رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:14.753
the reason that that initial lawsuit made it up to the Supreme Court is because the pharmaceutical companies that make these medications were like,~ hey, this is a problem. Could you guys stop Louisiana from ruining all Mm.
00:00:14.061 --> 00:00:20.375
of this for all of us? And it's it's a real twist in this MAHA world Mm-hmm.
00:00:19.736 --> 00:00:20.736
to be.
00:00:20.588 --> 00:00:24.740
depending on the pharmaceutical companies to defend us from evil.
00:00:24.740 --> 00:00:26.038
Like the tables Yeah.
00:00:25.850 --> 00:00:27.362
have turned apparently.
00:00:32.362 --> 00:00:40.509
Hey there, fellow nerds. Welcome to another episode of The Present Illness, the podcast where two physicians try to make sense of a world that is ~ febrile.
00:00:40.509 --> 00:00:47.854
And you know, I feel like we have more than just we say that every week, febrile, but I feel like we're like adding more illnesses every week.
00:00:47.854 --> 00:00:51.838
so we definitely have ~ foodborne illnesses happening left and right.
00:00:51.838 --> 00:00:57.073
Anyway, ~ I'm Arghavan Salles, a surgeon scientist in your friendly neighborhood, Doom Scroller in residence.
00:00:57.951 --> 00:01:08.635
And I'm Alyssa Burgart, an anesthesiologist and bioethicist who and health law like their EKGs, full of spikes and surprises. And I will tell you, there's more and more health news coming at us all the time.
00:01:08.635 --> 00:01:10.635
So we're gonna do our best here.
00:01:10.635 --> 00:01:20.308
This is The Present Illness It's where we dig into public health, politics, culture, and ethics with a scalpel in one hand and a meme in the as a note to our new listeners, we talk about some tough topics.
00:01:20.308 --> 00:01:23.849
And so if this is too activating for you, we totally get it. You can take a break.
00:01:25.055 --> 00:01:45.203
Absolutely. ~ we want to also thank everyone who's listening wherever you have found us and some extra love to subscribers and followers on the various platforms. we also want to extend a special warm welcome to anyone who has just stumbled in from the release of, I think it's over 170,000 documents about 9-11 that that just happened this week.
00:01:46.828 --> 00:01:48.138
Yeah, that's been the big news.
00:01:48.138 --> 00:01:52.873
This is the 25th anniversary of the 911 tragedy.
00:01:52.873 --> 00:01:57.876
And I I definitely saw that. We're we're recording this episode on 9-11.
00:01:57.876 --> 00:02:20.385
I am so pleased that Mamdani unsealed these records because it is really telling. I mean, I have not had a chance to really dig into them in depth, but what little I've been able to read,~ really shows how much information has been kept from the public for the past twenty five years.
00:02:21.557 --> 00:02:23.737
Yeah, absolutely. And it was I just want to correct myself.
00:02:23.737 --> 00:02:30.610
So 170,000 pages, not 170,000 documents, but ~ regardless, a huge amount of information
Load full transcript
that has been released.
00:02:30.610 --> 00:02:36.123
And you know, the upshot of it I haven't read to be clear, I have not read 170,000 pages.
00:02:35.756 --> 00:03:04.306
What~ but what what seems to be clear from the reporting around it is that one main point is maybe news to people is that there is acknowledgement in these documents of the fact That the government knew the health hazards for all the toxins that were in the air from the towers collapsing, and yet publicly reassured people that everything was fine.
00:03:04.306 --> 00:03:23.347
~ and we know now that, you know, almost 3,000 people died that day in the towers, and now over 4,000 people since have died from ~ Issues related to their exposures from what happened that day.
00:03:23.347 --> 00:03:33.314
~ There's a apparently in these documents, there is something that was sent to the deputy mayor in October.
00:03:33.314 --> 00:04:00.724
So this was in September in 2001, right? So in as soon as October, there was a document sent to the deputy mayor, a man named Robert Harding, talking about the city's legal exposure after the attacks. ~ talking about how many lawsuits they expected over toxic exposure due to poor air quality ~ and ways that the city could limit its liability,~ which just feels really disgusting.
00:04:00.724 --> 00:04:14.014
~ and then another memo It would just it would have been really cool if they'd limited their liability by giving good public health advice rather than telling people to go back into the toxic, you know, Yeah.
00:04:13.508 --> 00:04:17.865
ps areas around the ~ site.
00:04:15.478 --> 00:04:29.995
And absolutely. And we we talked we've talked many times you and I about masks on and off this show, but like they could have made N ninety fives available to anyone who like lived in the area, who like had no other choice but to be kind of close.
00:04:29.995 --> 00:04:41.620
~ and and especially the first responders and all the I mean, there were crews there for months ~ who, you know, may not have all had the proper protective equipment.
00:04:41.620 --> 00:04:44.403
well, we certainly know they didn't all have that.
00:04:45.824 --> 00:04:52.468
and it would have been there would have been to your point much less liability if they had just said, hey, like this is gonna be an issue.
00:04:52.468 --> 00:04:54.968
We want everyone to be protected as best as possible.
00:04:54.968 --> 00:04:57.750
Here's equipment that's going to help with that.
00:04:57.750 --> 00:05:00.992
~ but they didn't do that.
00:05:00.992 --> 00:05:15.346
~ in February of 2002, so just a few months down the road,~ Representative Jerry Nadler apparently wrote about how ~ this could open up the city to quote unquote major public relations problems.
00:05:15.346 --> 00:05:27.415
~ so it seems like this is what they were concerned about at the time was like PR and lawsuits, not the harms that were being done to people.
00:05:25.803 --> 00:05:33.004
The yeah, the health and well being of the city that the you know, the people that the city exists for.
00:05:33.884 --> 00:05:39.598
Exactly. And the people who who make the city run and function and make it the wonderful place that it is.
00:05:39.598 --> 00:05:45.259
so people may have seen one of the famous photos ~ from that time is a woman who people call the Dust Lady.
00:05:45.259 --> 00:05:51.841
Her name is Marcy Borders, and it's a picture ~ if folks go look at it look for you'll probably be yes, I have seen that photo.
00:05:51.841 --> 00:06:08.757
It's of a young woman, she was twenty at the time,~ and she's just fully covered in dust, but like all this all the parts of the building, right? Like that came down. ~ and she she ultimately died of cancer at age 42.
00:06:08.757 --> 00:06:22.384
And that's, you know, part of the legacy of that day is that our government did not do the most it could to help people who had exposures.
00:06:22.555 --> 00:06:25.526
The government did far less than it might have.
00:06:25.526 --> 00:07:09.041
I mean, ~ significantly less than what seems to be what should have been the minimum. And you know, the the toxin that really stuck out to me, and and first of all, I think this is obviously we're we're talking we're we're a health news podcast, like these tragedies are become public health Like they're these aren't just political events, they aren't just ~ you know, world events like these are things that impact the health and well-being of the people who are involved. And so ~ seeing the reporting around information asbestos exposure. And I remember, you know, when you and I were were in our teens and twenties, I mean, you couldn't watch daytime TV without seeing an ad for mesothelioma.
00:07:09.041 --> 00:07:12.742
And like the were you exp were you exposed?
00:07:09.211 --> 00:07:15.584
Do you have mesotheliomia? It was like do you or someone you love have mesothelioma? Were you exposed to asbestos?
00:07:15.584 --> 00:07:16.584
Yes.
00:07:15.942 --> 00:07:20.925
Yeah. And so and so, you know, everybody knew asbestos was bad.
00:07:20.925 --> 00:07:22.564
You couldn't build a new house with it.
00:07:22.449 --> 00:07:23.449
Yeah, yeah.
00:07:22.564 --> 00:07:29.016
You had to do ~ my my dad, who was a construction worker, like there's really special things that have to be done to abate asbestos.
00:07:29.016 --> 00:07:45.663
And so that was seeing that type of information covered up so explicitly and so purposefully was a~ A a punch to the gut, 'cause Well everybody knew better.
00:07:46.050 --> 00:08:04.122
yes, and it's worth noting that Giuliani did not think that Zoran Mamdani should attend the nine eleven memorial when he was part of this cover up back then and Zoran Mamdani was nine years old, let's be clear. But even if he wasn't, he was he is just a Muslim man.
00:08:04.122 --> 00:08:06.533
That does not make He is him guilty for anything.
00:08:06.971 --> 00:08:12.028
I mean, but he's also like the mayor of New York and
seems like, you know, anyway.
00:08:12.315 --> 00:08:16.867
Has every every right to be I mean, is it totally appropriate for him to be I this is just ridiculous.
00:08:16.668 --> 00:08:23.396
You know, you know, I can't think of Rudy Giuliani without thinking about his hair dye sweating down the s side of his face.
00:08:20.293 --> 00:08:23.766
The ma Yeah. Correct. Every time.
00:08:23.865 --> 00:08:28.843
Yes, that wa yeah. Down the side of this from his temple down to his cheek.
00:08:28.079 --> 00:08:29.079
Icon.
00:08:28.843 --> 00:08:30.689
Yeah. So he's so gross.
