ever said to Moses, who's Jehovah, that I should listen to him. Remember? I never heard of him. Now Pharaoh using Jehovah a lot, at least he's learned something. Now you menfolk go and worship Jehovah since that's what you want. You menfolk, that's it. Not the animals, not the female human among you. Just you menfolk go. and they were expelled from Pharaoh's presence. In Hebrew, in verse 11, is a very difficult grammar, which I just want to share with you for a moment. This is how it goes literally. Lochein, not so. Lechuna ha-gvarim, not so. Please the men go, v'ivdu et Hashem, and worship Jehovah. Ki otah atem evakshim, because you are asking for it. What's
the it? Right, the problem is, there is no noun for which the word otah, you're Israeli? What does otah refer to in that sentence? But then why would it be in the feminine? It's my dilemma. I don't know the answer, but there's one possibility. There's only one noun there with a kamate, which makes feminine in Hebrew.
00:29:14
Speaker 2: God.
00:29:16
Speaker 1: Jehovah is a feminine word. Yeah? No, it's a fascinating... That may be to whom he was referring. And who knows? I just want you to know that. It's a fascinating... I have not seen it discussed by any of the commentators, modern or ancient, but it's... yeah it could be certainly in modern I know it could be I don't know but in the Torah I don't think it's common I'm sorry I know but it doesn't use Avodah that's the problem if it did it wouldn't be an issue it uses Laavod which is not a noun but a vowel Verse 12, then God said to Moses, remember no warning here. Oh, excuse me, they gave the warning and now it's just going to do it. Sorry, that's going to be the next afterwards. Then the Lord said to Moses, hold out your arm over the land of Egypt for the locusts that they may come upon the land of Egypt and eat up all the grasses in the land, whatever the hail has left. So Moses held out his rod over the land of Egypt and and the Lord drove an east wind over the land all that day and all night. And when morning came, the east wind had brought the locusts. A very important aspect of this is the use of nature for all the plagues. You will see, however, that in the tenth plague something severely different is mentioned. I just, I'm not going to tell you exactly now, you'll see later, but I want you to bear in mind how the locusts are brought. The locusts are not brought by God said, poof, let there be locusts. Right? Yahi arbet. He did not do that. He uses the winds, and then they bring the locusts. Which, by the way, therefore, remember, it enabled, back to our earlier question, it enabled some Egyptians to say, what lousy luck. We keep getting these miserable developments. Right? And some to say, etspa elohim hi. It's the finger of God. You had the choice. God made it so that an Egyptian or a Jew could have said, boy, are we lucky that the wind blew in Egypt. God structures the world so that the atheist and the theist have equal evidence. Okay? With very rare exceptions, of which the tenth plague is one of the few. Okay, that's important because you think, what does God need to send winds? And look at how much. An east wind over the land all day and all night. Who needed it? If God wants to make miracles, here's a locust. And when morning came, the east wind had brought the locusts. Locusts invaded all the land of Egypt and settled within all the territory of Egypt in a thick mass. Never before had there been so many, nor will there ever be so many again, which is a relief to Egyptians to this day. They hid all the land from view. Remember now the description of a modern observer of locusts
now makes you picture what it must have looked like. They hid all the land from view and the land was darkened. and they ate up all the grasses of the field and all the fruit of the trees which the hail had left, so that nothing green was left. Incidentally, having been to Egypt, I've been to many countries, the most dramatic entry, I think, of the 70 plus countries I've been to has been Egypt. Egypt is a green line. That is all Egypt is. For all intents and purposes, it's a green line. And you see it from the air. From the air, it is dramatic. It's all gray until this long strip beyond what your eye could see of green, thin green, which is the Nile, going down into central Africa. And that's it. It makes very great sense that ancient Egyptians would have worshipped the Nile. The rest is truly dust. So if there was no green left, as described here, you can imagine what it means. And it's very possible. See, that's what I want you to understand. Because the greenness is such a narrow area in Egypt, this is not out of the question. You see, to say the United States had no green left is too bizarre to imagine. It's not too bizarre in Egypt, where green is a thin line. Nothing green was left of tree or grass of the field in all the land of Egypt. Pharaoh hurriedly summoned Moses and Aaron and said, I stand guilty. I'll do it from the Hebrew now. Literally, he said, I sinned to Jehovah your God or against Jehovah your God and against you or before you or to you. Now, this I found very interesting. If you did something very bad, you might say, if you were truly repentant, I sinned, right? I believe that he doesn't believe he did something wrong. I believe that his language here betrays his belief that he didn't do anything wrong objectively. He only did something wrong subjectively in the eyes of Jehovah, your God, and you. You get it? Otherwise, it just would have been, and he summoned them and said, I sinned. Pray for me to get rid of the locusts. But no, I sinned