رونوشت 🔗
James Rutter: an area where I have changed my mind over the years, which I think is always interesting, is around... centrality that purpose should play in comms or not. And I think if I were probably 10 years ago I was definitely of the kind of flag-waving why don't we talk about our wonderful purpose all the time and at every opportunity we possibly can. And I think what I've come to realize maybe occasionally painfully is that in whatever business you're in. people buy an amazing product or service. They don't buy a purpose. And you've always got to be so mindful of that fact.
Ned Wells: Welcome to the Impact Files podcast. ⁓ And this week Ally and I are joined by James Rutter, Chief Strategy Officer at Cook, most of the time. James, welcome to the podcast.
James Rutter: Thank you, Ned. Hello, Ali.
Ally Dunnett: Hi, welcome James.
James Rutter: Thank you. Yeah, most of the well, three days a week, actually, I'm Chief Strategy Officer at Cook these days and the
Ned Wells: Okay.
James Rutter: other two, I do kind of do my own thing. It's fairly recent, recent evolution, but it's fun.
Ned Wells: And what sort of things do you call your own thing?
James Rutter: Good question. Well, so I cover, well, I'd say kind of strategy, culture and brand, probably in that order as well. So I obviously have my strategy
Ned Wells: Right.
James Rutter: role at Cook, but I also do culture work at Cook as well. Historically, I used to do brand and marketing. was chief creative officer for many years at Cook. So I kind of let go of that part of my role there so that I've got a bit more time to really go out into the world and hopefully help some other businesses around strategy, culture, brand, how those three fit together. And again, definitely with a desire to work with people who are trying to make a positive impact and use business as a force for good.
Ned Wells: Well I really want to to dig down into that a lot more in a minute or two. But perhaps we could start with an introduction to you and your personal story. I remember you saying when we spoke off year of air that you started as a financial journalist, is that right?
James Rutter: Yes, that is right. Yeah, yeah, I had a kind of first career in business and finance journalism as a writer and editor there. And I was thinking about this. think it is ultimately about personal purpose, actually. And I don't have you guys done a little personal purpose kind of exercise. Have you ever done that? Do you have your personal purpose statements? I'd love to know.
Ally Dunnett: I do not. I I I was thinking, I'm sure I could conjure it up off the top of my head, but in fact I'm not sure I could. And I should do it more thoughtfully. It's a very interesting idea. How about you, Ned?
Ned Wells: I don't think I've done a discrete sort of fixed scope exercise, but I think I've thought very carefully, long and hard, about that. and actually I think that this podcast is a lot about that. I'm
James Rutter: Hmm.
Ned Wells: I
Load full transcript
feel that Capitalism is the world we live in, and we need money for all sorts of reasons. And I'm interested in how do you do that? How do organizations make the revenue they need, the short-term revenue they need, but with one eye on long-term purpose environmentally and socially. So that's what I'm most interested in, and that's what I want to. support facilitate and drive partly through this podcast.
James Rutter: Yeah, yeah, well, there's a very good, I mean, Simon Sinek for all his faults, he's good at what he does and so he's got a brilliant, find your personal why type book come format. And
Ned Wells: Mm, mm mm mm.
James Rutter: I went through it just with a kind of friend about 10 years ago. And it's really good, it kind of just delves into the story of your life and your career, what's kind of lit you up, what have been your low points and from that kind of view, you define your own driving purpose. And so mine, is to find, shape and share ideas that matter. And I think, you know, even 10 years on, I still think that's a really good, good little summary of what lights me up. And so for the first kind of 10 years of my career coming out of university, going into kind of business and finance journalism, I was, I was certainly finding and shaping ideas. And I loved that. And I loved going out to talk to people to, you know, to CEOs in banking and finance and that kind of thing. Fascinating people. But I wasn't really sure that those ideas mattered in the big sense. I you know, they made lots of
Ned Wells: Mm. Mm mm.
James Rutter: people lots of money, but they didn't necessarily matter. And so when I kind of left that world and joined Cook, which was completely out of the blue, I think I went into, probably without fully realizing it at the time, though, a company with an idea that really mattered, which was that business can and should be a force for good. And
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: that particularly in the UK at that time, you know, helping launch and grow the B Corp movement was a real way that we could have a bigger impact beyond just our own business. And so, yeah, so that driving business, I think has definitely shaped that driving purpose rather has definitely shaped my career. And I think in a way, the move I've made in the last year to kind of have a couple of days trying to do something as well as Cook is again, with that bigger purpose in mind in the sense that Seeing the opportunity to take all our learnings over 15 plus years of kind of growing successfully, a very purpose driven and impactful business. How could I take those learnings out into the world and actually help other people who are on that journey, maybe at a slightly earlier stage or very earlier stage and pass on some of that, hopefully that wisdom and those learnings that's going to help other people again, use business as a force for good.
Ally Dunnett: So that really speaks
Ned Wells: just
Ally Dunnett: to the the share part of your personal purpose, right? You've
James Rutter: Yeah.
