رونوشت 🔗
speaker-0: you Okay, so, Layla, we've had a pretty rambling conversation to jump off about the Odyssey, why we were doing the Odyssey, why we're having that conversation. We've also had Cassie of the High Key Obsessed podcast come in and do a fantastic job of tying the Red Rising world to the Odyssey itself. As we kind of come to the natural end of this conversation, as we kind of wrap up the Odyssey, and our deep dive into the Odyssey. What is a hero? I know that sounds basic. I know that should be the first thing that we talked about way back when we started this, but it almost, you almost have to go through your own Odyssey in reading the Odyssey to kind of get an idea to grasp this nebulous concept of the hero. So what is a hero in your understanding? And maybe if you could for the listener, what's a hero in the Western canon? Like what does it actually mean? And then what is it to you?
speaker-1: So my hot take, which I don't think is particularly hot, like maybe a little lukewarm, is that I think like Marvel and DC and all that has like really kind of somewhat ruined our understanding of a hero. And specifically the movie versions, because they flatten out a lot of the complexities of those characters. And I know that this has been the criticism around the new Odyssey movie is that it flattens out the complexity of Odysseus and the hero that he is. And so, and our understanding of a hero is distinctly different to an ancient understanding of a hero. And that's true of like somebody who was probably reading some of these texts in the forties to now. So like, I think we've really had a lot of cultural shifts around what heroes are and what they mean. Heroes. I think we often, especially like in this land and year of years of discourse and threads and having to fucking qualify everything you say a million times. Otherwise someone will be like, mean this? And that's not what you meant. I think we expect them to be extremely pure, extremely morally pure. And they never were, they're not supposed to be. And yes, we have like a very classic anti-hero. And, and those are very morally impure to the degree where you kind of rooting for the wrong guy. But a hero also like Odysseus is in the text is I think a really morally gray and a morally complicated character. And we see that with Daryl as well. I I blew up the dockyards of Ganymede, destroyed a bunch of his own people, you know? So, I don't know if that fully answers your question, but to me, a hero.
speaker-0: to you.
speaker-1: To me, a hero is most interesting. A hero, you know, there's this, there's a kind of famous quote, someone's hero is another person's terrorist. there's that kind of famous thing. To me, a hero is, often quite simply someone who believes in something and will fight for it. And that is what it is to me in like a text when I'm reading, right. When I'm reading a book or whatever. someone who believes in something is fight for it and is kind of our main character and what they, where they fit, where their actions fit morally can kind of be anywhere. that's kind of how I see it.
speaker-0: Yeah, that's interesting because that gives you, you know, wide, you know, it gives you wide latitude to take in any text or any movie or anything really and say, regardless of where my opinion or where I'm from or what my backstory is, I'm open to finding the heroic journey of this person or character through their own, their own vision. what they see, you know, like, Gabrielle Princep thought he was being a hero.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: know, you know, one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter, that kind of mentality. And, you know, you could say he was being heroic in trying to fight for his cause. And what you're saying, I think is accurate in that if you read his memoir, if there was such a thing, you might read it and see where the hero's journey in his life was. But it directly leads to tens of millions of deaths and the modern world in which we live in. it was the action of a hero. And then you could even dial it down even further. Like, is it the action of a hero to assassinate somebody? know, yeah, the act of assassination is probably not usually seen as heroic.
speaker-1: It's not heroic. It's definitely not heroic. But. Yeah.
speaker-0: And so, yeah, keep going. I cut you off there.
speaker-1: No, no, no. I just think that having that wider latitude to even If we talk about thing about Odysseus, right? Like I spent most of the text. This is the first time I'd read it since high school. Being like, man, I hate this dude. Like, why are you putting your goddamn dad to the test at that point? you know, at some point you're like, he's frustrating and he's so clever and he's so interesting and he's, all these different things. And that's, I don't know. I want a compelling character. and to me, a hero is kind of anything that. any character that is fighting for a specific thing that is our central character and that is compelling. it's pretty wide, it's pretty broad. I don't care that much one way or the other. That sounds harsh. I'm sure someone's going to take umbrage with that statement.
