رونوشت 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Hey everybody, welcome in to Tiger Territory. It is a new era for this show. I'm proud to introduce the newest Tiger Territory co-host, Rogelio Castillo. I call him Raj. He's been a friend for several years now. We've been softball teammates. He's appeared as a guest on this podcast and filled in as a guest host on a few occasions back when Kieran was in Italy. For anyone who missed the news in our last episode, Kieran unfortunately got a new day job and fell victim to corporate America. They didn't want him having a podcast. He had to do what was best for him and his family. And so unfortunately he had to give up the pod, but I was lucky to have a replacement I felt really good about. Raj was the first person who came to mind when I thought about who I would want as the next co-host. He's super knowledgeable about the Tigers, knows the minor league system in depth. Raj, I'll hand it over to you. Congrats. Thanks for joining me. What do you want the people to know about you and your background?
00:01:17
Speaker 2: Well, thanks, Cody, for that really good introduction. I'm just here to tell you a little bit about my background. I've been doing podcasts now for 10 years now. It's been 10 years since I started, uh, I started a, as an independent Tigers, uh, SRD, and then it grew in the tiger, my other report. And so, uh, Chris Brown and I have been, uh, at the hip for the last 10 years. And he's been, just been, we're been fortunate enough. Thanks to you and the crew of the Detroit baseball association. I'd be part of the baseball writers association, which is something I never thought that would be.
00:01:47
Speaker 3: Uh, happen.
00:01:48
Speaker 2: And, um, I'm here to just, I'm not caring. I'm not, I'm he's dude's a legend. I'm just here to do what I got to do and just contribute. I'm just really happy to be here and be part of this great foul territory network. This is a great group of people, and I'm looking forward to making.
00:02:07
Speaker 3: Some podcasts, man.
00:02:07
Speaker 2: I mean, I'm a little nervous right now, I'm not going to lie, but at the same time, it's just like us talking like we are in softball, except we don't have somebody like Nick ask us 500 questions.
00:02:21
Speaker 1: And I've seen Raj get a little fired up on the softball field, uh, a time or two.
00:02:27
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:02:30
Speaker 1: We'll see if we ever get that side of them, uh, out of them on the podcast. Uh, for now we're going to get going with a little bit of a mailbag episode. I'm going to let everyone know I'm running on like one and a half hours of sleep. I flew back from Tampa, uh, with the world series this morning before, you know, we're recording this here Thursday night. Um, I hope you guys will check out the story I wrote about Brewers fans and kind of what this win meant to them. It got a really good reception today, and that meant a lot to me because it was one of the most emotional stories I've ever written. Some people shared some really sad stories about loved ones who died, and then also some very happy stories about what it meant to see the Brewers win the World Series. there've been points working on that story over the past three days that I was like breaking down and, and randomly crying. So it meant a lot to me to see that get a positive reception. Certainly one of my favorite stories and the Brewers as an organization, you know, I was happy to see them win the world series. They've been the team that I've followed fairly closely in terms of teams outside the Tigers over, over the past several years and, I remember just being really impressed with him in 2024. Um, big fan of Pat Murphy, you know, a few days around that guy and you literally start to think about things differently, see the world a little bit differently. You know, he talks a lot about how like, Hey, it's not about you. It's not, it's, it's not about me. Like it's not about any, uh, any one person. If you're living your life like that, you're, you're, you're probably off course a little bit. Think about where you fit in the grander scheme. And even though I'm not part of a, baseball team trying to win a world championship. That's like a lesson I kind of feel coming away from a few days covering the World Series. I could probably talk more about that. I don't know, Roger. Did you have any thoughts just following that series, watching the Brewers? What were some of the things that maybe came to mind for you?
00:04:36
Speaker 3: You know, I think you did a really good job.
00:04:38
Speaker 2: The picture in the story where the towel where they have the towel hanging from the, uh, was it, it.
00:04:44
Speaker 3: Looks like the hospice room hospital. Yeah.
