رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.640 --> 00:00:04.640
Introduction: Welcome to the College Commons podcast, passionate perspectives from
00:00:04.720 --> 00:00:08.720
Introduction: Judaism's leading thinkers, brought to you by HUC Connect,
00:00:09.360 --> 00:00:13.360
Introduction: the Hebrew Union College's online platform for continuing
00:00:13.360 --> 00:00:14.755
Introduction: education.
00:00:14.755 --> 00:00:18.755
Introduction: I'm Joshua Holop, your host.
00:00:19.795 --> 00:00:23.795
Joshua Holo: Welcome to this episode of the College Commons podcast and our special
00:00:24.035 --> 00:00:28.035
Joshua Holo: series on the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the Hebrew Union
00:00:28.035 --> 00:00:29.180
Joshua Holo: College.
00:00:29.180 --> 00:00:33.180
Joshua Holo: We're going to speak with professor Michael a Meyer, who is the Adolph
00:00:33.580 --> 00:00:37.580
Joshua Holo: s Oakes professor of Jewish history emeritus at the Hebrew Union
00:00:37.980 --> 00:00:38.940
Joshua Holo: College.
00:00:38.940 --> 00:00:42.940
Joshua Holo: His awards and recognition constitute a list far too long to
00:00:42.940 --> 00:00:46.725
Joshua Holo: cite spanning both the United States and Germany.
00:00:46.725 --> 00:00:50.725
Joshua Holo: He has authored many books and hundreds of articles, including some
00:00:50.725 --> 00:00:54.725
Joshua Holo: of the most widely cited and influential scholarship on Jewish history
00:00:54.965 --> 00:00:57.610
Joshua Holo: in Germany and the United States.
00:00:57.610 --> 00:01:01.610
Joshua Holo: Most notably, response to modernity, a history of the reform movement in
00:01:01.690 --> 00:01:05.690
Joshua Holo: Judaism, which came out in nineteen eighty eight, and Above
00:01:05.850 --> 00:01:09.850
Joshua Holo: All, We Are Jews, a biography of rabbi Alexander Schindler, which
00:01:09.850 --> 00:01:12.415
Joshua Holo: came out in twenty twenty five.
00:01:12.415 --> 00:01:16.415
Joshua Holo: Doctor Meyer was also commissioned to write a centennial history
00:01:16.575 --> 00:01:20.575
Joshua Holo: of the Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion on the occasion
00:01:20.655 --> 00:01:24.655
Joshua Holo: of its one hundredth anniversary in nineteen seventy five.
00:01:24.690 --> 00:01:28.450
Joshua Holo: As part of our special series on the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of
00:01:28.450 --> 00:01:32.450
Joshua Holo: HUC, we welcome doctor Meyer to reintroduce us to the history of
00:01:32.450 --> 00:01:35.970
Joshua Holo: the Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion.
00:01:35.970 --> 00:01:39.970
Joshua Holo: Michael Meyer, thank you so much for joining us on the College Commons podcast.
00:01:40.165 --> 00:01:41.925
Michael Meyer: Pleasure to be here.
00:01:41.925 --> 00:01:45.925
Joshua Holo: Before we get going on the history of the college, situate
00:01:45.925 --> 00:01:49.925
Joshua Holo: us, if you would, in relation to the history of Reform Judaism
00:01:50.085 --> 00:01:51.365
Joshua Holo:
Load full transcript
as an idea.
00:01:51.365 --> 00:01:55.365
Joshua Holo: As you refer to it, Reform Judaism is a response
00:01:55.700 --> 00:01:57.140
Joshua Holo: to modernity.
00:01:57.140 --> 00:02:00.180
Joshua Holo: What does that mean as you understand it?
00:02:00.180 --> 00:02:02.180
Michael Meyer: Let me put it this way.
00:02:02.180 --> 00:02:04.020
Michael Meyer: For centuries,
00:02:04.020 --> 00:02:08.020
Michael Meyer: the Jewish communities in Central and Eastern Europe
00:02:09.165 --> 00:02:12.605
Michael Meyer: were very much focused inward.
00:02:12.605 --> 00:02:16.605
Michael Meyer: They did not participate in the great changes that were going on
00:02:16.845 --> 00:02:20.845
Michael Meyer: in the society around them, the science of Newton,
00:02:21.725 --> 00:02:25.725
Michael Meyer: the literature of Voltaire, the philosophy of Leibniz,
00:02:26.550 --> 00:02:28.870
Michael Meyer: and many more.
00:02:28.870 --> 00:02:32.870
Michael Meyer: Those individuals were fathers of what
00:02:33.110 --> 00:02:35.510
Michael Meyer: we call modernity,
00:02:35.510 --> 00:02:38.275
Michael Meyer: a different attitude
00:02:38.275 --> 00:02:42.275
Michael Meyer: to science, to literature, to culture in general.
00:02:43.315 --> 00:02:47.315
Michael Meyer: The Jews were left out of that until the eighteenth
00:02:47.715 --> 00:02:51.715
Michael Meyer: century when the enlightenment gradually
00:02:52.700 --> 00:02:56.700
Michael Meyer: came to accept Jews as part of the larger society,
00:02:57.500 --> 00:03:01.500
Michael Meyer: and Jews in turn responded to it.
00:03:02.300 --> 00:03:06.300
Michael Meyer: They found themselves in a situation where, really,
00:03:06.540 --> 00:03:09.235
Michael Meyer: there were three possibilities.
00:03:09.235 --> 00:03:13.235
Michael Meyer: One, they could simply continue to cut themselves off
00:03:13.475 --> 00:03:17.395
Michael Meyer: intellectually from the world around them,
00:03:17.395 --> 00:03:21.395
Michael Meyer: or they could say to themselves, in this modern
00:03:21.490 --> 00:03:25.170
Michael Meyer: world, Judaism is no longer relevant.
00:03:25.170 --> 00:03:29.170
Michael Meyer: We must therefore convert to Christianity, which
00:03:29.250 --> 00:03:33.250
Michael Meyer: is a religion that has responded positively to
00:03:33.250 --> 00:03:34.775
Michael Meyer: modernity.
00:03:34.775 --> 00:03:38.775
Michael Meyer: Or there was the third possibility, neither rejection
00:03:39.575 --> 00:03:43.575
Michael Meyer: nor adoption, but rather adapting the
00:03:43.815 --> 00:03:47.815
Michael Meyer: new insofar as it could be reconciled
00:03:48.520 --> 00:03:52.520
Michael Meyer: with the fundamental principles of Judaism.
00:03:52.600 --> 00:03:56.600
Michael Meyer: And that then is the beginning of reform, a
00:03:56.680 --> 00:04:00.680
Michael Meyer: positive reaction to the modern
00:04:00.680 --> 00:04:04.680
Michael Meyer: world without giving up the fundamental values
00:04:04.995 --> 00:04:07.955
Michael Meyer: of Jewish tradition.
00:04:07.955 --> 00:04:11.955
Joshua Holo: As you situate this phenomenon
00:04:12.035 --> 00:04:16.035
Joshua Holo: for us, it's notable that it all takes place in Europe.
00:04:16.595 --> 00:04:20.090
Joshua Holo: So when we think about the history of the Hebrew Union College in the
00:04:20.090 --> 00:04:24.090
Joshua Holo: United States, help us understand what the
00:04:24.330 --> 00:04:28.330
Joshua Holo: principal European institutions were that
00:04:28.330 --> 00:04:32.330
Joshua Holo: not only preceded the founding of HUC in Cincinnati, but also
00:04:32.650 --> 00:04:36.650
Joshua Holo: framed it as a modern institution of religious and higher
00:04:36.705 --> 00:04:38.465
Joshua Holo: learning.
00:04:38.465 --> 00:04:42.465
Michael Meyer: Traditionally, of course, rabbis were trained
00:04:42.545 --> 00:04:46.545
Michael Meyer: in a yeshiva by being instructed in
00:04:46.705 --> 00:04:50.160
Michael Meyer: the basic texts of Judaism,
00:04:50.160 --> 00:04:54.160
Michael Meyer: those texts being understood as
00:04:54.240 --> 00:04:57.760
Michael Meyer: divine in their origin.
00:04:57.760 --> 00:05:00.645
Michael Meyer: In the nineteenth century,
00:05:00.645 --> 00:05:04.645
Michael Meyer: a rabbi trained only in this world of the yeshiva
00:05:05.925 --> 00:05:08.325
Michael Meyer: could not easily
00:05:08.325 --> 00:05:12.325
Michael Meyer: relate to the world around him.
00:05:12.420 --> 00:05:16.420
Michael Meyer: It therefore became necessary to create institutions
00:05:16.740 --> 00:05:20.740
Michael Meyer: that combine secular learning with Jewish
00:05:21.140 --> 00:05:22.420
Michael Meyer: learning.
00:05:22.420 --> 00:05:26.420
Michael Meyer: And so in eighteen fifty four, there was founded in the
00:05:26.420 --> 00:05:30.420
Michael Meyer: city of Breslau, the Jewish Theological Seminary,
00:05:31.315 --> 00:05:35.315
Michael Meyer: which would serve as the model for the Jewish Theological Seminary
00:05:35.715 --> 00:05:39.715
Michael Meyer: of Conservative Judaism in America today.
00:05:39.715 --> 00:05:43.715
Michael Meyer: And in eighteen seventy two,
00:05:45.060 --> 00:05:49.060
Michael Meyer: the tombs, as it was called, the liberal seminary,
00:05:49.620 --> 00:05:53.620
Michael Meyer: which became the model for the Hebrew Union
00:05:53.940 --> 00:05:54.895
Michael Meyer: College.
00:05:54.895 --> 00:05:58.895
Michael Meyer: Some of the earliest instructors at Hebrew Union College,
00:05:59.215 --> 00:06:03.215
Michael Meyer: such as Jacob Reiter Marcus, studied at
00:06:03.215 --> 00:06:06.175
Michael Meyer: that seminary in Berlin.