speaker-0: And if they do it's on them because it's you're not you're you're not defining the hero as such you're not saying that the hero has a limited Confine within which they have to live or follow hit these steps and that makes them a magical hero Yeah, it's not Arthur pulling a sword out of a stone and that makes him a hero by imbuing him with some heroic thing it is just What does he do with that sword? that makes him then either a hero or an anti-hero or not a hero. What is the importance of the hero's journey in the modern age and literature? Like, why do we still feel compelled to understand heroes?
speaker-1: We wouldn't have literature without the hero's journey. would not have, like, we just wouldn't, I don't know. I feel like we wouldn't have books without the hero's journey. Right. And like, yes, it is based
Load full transcript
largely on the Western canon, right? Like the Campbell's specifically Campbell's, right? I think the first properly mapped hero's journey story is,
speaker-0: Kill Gamesh.
speaker-1: it's Gilgamesh, right? Yeah. It's the epic of Gilgamesh. And so we wouldn't, we just wouldn't have the stories that we have. I don't, I don't know what kind of stories it would have without the hero's journey. And the reason why it works is because it captures the whole, like the hero's journey captures the whole journey of being human. That's the reason why we have it, right? From like the, the mentor and the going to hell and the depth theory, and then they return to home and. All those things and all the characters as well along the way that the hero meets archetypes exists because they they're real and they're human. And so I don't know that we could possibly even have anything else as humans. Like we would have to be kind of a fairly different species to have anything other than the hero's journey as our structural thing that gives us our fiction and our stories and our kind of. Even if we think about our lives, there's a certain type of kind of a hero's journey, right? Like the kind of the things that we tell ourselves that we need to do, through life to kind of tick all the boxes. It's like, there's a bit of a hero's journey aspect to it as well. All You go to school, you have mentors and then you start a job and then your job like grinds you down. So you're in hell and you go home each day and return to your family. like all this stuff is just hero's journey nonsense. And it's kind of cool.
speaker-0: I think that's spot on. think for me, and it's probably a very simplistic male thought. It's why I love Westerns, but High Noon is always, I think Westerns are the perfect distillation of heroes. It's almost simplistic and at times it is simplistic, but that's almost the point. It's trying to show you that it doesn't have to be anything more than just a story about somebody doing something that's very difficult and sticking to it and then maybe getting the outcome that they want, but maybe not. And that that is also life. High noon, I think, is the epitome of the hero for me because it's the idea of doing something even when you're scared. What's bravery? What's courage? It's doing something even when you are not going to succeed, but still doing it. And I think that that's, to your point, like what would stories be if they didn't have that? If the main character or the character in question wasn't striving for something impossible or unlikely to succeed and didn't have impossible odds to face. and didn't try and overcome them and maybe overcome them, but maybe not, what would we be fucking consuming? And I think there's an element of what you were saying earlier where Marvel, Disney, all these things, they lose the force for the trees because they have so many heroes, but none of them are really ever going to not succeed. that's where it becomes pure escapism because There's no weight, there's no value to that lesson because that's not life. And life is about failure and then not letting that destroy you. But sometimes it fucking does.
speaker-1: Yeah, which is why I think that we find Red Rising so compelling and why the majority of the fandom says Darrow's in for it in Red God, right? Like, there's just something very real about him and about that hero's journey.
speaker-0: Well, so hold on before you pick that apart is I guess this is the question that that the howlers out there are going to be most interested in. Is Darryl a hero? Because some would argue that he's not. Some would say he can't be a hero because he's done terrible things. He can't be a hero because he's selfish. He can't be a hero because he doesn't care about others' feelings or opinions. or what they want.
speaker-1: At that point we're reading a different book. I'm sorry, but like...
speaker-0: I'm just listing the arguments that you might hear and that Darrow ultimately can't be a hero because in the process of gaining the thing that he wants, he has laid waste to a certain swath of humanity and he's become something different than when he started his journey and that that somehow makes him unqualified to then be a hero. Now, what are the arguments against that?
