رونوشت 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: Welcome to the Middle of Jeremy Hobson Live this evening from KJAZZ in Phoenix, Arizona. This is the last of our four live election specials, and we'll talk a bit later about what happens with the Middle going forward. But first let me bring in our house, DJ Anthony valadez Hi Anthony, Hey, Jeremy, how's it going. It's going very well. How are you. It's feeling really good at busy night last night, but it's so great to be back here today. Yeah, it didn't get a lot of sleep plus night, but it's good that we were in Arizona, where you know, the election results come in a bit earlier than they do when you're further east in the country. You get to go to bed slightly earlier. But we still don't know in this state the winner of the Senate race. That could determine the balance of power in Washington. That is the power of the Middle. And I have to tell you there has been so much response in terms of the calls we've been getting all across the country At eight four four four Middle last week, as you know, we were in Kansas City. We asked what is an area where you disagree with the political party that you affiliate with, and listen to some of the calls we got that didn't make it on the air. Hi, my name is David Brossard. I'm out of Kansas. Hi. I'm Dan Brashears. I am in Hot Springs, Arkansas. My name is Katherine Bowman and I live in Columbia, Missouri. I am a Republican and I have been all my life, but for me, I no longer trust most of the members of the Republican part of the government or voting for them. I have watched the Republican Party evolved. So I am a Democrat rare in Arkansas and pretty much Democrat on almost all social issues, except I do have a hard time with I can't not think about what I believe to be the life of an unborn child. And my issue is with my party, Republicans, refusing to view things through a systemic lens, and it really leads to some detriments when it comes to just talking about policy in general. That's where I'm coming from. Thank you, Thank you very much. Again. We are listening to all our voicemails. If you can't get through at eight four four four Middle because the lines are jammed, just leave a message for us. Okay, here's what we're asking this hour. What do the election results mean for you and your community? And what do you hope can be accomplished? Anthony, what is our number? The number is eight four four four six four three three five three threats eight four four four Middle, and remember, as we have this conversation, I want to hear from you, whatever your point of view. There's no condescension here. We're going to have respect for one another and have a civil conversation even when we disagree. Let's bring in our guests. Joining me in the studio is Mike Noble, chief of research at OH Predictive Insights, a nonpartisan polling firm here in Arizona. Mike, thank you for joining us. Jeremy, thanks for having me well. And is it fair to say, by the way, that the polls were wrong yet again,
Load full transcript
as a pollster in attendance here, No, absolutely not. Not only that the polls are actually incredibly accurate. You look at the States of Georgia which said it is gonna be incredibly tight race. Not only is it forty nine forty nine is going to runoff Federman slide edge in Pennsylvania, which we saw there tight in Nevada and Arizona, and as we're seeing right now, the polls are very much spot on. So it's a good year for polsters, all right. We're also joined from Atlanta, Georgia, by Emory University political scientist Andrew Gillespie. Andrew, welcome to you. And it's fair to say you're also in a state that could determine the balance of power when the Senate runoff happens next month. But were you surprised by the results overall across the country? I mean, I think all of us are still waiting to see what the final House races look like, to see whether or not Republicans gained the predicted number of seats. We have seen some surprises in some of these Senate races. I don't think anybody could have predicted that Lauren Bober would be behind seventy three votes right now, congresswoman from Colorado, very far right congresswoman as well, very very far right. And so you know, there's certainly, you know, have been some things that we have seen before. But the things that I am not surprised by our things that were perhaps discussed differently in the press, and so I think there was a lot of hype around the red Wave, and you know, a lot of that was just hype, right, And it was a lot of people just trying to fill airspace to talk about the horse race. And we probably could have done a little bit better not talking about that as much as we did. Well, let's see what our callers think about what happened and what it means for them. Once again, our number is eight four four four Middle. Our first call is Mary in Lexington, Kentucky. Mary, Welcome to the Middle. Hello, and thanks for having me. Well, thanks for being here, and tell us what is the meaning of the election to you, How does it impact you in your community, and what do you hope now for the future. Well, in August, our Supreme Court allowed an abortion band to go into effect as long as once the fetal heartbeat is detected, then as sixth day on abortions and less to save the mother's life. We recently had a Kentucky seemed a Kentucky Supreme Court ballot that well, basically, the government wanted to put into our constitution for our state that it would not allow abortions, and overwhelmingly, luckily, the people of Kentucky denied that. Yeah, that one of a number of referendums that happened across the country yesterday, and all five of them, the people in different states from California to Kentucky to Michigan, decided that they wanted abortion rights exactly. And that's you know, I'm a mother, I'm a grandmother. You know, I also have a master's degree in assist reproduction. I don't work in that field anymore, but still, you know, I mean, you know, I've I've been in that field, you know, where mothers are really start struggling to have children and