رونوشت 🔗
speaker-0: Hello and welcome to another edition of the Truth Encounter Podcast. I am John Rabe. Dr. Dell Tackett is here with me as well. Dell, it's great to see you again as always. How are you today?
speaker-1: It is good to be back, John. I'm I'm excited about our program today.
speaker-0: I am as well. And as we as people hear these, we the the podcast comes out every week, but in our actual scheduling it's been several weeks since we've been together, so I'm excited to to get back going here again. And we have a really important subject that we want to talk about today. on this podcast we've talked quite a bit about the the threats that are converging against the The family, the church, the Christian witness and our culture and so forth. And one of the themes that we're also going to be talking about often in this podcast is the restoration. How do we return to where we need to be? How do we get to where we need to be? And Dell, I'm sure you have anecdotal experience with this as much as I do. But when we look around among young people that I know, among people who we would categorize in say generation Z, and we'll we'll explain more of that as we go. But late teens, early twenties, we have what seems to be a a growing epidemic of anxiety, fear, even even mental illness. and the causes for that and the solutions for that are really important for us to get a hold on.
speaker-1: Well, it's really true. And and I I doubt that it's just you and me that are are observing that. There many, many people are seeing that. There's the there's almost one might say an alarm associated with what is happening in the younger generation right right now. And this is not to cast a stone. It's it's the assessment of some health issues, mental health issues, psychological things that are happening. to our children. and it is devastating families and devastating individuals as well. And we want to talk about that because we're interested, as you just said, this is part of the series on the restoration. We want to know how can we help change this? How can we restore at least portions of these pathologies that have infiltrated the the family in in our day.
speaker-0: And of course, excuse me, and of course for time immemorium, let me start that again. And of course, for time immemorium, there have been people of our generation talking about, these kids today, and and what's wrong with these kids today. but this is not that. The things that we're talking about are not just generational differences of opinion. this is a measurable. problem. This is a a measurable decline in well being and mental health and adaptability and resiliency and and a bunch of other things. And so we're gonna dig into that today because it's so important. Literally we have an entire generation that is not only at risk, it's really that the the things that they are at risk for for are already taking place. And so that restoration, that getting to where we need to be is is crucial. And And I think we will also have some advice and answer for pastors, for parents specifically, and and all those who are dealing with these pathologies as we go. And Dell, we have the opportunity to to bring a friend of ours into the conversation. It's our good friend Mark Fay. Mark is the president and founder of MKF Strategic Marketing and has worked. with you particularly for many years, through the Truth Project and through your various teaching enterprises. And Mark, it is great to have you with us today. How are you?
speaker-2: Hey, it's good to be with you. I it's I've I've been a big fan of the Doctor Tackett and John Rabe team f way back to the cross examine days. So it's
speaker-0: Well, that's very kind. And if we're being honest, we have to disclose Mark has been a big help to us even in getting this podcast going and has pulled a lot together for us. So a man of many talents and and always there to always there to help us. Now, Mark, I I introduced you by title, president and founder of MKF Strategic Marketing. for people like me who don't know what any of those things mean, what what what is that? What do you tell us about what you do?
speaker-2: Well, God has creatively blended many career tracks for me into this what essentially is a marketing position. So back to high from high school teacher to pastor to working I focus on the family and now was head of marketing at a couple of f for profit companies and now I help people build relationships of trust. That's a I think a good way of saying marketing with in integrity, marketing with ethics. So if companies wanna build relationships with the folks they're serving, that's what I love to do.
speaker-1: But you know what, we can't let it we can't let that also overshadow in terms of what Mark has meant, not only to me, but in terms of the Truth Project and the other things that we've done. Mark has has been, you know, I don't want to say right hand man, but because he's more than that. And so I'm thankful to the Lord for him. And we've we've been good friends for a number of years.
speaker-2: Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-0: Yeah. Which makes the the conversation even more fun, a conversation among friends. But the topic itself is is not what we would call fun, but it's extremely vital as we talk about really what has happened to our our our our our current generation. And again, even saying words like that, it sounds like, these kids today. But It really is a the what we're calling this program today is the tragic rewiring, how the phone based childhood has produced an anxious generation. And we'll also look at what parents and leaders in the body of Christ should know and do about that. But Mark, as we as we begin to broach this topic, and it really is a crisis, we'll explain that with demonstration, with proof as we go here, but What got you interested particularly in this topic?
speaker-2: Well, that's a great first question because really and little to do with what I do for a living, it has to do
Load full transcript
with being a dad. You know, and and being a brother in Christ and you know, having close friends who's own who are also raising kids and so I've got one of the one of my three kids are in this window that we're gonna be talking about. and so seeing the the effect, the damage, really the the tragedy that's happened in the body of Christ and And finding out that there's a really good reason why our kids maybe are struggling the way they are. You know, young men are not leaving they're not launching like they they used to and and girls are not healthy emotionally and there are really clear connections to what we're gonna be talking about today. So really as a dad and and member of the body of Christ, leader in the body of Christ, these are really critical issues we're gonna be talking about.
speaker-0: The figures demonstrate the crisis that we're talking about, a a an unbelievable rise in mental illness among and and again, I guess we should explain when we're what we're talking about specifically generationally. We're we're talking about people really born after nineteen ninety-five, the so called generation Z. and the the world that they have grown up in is entirely different than the world then that any of us grew up in. I'm what we call Generation X, and even the millennials, Generation Y, grew up with some of this stuff, but they were already mainly formed by the time it came along. What is the the demarcation line where things begin to change, where we see these terrible mental health outcomes and an enormous rise in suicides and attempted suicides, depression, anxiety. Where is the the on switch for all of that?
