رونوشت 🔗
MKR: The coolest thing for me is getting to work and talk with somebody that we've literally gone full circle. Like we've gone from professor, instructor to not committee member, but like unofficial committee member to watching him do his research to friend, friend, right to now colleague, colleague. It's just really cool. I think how so cool.
Sean Legnini: Well, I'm very excited to introduce ⁓ one of my professors for this semester, ⁓ Dr. Kyle Brun, who is an assistant principal in the Garnet Valley School District. And if you listened to a previous episode where I went on my little rant about turn it in, it is Kyle who is the one who showed me the behind the scenes. And ⁓ you know, thank God it was Kyle and not another professor who ⁓ might have had some less kind things to say about it. But Kyle, thank you so much for for coming on the program and and talking to us about your AI use.
Sean: Well, welcome to the line where we are talking to people about where their line is for AI use and ⁓ where this where the ethics of AI gets developed socially through conversation, which I think and lived in the moment. Yeah. and ⁓ we're gonna be joined today by ⁓ by Kyle Brun, who actually was my professor, the one who ⁓ saved me from the 100% AI turning in score.
Matthew: And lived in the moment.
Sean Legnini: Well it's fun it's also fun to talk to Kyle outside of the classroom where, you know, he and I I you he and I have a student teacher relationship right now where he's he's my professor and ⁓ we have good conversations, but you can be a little more open and honest about things, I think, when you're not in the classroom anymore. Yeah. And when I have submitted my final papers to him last week, so I'm all good. Yeah. Yeah, I
MKR: Yeah. Exactly.
Sean: By showing me his it was in my hand.
Kyle Brun: I'm so excited to be here. Thanks for having me.
Matthew: That wasn't even planned either, right? We had him on we wanted to talk to Kyle long before this this bubbled up.
MKR: But I just have to say this is my bragging part, which is that Dr. Kyle Brun, I have now, I I who I appreciate and look up to ⁓ as a colleague and thought partner. We have gone how Kyle, how long? We've known each other for four, five, six years. It's been a while. Five years. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So like we've gone from like 700, the beginning of the program, all the way through 702. Yeah. Yeah, a hundred percent. And what a unique
Sean: Yeah, and I could because I knew that like Kyle is Kyle is someone who he himself, like his line is is ⁓ pretty far down there. Like he he's he's pretty into AI and and the various uses of AI, which you'll see comes through in in this interview, where I I will tell you, like I was surprised, Matthew, his his district and his his school in particular seems really open to AI use. Like n
Matthew: It's pretty far.
MKR: But what a uni yes, but what a unique perspective. I don't know that we've had anybody talk like this.
Kyle Brun: Five I think five
Load full transcript
years, 'cause three in the program and you out. Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Well, he's I mean, we talk about the incorporation of tools. If you if we're gonna get phenomenological and talk about the body schema, he has incorporated AI one hundred percent into his body schema. It is now a part of him. And to a point where like it doesn't even ⁓ like there's no even thought to it. You know, the same the same way that we open a browser to go to wherever, which is what he talked about, it's the same as the internet, right? The same way that we open a browser without any thought, he is happy to open whatever without any thought, whatever AI tool. ⁓ not to say without any thought. I'm sure that he has thoughts about.
MKR: Fair. to on the other side of your dissertation getting to sort of watch from the side to now you're teaching in the program, which hallelujah, right? That you're back and teaching in the program. It's just really cool. And it's it's it's nice to be still connected in this new and different way. Just the same as being online.
Sean: No hesitation, which I think is something we have not seen before.
Matthew: Yeah, like I remember when we were talking to Jess and and and the Jess R ⁓ or Jess T, excuse me, ⁓ new Dr. Jess T. ⁓ and they were she was talking about how they used Copilot. So they were a Microsoft ecosystem, and about how folks were saying, use it, use it, use it. But it felt different talking to Kyle about how they were doing it as a district, right? It felt like there was more of a
MKR: Mm-hmm.
Kyle Brun: Yeah, and it's it's a really fun for me to be able to take, you know, the side of academic research that I learned and being in a district and working as an assistant principal and administrator and apply it and have people to talk to and think about. So th this is a great opportunity. So I appreciate it.
MKR: Mm. No, there's thought because I mean it's but it's the same thing we talk about when it's like the Merloponti, you go back through to Dewey, the habit. It's a habit, not a habit like we normally talk about, but like a habit in a phenomenological sense. It's right, it's true.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm. Well, Kyle, we we always start by asking, what tools are you using? What are you using them for? What is what does your AI life look like?
MKR: What I'm not comfortable with, dot sorry to jump right into the comp the the the ethics of it too soon for a podcast about ethics, ⁓ is the there's language around like cognitive debt or like that we are gonna we're but
Matthew: group effort more of almost like a shift in culture. But then Kyle said something about this is part of what they do, right? This is part of who they are is they are they are more likely than not as a district to lean in. And then how that's connected to leadership, how that's connected to their PD, how that's connected to right, he he spoke really ⁓ highly of of all those folks that he that he works with.
Sean Legnini: No, go on.
Kyle Brun: Well, I I mean the best way to answer that is I use whatever tools I can find as quickly as I can find them. You know, I'm really so I am always ⁓ in looking for different tools that can do different things. Now I will tell you my go-to every day. I use Chat GPT every single day. ⁓ that is my thought partner. That's what I use to run ideas by, clarify ⁓ my communications.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm.
MKR: I mean that's interesting though, right?
