رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.100 --> 00:00:11.520
Hey, folks. It's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company.
2
00:00:12.020 --> 00:00:17.820
But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question. That is, what can I do?
3
00:00:18.540 --> 00:00:29.140
It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost 200 episodes now. So here we are, The Most Important Question.
4
00:00:29.150 --> 00:00:45.880
Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. [upbeat music] Welcome to Important Not Important.
5
00:00:46.120 --> 00:00:58.630
My name is Quinn Emmett, and this is science for people who give a shit. Uh, folks, there's a lot going on out there. Our world's changing, being changed every single day, seems like it's going faster every single day.
6
00:00:58.630 --> 00:01:03.100
There's good news, though. You can take part in that change. You can affect that change.
7
00:01:03.720 --> 00:01:15.300
So I talk to the smartest, most impactful people on the planet to provide you with the inspiration and the tools you need to not only feel better, but to actively fight for a better future for everyone.
8
00:01:16.000 --> 00:01:25.420
My guests are scientists and doctors, uh, policymakers, activists, uh, investors, business leaders, doctors, nurses, astronauts, even a reverend.
9
00:01:26.200 --> 00:01:38.160
So if you want to be inspired, if you wanna find out how to make radical change, what you can do, hit the subscribe button right now to get even more conversations like this one, stories, and tools.
10
00:01:38.640 --> 00:01:39.580
You can also go backwards.
11
00:01:39.980 --> 00:01:55.820
Scroll through the feed, or you can go to podcast.importantnotimportant.com to find almost a hundred and thirty evergreen conversations covering everything from clean energy to, uh, cancer and artificial intelligence to regenerative agriculture.
12
00:01:56.400 --> 00:02:10.039
In this week's conversation, what I wanted to do and, and we're gonna try to do is to better understand data privacy, data stewardship, and what it actually means for indigenous cultures in the future of biotech.
13
00:02:10.680 --> 00:02:24.500
Questions like, how do we design equity and equitable benefit into genetic research? And who gets to decide the parameters of the data collection and the research done on that data and whatever else comes from it?
14
00:02:25.160 --> 00:02:38.020
And why do we consistently find cooperation on these fronts so difficult? What does the future of precision medicine hold when we haven't done the hard work of tearing down the systemic barriers to wellness and more?
15
00:02:38.820 --> 00:02:48.560
My guest is Crystal Tsosie, and I just wanna say upfront here how thankful I am for her time today. I learned so much, and I know that you will too.
16
00:02:49.180 --> 00:02:59.140
A reminder, you can send questions, feedback, or guest recommendations to me on Twitter at importantnotimp, or you can email me at questions@importantnotimportant.com.
17
00:02:59.680 --> 00:03:08.400
[upbeat music] My guest today is Crystal Tsosie, and together we're gonna explore a bunch of stuff.
18
00:03:08.540 --> 00:03:28.340
Uh, what biological data sovereignty means, uh, in context of, uh, the United States, in context of the hugely varied, um, I, I think, uh, correct me if I'm wrong, which I hope you do the whole time, like five hundred and seventy-ish Native American tribes across the continental US.
19
00:03:28.900 --> 00:03:42.100
Uh, it is hopefully going to be a conversation, uh, about the future, uh, which is coming fast, and the past all at once. So low bar. Uh, we're already losing Crystal. This is perfect. Crystal, welcome. [laughs] Hi.
20
00:03:42.240 --> 00:03:48.120
Thank you so much. It's my pleasure to be here. Uh, well, we'll see what, how, how that goes. You, you can judge that at the end.
21
00:03:48.180 --> 00:03:55.080
Um, Cr- My caffeinate is, my caffeination status hopefully will remain s- constant for the rest of the hour- Sure, sure, sure... but no promises.
22
00:03:55.180 --> 00:04:07.300
What is your go-to if you're like, "I gotta be on for an hour," uh, what is your mechanism for getting ready? Oh, um, so French press coffee. Mm-hmm. Ooh, that'll work.
23
00:04:07.770 --> 00:04:19.240
Um, I'm not qui- I'm not quite as bougie as pour-over, although I want to be. Sure, sure. I just don't have a gooseneck kettle. Uh-huh. Um, and then, um, I'll make a pot of that and then, um, ice it.
24
00:04:19.649 --> 00:04:30.870
And then I actually do the thing where I'll, uh, freeze leftover coffee into an ice cube tray. You do? That way, that way when the ice melts, it doesn't dilute your coffee and actually will contribute- Ah...
25
00:04:30.900 --> 00:04:42.520
more caffeine, uh, as the day goes on. You are nothing if not a scientist. That is amazing. Um, a friend, uh, one of my best friends, who's... We're gonna actually possibly, uh, talk about his dad. It's a whole thing.
26
00:04:42.980 --> 00:04:53.320
Um, he taught me, uh, you... Do you know what, uh, pesto is? It's like, sort of a, uh, it's an Italian sort of sauce. It's like, uh, pine nuts and... A- anyways, uh- Lot of garlic. Yes.
27
00:04:53.540 --> 00:04:55.280
Uh, blah, yeah, lot of garlic and basil.
28
00:04:55.300 --> 00:05:06.060
[laughs] His thing was you make it, you put it in the ice cube trays, but so it doesn't go rancid, you put olive oil on the top, and then same thing, you pop it out, and you've got, uh, fresh pesto. It's amazing.
29
00:05:06.160 --> 00:05:13.120
But yours is for coffee. I gotta teach that to my wife. Her heart does not start beating until I hand her coffee in the morning. So- [laughs]... um, I know.
30
00:05:13.160 --> 00:05:21.140
It's just- Well, I
Load full transcript
mean, great that her heart eventually gets going. Eventually. But- But what, but what happens- Good tip... if I forget to bring it or the kids are bother? Who can know? She just doesn't wake up.
31
00:05:21.440 --> 00:05:31.360
[gasps] Amazing. Uh- Don't make this, don't make this, uh, recording available, uh, to any law enforcement agencies, um, or any insurance firms. Yeah. Hundred, hundred percent.
32
00:05:31.390 --> 00:05:43.680
[laughs] We're just gonna take all this out. Crystal, if you could real quick tell the people who you are and what it is that you do. Wow, okay. That's a lot. Uh, so yeah, everyone.
33
00:05:43.800 --> 00:06:01.720
[speaking Navajo] I basically just told you in Dine bizaad, or Navajo language, everyone that I am related to, all my ancestors, um, on both sides of my family, and then of course introduced myself.
34
00:06:01.760 --> 00:06:13.376
And then in terms of who I identifyAnd how I identify, first of all, like, first and foremost, I'm a, I'm, I'm Indigenous to the US Southwestern region, uh, particularly the Navajo Nation.
35
00:06:13.976 --> 00:06:19.056
And then after that, I am a geneticist and also a bioethicist.
36
00:06:19.216 --> 00:06:31.576
I have, um, backgrounds in m- in bioethics and also in genetic epidemiology and public health, and I'm finishing my PhD at, uh, Vanderbilt University in Genomics and Health Disparities.
37
00:06:32.096 --> 00:06:41.696
I'm actually transitioning to a faculty appointment as assistant professor at Arizona State University, where I'll be the first, uh, Indigenous geneticist at that institution.
38
00:06:41.856 --> 00:06:52.876
And then also on top of all that, I'm co-founder and also ethics and policy director at the Native BioData Consortium, which is the first Indigenous-led biological and data repository for tribes in the US.
39
00:06:53.196 --> 00:07:03.836
Crystal, I'm exhausted every day, and I have a podcast. You're, you've got, like, 40 impactful and important things you're doing every day. That's incredible. Thanks. Uh, when you're not...
40
00:07:03.856 --> 00:07:11.136
When there aren't that many Indigenous peoples in the sciences, though, you, you tend to wear a lot of hats, um, especially in genetics. Okay.
41
00:07:11.616 --> 00:07:23.296
There is just so much going on in the world a- and in science and technology related to genetics, genomics, uh, the collectivica- the collectivization of data- Sure... um, and data privacy and ethics.
42
00:07:23.396 --> 00:07:28.616
Uh, it's just, it's a ti- a fascinating time to be in. Very scary, but fascinating. A hundred percent. A hundred percent.
43
00:07:28.756 --> 00:07:39.156
I mean, I think that's kind of the, the, the, the ethos of, of hopefully what our conversation is, uh, today for sure, which is, like, it is a heck of a moment, uh, for all of those things. Thank you for sharing that.
44
00:07:39.256 --> 00:07:45.356
I appreciate it. We usually start with one important question. Again, I'm not sure if you've listened to any other, uh, episodes or not.
45
00:07:45.436 --> 00:07:56.496
It's a, it's a pretty, uh, I think the wo- you could use the word preposterous question for sure. It's, it's both sincere but also completely tongue-in-cheek, so answer however you would prefer or tell me to go away.
46
00:07:57.056 --> 00:08:10.716
And the question is, Crystal, why are you vital to the survival of the species? Well, am I actually? [laughs] Great question. Oh, there, there's an underlying premise there that I am, right? Not necessarily.
47
00:08:10.816 --> 00:08:20.236
Um, before I can answer why- Most people just laugh at me, but please continue. Well, uh, can I assume that you've seen the movie Idiocracy? Oh, yeah, for sure. Uh, okay.
48
00:08:20.536 --> 00:08:38.336
So if we want to assume that I at least, uh, provide societal benefit and, um, you know, now that I have survived past my adolescence years, I, I know that I don't make ridiculously dumb decisions related to my own welfare [chuckles] and well-being- [laughs]...
49
00:08:38.346 --> 00:08:47.336
that maybe I do have some beneficial traits that could serve for the continued propagation of the species. However, I don't want that responsibility. That, that's...
50
00:08:48.096 --> 00:08:55.996
No, I, I don't feel like being pregnant in perpetuity, um. [laughs] No. But have something else have that responsibility. [laughs] Um, I love that answer, thank you.
51
00:08:56.056 --> 00:09:06.836
That might be our first Idiocracy reference, which is actually kind of surprising. Uh, boy, does, does that, does that one hold true these days. Awesome. Thank you, uh, so much for, for sharing that. All right.
52
00:09:07.056 --> 00:09:14.856
So Crystal, like I said before, I, I just wanna, uh, for a brief moment explain why I wanted to have this, uh, conversation today. So,
53
00:09:16.056 --> 00:09:23.056
you know, my wife lovingly describes this as my m- my climate change podcast as she puts it onto people's phones and... but that's only, you know...
54
00:09:23.096 --> 00:09:27.056
It's, it's a large part of what we do 'cause it touches so many different things, especially these days.
55
00:09:27.496 --> 00:09:34.976
Um, but we do talk about a lot of big systemic issues and questions here, um, as we kinda call it the, the make or break stuff.