speaker-2: Well, so we'll all remember the on the the adoption of the smartphone. So and especially in two thousand eight, when the iPhone came on the scene, that really brought together a lot of capabilities into that one device that has had these effects. And so in two thousand ten as soci sociologists looks looked at the mental health trends among adolescents, they saw and you look at the the actual graphs themselves, there's this trend line that's moving up but at a gradual pace. And then in 2010, everything shoots up, almost like a hockey stick. And it's alarming to see these are issues of adolescent anxiety, depression, really specific behaviors like self-harm, and then this they call persistent sadness, which which thinking of that as a as a sociologists or mental health term, that's that's a sobering two words to put put together that our adolescents would be dealing with persistent sadness. So all these measures rose sharply right at 2010 2010. And so the sociologists started doing the research, you know, what what's causing this and they research across classes, across socioeconomic levels or areas even across cultures. Many of these t this research has been done in other Western countries, Western yeah, that have adopted the iPhone or the cell phone in particular, and exact same results we're seeing in all of these cultures is this rise in in mental health issues in in our adolescents.
speaker-0: That's an important point too, because the a lot of people say, Well, there's y how do you know that it has to do with the cell phones? And it's particularly the marriage of the smartphone and social media that starts to take place around that time that puts the world in their pocket. But people say, Well, i they're afraid of climate change. It's it's the bad economy. We had the economic collapse in two thousand eight. We had you know, this this nine eleven, whatever. but in checking across all sorts of other societies, all sorts of other nations. it was happening in places with good economies, bad economies, places involved in wars, places where there was peacetime. It's happening across the board. And Dell, I interrupted you as you you were getting ready to jump in.
speaker-1: No, that's fine. And and I was just gonna add to that and and it it it appears, Mark, that what what we're saying here is that the connection is not just because of the dates associated, but with the consequences we're seeing and a direct relationship to what this technology has brought, right? So it's not like we're just saying, okay, things changed in the tin and what happened then well a phone came in. that there is a direct relationship to what that phone is doing to the pathology of the scene. Is that right?
speaker-2: Ex exactly right. The so this device was engineered to do some really important things and that's to hold children's attention, adolescents d attention. And so the what it was the social science was geared to create addiction. this was s social science that got applied to control and manipulate. to to create a dependency in the in kids' lives. And so th th that dependency then resulted in these the the damage that's that's happened. You you look at the social media platform you mentioned front facing cameras. You wouldn't think that would be a big deal, but that were on camera all the time. Algorithmic feeds, these this idea of of figuring out the the formula for keeping a a viewer attached to that device and then the deep we call the the the constant scrolling, we call it death scrolling for a reason because there's no bottom to it. You just keep going. And so all of these d were designed to create a dependence and ultimately an addiction. And that world we in fact one of the other trends that that one of the sh leading researchers, Jonathan Haidt, pointed out was that leading up to the adoption of the the smartphone was a a decline in or an increase in in pro over protection. So parents got over protected from the eighties leading into the 2000s. And so they were overprotected in the real world and then we handed them a smartphone and they were underprotected or not protected at all in the digital world. And so we saw really a two worlds got swapped. The real world For the virtual world and these are the results that we're seeing.
speaker-0: It's unlest anyone think
and by the way, you mentioned Jonathan Haidt and his book, The Anxious Generation, I know is one that all three of us have found to be enormously important and and helpful on this topic. And we recommend it. It's it's it's not written from a Christian perspective, and there are some evolutionary assumptions that turn up in the book and so forth, but overall, in terms of analyzing this problem and proving this problem. a I haven't seen much that's better than than the anxious generation and so I commend it especially to to parents out there. but lest anyone think that we're sort of using strong language here, this is all in the public record in terms of the social media companies purposely building their algorithms to be addictive, purposely building them to hit those dopamine centers in young people. who are continuing to scroll. You know, when when Facebook first started, whenever it was in the in the late aughts or the early twenty tens, it was just mainly a place for people to say hi to old friends. but it became something different. and and again, that algorithm fed the things to people. And then you have a a key moment when Facebook buys Instagram. Instagram at that point is a small startup company and they go from about nine million users to ninety million users in the course of a year or so after Facebook buys them. And so suddenly you go from one out of every hundred kids being on Instagram to almost all of them being on Instagram, which again is feeding the algorithm. And and it's as kids are looking at it, we see that they're they're their mental health self-reporting, their well-being, their their all the measures of thriving are dropping, dropping, dropping. And so this isn't just us shaking our finger at some kind of new technology. The the front facing camera, as you pointed out, gives us selfies. And suddenly everybody's putting their selfies online and they're using filters to do that. And so I don't look as good as This other person's filter looks online. And so my life begins to look more and more paltry compared to someone else's life and everybody's curating a brand. Everybody's curating an image. I can't imagine. Can you guys imagine having had that kind of pressure on you to curate your brand when you were 13 years old? I couldn't curate tying my shoes when I was 13 years old.
speaker-2: I I wouldn't wanna s I wouldn't want to find my thirteen year old self on a in an environment that never goes away. Yeah. Your thirteen self year old self will always be there. My goodness. Mm-hmm.
speaker-1: Mark, you you you mentioned the these two different environments and I want you to talk about those and help help us understand the the difference. You talked about a physical environment and then you talked about a digital environment.
speaker-2: Yes.
speaker-1: give us an idea of what you mean by that and what that looks like.
speaker-2: Yeah. So you know, the physical environment is the environment that we that human beings that that
God has created for us to embody. to you human re our relationships are are built in the real world, where we we see gestures and and we read the cues, we we are responsible. We're because we're together in a room physically, there's a relationship built there that is fully formed. If that goes away and is replaced by something that's virtual, that's manipulated, there's huge consequences in in that in the result of that. And and so understanding who the a person's real self is gets thrown out of whack. It it it becomes difficult for a young person. In this case, young people, when they're first working their way through adolescence, they their mind, the the reward center of their brain is really activated, but their their responsibility side of their brain, the prefrontal cortex, is not developed yet. So we're creating these young people growing up almost completely around immediate gratification, not around the things that we want to teach them in our around our dinner tables and around in the classroom and in our churches and youth groups and so forth. So we've really replaced real life with a world that they have the full control to to to form and shape on their own.