not before Ra, See, that concept is also important. You see, we are used to the monotheistic idea. There's a God of all the world. He's a moral God. We can sin in this God's eyes and we can repent. These are part of our daily vocabulary. But they weren't then. Who do you sin before? In the ancient world, who did you sin before? You sinned to a subjective element. Maybe before Rai did something bad. Maybe before your god or your group. But I didn't do something objectively, universally wrong. Throwing children in the Nile, enslaving and torturing people for generations is not wrong. But I admit, since you're winning now with these locusts, I sinned before you and your god. Do you understand how relativistic it is? He doesn't have a concept of objective sin, of universal sin. Your God is very strong right now, so let him know I think I sinned to him. Personally, I don't think I did a thing. But I know he thinks I did something very bad, so let him know, please. Do you understand now the power
of that sentence? It's not a big, contrite guy. Clearly, I ticked him off. That is what he is saying here. Not that I did anything really wrong, but I understand now, given all these locusts, I did something to you and to your God. And that's the end of it. So I'm talking to you and your God. Otherwise, enslaving people, throwing children in rivers is not a big deal. That's what we're dealing with here. The concept that one sins, that there is a universal law, and that one sins even if one isn't punished. It shows how corrupt he is, that he really is. This is another example for us to understand how this guy can progress morally. He doesn't understand the concept of morality. He understands only power. Your God is winning right now, so clearly I did something against him. I didn't do anything wrong. I sinned to him. Now do you see the significance of what he says here? He has no concept of doing wrong, but only because that was not a concept in the polytheistic world. I did wrong, oh, I ticked off this god, so I'll sacrifice my child. I ticked off the thunder god, so I will do a special dance and offer the following offering to the rain god. Do you see the point? That's what it was like. Not that there is wrong. It's such a difference. And that's what I, if I convey one thing over all these years, I want it to be the uniqueness, the radical difference of the monotheistic conception versus all other conceptions of the universe. It's a big, big sentence, his statement here.
00:38:54
Speaker 2: This episode of Timeless Wisdom will continue right after this. Now, back to more of Dennis Prager's Timeless Wisdom.
00:39:07
Speaker 1: So, I sinned before Jehovah your God and before you. Forgive my offense, or literally lift my sin, just this time. It's getting to be a little... insincere, I think, in Moses' ears. Just this time and pray to Jehovah your God so he can remove from me just this death. Right? He uses only twice in this time. Just this time and just this particular one. You don't have to pray any more times. Just this time. Now notice their response in verse 18. Or his response. So he left Pharaoh's presence. Doesn't say a word. Some commentators say it was a way of humiliating Pharaoh. My read is that he is simply sick of the man. That's frankly, what is he going to say Right. He is now experiencing keen deja vu. Plague. Please pray just this time. Moses now knows exactly what's going to happen. He realizes it's been a plot by God and he's acting out the thing. So he's really now going through the motions. He comes in, announces what's going to happen. McCall's called back. OK, you called me back. I don't say a word. I leave. It's very powerful. I don't think it was humiliation, although there is that element where you don't even bother saying anything. It's like, okay, I had to show up, I showed up. What is the Fox translation? That's exactly right. Oh, no, in the sense it's just stopped in the sense that he didn't say anything. He left Pharaoh's presence and pleaded with the Lord. And God caused a shift, you see, back to using the winds. Caused a shift to a very strong west wind, which lifted the locusts and hurled them into the Sea of Reeds. The sea that they will cross later. Not a single locust remained in all the territory of Egypt. I am very unhappy at the use of the word stiffened for the next verse, for what God did to Pharaoh's heart, because the Hebrew is vayichazek, and it is very clear. I mean, this is not one of these toughy words which has innumerable translations. It comes from chazak, which means strong. Vayichazek is he strengthened. It's as simple as that. Do any of you have strengthened? Strengthened. See, that kills me. The hardened gives the impression that you were wondering about, and so would Stephen. But if I would say what the Hebrew said, and he strengthened Pharaoh's heart, then there's not much of a problem, is there? And that's what he did. He strengthened him to choose what he really wanted to do. Remember that whenever this dilemma comes up. It's no freedom to choose if I'm giving locusts on you, I remove them, I strengthen you, what's your choice now? say say how he how does he do it okay well that that's fine that's the same as strength that's just i can live with that easily and he didn't send the children of israel uh verse 21 uh this is uh Just telling him what to do, right? This is the third series of three plagues, plague two. Is that correct? Oh, third plague. This is third plague, no warning. This is the third plague of the third series. This is the ninth plague. Remember that? Okay, there's no warning on the third plague of