رونوشت 🔗
speaker-0: This idea. I think what I realized in I realized through doing many of my projects that one of the key questions I was always interested in is what you said, which is like, this is what's happening and is it worth it? Is this a price worth paying for? And and then there was always the question of when you ask who if if it's worth it, you have to ask it for the individual. you know, general society, let's say, or you're then you're also thinking of it in the context of the nation, you know, the state. You know, it's that how they perceive it. Because you don't do big projects as a nation without thinking that you're gonna get something back out of it for for it. But the sacrifice is being brought ⁓ is being felt often by the individuals who live in these locations. And so I think That was a thing that you couldn't see. But what I could document was often what was unfolding. Mm-hmm.
speaker-1: Welcome back everybody to a new episode of iShot 50mm. And today we're sitting down with Iente. Ian is a British Malaysian photographer whose work has examined for more than three decades the relationship between economic development, environmental transformation, as well as human life. Together with iShot, we're doing this limited edition book called Undercurrents Reframed. China nineteen ninety nine two thousand and eight, which returns to the archive that defined the beginning of your career, in a way we could say, reinterpreting those photographs from a perspective of the present. Ian, thank you so much for being with me today and welcome.
speaker-0: Thank you for having me here.
speaker-1: Yes. And just a very small message before we start to everybody who's watching. I just want to remind to keep liking and keep subscribing because what's a very, very small click to you, it means the world for us. And since a couple of months now, we have all our interviews available as podcast. So Ian, let's actually start with the fun. And the very first thing I wanna discuss is your origins because your relationship with China began not only as a photographic journey, but also as a personal, I guess, investigation into culture, ancestry, and belonging. You were born in Malaysia. You grew up within a Chinese Malaysian cultural background, but later built much of your, let's say, professional ⁓ life in Britain, if I'm not mistaken. Perfect. Before photography entered your life, how did you see your cultural mm or understand your cultural identity?
speaker-0: I think I nev I knew very little about my own cultural identity. ⁓ so there was always a sense of wonder as to what my roots were before Malaysia. So whilst I was very familiar with Malaysian culture, I really had you know, my my grandfather on the paternal side came from China at some point. So there was a it was always shrouded in a sense of mystery. So I didn't really know ⁓ China at all. And I think throughout the eighties, ⁓ I grew up watching documentaries ⁓ from the BBC as China was opening up, ⁓
Load full transcript
and right through to the early nineties and that kind of caught my attention. So there's always a wonder, like, you know, I wonder what that place is like. And so when photography became a a focal point of interest, that was ⁓ it it Almost without me knowing it, that seemed to be a natural point, ⁓ destination for me to go to for for at least that reason and and a variety of others.
speaker-1: Cause you described traveling through China in the mid nineteen nineties as a decisive experience, if I'm not mistaken. I think I've read this. What happened during that first journey that made photography, I guess, feel like a possible life?
speaker-0: So there were two things. There was the pre-trip and the post-trip, I think, ⁓ and the the the actual trip itself. So the pre-trip, I had just finished a course in graphic design. I was very curious, ⁓ but I was very fascinated by photography and wondered if it could be a way of life for me. So that was the philosophical idea of how the camera could be one with me. Yeah. ⁓ in in the way I observed the world. ⁓ but when I went to China, I had a wonderful experience. ⁓ because at that time, I think it was nineteen ninety-five, ⁓ China was Deng Xiaoping's ⁓ policy economic ⁓ reform policies of opening the country up was kind of in swing. There was a real curious curiosity for the outside world. So as a foreigner visiting there, people were incredibly friendly, and of course. You could still see ⁓ many parts of China, like the old China that still existed there. So you could literally see history unfolding. That combination and that experience meant that I ended up traveling for three months in that place. ⁓ and I felt throughout that time that it was a sense of things like China was on the cusp of a major transition. And I didn't know. I was just learning photography. I didn't even know how to make a photo essay, but I felt like I needed to hang around. I needed to come back. And if anything, if I had to learn my my skills in China, that's what I would do. So I think it was that sense of commitment. ⁓
speaker-1: Okay, because also another very interesting thing about you about your trajectory, I guess, is that as we've been said, ⁓ you did not follow a conventional path of academic trained artists in that sense. So how did you educate your eye? Well were the experiences, the photo books, the photographers, the artists, not necessarily photography related, that really like shaped your initial visual eye. Language.