speaker-1: That like almost all of that is like, it's everything. Like all of that is the hero's journey. Hero has to do something terrible at some point. Like they can't, they don't get to go, they don't get to go to hell. They don't get to go and visit hell and go through all that stuff without having done something terrible. You are like, that's, that's just not how anything works. It's just not how that story structure works. You have to have done something terrible. I do not for one second believe that Darrow doesn't care what other people think and how they feel. Like frequently he's agonized by his choices. He frequently he's agonized by the men that he loses in.
speaker-0: But okay, I'm gonna push back on that in that
speaker-1: Okay.
speaker-0: That I agree with you. He definitely feels guilty feels concerned and he thinks about other people But that doesn't stop him from doing the thing that he wants to do or feels like is the right thing to do
speaker-1: Yeah, but I think that's, only really happens in iron gold and dark age. Well,
speaker-0: Morningstar, Golden Sun, the thing that they want him to do, or Harmony wants him to do, is blow up the gala and he decides not to.
speaker-1: Well, that's a heroic thing to not do, right? Like in that-
speaker-0: But it's kind of the example that he is thinking about what other people want and need and desire and wish for and then does what he thinks is right.
speaker-1: to the blow up the gala thing though, he doesn't do it because he doesn't want to. He says, EO would not want me to do this. Doesn't do it for himself. He doesn't not do it for himself. He doesn't do it for EO. So I have this argument that like rarely
does Darrow ever do anything for himself. He's either doing something for the rising, he's either doing something for EO, he's doing something for Mustang, he's doing something for Pax, he's doing something for the Republic. rarely, rarely, rarely does he make a choice for himself because it's what he would want to do. What does Darrow for funsies want to go blow up the docks of Ganymede?
speaker-0: Okay, well, I agree. At the same time, even if he doesn't, then why doesn't he do it? Or why does he not blow up the Dock Skinning?
speaker-1: Wait, say rephrase that question again.
speaker-0: I agree with you, he doesn't want to do it. Yeah. Then why does he still do it?
speaker-1: Because he sees a tactical reason to do it.
speaker-0: in my understanding of the world, that's him wanting to do it.
speaker-1: Hmm. I disagree with that because I think because he wants a successful strategic outcome.
speaker-0: Want's a successful strategic and that want drives him to do a thing that he knows is wrong, but the want supersedes the ethics or morality.
speaker-1: Yeah. but like I, here's another way of thinking about it. In the year of our Lord, 2026, where hiring and job, the job market is a motherfucker and somebody takes a job with Google that they don't really want to take a job with Google because Google is this big evil like corporation now that spies on everything and everyone. But the way that we put. food onto our tables and roofs over our heads is by working for Google.
speaker-0: And this is totally a pedantic argument. I agree with you that Darrow doesn't want to do the doxaganamine. He needs to, he has to, because of the strategic outcome has to be a certain way. It's not a want, but this is like a Diogenes very pedantic little argument. Well, you want food on your table. So you're taking the job with Google because you want food on your table. So the want is driving you to do the thing. totally agree.
speaker-1: At point, survival instincts really kick in, Colin. I don't know how to ride a bike and that's been a problem for 40 years, but now at age 40, I'm like, know what? My survival instincts are too strong and now not getting on two wheels that I don't know how to ride. Do you see what I'm getting at? I
speaker-0: You want to live, I get it.
speaker-1: want to live. I want to live by eating food. I want to live by putting some food in my tail. I'm going to go work for fucking Google. Like that's kind of what...
speaker-0: We're outcome driven, right? And so, you know, whether or not it's... I think if we dial it back to the hero, the outcome is what we're invested in. We're invested in the outcome because we're invested in the character. And Darrow's desired outcome is a society-less version of humanity. And how do we get there? And do we always take the right decision? Maybe not. Do we always take the right path? Definitely not. And if he did every time, and I think the crux of it really is, and I don't know if you agree with this or not, but the hero can't be the same at the end as he is in the beginning. If he is, then it's not a well-written story. It's Captain America. He's wearing the costume and he's the same at the end. Maybe he's got a couple of cuts in his shirt or he's got an eye loop that's ripped or whatever. but he's still the same at the end. And there's a safety blanket nature to it. We like that feeling, and that's why Marvel does so amazing numbers, is because they're very safe with it. But like, Darrow in the mine cannot possibly be Darrow at the end of Red God, and if he was, we wouldn't fucking like it.