speaker-0: And their their methods of doing that are low attachment too, which makes it a very tenuous situation. i y you all three of us had the experience when we were young. what what did I do on a summer day when I when I was twelve years old? Well, I I woke up, I ate breakfast, probably watched a cartoon or something, but then My friends and I all went out and we didn't quite have this is late 70s into the 80s. We didn't have today's helicopter parenting. We went out and played. We we played, we got a baseball game together, we got a football game together, we invented games that we that we played with each other. and there were arguments and there were difficulties, and what happened in those situations is well, these are my friends. And so We have to find a way to work it out. And I know Height talks about this, the the value of unsupervised play, which is almost even the term unsupervised play would give most parents heart palpitations now. But that unsupervised play is how we learn to negotiate in the world. It's how we learn to interact with each other and how we learn to resolve things. I can't just cut off my whole friend group here because they're my friends. These are the people who live around me. These are the people that I'm connected to. And so You work it out. whereas now in a virtual online environment, which as you point out, these kids are immersed in, there's no cost. It's a it's low entry bar for the relationship. You just click on a somebody sends you an invitation or somebody you know, somebody somebody clicks on your profile. And so we are friends. And as soon as anything goes wrong, well, you're gone. You're deleted, you're blocked, you're out of my life. and it ends up translating into the real world.
speaker-2: Yeah. Yeah, that's right. And and that
digital world has dynamics that are very damaging for girls in particular. There's it's all based on on how you look, on on image and the rise of bullying, cyber bullying, these are the more than fifty percent of girls, I think in Hate's research, he Heights research he pointed out that they've been more than fifty percent bullied in the last month. Imagine the the the psychological damage that a girl has to deal with and she really has now she's just trying to manipulate an image and you know how difficult that is and you're trying to figure out who you are and it's all coming down to what the crowd says about how you look.
speaker-1: Mark, I I have often you know, I I hear these things about the bullying and and all of that that happens to people, but you have to ask the question then why do you keep going back? Right? I mean, you know, if if you know grow gr I grew up on a farm, you know, and and if I if I did something that hurt, I I wouldn't do that again. I've learned Okay, that's okay, that hurts. I'm not gonna do that. What is it? There's something here that keeps people coming back, right?
speaker-2: Yeah, I think that's the conundrum of the whole thing is that the environment is addictive and you know it it it's kind of an argument in in the operating conditioning. If you have nine positive experiences and then one negative, but you had the nine positive or that you know, as long as you get that dopamine hit, then you know, that's what keeps you coming back and and the whole thing is designed To, wow, this girl just liked my post. Well, I didn't and then but then it's well I didn't like it as much as this person. And so y they get pulled into this world where their value gets defined by these very superficial actions, how many people are following you, what you like, and and how your image looks in your profile. And and because that's where all their peers are, it's the only place or it's the most important place. in in their world. They're you know, because there aren't these healthy places that you're describing, John, in in a regular what we understood is is growing up, you know, the real world. and they're holding these things with them all the time, twenty four seven. So we know the statistics of how often they're online. It's just hard for us to imagine why would you keep going into that world if it's harmful, but it's the only world they know. It's the world where they're getting their value, even if it's it's hurtful at maybe s most of the time for some of some of the girls and boys, obviously.
speaker-0: Yeah, and let's we'll talk about that. the there was a a Harvard professor who hyped quotes in the anxious generation. And I I didn't write down the quote, so I I will butcher it a little bit, but it's just something along the lines of we are now ever elsewhere. and that really is an amazing transformation in the way that we exist. And again, when I say we, this is increased many fold the younger that we get, people who've grown up with these. technologies and have never known anything but where you know you and I we went to school and that's where we were at that moment and then we went home and that's where we were at that moment and we did our homework and that's where we were at that moment. Now wherever we are, we're really not because there is this whole virtual world happening out there. And even when kids don't have their phones, they're constantly thinking about and even showing withdrawal symptoms of needing to get back to that get back to that world. but you mentioned boys as well. The the effects on girls I think have been more dramatic and more obvious, perhaps. You talked about that that almost that hockey stick that that goes up, self harm and suicide attempts and and and and depression and anxiety and so forth. just crazy increases, a couple of hundred percent among girls. but As you indicated, Mark, there have been effects on boys as well. They are a little more subtle, but what what what has happened to boys here?
speaker-2: Yeah. The girls we can say we've seen the the damage really clearly kind of up front and center, but we could say that boys have sort of just disappeared. And what they've disappeared into is gaming. you know, and some some boys can manage that at a certain level where it's not unhealthy, but unfortunately large pr that world pulls them into another world, gaming world. And the other very tragic reality is that pornography is a click away. And these worlds the that world can't be contr you can't keep that world out of a a a young man, a b boy's smartphone. They know how to get around whatever the filters might be. and even in not super h hardcore pornography, everything's gotten so sexualized on in in the world of online social media and everything that the that's a second area. And so then the third one is interesting to point out this is an interesting s statistic that ER visits for boys have gone dramatically they've gone down. And and the interesting thing about that is that they're they're not out taking risks, climbing trees, doing the things that boys do. And so they're not They're getting their licenses later, they're not getting speeding tickets. Some of these things are are on first blush good things, but what they tell us is there's a trend that boys are just timid. And there's also a a social a cultural dynamic that boys in general are less value today than twenty years ago. Their their masculinity is. So you put all this together and it it really creates the conditions for boys to disappear. And it's the reason they're they're launching later in life. They're they're not they're not proactive in their in in their life. They really just let life come at them.
speaker-1: So is there there does this then breed a deficiency then in terms of someone's ability to to meet a challenge, overcome a challenge, to be to be confronted with an obstacle and learn how to get around that obstacle or overcome that obstacle or to
accept you know, the obstacle's too big, I'm I'm gonna try something else. Are we saying that what happens in this in this digital world is that those things aren't there and therefore I'm n I'm not developing the ability to overcome those things?
speaker-2: Exactly right. So in the gaming world, you're becoming successful by knowing the game. but we know in real life that's not how you you you have real relationships or conflict that you learn to work through. there there are skills you develop that have meaning in the real world. But if you look at the gaming world, these are not skills that translate into the real world. They're they're you get good at a game. and any social connection has to do with, the scores on the on the game or who's winning or who's not winning. But real life skills aren't produced in a gaming environment. And then pornography, probably even a more extreme case, there's no risk. And boys are learning either whether objectifying women, they're learning that they're not having these experiences with the the opposite sex that where they learn the skills of re relationships and of of what it means to to have a be a responsible part of a of a loving relationship. These are there's not anywhere in the online world where these skills get developed.