speaker-0: I think the first was the recognition of photographs that spoke to me in the early days. And this was before ⁓ this was when I was still in college and I would go to the library, because I wasn't an internet then, ⁓ and I would actually look at books. Quite often there were magnum photographers or or or annuals, and I would look at that and certain images used to just capture my imagination and I was filled with wonder. ⁓ not only of because of the images, but also what I imagined that life
might be like. So those those were the first things. But I think beyond that, and my initial experiences in China, the next thing that was fundamental in my development were often the conversations I had with people that were my friends. ⁓ and in some way we became mentors to us e towards each other. Those conversations were incredibly important. They were like ⁓ critiques and discussions about what about our intention, ⁓ about the photograph, yeah, what it did, and whether it fulfilled those goals that we had in mind. And so those discussions, often informal and through friendships, but sometimes also seeked. So, like ⁓ at that time I would reach out to professionals in the field. gain their perspective on my work. And those provided insights and were in in many ways the foundation of how I kind of developed my eye. I think the last thing I would say, ⁓ and this was kind of an early recognition and also my decision, because I there was always a choice I could be an intern ⁓ in a well-known agency or somewhere else. I was aware of those, those kind of like paths. ⁓ but I remember s thinking to myself that I don't want to s be there. And of admittedly I will be sacrificing maybe the opportunities to meet people in in in these environments, but I don't want to be looking at all these photographs from these great people, ⁓ and not be able to take them myself. I wanted to be on that adventure. And so I decided that what was important was really the time I spent in the field, just kinda crafting my my my skill. And so the very early years when I started photography, there was some long periods of of travel ⁓ to to build my skills up, I said.
speaker-1: It's interesting because like your photography and your method, your editing, your post production and everything, your photograph often feel like quite quiet and carefully, let's say, controlled, even when they are mm in situations that are unstable, that emerge from unstable or polluted or rapidly changing environments as well. So behind I feel like that apparent stillness, there is like a very well structured process of observation, waiting, selection that has been built and definitely connects to what you've been said so far. And the connecting also to this, I wanted to ask you, when you then arrive in in a place, the first thing you do, what is it? How what's your approach? Do you research and imagine the photographs in advance or you let yourself be guided by whatever is the flow that you're in?
speaker-0: Early stages I would say it was ⁓ it was a lot messier and organic in the approach. Yeah. but ⁓ it also produced magic in in many ways. ⁓ but I think what I've realized in hindsight when I look at some of my ⁓ best work or or work that I consider meaningful, I realized that I need a framework. a way to kind of understand what I'm gonna do and where I'm gonna go. But I always have to leave room for experimentation or for me to look elsewhere rather than some kind of structured, ⁓ always a structured kind of routine of where and what I plan to do. Those things need to be in place so that I am in a way anchored in some way and maintain my sanity. The second part is I need Room for experimentation. and interestingly, I always felt that photography was was incredibly difficult in some ways. And what I mean by that is you can spend a whole day trying to look for a picture. And most of your day is actually quite boring. Until you have a magic 10 minutes where something happens and you kind of wait for that. And the trick sometimes is being patient enough to know that all of everything else is that's part of the whole process and kind of to be at one with it, which I never was for a long time. But I recognize that I think it was a very important part of the process to to do that, you know. So yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: And you have to kind of like trust the process, which is hard to do at the beginning. So but later on you realize that the boredom allows you to reflect on how you wanna approach your project. The the pre it allows you to adjust your perception of the subject matter that you're working on. ⁓
speaker-1: ⁓
speaker-0: Because you're now in the field and the information is coming at you and you have to adapt to your understanding to to what you're trying to photograph.
speaker-1: And in terms of post production, what role does post production play in your work and how do you decide when an adjustment is needed ⁓ or not?