00:06:06.175 --> 00:06:10.175
Michael Meyer: So the HUC was the first
00:06:10.700 --> 00:06:14.700
Michael Meyer: successful rabbinical seminary of
00:06:14.860 --> 00:06:18.860
Michael Meyer: a nonorthodox kind, that is to say, a non yeshiva,
00:06:19.580 --> 00:06:23.580
Michael Meyer: but it had its precedence in these two
institutions
00:06:24.060 --> 00:06:26.195
Michael Meyer: in Europe.
00:06:26.195 --> 00:06:30.195
Joshua Holo: So let's go now across the Atlantic to the United States
00:06:30.355 --> 00:06:34.355
Joshua Holo: and focus for a moment on the personality of
00:06:34.675 --> 00:06:38.675
Joshua Holo: Isaac Mayer Wise, who was the founder of the Hebrew Union
00:06:38.995 --> 00:06:42.995
Joshua Holo: College, And whose ambition was for
00:06:43.760 --> 00:06:47.760
Joshua Holo: American Judaism, not necessarily reform or any other
00:06:47.840 --> 00:06:51.840
Joshua Holo: stripe of Judaism, but American Judaism, to take the mantle
00:06:52.160 --> 00:06:56.160
Joshua Holo: of leadership for this modern Jewish experience
00:06:56.225 --> 00:06:58.305
Joshua Holo: that you've described.
00:06:58.305 --> 00:07:02.305
Joshua Holo: Given that, help us understand the ways in which Isaac
00:07:02.385 --> 00:07:06.225
Joshua Holo: Mayer Wise was a visionary reformer, maybe even a revolutionary.
00:07:06.225 --> 00:07:08.310
Joshua Holo: I don't know if that's too far.
00:07:08.310 --> 00:07:12.310
Joshua Holo: And in what ways was he, perhaps surprisingly, a
00:07:12.310 --> 00:07:14.310
Joshua Holo: traditionalist?
00:07:14.310 --> 00:07:18.310
Michael Meyer: Well, I think he was a visionary in that he recognized
00:07:18.870 --> 00:07:22.870
Michael Meyer: that American Judaism, as you suggested,
00:07:22.995 --> 00:07:24.755
Michael Meyer: was something new.
00:07:24.755 --> 00:07:28.755
Michael Meyer: It was a Judaism within a country that looked forward and
00:07:28.755 --> 00:07:30.275
Michael Meyer: not back.
00:07:30.275 --> 00:07:34.275
Michael Meyer: The great American thinker Ralph Waldo Emerson had talked
00:07:34.275 --> 00:07:36.355
Michael Meyer: about America being different.
00:07:36.355 --> 00:07:40.120
Michael Meyer: America looks forward and not backward.
00:07:40.120 --> 00:07:44.120
Michael Meyer: He therefore recognized, Isaac Meir Wise did,
00:07:44.280 --> 00:07:48.040
Michael Meyer: that here was an extraordinary opportunity
00:07:48.040 --> 00:07:50.600
Michael Meyer: to create a Judaism
00:07:50.600 --> 00:07:54.600
Michael Meyer: that was in line with a forward looking
00:07:55.345 --> 00:07:56.545
Michael Meyer: country.
00:07:56.545 --> 00:07:59.505
Michael Meyer: In that respect, he was a visionary.
00:07:59.505 --> 00:08:03.505
Michael Meyer: He also thought that the differences, sometimes rivalries
00:08:04.145 --> 00:08:08.145
Michael Meyer: among various Jewish groups in Europe would be overcome
00:08:08.310 --> 00:08:12.310
Michael Meyer: in the United States, and it might be possible, as you suggested,
00:08:12.790 --> 00:08:15.110
Michael Meyer: to create an American Judaism.
00:08:15.110 --> 00:08:19.110
Michael Meyer: He's called his prayer book Minhag America, the American
00:08:19.510 --> 00:08:21.245
Michael Meyer: right,
00:08:21.245 --> 00:08:25.165
Michael Meyer: and hoped that it would be adopted very broadly.
00:08:25.165 --> 00:08:29.165
Michael Meyer: He also thought that Hebrew Union College would be a
00:08:29.245 --> 00:08:33.245
Michael Meyer: school that would attract, young men for
00:08:33.645 --> 00:08:37.645
Michael Meyer: a rabbinate that was not limited to a single
00:08:38.040 --> 00:08:42.040
Michael Meyer: denomination even though it didn't turn out that way.
00:08:42.440 --> 00:08:46.440
Michael Meyer: And so he was very much an individual
00:08:46.920 --> 00:08:50.920
Michael Meyer: who had a vision of a great new
00:08:51.195 --> 00:08:54.555
Michael Meyer: and different American Jewish community.
00:08:54.555 --> 00:08:58.555
Michael Meyer: He was, as you suggest, at the same time, a traditionalist.
00:08:58.635 --> 00:09:02.635
Michael Meyer: And the way that that came out most clearly was
00:09:02.640 --> 00:09:06.640
Michael Meyer: his attitude to the important theological category
00:09:07.120 --> 00:09:08.880
Michael Meyer: of revelation.
00:09:08.880 --> 00:09:10.960
Michael Meyer: Isaac Nairweis
00:09:10.960 --> 00:09:14.960
Michael Meyer: rejected the critical biblical criticism
00:09:15.280 --> 00:09:19.280
Michael Meyer: of European scholars like Wellhausen, for example,
00:09:20.035 --> 00:09:24.035
Michael Meyer: and believed firmly that the Pentateuch or at
00:09:24.035 --> 00:09:28.035
Michael Meyer: the very least the Ten Commandments were a direct
00:09:28.195 --> 00:09:32.195
Michael Meyer: revelation from god to Moses.
00:09:32.370 --> 00:09:35.490
Michael Meyer: And in that respect, he was more traditional.
00:09:35.490 --> 00:09:39.490
Michael Meyer: He did not permit that critical
00:09:39.730 --> 00:09:43.730
Michael Meyer: biblical study would be part of the curriculum
00:09:43.810 --> 00:09:47.810
Michael Meyer: of the Hebrew Union College that changed only
00:09:47.975 --> 00:09:51.975
Michael Meyer: during the presidency of his successor, Kaufmann Kohler.
00:09:53.175 --> 00:09:57.175
Joshua Holo: The critical academic approach to understanding
00:09:58.170 --> 00:10:02.170
Joshua Holo: the Bible, particularly also the Pentateuch, the Torah that you're referring
00:10:02.170 --> 00:10:06.170
Joshua Holo: to, in terms of revelation, is so challenging insofar
00:10:06.490 --> 00:10:10.490
Joshua Holo: as it argues human authorship of the Bible,
00:10:10.730 --> 00:10:13.515
Joshua Holo: that being the nub of the problem and the difference.
00:10:13.515 --> 00:10:14.635
Joshua Holo: Correct?
00:10:14.635 --> 00:10:15.355
Michael Meyer: Yes.
00:10:15.355 --> 00:10:19.355
Michael Meyer: For Isaac Mayer Wise, it wasn't Moses who
00:10:19.435 --> 00:10:21.115
Michael Meyer: formulated the ten commandments.
00:10:21.115 --> 00:10:24.235
Michael Meyer: It was God who formulated the ten commandments.
00:10:24.235 --> 00:10:28.235
Michael Meyer: And the bible, he suggested, or at least the Pentateuch, was a
00:10:28.620 --> 00:10:29.580
Michael Meyer: single document.
00:10:29.580 --> 00:10:33.580
Michael
Meyer: He rejected the theory of men like Wellhausen,
00:10:33.820 --> 00:10:37.820
Michael Meyer: that there were multiple sources in the text of the Torah.
00:10:38.060 --> 00:10:38.460
Joshua Holo: Okay.
00:10:38.460 --> 00:10:42.460
Joshua Holo: So we have the situation of Isaac Mayer Wise's vision and energy
00:10:43.625 --> 00:10:47.625
Joshua Holo: and capability of making something real in Cincinnati
00:10:48.505 --> 00:10:51.625
Joshua Holo: at what we call the Hebrew Union College.
00:10:51.625 --> 00:10:55.625
Joshua Holo: Meanwhile, somewhat confusingly for many people,
00:10:55.625 --> 00:10:59.625
Joshua Holo: the official name of our institution is in fact Hebrew
00:10:59.840 --> 00:11:02.240
Joshua Holo: Union College
00:11:02.240 --> 00:11:05.520
Joshua Holo: Jewish Institute of Religion.
00:11:05.520 --> 00:11:09.520
Joshua Holo: What was the Jewish Institute of Religion and who founded it?
00:11:10.240 --> 00:11:14.240
Michael Meyer: The Hebrew Union College had developed
00:11:14.655 --> 00:11:18.655
Michael Meyer: an attitude characteristic of American Judaism, particularly
00:11:19.775 --> 00:11:23.775
Michael Meyer: outside New York, which was to see America as a
00:11:23.935 --> 00:11:27.935
Michael Meyer: substitute for the old Zion in the Middle
00:11:29.390 --> 00:11:29.790
Michael Meyer: East.
00:11:29.790 --> 00:11:33.790
Michael Meyer: Stephen Wise, by chance, has the same last name as Isaac,
00:11:34.110 --> 00:11:36.510
Michael Meyer: though they were not related.
00:11:36.510 --> 00:11:39.345
Michael Meyer: Stephen Wise was a Zionist
00:11:39.345 --> 00:11:43.345
Michael Meyer: and thought that there should be a rabbinical training
00:11:43.585 --> 00:11:47.585
Michael Meyer: institution that looked positively upon Zionism.
00:11:48.065 --> 00:11:51.470
Michael Meyer: He also thought that it should exist
00:11:51.470 --> 00:11:55.470
Michael Meyer: within the largest Jewish community in the United States,
00:11:55.710 --> 00:11:57.790
Michael Meyer: which was that of New York.
