رونوشت 🔗
00:00:03
Speaker 1: The Liberal Party is beside themselves with anxiety about something going wrong between now and.
00:00:11
Speaker 2: Politics. Welcome back to The Splash, the Herald Sun's podcast on all things state politics, with about two weeks to go until Election Day. As we open this episode, the Liberals are down another candidate.
00:00:28
Speaker 3: That's two so far. Two and counting. Yeah, Paul Lindemann from Williamstown.
00:00:32
Speaker 2: He's... Was in a good shape.
00:00:34
Speaker 3: He was doing really well.
00:00:35
Speaker 1: I mean, people in Williamstown will tell you that he had saturated the area.
00:00:40
Speaker 2: A lot of volunteers.
00:00:41
Speaker 3: Door knocked his knuckles off.
00:00:42
Speaker 2: He was in with a real show in a seat that you don't really think of them as having a show in. And now gone, or gone from the Liberal Party. Name's still on the ballot.
00:00:52
Speaker 3: His name's still there. What did he do?
00:00:54
Speaker 2: For those people who've been under a rock, what did Lindemann do that got himself.
00:00:58
Speaker 3: Shot by the Liberal Party?
00:00:58
Speaker 1: Well, he was running what you would call, I suppose, a secret. covert sort of Facebook page.
00:01:04
Speaker 2: How old is this guy? Like, what is he doing?
00:01:06
Speaker 1: I suppose it shows his, in one sense, his political brain in knowing that this stuff couldn't be out there publicly.
00:01:13
Speaker 3: But he had this sort of.
00:01:14
Speaker 2: He didn't know enough not to say it. Incorrect.
00:01:16
Speaker 3: He didn't know enough not to say it that it would be leaked.
00:01:19
Speaker 2: And the things he was saying were making reflections on Indigenous Australians and the achievements of their civilisation.
00:01:25
Speaker 3: Things that we shouldn't be repeating here.
00:01:27
Speaker 1: But, you know, whether they were an immediately sackable offence... I think that's arguable, but I think the fact that the Liberal Party disendorsed him immediately.
00:01:37
Speaker 2: I put that to people. Was this really sackable? And it was like, well, do you really want us to have to spend the next week defending this?
00:01:45
Speaker 1: The Liberal Party is, not all of them, but a lot of them, beside themselves with anxiety about something going wrong between now and polling day. The ones that think they can win don't quite believe they're going to win.
00:01:56
Speaker 2: Because- Are there any more?
00:01:57
Speaker 3: You know.
00:01:57
Speaker 2: Has Labor got any more? Has the Labor- Well, you know- This was a Labor hit, do we think?
00:02:02
Speaker 3: Almost definitely.
00:02:03
Speaker 2: The factor was the one, too. They dropped a story about him.
00:02:06
Speaker 3: Yeah, they just gave a little touch-up.
00:02:08
Speaker 2: They opened the batting with a story about, I think, him losing it.
00:02:14
Speaker 3: Losing his temper with an under-14-year-old basketball player.
00:02:17
Speaker 2: And then follow
Load full transcript
up with the brick in the stocking.
00:02:22
Speaker 1: If there's a dirt unit that will have a significant file on candidates, it will be the Victorian Labor Dirt Unit. So, yeah, you'd expect there'd be a few more to go. And, of course, at this time of the cycle, nominations have closed. So once the party loses– So they're on the ballot.
00:02:36
Speaker 2: They're stuck with them now, yeah.
00:02:37
Speaker 3: Yeah. Once the party loses that candidate, they can't replace them.
00:02:41
Speaker 2: Well, look, I have to say, for the Liberal Party on this front, things are looking up because normally when you read a story about the Liberal Party and some terrible thing that's wrong, that's happened, that someone shouldn't have said, you just automatically used to think, oh, an internal. But this one, not an internal. At least they're not doing it to themselves this time.
00:03:03
Speaker 3: They're growing up.
00:03:04
Speaker 2: They're growing up.
00:03:05
Speaker 1: Well, we have a very exciting budget update published today. Yeah, the update that was supposed to show us all the scaries and... Pre-election budget update.
00:03:13
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:03:13
Speaker 3: For those of you who really want to know. I mean, there's been some in there.
00:03:18
Speaker 1: I think if the opposition was hoping to see the true state of the books as they are, it's probably not contained in this document.
00:03:26
Speaker 3: But it made for pretty sombre reading. Things are a lot worse than What's worse?