each of the three series. Starts the whole thing over in each series. No warnings. And God said to Moses, hold your arm toward the sky that there may be darkness upon the land of Egypt, a darkness that can be touched. When I was a kid, I had trouble with this. How do you touch darkness? Because I always thought of darkness as the absence of light, which is normally the way you think of it. But there are many forms of darkness. And I don't mean it as a homily about spiritual darkness. Not at all, but physical darkness. I'll give you a good example. It is very easy to drive at night. It is extremely difficult to drive in heavy fog. And yet fog is not as dark as night. So there are different forms of not being able to see. That's how you must understand now there are two possibilities for the plague of darkness. One is the absence of light, which is the one I suspect most of you thought of darkness as that, just the sun is covered, as it were, or it's permanent night and there's no moon. That's the usual way in which people think of it. But the fact is the text really suggests that the thick darkness of fog or of something, specifically here, dust, How can you feel darkness? You can't feel darkness unless there's a substance. And so it's probably, though not definitely, dust that is being talked about in the speaking
about what you, that you can feel it. Okay. Hold out your arm toward the sky that there may be darkness upon the land of Egypt, a darkness that can be touched. Now, There are excellent arguments for both darkness of no light and darkness of dust. The excellent argument of darkness of no light is that he would point his rod to the source of the plagues, right? So if he's pointing it to the sky, that is not where dust comes from. If he's pointing it up to the sky, it would either be to the ground or perhaps level. That would be an argument for darkness of the sky. The argument for the dust is that it's Egypt, is that sandstorms are blinding, and that, in fact, you can touch it.
00:46:22
Speaker 2: 22.
00:46:25
Speaker 1: Moses held out his arm toward the sky in thick darkness, descended upon all the land of Egypt for three days. Another argument for a sandstorm of great severity is that you don't get three-day eclipses. If indeed it would have been a solar eclipse, they just don't last that long. Although, I will read to you an interesting argument for it being an eclipse and being darkness in a moment. People could not see one another, and that could happen in the thickest of sandstorms, or fog, for that matter, or terrible, but that's not what is here, but I'm giving you an example we more relate to. And for three days, no one could get up from where he was. But all the Israelites enjoyed light in their dwellings. The argument for eclipse is given by Hertz, the orthodox rabbinic commentator of the 20th century. Professor Mahler identifies the ninth plague, you'll find this very interesting, with the solar eclipse of March 13, 1335 BCE, which darkened Egypt proper but did not extend as a total eclipse to Goshen. That's where the Israelites are living. Hence, quote, all the children of Israel had light in their habitations, unquote. Thus, Hertz writes, the eclipse of the sun on January 24, 1925 was not visible in the lower half of New York City, 96th Street, marking the southern limit of the path of totality, which we know from eclipses. So that, York argues that. Tradition states that the darkness took place on the first of Nisan, which then fell on a Thursday. If Mahler's identification is correct, this is really fascinating, we would know the exact date Thursday, March 27, 1335 BCE of the Exodus. Isn't that funny to think they left on a Thursday? March 27. Any of you born on March 27? Professor Mahler, furthermore, takes the words three days at the end of verse 22 and joins them to verse 23. Thus, three days they saw not one another, neither rose any from his place three days. Accordingly, The eclipse was on one day only, but its terrifying effect, the blank utter paralysis of dread, lasted three days. So he makes an interesting case. Greek writers have left us graphic descriptions of the effects of eclipses. When sore fear comes upon mankind. Herodotus tells us that a total eclipse of the sun in 585 BCE during a battle between the Lydians and Medes so terrified the combatants that they ceased fighting and concluded peace. Too bad there weren't more eclipses in the ancient world. When the spectators are natives, quote-unquote, a total eclipse of the sun is the occasion of remarkable scenes in which alarm and despair and anger are intermingled. Okay. Verse 24. Pharaoh then summoned Moses and said, Go, plural go, worship Jehovah. Ha! It's amazing, is it not? The man is incorrigible. But your herds should be left behind. You know, what does it take? At this point, don't you say, what does it take? If you never knew the story before, you're thinking, okay, what's left? I mean, there's nothing left to eat. Everything's been killed. They've itched themselves crazy or scratched themselves crazy from boils. What's left in God's pantheon? And that's a very fair question. Clearly, only that is left is something so horrific that it would have to work. The guy is joking. Okay, because he knows. He was just told by Moses, correct? That we have to go with our herds. And he says, no, just leave your herds here. Even your children may go with you. So he's giving in. The guy's bargaining. All right, look at how much I'm giving in. But Moses said... You yourself must provide us with sacrifices and burnt offerings to offer up to Jehovah our God. Now, by the way, this