00:08:31.189 --> 00:08:43.836
Can you imagine like being him, having covered this up and then being like, no, the person who should not be at the memorial is the current mayor who's the one trying to fight for the city more than they've seen in who knows how many decades of leadership there.
00:08:43.836 --> 00:08:53.735
~ anyway, I I do wanna say that ~ I've spent more time than I'd like to admit looking at things from 9-11 the last few days.
00:08:53.735 --> 00:08:56.918
as one, you know, does.
00:08:56.918 --> 00:08:59.519
but especially because it's the 25th anniversary.
00:08:59.519 --> 00:09:08.847
And, you know, every year I come across new articles and videos and audios and things that I somehow had not seen before.
00:09:08.847 --> 00:09:16.234
~ and I will put a link to a couple of stories that,~ that I found really touching.
00:09:16.234 --> 00:09:29.458
~ and then ~ the names of some folks who had voice memos and calls to 911 if folks wanna revisit any of that or if you hadn't heard some of it.
00:09:29.458 --> 00:09:33.672
It it is part of I think our obligation to be a witness.
00:09:33.672 --> 00:09:57.995
and the stories that I I want to highlight just really briefly because this is not our main topic, hee hee, even though I'm still going on about it, but ~ there's there's an article called The Falling Man ~ that talks about it really iconic photo folks many folks have seen,~ which is of one of the people who ~ fell off the building that day.
00:09:57.995 --> 00:10:19.251
~ and it talks about the article is like trying to reconstruct who was this specific man and what can they learn from the clothes and the different there was a photographer who ~ an AP photographer who had gone to the site and once he noticed that there were people falling or or jumping or whatever.
00:10:19.251 --> 00:10:24.573
He photographed as many of them as he could,~ usually like 11 or 12 photos per person.
00:10:24.573 --> 00:10:32.596
So you see them. Anyway, ~ it's a it's a really beautiful story of trying to figure out who was this person?
00:10:32.596 --> 00:10:49.019
And how do you figure that out ~ based on the very few pieces of information you have from these photos and the reaction of People who thought it might be their family member or were like strongly to believing it could be their family member.
00:10:49.019 --> 00:10:51.919
~ anyway, I th I'll put a link to that one.
00:10:51.919 --> 00:11:05.105
It's called The Falling Man. And then there's another one about an a man named Bobby McElvain, who was in his late 20s, did not work at the World Trade Center, but a colleague of his had a presentation there that morning and had asked Bobby to come help him set up for it.
00:11:05.105 --> 00:11:09.576
And that happened to be at the time when this all happened.
00:11:09.576 --> 00:11:11.057
And so Bobby.
00:11:11.269 --> 00:11:14.903
you know, did not survive. And it's about his parents.
00:11:14.903 --> 00:11:19.235
It's about the woman who was all about to be his fiancee.
00:11:19.235 --> 00:11:24.809
Like he had just asked he would he had just made plans to propose to her.
00:11:24.809 --> 00:11:27.291
it's about her and it's about grief.
00:11:27.291 --> 00:11:54.610
and so I'll I'll I'll put those two and then there's a man named Tyree~ Bacon who had shown up that day ~ to help with the rescue and Because he was trying to rescue a woman who had been burned, severely burned, ~ he happened to be in a spot in the building where he ended up being able to get out, whereas the people he was with did not,~ and how he grapples with that.
00:11:54.610 --> 00:11:58.772
So I'll up at those three in the ~ in the show notes.
00:11:58.772 --> 00:12:05.855
And then I want to just leave us with one last thought about 9 11, which is from the memorial that was just this morning.
00:12:05.855 --> 00:12:14.243
And it's the son of someone who ~ Died 911, and so I just wanna share what he had to say.
00:12:14.243 --> 00:12:35.538
And my father, Michael Masseroli,~ this is an unusual position being the last one to go here, I gotta admit. ~ I think the one parting thing I wanna leave everyone with is that you do my dad's legacy and the legacy of all these victims no honor by using this tragedy to spread hate.
00:12:35.538 --> 00:12:46.884
We've seen A medley of people come up today of all races, all religions, all creeds. And this tragedy is just that.
00:12:46.884 --> 00:12:59.482
It's a tragedy. And it shouldn't be I've had to grow up and spend the past 25 years seeing people use it to hate on our Muslim brothers and sisters, to hate on people who don't look like them.
00:12:59.482 --> 00:13:02.945
And that's wrong. And that does no honor to the victims here.
00:13:02.945 --> 00:13:07.057
And I want to use the little platform I have to ask for that to please stop.
00:13:07.876 --> 00:13:19.672
I wanted the other thing that's wild is like the reason that that initial lawsuit made it up to the Supreme Court is because the pharmaceutical companies that make these medications were like, ~ hey, this is a problem.
00:13:19.672 --> 00:13:24.486
Could you guys stop Louisiana from ruining all Mm.
00:13:23.794 --> 00:13:30.107
of this for all of us? And it's it's a real twist in this MAHA world Mm-hmm.
00:13:29.470 --> 00:13:30.470
to be.
00:13:30.321 --> 00:13:34.474
depending on the pharmaceutical companies to defend us from evil.
00:13:34.474 --> 00:13:35.770
Like the tables Yeah.
00:13:35.582 --> 00:13:37.096
have turned apparently.
00:13:37.860 --> 00:13:49.231
the other thing that's wild is like the reason that that initial lawsuit made it up to the Supreme Court is because the pharmaceutical companies that make these medications were like, ~ hey, this is a problem.
00:13:49.231 --> 00:13:54.047
Could you guys stop Louisiana from ruining all Mm.
00:13:53.355 --> 00:13:59.668
of this for all of us? And it's it's a real twist in this MAHA world Mm-hmm.
00:13:59.029 --> 00:14:00.029
to be.
00:13:59.880 --> 00:14:04.033
depending on the pharmaceutical companies to defend us from evil.
00:14:04.033 --> 00:14:05.331
Like the tables Yeah.
00:14:05.143 --> 00:14:06.655
have turned apparently.
00:14:07.421 --> 00:14:18.792
the other thing that's wild is like the reason that that initial lawsuit made it up to the Supreme Court is because the pharmaceutical companies that make these medications were like, ~ hey, this is a problem.
00:14:18.792 --> 00:14:23.606
Could you guys stop Louisiana from ruining all Mm.
00:14:22.914 --> 00:14:29.227
of this for all of us? And it's it's a real twist in this MAHA world Mm-hmm.
00:14:28.590 --> 00:14:29.590
to be.
00:14:29.441 --> 00:14:33.594
depending on the pharmaceutical companies to defend us from evil.
00:14:33.594 --> 00:14:34.890
Like the tables Yeah.
00:14:34.702 --> 00:14:36.216
have turned apparently.
00:14:39.118 --> 00:14:59.068
And I I I think the best we can do to honor those folks is to try to repair the society and all the hate that's out there,~ rather than continuing to do exactly what those terrorists wanted us to do, which is to hate each other. ~ so on that note.
00:14:59.068 --> 00:15:04.183
~ Well, thank you for sharing that clip as well at the end.
00:15:04.183 --> 00:15:07.118
That's a really beautiful and important sentiment.
00:15:07.919 --> 00:15:11.903
Well, we are glad all of you are here to listen to this podcast.
00:15:11.903 --> 00:15:14.245
We have two main topics we're going to talk about.
00:15:14.245 --> 00:15:31.668
There are some big stories that have come out this week related to AI,~ and particularly open AI and some mathematics that Arghavan's gonna tell us And then ~ I'm gonna share some information around the Louisiana lawsuit the FDA, which just ~ was heard in the Fifth Circuit.
00:15:31.668 --> 00:15:38.672
~ Before we do that, I thought I would just tell you a nice thing that people said online about us. Do you want to hear it?
00:15:38.480 --> 00:15:39.727
Great. Yes, I do.
00:15:38.672 --> 00:15:42.754
I mean, we talk about such downer stuff.
00:15:42.754 --> 00:15:45.125
It's nice when people have sweet things to tell us.
00:15:45.125 --> 00:15:46.337
So if you have sweet Yeah.
00:15:45.875 --> 00:15:49.357
things to tell us, we would like to read them on the air for you.
00:15:48.133 --> 00:15:49.133
Yeah.
00:15:50.437 --> 00:15:53.139
so this was from a listener on YouTube.
00:15:53.139 -->
00:16:03.787
It said the podcast discussion covering public health, reproductive access, and current events is exceptionally thorough, informative, and engaging. Which Thank you so much.
00:16:03.586 --> 00:16:04.625
Everything we aim to be.
00:16:05.339 --> 00:16:07.837
Yeah, I love it. That's great.
00:16:07.437 --> 00:16:13.785
Yeah. Well, on that Thank you for sharing that. ~ lovely note, you want to tell us all about~ how AI will kill us all?
00:16:14.510 --> 00:16:21.595
Yes, I do want to talk about that a little bit, but I more want to talk about I we will get to that because that was a major story this week in in the AI world.
00:16:21.595 --> 00:16:34.572
But I want to talk first about this other major story that happened ~ this week that directly relates to academics and discovery and innovation,~ which is as you foreshadowed about math.