speaker-0: ⁓ so post production is an important role and but I it's the what I used to do in the dark room ⁓ when I was shooting black and white. Yeah. ⁓ all of those tools are what I use in the lightroom. ⁓ so in the sense that you know my traditional skills of printing, ⁓ dodging and burning, all of those things that you do. So I always kind of feel like a photograph, what you compose and what you capture, is essentially ⁓ a rough sentence. But the actual ⁓ work that you do on the print is kind of like the copy editing that you do to a sentence to bring precision to where you want the attention to be foremost, forefronted, and what is Perhaps less important. And you do that maybe in the English language, you might put ⁓ the first few words and the last few words are the ⁓ the key important words that leave an impression, more of an impression. And with the photograph, it's through dodging and burning where you want to how you compose the light you use and how you bring that up becomes part of that process of creating that sentence that you want to develop.
speaker-1: You there is one thing that I really really liked that I read as well is that you have compared your photographic project to a small films made from still images. What can what first of all, what do you mean by that and why? I would love for you to explain it as well. And what can sequencing then express that an individual photograph cannot? I'm leaving it like that.
speaker-0: Yeah yeah. No, good. It's a good one. It's ⁓ so I kind of one
of the things that I felt really frustrated with still photography was that that base was the sense of time. ⁓ you can't in movies you can put the end at the beginning. You can basically chop up time or chronology in multiple different ways. And I love that about film. And I love that how you can show different perspectives, ⁓ in the process through the way you edit ⁓ a movie or or film. But with photography, there isn't that. And it and it if there is, it's not very clear. So a lot of my early work was really trying to explore this idea of how how could I work with almost different threads. So sometimes it would be and that caused me to explore things in the way I choose to photograph. So in terms of like ⁓ the way I use colors. So I almost imagine them to be these multiple threads of different ⁓ narratives that were going on when I sequence my work together to kind of create these different narrative threads, if you want. And it might be characterized by color ⁓ and form and the way I compose the work, etc. And so Undercurrents became these different short stories as a result of that. But also in my later work, I would try to combine that into one story, let's say, but ⁓ be approaching the work fundamentally in two different ways in the same story, in order to create almost two different types of narrative that ran alongside each other. ⁓ and and those experiments, I mean, I really enjoyed the process because it it it was something that was frustrating me ⁓ creatively, but at the same time because there was that frustration, it forced me to kind of work ⁓ towards finding a satisfactory creative solution to these things that I l enjoyed in movies.
speaker-1: Okay, cool. Because that's exactly what stayed with me and I'm I'm glad that you have explained it as well and it's very interesting. Now instead changing gears a little bit, I wanna discuss your period between nineteen ninety nine and two thousand and eight 'cause you travelled extensively through China during one of the most I guess important as well as dramatic, I guess, periods of transformations. in the country as well, both on the social and economic level as well. So when you returned to China in nineteen ninety nine, did you already know what you wanted to photograph or did the project kind of reveal itself while you were doing it?
speaker-0: ⁓ I knew what I wanted to do for my specific project, but I didn't know that that specific project would form one of the stories to undercurrents is the short answer. ⁓ I I was largely following my nose. ⁓ these were the the projects or the stories that I was interested in were things that caught my attention and I wanted to document and explore. but the subsequent returning of to to expand on these stories and the discovery of new stories that I wanted to work on meant that I eventually started to see similarities or things that connected ⁓ what I was observing among these various stories as an overarching kind of themes that I started noticing
throughout China.
speaker-1: Exactly. And connecting to these themes because China is really not presented through, let's say, official symbols or major historical events yeah emerged from bars, ⁓ workers, daily life, ⁓ provincial towns, industrial spaces of course, and everything like that. So what were the themes that you started noticing, I guess, that were developing with this within This project.