speaker-0: You've talked about w and and Height talks about, you know, the phone-based childhood. And it really is an entire environmental change, isn't it? Where where this isn't just a matter of, well, they have this other thing that's part of their lives now. And so that's something that we have to sort of you know, just figure out along with the other factors in their lives. There is a sense in which this is the determining factor in their life, that it is a A virtual childhood, a phone-based childhood, as opposed to an embodied one. And Dell, you and I'll talk about this some later on too. But it as we do that, you know, everyone has heard the tur the term dehumanization before, but when we deal with each other as pixels on a screen as opposed to embodied human beings, there is a cost to that. And it it seems, Mark, that. an entire generation now almost entirely interacts with others in in digital form rather than in in in real life. And the the the consequences of that I don't even think we've begun to measure yet, even though we can see so many of them.
speaker-2: Yeah, that's right. D Dr Tag, Dell and I have talked about this, you know, when we're traveling together for a an event. We'll look around and you can just see in a in an airport, everybody's faces are on their screens and and a family traveling together, you know, there's five people five fa family members sitting next to each other, but they're all in their own little world and and so it's hard to overstate. how dramatically adolescence world has what world they've taken into adulthood, because we didn't ha do that. And and so, you know, to understand what their world means and you know, the other thing is we just
see the effects on in a day-to-day way that's that things like slep sleep deprivation, these kids will stay awake way into the night, gaming or or being on their social media feed. They don't sleep. They they don't have these social interactions. And also the world is is, especially for boys who have already a hard time to focus hard time focusing, fragments attention, teaches, it's only the quick, thing that's happening fast. And then of course the compulsive, addictive nature of all of it. So the the impact is is almost daily. It's impact the impact is daily in these very basic skills that we use to to succeed in life and but then it's also profoundly impacting in this on this level of a whole world that they live in that we don't really understand what that means because we we didn't grow up in it. And it's it is their world.
speaker-1: I I will confess that I have I'm somewhat old fashioned and and ignorant. I haven't I haven't gotten into social media. I I have a Facebook page, but I never never go there. And and so a lot of things that I see are really really reveal that I that I'm I'm out of touch, I guess you could say. But I do a lot of travel. I sit next to a lot of people on airplanes and and I can kind of see a little bit what they're doing. And the th and one of the things that almost I can I can feel it in myself when I see people flipping through video after video th and they don't watch the whole thing.
speaker-0: TikTok.
speaker-1: For a a second or two, then they flip to another. And I will tell you, I just in observing that it it raises anxiety in me. and so just I'm talking as an observer here, that and I see people do that all the time. So I don't e I don't know what that is and so forth, but I see them do it all the time and I know how it affects me. I can't imagine what it does to them.
speaker-2: Yeah, that's right. I I have the same anxiety myself of just I just to see someone with their w just watching their thumb scroll. you know, I just I just see I get the picture in my mind that someone's going deeper and deeper into this hole that there's no bottom to. and and so but that but the answer to I think lies in that that picture that we're talking about, and that is that, you know God has made us for relationship. He's designed us that way. and you know, we talk about, you know, Augustine, th there's a whole God shaped vacuum, it was a Pascal, the God shaped vacuum that only God can fill in our hearts. And the same is true in our families and and so if there's you know, making the effort to break these patterns and start to see, you know, eye to eye contact and communication. And and giving kids the gift to the even if it's painful, on the way in, we're really giving them what they were designed for is real relationships. And that's what makes it such an important topic in the body of Christ. if anyone should lead on this, it should be us.
speaker-0: Amen. We we've talked about how this technology and then these algorithms, these apps sort of rewire people's brains and and what they're doing just to sort of you know psychological well-being. but one thing that we haven't yet touched on that that I want to ask you about, Mark, is the cost to truth. This is we call this this this podcast the truth encounter. And of course Dell did the truth project. We value truth. and there is a cost in this technology. And I almost hesitate to call it technology because it's not like it's just machines. People are programming these things. People are leveraging this technology to hijack our brains. but the there is a cost to truth in all of this as well, isn't there?
speaker-2: There there is. w i it's and I this is one thing I've seen in my own kids' life. There's a battle for for who is gonna have who's gonna what voice will have the authority to speak into our kids' lives what is true. And in that virtual world when the credibility is is defined in a way that Who gets the most follows or the most views or the most whatever's and not on what is true based on the word of God and and based on the witness of creation around us that we see God has placed in in the real world, the evidence of who He is in the real world. When all of that's w our kids are cut off from that, now they're at the the the they're vulnerable to the most persuasive voices or the most seductive voices, or the ones that have the best image, or say things the you know, most persuasive ways and not based on what is true. And and so, you know, I think that's the the challenge for us is to help our kids move from this immediate gratification that they get on a on a phone to the deeper desires of the human heart that are for for God and and That happens through real relationships. And so there's really practical places we can start. I may I re read Romans twelve too, d do do not be conformed to the patterns of this age. Have we we've always been, the world has always tried to conform us to the pattern of this world. But in this digital world, gosh is so stark, almost like the enemy is o has overplayed his hand, because we can see it all so starkly. And I think this younger generation is starting To wake up to that. If you look at the statistics of of young people, they're coming back to church in their late teens and twenties. They're looking for what's real. They're seeing finally the emptiness of the virtual, what is virtually real. And so we have an opportunity, I think, before us to to but it's going to take relationships. We talk about this, Dr. Tackett, real relationships. We talk about it with our neighbors and family members. It's it's making the investment in in in r real relationships, spending the time, and not just, well, I guess that's just what we're gonna be the family that looks down at our phones when we're on vacation. push it back, it it takes effort, but but it's gonna be worth it.
speaker-1: Mark, you in in some of the things that you you said to us bef before we got together here
today, you were you were laying out a pathway forward here that was not simply you know saying, okay, throw these things away, but it's it's another pathway. What is that?
speaker-2: you mean in terms of just what what can we do?