speaker-1: Yeah. like, and we have a real, like the thing that, the thing that's like, I guess like easy and a bit of a cop out with Darrow is that he has like a real genuine physical transformation, right? Like he, in the first book, right? Like he like that in and of itself is like, it kind of not quite enough, but you know, gets him there fair way.
speaker-0: It's jet fuel to the process. Right.
speaker-1: But you see this in other great pieces of fiction that, you know, we both know that, that, that Pierce has talked about as, as kind of pieces of inspiration. The Rand is a piece of shit by the end of the wheel of time. It's a real piece of shit by the end of the wheel of time. Paul Atreides is a fundamentally different person from book one to book. How fucking many there are.
speaker-0: Isn't he like a thousand year old worm god or something?
speaker-1: Yeah, at some point, right? There's a fundamentally a different person. Again, the hero's journey would not work if there weren't these transformational bad choices, right? Like the dockyards of Ganymede, I'm sure, I know you guys have done it or you're about to do it. Have you?
speaker-0: We haven't gotten there yet, but we've touched the- Is the, think I've come around to this idea that the dockyards is tactical. mean, it really is, if you think about it, it's just tactical. If you really want to dive into whether or not Darrow is a hero or not, it is almost a passing line in, I think, Lightbringer, where they are torturing Diomedes, Severo's torturing Diomedes. They throw the idea of honor at Cassius and Severo says something to the effect of, really did miss the war. This is a speeding ticket. You're thinking this is a murder. This is a speeding ticket. We have tortured, we have done way worse. And Darrow in that conversation flips and at first he's horrified seeing his friend do something horrible. But then when he realized that there's information, there's value to what was being done, he in that chapter is like, well, what did he say? Because he's instantly engaged with, okay, well, I didn't agree with the methods, but sure, what was the information?
speaker-1: Yeah, right.
speaker-0: That change right there is vastly more important to me than the Ganymede.
speaker-1: Hmm
speaker-0: Because that tells you that in the 12 years or so since Ganymede, he has done horrible stuff to then get where he
is now. Yeah. As far as the hero changing, that to me is way more of a red flag, or not a red flag, but...
speaker-1: But yeah, I see what you're saying. And, and has become comfortable with it in a way, not necessarily fully comfortable. Like he still gets, he's not so far, he's not a Paul Atreides by the end of it, right? Like where Paul completely goes off the rails. Like he's, we don't have that in Dara yet, but, but we, have, you know, we have somebody who, I just think. He lives in the real world and I to say that. Like I, I wish that the real world was butterflies and craziness and hugs and whimsy and all that beautiful shit that we all love and all that sort of stuff, but it just isn't. And morality and these hero stories really are just a weighing the means to the end always, every step of the way. And, and where does, where does the, where does the, where do we justify that long way? So. I don't know. Like I think, I think, we can get pedantic about what type of hero he is. can say, he an anti-hero? Is he this? Is he that? Is he a tragic hero? he- changes. It changes from-
speaker-0: That's something that you see and I don't you know to drop back to the Odyssey I think you see that with Odysseus too like the version of the hero that he is is is similar to Dero or they kind of mirror each other in that According to the problem that he's faced with he becomes the version of the hero that needs to yeah Overcome that yeah, sometimes it's the antihero and it's dirty and it's horrible. Yeah Sometimes it's the tragic hero Is that a function, do you think, of this totemic thing, the hero, or is that just good writing?
speaker-1: Ehm. think it's a little bit of both, but I do think it's bit of good writing. And like I talked to Skipper about this, her favorite Darrow quote is, expect me. I think he it a couple of times.
speaker-0: Yeah, when he falls off after tree dies and he goes down
speaker-1: Yeah. Like expect me. And it's just like, favorite is, you know, is in light bringing. And one of my favorites is in light bringing it where he's like, lady, I fucked you up. It's just like, I love Darrow when he's arrogant as shit. And one of my favorite, one of my.
speaker-0: That's the dark age conversation with Atlantia before when he finds out the red dot.
speaker-1: It's not library, it's dark age.