00:04:46
Speaker 2: Hospice room that like kind of hit home for me too, in a lot of different ways. Um, I thought the series was really, I was, I thought Pat Murphy, even yesterday with the whole moment with, with Jake Bowers and the Yankees, I thought it was a lot of just, it, it, it held, it had the vibe of what Harvey King was able to do in 1982, almost in a sense that because, uh, Here he is. He came in mid-season in 82 and rallied the Brewers with that young talent. The same core with Robin Gout and Paul Monitor. And they had a really good Cecil Cooper. It has almost the same vibes to it, too. It's like they ran into a very good Cardinals team. And I think that Tampa really had a really good season. But the Brewers felt like a team of destiny kind of thing. And there was always this thing about them, this vibe about them, especially the Jackson Terrio game-winning hit. I believe it was in the San Diego series where it was just one of those, the timely hitting, the two-out hitting. I've never seen it was eight, nine runs on two outs.
00:05:52
Speaker 3: That's unheard of.
00:05:54
Speaker 1: Kevin Cash talked about it after the game. He said that was the best at-bat quality game-to-game, inning-to-inning that I've ever seen. And it
Load full transcript
generally feels like that, watching the Brewers. And to some degree, the Rays, too.
00:06:09
Speaker 2: Yeah, and the biggest takeaway I thought, too, was just seeing all the X-Rays, Tiger Glass now, they showed Chris Archer rallying everything around their former team.
00:06:20
Speaker 3: To me, I thought that was really cool.
00:06:22
Speaker 2: I know that was kind of like MLB trying to promote unity and what have you, but I thought that was really cool. I mean, I know Tampa is a relatively young franchise, comparatively speaking, to the Tigers.
00:06:31
Speaker 3: Or even the Brewers, but I don't know.
00:06:33
Speaker 2: I was just tired of last night just rooting the Rays and getting in the face about everything.
00:06:38
Speaker 3: I was not expecting that whatsoever.
00:06:41
Speaker 1: Yeah, I was asked to try to go talk to those guys before Game 5. I don't think they were there for 5. They were for 3 and 4. If they were there for 5, I didn't see them, so I didn't get to do that story and pick their brains about it. But that brought to mind one of the other things, like culture gets tossed around so much, especially with the Brewers, and I think somewhat the Rays, too. It's easy to say coming off the heels of a World Series victory. No one talks about like, oh, they won the World Series, but their culture wasn't that great. Like everyone's, you know, vibes are great when you win a ring. But the Brewers, I think another reason I've kind of been drawn to them and written about them a decent bit, like they're a pretty good organization with people. They're pretty loose, approachable. I just think there are a lot of good people over there. I don't know the Rays as well, but I get a similar sense and look, two years ago, the Tigers had a feel good playoff run and we were talking about how great their culture was, but comparatively speaking, like the Tigers have gotten very buttoned up. There's kind of a very corporate feel around their organization. And look, I mean, they're owned by the Illich family, the president of baseball operations, the son of two doctors from the Bay area who has a degree from the London school of economics. The manager went to Stanford. It all kind of makes sense for better or worse. But I do wonder if maybe the Tigers have gone a little bit too far down that road. And maybe you saw that manifest. Maybe some people were playing for themselves a little bit. People probably think I'm talking about Tarek Skubal there. I'm not. I'm not even saying it's a bad thing. It's just a natural thing that can seep in. And when things are overly buttoned up, can that make for a tense environment? Or is there the same level of motivation? People always talk about the Brewers like, oh, they're kind of like a college team. I think not just in the way they play, but there's kind of this prevailing sense of belief. You can tell Murphy believes in his players and wants the best for his players. I don't know. I wonder if the Tigers have lost that a little bit. That's just one thought I had coming away from this World Series.