speaker-1: Yeah, how how do we go forward? How how do we at this point advise people who are viewing parents, even younger people at this point? How how do we say we go forward in in in in pursuing a a a solution to this deeply troubling pathology?
speaker-2: Yeah, well I I think it starts by not looking at all of this and feeling powerless that there isn't anything we can do. But it starts by I think parents and we could say teachers and you know in that environment. also of course our churches, but but acknowledging that that it's a problem and and beginning to lead out into Creating an environment that's healthy. And so very practically many of researchers are are and I would agree with this, is it to delay smartphone use to after sixteen or a or social media till after sixteen. know, recommendations of just not having the the phone in the bedroom at night. There are these really practical things that we can do to create phone-free. environments that really then create room for us to have conversations, real relationships. so I think it and it and really it it I think as a family it's owning that together. Let's solve this together. So it's not a lecture at our child children about the harmful effects of of the phone, but it's it's like moving the phone out of the bedroom at night, creating phone free meals. It's talking honestly about what the devices are doing. what where the risks are. and probably maybe most of all it's parents modeling this, not being on their phones themselves a hundred percent of the time. And you know, that his home close to home because many of us have developed our own addictions to the to phones and the things that the activities that we're involved in when we're on our phones. and and the church, I think we can be we can be so We can be hopeful in the way that we challenge families to take the lead in this in their h in their in their families and in their homes. So that it's not a rules based, you can't do this, you can't do that, but it's more a a yes. Let's say yes to looking each other in the eye when we have conversations. Let's say yes to gathering around a meal and there are no phones, not even on the table or in your back pocket, you know. Because all of that phone is always pulling at us. And so, and then we need voices in the body of Christ who will help us connect the word of God to these very real places that young people are struggling. And so you know, where your heart is, where your treasure is, there where your heart will be. So, you know, it's not It's interesting, that's not where your heart will be, your treasure will be. No, it's where your treasure will be, your heart will be. And so, i if we spend this much time on that device, we have to ask ask the question, is is that our treasure? And so we have we can help to lead our children out of these places, out of this world that we probably don't fully ourselves understand the the damage of it 'cause we just see it in their lives. We're not living it out like they are.
speaker-0: I I think too, there are things to be done at every stage in this, but I I would particularly want to implore parents of young kids, newborns to eleven or twelve years old, because that's not to take away hope from parents of teens or or even parents of people who are in their early twenties, but it gets harder because this stuff becomes wired in, it becomes entrenched, and there really is an addictive property to it where you know, in in Heights book he he reports so many parents who have the experience of, okay, we're gonna change this. And the the the child freaks out in some cases threatens suicide. I you we cannot I cannot be off of my device. And it's it's the the the more enmeshed it is, the more difficult it is. And so having a a common vision and and and tell me, Mark, I think this is somewhere where the churches can help, the pastors can help, having a a uniform vision where it's not just rules, but a combined vision of actual childhood as opposed to a telephone-based childhood can be extremely helpful, giving parents a vision for keeping the the smartphone out of their kids' hands until high school and keeping social media away from them until at least sixteen or more. And it it's very hard to be the only parent who's, you know I I'm the only kid in school who doesn't have it. That's a very difficult position to be in. But if we if we made communities that held this common conviction and raised kids in that community from the get go, we could have a a substantial effect.
speaker-2: Yes. And and I think the tide has fi is finally turning where our culture is realizing that these are not extreme extreme measures anymore to be in instituting. one of the things we hear is that if you ask somebody at an employee at Facebook whether or not their own children have access to Facebook, they'll tell you no. Because the employees know they see behind the curtain. And so, you know, the practices of the social media engineers themselves would would instruct us like this is how dangerous it is. And so, you know, I I think I saw an article come out just in the last couple of days in one of the large An Atlanti Atlantic Monthly that said, you know, the research is in. It's decisive. Screens are not good for k children. But who among us will have the courage to not put our kids in front of these screens because as a parent it's easy parenting. We put our kids in front of a screen. And so these are gonna be hard choices not only that we're gonna require our kids to make, but it's gonna start with us as parents.
speaker-1: I think that's an important point there, Mark, because I have seen and and I think it's I I f I feel the the pain associated with watching when this happens where parents
will just put their child in front of a screen to to entertain them. and and you know I I I understand parenting requires a lot of time. And and there are times when you just need a break. I underst I understand that. But the the danger here that we're talking about, and I think that's why why this is an important topic. Because I think parents need to recognize this is not just a neutral thing here that that we're doing. It's not neutral. and y you know, we were talking about, you know, the the the the child or or the son or whatever the parent tried to take it away from him he says, I can't live without it. Okay, that that ought to give us a clear indication. Okay, this this is an addiction.
speaker-0: An idol.
speaker-1: Yeah, that and and you don't want no I don't think any parent wants to wittingly pull their child into an addiction like that. So it's important to know that this is an addictive thing. It's planned to be addictive. you know companies are making it addictive and your child is gonna suffer because of this. And it seems to me that there is also the basis for how we have a healthy discussion with our children. To sit down and say, okay, here this is going to harm you. it's gonna hurt you. Here are all the the pathways that this is trying to draw you down. And what we're gonna do as a family here is we're gonna say no to that to that threat, we're gonna say no to that temptation. And instead, you know, we're gonna we're gonna do things together. We're gonna go to the park or whatever whatever it is. but that that costs us, I understand that. And so to some extent, you know, the burden here is going to be on a parent to be willing to be sacrificial in their own addictive behavior and sports and games and all the other things that even parents have become addicted to.
speaker-2: Yes. Yeah, that that's that hits ho it hits home, doesn't it? I I have a granddaughter who's nine, so I'm watching my son negotiate these questions for her. And man, she can be really really persuasive and and stubborn. We could even say about no, well can I how about this? Can I get this you know, and and so but he's holding the line, you know, and I've talked to him about this book and but it forces it forces him and parents in general to say, well, what else could we do? And there's some great s answers on the other side of that question. It it's just gonna take some effort. One thing that I th I I think we can also do is because this can feel like a big challenge is just ask maybe everybody in the family, all right, what's one thing that this has cost us? And for, you know, a w one child it could be well sleep, I'm I'm gaming way into the night, or another one it could be that it could be relationships, it could be you know, any number of things. It may be different for each person in the family and then say, what are we willing to commit to recover that one thing? And start with w recovering one thing that it that the social media has cost you or the devices cost you. And then as a family, you know celebrate those those victories. And so, but but we have to lead out and and I think there are ways we can make that that journey a positive one, you know, not just negative.