56
00:09:35.476 --> 00:10:04.546
A- and many of the big issues when you really drill down, which we, we try to do, from air pollution to, uh, clean water or maternal health or the lack of Black doctors and nurses to climate investing or AI ethics, right, biotech, I've increasingly found, a- and this is obvious to people who've been doing this for a while, but it's increasingly, uh, more obvious and necessary to me to, to, to work on this level, but there, there, there are these common denominators, right?
57
00:10:04.576 --> 00:10:17.796
It's not really about the, the medical outcome or an algorithm, a particular algorithm, uh, or some mutual fund return or a
dataset or a water pipe or some deep sea minerals that we need for electric batteries, right?
58
00:10:19.276 --> 00:10:27.596
Um, just like it's not, it's not really about, like, who you see or don't see, like, up on the screen in a Disney movie, right? The underlying factors
59
00:10:28.796 --> 00:10:38.116
behind all of them, I, I guess it's one, but it's sort of twofold, is who is in the room writing and building these things? Who governs them?
60
00:10:38.296 --> 00:10:44.296
And, and most specifically in, in the American case, who benefits from each of these things, from
61
00:10:45.476 --> 00:10:54.336
water pipes that, uh, deliver clean water or not or a, a lack of representation in the medical field or, or air pollution, plastic factories, whatever, right?
62
00:10:54.636 --> 00:11:08.136
And, and I, I, I want to be fully transparent that this, this recognition of this piece of the puzzle, if not the puzzle itself, uh, I feel like I can tread in this water 'cause I'm a m- liberal arts major who loves to ask questions.
63
00:11:08.296 --> 00:11:22.016
Uh, but, but no, there's no question that the, the practical investigation of it and the exploration of it is, was delayed in both in my life and, and I guess in this show because of a huge amount of privilege.
64
00:11:22.116 --> 00:11:32.616
I, I cannot, you know, really change where, where I'm from or what I look like, but it's all born from this colonialism obviously. I, I'm literally from colonial Williamsburg, right?
65
00:11:33.016 --> 00:11:42.776
But it has made me reevaluate who I talk to and, and how I listen to them in, in examining this, this moment and, and the work that we do and any analysis or action steps.
66
00:11:42.796 --> 00:11:56.896
And so as we barrel into, like you were talking about, this, this wildly sort of exciting but uncertain future, biotech and, and what we do in biology and, and who gets to do it and who gets to profit from it, same thing for AI, right?
67
00:11:57.286 --> 00:12:04.876
They really linger as these two sectors that could get out of hand real fast unless we approach them in a way more inclusive and cooperative way.
68
00:12:05.376 --> 00:12:09.148
So when I learned about your work-Uh, which is again, like 12 different things.
69
00:12:09.588 --> 00:12:17.128
It was very clear that i-it was necessary to have at least, at least one conversation because I feel like I still have just so much to learn about this space and, and from you.
70
00:12:17.528 --> 00:12:24.468
So I, again, I do wanna thank you in advance for sharing your incredibly precious, uh, caffeinated time with, with me and the folks out there.
71
00:12:25.008 --> 00:12:33.048
Krystal, I actually wanted to start, uh, if we could go back just a little bit and talk about preeclampsia. So
72
00:12:34.108 --> 00:12:44.887
my mom, before she had me, there's four and a half years between my older brother and me, um, they lost a baby pretty late in between us, which is why there's that gap,
because of preeclampsia.
73
00:12:44.928 --> 00:12:54.987
And any sort of miscarriage is [clears throat] super rough. I, I, I'm, I'm just a man in, in my own family and, and the few that my wife and I suffered through were just brutal and obviously so much worse for her.
74
00:12:55.528 --> 00:13:00.608
But when that happened to my parents, it was... Carry the one, 1980 or so.
75
00:13:00.688 --> 00:13:15.288
There's no internet, there's no real genetic testing, but still their, their doctor, who's now [laughs] my, my best friend's father, trudged through a snowstorm with his medical textbooks, right, to their house to explain, "Hey, here's what happened, and it doesn't mean you're never gonna have another kid," as painful as it was.
76
00:13:15.368 --> 00:13:26.228
But f- 40-ish years later, millions of people in America, however you identify, don't get anything remotely close to that kind of attention from the medical industry or from their own doctors, right?
77
00:13:26.328 --> 00:13:38.708
We're, we're aware of that. Much less women and, and, and women of color, and we talked about that with, uh, Representative Underwood in episode 106 about Black maternal health and Seraphina Nance and Dr.
78
00:13:38.888 --> 00:13:51.268
Elizabeth Russo about birth control. Krystal, why did you choose for your dissertation to investigate the impact of, of PE, if we can call it that, on, uh, American Indian women?
79
00:13:51.468 --> 00:13:58.428
Why did you start there with everything else you've got going on? Well, actually, I didn't start there.
80
00:13:58.588 --> 00:14:06.608
I started with an even more broad question as to why indigenous peoples generally don't participate in genetic studies. Okay.
81
00:14:07.138 --> 00:14:22.308
And it just so happened that one of the longest ongoing genetic studies in a US indigenous community happens to be on preeclampsia. All right, so actually, can we go back a little bit further in my story?
82
00:14:22.488 --> 00:14:27.648
Uh- To be clear, you're in charge. So my mother... Cool. So I [laughs] actually started, uh...
83
00:14:28.028 --> 00:14:41.438
It's really horrible to start this, this, this question that is truly impactful with, unfortunately, a very egocentric question or self-centric question about my own career in, in genetics as, as an indigenous person.
84
00:14:41.508 --> 00:14:51.328
But if we go back e-even, like, a decade prior to when I actually started doing preeclampsia work, my intent and purpose was actually to become a cancer researcher.
85
00:14:52.008 --> 00:15:05.077
And I actually was pretty successful in, as an undergraduate postbaccalaureate researcher in that I had a couple patents related to, um, microbiology or micro, um... So you've heard of n-nanotech?
86
00:15:05.188 --> 00:15:15.148
Well, I've done like micro, um, scale, uh, solutions to, uh, targeted chemotherapeutics, and I really wanted to go into cancer biology, even went to Hopkins University.
87
00:15:15.328 --> 00:15:18.768
I had my own pick of any institution in the world, and I hated it. Wow.
88
00:15:18.778 --> 00:15:32.948
'Cause the, you know, the field of cancer biology is not only oversaturated, but I was witness to, uh, scientists that were basically having, um, an ego me-measuring contest as to how many drug patents they had on their wall.
89
00:15:33.508 --> 00:15:41.968
And when we think about cancer biology and what drives a, a lot of the research, it's, you know, money, and it is drug innovations that regulate the FDA.
90
00:15:42.048 --> 00:16:05.088
And I just had this, this sickening feeling, um, that, you know, even if I were to be successful in developing a, you know, a cancer therapeutic, that chances are it would probably benefit, you know, people that were already affluent, who had already had access to, um, adequate re- health, uh, care resources, and it wouldn't be my own people.
91
00:16:05.588 --> 00:16:20.008
The Native people that I grew up with, which were living in rural communities and relying on the Indian Health Services for their, for their healthcare and not really getting access to, like, the top-tier drugs, uh, unless they were paying for it out of pocket at exorbitant rates, right?
92
00:16:20.017 --> 00:16:26.358
And I just had this sickening feeling of, what am I doing as a Native person in the field of cancer biology if I'm not gonna be benefiting my own people?
93
00:16:27.248 --> 00:16:36.868
And that actually led me back to, back to grad school for my first master's in ethics 'cause, in bioethics 'cause I actually wanted to switch to a, a career in law.
94
00:16:37.568 --> 00:16:57.567
And then this is where I, I started learning more about genetic controversies related to indigenous participation in genetic studies and all of these different lawsuits and controversies in which indigenous peoples felt like they were being exploited for the genomic data, you know, for the, quote, "good, greater good of society and research."
95
00:16:57.768 --> 00:17:01.348
Um, but the research wouldn't be beneficial to them.
96
00:17:01.408 --> 00:17:21.828
And then, you know, I could already see the writing on the wall even, like, 10 years ago that there's gonna be this huge emergence and rush for the collectivization of genetic data across all data sets, and indigenous peoples will still, unfortunately, continue to be disenfranchised unless we had more indigenous geneticists in the field advocating for the communities.
97
00:17:22.448 --> 00:17:45.488
So I actually came to, uh, Vanderbilt University because it had, like, the, the cr- uh, it had, like, the perfect breeding ground for the skills that I wanted to, to, to gain, which was in epidemiology and data science and, and, um, looking at genetic data sets for, like, conditions that had, like, broad scale health dis- disparities.
98
00:17:45.868 --> 00:18:01.828
And I actually centered on a, a research lab that focused on uterine fibroids in African American women, and
uterine fibroids is a benign tumor that, um, is increasingly prevalent in, in African American women, and there's a huge disparity.
99
00:18:01.948 --> 00:18:05.448
And it's like, its prevalence is I think at least four to one.
100
00:18:05.588 --> 00:18:16.138
For every, for every, uh, woman of a European ancestry, uh, four women of African ancestry will have, um, a uterine fibroid at some point in her life, and it's like- Wow...
101
00:18:16.168 --> 00:18:20.498
something that's of huge, uh, medical concern because it's costly to treat. Sure.
102
00:18:20.628 --> 00:18:46.244
Um, and it, it is related to all these different maternal and child outcomes when, when a woman is pregnant with, with uterine fibroids and is just [laughs]Something that is really speaks to almost the erasure of and invisibility of women of color in terms of seeking, uh, general medical care for what, you know, is usually been unfortunately, uh, ignored.
103
00:18:46.504 --> 00:18:55.684
Uh, there's been a huge amount of criticism in that we have this wealth of understanding of, of conditions and an understanding of disease related to men's health, but not women's health.
104
00:18:56.644 --> 00:19:13.264
So anyway, as I'm like sitting in my computer, at like my desk at a computer terminal, like looking across all these genome-wide, uh, data sets with m-millions of SNPS or single nucleotide polymorphisms across the genome,
105
00:19:14.284 --> 00:19:25.614
across like hundreds of thousands of, of women, uh, but in different multi-ethnic cohorts, I just... You know, as a Native American, I was looking, well, how many Native Americans are in this study? Mm-hmm.
106
00:19:26.204 --> 00:19:38.264
And time and time, it was zero. And, um, I learned that Native Americans, again, are not participating in genetic s-studies, and the, the treatment is effectively a, a form of erasure.
107
00:19:38.344 --> 00:20:04.944
They're either not included in studies, and therefore we're not getting this wealth of understanding of health outcomes related to Native Americans, or even sometimes what happens is geneticists who don't understand that Native Americans are not just this unique, monolithic identity, uh, just pull us all into the same like, uh, data set, uh, ignoring our unique genetic histories and then they'll like, just to get a, an adequate sample size to detect association.
108
00:20:05.684 --> 00:20:17.754
And, you know, these inferences could be flawed, like they're meaningless for us because they're, they're not actually based off of meaningful measures of, of like who we are as peoples. Sure.