00:08:51
Speaker 2: Yeah, because when you think about, for example, the Tigers in the past in 1984 when Jack Morris had to go on a helicopter to Domino Farms get pizzas because they had no food in Tiger Stadium. I don't see that story coming out. If the Tigers get that far, I don't see that happening. You hear something like that probably with the Brewers. There's always the jokes about Wisconsin having cheese and the beer. All the stereotypes that come with Milwaukee being in Wisconsin.
00:09:24
Speaker 3: But I agree with you. Going down to the clubhouse this year, sometimes at Comerica Park was... a little too quiet, a little too eerie.
00:09:31
Speaker 2: And looking at guys like Sal Frederick, these guys just seem like the type of guys that would hang out with each other after the game. And they seem to have a very good sense of camaraderie that didn't seem disingenuous whatsoever.
00:09:48
Speaker 1: Yeah, so I don't know if that actually means anything for the Tigers, but certainly a thought I had, certainly something we'll keep an eye on. Whenever there is baseball again, which none of us know, but we do have a long offseason to talk and to speculate. So, Rog, let's go ahead and get into some questions from listeners here for our mailbag. We'll start with this. It's pretty wide-ranging. It's from Caleb Williams, number one hater. Is this current Tigers blueprint a recipe for long-term sustained success, meaning multiple playoff appearances and division contention for the foreseeable future? Basically, I think our pal Certified Troll, that's the handle for Caleb Williams' number one hater, this question actually doesn't seem to be trolling. I think they just want to know kind of the long-term outlook for the Tigers and Rod, especially given your knowledge of the system kind of up and down, what are your thoughts on that?
00:10:50
Speaker 2: Well, I think that in terms of infield talent and some of the outfield talent, or excuse me, infield and probably some starting pitchers, there is some sustainability that can help.
00:11:02
Speaker 3: With the Tigers.
00:11:02
Speaker 2: One of the questions that I still have is where are the swing and miss relievers coming from internally? The Tigers, Scott Harris mentioned this, that during the closing press conference, they're going to look eternal for some pitching. And I'm just, I have many questions about that because you look in on the aisle across the board from double A to triple A, the Tigers had a lot of guys are down and they were trying to fix things with a lot of minor league free agents in triple A. And so, but if you look below that, I mean, you have Ben Jacobs, you have a couple of guys in low A that at West Michigan, if they can take the next step this year in double A, then yeah, I think that you, you have something to build. I think the Tigers have way too much for the first time. I can say
this in, in 20 plus years, they have a lot of infield options to choose from. And so it, now you have, you know, Kevin O'Donnell who let the human war, you have how you use intriguing. You have all these intriguing pieces that at least can keep you competitive. It's just, I think to me, the one part of this blueprint that's missing is swing and miss pitching.
00:12:07
Speaker 3: And that is a big thing. If you look at what the, what the brewers were able to do with a raise, we're able to do this postseason.
00:12:13
Speaker 2: Dominant bullpen and they don't have that and so that it's like the it's a house of you know if you're looking at blueprint you look at the foundation your foundation is cracked right now with that and that's where i think the tigers biggest uh biggest hole.
00:12:26
Speaker 1: Is right now well yeah i think i think that's pretty obvious i i would say here one thing that gets lost when the heels have a really disappointing season is like all things considered i think the organizational health for the tigers remains really good helps when you have a guy like kevin mcgonigal Seven War is a rookie, and he's already locked up. Helps when you have Max Clark come up and taste success in his first glimpse of the big leagues. Helps when you have Jackson Jobe, Troy Melton, Frambois Valdez, Cater Montero, like the makings of a pretty good rotation already just sitting right there. I think even going forward, and some more prospects on the way, Bryce Rainer's on the way, Josue Bersanio's on the way. The Tigers... I don't think they're going to be terrible again anytime soon. Like we're not going back to the 2018, 2019 dark ages anytime soon. The whole question is like, okay, you should be pretty good. Now, what can you do with that? Going from pretty, as we talked about a lot, going from pretty good to really good often depends on kind of the small things around the margins, the small things that the Scott Harris front office seemed to pride themselves on, but hasn't worked out as well, at least in the past year and a half. Bullpen being a big part of that. Can you be better than a middle-of-the-pack type offense? Well, the Tigers certainly have a lot of faith in their young bats, but what's going to kind of push them over the top? There were some way too early power rankings that came out recently. I think ESPN had the Tigers at number seven. My colleagues at The Athletic had the Tigers down at 16. I think they're closer to 7 than 16, actually. I mean, especially, like, they're just not in that good of a division. I think they should probably be AL Central favorites. At the same time, they have not beat the Guardians in the AL Central. You know, they have not done it before. So there's certainly a lot left to prove. But in terms of the health, the prognosis, I think it's pretty good. You just got to get some things right to actually take advantage.