speaker-0: I think ⁓ for example, when I worked on like the three cordial, so that series is called The Vanishing, and when I looked at how that massive transformation over seven hundred kilometers of river, ⁓ where you know, a total of something like a thousand villages, towns and cities were destroyed and submerged in order to displace some one point four million people, what I noticed that all of that that was happening was done often through the hands of migrant workers. and then the other thing that obviously was was apparent was the scale. ⁓ and that this is this was something that was going to be repeated throughout many endeavors that China was doing. You know, whether it's in the coal industry or the industrialization process, everything was at scale, but often ⁓ built through by migrant workers, people who were originally farmers, but migrated to find basically ⁓ better opportunities by doing work in in the booming economy. And quite often it would be more dangerous or it would be ⁓ far away from where their homelands were. So that was that was a ve ⁓ one a very common theme. ⁓ yeah. And I I think in dark clouds it was not only migrant workers but also it was the you know, the abundance of let's say coal as an energy that was there. So all of these things yeah, made me feel like there was always these key repetitive things that that were recurring in in in in in the story that was unfolding in China at that time.
speaker-1: Because in your work I feel like a a central question concerns what society's desire from progress and what they prepare to sacrifice in order to achieve it some ways. So the question I have for you is your because it starts from the fact that your work is often described about being ⁓ about the environmental cost of development, but it also contain ambition, desires and every kind of like those emotions and hope as well, I feel. How do you photograph progress without either celebrating it or condemning it too easily? Condemning too easily. Yeah.
speaker-0: Good question. It's hard.
speaker-1: It's hard, right? Yes, because sometimes it's not always like it depends. I will let you the floor actually.
speaker-0: Yeah. No, and and I think I think those ideas didn't come to me immediately. This idea I think what I realized in I realized through doing many of my projects that one of the key questions I was always interested in was what you said, which is like, this is what's happening and is it worth it? Is this a price worth paying for? And and then there was always the question of when you ask Who if if it's worth it, you
have to ask it for the individual, you know, general society, let's say. Or you're then you're also thinking of it in the context of the nation, you know, the state. You know, it's that how they perceive it. Because you don't do big projects as a nation without thinking that you're gonna get something back out of it for for it. But the sacrifice is being brought ⁓ is being felt often by the individuals who live in these locations. And so I think that was a thing that you couldn't see. But what I could document was often what was unfolding. But what I could also do was be conscious about how I documented and framed my images so that and how I sequenced and told that story so that I left enough room so that these questions or these considerations can be suggested to the viewer. You know. So if you took Dark Clouds, for example, which was looking very much at the coal industry, I felt in the early stages of doing the work, I really felt like ⁓ my f my first trip was an absolute failure. Because I thought this was such a visual subject that I could not fail because images would just come out in front of me. Yeah, they would just come out of me when I turn when I turn up to these places. I d later realized ⁓ after I finished that trip, I was incredibly disappointed. I didn't even want to look at my contact sheets for months later because I felt it was a failure. But I then it then dawned on me, ⁓ on my second trip that what I was interested of the things what was what drew me to this. What were the fundamental questions that drew me to let's say the subject? And and what came out was this idea that ⁓ you have one of the biggest things that are happening in the country, which is essentially you're trying to create energy to build, let's say, the factories and the products that are going going out to the rest of the world. And I was going to the source of that place. ⁓ many of these places were the sources of that place. And you felt like on that scale you could see the national dream. But when you look at it on a smaller scale to the individual, I recognized that every single person who was working in these spaces were also pursuing a dream. Their dream of not being a farmer, but to improve their life. And because of that, because of that sense of hope, they were prepared to sacrifice maybe their safety. being away from their family for a whole year in a faraway land within their country to do all of this stuff. So it felt like what I was witnessing was a giant machine. And that the people who are within that were cogs. And that in many ways formulated formulated the way I would approach the visuals. I w I f I at one point started to creatively visualize myself as and as a worker in these spaces. And I wanted for scenes that I was witnessing, the industrial landscape, to be overwhelming in the way ⁓ it was larger than life. And that was how I approached it. I also wanted people to feel small. And so even though I had many great pictures that I really loved, the final edit that I did in Dark Clouds was one where You hardly saw any faces. They were either silhouettes, s ⁓ small figures, or they were ⁓ in some ways ⁓ reflected. So it's almost like you weren't seeing the real person. And that in its way anonymized the individual because I was trying to forefront the machine, and then through portraits I was trying to then give the individual recognition at that point. That's the only time I gave them recognition was a portrait to say, here's this person and here's what they do. And in many ways, this they are a container for their own individual dreams. And they represent the many individuals that are working within this space. So how I edited and sequenced that through portraits, etc., was my way of trying to work with these different narrative threads that I was trying to build in. That wasn't explicit, but was in was very much part of the consideration of the edit and sequencing of the work.