speaker-0: Mark, of course, as we look at the landscape, it would be easy to become discouraged. It would be easy to throw our hands up and just say, Well, this is a tidal wave, there's nothing we can do about this. But there is some reason for hope. You pointed out that even the the Gen Z kids themselves are getting to the point where they're recognizing that they're being harmed by this stuff. They want to change it and find it difficult to do so because of the addictive nature of it and and just because it's It's hard to be the only one who's not part of it. but so we see that, but rather than hopelessness, it's just this is this is the death spiral of of our society, what hope do we have here? Do you have hope in all this?
speaker-2: I do. Y you know, we ultimately, we know this from the gospel that we can't even really fulfill our own righteousness i as a follower of Christ. We gotta rely on on the Holy Spirit to give us the power to to do the right thing, to follow Christ. So, you know, it's I think it's important that we don't try to just feel like we gotta figure out a way to do this on our own. First starts by really inviting the Lord to help us and probably that's the maybe one of the best prayers for our kids to hear us, pray with them, is Lord, I you know, I'm not sure how to do this. So can you can you help us, you know, change these patterns? And I think it's all also when a parent is honest about their own, you know, struggles and with the device, with the phone, with social media. but that place of honesty I think is what our our kids will really benefit from. And and then let's do this together. And and we can see God we g we talk a lot about fruitfulness. What does a fruitful life look like? It's we might be amazed, I think we will be, of of the fruitfulness that's that's on the other side of removing these these negative inputs in our life. And God invites us, you know, into that world to meet him in reality, not in a virtual world, in reality.
speaker-0: Amen. Well, Mark, we appreciate your thoughts on this and your expertise. It is is great to talk to you about this. And in some ways, we've only just scratched the surface here because this is such an enormous issue, and it is as big as anything that we've ever faced as a culture that affects our children and so very important, but I think also some pathways forward, some reason for hope. thank you. We we do appreciate it. Thanks for your insights and let's do it again one of these days 'cause there's a lot more to say.
speaker-2: It's awesome. Thank you so much.
speaker-0: Mark. Well, Dell, this has been an excellent conversation. And I you know, I understand the the thing is is is I'm a guy who's as I said, Generation X. So I well predate by a couple of
generations the generation Z. And and yet even at my advanced age, I find myself, I feel the lure of the phone. we've talked, I think, before about Neil Postman's really important book from the 1980s, Amusing Ourselves to Death. And his thesis in that book was just that the form is as important as the content. So you can have educational television programming, for instance, that still makes you dumber because it's short attention span, it's quick cuts, it's and and He he talked about how we were getting dumber as a society because it was entertainment based. And he was lamenting that we had political sound bites that were only twenty to thirty seconds on the news. Well, now a soundbite on the news is three to four seconds and that's only increased. So we've talked about sort of the the mental effects to well being and to to to depression and anxiety, but one of the things we haven't really discussed as much is Just how this shreds our ability to pay attention, how it shreds our ability to reason. You you talked about the people just thumbing through the videos on TikTok, boom, boom, boom, with a three second attention span. I as I started with, I'm a couple of generations past that, and I see it happening in myself. I have less of an attention span than I had 20 years ago. And it's a fight, it's more of a fight now. concentrate rather than check the phone, check Twitter, see what the score is, all on my phone. And so if that's true for me, and and for my generation, I I can't even conceive of what it's like to be twenty right now.
speaker-1: But I think John, the important thing here is to recognize it. that r the first the the first pathway to a solution is you have to first recognize there's a problem. Right. And I think for a long time, thankfully I think that's changing now, but for a long time, this came upon us and there was no sense there's something wrong here. It just there was it was more beautiful every day, things were more exciting every day, there was more feeds every day, and and we just we found ourselves pulled into this and but now hopefully we're beginning to to to say, hey, wait a second, there's something problematic here. There's something harmful here. So that's the first step, you know, is to recognize that. Whether we're we're talking about that in general or whether we're talking about you and me recognizing this is a problem. And and so I have to begin to do something to to change that. it is addictive. I I have to protect myself from that. But I'll tell you, John, the the thing that keeps kind of flowing through my mind through our whole topic here today is is what Jesus said. The thief comes to steal and destroy. And I can't help myself seeing this is this is like grand theft. Because it's stealing your life. It's stealing your time. It's stealing your attention. It's stealing your heart. It's it's stealing your productivity. And the and the fruitfulness of our life is being stolen by the enemy here. I'm not trying to, put a demon behind every every cell phone here, but what I'm what I'm saying is this is exactly something that the enemy would want. That he would want us to be so trapped in our own selfish satisfaction of our pleasure and so forth, that we become less and less fruitful, we become less and less involved in true deep relationships, which bring up brings about fruitfulness. And that fruitfulness, which is meant to bring glory to God, then gets cut off. And so anyway, I just some thinking. Boy, Satan's having a heyday here.
speaker-0: That is really such a powerful point. And again, we've talked about that in a number of our podcasts, but Satan, of course, is real and and like you said, this is not an issue of of you know im g giving immediate demonic cause to everything that happens, but it is to say that Satan has a strategy and and again the Bible tells us clearly what it is and and kill, steal, destroy and we see the suicide rate skyrocketing. As you said, we see all of our our our heart, our mind, our attention, our productivity, our fruitfulness, all these things being stolen, the and and even our ability to think destroyed. And of course they're ultimately that is a it is a a it is a a an attempt to destroy us and destroy our fruitfulness, which is Satan's goal from the beginning. And that doesn't mean we're not saying that every use of the device is satanic. We're not saying even that that some use of social media is satanic. We're using social media. This this this program will be pumped out on certain social media channels and and it can be a very useful tool, but we have to remember that whatever it was originally intended to be, a tool perhaps, it has stopped being that. And those people even who built and maintained these things have purposely turned it into more than a tool. It is something that is is designed to reach out and grab you and and hold on to you. So being aware of that and being extremely conscious and and proactive about what we're doing, as you say, I think is just so important. Yeah.