00:14:36
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I would go closer to 7-2. It just depends on what they do this offseason to address the bullpen. I think that the Tigers even, I know there's just a lot of impatience with Cole Keith, and there's, of course, the ever, ever pop, ever, it seems like an evergreen topic about, you know, much to do about Spencer Torkelson. But if I look at the Tigers on paper with some of the guys that are coming back next year with Reese Olsen, And even with some of the versatility they have, they can have to trade some players that they have in the system.
00:15:08
Speaker 3: It just depends on how Scott Harris wants to pull the trigger with this.
00:15:11
Speaker 2: Because if John Pack can take another step forward, you still have to think about Zach McKinstry and in terms of arbitration coming up. There's some big questions coming up where it can take the Tigers either 7 or to 16. Yeah, that's a good way to put it. how they're addressing these salary concerns coming up. So I'll be interested to see how they will address that going forward.
00:15:36
Speaker 3: All right.
00:15:37
Speaker 1: Well, let's dive a little deeper into some of the issues you mentioned. Here's a question from James with the Twitter handle, xhandle, at gritty underscore tags. What is the best path forward to building a great bullpen? Raj, I struggle with like a concise way to answer this because I would say that's kind of what every organization is trying to figure out how to do, how to build a great bullpen. Bullpens are volatile by nature. Pitchers are prone to injuries. But one of the things you mentioned, like, well, I think it starts with stuff and getting swing and miss capabilities. What else kind of enters your mind here in terms of how the Tigers can actually make their bullpen better?
00:16:18
Speaker 2: I think it's also really velocity. I mean, velocity is not everything, but the way you use your velocity.
00:16:24
Speaker 3: I look at, for.
00:16:25
Speaker 2: Example, I was talking about this earlier. that Jason Foley comes to mind. Jason Foley had all 99 to 100, but everything was kind of straight. It took him a while before he could take that velocity and use it a certain way. And the other part of it is versatility. And the reason why I mention versatility is because the Tigers, one of the things that I noticed about the Brewers' bullpen was how they were able to go multiple innings several times.
00:16:50
Speaker 3: Aaron Ashby was so clutch. He was able to escape.
00:16:54
Speaker 2: Like just every time, and Tyler Holden has those kind of qualities to a certain extent, but the versatility, strikeouts, I mean, every single pitcher they had, with the exception of Grant Anderson, it just seemed like they had guys that could go out there and strike out anybody at any given time.
00:17:11
Speaker 3: I know that involves swing and.
00:17:12
Speaker 2: Miss, but it's really just a matter of when you can get the swing and miss. I mean, it's great when you get the first out of the inning, but when you can get those strikeouts
second, third out of the innings and just finish, just go in there and complete the strike zone. Tigers have a guy like Drew Summers, for example, good strikeout rate, but walks so much. So reducing walks, that's another part of that bullpen, a path to a very good bullpen.