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
MKR: I don't think that's accurate. I just I feel I don't think it's accurate. I think it's different. I don't think it's a dead. I think it's different. It's like measuring one it's like apples and oranges. It's a different paradigm. It's a different way of thinking. It's extension and extending our thinking. It's like saying to the ⁓ person who works with walks with the cane, well, if you didn't use that cane, like wow, you're really
Sean: Well we he actually brought in this semester to come and speak to us. ⁓ I can't I can't tell you what his title is. He was the director of technology or something for the district.
MKR: Okay.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm.
Matthew: ⁓ I forgot.
Kyle Brun: But really thought partner there. Like I I will this sounds crazy, but on my drive home, I get these ideas in my head and I turn on the voice and I'll show you and and so chat GPT is the one I'm the most comfortable with and I use the most often. However, it there what I'm learning about AI and what I love about AI is people are starting to create tools that do certain specific things really well.
Matthew: Yeah, how was that?
Sean: Well, it was interesting because he so he's worked with open AI before and helping them to or being a part of their their sorry, not Kyle, yes, the guy, the guy from his district. ⁓ the district and him, they've worked with open AI and in their like open AI for schools or for educators system and helping them sort of like figure out what that's gonna look like and being being a part of that early phase of things. But that to me is like
Sean Legnini: Yeah, you're offloading your ability to the cane. Yeah.
MKR: You're offloading your your ability to the cane. And in that context, then you sort of maybe people can hear it and go, Wow, that's ridiculous. Well, we're not it's a parallel argument, I think. You start talking to
Matthew: the guy, not not Kai. Okay. Okay.
Sean Legnini: Yep. Yeah. I do think it is it is fascinating to me that his entire school seems to have gone in. I'm not sure I fully buy into the idea that every teacher is on board.
Matthew: Mm-hmm.
MKR: Gone in.
Kyle Brun: So for example, goal poll, goal G O L P O goal poll, goal poll. Have you ever seen those YouTube video clips where someone wants to explain a concept and it's like the drawings of the people and it like it's like a graphic, like it puts the little pencil in the person as you're narrowing? It does that and it does it phenomenally well. So if you need a four minute, I need to get an idea across in that cool little I talk in this
graphic design.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm.
Sean: That itself is a sign of the of the culture of the district, which is like like you said, is the lenient on everything. And not only are we going to adopt this, but we're going to try and become leaders in this. Yeah. Now I will say my personal perspective on it is that it feels a little over-gung-ho. Like I think that they're going a little too hard into it without really thinking too hard about what it means. I think.
MKR: No, but I get but I mean I get. I bet you in living in that context, you people are at least leaning in.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
MKR: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Well and like he talked about, like if there is a culture of of ⁓ I guess being on the cutting edge, right? Of of buying into progressive technological changes, then that can already be there.
Matthew: Like leaders.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
MKR: Yeah. True, then it's then it would already be sort of not the expectation, but that's that is what it is.
Matthew: Maybe.
Sean Legnini: Yeah. Well, and to the point that I was trying to make too, is they're not doing it by policy. They're not doing it by like rule. They're doing it by by a culture change and and a s like we talk about a social a social creation of an ethics in the school. Where people are recognizing, maybe, maybe they're not, but people are are ⁓ recognizing it as a cognitive whatever you want to call it, extension, right?
MKR: Kind of draws itself out.
Kyle Brun: Yeah, it's really neat. So that's one ⁓ the Garner Valley has so Garden Valley where I work is super supportive of AI. We have a account for it. Now I I it has a free component, but I don't know what the limitations are. ⁓ napkin ⁓ that's a really good one. And napkin AI is another really good one. Napkin does ⁓
Sean: I think it opens a really interesting question for well, it I think it leads to the line of question that you and I always have, right? Like it's like I neither of us doubt that AI is useful for for lots of things and AI is a wonderful tool for lots of things. But the question that sort of like frames the relationship you and I have and frames the research we do is for you, is what is it to teach? And for me, what is it to learn? And I think that I don't know that people are putting the ⁓
MKR: Is it free? Is it free?
Sean Legnini: That's cool.
MKR: ⁓ Okay. Okay. Mm-hmm. Uh-huh. No, got it. But I know I had not heard of this. What is napkin?
Matthew: Mm-hmm.
Sean Legnini: Ha ha ha.
Kyle Brun: In AI does ⁓ visual graphics, like almost infographics. So you can put in any information. You can put in a paper, an outline, ⁓ or do a prompt and say, give me a graphic that shows blank and it makes a visually appealing thing that's designed for presentations or like a one pager or something like that. Yeah. So and then yeah. So there you go.
Sean Legnini: Not a cognitive debt.
Sean: Are putting the big thinking into that yet. And so for me, for a district to go all in on AI use and to like really embrace it, I think
is smart on one hand, because I think you're giving teachers an opportunity to mess with it, which I think we've you and I've have found through our research that the more opportunities teachers have to like implement it in their own personal use and to figure out what their own identities are within AI is better for the teachers.
MKR: Maybe maybe we should talk I mean, maybe not right now, but maybe we should talk about this further. Like we really need to how we talk about things matters. And and and sorry, that seems like an empty platitude. But we keep the way in which we keep talking about it keeps like reinscribing sort of silently some assumptions.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm.
MKR: Huh. No, right there, you've just taught me two new ones.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: So those are two and in the world of education, ninety percent of my job is how do I effectively communicate information? So most of my AI use is around effective communication.
MKR: Maybe we shouldn't necessarily be making I don't have a good answer to that, if I'm honest. But
Sean: ⁓ and I think no doubt it's providing opportunities for things to become efficient, things become, you know, allowing teachers to have more time for other things. Absolutely. But I do wonder what it's gonna mean for those students and those teachers when I don't know that we've put enough thought into the that sort of big picture thinking yet of like what is this gonna mean for their learners.