109
00:20:17.764 --> 00:20:22.924
And that's always hard to determine. And also, there was just about something a little bit,
110
00:20:23.884 --> 00:20:40.634
a-again, you know, I felt this, this, this question that the pit of my stomach of what are we doing when, in data science when we're just thinking about collectivizing this increasingly larger aggregated data sets, uh, and just pushing out a paper?
111
00:20:41.124 --> 00:21:00.224
The pipeline, I'm, I'm saying this very lovingly, but also sort of i-i-in a, in a critiqued fashion about the field of data science is that you almost re- you remove the human element of, of the science and the work, and you just start treating people as, uh, uh, as, as, um, anonymous numbers.
112
00:21:00.844 --> 00:21:15.804
And you want to just increasingly collect more and more data, and that's, that's kind of like the big hunger machine of the big data era is that, you know, you need more data to feed into these logistical models in order to detect these associations.
113
00:21:16.464 --> 00:21:29.924
But what ends up happening is you get these statisticians who are just thinking in terms of numbers, in terms of their ability to run a statistical test of association, but then it's almost like the, the health, underlying health question doesn't even matter.
114
00:21:30.544 --> 00:21:43.944
Like some statisticians might have their pet phenotype or condition of interest, but, you know, the pathway then between, you know, somebody c- using somebody's data and then how it actually translates to a direct health benefit-
115
00:21:45.084 --> 00:21:46.114
Mm-hmm... is not clear.
116
00:21:46.364 --> 00:22:11.484
But instead, you know, we get more and more, uh, uh, uh, funding agencies that are collecting more and more data and preempting the collectivization s-set of data sets, but not asking the question of, well, if this is supposed to affect and benefit, um, uh, health outcomes for people, then why aren't we talking more about translating these, these, uh, direct benefits to communities that are providing the data?
117
00:22:12.464 --> 00:22:16.844
So, you know, that actually brought me to this study related to preeclampsia.
118
00:22:16.884 --> 00:22:27.204
There really aren't that many, uh, community-engaged approaches related to genetics, uh, that are long ongoing and in existence still in indigenous communities in the US.
119
00:22:27.784 --> 00:22:40.644
And it happens that the only, the one that I really wanted to work with, which was like based in a tribal community, was related to preeclampsia. Oh, yeah. Um, yeah, that's kinda how I got to that part of the story.
120
00:22:40.664 --> 00:22:50.804
[laughs] Well, no, I, I really appreciate that background. That's, I mean, it's, it's so interesting. You know, I, I, I mean, I think like when you're growing up, you're like, "What am I gonna do?" And you, you always...
121
00:22:51.384 --> 00:23:00.644
I don't know if it's some product of like the, the '50s or something, but it-it-it's, it's easy to imagine like that you're picking your job for the rest of your life, but in reality, [laughs] that's just not how it works.
122
00:23:00.704 --> 00:23:11.544
It's this, you know, it's sometimes it's serendipitous, sometimes it's process of elimination, sometimes it's this, uh, you know, there's some sort of revelation or a moment that leads you
in one direction or another and you go, "Oh, I'm gonna do a nonprofit thing.
123
00:23:11.604 --> 00:23:19.964
Like, I can do that. I'm really excited," or wh-whatever it might be or, or scientist. I mean, uh, I, I mean, again, I went to a, a, a liberal arts u-university.
124
00:23:20.024 --> 00:23:30.464
It was very privileged, of course, to be able to go there, and a lot of the students who go there were very similarly, but it was always funny, and this was not me because I'm not that intelligent [laughs] in tha- in this capacity.
125
00:23:30.484 --> 00:23:34.364
The kids that came up and were, you know, their whole life like, "I'm gonna be a doctor. I'm gonna be a doctor.
126
00:23:34.444 --> 00:23:42.964
I'm gonna be a doctor," and then they take some philosophy class or whatever it might be, and their mind is blown, and all of a sudden, you know, they, they become a professor or whatever it might be, and you're just like, "Wow."
127
00:23:43.044 --> 00:23:52.224
You just never know what you're gonna be exposed to and how that's gonna influence your thing. And again, it could change even later. You could apply it in some, some different way.
128
00:23:52.384 --> 00:24:01.624
Um, so anyways, I, I really appreciate you, you sharing that. It's, it's interesting, uh, the, the way that these things take us. Yeah, it really is.
129
00:24:01.784 --> 00:24:10.634
I remember in fourth, no, third grade or something like that, we had to draw a picture of ourselves in our intended career paths. Mm-hmm.
130
00:24:10.644 --> 00:24:16.804
I drew myself with like a little suit and a briefcase, and I thought it was very clear- [laughs]... that I was going to be a lawyer.
131
00:24:16.864 --> 00:24:28.924
And my teacher, who, I mean, she's such a sweet person, she's like, "Oh, you wanna be a teacher just like me." Aw. And I, I love teachers. Did you break it to her? Teachers are amazing. I didn't.
132
00:24:29.104 --> 00:24:35.654
I just, I went ahead and just like nodded along- [laughs]... um, because I didn't wanna insult her. Sure. And teachers are amazing.
133
00:24:35.764 --> 00:24:45.048
Oh my God, they are so amazing and overworked and underappreciated, but at that time, I didn't wanna become one.Yeah. No, I mean, uh, yeah, my, my, my mom was a kindergarten teacher.
134
00:24:45.088 --> 00:24:51.388
It's like, pay them a million dollars, and they should be all treated incredibly. It's, it's preposterous. I know.
135
00:24:51.528 --> 00:25:07.508
I mean, just as a brief offshoot, I mean, when COVID happened, right, we, all of a sudden we had this huge appreciation that parents had for teachers that didn't exist beforehand, and now we are returning back to, quote-unquote, normal, right?
136
00:25:07.668 --> 00:25:20.188
Whatever that means. And now we- we're, we're not fixing all of the issues that, you know, caused this, um, potential teachers to continue in the field or, um, I don't know.
137
00:25:20.248 --> 00:25:29.038
No, it's, uh- We've just removed the love of teaching. Yeah. It's, it's frustrating. It's sad. Um, there's a, there's a writer, uh, for The Atlantic named Ed Yong, who I have just enormous respect for- Yes...
138
00:25:29.088 --> 00:25:46.487
um, and ar- around the beginning of pandemic, and to be clear, this is, [laughs] caveat, this is not me comparing myself to Ed Yong, but we both sort of had these metaphors that we were writing about where he- I believe his was, um, COVID was like a flood on a sidewalk exposing all the cracks that were already there, and mine was like, oh, this, here's your pop quiz.
139
00:25:46.568 --> 00:25:52.548
Like, you've made four hundred years of decisions. Let's see how you do. And we've, we've failed all of them. It didn't go great.
140
00:25:52.578 --> 00:26:01.288
And it's everywhere from, again, the medical, uh, establishment and the decisions we've made and, and who's been marginalized too, like you said, teachers, where, uh, th- every...
141
00:26:01.768 --> 00:26:07.148
All, all, all of these parents immediately had to teach math for one hour, and they were like, "It's exhausting. This is brutal.
142
00:26:07.248 --> 00:26:17.098
We should celebrate teachers and frontline workers and all this," and now we have not done those things. But I do believe, uh, that we can, that we can work on these things and that we can make progress.
143
00:26:17.128 --> 00:26:26.768
So I wanna hear about the Native BioData Consortium. And again, uh, I could not enjoy and appreciate more wherever you correct me, I'm wrong.
144
00:26:27.188 --> 00:26:50.848
So as far as I understand, m- many, I don't wanna use the word most, many trou- tribal groups so far have, uh, uh, I don't know if refused is the right word, but, um, have, have abstained from using a lot of these sort of popular genetic tests that are out there and, and further to add their DNA, DNA information to s- some of these broader public databases that have, that have come along.
145
00:26:51.228 --> 00:27:00.608
Again, I'm just thinking about probably governance a- and profit, and I learned this word biocommercialism from reading about your work. Tell me about the project. Tell me why and why now.
146
00:27:00.888 --> 00:27:15.157
And, and tell me why it had to be you. What did this... W- what does this solve for you to, to do this work? Sure. Um, as everything goes with Native people, everything starts with a story. [laughs] Please. Hit me.
147
00:27:15.188 --> 00:27:26.288
So, um, I, I'll, I'll, I'll give you a background a little bit about the field, which is surprising that not enough geneticists actually understand their own fields. So, like, it starts, like, actually in the '90s.
148
00:27:26.768 --> 00:27:43.648
There was a, a, a professor at Stanford University called Luca Cavalli-S- So- Forza, and he wanted to sample as many populations around the world as possible, which sounds a lot like some of the large-scale diversity projects that are ongoing today.
149
00:27:43.688 -->
00:27:54.848
Mm-hmm. And but he had, like, the... Y- if you look in publications, uh, the way that he described Indigenous peoples is a little insidious. It was like, "We have to sample Indigenous populations before they vanish."
150
00:27:55.728 --> 00:28:02.668
So not even caring, like, why Indigenous peoples were- Mm-hmm... being disenfranchised from their lands and their cultures and their way of living. No, we don't care.
151
00:28:02.748 --> 00:28:10.278
We'll just ignore colonialism and not fight colonialism except that it's gonna exist, and these people are gonna become extinct, another word that was used.
152
00:28:10.288 --> 00:28:13.948
But we need their blood as quickly as possible because it's a race against time.
153
00:28:14.468 --> 00:28:31.708
And, you know, unsurprisingly, Indigenous peoples around the world didn't like being characterized in such a way as being esteemed as only valuable to science and r- uh, as, um, a means to gain access to their blood as a resource for continuing research that won't benefit them, right?
154
00:28:31.768 --> 00:28:31.788
It's not great.
155
00:28:32.148 --> 00:28:44.657
So, um, yeah, unsurprisingly, I think at this point in time, uh, global Indigenous populations around the world, uh, just started, you know, calling for the cessation of, um, the Human Genome Diversity Project, HGDP.
156
00:28:44.668 --> 00:28:59.508
Mm-hmm. And then, um, even, like, the s- the criticisms of the project continued into 2000s, and a huge concern then that's still sustained today is that, like, what are you collecting this data for?
157
00:29:00.188 --> 00:29:13.488
Um, and it was even at that time, it, you know, the huge push was to make this data available openly and publicly available to increase the rate and support of innovations in science.
158
00:29:13.988 --> 00:29:20.818
But, you know, Indigenous peoples thought, "Well, who else is going to have access to this? It's going to be companies- Mm-hmm...
159
00:29:20.848 --> 00:29:32.748
and people with a biocommercial interest in profiting off of access to Indigenous genomes," and that is called biopir- uh, piracy or bioexploitation. Mm-hmm.
160
00:29:32.778 --> 00:29:46.648
Um, and, uh, you know, sure enough, what happened in 2005 is that HGDP published their, their, their paper that had their supposedly successful recruitment of global populations worldwide.
161
00:29:47.108 --> 00:29:59.808
And if you look at the Indigenous, um, peoples, like, and their geography mapped, all of the Indigenous peoples that they recruited were in, uh, countries outside of the US, in Central and South America.