00:17:38
Speaker 1: Yeah. I think Scott Harris was pretty clear that he seemingly wants to continue, you know, creating a stable of starters, having starting pitching depth that some of those guys get bumped to the bullpen, and can then be effective relievers. That didn't work out for the Tigers this year, but I don't hate that as an approach. I mean, think of someone like Reese Olsen. Could be a pretty interesting X factor for next year's team. He could be healthy and a starter and really good if he picks up where he left off. He could be injured, a shoulder injury, and maybe he's never quite the same again. There is a world where maybe it just makes more sense to put him in the pin, ease up the workload a little bit, but Reese Olsen was able to miss a decent amount of bats, especially, I think, with his changeup as a starter. Could be an interesting reliever mix. Maybe that helps you out of the pin a little bit. Drew Anderson was, of course, notably better as a starter, but still has some swing and miss capabilities. I think he's going to come back in that swingman role. Cater Montero is a guy... for as much as I feel like he has earned to have his name written in the rotation, wouldn't be shocked if he sees time in the bullpen, assuming the Tigers signed another starter or two, in part because he can be really good back there and he's already proven that as well. And then it's like, okay, well, how much are you going to stake on signing relievers, paying for relievers? It can be risky. There are a lot of moves out there that Haven't worked out. Edwin Diaz being one of them. Devin Williams in the past. Ryan Helsley. They're more that come to mind. I still kind of think maybe the Tigers are at a point where, look, especially, let's say they're not going to chase Tarek Skubal. Let's say they're not going to do anything crazy in terms of adding a bat. It's not like they really have payroll constraints stopping them from paying a decent amount for a reliever on a two- or three-year deal. I think if you could get one real ninth-inning-type guy Hope you can hit on a couple guys in development. Hope someone like a Rieselsen or a Cater Montero helps your pin. Suddenly you could be in better shape, but I guess that's my way of saying it. saying there's never one right way to do things. You probably have to build your bullpen through those three or four different type avenues, and that's how you're going to have a better bullpen next year, which obviously requires a lot of things going right.
00:20:04
Speaker 3: Right.
00:20:05
Speaker 1: Right.
00:20:06
Speaker 3: And you know what?
00:20:07
Speaker 2: Look, I'll say this early on. I think River Ryan's a perfect candidate for the bullpen.
00:20:12
Speaker 3: And here's why.
00:20:13
Speaker 2: I think because of his... I mean, everybody was making this big deal about his age when they acquired him. If you want to keep him healthy, you have a guy who uses his fastball almost 40% of the time. Combine that with a slider and a change, that you have enough. And then he can also throw a cutter and a curve or a sinker if he needs to. It would be a two-seamer, technically.
00:20:33
Speaker 3: But still.
00:20:34
Speaker 2: That combination of everything, with the starters mixed into the bullpen, with that velocity, his stuff is really good. His swing stuff is really good. I think, personally, that's just me, that he should be in the bullpen because that allows you to, if you want to put Olsen out there or Monteiro, maybe go with a six-man possible rotation. I just think that River Ryan is the key to the bullpen next year. If you're going to stick with something eternal, because a lot of times, what, bullpen guys are, former starter failed starters dennis chakras comes to mind i mean also that ancient example but still you never know until what you're going to try with and so i think with that velocity and river ryan's capability of getting swing and miss i think he'd be a perfect guy that you can put out there in something any.
00:21:16
Speaker 1: Well that's that's an interesting one to kind of plant your flag on raj but i like it i certainly think the tigers are going to try river ryan as a starter given he was part of the scoogle trade and like you said given he has at least five potential plus pitches But the injury concerns, the age, the fact, hey, it'd just be nice to have a dude who throws 100 in the back of your pin. I don't hate it as a concept. We're going to go into another question real quick. And this is something I think we're going to talk about a lot more over the next month. But for now, this is from TriggerCity at OSU Tiger 7. I think Jeremy Pena makes too much sense for the Tigers. Hinge ties, great defense, Phil's shortstop, right-handed batter, speed. What, realistically, would we need to move to acquire him? Raj, any general thoughts there?
00:22:14
Speaker 2: If you want to get Pena, if you're going to make a trade, it's going to be obviously through trade, right?