Sean Legnini: I think that we make I think that we make assumptions around language often. I know that I'm in a language mode right now because I'm just I'm thinking about l language all the time. I think we make a lot of assumptions about language, about epistemologies, about So you said you said Garnet Valley is pretty supportive of of of AI use. Are there tools I know you said you have a a what's it called? Goal poll? Is that what you said? Goal poll. Are there other services that Garnet Valley is like all in on that they've they've paid for, you know, for site licenses or or access to? Yeah.
Kyle Brun: Go G L L
MKR: Yeah, GoPole. People. About people and how they act and behave and think and believe.
Sean Legnini: Yep. about what knowledge even is in the first place.
MKR: Access to
Matthew: and ⁓ ⁓ it is this an example of remember from the very way back when when we first started talking about this, is this just the polar opposite of the anti? Right? Right. We've got the folks who are like block, block, block, right? Block everything. And then we've got maybe this is ⁓ leaning into it. ⁓ or ⁓
Kyle Brun: Yeah, our teachers have every teacher has a Chat G PT license. Every teacher has
MKR: I think we make assumptions about I like this game we're playing, by the way. I like it. I think ⁓ I think we make assumptions about what it means for change to happen. Like people like to make evolutionary or developmental arguments with a dramatic misunderstanding of the actual arguments made by those theories, right? For
example, these are making us dumber. Well, it depends on it depends on a lot. And the depends on is the assumptions, right? Well, what assumptions are you asking? Is that district wide or is that school wide?
Sean Legnini: Yeah, me too.
Kyle Brun: Wide district district wide. They're even element
MKR: So when you were so I'm sorry sorry, so when you were saying you talk to yours, are you talking to are you engaging with your work Chat GPT or do you have a personal private
Sean: Mm-hmm.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm.
Kyle Brun: Great question. Great question. I have both. Okay. I have both. The I use the work one because it's paid, but we each have our own account on the work one. Does that make sense? So I have my Garnet Valley my name. I use that because of the pay. I'm not gonna pay for Chat GPT when it's already paid for by my district. Do you get what I mean? But if I'm just doing prompts, I'll use my private one.
Sean: Right.
Sean Legnini: Mm, good question.
Matthew: What is that statistical ⁓ mean of measure where there's like to the depends on where the mode is, right? Or is because the the the the ante is so far over here that when we have a moderate position, it feels radical, but it's not radical, it's actually moderate. I who knows, right? I don't know. But it does feel but I remember having this conversation with Kyle and feeling refreshingly like, ⁓ this is a nice different conversation to have. Other than hold up.
MKR: Okay.
Sean: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Well, and I think to that point like Okay. Yeah.
MKR: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: I'm gonna pull from Michelle Serp because that's what I'm reading right now. ⁓ there there is no such thing as a binary for this. The there it's fake. It's if there's no binary for AI use where it's like it's good, it's bad, right? There's there's so much nuance to this. Is there some cognitive offload? I'm sure there is some cognitive offload. Are we d are we establishing there's also cognitive gain, right? And I think that
MKR: Okay. Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, yeah.
MKR: Yeah, it's made up. It's fake. Yeah.
Kyle Brun: But the voice and all of that comes with the paid and the image generation is so much better. ⁓ so yeah, I use my Garda Valley one almost all the time for that. But they pay for GoPol, Napkin, Magic School AI for all our teachers, ⁓ notebook LM. I think you know, we use that a lot. So those are all mm, yeah. Yeah.
Sean: Mm-hmm. Right.
Matthew: Like no. No. We're trying.
MKR: It's yeah.
Sean: Well that's why I think this is so difficult is because like we're there's no way of knowing unless we try it. Right? Unless there's no way of knowing how this is gonna work unless we try it. And
MKR: Sure. But there's also cognitive gain. Okay.
Sean Legnini: It's it's silly of us to use binary language to try and explain this.
Matthew: I know and it bugs me so much that when we try to think about it and make rules around it without trying.
MKR: Yeah. Are you a Google school? Okay, so and then that's that comes along with Google. Okay. From an from a Kiern standpoint, from an Egan standpoint, he would say that the binary begins. Sorry, the binary itself as an idea is a cognitive tool. It's a tool. It's a thing that we use to help we being humans, that humans use to help us understand things. It's not bad, it just is, right? So we start when we're very little, somatic. We have look at the twos on our body, two eyes, two nostrils, ⁓ two lips, two hands, two legs. We're bipedal, right? We walk left, right, right.
Sean: Yeah. Now I will say, like, actually ⁓ this this led to an interesting conversation with my sister. So I I will say that one of the things that I left this conversation with Kyle was ⁓ I left with was how many teachers are are maybe against the idea, but they're feeling pulled into this like they have to. But also I wonder how many teachers just don't care. And I
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: With it, yeah. But even some so, and let me clarify this, right? So, this is where the world gets interesting. So, we have paid subscriptions for our teachers, but ready, our teachers also get a paid ⁓ Canva account through Garda Valley, and Canva has its own built-in AI. So, at what point are you buying services that are supported by AI versus direct AI services? That's you know.
Sean Legnini: So what
MKR: Yeah. You're right.
Matthew: Mm-hmm.
Sean Legnini: Right.
Matthew: I I don't and I don't blame them.
Sean: Yeah. And I think this is where at least my conversation with my sister, you know, my sister works in politics, so she is thinking all the time about like voters and how they vote and whatever. And there is sort of this like bell curve of voters where you've got, you know, you've got the very vocal ones who are protesting, who are leading campaigns, who doing all the things, and then you've got the, you know, the other side of it, the people who are very against it, blah, blah, blah. And then in the middle are a bunch of people who just I don't think
MKR: We have two lungs. We two is everywhere. So the fundamental understanding would be the somatic, the body, which is why I'm referencing that, because I'm because you know, you and the body. But then the next thing that happens is it jumps up into the mythic understanding, which is oral language. What do we do when we tell stories? We tell about also binaries, good and bad, light and dark, right? Beginning and end. Why? And ⁓ it feels so satisfying to us as humans when there's a binary. Why? Because we can understand it. Now the problem is that's where we stop.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, yeah.