speaker-1: And so, part of our the our series here of the restoration is to look at at the family, I think, and you know, what is happening to the family. And from my perspective, this is the target here is on the family and children, adults and and everything that the family was designed to be, what we see here is is the thief. And I and again, I I agree with you. We can't But if things are following the same pathway the enemy wants, we know there's something wrong with that. And so, you know, the call here is for for families, you know, to be wise, to have these discussions with their children, to call them to something better, than just wasting their life. satisfying their own fleshy desires here. And and I think it it also involves the the community that God calls us to as Christians. We need to help each other. You know I I need to I need to help you. You need to help me. our life group needs to be encouraging one another because
as as you pointed out, several times and it's big, for a child all of a sudden to to to be confronted with a parent who's now saying, you know, you're not gonna bring the phone to dinner. And and they're used to spending all their dinner time with a fork in one hand and the phone in the other, okay, it it's gonna disrupt a pattern, or to say they can't have it at school. And Now I under by the way, I understand that there are a number of schools now that are finally getting to an understanding of the harmful nature here and they're beginning to implement rules that's phones aren't allowed to be in school. I am excited that that's happening. but eventually it it it boils down to the parent and the parent governing themselves. and but also being being the proper parent to guard their children, to protect their children and to help them see things that are harmful.
speaker-0: Yeah, and parents banding together in the body of Christ will help each other and be able to help the kids have a community where it's not so abnormal to not spend all your time online as well. And it Del, one of the the the terms that we mentioned a number of times in our our conversation with Mark was embodied, embodiment. And I I think that's a really important part of this discussion too. Another word perhaps for embodied is incarnate, in the flesh. And you know, it it is it is telling to me that while God did give us a book that ultimately for our redemption, he sent his son as a an embodied human being to save other embodied human beings. it wasn't enough just to send words. It certainly wouldn't have been enough to send pixels or pictures. It it required a human being. And there is something deeply profound about this embodiment. And I don't think that we've really reckoned with how much of that that we've lost. I I think of COVID when churches were and and when we had to do it. You know, there was a time where we were just trying to figure out what was going on and trying to be wise, but where churches met online and so forth. But there was there were a lot of people who just thought it was the same thing and I I know in my own church we taught people it is not the same thing. As soon as we are able to be together in the flesh again, we are going to do that because there is no substitute for that. But that is a a a profound issue that's all part of this as well. We're losing embodiment. Yeah.
speaker-1: Well it's you know, you're exactly right. When we look at the nature and character of God, he he has engaged himself with us personally and he has done that ultimately through Jesus Christ. and his ultimate goal is to restore relationships that were broken at the fall. He began with this, you know, walking with with Adam the broken and everything since then has been moving towards a restoration of relationships. What we're talking about here is an attempt to to destroy relationships or to isolate people, to put them in this atomistic atomistic form where we wear hoodies
and earbuds and our faces buried in a screen and i it's like there's no one else around us. it's an un unreal world, but I th again, you know, back back to the enemy. That's where the enemy wants us. It's it's hard for me to even imagine that Jesus would relate to us digitally. He you know, he he was so involved in in in pulling the three guys, Peter, James and John, aside. he was so involved in personally talking to people, touching people, touching the lepers. And and and of course the you know, the incarnation of Christ is the ultimate you know, picture of God involving himself bodily in this world. And so I I absolutely agree with what what you're saying there, John. That this is part of what we need to recover in our world today is this personal relationship that we have with each other. And also, I would add our personal relationship to the true world, because what this is bringing is an unreal world, and you will increasingly be. bored with reality because you have a better picture on your phone. I s I saw this last time I was at at the Grand Canyon. I saw young people coming up to what is a view of the of the Grand Canyon which should drop us in awe. And I saw young people that looked at it and then just went back and sat down and looked at their phone.
speaker-0: My goodness.
speaker-1: It's a it be it brings a boredom of the world around us. And again, that certainly isn't healthy.
speaker-0: lose our capacity for grandeur. And that's that's that's if you if you don't have a capacity for grandeur you can't love God. And and that's that not that's yeah I'm not making a spiritual judgment on any of those particular people, but we're shrinking our souls by doing this. Dell, I don't know if you saw this was in April of twenty twenty six a company released an app that had an AI Jesus who was modeled on the guy in the movie The Chosen, or in the film series, I guess I should say, the the series The Chosen. but an AI Jesus, and so you could interact with this artificial intelligence Jesus in real time. I think it was $1.99 for 10 minutes or something like that. it seems to me and and again a lot of times the best of intentions what is it? The road to road to hell is paved with good intentions. I I don't know what the intentions are here. Perhaps they're good ones, but it seems to me that almost all rolled into one, that's as catastrophic a misunderstanding at best of what this is all about that you could have.
speaker-1: Well, I that just chills me, John. I think back to, the very first command of God where he said, You're not supposed to make an image of me. And and unfortunately we do. we live in a world we have all kinds of images and and those images always fall short. and and the and and the real possibility is that we will have systems that will make that image into what we want it to be. And AI engines are famous for wanting to make you feel good and to not make you feel uncomfortable. And so my guess is an AI Jesus would probably maybe
not look in the eye and say, You are de you are wrong or whatever.
speaker-0: Ever. He's not gonna call you a whitewashed tomb. No.
speaker-1: that's right. I could call you a hypocrite and you know, you know, and maybe virtually s you know, turn over your tables. But but and and by the way, John, this raises another issue which we're gonna talk about sometime soon and that is the whole issue of AI. because AI is is the is the accelerant to everything we've been talking about here on this program. You know, it's gonna bring it's going to bring virtual people that you can have a relationship with online, which means you don't have to go through everything we've been talking about, the the necessary sacrifice associated with having a good relationship. True love requires sacrifice. I have to give something up here, you know, in this relationship. an AI bought. is not gonna require you to give up anything. And so it we need we will talk about that someday.