00:22:20
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:22:20
Speaker 2: You're going to have to trade somebody like Jose Bersoño to get him. you really have to, I mean, you have to give up a top five prospect to get them. As far as like I give the Tigers.
00:22:31
Speaker 3: I like them a lot. I like the fact that you can hit, you know, you hit.
00:22:34
Speaker 2: 22 home runs this year, at least two 77 gives you that a nice strong OPS and has speed, which Tigers do not have at all. I mean, they were trying to experiment with that, but that's another story for another day. I, the, this concern a little bit, he does strike out a lot, but I can live with that.
00:22:49
Speaker 3: If he can still do what he's doing now.
00:22:52
Speaker 2: Um, the fact that he is a plus runner when he does make the right decisions and he just brings a lot to this table, but you have to, I can't stress this enough. The tigers have to trade some major prospects in order to get this happen. They just cannot, I don't want to hear this, you know, uh, uh, caller driven radio.
00:23:10
Speaker 3: Well, we can trade on Max Anderson and JC on court. No, no, can't. Houston's not dumb.
00:23:16
Speaker 2: Right.
00:23:16
Speaker 3: They're going to want some guys in return.
00:23:18
Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, I think you made a really good point. I think it's a point that sums up like my time podcasting about the Tigers and the Scott Harris era. It's like, does this make sense?
00:23:29
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:23:29
Speaker 1: Do I see him doing it? Not really. I do think the Tigers are going to have some interest in trading for a shortstop. And then it's like, okay, well, who's that going to be? What is a palatable price? Payne is about the highest end guy out there. He was a 5.8 war player, uh, uh, Two years ago, 3.4 wore this past year. Final year of his contract. So the fact he's only going to be here for one year is going to make him cheaper than someone like Zach Netto, who's another super interesting name. But then you're talking about really giving up a haul. But maybe it makes more sense to do that for a controllable guy rather than one year. Because even though Pena is only the one year solution, I do think it's going to take, to your point, like a top 100 type prospect. I mean, someone mentioned to me, like, does it cost Job? And I'm like, well, if it costs Job, I don't think I would do it, and I damn sure don't think Scott Harris is going to do it. And then it's like, okay, well, who else are you going to give up?
00:24:33
Speaker 3: Rainer?
00:24:34
Speaker 1: Like, I don't think so. Bersanio, like, maybe, except you kind of probably want Bersanio to be your first baseman in a couple years. The Astros don't need Torkelson. They have Christian Walker. It's like, could you... You know, could you sell him on some combination of like Carpenter and Andrew Sears type? But I don't think that's enough. So, yeah, they're going to have to really pony up and risk parting with a big part of their future.
00:25:08
Speaker 2: Yeah, I know there's a strange part of the Tiger fan base that's not like Tyron Lorenzo for whatever reason. And so, you know, despite his age and Look, I think Houston could be interested in him. I mean, Lorenzo is a switching catcher who can play first base. He swings a little grooved, which is what.
00:25:27
Speaker 1: What did he hit in the Erie last year?
00:25:30
Speaker 2: 220, but he had 20 home runs. It was healthy, but the point was he was actually healthy, and he actually was able to catch.
00:25:39
Speaker 3: That being said, though, I don't think that's even enough either. If you throw in Lorenzo in the trade, it's intriguing... But I don't think Houston's going to go. I mean, Houston's going to go.
00:25:48
Speaker 1: Really? When I look at Houston's roster, I think they have needs in the outfield. And that's kind of where the Tigers are a little more thin in terms of, like, you're not giving them Zaire Hope. Are you, I don't know, are you going to trade, like, Callahan or Malgieri? Like, well, does Houston like those guys at all? Like, they're not enough to carry a trade. I guess Parker Meadows could be an interesting idea. But again, like, You're kind of giving them spare parts, and that's usually not enough to get a deal done for a player the caliber of Jeremy Pena.
00:26:22
Speaker 2: No, I mean, unless they trade for some minor leaguer from Boston. I mean, I don't know what they're going to do, so we'll see what happens.