162
00:30:00.308 --> 00:30:12.808
And that's because countries in the US, like... or, sorry, tribal nations in the US, they actually have federally recognized sovereignty- Mm-hmm... or a right to be able to, um, self-govern as a peoples.
163
00:30:13.208 --> 00:30:23.708
So you actually have, like, now 574-plus, uh, sovereign nations that are in, within the boundaries of
the colonial US- Mm-hmm... right?
164
00:30:23.868 --> 00:30:30.927
Um, that all have their own tribal governances and their own ways of governing, ways of life for their people.
165
00:30:31.008 --> 00:30:43.888
And in, you know, there were a number of other controversies related to, like, in the early 2000s of non-Indigenous researchers, um, doing questionably ethical things with Indigenous peoples' data.
166
00:30:43.948 --> 00:31:11.038
Like, for instance, in the early 2000s, the Havasupai nation sued the Arizona Board of Regents and Arizona State University because an Arizona State University researcher basically engaged in a promise to study type 2 diabetes in the Havasupai nation and then turned around and started study- using those samples to study other things like schizophrenia and, uh, population migration, uh, theories that were culturally incongruent with their own origin narratives.
167
00:31:11.448 --> 00:31:22.108
Mm. And just using words like inbreeding and, um, also just some really, uh-Stigmatizing language that the tribe just didn't feel like they actually consented to. Sure.
168
00:31:22.528 --> 00:31:32.448
Um, and that lawsuit actually could have bankrupted, uh, the three s- state universities. I think they originally asked, the original suit was something like $80 million- Mm-hmm...
169
00:31:32.468 --> 00:31:49.768
but then it got settled, and the, the, the result of that is, like, you know, tribes, the Havasupai Nation basically, uh, banished any ASU employee from setting foot in their tribal lands for a period of time, and then this is already concurrently going on with a bunch of Indigenous people's concerns related to genetic data.
170
00:31:49.808 --> 00:31:58.218
Mm-hmm. So by and large, in the 2000s, US tribal nations exercised their means of auth- or sovereignty to not engage in- Mm-hmm...
171
00:31:58.218 --> 00:32:10.048
more research, which meant that researchers, if they want to gain access to Indigenous peoples, had to go further south, in the Global South, to c- to tribal nations, Indigenous communities that weren't protected.
172
00:32:10.488 --> 00:32:18.208
So, like, for instance, if you follow, um, like, how Brazil treats its Indigenous peoples, it's not great.
173
00:32:18.448 --> 00:32:30.088
Uh, many, uh, governments, uh, in the Central South Americas, uh, may fundamentally refuse to ex- uh, um, acknowledge the existence of their Indigenous peoples.
174
00:32:30.708 --> 00:32:46.508
So [laughs] um, you can imagine that researchers coming into the communities d- if they didn't have to undergo, if they had, like, very lenient government, uh, uh, policies a- and, you know, there, that some potentially questionable ethics could, could occur.
175
00:32:46.608 --> 00:33:06.108
And from the viewpoint of Indigenous peoples, they called these projects vampire projects or helicopter projects, because to them, in their perspective, scientists would come in like vampire bats or vampires in the middle of the night
and take their blood and then leave, or come in in helicopters one day and leave with all their blood and, and leave again.
176
00:33:06.118 --> 00:33:19.588
And this is really important, because, um, after the publication of their data in, uh, in 2005, the HGDP made the, the Indigenous biomarkers publicly available on a website.
177
00:33:19.958 --> 00:33:41.188
And then you sort of fast-forward a couple years to, like, 2007 to 2012, when you had the, uh, e- the emergence of companies like direct-to-consumer ancestry companies like 23andMe and AncestryDNA that started utilizing their access to this public available resource for their own product development.
178
00:33:41.748 --> 00:33:57.518
So AncestryDNA was just sold last year to venture capitalist firm Blackstone for $4.7 billion, and then every holiday quarter since 2017 has had, like, a billion dollars in profit, so every holiday season, right?
179
00:33:57.528 --> 00:34:04.088
When people, like, wanna gift- Of course... their- Put it in their stocking... beloveds. Yeah. Right? Figure out who you are.
180
00:34:04.448 --> 00:34:14.348
Um, it's like, it's really interesting, 'cause Ancestry admits on their own vlog that their number one question is, "Why isn't my Native American ancestry showing up?"
181
00:34:14.968 --> 00:34:28.088
So already, like, tying, like, the hubris of peoples and the fundamental misunderstanding of what Indigenating means to this scientifically, uh, scientific test that supposedly reifies those false narratives of Indigenating.
182
00:34:28.157 --> 00:34:38.818
Sure. Right? And making a buck out of it. Of course. I'm so cynical about these things, 'cause I think people need to understand what they're giving up- Mm-hmm... uh, when they're contributing their DNA- Mm-hmm...
183
00:34:38.848 --> 00:34:52.188
to these, to these companies. They're willfully paying $100 to $200 to become contributors to research studies that they have absolutely no idea, like, what is being used for- Sure...
184
00:34:52.208 --> 00:34:57.627
like, what they're being used for, and even for the continued, uh, profit, bottom line of the companies.
185
00:34:57.668 --> 00:35:04.688
Like, they're just gonna use your data to continue adapting their alg- own product algorithms that you're not gonna benefit from. [laughs] Sure.
186
00:35:05.128 --> 00:35:16.118
Anyway, so, you know, there's this huge interest in, in collectivizing Indigenous biomarkers, um, not just for gen- genetic ancestry companies, but also drug companies. Mm.
187
00:35:16.118 --> 00:35:28.068
'Cause now drug companies are really interested in figuring out, well, what are the next novel genetic variants associated with disease? And all of, like, the lowest hanging fruit has already been picked.
188
00:35:28.208 --> 00:35:33.108
Like, common variants related to common, uh, diseases have already been s- heavily studied.
189
00:35:33.347 --> 00:35:45.648
Uh, variant, um, variants that associate with Mendelian disorders or heritable diseases and traits, those have been studied with, uh, earlier genetic, um, tests for, like, the last few decades.
190
00:35:46.088 --> 00:35:58.908
What really, uh, people are, uh, companies and, uh, researchers are looking for are, like, what's the next variant that is going to unlock our understanding of, like, cancer and diabetes, and where are we gonna find it?
191
00:35:59.008 --> 00:36:05.348
It's gonna be in small, untested populations like Indigenous populations, and these are the same people that have been exploited.
192
00:36:06.228 --> 00:36:15.888
It is really interesting, by the way, when the Native BioData c- Consortium started, I'm kinda skipping ahead here in my own timeline of things, but it's really interesting, because we, we
193
00:36:16.868 --> 00:36:24.188
officially incorporated in 2018 as a nonprofit company, and as a nonprofit research organization.
194
00:36:24.788 --> 00:36:41.608
And when we started and beca- became a little bit more known, uh, nationally, internationally, we had a number of some of the largest drug companies reach out to us and ask us, you know, what kind of data we had on Indigenous peoples, and whether they wanted to, quote, "partner with us," right?
195
00:36:42.448 --> 00:36:57.628
And of course, what we wanted to ensure was that genetic variants that are specific to Indigenous communities, that are gonna be, for which are gonna be, form the basis for intellectual property, that those intellectual property rights are retained by the tribe, not by the companies, right?
196
00:36:58.428 --> 00:37:06.708
And another thing that we wanted to, uh, we were asking them is, like, well, what, uh, phenotypes or conditions are you interested in studying?
197
00:37:07.158 --> 00:37:18.016
They were only interested in studying the things that affected the massive population, not the, the, the conditions that affected the Indigenous peoples. I'm sure that's where the money is.Exactly.
198
00:37:18.516 --> 00:37:38.535
So this, you should tell you, like if our goal of collectivizing indigenous DNA is to benefit the most, then we are still gonna fundamentally ignore the individuals that also still suffer, that are contributing the DNA to begin with, right?
199
00:37:39.476 --> 00:37:55.256
This is why I question the phrase democratizing data or democratizing science, which, you know, democratization of science is like this popular buzz phrase that's been going on recently, and people don't understand or qu- or critically question what it means.
200
00:37:55.836 --> 00:38:06.216
So first of all, [laughs] democracy is not really something that we should be aiming for, especially when we consider the garbage fire of twenty- Yeah, to be clear, like... twenty twenty, right?
201
00:38:06.256 --> 00:38:09.146
The recent election or- It's not going great, this democracy exp- No...
202
00:38:09.156 --> 00:38:20.716
I mean, I w- I don't re- The American- I don't remember what the Winston Churchill quote goes,
but, but, you know, to, to par- to, to butcher it, it's essentially like it's, it's, it's the best of like all the worst options, but also like it's not going great.
203
00:38:20.886 --> 00:38:29.266
[laughs] We could use a different word [laughs] or, or idea. Yeah. Whoever like equated democracy with, you know, something that means- [sighs]...
204
00:38:29.266 --> 00:38:35.826
something to be fundamentally good is, it hasn't, hasn't paid attention to history. And also like, um, you know, different forms of democracy- Sure...
205
00:38:35.836 --> 00:38:43.006
like the, uh, Athenian democracy and also the Haudenosaunee, uh, Confederacy, like indigenous peoples had their own form of democracy, right? Sure.
206
00:38:43.016 --> 00:38:47.976
But, you know, democracy like is like, you know, the benefit to the majority. Mm-hmm.
207
00:38:48.116 --> 00:39:02.906
And in this case, it's, you know, how can we extract the data from a very small portion of, of peoples that have suffered the worst in terms of colonial factors, and let's continue extracting and exploiting these individuals as long as we're benefiting the most.
208
00:39:02.916 --> 00:39:13.316
But this is supposed to be considered a good thing. It's horrible. I think people need to stop e- e- equating diversity and inclusivity with equity because it's not the same thing.
209
00:39:13.356 --> 00:39:28.276
Like, we have all of these DEI or EDI efforts in terms of like trying to ensure that we have, uh, more inclusion and participation of it, of, of peoples of color in like all levels of academia and different fields, right?
210
00:39:28.316 --> 00:39:42.476
But, you know, that means nothing if you're not also providing equity to that representation. [gentle music] Hey, it's Quinn. I'll make this quick. Sifting through the news is a slog.
211
00:39:43.136 --> 00:39:55.856
Finding the signal and the noise, it's damn near impossible. And if you do, what can you even do about it? I'll tell you what you can do. Literally, every week I'll tell you the most impactful thing you can do.
212
00:39:56.556 --> 00:40:06.916
In just 10 minutes a week, you can get smarter, feel better, and make radical change for yourself, your family, your investments, your company, and for the world.
213
00:40:07.836 --> 00:40:21.976
Join tens of thousands of other leaders and subscribe to our free weekly newsletter at newsletter.importantnotimportant.com. Get the most vital science news, exclusive analysis, and action steps for free.