Ally Dunnett: yeah, you've implemented it or or continuing to drive it forward in the organisation you work for and and now you've had this opportunity to share beyond that.
James Rutter: Absolutely.
Ally Dunnett: Yeah.
James Rutter: Why bother saying yes to a podcast like this? Well, because actually it's all about sharing ideas that matter fundamentally.
Ned Wells: And is there a particular style of business that you are sort of ideally wanting to be supporting and working with for those two days a week?
James Rutter: I mean, know, I'm all comes welcome, you know, I'm a broad church of one. So
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: I think it's been really interesting. I mean, it is so fascinating again, as you may have perspective on this, know, working inside a business for a long time is wonderful in many respects. But then stepping at least some of the time away from that and suddenly having a broader perspective and seeing how different people operate. people do things. What other issues are driving people's behaviour? I mean, it's just fascinating and enriching in equal measure, I guess. I definitely want to work with businesses where I can see there is a desire to be a force for good in some way, shape or form. I'm not kind of being didactic about that in the sense of it has to be a B Corp or it has to be this or it has to be that. But I definitely, you know, I'm drawn towards businesses that have a bigger sense of purpose than just to maximise the money they can make. And equally that have a sense of... being able to create. something valuable through people and the sense in which actually one of the joys we have as business people is to bring people together to achieve something bigger than they could ever achieve alone. So let's make sure we're giving them that opportunity to really find fulfillment through what they're doing and again to find their purpose through what they're doing and that actually what we're asking them to do is worthwhile in the bigger scheme and I think It's often one of the most obvious but overlooked aspects of, if you like, purposeful, impactful business is to actually create great workplaces that people feel kind of energized and inspired to be part of. Because I think that's definitely going to ripple out in all kinds of positive ways.
Ally Dunnett: I'd I'd be interested to know, James, if there are any organisations who've approached you in in that capacity, in your in your personal work, where where perhaps purpose hasn't been that near the the top of their agenda. As as you say, you're you're not being overly choosy, but perhaps they've started off where it hasn't
James Rutter: You
Ally Dunnett: been high on their agenda, but either by osmosis or indeed in a more conscious way, they've they've sort of taken stock, listened to what you had to say. And really bumped that purpose up to the agenda. Has has that happened?
James Rutter: I think, well, mean, funny enough, I was talking
to somebody just this morning who's an entrepreneur who's started a success, he's done well, he's grown a good business over five or six years, but he's got to a point where he's feeling a certain, I guess, emptiness in terms of actually why he's still doing it. And so he's wanting to try and explore that and articulate it. He's got a sense that there is... there is some kind of inner drive there that isn't just about making money, but he's not quite sure how to pull that out of himself and articulate it in a way that is both going to inspire him. But as he said to me, you I've now got a team coming to me and saying, look, we want to know kind of why we're doing this. You know, yeah, we enjoy turning up for work, but over five years, actually, what's going to be the point? And so again, having that whether you call it purpose or something else, but having that sense of direction and a clear kind of sense of what you're seeking to achieve in the bigger picture, not just the business metrics, I think is so important just in terms for galvanizing your team, creating energy within a business and really taking that kind of momentum through into your business success. So the two, it's interesting how, you know, I think, you know, Historically, people have often looked at, if you like, that kind of cultural work as a kind of a nice to have, a bit fluffy, what have you. And yet it's arguably the hardest tangible business drive that there is, is people who are inspired and engaged in their work and really turning up wanting to do a brilliant job, not because of the bonus that's being dangled at the end of it, but because they feel like what they're doing is worthwhile and they're in
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: great relationships with people and they feel that they can grow. personally and professionally.
Ally Dunnett: Yeah, and and just following on from that, I was thinking as as you say, it's being seen as or people have perhaps struggled with that idea of the the cultural side thinking because it's intangible, we can't measure it. So because we can't measure it, we're going to put shove it back over to one side and focus on those financial KPIs or whatever they may be. But but actually it would be interesting to hear how the the tools or the frameworks you do use to measure. Happiness actually, the happiness at work and and those other cultural elements.
James Rutter: I think there is a danger in seeking to measure everything.
Ally Dunnett: Yeah.
James Rutter: Which isn't to say you shouldn't seek some measures, but I think there is always an inherent risk in saying unless we can measure it, we can't quantify whether it's been valuable to us or not.
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: And that's kind one of the curses of the modern age, isn't it? That we seek to constantly create measurable to every single area of our life and turn it into ever more minute data points that we somehow think by pursuing each one of those will add up to something
that's incredibly productive and rewarding. Whereas I think perhaps part of the secret is actually to let go of that desire to measure everything and step back and try and take a much more holistic view of what's going
Ned Wells: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: on and just feel instinctively that actually we're going in the right direction. And I know that that's kind of anathema to most kind of modern business folk. But I think there's some definite truth in it. That said, you can still have some measures for culture, even though I don't think they're exact. And, you know, over the years, you know, this is going back, gosh, 2012, I want to say we started doing the best companies to work for survey, which at the time was kind of in the Sunday Times was the top one. And And for the reason that we wanted a measure. We didn't pretend that that was going to be perfect, but it gave us a sense of whether we were progressing. And so we've done that every year since. And I think we're, I want to say we might be the only company that's been in the top 100 since 2013. I think the first year we did it, we came about 300th and were devastated. And then we came like 82nd and celebrated like we won the World Cup.