stuff. But then you know, sometimes even if they have, if they have a pregnancy, they may still end up having to lose that child or give up that child before it's born because of health issues either to the mother or non viability of la fetus. Well, yeah, it's a it's a great topic that you brought up there. Mary, Thank you so much for your call. I'm gonna go to you first, Mike on this because I imagine, as you see state after state after state after state, including some red states like Kansas earlier this year, vote in favor of abortion rights, the people going and voting in favor of abortion rights. Did that surprise you, Actually it doesn't. I think what really the surprisal was is that prior to the Roe v. Wade decision that came out, it was that Republicans had a double digit lead and voter enthusiasm. Midterms are all about who comes out and shows up, and when Roe v. Wade happened, it basically jumps started the anemic support that Democrats had at the time and got them motivated. But also we see, like from the polling, it really impacted especially of females, because once they pulled back that federal law, and it goes down to the states, like here in Arizona went back to the law that was during the territorial day, so before we were even a state. And so you see that, and you know, people really started to pay attention when things start to impact them. But when you look at the numbers among females very much it was the number two issue overall that was going on outside of jobs, in economy, inflation, but among women it was just huge where females eighteen to thirty four year old females or suburban women or even independent women all were very much leaning much more to the Democratic candidate than the Republican candidate. Do you think that abortion was a big factor in what happened yesterday and sort of tamping down what people expected to be more of a red wave. I think it was a factor. I do question how we asked the question and surveys to try to figure this out. So, you know, if we asked the question what is the most important issue in the election? Abortion was certainly an issue for some people, but it didn't rank at the top of the list they that inflation did. And so the question that we would ask using multivariate statistic models would be, you know, what is the predictive value of saying that the inflation was first or abortion was first in predicting a person's vote choice. It may still play a role, but what it doesn't quite capture is people who may care most about abortion or immigration, but who are also using abortion attitudes as a litmus test. And so I think there's another version of the question that's not in all surveys. The Public Religion Research Institute does ask this question, does a candidate's views on abortion like affect your vote choice? In other words, would you not vote for somebody who does not share your views? On abortion. I think that that's
actually probably a much more accurate question that's not asking a lot of surveys. So we do won't know the answer to the question. But what we do know is that right after the dab's decision, pr I asked this question and they noticed that the number of Democrats who said that yes, a person's views on abortion could be a deal breaker in terms of voting for them basically doubled after that. So we do know that there were some voters who were at least poised. We need to see whether or not they actually followed through and turned out to vote. But we're in the summer poised to make this the defining issue of their election. Let's go to another call. This is Victoria in San Diego. Joins us. Now, Victoria, how does the election there? Hey? Great, great to have you with us. What does the election result mean to you? It means we're becoming more moderate again. I've been a life time Democratic voter. However, I was raised by moderate Republicans from Michigan Ann Arbor, and so I just it was so relieved today to know that women's health careaters passed in winder you know, was kept in office in Michigan on class and life fingers about Mark Kelly in Arizona because that's where my grandson lives. And so I'm just sitting here making a stew from Alice waters because I you know, I know that it takes another hour. So we're good. But you're happy that you're saying you're happy that that that the country you see it as getting more moderate? Yes, And I mean that even from my side, I'm kind of like almost what you'd call a blue dog Democrat, and I just, you know, I was thinking, do I have to move back to the family home in Portugal or what. So I feel relieve like maybe I could stay all right in the States because I was really getting worried. Victoria, thank you for that car. I'll say, by the way, as a person who's from Champagne or ban Illinois, where they have, you know, bumper stickers on the cars that say I break for all animals of Wolverines, referring to the mascot of the University of Michigan. Hey, I love Ann Arber. It's a great town. Mike, just real quick before we have to go to break here, your thoughts on that, you know, it did show kind of the power of the middle. Well, no, what absolutely did, because you're seeing kind of this civil war breakout in the GOP, this battle between the Republican Party of old, what's based on a platform or issue compared to the mega crowd that's kind of more centered around a bit of Donald Trump, and he saw that. You know a lot of these cans like Arizona is a prime example. You look at our Republican primaries, is that everyone that Trump endorsed won their primaries. Like you could. You could be this water bottle I got sitting here. If Trump endorset it would probably win that Republican primary. We're talking with political polster Mike Noble and Andrew Gillespie of Emory University and taking calls from around the country. You're listening to the Middle. This is the Middle. I'm Jeremy Hobson. If you're just tuning in,