is humiliating to Pharaoh because you're going to give us gods you worship for us to sacrifice. That's in effect what Moses is saying to Pharaoh. Our own livestock too shall go along with us. Not a hoof shall remain behind. For we must select from it for the worship. See, again, rubbing it in. We sacrifice what you worship. And we shall not know with what we are to worship the Lord until we arrive there. I mean, he's really being chutzpah-dick. At this point, Moses is just filled with annoyance and sarcasm. We'll decide exactly what to sacrifice when we're there. Thank you, sir. He developed an English accent by the end. But the Lord, again, strengthened. See, it's strengthened in Hebrew. See? Strengthened. Pharaoh's heart, and he would not agree to let them go. Pharaoh said to him, this is very dramatic, be gone from me and take care, or Hebrew, watch yourself. Don't continue to see my face because on the day that you look upon my face you will die and what does Moses respond so you have spoken I will not continue I will not see your face again Therefore, at this point of the story, it is clear the exodus has to work. There is no more negotiating. Right? That ends chapter 10. Chapter 11. And God said to Moses, I will bring but one more plague upon Pharaoh and upon Egypt. After that, he will send you from this. And when he lets you go, he will drive you out of here one and all. I mean, the Hebrew is very strong. He will kick you out. He will chase you out. Tell the people, please. I don't know why they don't ask. Does he do please? Does Fox put please? Please. in verse 2. Does anybody have please? Which one? Which translation do you have?
Fox does not say please. Who does? I am surprised that I would like to ask Fox why he doesn't and all of the others. Na in Hebrew, right, is would you please, kindly. And it's very touching that God God says please to Moses. That's why I think it's important to know that. Yes? Okay, excellent. Okay, so he does show it. Pray, speak, fine. It's like old please. It's very important that you know that, that God says please to Moses when he gives him a directive. Isn't it? I think it's very touching. I mean, God is God after all. And he knows Moses is going to obey him. Please is said... to elevate the doer even when the doer has to do it. That's why we have to say please to our workers. They have to do it or they're fired. They know that. But we have to say please anyway. And God sets the model here. Yes? That also, yes. Certainly, he said God gives us freedom of choice, so he has to respect it and can't assume that it will be done. Tell the people, please. Now, this one, this is among the toughest verses I have come across in the Torah. Tell the people to borrow each man, not tough, It's just tough to fully understand, A, what is it doing here, the next two verses? And what does it exactly mean? And what is the moral intent? I didn't find this easy. And to my great relief, none of the other commentators did either. In fact, one just says he doesn't even know why they're there, these verses. He's not a traditional commentator. A traditional commentator would never say that. In fact, I will read to you what he does say. He is a non-Jewish Brevard Childs, professor of Old Testament Yale University. This is the Old Testament library. And he has something to say about these two verses, which are very interesting. But let me read you the two verses. Tell the people to borrow or ask each man from his neighbor and each woman from hers... Objects of silver and gold. God disposed the Egyptians favorably toward the people. Moreover, Moses himself was much esteemed in the land of Egypt among Pharaoh's aides and among the people. There's nothing more about this right here. It is three times mentioned that they took from the Egyptians gold and silver. We dealt with one of them earlier and you'll have another one later. what does this, first of all, why is it here? We're up to the 10th plague. There's no continuity. Why is it there? The answer is, I don't know. I know you're expecting an answer to that question. I don't know. The only rational answer I heard, and maybe one of you will come up with one, is to make it clear that this is the preparation for the exodus, which is a good answer. It's not Great, but it's a good answer. This tenth plague is going to work. This is the one that's going to work. Be now prepared. Tell the Jews to ask from, to borrow or ask from their neighbors, the Egyptians, for gold and silver. Now, first of all, the word in Hebrew is lishol. Which means ask and borrow. It depends on how... We don't know which it means here. Borrow is foolish if you take it literally. They're going to return it? I'd like to borrow some silver for the exodus, and if I see again, please know I'd love to give it to you back. It's absurd, right? So borrow on the face of it. But one commentator noted, well, it's like in English. If somebody said to you, can I borrow a match? in the days when people actually smoked. Ancient American history, you will recall. You can see it in some movies. Can I borrow a match, right? Or can I borrow a tissue? Right. Do you want it returned? Rarely. So even if the word is borrow, it doesn't mean in the sense of I will return it, okay? I want to make that clear to you because it wasn't, don't think this trickery involved here, oh, may I borrow some of your silver on my way out? No, it's really ask. I want, you know, I'm asking you for some silver and gold. The next verse seems to explain why the Egyptians would give it. Is that right? I mean, is that, and I mean it is that right. This is not a rhetorical