00:11:57.790 --> 00:12:01.790
Michael Meyer: And, therefore, he founded the Jewish Institute of Religion
00:12:02.030 --> 00:12:05.095
Michael Meyer: in nineteen twenty two.
00:12:05.095 --> 00:12:09.095
Michael Meyer: The two institutions remained separate during the
00:12:09.095 --> 00:12:13.095
Michael Meyer: presidency of Julian Morgenstern of
00:12:13.255 --> 00:12:17.255
Michael Meyer: the Hebrew Union College and for the career
00:12:17.335 --> 00:12:20.630
Michael Meyer: of Stephen Wise in New York.
00:12:20.630 --> 00:12:24.630
Michael Meyer: It was only when Nelson Glick, who had
00:12:25.110 --> 00:12:29.110
Michael Meyer: a very positive attitude to the land of Israel where he
00:12:29.750 --> 00:12:33.750
Michael Meyer: spent much time as an archaeologist, became president of
00:12:33.895 --> 00:12:37.655
Michael Meyer: the Hebrew Union College in nineteen forty seven.
00:12:37.655 --> 00:12:41.655
Michael Meyer: And when Stephen s Wise was not able easily
00:12:41.895 --> 00:12:45.895
Michael Meyer: to raise funds for the JIR anymore and,
00:12:46.055 --> 00:12:50.055
Michael Meyer: was not a well man anymore, that a process of merger
00:12:50.490 --> 00:12:54.490
Michael Meyer: between the Hebrew Union College and the Jewish Institute of Religion
00:12:55.370 --> 00:12:59.370
Michael Meyer: could come about, which was finalized in the year nineteen
00:12:59.370 --> 00:13:00.330
Michael Meyer: fifty.
00:13:00.330 --> 00:13:04.330
Michael Meyer: And ever since then, the school has this compound name.
00:13:05.265 --> 00:13:09.265
Joshua Holo: So before the actual binding merger of HUC
00:13:09.825 --> 00:13:11.585
Joshua Holo: and JIR,
00:13:11.585 --> 00:13:13.425
Joshua Holo: each institution
00:13:13.425 --> 00:13:14.945
Joshua Holo: respectively
00:13:14.945 --> 00:13:18.945
Joshua Holo: played signal roles in American Judaism's response
00:13:19.810 --> 00:13:22.450
Joshua Holo: to the tragedy of the Holocaust.
00:13:22.450 --> 00:13:26.450
Joshua Holo: Tell us a bit about those roles and the roles of
00:13:26.450 --> 00:13:30.450
Joshua Holo: the respective presidents at the time whom you named Julian Morgenstern
00:13:30.690 --> 00:13:34.690
Joshua Holo: at HUC and Stephen s Wise at JIR.
00:13:34.935 --> 00:13:38.935
Michael Meyer: In that regard, Hebrew Union College in Cincinnati
00:13:39.255 --> 00:13:43.255
Michael Meyer: and its president, Morgan Stern, played really a
00:13:43.575 --> 00:13:45.495
Michael Meyer: remarkable role.
00:13:45.495 --> 00:13:49.495
Michael Meyer: When it became clear that the situation
00:13:50.100 --> 00:13:54.100
Michael Meyer: of the Jews in Germany had become intolerable and
00:13:54.740 --> 00:13:58.740
Michael Meyer: increasingly dangerous, Julian Morgenstern, as
00:13:58.820 --> 00:14:02.555
Michael Meyer: president of the school in Cincinnati,
00:14:02.555 --> 00:14:06.235
Michael Meyer: decided on two courses of action.
00:14:06.235 --> 00:14:10.235
Michael Meyer: One, he would bring over five students from the Liberal
00:14:10.715 --> 00:14:14.715
Michael Meyer: Seminary in Berlin so that they could continue their studies
00:14:14.955 --> 00:14:16.650
Michael Meyer: in Cincinnati.
00:14:16.650 --> 00:14:20.650
Michael Meyer: Among them was rabbi Gunther Plaut,
00:14:20.650 --> 00:14:24.650
Michael Meyer: one of the leaders of American Reform Judaism.
00:14:25.370 --> 00:14:29.370
Michael Meyer: The second thing that he did was to bring over and
00:14:29.675 --> 00:14:33.195
Michael Meyer: to make members of his faculty
00:14:33.195 --> 00:14:37.195
Michael Meyer: scholars of the Liberal Seminary in Berlin
00:14:37.755 --> 00:14:41.755
Michael Meyer: in particular, give them positions at HUC
00:14:42.490 --> 00:14:46.490
Michael Meyer: even though we really didn't need to have more individuals
00:14:46.650 --> 00:14:48.410
Michael Meyer: on the faculty.
00:14:48.410 --> 00:14:52.410
Michael Meyer: Among them were,
again, important people,
00:14:52.970 --> 00:14:56.970
Michael Meyer: the best known of whom was Abraham Joshua Heschel, who
00:14:57.205 --> 00:15:01.205
Michael Meyer: for a time was a professor at HUC in Cincinnati
00:15:02.085 --> 00:15:06.085
Michael Meyer: before he went to the Jewish Theological Seminary in
00:15:06.165 --> 00:15:07.205
Michael Meyer: New York.
00:15:07.205 --> 00:15:11.205
Michael Meyer: As far as Stephen Wise is concerned, he and the JIR
00:15:11.790 --> 00:15:15.790
Michael Meyer: did not play as larger role in saving students and
00:15:15.790 --> 00:15:19.790
Michael Meyer: scholars from the impending holocaust in
00:15:19.870 --> 00:15:20.910
Michael Meyer: Europe.
00:15:20.910 --> 00:15:24.910
Michael Meyer: But the JIR did participate together with JTS,
00:15:25.575 --> 00:15:29.575
Michael Meyer: the Jewish Theological Seminary in New York, and HUC in Cincinnati
00:15:30.535 --> 00:15:34.535
Michael Meyer: to bring over and to support the very important Jewish historian,
00:15:34.855 --> 00:15:38.855
Michael Meyer: Ismar Elbogen, who spent his time in New York, his
00:15:38.950 --> 00:15:42.950
Michael Meyer: salary paid by the three institutions collectively.
00:15:43.910 --> 00:15:47.910
Joshua Holo: And is it fair to say that Stephen s Wise was more
00:15:48.470 --> 00:15:52.470
Joshua Holo: politically connected in the higher echelons of American politics
00:15:52.815 --> 00:15:56.815
Joshua Holo: and that he leveraged those connections to the best of his ability
00:15:57.615 --> 00:16:01.615
Joshua Holo: to try to shape policy and lobby for the interests of European
00:16:01.775 --> 00:16:02.815
Joshua Holo: Jewry?
00:16:02.815 --> 00:16:06.815
Michael Meyer: That, of course, has been a controversial
00:16:06.950 --> 00:16:10.550
Michael Meyer: question among scholars now for many years.
00:16:10.550 --> 00:16:14.550
Michael Meyer: Certainly, he tried to influence president Roosevelt
00:16:15.430 --> 00:16:19.430
Michael Meyer: to allow more Jews to come to the United States
00:16:19.535 --> 00:16:23.535
Michael Meyer: to perhaps have the Allied forces bomb the
00:16:23.695 --> 00:16:25.455
Michael Meyer: concentration camps.
00:16:25.455 --> 00:16:29.455
Michael Meyer: He was only partially successful in that, and
00:16:29.695 --> 00:16:33.695
Michael Meyer: there are those who have argued that he should not have been
00:16:33.810 --> 00:16:37.810
Michael Meyer: so accepting of Roosevelt's position, should have
00:16:38.090 --> 00:16:42.090
Michael Meyer: tried to bring more Jewish pressure to bear.
00:16:42.090 --> 00:16:45.290
Michael Meyer: So the answer is he tried.
00:16:45.290 --> 00:16:46.890
Michael Meyer: He might have done more.
00:16:46.890 --> 00:16:50.890
Michael Meyer: And how much more he might have been able to accomplish
00:16:51.265 --> 00:16:55.265
Michael Meyer: remains a question to be discussed, perhaps even for
00:16:55.265 --> 00:16:57.585
Michael Meyer: another generation.
00:16:57.585 --> 00:17:00.705
Joshua Holo: I'd like to go back to the college itself.
00:17:00.705 --> 00:17:04.705
Joshua Holo: Talk a little bit about the HUC libraries because unbeknownst
00:17:05.230 --> 00:17:09.230
Joshua Holo: to many, the HUC libraries count among really the very
00:17:09.310 --> 00:17:13.310
Joshua Holo: best and most comprehensive Jewish libraries in the entire world,
00:17:13.470 --> 00:17:17.085
Joshua Holo: arguably the largest outside of Israel.
00:17:17.085 --> 00:17:21.085
Joshua Holo: And in fact, we owe this prominence to many people as is always
00:17:21.085 --> 00:17:22.445
Joshua Holo: the case in institutions.
00:17:22.445 --> 00:17:26.445
Joshua Holo: We owe it to visionary donors, librarians, and presidents of
00:17:26.525 --> 00:17:27.725
Joshua Holo: HUC.
00:17:27.725 --> 00:17:31.725
Joshua Holo: But perhaps, at the end of the day, the incredible collection
00:17:31.870 --> 00:17:35.870
Joshua Holo: in our HUC libraries is thanks most of all
00:17:35.950 --> 00:17:38.030
Joshua Holo: to Adolf Oko.
00:17:38.030 --> 00:17:42.030
Joshua Holo: Tell us a little bit about this really complicated person
00:17:42.270 --> 00:17:45.515
Joshua Holo: and the nature of his achievement.
00:17:45.515 --> 00:17:49.515
Michael Meyer: The HUC library in Cincinnati began with virtually
00:17:50.075 --> 00:17:54.075
Michael Meyer: nothing, with a couple of dozen books at the very beginning.
00:17:54.155 --> 00:17:58.155
Michael Meyer: Mostly, it was made up of donations of old prayer books and
00:17:58.240 --> 00:18:02.240
Michael Meyer: the like that people who came to Cincinnati were ready to
00:18:02.320 --> 00:18:03.680
Michael Meyer: discard.