we're live. We are a new national call and show focused on bringing voices from the middle into the national conversation. By the way, if you miss any of the show you want to hear more, you can check out our podcast The Middle with Jeremy Hobson wherever you get your podcast. You can also go to listen to the Middle dot com and we will link you to it there. My guest this hour, our Arizona based polster Mike Noble of oh Predictive Insights and Emery University political science professor Andre Gillespie in Atlanta. Our question, what do last night's election results mean for your community and what are your hopes about what can get done now? Our number eight four four four Middle. That's eight four four four six four three three five three. Let's go to Julie in Springville, Utah. Julie, Welcome to the Middle, Connie, thanks for taking my call. Well, what do the election? Thanks for taking my call? Yeah, you know, to be honest, I'm living in Utah. I'm not surprised by the results at all. I'm disappointed. There's no democratic or even independent representation kind of for the state of Utah now and there won't be any for you know, for the foreseeable future, basically due to gerrymandering, and they redrew the district lines to completely dilute the democratic areas, and I just think it really puts the people of Utah at a disadvantage without any kind of like representation, and definitely not in Washington. Well, given that you're disappointed by that, let me ask you part two of our question, which is what are your hopes for the future. Do you have any hopes for the future of is there anything you expect we'll be able to get done that you want given the situation? I mean, maybe not at the Washington level, or to be honest, I kind of think that politics is best practice when you even kind of like do the small stuff, when you show up at like community community board meetings, city hall meetings, like, that's where the stuff that really affects you in your community and the people that you share your community with. And so I just hope that people who may feel like there's no point it's like, well, show up at the local level. That's really the place to direct your efforts and your passions. Julie, thank you for calling in. Andre. Let me ask you. You know, as you look at the map across the country of the House seats, many analysts have said, if it weren't for jerrymandering, Republicans probably wouldn't even be taking a majority. If they do indeed do that which they're now expected to do, that they wouldn't be doing that except for jerrymandering. Well, at this story is more nuanced than that. I do want to acknowledge that in most parts of the country, partisans are still allowed to draw maps, and this is a place where paying attention to local and state politics matters, because it's your state legislators who redraw those maps every ten years. There are some states, like California that have moved to nonpartisan redistricting, and from a normative standpoint, that does make sense. I think we need to ask ourselves philosophically whether or not it makes sense to allow people who are holding office to draw their own districts and to draw the districts of their friends and people that they may aspire to be one day if they have federal aspirations. But then there's also this larger issue of a lot of the polarization that we see today is not only manifesting itself in terms of, you know, districts not being competitive by design and by the parties that control the most state legislatures kind of having the most way and actually being able to determine how many congressional seats they can draw to their advantage. But we also have to acknowledge the ways that we have changed and how our behavior has actually contributed to polarization. And so one of the other things that we see is that the Democratic and the Republican parties used to be really big tents, and they were ideologically heterogeneous, and so you'd have liberals and conservatives in both parties, and the moderates could be bridges towards each other. The middle has shrunk. The liberals are are by and large Democrats, with the exception of people of color, particularly African Americans, and the conservatives are Republicans and never the Twain shall meet. And there are fewer people who lose. So if we think about the places where we have seen seat flips, it's not the Louren Berberts a Boberts of the world who are losing, even though she may lose in this case. Right, if you look at Marjorie Taylor Green she won handily last night. You know it is not Paul Gossar or Andy Biggs. It is not that you know, the election deniers. It's not on the far left, your AOC's and your ilhan Omar's right, it's the people in the middle who are the most vulnerable. And so we have to on a personal level think about ideological heterogeneity, own it, and then also stop using that as a means to other our opponents. So even when we disagree with members of the party, and I know that's hard to do in this particular moment, as much as possible, I think you can call out people without sort of proclaiming them the other end, right mortal, right, right, right, which I think actually, by the way, is one of the things that has attracted people to the idea of the middle as we as we have done this show, I will also say, Mike, yeah, I remember, just to make the point that jerrymandering is not new. I remember, I remember a clip of the Texas Governor, the late Texas governor and Richard's like on Larry King Live twenty years ago saying Larry, some of these districts are so jerrymandered you could drive down the street with both your car doors open and hit every house. You're exactly right. And that's what's interesting is that depending on which state, some have independent redising commissions commissions, but in the partisans, whether it's a blue or red team that is controlling it, they both do it. They basically, you know, the party in power will typically take