question. I wrestled with this. God disposed the Egyptians favorably toward the Jews. Now, this is in itself an odd statement. What does that mean? The Egyptians liked the Jews? Moreover, Moses himself was much esteemed in the land of Egypt among Pharaoh's advisors and among the people. I believe that about Moses. I'll bet Moses was much esteemed. After all, he was regarded by the Egyptians as largely Egyptian. Remember that. It's a very tough sentence. One commentator has an interesting idea, because it says here, and there are only two descriptions of Moses in the Torah, only two, that give adjectives to him. One is he was the most humble man who lived in the world, which you'll see much, much, much later. And this one, and Moses... Moshe Gadol Ma'od, even if you know very little Hebrew, you know what Gadol Ma'od is, very big. Moses was literally very big in the land of Egypt, the Eretz Vitzrayim. The Torah's fear is that Moses will be worshipped by the Jews. You must understand that fear to understand why he's not allowed into Israel, why his grave site disappears from the face of the earth and can never be found. And it is a legitimate fear. After all, after the splitting of the sea, it says, and the Jews believed in God and Moses his servant, and in Moses his servant. So... They believed in both. He could have easily been worshipped. Their pharaoh, as it were. So there's one commentator who says this was part of a larger story of Moses' greatness, not incorporated into the Torah. So it doesn't seem to fit here, right? Remember what we said earlier? The verses don't seem. But it was allowed to stay in, but only in very truncated form. Just to give you an idea of some interesting... and the way people will read it. Yes? In verse 2, why are you, why do the commentators, do you designate those who are asked as Egyptians? In this chicken box it says, ask each man of his fellow, each woman of her fellow. In the other translation I have, each man of his friend, each
woman of her neighbor. Why are there... We assume that's the Egyptians that they're asking. Excellent, excellent. I thought the same thing because the Hebrew is not clear on that at all. Yes, did you all hear the question? Did you hear the question? The Hebrew there does not make it clear at all that you ask your Egyptian neighbor. It just says every man his neighbor, every woman her neighbor. Slaves would have gold and silver. Okay, that's one problem. How much gold and silver did the Israelites have? That's one obvious reason why it's probably not them. There's another one. There are three times mentioned that they got gold and silver from the Egyptians when they left. Yes? Could God have been anticipating that when they wanted to make the golden calf in a later time, they would need the means so he could teach his lesson to the people? Did... I'm sorry, you're... I lost the second half because I was thinking of something else. When they went to the golden calf... So why was this a lesson? I don't understand. Why is this a lesson with regard to the golden calf? Yes, he did foresee that the golden calf would happen. Well, and also, yeah, well, if there is a teaching here, it might be the corruptibility of gold and silver, how it can corrupt you. If that's what you're saying, I think there may be truth. But I don't think God would set them up for corruption. If he's telling them to take gold and silver and knows that in order to teach them the lesson, look what you're going to do with it, you're going to make a golden calf, I don't think that would really be a question of God setting you up and then punishing you. So I'm willing to live with the most logical. It's ask the Egyptians. Even though, by the way, if it is Egyptian, it answers another very interesting problem. And that is, what is the definition of the word rea? Which is neighbor. It says later, love God. your neighbor as yourself via hafta l'reach ha'kamocho. He uses this word, reach. Love your neighbor as yourself. Now, there are those who say it only meant fellow Jew. But here is a case where overwhelmingly likely it did not mean fellow Jew. Since A, there was probably no gold or silver to be gotten from a fellow Jew. I mean, we don't know that for a fact, but it's probably true. They are slaves for hundreds of years. And secondly, it does imply, no, not imply, state specifically that they took gold and silver when they left from Egyptians. So that's how we really know what it is. But I wanted you to know that the word neighbor doesn't mean only a member of your own group. So love your neighbor as yourself, as anyone. Okay, let me continue because I want to finish this chapter. The problem to me in this verse is this. What does it mean that the Egyptians liked the Jews? That I don't have an answer for. Yes, Alan. I think that there's some truth to that. Yes. Not humorous joke, joke, ha, ha. But rather, yes, there may be a lot of truth to that, that by this time they were really in love with the Jews and dying to give them money. In a sense, they're so sick of them, if this will do it, get out of here. Okay? That may very well be the intent. There is no question that the Torah has humor and sarcasm. Absolutely. It plays on words. And remember, the ancient Jew reading this was probably cracking up reading that. You're right. Oh, boy, did they love us. They were just, you know, that's right. I think that that is a legitimate possible answer. With the second part, though, being true. And, you know, and, boy, they loved the Jews. And Moses was a very big man in Egypt. That was true. He was a very big man in Egypt. That is pretty clear.