speaker-1: And after having said all of this, ⁓ also mm the social and the individual relationships and evert and dreams of these people, do you think documentary photography sometimes can create, let's call it, like a false moral distance allowing like viewers to condemn the systems in which they are themselves involved, if that makes sense.
speaker-0: I think like based on what you see from the photographs of other people's work, etc. ⁓ people form judgments and some of that you're asking if whether some of that is, you know, ⁓ can be false or it can be kind of unintended interpretations of the work. And I think over time, I feel like as a creator. or as a and as an observer and as a creator, I realize that you are only fifty percent of that equation. The other fifty percent is basically the viewer and what their experiences and their past life experiences come from that. So there's that these two two there's this dialogue that's happening between what what's been witnessed and also the the the viewer perception of what they see. And a photograph without a caption, in many ways provides you so little information. So I think, yes, you're right, that ⁓ the photograph, any photograph, can leave many plenty of room for ⁓ misinterpretation or just inter or if you want to maybe look at it in a more beautiful way for multiple interpretations. I think that's the thing I realized quite early on about photography, and that's why I love photography. Is that it is a language that is strongest at leaving
speaker-1: When
speaker-0: For reflection and a variety of interpretations. That doesn't mean that any of those reflections are necessarily ⁓ conclusive. But what it does for the viewer, I feel, if you really engage with the photograph and the body of work, is pause, reflection, and therefore multiple thoughts and processes can happen in that process in your and through that. Through your own experience and the interpretations that you come from there and the meaning that you're trying to extract from, let's say, the
author, et cetera, that is where its value is, I I feel. ⁓ not in providing a conclusive proof. I mean, that's there's other ways of phot photographing with that intention in mind, but ⁓ for me, the kind of photography I love, it's it's what I just described.
speaker-1: And pushing this thought ⁓ forward, photography records ⁓ let's say visible surfaces, while many of the processes that you have address climate change, globalization, displacement, ⁓ progress and ever and everything are complex and, let's say, partially invisible, we could say. What can a photograph prove? And where does instead its evidential power end?
speaker-0: What can a photograph prove and where does its evidential power end?
speaker-1: Yes. In documentary photography, of course, then there are different genres where mm are the art in documentary photography I'm not saying that beauty is not part of documentary photography. Sometimes it's it's also necessary, sometimes maybe not, and there is the risk of kind of like mm beautify something that's not so
speaker-0: beautiful. I think there's there's always those everything that you're mentioning is something that's a ⁓ it's a conversation that's been going on for a very long time in in photography, documentary photography itself. And it's kind of what makes it interesting in many ways. But I also think that I ⁓ if you're asking what it can prove, I think if if your intention is to create proof, then your approach will be fundamentally quite different also. Okay. Yeah. And and I think I think if what you're trying to tell, and in my case is I'm trying to document as in provide a record in on one level, but I also see myself as an author, ⁓ a visual author that's trying to use this process to communicate, but also through the process of communicating and discovery to understand issues that I myself as a lay person is struggling to understand. And so in that sense, the photographic process is not it's one part proof on one level, but you can't say it's conclusive in any way. But on another level, ⁓ it's it's an interrogation into a subject. ⁓ and the in some many ways the beneficiary is the author because they're in there and they're most invested in that process, and that's that's the other journey. But through that process, what you communicate and produce is in my in my for my purposes is to provide open pictures where people can travel within it beyond the boundaries of the moment it was photographed and beyond the boundaries of the frame that it was taken. And you can argue that many other photographs can do that, but essentially I come to that with that purpose. there's a documentary aspect of it and as well as as this other facet that I find really interesting. And I feel like, yeah, you can't if proof was your sole purpose, you would approach photography very differently. In as in the case of like let's say a crime scene photographer, let's say, if you wanted to really bring it down to that level.