speaker-0: It's fantastic.
speaker-1: it's so good. It's so good. Cause it comes on the heels of, well, here I am, you deviant bitch. Right? Like, so it's like, it's, that's the payoff for here I am, you deviant bitch. and then my favorite, my favorite Odysseus moment is, you know, is no one. And then he turns around and fucks it up by being like, why did I miss Odysseus? on, you know? And like, but I love those moments. I love the arrogant moments in characters. Cause like, to be honest, they both deserved it at that point. They've earned that arrogance at that point.
speaker-0: Yeah, I think there's nothing more unappealing in fiction or in the real
world than unearned arrogance. Yes. That is a terrible quality for somebody to have. Yeah. But when somebody can say, am the best at this fucking thing. know, Michael Jordan is the most cutthroat trash talker ever, but he can be. Yeah,
speaker-1: Three
speaker-0: Because fucking Michael Jordan, he's on a show.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Nobody's gonna say, you you can't really talk back. It's that mentality where it's kind of a pleasure to watch because, or read about because as the reader or the consumer, you're like, wouldn't that be awesome to be able to say, expect me and then have somebody in a room be like, shit, he's coming back at some point, you know? We never get that moment.
speaker-1: I'm going to go off the rails slightly here, but like you see this like, you know, there's a lot of friends of mine who, who like Taylor Swift. I'm a big Swifty who liked Taylor Swift. like, she's punching down with some of her songs recently. Like there was a song where she's, you know, talking about people trash talking her and she's just like, trash talk back. And I'm like, is she though? Like she can, she kind of can punch down. Like she is the Taylor Swift. Like she has earned the right to be like your motherfuckers, I'm the greatest. She just has earned that right.
speaker-0: I mean, that would be like if the Beatles put out a diss track, nobody would question that. Yeah. They'd just be like, well, the Beatles put out a diss track, so that's cool.
speaker-1: Yeah. So it's the same kind of thing. Anyway, so I've kind of derailed this a little bit, but I like those, but that also makes them human because like what you said, there's nothing more attractive than unearned arrogance, but there's also something that's also equally unattractive. And that is, modesty that is false, right? Like where you're like, I'm, it's, I'm, I'm just Darrow. I'm, I'm nobody. I'm just, I'm just a guy from the mines. It's like, piece of shit. You're like, you are like, built stronger than any other gold, deliberately so, you have an insane strategic mind, you've taken down the society, you've married to the baddest bitch in the Republic, you've done all of these things. Like, yeah, you get, you get to trash talk, you get to do all of these things. And if he was modest or like just kind of, you know, hand waving it away, that would just be equally annoying. know, like that's just as annoying because it's not real. Like it's not real because you know, know, you know, you know, if you're pretending you don't know, then that's.
speaker-0: And we have the added layer of knowing the inner workings of Darrow's mind. So like we also know that he trash talks, but he's also not he's not a Callous arrogant asshole. Yeah, he feels bad about shit and he doesn't want to do the bad stuff and he feels like that's there's a way around it or whatever and So it's not part of his identity to just be a it's not weightless. It's not It's not based in nothing. know, it's not figments of his imagination of greatness. He is great. And so he can do that. One thing that I wonder about with Dero is if, I think another aspect to that, that we all love those moments, the here I am, the motherfucking consequences, the expect me, the I fucked you up bitch.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: There's also immediately, usually like the no man and then saying his name. There's also that part of it where he almost always after one of those moments has like a huge letdown where everything goes fucking awry and he's got to pick up the pieces. So we don't really wallow in that moment because we don't have time to because something shitty happens pretty quickly after. Back to the Odyssey and let's kind of. put a button or a bow on this. The Odyssey is an incredible journey, an incredible story. It's probably one of two foundational Western canon pieces, the Odyssey of the Iliad. Where it's super interesting from our point of view now is to see it over thousands of years evolve, take on the moral and ethical mores of the time. change with the medium and the invective of the world in which it's being consumed and put out. When you first read it, I'm assuming in high school, to now, at 40, how has it changed in a smaller version of that thousands of years of evolving?
speaker-1: I I think that like, you're asking me to like think back 25 years.