advantage of that. But it's interesting even within independent redistricting commissions, you have two Republicans Democrats, but any of that fifth independent, but as you know, as one truly independent. And so it's but what we're seeing right now because this hyperpartisanship. Like ke Research asked the question in the twenty twenty election, you know, if a Biden would win or Trump would win, what would that mean? And basically both of them are like, this would be cataclysmic, and so I both feel like they're battling for the soul of the country. Let's go to Jonathan, who is joining us from Kentucky. Jonathan, Welcome to the Middle Hi, Love PBS, Thanks for taking my call. I'm in a state like your earlier caller from Kentucky, where we're kind of starved for political choice. You know, McConnell and Rand Paul, it's really about all you have got re elected pretty handily. Yes, absolutely, and so as as a moderate, it's difficult to get your voice heard. But I guess my hope for the future is that with moderation. If you remember Clinton Bill Clinton's second term when it was a heavy Republican House and Clinton was president, probably one of the best four years I remember for creative and positive legislation, and I'm hoping that the Democrats will propose a non buying solution for the presidency and we can have some moderation because it looks like the Republicans they're going to take the House in the Senate. Maybe not, but by the next two years, I think they will for sure. So moderation, I guess, is what I'm hoping for because there's a lot of hateful elements on either side, you know what I mean, on the Democratic side and on the Republican side, and we need to quell those voices and keep that hatred down and work towards positive solutions. I guess it's my hope for everything. Jonathan, thank you so much for that call. Again. Our number, by the way is eight four four four Middle. That is eight four four six four three three five three. You can also reach out to us at Listen to the Middle dot com. Let me take a look at some of the notes that are coming in online. John writes from Wisconsin that he's frustrated by the impact of the Citizens United case equating political donations as speech and how the Supreme Court, he says, disabled the Voting Rights Act. Larry and Phoenix says his number one issue is political dysfunction. He says malfeasance, misfeasance, and nonfeasance, and a political public school teacher writes from Oklahoma concerned about two things, the safety of transgender students as a result of the election, and says criminalizing teaching history strangles the opportunity for our youth to learn from the past. Andrew, let me ask you about that, because we did hear we have heard from a number of listeners over the last few weeks about trans rights. I've actually been surprised at how many people have called in on that issue. But clearly many people see that as one of the things that's at stake right now with the results of this election, especially in places where more socially conservative Republicans have taken control. You know, this is an issue that's likely going to play out at the local level and at the state level. And so you know, where we have seen legislation regarding transgender youth issues, it's it's largely come up in state legislatures, and so what we don't have the bandwidth to do, but lots of people at the state and local level can do or pay attention to what the balance of power looks like in state legislatures and what not, the types of candidates who are getting elected who are going to make that their issue, and so as your listeners are well aware that's you know, it encompasses a wide range of issues. It's started with bathroom bills, you know, in some instances, it's talking about gender affirm and care and lots of places right now. I mean, we saw this happen in the last session, and I wouldn't be surprised if we see more of this in future legislative sessions around the country. The bills that come up about preventing transgender youth, particularly transgender girls, from participating in girls sports with cisgender girls. So you know, this is an issue that I suspect isn't going away. And in states that have Republican majorities and have the Republican trifecta where both the state House, the state Senate, and the governor's office are Republican, we may see the passage of more of these types of bills. Mike, do you see that show up in polling trans trans rights issues? Not so much, because basically, when we have at least from my experience of going through the polling, and I've done a lot even studies specifically on this, is that you know, when you get to the LGBT crowd, that's great, but then as they've kept expanding it, but once you get to the transgender stuff, what we found is a lot of folks don't. Like the ones that say they understand it, they actually really don't at the end of the day when you run them through a battery of questions, and that it's just tough because on that issue, especially with competing et cetera, it's they're incredibly small population, if I would guess probably one point one percent if that of the population, So they're again they're a very very small group, and so with that issue. But also I think that's one of the issues that like, for example, folks on the left that pushing it again it is kind of really push more moderate Democrats or more socially conservative Democrats out of that tent as the kind of pushing some of these other, you know, issues. I will say, by the way, I think the number is higher than point one percent. I think actually, now they've done surveys about this, PEW, I'm looking at a Pew survey about five percent of young adults in the US consider themselves trans or non binary. So it's certainly an issue that's coming up more and more and more people are identifying that way. Let's go to another call. Tim in Gilbert, Arizona is with us. Tim, Welcome to the middle. Hello, Hello, hello, tell