speaker-0: It's a a pressing discussion. I I was just speaking to a church this weekend about sort of the Imago Day, what it means to be created in the image of God, and that we who understand that as Christians are going to be the only ones who are going to have answers to what's the difference between artificial intelligence and humanity when it can replicate all the speech and apparent thinking functions of a human being, what will distinguish us. we're the only ones who are going to have the answer to that, and that's gonna be it's already becoming a bit of an issue and will continue to become even more so. But Dell, one more thing I wanted to talk about with you before we wrap up, and it's it's related to this, and we briefly touched on it in the episode, but it's the loss of truth. Again, this is the the truth encounter, and we spent a lot of time talking about truth. One of the things that being sort of siloed in an online virtual world is that the algorithm learns your tastes and it finds out what you watch and it feeds you more things and it will take you down rabbit holes. And it's very difficult to distinguish truth from fiction often in the online world. And so we have this amazing growth of Of and and there are other things that have fed this as well. We relied to quite a bit by the official apparatuses, apparati. I don't know what the plural of that is, but by official apparatuses during COVID, you know, sometimes the government didn't tell us the truth, sometimes the scientists didn't tell us the truth. and so there's this shaking of authority that's taking place. And at the same time, you have these. Everybody's a content creator now. So you have these wormholes you can go down. And so whether it's you name any belief, any, any what would have been considered a fringe belief 30 years ago, we didn't land on the moon. you know, the the the there there's a an online conspiracy theory that you know, everybody but the guy on the roof killed Charlie Kirk last year, et cetera, et cetera,
et cetera. But you can go down these really deep dark holes and There's no resistance, there's no counterpunching, it seems convincing. And so almost any crazy thing you can think of now, I c I can point to one or two people in my vast outer circle who believe those things. and and once everything becomes plausible, n sort of then the truth is just up for grabs, and we end up with a real problem on our hands. There doesn't seem to be we're losing the ability to to be able to parse truth from elaborate fictions or near counterfeits.
speaker-1: Yes. that this is a huge, huge thing. and it's possible maybe we need to have a an an episode on this, but it's huge. And the you know what happens, what technology has brought to us is that the you know, I don't mean to be offensive here, but the young teenage boy with acne can sit in a room and he can't if he's a good hacker, he can bring a a whole corporation to its knees or he can present his truth claim and it goes to the world. It used to be that things were refereed before they're published. And and we had we had a an ethical notion of journalism that, you know, couldn't publish an article in the paper unless it it met the ethical criteria of a journalist, or in some cases it was refereed by by people now that is all gone because anyone can publish anything and with AI, they can make it look like there was there was millions and millions of dollars that went into the production. And and if we get trapped into thinking whether consciously, unconsciously, that if it's on my screen it must be true because I saw it. And and even more so now I saw it in real life, which wasn't real life. I saw people playing out this truth claim or whatever it is. So yeah y this there is an attack upon truth, and not to bring us in eschatology here, but there is a there is an image in in the book of Revelation that talks about the dragon who is enraged and and he it pours out of his mouth this flood to sweep away the woman and and her followers, believers. And what comes out of the mouth of of of Satan is lies. Remember Jesus said he is a liar. He was a liar from the beginning. He's the father of lies. And and so you have this flood and it's almost like we look around today and it y it's overwhelming. You know overwhelming. Why? Because Anybody anywhere can publish anything they want and now with AI they can make it look as if, you know, it has been produced by a large production company of the highest order.
speaker-0: And it'll be very convincing because it may be filled with there's the they call it the 7030 rule, but it may be filled with 70% verifiable truth. And so that runs cover for the 30% of quackery or insanity that's embedded in there and think, well, if these things are obviously true and they affirm those, then these things that I don't know as much about, they must also be telling the truth on. and and so we have a a culture in which Everybody is capable of now stating a truth claim, and we seem to have no way of evaluating or discerning one from the other or even an agreed upon set of standards by which to evaluate those. And so it feels rather catastrophic. But at the end of the day, as with these other things, I don't know how it's going to play out in the near term, but I knew how I do know how it's going to play out in the middle to far term because our God is a God of truth. Jesus Christ is the way, the truth, and the life, and so ultimately the darkness does not win even if it seems ascendant for a time.
speaker-1: Amen. And I think I think the call here for us is that the the word of God has always been critical for for man to rest upon. That's always been true. And I don't know how you can say it's more yet it's more critical now, but it is. and it's more critical now because of the flood of of stuff, the the flood of of anti-truth. is everywhere around us. And so speaking now to the body of Christ, we must ground ourselves continually in the word of God and we also need to fulfill our role loving one another the in the within the body of Christ of of maybe admonishing one another but we need that more than ever now And w and one of the schemes of the enemy would be to isolate us so that we don't have the admonition from a brother. or we we don't even have the admon admonition from the Word of God because we're all of our time is spent here. So it's a good point, John, a really good point.
speaker-0: Well, Dell, as always, I've enjoyed and appreciated the discussion. We're talking about some difficult things and again, I I always appreciate the term you use, pathologies, social pathologies. These are some real social pathologies, virulent, deadly social pathologies that we're dealing with, but shedding light on them I think is is is helpful. we trust God to to do with it as he will. but always a pleasure to have the discussion. I appreciate your insights and look forward to doing the next one. We'll we'll come back again for another episode next week and I I look forward to it.
speaker-1: I do too, John. I I enjoy our interaction. And
speaker-0: Fun.
speaker-1: the topic today, even though it was tough.
speaker-0: Yeah, amen. And we thank our friend Mark Fay for joining us as well. And we'd like to hear from you as well. You can email us currently at the Truth Encounter Podcast at gmail.com. And of course, you can find this and the other podcasts and other resources at deltacket.com and you find us on on YouTube channel and And all other typical outlets. So let your friends know about it. Let other people that would be helped by this to know about it. We want to get it out there for them as well. We appreciate you joining us on the Truth Encounter podcast, and we will see you next time. Bye bye.