رونوشت 🔗
David: The key to understanding American politics is one word. And they look at me thinking, well, this is going to be great if it's only one word, not much reading. But they look at, and I write the word down, fear. And I say, it's actually fear of abuse of power. We fought an American Revolution because we feared strong central authority.
Christy: Welcome to the Politics Chicks. I'm Christy Branham.
Monica: And I'm Monica Healy.
Christy: With the midterms less than two weeks away, there's no shortage of predictions. Today, we want to sort out what we could reasonably know, what could still change, and what the results will mean.
Monica: Joining us today is David Schultz, Distinguished University Professor of Political Science and Legal Studies at Hamlin University and an adjunct law professor at University of St. Thomas. His work includes American politics, election law, and media and politics.
Christy: David, welcome to the Politics Chicks.
David: Thanks for having me. It's my pleasure.
Christy: We're so excited to have you. Good. And we said before we even came on, we're so excited to pick your brain about this election. We've been living, eating, sleeping, breathing it now for the past year and a half, and we are only, what, 14 days away? 13 days away.
David: 13 days away now.
Monica: As of recording, yep.
Christy: Boy, boy. So before we get into the individual races, what is the most important thing you think people are missing about this election?
David: What they are most importantly missing about the election, I would tell a lot of people that a deep breath is needed. And what I mean by that is that on the 20th of October, the day before we recorded, I gave a talk to the Federal Bar Association, which is the attorneys in Minnesota who practice in federal court. And they asked me to do a presentation called What If? And the What If? was about, well, what if the president called off the election? Or what if the president brought out federal troops? Or a whole bunch of what ifs? All these things that people are working themselves up about. And what I said is that legally, none of them can happen. And practically, probably can't happen either. And the reason why I said that is what most people don't realize is that we have an incredibly complicated election system in the United States. We've got federal elections. We've got state and local elections. We've got some federal rules, mostly state rules. We have states that then devolve responsibility down to the counties, down to maybe even the city level. We've got paid staff. We've got volunteers. If somebody wanted to rig an election, it would require a conspiracy way beyond what anybody could actually achieve in this country. So I've been telling people that the most important thing to think about is that this incredibly decentralized election system that we have makes it impossible to rig. Or let me say, when I say nearly impossible to rig, you never want to say never. But it's so complicated, so complicated that there's really not much Donald Trump can do, I mean, to upset the election. Like if he says we're canceling the elections, he has no authority to do that. If a local election official says that I'm not going to certify the election, the courts don't listen to them. If the federal government tries to seize the ballots, they're in possession of state governments. So there's so many, I'll call it what, checks and balances and separation of powers in our system that our framers design that it's highly protected against, I think, people's worst nightmares.
Christy: And that was on purpose, because that is how the Constitution was set up, because at least our founding fathers had that foresight to understand that they needed to decentralize it, correct?
David: Correct, yeah. When I teach my American politics class, almost all of my classes, but my intro American, the first day of class I write in and I say, the key to understanding American politics is one word. And they look at me thinking, well, this is going to be great if it's only one word, not much reading. But they look at, and I write the word down, fear. And I say, it's actually fear of abuse of power. We fought in the American Revolution because we feared strong central authority. We feared kings who were like judge, jury, execution, everything. And so what do we decided to do? The solution to the concentration of power is something that all of us know. It's what? Checks and balances, separation of powers, federalism. It's all those things that we should have learned in school at some point. And so I tell my students, all I'm going to teach you this semester is everything that you already know, but we're going to explain it a different way. So our election system is just like that. It's that the Constitution explicitly says that states have the responsibility for running elections and determining eligibility to vote, subject to some exceptions that Congress, not the president, that Congress may make. So the president barking out and saying we're not going to hold elections or something like that legally, he's in no position to be able to do that.
Monica: Well, that's reassuring to hear you say that because there are a lot of fears out there about what might happen. And people have pointed to things that he's already done that are blatantly against the law. And we've seen the checks and balances at the federal level sort of buckle with Congress abdicating their power. But with the election, it feels like the states are really the bulwark that are going to hold that accountable.