00:18:03.680 --> 00:18:07.520
Michael Meyer: Its cataloging was almost nonexistent.
00:18:07.520 --> 00:18:11.520
Michael Meyer: And then they decided to hire this rather
00:18:11.745 --> 00:18:15.745
Michael Meyer: extraordinary and difficult and controversial individual
00:18:15.745 --> 00:18:18.225
Michael Meyer: named Adolph Oko.
00:18:18.225 --> 00:18:22.225
Michael Meyer: Adolph Oko was a rather arrogant man.
00:18:22.545 --> 00:18:26.210
Michael Meyer: He was more of a New Yorker than a Cincinnatian.
00:18:26.210 --> 00:18:30.210
Michael Meyer: He was part of the intellectual circle around the Menorah Journal
00:18:30.370 --> 00:18:34.370
Michael Meyer: in New York, saw himself as someone
00:18:34.370 --> 00:18:38.370
Michael Meyer: who really belonged to the intelligentsia.
00:18:39.515 --> 00:18:42.795
Michael Meyer: But he was also a damn good librarian.
00:18:42.795 --> 00:18:46.795
Michael Meyer: He revised the catalog assisting of the library in Cincinnati.
00:18:47.995 --> 00:18:51.995
Michael Meyer: He went to Europe, and he purchased significant
00:18:52.315 --> 00:18:54.380
Michael Meyer: collections
00:18:54.380 --> 00:18:57.020
Michael Meyer: of valuable materials,
00:18:57.020 --> 00:18:58.700
Michael Meyer: incanabula
00:18:58.700 --> 00:19:02.700
Michael
Meyer: manuscripts, a very important music collection.
00:19:03.020 --> 00:19:07.020
Michael Meyer: He was a strong individual, and it really was he
00:19:07.235 --> 00:19:11.235
Michael Meyer: who, over many years that he served as the librarian,
00:19:11.795 --> 00:19:15.795
Michael Meyer: made the HUC library in Cincinnati the foremost
00:19:15.875 --> 00:19:19.875
Michael Meyer: Jewish library in the United States in his time.
00:19:20.750 --> 00:19:24.430
Joshua Holo: And for our audience, incunabula is a plural.
00:19:24.430 --> 00:19:28.430
Joshua Holo: It means printed books that were printed in the very, very first
00:19:28.910 --> 00:19:32.910
Joshua Holo: generation of the technology of the European printing press dated
00:19:33.265 --> 00:19:35.505
Joshua Holo: before the year fifteen hundred.
00:19:35.505 --> 00:19:39.505
Joshua Holo: So they're particularly precious and rare.
00:19:39.585 --> 00:19:43.585
Joshua Holo: Another remarkable constituent institution of the Hebrew Union
00:19:43.585 --> 00:19:47.585
Joshua Holo: College is the American Jewish Archives, also associated
00:19:48.730 --> 00:19:52.730
Joshua Holo: with a remarkable, perhaps less controversial figure, Jacob
00:19:52.730 --> 00:19:56.730
Joshua Holo: Reiter Marcus, whom I trust you, Michael,
00:19:56.730 --> 00:19:58.090
Joshua Holo: knew personally.
00:19:58.090 --> 00:20:02.090
Joshua Holo: Tell us in parallel to the libraries the thumbnail sketch
00:20:02.410 --> 00:20:06.410
Joshua Holo: of the archives and Jacob Reiter
00:20:06.675 --> 00:20:08.515
Joshua Holo: Marcus who founded them.
00:20:08.515 --> 00:20:12.515
Michael Meyer: Jacob Reiter Marcus began his career as a
00:20:12.675 --> 00:20:14.195
Michael Meyer: historian
00:20:14.195 --> 00:20:18.195
Michael Meyer: studying medieval Judaism in Germany,
00:20:19.000 --> 00:20:23.000
Michael Meyer: specifically care of, sick Jews, as I recall.
00:20:24.280 --> 00:20:28.280
Michael Meyer: He had thought that that would be his area
00:20:28.440 --> 00:20:30.440
Michael Meyer: of specialization
00:20:30.440 --> 00:20:33.625
Michael Meyer: until the holocaust came along.
00:20:33.625 --> 00:20:37.625
Michael Meyer: When the holocaust came along and wiped out so much of European
00:20:37.785 --> 00:20:39.385
Michael Meyer: Jewry,
00:20:39.385 --> 00:20:42.985
Michael Meyer: Jacob Reiter Marcus came to the conclusion
00:20:42.985 --> 00:20:46.985
Michael Meyer: that as a historian, he would devote himself not to the Jews
00:20:47.225 --> 00:20:51.225
Michael Meyer: of Europe who had been in such large measure wiped out
00:20:51.600 --> 00:20:55.600
Michael Meyer: by the Holocaust, but rather to the Jewish communities
00:20:56.000 --> 00:21:00.000
Michael Meyer: of the United States that he would gather material from
00:21:00.240 --> 00:21:04.240
Michael Meyer: congregations all over the country and even in the
00:21:04.285 --> 00:21:08.285
Michael Meyer: Caribbean, and he would bring those together in Cincinnati
00:21:08.365 --> 00:21:12.365
Michael Meyer: in an institution that would be an archives
00:21:12.445 --> 00:21:16.445
Michael Meyer: for all of American Jewry, but which would particularly
00:21:16.525 --> 00:21:20.525
Michael Meyer: specialize in the history of the reform movement.
00:21:21.550 --> 00:21:25.550
Michael Meyer: He was certainly a visionary in that regard, and
00:21:25.630 --> 00:21:29.630
Michael Meyer: the institution which he established continues to flourish
00:21:29.950 --> 00:21:33.950
Michael Meyer: today and is used by scholars from all
00:21:34.065 --> 00:21:38.065
Michael Meyer: over the world who want to study the history
00:21:38.225 --> 00:21:42.225
Michael Meyer: of American Jews and American Judaism.
00:21:42.625 --> 00:21:46.625
Joshua Holo: And Marcus was also a centenarian himself, as I recall,
00:21:48.000 --> 00:21:51.680
Joshua Holo: and a widely beloved professor, at HUC.
00:21:51.680 --> 00:21:55.680
Michael Meyer: He was, I believe, the first professor at HUC that
00:21:55.840 --> 00:21:58.160
Michael Meyer: was born in the United States.
00:21:58.160 --> 00:21:58.640
Joshua Holo: Ah.
00:21:58.640 --> 00:22:02.640
Michael Meyer: And consequently was able to relate to American students
00:22:03.255 --> 00:22:07.255
Michael Meyer: much more easily than the European born professors
00:22:07.655 --> 00:22:10.455
Michael Meyer: who had preceded him.
00:22:10.455 --> 00:22:14.455
Midtro: The College Commons podcast belongs to HUC Connect, the online platform for continuing education from Hebrew Union College. HUC Connect includes webinars, syllabi for community learning, and masterclasses for HUC alumni, with interviews, expert panels, and classroom materials, on topics ranging from the arts to civil society, Israel, and much more. Check us out at huc.edu/HUCConnect.
00:22:39.185 --> 00:22:43.185
Midtro: Now, back to our interview.
00:22:44.120 --> 00:22:48.120
Joshua Holo: Before we get to the singular, perhaps, defining controversy of reform Judaism
00:22:48.920 --> 00:22:52.920
Joshua Holo: in the early twentieth century, that is to say, Zionism, tell us about
00:22:53.000 --> 00:22:57.000
Joshua Holo: another controversy that is all but lost to memory, except
00:22:57.025 --> 00:23:01.025
Joshua Holo: insofar as you preserve it in a centennial history of the Hebrewian
00:23:01.105 --> 00:23:02.065
Joshua Holo: College.
00:23:02.065 --> 00:23:06.065
Joshua Holo: And I'm speaking of the controversy among the faculty
00:23:06.225 --> 00:23:10.225
Joshua Holo: of the Hebrewian College regarding America's
00:23:10.500 --> 00:23:14.420
Joshua Holo: role in World War one.
00:23:14.420 --> 00:23:18.420
Michael Meyer: The reformed Jewish community at the time of World War one
00:23:18.900 --> 00:23:21.540
Michael Meyer: had its roots in Germany.
00:23:21.540 --> 00:23:25.540
Michael Meyer: The East European Jews tended to flock
00:23:26.015 --> 00:23:30.015
Michael Meyer: rather to orthodox or conservative
congregations, or
00:23:30.015 --> 00:23:32.815
Michael Meyer: they were militant secularists.
00:23:32.815 --> 00:23:36.815
Michael Meyer: Consequently, reform Judaism was understood
00:23:36.870 --> 00:23:40.870
Michael Meyer: as being rooted in German reform Judaism,
00:23:40.950 --> 00:23:44.150
Michael Meyer: and that was certainly true of the faculty.
00:23:44.150 --> 00:23:48.150
Michael Meyer: One faculty member in particular, Gotthard Deutsch,
00:23:48.230 --> 00:23:52.135
Michael Meyer: was very much an advocate
00:23:52.135 --> 00:23:55.335
Michael Meyer: of the German Jewish tradition.
00:23:55.335 --> 00:23:59.335
Michael Meyer: When World War one came around, Deutsch
00:23:59.575 --> 00:24:03.575
Michael Meyer: in particular argued that, really,
00:24:03.690 --> 00:24:07.690
Michael Meyer: Jewish interests lay with the central powers
00:24:08.250 --> 00:24:10.730
Michael Meyer: and not with the entente.
00:24:10.730 --> 00:24:14.730
Michael Meyer: That is to say with Germany and Austria and not with
00:24:14.810 --> 00:24:18.615
Michael Meyer: Russia, France, and Great Britain.
00:24:18.615 --> 00:24:22.215
Michael Meyer: And what he pointed out was in a way convincing.