01:07:30
Speaker 2: This episode of Timeless Wisdom will continue right after this. Now, back to more of Dennis Prager's Timeless Wisdom.
01:07:42
Speaker 1: Okay, now, let me read to you what he says. He thinks that there are people who raise a moral dilemma with the Jews asking or demanding or certainly borrowing gold and silver from the Egyptians. This is from Brevard Childs, the professor of Old Testament formerly. This was written in 1974. Also, he still may be there. He may be with us or not with us, I don't know. There are three passages within Exodus which record the tradition of Israel's despoiling of the Egyptians before the departure of the nations. It was in chapter 3, which we talked about. Take advantage of, remember, or save. Which one was it? This one, chapter 11, verses 2 and 3, and then chapter 12 later. Next chapter. The very close conceptual and linguistic formulation of the tradition lends itself to treating the passages together. Accordingly, Israel was commanded by God to, quote, ask, unquote, of their Egyptian neighbors on an individual basis objects of silver and gold. Then God caused the Egyptians to respond favorably to the Israelites' request. Two of the Exodus passages summarize the event as a despoiling of the Egyptians. Remember the last one, that was the debate, and the one after this. Few passages have provoked such an obvious embarrassment, both to Jewish and Christian expositors, as has this one. It is amazing to see the vigorous apologetic in defense of the tradition which began in Hellenistic times and continues up to the present. Of course, it should not be forgotten that the apology was often called forth by scurrilous attacks against the Jews. There were a lot of attacks. Look at the Jews. Look at these money-grubbing people demanding from every one neighbor, give me all your gold and silver. So these were attacks made on the Jews, and therefore there were defenses. Now, it's very interesting, by the way. Augustine defends the Jews against such an attack in a work that I am not familiar with, Contra Faustum. The issue at stake turns on whether or not Israel was guilty of deception in gaining an advantage and how one is to explain the explicit command of God in affecting and despoiling. Since the attack on Israel's behavior involved invariably an attack on
the Old Testament and the God of Israel, Jews and Christians generally found themselves waging a common battle against agnostics and heretics. Only occasionally, at least until the 19th century, did Christians, such as Marcion, exploit the passage in order to contrast, quote, the higher ethics of the New Testament. Yes? The first case of severance pay. That's right, the first case of severance pay. There is a CPA and his view of the reading of this particular, a Jewish CPA, because he's defending, of course, what was going on. It is remarkable to see the great variety of answers given by which to justify the despoiling. A few have continued to be used right through the modern period. First of all, it was argued that the despoiling compensated for Israel's legitimate wages. There you go. Of which she had been deprived as oppressed slaves, which is very legitimate, right? I mean, if black slaves had gone to plantation owners and said, I'd like money, I think we would think that was a legitimate demand. Again, it was suggested that the Egyptians were not compelled, but gave of their own free volition even more than was requested. That is a Jewish tradition, believe it or not. Josephus, they felt guilty, which may very well be what the Torah is implying here without humor. Josephus suggested that some gave gifts to speed Israel's departure. Sure, take anything you like and get the hell out of here. which makes sense after all the plagues, right? All of these make sense, but it shows how everybody was wondering, what are the ethics about this God telling them to take money from the Egyptians? But others, out of affection. In other words, others argued not to get rid of them, but out of affection for the Jews, which was perhaps without humor. Maybe we were wrong in that reading. Maybe they did have some affection for the Jews after all these years. Which, by the way, is not odd. There really is an affection in the Old South for blacks, providing they knew their place, of course. But there really was an honest-to-goodness affection, which did not exist in the North. The North didn't have slavery, but it didn't have this affection. And you could see that, by the way, unfortunately, fortunately, and so on, to this day, in many ways, in the South, contrasted with northern urban areas. where northern urban whites were extremely liberal on integration and so on, but had no relations with blacks as individuals. Whereas whites were for segregation, but had daily contact, loving contact, with individual blacks. So this is not, you know, the Torah may not have been humorous at all here. This is one of the arguments. It really may have felt this towards our good old Hebrew slaves. Augustine argued that Egypt had not made good use of their treasures and that it was better for these to be used in the service of truth. Better that monotheists have gold and silver than pagans. I'm with Augustine. Still others interpreted the despoiling as evidence that God was forcing Egypt to send Israel free with the compensation which the Mosaic law demanded for any slave. Later you'll see, when you send a slave away, you've got to give him money. So this is simply a foreshadowing of that