00:16:34.572 --> 00:16:39.618
So there are these ~ millennium problems.
00:16:39.618 --> 00:16:44.017
I think there's seven of them that are like these really difficult to solve math problems.
00:16:44.544 --> 00:16:46.625
~ that have a prize associated with them.
00:16:46.625 --> 00:16:52.788
So there's something called the Clay Institute offers a one million dollar for anyone who solves these ~ specific problems.
00:16:52.788 --> 00:16:55.749
One of these problems is called the Navier Stokes.
00:16:55.749 --> 00:17:00.390
And you and I do not need to know exactly what that's about.
00:17:00.390 --> 00:17:02.772
It's it has to do with fluid dynamics.
00:17:02.772 --> 00:17:04.923
That's fine. But the point.
00:17:04.559 --> 00:17:11.001
But the point is there like s there are these very extremely challenging questions that Yeah. Yeah.
00:17:09.046 --> 00:17:14.182
are extremely difficult to answer and so you get to show that you're like the mathiest of math people if you can solve them.
00:17:13.722 --> 00:17:15.182
Yes. And Okay.
00:17:14.815 --> 00:17:39.439
only one of them has been solved ever, up until like this week. ~ so what happens is there's a man named~ a professor, Buck Master at NYU, who has been for about a year working on a related problem, actually not Navier Stokes, but a related problem, which is Euler. And he's been working on it with another person, Levent Alpage.
00:17:39.760 --> 00:17:41.555
Who happens to be an anthropic employee.
00:17:41.555 --> 00:17:43.648
So Anthropic is one of the big AI companies.
00:17:43.648 --> 00:17:45.643
OpenAI is a different AI company.
00:17:45.643 --> 00:17:49.201
Okay. So Alpoge and Buckmaster.
00:17:51.542 --> 00:17:55.642
~ for people who use quad, for example, that's an anthropic tool.
00:17:55.441 --> 00:17:56.441
Correct.
00:17:56.260 --> 00:17:58.340
Yes, whereas ChatGPT is open AI.
00:17:58.340 --> 00:17:59.813
Yeah, thank you for that clarification.
00:17:59.813 --> 00:18:01.443
So ~ for a second I couldn't hear you.
00:18:01.443 --> 00:18:03.263
So if you're watching this, you saw a weird look on my face.
00:18:03.263 --> 00:18:13.528
That's why. ~ but anyway, so this guy, Alpoge, partners with Buckmaster to work on this Euler problem.
00:18:13.528 --> 00:18:23.292
And they're using AI. So they're using multiple different products, actually, some anthropic products, some open AI products. But they are using something of open AI is called codex.
00:18:24.080 --> 00:18:26.873
Where they're documenting things at least as they make progress.
00:18:26.873 --> 00:18:36.249
Okay, so pretty recently, somebody leaks that someone has solved or that someone at Anthropic has solved the Navier Stokes problem.
00:18:36.249 --> 00:18:47.696
And then OpenAI, by their own admission, dedicates 10,000 AI agents to solving the Navy Stokes Navier Stokes problem.
00:18:47.696 --> 00:18:53.230
Okay. By TechCrunch's estimate, it's like over $20 million worth of compute.
00:18:53.478 --> 00:18:57.299
That they spent to try to solve this Navier Stokes problem.
00:18:57.299 --> 00:19:01.241
Somewhere along the way, Buckmaster knows something is going on.
00:19:01.241 --> 00:19:04.624
Buckmaster reaches out to OpenAI and is like, hey, can we have a conversation?
00:19:04.624 --> 00:19:08.286
Worth noting again, because it's a confusing story.
00:19:08.286 --> 00:19:19.603
Buckmaster and Alpose were not working on Navier Stokes and did not solve Navier Stokes, but they did solve this separate Euler problem, which is related, and people think that their strategy could be used for Navier Stokes, which that's important.
00:19:19.603 --> 00:19:21.913
That's why I mentioned it. Okay, so he reaches out to OpenAI.
00:19:22.916 --> 00:19:27.488
He ends up having a conversation with OpenAI where they tell him, and this is all according to Buckmaster.
00:19:27.488 --> 00:19:36.961
Okay, if you want to know where I'm getting the information from, this part is from Buckmaster. So he has a conversation with OpenAI where he wants to know like what's going on.
00:19:36.961 --> 00:19:47.182
And they say, okay, great. How about you publish your Euler solution, like on whatever day, I think it was Saturday, and then we'll publish Navier Stokes the next day.
00:19:47.182 --> 00:19:52.654
And then they said you could be the sole author on the Navier Stokes.
00:19:53.355 --> 00:19:58.371
paper if you want. But we just can't have Alpog be Who said that?
00:19:58.147 --> 00:20:01.109
part of it. OpenAI said that to Buckmaster.
00:20:01.109 --> 00:20:05.373
Uh-huh. They mm-hmm. I that that's another important point.
00:20:05.373 --> 00:20:07.294
So they say you can be the sole author.
00:20:07.294 --> 00:20:14.138
We just cannot have Alpog be an author on any of it, because Alpog works at Anthropoc.
00:20:12.452 --> 00:20:14.739
Because he works because he works for Anthropic?
00:20:14.138 --> 00:20:15.138
Correct.
00:20:14.739 --> 00:20:15.903
~ jeez, Louise.
00:20:16.181 --> 00:20:19.712
Yeah. So that's their proposal.
00:20:19.712 --> 00:20:21.624
That's OpenAI's proposal to Buckmaster.
00:20:21.624 --> 00:20:24.482
And
Buckmaster is like, The fuck are you talking about?
00:20:24.313 --> 00:20:36.059
We're not gonna kick off someone who contributed to this work because he works at Anthropic. By the way, Alpage has said that his work on this was independent of his this was not like part of his job at Anthropic.
00:20:36.059 --> 00:20:52.929
This was something he was interested in and he was collaborating with Buckmaster So in the meeting, again, according to Buckmaster, he says, No, I'm not doing that. And the guy, Sebastian is his name, at OpenAI, says.
00:20:52.750 --> 00:20:54.142
Why are you trying to ruin your career?
00:20:54.142 --> 00:20:58.733
And like and Buckmaster's like, I don't even know what you're talking about.
00:20:58.733 --> 00:21:01.565
I'm an academic. Like, how what how what are you talking about?
00:21:01.565 --> 00:21:09.907
And then Buckmaster says something like, Well, if I if you don't want me to be nice, I mean sorry, not Buckmaster, the open AI guy says, if you don't want me to be nice, then I don't need to be nice.
00:21:12.018 --> 00:21:17.090
So he's like threatening Buckmaster over what?
00:21:17.090 --> 00:21:30.847
Like math proofs? Anyway, so Buckmaster says, look, if you go ahead and publish this Navier Navier Stokes proof without us, I will go public with this with all these things.
00:21:30.847 --> 00:21:32.519
And that's exactly what happened.
00:21:32.519 --> 00:21:35.550
So OpenAI announces, we have solved the Navier Stokes problem.
00:21:35.550 --> 00:21:37.731
Here's our 100 page proof about it.
00:21:37.731 --> 00:21:38.843
Hooray for AI.
00:21:40.878 --> 00:21:50.613
And Buckmaster then publishes ~ some pretty succinct documents, about four pages, talking about all of these things that I just described to you.
00:21:50.613 --> 00:21:58.106
One key thing that I I left out is that in that meeting, Buckmaster says, What for my codex did you use?
00:21:59.606 --> 00:22:03.009
And they say, well, we don't have ~ access to user data.
00:22:03.009 --> 00:22:12.935
Mm-hmm. Wait, and then Buck Buckmaster says, liar liar pants on fire well, wait, because Buckmaster says, okay, but how about these agents?
00:22:12.935 --> 00:22:28.057
What were they trained on? Even if you're saying you didn't directly like steal our method, even though that's kind of the accusation that's out there, he says, how what what were your were your agents trained on what's in the codex?
00:22:28.778 --> 00:22:32.673
And OpenAI refused to answer that question during the meeting.
00:22:32.673 --> 00:22:48.348
What they did say in a statement that they published themselves was,~ give me two seconds, here. While unlikely, we cannot rule out that de-identified data derived from their usage of our products helped improve our model.
00:22:50.425 --> 00:23:05.153
Okay, so basically OpenAI most likely took the approach that these mathematicians were using, which by the way, Bookmaster was very clear comes from the idea for that approach came from two other mathematicians.
00:23:05.153 --> 00:23:18.970
But OpenAI seems to have stolen the IP of these mathematicians, then put an insane amount of resources into solving this problem within they said 88 hours.
00:23:18.970 --> 00:23:31.247
So 10,000 AI agents, 88 hours worth somewhere between 15 and 20 million depending on which estimate you look at, to then steal their thunder and say, hey, we've solved the Navier Stokes problem.
00:23:31.247 --> 00:23:35.288
AI is amazing. Without giving credit to these two.
00:23:35.288 --> 00:23:43.613
So then Buckmaster put publish his thing, people give a lot of pushback, and only then does OpenAI make that statement that I just read to you or at all acknowledge these individuals.
00:23:44.297 --> 00:23:48.279
And they have a like a citations page for their proof.