00:03:31
Speaker 2: Let's go through the bad news.
00:03:33
Speaker 1: The most stark figure out of this is the rate of growth of the economy, which Treasury is now forecasting to be 1%.
00:03:41
Speaker 3: Thanks, Jimbo.
00:03:42
Speaker 2: Thanks, Albo. Yeah, well, four or.
00:03:44
Speaker 1: Five months ago, it was 1.5%. It might not seem a lot, but, you know, it's quite the.
00:03:50
Speaker 2: … It's quite the haircut on that front.
00:03:52
Speaker 3: It really is, and that then impacts everything, obviously. Staff duties?
00:03:56
Speaker 1: Stamp duty has taken a hit, as you would expect, and we're just realising that in this update.
00:04:02
Speaker 3: And net debt.
00:04:02
Speaker 1: Now, net debt, forecasts for net debt have gone down. So we were supposed to hit $ 199. 3 billion, I think it is, in 2030. That's been revised down to about $ 196. 2. So the government will say, wonderful, debt's coming down. It's actually not, because while that figure has come down, as a percentage of the overall economy, it's risen very slightly by 0.1%. Of a percent, but it's risen and it's contrary to everything Labor have been saying that their fiscal strategy will do, which is to bring down debt as a proportion of GSP.
00:04:37
Speaker 2: And the estimates of unemployment have been revised up.
00:04:42
Speaker 3: Yep. So that's worse.
00:04:44
Speaker 2: The opposition is claiming that they would have had a deficit this year had they not pinched some money out of WorkSafe.
00:04:50
Speaker 1: Yeah, and this is government maths, and it's the shuffling around of money that we've become used to.
00:04:56
Speaker 3: This is not the only government that does it. It's not the only government that will do it.
00:04:58
Speaker 1: In May's budget, when we had the lotto deal for a billion dollars or whatever it was that kept us in surplus, as I say, it's sombre reading ahead of the election, but it gives the opposition a better idea of what they're hoping.
00:05:10
Speaker 2: I was talking to a senior Labor person who was trying to talk up what a good job Ben was doing. And one of the things he said was, oh, people have no idea how much he's had to do in the short time he's been there to avoid a ratings downgrade, which I thought was interesting.
00:05:29
Speaker 3: There's lots of talk that a downgrade will come. Very much so. You will remember this better than me.
00:05:35
Speaker 1: There is a growing concern within the coalition that you know, very shortly after they inherit government, should they win the election, that they will face a downgrade. And they point back to 92 and Geoff Kennett winning that election. And their memory is that very shortly after he won, Victoria was slapped with a downgrade. Now, if that happens, it makes Jess Wilson's job infinitely more difficult of getting the economy back on track.
00:06:00
Speaker 2: Why?
00:06:01
Speaker 1: Well, I mean, you know, on a very basic level, borrowing costs become more Our interest bill goes up. You know, you sort of– not immediately, not immediately, but this will happen. There's less confidence in the state. There's all sorts of flow and effects from a rating downgrade.
00:06:20
Speaker 2: I don't know. I mean, people I've spoken to in bond world reckon that ratings upgrades and downgrades are now downstream of the bond market itself.
00:06:33
Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.
00:06:35
Speaker 2: And that it won't really have that much difference to how much we borrow.
00:06:40
Speaker 1: Well, yeah, there is that. I mean, what Jess Wilson is really going to have to grapple with is.
00:06:45
Speaker 2: So what I was going to say, what a ratings downgrade on the back of terrible numbers would do is enable Jess Wilson to take the promises, her spending promises, and park them.
00:07:00
Speaker 3: Some of them if she needs to.
00:07:01
Speaker 1: It's interesting you say that because I think she's going to have to do that. So we've spoken to a whole bunch of economists this week about how to get the economy firing again, how to bring down debt. And the general view, the consensus view, is that whoever wins the election will have to take a machete to spending. There is no other option but to seriously rein in spending and fast.
00:07:24
Speaker 2: If you want to get debt down.
00:07:26
Speaker 3: Correct.
00:07:26
Speaker 1: The selling off of assets is not possible because there aren't any. Saul Eslake will say that the, I mean, everyone will say the raising of
taxes is not palatable, but he will say more than that, it would damage the economy substantially. So you're left with funding cuts. The Commonwealth Grants Commission data fairly recently showed that we are outspending every other state per head of population in all sorts of areas and getting the same level of services.
00:07:56
Speaker 2: Well, that's because we– bad rostering, bad enterprise agreements.