David: We do. I mean, the federal government actually, I mean, we're unlike some countries in the world. Like I teach in Lithuania. I teach in Europe a lot. And there's central election agencies. The national government runs the elections. They administer. They determine eligibility to vote. We don't have that. And again, that's why I say it's state responsibility. In Minnesota,
Load full transcript
it then gets pushed down beyond the secretary of state down to the counties. Again, in some situations, it gets pushed back down to like a city or something like that. And then it's not just paid staff. It's volunteers. I mean, many listeners here might have been election judges at some point. The way I describe it, we've got so many moving parts in the system that it's so complicated that one person can't really do anything. And what's also important to realize, and I was talking to a reporter about this earlier today, and she was saying, well, are the judges getting wise to the president? And I said, yeah. I said, when he first took office the second time, cases are coming, judges are giving the president orders, and he's disregarding them. And they're kind of cutting him a little bit of slack saying, okay, maybe he didn't quite understand us. But if you start to look at recently what's happening right now, the judges have basically are learning how to work with Trump and are learning that, wow, he's not going to do good faith compliance. And so the judges are getting better at this. And you're right. Congress has basically rolled over and played dead at this point, forcing Congress and forcing the people to do what they're supposed to do, which is what? Show up for rallies and so forth. But the thing I've been telling people, the most important thing you can do if you're afraid about the integrity of the elections and what's going to happen, go vote. Go vote. And maybe secondarily, encourage your neighbors to vote. Maybe help somebody register to vote. But show up yourself and actually vote. That's how you protect the system.
So let's assume that all goes
Monica: as planned. And now let's look at the possible outcomes. And let's start with the House. What's the most plausible path to a majority for each party? And which races would you tell whether that path is actually opening up?
David: Okay. So, you know, right now, the majority for the Republicans is the thinnest majority since the 1930s. Okay. Yes. The Democrats have to flip three seats to take a majority. Okay. We know with only a couple of exceptions, the midterm elections are essentially a referendum on the president's party. The last time the president's party gained seats in a midterm election was in 2002 when Bush was president. And that was right after 9-11. Post 9-11. That's kind of a weird election because it's just literally, you know, within, you know, within a year after it. So all kinds of things are screwed up at that point. Generally, the president's party loses over 20 seats. And we also know the more unpopular the president, the worse his party does. And we also know that in general, the more the people are sour on the economy or think the country is going in the wrong direction, it's also worse for the president. So saying all of that, okay, this should be a banner year for the Democrats in the House of Representatives. That if we're going to use that phrase blue wave, there's a possibility of a blue wave. Now, keep in mind, there's maybe 30 or so seats that are really in play. You know, 435 seats because of a whole bunch of factors we could talk about if you want. There's probably 30, 35 seats, maybe 40 seats that are truly in play at this point. But if the Democrats, you know, do a net gain of three, they've got the House. But let's say one possibility is the blue wave. All the polls are correct. All the patterns are correct. They do exceedingly well. They've got the House. Pretty good majority at this point. There's somewhere around 250 seats. They're in good position.
Monica: Excellent.
Yeah.
David: Now, here's where, and by the way, let me do the Senate, by the way, too. Yeah, you're saving me from
Christy: asking you the next question. So just go ahead. Yeah, and you'll see where I'm going to go.
David: Yeah, you'll see where I'm going to go here. Okay. There is, normally, I would have said about seven to 10 seats in play in the Senate right now. Only 35, every two years, one third of the Senate is up for election. This year, because there's also a special election, there's 35 seats up for election. Normally, I would tell you, looking at it, about 10 seats are in play at this point. But because of the polling and because of Trump's unpopularity, seats in places like Texas and Kansas are in play, of which people thought was not possible. So putting that out there, the best scenario, the best scenario, assuming those states are in play, not sure if the Democrats can win them, but they're forcing Republicans to defend them. The Republicans have conceded North Carolina. Maine is a possible pickup, as is Alaska. Democrats could be at about 51, 52 seats in the Senate. They've got majorities in both bodies. That's the blue wave. Now, maybe pick up, like, if all goes well for the Democrats, they pick up Texas. Now, I wasn't thinking they had a shot at Texas until 2028, but they might. Okay. That's the blue wave. That's the blue wave. Okay. So now, good news, bad news. Okay. Good news. 58% of the American public has an unfavorable view of the Republican Party. Bad news if you're a Democrat. 59% of the American public has an unfavorable view of the Democratic Party.
Monica: Yes.
David: Now, it's not the same grouping there, but the Democrats have a brand problem.
Monica: They do. They have a messaging problem.
Christy: They have a messaging problem.
David: That's exactly what it is. For the last several elections, they've tried to run on, we're not Trump. Okay.