00:23:48.279 --> 00:24:06.505
Neither of these people, not the other two people who came up with the idea in the first, but like a lot of the key players in solving this particular problem are not cited on that page. And so if we take a step back, do we know for sure that they trained on this person's data?
00:24:06.505 --> 00:24:14.340
I mean, I guess I would say with 99.99% certainty, but like maybe not 100%. But yeah, it seems.
00:24:13.994 --> 00:24:19.887
very much like that's what happened here, especially because I mean again, this is not my the this math is not my area of expertise.
00:24:19.887 --> 00:24:22.480
But Buckmaster himself says like this is a very unusual approach.
00:24:22.480 --> 00:24:25.790
No one else was working on it in this way that we know of.
00:24:25.790 --> 00:24:35.115
So how would this AI, any of these AI agents within a matter of just a few days, have come to this approach without having seen that that's what we were doing.
00:24:35.115 --> 00:24:38.657
So it seems that they stole these people's IP.
00:24:38.657 --> 00:24:43.340
They then it seems they then, according to Buckmaster, threatened him.
00:24:44.076 --> 00:24:54.440
And wanted to kick off his co-author because the co-author worked for a And now they've still refused to really give proper credit where credit is due.
00:24:54.440 --> 00:25:03.383
And you might say, okay, it's just a math problem, it's an esoteric problem. Very few people really are working on this.
00:25:03.383 --> 00:25:12.472
And I would say to you, sure, if principles don't matter to you, but also this could happen in Any situation. Like, think about the number of people.
00:25:12.472 --> 00:25:19.530
Neither you or I are big users of any of these generative AIs or LLMs, but many, many people are. And we both work Mm-hmm.
00:25:18.934 --> 00:25:20.986
with people who are using this stuff all the time.
00:25:20.986 --> 00:25:22.336
Now, You are obsessed.
00:25:22.807 --> 00:25:30.099
correct. And so you're putting your ideas for drug discovery, perhaps, into these LLMs.
00:25:30.099 --> 00:25:35.951
And you're like, help me figure out which molecule I should target, let's say, based on this
large data set.
00:25:35.951 --> 00:25:55.086
Or whatever it is. And you can imagine so many different ways in which People are using this to help supposedly to help refine their own ideas, right? But then you do 80, 90% of the work. And then somebody at OpenAI is like, hey, it looks like they're close to having a miraculous cure for diabetes.
00:25:55.086 --> 00:26:13.298
Let's put a bunch of AI agents on it because we have basically unlimited Whereas like random scientists at a biotech or at an academic center does not have that. We're going to put, Well in immense resources into it and then we're gonna solve it and then we're gonna have this new medication that we're gonna bring to market and make millions and millions of dollars off.
00:26:14.509 --> 00:26:30.317
And to your point about like how much money was spent on compute, which is like the term that's used for how much energy and data and all that that it takes to generate solutions, you know, academia you have to buy compute power.
00:26:30.317 --> 00:26:33.278
Like you like organizations have to have to pay for it.
00:26:33.278 --> 00:26:43.755
And so academic organizations simply do not have the access to the d to the amount of compute that these organiz these primary organizations have.
00:26:44.141 --> 00:27:03.836
The other thing that I will just say, because we're talking about academia and like who owns what who owns what you put into it. And the reality is that like, well, first of all, if you're using the public, like let's say you you are using the free version of ChatGPT, or even if you pay for Chat GPT, your ideas are going into their data.
00:27:03.836 --> 00:27:11.728
You can you can make some designations to~ elect for your data to not be included in that training data.
00:27:11.728 --> 00:27:18.681
But to be honest, having seen Facebook lie to us for 20 years, like I don't exactly like believe that.
00:27:18.681 --> 00:27:36.855
~ and if you're using, let's say you have you work at a university or you work at your employer says, we're giving you access to this LLM, your employer owns that data. And so it's also something where that can be used for all sorts of other reasons that you may not anticipate.
00:27:36.855 --> 00:27:48.480
So for example, there's evidence, and and for people who are, let's say, not good actors who are using AI, for example, to generate fake information for data sets Mm-hmm.
00:27:47.963 --> 00:27:55.192
or things like that. You know, your university or your employer can actually go and see, well, what are all the things that you have used this for?
00:27:55.000 --> 00:27:56.000
Mm-hmm.
00:27:55.192 --> 00:28:00.539
Is there any evidence that you've used it for something that is nefarious?
00:27:59.383 --> 00:28:00.383
Yeah, nefarious.
00:28:00.701 --> 00:28:01.701
Yeah.
00:28:01.894 --> 00:28:15.278
Yeah. So I think it serves the reason I want to talk about this is not like I'm not like a math buff or anything, but I think it's a really important cautionary tale for people who are putting a lot of their IP into these models.
00:28:15.278 --> 00:28:22.910
I do not think that we can trust any of these companies to pro to respect our privacy in any way.
00:28:22.910 --> 00:28:27.560
I do not care what they say. ~ and that's because, like you said, we have.
00:28:27.449 --> 00:28:31.510
proven track record of just really lying.
00:28:31.510 --> 00:28:39.013
I mean, outright lying. ~ and so that's part but you know, why I wanted to bring that up.
00:28:39.013 --> 00:28:45.636
And it relates to what you said about will AI kill us, because the other big story this week, Can I but before we do that second yes, you want to add something.
00:28:45.636 --> 00:28:46.636
Yes.
00:28:46.375 --> 00:29:08.915
yeah, so this is something that I talk about when when I'm talking about AI to a group of people is that For example, this whole story that you've described is basically how a giant mega corporation required, in all likelihood, the theft of human people's labor and Yes.
00:29:08.261 --> 00:29:17.809
work in order to say that they did this triumphant thing, which of course is being spun as AI is the most incredible thing, and that's why you should invest more money in it and you should pay for it.
00:29:17.772 --> 00:29:20.480
Yes, correct. Correct. Yes.
00:29:17.809 --> 00:29:19.921
And that's why that's why it's inevitable.
00:29:19.921 --> 00:29:22.913
But all LLM data.
00:29:23.476 --> 00:29:33.809
is based in human production. And I just I just think it's always a great thing to remember, you know, I don't need much to power the compute of my mind.
00:29:33.809 --> 00:29:37.277
A handful of and Ms will do. So ~ Mm-hmm. Yeah, that's right.
00:29:37.277 --> 00:29:52.642
I mean, no, I think it to your point, Scientific American had a video about this that I found very disappointing because they basically started the video by saying, like, AI, I forget the exact words, but basically AI has done something humans could never do.
00:29:52.642 --> 00:29:54.823
Right? Like AI solved this thing.
00:29:54.823 --> 00:29:59.253
No, AI, in this case, these out like these AI agents.
00:29:59.958 --> 00:30:05.049
What they did was just try over and over and over and over and over and over again with a strategy developed by humans.
00:30:05.049 --> 00:30:13.731
That's it. Those humans, had they had access to unlimited time and resources, would have come to the same outcome.
00:30:13.731 --> 00:30:17.480
And so that's not nothing. I mean, that's what computers help us with.
00:30:17.480 --> 00:30:19.124
Like computers help us do more things.
00:30:19.124 --> 00:30:20.815
Like that's just generally true.
00:30:20.815 --> 00:30:30.384
But it's the fact that then they're taking credit for it and then Pretending like they didn't use the contributions of these people at all, erasing the contributions of those people.
00:30:30.384 --> 00:30:42.574
Those are the parts that I think are really, really problematic
in that story and should give anyone doing serious work pause when using any of these companies to do that work.
00:30:42.574 --> 00:30:54.284
Okay, so the other story, big AI story that was out this week, was a researcher at ~ Anthropic resigned saying that he thinks basically AI is gonna kill us all.
00:30:54.669 --> 00:30:56.710
He doesn't feel it's ethical to work there.
00:30:56.710 --> 00:30:59.751
Another person at Anthropic then chimed in.
00:30:59.751 --> 00:31:04.413
he works on, he's a scientist working on alignment at Anthropic.
00:31:04.413 --> 00:31:06.286
He then said, Yes, I agree with this.
00:31:06.286 --> 00:31:14.220
I think there's a greater than 10% chance that we will become extinct in the next 10 years ~ because of AI.
00:31:14.220 --> 00:31:21.354
There's many other people from Google, DeepMind, and other places that have.
00:31:21.826 --> 00:31:27.678
Posted similar things, and it's not just this week, but this one story from this man, Jacob Coxson, got a ton of attention.
00:31:27.678 --> 00:31:31.759
He did Wall Street Journal, he was on CNN, like he's done lots of press around this.
00:31:31.759 --> 00:31:43.301
And what has been interesting to me, because I posted these two stories together ~ on my Instagram, and people really lashed on to this AI is gonna kill us story, but not perhaps in the way that you think.
00:31:43.301 --> 00:31:47.383
There were multiple people who were like, This is just PR, this is just marketing.
00:31:47.383 --> 00:32:01.714
Yeah. That this is ~ They believe that this person's resignation is part of some massive PR scheme because both of these companies are expected to have IPOs soon.