00:24:22.215 --> 00:24:25.895
Michael Meyer: What were the worst examples of antisemitism?
00:24:25.895 --> 00:24:29.895
Michael Meyer: To be sure, there was antisemitism in Germany, but nothing
00:24:30.080 --> 00:24:34.080
Michael Meyer: like the pogroms in Eastern Europe that had destroyed
00:24:35.120 --> 00:24:39.120
Michael Meyer: Jewish villages since eighteen eighty one.
00:24:40.320 --> 00:24:44.320
Michael Meyer: And as for France, there was the Drafus case,
00:24:44.765 --> 00:24:48.765
Michael Meyer: an indication of how unpopular Jews were
00:24:48.765 --> 00:24:52.685
Michael Meyer: for a large portion of the French population.
00:24:52.685 --> 00:24:56.685
Michael Meyer: So simply in terms of Jewish interests, Deutsch argued,
00:24:57.400 --> 00:25:01.400
Michael Meyer: we really should be supporting the Germans
00:25:01.640 --> 00:25:05.640
Michael Meyer: and not, the Russians in particular.
00:25:06.040 --> 00:25:10.040
Michael Meyer: He got himself in trouble for not being willing to come out
00:25:10.725 --> 00:25:14.725
Michael Meyer: openly in favor of the American side in the war and
00:25:15.365 --> 00:25:18.165
Michael Meyer: was almost fired from the faculty as a result.
00:25:18.165 --> 00:25:22.165
Michael Meyer: But, ultimately, the board decided not to fire him.
00:25:23.550 --> 00:25:27.550
Joshua Holo: Now let's move on to the question of Zionism.
00:25:28.190 --> 00:25:32.190
Joshua Holo: Help us understand the merger of HUCJIR
00:25:32.510 --> 00:25:36.510
Joshua Holo: that we spoke about earlier in relation to their differing approaches
00:25:37.005 --> 00:25:41.005
Joshua Holo: to Zionism as a philosophy, as an idea,
00:25:41.245 --> 00:25:45.245
Joshua Holo: and ultimately, the role of Zionism in the resolution
00:25:45.325 --> 00:25:49.325
Joshua Holo: of that difference by sheer force of historical developments
00:25:49.500 --> 00:25:52.140
Joshua Holo: and the founding of the state of Israel?
00:25:52.140 --> 00:25:56.140
Michael Meyer: The reform opposition to Zionism has
00:25:56.220 --> 00:26:00.220
Michael Meyer: to be understood as being based on a number of considerations.
00:26:01.655 --> 00:26:05.655
Michael Meyer: The one that is perhaps the least often mentioned, but which I
00:26:05.655 --> 00:26:09.655
Michael Meyer: think is significant, is that reform Judaism
00:26:10.055 --> 00:26:12.135
Michael Meyer: is a religious
00:26:12.135 --> 00:26:16.135
Michael Meyer: denomination, and the Zionist movement was largely
00:26:16.295 --> 00:26:17.470
Michael Meyer: secular.
00:26:17.470 --> 00:26:21.470
Michael Meyer: That you could be fully a Jew and not be religious was okay within
00:26:21.550 --> 00:26:25.550
Michael Meyer: Zionist circles, but not within reformed Judaism.
00:26:26.110 --> 00:26:28.190
Michael Meyer: So there was a gap there.
00:26:28.190 --> 00:26:32.190
Michael Meyer: Also, of course, the understanding of men like
00:26:32.915 --> 00:26:36.915
Michael Meyer: Isaac Merweiss, Julian Morgenstern, and others
00:26:37.235 --> 00:26:39.715
Michael Meyer: was that America was different.
00:26:39.715 --> 00:26:42.915
Michael Meyer: America was in a way the new Zion.
00:26:42.915 --> 00:26:46.915
Michael Meyer: America was a country where Jews would be accepted fully,
00:26:47.100 --> 00:26:51.100
Michael Meyer: where Judaism could flourish, whereas it could not flourish
00:26:51.340 --> 00:26:52.620
Michael Meyer: back in the Middle East.
00:26:52.620 --> 00:26:56.620
Michael Meyer: It did at some time flourish in the old
00:26:56.620 --> 00:27:00.035
Michael Meyer: homeland, but that was in the past.
00:27:00.035 --> 00:27:04.035
Michael Meyer: And, therefore, to argue that America was exile
00:27:04.755 --> 00:27:08.755
Michael Meyer: and that Jewish life could not survive in America simply ran
00:27:08.755 --> 00:27:12.755
Michael Meyer: counter to the faith of reformed Jews.
00:27:12.940 --> 00:27:16.940
Michael Meyer: There were, however, of course, Zionists within the reform movement from
00:27:17.020 --> 00:27:21.020
Michael Meyer: the very beginning, including some students of the Hebrew Union College in
00:27:21.100 --> 00:27:22.140
Michael Meyer: Cincinnati.
00:27:22.140 --> 00:27:26.140
Michael Meyer: And, of course, Stephen Wise was very much a Zionist leader
00:27:26.615 --> 00:27:30.615
Michael Meyer: as was Rabbi Abba Hillel Silver, who was a graduate of the
00:27:30.695 --> 00:27:33.095
Michael Meyer: Cincinnati Hebrew Union College.
00:27:33.095 --> 00:27:37.095
Michael Meyer: So there was a growing Zionist presence within
00:27:37.175 --> 00:27:38.455
Michael Meyer: the reform movement.
00:27:38.455 --> 00:27:42.455
Michael Meyer: And by the mid thirties, the bulk of reform
00:27:42.520 --> 00:27:46.520
Michael Meyer: Judaism,
both rabbis and laity, had become
00:27:46.920 --> 00:27:50.920
Michael Meyer: favorably inclined to Zionism, though a minority
00:27:51.800 --> 00:27:53.480
Michael Meyer: continued to be opposed.
00:27:53.480 --> 00:27:57.480
Michael Meyer: And, of course, once the state of Israel was established, as you mentioned,
00:27:57.775 --> 00:28:01.775
Michael Meyer: there was no question about the fact, that the reform movement
00:28:02.255 --> 00:28:06.255
Michael Meyer: as a whole, whether JIR or HUC, were committed
00:28:06.895 --> 00:28:09.190
Michael Meyer: to the Zionist enterprise.
00:28:09.190 --> 00:28:13.190
Michael Meyer: And it manifested itself, of course, especially in nineteen
00:28:13.270 --> 00:28:17.270
Michael Meyer: seventy when all rabbinical students were required
00:28:17.510 --> 00:28:21.510
Michael Meyer: to spend the first year of their studies in Jerusalem.
00:28:22.635 --> 00:28:26.635
Joshua Holo: And between nineteen forty seven, the ascent of
00:28:26.715 --> 00:28:30.715
Joshua Holo: Nelson Glick and nineteen fifty when they actually merged, presumably,
00:28:31.195 --> 00:28:35.195
Joshua Holo: the establishment of the state of Israel in nineteen forty eight removed one
00:28:35.550 --> 00:28:39.550
Joshua Holo: hurdle to the merger that had in fact been on people's minds
00:28:39.870 --> 00:28:40.990
Joshua Holo: for a long time.
00:28:40.990 --> 00:28:41.390
Michael Meyer: Yes.
00:28:41.390 --> 00:28:45.390
Michael Meyer: Once Nelson Glick became the president of HUC,
00:28:45.630 --> 00:28:49.630
Michael Meyer: it became possible to create the merger, which couldn't have happened at
00:28:49.630 --> 00:28:53.125
Michael Meyer: the time of Julian Morgan Sternius.
00:28:53.125 --> 00:28:57.125
Joshua Holo: What was the salient reason for HUC's expansion to Los Angeles,
00:28:57.205 --> 00:29:01.205
Joshua Holo: your hometown, my hometown, back in the nineteen fifties?
00:29:01.765 --> 00:29:05.765
Michael Meyer: I think it was the growth of the Jewish community in
00:29:05.765 --> 00:29:09.765
Michael Meyer: Los Angeles That was the critical factor.
00:29:10.360 --> 00:29:14.360
Michael Meyer: When HUC was established, when JAR was established, the
00:29:14.520 --> 00:29:18.520
Michael Meyer: community in Los Angeles was still quite small.
00:29:18.600 --> 00:29:22.600
Michael Meyer: But by the post war period, that community
00:29:22.765 --> 00:29:24.925
Michael Meyer: had become significant.
00:29:24.925 --> 00:29:28.925
Michael Meyer: The conservative movement had taken note of that and
00:29:28.925 --> 00:29:32.925
Michael Meyer: had established the University of Judaism
00:29:33.085 --> 00:29:37.085
Michael Meyer: in Los Angeles, which although didn't have a rabbinical program
00:29:37.710 --> 00:29:41.710
Michael Meyer: yet, did have a very strong educational
00:29:41.870 --> 00:29:45.870
Michael Meyer: program, and it was associated with the Jewish Theological
00:29:46.030 --> 00:29:48.365
Michael Meyer: Seminary in New York.
00:29:48.365 --> 00:29:52.365
Michael Meyer: Therefore, in nineteen fifty four, it was decided that
00:29:52.525 --> 00:29:56.525
Michael Meyer: the reform movement too should have a presence
00:29:57.165 --> 00:30:01.165
Michael Meyer: in this community that was fast becoming the second largest Jewish
00:30:01.485 --> 00:30:04.380
Michael Meyer: community in the United States.
00:30:04.380 --> 00:30:08.380
Michael Meyer: And so it established first an educational program
00:30:09.100 --> 00:30:13.100
Michael Meyer: and then ultimately beyond a program for teachers,
00:30:14.140 --> 00:30:16.875
Michael Meyer: also a rabbinical program.
00:30:16.875 --> 00:30:20.875
Michael Meyer: It eventually purchased a property up
00:30:20.955 --> 00:30:24.955
Michael Meyer: in the Hollywood Hills on Appian Way, which had
00:30:25.115 --> 00:30:29.115
Michael Meyer: at one time been a school for asthmatic
00:30:29.275 --> 00:30:30.880
Michael Meyer: girls.