us what is the what is the meaning of the election to you? How do what do the results mean for you in your community? So I'm a pretty young voter. This is the first ever election where I voted in person. My girlfriend and I just went down to the ballots together for the first time in person. And for me, it's it's been somewhat concerning because you know, I've I've always you know, mean, lest my entire life in this election. You know, I'm not thrilled with the candidate's election on my side, but I also, you know, I recognize that the opposing party in the Arizona election is a very clear platform of you know, kind of these theories of election fraud, and to me, that's just you know, to elect those officials would be so damaging to the integrity of our democracy. And you know, as a young person participating in this process. It's just it's so concerning to me to see that, you know, we're walking such a fine line between these two parties in Arizona, and you know, to me, it seems that the Republican Party in Arizona is just you know, the consequences would just be damning to you know, our our democratic process. Do you feel like your you said that you're your first time voter, yes, Do you feel like your vote will make a difference? I think so. I'm given how tight of a race it is, you know, we're we're still waiting for for a good amount of the votes to come in. But just looking at some of these preliminary results that have come in from Arizona, you know, it's it's margins of thousands of votes, which is I mean, that's that's barely anything. I feel like, you know, so yeah, to see that, and then just to think of how many young people I know who you know, probably weren't at the polls yesterday, just because I know, you know, voter engagement just isn't where it ought to be with people my age. It's just it's really concerting to see those one margins. Well, Tim, thank you for for voting and thank you for calling. And Mike, we did see in the last day or so that the numbers are showing that more young people turned out than in past elections. Well, yeah, we see that. Obviously with the social media and ability to interconnect and actually pass information much quicker that you can raise that awareness, so that has helped increase turnout. Also the abortion issue and of course threats to democracy which has been pushed along. Member Arizona was home to the nationally watched audit that was going on. So we spent after last election usually you're done, and spent six months talking about it watching that very unprofessional audit go happen, and it was interesting that they found that, you know, there's no malfeasance going on. Plus, Arizona is actually a really good election system in place, and it's been good for some time and it's really just been propagated due to really just you know, from the powers that be over on the Republican side and the mega side. But it is definitely concerning because if you don't have trust in the electoral system, how do
you have a republic Let's go to line three here, deb in Toledo, Ohio. Dev Welcome to the middle and what do the election results mean for you? Hi, thanks for having me on the program. I'm being in Ohio. I was really sad to see Tim Ryan's loss because I think that Jim Ryan sort of represents a way forward for the Democratic Party in terms of he has a real understanding, I think of working class people that Democrats have sort of lost over the last several years. But I also just wanted to say that I think that his concession speech just show what a class act he really is, because in his concession speech, he talked about the fact that it was his privilege to concede and to congratulate his opponent. Because in this country, when the people have spoken, that's what we do is we get over the loss and we move on. And I think that's a message that this whole country really needs to hear and pay attention to. Deep Thank you for your call, Andra. She's talking about Tim Ryan, who's running for Senate as a Democrat in Ohio lost that race to the venture capitalist j d Vance, who had been endorsed by Trump, and Tim Ryan came out and gave this concession speech and said something to the effect of it's an honor to give this speech. Because this is what you do when you lose an election in this country. What do you think of that? You know, I was in Georgia, so I watched Stacy Abrams enough going on in Georgia yourself, exactly right, Yeah, but well, I mean, you know, the issue was is that that's come up in the national precedent had become a talking point that you know, if Donald Trump didn't concede the twenty twenty electible, Stacey Abrams didn't either. And you know, having lived in Georgia in twenty eighteen, you know what Abrams did was acknowledge that she wasn't going to be the governor, even though she thought it was unfair, and at the time, she was convinced that enough of voters had been suppressed or turned away from the polar discouraged from voting by long lines, that if she was able to make a case for it, that she might be able to kind of like, you know, get their votes counted in some way, shape or form. And you know, that proved to be a feudal effort. But you know, ultimately, at the end of the day, the way that that that I looked at it was she acknowledged she wasn't going to win. She wasn't plotting to you know, move into the governor's mansion while Brian Kemp was being inaugurated. She certainly didn't foment a riot in order to make that happen. But this time around, that strategy, which you know, you know, may not have been the most gracious, but was handled very definitely and very professionally, because that's how Stacy Abrams carries herself, you know, could still end up being weaponized a few years later when other people were doing things that were actually very very different and very very dangerous. So I think it was really incumbent upon Democratic candidates to last night, and as we're seeing election results come in, model a different type of behavior to draw a sharp contrast. That is Emery University political scientist Andrew Gillespie. And you're listening to the Middle. We'll be right back. This is the Middle. I'm Jeremy Hobson. We are live from kJ ZZ and Phoenix, Arizona. We're asking you what the election results mean for you and your community and what your hopes are about what can happen now. Our number is eight four four four Middle. That's eight four four four six four three three five three. You can also reach out to us at Listen to the Middle dot com. Our guests are Arizona based polster Mike Noble and