Kyle Brun: Where that's why we're so in on it because you can't pretend that the AI isn't there for other things as well, you know.
MKR: Mm.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Matthew: Mm-hmm.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm. Do you find that the that the teachers are using it maybe not as much as you are, but like they are they've bought into it there at the school?
MKR: Yeah, are they leaning in?
Kyle Brun: ⁓ yeah. ⁓ they're leaning in, but
it's it's a progressive leaning in. Anybody who is into AI knows like it tends to start with write me this email, right? Like you do the very basic prompts. Every one of our teachers is doing that at this point. ⁓ then there's the like next group who are starting to use AI to create, design me a lesson.
Matthew: They're just trying to get through their day.
Sean: They're just trying to get to the day, right? Like they don't, they don't necessarily care all that much. Or not they don't care, but like they're not thinking about it. They're not really thinking about it. And I wonder how many people, you know, you and I are like always talking about AI, always. And ⁓ we are involved in conversations with people about AI, but it does make me think like how many people are just in the middle of this bell curve where they are just like never like it's never even a thought.
Matthew: Right.
Sean Legnini: Right.
MKR: And no one asks the question or keeps pushing beyond. It's not that binaries are bad, it's just that they're too simplistic and we don't keep going. As you continue to grow in language and understanding and epistemology and knowledge and whatnot, you realize there are shades. It's more complicated. It's a gradient. And you can, when you have to talk about it, sure, you can drop it back down into a binary. But forgetting that you dropped it down from the complex doesn't, you know what I mean?
Matthew: Yeah, for trying to, yeah.
Kyle Brun: How can I tweak this? I need an enrichment activity. I need, you know, some discussion questions. And then the the highest level of teachers are starting to use AI with the kids. And so, for example, we have a seventh grade science teacher who did an activity. They were talking about adaptations, and they had their students pick two animals and use AI to combine the animals to see what adaptations would come out, create.
Sean Legnini: Right. It's a gradient. Yeah.
Sean: You know, we have you seen the statistic of like if you are someone who uses clawed code or who like uses codex, you're in the like one percent or something like that.
Matthew: ⁓ yes. Yeah. You're part of the you're part of the what present. And I mean who knows? And that even could be BS, right? That who knows? I know that that could just be clickbait. But for a split second I do feel a little special, which is of course what they want me to feel. But then I said to Sean, I met with I had a fantastic meal ⁓ with Perry Winkle and and colleagues this over the weekend.
MKR: There something happens there. It's just don't s
Sean Legnini: The binary is the the cause and effect of the quantification of everything. Yeah, right, exactly. Yeah, there you go. There you go.
Sean: Yeah.
MKR: Well cause effect binary.
Sean: Right.
MKR: Mm-hmm. Right? We love it. We love it. It's so addictive. It's addictive. We're addicted to meaning. We're addicted to binary.
Kyle Brun: create an image, but then also analyze what environment would this animal thrive in and
why? What would they outcompete? What would be its predators? What would be its pre like and the kids are doing this, ⁓ you know. So that's that's where we have a whole bunch of different levels then.
Matthew: And we were re-like talking again about the interview and how things have changed ⁓ for for them and for us. And I even mentioned like you and I building our dashboards as just an example. And Pyramid Go was like, what? What are you talking about? In in in a way of like the it's the you and I and the leapfrog, right? Like, ⁓ my gosh, what what would that even mean? And I'm like, you gotta get into cloud code, you just gotta get rid of go.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ interesting. Yeah, which again, like I wanna go to Kyle's school and I wanna find out because I know it I know it's not a binary. I know not every teacher is like, Yep, got it, we're using it and not every teacher is saying no, we hate it. And so I wanna figure out what the gradient is. What is the gradient? Has there been any like parent response to that?
Sean: Mm-hmm. Right?
Kyle Brun: ⁓ yes, I mean yes. ⁓ the here's where our superintendent is just very good at his job. So before we do any of this, he is big on incorporating stakeholders in the whole conversation. So we we do not believe, and we've been very clear about this, that banning technology is effective because kids get access. So we believe in teaching tech like
MKR: I know. And there's gonna be complexity. And is there only one gradient? Because there's probably lots of different gradients. All these are simplifications, right, of the the complexities of of reality and and our human relationships and our our knowledge and understanding. It's just we forget that the map is not the thing itself. Right? The language is not the thing itself. I mean it it's helpful, but
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Matthew: The interestingly, what I said to her to to this group when we were talking about this, to try to bring it up, because I when you and I get into this conversation, we can become like a little bubble and nobody else around us knows what we're talking about. So I tried not to do that with this group. And so I said to her to to them to bring others in the group. What I'm finding really interesting about that part of the AI journey is I actually feel, and this is the part that drives me also bonkers.
Kyle Brun: proper use of technology and then holding kids accountable. So we built, we had a committee, we built all these digital citizenship lessons that we embedded kindergarten through 12th grade. And they teach not just AI, AI is a huge component of it, but also just what is digital citizenship, what is digital literacy, what is appropriate use, what is not appropriate use. And then as a district, we adopted the stoplight, the pretty standard stoplight method.