Monica: Mm-hmm.
David: I think there's a ceiling. You only get so far on, we're not Trump. And unless you actually talk about what you're going to do, there may be an outer limit. And so, I think the brand problem that Democrats have is, and I've seen a billboard about this recently, where a Democrat candidate for office said, I'm in favor of lower costs. Who isn't? I mean, it's like saying you're -
Christy: That's bipartisan.
David:
Yeah. It's like saying you're against clean living or something like that. So, it's got to be more than that. So, assuming there's some, I call, stickiness in the system, my other scenarios get down to second scenario where it could be the Democrats take control, not quite the blue wave of the House, don't take control of the Senate, but it goes maybe 50-50. Third scenario is that they have a majority, very, very thin, don't have control of the Senate. And then the last scenario, which I don't think is going to happen, is that the branding problem is so bad that they don't win the House or the Senate. I think right now we're somewhere between two and three. Okay. If you had asked me about three weeks ago, I would have been in a slightly different place. But I'm thinking right now in the House, upper 220s, maybe two, they're around 230 seats in the House, you know, sorter in there. So, they've got the majority. And I think it's about 50 to 51 seats in the Senate. And I'll give you my qualification in a second here. So, they've got majorities in both, potentially. That's the scenario I think that's most realistic.
Christy: It just won't be a massive majority. It'll be razor thin is what you're thinking.
David: And it's going to be razor thin. But even if they had a massive majority, they're not going to have enough to overcome the Senate filibuster. And they're still not going to have enough to overcome a presidential veto on straight Democratic Party votes at this point. Now, the other thing I have to throw in here, what complicates it a little bit, the calculus to get to the majority in the Senate assumes one thing. The Democrats win the U.S. Senate in Minnesota. Yeah. And the most recent polls right now have Peggy Flanagan, Lieutenant Governor Flanagan, with about a two-point lead over Michelle Tafoya. Survey research, plus or minus about, what is it? Plus or minus around four to four and a half points margin of error. Right. Right. And about 10% undecided. Which means they could be dead tied. It could be a six-point lead for the Lieutenant Governor. She could be behind. That's the margin of error. But this is a case of where we need to look at what the undecided voters are doing.
Christy: Right.
David: Generally, if undecided voters vote, they break against the incumbent. At about at least a 60%. Some people say 67%. I go conservatively and say six out of 10. Here's the complication now. Tell me what you think. Is that midterm elections are a referendum on the president's party. President and the Republicans are the incumbent. That should help with the independence with Flanagan. On the other hand, the Democrats have controlled the governorship for 16 years. Have had the trifecta a few times. Which party is the incumbent in Minnesota? The Democrats or the Republicans?
Christy: That does muddy the water. That muddies the water a little bit. It does. Yeah.
Yeah.
David: And with that, we also know when we look at the independent, not independent, when we look at the undecided voters, the undecided voters seem to be very heavily saying that fraud and corruption are the biggest issues that they're concerned about here. Now, that could be fraud and corruption at the state level. It could be fraud and corruption at the national level.
Monica: At the federal level. Yeah.
David: At the federal level. So we have on the one hand, fraud and corruption is an issue. We have the Democrats wanting to say that it's all about Trump. We have the Republicans saying in Minnesota, it's all about fraud. This is what makes them a little bit more complicated in Minnesota because while it looks like a good year for the Democrats, potentially nationwide, Minnesota is a lot more muddled at this point. And we are, I mean, think about it here. Take the five-county metro region out of the equation. We're basically a Republican state. Yes. I mean, the rest of the state, you have 87 counties. There's only about 11 counties that are consistently voting Democrat. The other, what, 87? The other 76 or so are Republican. And so that, so the Democrats need to have really good turnout in the metro area, which is possible to hold the Senate seat. Because if there isn't, if some of those undecided voters say, yeah, it's time to throw the Democrats out or Flanagan's too closely attached to Walts or something like that, that could be the surprise. And if, and if, and if Tafoya wins, that just makes it harder for the Democrats to hold or take this U.S. Senate.
Christy: Well, let's look at Klobuchar then also, because, you know, we're looking at the same type of situation with her, where if we are assuming that the Democrats are the incumbent in Minnesota, and this is a referendum on the incumbent, so what, what is going on with that race between her and Lisa Dameth?