Emery University political science professor Andrey Gillespie. Let's get back to the phones, and we've got Alex here in Phoenix, Arizona. Alex, Welcome to the Middle. Thanks for having me, Thank you being here. The election results so far, obviously in Arizona there's a lot of what's undecided, so locally I can't speak to that, but nationally, I do think it's really notable. What's hardening to me is the fact that a lot of what I call election deniers have actually conceded their races. I had a lot of concern before this election that if that were to occur, we'd have a large swap of candidates basically calling into question our election system as a whole. And I am more positive about the rebustness of our electoral system than I was before him. Great, that's another call on that issue of people happy that we're seeing concession speeches. I'm just going to go straight into another call if I can. Here from Benjamin in Oa Claire, Wisconsin. Benjamin welcome to the middle. What do the election results mean for you? Thanks Jeremy. It's actually a doctor faustic and I am a practicing ob G. I n the Marshfield Clinic. I am incredibly relieved that we uh, you know, have a democratic governor that will be staying on in twenty vers as well as likely democratic Attorney general, because right now I am unable to practice medicine the way that I've always practiced and provide the standard of care to women that may happen to have a fetal cardiac myosite rhythmic beating. If I were to do anything to that fetus, regardless of the women's status, I could be you know, prosecuted, criminally, lose my license and potentially end my career. And it's it's a it's a literal day to day practice for me and a life and death issue for my patients. So just a real sense of relief that the Democrats look to have held on to at least those positions. Hopefully the Republican Party won't get a supermajority in both of the Senate and the Assembly. And looking forward to the April election of a new Supreme Court justice that may be able to flip the composition of our state Supreme Court and look into overturning that eighteen forty nine law. Let me just ask you one question, what would you have done if the Republican had won the governorship instead of Tony Evers? Would have continued what we're doing now, which is unfortunately, either you know, denying care to some patients at our
facilities or referring them over to the Twin Cities, which thankfully is close enough that most patients can get to fairly easily, but it is still a significant concern. Thank you so much, and looking yeah, yeah, thanks for your call, and let me go to you Andre, because you're in a state that now does have much more restrictive abortion laws. Correct. Following the DABS decision in Georgia. Correct In twenty nineteen, the Georgia's legislature and Governor Bryant Kemp passed a law that restricted abortion after the detection of a fetal heartbeat, so at the six week mark. It was enjoined until the DABS decision, and then after the DABS decision, the current interpretation, which I believe, don't quote me on this is still actually up for litigation, might open that up to actually allow for the abortion ban to go into effect. Do you think that do you think that voters made different decisions about who they were voting for, let's say, for the Senate or for governor if they lived in a state like Georgia where there were more restrictive laws after Dabbs, versus if they lived in a state like Illinois where abortion was not an issue in the same way because the laws didn't change Postdobs. I can't answer that question right now. Political scientists do run a big national survey that has suffic sample sizes in each congressional district. I have no doubt that abortion questions were answered. Are you know? We're asked on that survey, so you know, within the next year or so, I expect that somebody is going to be writing that paper that's actually going to look at that data per each congressional district and actually be able to answer that question. Mike, you haven't done any pulling on that. Oh, We've asked a lot of questions basically as we've we've tested in the states. Is that you know, really, and it's funny a lot of the answers, frankly, in politics are usually common sense ones of that. You know, when you talk about how this impact, like, once the thing's impact you, you start paying attention. So when the law gets passed and again ROVIE was talked about for four decades and then all of a sudden it dropped in the middle of When it did, it was kind of too late for folks to kind of get ballot into ships on there. And that's why I'll be a big twenty twenty four point. But when you have that, and once you have certain things impacting, they really start thinking, they start getting involved. And actually, I wouldn't not be surprised whatsoever when the results come out of some of these more larger studies that it did in fact play an impact, especially again those most impacted females, especially younger females and Republican female. Well, and we haven't talked that much about inflation this hour, but that is obviously something that impacts just about everybody in this country in some way, especially people who are lower on the economic ladder, where you know, the cost of gas, the cost of milk, the cost of housing, the cost of transportation really