00:08:04
Speaker 3: But this is the argument.
00:08:04
Speaker 2: People not doing very much who should be doing more.
00:08:07
Speaker 3: But this is the argument.
00:08:08
Speaker 1: And one of the areas in which we're spending far more than anywhere else is health. So, again, Saul Eslake would say that is an area. Now, this will not be politically popular.
00:08:18
Speaker 2: Are we getting better outcomes than the rest of the state?
00:08:20
Speaker 3: No, we're not.
00:08:22
Speaker 1: So what Saul would say, and it won't be popular, is that an area Jess should be looking at, is health to make spending cuts and efficiencies.
00:08:30
Speaker 2: Sure. But the problem with that is, yeah, very good. Thanks, Saul, for that big insight. Nothing wrong with it. But the reality is that two things. A lot of the staffing ratios in Victoria are legislated.
00:08:48
Speaker 3: Yeah, but Jess can address all that. Well, she can. It would be very hard.
00:08:52
Speaker 2: They're also, though, more importantly... In their enterprise agreement.
00:08:57
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:08:58
Speaker 2: Which she does not have control of.
00:09:00
Speaker 3: Not yet.
00:09:00
Speaker 1: She has to wait a few years for that. I mean, it's probably, what is it, three years away. They've only all just recently signed their agreement.
00:09:06
Speaker 3: So she's stuck with them.
00:09:07
Speaker 2: So what's she going to do about that? She's stuck with them.
00:09:10
Speaker 1: I think, I mean, I wonder if the best that Jess can hope for is to just be brutal when she comes in. Well, but okay, that's... But then, but then toward the end of the next term.
00:09:21
Speaker 1: Hope that you are realising the results and voters say, well, it worked.
00:09:26
Speaker 2: Yeah, they might. I mean, voters might once have said that or been inclined to say that. I'm not sure they are now. The biggest problem she's got, though, is she does not have a political mandate for those sort of cuts. She'll have a quite explicit lack of mandate. She is saying, I'm not going to fire people. I'm going to shrink the public servants through attrition. Fine. So she can't immediately come in And then sack a bunch of people, can she?
00:09:51
Speaker 3: No, she can't.
00:09:51
Speaker 2: She cannot?
00:09:52
Speaker 3: Well, she can.
00:09:53
Speaker 2: I mean, if she's got the numbers, she can do it. But she will be basically liar, pants on fire.
00:09:58
Speaker 1: But this is where the credit downgrade comes in if she you know if she can run a narrative that says I need to do this for the for the.
00:10:05
Speaker 2: That's going to really test her political skills a lot more than running up against Ben Carroll is going to do yeah does she have the mandate to do that does she have.
00:10:15
Speaker 3: But also depending depending on the.
00:10:17
Speaker 2: Can she take people with us on this journey do That's.
00:10:20
Speaker 3: What I want to know.
00:10:21
Speaker 1: But depending on the result on November 28, let's say Jess wins, she may have enough of a buffer where she will take the risk.
00:10:28
Speaker 2: No, no, no.
00:10:29
Speaker 3: Well, she may.
00:10:30
Speaker 2: She may. No, no, no. She will not.
00:10:32
Speaker 3: But she may.
00:10:33
Speaker 2: No, she won't because there's a name that is uttered in conservative circles with horror and it's Campbell Newman. Big, big majority. Labor was reduced to two parts of three-fifths of all. And they were back four years later.
00:10:52
Speaker 3: Yeah, true, true. This will be for her to reckon with, I suppose.
00:10:56
Speaker 2: This will be for her to reckon with.
00:10:58
Speaker 3: Good luck, Jess. Good luck, Jess.
00:11:00
Speaker 2: The reality is Labor has signed these very expensive enterprise agreements on the way out the door. The last thing I would say about this is there are still question marks over whether or not the pre-election budget update does reflect the true state of the books because the opposition say, that the public servants had put it together to stick to the line that if the government hasn't revealed it, they're not sure that they need to. If you read the letter today that they've written regarding a cut to Catholic school funding that does not appear to have been announced. You and other members of your crew have got a story about the coalition costings. And do they add up?
00:11:50
Speaker 3: Walk us through it.
00:11:51
Speaker 1: Yeah, this is something that the government have been at pains to prosecute over the past few months, and that is that the promised savings that Jess Wilson has said will fund her spending commitments don't add up. And for two or three months, the government has been saying they don't add up without any evidence or proof. So they thought they'd go and get some. And they went to the Parliamentary Budget Office to cost Jess Wilson's plan to implement a public hiring freeze Now, she says that that will save $ 22 billion over the next decade. The PBO, and it should be noted, the PBO costed Jess's policy in May. They've come back to recost it under some slightly different parameters that the government have given.