00:26:32
Speaker 1: All right, well, let's just go right into something you mentioned. This is from ContainsPeanuts, which is one of the more interesting user names I've seen recently. With Dingler, Valencia, and Bersagno, it seems as if Tyron Lorenzo has been somewhat glossed over. But isn't he currently the second best defensive catcher in the organization? Raj's question seems right up your alley. What are your thoughts there?
00:27:00
Speaker 2: Yes, he is very good defensively. I mean, he struggled with injuries last season, and there was a point in time last year where he didn't catch until after his hand injury until I believe late August in Erie. But when he came back this year, was catching just fine. As far as, like, calling the own games, I know the minor leaguers, the managers tend to do that. But he's still very good arm, very good ability to pick somebody off at second base, and does a pretty good job of framing. He was a better alternative than Eduardo Valencia when Valencia was down in Erie. Valencia could hit the ball anywhere. And so I think Lonzo, the reason why Skyhurst loves Lonzo is because his ability to can hit for power. And his defensive, like, just in terms of framing and his arm.
00:27:46
Speaker 3: He's got a big arm. The problem is just consistency of health. I think he can stay healthy.
00:27:52
Speaker 2: And so the reason why he got glossed over is because his numbers this year were down. He struck out quite a bit more. But also there was questions about his hustle. There's a reason why Andrew Graham's not in the organization anymore because they just, that's another story for another day, but that's, Basically for Lorenzo's purposes. But I think there's a lot to like about Lorenzo. It's just a matter of... We've seen this time and time again, Cody. We've talked about this in the press box. Catchers take time to develop.
00:28:26
Speaker 3: And there's a lot.
00:28:27
Speaker 2: I don't know why people are harder on Lorenzo than they were on Dingler. It took Dingler a long time to develop before he became something. So there's some metrics that are similar. But this is the year where Lorenzo has to put it together. If he doesn't put it together this
year... It's just a lost cause, honestly. And he's on the 40-man roster for a reason. But at this point, look, if a team's interested in him and you use that for leverage, the Tigers have Depp a catcher for once.
00:28:56
Speaker 3: And so.
00:28:58
Speaker 2: I think personally, if the Tigers moved on from him, I think they'd be fine. Some team would be happy about the power, but I think the Tigers would be fine.
00:29:06
Speaker 1: So do you think he's a better or worse defender than Valencia?
00:29:09
Speaker 2: Yeah. He's a better defender than Valencia is. That's 100% for sure. Valencia has worked on his game quite a bit. I think he's gotten better up here than he did in the minor leagues.
00:29:22
Speaker 3: He's done a very good job. But I think Lorenzo has a better arm than Valencia does.
00:29:28
Speaker 1: The arm, I think, for sure is better. Lorenzo's receiving, just based on what I've seen, still scares me at times. And it seems like Valencia calls a pretty good game. So I think they're definitely... different behind the plate.
00:29:43
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think the biggest thing between him and Briseño, for example, Briseño is still a little rough around the edges sometimes with just sometimes when he catches in terms of receiving and framing.
00:29:55
Speaker 3: I think Lorenzo's a better framer.
00:29:57
Speaker 2: But yeah, there's times where There was a lot of pass balls with Lorenzo last year, and he got better this.
00:30:02
Speaker 3: Year about it. So, defensively, there were.
00:30:05
Speaker 2: Some improvements this year compared to last year where there was just, I think it was more mental lapses. He had a lot going on last year, to be fair, and so it gives him the benefit of the doubt.
00:30:14
Speaker 3: All right.
00:30:14
Speaker 1: Well, we are coming up on time here, so we're going to do just one more, but I think it's another good one for you, Raj. Again, from our friend ContainsPeanuts, out of Peyton Graham, Trey Sweeney, and John Peck. Who has the most untapped upside?