does affect what they are able to do on a day to day basis. Let's go to a call in Texas. Quinn is joining us. Quinn, Welcome to the middle. What do the election results mean for you? Hey, thanks so much for having me. Probably appropriate for the title of your show. I found myself kind of lamenting the loss of the middle. Generally, I tend to be I want my government small, and I don't want laws that the legislate my personal liberty. So let family planning decisions be left to the family, and if somebody wants to hunt, and let him make the decision to go hunt. And I started looking through voting records and issues, and it just seemed that generally my choices were all very It was a very divisive lot, like the rhetoric and the narrative is all or nothing, far left or far right. And I got to thinking about other geographies where they have multiparty systems, where there may be six parties and they have to share power and come to compromise, and I think maybe that's kind of the recipe for finding the middle. And I just didn't seem that I felt like I had candidates that represented a common sense middle ground approach to our problem solving. Can I ask who you voted for in the Texas governor's race that a lot of people were watching between Governor Greg Abbott who won and Beto O'Rourke who lost, And there you go. I voted libertarian almost straight ticket, largely because some of the rhetoric around gun policies from Vetto were a little bit leftist for me. But on the family planning issue, I couldn't in good conscious vote for the incumbent and I would have basically written in anybody except Dan Patrick. Well, that's very interesting, Quinn, Thank you so much for calling andre I knew we'd get to this issue, which is, you know, people not happy with the two parties and they don't know what to do. Well, I don't have a good answer for you, probably have an answer that your listener will not like. The reason why we have a two party system is because we have single member districts in first past the post elections, and that tends to lend itself to two dominant parties emerging from that. And the proportional representation system that the listener speaks about works very well in a parliamentary democracy where the executive and the legislative branch are one and the same. But our separation of powers would actually probably make that a little bit more unwieldy here in the United States. So moving to a multi party system, I don't know is going to have the exact same type of impact that the listener and visions. What I would say, though, is that there may be other opportunities for people to be able to exert influence on elections in other ways. And so, you know, one of the ways that people talk about this, and I will defer to my colleagues who specialize in social choice to answer this question, but you know, one way we could sort of alter our election system to think about this a little bit differently is to think about moving towards ranked choice voting, where people where you have to get a clear majority of support, but where people actually get to rank their choices. You know, in a multiple field of candidates, it's likely going to be Democrats and Republicans and who just have many of them running, as we have seen happen in the places where this is being used, like New York City, in San Francisco and now Alaska. So you know, this is an opportunity for people to say this is my first choice, this person is my second choice, this person is my third choice, and the hope of lots of proponents of ranked choice voting is that it actually allows for the moderate candidate, the compromise candidate too, if not outright win on the first ballots, to perhaps end up being the second or third choice and actually being able to cobble together a victory there. Mike Dobell, what about the issue of people not being able to find what they want and the choices that are available to them, and do you think ranked choice voting is the way forward? I think rank choice voting definitely will help with the current system. But it's actually one of the most common questions I get asked in the last few years, and I've noticed it's bubbled up more and more. But you see it in the current numbers, for example like Arizona, Nevada. You look at party registration levels, actually both Democrats and Republicans are both dropping Independence or actually the fastest growing party. But the problem is currently is that third party vote share is at it's all time low. I mean the heydays of Ross Perot, those are long gone and so right now that what we're seeing is that there is a clamoring for that. And you look at yeah, like you look at in England or Israel, they have multiple parties. Heck, in India they got like thirty over there. But it's interesting when you have a lot more parties, it makes you have to make deals and cobble together coalitions. Right now, you got red team and blue teams. I like to refer to mass and as they're getting pulled to their respective fringes, the people are finding there's really not a home for them and not much of a viable choice in the middle. You know, we've got some comments coming in online to this issue. Maggie and Wisconsin calls herself a split ballot voter and she wishes there was a candidate who would protect my uterus, the environment, and my right to firearms. Let's go to Noah in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Noah, welcome to the middle, and what do the election results mean for you. I was happy to see Fetterman win. I know that was really close and a lot of people were concerned after the only one debate that they had, you know, so it's really hoping for him to win, especially now that I know you guys have a lot of people who's talking about split ticket voting. You see that at a big difference between Shapiro and Fetterman. Shapiro, the governor, got more more votes from Democrats than Fetterman did. It wasn't even close with Shapiro, but with Fetterman, as you say, it was pretty