Ally Dunnett: Yeah.
James Rutter: But since then, we've done that every year really as a benchmark for where we're at. And not to pretend that that really describes in any fullness our success or failure in terms of our culture, but it gives us a regular benchmark that says, OK, this is where we're at as an organization. So having some kind of measure, I definitely think is great. But not to pretend that chasing the measurements, you know. is going to result in the outcome you want.
Ned Wells: Just in terms of
Ally Dunnett: Makes complete sense.
Ned Wells: metrics and for any of our listeners that may not be as familiar with Cook, how how large is the organisation? What sort of scale are we talking about?
James Rutter: So these days cooks kind of 2000 people.
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: We are about 150 million pounds in terms of sales. And we're very unusual, I always think, as a business. I would say we've got kind of the whole of humanity under our umbrella because we are vertically integrated in the sense that we're a manufacturer. make nearly all of our own food. So we've got four big kitchens where we make food. We also then own shops. So we a retail estate.
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: about 120 shops nationwide these days. And then we obviously have all the kind of central functions. And so I'm sitting in the middle of that, be it marketing, finance, what have you. And logistics as well, trucking things around. So in that sense, we have an incredibly diverse kind of workforce. it is one of the joys of being at Cook in the sense that we can create a culture in which everybody feels welcome across that very broad spectrum of people. and everybody feels some unity around our values, our essential ingredients, as they call them. And everybody feels a sense
of purpose in the business, which I think is very different from their personal purpose, but we can talk about that
Ned Wells: Hm.
James Rutter: if you like. But if we can create
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: that kind of culture, then that is a wonderful thing. And it definitely keeps everybody connected, I think, to maybe society in the broad sense. in which I think businesses that tend to be very kind of focused in a particular demographic in terms of their team often lose that broader cultural kind of perspective.
Ned Wells: And I'm curious, and I think we'll we'll sort of dig into this as we go on, but I'm curious about how your experiences working for an organization of that scale can translate into the sort of the sort of roughness of tumble of a smaller organization.
James Rutter: Mmm.
Ned Wells: and in some senses, you know, there are some aspects of large organizations which don't particularly translate, and others, and I suspect the sort of the cultural side would. be more translatable, if you see what I mean.
James Rutter: Yeah, I mean, most of it, I would say most of it translates, to be honest, because ultimately, I think the basic frameworks by which you want to operate are kind of the same, whether you're 1 million, 100 million,
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: or 1 billion. You could argue, actually, the bigger you get, just the more complicated it all gets, and the
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: more susceptible you are to drift in some respects. I think, and remember Cook wasn't always that big, so back when I started,
Ned Wells: Sure.
James Rutter: we were, you 25, 30 million pound turnover and team of 500. Still, you know, by some standards sizeable, but definitely
Ned Wells: Yeah.
James Rutter: not the size we are today. But like I say, I do think particularly around those areas that I'm interested in, know, strategy and getting real clarity around that, then culture and how you build energy through your people. And then the brand and the sense in which actually your comms and your brand brings vitality to that whole endeavor. So I think those apply whether you're kind of a one man band, which again, remember now I am two days a week or you know,
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
Ned Wells: Yes.
James Rutter: a 2000 person, 150 million pound business.
Ned Wells: digging back down into what you said about strategy, I've got a question here around strategy classically taking a kind of long-term outlook. And wanting to ask you how leaders should tackle the the sort of balance of achieving that near-term economic results that they need with longer term sustainability objectives.
James Rutter: Hmm. You know, I think that that balance of long and short term is a challenge for everyone in a sense. And
Ned Wells: Hmm.
James Rutter: there's differences between the short term needs in a sense, which they might be a survival situation. We just need to make X to keep going
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: versus short term financial needs, which are more like we need to make X to keep the bank or the investors happy, or we need to make X because we want to keep ourselves happy or because we said we would or whatever it is. Do you know what I mean?
Ned Wells: Mm, mm, mm.
James Rutter: So I think you have to qualify that short term pressure. It is a kind of financial pressure. And then you have to keep in mind, if you like, the long term is made up of lots of short terms added together. It's like that classic. I think Keynes' quote, is something, you know, like something along those lines around the short term is made up of the long term is made up of the short term multiplied many times. So the two are connected. And obviously the trick or the secret in any credible kind of strategy and successful strategy is to acknowledge and embrace that fact and be able to use it to arrive at your long term destination. Now that I think the particular challenge though, when you're then, if you like layering on. measures outcomes of different kinds, as it were. So a financial on top of a sustainable or impact, whatever you want to call it, where the two are connected but very distinct. I think that's almost adding in the whole new dimension to that strategic debate. And my experience at Cook is that if you are If you are coming from, if you like, the impact or sustainability side of that debate, you have to be... I think you have to be prepared to occupy the position that says the long term is what's important. And actually any short term
Ned Wells: Yeah.