David: Yeah. Well, right now, again, the polls seem to be suggesting she has a more comfortable lead. She seems to be leading by about nine or so points. Again, margin of error, four to five points. So she probably has a bonafide lead. Now, whether that lead is nine points, 13, or it's down to four, it's not clear, depending on how you calculate the margin of error. And again, the same thing. About 10 or so percent of the voters are undecided. If she truly has a nine-point lead, unless every independent voter votes and breaks against her, she probably has a real lead at this point. But it's still not a foregone conclusion at this point, you know, that there is a great adage, okay, a story. When Tip O'Neill used to be a Democratic Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, the first time he ran for Congress, and again, the great trivia question is, when he ran for Congress, whose seat did he run for? It was this guy named John Kennedy. So he's running for Congress for the first time, and the day before the election, he goes across the street to talk to an elderly woman who was kind of like his nanny, his babysitter when he was growing up. And he
said to her, I hope you're going to vote for me tomorrow. And she says, yes, Tip, I am, but I'm glad you asked. And what Tip O'Neill always used to say is never take voters for granted. Always ask for their vote. Yeah. And so complacency is a problem. And a great example of that was in 2016. Hillary Clinton, remember, we still had caucuses in Minnesota in 2016. Bernie Sanders beats Clinton two to one in the caucuses. He beats her two to one in the primaries in Wisconsin. And I believe he beats her in the primaries in Michigan. Goes to the general election, she figures, well, these people are going to vote for me. These states are going to vote for me. They have nowhere else to go. She doesn't come back and campaign in any of those states. Trump makes an appearance in all three of them. And what happens? He wins. He wins. Wins two out of three states. And so, I mean, yes, there's a lot of sexism in terms of that race. But at the end of the day, it was about what? Don't take voters for granted. And so, one has to worry if you're a Klobuchar supporter that even though you've got this lead, don't sit on the lead. I'm trying to think of like an analogy or like in the NBA or the WNBA, if you've got a 15-point lead with a minute to go, maybe you can sit on the lead or something like that. You can't in politics.
Yeah.
Monica: I tell you what, David, you are a podcaster's dream because you are pretty much running down our questions without us even having to interject because our next line of questioning is about polling. And you have already mentioned that. And we have seen in the past where the polls show one thing and after election night, the result is very different. And to your point, you know, it's not just the candidates that can't take the votes for granted. It's the voters that can't take the polls and the votes for granted. So, a listener sees one poll showing a close race and another showing a comfortable lead. How should they decide what deserves their attention?
David: Just go vote. Just first ignore all the polls. Okay. First ignore all the polls. Okay. I mean, okay. If I, okay. Do I have it here? No. Okay. Yes, I do have it here. If I could wave my magic wand. Okay. Oh my God.
Christy: You have a magic wand. He has a real magic wand. Sitting on his desk.
David: Okay. So, if I could wave my magic wand, I wish we could do something that many other countries in the world do, which is within X number of days of the polls, basically, you can't run ads and you can't do polling. Like Canada does that. And that's a cooling off period. So, people aren't sort of saying, well, should I vote? Should I not vote? What's the poll say? Et cetera, et cetera. But we can't do that. Just go vote. Yeah. We can't do that. Okay. So, a couple things to think about here is that when it comes to the polling, we know it's much more difficult to poll now than it used to be. It used to be calling people on their landlines. Well, very few people have landlines and
even cell phones nobody picks up anymore. I don't know about you. Right. I'm always afraid that someone's going to try to tell me that they have a warrant for my arrest or that my car warranty's expired or something like that. You know, the scams that are out there. Okay. So, in terms of the polling, what we have known for the last few years is that Trump performs better than the polls. That's the first thing. The second thing to know, and again, it's not a presidential election year, but I always tell people in a presidential election year, ignore all the national polls. And it's the same thing here. Ignore every national poll. Why? We don't have a national election. We're having, what, Senate races all across, you know, 50 different states or however many states this year, 435 congressional races. National popular vote means absolutely nothing at this point. Additionally, we don't have a lot of polling data at the congressional levels that are very good. But, again, an interesting story I will tell you is that back in 2016, Clinton versus Trump, the polls were saying that Clinton was ahead in the national polls by two to three points, plus or minus a margin error of about three to four points. Well, she won the national popular vote. There was a positive error of about four to five points. Was she in the lead or was she not in the lead? Plus, also, there was also 10% undecided at that point, each of them roughly. She could have been ahead. She could have been behind. But even if she was ahead, it was still so close. And with the 10% undecided, yeah, maybe, maybe she was ahead. The undecided voters voted and said, yeah, we're going to vote against her because she's what? We perceive her as the incumbent. So, I actually do think, at least back then, the polls were reasonably accurate, some of them. But there are good polls and there are bad polls that are out there. So, that's the other thing. But my general answer is just ignore all the polls, folks.