00:30:30.880 --> 00:30:34.880
Michael Meyer: And there, it established first a two year program
00:30:34.880 --> 00:30:38.880
Michael Meyer: and, ultimately, a full program of rabbinical study.
00:30:39.040 --> 00:30:43.040
Michael Meyer: I studied there myself as a student for a year and taught there for
00:30:43.600 --> 00:30:47.600
Michael Meyer: three years when it was still up in the Hollywood Hills.
00:30:47.775 --> 00:30:51.775
Michael Meyer: Once it became possible to purchase a property that was a little
00:30:51.935 --> 00:30:55.935
Michael Meyer: more accessible in connection with the University of Southern
00:30:56.015 --> 00:31:00.015
Michael Meyer: California, that was accomplished, and that's where the so called
00:31:00.190 --> 00:31:03.310
Michael Meyer: California school still exists today.
00:31:03.310 --> 00:31:06.910
Joshua Holo: And still very connected to the University of Southern California as well.
00:31:06.910 --> 00:31:07.230
Michael Meyer: Yes.
00:31:07.230 --> 00:31:08.910
Michael Meyer: Indeed.
00:31:08.910 --> 00:31:12.910
Joshua Holo: The truth is that we can't possibly capture the breadth of your work,
00:31:13.125 --> 00:31:17.125
Joshua Holo: but I do want to offer our audience a taste of
00:31:17.125 --> 00:31:20.325
Joshua Holo: the nature of your work as an historian.
00:31:20.325 --> 00:31:24.325
Joshua Holo: So take us to the period of HUC's history
00:31:24.805 --> 00:31:28.805
Joshua Holo: that was still living memory in the mid nineteen seventies
00:31:29.250 --> 00:31:32.690
Joshua Holo: when you were writing a centennial history.
00:31:32.690 --> 00:31:36.690
Joshua Holo: In the introduction to that book, both Samuel Karpf, who edited
00:31:37.010 --> 00:31:41.010
Joshua Holo: the volume titled Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion at
00:31:41.170 --> 00:31:44.725
Joshua Holo: one hundred years, and
00:31:44.725 --> 00:31:48.725
Joshua Holo: you took care to point out your freedom
00:31:48.805 --> 00:31:52.805
Joshua Holo: to
tell the story of the college institute warts and all
00:31:52.885 --> 00:31:54.485
Joshua Holo: as it were.
00:31:54.485 --> 00:31:58.485
Joshua Holo: What was it like, therefore, for you as a young
00:31:58.810 --> 00:32:00.330
Joshua Holo: scholar
00:32:00.330 --> 00:32:04.330
Joshua Holo: to interview living colleagues on really sensitive
00:32:04.650 --> 00:32:07.690
Joshua Holo: matters of HUC's history?
00:32:07.690 --> 00:32:08.010
Michael Meyer: Yes.
00:32:08.010 --> 00:32:10.795
Michael Meyer: It was a little bit daunting, I think.
00:32:10.795 --> 00:32:14.795
Michael Meyer: I interviewed lay leadership as well as rabbinical
00:32:14.795 --> 00:32:16.475
Michael Meyer: leadership,
00:32:16.475 --> 00:32:20.475
Michael Meyer: and I had a couple of interesting experiences.
00:32:20.555 --> 00:32:24.555
Michael Meyer: Among the individuals that I interviewed was the provost
00:32:25.140 --> 00:32:29.140
Michael Meyer: at that time of Hebrew Union College, a very significant
00:32:29.700 --> 00:32:33.220
Michael Meyer: scholar by the name of Samuel Sandmill.
00:32:33.220 --> 00:32:37.220
Michael Meyer: And I recall asking him in the course of my
00:32:37.460 --> 00:32:41.460
Michael Meyer: interview, is it true that, you are thinking of succeeding
00:32:41.995 --> 00:32:45.355
Michael Meyer: Nelson Glick as president of Hebrew Union College?
00:32:45.355 --> 00:32:49.355
Michael Meyer: And he readily acknowledged that that was indeed his intention.
00:32:49.915 --> 00:32:53.915
Michael Meyer: But when the book came out, he completely denied ever
00:32:54.150 --> 00:32:58.150
Michael Meyer: having said anything like that, so I simply had
00:32:58.310 --> 00:33:00.550
Michael Meyer: to accept that.
00:33:00.550 --> 00:33:04.550
Michael Meyer: The other experience that I remember having, had to
00:33:04.550 --> 00:33:08.550
Michael Meyer: do not so much with an interview as with the reaction
00:33:08.785 --> 00:33:10.145
Michael Meyer: to the book.
00:33:10.145 --> 00:33:14.145
Michael Meyer: I had, of course, written a great deal about Stephen Wise
00:33:14.945 --> 00:33:18.945
Michael Meyer: and how he had established the Jewish Institute of Religion.
00:33:19.505 --> 00:33:23.505
Michael Meyer: And among other things, I mentioned in passing that Wise was someone
00:33:23.680 --> 00:33:27.680
Michael Meyer: who liked to run his own show and that, therefore, he had left
00:33:27.840 --> 00:33:29.760
Michael Meyer: Temple Emmanuel,
00:33:29.760 --> 00:33:32.935
Michael Meyer: in order to establish the free synagogue.
00:33:32.935 --> 00:33:36.935
Michael Meyer: And similarly, he was not willing to be a supporter of a school
00:33:37.015 --> 00:33:41.015
Michael Meyer: in Cincinnati and therefore established his own school.
00:33:41.495 --> 00:33:45.495
Michael Meyer: Well, it seems that when his daughter, Justine
00:33:45.650 --> 00:33:49.650
Michael Meyer: Wise Poillier, saw that, she was very upset that I should
00:33:49.650 --> 00:33:53.650
Michael Meyer: suggest that her dear father should have done anything for any kind
00:33:53.810 --> 00:33:56.930
Michael Meyer: of a selfish reason.
00:33:56.930 --> 00:34:00.930
Michael Meyer: And, therefore, the book was out of line in,
00:34:01.205 --> 00:34:02.645
Michael Meyer: in having done that.
00:34:02.645 --> 00:34:06.645
Michael Meyer: So dutiful daughters don't tend to be critical of their fathers.
00:34:08.485 --> 00:34:11.845
Joshua Holo: Well, thanks for the insight into the sausage making of history.
00:34:11.845 --> 00:34:15.610
Joshua Holo: It's it's good to remember.
00:34:15.610 --> 00:34:19.610
Joshua Holo: I'd like to ask about a theme that bookends history
00:34:19.610 --> 00:34:19.930
Joshua Holo: here.
00:34:19.930 --> 00:34:23.930
Joshua Holo: It bookends the founding of the college under Wise and I believe
00:34:24.330 --> 00:34:26.585
Joshua Holo: contemporary history today.
00:34:26.585 --> 00:34:27.705
Joshua Holo: And here's what I mean.
00:34:27.705 --> 00:34:31.705
Joshua Holo: In in the nineteenth century, Isaac Mayer Wise had ambitions, as you
00:34:31.785 --> 00:34:35.785
Joshua Holo: and I discussed, for the college to exceed the limits of
00:34:35.785 --> 00:34:39.785
Joshua Holo: reform Judaism narrowly understood and ultimately
00:34:39.785 --> 00:34:42.640
Joshua Holo: to represent American Judaism as a whole.
00:34:42.640 --> 00:34:46.640
Joshua Holo: And, you know, this ambition was ultimately sundered
00:34:46.800 --> 00:34:50.800
Joshua Holo: by really deep seated differences among Jewish versions
00:34:51.040 --> 00:34:55.040
Joshua Holo: of modernity that coalesced into what we would call today
00:34:55.515 --> 00:34:59.275
Joshua Holo: reform Judaism and conservative Judaism.
00:34:59.275 --> 00:35:03.275
Joshua Holo: Tell us about the early fracturing
00:35:03.275 --> 00:35:07.275
Joshua Holo: of American nonorthodox Judaism back then
00:35:07.755 --> 00:35:09.195
Joshua Holo: in the late nineteenth century.
00:35:09.195 --> 00:35:12.530
Joshua Holo: What happened, and and what was at stake?
00:35:12.530 --> 00:35:16.530
Michael Meyer: When Wise founded the Hebrew Union College in eighteen
00:35:16.610 --> 00:35:20.610
Michael Meyer: seventy five, he really wanted it to be what
00:35:20.690 --> 00:35:23.170
Michael Meyer: we call today a large tent.
00:35:23.170 --> 00:35:27.170
Michael Meyer: He wanted to attract students from all Jewish backgrounds.
00:35:27.535 --> 00:35:31.535
Michael Meyer: He wanted to give them a solid education
00:35:31.775 --> 00:35:35.775
Michael Meyer: in Jewish sources that even someone from an orthodox
00:35:35.935 --> 00:35:39.935
Michael Meyer: background could not say that this was not sufficient
00:35:40.180 --> 00:35:44.180
Michael Meyer: to give them knowledge of what classical Judaism was all about.
00:35:45.460 --> 00:35:49.460
Michael Meyer: As a result, he was able, during the first years of his
00:35:49.620 --> 00:35:53.620
Michael Meyer:
presidency, to attract, as supporters,
00:35:54.515 --> 00:35:58.515
Michael Meyer: individuals like, Rabbi Benjamin Zold
00:35:58.755 --> 00:36:02.755
Michael Meyer: of Baltimore and Rabbi Frederick de Sola Mendes
00:36:03.155 --> 00:36:07.155
Michael Meyer: of New York, strictly conservative rabbis
00:36:07.220 --> 00:36:11.220
Michael Meyer: who would come as outside examiners who would
00:36:11.220 --> 00:36:15.220
Michael Meyer: check on the students and their teachers whether or not the students
00:36:15.780 --> 00:36:17.540
Michael Meyer: were learning.