214
00:40:22.776 --> 00:40:34.516
That's newsletter.importantnotimportant.com, or just click the link right in your show notes. Back to the show. Well, and that's the point about who's in the room.
215
00:40:34.556 --> 00:40:47.306
It's not just, uh, like w- we have failed to do the input side, right? Which is, which is, i- inclusivity is not just like hiring people or statistics in like your, your, your PR of your company.
216
00:40:47.726 --> 00:40:53.436
It is literally who's in the room, who gets to participate and why, and what's the, what is the hierarchy there.
217
00:40:53.446 --> 00:41:03.136
And, you know, not just, not just what story is told, not just who gets to tell the story, but who gets to decide who gets to tell the story. But then you also, like you're saying, the equity side.
218
00:41:03.176 --> 00:41:12.876
You have to consider the output, which is like, okay, that's great. I- imagine, imagine we had a pandemic that affected everybody on the planet, right? And the N was everyone.
219
00:41:13.316 --> 00:41:37.136
Um, you still have to consider, and this is what we're seeing, and this isn't specifically tied to, to a- any particular indigenous population or, or, or any population, but this, uh, idea now we've got, uh, these, these, uh, two main drug companies have developed the mRNA vaccines, but developed them in participation with, uh, at least one federal government that threw billions of dollars at it and contributed their own scientific expertise.
220
00:41:37.175 --> 00:41:51.416
And now you've got, yes, it did help the most and everyone, but who is profiting from it is exclusively exactly who you'd expect it to be, and now they're refusing to both share those profits, but also the patents that are driving those profits.
221
00:41:51.456 --> 00:42:02.686
And so once again, the low income populations of the planet, the most marginalized, four billion people are not receiving the output, which is where is the benefit, right? And where is the equity in that?
222
00:42:03.216 --> 00:42:10.856
If those people aren't protected, if, if only certain, you know, capitalistic corporations are benefiting from it, then, then, then we're doing it all over again.
223
00:42:10.876 --> 00:42:22.336
And it seems like that's the same thing, if, if I'm understanding it correctly, with this idea of, "No, we're, we're not gonna give you [laughs] the, the DNA because you haven't proven that there's an equity for us on the other side of this."
224
00:42:23.296 --> 00:42:31.936
Exactly. We cannot equate equity of participation with equity of- Mm-hmm... benefiting. And, and this is what we're, we're really calling to, to push.
225
00:42:32.136 --> 00:42:40.036
Like if you're gonna create technologies based off of our people's DNA- Mm-hmm... then we need to talk about a more direct path in which we benefit.
226
00:42:40.476 --> 00:42:51.756
What has happened is that scientists will enter indigenous communities, and they'll overpromise something that they can't deliver. They'll overpromise on the delivery of genomic and precision medicine and health. Mm-hmm.
227
00:42:51.796 --> 00:42:53.276
It is not unlike... Let's see.
228
00:42:53.676 --> 00:43:09.216
So a New York Times reporter went back to the Cristiano, which is a central Amazonian community, in like 2007, and he basically asked them, um, you know, "What was it that scientists promised you, um, in exchange for access to your genomic da- data?"
229
00:43:09.796 --> 00:43:18.496
And the people stated, "Well, we were promised, you know, innovations and access to medicine that was gonna treat the things that were, were, were killing us in our communities."
230
00:43:19.076 --> 00:43:24.908
And, you know, the reporter was like, "Well-Did those medicines ever arrive? Like, no.
231
00:43:25.468 --> 00:43:35.718
But the reporter did state, though, that their, um, access to the genomic information was being sold by Coriell Cell Repositories for, like, seventy-five or eighty-five dollars a vial [laughs]
232
00:43:36.188 --> 00:43:52.728
um, which, you know, is not dissimilar to the profit by which, uh, 23andMe, and Ancestry, and all these other companies have had based off of their, their people's DNA, um, 'cause they're one of the, um, HGVP, uh, Indigenous populations Mm-hmm So yeah.
233
00:43:53.348 --> 00:44:19.368
You know, there sh- one of the reasons why US Indigenous peoples have at least voiced to us at the beginning of, um, the Native BioData Consortium and why they don't participate in federally funded research is that in the US, data that is collected from federally funded research has to be collected into a repository, again, with the underlying assumption that it will, um, advance, um, health and, and science and, and the rate of innovation, right?
234
00:44:20.008 --> 00:44:31.788
But what this does is it takes Indigenous peoples', um, DNA, if they participate, and it makes that, those data decisions related to access outside of tribal hands.
235
00:44:32.488 --> 00:44:35.488
And tribal leaders basically say, "We don't wanna, we don't wanna do that.
236
00:44:35.728 --> 00:44:49.608
We have a sovereign right to be able to have a say in what happens to the data that is collected from us, and we have a say in terms of, of, um, s- you know, even to, um,
237
00:44:50.528 --> 00:45:01.148
uh, to not have our DNA being involved in studies that have absolutely noth- no interest for us," like for instance, ancient DNA studies, which are not really of interest to Indigenous people.
238
00:45:01.228 --> 00:45:12.948
So, you know, they were just fundamentally not engaging in research. So what we thought was of a good alternative solution was to re- create a tribally managed biological and data repository.
239
00:45:12.978 --> 00:45:40.208
So if tri- if tribes were interested in working, um, in, in, in partnering with researchers, then they would entrust that data to a tribally managed entity, and then researchers would have to come to us or that tribally managed entity in order to gain access to the research, which means that they have to undergo tribal, uh, research governances and proc- processes for approval in order to gain access to that DNA.
240
00:45:40.308 --> 00:45:50.308
So at least then the tribes actually have a say in what types of data- Sure... is being accessed. Governance. And also it's just i- in terms of also saying, like, what, what people they actually trust.
241
00:45:50.408 --> 00:46:06.488
And it's, we've been able to do this because at this point in time we have the largest cohort of scientists who are Indigenous, who come from communities, and we have been able to leverage that new talent and expertise.
242
00:46:06.518 --> 00:46:15.948
And those individuals pr- um, primarily comprise our directors, our board advisors, um, and also the researchers that we work with.
243
00:46:16.068 --> 00:46:29.948
So we really, really, uh, rely on working and building these connections with, with researchers and communities that understand that this goal, and we're really grateful that we've been so successful in the, in the past couple years.
244
00:46:30.648 --> 00:46:45.008
Um, and how I get caught into it was more the fact that I just happened to have, be in the right place at the right time in terms of, of foreseeing the needs to have Indigenous scientists who also had this bioethical implications of, of data.
245
00:46:45.568 --> 00:46:59.748
And, um, so I do wear a lot of hats, and I use every single one of them [laughs] in my work. Um, and I do have more work than I have hours of the day, but I love it. It is ul- ultimately fulfilling.
246
00:47:00.148 --> 00:47:14.217
But if you asked me, um, you know, five or so years ago if I was going to be, uh, entering the space of, of becoming a scientist/entrepreneur, like, I would've thought you were pulling my tail or something [laughs]
247
00:47:14.348 --> 00:47:25.628
So, and, and you can f- ple- please feel free of course to, to say, uh, n- not interested in sharing, or we can't share, or whatever it might be or, or, or even as far as just, uh, you know, speak in generalities.
248
00:47:25.708 --> 00:47:51.588
But, but now that the consortium, uh, exists, and there is cooperation, and there is, uh, governance, and there are, uh, both philosophies and methodologies to, to how, um, I, I imagine you are encouraging participation, garnering trust, and, and thinking about if, and if so, how to use the data that has been collected with permission, with that trust.
249
00:47:52.468 --> 00:47:57.768
Are there projects that are actively being worked on from that data?
250
00:47:57.857 --> 00:48:15.488
And how do you go about, I guess, identifying what, uh, both the priorities and also w- what is gonna be, um, most beneficial, uh, in, in every way to the tribes that gave, uh, a- and the people within those tribes that, that, uh, participated in giving their data?
251
00:48:16.268 --> 00:48:26.728
Sure. [laughs] That's, that's a huge question. So just collecting- I guess it's like what's next?... and housing data... Yeah, no, collecting and housing data is one challenge, right?
252
00:48:26.748 --> 00:48:35.488
But then, um, what you do with that data is an entirely different question. So a biobank, at its very minimum, can just be a freezer holding samples, right?
253
00:48:35.508 --> 00:49:04.748
But if you wanna do something useful for it, you know, you have to have a lot of other, um, ethical and legal
frameworks that are in place, and that's actually what we spent the last two years doing, is working with tribal lawyers and tribal leaders and, um, a non-tribal firm that is related to intellectual property, just so that we can build up legal protections and, um, standard legal language in terms of, like, ensuring that data-sharing policies are actually, like, equitable for tribes.
254
00:49:05.228 --> 00:49:32.468
Because what h- what we noticed as we were starting to talk about partnerships, particularly with universities, is that universities, obviously, like, they, they have institutional review boards that are supposed to, like, ethically govern how they work with, uh, with human, uh, participants in research, but those i-Entities are very centered on protecting the university's right to access, um, and their rights to, um, claim intellectual property.
255
00:49:33.048 --> 00:49:46.868
So for instance, one of the major universities that we work with, they have a policy in which they will refuse to cede review to any other, um, institutional review board, including other tribes' research regulatory processes.
256
00:49:46.928 --> 00:49:56.278
So they're already stating, you know, "It's our way that approves it or no- nothing." Or, or you can't basically, you know, use us as a partner in your, in your research grant.
257
00:49:56.768 --> 00:50:08.248
And then, you know, there's something called the Bayh-Dole Act in which, um, basically it protects universities', uh, right to claim intellectual property on technological innovations.
258
00:50:08.868 --> 00:50:20.608
So universities have this legal protection for, for IP, but not tribes. Tri- if a tribe doesn't have their own legal laws in place, then, you know, they're just le- left unprotected.
259
00:50:20.688 --> 00:50:33.508
So we- we're, we're really, like, starting from scratch in terms of ensuring that tribes re- retain ownership of intellectual property from their own people's DNA, and that's actually where we have spent the last one to two years is our own legal education.
260
00:50:33.968 --> 00:50:41.648
[laughs] Um, and then we're also been able, because of COVID, we're, we're also extending into this public health sphere.
261
00:50:41.728 --> 00:50:53.108
We are en- wanting to ensure that samples collected from community members are related to COVID, that those samples are held locally and tested locally.
262
00:50:53.148 --> 00:51:16.588
What used to happen, uh, what still happens unfortunately, um, is that wh- when the pandemic started, uh, many tribes, most tribes didn't have their own local testing facilities, and they would have to either send out their samples to, like, a, a public health resource or even to, uh, companies that were creating these, um, COVID detection assays, right?
263
00:51:17.108 --> 00:51:28.508
And that actually put genetic data in proprietary hands [laughs] that, you know, they had no, um, uh, sovereignty over and no protections over, and that's their
genetic data.
264
00:51:28.588 --> 00:51:35.888
So now we don't know how many companies have had access to genomic information from indigenous peoples and, you know, that was just part of the pandemic.
