رونوشت 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: A man that, well, he looks after us every time. He's been an absolute expert. I did my first boundary riding job in radio broadcasting, and this man right alongside me helped me out, Dr Peter Larkins.
00:00:12
Speaker 2: Welcome. Nice to talk to you again. Jeez, you're reminding me of that time. We must have been the only two that sat around when the rain arrived. Remember that? Everyone else disappeared, all the softies. I did ask. We went out for the cup of tea and the pie, and we stayed there to nut it out.
00:00:29
Speaker 1: I did ask to go upstairs, Doc, but they said no.
00:00:34
Speaker 2: They wouldn't let us up here, sir. There were days when I was the only one there, and then some days they would start up with six or seven sort of buddies around me, you know, all the radio stations, you know their names, and then that gradually wills away. And the blokes upstairs talking to me, James Brayshaw, one of them would say, don't you dare move. Don't you move. You stay there.
00:00:54
Speaker 1: Toughed it out. Well, a few blokes toughed it out in the grand final. There was some talk about Logan Morris having a bit of a back injury and Dane Zorko carrying a hammy. I'm just wondering how serious both of those injuries were that they could contribute like they did.
00:01:12
Speaker 2: Yeah, I'll talk about Logan Morris first because he's got a stress fracture in the back, which is very common in the footy world. They're obviously the very severe ones where the back pain is so high and your mobility is limited that you can't play footy. But there are low-level ones that players play with for quite an extended period of time. So they can be stress reactions or a low-grade stress fracture in one of the vertebrae. So it sort of sounds dramatic, doesn't it? But it's something that can be treated with pain relief, not injections, but just by normal pain relief therapy. And unless it gets really severe during the season, most people can carry those through. Now, the risk, of course, is the stress fracture gets bigger and bigger and takes longer to heal. We see them all. The classic ones, I guess, are in the fast bowls at cricket because they do that extension or the tennis players when they're serving. So this type of stress fracture in athletes who've got to arch backwards quite a bit, so Ruckman might get it, or obviously if you're a tall marking forward where you're extending your back. But as dramatic as it sounds, playing with a fractured back, it's actually a small area of the back and it's really just pain management. And I mean, it was hardly noticeable. And again, the fact that the story came out, it wouldn't be the only one in the league that's had that. And the fact that it was announced is sort of even surprising that they announced it, I would think.
00:02:29
Speaker 3: And Dr Larkins for the losing mob, their skipper, Alex Pearce, he suffered a partial tear on his right Achilles tendon and a calf strain as well.
00:02:39
Speaker 2: Yeah, well, of course, the calf and the Achilles work together because the Achilles tendon is the tendon attached to your calf muscle. So the distinguishing thing between a torn calf and a torn Achilles is often quite difficult. Obviously, the Achilles is lower down closer to the heel. I mean, I'm really surprised that it's not a surgical one. The way he went down and collapsed, it's almost a classical technique. um visual situation when the Achilles completely snaps and clearly he couldn't you know put weight on it or go back on um so so they've said he's got a partial tear now I reckon it's a pretty high percentage partial um obviously they've got the advantage of examining and having the scan and free obviously he doesn't require surgery but a high grade partial tear takes months and months to heal uh naturally without surgery um And we know if you snap your Achilles, and we've had plenty of those in the AFL in the last 10 years, that's really a 12-month injury. So that's a worse fate if it's fully snapped. But, gee, the partial tears, when we look after them, they take, you know, three, four, five months before people get going much on them. So I guess that's the good news is, you know, three or four or five months means he probably will be pretty much right to go come March or April. But it certainly was a dramatic tear, even though it wasn't complete. Dr.
00:03:48
Speaker 3: Larkins, this is a bit of a curveball. I haven't worded you up on this, but I reckon our listeners would be interested. Let's do a case study, right? I'm AFL player X. I've either done my hamstring or call it a soft tissue injury. What can you do and what happens as an AFL club doctor to get players up to continue the game? What are some of the things that can be injected, swallowed, tasted on?
00:04:11
Speaker 2: What is it? Taped up. Well, you're talking about during the game, if you've done it today.
00:04:16
Speaker 3: I'm talking grand final, halfway through the second quarter, the coach says, we need him on. What are some of the legal and ethical things you can do.