Christy: Yeah, so we hear a lot about the generic ballot. So, what I'm gathering from you is that is a bunch of hooey. Like, don't even put any stock in that.
David: Yeah, because a generic ballot is which party would you prefer to have control of Congress? And I think right now it's Democrat plus 11, which, I mean, most people are saying the Democrats need a plus 5 or plus 6 to take control of the House of Representatives. Possibly, yes. But, again, we have to think in terms of how accurate that is, how many of those people are actually going to show up to vote compared to Republicans. I mean, I get a lot of variables. Not saying these are bad barometers, but, again, I still say that, and I probably will say this a half a dozen more times before this podcast is over, just ignore the polls, show up and vote. Yeah. Just show up and vote. Because even if you think that one race is resolved, remember, there's a lot of down-ballot races. Right.
Monica: And we preach that all the time.
David: Yeah. Yeah. You know, so don't just go and vote for, let's say, governor or senator or House of Representatives. You know, I don't know, maybe your city council's up for election. Maybe your school board's up for election or something like that. And those are important to show up for and vote for, too.
Christy: Mm-hmm. Yeah. And America is notorious for its voting turnout problems. So let's talk about that for a second. Because that, in 2024, was an issue. A large number of registered voters just didn't show up at the polls. So can we get your read on that?
Yeah.
Christy: And how can the poll measure people's preferences reasonably well and still get the result wrong? Because they're not showing up to vote. Yeah. You know, it just, if they're not, those two numbers are not reconciling, is it an attendance problem then?
David: Yeah. The hardest problem for a lot of people is figuring out if they're really likely to vote. I mean, of course, you know, and I do this with my students, too. And I'll say to them, are you going to vote? And every hand goes up. The reality is they're not going to all show up to vote. You know, the politically acceptable answer is to say, yes, I'm going to show up and vote. But the pollsters never really ask that. They try to ask a series of other questions to tap in. They're going to ask you, are you registered to vote? How excited are you about the election? Have you voted previously? Things like that. All trying to figure that out. And that's the real problem here, is really tapping into that. Now, where the Democrats have a special problem is that for the Democrats to do well, there's three groups of people they really need to show up. These are like the swing voters, okay? And what it means to be a swing voter is to swing in and show up to vote or swing out and vote, okay? So the three most important ones, okay? I'm looking at the two of you, and you're the profile of the single most important voter in America, college-educated suburban women. You're at the top of the list. You show up and vote, Democrats do well. You don't show up and vote or not in good enough numbers, Republicans do well. Second group, persons of color. They show up to vote, Democrats do well. They don't show up, Republicans do well. And then the third, people under the age of 30. Same pattern. And so what happened is two years ago, there were, first off, had Harris picked up 230,000 more votes in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan? She's president of the United States. She might have lost the popular vote, but she would have won the electoral college. And that's important how razor thin it is, you know, in terms of the election. But what we know is, you're right, several million people just didn't show up, in part because why? It goes back to what we said before, the messaging issue. It's about, what are you going to do? I mean, there was a point I could absolutely tell you two years ago when Harris was over. She was narrowing in the polls. There
was some evidence that she was an elite. Then she went on to show The View. And it's a notorious scene. And they asked her a question, is there anything that you do differently than Biden? And she kind of looks in the camera and goes, I really can't think of anything.
Christy: Oh, yeah, I remember that. I saw that live. And I just, my heart sank when she said that.
David: Yeah. I mean, campaign managers and communications people should never let candidates go online, say something like that. And the reason why that was so important, two years ago, like now, the biggest issue for many people nationwide was the affordability issue. I call it the cost of milk, bread, eggs. I'm going to give you a great story about this in a second, too. Milk, bread, eggs, and now gasoline. And when Biden was saying, when he was still running, well, the economy's doing well, and then Harris is saying the economy's doing well, there's a disconnect. People are saying, what do you mean, Democrats, the economy's doing well? It's expensive. Okay. Story for you. About three weeks before the election last year, not last year, two years ago, 2024, I teach at Hamlin. I live south of Hamlin University. There was a cup food store open at that point. And that's where I used to do my grocery shopping. And I stopped there after work, and I bought a couple items, and there was a woman ahead of me. And her demographics are important. She was female, mid-30s, Hispanic. Okay. She bought four containers of infant formula. Cash register goes off. It was $140. Now- Oh, my goodness. Oh, my gosh. I mean, I don't know if you are, any of you are parents, you know, or have young children. But, I mean-
Christy: Our kids are all grown. We're in our mid-50s. I would not have known that.