00:12:40
Speaker 3: The PBO.
00:12:41
Speaker 1: And they came back with a figure of $ 19 billion will be saved over a decade. The government is not quibbling about the difference between 22 and 19. There is an agreement that yes, this plan will save a lot of money. What the government says is, well, that's fine, but Jess Wilson has promised Victorians that by 2032 she will return the state to a cash surplus.
With the savings identified by her so far, that can't happen.
00:13:10
Speaker 3: How far off is she?
00:13:12
Speaker 1: She's about $ 14 billion off.
00:13:16
Speaker 3: Not nothing.
00:13:17
Speaker 1: If you're only looking at the public servant hiring freeze, And what the government says is the PBI report shows very clearly that of the 19 or 22 billion that will be saved over the next decade, only eight and a half.
00:13:31
Speaker 3: Will be saved by 2032.
00:13:33
Speaker 1: So the question for Jess is, where does the rest of the money come from? Now, she's been asked that countless times at press conferences, at forums, public forums. She's not answering because she says our costings will be released in the usual way. which means day before election.
00:13:52
Speaker 2: So does she acknowledge that she has a shortfall and she'll explain it?
00:13:59
Speaker 1: She acknowledges that there's more questions to be answered and that the answers are coming. She doesn't accept that there is a problem. I mean, I think what's worrying is, again, this is not just the government running this attack line. All the economists we spoke to this week about how to get Victoria back on track have said that On what is publicly available from what Jess Wilson is saying, there is no way on earth that she can do what she says she can do, which is return Victoria to cash surplus by 2032. They are all in agreement that it is impossible on the figures that we've got. So I don't know what the coalition come out with to explain how they do the rest of it. But as always, it's political party maths and you can make anything add up to anything you want it to be. And all you have to do is convince voters that it's right and believable.
00:14:50
Speaker 2: I suppose the thing that they've got going for them is at the moment, nobody cares.
00:14:56
Speaker 3: They just want these guys gone. Correct.
00:14:59
Speaker 1: And if you're taking your cues on economic management from this particular Labor Party who have run the state for the past 12 years, I don't think people are going to accept that.
00:15:10
Speaker 2: It's interesting that this line has been successfully prosecuted by Colin Brooks. Well, Brooksy. He's turned out to be a bit of a weapon for them, hasn't he? A surprise. It's a surprise. One of his federal colleagues said to me, I would never have had him pegged as being the guy to hold them to account.
00:15:32
Speaker 1: Well, he's universally considered the nicest man in Parliament. He's just a very nice, unoffensive, unassuming fella. So for him to become their weapon and attack dog on this has been surprising.
00:15:48
Speaker 3: Could he be the leader?
00:15:49
Speaker 1: His name is increasingly mentioned. I think one thing that people would say is, you know, if they are in opposition, is Colin Brooks an opposition leader? Does he have the grunt to be a good opposition leader?
00:16:01
Speaker 2: You mean does he have the nastiness?
00:16:03
Speaker 3: Yeah. The hard work? I think, you know, people would agree he would be a good premier.
00:16:08
Speaker 2: Yeah. It's a weird trajectory career-wise because he took the job of Speaker, which is traditionally a departure lounge for.
00:16:16
Speaker 3: People who want to leave. It's like, oh, Speaker, exit.
00:16:21
Speaker 2: Comes back from that, rejoins the ministry, is elevated to Treasury, and now here we are near the election. People are starting to speculate he might be the leader afterwards if Ben either loses his seat or decides that he doesn't want to go on or they're sick of him.
00:16:36
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, it is to take nothing away from Colin, but, you know, there has been over the past four years a mass exodus of ministers from this government.
00:16:46
Speaker 3: So there were vacancies to be filled.
00:16:49
Speaker 1: I don't think if you would ask Colin three or four years ago if this is where, you know, if he would want to be the treasurer, I don't imagine he would have put his hand up for that job.
00:16:58
Speaker 2: No, not at all. These are problems, though, for kind of after the election if the polls, which we should talk about now, are correct, aren't they? These problems of the coalition maths will be problems for after the election if the polls are to be believed. We've had a slew of polls in the past week and they all paint the same story, don't they?