00:04:25
Speaker 2: As a doc? Well, sometimes you just say to the coach, you're dreaming. There's no way you can go back on because it's a high-grade hamstring. It's off the bone or it's fully ripped and the player can hardly run and they're not going to be of any use. So you've got to be honest with the coach. And you might be alluding to the fact that Dane Zorko hurt his hamstring in the first quarter and has got a premiership medal around his neck by playing out the game. So clearly it's not the sort of hamstring that you and I are used to seeing most weekends when they go down like they've been shot in the leg and they limp off and you hear about them. you know, being off the bone. So a real hamstring, a really high-grade hamstring, you cannot continue to play on the day. It doesn't matter what injection you might be thinking of. So legally, you're allowed to use Panadol. You're
Load full transcript
allowed to use normal pain relief. You can strap up and compress a low-grade injury, and that's what Dane Zorko did to use a specific player example from Saturday. He played with strapping on his thigh. It looked like it was a little strain. They called it a corky, which is obviously bleeding, and that sort of put the scent off from a few people. But it wasn't a high-grade tear because he was still able to contribute. He's hardly the speediest player on the ground, but he still needed his hamstring to chase an opponent and to dash. So he got away with it because he was able to get strapping, which compresses it, and he was able to get pain relief, which wouldn't have been an injection because once you inject around that area, you cause more bleeding and you lose feeling in it, so it would have been a higher risk of injury. So those sort of strategies aren't available. So you've really got to be honest with the coach. I mean, soft tissue injuries can be a calf, it can be a quad, it can be a groin, and it can be a hamstring. They're the four key soft tissue injuries we talk about in footy. And, you know, generally people get low-grade ones regularly that you can just strap up, take some pain relief, ice them up, and they might finish out the game. So that's the available strategies. But generally, with the intensity of the game, and when we talk about a real calf injury or a real hamstring, we're talking weeks and weeks in most circumstances.
00:06:13
Speaker 1: Hey, Doc, we see Jake Colajasny has now been medically retired. Does it sort of make that whole concussion waiver thing look a bit more ordinary, or is this a good call? I felt like the Amber-like call on him was a bit, you know, average, and it should have been one way.
00:06:33
Speaker 2: Or the other.
00:06:33
Speaker 1: But how do you feel like now he has been sort of medically retired?
00:06:39
Speaker 2: Yeah, well, just to address your colours point, red, amber, green, I mean, that is terminology. I've looked into this very thoroughly over the last month, as you might imagine, because of all the publicity. And I actually can guarantee you that that terminology was not used at all by the medical panel. And the medical panel does not know where this amber term came from because it did confuse people because there clearly was– a thought that, well, they didn't say he can't play and they didn't say he's good to play and someone's called an amber in between. Now, there was an opinion from the medical panel, which is more than one person. They weren't all in agreement, I understand. So the reason that Geelong tried to go down the pathway of continuing to play with the knowledge that he had problems, but he wasn't completely excluded, which some of the panels can do, it really confused everyone. And the waiver was sort of, it was the best intent by the club to to allow him to play at his request by the way and his manager's request with the understanding that you know there was a high risk and and he really needed to take that on board now clearly that's been thrown out and it'll never happen again because it's created such a you know a backlash hasn't it but just back to the terminology so let's get rid of this amber term because it was never used by the afl medical commission or the medical people that looked at him and i've actually spoken to them directly about that so this is not me just having a guess But the problem that arose was sometimes the medical panels make a very strong opinion. And I'll give you the example of Angus Brayshaw and people like Nathan Murphy at Melbourne have all been medically retired. The problem with Jake is that he didn't have all the severest signs of trouble, but he had enough trouble that he'd had multiple concussions and clearly had been assessed and asked by the club to do that. But they didn't make a definitive decision, hence he continued to play. But... The problem is, at his age, he's had lots of concussions. I think it's really hit home to him that his future health is more important. So the decision to medically retire is based on the fact that the medical committee did say that you have a lot of problems. We can't force you. They can't force people to retire. It's up to the player and the club, and that's happened on every occasion. And I think on reflection, over the period of the last few weeks, Jake has probably taken on board with his family and his loved ones that he really should be taking the advice that he's got changes consistent with too many concussions and he doesn't want to take the risk for his brain going forward.
00:09:08
Speaker 1: Doc, as comprehensive as normal, we really appreciate your time on this one, mate. Really appreciate it.
00:09:14
Speaker 2: That's all right. Well, hopefully there's nothing too dramatic in the pre-season we have to talk about. And what did you say before, how the Crows and Port, how they're going to improve? I'm interested to hear what the listeners come up with.
00:09:24
Speaker 1: Yeah, spot on, mate.
00:09:25
Speaker 2: Spot on.
00:09:26
Speaker 1: We've got a long pre-season ahead of us, so we look forward to that too.
00:09:29
Speaker 2: Okay. Good luck, boys. Nice to talk to you.
00:09:31
Speaker 1: Brilliant. Thanks, Doc.
00:09:33
Speaker 2: Dr.
00:09:33
Speaker 1: Peter Larkins, always giving us a great insight to AFL injuries and what's happening there. And a Isn't that interesting, him saying that the Amber thing was never, ever a proper medical, what would you say, they never used that term.
00:09:48
Speaker 3: It's like when you roll a big rock down a hill, Timmy, you just can't stop it.
00:09:52
Speaker 1: Yeah, and off she went.