speaker-1: Okay, okay,
that's very, very interesting. And when you look and when you depict 'cause then that's the then there is the role of the photographer, when you depict people or portray people that are being affected by environmental issues such as that one or transformation industry and everything, what kind of responsibility do you feel you have towards the subjects you're shooting in this delicate, let's say? situations.
speaker-0: I think for myself, I've admired many photographers who work on the micro level. And when I say micro level I mean is they become incredibly intimate with their subjects. I realized very early on I was not that kind of phot photographer, even though it was something I could access because I could never come to terms with I struggled to come to terms with ⁓ ethical issues that I was having with the way I was working and I didn't in some ways trust myself. That's and that these were decisions I made quite early on. And it's one of the reasons why I choose to focus on the epic and the larger scale because of things. Whether it's using a camera that's that allows you know high volume of pictures like a 35mm ⁓ camera. or a larger format camera. ⁓ my interest is really like looking at the workings of what I'm observing on a societal level and those problems that they're so I in answer to your question I would say is is I think there's many issues that are connected to to that. And the way I've chosen chosen to navigate through that is to work on the bigger picture rather than go too intimate onto that single person or the single family that I'm working in. Because yeah, it's something that I s I struggle with, I would say.
speaker-1: That's perfect. That co definitely closes it perfectly. Now I wanna change gears quite a lot while still staying on the topic. And I wanna talk about the book. This limited edition book we're doing together. And almost thirty years, I guess, after these photographs were made, with this version of Undercurrents, we're returning to that work, as we have been said so far. And rather than reproducing the original. ⁓ publications were going into separate ways. The very s the very first thing I wanna mention is that undercurrents, the title, suggests this hidden movements beneath the visible surface. What were the undercurrents you felt in China at the time? And could you explain how you see this work to the people who are watching?
speaker-0: ⁓ so yeah, you some summed it up very well. so what can I add to it? I think basically ⁓ the visible surface, the things that I was observing were in a way this layer that encouraged you to want to understand and look deeper because on the surface ⁓ what what we saw was an economic miracle. it was
speaker-1: Damn it.
speaker-0: ⁓ a giant engine that was, you know, the country was going through a transition ⁓ and it was mobilizing huge sections of society or all sections of society in the process. But in that I felt like in so many of my works that was that that the stories that I was looking at, I was fundamentally interested in the cost and the price that was that was happening because the point and those years I was working in there, I can say is probably one of the it was the peak of transformation in terms of industrialization. And what I saw on the ground made me pause because you could see the environmental ⁓ and the societal impact it was having in a negative sense. to the to in those areas and the scale of it. But on another level, you could also see this incredible benefit that was coming out and the elevation of 800 million people that was brought out of poverty in the process. At that time I didn't know that figure, but post that period you see that. Yeah. So that question was forefront in my mind. And and The undercurrents that you're referring to were all of these things that I never knew or wondered, is there a possible will there be a time that this will I be able to see it in my lifetime that those questions could be answered? You know, ⁓ and, you know, would it take decades before you actually see the results of that, you know, of of of the fruits of this labor that was being conducted on a national basis and at at probably the largest scale that the world has ever seen.
speaker-1: And working on this book also meant looking again at photographs made by a much younger pass me the term ⁓ version of yourself. And did you ever find yourself disagreeing with the photographer of the time now? If that makes sense.
speaker-0: ⁓ well I'm still in that journey right now. So I'm I'm I'm ⁓ I would say I am wondering if I'm gonna have many disagreements with with with myself in that in that regard. ⁓ I know I know that the way I chose to shoot many of my projects meant that while you can't help but maintain your individual DNA or stamp that exists in your photographs and in your stories. I did consciously work quite differently as much as I was able because I wanted to approach each story with intent rather than with a you can say a house style or whatever, you know, like with a with a particular one size fits all approach. So that meant that I needed to vary it. problem with that comes with how do you put all of this together and and that's that's a mental challenge that I'm still having a conversation with but I'm very excited to to be in this process because it's something that you know when you approached me about this idea, I thought, wow, this someone has just knocked on my door, something I've been thinking of for a long time. So thank you.