00:17:21
Speaker 1: Yeah, and the story is people have largely made up their minds on which way they're voting. They're not voting with Labor. It's hard to see how any of this argument that they're prosecuting has much impact.
00:17:33
Speaker 2: It's not that they're not going well. These are all diabolical. I mean, they're all polls with the Labor Party's primary vote in the low to mid-20s. The most recent was the second lighthouse tracking poll, which has showed coalition up one, Labor down one.
00:17:50
Speaker 1: Yeah, and it's only one, but it's... One in the wrong direction. It's one in the wrong direction and only after two weeks.
00:17:55
Speaker 3: I mean, they are getting.
00:17:56
Speaker 2: The Demos poll was terrible.
00:17:59
Speaker 3: They're just getting more.
00:17:59
Speaker 2: That was 18%.
00:18:00
Speaker 3: They're getting more and more backwards. Redbridge.
00:18:02
Speaker 2: had, I think, was it 22, primary of 22?
00:18:06
Speaker 3: 22 or 23.
00:18:08
Speaker 2: It's a very, very, very grim position.
00:18:11
Speaker 1: There has been the hope amongst Labor people for the past few months that these numbers will start improving, even if slightly.
00:18:19
Speaker 2: Two weeks to go, the trend appears to be the other way.
00:18:21
Speaker 3: Yes, yes.
00:18:23
Speaker 1: The breaking voters are breaking away. A week is a long time in politics, but to get these polls turned around, you're going to need a lot of weeks.
00:18:29
Speaker 2: I think.
00:18:30
Speaker 3: The only thing.
00:18:32
Speaker 2: Labor seems to be pumping hard on their
TV ads now is this Americanize the Health System ad.
00:18:40
Speaker 1: Well, that's smart because, you know, health is one area where I think the latest polling had voters split 50-50 on who they thought best to manage health.
00:18:51
Speaker 2: If you're Steve Stakos, the State Secretary running the campaign, you'll take that 50-50 because they're behind on everything else.
00:18:58
Speaker 1: Correct, but also, you know, and it may happen before the election, but it would be unlikely, I think, to see a significant majority of people back the coalition over Labor to manage the health system.
00:19:14
Speaker 2: Yeah, they've got to push the salience of health. They've got to make people scared about how they're going to manage the health system. The view of the coalition is that they are monitoring this closely, like they're not naive about the capacity of a labour scare campaign on health to hurt them. I mean, it's hurt them in the past, most famously with MediScare back in 2016. But they say they haven't yet seen any evidence that's biting. The problem they've got, of course, is that by the time they see the evidence, it might be too late for them to do anything about it. like these things can kind of when they hit they really hit yeah I mean labour is going hard I mean I sit at my desk at work and I have the TV on in the background and you know every time I look up and there's a labour ad it's don't let Jess Wilson Americanise our health system whatever that.
00:20:07
Speaker 1: Means yeah if there's one thing that really exercises people's minds. It's the health system and the fears that you're going to have to use it. And if you need to use it, either it's not there and not working or it's too expensive to access.
00:20:22
Speaker 2: Yeah, and we've now had four years in which the health system is not the top priority for voters, right? It's cost of living, cost of living. Every poll since around 2022 has said cost of living.
00:20:33
Speaker 3: Cost of living, crime.
00:20:35
Speaker 2: But before that, it was health.
00:20:36
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:20:38
Speaker 1: And this is the worry for the coalition, I suppose. You know, that is a deeply ingrained value on which people will vote on. And I think to then turn up to a ballot box and sort of ignore that is not really going to happen. If people have always believed that Labor will manage health better and if they've got some anxiety about a coalition management of health and if this scare campaign works, then you could see... when people go to vote, you might just get a bit of a change in.
00:21:09
Speaker 2: Yeah, and when you marry that with the evidence that the softest, least rusted-on voters are women aged 35 to 55 or 34 to 55, whatever the group is, clearly Labor knows who it's talking to.
00:21:27
Speaker 1: Yeah, it's why Jacinta Allen made women's health an absolute central plank of her premiership.
00:21:33
Speaker 3: It's one of the things she.
00:21:34
Speaker 1: She left saying she was most proud of all the changes she'd made to women's health. You know, a hugely winnable area for them.
00:21:41
Speaker 2: You have been listening to The Splash, the Herald Sun's state politics podcast with me, James Campbell, and him, Shannon Deary. If you liked it, please subscribe. If you really liked it, leave a review and a rating and press the little bell so you get an alert when the next one drops.