David: I would not have known that. Okay. But the point being is that infant formula is really, apparently, really expensive.
Christy: It was way expensive back when my kids were young because I had to use formula. Yeah. So, yeah.
David: Yeah. So, it's $140. She looks at it. The cashier looks at her. This woman says, I can't afford this. Puts the infant formula back and buys a case of ramen noodles. Now, you know this is not good. I mean, you do not feed little kids ramen noodles at this point. And she walked out, and I thought to myself, if this woman votes, she's not voting for Harris.
Yeah.
David: Yeah. And so, this election, this is what I worry about, too. Affordability is on people's minds. People are still concerned about milk, bread, eggs. How about if I add it into your, what, diapers, infant formula, gasoline.
Christy: The cost of everything.
David: The cost of everything. Yeah. A couple of months ago, it would have been what? For people who have kids in school, backpacks, shoes. Sneakers.
Christy: Shoes are expensive now. And computers are expensive because of the cost of memory. Some computers have doubled in price in the past year just because of the cost of memory.
David: Right. And as you know, you can't exactly say to your kids who are growing, wear last year's shoes. Yeah. Or you can't wear last year's pants or something like that because they've grown out of it. So, I think the Democrats, this is a little bit, this is the danger. Again, going back to it, is that I think in Minnesota and nationwide, they need to be articulating this message, what they're going to do. And maybe it's a little bit late. I don't see them doing that very successfully at this point. And so, that's why I qualified the blue wave by saying that if there's a branding problem, that blue wave gets depressed a little bit. But again, right now, I'm still reasonably convinced at least the House of Representatives they take control of.
Monica: Can I take a little side quest here? Because I heard an interesting podcast yesterday with James Tallarico, actually. He was on the New York Times, The Daily. And he was asked about the filibuster. And you mentioned the fact that even with taking the Senate, the margin is not going to be filibuster proof. Tallarico points to the filibuster as one of the reasons that we swing wildly between Democrats and Republicans from one administration to another. And he advocates for getting rid of the filibuster.
Christy: I heard him say that. And that made me a little bit nervous.
Monica: Well, he advocates for it because he says he thinks that the majority should get what they want. And then the party in power needs to take ownership of it. And so, if the American public sees who they voted for and those policies fail, then that leads to them voting for the other party. And then if the other party filibuster is gone and those policies can go forth and then they're successful, then that party continues. What are your thoughts on that?
David: I have moved over the years towards supporting repeal of the filibuster. Also, I should point out that the historical use of the filibuster more often than not, before the Civil War, was supporting slavery. And more often than not, post-Civil War, has been used to oppose civil rights legislation. And that it's really been perverted, I'd say, in the last, let's say, 25 or 30 years. And you're making an important point about majorities. Because if the logic of our system is majority rule, what the filibuster does is to basically let a small minority, basically what? Basically thwart majority preferences. And I think a lot of times what you get is that a party will say, well, yeah, we'll pass something, but we know it's going to be filibustered. But we're going to do it anyhow, knowing that it's not going to go anywhere. And they get to sort of claim and say, yeah, we did it, but those dirty, rotten other party prevented from happening. I think transparency's sake, I think from the fact that we have letting government actually govern, we ought to get rid of it. Because I think one of the other criticisms we have right now is that a lot of people are frustrated. That government's not doing
its job. If we look at the polarization in Congress, the lack of output of legislation at this point, that I think a lot of people are saying, let's just do something. Do something like that. And so I'm not quite to that point, but I am at a point of saying that we can't let a minority, a small minority of states. I mean, think about it at this point. You could get, and nothing against my friends in South or North Dakota, wonderful people. One senator standing up in North Dakota could basically say, what? We're not going to let anything clear the Senate. And if I remember correctly, what's South Dakota's population? About a million people. Less than a million. Yeah. What's the rest of the-
Monica: That's where I grew up.