00:32:01.714 --> 00:32:11.301
And so this idea it it it starts to get very complicated, but the basic gist of the idea is AI is really powerful.
00:32:11.301 --> 00:32:15.503
And like you were saying earlier, like we want to be in control of it.
00:32:15.503 --> 00:32:17.796
And so which company is the one that's gonna do that?
00:32:17.796 --> 00:32:20.987
Like supposedly anthropic is the more ethical, supposedly.
00:32:21.130 --> 00:32:43.175
Of the two, which is this person had been at OpenAI before, Jacob Coxson. And then he moved to Anthropic and was there for a pretty short of time before he left. ~ so my point is just that it's it's a very interesting right now because everybody, not everybody, a lot of people think that they know exactly what is going on without really a lot of information to go on.
00:32:43.175 --> 00:32:49.718
So there are people who are very convinced and smart people who are very convinced that this is all a marketing ploy designed.
00:32:50.270 --> 00:32:54.462
~ to ratchet up the valuations for these IPOs.
00:32:54.462 --> 00:33:07.388
I personally, just for whatever it's worth, as a human who's been watching this stuff develop and seeing all the different comments from different people, I'm not convinced that's what it is.
00:33:07.388 --> 00:33:15.932
I think there is genuine
concern for the lack of guardrails around all of these companies and the work that they're doing.
00:33:15.932 --> 00:33:22.165
Now it's a I mean the lack of guardrails on the data centers and the environmental impact while Yes, yes. Yes.
00:33:22.324 --> 00:33:24.318
we're already in climate catastrophe.
00:33:24.887 --> 00:33:49.605
Correct. And I think, well, some some of the people also say that this is like designed, this AI is gonna kill us, is designed to stop us from thinking about like things that you just mentioned, like the other harms of these systems, like we get like into some kind of panic mode about anyway, there's lots and lots of ideas about why this story is happening and what the motivations of various people it are.
00:33:49.605 --> 00:33:53.726
But I will just say that Jacob Copps Coxan left Anthropic before his stocks vested.
00:33:55.061 --> 00:34:04.094
I just want to say that because there's this idea, well, he still has the stocks, he'll still make money, and maybe he's, you know, in cahoots with Anthropic to like push up the IPO value evaluation.
00:34:03.564 --> 00:34:11.244
I also I just I am s totally trying to understand why we think that this would ratchet up the IPO value.
00:34:10.443 --> 00:34:17.027
Well, there's okay, so there's this story that ~ also has been repeated by multiple people.
00:34:17.027 --> 00:34:20.228
Like AI theoretically, this is what they say.
00:34:20.228 --> 00:34:34.373
Like AI could kill us, so I wanna be involved in getting there first so that because I'm ethical. So I'm gonna make sure that I get there first and then I can rein it in, and then we won't all die.
00:34:34.373 --> 00:34:39.266
It there's some part of that. So like anthropic is supposed to be the good.
00:34:39.724 --> 00:34:44.746
Company, right? And so, like, if we support anthropic, then maybe it won't kill us all.
00:34:44.746 --> 00:34:49.563
Because maybe they're gonna actually do the right thing versus open AI.
00:34:49.563 --> 00:35:05.094
The CEO's Sam Altman, who is like not by any evidence that I've seen a good person,~ versus like China, people love to talk about China, right? So these are the ideas that are out there, like we must win this like AI arms race so that it doesn't kill us.
00:35:05.094 --> 00:35:07.394
That's kind of ~ my best understanding anyway.
00:35:07.394 --> 00:35:18.175
I'm sure there's more the That sounds like something that like I don't know, the guy with the top hat in Monopoly would sell us like No, more business, hey.
00:35:19.414 --> 00:35:20.554
Yeah, I mean, that's the thing.
00:35:20.554 --> 00:35:24.867
I don't I don't think that the way that these people are thinking.
00:35:24.867 --> 00:35:29.311
And I'm sure there's more to that argument that I haven't picked up on because it's not really how I see it.
00:35:29.311 --> 00:35:39.800
Again, for me, just looking at just as a person, looking at what all these different people and different players in this space are saying, I think that there's a genuine concern.
00:35:39.800 --> 00:35:41.601
Does it mean that it's gonna happen?
00:35:41.601 --> 00:35:43.262
No, I don't think so. 10% is 10%.
00:35:43.262 --> 00:35:45.204
And and that's just one person's estimate.
00:35:45.204 --> 00:35:47.246
It's not 100% and it's one person's estimate.
00:35:47.246 --> 00:35:59.326
But I think what the To me, like the downside of saying this is all just marketing is that, okay, and are we still gonna regulate?
00:35:59.326 --> 00:36:01.856
Like, are we gonna still do something about it anyway?
00:36:01.856 --> 00:36:15.501
If so, great. But if these kinds of conversations get our legislators to care and start regulating, then I actually honestly don't care about the valuation, whether it's a ploy, because what I want to see is that regulation.
00:36:15.501 --> 00:36:19.143
And there were multiple legislators who responded after Jacob.
00:36:19.224 --> 00:36:23.474
Coxan's post because it went super viral, like over 120 million views or something.
00:36:23.474 --> 00:36:25.920
~ I saw multiple.
00:36:24.898 --> 00:36:33.047
I mean, we're in the dec we're in the like government deconstruction era where, you know, everything's less regulated every passing day.
00:36:33.398 --> 00:36:42.771
Yes. But so there have been multiple people, multiple legislators who posted in response to that, like we need to do this, we need to adopt this, whatever we need a AI kill switch, like, you know, all sorts of things.
00:36:42.771 --> 00:36:54.315
And I I just think whatever the motivations are for Jacob or anyone else, like having that be back on the table in a way that it hasn't been in the last couple of years is good.
00:36:54.315 --> 00:37:12.427
~ and again, personally just reading the things I've seen, I don't think it's a marketing ploy, but I also don't think we're gonna like Die next week. I don't think we should all be panicked about it, but I think that we should be pushing for regulation to prevent things like, you know, because people have said, well, how is it gonna kill us?
00:37:12.231 --> 00:37:23.532
Well, it could freeze all our bank accounts instantly, right? Like, I mean, if some of these agents had instructions that let them do different ways.
00:37:23.338 --> 00:37:24.338
there's so many different ways.
00:37:24.288 --> 00:37:28.617
They could hack into air traffic control, all of a sudden, like nobody knows where anyone's going.
00:37:28.617 --> 00:37:32.782
There's crashes, people die. I mean, there's lots of different things that could happen.
00:37:32.782 --> 00:37:49.030
And the idea is not I don't think these people are saying just to be clear that there's gonna be like robotic automatons that are gonna come It's more like what these agents are allowed to do because we refuse to constrain them in appropriate Mm-hmm.
00:37:49.068 --> 00:37:53.461
ways now before ~ before they say change in character.
00:37:53.461 --> 00:37:59.246
Cause like you said right now the the AI
agents that exist are working off previously existing material.
00:37:59.246 --> 00:38:15.458
But there's this idea of like self-recursive improvement that I don't I I'm not an expert in this, but the idea is that like at some point AI may be able to improve itself and then it could be outside of our control and then it could be doing these types of things theoretically, you know, like anyway.
00:38:16.507 --> 00:38:20.518
That's you know I think it's an interesting conversation.
00:38:20.518 --> 00:38:24.878
I think it's worth reading about because this is the world that we live in now.
00:38:24.878 --> 00:38:27.380
I would love to see all AI go away completely.
00:38:27.380 --> 00:38:30.166
~ but anyway, I'd be fine with that.
00:38:30.561 --> 00:38:33.262
yeah. As someone said, everything was fine.
00:38:33.262 --> 00:38:37.367
Maybe not everything, but we were fine Yeah.
00:38:36.822 --> 00:38:40.804
before this all came up. ~ anyway, Well thanks for so that's enough about that.
00:38:42.456 --> 00:38:45.920
Well, thank you for taking us on the AI Tour de jour.
00:38:45.920 --> 00:38:47.125
There's always Mm-hmm.
00:38:46.862 --> 00:38:48.182
there's always something going on.
00:38:48.182 --> 00:38:53.827
~ so the thing that I want to update people on is the Fifth Circuit case.
00:38:53.827 --> 00:39:13.405
~ people may remember back it feels like it was 10 years ago, but during the Biden administration,~ the Biden administration worked with the FDA and they removed the in-person dispensing requirement for one of the two main abortion ~ medications that are used, which is called Miphipristone.
00:39:13.405 --> 00:39:18.568
So there have been a number of lawsuits ~ related to Miphipristone.
00:39:18.568 --> 00:39:26.115
They have been selectively sent to the Fifth Circuit, which is a very pro-Trump, ultra conservative ~ court.
00:39:26.115 --> 00:39:33.175
One of the judges, for example, who's there is Matt Kazmarak, who's become sort of like famous, like a famous like villain judge, Mm-hmm, I think.
00:39:32.219 --> 00:39:33.219
if you will.
00:39:34.072 --> 00:39:51.898
so there was previously a case that also went to the Fifth Circuit related to Mifepristone, which ultimately went up to the ~ Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court had stopped that case, which would have basically led to a nationwide ban on the the distribution of Mifepristone.