speaker-1: ⁓ no, thank you. I have another question because looking at this photograph in twenty twenty six, do they feel like documents of a disappearing world or documents of or the beginning not documents or the beginning of the world we inhabit instead today? I know my perspective.
speaker-0: I'm sure you do. I do feel like it's I feel like it's another planet, to be honest. ⁓ I feel like my photographs show an era that feel like they're even further away than
the date the years suggest. That's how I feel about it. The China that I hear about or have seen even in my last ⁓ trips has is so different now and materially so much more advanced. And but I feel like so so in that sense it's it's it does feel like, you know, y some of the places I went to had donkey carts to cart coal around, you know, and that was a common sight. So it they are literally pla you know, worlds apart in that sense. But ⁓ I would say though, that that period of time had a huge sense of hope and optimism as well, despite all the hardships that I was witnessing.
speaker-1: When you began photographing China, many of the transformations you encounter were let's say barely visible internationally, speaking internationally. Today instead we live within an environment of such like stream of images, it's so easy to photograph and share sharing thoughts and everything like that. Has then greater visibility produced greater understanding? Or has our inability to sustain attention become the real problem?
speaker-0: I think the latter.
speaker-1: The latter, yeah, fair enough.
speaker-0: For sure. Yeah, no, I I feel I feel like I think the technologies that we have now allow us to disseminate work and get more eyeballs on on this works. But I feel like also sometimes the interest and is also and the attention is also short lived in the process. So I think I think short answers to the latter, yes.
speaker-1: Okay, perfect. Just a couple of more questions and then I swear I let you go. I let you free. Absolutely. I wanted to ask you, after more than thirty years photographing change, what have you learned to distrust about the appearance of progress?
speaker-0: ⁓ distrust. That's that's a heavy word. I'm not so sure I would use that word. I think more along the lines of complexity. Interesting. And it depends which way you look at it. And I think also no, I mean th this is a question I have myself and I don't think I have one that I have an absolute answer to.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: And and I think the answers that I have tend to ⁓ shift depending on, you know, what I've observed and situations, etcetera. Yeah. But I think I think that I think complexity is a is is a big one. sorry. And the second thing is I think if I took the case of China, let's say, the material benefit that China's gained over the last that decade that I documented it is unquestionable. So you can say materially it's worth it. But at the same time, in the society that exists right now in China, we I also notice that there's a much higher level of migration of Chinese nationals leaving the country, for example. So that suggests, you know, a whole bunch of new challenges that the society's facing there. So that dream of progress. while having in some way materially attained it, has created a whole set of different other problems as well. And that because what we're observing is not necessarily conducted in a laboratory, then you can't pin things down absolutely to understand what causes what. But I think that's what I mean by complexity. So it's a question that I feel like, you know, we move s So fast forward and and whatever China's experiencing, we as societies have obviously experienced it in other countries as well, at different times, that level of progress. So the question comes: is like we save more time, we improve our quality of lives, we produce technology that saves time, but somehow we feel like even more under pressure in the process. So what does that tell us about you know, progress? You know, or is it more about something that we need to look at in ourselves and the way we approach life, the world, etcetera. So yeah. That's why I can't I I struggle to answer that. But I I think if that's an answer, that's that's kind of where I I stand with that.
speaker-1: That's w that that was exactly was what I was looking for. Ian, I thank you so so much for being with me today and I hope I made you feel comfortable. I felt super comfortable and it was very, very interesting to talk to you. So thank you so so much.
speaker-0: It was a pleasure and thank you to you two and your team. It was ⁓ yeah, it's been a pleasure to talk to you.
speaker-1: Great, thank you so much. And just a very small message before we conclude, I just wanna remind everybody who's watching to keep liking and keep subscribing. And until September thirtieth, Ian's limited edition book with iShoot will be available for pre-order. And after that it will never be reprinted or restocked again. Ian, once again, thank you and talk to you soon.
speaker-0: Thank you. Thank you, Lucretia.