law. So what sounded and originally is not so wonderful comes out with explanations to be very legitimate, doesn't it? Then again, the borrowed jewelry was needed for the festive dancing in which Israel came forth as a bride. Finally, it was God's way of providing the needed materials for the tabernacle and its furniture, which would serve Augustine's point. In considering this text, it is important to distinguish, at least at the outset, between the descriptive task of understanding what the text meant in the context of the Exodus narrative and the broader ethical and theological problems which involve the modern reader. In all three texts, the same verb appears to describe the manner by which the Israelites acquired the jewelry, Each woman is to ask of her neighbor. The Hebrew root is sha'al. The initial problem arises in that the verb can mean either to ask or to borrow. And he gives examples. In other words, the same word has a semantic range which covers both meanings, and it depends on the context. For whatever reason, the context for the despoiling in Exodus is not clear. There is no indication that a pretext was involved. The text does recognize that such willingness on the part of the Egyptians to comply with the request is highly unusual, but attributes this response to the intervention of God. This is his interesting reading. God, as it were, made the Egyptian response as it was. In sum, the traditional way of putting the question, permanent gift or temporary loan, runs into an impasse which cannot be answered from the text itself. So what is his answer? Two more paragraphs. A somewhat more fruitful entry into the intention of the tradition is provided by the summary statement found in 322 and 1236, the other two times it's mentioned about taking from the Egyptians. Thus they plundered the Egyptians, as he translates it. The point of the tradition focuses on God's plans for the Israelites to leave Egypt as victors from a battle. In striking contrast to the entire history of exegesis, exegesis is commentary and explanation of the text, the Old Testament text makes no attempt whatsoever to justify the act. I like this guy because he's honest to the text. The Torah does not intend to impress you with justifying the act. It simply has it done. Rather, the concern of the text is to explain how it came about. God gave the people favor in the sight of the Egyptians, and the result of the action, they stripped Egypt clean. Turning now to consider the larger ethical question on which the subsequent history of exegesis explanation is concentrated, The immediate danger to avoid is to isolate this one issue from the rest of the Old Testament. The tradition of the despoiling of the Egyptians is primarily a witness to God's complete
solidarity with his people who are set over against the nations. This guy is not attempting to put beautiful ethical explanations like all the other ten explanations we gave, which are fine. He says, please. Don't bother me with that. That is not the Old Testament. That is not the Torah's task. The Torah's task is to tell you God was on the side of the Jews. Period. End of issue. He not only delivers Israel from Egypt, but intervenes in such a way as to affect the plundering of their treasures. But then is this identification of God with one people justifiable? Obviously the Old Testament has much to say about this issue. The whole prophetic polemic called into question Israel's special election because of the sinfulness of the nation which was spelt out in terms of basic injustice to one's neighbor. In the end, the God of Israel destroyed the nation which he had once delivered. Right? You with me? He took Israel out, made a nation, and then destroyed that nation that he took out. Seen in the light of the old whole Old Testament, the despoiling of the Egyptians is another sign of Israel's election, which constituted the faith of Israel. This element was never explained rationally, but ultimately derived from God's inscrutable will. We don't understand why God chose this people. God's relation to Israel was unique. The Old Testament is a testimony to his purpose for this people and for the world through this people. No one incident can therefore be extrapolated from its context within the history of redemption to form an ethical principle for all times. That's how he explains it. God chose this people. Anything he can do to show he has chosen them, he will do. You do not extract an ethical principle from the inscrutable act of chosenness. That doesn't mean you go to the next group and take their treasures away. That is his argument. A good friend of mine who's Catholic, Michael Noseda, said many times when he was a priest and has said many times since he left the priesthood, God is not a Democrat. Small d. He was not making a political statement. God works the way he wishes to work. And applying our democratic principles to God violates the very notion of chosenness. And that is why modern people are not comfortable. I'll have plenty to say about chosenness when we get up to it. We're not up to it. But it violates our egalitarian minds of modernity, taking one people, showing solidarity with them. But as he points out, the very same people that he chose, he then gets rid of their nation. I chose you, that's true. But if you don't act right, I destroy you too. I have criteria for you. Elie Wiesel is supposed to have said, God told the Jews they had a mission, but he didn't tell them it was a suicide mission. It's very important to know both factors. Yes, chosen, but you will live by criteria that I give you, or you will not live. Yes? I'm wondering, would it not be a reason that God was flying and faced the criminal again? Because... Isn't it true