00:36:17.540 --> 00:36:21.540
Michael Meyer: So it seemed that Wise was able to bridge the gap
00:36:22.565 --> 00:36:26.565
Michael Meyer: between the more radical reform of the east
00:36:27.045 --> 00:36:31.045
Michael Meyer: individuals like Rabbi Samuel Adler, for example,
00:36:31.125 --> 00:36:35.125
Michael Meyer: in New York at Emmanuel and others, and the
00:36:35.180 --> 00:36:39.180
Michael Meyer: more conservative rabbis, especially in the Midwest.
00:36:39.980 --> 00:36:43.980
Michael Meyer: But then the center simply did not hold.
00:36:44.620 --> 00:36:48.620
Michael Meyer: There is the example of the banquet that was
00:36:48.655 --> 00:36:52.655
Michael Meyer: held in eighteen eighty three upon the graduation of the first
00:36:53.055 --> 00:36:57.055
Michael Meyer: graduates where among the dishes served were seafood,
00:36:57.695 --> 00:37:00.735
Michael Meyer: which is, I think, been much exaggerated by scholars.
00:37:00.735 --> 00:37:04.735
Michael Meyer: I think more significant is what happened a couple of years later
00:37:04.990 --> 00:37:08.990
Michael Meyer: in eighteen eighty five when the more radical rabbis
00:37:09.230 --> 00:37:13.230
Michael Meyer: called a conference to the city of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
00:37:13.310 --> 00:37:17.310
Michael Meyer: and adopted a platform which completely rejected
00:37:17.655 --> 00:37:21.655
Michael Meyer: the Jewish dietary laws, rejected the
00:37:21.735 --> 00:37:25.735
Michael Meyer: notion of a personal messiah and return
00:37:25.815 --> 00:37:28.380
Michael Meyer: to the land of Israel.
00:37:28.380 --> 00:37:32.380
Michael Meyer: In other words, it was a radical platform, which Wise
00:37:33.020 --> 00:37:37.020
Michael Meyer: decided to accept and even propagate.
00:37:38.620 --> 00:37:42.620
Michael Meyer: And, therefore, at that point, Wise must have
00:37:42.780 --> 00:37:46.780
Michael Meyer: recognized that this broad coalition that he had assembled,
00:37:47.835 --> 00:37:51.595
Michael Meyer: was fracturing, and he had to jump one way or the other.
00:37:51.595 --> 00:37:55.595
Michael Meyer: And he decided to side with the,
00:37:55.675 --> 00:37:59.675
Michael Meyer: more radical portion of the reform movement.
00:37:59.970 --> 00:38:03.970
Michael Meyer: And, certainly, that was true of his successor, Kaufmann Kohler,
00:38:04.610 --> 00:38:08.610
Michael Meyer: who, unlike Wise, also believed, as
00:38:08.610 --> 00:38:12.610
Michael Meyer: the radicals did, in the critical study of the bible.
00:38:13.095 --> 00:38:15.735
Michael Meyer: So as I said, the center didn't hold.
00:38:15.735 --> 00:38:19.735
Michael Meyer: It was a coalition that sooner or later was bound to split,
00:38:19.975 --> 00:38:23.975
Michael Meyer: especially as the East European Jews coming to this country
00:38:24.535 --> 00:38:28.535
Michael Meyer: did not feel at home together with the German Jews who
00:38:28.560 --> 00:38:30.560
Michael Meyer: ran the Hebrew Union College.
00:38:30.560 --> 00:38:34.560
Michael Meyer: And in eighteen eighty seven, created their own
00:38:34.720 --> 00:38:38.720
Michael Meyer: rabbinical institution, the Jewish Theological Seminary of America
00:38:38.960 --> 00:38:42.960
Michael Meyer: in New York, which in fact gained the support of some reformed
00:38:43.415 --> 00:38:47.415
Michael Meyer: Jews, members of Temple Emanuel, like, Marshall and
00:38:47.415 --> 00:38:50.055
Michael Meyer: Schiff, for example.
00:38:50.055 --> 00:38:54.055
Joshua Holo: Today, we are reform and conservative Judaism,
00:38:54.215 --> 00:38:55.110
Joshua Holo: that is.
00:38:55.110 --> 00:38:57.910
Joshua Holo: Highly institutionalized
00:38:57.910 --> 00:39:01.910
Joshua Holo: movements with a lot of collegiality, friends, and people who go to each other's
00:39:02.230 --> 00:39:03.430
Joshua Holo: synagogues.
00:39:03.430 --> 00:39:07.430
Joshua Holo: But institutionally, we remain quite distinct from one another.
00:39:08.710 --> 00:39:11.005
Joshua Holo: Nevertheless,
00:39:11.005 --> 00:39:15.005
Joshua Holo: it's very, very common, certainly in my earshot,
00:39:15.565 --> 00:39:19.565
Joshua Holo: for people to speak, advocate for, and even
00:39:20.125 --> 00:39:24.125
Joshua Holo: really push quite hard for some
00:39:24.230 --> 00:39:28.230
Joshua Holo: kind of merger between reform and conservative
00:39:28.310 --> 00:39:32.310
Joshua Holo: Judaism or reform and conservative Jewish institutions
00:39:33.910 --> 00:39:37.910
Joshua Holo: on the basis of a kind of
00:39:37.935 --> 00:39:41.935
Joshua Holo: broad understanding that our similarities far outweigh
00:39:42.255 --> 00:39:44.495
Joshua Holo: our differences.
00:39:44.495 --> 00:39:48.495
Joshua Holo: What do you make of this urge, this sensibility, and this
00:39:48.735 --> 00:39:52.735
Joshua Holo: call to reconsider our differences today?
00:39:54.180 --> 00:39:57.540
Michael Meyer: Well, first of all, I think it's important to note that there has been
00:39:57.540 --> 00:40:01.540
Michael Meyer: a remarkable convergence between conservative Judaism
00:40:01.540 --> 00:40:03.380
Michael Meyer: and reformed Judaism.
00:40:03.380 --> 00:40:07.380
Michael Meyer: They were much further apart a couple of generations ago
00:40:07.535 --> 00:40:11.215
Michael Meyer: when you had what was called classical reform Judaism.
00:40:11.215 --> 00:40:15.215
Michael Meyer: That is to say the
Judaism represented by the Pittsburgh platform,
00:40:15.535 --> 00:40:19.535
Michael Meyer: and the conservative movement was composed of East European Jews
00:40:19.535 --> 00:40:22.710
Michael Meyer: who were highly traditional in character.
00:40:22.710 --> 00:40:26.710
Michael Meyer: In more recent years, the conservative movement has followed in the footsteps
00:40:26.710 --> 00:40:30.710
Michael Meyer: of the reform movement on such matters as the ordination of women,
00:40:31.110 --> 00:40:34.470
Michael Meyer: attitudes towards same sex marriage, and the like.
00:40:34.470 --> 00:40:38.470
Michael Meyer: So one can say that the conservative movement has become more
00:40:38.575 --> 00:40:39.775
Michael Meyer: like the reform movement.
00:40:39.775 --> 00:40:43.775
Michael Meyer: At the same time, the reform movement has also, in some ways, become more
00:40:43.855 --> 00:40:47.855
Michael Meyer: like the conservative movement, for example, adopting a more traditional
00:40:48.415 --> 00:40:49.370
Michael Meyer: liturgy.
00:40:49.370 --> 00:40:53.370
Michael Meyer: If one looks at the union prayer book of the classical reform and the
00:40:53.690 --> 00:40:57.690
Michael Meyer: contemporary prayer book today, Mishkanah Nefesh, the differences
00:40:57.690 --> 00:41:01.690
Michael Meyer: are huge, and Mishkanah Nefesh is much more like the conservative movement.
00:41:02.205 --> 00:41:06.205
Michael Meyer: However, I do not believe that a merger is at
00:41:06.205 --> 00:41:10.205
Michael Meyer: all likely as long as a merger is not absolutely necessary.
00:41:11.005 --> 00:41:15.005
Michael Meyer: By that, I mean that if you go into a conservative synagogue, the
00:41:15.005 --> 00:41:19.005
Michael Meyer: liturgy is still quite different from what it is in a average reform
00:41:19.610 --> 00:41:20.730
Michael Meyer: synagogue.
00:41:20.730 --> 00:41:24.730
Michael Meyer: The conservative movement pays more attention to halakhah than does
00:41:24.730 --> 00:41:26.490
Michael Meyer: the reform movement.
00:41:26.490 --> 00:41:30.490
Michael Meyer: Even though we have our own responsive committee and have that for many years
00:41:30.570 --> 00:41:34.570
Michael Meyer: within the reform movement, Our movement is much more focused on social
00:41:34.865 --> 00:41:38.865
Michael Meyer: justice and ethics and far less focused upon halakha.
00:41:39.265 --> 00:41:43.265
Michael Meyer: Therefore, I do not believe that a merger will happen, especially
00:41:43.585 --> 00:41:47.585
Michael Meyer: for organizational reasons quite apart from the ideological
00:41:47.850 --> 00:41:51.850
Michael Meyer: ones that I mentioned, unless there is no
00:41:52.170 --> 00:41:53.690
Michael Meyer: other choice.
00:41:53.690 --> 00:41:57.690
Michael Meyer: If, and I certainly hope it doesn't happen, both institutions, the
00:41:57.690 --> 00:42:01.690
Michael Meyer: Conservative Jewish Theological Seminary and HUCJIR,
00:42:02.335 --> 00:42:06.335
Michael Meyer: become financially unsustainable without
00:42:06.335 --> 00:42:07.215
Michael Meyer: a merger.
00:42:07.215 --> 00:42:11.215
Michael Meyer: Only then, I think, would such a thing come about.
00:42:11.500 --> 00:42:15.500
Michael Meyer: If it isn't that, however, I believe that each one has enough
00:42:15.500 --> 00:42:19.500
Michael Meyer: history of its own that it wants to preserve that they will continue
00:42:19.980 --> 00:42:23.980
Michael Meyer: to exist as separate movements with separate rabbinical
00:42:24.460 --> 00:42:26.535
Michael Meyer: institutions.