close, right right. And I just think I think the previous follower you were just talking to talking about protecting her uterus and also her gun, her gun rights. You know, I think I called previously and talked about gun rights briefly to you know, I left the message. But I think that you know, there's room there. You know, was the ring choice voting and and with the Georgia race, you know, going into a runoff and they have two percent libertarian vote that they're going to have to basically go for. I think that, you know that that could be a you know, should be a bigger thing and bigger growth and maybe a third party or our fourth party or more parties. Is there is there one thing? Is there one issue with Fetterman that you're excited about now that he'll be in the Senate. Yeah, I think that his stance on like he has a libertarian Santon cannabis, you know, And I think that you know, I used to be a Canvasser recently, I switched jobs, but a top people where a lot of people were talking about that was a top issue for them, you know, just as like this, and they used it medically for that nature and just taking away the stigma or you know, allowing more people to have jobs from that. So I think that he to think he represents a good direction for the party picking up you know, more role voters in that aspect, like a libertarian way. No, thank you so much for that call. I guess you know that as a that's a topic we should talk about because honestly, a couple of states at least yesterday voted to legalize marijuana, including Missouri, just more and more and more. Is this an issue that you think, Mike Noble, that we are going to see federal action on? Is the Are the polls catching up to the point are the people's attitudes changing to the point where somebody's it's going to be a popular position to say we're going to legalize it nationwide. That's a great question, Jeremy. I think it is actually an inevitability. So for Arizona, for example, for back in twenty sixteen, it was on the ballot, it was closed and only lost by like, you know, half a percentage point, came back again and four years later and it passed with sixty percent of the vote. And you know what is kind of considered more conservative, right Arizona, And so I think you're gonna because the way the folks view it, it's kind of very normalize it. People kind of treat it like alcohol. It's very similar in that respect, but actually actually significantly safer. But I think it's it's an inevitability, and I think it's going to happen sooner rather than later. But I think more and more states are going to be piling on as your years ago thinking. Yeah. So even though it passes in three states, I believe it also failed in the Dakotas, both north and South. I'd behave So, you know, this still doesn't quite stem the tide of it having been legalized in so many parts of the country, but there is the potential for backlash and not everybody seems to be completely on board with this. And by the way,
the middle is on all the way across the Dakotas. So if you're in the Dakotas, please write to us from either North Dakota or South Dakota to listen to the middle dot com and let us know what you think about those measures on cannabis. Failing there, we have run out of time, which means, well, we run out of time for the serious part, which is the cause, which means we now have time for the fun part, which is the Anthony Anthony Valades. It's back with us with the most fun part of the show, The Notorious Needle to be infamous. It is the infamous and the Notorious Needle drop. Now here's what we're gonna do. I'm gonna drop the needle in the middle of the record, and I'm going to play a five second snippet. And you need to tell me who this British band is, which features and I Conic Phoenix born vocalists. Bonus points if you can name her now a little hint. They were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in nineteen ninety eight. And for a little fun, because you political folks are really good at this game, I'm gonna play a remix version. All right, Jeremy Andre, Mike, are you all ready to play the needle? All right? Here we go, Okay, needle drop time. Who's the band. Who's the artist to go? I'm gonna have to take a pass. I was born in nineteen eighty four. Oh my gosh, Andra, I don't know this on my own, but the producer here is is telling me it's Fleetwood mac Oh. That's not fair. That is not fair. That's a friend. This isn't who wants to be a millionaire? All right? Andre Gillespie at Emory University and Mike Noble with O H Predictive Insights. Thank you both so much for for your your the context you brought and your ex for tease tonight. Thanks for having it. Thank you, Anthony. Let's talk for a minute, because we just did four live shows on over five hundred public radio stations with no distributor. There's no NPR, no APM, no PRX. We did this all by ourselves. It has never been done before. We did it thanks to four wonderful public radio stations that lent us their resources to make this happen. KJAZZ and Phoenix, Kcure in Kansas City, WGCU and Fort Myers, and of course WILLL in my hometown of Urbana, Illinois, which helped us get all the shows up to the satellite so that public radio stations could carry them live. We did that all with this wonderful team Alex Ashlock, John Bart, Sam Burmstaws, Ccfatape, Lisa Napoli, and Harrison Patino. So what happens now, Anthony, what happens now? Well, we would like to make this don't needle drop, I don't know. We would like to make this into a regular program in twenty twenty three to keep giving voice to so many Americans in the middle, whether the geograph fuckle middle, the political middle, the middle class, or just the middle is a state of mind. We'd like to keep a live national call in show on public radio. It has not existed with this kind of reach since the end of Talk of the Nation back in twenty thirteen. We are going to need support to keep this going, so we're gonna be on the hunt for funding. This isn't a pledge drive. Don't worry unless you were a big foundation and have a lot of money, in which case, please call us. In the meantime, subscribe to our podcast The Middle with Jeremy Hobson, reach out to us and listen to the Middle dot Com. Tell us what you think, Anthony, I want to Thank you so much for being a part of this. Your energy is so infectious and the music you brought was really wonderful. Thank you, Jeremy. Such an honor and such an honor to hear from the voices from everybody listening. Our theme music was composed by Andrew Hague, our technical director here in Phoenix. Tra Van here at KJAZZ also helped from Ben Overbon John Hoban, one of the first station leaders to say Yes to the Middle. Thanks also to WABE, KCRW, Jason Kropp and Lilly Duncanson and the more than five hundred public radio stations that made it possible for the whole country to listen to the Middle. I'm Jeremy Hobson. I hope to talk to you again very soon.