Sean Legnini: What and I think even even for even for Kyle, who I think you and I both recognize as like the most ⁓ the most leaning in of people that we've spoken to or or
people that we what we know, even for him it's not an easy binary of yes, no. Like there are there are times but for him it's more of like a ⁓ how do I describe it? He talks he talks about it like just g opening a browser and doing it when he when it's there.
MKR: Yeah, leaning in. Yeah.
Matthew: When people talk about cognitive debt and other things like that, I feel my brain feels still feels like on fire, like I'm learning. Like there is one way to do the vibe coding thing or building our apps, whatnot, where you just say do it, right? And then every once in a while I'll stop and go, explain to me the choices you made and why you made it. Why didn't we go this way? What does this word mean? What does this code mean? And and it still does it feels like I'm learning. I don't think I could take a test on it.
MKR: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: But other times it's not even a thought. He's not he's not having a he's not having a conversation in his head of, Well, should I use AI for this or not? He's just like, ⁓ well, no, I wouldn't use AI for this 'cause I'm not using the internet for this.
Kyle Brun: Green, you can use AI, yellow with restrictions, red, it's AI no. ⁓ and we are very clear with our students what they can use. And then when parents ask us in pushback, you know, we explain very clearly that our use of AI is intentional and it is deliberate. It is not open. It and that's that's where we are very clear. So we get pushback, but ultimately we feel very strongly about our philosophy, our talking points and
Sean Legnini: Right.
Sean: Mm-hmm.
MKR: But right. But there there so there is a line. So I mean we joking he jokingly said at the beginning, or when we asked the question, not at the beginning, that no, you know, there's the like no, there's not one. Like, yeah, there is. There was like we when we got to the girlfriend relationshipping, all three of us went, whoa. Like we bounced off of that like it was an electric fence.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Matthew: I don't think can do it by myself. But I don't feel empty in the way that I think people who don't know what they're talking about are describing when it comes to offloading your cognition. Do you know what I'm saying? Is this making sense?
Sean Legnini: Right. There is. ⁓ right. Yeah, yeah.
Kyle Brun: We we do well with that. So it's it's been very positive experience in our district.
Sean: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, well I think I think it's that
Sean Legnini: But maybe there's just not a line that he's encountered yet. Like he hasn't actually gone to the the AI girlfriend thing, you know what I mean?
MKR: Hmm. This just strikes me that I'm gonna ask this question. Of course you know I'm gonna this question. Is somebody researching this? Because this is not the norm. And someone needs to be doing like an ethnography of your district to capture this moment in time because this feels abnormal.
Sean: I think that people look for a clear black and white answer for things and without nuance. And this is just
another one of those things that requires a lot of nuance. Yeah. And I'm I'll I'll, you know, and in terms of people who just don't even think about it, or who maybe think about it without using it, I'm gonna I mean I'm gonna bury the lead here because we don't have time to talk about this, but like a the a s a sign that people are talking about this is that the Pope just
MKR: I think I think there does want we need more time. But I think that there are there's some there. And I think he probably has if we had pushed, and maybe we can talk about it next time. ⁓ here you go. Tell us about but this gets questionable. The last time a student pushed the boundaries with it, because there's where a line would show up. And how did y'all deal with it as a staff, as admin? How did you talk about it with parents?
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: Mm-hmm.
Matthew: Gray Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Kyle Brun: It it I would say it is abnormal, but I will also say Garnet Valley's culture is always been innovative first. And we are we we believe in being out front so we can shape initiatives and shape cultural changes to our needs as a district. We're very big on that. You you hear that word personalized learning, but we truly believe it. And we believe to help our students be successful, not only today, but in the future.
Sean Legnini: Mm. Right.
Matthew: ⁓ the pope.
Sean: The Pope just dropped this encyclical, right? This humongous thing about about AI use and it's become now that has made it part of a conversation, which I think is so interesting. But that is a topic for another time. We are we are keeping this tight. ⁓ we are ⁓ I'm I'm really excited for you guys to hear this interview with Kyle. ⁓ I think it's fascinating. Kyle is a is a great speaker. ⁓ he's really engaging and he he knows what he's talking about. And he's a good guy.
MKR: Okay. Right.
Sean Legnini: Yeah. ⁓ that's why I was curious about the parent perspective of it all. And he did say like parents pushed. it was interesting too that the that he thought he his interpretation was that the majority of the pushback was environmental.
MKR: Mm.
Matthew: Yeah, no. Gotta get the cow.
Kyle Brun: We want to shape what that looks like. We don't want to be reactionary. ⁓ I will say a lot of it is is credit to a lot of people working as a team, but our director of technology is super innovative. And when this first happened, he reached out to is it open AI? Who I always forget who does chat GPT? What's their company's open AI? And he I think he still is like.
MKR: think that an another example of where I think it's too simple. I think it's way too simple.
Sean Legnini: Which is interesting.
Matthew: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: It is it's far too simple. Yeah. Huh. Well it was a good episode. ⁓ I I wanna talk about it more. I'm I'm glad to have had a chance to have Kyle on here. I'm glad to have had Kyle as professor. especially to have Kyle as the professor when I had my Eternity in incident. ⁓ And we'll have to have him back. Yeah, right? I can't imagine if that was a different professor. ⁓ but we'll have to have him back.
Matthew: And he's a really great guy and just a nice he's a great colleague too. Yeah.
Sean: Yeah. Yeah. All right. So we will catch you on the other side.
MKR: I know and I just wanna talk about it more. I just wanna talk about it more. Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Open AI. Yeah, open AI.
MKR: Open AI. ⁓ yeah. You won the lottery on that one.