00:39:51.898 --> 00:39:59.619
So this lawsuit that went that that was discussed this week is sort of like a follow-up lawsuit related to that.
00:39:59.619 --> 00:40:02.170
They were basically asking the Fifth Circuit.
00:40:02.949 --> 00:40:20.494
A slightly more complicated question, which was really like, ~ we it was almost it it actually took me a little while to kind of understand it. Where it was like, Well, we kind of want you to like only enforce part of what the Supreme Court because like we also want to be able to like, they want to have their cake and eat it too.
00:40:20.494 --> 00:40:27.054
They want to be able to ban mailing Mifepristone to people in Louisiana and they're claiming that they have standing.
00:40:27.547 --> 00:40:28.547
Mm-hmm.
00:40:28.456 --> 00:40:35.438
But they also don't want that question to then go back to the Supreme Court because they're not that because the first case didn't go their way.
00:40:35.130 --> 00:40:36.130
Right, right.
00:40:35.438 --> 00:40:48.378
So they they're like, Well, we want you to sort of like take off the the stay and then do something for us and then put the stay back on so that it doesn't go to the Supreme Court. Is that really I'd never heard anything like it before.
00:40:46.427 --> 00:40:52.152
Hmm. Yeah, I was just gonna say, I mean I'm not a is that like a thing? I didn't know if that was I didn't know that was a thing.
00:40:52.398 --> 00:41:07.333
I don't I do not believe that any now again, I'm not like some constitutional legal expert, but I've I've just never heard of a case like this, but we'll see. I'm sure that people will write more about it in the coming weeks.
00:41:07.333 --> 00:41:08.574
This only just happened this week.
00:41:08.574 --> 00:41:16.097
So what's wild, right? So this this case is Louisiana versus the FDA, so the Federal Drug Administration.
00:41:16.336 --> 00:41:31.414
The Federal Drug Administration collected tons and tons of safety information on Mifepristone. It's part of why they took away the in-person~ dispensing requirement and why you could use telehealth to be able to both prescribe it and then you could have the medication mailed because it's so freaking safe. It is Mm-hmm, I do.
00:41:31.248 --> 00:41:35.492
much safer than being pregnant, especially pregnant in America.
00:41:35.963 --> 00:41:36.963
That's right.
00:41:37.673 --> 00:41:39.675
being pregnant in America is a whole deal.
00:41:39.675 --> 00:41:45.760
So so in this process, they're saying, ~ well.
00:41:46.485 --> 00:41:51.146
W in Louisiana, we don't want anybody to get abortion pills.
00:41:51.146 --> 00:41:56.297
But because the FDA has removed these requirements, our abortion ban doesn't work.
00:41:56.297 --> 00:42:00.088
And so they're saying the state is blanketed in Mifepristone.
00:42:00.088 --> 00:42:02.317
It's just everywhere. Because Yeah.
00:42:01.889 --> 00:42:12.032
all you have to do is have a telehealth appointment with a, you know, physician or a nurse practitioner, and then you get your prescription and you can have your abortion in the privacy of your own home and control your own body.
00:42:12.032 --> 00:42:13.581
And Louisiana's not into that.
00:42:13.581 --> 00:42:14.581
They don't like it.
00:42:16.088 --> 00:42:18.891
So the Fifth Circuit heard this case.
00:42:18.891 --> 00:42:22.313
Now, what's wild, the FDA basically did not defend itself.
00:42:22.313 --> 00:42:30.248
The FDA was like, like the judge kept being like, hey, ~ are you guys concerned about the safety data?
00:42:30.043 --> 00:42:32.543
Mm-hmm. Yeah.
00:42:30.248 -->
00:42:32.739
Like, tell me tell me what the FDA knows.
00:42:33.041 --> 00:42:39.724
And essentially, the FDA's own lawyer was like, I don't know. And the judge was not pleased.
00:42:39.724 --> 00:42:41.652
The judge was not pleased. ~ Yeah, yeah.
00:42:42.226 --> 00:43:00.472
he was like, that seems He he expressed a a significant amount of concern because Louisiana's also saying, like, because all this miphopristone is just swirling around in Louisiana, that it is causing irreparable harm because you know, because abortions are happening, and that's irreparably harming the state of Louisiana.
00:43:00.112 --> 00:43:02.157
I don't know, did you have And your daily abortion yet today?
00:43:03.931 --> 00:43:10.556
imagine like it's just the the dumbest just It is, but you know, that's that's definitely a major right-wing talking point.
00:43:10.556 --> 00:43:20.500
Like there's these estimates now that I see of like how many people women have killed by abortion. And ~ it that's how they phrase it.
00:43:20.500 --> 00:43:24.992
And and it's like somebody did the math and was like, that's a thousand abortions per woman.
00:43:28.704 --> 00:43:39.545
Like I mean, that's a lot. So I mean, I don't even think does it does do we even have I don't think we have that's like ten. I one thousand cycles in our lives.
00:43:39.690 --> 00:43:48.521
was gonna say, I was trying to think about I'm like, okay, well, like, I mean, if I guess if you have twelve cycles a year,~ ten years would be a hundred and twenty cycles.
00:43:48.521 --> 00:43:50.362
I don't think you ever would get to a thousand.
00:43:50.362 --> 00:43:53.215
Like, I guess you're eighty and you're still well, No, I don't think so either.
00:43:54.525 --> 00:43:57.637
that's why they that's why we can't have we this is why we can't have hormones.
00:43:57.637 --> 00:44:00.101
You can't still be having abortions in your eighties.
00:44:01.106 --> 00:44:06.699
But also this is why men should not be legislating our bodies because the numbers don't make any kind of sense.
00:44:06.699 --> 00:44:08.032
They don't know what they're talking about.
00:44:07.036 --> 00:44:09.032
Cause cause these these Anyway.
00:44:08.655 --> 00:44:15.257
folks are ding dongs. I'm telling you, there's just there's a lot of ding dong ideas out there and they're using it to oppress all sorts of people.
00:44:15.257 --> 00:44:16.501
So, Absolutely.
00:44:16.259 --> 00:44:26.547
~ so it was super weird. So the FDA's lawyer, I mean, clearly like these are Trump's people, like did nothing to defend the scientific or regulatory basis of the Hmm.
00:44:26.362 --> 00:44:29.003
of their own policy, which is what's being fought.
00:44:29.003 --> 00:44:37.557
so the judges were super annoyed with that person and they cause they were like, Well, how do you guys it was it was literally questions like, Okay, well, how does the FDA evaluate safety?
00:44:37.306 --> 00:44:38.306
Yeah.
00:44:37.557 --> 00:44:38.657
And he was like, I don't know.
00:44:39.271 --> 00:44:40.771
Yeah, I'm just a lawyer, I don't know.
00:44:42.784 --> 00:44:57.864
anyway, so the the and the other thing that's wild is like the reason that that initial lawsuit made it up to the Supreme Court is because the pharmaceutical companies that make these medications were like, ~ hey, this is a problem.
00:44:57.864 --> 00:45:02.679
Could you guys stop Louisiana from ruining all Mm.
00:45:01.987 --> 00:45:08.300
of this for all of us? And it's it's a real twist in this MAHA world Mm-hmm.
00:45:07.661 --> 00:45:08.661
to be.
00:45:08.512 --> 00:45:12.666
depending on the pharmaceutical companies to defend us from evil.
00:45:12.666 --> 00:45:13.963
Like the tables Yeah.
00:45:13.775 --> 00:45:15.288
have turned apparently.
00:45:16.043 --> 00:45:17.226
~ Yeah, that is really wild.
00:45:17.889 --> 00:45:30.248
super wild. ~ Louisiana really overstated they they made these ridiculous claims about the numbers of supposed ER visits related to the use of Mifepristone, which is they're Yeah.
00:45:29.708 --> 00:45:34.961
just again not this is not plausible arguments.
00:45:34.961 --> 00:45:36.137
~ Mm-hmm.
00:45:36.626 --> 00:45:40.568
And so anyway, they were it was just a really weird case.
00:45:40.568 --> 00:45:59.333
I am pleased that that because the judges seemed so irritated by the behavior I don't know of both sides and so ~ I mean it's quite unprofessional, like in in the context. Like I can't imagine being like, I have this huge case before a judge, but I'm gonna show up totally unprepared to like do my job.
00:45:59.333 --> 00:46:02.454
I don't think if I was a judge, I don't think I would love that.
00:46:02.719 --> 00:46:03.719
Yeah.
00:46:04.135 --> 00:46:12.807
so the other thing, you know, and As I was just mentioning, the overstatement of ~ deaths that the Louisiana government is claiming.
00:46:12.807 --> 00:46:34.387
Now, also this week, we did have some really interesting reporting that's devastating, come out of ProPublica that's actually about something that does lead women to the emergency room and they can die from, which is ectopic pregnancies. And ~ dying from an ectopic pregnancy should be a never event. Like people who have ectopic pregnancies should get emergen.
00:46:34.530 --> 00:46:37.822
qua fast emergency care and should never die from it.
00:46:37.822 --> 00:46:49.367
and so what they showed is that there's been a doubling of deaths from lack of like essentially inadequate treatment ~ for ectopic pregnancies.