265
00:51:35.988 --> 00:51:56.398
So what we created was a, a tribal public health surveillance program in which we are ensuring that that data is housed locally, tested locally, and also ensures that we don't have this huge lag period in which somebody has to wait, like, two weeks for their test results to come back and meanwhile maybe, uh, unfortunately infecting other people.
266
00:51:56.668 --> 00:52:08.168
Now you can turn around those results a lot quicker because, you know, the sample is just down the street as opposed to several states away, and then you can perhaps mitigate the spread and transmission o- of the virus.
267
00:52:08.388 --> 00:52:17.508
So that's one thing that we're, we're working on. We're also working with a number of tribal communities that want to set their own biobanks. It doesn't have to be, um, human, um, samples.
268
00:52:17.548 --> 00:52:22.808
It could be things like creating their own seed biobanks. Yeah, there's actually a lot of interest in that.
269
00:52:23.088 --> 00:52:38.747
Like, for instance, um, museums have had archives of, like, indigenous samples of plants, and because, you know, big agriculture has created these huge monolithic cultures, uh, monocultures, right, there's a, there's a huge threat to, like, genetic diversity.
270
00:52:38.948 --> 00:52:56.118
So like, for instance, um, the, the, the banana plant that we have is actually under risk of, of, um, of perhaps being totally obliterated, uh, because I think, I think it's the Cavendish species o- of banana plant is really open to susceptibility of disease.
271
00:52:56.118 --> 00:53:02.048
I remember reading something about that. So there, there- Which is basically like I don't think people realize bananas are going bye bye. Yeah.
272
00:53:02.488 --> 00:53:16.398
And so now, you know, agriculture's looking to these museum archived samples of indigenous plants to sort of, you know, re-integrate back into their species, but that's, you know, a, a, a form of exploitation of indigenous knowledges, right?
273
00:53:16.988 --> 00:53:21.997
Um, there's a battle... So, like, there's this huge interest in s- you know, indigenous seeds.
274
00:53:21.997 --> 00:53:31.558
Um- Well, the same thing as, you know, California dealing, you know, now going, "Oh, wait, it turns out, uh, we should have been listening to indigenous people and how they managed forests for thousands of years," because
275
00:53:32.508 --> 00:53:42.118
... Oh, my... Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Indigenous science is always considered, like, this fringe thing or this alternative hypothesis, but when it services supposed Western science- Sure...
276
00:53:42.168 --> 00:53:49.508
then we're deemed useful, which is another form of- Sure... extraction and exploitation of- Yeah... our knowledges. So
[laughs] it's all integrated.
277
00:53:49.548 --> 00:53:57.898
Like, for us as indigenous peoples, like, we don't have, like, these weird arbitrary definitions of what constitutes human versus- Mm-hmm... non-human. We steward all types of data, which is- Mm...
278
00:53:57.968 --> 00:54:18.548
awesome, and it also speaks to the fact that as a geneticist, I am so annoyed with the prioritization and preemption of, of genomic data as being, like, the, the means of, of studying health disparities 'cause only, like, up to 50% of diseases are, are heritable.
279
00:54:19.148 --> 00:54:28.668
A lot of it has to do with, um, uh, non-genetic factors that relate to disease, like structural barriers- Sure. Oh, yeah... related to disease, environmental factors. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
280
00:54:28.698 --> 00:54:32.568
And we're not studying these things. No, of course not. Um, and- There, there, there- No... there are systems that we- Like, okay...
281
00:54:32.648 --> 00:54:43.948
have designed that are so inescapable, like, uh, even the idea of them are inescapable for so many marginalized peoples in the US and, and, and elsewhere, um, that, you know, to, to not consider them is just gross negligence.
282
00:54:44.058 --> 00:54:49.368
Like, you can't just look at the DNA. I mean, I, I think of, a- again, this is a totally different version, but the research...
283
00:54:49.568 --> 00:54:56.008
Oh, gosh, I'm totally forgetting the gentleman's name, uh, who w- um, does the Blue Zones research. Have you heard about this?
284
00:54:56.488 --> 00:55:13.708
He, he's worked with National Geographic forever, and basically he's identified the places around the world and, and the unifying sort of, I don't remember what it is, seven or eight, um, sort of building blocks where the people live the longest but also the healthiest essentially and how they can be in totally different places but these are the things.
285
00:55:14.168 --> 00:55:17.468
And one of his i- initial identifications was
286
00:55:18.388 --> 00:55:38.492
the things, uh, like you were just saying but almost the inverse, what makes these folks live the longest, healthiest is only something like 20% genetic and 80% of it is all of these other factors that, that in the West we are both happy to ignore or invert and just totally ruin.From junk food to sitting to, uh, you know, isolating people, et cetera, et cetera.
287
00:55:39.132 --> 00:55:44.432
Yeah. No, that's actually accurate. It's, uh, I go into, uh, conferences all the time.
288
00:55:44.812 --> 00:55:59.892
Like, for instance, I just presented at a Society for Clinical Pharmacology conference, and I basically told them, like, we are over-promising on things that we can't deliver, we are over-prioritizing genetic information and their contributors toward disease, and really we should be thinking of structural factors.
289
00:56:00.212 --> 00:56:13.402
A- and, uh, the statistics I cited to them was, like, in 2018, so right before the pandemic, uh, the Indian Health Services spent 2.4 times, um, less, uh, per patient than the national per capita spending for- Wow...
290
00:56:13.402 --> 00:56:24.792
healthcare. So I'm all like, um, yeah, when COVID hit, right, the communities that were hit the hardest were, were Black, Indigenous communities, and also tribal communities.
291
00:56:24.862 --> 00:56:32.422
And tribal communities, um, just to seek preventative healthcare, some of them have to drive three, four hours in one way- Sure... just to be able to see a clinic. Sure.
292
00:56:32.452 --> 00:56:43.112
So I'm like, maybe we should be thinking more along the structural, uh, access to, to disparities in health than just claiming everything to be genetic, and that is my critique as a geneticist.
293
00:56:43.282 --> 00:56:45.752
[laughs] Well, sure, but I mean, you, it's...
294
00:56:45.812 --> 00:56:58.172
I'm so inclined, and part of this is having young children who do this to me all day, but it's, it's this, this methodology of just going why, why, why, why, why until you get to the bottom of things where you think wider with more nuanced and layered context.
295
00:56:58.232 --> 00:57:29.312
But, you know, like you're saying, uh, over-promising and under-delivering, I mean, per- we've been talking about, and it's been on the cover of Mag- Personalized Medicine for, for h- for how long now, and maybe it's time to take a step back and go, maybe the reason it's not working isn't because of, uh, you know, these, these h- uh, hyper expensive personalized medicines, and it's these enormous structural barriers and food deserts and all of these different things and, and the air pollution and the water, uh, that are, that just nullify anything you're gonna do with medicine if it works in the first place.
296
00:57:30.792 --> 00:57:37.412
Precision... Personalized medicine is such a misnomer anyway. We're writing a paper on just this. We just had a con- a conversation about this before this phone call.
297
00:57:37.852 --> 00:57:50.532
So, um, personalized medicine makes sense from a clinician's point of view in that a clinician's, their, their, their, their point of care is each individual, so they, they're considered with one individual's, um, uh, personal care and their data.
298
00:57:51.372 --> 00:57:57.032
Fine. To everyone else in the world, though, um, that accesses health data, like, it's a misnomer.
299
00:57:57.132 --> 00:58:13.452
So personalized medicine became precision medicine, and, um, precision medicine, especially related to genomic medicine, is basically defining, um, biological groups by at-risk categories, like who is at risk for this disease versus who is at risk for this other disease, right?
300
00:58:13.912 --> 00:58:30.412
And then those, when those strata, when those groups are defined by racial and ethnic categories, so then you get into racial medicine, which is opening up a whole floodgate of, of issues because, like, one, um, Indigenous person's not the same
genetically as another Indigenous person.
301
00:58:30.452 --> 00:58:36.352
One white person's not the same as another white person. A Latino person, it could be genetically diverse from another Latino person.
302
00:58:36.392 --> 00:58:43.521
These are just, like, really broad social categories that are dangerous when you over-biologicize them. Well, I mean- Right?...
303
00:58:43.572 --> 00:59:03.432
w- our, our conversation with, uh, Lauren Under- Lauren Underwood, uh, Representative Underwood, about, um, you know, about the Black, uh, people who identify as women, as, as birthing persons, I'm trying to use the correct language here, uh, are nationally two to four times more likely to die in the year after childbirth.
304
00:59:03.492 --> 00:59:13.852
Uh, but in her home state, it's six times as likely, right? And that's not a biological [laughs] thing. That is a societal construct that we, that h- we have built and is probably working to, to plan.
305
00:59:13.892 --> 00:59:21.152
It's not something that's broken. That's designed this way. And by trying to, like you're saying, trying to get into the, the racial medicine side, it is not that way.
306
00:59:21.212 --> 00:59:41.032
Otherwise, when, you know, uh, Serena Williams and Beyoncé published their stories about their, their miscarriages and, and, and Serena Williams almost bleeding out, uh, in her, in her delivery room after she had her baby, uh, you know, if there was a biological answer, a, a medicinal answer, she could've afforded it, and it would've been available, but that's not what that was.
307
00:59:41.072 --> 00:59:48.852
It was doctors who don't listen to her and a whole system that's failed her, uh, uh, you know, for generations, and we just keep repeating that. Yeah. Exactly.
308
00:59:48.952 --> 00:59:59.492
I'm not gonna say that, you know, these, uh, that genetic ancestry is not useful- Of course not... for some things. It's just, it's just not useful for everything, and especially building... Like,
309
01:00:00.812 --> 01:00:11.892
scientifically reifying these social categories of, of basically human diseases without also considering the social underlying causes- Mm-hmm... is just irresponsible and is illogical.
310
01:00:12.492 --> 01:00:18.732
We really just should be thinking about these societal factors related to disease. So another one, I'll give you another one. Like,
311
01:00:19.832 --> 01:00:26.752
uh, Native Americans, a common negative stereotype about us is that we are supposedly genetically predisposed to alcoholism, right?
312
01:00:27.252 --> 01:00:39.312
So the, the NIH has funded, um, uh, has published over 200 papers over the last several decades about looking at genetic variants associated with alcoholism in Native American communities. Right. Right?
313
01:00:39.392 --> 01:00:49.542
So they're, like, searching already w- with this, like, circling towards this, um, preempted, uh, uh, uh, story that they wanna create about us, right? Right.
314
01:00:49.552 --> 01:00:58.912
But turns out if you look epidemiologically, just on data, most, in tribal nations in the US actually don't have higher rates of alcoholism compared to other populations.
315
01:00:58.942 --> 01:01:11.012
And in fact, in some cases, their rates of alcoholism is even less. Um, [laughs] but, you know, this, this stereotype continues to be perpetuated against us, and it's so demoralizing and demeaning.