00:42:26.535 --> 00:42:30.535
Joshua Holo: You raise the specter of difficult decisions depending
00:42:30.775 --> 00:42:34.775
Joshua Holo: on hard situations, financial, or otherwise, that might arise.
00:42:35.735 --> 00:42:39.735
Joshua Holo: And in that vein, we cannot help but note that on the
00:42:39.735 --> 00:42:43.735
Joshua Holo: occasion of the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of HUC,
00:42:44.060 --> 00:42:47.900
Joshua Holo: which this podcast series is commemorating,
00:42:47.900 --> 00:42:51.900
Joshua Holo: we have, in fact, just this month, May of twenty twenty
00:42:52.060 --> 00:42:56.060
Joshua Holo: six, celebrated the final rabbinic ordination
00:42:56.905 --> 00:42:59.225
Joshua Holo: on the Cincinnati campus.
00:42:59.225 --> 00:43:03.225
Joshua Holo: HUC will henceforth ordain rabbis only in Los
00:43:03.385 --> 00:43:07.385
Joshua Holo: Angeles, New York, and Jerusalem, though we will retain
00:43:07.465 --> 00:43:11.360
Joshua Holo: our campus on its historic site in Cincinnati.
00:43:11.360 --> 00:43:13.200
Joshua Holo: In fact,
00:43:13.200 --> 00:43:17.200
Joshua Holo: controversy surrounding the college's location in Cincinnati
00:43:17.840 --> 00:43:21.840
Joshua Holo: dates almost to the founding of the college itself back in
00:43:22.000 --> 00:43:23.995
Joshua Holo: eighteen seventy five.
00:43:23.995 --> 00:43:27.995
Joshua Holo: How do you interpret our current decision, specifically
00:43:27.995 --> 00:43:31.995
Joshua Holo: in the context of the college's history and
00:43:32.155 --> 00:43:36.155
Joshua Holo: that of American Judaism writ large today?
00:43:36.600 --> 00:43:40.600
Michael Meyer: Well, I was present for the last ordination, which
00:43:40.680 --> 00:43:43.640
Michael Meyer: took place here in Cincinnati,
00:43:43.640 --> 00:43:47.640
Michael Meyer: and it was a sad occasion as someone who taught
00:43:47.720 --> 00:43:51.720
Michael Meyer: for more than half a century at the campus
00:43:51.905 --> 00:43:55.905
Michael Meyer: in Cincinnati, I very much regret that
00:43:56.385 --> 00:44:00.385
Michael Meyer: there are now no plans for rabbinical
00:44:01.025 --> 00:44:05.025
Michael Meyer: education or graduate education here in Cincinnati.
00:44:05.820 --> 00:44:09.820
Michael Meyer: We have our library, which doesn't have a sufficient
00:44:10.060 --> 00:44:12.380
Michael Meyer: budget to buy new books.
00:44:12.380
--> 00:44:16.300
Michael Meyer: We have our archives, which does flourish, and we have a museum, but we
00:44:16.300 --> 00:44:19.845
Michael Meyer: don't have an instructional program.
00:44:19.845 --> 00:44:23.845
Michael Meyer: I understand that we are in an age in
00:44:23.925 --> 00:44:27.925
Michael Meyer: which not just liberal Judaism, but
00:44:27.925 --> 00:44:31.925
Michael Meyer: a liberal religion generally is contracting while orthodoxy
00:44:32.645 --> 00:44:36.645
Michael Meyer: and secularism is growing, even as humanities
00:44:37.790 --> 00:44:41.790
Michael Meyer: in American colleges and universities are declining.
00:44:42.750 --> 00:44:46.750
Michael Meyer: People are simply not seeing
00:44:47.235 --> 00:44:51.235
Michael Meyer: what we have seen, which is how liberal religion,
00:44:51.875 --> 00:44:55.875
Michael Meyer: religion that combines reason with tradition,
00:44:56.275 --> 00:45:00.275
Michael Meyer: sentiment with serious thought, is so important
00:45:00.595 --> 00:45:02.880
Michael Meyer: for human life.
00:45:02.880 --> 00:45:06.880
Michael Meyer: My hope is that as has been true in history in the
00:45:06.960 --> 00:45:08.560
Michael Meyer: past,
00:45:08.560 --> 00:45:12.560
Michael Meyer: dialectical process may bring about
00:45:12.640 --> 00:45:16.640
Michael Meyer: once again a revival of education
00:45:17.355 --> 00:45:21.355
Michael Meyer: for the rabbinate in Cincinnati.
00:45:21.515 --> 00:45:25.515
Michael Meyer: At present, it is not visible, but perhaps
00:45:26.555 --> 00:45:29.730
Michael Meyer: sometime in the future, it will be.
00:45:29.730 --> 00:45:33.730
Michael Meyer: Meanwhile, it is important for the College Institute
00:45:34.370 --> 00:45:38.370
Michael Meyer: to build the centers that it has in Jerusalem,
00:45:38.530 --> 00:45:42.455
Michael Meyer: in New York, and in Los Angeles,
00:45:42.455 --> 00:45:46.455
Michael Meyer: And recall the important origins that
00:45:46.775 --> 00:45:50.775
Michael Meyer: took place here in Cincinnati as the fountainhead
00:45:51.735 --> 00:45:55.600
Michael Meyer: of American Reform Judaism.
00:45:55.600 --> 00:45:59.600
Joshua Holo: Let's close out this interview by having you send us back
00:45:59.760 --> 00:46:03.760
Joshua Holo: again to the nineteen seventies as you researched and wrote
00:46:03.920 --> 00:46:06.400
Joshua Holo: a Centennial History.
00:46:06.400 --> 00:46:10.400
Joshua Holo: Tell us with this now fifty year gap
00:46:10.575 --> 00:46:14.575
Joshua Holo: between then and now, what has stuck with you as
00:46:15.055 --> 00:46:19.055
Joshua Holo: the most surprising thing you learned in the course of that work?
00:46:20.015 --> 00:46:24.015
Michael Meyer: I can't say that there was anything that was a
00:46:24.095 --> 00:46:25.960
Michael Meyer: total surprise.
00:46:25.960 --> 00:46:29.960
Michael Meyer: What I found particularly interesting and perhaps was not sufficiently
00:46:31.080 --> 00:46:33.560
Michael Meyer: aware
previously
00:46:33.560 --> 00:46:37.560
Michael Meyer: is how each president left his mark
00:46:38.405 --> 00:46:42.005
Michael Meyer: on the institution that he headed.
00:46:42.005 --> 00:46:46.005
Michael Meyer: Isaac Mayer Wise in terms of the wide vision
00:46:46.565 --> 00:46:50.565
Michael Meyer: of Israeli Israel, of the people of Israel,
00:46:50.780 --> 00:46:54.780
Michael Meyer: within an American setting, which had such a glorious future.
00:46:55.900 --> 00:46:59.900
Michael Meyer: Kaufmann Kohler with his concern for Jewish
00:46:59.900 --> 00:47:02.795
Michael Meyer: belief and Jewish practice.
00:47:02.795 --> 00:47:06.795
Michael Meyer: As he put it, research and reverence, scholarship,
00:47:07.835 --> 00:47:10.315
Michael Meyer: and piety.
00:47:10.315 --> 00:47:14.315
Michael Meyer: Morgenstern, the first American born president
00:47:14.475 --> 00:47:18.475
Michael Meyer: with his emphasis on the American roots of American
00:47:18.970 --> 00:47:20.730
Michael Meyer: Judaism.
00:47:20.730 --> 00:47:24.730
Michael Meyer: And then Nelson Glick with his archaeological
00:47:25.690 --> 00:47:29.690
Michael Meyer: interests and his love of the land of Israel,
00:47:29.770 --> 00:47:33.770
Michael Meyer: moving the reform movement closer to
00:47:33.875 --> 00:47:37.875
Michael Meyer: ties, not alone with America, but also
00:47:38.115 --> 00:47:40.195
Michael Meyer: with the state of Israel.
00:47:40.195 --> 00:47:44.195
Michael Meyer: So I would say this movement within our movement,
00:47:44.430 --> 00:47:48.430
Michael Meyer: within the Hebrew Union College, from one particular
00:47:49.150 --> 00:47:53.150
Michael Meyer: emphasis to another is indicative of the
00:47:53.150 --> 00:47:57.150
Michael Meyer: variety of Jewish experiences
00:47:57.230 --> 00:48:00.885
Michael Meyer: that have marked the history of our school.
00:48:00.885 --> 00:48:04.885
Joshua Holo: And indicative of the self understanding of reformed
00:48:04.885 --> 00:48:08.885
Joshua Holo: Judaism as an evolving expression of Jewish
00:48:09.365 --> 00:48:11.205
Joshua Holo: religion and civilization.
00:48:11.205 --> 00:48:13.140
Michael Meyer: Exactly.
00:48:13.140 --> 00:48:17.140
Joshua Holo: Well to you, Michael Mayer, one of the foremost historians of that
00:48:17.220 --> 00:48:21.220
Joshua Holo: evolution and history, thank you so much for
00:48:21.220 --> 00:48:25.220
Joshua Holo: joining us on the College Commons podcast and sharing your insight.
00:48:25.805 --> 00:48:26.445
Michael Meyer: My pleasure.
00:48:26.445 --> 00:48:28.605
Michael Meyer: Thank you, Josh.
00:48:28.605 --> 00:48:32.605
Closing: We hope you've enjoyed this episode of the College Commons podcast available
00:48:32.765 --> 00:48:35.245
Closing: wherever you listen to your podcasts.
00:48:35.245 --> 00:48:37.245
Closing: And check out HUC Connect, compelling at the forefront of Jewish learning. For more information about all that HUC Connect has to offer, visit HUC.edu/HUCConnect.