00:46:49.367 --> 00:46:56.871
Now part of that's going to be related to who has access to medical care and who has ~ the ability, you know, especially as more and more hospitals are shutting down.
00:46:56.871 --> 00:47:06.929
but it is really telling and and also I don't want to confuse people, mifepristone is not a treatment for ectopic pregnancy, it needs to be surgically treated.
00:47:06.929 --> 00:47:30.217
There is some it's a it's an emer it's an emergency that
requires treatment that is not with Mifepristone. ~ but it is very it's a very much an overlapping situation that women in this country are dying of things that be treated and prevented. Meanwhile you have states like Louisiana and other ~ states that have abortion bans.
00:47:30.577 --> 00:47:37.074
Overly focusing on denying women access to reproductive health care that is convenient, Mm-hmm.
00:47:36.972 --> 00:47:44.878
safe, and available. So the death rate in what ProPublica found, and we'll put a link to this in the show notes.
00:47:44.878 --> 00:47:59.670
What ProPublica found was that ~ death rates, the death rate increased significantly in states where they did also have abortion bans. The abortion bans themselves likely can't completely explain ~ the level of increase.
00:48:00.139 --> 00:48:03.541
But ~ it's not nothing, obviously.
00:48:02.998 --> 00:48:03.998
Mm-hmm.
00:48:03.641 --> 00:48:09.224
There's something happening in those states where shocker, people are not getting the care that they need and deserve.
00:48:09.224 --> 00:48:16.568
So I know that there anyway, that's enough about about abortion for this week.
00:48:16.568 --> 00:48:18.730
One of our another casual topics.
00:48:18.922 --> 00:48:19.922
Yeah.
00:48:20.391 --> 00:48:28.003
I did want to talk to talk briefly with people about, you know, in our other news that have happened has happened, you sent me.
00:48:28.800 --> 00:48:37.048
As a a real treat yesterday, I was having a a a very, very busy day, and you sent me the clip of the Elizabeth Holmes documentary.
00:48:37.048 --> 00:48:40.152
And holy guacamole.
00:48:40.152 --> 00:48:49.969
Woo! She's a weird It's so weird. It is so freaking weird. Yeah. So if folks haven't seen this,~ there's gonna be a new documentary.
00:48:49.969 --> 00:48:53.280
It's not out yet ~ from A twenty four, but it was screened this weekend.
00:48:53.280 --> 00:48:54.760
This past sorry, last Coming out in October.
00:48:54.811 --> 00:48:56.521
weekend. It was screened in Tell Youride.
00:48:56.521 --> 00:48:57.521
Yeah, it's coming out in October.
00:48:57.503 --> 00:48:58.733
They haven't said exactly what day.
00:48:58.733 --> 00:49:05.137
~ and the there was a clip that was posted by A twenty four.
00:49:05.137 --> 00:49:22.378
So it's Nathan Fielder. If people know Nathan Fielder, he's a comedian. ~ it and satirist and you know, there's probably lots of other adjectives that be used. But anyway, so Nathan Fielder, it's a clip of him sitting close to Elizabeth Holmes.
00:49:22.378 --> 00:49:29.643
Elizabeth Holmes, of course, is the ~ I wanna like ~ not it's not just sitting close, like they look like they're breathing on each other.
00:49:29.963 --> 00:49:39.929
They're yeah, when when they zoom out, they're they don't look like they're as close, but it's like it's edited in such a way that it looks like they're like this, like like just right next to each other.
00:49:38.856 --> 00:49:41.976
Yeah. The shots are very close to their faces.
00:49:39.929 --> 00:49:42.541
But yes.
00:49:41.976 --> 00:49:45.826
So you can see like every little micro movement of people's faces.
00:49:45.440 --> 00:49:46.440
Correct.
00:49:46.371 --> 00:49:51.210
And Elizabeth Holmes, I just want to say in case folks ~ are like, that sounds familiar, but I can't remember who that is.
00:49:51.210 --> 00:49:55.840
She was the founder of Theranos, huge fraud. she's currently in prison.
00:49:55.840 --> 00:49:58.684
Theranos was this Correct. And so Bad blood, baby. Bad blood.
00:49:58.902 --> 00:50:11.273
we've talked about it before ~ on the show, but she had this idea that like we could do lots of blood tests from a finger prick and that was all wrong and it was a sham and she raised millions of dollars, defrauded lots of people.
00:50:11.273 --> 00:50:13.675
At one point the company was valued at nine billion.
00:50:14.192 --> 00:50:21.867
~ but she was they were giving people false lab results, like telling people they had HIV when they didn't, telling people they were having miscarriages when they weren't.
00:50:21.867 --> 00:50:28.400
And it was just like terrible, terrible. One of the employees who was a director of the lab died by suicide.
00:50:28.400 --> 00:50:42.871
Anyway, just terrible. All that I'm trying to say is she did terrible, terrible things that weren't just stealing money from rich people, although she did that too. ~ anyway, so this documentary was.
00:50:43.315 --> 00:50:49.119
A little more than a it's documenting a little bit more than a month before she had to turn herself in for her prison sentence.
00:50:49.119 --> 00:50:53.603
And Nathan Fielder lived with her for some of that time.
00:50:53.603 --> 00:51:15.818
And so this scene that's in the clip, so very weird. And it's like two people who I don't know if they're both trying to fool each other or like get a leg up on the it's very weird. ~ and so She's she ki she's trying to convince him that she would never yeah.
00:51:13.684 --> 00:51:15.298
Yeah, she says, Why would I deceive you?
00:51:16.434 --> 00:51:19.081
I I'm just a fraud, but why would I deceive you?
00:51:19.081 --> 00:51:20.673
I have no reason to deceive you.
00:51:20.737 --> 00:51:28.780
But like and then like with the cash patel eyes and the like w I mean it's yeah. Her eyes are like super open, like very exophthalmos.
00:51:28.780 --> 00:51:34.702
Yeah. And she has this, yes, if you if people are watching this, you can see ~ Alyssa's expression.
00:51:34.702 --> 00:51:44.905
But she she does this very weird thing where she's like raising her eyebrows up and her eyes wide open, which is like a look of surprise typically, but then she's got this weird smile underneath.
00:51:44.905 --> 00:51:50.056
Like the bottom half bottom half of her face doesn't match the top half of the It's very clownish. You know, I should I should dr Very weird.
00:51:49.871 --> 00:51:53.221
maybe I'll dress up as Elizabeth Holmes for for Halloween this year.
00:51:53.221 --> 00:51:55.538
I I could do it. I think I just need a black It's a good idea. You could totally pull it off.
00:51:55.844 --> 00:51:59.396
black turtleneck, terrible lipstick, talk low.
00:51:59.934 --> 00:52:12.298
Yeah. that's the other thing. Like her voice is not at all the same voice that she pretended to have for all those years, which we knew. I mean, that's been talked about many times that she was faking this low voice. I mean, everything about her almost was fraudulent.
00:52:12.298 --> 00:52:31.050
~ but yeah, anyway, so she and her husband are apparently planning to found a new blood diagnostic company at at some point and You know, all I can say is it is really impressive to go through everything she's been through and not learn a single lesson.
00:52:31.050 --> 00:52:33.505
Just not one thing.
00:52:31.896 --> 00:52:48.552
Well, you know, she's never she has never once admitted wrongdoing. And in twenty twenty three I'll put it I'll put a link to an essay that I wrote in twenty twenty three about her because she she had like a full multi page spread in the New York Times that I'm like, who paid off this newspaper to show this lady like this?
00:52:48.552 --> 00:52:52.402
And it was like really highlighting her as a mother, and they had Mm-hmm.
00:52:51.826 --> 00:52:56.059
her in these like soft tone oatmeal sweater.
00:52:56.722 --> 00:52:58.342
And ~ Okay.
00:52:57.833 --> 00:53:05.237
just like California chic with her beautiful babies and I was just like, Lady, you're you're fraud. Like how many there's so many mothers who go to jail.
00:53:05.237 --> 00:53:08.219
They don't get to spend sp extra time with their kids.
00:53:08.219 --> 00:53:13.603
They don't get a three page spread trying to ri you know, whitewash their their crimes.
00:53:14.369 --> 00:53:16.219
Well, and she says, yes, correct.
00:53:16.219 --> 00:53:30.144
And she says in this video, in the clip, that she's being real. And she posted her her Twitter account, posted the clip and said the same thing, which is the last line in the clip, which is I'm always being real.
00:53:30.144 --> 00:53:34.286
What a thing for a total fraud to say.
00:53:36.088 --> 00:53:39.009
Sh th I c I cannot wait to watch this documentary.
00:53:39.422 --> 00:53:41.423
Anyway, I think it will be fascinating.
00:53:41.423 --> 00:53:45.097
~ okay, so that was yeah, that was one of the things Hmm.
00:53:44.797 --> 00:53:54.362
in the news this week. ~ another thing that I wanted to highlight is last week we talked about that it looked like the Lindsay Clancy trial was gonna be a mistrial, and indeed it was.