James Rutter: period, we may look horrible from whatever measure we're using in terms of an impact or sustainability measure. But as long as we remain committed to the long term, we shouldn't delude ourselves that we are failing because because down that route despair lies as it were and definite failure lies. So you've got to kind of hold on to that long-term dream and vision and not be constantly berating yourself for short-term failures because they will come and I would say particularly in the sustainability and impact space they will come frequently because it isn't with the best in the world. It isn't a kind of linear type of practice in the best sense, in that sense. think there are so many dependencies within a business that ultimately wash out in a sustainability or impact number that you have to be kind of hold it lightly in terms of your goals and ambitions. Not in the sense of constantly changing them or watering down, but seeing that actually the bigger fight is always worth losing a small battle as long as you stay in the big fight. I don't know if that helps at all because it's a tricky
Ned Wells: Yes.
James Rutter: one to answer, I think.
Ned Wells: I think that's good. I mean, I think there are two things that come out of that for me. One is that it that requires a certain amount of bravery to keep your eye on that long-term prize. And I also think that I can see now the value of having somebody like you on side who's been at it for 15 years
and can show a business that has grown and succeeded whichever metrics you choose and by the way last weekend I had the most delicious pudding from Cook which was probably the first time I had I thought it was really yummy so yeah huge success
James Rutter: Gosh, well you have to buy many more puddings.
Ned Wells: Ali over to you
Ally Dunnett: Thanks, Ned. I going to say I'm sure you'd be happy to buy more puddings just in the interests of us reinforcing our podcast
James Rutter: You
Ned Wells: Huh.
Ally Dunnett: network and our lovely guests. You'll you'll do that, won't you, Ned?
Ned Wells: Of course.
Ally Dunnett: Okay. Yes, I I'd like to move on to or come back to really this this intersection of strategy, culture, and brand or brand building. Because I know, James, you've started off by speaking a a little bit to that, and I know that's what That's what you lead with on your personal website. It's it's what you're all about, that that interesting relationship across those three elements. So for our for our audience, for our listeners, many of whom will be leaders in established SMEs, can you explain how you how you feel strategy, culture and brand interact, or perhaps how they should interact? I don't know. What's that relationship look like?
James Rutter: So I think definitely think it runs in that order. So it starts with strategy, goes
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: through culture and should end up in brand. ultimately what you're looking for in terms of strategy is, think, is this idea of clarity. So just do you have clarity on where you're heading and why? In the most basic sense, that's what we're talking about. And I think it's always surprising to me how how many businesses big or small actually don't when you get below the surface, if you know what mean. They actually don't. And so I would say, you know, should be able to get that on one piece of paper and it to be immediately understandable for anybody in your business or outside to say, I kind of get it. I get what you're doing. there's that clarity piece. And so figuring out what the business is doing, why, where you think you can have that real advantage and therefore what you're focusing on. And the classic strategy question is what you're choosing not to do. you've got to be really disciplined around those choices. And if a strategy doesn't hurt, you're probably not doing it right. So what are you saying no to? And are you really clear about that? Because in many respects, it's that negative space that almost defines what you are about. So really kind of thinking about that in some detail. So making that strategy lovely and clear and crispy. And that then should provide the framework for you to kind of do all the nuts and bolts of your business in terms of planning, budgeting, and so on and so forth. And making sure again, it's coherent. I think that's again one of the kind of the areas where business is big and small fall down is thinking about, well, actually, if we're
saying this is what we're all about, this is what we're setting out to achieve in terms of our long-term objective or aim, then why is it we're doing X, Y, and Z? Because actually they don't have anything to do with that. And we're doing
Ally Dunnett: Right.
James Rutter: them because kind of enjoy it or it's fun or it's a legacy or it's actually the boss just likes football, whatever it might be, do know what mean?
Ally Dunnett: Yeah, yeah.
James Rutter: So again, it's that and it's really hard to say no to some of those things and to let them go. But really thinking about is everything we're doing adding up to that simple strategic picture or not. And so once that's clear, then the cultural bit and it's like famous Peter Drucker quote or misquote that culturally strategy for breakfast
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: is actually your culture is how strategy gets into the world. The bit of paper is useless on its own. It's only useful if it helps shape the ideas and activities of the people that are going to make it happen. So that's then all about, OK, so how do we create this kind of cultural energy that is going to put that plan, that business idea into the world in the most effective and efficient way we can. And that gets everybody behind it. They're really clear about what they're going to do, why they're going to do it, how they're going to make it happen. So that's the kind of the cultural piece.