316
01:01:11.092 --> 01:01:17.032
And it's so difficult to escape, again, just like the practical systems themselves are, are difficult to, to escape.
317
01:01:17.172 --> 01:01:27.672
I mean, a huge, uh, sort of, uh, canary in the coal mine for me and, and, and how I try to understand and think about things and listen to process was the incredible book, uh, The New Jim Crow.
318
01:01:28.032 --> 01:01:33.632
Uh, just, uh, uh, it's just, you just go, "Oh, the, this is how this is designed."
319
01:01:33.752 --> 01:01:50.828
And, and any of these biological stuff, again, not that it's not important and not that it, it, it, uh, can't be an inclination to other things, but, but it's almost the last piece of the puzzle because if you don't undo these other things, it doesn't matterYou know, it's like when you say like, "Oh, Black kids are, are twice as likely to have asthma."
320
01:01:50.948 --> 01:01:59.898
It's like, okay, but why? It's 'cause they live next to coal plants, you know? And that's because we made housing unaffordable, and we redlined everywhere. And like, uh, you can just keep doing this.
321
01:01:59.968 --> 01:02:12.788
It's, it's not that difficult, but apparently it is. Um, and so it's, it's understandable when 574 tribes say, "We're, we're not giving you your DNA, man." [laughs] Like, there's, there's no equity here.
322
01:02:12.808 --> 01:02:23.908
There's no benefit. Um, it's really important that everybody has knowledge of these issues, uh, and the underlying ethics behind all this, because it effectively... well, ultimately affects everybody. Mm-hmm.
323
01:02:24.548 --> 01:02:33.168
So these issues related to data privacy and consent affect not just indigenous peoples, not just, uh, peoples of color, but all people.
324
01:02:33.788 --> 01:02:43.028
So there have been a number of studies that have shown that, um, for people that don't understand all the intricacies of, of research consent forms- Mm...
325
01:02:43.048 --> 01:02:53.218
that there's, um, there can be a confusion between research and also clinical care, especially, like for instance, if a patient is gonna go into a university hospital- Mm...
326
01:02:53.218 --> 01:03:02.208
or a clinical setting, and, um, they're asked to be recruited into a medical study, right? Sometimes there's a confusion about...
327
01:03:02.258 --> 01:03:11.418
there's actually a huge amount of confusion sometimes ab- that, that their clinical care, it can, is tied to their participation in research. That is a huge problem. Mm-hmm.
328
01:03:11.448 -->
01:03:14.668
Okay, that's also considered clinical genetic tests, right? Mm-hmm.
329
01:03:15.088 --> 01:03:32.448
When your provider, um, recommends that somebody takes a clinical genetic test, what they're doing is they're providing access to a third party, the makers of that clinical test, to provide access to one's individual genome or everyone that they're biologically related to, but that's a commercial entity.
330
01:03:32.548 --> 01:03:44.128
Sure. And it's really fascinating because, um, it, there really very few clinical genetic testing companies have opt-out policies, data sharing opt-out policies.
331
01:03:44.828 --> 01:03:59.508
Um- [laughs] I'm, I'm just thinking of- And you're still- Without g- without, without sharing too much, I'm thinking my wife and I had, had an impossible time m- making our children and had to do a lot of IVF and, and there was a, a phenomenal amount of testing involved, and we never actually discovered why we had such a hard time.
332
01:03:59.548 --> 01:04:10.237
We were very lucky to eventually be able to, um, uh, m- make, make some babies. Um, but I can't imagine the forms e- that I eventually was just like, "Yeah, fine." Like, whatever gets us to the answer.
333
01:04:10.388 --> 01:04:20.897
I, I cannot even imagine what I've signed away at this point. Yeah, I had that same issue. Um, and I know how valuable, uh, companies find, uh, supposedly Native American DNA.
334
01:04:21.648 --> 01:04:30.198
Um, I, I was at the American Society of Human Genetics meeting a few years ago, which is like the largest, uh, worldwide conference of the geneticists in the world. Mm.
335
01:04:30.328 --> 01:04:32.448
If it's not the largest, it's like the second largest.
336
01:04:33.028 --> 01:04:41.908
And I had a question related to 23andMe and some university-partnered research, so I went downstairs to their booth, their exhibitor booth, and I got ahold of the technical advisor. And I like...
337
01:04:41.928 --> 01:04:50.718
He basically looked at me and was like, "Oh, you're Native American? Can I give you a free test to everyone, all your friends and family?" Um- [sighs] Like, oh my God. Wow. They just do it live.
338
01:04:50.748 --> 01:04:59.858
Way to reduce- Like, they're just like [laughs] they're not even being subtle. Way to reduce the sci... I know. W-way to reduce a supposed scientific colleague to the color of my skin, right? Sure.
339
01:04:59.868 --> 01:05:06.708
And, and the utility for the company. In the booth. And, and exactly. Exactly. At the fricking genetics conference. Yeah.
340
01:05:06.768 --> 01:05:19.488
A-and this happens all the time where 23andMe and Ancestry and other, uh, genetic sites will just set up booths at like tribal fairs, and, um, in some cases they'll prey on like missing and murdered indigenous women.
341
01:05:19.548 --> 01:05:35.308
Like, "Hey, you wanna find your missing relative? Provide us your DNA. We'll deposit into a database, a data set, um- Oh my God... so that it can
help you find a solution better." [outro music] Hey, everyone, it's Quinn.
342
01:05:36.068 --> 01:05:50.188
Have you ever looked around your job and thought, "What are we even doing here?" If you've ever wanted to take your skills to more impactful work, to do world-changing work, let me tell you, now's the time.
343
01:05:50.788 --> 01:05:56.348
With just one click, you can find a job that does that work at importantjobs.com.
344
01:05:57.128 --> 01:06:12.968
Important Jobs is for journalists, students, engineers, software developers, accountants, designers, nurses, research assistants, people who wanna work in clean energy, consumer products, health tech, agriculture, and artificial intelligence.
345
01:06:13.948 --> 01:06:24.608
And if you work for a company or organization already doing that work, you can list your open roles at Important Jobs for competitive rates and get them in front of our entire community.
346
01:06:25.588 --> 01:06:41.648
Reinvigorate your career on the frontlines of the future at importantjobs.com. Back to the show. I, I, I could have this conversation all day, but your time is just so, so valuable to, to so many other people.
347
01:06:41.708 --> 01:06:48.728
Um, I, I wanna just talk about one thing that's a little less, uh, a little less, what do they call it these days, hard science.
348
01:06:49.128 --> 01:07:07.468
Uh, before we get into really specific action steps that our community can take, whether they i-identify, uh, and, and are part of a, a, a tribe anywhere in the world, or, um, they're someone who looks a little bit m- more like me, and, and the answer might be like, "Leave us alone," or, "Do this," but we're game for whatever you say.
349
01:07:07.588 --> 01:07:11.988
But before that, because we are also in this moment of
350
01:07:12.968 --> 01:07:25.528
there, there are some, some battles going on, both, I think, internally within a lot of people, but also, you know, obviously in the courts about governess- governance and identity over our own persons, over our own bodies, right?
351
01:07:25.648 --> 01:07:39.008
Because like you were saying, who we are isn't just our genetic makeup. It is our culture. It is, um, uh... But forever we framed it ridiculously, right, so simplistically as nature versus nurture.
352
01:07:39.448 --> 01:07:50.788
But it ignores, um, the, all of the different inputs and variants of those and how they combine and, and it ignores, um, you know, this i-idea of like it, it's, it's how we feel in our bodies. It's, it's how we live.
353
01:07:50.828 --> 01:08:00.268
It's who we live with. It's how we were raised, the languages we, we may have spoke when we were growing up or we sp- now, speak now. It's, it's, it's who we choose to surround ourselves with.
354
01:08:00.368 --> 01:08:20.708
So, um, I, I know you've written a little bit about, um-This idea of uncoupling DNA and identity and, and what they mean to us and how we are judged by others and accepted, what, what does that,
what does that mean for you now in this crazy period where the news seems to change every day and, and you've got fights over, um, you know, can trans kids go in the bathroom or not?
355
01:08:20.788 --> 01:08:31.748
And, and how does that apply to your work? And I know this is kind of a different pivot, but I, I did, I felt bereft not engaging in this because it does obviously matter to so many people. Yeah.
356
01:08:32.048 --> 01:08:36.328
So this is so complex- I know, I know... when you look at it I feel like it could be an entirely different discussion.
357
01:08:36.388 --> 01:08:47.048
We can do that if- It really- And I'm happy to do that, but I, I know it really does matter I mean, for one thing, we're not just one thing. Yeah Right? We belong to multiple communities, and
358
01:08:48.388 --> 01:08:56.768
we should be embracing those identities, um, to the extent that it embraces us back, right?
359
01:08:56.888 --> 01:09:08.067
Um, a huge part of people wanting to claim genetically, um, uh, creating indigenous claims is a, a sense of wanting to belong somewhere, right?
360
01:09:08.168 --> 01:09:15.508
That, that's kind of what we're, we're talking about is this human, um, want to connect to something somewhere.
361
01:09:16.078 --> 01:09:28.608
And this is possibly why we get a lot of, um, fetishization of indigenous cultures from people of European descent because, um, you know, there have been papers that have substantiated this.
362
01:09:28.638 --> 01:09:42.298
It's not just my own anecdotal experience, although that also adds to it. Like, you know, Europeans, um, you know, they don't feel, uh, they feel like a dif- they don't feel like a, a concrete tie to their ancestors.
363
01:09:42.348 --> 01:09:52.188
It's too diffuse in terms of the number of heritages from which they, they, they came. So they feel like mutts in a way, and that's their wording, not mine. [laughs] And I don't know.
364
01:09:52.208 --> 01:09:59.948
There's something ti- it's, it's intriguing about being tied to the exotic or something that's really tangible geographically, like indigenous cultures, right?
365
01:10:00.608 --> 01:10:16.168
Um, and so there's a, there's a lot of instances in areas in the US of people wanting to falsely claim indigeneity, like for instance in the Southeast, um, and South, which has a huge complex, uh, racial history com- uh, related to all the different identities.
366
01:10:16.508 --> 01:10:27.118
So, you know, just using that as a microcosm for people just wanting to belong somewhere, um, you know, many people look to, to genetics as an easy fix. And I say that- Mm-hmm...
367
01:10:27.138 --> 01:10:34.597
as an easy fix because, um, I used to volunteer for the Native American Indian Association of Tennessee. It's just a nonprofit there. Mm-hmm.
368
01:10:34.648 --> 01:10:45.428
And, um, people would call in daily saying, "Oh, I took this genetic test, and I'm 10% Native. Can I get a tribal enrollment card so that I can get a free house?"
369
01:10:45.888 --> 01:10:53.308
So there's some insidious, um, you know, wants to claim- [laughs]... indigeneity because there's this perceived, um, gain there. Mm-hmm.