David: Yeah. I was going to say, what's the rest of the country? About 330, 340 million. There's something anti-democratic about that.
Monica: Right.
Christy: Yeah. I agree. I agree.
Monica: Yeah, and that could bring about a topic of all kinds of other things that need to be addressed going forward, like the Electoral College and how the Senate is set up. But we digress. Yes. So, David, thank you for being here. Don't go away. I won't. We're going to take a break for a PSA from The Sounds of Blackness.
Sounds of Blackness: We're the Sounds of Blackness. Every election gives us an opportunity to shape decisions that affect our communities, our families, and our future. Voting is the one way we make our voices heard. Show up, participate, and be counted. It's important. You are important. People before us worked, marched, organized, and sacrificed for access to the ballot. We honor that history by staying engaged. Local elections matter, too. The people we elect affect our schools and our neighborhoods. Also, our public safety, businesses, arts, and everyday lives. Learn what's on your ballot. Learn about the candidates and issues. Make informed decisions. And make a plan to vote. Voting is another way to use your voice. Stay informed. Stay involved. And participate in our democracy. Sounds of Blackness continues to stay optimistic. And we believe in the power of voices coming together. Different voices, different experiences, one community. Your voice matters. Your voice matters. Your vote matters. Get informed. Get involved. And get off your hands and vote. Get off your hands and vote. Get off your hands and vote. Get off your hands and vote. Just get off your hands and vote.
Christy: Welcome back to the Politics Chicks. David, when we first met, the very first thing that we talked about, you sat in your car. You were actually driving home. We talked about the millions and millions of dollars pouring into local races of out-of-state money, particularly into Senate seats. So, before we end, let's just talk about that a little bit. Because a lot of that money is going into negative attack ads. And I think all of us can at least agree that these attack ads, I'm done with them. I'm done with them. They're just too much. So, why don't we just talk about, for our very last topic, that money coming in. Because we actually wrote an article on it and found that a good part of that money is coming from GOPAC. Right. And that's another discussion in itself. But about $5 million is pouring into Senate races, local Senate races in the state. So, let's talk about those ads and what people should question when they see those ads.
David: Well, first off, remember, they are political ads. They're, they are, and we've known this for a long time, especially when they're non-candidate ads. Those are really the attack ads. I mean, most candidates don't do the direct attack ads because they want to have sort of what, plausible denial and say, oh, it's not me that's calling my opponent a scoundrel or something like that. So, most of the negative is coming from that outside, from the independent groups, outside money, et cetera, et cetera. And a lot of this is a consequence of Citizens United. Yes. A consequence of where that corporations never used to be able to dump this kind of money into elections. Now, they're much more freer to be able to do so. And also, because there's not adequate disclosure laws in place to capture all this, it's pretty easy to get around having to make any kind of disclosures for the money. Add to that now that, at least in the state of Minnesota, again, remember, of the 201 state legislative seats, 101 are held by Democrats, 100 are held by Republicans. I mean, it doesn't get any closer than that. Shift control by one seat in both houses, and you've got a different political control. That's important because it's that close. Again, we are, Minnesota, despite what people think, we are actually a very swingy state, you know, very, very closely divided. And that money's being poured in because why? Because the few House seats, maybe 15 House of Representatives seats in Minnesota, maybe seven Senate seats in Minnesota are going to determine the control of the state legislature. And so, at that point, those very few seats are basically like vacuums, just sucking up incredible amounts of money that's coming in from, as you pointed out, out of state.
Yeah.
Christy: Yeah. Well, let's just, as our last question here, have you, tell our listeners and our viewers, if they do see one of these negative ads, and I'm asking you this because I asked you it for the interview and you gave me a great answer. What should they, what is the first question they should ask?
David: Boy, I can't remember what I told you for that, so you really put me on the spot. You put me on the spot here.
Christy: Who paid for it?
David: Well, that's, of course, the first question I would ask if you paid for it. Great, great hint, great hint. If you could, if you can figure that out, because a lot of times, a lot of times these groups will come up with like really, like bland names, like Citizens for a Better Tomorrow or something like that. Who the heck are they? Yeah. And they're all the
same, and
Christy: just so that people know, they're all the same group. It's all the same money. They're just using different names to make it look like that they are, they're different groups.
David: You're absolutely correct. And then the second thing, sometimes these ads have information there and will say something like, if you want more information or something like that, go call them and make life miserable for them.