00:30:32
Speaker 2: Well, there's this contingency of Tiger fans that think I hate Peyton Graham because I'm always getting comments about because of his numbers and stuff like that.
00:30:39
Speaker 3: I don't hate Peyton Graham.
00:30:41
Speaker 2: I think Peyton Graham is a fine player who this year came out and had a really good year. That being said, John Pack surpassed him in the order for reasons that are pretty simple.
00:30:53
Speaker 3: I think that Peyton Graham.
00:30:57
Speaker 2: has a little more, in terms of like, I think he can get a little more power, but defensively, I think Peck is a better defender. I think the untappedness is, if John Peck can lift the ball more, I mean, we saw him this year struggle a little bit with just trying to get more line drives, more of what we're seeing in the minor leagues. He made a swing change in West Michigan, and that's what made him surpass Peyton Graham.
00:31:21
Speaker 3: Peyton Graham's healthy this year.
00:31:22
Speaker 2: He stole a lot of bases. He has a The Tigers have to make a Rule 5 decision on him. And no offense to Trey Sweeney, but I haven't... Trey Sweeney, to me.
00:31:35
Speaker 3: You know, it's like....
00:31:38
Speaker 2: It's almost like how often... I haven't seen him play in a while, so I'll be honest with you. I think out of all the two that I just mentioned, I think Peck has a slight upside. Then Peyton Graham. Peyton Graham has a little more potential for power. And I saw him game against Ackroyd. He went five for five. Five for six or something like that. And there are some times where you're like, man, this guy really struggled. And sometimes defensively you see him in the same game he collapsed. You're like, where Peck is the sure-handed defender. But I haven't seen Trey Sweeney in a while. So, I mean, outside of the series in Baltimore, he made that great play.
00:32:14
Speaker 3: I haven't seen him play since then.
00:32:16
Speaker 2: Right.
00:32:17
Speaker 1: Something I talked about with Kieran, I think, just a couple episodes ago was that in the early stages of this past year's spring training, Trey Sweeney had made some noticeable swing adjustments, and it looked pretty interesting. And then he got hurt, and we never got to see it. So, like, as much as he's been out of sight, out of mind, like, I don't know. I think this question is interesting in that if you were to ask me, like, who is the best player out of the three, I certainly would not say Peyton Graham. I think Peck's the best defender. I don't think either he or Sweeney are great hitters, but I might lean towards Sweeney's bat.
00:32:58
Speaker 2: Maybe.
00:32:58
Speaker 1: I don't even know if I feel good about that. Now, if you're asking who has the most untapped potential, I think Graham has the most interesting raw tools. You mentioned power, the speed, stealing, what, 60-something bags in the minor leagues.
00:33:14
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:33:15
Speaker 1: If there's some sort of pick to click, maybe it could be him. That's a super probably bottom 20% outcome in terms of his profile. But for the purpose of this question, who has the most untapped potential? I kind of think Peyton Graham. Who's the most likely to one day maybe become a major league regular? I'm not sure if I would pick Sweeney or Peck. That's kind of a tough call.
00:33:42
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think if you look at Graham, I think Graham in the right situation could be a good utility player for a team, whether it be the Tigers or somebody else.
00:33:51
Speaker 3: But as far as all three being regulars, I don't know, man. I don't see that happening.
00:33:58
Speaker 1: I think you're right. I think that's what this boils down to. They're probably, Peck and Sweeney, right now, profile as extra infielders, if not up-down type guys.
00:34:09
Speaker 3: And Graham.
00:34:11
Speaker 1: it still kind of has to prove he can even become a big leader. There are a few more boxes he has to check.
00:34:17
Speaker 3: Absolutely.
00:34:19
Speaker 1: All right, well, we are at time, but Raj, thank you so much. I hope you guys enjoyed this. That is number one. Actually, it's not number one. Raj has hosted a few Tiger Territory episodes before, but in terms of official, in terms of being signed, sealed, and delivered, congrats to Raj on his official Tiger Territory debut. We will see you guys again soon.