speaker-0: It's tough, it's tough out there.
speaker-1: Dude, you know, I think that... When I studied in high school, we kind of took a lot of little side quests too, right? we didn't necessarily- What's a Vehicle,
speaker-0: It's it's a-
speaker-1: gods, you might've done an entire lesson on the gods and Apollo and Athena and blah, blah. So I don't recall kind of focusing on Odysseus himself and his particular journey that much. So that was my focus during this read, because I knew we were reading it for this. was reading it before the movie comes out because, know, I think it's, think it's, saw it, so sorry, gonna take a little side quest here right now. I saw, I read somebody being like, something like, let me get this straight. People are now reading the Odyssey and East of Eden or whatever, just because a movie or a TV show is coming out. Is that why? And I'm like, why do we care why people are fucking reading? They're reading, let them read.
speaker-0: it's so bizarre to me. Like not only like let them read, but also this is how it works. people, people a hundred years ago would read a review or a book and in it they would talk about India and then they would say, I'm going to pick up, know, read your, you know, whatever. That's how this works. You, you, you are influenced by something else in the culture or somebody else that then puts you onto a new thing. How else are you supposed to find shit?
speaker-1: Are we really gatekeeping why people read? Like, I just think that's insane. Anyway, all this is-
speaker-0: Really 3000 year old poems or 85 year old novels like who gives a shit how they found it.
speaker-1: So all this is to say is that in the preparation for reading it, I did focus on Odysseus this time around. and that is, think, a fundamentally more interesting way to approach this particular text. Right? Like I can go and I can learn about Athena and Apollo, et cetera, sideways, all kinds of different ways. Like it is fundamentally a book about one man and his journey. And if you focus on that one man and his journey, it's more interesting. I. To me, the second half of the Odyssey, once they arrive back on Ithaca, is way more fascinating than anything he does before then, for most of it. That's just because most of the plot is there. But until then, he's like, off we go to another place and something terrible happens and he loses a bunch of his men and he faces his monsters, et cetera. I know that people will disagree with me on this. know they're going to say, but when he goes and he talks to the shades, that's really important. Yes, it is. We've talked about throughout part as well. There's some really important moments with the women and how the women weave themselves into the story. But fundamentally for me, it's kind of, it just uses great plot to get Ithaca back is fucking cool. And it is, and he wouldn't be able to do it and he wouldn't be who he is and he wouldn't be able to plot the way that he does if he hadn't gone through those 10 years of hell. So what I think was interesting about the movie is that it takes some of that away and we have the one trick. Right? Like he's not, he's not the great trickster. He has the one great trick and it's the horse and the rest of it kind of goes away. That's why I was upset with the removal of no one because that's a great trick. That's a fucking great trick that he pulls on polyphemus.
speaker-0: Yeah, I think you're you and I probably are maybe by osmosis or something. We had the same kind of pull away. I remember in high school finding it really interesting and I really was reading it for Odysseus because I just thought it was cool that you had a hero being smart at times and not just being the strongest on the field. A lot of you know when I was like 16 or 17 or whatever. most stuff that you're reading, it's usually like the guy who can punch the hardest and happens to whatever. Odysseus is thinking his way out of the box a lot of the time. that was interesting. Less interesting now at 40. And not because I'm like now way more interested in the guy who punches harder, but because I think it was, I felt like I've maybe read so much that's based or has, you know, ancestry here that I didn't really need the evolution of him and the growth and the fighting the monsters and figuring out how to solve these things. I also was like, just get to fucking Ithaca. Get to
speaker-1: Yeah
speaker-0: Ithaca. Let's do the Ithaca thing because that's where it really gets interesting. And I think maybe because you're, you're also right in that that's where the plot is. And it almost feels like a series of disconnected side quests because there's really no plot. For the first two thirds of it or whatever. I mean, there is, but it's very ethereal. It's misty. Once we're in Ithaca, to me, it becomes much more interesting, much more compelling. And I also think an age thing. At that point, there is an element of when I was 18 or 17, however old reading it, the adventure was exciting. The destination isn't really what I'm thinking about. It's the adventure and the process of getting there. Now I'm at the destination in life and I'm, or, you know, I'm not at the destination, but I'm getting there and.