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: And very much I'm kind of influenced there by the work we've done at Cook over many years around the idea of big relationships and that ultimately all the business boils down to is a bunch of people doing something together that they couldn't do alone and therefore the relationships between those people are really the engine that drives the business forward. And so that's kind of three circle vein with unity, clarity and appreciation as the three circles. So you've got unity if you were all on board for where you're to be going. You buy into the vision, you buy into the destination, then you've got clarity in terms of roles, responsibilities, it's really clear who does what and why. And then you've got appreciation, of kind of what other people bring, what you bring, both in terms of recognition, reward, et cetera. Those three things together, well, add up to great relationships among your team. So that's kind of the cultural bit, the foundation's for that. And then kind of the brand is then, well, and then how does that show up in the world?
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: You know, I'm the big believer in the side of that brands work from the inside out again, so that wouldn't be a surprise with that model.
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: it actually is driven by your culture. Because really what you're showing the world should be the expression of who you are when you show up to work every day. There shouldn't be this horrible disconnect between what happens inside the office doors and what the world sees. Because, down that route, probably disaster lies. So how do you bring that kind of that internal cultural energy out into the world
Ned Wells: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: is really compelling brand. And most importantly, how do you make that brand memorable? I think this is the thing we've got to remember. We're bombarded with messages. I can't remember the latest number. It's like 2000 a day or something. And you want your one little message to stand out among all that noise. So making it memorable is the most important thing. And memories get formed not by facts, but by feelings. So in what sense are you trying to get people to feel something about your brand and business? And so that's where the of the brambit comes to life. How do you bring that culture out into the outside world in a memorable way?
Ally Dunnett: Thank you. Please.
Ned Wells: Do you mind if I jump in with a quick question on that? So I know intellectually what strategy, culture, and brand building mean. I guess what I'm curious about is those are two large areas, and over over 15 years you were involved with those at Cook. What did your sort of what did your week look like, if you see what I mean? What did you actually spend your time doing?
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: Guff. if I'm honest, think towards the end of that period, maybe this is one of the things that maybe prompted the change in some respects was that the bit that was getting most squeezed was the brand building bit. Because actually, as we got bigger, the demands around culture and strategy got bigger. And I was spending much more of my time, particularly at certain points in the year. Pretty much solely on that. And so, but you know, again, I think I think it's interesting looking back in terms of. of across businesses as they grow. I think you do need people who are tying it all together, if that makes sense, and who aren't just in the strict silos that say over here we do marketing and over here we do finance and over here we do ops. Who are the people who are genuinely going across that in a way that is very very true to the business purpose and the business culture. And I think we've probably got a few people to do that at Cook and it's been one of the real strengths of the business. But as you get ever bigger, I think it becomes much harder as well to have people who do operate.
Ned Wells: And I think that's what my question was about. I think that, you know, strategy is a very important aspect of a business, but typically one might write a strategy piece and there'll be some sort of some grand statements and some objectives and some the deliverables out of that. culture again, it's a sort of central thing, but it can be quite a sort of hard to put your Finger on kind of aspect of a business. And likewise, brand, I think to a lot of people is a slightly intangible area. So I guess my question is more about how did you structure v that side of Cook? I mean, there must have been more than just you that was
stretched that was spread across those three areas.
James Rutter: Yeah, I mean, all of those are definitely kind of and remain joint endeavours with lots of people involved. So I think
Ned Wells: Mm. Mm.
James Rutter: on the strategy side, again, one of the things I think we did very well, which ultimately I want to say we borrowed or stole from Pratt, was a just a very clear rhythm to how strategy works with the year.
Ned Wells: Right.
James Rutter: And so this is definitely building around the idea, getting back to short term and long term, you could argue. So yes, you have a kind of three to five year strategy with a plan behind it. and then you're much clearer on the next 12 to 18 months in terms of that. But each year we're revisiting that longer term plan in the summer. So next week we're going off with the Cooke team to kind of revisit that longer term strategy. Out of that trip will come various kind of ideas, initiatives we think we want to pursue. So everybody goes back to their teams and digs into those. And then we get back together in the autumn to actually put the detail on actually therefore the plan for the following financial year, maybe beyond depending on what we're working on in much more detail, but then that repeats every year. And so I think that kind of cycle is really helpful in terms of how you take kind of strategy from the lovely deck or presentation into reality.
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: And equally, because those moments are known broadly across the business, you the invitation is there to everybody to feed in ideas, feed in feedback, whatever it might be, so that everybody knows that's happening. And equally, everybody who's going on that trip should have been out to their team to bring their team's ideas into the strategy process. So again, it's not just happening at a very kind of esoteric top team level, but it's something that is built, hopefully, from much more broadly across the business. kind of that's having a rhythm to it definitely helps. And culturally at Cook, I think The place where I still get most involved is events, massive part of how we build culture. so
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: bringing people together, making sure they experience cooking in a really kind of deep and rich way by spending time with people outside of their day to day. That has been probably the strongest glue in terms of bonding people to the organization and to each other beyond just making sure you then have great day to day practices in the workplace. And so I you know, I continue to kind of oversee and run all the events. So again, those have a certain calendar and timing in terms of how events work. then, yeah, and then brand is much more always on, you know, so always on comms, marketing, what have you, and things like that. But yeah. But again, you know, and I'd say again, for any, for any business of any size, I think it's really interesting to think about the rhythms that actually govern
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: how you work. both across maybe 12 months, but then across a single month. actually, are those rhythms reinforcing each other? Do they fit together? Do they actually help you create some momentum? Or are you sometimes getting stuck or are you sometimes getting lost because the rhythm isn't there? So I think if you can figure out how the rhythms work, that really helps.