Christy: Yeah, I love that. Make life miserable for them. I love that. Yeah.
David: I used to be a community organizer. We used to say, if we couldn't win, at least make life miserable for those in power for a day.
Christy: You're my kind of professor. I needed a professor like you when I was in college, and I was a history major. All right.
David: All right.
Monica: I don't think we can leave this portion of the conversation without mentioning an ad that came up last night from Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio against his opponent, Amy Acton. And that was one, like, David, you mentioned that the first question you need to ask is who paid for it. And that was a question for a long time after that ad first came out because there was no evidence about who paid for it. And it was Ramaswamy. It was the campaign. Who paid for it. Yeah, it was their campaign. So, yes, look for that.
David: Yeah. If you want to just explain, I mean, I know what it was about, but just explain to the readers why this ad is so despicable because it truly is despicable.
Monica: It really is. Amy Acton spent her early childhood with her mother and her stepfather who was convicted of abusing her. Yeah. And she is estranged from her mother. So, the ad is her estranged mother saying that you can't vote for my daughter because she lies. Yeah. So, there's this family trauma that he's totally exploiting. Ramaswamy is totally exploiting this family trauma. And the response from Amy Acton's brother was that, yes, this trauma was real. There was abuse there. And just a despicable tactic for Ramaswamy to take.
Christy: I think what else is despicable is that they called her a fabulist. And that's a word, I mean, you know, if you're a fabulist, we know what it means, but do you think an average voter is going to know what fabulous means? I mean, that is, it's, that, I just found that that was despicable the way that they responded to it. Instead of saying she was a liar to kind of, you know, soften the blow a little bit. Yeah, I think you're right.
David: And it's important to understand that all of this has, in terms of the abuse and all this is documented. I mean, this is not fabricated. And in fact, I mean, just to understand here, a lot has to happen also for you to be taken away, a child to be taken away from their family. She was basically, again, I don't know all the detail. I mean, obviously her father was the abuser, but they basically took her away from her mother too. So there's all, and so again, suggesting, again, I don't know all the facts here, that
her, I'll say her mother was at least part of the problem in the abuse.
Christy: Right, right, because she chose her husband over her children, and that was part of it.
David: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And so, and so, so, so what we're all hoping is that the voters in Ohio will look at this and say, this is, again, truly despicable. I mean, how do you, I mean, how do you get away with basically attacking somebody for being a victim of child abuse?
Right.
Christy: You know, I had a professor in college who, and you brought up patterns earlier, and one of the things that this professor, like, just completely drilled into us is that you don't use history to predict the future, you use history to identify patterns. Yes. And then you can make a better guess at what the outcome is going to be based on those patterns. Vivek Brahmaswamy has an established pattern of doing this, especially to women. Yeah. So, and putting, and, and, yeah. So, I think that it's, it's that type of situation where we knew who he was when he was running for president, and he went after Haley, Nikki Haley on, you know, during the debate and went after her daughter. So, I think it's just an established pattern that we're seeing with him. So.
David: Well, we can only hope that the voters of Ohio do the right thing.
Christy: Yeah. Well, David, thank you so much for being on today. Of course. And can you tell our listeners and our followers where they can find your work?
David: Well, boy, where you can find my work. Well, first off, I'm on Facebook. I'm on Blue Sky. And so, I try to post announcements there about my interviews or talks or something like that. The, the Selim Center at the University of St. Thomas will be having me on right after the election to kind of do an election wrap-up. So, if you go to what's called the Selim Center site, the University of St. Thomas, you could register for a program, and you'll get to hear me right after the election do my best guess in terms of what happened and why.
Christy: Great. Great. Thank you so much for being on today. Of course. We just appreciate your time. We know you're a busy guy, especially with the election right around the corner. Yeah. My pleasure. We appreciate your time.
Sure.
Monica: To our listeners, if you're finding meaning in the stories we're sharing, if something moves you, challenges you, makes you see the world a little differently, please like, comment, and share. It helps more than you know.
Christy: And follow us everywhere at The Politics Chicks on Substack Threads, Blue Sky, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook.
Monica: Thanks for being a part of our community, folks. And keep shining your light so we can find each other in the dark and go vote.
Christy: And remember, we're stronger together. David, thank you so much for being with us today. And we look forward to talking to you after the election because we want to hear your thoughts on the outcome.
David: I would love to do so.
Christy: Great. Well, we'll see you soon. - Good.