Kyle Brun: the educational representative on their core group. So he's had meetings with their head people to try to say, Hey, don't forget to put this into your AI stuff to try to shape it for education. So yeah, I I mean to answer your question, yes, it should be studied. I don't know, you know, it's probably
MKR: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: We'll have to him back. We are, I have to say, we are approaching what will be the end end of this season. Yeah, we we decided to have 10 episodes. This is episode nine. ⁓ so we'll have one more after this. Yep. We'll have a we'll have a short break, and then Matthew and I have been have been talking about what to do next with this. And I think we have a little bit of a plan. So we'll we'll start teasing some things out there. ⁓ but it'll be
MKR: The end of this, yeah.
Sean Legnini: It's
MKR: Yeah, my gosh. In your free time.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, well it's it's just so interesting that everyone everyone has been Yeah. It's just it's really interesting that everyone has ⁓ it sounds like the teachers have all jumped on board and are and are using it because that like Matthew said, this is not you know, we've done we've done this research. We've spoken to districts and that is not the case. It is it is there's always there always seems to be a group who push who push back on it, a group who's all in on it, and a group who just doesn't seem to have any sort of opinion on it.
MKR: Yeah, so just got the one more. And we we have a plan. Yeah. But we'll be back to this conversation. And it is not like this.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, this conversation is gonna be ongoing for a long time because Yeah, exactly. So ⁓ so stay tuned and ⁓ I appreciate all of you listening. You can find all of our information in the show notes. ⁓ and we'll see you next time.
MKR: It's just we won't be yeah, we just won't be recording it. Putting it out, right? Yeah.
Kyle Brun: You know, Sean, it's it's interesting you say that because I always get nervous when I hear the word all the teachers. Right. So can I tell you where we are getting pushback? It's not in the use of AI as a tool. Our our educators are really on board with that. They're pushing back on the ethical use of AI from an environmental standpoint, believe it or not. ⁓ if we are encouraging this.
Sean Legnini: Well I can't.
MKR: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, thank you, Sean.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
MKR: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: But we know the amount of electricity it takes and is it sustainable and you know, for a tool, like is the juice worth the squeeze is
essentially the argument we get. ⁓ and that is it's an interesting argument that we didn't necessarily anticipate. So I and I don't know if you're hearing that in other districts, that that ethical conundrum of some people struggling with just the environmental impact that they're reading about with AI.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, right.
MKR: Mm.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, would I would call it an undercurrent. I would say it's not it's never it's never anybody's first first pushback, but it is it seems to always come up in some in some respect. ⁓ and I don't know. And that is it is something that I think about all the time, also. But I think the mindset that I'm in about that is that these energy energy is not cheap. And these companies need a ton of energy. And they are profit first companies, right, who will need to establish ways to get energy. cheaply and more effectively. ⁓ and that process will always inevitably lead to more sustainable electrical generation. ⁓ and so I'm hopeful that that that's gonna fix itself, I guess, down the line.
Kyle Brun: And And and we agree completely. Like that's tends to be our response is that we only see this getting better. Like we you know, we believe that. So
Sean Legnini: So Kyle, in in your use, ⁓ are there spots, you know, you're an assistant principal. So the a lot of like student facing, parent facing, you know, I'm assuming a lot of disciplinary things too, right? So are there are there points in your in your professional life where you realize like, okay, AI can't do this. I need to go do this myself. I need to this can't be something that AI can touch.
MKR: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Kyle Brun: Yeah, can I be honest? No. ⁓
MKR: Yeah. ⁓ say say more, say more.
Sean Legnini: Yeah. Yeah.
Kyle Brun: Let me clarify that. If you're if you're asking, are there things in my life that AI can can't create, the answer is yes. But I don't use AI to do a lot of blind creation. I use it a lot as a thought partner. So let's talk about like in you just gave a perfect example, discipline where I'm working with students and parents. You better believe when I know I'm going into a difficult discipline, I might use AI to say, here's what I'm about to walk into, here's my thinking. What am I missing here?
MKR: Where are my blind spots?
Kyle Brun: Right. Right. So like, do I use AI to talk to the student? No. But do I use AI to make sure I'm be I'm doing right by families, doing right by students, checking my boxes, making sure I'm not missing things in almost everything I do. So it it's it's kind of like asking, is there a time you don't use the internet? Well, yeah, sometimes I'm not
Sean Legnini: Mm.
MKR: Mm-hmm.
Kyle Brun: But it doesn't mean that I'm not gonna use the internet to influence the things I do in everyday life.
MKR: Hmm. Hmm.
Sean Legnini: Yeah. So at this point it is like it's just fully incorporated into your into your your work, yeah.
Kyle Brun: It's AI is no different for me than the like I said, the internet or my phone or anything else. So it's incorporated. Now, could I be using it more effectively? I'm sure like I I know of people who are using it to code and our director of technology build a whole new website for our teachers to track professional development using coding through it's a it there's a term for it and I don't even know, but it's this new type. Yeah.
MKR: The internet. Vibe coding. Yeah. Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Vibecoding. Vibecoding.
Kyle Brun: Yes, five yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah and I'm like and I didn't even know about that, right? But ⁓
MKR: ⁓ Kyle, when you're ready to go down that path, just let us know.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ Yeah.
Kyle Brun: Yeah. Alright. Yeah. And like what he's producing, I'm like, holy this is incredible. Like, how are you doing? But ⁓ so the potential is there for it to continue to grow and and enhance my life and stuff, but to say that I don't, yeah, it's embedded it for me.
Sean Legnini: That was that was a big jump for both Matthew and I.
MKR: Yeah. Mm. Yeah, it's yeah.
Sean Legnini: Kyle, we spoke we spoke to somebody who was not happy with the price of their LMS and so they vibe coded an LMS for their school.
Kyle Brun: A ho an entire LMS?