Ned Wells: Really interesting. Sorry, Ali, I stole your your c question.
Ally Dunnett: That's quite okay because I'm I'm thinking actually we've got a nice segue into talking a little bit more about comms and marketing. If you're happy to to do that, go on to that note. Yeah.
Ned Wells: Yes. Yes indeed. So our question, I guess, is about how our listeners can use comms and marketing to drive to drive longer term purpose and near-term revenue. and I wonder if you've got some examples of what you're doing today with either with Cook or with your other clients you're working with in your fractional role.
James Rutter: Gosh, do have any good examples of that? I'm not sure, I'm trying to think. think the thing, an area where I have changed my mind over the years, which I think is always interesting, is around... centrality that purpose should play in comms or not. And I think if I were probably 10 years ago I was definitely of the kind of flag-waving why don't we talk about our wonderful purpose all the time and at every opportunity we possibly can. And I think what I've come to realize maybe occasionally painfully is that in whatever business you're in. people buy an amazing product or service. They don't buy a purpose. And you've always got to be so mindful of that fact. And a really helpful way to think about it, which again, I'm stealing with pride from a guy called Alex Smith, is that you have a company story, which is kind of purpose, values, you have a customer story, which is actually, what are you doing for the customer? in a way that is going to
Ally Dunnett: What's the
James Rutter: deliver for them. so he views those as very separate. I think the really interesting part of that is actually from a purpose-driven business perspective is how much do those two circles overlap? And that's where you can really gain some brand benefit when they do. But it's still not losing sight of the fact that what people are buying is an amazing product or service. And you have to be cognizant of that at all times. And then thinking about the company story, which is really important to your people, which is really
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: important to you, which is really important to your shareholders, maybe. That might also have a role to play, but don't assume it does. And particularly, think, you know, think at Cook, we have lots of people now who are very passionate about our purpose, which is fantastic. But they got there, I'm pretty much sure. through eating lasagna or chicken ham and leek pie or a lovely pudding. Do you know what I didn't get there. Yeah, they didn't
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
Ned Wells: Exactly.
James Rutter: get there through us shouting about purpose. They got there through an amazing
Ned Wells: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
James Rutter: product that said, wow, this is incredible. Or I want to know a bit more about the company behind this and maybe read the packaging or did, you know, start
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: to dig a bit further or sign up to our e-newsletter. So I do think that's a really helpful just idea for everybody to keep in mind, know, company story, customer story.
Ned Wells: Yeah.
James Rutter: Where do they overlap? What's going to live in that overlap? And actually it's OK if all your purpose or impact isn't in your customer story. Because you've got to remember the bigger prize is to genuinely create a successful business. It's a force for good. It's not necessary to have everybody believe in your purpose.
Ned Wells: I think that's so interesting. I there's a there's a podcast that I admire greatly called can marketing save the planet? And there was an episode on that where they were talking about some research that had been done into companies. And one of the examples was Octopus, who have numbers of customers who aren't especially interested in the sustainability credentials, but what they like is the brilliant customer service, the good pricing and all that kind of stuff. And that's I think really kind of hit home hard when I heard it. And that's sort of what you're talking about, I think.
James Rutter: absolutely. Let's be, Octopus is a great business because it offers great service in an otherwise shitty industry. Let's be honest, great
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: service at a fair price.
Ned Wells: Yeah. Yeah.
James Rutter: You know, and I was just reading something this morning, literally about Octopus and saying they've kind of, they just found this gap in a market that shouldn't have been there. Because why should modern market economics would tell you actually there shouldn't be a sector where actually everybody is equally crap at customer service. But it was, it was called the UK power sector. And Octopus just said, you know what, we don't have to be as crap as everybody else. And actually, as long as we don't, as long as we charge a fair price, everybody's going to love us. And there you
Ally Dunnett: Hmm. Yeah.
James Rutter: go, you know, 10 billion pounds later, whatever it's valued at these days. Yeah.
Ned Wells: Ali, over to you.
Ally Dunnett: Thank you. I'm still reflecting on a few things there. I just think it's so interesting that point about not having to have purpose front and centre of your your external communications and just again letting that letting it seep through, letting it hit or not hit, and chances are it will hit, even if even if your your customers or clients have come to you for another reason initially or or or have built their relationship with you initially. I think it's very interesting. I'm also I keep coming back in in my brain to your your various venoms. diagrams 'cause I I think you're you're all about Fenn diagrams, something James. It's I I like thinking in that way of there's yeah.