00:53:54.362 --> 00:54:08.342
And the thing, the only thing I wanted to add to that conversation is that we now know, because of multiple jurors who have come forward, is that that the reason that it became a mistrial is because there was one man on the jury.
00:54:09.056 --> 00:54:18.269
Who refused to say that she would be not guilty by reason of insanity, even though he said that he had reasonable doubt.
00:54:18.269 --> 00:54:29.492
And so the criteria, right? If you listen to the judge's instructions, is if they have reasonable doubt, they cannot convict her of being guilty of murder.
00:54:29.492 --> 00:54:56.666
And this one person, you know, according to the other jurors, refused to look at the evidence, didn't take like, know there were nurses who were on the jury, didn't refuse to listen to them when they would talk about the medical stuff, like just was had his own agenda,~ which is really unfortunate for Lindsay, her family, you know, everyone involved is now the DA will have to decide whether he wants to try again or not.
00:54:58.166 --> 00:55:01.338
Well, ~ you hate to be right, you know.
00:55:01.338 --> 00:55:07.920
anyway, so Mitch McConnell update, mis Mitch McConnell watch.
00:55:07.920 --> 00:55:15.795
~ we haven't heard about old Mitch in a while, and we still have not seen him other than that one janky photo that we saw like over a month ago. ~ Yep. Yeah.
00:55:16.244 --> 00:55:24.483
however, ~ On Fox News he was like called out basically like you need to resign, either show up and vote or resign.
00:55:23.222 --> 00:55:24.860
Yeah. Yeah.
00:55:24.483 --> 00:55:33.938
And so the expectation is that on September fourteenth he might show up and vote on the farm bill. ~ the farm bill of Well, one can see.
00:55:34.009 --> 00:55:42.155
I mean, there was a there was a headline maybe a week ago that was like Mitch McConnell says he's having difficulty breathing and people were like, It is hard to breathe when you're dead.
00:55:42.155 --> 00:55:45.697
But anyway, ~ we will see what happens.
00:55:46.525 --> 00:56:09.521
We will see what happens. and then the other thing I I just thought this was an it was a it's not a it's not a brand new news piece, but it was an essay that I thought was very helpful, especially as we think about so many things that are happening and how they can be connected. I'm I'm a big fan of the work of journalist Sarah Kenzior, who's an independent, ~ like she's politically independent.
00:56:09.521 --> 00:56:10.922
She's also an independent journalist.
00:56:10.922 --> 00:56:31.768
And she wrote an essay on essentially ~ the US relationship with, you know, Israel, Iran and Epstein and really how as we look at so many things are both being revealed about those relationships as well as what we know from the past, how can we sort of make sense ~ of of this as a whole?
00:56:31.768 --> 00:56:33.840
So the essay's called No World Order.
00:56:33.840 --> 00:56:35.121
So I'll include that in the show notes.
00:56:35.121 --> 00:56:37.822
I think it's ~ it's worth folks checking out if you're interested.
00:56:40.289 --> 00:56:43.275
Yeah, I do know her work and and generally appreciate her.
00:56:43.275 --> 00:56:46.110
~ have not read that specific essay.
00:56:47.831 --> 00:56:49.494
Well, I think it's time for some joy.
00:56:50.494 --> 00:56:51.494
Yeah.
00:56:52.222 -->
00:57:02.971
And folks, you know, we we knew that when we started this this podcast talking about the news that it would generally be unjoyful. And so we had to build it in.
00:57:03.289 --> 00:57:07.619
Yeah, we had to make it part of the structure or else we were never gonna have any joy here.
00:57:07.619 --> 00:57:21.094
Okay. All right. So ~ my thing that I want to share is this I guess DJ guy, I don't know ~ how how he refers to himself, who mixes Hamilton songs with EDM.
00:57:21.094 --> 00:57:24.755
And so I wanna play a snippet for you.
00:57:24.755 --> 00:57:29.295
It's like I mean, if if you're not a Hamilton fan, it probably won't really do that much for you.
00:57:29.295 --> 00:57:31.947
But for the Hamilton fans out there, I think it's amusing.
00:57:33.447 --> 00:57:35.927
I just might forget that night blasteries.
00:57:35.927 --> 00:57:38.126
I don't remember those salty boys.
00:57:40.155 --> 00:57:44.016
I remember that dream like candle light like a dream that you can't fight face.
00:57:44.016 --> 00:57:48.956
But as a banter, I'll never forget the first one I saw your face.
00:57:48.956 --> 00:57:52.969
I've never been the same. Talented eyes and I'm older games.
00:57:52.969 --> 00:58:06.490
~ You gotta hear that beat drop, man.
00:58:07.317 --> 00:58:09.099
Yeah, that's pretty good, right?
00:58:09.099 --> 00:58:10.639
The beat job is the best.
00:58:09.552 --> 00:58:10.552
That's pretty good.
00:58:10.639 --> 00:58:12.822
Yeah. Anyway, I'll put a link to that.
00:58:12.822 --> 00:58:14.922
The person's name is Jason, apparently.
00:58:14.922 --> 00:58:17.184
Yeah, what do you put?
00:58:15.653 --> 00:58:35.385
Awesome. Well, you know, the other th what what that also made me think of is the original before Hamilton actually came out like as a full play,~ they played the the cast played one of the songs from it at an event at the Obama at at the White House when the Obamas Right, right.
00:58:35.340 --> 00:58:40.340
were in ~ in office. So I will put a link to that in the show notes.
00:58:41.373 --> 00:58:43.003
Great. And what what do you recommend?
00:58:43.003 --> 00:58:44.291
What's your take too for this week?
00:58:44.652 --> 00:58:51.657
My joy and I and I I do think that I need to shout out to you, Argivon, for really helping my algorithm have more dogs in it.
00:58:51.657 --> 00:58:58.483
I think that because you know, Arghavan's always sending me like fun dog videos.
00:58:58.483 --> 00:59:08.509
And I think it's really helping because I received this one in my algorithm and I loved it. And it is a dog, and it's a mashup. The algorithm knows that I like crafts.
00:59:08.509 --> 00:59:09.797
And so it's a Mm-hmm.
00:59:09.130 --> 00:59:12.521
mashup of this woman who does a bunch of sewing.
00:59:12.521 --> 00:59:13.612
It looks like she's sewing pregnant.
00:59:13.755 --> 00:59:24.748
garments and things. And every time she sits down with the sewing machine, her dog brings her one of her toys so that she will fix it, that it needs to be sewn up. So she'll br Mm. Hmm.
00:59:24.797 --> 00:59:28.409
the dog will bring her one of its h toys that has a hole in it.
00:59:28.409 --> 00:59:29.657
And Mm-hmm.
00:59:29.059 --> 00:59:37.742
so there was this whole compilation of like she's at her sewing machine working diligently and then you can see her like talking to the dog and she's like, okay. And then she's like Yeah.
00:59:37.152 --> 00:59:39.762
hand sewing the dog's toy and the dog's just waiting.
00:59:39.762 --> 00:59:41.072
He's just waiting.
00:59:41.329 --> 00:59:44.231
And then she gives the dog the toy and then he walks off and he's so happy.
00:59:44.231 --> 00:59:48.576
And then he shows up, you know, in the next the next sewing project with another toy.
00:59:48.576 --> 00:59:50.286
~ so it's super~ that's very cute.
00:59:50.356 --> 00:59:54.300
it yeah, it's very sweet, it's very cute and ~ and it's dogs.
00:59:56.016 --> 00:59:58.628
What could be better? There were, That's right.
00:59:57.777 --> 01:00:03.079
~ going back to our 9-11 conversation, there were a lot of rescue dogs at 9-11.
01:00:03.079 --> 01:00:05.561
So we had some four-legged heroes as well on that day.
01:00:06.942 --> 01:00:09.893
all right, well, I think that's it for this week's episode.
01:00:09.893 --> 01:00:15.525
If you didn't like what you heard, this has been the impulsive with Logan Paul podcast.
01:00:15.525 --> 01:00:21.568
~ if you liked it, don't forget to subscribe to The Present Illness leave us a review, and tell other folks to tune in as well.
01:00:21.579 --> 01:00:31.487
follow us on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube at The Present Illness and stay on top of all of our TPI related We will be back next week with more headlines, hot takes and doom scrolling, hopefully wrapped in some laughs.
01:00:32.269 --> 01:00:34.320
Until then, agitate, hydrate, take a nap.
01:00:34.320 --> 01:00:36.081
We'll see you next time on The Present Illness.
01:00:36.081 --> 01:00:43.282
Production by Arghavan Salles and Alyssa Burgart, editing by Alyssa Burgart, social media by Arghavan Salles, original music by Joseph Uphoff.
01:00:43.282 --> 01:00:46.324
Don't take advice from random people on a podcast.
01:00:46.324 --> 01:00:47.985
This shows for informational purposes.
01:00:47.985 --> 01:00:50.706
It is meant to be fun, and it is certainly not medical advice.
01:00:50.706 --> 01:00:53.407
Please take your medical questions to a qualified professional.
01:00:53.407 --> 01:00:54.867
Also, this podcast is our hobby.
01:00:54.867 --> 01:00:57.788
We only represent our own opinion, not our employers or anybody else.