that gold is necessary for Pharaoh, gold and silver, to pass over into the next life? And so by once again... Oh, that's interesting. Was not the taking of all the gold and silver another anti-Pharaoh maneuver, since you need so much gold and silver to be buried with to pass over into the next life? It's an excellent point, and to this non-Egyptologist sounds very possible. Let me try to just finish 11... Chapter 11. You'll certainly never forget verses 2 and 3. I'll tell you that. But when something sticks out like that, that's when I really get to work. Because there's got to be something going on there. Verse 4. And now, I told you we're going to come to this point. Moses said, he's now talking, the assumption is, to Pharaoh. Thus said Jehovah, at about midnight, I will go forth in the midst of Egypt. No more winds. That's why I focused your attention on the winds bringing the different plagues. Now, folks, just me. I get the chills as I tell it to you because of the drama involved. Now do you see the difference? Not that a thing will come forth and this will come forth and overnight it will happen and a rod will, Moses will not lift a rod. No more Moses, no more wind. I am entering Egypt. That's scary stuff. And every firstborn in Egypt from the firstborn of Pharaoh who sits on his throne to the firstborn of a maid who is behind the millstone and every firstborn of the cattle. And there will be a scream or a cry, a great cry in all the land of Egypt, the likes of which there never was and the likes of which there will never be again. But throughout or for all the children of Israel. A dog will not even bark or snarl at a person or even an animal so that you will know that God has made a distinction between Egypt and Israel. And then all of your advisors will come to me and bow down to me saying, get out, you and all of your people who follow you. And afterwards, I will get out. And he left Pharaoh with great anger. The obvious question, that's very dramatic. Very dramatic. It's frightening, actually. Even though it doesn't happen to you, it's frightening to read it. The problem is the chronology of what happened here. Because he had just said at the end of chapter 10, I won't see you again. He was kicked out of Pharaoh's... There is no answer to that chronological dilemma. There are those who even say this all went on in Moses' mind. It's interesting, isn't it? And I don't have an answer to that particular question. Maybe there was no time lag between the two conversations. That's correct, but even if there's no time lag, does this happen after he says, I won't? Yes, that's possible. It could be the same conversation. That's a possible answer. But then when does God speak to Moses in the beginning of 11? In front of Pharaoh? In his head. Exactly. That is exactly what a lot of commentators have said. The first part of chapter 11 was in his head, and then he spoke to Pharaoh. Okay, that's the one possible answer to the question. Verse 9, yes. That's the Rashi answer. Yes, the traditional answer. Yes, okay. The point I'm making is everybody knows there's a problem here. Something had to happen in Moses' head. Was it the conversation to Pharaoh? Did the conversation to Pharaoh happen earlier? Or was it where God spoke to Moses? You see? But even Rashi acknowledges, everybody does, there's a problem here. It's not a big problem, but I just wanted you to recognize it. Verse 9, and we're virtually done, two more verses. And God said to Moses, Pharaoh won't listen to you, so that my marvels may be multiplied in the land of Egypt. And this is really now just a summary And Moses and Aaron had performed all these marvels before Pharaoh. But God had strengthened, not stiffened, not hardened, strengthened Pharaoh's heart. And he did not send Israel from his land. And it ends this way before this terrible and awesome plague to remind you why it has to happen. Two reasons, two verses, two reasons. I have to show who I am, which we spent two weeks on, and because he wouldn't send the Jews out. Okay, thank you very much. I'll see you next week. What is an example of being raised to be ungrateful? Well, the way in which Americans are taught about America. There's no reason to be grateful to be an American. Why would you be grateful to be something that not only is no better than any other thing, but in fact is is filled with racism and sexism and oppression and homophobia and xenophobia why would you be happy to be an American especially if you are a woman or a black or a Latino or an Asian did I miss anybody or gay Oh my God, you just are oppressed. When I speak at colleges and some member of one of those groups gets up at a microphone and says, are you saying that we are, my group, whatever it might be, we women are not oppressed? I say, not oppressed? You're the luckiest women in the history of femaledom. What, are you kidding? You've got to be joking. Oppressed? Women in America are oppressed? What the hell is wrong with you? What did you do, go to college? And then I realize I'm at a college.
01:29:33
Speaker 2: Join us tomorrow to hear more untimeless wisdom with Dennis Prager. Visit DennisPrager.com for thousands of hours of Dennis' lectures, courses, and classic radio programs, and to purchase Dennis Prager's Rational Bibles.