James Rutter: I managed to do a year of event every week. I managed to post an event every year, every week for a year, which I felt quite pleased about at the end of that. And then I thought, you know what, I don't think anybody's really waiting for my next event. So I quietly stopped.
Ally Dunnett: Exactly. And I love event. Yeah. To know, I keep an eye out now. Since you spoke to us about them when when we first chatted, I th I think it's very interesting. okay, but yes, to move move us on a little bit. we always like to ask whether whether there are inter any interesting developments coming up for you. and this could be either in Cook or in terms of the way you want to be shaping your your own independent work in the next twelve months or so.
James Rutter: So what might be interesting, I'm just going to say this because then it might force me to do it because I've said it in public.
Ally Dunnett: Ha ha ha.
James Rutter: I'm planning to, so one of the things that I did when I kind of started my little solo printer business was I think, oh yeah great, I'll do kind of a monthly newsletter and that's going to be really easy. And I quickly found out that doing a monthly newsletter when you've got loads of other stuff on is not very easy at all. So after about three months it died a quiet death. I mean, it's not like I had an audience of thousands.
Ally Dunnett: Ha ha.
James Rutter: But I'm committed. I want to get a newsletter up and running. And so I've got an idea which is a little bit fleshed out. I'm planning a weekly newsletter called The Secret Strategist. And this is a kind of a new slant on strategy for anybody who's supposed to know what it means but often doesn't, basically. So which is most of us because it's one of those words that
Ally Dunnett: Yeah.
James Rutter: everybody bands around. And actually not many people know what it means. So I'm planning to launch that over the summer, The Secret Strategist. Yeah.
Ally Dunnett: Great. Well we'll be looking for it so so that will hold you to it as you say. That that sounds
James Rutter: You
Ally Dunnett: great. I love it. Ned.
Ned Wells: Okay, James, yeah, we're reaching the end of our time, which is a shame. but I've got a couple of little ending questions. So the first one is thinking about the sort of the food and retail sectors, where where do you hope they will be in ten years' time?
James Rutter: do I hope there will be or where do I think there will be? Those are two very different questions. think, well, food retail, so not food and retail, I would say food retail specifically. It just makes me cry sometimes in this country how bad our approach to food retail is. And there are a couple of instances
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
James Rutter: recently that just really hit home to me. So in London Bridge station, this must be going
back maybe five years, maybe longer. I can't remember which company, one of the big companies who owns those sites in transport hubs, they wanted to test out a new format of kind of convenience store within a station. And they created this lovely space in London Bridge, which had a great variety of things, including two Cook freezers, but a good kind of selection of interesting food. It had some kind of pretty high end wine. had some books. It just felt
Ned Wells: Hmm.
James Rutter: like a really lovely kind of high end place. But it's now just reverted back to a classic convenience store with rows upon rows of chocolate, crappy sandwiches, protein drinks. and not a else. And so just that just made me sad. And then equally near me here in Kent, in a town called Headcorn, there was a lovely kind of deli, guess, can't remember what it was called, but it was a deli. did some lovely stuff, locally made things. Again, had some lovely Cook freezes in there. It must have been there for five or so years. Suddenly, out of the blue, it shut just before Christmas. No idea what happened. And now it's turned into, you know, a fried chicken takeaway. on one hand a vape
Ally Dunnett: Why?
James Rutter: shop in the middle and, you know, and again,
Ned Wells: no. Yeah.
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: kind of UPF toting newsagent on the other side. And it just makes me, it just makes me despair a bit because ultimately, you know, food, food culture drives so much else. You know, we think about healthy outcomes, which therefore impact economic outcomes, which impact, you know, society.
Ally Dunnett: Mm.
James Rutter: And actually we're failing. to see how these things connect and how actually without some really bold and intentional action, we're just gonna keep sliding further into the abyss on this kind of stuff. So, sorry, that's a very depressing thing to say, it? But that's why I do despair a bit of food retail specifically in this country because I think without some more proactive action, particularly from government, around what we can do and we've
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: started to make a few baby steps in that direction but linking things more closely together, food, health, education as well, without that kind of action we're probably not going to up in a very good place in 10 years. Or what we'll end up with is a very high-end, expensive, extremely quote unquote good end of the market and a very big kind of Sway's are pretty depressing.
Ned Wells: Mm.
Ally Dunnett: Yes, that's easy to picture, isn't it? That that increased polarization. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
James Rutter: Yeah. Sorry, I shouldn't be so depressing, should I? Because there is some good, I mean, there is some good stuff at the same time. Yeah.
Ned Wells: It's fascinating. I mean I wanted to go on to spot to sort of put a spotlight onto Cook's longer term plan to grow at ten, fifteen percent, I think you said. But I suppose the reflections I've got there is that one was, you know, is growth always a good thing? Do we need growth? But I think in the light of what you've said, where there's a clear opportunity to you know, grow for organizations to grow into that area which is so shit in in in in food retail.