MKR: Yeah. You would think, I know. That's what I'm saying. You see what I'm saying? It it pushes your brain. But once you see it, it's like I keep saying this you to you, Sean. It's like touch the matrix and you see, right? And you're like, whoa.
Sean Legnini: Yeah, all of a sudden you're like, ⁓ wait, there's just green there's just green numbers everywhere around us.
Kyle Brun: Yeah.
MKR: I'm having ⁓ yeah, because like maybe y'all can help me sort of think this one out and and ⁓ maybe this will also lane with you, Kyle. There's this way of being with AI, if I can be philosophical for a second, where we as humans keep trying to push it and test it, which I think is exactly what we're doing, right? I think that's what humans do. Invent tools and then play with them and figure out what works and what doesn't work, is right, is my point. But if like if if the shovel breaks. You just throw away the shovel. Or like, or right, or you like go get another shovel, right? Or, but with AI, when you bump into a problem, and this will happen sometimes with Sean, I'll text Sean when I'm doing a vibe code or whatever and go, God, I've hit this wall. And it'll take me a couple of minutes, and then I'll realize, ⁓ my gosh, it's not the AI's fault, or it's not the the problem is the solution, or the solution is the problem. I can't figure out which one the logic is. if if I'm making sense. Sean, is this making sense? Like it's just you hit the wall and you go, wait a minute. The wall becomes the condition that you have to give back. Right? ⁓ and it's one of the things I can when I'm talking with people who have not actively played or worked in these spaces, and they'll say, ⁓ it can't do blah, and you're like, ⁓ you so you haven't had this experience, right? Where you say, ⁓ it can't blah blah blah.
Well, have you told it to do blah blah blah?
Sean Legnini: Mm-hmm. Mm, but it can.
MKR: And then you you keep doing that, and that's where you realize, well, hold on, this is a different. Is there a name for this? What is this that I'm describing? Do you know what I'm saying?
Kyle Brun: Mm-hmm. I mean, yeah, you're talking you're you're talking about the the challenge with any tool or skill. It it it's it's what you put in determines what comes out. And I I hate to say it, but like all all of those barriers and everything, i I liken it to Minecraft. I don't know if any if you're familiar with the game Minecraft, right? Okay, so I you know, my kids played it and then as I would play with them and then before you know it, I love this game, right? And
MKR: I ⁓ I am familiar.
Sean Legnini: Ha ha.
Kyle Brun: Do you know many times you build something and you get to the end, you're like, wow, that's amazing, and then you completely destroy it and start again, and you make little tweaks, and then all of a sudden a shift happens, and now you're thinking about it in a different way, and you can construct things you never conceived of before. So I would argue if it's a paradigm. Ooh, you wanna go philosophical. It's it's paradigm shifts. You're shifting paradigm, right? Like
MKR: Uh-huh. Huh? Exactly. What is that? What is that, Kyle? Name it. We're gonna be famous.
Sean Legnini: It's iter it's it's iterations.
MKR: I ⁓
Kyle Brun: That's what you're doing. You're you're shifting the way it's your the universe cosmology, right? It's your understanding. Your understanding of how things work. You gain a piece of knowledge and changes your understanding, man, you know?
MKR: Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Well we thought
MKR: All people who was gonna drop cosmology, I thought it was gonna be me. But no, it's it's Dr. Brun over here dropping cosmology. Right? But he you're right though. Sorry, Sean.
Kyle Brun: ⁓ no. Like understanding the universe itself.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ Well we talk we talk about the epistemology of AI use and like how how it completely changes how we are thinking about knowledge sources and how knowledge is used and where knowledge is coming from. It's it's a whole epistemic thing that we need to reckon with here.
MKR: Upheaval.
Kyle Brun: Geek not to geek out, but like I'm hearing this is ⁓ does does AI prove constructivism because the idea ⁓ I'm a saying I was right all along. No, all right.
MKR: Right.
Sean Legnini: Ha ha ha. Ha ha
MKR: When when when Kyle takes over the world, which is what I'm advocating for.
Kyle Brun: No, but but but but the thing the thing that's tough tough about this is when you're in a room of people who all love AI and like can talk and have fun like this, but we we also should recognize the other part of it, which is there is a real fear that all the people who are doing this for good intentions end up unlocking a potential that we know will be used if for other ways. For example, one of the biggest uses of AI right now.
MKR: ⁓
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: is in pornography, right? It's completely unlocked worlds there that people are profiting off of. Have you heard of chat girlfriends, AI chat girlfriends and stuff?
Sean Legnini: Yeah, yeah. Or like deep fakes and things, yeah.
MKR: But I this
Kyle Brun: No, not even that. There's people that there's there's AI sites now where you start talking to an AI who has a personality and people are building relationships with these AI. Right? And like I know you sit there and you say But that
MKR: Okay.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ yeah, yeah.
MKR: Okay, there's there's a line. There's a line.
Sean Legnini: There's a line. But yeah, this I mean it's it's like you know, we we always say about this this podcast and what Matthew and I are doing with these conversations is that we are constructing this at these ethics as we go because yeah.
MKR: at w on the fly, right? And that feels like a whoa.
Kyle Brun: Mm, mm-hmm.
Sean Legnini: Yeah. But because these things these things pop up. You talk about all the all the like third party apps that you're using that pop up. Like there are these things pop up every single day. And now that we're vibe coding stuff, it's definitely coming up every single day. And like the legal the legal guidelines are incredibly gray. You know, we Matthew and I talk about copyright for stuff. It is so gray and it is it is something that will ⁓
Kyle Brun: Yeah. And you re Legal
Sean Legnini: I don't think will ever be guided by policy or guided by law. It's only going to be guided by a social ethics.