370
01:10:53.338 --> 01:11:04.138
But then also there are just individuals that don't want to do the work of genetic genealogy because some people will say, ask like, "Well, how... What is the legitimate way to claim indigeneity?"
371
01:11:04.588 --> 01:11:15.228
It's like, well, family history, family records, going through census rolls. And, oh, it's too much work, which is also horrible for me to hear as a Native person. Like, oh, great.
372
01:11:15.348 --> 01:11:24.888
Like, you wanna be one of us so badly, but it's so much work for you. You're gonna ha- if you actually were a Native American, you'd find it really difficult to exist as a Native person.
373
01:11:24.908 --> 01:11:30.708
I'll just tell you that considering how much backlash we get just from merely existing. So maybe you should, um, rethink that.
374
01:11:30.788 --> 01:11:49.568
But going back to the larger question of belonging, I think sometimes people look as genetics as too easy of a solution to, to create these senses of belongingness, but really they should just be thinking about the communities that they already exist in, um, and really thinking about embracing those because there's, there's numerous layers to our identities.
375
01:11:49.608 --> 01:12:00.368
And, um, and when you think of it that way, then over biologizing it re- removes the beauty and the diversity of all those experiences. So I don't know.
376
01:12:00.408 --> 01:12:11.928
I'm just hoping that people really think about, um, creating community and connections in places that are legitimate and more proximal to them rather than trying to falsely create these claims. I love that.
377
01:12:11.968 --> 01:12:19.208
Thank you for that. That's a very thoughtful answer to a ridiculously complex question. Um, I, I, I thought of something, and this is a little off beat. One second.
378
01:12:19.248 --> 01:12:34.688
There's a, um, there's a book/cookbook that's available, I think it's a couple years old, um, now, called The Cooking Gene, and it's by a gentleman named Michael Twitty, uh, who's an African American gentleman, but, um, also identifies, like you were saying, like w- no one's a monolith, right?
379
01:12:34.788 --> 01:12:36.548
And, and no one wants to be identified that way.
380
01:12:36.588 --> 01:12:54.608
And he talks about basically how did food come from all these different countries and cultures and peoples in Africa and make its way to the American South, but also what does it mean for him and his history and all his different places, but also the ways he identifies as an African American man, as a gay gentleman, as a Jewish man.
381
01:12:54.668 --> 01:13:03.988
Like, a- and it's one of the most beautiful books I've ever read, and I recommend it to anyone. So, um, and, and it just talks about delicious food the
entire time, so there's just that as well.
382
01:13:04.028 --> 01:13:07.248
[laughs] Um, but I thought you would appreciate that because, um, you know,
383
01:13:08.368 --> 01:13:20.848
the, the, the biological, uh, you know, biomarkers are, are there, but his point is, like, yeah, but what does it, what else does it mean, and what else makes me me, and what else makes food important to people and how we nourish people through stories and, and things like that?
384
01:13:20.908 --> 01:13:26.588
So anyways, I can't recommend that one enough. All right. There's a point... There's... Sorry. There's a point to be made- Sure...
385
01:13:26.598 --> 01:13:42.368
here in that even these categories, these social con- categories of, um, of a, of peoples is arbitrary 'cause it's based off of a definition based on one point in time, a cross-sectional point of history, and peoples move all the time.
386
01:13:42.468 --> 01:13:58.088
Um, just to give you an for instance, uh, the Navajo Nation, um, as it's defined now, right, is kind of a recent colonial definition based off of when we were recognized by the federal government, and that's just been perpetuated since then.
387
01:13:58.148 --> 01:14:10.508
Because before then, as a peoples, we recognized that we were a construct of many peoples. So, um, we used to have over 400 clans. Unfortunately, due to genocidal factors, it's now, like, more like 100 to 200.
388
01:14:10.988 --> 01:14:19.428
But we have, we acknowledge, like, when, for instance, one of my four clans is Mexican peoples clans. Um, there's Zuni clan. There is a Ute clan, right?
389
01:14:19.588 --> 01:14:30.888
And it's, these are part of the umbrella of, of what constitutes Navajo peoples, but it recognizes that we came from other places and we have incorporated all these different identities of other peoples in our spaces.
390
01:14:30.918 --> 01:14:33.928
And it's the same thing for food to use your analogies.
391
01:14:34.028 --> 01:14:46.960
Um, what constitutes, um, Southern culture is just an amalgam of a much different identities in terms of spaces, and it's just that we happen from this point or an arbitrary point of time to, like, just overcategorize it so-I love that.
392
01:14:47.320 --> 01:14:57.620
Um, okay, listen, uh, we're gonna get you out of here in a second, but, but, you know, one of our sort of our bread and butter is these, these action steps as we put them. So I'm gonna sort of l-leave this to you.
393
01:14:58.100 --> 01:15:17.659
How can our community, again, which is a widely varied community of professionals and students, and, um, you know, all these different folks from, from so many different places comprised of so many different things, but they're unified in the sense that they, they give a shit, and they like to take action and support good things and good people, and that is, that is definitively you, uh, Crystal.
394
01:15:18.100 --> 01:15:28.120
So what... How can they best, uh, support your efforts and your work and the projects you're working on? Give us... I mean, I'm talking like, what is the URL? Like, what are we doing here?
395
01:15:28.480 --> 01:15:41.080
Uh, one, you can donate money to the Native Bio Data Consortium. We're a nonprofit. Awesome. Uh, we would be happy to receive your, um, tax-deductible donation. But also just learn and read things that you are signing.
396
01:15:41.200 --> 01:15:51.740
Okay. Um, you know, these, these issues related to like genomic privacy bleed into data privacy, which, uh, and algorithms lead into like, um, data social and informational justice.
397
01:15:52.320 --> 01:15:59.260
How many people read the EULA, the end user license agreement for Facebook? And, you know- No one. [laughs] Similarly, yeah.
398
01:15:59.380 --> 01:16:08.240
Similarly, you should be paying attention to the informed consent forms that you're signing, uh, when you're, um, at the doctor's office, and somebody asks you to, um, sign on to research.
399
01:16:08.280 --> 01:16:15.770
And also understand that your DNA is not just your own right to privacy, but also everyone you're biologically related to. Sure.
400
01:16:15.770 --> 01:16:26.760
So we really need to think in terms of not just steward- data ownership, but also data stewardship. Sure. And also just understanding that we are connected to other peoples besides our own spheres. I, I love that.
401
01:16:26.780 --> 01:16:35.320
Thank you. I, I couldn't put together a more thoughtful sentence if I tried. That is so helpful. What is, uh, what is literally the place that people would go to donate to the consortium?
402
01:16:36.980 --> 01:16:48.700
Oh, go to na- uh, www.nativebio.org, and then- Perfect... you'll find a link at the bottom. Awesome. Well, we'll put that in the show notes too. Last question for you before, uh, I, I get you out of here, Crystal.
403
01:16:49.080 --> 01:16:57.380
Um, what is a book you... To preface, we have a whole list on Bookshop, which supports independent bookstores, of our guest recommendations. It's a specific question.
404
01:16:57.480 --> 01:17:07.660
What is a book you've read this year that's opened your mind to a topic or an idea or a question you hadn't considered before, or that has actually changed your thinking in some way?
405
01:17:08.080 --> 01:17:18.030
So first, um, I had a book in mind before you had the coffee of this year. First book, Native American DNA- I mean, I don't care. Say, say all the books you want. [laughs] Native American DNA by Kim TallBear. Okay.
406
01:17:18.060 --> 01:17:29.560
Like, if you're interested in genetics and indigeneity, that's the book to go to. Okay. This year I picked up, uh, Data Feminism- Ooh... by Catherine D'Ignazio- Okay... and Lauren Klein. Okay. I love this.
407
01:17:30.040 --> 01:17:40.670
Um, we've heard of big dic- big dick energy, right? Oh, 1000%, yeah. Um, [laughs] and they draw characterizations between like the masculinity for collectivizing this data- Mm-hmm...
408
01:17:40.860 --> 01:17:53.000
as like just this big push, a big data era, big dick energy. Yeah. I don't know, just calling into like the humanity and, and, uh, justice of relating to these data science decisions, and I love it. I love it.
409
01:17:53.060 --> 01:17:59.380
That is awesome. I'm definitely gonna dig into them. We'll put, we'll put them in the show notes, and we'll put them on our list where everyone, uh, can find them.
410
01:17:59.740 --> 01:18:08.810
Uh, last one, where can our listeners, uh, follow you and your work online, Crystal? Uh, most of my... Uh, I'm a private person, but I do have a Twitter profile. Okay.
411
01:18:08.990 --> 01:18:20.900
So if you just do Twitter, @K-S-T-O-S-I-E, Kstosie, Kstosie, you'll find me. So it's not sushi? Are you sure? Nah. [laughs] You can pronounce it sushi all you want, because I won't be able to hear it. [laughs] Perfect.
412
01:18:21.460 --> 01:18:27.720
Um, Crystal, I, I know that your time is immensely valuable, and, and you have given so much to us here.
413
01:18:27.780 --> 01:18:46.980
Um, I, I, I do hope, and I believe we've done 129 of these, that our community can, can pay back the time, uh, you've given us today, uh, through, like you said, learning and listening, a greater understanding of the landscape, um, but also hopefully this, uh, proclivity to, that we tend to show towards supporting good people's work.
414
01:18:47.040 --> 01:18:59.660
So let's, let's do that, folks. So thank you so much for your time, and, and I sincerely appreciate it. [outro music] Thanks to our incredible guest today, and thanks to all of you for tuning in.
415
01:18:59.700 --> 01:19:08.199
We hope this episode has made your commute or awesome workout or dishwashing or fucking dog walking late at night that much more pleasant.
416
01:19:08.240 --> 01:19:19.000
As a reminder, please subscribe to our free email newsletter at importantnotimportant.com. It is all the news most vital to our survival as a species. And you can follow us all over the internet.
417
01:19:19.060 --> 01:19:30.220
You can find us on Twitter @importantnotimp. Ugh, just so weird. Also on Facebook and Instagram @importantnotimportant. Pinterest and Tumblr, the same thing.
418
01:19:30.260 --> 01:19:40.100
So check us out, follow us, share us, like us, you know the deal. And please subscribe to our show wherever you listen to things like this. And if you're really fucking awesome, rate us on Apple Podcasts.
419
01:19:40.140 --> 01:19:48.200
Keep the lights on. Thanks. Please. And you can find the show notes from today right in your little podcast player and at our website, importantnotimportant.com.
420
01:19:48.780 --> 01:20:00.600
Thanks to the very awesome Tim Blaine for our jammin' music, to all of you for listening, and finally, most importantly, to our moms for making us. Have a great day. Thanks, guys.
421
01:20:01.300 --> 01:20:18.220
[outro music] That's it for this week's conversation.
422
01:20:18.260 --> 01:20:31.740
For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing. Thanks for leaving a review, and thanks for giving a shit.
423
01:20:33.660 --> 01:20:52.880
[outro music]