Ally Dunnett: Mm-hmm.
Ned Wells: I can see that sort of growth being really positive.
James Rutter: Yeah, and I do think, you know, the growth question is always a really interesting one from anybody who takes, if you like, sustainability and the planet's boundaries seriously. It's a very
Ned Wells: Hm.
James Rutter: serious question. And yet I think the challenge... The challenge is that as businesses, operate in a market that largely ignores all those challenges. We mustn't kid ourselves that that isn't the case. know, we're part of a whatever, there's 3000 B Corps in the UK. I want to say there's three million registered businesses or six million or something. don't know. You know, it's literally a drop in the ocean.
Ned Wells: Yeah. Yeah.
James Rutter: And actually, the imperative for us as purpose driven, impactful, seeking businesses is genuinely to be as successful as we possibly can because through our success, we will hopefully inspire other people, show people a different way as possible and to a degree start to shame other businesses into actually doing some similar things. so while on the one hand you can kind of have the anguish about growing in a in a planetary environment in which we're already exceeding the boundaries.
Ned Wells: Mm.
James Rutter: I think the other imperative is almost, if you've got the seed of a great thing, you need to keep going. You need to keep figuring out how to make that as successful as you possibly can. Because actually that's your obligation. Having started down that road, your obligation isn't to give up and say, work's done, because actually the challenge is immense.
Ned Wells: And it's not a trivial question, nor is that a a single sort of easy answer.
James Rutter: No, God no. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And you know, business is tough as well, you know, so. So I do think, you know, I'll leave you with one one kind of factoid, which I can't quite remember the details, but I remember some research from about five years ago was about the performance of B Corp's. I think it was based on the US, but but over the preceding decade, this was for mostly kind of retail facing or FMCG type B Corp's, you know, that outperformed the general market by a significant point, 10%. to know. I've got the slides somewhere. And then I think that research has been updated more recently for the UK to show a very similar result. And I think the interesting thing I've always said around that, my kind of leap of faith a little bit in interpreting that data point, is that business is blooming hard to succeed at the best of times. And then you add on all these constraints that come with being a B Corp, or whatever you want to be in terms of. a personal wrapper, but having some kind of genuine constraints.
You have got to be so good at operating a business that actually you're going to perform a bit better than the average. Because just to embrace the constraints, to add on a load of pain to what already is a pretty painful process of trying to succeed in business is almost embracing a more rigorous way of operating, which means your chances of performing, surviving, succeeding. are just that little bit better than the average bear because you've got that extra bit of commitment in that and that extra bit of rigor that's contributing to your performance.
Ned Wells: So fascinating. Ali,
Ally Dunnett: Very good.
Ned Wells: over to you.
Ally Dunnett: Okay. I my usual concluding question, you've given us so much good advice already, I think, for for businesses who are trying to to do this balancing act of sustainability and and hitting their financial targets. But would you pick out one piece of advice for for other businesses trying to to make that balance?
James Rutter: I would go for clarity, Slightly talking my own book, but in the sense of I just think you have got to just get really clear, both on the strategy for the business, but then if you like your strategy and ambitions on the sustainability or impact side of things and how those two things connect and link together or not. And I think getting really clear on that will just help you avoid a lot of anguish and pain. down the line as it were. And just accept that it is always hard and there are always trade-offs and that doesn't make you a bad person or a bad business person. Actually, you have to make some trade-offs in order both to survive and prosper and so accept that but never lose sight of the bigger prize.
Ally Dunnett: Great, thank you.
Ned Wells: I guess the burning question for me, we may or may not include this in the podcast, is is strategy. What is it? What are the have
James Rutter: Hehehehehe
Ally Dunnett: Huh.
Ned Wells: do you have at your fingertips like four or five things you need to think about? Because it's it's a huge and important, but also, as you say, not often that easy to sort of visualize.
James Rutter: Yeah, yeah. so many definitions. Yeah, and they're all equally vague and rubbish. You know, I do think there is some truth in strategy as choice. And so being able to put on a piece of paper, what is the intentional choices you're making in order to move you further to your desired outcome that you think is valuable? I think if you can do that, you're part of the way there. And then and how are you going to make sure that you follow each of those choices right through your organizational business? You know, I think I think that's a that's a decent that's a decent kind of definition.
Ned Wells: Nice one. We'll
Ally Dunnett: Record.
Ned Wells: wrap it up there. That was brilliant. Thank you, James. finally, how
James Rutter: Cool, no thank you both.
Ally Dunnett: Yeah, thank you.
Ned Wells: can people find out more about you?
James Rutter: Oh, well, I try and post a thought or two on LinkedIn every week. So do look me up there. I guess how do you search on LinkedIn? James Rutter. I guess you'll find me. And
Ned Wells: Exactly.
James Rutter: then my website, my personal website is james-rutter.com.
Ned Wells: Awesome. What fun. That was brilliant, James. Thank you.
Ally Dunnett: Yeah, thank you.
James Rutter: Pleasure.