Kyle Brun: And and Sean, thank you, like thank you for saying that because the the reality with all of this is that you're you're not you're not wrong. Policies are not able to articulate the challenges. They're gonna try. They're gonna try, right? But they're but the social ethics will ultimately find those bounds, right? And I I do a hundred percent agree with that.
MKR: Mm-hmm. ⁓ Mm. We have senators who
Sean Legnini: And that's why like it's so interesting to me that you're
MKR: Sorry, keep going.
Sean Legnini: I was gonna is it's it's it's it's so interesting to me that your school has has like fully gone into it 'cause you this so that tells you that there is a a cultural, social ethics in your school that has been adopted already. Your teachers have agreed to a you know ⁓ an ethics of how AI is going to be used and that's something that we don't see ⁓ in other schools, let alone in other communities or other or, you know, groups of people.
MKR: Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. But it but there's ⁓ but and and I think what I like about sorry, that's not the right way to put it. I think what is impressive and honorable about it, it is is it is a leaning in that adopts agency rather than being at the effect of. And there are majority of people are at the effect of other things that are happening. And that puts you on your back foot, right? As opposed to the leaning in where it's like, well, are there gonna be bridges
that burn? Yeah. Are there gonna be bridges that are built? Yeah. And we're gonna learn and figure it out. Because again, sorry, I feel like I'm on my soapbox, but this is like humans. This is what we do. We invent things and we play with them and then we figure out does it do this? Ooh, it does that really well. Maybe we shouldn't do that anymore, right?
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: Well and I and I think you're you're hitting on a major component here, which is there's the the idea of learning the tools and how to implement the tools, but there is the the I'm gonna call it the responsibility of leaders in communities and in organizations to own
MKR: Mm-hmm.
Kyle Brun: the ethical considerations and own the leaning in and the communication of helping the community find those boundaries. Because again, it's the difference to exactly what you said. It's you either get caught reacting or you proactively have the discussions and say, we know this could happen, but that we know that that's not okay. So here's what we do to to address that. So I think yeah, it's it's fun though. It's it's a fun world. Like it's
MKR: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. ⁓
Kyle Brun: A has it hit you two like I sometimes I sit there and I go, All right, I didn't really realize the comp when computers came that I was in the middle of experiencing a a ⁓ generational change and now I'm like I'm in a generational like I'm seeing it happen. Yeah.
MKR: Yes. thing. And yeah.
Sean Legnini: Yeah. Yeah.
MKR: We're here. It feels like it feels like Kyle, it feels like the dawn of the internet and it feels like the dawn of social media. Right? Like I feel like there are times when I just I say to I say to Sean sometimes, I gotta go touch grass, man. Because right. But sometimes I will just stop and I will look out my window and I will just like my brain just explodes. It's like reorganizing.
Kyle Brun: Yes. Yeah.
Sean Legnini: Yeah.
Kyle Brun: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. I just use chat I use Chat G P D and say, Give me a gr a field of green and then I look at that. No I I
Sean Legnini: We're gonna vibe code the ⁓ the grass touching simulator.
MKR: You had me there. You had me there. I was like, what?
Kyle Brun: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah yeah yeah you're right.
MKR: So, Kyle, the obvious thing is that we like Sean sort of alluded to earlier, we started this because we were having these conversations and realized, ⁓ my gosh, people might want to listen to us talk about this. And if we get people who are in this conversation in other ways, they'll want to listen to all of us talk about it. The other thing we're learning is we can't do it all in in one go, right? Not only because the topic is so big, but it's changing, right?
Sean Legnini: Mm.
MKR: Two months ago, three months ago is very different than where we are right now. Last week is different than where we are now, right? ⁓ Claude Anthropic was throttling the the use of their new model. And then that's now sort of gone up right now. Exactly, right? So we ⁓ all that is to say, when we get back ⁓ and recover, we'll have to have you back on, right? And do a whole other round of a whole other conversation. Uh-huh.
Sean Legnini: Now they gotta deal with SpaceX, yeah.
Kyle Brun: ⁓ See how things change, you know. So I
Sean Legnini: Yeah. And ⁓ to that point, a little behind the scenes, like we're we're recording this ⁓ three weeks before it's gonna release. Like things things are going to change. And we've already seen that. We've had Matthew and I have had to re-record ⁓ an intro to an episode already because things were different before the episode came out. Yeah, exactly.
MKR: Uh-huh. Who knows? Mm-hmm. Things change. Yeah, 'cause then you sound like you're out of touch, right? 'Cause you're like what ⁓
Sean Legnini: But Kyle, thank you so much for coming on. It's been a great conversation. And I'm I'm fascinated by how how your school has just like gone all in on.
Kyle Brun: Yeah.
MKR: And I'm so grateful that we're still in touch and even in this new and different way, 'cause you're such a cool person. You're just so cool.
Kyle Brun: ⁓ thank you guys. And this this is so fun for me and I love being able to step away for a second have conversations like this because you know, life gets busy, but I do see so much value in talking about it and seeing where we might end up. So thank you. Thank you for having me.
MKR: Mm.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ and thank you for not ⁓ kicking me out of the program for my 100% AI score on Turnitin.
Kyle Brun: Yeah. Sean, you'll be happy to know your your last paper only was seventy five percent. So we're going to direction.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ okay, good.
MKR: ⁓ you're only seventy five. You're getting better.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ it's 'cause I added in some spelling errors and and grammatical errors. ⁓
Kyle Brun: They on purpose, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Thank you, Pat. All right. Thank you guys. Yep.
MKR: You made the writing worse. Yeah. Thank you, Kyle. Thank you.
Sean Legnini: ⁓ all right, thank you, Kyle.