speaker-1: typed that in for a while yet, Colin.
speaker-0: But I'm more interested in how, one navigates the homecoming and all that.
speaker-1: was just far more interested in this re in this time around about what people are saying, not just Odysseus, but all the characters around him, what they say about him, what they say about their world, what they say about their structure, et cetera. And it's interesting that you say that whole thing about like, you know, I, for example, I watched star Wars for the first time, like really quite late. I think I was like almost 30 when I watched the original trilogy and I was like, This is what everyone's like really into all the time, but I think it was that whole thing. So many other things that are based on Star Wars that I had just absorbed it and it no longer felt original. actually felt really hokey. and I think it, I think it takes a very special type of text or film or whatever to survive its, offspring. Do you know what I mean? Like one of my favorite films is, one of my favorite films is the cabinet of Dr. Caligari. It's kind of largely regarded as the first horror film. Yep. And it survives, it survives its offspring in so many ways. And that's, it's very rare for something to do that. Star Wars doesn't, I'm sorry to say, it just doesn't survive its, its offspring.
speaker-0: I think that's honestly a larger more, you know larger and interesting conversation because that is a I think that's that's Speaks to the Odyssey in that it has survived Its offspring for thousands of years. It's still is there
speaker-1: It's done it because it's evolving constantly. It's done it because we've never let it be an originalist thing, right? If we talk about originalist readings of the constitution or whatever, right? Like, let's frame it that way. We've never had an originalist reading of the Odyssey. just never ever have. We've already talked about this a little bit before, but like that's part of my issue with some of the reviews around this. Like let, let this be a different Odysseus, let this be a different, like it is the text for our times right now. And it might not hold up. Like maybe in 20 years we'll be like, look at that way that we agonized over that for no good reason. But like, that's what's beautiful about it. Whereas, you know, when we, you know, what was it that I was saw a long time ago? Someone, I was like somebody complaining about how. Batman was shot in Chicago and not in New York when Gotham is like a stand-in for New York. And I was like, we're gonna, if we're gonna like hold onto that so tightly, Batman and that text will never evolve in any meaningful way where it, where it becomes relevant to its newest audience. Right? And so if we had held on to whatever it is that the original Greek version was that they would have heard in Greek taverns of the Odyssey. No, of course it wouldn't have held up. There's no way it wouldn't have survived. We would not be talking about it now. So.
speaker-0: Yeah, I love that. think that that's exactly the right message here because in a thousand years, if somebody remakes a new hope, well, it's not a new hope. It's a different fucking thing. Whereas this has it built in that every time you tell the story of Odysseus, it is a different Odysseus. It's a different Odyssey and that's Okay. Well, this has been the first Version the first iteration of the forum and the next time it will be a different version. We will have Layla and myself here, but everything else will be different We'll be talking about a different topic a different book. I think we are planning to do Antigone. Is that?
speaker-1: Yeah, that's the we have on the dock.
speaker-0: So we will stay in the world of ancient Greece and mythology, but it'll be a different entirely take because we'll be talking about Antigone and her fight to do what's right, whether it's moral or natural or whatever argument you want to make, we'll figure it out. So thank you for listening to the forum. I've been your host, Cullen. We want to reach out and say thank you again to Beers the Mindkiller for the fantastic forum logo. And also a special thank you to Cassie for taking the time away from the Highkey Obsessed podcast. Join us. Layla, any last words? Or not last words, that's kind of bleak, but I mean like, know, anything you want to say at the end here.
speaker-1: just want to say thank you to Janelle for her time as well. We've had a wonderful conversation there, all of which you'll be able to find on our Patreon. Thank you for joining us. We hope that you find this as interesting and stimulating as we have found putting it together. And we will, do you want to do the line?
speaker-0: Yeah, Layla, very good job. You did the business part, which I always am bad at. You can find us on Instagram and Patreon at the Forum with a V pod. And you will get access to all this material for $3. That's a cup of coffee a month and you'll have full access to the entirety of the Forum. Thank you for listening. This has been Colin and Layla. We'll catch you next time.